Here are some of the references in the video to (hopefully) help clear out any confusion: *1)* That fox is a main character from Jonghyun's favorite book, "The Little Prince". Also the shadow of the man behind Onew is Antoine de Saint-Exupery himself (author of The Little Prince). *2)* In several cultures the fox bears a symbolic assosiation to the afterlife. In Celtic folklore, in particular: "The ancient Celts considered the Fox an expert on the layout of the forest and held this particular animal in high esteem for it’s wisdom. They also relied upon the Fox with his intuitive sense of direction to be their guide on the path to the spirit world" I don't think the "spirit world" part needs explaining I just want to point out that we did see the boys run through a forest. *3)* There is an empty chair in the beginning, on their right and it appears as if they are expecting a 5th person to fill it. Also at the part where they are at the well, there are 5 trees behind them and there is also a 5th person as a shadow inside it. Even tough we can only see four, the members of SHINee are always 5. The point when they are looking inside the well itself is also a scene from "The Little Prince" book illustrations. *4)* The pearl aqua blue lighting throughout the MV and the pearl aqua "stage" they dance on is a tribute to their fandom, SHAWOL (pearl aqua blue is the fandom's official color). It alludes to the fact that the fandom is always there to illuminate them (SHINee means "the one who receives the light", the fandom provides said light) and support them (stage). *5)* A lot of fans have been saying that the MV alludes to the stages of grief: i) Denial & Isolation - at several points of the MV ii) Anger - Key smashing the piano iii) Bargaining - The lyrics iv) Depression - again, at several points of the MV, esp the part where they appear to be drowning. v) Acceptance - The dance. The choreographer is world-renowned Japanese choreographer, Koharu Sugawara, who is known for her interpretive dance style. At first, their moves are too slow- they are almost idle. As the song goes on, their dance picks up and at the end of the song, their dance starts to match the upbeat tempo of the song- but still not at 100%. *6)* The whole "entrapment" theme: Not completely sure but most probably it's about them not being able to voice their feelings/grieve the way they want to, since the media has always been and still is, present (you can see them at several times in the MV being circled by cameras and TVs). There are many more layers to this song & it's MV but I'll stop here. Also if this comment looks familiar, it's because I've posted it elsewhere too, since a lot of people are confused :) And thank you for the reaction!!
Alexis Crimiel Yeah, SHINee just loooooves sending us looking for the messages the hid in their MVs for us cause... cause they can, I guess! No wonder SHAWOL also goes by the name of SHERLOCKWOL 😂
I feel you. I don't know whether I will one day get over his death... It's a perpetual emptiness, and even if months have passed, I always end up crying alone when I think about him too much. But I love and can't help thinking about him because _I loved him._ In my own way, as a fan, but still.
I still cry too when I think about him now and then. Honestly, I think it's okay if you never really get over it. I think it's important to hold a place for him in your heart and never forget the wonderful things he did.
Minho's lost soulmate It’s exactly the same for me. Even when I’m at school i start crying when I think about him to. Luckily i have friends who understand and support me. Also when looking at his poster in my room, i just stare at it and start crying again. I’m not ever going to get over his death to. I just miss my bias so much😞
shinee's music means so much to me and i gotta say, it was so, *so* weird not seeing jonghyun with the members. it's a boppy song but i feel like crying when listening to it. thanks for reacting to it~
wavymin me too SHINEE was my first group that got me into K-POP they have a special place in my heart💓, watching jonghyunie isn't with them breaks me I know they are trying to not show the sadness in their faces and want us to see them strong and happy but I can see it through the whole MV which makes me cry so freaking hard.(TT)
Yeah... 4 is so weird. I talked about this with my friends and they just said to me "Mamamoo and Blackpink have 4 members as well, and you adore them" but... No, 4 stays weird, sad and empty
I guess they were not a fan of SHINee? Because if so they would know they were 5. It's like TVXQ being 2. Just doesn't work just because other groups are 4 or 2. >
Minho's lost soulmate That's a weird comparison tbh. BP and Mamamoo actually debuted as 4, so there's no one missing & their complete. SHINee didn't, and we know in the back of our minds that someone will always be missing.
Love love the song... in the MV, like when Taemin’s in the water, and when the plastic is over them, it just gives me this feeling of... suffocation? I don’t know how to explain it... but... whoa... SHINee is just... amazing and they have a way of making me feel better... The album is...💜💜💜
Thank you for supporting them I also feel the same way They were never in a race and it's still the same for them Their music make us feel emotions,take us on a journey Just give them a mic and baamm Any random album and a headphone is a gateway to a magical journey And they are legends No hate to anyone But They have been unique since the start they have already been doing marvels something which the artists today claim to do I feel bad a lot that they are not that appreciated But for me they will always be no. 1 They are more than visuals or celebrities Their music can stir up the soul Whether it's DYNAMITE or LOVE SHOULD GO ON whether it's DONT CALL ME or TONIGHT whether it's a title track or any random B SIDE TRACK EVERYTHING IS ART
Please don't ever apologise for getting emotional or feeling sad. It's entirely human and it's seen as a deluded social norm to shame especially men, who show emotions. It may be 'improving' ~slightly in the west, but in many cultures it is still entirely normal that men shouldn’t get emotional or sad. You really don't need to apologise to us, people apologise when they've done something wrong, you haven't. Thank you for sharing your emotions with us, please don't try to hide or suppress, we're all here feeling the same. And as a shawol who also shares the fact that shinee got me through some dark times, I'm thankful for your honesty and rawness. Down with perpetuating the stigma around mental health, I say!
This is such a roller coaster of emotions. The excitement, the pure happiness and then the reality hits you hard. He's not here anymore... It's like that door that you couldn't completely close that suddenly shuts on your face. I can't help imagining him dancing next to them, wondering what outfits he would've wear, what parts of the song he would've sung. This is a really torturous feeling. But I really want to support SHINee with all my heart. They worked so hard. The song is awesome, the MV is great. They're so brave. I wish them all the best from now on. 💖
Can completely relate to your feelings about SHINee and I am sure I am not the only one, thank you for always being open and honest when sharing with us, helps to see someone else being human
Don't feel pressured, don't feel sorry, don't be ashamed shedding tears JRE. It's still sensitive but... We couldn't help but miss him and on the other hand these four amazing guy are standing on the stage, together, always have their brothers in their hearts... I feel just like you and thank you so so much for your being honest, your reaction 🙏
I swear this MV and song made my whole fucking year look like a shining diamond... I loved everything about this mv and symbols behind every scene. Your reaction was everything, really. I can't wait to see more from our boys... They are art!
SHINee are here with us, all together, five members, forever Jonghyun beg us in his songs not to cry, so please don't cry anymore, he is still here, in our little hearts 💙 Thanks for reaction ~
Same!! I love it! Im obsessed with Key's hair (but as a Locket I am always obsessed with Key's hair) and I miss Jonghyun too. Thank you for talking about him and showing your honest emotions. He really is so missed and loved.
I've been crying all day Jre. I know that feel. SHINee has gotten me through every single day of the last 3 years of my life and it still hurts, but they are still here for me. They are still here for you. The are still here for all of us. Never forget, never stop loving SHINee.
i know that feeling bro. Had that same reaction when Ladie's Code had their accident. Never listened to their music afterwards even tho they were my favorite girl group at the time. It's just not the same and you always think about what could have been... . Really difficult topic :(.
Great video. Thank you for showing that vulnerability. When I found kpop 6 yrs ago it helped me get through some very dark and trying times as well. Shinee was one of the first groups I found and Jonghyun will always be one of my top top top favorite vocalist. Tbh I can honestly say he is my favorite. He will forever be missed.
I started crying half thru the MV sobbing by myself. Shinee also got me into k-pop and it got me into a new world honestly. My heart breaks when I think about Onew, Key, Minho and Taemin and how big of a step they are taking right now. I loved the song. Shinee never lets me down.( I also ADORE Keys new hair. I am living for it😆😍)
I feel exactly the same about their music. people can love and listen to whatever they want but it's just a great waste not enjoying their music, they really have that special sound and artistic side that is so inspiring. and good evening everyone reading this❤️
every two words.."sigh" I feel you Jre...I feel you. It's so sad what happened to him. Shinee wont be the same without him, he was such an amazing guy. I'm so happy to see them continuing on.
Please don’t cry jre I love you so so so much I know it hurts I’m still in pain it’s ok I love you thank you for loving him I’m forever grateful to you for that
I’m crying with you... I was blessed to have seen them at kcon too :( SHINee was one of the first groups that got me into kpop. Without them, I wouldn’t be here tbh :( they’ll always be 5. 5HINee forever.
I follow you since almost 6 years ago when I discovered SHINee. I'm always looking for your videos and I appreciate the way you talk about our boys. Thank you, Jre💖 It's ok if you cry, if you take your time, we are doing our best to keep going and preserve Jjongie's memory. Thank you for your love and support towards SHINee🌹💖
I saw SHINee back in 2010 i think and it was a joint concert that had many other artists, but im glad i saw them live, but also regretful that i wasn't able to see them in their own concert. SHINee always puts out great music at the right time for me as well. we all needed this, and im glad they decided to comeback. I don't think i'll ever get over it, but i know he wont ever be forgotten.maybe one day we won't shed tears, and just smile for SHINee, all 5 of them ^^
I wasn't ready for the comeback but still watched and listened their mv and songs. It was really heart warming and heartbreaking to see that chair empty. but still shinee is SHINEE. They will always have a special place in every shawol's heart.
y'know, this is why I love you. Being the great and famous reactor you are you could have *easily* made it click-bait-y and unecessary over the top dramatic, but you were just, *sincere* and *geniune* and you made me tear up tho I didn't while watching the mv. So yeah, huge props to you and a heartfelt greeting from a hardcore *shawol*.
Even after all of the months that past, I still haven’t processed the fact that Jonghyun isn’t here anymore. When I first watched this video, I constantly felt like everything was just off without him in it. But SHINee’s comeback is really good overall and I’m so happy that they came back
It's been almost 6 months, yet I feel the same way too. He moved and touched the hearts of so many people. We grew up with them and bonded, it's like losing a friend that many of us never got to meet, so it can be an odd feeling. SHINee was the group that started it all for me, I hope the best for them and for the rest of the celebrities who may feel the same way he did.
Seeing you open up more about your feelings on the topic just made this reaction even more special. I found Shinee at one of my darkest times and they helped me so much, as well they were my first group continues to be my ult and I’ll forever regret not seeing them more times but also grateful that I got to experience them as 5 physically at all. And im grateful for them and their music. Jonghyun will forever be with us through our memories
Jre it's okay to cry I cried on my shift at pizza hut when the news broke, I still cry. I supported you for five years and I saw your growth from each kpop group but you always had a spot for Shinee, I'm still on shift at Pizza Hut tear up as you opened up about Shinee. Shinee will always be 5
SHINee also got me through some hard times back when I was in high school and I discovered them when they released Sherlock! For some reason, they always had good timing with releasing music when I needed it most. This is why SHINee is and forever will be my favorite group ❤️ stay strong shawols!
you know the last chorus(?) when they drop the instrumental and everyone sings together. when song do that it always gets me in me emotions but i could REALLY feel this one deep. i really feel like they doin this all with jjong in mind and it gives me comfort somehow
Shinee helped me to change my life for the healthiest. Their music is just so energetic and positive, and their life performances are just full of energy. They make me feel better.
"Maybe it's because SHINee did get me through some dark times than's all." Yeah that sums up so much about the band and why so many emotions are attached to this.
It’s ok to feel what you feel JRE. As a shinee fan, we feel it too. Thank you for the react and hard work as always. He’s always here with us. Don’t worry (look at the last scene again~ I believe the lighting peps did that intentionally ~) :D
Actually there are 4 chairs from the start to the end and that empty chair at the beginning is part of their choreography And the fox has story, they said it will appear on the other 2 mvs too so make sure to watch them all! They're all connection and has story 😊
And the fact that this song still sounds like something that you would hear his vocals on just makes it even more special. They did amazing by themselves. But it feels like they still carry an element of him with them. And I'm so grateful for that.
omg JRE you made me cry so hard idk why but I feel you really I just want to say you're a beautiful human too and keep on what you're doing because you're doing great and never stop to believe in your dreams
i am feeling same thing what you are feeling. At the end of the day he will always be here and watching over us. It is hard and we all miss him but he is in our hearts. We will always support shinee no matter what and protect them forever! ❤
there is a fox there for a reason but i forgot but it has something to do with jonghyun EDIT: the fox is the main character from jonghyun’s favorite book, “The Little Prince” and the “bad” cgi on the fox is intentional and alludes to the Little Prince book animations (i saw this some where so don’t go saying i stole it) rip angel
I see the tears stain on your shirt JRE and this song I've been listening to it like non stop and has got me the feels alright... I'm glad they still have that same feels
Thank you for talking about baby jong and not tiptoeing. Nothing hurts more than when people are too afraid to say his name. I love the love you have for shinee, thank you for reacting to this video!💙
that moment of silence made me cry. i know what you mean when you said SHINee got you through some through some tough times. its so difficult but thank you so much for not editing around that part and just showing your emotions because it helped me as viewer know that i'm not alone.
this song was everything! these guys were the reason i got into KPOP and i'm sure there are a lot of people around the world who have the same thought about them. ndidot going to lie it was really difficult to watch this without him ...it was like i could hear him or like feel his presence I dunno..well regardless SHINee deserve all the happiness and success..they'be been through a lot and they have literally changed so many people's lives with their genre of music...it'a crazy P.S. you notice that there was a shadow in the well like in the last scene....to represent jonghyun maybe??
i am feeling same thing what you are feeling. At the end of the day he will always be here. It is hard and we all miss him but he is in our hearts. We will always support shinee no matter what and protect them forever!
Jre I just want to say that I really like you ! I've been following you for a really long time ( like 5- 6 years) and I think you are great human :) I think about you as my kpop friend because we share a lot of opinion and have similar taste ! Anyways it's difficult for me too, it's very bittersweet.... but I love this song and I want to support Shinee the best that I can! Also I think we should all spread love, respect and be empathic because we are all doing the best that we can! I wish everyone the best
I keep having this feeling that it’s all a dream and I’m going to wake and that peace of Kpop that is missing is still alive I really miss him but I’m glad shinee will still have him as part of them and I’m going to support them with this bop cause this is song is amazing
Ahhh, this made me emotional! I feel you boo. It's a lot. I'm so proud of them though, they've been so strong and this is an amazing comeback. Love them so much 💕
OH MY GOD DID YOU NOT SEE THE SHADOW AT THE END Y’ALL THAT WAS A SYMBOL FO JONGHYUN!!!!!!💛💛💛 Everyone who watched this video you all are beautiful, wonderful, sexy people and keep on jreaming!!!!!🤣🤣🤣💛
Shinee led me to your react videos! I’ve been a fan of Shinee since their debut and it’s hard, I miss Jonghyun! JRE we just have to keep supporting them and keep spreading kindness to others.
Jonahyun is singing with them up in heaven... I’m still new to k-pop... I’m into SHINee but I am scared to even mention that I want to be in the fandom. I tearing up about this... it’s ok to open up on your own time. I am always with you Shawols! Fighting!
Thank you for this genuine reaction, JRE! Honestly, I was really excited for this comeback too but still can't help but feel that something is missing and we all know why. I think it will take a long while for reality to really sink in for some of us, but as always, SHINee's music makes everything brighter!
Ah, this got so real at the end. Thank you for sharing that vulnerable moment with us, Jre. People should indeed compliment each other more often! I try to do it as often as possible, though it's really hard to do towards guys without them thinking you're trying to start something lol. Still, I get some in there every now and then. Awhile back I complimented an older gentlemen on his suit (it was very ostentatious and amazing), and his whole face lit up. It's incredible to see how much a simple compliment can turn around a person's entire day. But about the song - it's an excellent bop! I expect nothing less from SHINee. It's hard to watch, true, but I'm really happy they're able to continue on and bring us all the joy and beauty they always have. Jonghyun would have wanted it that way, and it only makes his memory live forever in our hearts.
Jre you made me cry 😞... but for real Shinee was the group that got me into kpop about 2 years ago, and I was fortunate enough to see them in concert last year and got to experience all 5 of them... I just wish I can see all 5 of them again... Love you Shinee 💕💕💕
I’m really glad you made a reaction to this. I wanted to watch this but I didn’t wanna watch it alone and none of my friends would watch it with me because they were nervous and scared and just weren’t ready and honestly I wasn’t either but I needed to watch it and I was so glad to watch it with you. It was hard but SHINee always makes me feel good like their music is so light it makes me feel....ughhhh it was a good comeback. They sounded amazing and all of this was to say I’m glad I watched this with you...through my tv...otherwise I don’t think I could’ve watched it alone so thanks Jre 💕💕💕
I was watching Shinees new song and thought to myself: This was good! Wonder how Jremkl would react. Guess what!? You just uploaded a video 4 mins ago! 🙌
SHINee was one of the first bands I was into when I got into kpop back when I was in middle school. Kpop was my happy bubble and listening to these songs made me feel better when I felt down. Now ten years later when Jonghyun died, it was like my happy, childhood bubble burst and it became a nightmare. Like everyone else, I was really distraught for a few months but I came to accept it for what it is and I feel like the part in the mv when all four members are dancing in the rain is symbolic of how they are accepting it as well. SHINee will always be five in spirit
Man this got me crying... I miss Jonghyun too. I'm lucky that I'm one of those people that can speak freely about him without crying and with a smile on my face, but watching somebody get teary and understand the pain made me want to cry along.. as if I was crying with a friend that understood since none of my friends stan shinee.
I loved this entire mv, i watched it so so many times but after a few times it's amazing how they included Jjong at the end with the trees.. Down the tunnel with the shadow.. It hurts my heart still that he's no longer here.. 😔 Forever in mind and in our hearts.
Thank you so much for not being one of those youtubers who put shots of them crying as the thumbnail for this reaction, using tragedy to get views and likes.
Thank you! I wanted to write you a lot of things about this reaction but everything comes down to thank you, for pointing out how SHINee's music is all about "feel good" and how is okay to still feel sad and listen to their music anyway. It's a happy kind of sadness.
Thats what i feel about jjong too..listening to his solo album always make me cry 😢 btw, this comeback is amazing!! Cant wait for the rest of albums to come 💖
![ROSÉ (로제) - number one girl [더 시즌즈-이영지의 레인보우] | KBS 241129 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A9oByH9Ci24/mqdefault.jpg)
Here are some of the references in the video to (hopefully) help clear out any confusion:
*1)* That fox is a main character from Jonghyun's favorite book, "The Little Prince". Also the shadow of the man behind Onew is Antoine de Saint-Exupery himself (author of The Little Prince).
*2)* In several cultures the fox bears a symbolic assosiation to the afterlife. In Celtic folklore, in particular: "The ancient Celts considered the Fox an expert on the layout of the forest and held this particular animal in high esteem for it’s wisdom. They also relied upon the Fox with his intuitive sense of direction to be their guide on the path to the spirit world"
I don't think the "spirit world" part needs explaining I just want to point out that we did see the boys run through a forest.
*3)* There is an empty chair in the beginning, on their right and it appears as if they are expecting a 5th person to fill it. Also at the part where they are at the well, there are 5 trees behind them and there is also a 5th person as a shadow inside it. Even tough we can only see four, the members of SHINee are always 5.
The point when they are looking inside the well itself is also a scene from "The Little Prince" book illustrations.
*4)* The pearl aqua blue lighting throughout the MV and the pearl aqua "stage" they dance on is a tribute to their fandom, SHAWOL (pearl aqua blue is the fandom's official color). It alludes to the fact that the fandom is always there to illuminate them (SHINee means "the one who receives the light", the fandom provides said light) and support them (stage).
*5)* A lot of fans have been saying that the MV alludes to the stages of grief:
i) Denial & Isolation - at several points of the MV
ii) Anger - Key smashing the piano
iii) Bargaining - The lyrics
iv) Depression - again, at several points of the MV, esp the part where they appear to be drowning.
v) Acceptance - The dance. The choreographer is world-renowned Japanese choreographer, Koharu Sugawara, who is known for her interpretive dance style. At first, their moves are too slow- they are almost idle. As the song goes on, their dance picks up and at the end of the song, their dance starts to match the upbeat tempo of the song- but still not at 100%.
*6)* The whole "entrapment" theme: Not completely sure but most probably it's about them not being able to voice their feelings/grieve the way they want to, since the media has always been and still is, present (you can see them at several times in the MV being circled by cameras and TVs).
There are many more layers to this song & it's MV but I'll stop here. Also if this comment looks familiar, it's because I've posted it elsewhere too, since a lot of people are confused :)
And thank you for the reaction!!
Lily X M Holy shit... I have never been so amazed in my life.
Alexis Crimiel Yeah, SHINee just loooooves sending us looking for the messages the hid in their MVs for us cause... cause they can, I guess!
No wonder SHAWOL also goes by the name of SHERLOCKWOL 😂
Lily X M thank you so much.
Lily X M I saw your Brixgang comment. (Sorry if I butchered his name) thank you for the insight!
Lily X M thank you
damn jre you got me tearing up again too 😭
but as expected from shinee this song is a bop 🔥
Hey we covered shinnee good evening can u check our voices ? andd give us ur feedbacks plz .. will be a honor
ruclips.net/video/dHh-cyEiuKI/видео.html
notyouraveragenails imagine crying but still boping bc the songs a bop
I feel you. I don't know whether I will one day get over his death... It's a perpetual emptiness, and even if months have passed, I always end up crying alone when I think about him too much. But I love and can't help thinking about him because _I loved him._ In my own way, as a fan, but still.
That's EXACTLY how I feel. No matter how long it is, I will never be over it. The best we can do is just keep moving forward and never forget.
I still cry too when I think about him now and then. Honestly, I think it's okay if you never really get over it. I think it's important to hold a place for him in your heart and never forget the wonderful things he did.
I got over it's still sad and heart broken but I moved on and will support them no matter what.
Hey we covered shinnee good evening can u check our voices ? andd give us ur feedbacks plz .. will be a honor
ruclips.net/video/dHh-cyEiuKI/видео.html
Minho's lost soulmate It’s exactly the same for me. Even when I’m at school i start crying when I think about him to. Luckily i have friends who understand and support me. Also when looking at his poster in my room, i just stare at it and start crying again. I’m not ever going to get over his death to. I just miss my bias so much😞
What if the Fox was jonghyun watching over the members silently and making sure that they’re all ok and and ......god I’m crying now
Daddy Jun-trash 123 I've seen that theory a lot, they also say it represents him because he loves The Little Prince a lot
Now I’m going to cry too😭😭😭
😭😭😭😭
IF you go read or watch the little prince . You will know what it represents. It’s a heart warming story.
You have a point .. its what i thought too
it feels weird not to hear jonghyun’s beautiful and poweful voice but IM SURE JJONG IS PROUD OF HIS TEAM MEMBERS!!!!!!!
shinee's music means so much to me and i gotta say, it was so, *so* weird not seeing jonghyun with the members. it's a boppy song but i feel like crying when listening to it. thanks for reacting to it~
wavymin me too SHINEE was my first group that got me into K-POP they have a special place in my heart💓, watching jonghyunie isn't with them breaks me I know they are trying to not show the sadness in their faces and want us to see them strong and happy but I can see it through the whole MV which makes me cry so freaking hard.(TT)
me too, i still deluded myself his voice, like i can hear his voice singing this song. it's bittersweet, this album
Yeah... 4 is so weird. I talked about this with my friends and they just said to me "Mamamoo and Blackpink have 4 members as well, and you adore them" but... No, 4 stays weird, sad and empty
Minho's lost soulmate ii
Fr though, blackpink was always 4, shinee wasn’t and never be 4. That hole jonghyun has left can’t be filled, but we got to support them ✊🏽
it will always be 5HINee 💞 4HINee doesn't make any sense lmao
I guess they were not a fan of SHINee? Because if so they would know they were 5. It's like TVXQ being 2. Just doesn't work just because other groups are 4 or 2. >
Minho's lost soulmate That's a weird comparison tbh. BP and Mamamoo actually debuted as 4, so there's no one missing & their complete. SHINee didn't, and we know in the back of our minds that someone will always be missing.
I just cried during the MV since the moment I saw 1 empty chair and the fox... He is going to be my bias no matter what
Love love the song... in the MV, like when Taemin’s in the water, and when the plastic is over them, it just gives me this feeling of... suffocation? I don’t know how to explain it... but... whoa... SHINee is just... amazing and they have a way of making me feel better... The album is...💜💜💜
Lucy R ok that actually makes sense....
aww jre! it’s alright to cry. shawols love you 🧡 thanks for this cute reaction video, i hope you get to see shinee perform live soon 😙
SHINee's back means AESTHETIC KINGS ARE BACK
여자친구세훈 they aesthetic even before aesthetic is a thing in kpop world.
Couldn't agree more
Thank you for supporting them
I also feel the same way
They were never in a race and it's still the same for them
Their music make us feel emotions,take us on a journey
Just give them a mic and baamm
Any random album and a headphone is a gateway to a magical journey
And they are legends
No hate to anyone
But They have been unique since the start they have already been doing marvels something which the artists today claim to do
I feel bad a lot that they are not that appreciated
But for me they will always be no. 1
They are more than visuals or celebrities
Their music can stir up the soul
Whether it's DYNAMITE or LOVE SHOULD GO ON
whether it's DONT CALL ME or TONIGHT
whether it's a title track or any random B SIDE TRACK
EVERYTHING IS ART
I’m not crying you are😭
Kpop Trash you're right 😢
Everyone that knows SHINee is crying I literally am right now as I write this
Yeah, I am.
Yeah, I was crying😭😭😭
I'm not crying you are 😥😥😥
Please don't ever apologise for getting emotional or feeling sad. It's entirely human and it's seen as a deluded social norm to shame especially men, who show emotions. It may be 'improving' ~slightly in the west, but in many cultures it is still entirely normal that men shouldn’t get emotional or sad. You really don't need to apologise to us, people apologise when they've done something wrong, you haven't. Thank you for sharing your emotions with us, please don't try to hide or suppress, we're all here feeling the same. And as a shawol who also shares the fact that shinee got me through some dark times, I'm thankful for your honesty and rawness. Down with perpetuating the stigma around mental health, I say!
This is such a roller coaster of emotions. The excitement, the pure happiness and then the reality hits you hard. He's not here anymore...
It's like that door that you couldn't completely close that suddenly shuts on your face.
I can't help imagining him dancing next to them, wondering what outfits he would've wear, what parts of the song he would've sung. This is a really torturous feeling. But I really want to support SHINee with all my heart. They worked so hard. The song is awesome, the MV is great.
They're so brave. I wish them all the best from now on. 💖
Choreo by Koharu!
Also, there was only 4 chairs in the beginning but
Minho was standing so the setup was for 5. :’(
It’s still hard for me too.
Can completely relate to your feelings about SHINee and I am sure I am not the only one, thank you for always being open and honest when sharing with us, helps to see someone else being human
Don't feel pressured, don't feel sorry, don't be ashamed shedding tears JRE. It's still sensitive but... We couldn't help but miss him and on the other hand these four amazing guy are standing on the stage, together, always have their brothers in their hearts... I feel just like you and thank you so so much for your being honest, your reaction 🙏
I swear this MV and song made my whole fucking year look like a shining diamond... I loved everything about this mv and symbols behind every scene. Your reaction was everything, really. I can't wait to see more from our boys... They are art!
SHINee are here with us, all together, five members, forever
Jonghyun beg us in his songs not to cry, so please don't cry anymore, he is still here, in our little hearts 💙
Thanks for reaction ~
Same!! I love it! Im obsessed with Key's hair (but as a Locket I am always obsessed with Key's hair) and I miss Jonghyun too. Thank you for talking about him and showing your honest emotions. He really is so missed and loved.
We know Jre. Its hard. Its hard for all of us. Its okay.
I've been crying all day Jre. I know that feel. SHINee has gotten me through every single day of the last 3 years of my life and it still hurts, but they are still here for me. They are still here for you. The are still here for all of us. Never forget, never stop loving SHINee.
i know that feeling bro. Had that same reaction when Ladie's Code had their accident. Never listened to their music afterwards even tho they were my favorite girl group at the time. It's just not the same and you always think about what could have been... . Really difficult topic :(.
Great video. Thank you for showing that vulnerability. When I found kpop 6 yrs ago it helped me get through some very dark and trying times as well. Shinee was one of the first groups I found and Jonghyun will always be one of my top top top favorite vocalist. Tbh I can honestly say he is my favorite. He will forever be missed.
*whispers* SHINee's back
Kang Daniel is my aesthetic *SHINee's back back back back*
I started crying half thru the MV sobbing by myself. Shinee also got me into k-pop and it got me into a new world honestly. My heart breaks when I think about Onew, Key, Minho and Taemin and how big of a step they are taking right now. I loved the song. Shinee never lets me down.( I also ADORE Keys new hair. I am living for it😆😍)
I feel exactly the same about their music. people can love and listen to whatever they want but it's just a great waste not enjoying their music, they really have that special sound and artistic side that is so inspiring. and good evening everyone reading this❤️
every two words.."sigh" I feel you Jre...I feel you. It's so sad what happened to him. Shinee wont be the same without him, he was such an amazing guy. I'm so happy to see them continuing on.
Please don’t cry jre I love you so so so much I know it hurts I’m still in pain it’s ok I love you thank you for loving him I’m forever grateful to you for that
I’m crying with you... I was blessed to have seen them at kcon too :( SHINee was one of the first groups that got me into kpop. Without them, I wouldn’t be here tbh :( they’ll always be 5. 5HINee forever.
So weird seeing them as four, that empty chair and everything 😭😭 beautiful. Omg they did such a fantastic job. That choreograph tho! Shit is 🔥
I follow you since almost 6 years ago when I discovered SHINee. I'm always looking for your videos and I appreciate the way you talk about our boys. Thank you, Jre💖
It's ok if you cry, if you take your time, we are doing our best to keep going and preserve Jjongie's memory. Thank you for your love and support towards SHINee🌹💖
Yessss I’ve been wanting this!!!
Hey we covered shinnee good evening can u check our voices ? andd give us ur feedbacks plz .. will be a honor
ruclips.net/video/dHh-cyEiuKI/видео.html
ELISTAL OFFICIAL yes I will check it out thank for the information
I saw SHINee back in 2010 i think and it was a joint concert that had many other artists, but im glad i saw them live, but also regretful that i wasn't able to see them in their own concert. SHINee always puts out great music at the right time for me as well. we all needed this, and im glad they decided to comeback. I don't think i'll ever get over it, but i know he wont ever be forgotten.maybe one day we won't shed tears, and just smile for SHINee, all 5 of them ^^
SHINee!!💞💞💞💞💞
that empty chair wrecked my heart .. thanks for your reaction and as you said, this was art and so is SHINee ♥
They leave one empty chair and have one shadow for Jonghyun....so happy they still coming back with such a good song TT
I wasn't ready for the comeback but still watched and listened their mv and songs. It was really heart warming and heartbreaking to see that chair empty. but still shinee is SHINEE. They will always have a special place in every shawol's heart.
y'know, this is why I love you. Being the great and famous reactor you are you could have *easily* made it click-bait-y and unecessary over the top dramatic, but you were just, *sincere* and *geniune* and you made me tear up tho I didn't while watching the mv. So yeah, huge props to you and a heartfelt greeting from a hardcore *shawol*.
Even after all of the months that past, I still haven’t processed the fact that Jonghyun isn’t here anymore. When I first watched this video, I constantly felt like everything was just off without him in it. But SHINee’s comeback is really good overall and I’m so happy that they came back
It's been almost 6 months, yet I feel the same way too. He moved and touched the hearts of so many people. We grew up with them and bonded, it's like losing a friend that many of us never got to meet, so it can be an odd feeling. SHINee was the group that started it all for me, I hope the best for them and for the rest of the celebrities who may feel the same way he did.
Seeing you open up more about your feelings on the topic just made this reaction even more special. I found Shinee at one of my darkest times and they helped me so much, as well they were my first group continues to be my ult and I’ll forever regret not seeing them more times but also grateful that I got to experience them as 5 physically at all. And im grateful for them and their music. Jonghyun will forever be with us through our memories
Jre it's okay to cry I cried on my shift at pizza hut when the news broke, I still cry. I supported you for five years and I saw your growth from each kpop group but you always had a spot for Shinee, I'm still on shift at Pizza Hut tear up as you opened up about Shinee. Shinee will always be 5
SHINee also got me through some hard times back when I was in high school and I discovered them when they released Sherlock! For some reason, they always had good timing with releasing music when I needed it most. This is why SHINee is and forever will be my favorite group ❤️ stay strong shawols!
You cannot don’t feel good after listening SHINee’s song for sure
you know the last chorus(?) when they drop the instrumental and everyone sings together. when song do that it always gets me in me emotions but i could REALLY feel this one deep. i really feel like they doin this all with jjong in mind and it gives me comfort somehow
SHINEE PINEE SHINEE PINEE SHINEE PINEE, it’s your girl Maya
Shinee helped me to change my life for the healthiest. Their music is just so energetic and positive, and their life performances are just full of energy. They make me feel better.
This has a Jonghyun feel to it and it feels like he's still there
"Maybe it's because SHINee did get me through some dark times than's all."
Yeah that sums up so much about the band and why so many emotions are attached to this.
I'm crying and dancing at the same time QWQQQ
It’s ok to feel what you feel JRE. As a shinee fan, we feel it too. Thank you for the react and hard work as always. He’s always here with us. Don’t worry (look at the last scene again~ I believe the lighting peps did that intentionally ~) :D
The end was amazing Jre I love you 😭💖
I always watching your reaction for SHINee's mv))) Thank you! And you got me tearing up too. Have a good day !!!
I was waiting for your reaction thank youuu 💞💞
Ahhh Jre, thanks for your honesty! SHINee will be there for you! Keep on smilin cause you make others smile!
Actually there are 4 chairs from the start to the end and that empty chair at the beginning is part of their choreography
And the fox has story, they said it will appear on the other 2 mvs too so make sure to watch them all!
They're all connection and has story 😊
And the fact that this song still sounds like something that you would hear his vocals on just makes it even more special. They did amazing by themselves. But it feels like they still carry an element of him with them. And I'm so grateful for that.
omg JRE you made me cry so hard idk why but I feel you really I just want to say you're a beautiful human too and keep on what you're doing because you're doing great and never stop to believe in your dreams
i am feeling same thing what you are feeling. At the end of the day he will always be here and watching over us. It is hard and we all miss him but he is in our hearts. We will always support shinee no matter what and protect them forever! ❤
there is a fox there for a reason but i forgot but it has something to do with jonghyun
EDIT: the fox is the main character from jonghyun’s favorite book, “The Little Prince” and the “bad” cgi on the fox is intentional and alludes to the Little Prince book animations
(i saw this some where so don’t go saying i stole it)
rip angel
The Fox isn't the main character but he is in the book
That’s exactly how SO many people feel right now..😭💔
Everything you have said was amazing..Thank you!👍
I see the tears stain on your shirt JRE and this song I've been listening to it like non stop and has got me the feels alright... I'm glad they still have that same feels
SHINee's bacc
Thank you for talking about baby jong and not tiptoeing. Nothing hurts more than when people are too afraid to say his name. I love the love you have for shinee, thank you for reacting to this video!💙
aaand of course you had me in tears with you but thank you for that and thank you for bringing up jonghyun
that moment of silence made me cry. i know what you mean when you said SHINee got you through some through some tough times. its so difficult but thank you so much for not editing around that part and just showing your emotions because it helped me as viewer know that i'm not alone.
this song was everything! these guys were the reason i got into KPOP and i'm sure there are a lot of people around the world who have the same thought about them.
ndidot going to lie it was really difficult to watch this without him ...it was like i could hear him or like feel his presence I dunno..well regardless SHINee deserve all the happiness and success..they'be been through a lot and they have literally changed so many people's lives with their genre of music...it'a crazy
P.S. you notice that there was a shadow in the well like in the last scene....to represent jonghyun maybe??
i am feeling same thing what you are feeling. At the end of the day he will always be here. It is hard and we all miss him but he is in our hearts. We will always support shinee no matter what and protect them forever!
Jre I just want to say that I really like you ! I've been following you for a really long time ( like 5- 6 years) and I think you are great human :) I think about you as my kpop friend because we share a lot of opinion and have similar taste ! Anyways it's difficult for me too, it's very bittersweet.... but I love this song and I want to support Shinee the best that I can! Also I think we should all spread love, respect and be empathic because we are all doing the best that we can! I wish everyone the best
I keep having this feeling that it’s all a dream and I’m going to wake and that peace of Kpop that is missing is still alive I really miss him but I’m glad shinee will still have him as part of them and I’m going to support them with this bop cause this is song is amazing
Are you Key biased? Btw I LOVE HIS HAIR TOO
(He's so beautiful whatever he wears and how his haircut is 😷💚)
his bias is jonghyun
Omg i follow him since 3 years and awalys thinking that Key is his bias 😂😂😂
Ahhh, this made me emotional! I feel you boo. It's a lot. I'm so proud of them though, they've been so strong and this is an amazing comeback. Love them so much 💕
Omg finally I’ve been dying for this comeback ! (But not seeing Jonghyun makes me sad tho...)
this old combination like you reacting to SHINee is just so precious thank you so much JRE
OH MY GOD DID YOU NOT SEE THE SHADOW AT THE END Y’ALL THAT WAS A SYMBOL FO JONGHYUN!!!!!!💛💛💛 Everyone who watched this video you all are beautiful, wonderful, sexy people and keep on jreaming!!!!!🤣🤣🤣💛
Shinee led me to your react videos! I’ve been a fan of Shinee since their debut and it’s hard, I miss Jonghyun! JRE we just have to keep supporting them and keep spreading kindness to others.
Another great reaction Jre. I feel the same bro♥️
thanks for the review! SHINee is lit !! &... their music is so great and inspiration
Jonahyun is singing with them up in heaven... I’m still new to k-pop... I’m into SHINee but I am scared to even mention that I want to be in the fandom. I tearing up about this... it’s ok to open up on your own time. I am always with you Shawols! Fighting!
You love that kyungsoo/key hair don't you Jre 🤣🤣🤣
But my boys are back !!!
Yall don't sleep on my 5 boys
Thank you for this genuine reaction, JRE! Honestly, I was really excited for this comeback too but still can't help but feel that something is missing and we all know why. I think it will take a long while for reality to really sink in for some of us, but as always, SHINee's music makes everything brighter!
Jre did u saw his shadow in the well
Ah, this got so real at the end. Thank you for sharing that vulnerable moment with us, Jre.
People should indeed compliment each other more often! I try to do it as often as possible, though it's really hard to do towards guys without them thinking you're trying to start something lol. Still, I get some in there every now and then. Awhile back I complimented an older gentlemen on his suit (it was very ostentatious and amazing), and his whole face lit up. It's incredible to see how much a simple compliment can turn around a person's entire day.
But about the song - it's an excellent bop! I expect nothing less from SHINee. It's hard to watch, true, but I'm really happy they're able to continue on and bring us all the joy and beauty they always have. Jonghyun would have wanted it that way, and it only makes his memory live forever in our hearts.
Jre I appreciate your videos so much. Just, thank you 💞
Jre you made me cry 😞... but for real Shinee was the group that got me into kpop about 2 years ago, and I was fortunate enough to see them in concert last year and got to experience all 5 of them... I just wish I can see all 5 of them again... Love you Shinee 💕💕💕
SUPPORT OUR BOYS AND STREAM THEIR MV AND RAISE THE VIEWS!!
LETS GO SHAWOLS!! ❤️❤️
I’m really glad you made a reaction to this. I wanted to watch this but I didn’t wanna watch it alone and none of my friends would watch it with me because they were nervous and scared and just weren’t ready and honestly I wasn’t either but I needed to watch it and I was so glad to watch it with you. It was hard but SHINee always makes me feel good like their music is so light it makes me feel....ughhhh it was a good comeback. They sounded amazing and all of this was to say I’m glad I watched this with you...through my tv...otherwise I don’t think I could’ve watched it alone so thanks Jre 💕💕💕
I was watching Shinees new song and thought to myself: This was good! Wonder how Jremkl would react. Guess what!? You just uploaded a video 4 mins ago! 🙌
SHINee was one of the first bands I was into when I got into kpop back when I was in middle school. Kpop was my happy bubble and listening to these songs made me feel better when I felt down. Now ten years later when Jonghyun died, it was like my happy, childhood bubble burst and it became a nightmare. Like everyone else, I was really distraught for a few months but I came to accept it for what it is and I feel like the part in the mv when all four members are dancing in the rain is symbolic of how they are accepting it as well. SHINee will always be five in spirit
I came here as soon as it notified me! HI JRE!!!
Man this got me crying... I miss Jonghyun too.
I'm lucky that I'm one of those people that can speak freely about him without crying and with a smile on my face, but watching somebody get teary and understand the pain made me want to cry along.. as if I was crying with a friend that understood since none of my friends stan shinee.
Everyone in these comments you are beautiful! Listen to kpop it's feels great! Lol shinee did fantastic!
I loved this entire mv, i watched it so so many times but after a few times it's amazing how they included Jjong at the end with the trees.. Down the tunnel with the shadow.. It hurts my heart still that he's no longer here.. 😔 Forever in mind and in our hearts.
Thank you so much for not being one of those youtubers who put shots of them crying as the thumbnail for this reaction, using tragedy to get views and likes.
Thank you! I wanted to write you a lot of things about this reaction but everything comes down to thank you, for pointing out how SHINee's music is all about "feel good" and how is okay to still feel sad and listen to their music anyway. It's a happy kind of sadness.
my dude, i choked up sm :( i relate to you lots. Keep smiling JRE ~~
Thats what i feel about jjong too..listening to his solo album always make me cry 😢 btw, this comeback is amazing!! Cant wait for the rest of albums to come 💖
I still miss jonghyun tho ;----; I cant stop thinking of him