Don´t f... me, pleeaaaase! Floor is great but Tarja... is from another planet!!! She has a "hauntingly" magnificent voice!!! For this reason the style of Nightwish was never the same! Is as adrianemus says: She´s singing in Turunenglish! There is no one with "devilishly sweet" voice like Tarja!!! GOD BLESS TARJA!!! TARJA FOREVER AND EVER... AND EVER... AND EVER...
Escuche usted más música, Tarja es una soprano normalita sin estudios ni recursos que fué la primera en su género, pero que realmente nunca llegó a fusionar bien del todo bel canto y rock, compararla con Anette es absurdo pues esta no tiene nivel para otra cosa que no sea el pop comercial, pero de ahí a divinizar a Tarja hay un trecho. Por otro lado Floor es una cantante completa que puede hacer absolutamente de todo con una técnica vocal y registro realmente muy muy fuera de lo comun. De hecho como ya comenté como soprano tiene un registro una octava más alta que Tarja y otra serie de recursos, cualidades y fuerza y simpatía que ni Tarja ni Anete tendrán nunca
This is totally awesome. Imagine them really singing it together. It would be an amazing performance. Noone should ever tell me that Floor cannot sing Tarja´s songs. They are unique in their own ways but this song proofs that NW is coming back to its old self. Floor you are the new breath to NW. Everyone loves you im sure. May you stay in NW forever.
This was one of the coolest videos ever created. Ghost Love Score in both versions is magnificent but with two of the world's talented ladies singing in duet was just incredible
Two very beautiful versions! At the end of this side-by-side comparison, it's like Tarja is saying, "I'm done. I'm going to go do my own thing. I leave you in the capable hands of Floor." Then Floor does her amazing finale! Great job as usual. Thanks for your efforts.
It's really complicated to analyse who is better for many reasons and the comments section is really limited. They are both good, but different. Tarja is lyric, Floor is dramatic, the first is more classical, Floor is more ''heavy metal'', Tarja sings ONLY with classical voice, her speaking voice is weak ( she herself has stated that), Floor sings more with speaking voice. Afterwards, voices can only be compared under the same place and event, because each stage has different audio etc. All in all, they are both great and fit Nightwish, but they are DIFFERENT. It's up to you to decide who's to your own ears.
George Jansen However, Floor has an advantage over Tarja... Floor can sing in operatic style, while Tarja cannot sing with speaking voice like Floor. It's a matter of taste, then, and which voice appeals to you more... :)
Ce ne sont pas les 4 Fantastiques mais les 2. J'ai été transportée dans une battle de The Voîce puissance infinie. J'en ai des frissons et les larmes aux yeux tellement que c'est inouï. Fabuleux ! Incroyable de purs talents. Merci d'avoir eu l'idée géniale de ce duo. J'en redemande !
Amazing video, beautifully synchronised. While Ghost Love Score was originally written for Tarja's voice, it shows just how much Floor believes in this song and commits her entire being to its performance. You can't compare the two of them. Both singers are extraordinary, both are Nightwish. End of discussion.
Tarja with this song is just pure magic. Untouched rare magic. Floor with this song is fire, brightly burning, consuming fire. I think both bring their own originality to this song and make it their own. I still lean towards Tarja, because I love the song when it's sang a little softer, but Floor sells the hell out it at the end. Two great singers' depictions of a song and both are perfect 10s!!!!
They both are amazing. I dont understand why is this urge of yours to take side and to mark one of them as better. They have their own style. Both versions are amazing. You can like Tarja and Nightwish with Floor at the same time, you know that?
I would love to hear them perform this song together... They sound magnficent. Although I love Floor for many years longer than I even known Tarja, I love them both. But I think Floor gives Ghost Love Score an extra boost by slowing it a little bit down until the end, where she gives it a bite. Love her touch too this song. The only thing missing in the performance of Floor is the confetti ;)
Both are awesome,I love Tarja's job I really do, but Floor just simply did a perfect job and that last scream near the end oh man!!! I don't how to express it but i think epic climax is close enough.
I did a audio mix of the album version and the new live version from wacken.....lets just say OMG....there were times that i couldn't tell who was who. And Floor seems like she sang the album version closer than Tarja did on this version.
Floor le ha devuelto a Nightwish lo que perdió cuando Tarja dejo la banda, puedo decir por fin, NIGHTWISH HA REGRESADO!! (Anette tiene buena voz, pero Floor tiene ese algo fuerte que Tarja le daba a Nightwish y a la audiencia) yes I know Floor is not Tarja, Ya se que Floor no es tarja, but still, Nightwish finally have something even more powerful, pero igual Nightwish al fin tiene algo màs poderoso.
Just watch the end of the video and see who wins, people chants Flor ! Floor ! Floor!... and she is the only one. Tarja is taking a shower at that moment, Floor really feels it.
Gonna put this out there: I saw the title and thought that it would sound horrible but it WORKS!!! I don't think Anette would have worked with either of them this way.
Watching this I can finally and definately say: FLOOR! I always thought she was the only one who could substitute Tarja.. Really happy to have her in the band, and hopefully she's gonna stay! :)
No, I think there couldn't be any type of war among them because both are great singers and performer. So There's no need to choose!! They both are just amazing!!!
Another big difference between the two versions apart from the singers' voice is that Tuomas smiles in the second version and the band in general seems happier playing together ;) As much as I miss Tarja in Nightwish, the atmosphere in the band now is way better, Tuomas himself said so and even laughed at a later joke of the interviewer (for me the words 'Tuomas' and 'laugh' could not be combined until 2005 at least).After Floor's voice, this is the second reason I pray she stays in NW.
Please, don't extol who you think is the best (it's kinda disrespectful), these are two different versions and this is the closest to a dream we will ever get! *-* Tarja owns this song and Floor managed to match the epic feeling! Amazing!
I see. You are saying the background orchestra music acts as a metronome. This accounts for the two versions, recorded so many years apart, yet so perfectly synchronized. The truth is obvious once it is revealed.
I think Floor did not apply for Nightwish because she already sang in After Forever. Both bands (Nightwish and After Forever) are really great bands. After Forever was opening act for Nigthwish many times in the Netherlands, which was really cool because you did got 2 great bands for the price of 1 :) I did not see ReVamp yet but i bet they are really good too.
Very well done video. I love Tarja and Floor, they both are great singers! Tarja is not coming back to Nightwish so Floor is the best option for Nightwish in my opinion :)
The first time they played the song. There were two times where Emppu and Marco shared a "Fuck! She can do that!?" moment. That powerscream was one of them. her first "Into the dark....." there were hidden high-fives all around on stage. Don't remember the date though. it's right here on the tube.
Vocalists aside, did anyone notice the real star of the show: NIGHTWISH. Seriously, those guys are so good they sound almost like a relentless flawless musical machine ! I bet Floor knows this and that's why she will definitely do everything she can to get to be permanent vocalist...
Don´t f... me, pleeaaaase!
Floor is great but Tarja... is from another planet!!!
She has a "hauntingly" magnificent voice!!!
For this reason the style of Nightwish was never the same!
Is as adrianemus says: She´s singing in Turunenglish!
There is no one with "devilishly sweet" voice like Tarja!!!
GOD BLESS TARJA!!!
TARJA FOREVER AND EVER... AND EVER... AND EVER...
Escuche usted más música, Tarja es una soprano normalita sin estudios ni recursos que fué la primera en su género, pero que realmente nunca llegó a fusionar bien del todo bel canto y rock, compararla con Anette es absurdo pues esta no tiene nivel para otra cosa que no sea el pop comercial, pero de ahí a divinizar a Tarja hay un trecho. Por otro lado Floor es una cantante completa que puede hacer absolutamente de todo con una técnica vocal y registro realmente muy muy fuera de lo comun. De hecho como ya comenté como soprano tiene un registro una octava más alta que Tarja y otra serie de recursos, cualidades y fuerza y simpatía que ni Tarja ni Anete tendrán nunca
oh God...
This is totally awesome. Imagine them really singing it together. It would be an amazing performance. Noone should ever tell me that Floor cannot sing Tarja´s songs. They are unique in their own ways but this song proofs that NW is coming back to its old self. Floor you are the new breath to NW. Everyone loves you im sure. May you stay in NW forever.
This was one of the coolest videos ever created. Ghost Love Score in both versions is magnificent but with two of the world's talented ladies singing in duet was just incredible
Think I just had an eargasm! How amazing it would be to have a show with both Tarja and Floor sharing the stage!
Two very beautiful versions! At the end of this side-by-side comparison, it's like Tarja is saying, "I'm done. I'm going to go do my own thing. I leave you in the capable hands of Floor." Then Floor does her amazing finale!
Great job as usual. Thanks for your efforts.
It's really complicated to analyse who is better for many reasons and the comments section is really limited. They are both good, but different. Tarja is lyric, Floor is dramatic, the first is more classical, Floor is more ''heavy metal'', Tarja sings ONLY with classical voice, her speaking voice is weak ( she herself has stated that), Floor sings more with speaking voice. Afterwards, voices can only be compared under the same place and event, because each stage has different audio etc. All in all, they are both great and fit Nightwish, but they are DIFFERENT. It's up to you to decide who's to your own ears.
It's not that complicated :) If you prefer the more opera like rendition, it's Tarja, if you prefer the more metal sound, Floor.
George Jansen However, Floor has an advantage over Tarja... Floor can sing in operatic style, while Tarja cannot sing with speaking voice like Floor. It's a matter of taste, then, and which voice appeals to you more... :)
When the great finale starts 9.00 Tarja leaves the stage.. WTF?? Gotta love FLOOR!!
Tuomas' face at 2:01 and Emppu's at 9:23, lol!
Its nice to see the boys so happy
The queen of metal takes her rightful place, all hail to queen Floor.
So good and so different styles. I am an old fan so my first love was Tarja.
Floor's vocals especially the last 2 minutes is simply WAW! Orgasmic!
Ce ne sont pas les 4 Fantastiques mais les 2. J'ai été transportée dans une battle de The Voîce puissance infinie. J'en ai des frissons et les larmes aux yeux tellement que c'est inouï. Fabuleux ! Incroyable de purs talents. Merci d'avoir eu l'idée géniale de ce duo. J'en redemande !
Floor simply nails it!!!!!!!
I'm surprised how well it mixes together. Nice piece of work.
Truly amazing and epic. They are both incredible.
AMAZING! There voices fit perfectly.
well done for this 'duet'. I'm totally speachless.
Amazing video, beautifully synchronised. While Ghost Love Score was originally written for Tarja's voice, it shows just how much Floor believes in this song and commits her entire being to its performance. You can't compare the two of them. Both singers are extraordinary, both are Nightwish. End of discussion.
9:04 there you begin to experience the real difference between them.
Santo cielo que joya!!!!! Dos divas del metal!!! Las amo!!!
Epic beyond words! Chills everywhere.
But Floor's voice is so much stronger, and it seems like she really enjoys singing there! :)
I knew clicking this would be the best thing I ever did! Thanks for sharing!
Tarja with this song is just pure magic. Untouched rare magic.
Floor with this song is fire, brightly burning, consuming fire.
I think both bring their own originality to this song and make it their own.
I still lean towards Tarja, because I love the song when it's sang a little softer, but Floor sells the hell out it at the end. Two great singers' depictions of a song and both are perfect 10s!!!!
Wow great video, Floor is amazing in the end.
Emppu's guitar solo duet with himself is the best part of the video for me ;P
I wholeheartedly agree. In my opinion, Emppu is one of the best, if not the best, at melodic solos.
They both are amazing. I dont understand why is this urge of yours to take side and to mark one of them as better. They have their own style. Both versions are amazing. You can like Tarja and Nightwish with Floor at the same time, you know that?
Weird. Parts of the guitar melody reminded me of April Wine's Could of Been a Lady, particularly near the end, around 8:25. I love that song too.
Amazing voices!
No tengo palabras e quedado en shock! que sincronisación wooooww!!! que gran final !!!
mis respetos a Nightwish y sus dos talentosas sopranos.
They are equally great ! I like them both very much...
Oh look, its the best singer Nightwish ever had! And Tarja is there too.
Is awesome, the way you matched great job dude....
There is just too much awsomeness in this video
Damn. Why can't Nightwish just have two angels?
They are perfect!!!!!!
OK...I can die happy now. Amazing.
Perfeitas! Amo as duas! Lindas e com uma belíssima voz! :)
9:20
The Truth has been sung.
I just prefer Floor, I can't help it, that voice catches me all the damn times
I think Emmpu agrees with you. Lol I love his smile as she's singing that last high note.
I totally loved your video....
I would love to hear them perform this song together... They sound magnficent. Although I love Floor for many years longer than I even known Tarja, I love them both. But I think Floor gives Ghost Love Score an extra boost by slowing it a little bit down until the end, where she gives it a bite. Love her touch too this song. The only thing missing in the performance of Floor is the confetti ;)
all my thoughts of comparison making disappeared, checking out this awesome video became more important
y me encanta este video por que reúne lo que mas me gusta de cada una, mis dos cantantes favoritas juntas en una de mis canciones favoritas :D
Stunning...
Both are awesome,I love Tarja's job I really do, but Floor just simply did a perfect job and that last scream near the end oh man!!! I don't how to express it but i think epic climax is close enough.
love them both))
Holy moly this is good.
lindas !! Deusas do caos caótico .
ja imaginaram as 2 juntas seria o maior espetáculo da terra !!!!
I did a audio mix of the album version and the new live version from wacken.....lets just say OMG....there were times that i couldn't tell who was who. And Floor seems like she sang the album version closer than Tarja did on this version.
Where can we hear this? Upload it please!
Just enjoy guys :). Im so happy that Floor found a band that deserves her, and NW found a face/voice that represents proudly the band.
Floor le ha devuelto a Nightwish lo que perdió cuando Tarja dejo la banda, puedo decir por fin, NIGHTWISH HA REGRESADO!! (Anette tiene buena voz, pero Floor tiene ese algo fuerte que Tarja le daba a Nightwish y a la audiencia) yes I know Floor is not Tarja, Ya se que Floor no es tarja, but still, Nightwish finally have something even more powerful, pero igual Nightwish al fin tiene algo màs poderoso.
que limado el que hizo este video, buenísimo esta!!!
Awesome! It took me a while to get them lined up perfectly, but that Was very cool! :)
Hands down Floor!!! I bow to your awesomeness!
Awesome!!!
ME ENCANTÓ!!!!!!!!!! lo amé
i love it!!
I love this! Nice work!
Just watch the end of the video and see who wins, people chants Flor ! Floor ! Floor!... and she is the only one.
Tarja is taking a shower at that moment, Floor really feels it.
amo esta cancion ambas la cantan muy bien...pero me quedo con la diosa TARJA passssssssssiioon!
This is SYMPHONIC metal band with a major background orchestra.
The perfect synchrony is due to the identical background orchestration.
JUST... PERFECT
Gonna put this out there: I saw the title and thought that it would sound horrible but it WORKS!!! I don't think Anette would have worked with either of them this way.
hacen una armonia perfecta!
En Buenos Aires habia público, en el End of an Era habia white walkers.
Esto es épico, realmente genial como quedan sus voces juntas
Amazing!!!! I wanna cry *w*
Excelente!!
Watching this I can finally and definately say: FLOOR! I always thought she was the only one who could substitute Tarja.. Really happy to have her in the band, and hopefully she's gonna stay! :)
Yahhhhhhh, she rocks!!!!!!!!! Greetings.
that ending by floor never gets old.. and will never get old
No, I think there couldn't be any type of war among them because both are great singers and performer. So There's no need to choose!! They both are just amazing!!!
the best duo, waaaaa
Sony Vegas Pro
This is really nice...
BRUTAL
9:10 Error 404 Tarja Not Found. LOL
Wow, you did a great job with this vid...
Another big difference between the two versions apart from the singers' voice is that Tuomas smiles in the second version and the band in general seems happier playing together ;) As much as I miss Tarja in Nightwish, the atmosphere in the band now is way better, Tuomas himself said so and even laughed at a later joke of the interviewer (for me the words 'Tuomas' and 'laugh' could not be combined until 2005 at least).After Floor's voice, this is the second reason I pray she stays in NW.
Genious
Please, don't extol who you think is the best (it's kinda disrespectful), these are two different versions and this is the closest to a dream we will ever get! *-*
Tarja owns this song and Floor managed to match the epic feeling! Amazing!
please do other ¡¡¡ floor & Anette storytime
I see. You are saying the background orchestra music acts as a metronome. This accounts for the two versions, recorded so many years apart, yet so perfectly synchronized.
The truth is obvious once it is revealed.
I think Floor did not apply for Nightwish because she already sang in After Forever.
Both bands (Nightwish and After Forever) are really great bands.
After Forever was opening act for Nigthwish many times in the Netherlands, which was really cool because you did got 2 great bands for the price of 1 :)
I did not see ReVamp yet but i bet they are really good too.
Very well done video. I love Tarja and Floor, they both are great singers! Tarja is not coming back to Nightwish so Floor is the best option for Nightwish in my opinion :)
The first time they played the song. There were two times where Emppu and Marco shared a "Fuck! She can do that!?" moment. That powerscream was one of them.
her first "Into the dark....." there were hidden high-fives all around on stage. Don't remember the date though. it's right here on the tube.
Vocalists aside, did anyone notice the real star of the show: NIGHTWISH.
Seriously, those guys are so good they sound almost like a relentless flawless musical machine !
I bet Floor knows this and that's why she will definitely do everything she can to get to be permanent vocalist...
Love me some Floor!!!
end of an era was sooo epic!
I like Tarja, but I LOVE Floor(tje)
Floorgasm !!!
ese dia estuvo INCREIBLEEEEEEEE
Floorality! proof = 7:43 Tarja, u was good, but not enough!
:s
I love how Emppu looks at Floor just before "that note" and is grinning like a Cheshire cat afterwards :D
Buenos Aires FTW!
wow thank u
A request if I may?
Could you do a version from End of an Era and Showtime, Storytime (Wacken 2013)?
I think that would be perfect if y'ask me..
TE FUISTE A CARAJO JOJO GRACIAS X ESTO EH
Floor owns the stage.
Tarja owns the song.
🖤
9:18 OH MY FREAKING WHATEVER-OR WHOEVER--I-BELIEVE-INTO!!!