YEAH IT WOULD BE SUPER DOPE IF YOU MADE A SPECIAL! sorry for the caps XD but like for real they celebrated their 10th anniversary and it would be super cool of you if you did like a reaction special or something^^
There are so many references in this MV, I feel I can write a thesis and everything but for now, I'll only point out a couple of things: *I)* That fox is a main character from Jjong's favorite book, "The Little Prince". The "bad" cgi on the fox is intentional and alludes to The Little Prince book animations. *II)* In several cultures the fox bears a symbolic assosiation to the afterlife. In Celtic folklore "The ancient Celts considered the Fox an expert on the layout of the forest and held this particular animal in high esteem for it’s wisdom. They also relied upon the Fox with his intuitive sense of direction to be their guide on the path to the spirit world" Keep in mind that we did see the boys run through a forest. *III)* There is an 5th empty chair in the beginning. Also at the part where they are at the well, there are 5 trees behind them and there is also a 5th person as a shadow inside it. The point when they are looking inside the well itself is also a scene from "The Little Prince" book animations and I am a crying mess again. *IV)* The pearl aqua blue lighting throughout the MV and the pearl aqua "stage" the dance on is a shoutout to SHAWOL (pearl aqua blue is the fandom's official color). *V)* The song's lyrics are very heartwarming and touching and, imho, the are for both Jonghyun and SHAWOL. *VI)* I also think that the reference to 112 Cupid is more than an hommage. It's more of a message for all the negative things they've been hearing this whole time since that day. I won't elaborate further on this, fans know what I'm talking about. Esp the part of the lyrics of 112 Cupid that go: "Girl if I told you I love you That doesn't mean that I don't care, oooh And when I tell you I need you Don't you think that I'll never be there, ooooh Baby I'm so tired of the way you turn my words into Deception and lies Don't misunderstand me when I try to speak my mind I'm only saying what's in my heart" There are so many layers to this song & MV, I could write *so* much more but I'll stop here. I hope what I did write made sense, If not, forgive me; my mind and heart are racing, I'm too shook right now. *5HINee's back everyone!!!*
CER15E KPOP I want to write a more detailed "analysis" on the official MV comment section once I manage to calm down a bit. Also I wanna know who the man in the shadow behind Jinki is in the MV (here he is at around 3:55 and on the official MV at 1:11 approx) I swear he looks familiar but I really can't remember who he is. Someone please help me with this, I'm losing my mind here 😵
The Fox isn’t supposed to look realistic. It was put in for Jonghyun and a shout out to the art style of one of his favourite books. It’s not always about being realistic or the special effects. :) Look at the rest of SM’s MVs. It’s not like they can’t afford it. It’s just very meaningful.
I cried watching the mv. It's bittersweet. This is such a great moment for them and they've proven time and time again that they deserve the recognition they receive. We all wish there was one more person standing by them in this mv but I think he would of been happy with this one. Thank you 5hinee for never letting us down.
Elijas Same. I feel you. I had tears come out until the last chorus when I stop crying and I started dancing. I realize we have to celebrate SHINee and wipe our teaes. I love them and I'm so proud of them. If they can go forward so can we.
He's not too bright on the uptake! "Guys, we can save a few pennies making this fox look like crap." "Yeah, let's go for it -- after all who's this SHINee group but one of K Pop's legendary groups."
I wonder why Key is bashing in a piano so angrily (for any musician, that is a pretty symbolic thing). And they look so unimpressed in the media room. Maybe to express their disappointment with how the media handled JH's death, or Shinee? Or having to do interviews where people ask them intrusive questions about their grieving? Anyway even with the lightheartedness of the MV and the good vibes, you can still see some anger beneath and thats pretty cool. I'm glad their company is letting them express themselves like this.
It might be signaling the frustration towards being a musician, the creative demand it implies and how mad he is that music actually betrayed the musician (you know, Jjong not feeling good enough with what he was most passionate about...) I don't know. I might just be rambling, but that's my personal interpretation.
Interesting... you made me think about this more.... Here are my little thoughts on the subject: I have been watching one hell of a lot of videos of Jonghyun ever since his death. And there are times when I come across some performance that is mind-blowing in its artistry and I literally find myself yelling at the screen in fury !! Out of the blue a flash of such anger at Jonghyun -- that he murdered this beautiful, talented, deeply good and worthy person! How could he? How COULD he???!!!! Suicide elicits so many feelings in those who survive. I didn't know him personally. I didn't live years in a dormitory with him and go through the incredible hardship of building a dazzling career together --- yet here I am with these feelings. So I can only imagine the roller coaster of emotions that SHINee members are experiencing as they face the tragic death of Jonghyun. And of course some of those emotions must be blinding rage -- all the more intense as their love was so deep. Let me just be clear: My heart breaks for Jonghyun and I admire the strength he demonstrated soldiering through many years (according to him) of horrible, hideous emotional pain before he finally succumbed to it -- I am not in any way blaming him for what he did. I think also the rage one might feel if one was close to him is self-directed, "Why was I so blind to his despair? Why did I not save him???" What I so admire about SHINee is they are not sweeping this devastating tragedy under the rug -- they are dealing with it and they are honoring Jonghyun and not pretending that "all is well." They are treating themselves and their fans like full and mature human beings who know that life is about more than entertaining and being entertained. They are telling us all the time that SHINee will always be five -- that Jonghyun, in all his complexity, will always inform the group's future work and he will forever be part of their story. It's really beautiful stuff....
Interestingly enough most artists don't feel they measure up -- in a way that's why they might be deemed "artists". They have a vision that they rarely feel they achieve and it is what keeps them striving and also often unhappy. I've often heard very high-level musicians whom I've personally known (principally concert-level classical musicians) say after what they deem a "good performance" that they've been channeled by God. So a self-satisfied musician would have to have a bit of a God complex if they felt too good about their own work :-) And most of them, thankfully, feel like mere mortals. From the little I know of Jonghyun his sense of inferiority was across the board -- he said it in his suicide not: He hated himself. Music didn't fail him. He failed himself -- meaning, he failed to see what all of the rest of us so clearly saw -- that he was extraordinary in ALL ways -- we saw an exemplary human being whose presence made this world a better place. It's a great tragedy.
This whole mv was a dedication to jonghyun because the concept is "The Little Prince" Which is jjong's favorite book. And i think the fox is jonghyun leading them to happiness and watching over them. Its so sweet ❤❤ #5hinee
Layla I think so too. I wrote this is my comment and I'll write it again, I think it was made to look "cartoonish" to reference the drawings of the fox on "The Little Prince" book which is amongst Jjong's favorite books and it (the book) is also their theme for this comeback. Man, I love 5HINee and their artistry 💙
Don't even give this fellow'Brisbane comment (?? Oops how rude of me that I might have forgotten his name. My apologies) a second thought re the supposedly bad job they did with the fox -- SM's art directors, et al are some of the most sophisticated and aesthetically evolved professionals on the planet and with a budget commensurate with the legendary stars for whom they're producing this MV. The fox looks this was FOR A REASON. Every last little detail on this MV was conceived with meticulous purpose and intent! Might as well say right here Lily M X that I await your thesis :-)) I loved your commentary on this MV and hope you continue to share more thoughts on this comment space so we can continue to read your analysis. I was really moved so much more so by this video because of what you said re the fox and Jonghyun. I found this MV actually rather sad...It almost looked like they were lost in a world of cameras that are watching them and which was also the world that they had inhabited with Jonghyun as stars. There seems to be a feeling of aimlessness and mourning. And then they're liberated in the end, like you say, maybe through entering a spiritual plane (the forest) where they'll always be together and maybe guided by him -- hmmm? Who knows. All I know is I do find a sadness to this video. The melody is melancholy and they're dancing is limited and staccato as if there is no cause for exuberance at the moment (great choreography, the little there is of it.) So thanks again for your insights! Sure do miss precious Jonghyun but they are carrying on beautifully.
The hook is from 112's 'Cupid'. They did the same thing with 'Juliette'. They used Corbin Bleu's (From High School Musical) song 'Deal With It'. I love how they take songs from the past & make it their own. I give them so much credit for doing this comeback. I can't imagine the hurt they must've felt while filming this mv. But I know that Jonggie is there with them cheering them on. Ugh, I need a tissue. I'M NOT CRYING, YOU'RE CRYING!. Lol. RIP Jonghyun, We love you. 👑😢💕 Wait, Was there an extra shadow while they were looking down the well?!.... Jonghyun?!. 😱
@@avoo190 he did write a lot of their song but I don’t think it was this one. I feel like there’s a song that has to do with Juliette that he wrote though.
someone tell me i aint the only one who noticed there was a shadowy figure when they looked down the well in the last scene and how it dissapeared at the same time standed up from that view (sorry my english is bad) Idk, it made me feel a little sad :c But at peace at the same time, like some sort of closure
We all noticed it since the teasers, they had it all over the internet on facebook, instagram and twitter so I think you are the one who is a bit late noticing.
i'm no shawol nor follow many kpop fb pages or instagram/twitter accounts so no idea what was goong on with shinee (except that they are supposed to go on a tour soon and some video M2 uploaded um.. on friday I believe). It's the first time I watched the video or anything related to it, so yeah it got me shocked lmao To think I was just waking up I thought I was seeing things jsjd
I am glad that there are people who are "a bit late to noticing." It helps us all see with fresh eyes! I too felt a sense of relief and also, to be honest, scared. Relief that he was remembered and scared that this vibrant and beautiful young man is now just a ghost. Rest in peace, dearest Jonghyun....
FAVORITE GROUP BOYS K-POP SHINEE LOVE TAEMIN LOVE KEY LOVE ONEW LOVE MINHO FOREVER LOVE JONGHYUN I MISS RIP ANGEL JONGHYUN FOREVER ALWAYS BE 5SHINEE NEW LOVE SONG GOOD EVENING
The 5th chair......I know that Jonghyun is standing in that chair, watching them dancing and singing! Reast In Peace , our lovely angel! You did so much for us! And now is the time to make you proud! #FOREVERSHINE #FIGHTING 👊🏻❤️
Omg thanks for this reaction! The question n my mind was answered! That song cupid! 😂 i also felt the same way when I heard the song. I felt like I heard it before I just dont know which song exactly is that i've been thinking for hours hahaha so yeah thanks a lot! 😂
Cupid by 112 chorus was lit on this track!! I feel old to remember the premiere of the video on BET back in the 90's! Now I get to hear it on a Shinee track in 2018!! Love Kpop and ol skool R*B/Soul!!
This song and mv are really bittersweet and melancholy. Anyone who's going through some shit at the moment I know that it can be extremely difficult and completely unfair but please wait, please be patient. There IS light at the end of the tunnel, I promise!
The saddest part of this song's MV is that they said "Bring me with you, No, I'll go to you" which symbolize how much they miss Jonghyun. This part make me cried.
This is such a great song! It shows them looking back but then running forward smiling. It symbolizes that the obstacles in life, that you can recover and surpass it. Edit: Some theories are that the fox is supposed to be Jonghyun since his favorite book was ‘The Little Prince’.
This song has always been bittersweet for me...the only song to EVER make me cry. I wasn't even a hardcore Stan at the time of its release. SHINee is showing the world that they are still powerful and strong. Jonghyun we miss you...your brothers are keeping the legend alive.❤ That shadow at the end truly had me crying again.
SHINee were my first k-pop group more than 10 years ago. Every time I see this MV I remember there's one member who is no longer there and I cry. Rest in Peace Jonghyun.
I heard it too when I first saw the video. It sounds a lot like 112- cupid Edit: just realized you looked up the video on this reaction lol that’s what happens when you comment before seeing the full reaction.
I'm so happy you're reacting to Shinee. If you like their stuff, and are a fan of dancing, check out Married to the Music, Everybody, or Sherlock. If you like vocals, check out 1 of 1 or Tell me what to do. Their live performances are AMAZING too, if you want your mind blown. Evil, Picasso, Stranger, or Spoiler live are all good.
BRIS i wanted to let you in on the meaning of the FOX . I decided to look into the meaning of the fox because i know everything has a meaning with SHINee , so the fox if something that as honored for its wisdom . Its also a signal from the spirits of the deceased . In which case the fox is Jonghyun . please like the comment so i amable to know weather you seen this or not .
Finally a SHINee video after scrolling so far into your video list ohmygod this song is 😭😭😭 been there when they were promoting the song and saw them perform it live this song is so close to my heart 😭😭😭
It's 112's Cupid, another Bris gang member said they worked together with 112. This is why I fell in love with Kpop/KR&B, whatever you want to call it.... the groups who pay homage to 90s R&B
OMFGAHHHH, I clicked on your thumbnail quicker than lightening. I thought I was the only one tripping about the hook and you found it. haha Thank you. Now I can finish Shinee's song.
You have to look a the dance practice video. It's all about subtle movement. That choreographer is incredible. She is also the one who made the dance for "MOVE" for Taemin and "Sayonara Hitori". Make sure to check out Koharu Sugawara, she's a dance kween
Dee Ca search V interview if you have the V app they were there, if you follow them on instagram parts were there maybe dailymotion has it with subs I speak some Korean so I can understand most of it without them some people uploaded it here without subs.
The fox looks like that on purpose. It is from a book that Jonghyun loved. The cupid 112 people are credited with helping write "good evening", so I am sure that's why they used that tune. Thanks for reviewing. Also, Key gave another nod to Jonghyun by using the cane in the same way that Jonghyun used it in the song "Everybody".
Lol at least you figured it out right away. Throughout the whole video I was trying so hard to figure where that chorus' beat was from. It's so good. The beat works so well!
CUPID DOESN'T LIE I knew I wasn't the only one who heard that I sat down for a damn near hour trying to figure it out I honestly love this music video though it's so emotional
SHINee always brings new era to the world of K-Pop. They're the real KINGS OF K-POP. Am a shawol and am soo much happy to be a part of SHINee world. I would like to request you to watch SHINee's STRANGER LIVE PERFORMANCE. THAT IS SIMPLY AMAZING. Am pretty much sure that you'll be more amazed about SHINee and JONGHYUN after watching this. SHINee is forever five💎💎💎💎💎 Jonghyun is the member of SHINee forever. We will always remember you and loves you forever. YOU DID WELL KIM JONGHYUN. YOU ARE THE BEST.
I like the freshness they've brought back after such a long period of grief. This release reminded me that SHINee is, in fact going be still be fantastic without jonghyun, who is my bias. It just didn't feel right, you get what I'm saying? I've been listening to kpop since 2008, SHINee was my first introduction into a whole new world of music. They've helped me strive to become a better and more diverse musician and that's helped me get into the school of my dreams, and ecstatic to be returning for my second year. After jonghyun passed, I kinda fell out of touch with SHINee which was way different than what I was used to. But, I appreciate what they've done for me. They're fantastic musicians, and they never cease to amaze me.
So far, your SHINee Good Evening MV Reaction is my FAV!!! Other just doing screaming and wow and bla bla, but you, I could tell how much you know stuff about music!! Thank You!!
honestly it just hurts so much to only see four of them. i want to listen and support their music so badly but it still hurts too bad. i love you shinee.
Jonghyun you will always be remembered.
RIP Jonghyun😭😪😢
BRISxLIFE you should react to their debut song Replay.. you know just to celebrate their 10th anniversary 😊💜
YEAH IT WOULD BE SUPER DOPE IF YOU MADE A SPECIAL! sorry for the caps XD but like for real they celebrated their 10th anniversary and it would be super cool of you if you did like a reaction special or something^^
You’ll notice in the scene where they’re looking down the well, Jonghyun‘s shadow appears
Thank you for reacting to this!😢😢
There are so many references in this MV, I feel I can write a thesis and everything but for now, I'll only point out a couple of things:
*I)* That fox is a main character from Jjong's favorite book, "The Little Prince". The "bad" cgi on the fox is intentional and alludes to The Little Prince book animations.
*II)* In several cultures the fox bears a symbolic assosiation to the afterlife. In Celtic folklore
"The ancient Celts considered the Fox an expert on the layout of the forest and held this particular animal in high esteem for it’s wisdom. They also relied upon the Fox with his intuitive sense of direction to be their guide on the path to the spirit world"
Keep in mind that we did see the boys run through a forest.
*III)* There is an 5th empty chair in the beginning. Also at the part where they are at the well, there are 5 trees behind them and there is also a 5th person as a shadow inside it. The point when they are looking inside the well itself is also a scene from "The Little Prince" book animations and I am a crying mess again.
*IV)* The pearl aqua blue lighting throughout the MV and the pearl aqua "stage" the dance on is a shoutout to SHAWOL (pearl aqua blue is the fandom's official color).
*V)* The song's lyrics are very heartwarming and touching and, imho, the are for both Jonghyun and SHAWOL.
*VI)* I also think that the reference to 112 Cupid is more than an hommage. It's more of a message for all the negative things they've been hearing this whole time since that day. I won't elaborate further on this, fans know what I'm talking about. Esp the part of the lyrics of 112 Cupid that go:
"Girl if I told you I love you
That doesn't mean that I don't care, oooh
And when I tell you I need you
Don't you think that I'll never be there, ooooh
Baby I'm so tired of the way you turn my words into
Deception and lies
Don't misunderstand me when I try to speak my mind
I'm only saying what's in my heart"
There are so many layers to this song & MV, I could write *so* much more but I'll stop here. I hope what I did write made sense, If not, forgive me; my mind and heart are racing, I'm too shook right now.
*5HINee's back everyone!!!*
ooooohh..... You should add that to the mv comment box
Lily X M that was the best explanation ever, thank you now I understand much better. Somethings I already had figured out but now I understand more.💕💕
CER15E KPOP I want to write a more detailed "analysis" on the official MV comment section once I manage to calm down a bit. Also I wanna know who the man in the shadow behind Jinki is in the MV (here he is at around 3:55 and on the official MV at 1:11 approx) I swear he looks familiar but I really can't remember who he is. Someone please help me with this, I'm losing my mind here 😵
sorry, but what day do you mean?;;; i'm confused;;
jintonic The day Jjong passed
The Fox isn’t supposed to look realistic. It was put in for Jonghyun and a shout out to the art style of one of his favourite books. It’s not always about being realistic or the special effects. :) Look at the rest of SM’s MVs. It’s not like they can’t afford it. It’s just very meaningful.
I cried watching the mv. It's bittersweet. This is such a great moment for them and they've proven time and time again that they deserve the recognition they receive. We all wish there was one more person standing by them in this mv but I think he would of been happy with this one. Thank you 5hinee for never letting us down.
Elijas same feels. my boyfriend was shocked when I cried suddenly while watching the mv. 😅
Elijas Same. I feel you. I had tears come out until the last chorus when I stop crying and I started dancing. I realize we have to celebrate SHINee and wipe our teaes. I love them and I'm so proud of them. If they can go forward so can we.
all their voices in harmony kind of remind me of Jonghyun tho X.x I love the mv so much, I love the song so much.
Jonghyun's shadow appears at 6:41 and is still there at the end. I cried at that part. Some also say that the fox represents him.
Jakkie Betters it is just taemins shadow
If it was Taemin's shadow, it'd be coming from a slightly different angle judging by the light source.
It's probably supposed to represent Jonghyun.
Jakkie Betters I wish I didn’t know that. Now I want to cry.
Shinee got money, dude. If the fox looks like that it's an artistic choice lol
He's not too bright on the uptake!
"Guys, we can save a few pennies making this fox look like crap." "Yeah, let's go for it -- after all who's this SHINee group but one of K Pop's legendary groups."
I wonder why Key is bashing in a piano so angrily (for any musician, that is a pretty symbolic thing). And they look so unimpressed in the media room. Maybe to express their disappointment with how the media handled JH's death, or Shinee? Or having to do interviews where people ask them intrusive questions about their grieving? Anyway even with the lightheartedness of the MV and the good vibes, you can still see some anger beneath and thats pretty cool. I'm glad their company is letting them express themselves like this.
You're right some shots like act quite angrily like even the way Minho bites that orange.
It might be signaling the frustration towards being a musician, the creative demand it implies and how mad he is that music actually betrayed the musician (you know, Jjong not feeling good enough with what he was most passionate about...)
I don't know. I might just be rambling, but that's my personal interpretation.
I've always wondered about musicians destroying instruments in music videos. I know I would feel hesitant and sad for the instrument. 😂
Interesting... you made me think about this more....
Here are my little thoughts on the subject: I have been watching one hell of a lot of videos of Jonghyun ever since his death. And there are times when I come across some performance that is mind-blowing in its artistry and I literally find myself yelling at the screen in fury !! Out of the blue a flash of such anger at Jonghyun -- that he murdered this beautiful, talented, deeply good and worthy person! How could he? How COULD he???!!!!
Suicide elicits so many feelings in those who survive. I didn't know him personally. I didn't live years in a dormitory with him and go through the incredible hardship of building a dazzling career together --- yet here I am with these feelings. So I can only imagine the roller coaster of emotions that SHINee members are experiencing as they face the tragic death of Jonghyun. And of course some of those emotions must be blinding rage -- all the more intense as their love was so deep.
Let me just be clear: My heart breaks for Jonghyun and I admire the strength he demonstrated soldiering through many years (according to him) of horrible, hideous emotional pain before he finally succumbed to it -- I am not in any way blaming him for what he did. I think also the rage one might feel if one was close to him is self-directed, "Why was I so blind to his despair? Why did I not save him???"
What I so admire about SHINee is they are not sweeping this devastating tragedy under the rug -- they are dealing with it and they are honoring Jonghyun and not pretending that "all is well." They are treating themselves and their fans like full and mature human beings who know that life is about more than entertaining and being entertained. They are telling us all the time that SHINee will always be five -- that Jonghyun, in all his complexity, will always inform the group's future work and he will forever be part of their story. It's really beautiful stuff....
Interestingly enough most artists don't feel they measure up -- in a way that's why they might be deemed "artists". They have a vision that they rarely feel they achieve and it is what keeps them striving and also often unhappy.
I've often heard very high-level musicians whom I've personally known (principally concert-level classical musicians) say after what they deem a "good performance" that they've been channeled by God. So a self-satisfied musician would have to have a bit of a God complex if they felt too good about their own work :-) And most of them, thankfully, feel like mere mortals.
From the little I know of Jonghyun his sense of inferiority was across the board -- he said it in his suicide not: He hated himself. Music didn't fail him. He failed himself -- meaning, he failed to see what all of the rest of us so clearly saw -- that he was extraordinary in ALL ways -- we saw an exemplary human being whose presence made this world a better place. It's a great tragedy.
I think this was every black person’s problem that was born by the 90’s 😂😂😂😂😂
Mimi Chanakira i recognized it on the first listen!
Same start singing it once I heard the beat
Yo I felt it immediately!!😂😂
Mimi Chanakira or if you're raised on rnb
Mimi Chanakira Cupid was my shit.
This whole mv was a dedication to jonghyun because the concept is "The Little Prince" Which is jjong's favorite book. And i think the fox is jonghyun leading them to happiness and watching over them. Its so sweet ❤❤ #5hinee
yeah, curtis richardson said himself it was callback to 112.
Onew's Falsetto when?
on his twitter
They were credited as producers on the song too.
yeah.its true.Listen it it really same
Shinee did their thing. Amazing video so proud of them. Such a strong group.
*THE KINGS ARE BACKKKK*
wunderlust YAS!!!! 💕
*whispers* Shinee's back
wunderlust yes it is true. O My Got😂😂😂
but one s left🕯❤😢
Jasmin Dietz jonghyun still with us❤️
I honestly think that they purposely made the Fox 🦊 look like that and personally I like it.
Layla I think so too. I wrote this is my comment and I'll write it again, I think it was made to look "cartoonish" to reference the drawings of the fox on "The Little Prince" book which is amongst Jjong's favorite books and it (the book) is also their theme for this comeback. Man, I love 5HINee and their artistry 💙
Don't even give this fellow'Brisbane comment (?? Oops how rude of me that I might have forgotten his name. My apologies) a second thought re the supposedly bad job they did with the fox -- SM's art directors, et al are some of the most sophisticated and aesthetically evolved professionals on the planet and with a budget commensurate with the legendary stars for whom they're producing this MV. The fox looks this was FOR A REASON. Every last little detail on this MV was conceived with meticulous purpose and intent!
Might as well say right here Lily M X that I await your thesis :-)) I loved your commentary on this MV and hope you continue to share more thoughts on this comment space so we can continue to read your analysis.
I was really moved so much more so by this video because of what you said re the fox and Jonghyun. I found this MV actually rather sad...It almost looked like they were lost in a world of cameras that are watching them and which was also the world that they had inhabited with Jonghyun as stars. There seems to be a feeling of aimlessness and mourning. And then they're liberated in the end, like you say, maybe through entering a spiritual plane (the forest) where they'll always be together and maybe guided by him -- hmmm? Who knows. All I know is I do find a sadness to this video. The melody is melancholy and they're dancing is limited and staccato as if there is no cause for exuberance at the moment (great choreography, the little there is of it.)
So thanks again for your insights! Sure do miss precious Jonghyun but they are carrying on beautifully.
I wished he would have noticed that there was a shadow at 6:41 that was supposed to be jonghyun.
Janiya LastName? Wow I only saw it now, I was looking for something representing Jonghyun in the MV ‘cause I knew they would
The hook is from 112's 'Cupid'. They did the same thing with 'Juliette'. They used Corbin Bleu's (From High School Musical) song 'Deal With It'. I love how they take songs from the past & make it their own. I give them so much credit for doing this comeback. I can't imagine the hurt they must've felt while filming this mv. But I know that Jonggie is there with them cheering them on. Ugh, I need a tissue. I'M NOT CRYING, YOU'RE CRYING!. Lol. RIP Jonghyun, We love you. 👑😢💕
Wait, Was there an extra shadow while they were looking down the well?!.... Jonghyun?!. 😱
Kpopislife16 they actually bought the rights to that song for Juliette. I thought that was pretty cool.
SM tends to do this it seems
@@Lisa-pq4id didnt Jjong rewrite it though??? or was that another song 🤔
@@avoo190 he did write a lot of their song but I don’t think it was this one. I feel like there’s a song that has to do with Juliette that he wrote though.
Did they buy the rights to Cupid too??
You should listen to the whole album. All tracks are soo good
SHINee taemint
I'm obsessed with "Undercover" ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
There all bops. My fav right now is jump
SHINee taemint Totally agree. My faves are this song, I want you, countless and you and I. Dope album. Hope they come to the US 😍
True😍
CAN WE JUST TALK ABOUT HOW MUCH RESPECT THEY DESERVE
i’m so proud of my guys and i’m sure that jonghyun is proud too
It‘s so weird watching this bc you know someone is missing.. Jonghyun you will always be remembered ..
I'm crying 😭😭😭
someone tell me i aint the only one who noticed there was a shadowy figure when they looked down the well in the last scene and how it dissapeared at the same time standed up from that view (sorry my english is bad)
Idk, it made me feel a little sad :c But at peace at the same time, like some sort of closure
AmaiAi
Hell no! LOL 😂 shocked the hell outta me. But I figured they would put some Jonghyun in here. So it's cool LOL.
Yes it's supposed to be Jonghyun
We all noticed it since the teasers, they had it all over the internet on facebook, instagram and twitter so I think you are the one who is a bit late noticing.
i'm no shawol nor follow many kpop fb pages or instagram/twitter accounts so no idea what was goong on with shinee (except that they are supposed to go on a tour soon and some video M2 uploaded um.. on friday I believe). It's the first time I watched the video or anything related to it, so yeah it got me shocked lmao To think I was just waking up I thought I was seeing things jsjd
I am glad that there are people who are "a bit late to noticing." It helps us all see with fresh eyes!
I too felt a sense of relief and also, to be honest, scared. Relief that he was remembered and scared that this vibrant and beautiful young man is now just a ghost. Rest in peace, dearest Jonghyun....
FAVORITE GROUP BOYS K-POP SHINEE
LOVE TAEMIN LOVE KEY LOVE ONEW LOVE MINHO
FOREVER LOVE JONGHYUN
I MISS RIP ANGEL JONGHYUN
FOREVER ALWAYS BE 5SHINEE
NEW LOVE SONG GOOD EVENING
So proud of these boy and i love your vids. Jonghyun will always be missed.
The 5th chair......I know that Jonghyun is standing in that chair, watching them dancing and singing! Reast In Peace , our lovely angel! You did so much for us! And now is the time to make you proud! #FOREVERSHINE #FIGHTING 👊🏻❤️
6:40 on that part you can see a shadow that's Jonghyun
BTW, it turns out the song was produced by the Fliptones and they got permission to use 112's hook.
theblerdgurl I love that they make sure they’re being honest with their music.
Right! I immediately thought the hook was similar to 112’s Cupid; but so what! Still a great song! Love you SHINee!
Kelli Rae one of the member of 112 have take part of the songwriting of the song so i guess he put some cupid vibes in it
YEah I saw not just one is part of the song production team all of them are credfited and made the song similar intentionnaly
I think that Fox is Jonghyun.
Minseok Kim same here you know?
Omg thanks for this reaction! The question n my mind was answered! That song cupid! 😂 i also felt the same way when I heard the song. I felt like I heard it before I just dont know which song exactly is that i've been thinking for hours hahaha so yeah thanks a lot! 😂
And whenever I ask in the comment section of that song, they are deleting my comments.. im curious tho..
SHINee is back 💎💎💚💙💚💙 thank youuu 💓💓 the other songs are sooo beautiful as always SHINee songs are art 🤗🤗
Cupid by 112 chorus was lit on this track!! I feel old to remember the premiere of the video on BET back in the 90's! Now I get to hear it on a Shinee track in 2018!! Love Kpop and ol skool R*B/Soul!!
This song and mv are really bittersweet and melancholy. Anyone who's going through some shit at the moment I know that it can be extremely difficult and completely unfair but please wait, please be patient. There IS light at the end of the tunnel, I promise!
Cupid 112 is my favorite and the fact shinee used a similar beat kills me 😭it’s such a beautiful song
Idk them too well but Key is gorgeous
I'm a simple person. I see SHINee, I thumb up.
Can you please react to Press Your Number and Drip Drop by Taemin, one of 5hinee's members
I LOVE PRESS YOUR NUMBER!
The saddest part of this song's MV is that they said "Bring me with you, No, I'll go to you" which symbolize how much they miss Jonghyun. This part make me cried.
This is such a great song! It shows them looking back but then running forward smiling. It symbolizes that the obstacles in life, that you can recover and surpass it.
Edit: Some theories are that the fox is supposed to be Jonghyun since his favorite book was ‘The Little Prince’.
112 was my favorite boy groups back in the day so this makes me very happy
Thank you so much for reacting to them again 😊❤!
This song has always been bittersweet for me...the only song to EVER make me cry. I wasn't even a hardcore Stan at the time of its release. SHINee is showing the world that they are still powerful and strong. Jonghyun we miss you...your brothers are keeping the legend alive.❤
That shadow at the end truly had me crying again.
The they dedicate to one of their member who laready gone - JONGHYUN. they said from now on they only gonna look for future n x looking back.
Thank you for loving our boys
SHINee were my first k-pop group more than 10 years ago. Every time I see this MV I remember there's one member who is no longer there and I cry. Rest in Peace Jonghyun.
I heard it too when I first saw the video.
It sounds a lot like 112- cupid
Edit: just realized you looked up the video on this reaction lol that’s what happens when you comment before seeing the full reaction.
One of 112 member is part of the songwritting of this song so i guess i have put some cupid vibes in it
gegepipo TV 112 x SHINee?! Never in a million years would I have imagined that. Awesome!!
Shinee had me so emotional here, I teared up and rocked out to it. I'm glad they're back.
CUPID BY 112!!!!
Darion Foster 112 members were on the songwriting team of "Good Evening", the similarities to "Cupid" are intentional :)
I hope that you will see a concert for shinee. They are great with direct performances and will renew the diversity and renewal of each song 😎👌
SUCH A BOP
I'm so happy you're reacting to Shinee. If you like their stuff, and are a fan of dancing, check out Married to the Music, Everybody, or Sherlock. If you like vocals, check out 1 of 1 or Tell me what to do. Their live performances are AMAZING too, if you want your mind blown. Evil, Picasso, Stranger, or Spoiler live are all good.
I knewwww it sounded familiar!!!
I never stop crying when I hear this song tbh...ahh shinee always 5 no matter what!! Ahh shinee so strong I'm so emo rn
5hinee will always be 5.
SHINee are so good with their cryptic messages. I love their MV. So many references to OT5
MY KINGS ARE BACK!!! 💎💗
I'm so proud of SHINee this is their 10th anniversary and I've been with them for 9 of those 10 years, they truly are Kings!
BRIS i wanted to let you in on the meaning of the FOX . I decided to look into the meaning of the fox because i know everything has a meaning with SHINee , so the fox if something that as honored for its wisdom . Its also a signal from the spirits of the deceased . In which case the fox is Jonghyun . please like the comment so i amable to know weather you seen this or not .
Finally a SHINee video after scrolling so far into your video list ohmygod this song is 😭😭😭
been there when they were promoting the song and saw them perform it live this song is so close to my heart 😭😭😭
You need to react to SHINee "Sherlock", probably their most famous song!!
It's 112's Cupid, another Bris gang member said they worked together with 112. This is why I fell in love with Kpop/KR&B, whatever you want to call it.... the groups who pay homage to 90s R&B
The best come back ever!!!
SHINEE'S BACK!! 💙💎💎💎💎💙
WE ARE PROUD OF THIS NEW ALBUM!💙💎
OMFGAHHHH, I clicked on your thumbnail quicker than lightening. I thought I was the only one tripping about the hook and you found it. haha Thank you. Now I can finish Shinee's song.
You should react to Prisin V “Get it”
YASSSS!
OMG YESSSSSSS
YESSS
Amd Bingle Bangle as well!!!
Cupid by 112, Bris!!!!!! 😍😍😍
My god, they had to bring back one of my faves-shinee’s always had such good taste.
Ik what you mean I was listening to it and it sounded so familiar
You have to look a the dance practice video. It's all about subtle movement. That choreographer is incredible. She is also the one who made the dance for "MOVE" for Taemin and "Sayonara Hitori". Make sure to check out Koharu Sugawara, she's a dance kween
It's a 112 song but i dont remember the name lol
Cupid
they said they were using the song 112 cupid, watch the V interview.
Where can I watch that interview?
Dee Ca search V interview if you have the V app they were there, if you follow them on instagram parts were there maybe dailymotion has it with subs I speak some Korean so I can understand most of it without them some people uploaded it here without subs.
The fox looks like that on purpose. It is from a book that Jonghyun loved. The cupid 112 people are credited with helping write "good evening", so I am sure that's why they used that tune. Thanks for reviewing. Also, Key gave another nod to Jonghyun by using the cane in the same way that Jonghyun used it in the song "Everybody".
FIRST LIKE AND COMMENT FINALLLLAYYYYY😂🙏🏼❤️
Lol at least you figured it out right away. Throughout the whole video I was trying so hard to figure where that chorus' beat was from. It's so good. The beat works so well!
Idk but I kinda heard in my head " Last Christmas I Gave You My Heart " but I love the song and group☺💞
K-PopRockerAri SHINee did a cover of that song. Lol
Challise Inuzuka That shall be engraved into my brain
CUPID DOESN'T LIE
I knew I wasn't the only one who heard that I sat down for a damn near hour trying to figure it out
I honestly love this music video though it's so emotional
the deep voice is from KEY who with that colorful hair
sau man fung actually the rap part was by MinKey ( Minho and Key my 2nd best ship)
Yessss Key was the one that started the rap :’) king of all talents :’)
Thanks for such an early reaction to this, I suggest checking out more stuff from Shinee.
Good i love your videos
You betta tie it to "CUPID" !!!! I heard it immediately when they played the extended teasers earlier. I love how SHINee tied it in. Sooooo good :)
My heart was so into this😍😍😍😍😭 sounded so beautiful 😎😎😎😎
SHINee always brings new era to the world of K-Pop. They're the real KINGS OF K-POP. Am a shawol and am soo much happy to be a part of SHINee world. I would like to request you to watch SHINee's STRANGER LIVE PERFORMANCE. THAT IS SIMPLY AMAZING. Am pretty much sure that you'll be more amazed about SHINee and JONGHYUN after watching this. SHINee is forever five💎💎💎💎💎 Jonghyun is the member of SHINee forever. We will always remember you and loves you forever. YOU DID WELL KIM JONGHYUN. YOU ARE THE BEST.
REACT TO MORE SHINEE PLS
So many creativity in this mv for every single part..
112 CUPID I KNEW I WASNT THE ONLY ONE
Thanks for making this video💙
Khan - I'm your girl. Please react to this... the song is dop. Worth listen to it.
NCT127 Chain dance practice is come out. Can u react to this also?
The members of 112 actually helped compose the song for SHINee!
react to Taemin - Sayonara Hitori
oh yesss
watch BIGBANG - Fantastic Baby x2
He might get a strike on his channel because it's universal music Japan
StrongPower THANKYOU the Mv under SMent
no don't worry it's under SMent
So much helpful info in the comments! Off to watch the mv again
React to Pristin V, it came out today! Got some R&B vibes
That high note you loved was Taemin 🥰❤️ He’s amazing both at both dancing and singing ❤️
112 Cupid is the song u hear just sped up
Quinnes Parker from 112 was one of the composers of SHINee's Good Evening, that's why we had the hommage to 112 here
React to 10 years of shinee!! Video
I like the freshness they've brought back after such a long period of grief. This release reminded me that SHINee is, in fact going be still be fantastic without jonghyun, who is my bias. It just didn't feel right, you get what I'm saying? I've been listening to kpop since 2008, SHINee was my first introduction into a whole new world of music. They've helped me strive to become a better and more diverse musician and that's helped me get into the school of my dreams, and ecstatic to be returning for my second year. After jonghyun passed, I kinda fell out of touch with SHINee which was way different than what I was used to. But, I appreciate what they've done for me. They're fantastic musicians, and they never cease to amaze me.
when are you going to upload the second part of the nct introduction video?
selina ctl I am waiting for the second part too!!
Yes, I'm really excited to see it too.
I thought I was the only one asking.
he said today i think
tear承 i fucking hope so lol
So far, your SHINee Good Evening MV Reaction is my FAV!!! Other just doing screaming and wow and bla bla, but you, I could tell how much you know stuff about music!! Thank You!!
Please review the album too thank youu
I certainly cried at the end of the mv, I know it was a positive beat but still tears
could you maybe react to SHINee-Replay? it was theri debut song
Sina 886 Yes!!! Love Replay!!
honestly it just hurts so much to only see four of them. i want to listen and support their music so badly but it still hurts too bad. i love you shinee.
please react to Dreamcatcher 🙇♂️🙇♂️🙇♂️
Thank you for reacting to this.
You are very early on posting reactions😂