I started listening to Nightwish since Tarja era. Then Annette, Now Floor. Of the 3, Tarja the Gothic Queen, Annette the “Pop” Queen, and finally Floor, the Valkyrie Metal Queen. All have their merits. I just prefer FLOOR, because I can feel the emotion of the song when Floor sings.
Toveri Juri I agree! Well done... Nightwish is the Music and Composition of Mastermind Mr. Holopainen. The singer isn't important imho. Tarja was great, Anette was cute, Floor is ok, but Roy Khan would fit also to the music imho... With a matching Instrument for the main melody part and its voice , you could even do this music without a singer. Ich stimme zu! Gut gemacht... Nightwish ist die Musik und Komposition von Meister Holopainen. Die Saengerin ist unwichtig, meiner Meinung nach. Tarja war grossartig, Anette suess, Floor in Ordnung, aber Roy Khan wuerde genauso zur Musik passen, wie ich finde... Mit dem passenden Instrument fuer die Erste Stimme, könnte man sogar auf einen Saenger verzichten.
i like both singers, so instead of joining in on the arguement over who is better, i want to take a moment to admire the human metronome, Jukka Nevalainen. -_-
Yeah! Jukka was my favourite. I miss him in Nightwish more than Tarja or Anette. He was the pulse and his stage presence was pure rock'n'roll bad ass vibe with his bandana and tattoos.
Anette is still my favourite. yes she was the weakest live, but Dark passion play and Imaginaerum are easily my favourite NW records so she will always be the best in my eyes
I love them both. For me, it is impossible to say which one is better, because they are both incredible, irreplaceable talents, and they both are brilliant in their own ways, and I can't say anything bad about either. I love Nightwish and they've never done anything I thought was bad.
Nightwish has to be the luckiest band in existence. How do you get two of the most incredible singers. They don't have to change any of the music to switch between them.
Ironically, despite agreeing that Tarja and Floor are two of the most incredible vocalists, I think Tuomas has hit his composer peak with the two albums that they released with Anette.
@@mihaitha yep. Nightwish are a greatest hits band now. The studio albums with Floor have lacked, and now with Marko leaving, I can't help thinking it's becoming the Tuomas and Troy show.
Jaw-dropping. Did you see the chubby red-hed in the front row just after Floor screams "Time to never hold our love"? She was having one hell of a Floorgasm. Looked like she was going to faint :D I love how for the 1st 4 minutes she sings just like the original but after that she decides to sing it her way.
Man, if I was there at the concert, when Floor does that angelic yell, (9:29) in the video, I would have blacked out from the sheer epic metal in her voice.
You will most likely get that chance. She does that yell every time when she sings this song, and in all my years of listening to Floor's singing, I haven never heard her miss 1 note
Very good mix. Floor and Tarja are friends, any attempt to create antagonism is just a whim. Tarja has a unique voice, she has a unique vibrato. Floor may not have exactly that, but she has a great voice, and the strength and resilience she has on stage is wonderful
Thallanar Rabidtooth i heard her live and i can safely say that you will black out, there is so much power coming from that voice it's insane and awesome :)
I started following NW music just when TarJa exit ...went to NW live shows couple time with Annette ( loves & missed Annette ❤ ) also saw Floor for couple of time plus planning to see NW in Los Angeles beginning 2022 ...CANNOT WAIT !! MY FAV SYMPHONIC ROCKS BAND EVER .
9:30 And thats when Floor took the crown from Tarja for me. She earned it, did NOT steal it. Both are great, but Floor was made to be in this band. Our Valkyrie!
Could it be that you just smoke some weird stuff ? Floor has neither the class nor the voice to even remotely hold a candle to Tarja. A high tone does not make an extraordinary singer. It's just average and boring. And today's success and fame Nightwish owe entirely to Tarja and not to a third-rate Dutch singer.
Just imagine, if Tarja would ever join Nightwish on stage just for one song and do a duett with Floor... How incredible that would be, I know this will never happen, understandably so considering how Tarja and the rest of the band parted ways, but just imagine it..... IF it ever did happen, I would literally give ANYTHING to be there and see that show in person I have always and will always be in Tarjas corner, she's the OG, I dont think Nightwish would have ven formed without her and definately not reched the heights they have, but I will never deny that Floor is an incredible singer too, and probably more versatile in her vocal abilities And no, me saying I dont think Nightwish would have formed/reached the heights they have without Tarja does not mean that I think Tuomas and the rest of the band would not have been sucessful, they are all brilliant musicians and Tuomas a fantastic composer, I just don't think they would have done it toghether, as one band
It's 3:14 that makes difference. Tarja is fantastic. Floor addition at the ending , very good. I love the duet. Each One of them has a different characteristic with which prevails.
Just watched a recent interview with Floor. She is now FLUENT IN FINNISH!! When she joined, she said that she wanted to learn to feel closer and more at home with her boys. Well she has learned, and it didn't seem like she had any trouble going into Finnish and back to English. Learn all our songs in two days? OK! Learn Finnish next? OK! Is ther anything this wonder woman can't do? Love you Floor!!
I think the world of this group. They are more talented then many. Opera and metal blend. VERY moving and powerful! Floor has it for me, hands down! I hope she is healthy and happy!
Thank you ALL from my deepest heart RUclipsrs ! I'll try to do other Nightwish Mixes when I'll have time! Thanx for your comments, thanx for sharing and, thanx for "Likes" ! Peace !!! Spydee.
i think the conclusion here is. for anyone thats used to Tarja , she will always have a special place in the nightwish army , BUT Floor is just so damn good she cant be ignored , her voice is something extraordinary .
I hated Nightwish with Anette. Anette was not a bad singer, it just did not feel like Nightwish with her. With Floor it feels like Nightwish again. They need a certain type of singer for their sound.
@@maxrav1831 I don't care. I think Nightwish sounds much better with Tarja, and Floor. Aneete just did not sound like Nightwish to me. It was like when Ray Manzarek tried to be the lead singer of the Doors after Morison died. It just did not sound like the Doors.
@@DarthSoto78 Nah I would say more like Brian Johnstone replacing Bon Scott, Brian got and still gets the same shit Anette gets from so called fans yet his first album with the band is the 3rd or 4th biggest selling album of all time, much like the effect Anette had both commercially and creatively.
@@agustinmanyari i will add she also interacts with the audience more too meaning Floor, her voice is much clearer and she has the ability at least in this song to almost vocal fry ..maybe more versatile than Tarja but I like opera so it is all good, Now , I will say, I have not listened to other songs with Tarja singing, only based on this song having heard both versions. and can I say that that drummer is fantastic!! all of them are great but jeez..he goes all out
To be honest Tarja had to change her outfit after this song, and GLS wasnt originaly ment to finish with such a scream. Otherwise she would do something like the end of Tha phantom of the opera. On the other hand Floor is capable to add something from her to the song, so why not?
@@rientsdijkstra4266 ridículo.🤣🤣🤣 Eu iria ao otorrinolaringologista. Na melhor das hipóteses, Floor é uma cantora comum que fica entediada depois de um tempo. O Nightwish deve seu sucesso exclusivamente a Tarja. Se Floor tivesse sido a primeira cantora, o Nightwish ainda estaria tocando em algum quintal hoje.
@@tommyr.6473 Many lost words without point. I Like Floor's singing much better than Tarja's. Tarja has bad vowels, harsh "iii", "eee", "aaa", bad control, bad tone, always the same 0-0-0-0 vibrato. Tarja is wannabee opera singer, but not a good opera singer. Sorry.
@@rientsdijkstra4266 You don't have to apologize because you write stupid stuff here and really have no idea. Floor is an ordinary, average singer with nothing special about her. It probably satisfies the average taste. I've already listened to your songs here on YT. After the 2nd I switched off because it's so boring and I would have fallen asleep otherwise. This voice doesn't stick in your memory because there's just nothing special about it. For me, Nightwish died with Tarja's inglorious departure, because without her it's just a normal band without a soul. You don't have to answer anymore either, your first statement was embarrassing enough. Thank you, at least you made me laugh.🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@tommyr.6473 You say you listened to only two songs of one of the greatests and most versatile singers alive, who is hailed by millions not only because of her great technique, but especially because of her enormous versatility, her ability to emotionally connect and tell the story of the song, and bringing millions to tears by doing so. I literally have more then 1500 reaction to Floors version of GLS here, and in more then 90% comment are like "WOW..." , "It is so effortless.."", "I don't what to say after that", "I need a cigarette", "Thanks Floor, now I am a blubbering mess for the rest of the day", etc, etc. Yet, you listened to only two(!!) songs of her, and you are already able to tell that she is "forgetable" and "boring". Wow man, I must say that I admire the accute power of observation of that brilliant mind of yours! Few are to able make such astute observations as you are! But now back to reality. If you listen to this video, you will simply hear that in the parts between 8.82 and 9.13 Tarja seems to run out of ideas and sounds boring and flat untill she throws a handkiss and walks of the stage (... leaving the song to peter out) , then Floor comes on again with her unique power and gives us the spectacular ending that she invented and that made the song world famous. But also in the other parts of the song, Floor simply sounds better, and especially more fluent and better integrated with the music. Floor is simply the better singer. So I remain with my view: Tarja has a certain special sound, that a certain group of people (like you) seems to like very much. Well you are welcome to it (!). Taste and preference are personal, and I wont fight you on that. I personally don't like that sound however. To me it sounds like an empty trick, that she repeats again and again, without any real personal or emotional involvement That is why I say that Tarja is OVERRATED. Tarja is a great singer, but LIMITED (partly by her own choice) and she will never become a true great opera singer. For that she has too many technical shortcommings. And the things that she can do well, I simply don't like... (taste and preference!) That brings me back to you. Pittyfull are people who can not see greatness because they are blinded by empty spite.
This is perfect for someone like me who prefers this song with Tarja's operatic vocals and Floor's ending. Just my personal opinion, of course. These two make my favorite singers of the genre. Also, good job to Spydee RAJAONAH. I like this video very much. :)
I don't know if it's nostalgia but when I hear Tarja I want to cry, she makes me feel so many emotions with her voice and I feel like I'm transported to a different era. Floor is amazing but Tarja for me is hands down the best in Nightwish.
9:14 is all I have to say. Does anyone remember that one time Tarja sung this song absolutely belted the end and then headbanged until the song finished? Me neither. I absolutely love Floor so much energy and passion.
So Tarja should have foreseen years into the FUTURE and should have performed this NEW version?? Is that what are you trying to say?? Do you think it was Floor idea to do that finale?? hahaha
@@user-1953. Олег! Страна большая! Путин за всеми не успевает! Это не Сталин,которому никто не был указ, и который расстреливал, когда хотел, и для него не было никакой Америки. Сейчас две правящие силы- деньги и лицемерие! И обе очень опасны и ядовиты!!!
For the love of God I hate the argument! The truth is that these two ladies have & would work together again. Perhaps even on the same stage! I'll point a finger of blame at the mad genius Tuomas, for he was the one to have needlessly complicated an iconic band & concept! Personally, I am glad the two ladies appreciate each other's God-given gifts & it's only the fan factions who "wish" to kill each other! I love this Tribute to both!!!
They singing Over the Hills and Far Away together gives me life. They're amazing. They're different and shouldn't be compared since they have different signatures di their singing
Say what you will about either singer, but Floor and Nightwish have carved themselves into history as creators of the most majestic metal moment ever. There's no need to link to it. You all know that moment.
i always thought that it was a great loss, that Tarja stopped. Nightwish has never been the same again, but with Floor, the band is back on track. Go Nightwish !!!!
Duas Deusas do Metal juntas... Uau!! Curto a Voz e Performance impecável de Floor Jansen... Mas Tarja turunen é a Deusa com Voz de Anjo... Belíssima!! Dois estilos distintos e magníficos... Mas Tarja é Inigualável!!! Parabéns às duas talentosíssimas cantoras... Tarja turunen é de Outra dimensão!!!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🍷🍷🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤💙💙💙🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩✌🤟🤘
penso o mesmo, as musicas escritas na epoca de tarja são outro nivel, espero que nightwish escreva músicas para a Floor agora, por que essa cantora é muito boa, só que me parece que a banda ainda tenta implacar uma tarja turunen, e não devia, tem um diamante bruto ali, não sabendo usar....com asaida do marco hietala então....nem se fala
@@marcosroliveira360 Discordo bastante na verdade na questão de fazerem dela uma nova Tarja considerando que boa parte das músicas dela sem usam a voz operística, fora que o alcance e a versatilidade da Floor é maior até do que a Tarja, não é a toa que até nas músicas da Anette ela arrasa, sem dúvida minha favorita, principalmente ao vivo!
Just recently crawled out from under the rock I apparently live under and discovered Nightwish. I've compared them for days now. In my opinion, Floor easily wins. Tarja has a beautiful voice but Floor just has an air about her that takes it to another level. She can bring a grown man to tears with ease. Tarja just doesn't have that.
Tarja es la única que le da esa magia a esa canción. Ya no se puede comparar nos acostumbraron a lo sublime las canciones que ahora canta floor ya son. A su estilo es y es bueno a secas Nightwish ya no es mágico ya no te transporta como con Tarja
Pues tengo otra opinión sobre eso, sobretodo porque la primera vez que escuché nightwish ha sido con Tarja, pero no he podido sentir toda esa magia de la que tanto se habla... Había escuchado Nemo y me gustó, así que me puse a investigar un poco más, pero lo que parecía bueno, la verdad era lo más aburrido que había escuchado. En esa misma época descubrí Within Temptation y Epica, solo después Afterforever y Floor Jansen... El estilo de voz de esas tres bandas me gustaba más que Nightwish, pero cuando escuché a Floor cantando Ghost Love Score, me he dado cuenta de que la música era buena, pero el estilo vocal de Tarja no...
Thanks for this mix, I rather love both singers than comparing who's the best, they have unique voices and unique style and listening them together....oh god, truly amazing!!!!!!!!!! \m/ 😎
This is what Floor means to us. Not trying to start a war here or anything. Just wanted to share some things I've noticed in these boards in my short time here. And also to drop a bit of reasoning as why us Floor fans are just as passionate about our superwoman as Tarja fans are. Tarja fans, for the most part, don't seem to know a whole lot about Floor, otherwise they would probably treat her with a little more respect. And for that we do have to cut them a little slack. They only judge her by her live performances with NW and usually the earlier ones when she'd only been in the band a month or two as opposed to 10 months or so by the time she performed at Wacken. Floor's work ethic alone and what she was able to accomplish in so little time is unspeakable. Sadly, we think of Tarjaholics as snobbish bullies who are stuck in the past and who think they are vastly superior about their knowledge of singing than the rest of us are and take every moment to put down anyone else that is not Tarja. Obviously I do not think all Tarja fans think like this but the very vocal ones you see popping up in every video don't help matters. Anyone who knows anything about Floor realizes this woman has it all. Rock, metal, classical, contemporary and that stage presence is second to none. Us Floor fans don't care if Tarja's classical voice is technically better. She's not a classical singer like Tarja is and we don't expect her to be. But when Floor comes soaring in with her operatics we appreciate Floor's softer and prettier voice just to have her turn around and growl and snear and then belt out an insanely pitched note. We love how she takes a song like Ghost Love Score and uses her voice and body in unison to portray a variety of emotions. The way she just adds her own flair to the end and turning it from a great song into a true epic. There is a reason that the last 90 or so seconds of this video end with Floor. She continues the note that Tarja left on, stretches it out 2 to 3 times longer and then just launches into this unworldly vocal assault that left the audience screaming in delight and wonderment. And these moments we call Floorgasms. When the hair stands up on our skin, get chills down our spines or when we are suddenly moved to tears. This is why we love Floor. 09:13, nuff said. Comments are welcome just don't be an a-hole trying to start a flame war. I would truly love to read a well thought post about why you like Tarja better.
All that, plus the song was written with Tarja's voice in mind -- not Floor's. That she adapts it so well is truly remarkable. Tarja's rendition is powerful and still very much worth listening too -- particularly the studio version -- but ultimately nothing beats the ending of Floor's live version: simply astounding.
Yeah..why argue about both when both are so different? And many Floor fans also often argue about Tarja being bad (because of the letter which called her a diva which means they don't know alot about Tarja because Tarja is one of the kindest musicians out there..she is so cute xD) so ...yeah if just fans of both sides would stop being ignorant and would stop judging without reason it would be realy cool..but we can't have nice things can we? :/ Also going back to the letter thing, Tarja is not anymore like in nightwish..since the break-up she has never been like that..people often forget that over the time stuff changes. Tarja also has stage-presence now and interacts alot with her fans. But people often ignore that. Floor and Tarja are both great singers and I think they don't deserve the hate...
TheOther98 Seriously get a life instead of posting the same comment over and over again. And please, Charlotte Wessels, if that's the Charlotte you are referring too, isn't even in the same league as Floor or Tarja.
The range of Floor is incredible. Low, metal grunting, screaming, pop, opera...she can do everything. Tarja is great too, but only in opera/soprano. And here english is not that good. Besides the volume from Floors voice is much betterand louder, she owns the band, like a goddess!
skinnybmw Agree. Both are amazingly amazing ! Personally I prefer Floor though. She seems to cover the whole spectrum incredibly well. God this was insane to watch !
still love Floor but her mainstream vocals are lady gaga like, lazy grunting,too much screaming and thin operatic utterances..far cry from her glory days with After Forever and REvamp..hope she goes back to that model...Tarja is operatic but with a myriad of equally powerful flavors
I would never deny Tarja's talent, and she had the history behind her of course. But I feel like her style is overly affected. Floor is a force of nature. Its almost unfair to compare her to any other mortal in the genre. I love metal opera jazz you name it; my impression is that she has very few peers across history and the various disciplines. At the very least she absolutely dominates and owns this song. One can still appreciate Tarja while allowing this.
I love both Tarjas and Floors voice. Both of them fit Nightwish. Both of them have classically trained voices which is what I appreciate in Nightwish music. Anette was a sweet girl with a good voice, but for me personally the classical touch is a must in Nightwishs music.
Spydee RAJAONAH ye lmao, her voice tends to " run out ", in all honesty anette has a good voice but not for a band with this style of music, bands like this need a good soprano
Lo contrario es cierto. El problema de Tarja es que ese amplio vibrato 0-0-0-0-0 choca con los fuertes y complejos ritmos del Metal, impidiendo que fluya. Además, el sonido del paladar hueco de Tarja tampoco suena bien.
@@jeysonsoto5343 Por eso la voz de Floor es mejor. Tarja solo puede hacer un truco y se vuelve molesto. Floor puede expresar cualquier cosa que el compositor le pida, Y tiene el sentido de entender cómo capturar y transmitir ese sentimiento.
Спасибо, Тарья,за то что когда-то исполняла эту песню. Спасибо Анетт, которая тоже когда-то постаралась и исполняла эту песню. Спасибо Флоор Янсен, за то что сейчас исполняешь эту песню. Спасибо Вам: Эмпу, Марко, Юкка, Кай, Юкка( новый басист) и Трой(?) , за то что играли и играете эту песню. И огромное спасибо уважаемый маэстро Туомас Холопайнен, за создание этого шедевра, за создание всех песен Nightwish. За Ваши идеи, за Ваши труды, за Ваши упорство и за такие потрясающие результаты. Спасибо тебе большое Nightwish.
+haleskiss I think he really did mean amazon because Floor is so tall and beautiful and her voice is very feminine and rich. Tarja could be compared to a sorceress because of her style of dress as well as her voice which sounds like it came straight from a fantasy its so beautiful. Really both of them have such great voices.
+Virginia Harp was just making a play on his choice of words, If I thought he was being an ass in his word choice, my response would have been very different. cheers and keep rolling with the music😃
The sync between the two versions of this masterpiece is godly!!!!! My goodness I'm simply not emotionally prepared for this... Got goosbumps over goosebumps over goosebumps. And I don't know if that is even possible
El lugar que Tarja dejó en Nightwish es demasiado grande y no lo pudieron llenar nunca más. La potencia y la tecnica de Tarja la hace simplemente la mejor.
I absolutely love Floor.. but when I was introduced to Nightwish Tarja was Nightwish for me. Even loved Annette. All 3 bring their own and love that We shouldn't compare them which we do but Nightwish and the music is what makes us happy.
For the first half of the song, both sound amazing, but after the interlude, Floor dominates, what's amazing, this song was written with Tarja in mind, yet Floor just makes it hers.
@@Lesandwish shes not amazing in the second half either. Has similar traits to a generic pop singer who strains her voice to change it at specific tones... nothing bad about it tho it sounds great but Tarja just keeps it clean and only widens her voice instead of using the more generic tricks to make it glorious, she has stronger voice for sure.
@@Otakahunt Tarja just keeps clean and boring as always... Her dynamic didn't change in the second part: all the instrumentation got more heavy, but she couldn't match the same with her voice... in other words, she can build up a song from soft to heavy,she is always soft and that's it!!!
@@Otakahunt Do you have any type of musical training with an opinion like that? I’m not sure what you’re hearing, but maybe your eardrums don’t work the same way the rest of our do?
@@Otakahunt The only thing we can actually argue about is range, and Floor’s range is much wider than Tarja’s. Phrasing and “beauty” in voices is all subjective and preference. I prefer Floor’s phrasing and think her range opens doors this song never had with Tarja, but again that’s my opinion
They're both amazing, with a few special voice characteristics each. Both hit the highest notes but Tarja's lower range is better. However Floor as a growl in the angry rocker phrases that Tarja doesn't have. You can't see it in this version, but Floor has a special ability for adding her own creation/improvisation at the end of Ghost Love Score, not so much in this Wacken version but especially the orgasmic end in the Buenos Aires Live DVD. The audience sure noticed it there chanting her name. And then Tarja invented the *whole genre* herself!! I can only imagine a NW + Floor studio album will be amazing, and Tarja's solo albums are getting better all the time. Impossible to choose one over the other. Hope I will see more of the two singing together one of these days, like that gig in Belgium.
Imposible no emocionarse con esta banda y sobre todo con esas dos mujeres cantantando tan dulce, las escucho a las dos y no puedo decidir cual me gusta más, dos grandes de verdad
Amazing editing holy shit I had goosebumps like the entire time. You should do more of these. I'm pretty sure you're the only one that mixes them together this good.
isn't the Fins kind of close cousins of you Russians? im from the extreme west of the continent ( just for reference) and on my modest opinion Finland produce some of the best heavy metal in the world
I never thought I would like anyone, other than Tarja, performing this. Floor Jansen proved me wrong! What an amazing performance :-) Brilliant edit and mix up of the two RAJAONAH.
I believe that all three nightwish singers should do a show together. I think comparing them is foolish. Nightwish is a living entity that changes over time like you have. We get to see the band from tarja to floor and ŵe get to enjoy the entire life span. Be thankful.
Just a Jot: No one comes close to Tarja's melodic depth! Leave modulation to key changes. She's highly skilled not wild in any way. All the best, Jamieson. Please remember...there's a natural silence to melodic depth. You can hear it. You can feel it. But, most of all it's an awakening to the sound & enjoyment of melody and orchestration. All the great composers would die for the depth Tarja brings to melody & orchestration.
hedwegg Tarja is awful. Horrible pronunciation, uncontrolled vibrato, zero versatility and can't stop fishing for her notes. Thank god they kicked her to the curb. The era of the Nightwish began when Floor joined. FLOORGASM!!!!
+Dave Mason to be fair, when Tarja sings in Finnish, her voice is quite lovely...and there is very little misplaced vibrato or that horrendous mashing of vowels. And you sir are one funny man, thank you for spreading your humor liberally through these comments. It does help lighten the Tarjaholic fog.
I love them both and I am happy that Nightwish have Floor now. Floor is cool and has by far the best stage presence of all the 3, and she sings some old songs really good. She is Metal, and she is domination and sweetness as well :(I say this as a girl!!!) :))) But sorry, if anyone listens to this mix and then seriously says that Floor is a better singer than Tarja, (s)he must simply be deaf or be driven by personal sympathy (or most likely deafened by personal sympathy). As a person I also like Floor more than Tarja, but as a singer Floor is not anywhere near Tarjas ability (as everyone not deaf dumb blind can easily notice by hearing this mix). I actually don't know why Floors performance of this song gets praised so much, as in this mix its undeniably obvious how limited her skills are, compared to those of Tarja. And now, may you believe or not: Still I am absolutely glad that Floor is in Nightwish, and may they be as happy and successful as possible (and the same for Tarja and her band, of course) :) :.. Btw fanboys on each side, Tarja and Floor are close friends, and the hate is only in your heads - definitely neither in Tarjas nor Floors heart. Think about it.
@@davemason4055 What?!!! Tarja is very trained opera singer, try to compare Wishmaster of both and you'll understand something about music! Kind regards
i like both versions. floors is amazing cause its an iconic moment where she hits insane notes, but tarja is more enchanting and operatic, which is funner to sing along to :)
Tarja Turunen is the greatest vocalist Nightwish ever had. She's unique, like a Goddess singing, and the songs recorded with her voice belong to the golden age of Nightwish, but the best live version of Ghost Love Score is definitely this version With Floor.
y en el minuto 8:12? escucha la version de tarja y la de flor, terrible derrape de flor horrible le sale este tema! por que grite en el 9:29 no hace que sea mejor jajajaja!
the 2013, more rolling baseline Floor fit beautifully, but in the earlier, more orchestral, symphonic version, Tarja's angelic fluidity was so perfection
Both are oprah singers and their voice range is jaw dropping. They are two most powerful and explosive singers. Tarja phantom of oprah and Floor Ghost love score are two masterpieces can never and ever be copied or attempted.
I am listening in 2024, and it's very epic. Hoo else?
Here and still amazing 🖤
the army will be always here
I'm listening to it today
Imposible olvidar!!!
Me too! Masterpiece!
Floor is angelic and devilish at once, Tarja is an epic goddess singing for us from the ancient eras... These two cannot be compared. Guys, stahp.
A Floor tem uma voz mais bela e marcante, além de mais potente, vai da base grave a aguda (lírica naturalmente). Já Tarja não. Floor é a melhor.
Te apoyo totalmente, el encanto de Tarja es su voz "teatral" que es necesaria en canciones como Planet Hell pero en esta ocasión me quedo con Floor.
Minha opinião fera, Tarja contribuiu muito com o Nightwish, mas eu prefiro a atual fase!
I totally agree! Finally somebody put words to my thoughts and feelings about this! :D
Agree totally. There wouldn"t have been Nightwish without Tarja. This is now a second chapter and they are lucky Floor brought them back to life. .
Listening to:
- Ghost love score with Tarja = goosebumps
- Ghost love score with Floor = goosebumps
- Ghost love score with both = intense goosebumps
What about Anette?
@@anmirurimaure Right...who?
@@peteswift1710 XDDD
Floor Jansen mejor calidad vocal 👍👍👍
I dont think she ever covered this one. Her voice just isnt made for this band
They both are awesome there is no comparison needed between them! We asked God for an angel so instead he sent us two!!
3, do not forget Simone of Epica
@Susan Moran xx v. Jnnnñlmmmwslmkllpññ
How bout:
1. Elli Berlin of Null Positiv (German band)
2. Charlotte Wessel of Delain
3. Elyze Ryd of Aramenthe
4. Sharon Den Adel of within temptation
All talented as well but these two are in a league of their own sorry!
Amen !
I started listening to Nightwish since Tarja era. Then Annette, Now Floor. Of the 3, Tarja the Gothic Queen, Annette the “Pop” Queen, and finally Floor, the Valkyrie Metal Queen. All have their merits. I just prefer FLOOR, because I can feel the emotion of the song when Floor sings.
Nightwish should have a concert with the 3. Just imagine that combination. It could be very very awesome...
yeah her powerfull voice is WONDERFULL!!!!
Agreed
same here
I'm enjoying your opinion, but l like the Gothic woman most of all!!! Tarja is absolutely perfect in this project!!!
Who would not listen this in 2024? Or any year which comes after?
Masterpiece!
BEAUTIFULLLL
essa voz ai vou escutar pra sempre a cantora mais completa que existe.
Escucho mucho Nigthwish, son mis favoritos. 😊
THANK YOU so much
Yes I am ❤
No matter what your opinion is on the singers this mix is masterfully done.
Oh, so kind of U Toveri, I really appreciate :) Thank you
agreed!
Yahhh!!!!
Toveri Juri
I agree! Well done...
Nightwish is the Music and Composition of Mastermind Mr. Holopainen. The singer isn't important imho. Tarja was great, Anette was cute, Floor is ok, but Roy Khan would fit also to the music imho...
With a matching Instrument for the main melody part and its voice , you could even do this music without a singer.
Ich stimme zu! Gut gemacht...
Nightwish ist die Musik und Komposition von Meister Holopainen. Die Saengerin ist unwichtig, meiner Meinung nach. Tarja war grossartig, Anette suess, Floor in Ordnung, aber Roy Khan wuerde genauso zur Musik passen, wie ich finde...
Mit dem passenden Instrument fuer die Erste Stimme, könnte man sogar auf einen Saenger verzichten.
Toveri Juri tis
i like both singers, so instead of joining in on the arguement over who is better, i want to take a moment to admire the human metronome, Jukka Nevalainen.
-_-
Yeah! Jukka was my favourite. I miss him in Nightwish more than Tarja or Anette. He was the pulse and his stage presence was pure rock'n'roll bad ass vibe with his bandana and tattoos.
Anette is still my favourite. yes she was the weakest live, but Dark passion play and Imaginaerum are easily my favourite NW records so she will always be the best in my eyes
Human metronome... my god, this description fits him like a glove
Great job, thank you!
And gosh they both are incredible!
god i miss him
I love them both. For me, it is impossible to say which one is better, because they are both incredible, irreplaceable talents, and they both are brilliant in their own ways, and I can't say anything bad about either. I love Nightwish and they've never done anything I thought was bad.
Nightwish has to be the luckiest band in existence. How do you get two of the most incredible singers. They don't have to change any of the music to switch between them.
and of course Simone of Epica
They did kinda have that blip in between the two that we won't mention....
Ironically, despite agreeing that Tarja and Floor are two of the most incredible vocalists, I think Tuomas has hit his composer peak with the two albums that they released with Anette.
@@mihaitha yep. Nightwish are a greatest hits band now. The studio albums with Floor have lacked, and now with Marko leaving, I can't help thinking it's becoming the Tuomas and Troy show.
@@mihaitha That does concern me. Too many live CDs and old material.
That ending with Floor was beautiful!
Jaw-dropping. Did you see the chubby red-hed in the front row just after Floor screams "Time to never hold our love"? She was having one hell of a Floorgasm. Looked like she was going to faint :D
I love how for the 1st 4 minutes she sings just like the original but after that she decides to sing it her way.
Hamster Munchies Looking her almost made me faint too xd
I consider floor one of the best female singers in the world
❤
Me too.
Kills is one of the best drummers in the universe. I try to play like him but can’t 59 and worn out.
Man, if I was there at the concert, when Floor does that angelic yell, (9:29) in the video, I would have blacked out from the sheer epic metal in her voice.
I see what you mean Thallanar :)
You will most likely get that chance. She does that yell every time when she sings this song, and in all my years of listening to Floor's singing, I haven never heard her miss 1 note
No words, she sing like no boby in this planet
Very good mix. Floor and Tarja are friends, any attempt to create antagonism is just a whim. Tarja has a unique voice, she has a unique vibrato. Floor may not have exactly that, but she has a great voice, and the strength and resilience she has on stage is wonderful
Thallanar Rabidtooth i heard her live and i can safely say that you will black out, there is so much power coming from that voice it's insane and awesome :)
The ending which Floor added over the original is, without a doubt, EPIC.
I like them both. But just Floor's version - hits harder for me.
Tarja Turunen and Floor Jansen. Incredibles voices. Amazing 👏👏👏🔥💯🔥🔥🔥💥💥💥
I started following NW music just when TarJa exit ...went to NW live shows couple time with Annette ( loves & missed Annette ❤ ) also saw Floor for couple of time plus planning to see NW in Los Angeles beginning 2022 ...CANNOT WAIT !! MY FAV SYMPHONIC ROCKS BAND EVER .
Has someone send this to Tarja and Floor? THIS SHOW NEEDS TO HAPPEN ON THE FUTURE!!!
At the end of the song the power and range of floor Jansen is there's no comparison.
I prefer Floor, but I have to admit that this song shows off both of their voices in the most lovely manner.
Ain't it ! :)
Final Floor's "My fall will be for you" always give me creeps
written by Tuomas in 2004 in yet another romantic overture to guess who?...
Heebee Geebees
Goose bumps omg😯 😍💃🤘
Intense emotion, power, perfect voice, very deep, that's amazing 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
that is called a floorgasm.
There is just ONE thing, that could make this even more awesome: Having an ACTUAL choir to sing the chorus.
Also an actual live orchestra
No without Jukka on the drum. The result will only little better than tarja and her band. 😅
Great idea. 😉
Scardust did that.
9:30 And thats when Floor took the crown from Tarja for me. She earned it, did NOT steal it. Both are great, but Floor was made to be in this band. Our Valkyrie!
Floor no took the crown, she inherited it. Only she was worthy.
Marco is thanos!😂
Meravigliosa...
Floor, doesn't need anyone else's
She came, with her own crown..
Could it be that you just smoke some weird stuff ? Floor has neither the class nor the voice to even remotely hold a candle to Tarja. A high tone does not make an extraordinary singer. It's just average and boring. And today's success and fame Nightwish owe entirely to Tarja and not to a third-rate Dutch singer.
Just imagine, if Tarja would ever join Nightwish on stage just for one song and do a duett with Floor... How incredible that would be, I know this will never happen, understandably so considering how Tarja and the rest of the band parted ways, but just imagine it..... IF it ever did happen, I would literally give ANYTHING to be there and see that show in person
I have always and will always be in Tarjas corner, she's the OG, I dont think Nightwish would have ven formed without her and definately not reched the heights they have, but I will never deny that Floor is an incredible singer too, and probably more versatile in her vocal abilities
And no, me saying I dont think Nightwish would have formed/reached the heights they have without Tarja does not mean that I think Tuomas and the rest of the band would not have been sucessful, they are all brilliant musicians and Tuomas a fantastic composer, I just don't think they would have done it toghether, as one band
You said that so well and good. Nightwish the best symphonic metal band I ever learned to listen wholeheartedly .
I do agree in that floor’s vocal abilities are more versatile
And ofcoz the rest of this cm
They have sang duets together. Just search Tarja and Floor. They’re awesome together.
ruclips.net/video/57WsNYItbSU/видео.html
2023
Still listening 2 this golden masterpiece
Thank you very much for sharing this with us
Lots of love from Oporto, Portugal 🤗
HŰŰŰ JÈZUS!! 9 20 perc Kaposvár🎉🎉🎉
To me, Floor lives the song and Tarja just sings it.
It's 3:14 that makes difference. Tarja is fantastic. Floor addition at the ending , very good. I love the duet. Each One of them has a different characteristic with which prevails.
Just watched a recent interview with Floor. She is now FLUENT IN FINNISH!! When she joined, she said that she wanted to learn to feel closer and more at home with her boys. Well she has learned, and it didn't seem like she had any trouble going into Finnish and back to English. Learn all our songs in two days? OK! Learn Finnish next? OK! Is ther anything this wonder woman can't do? Love you Floor!!
Germanic language so relatively easy to learn. I have friends that are Latinos that have learned Finnish due to the job necessity also.
@@alxdava2004 But dude, Finnish isn't a Germanic lang. Uralic. I don't know about learning difficulty tho.
I think the world of this group. They are more talented then many. Opera and metal blend. VERY moving and powerful! Floor has it for me, hands down! I hope she is healthy and happy!
Thank you ALL from my deepest heart RUclipsrs !
I'll try to do other Nightwish Mixes when I'll have time! Thanx for your comments, thanx for sharing and, thanx for "Likes" ! Peace !!!
Spydee.
What about "Ever Dream"? Just saying
_Amazing_ job, brother! Salute from Finland!
lola Floor is a true metal singer and does an infinite better job than POP start tarja.
wolfshade1979 You dont have to talk bad about Tarja, she´s also really talented as her own way :)
wolfshade1979 Tarja is more like an opera soprano than a pop "artist" -.-
...but I also mostly prefer Floor (Sleeping Sun by Tarja though)
i think the conclusion here is. for anyone thats used to Tarja , she will always have a special place in the nightwish army , BUT Floor is just so damn good she cant be ignored , her voice is something extraordinary .
I really love how they sound together. 😭❤️❤️❤️
Floor is the best that could happen to Nightwish after Tarja left.
I hated Nightwish with Anette. Anette was not a bad singer, it just did not feel like Nightwish with her. With Floor it feels like Nightwish again. They need a certain type of singer for their sound.
@@DarthSoto78 lol she was the best thing that happened to them. Have a look at the album sales
@@maxrav1831 I don't care. I think Nightwish sounds much better with Tarja, and Floor. Aneete just did not sound like Nightwish to me. It was like when Ray Manzarek tried to be the lead singer of the Doors after Morison died. It just did not sound like the Doors.
@@DarthSoto78 Nah I would say more like Brian Johnstone replacing Bon Scott, Brian got and still gets the same shit Anette gets from so called fans yet his first album with the band is the 3rd or 4th biggest selling album of all time, much like the effect Anette had both commercially and creatively.
@@maxrav1831 I don't care I stopped listening to them till Floor came along. I saw that fist video, and it did not sound like Nightwish.
My god. I'm a 35 year old guy with tears streaming down my face. f'ing amazing.
Same here @ 51 \m/
... and here. I'm 37 :p
Same here 25 :(
37 \m/
Same here! I'm 46 \m/
If Floor's ending at wacken does not bring a tear or two, you must be faulty.
viu floor's eu expus o meu car Roll Royce GHOST na Estrada em área GHOST.😊 tá lá em Tweet na minha página inicial.#
I might be faulty for thinking it ruined the piece then
@@ChippZanuff93 You are. It MADE the piece. Without it = boring and pointless, with it = spectacular.
No tears… but chills, yes!
And just as Tarja blows the quick kiss Goodbye, Floor takes another deep breath and belts out the most epic ending to the song and takes the crown...
That part kills Tarjacoholics!
@@agustinmanyari i will add she also interacts with the audience more too meaning Floor, her voice is much clearer and she has the ability at least in this song to almost vocal fry ..maybe more versatile than Tarja but I like opera so it is all good, Now , I will say, I have not listened to other songs with Tarja singing, only based on this song having heard both versions. and can I say that that drummer is fantastic!! all of them are great but jeez..he goes all out
To be honest Tarja had to change her outfit after this song, and GLS wasnt originaly ment to finish with such a scream. Otherwise she would do something like the end of Tha phantom of the opera. On the other hand Floor is capable to add something from her to the song, so why not?
tarja ,,,, lejos lo mejor q a pasado por nightwish
tarja turunem , pra mim é indiscutível a melhor frontwoman no vocal do nightwish !!!...
Nope. Floor > Tarja.
@@rientsdijkstra4266 ridículo.🤣🤣🤣 Eu iria ao otorrinolaringologista. Na melhor das hipóteses, Floor é uma cantora comum que fica entediada depois de um tempo. O Nightwish deve seu sucesso exclusivamente a Tarja. Se Floor tivesse sido a primeira cantora, o Nightwish ainda estaria tocando em algum quintal hoje.
@@tommyr.6473 Many lost words without point. I Like Floor's singing much better than Tarja's. Tarja has bad vowels, harsh "iii", "eee", "aaa", bad control, bad tone, always the same 0-0-0-0 vibrato. Tarja is wannabee opera singer, but not a good opera singer. Sorry.
@@rientsdijkstra4266 You don't have to apologize because you write stupid stuff here and really have no idea. Floor is an ordinary, average singer with nothing special about her. It probably satisfies the average taste. I've already listened to your songs here on YT. After the 2nd I switched off because it's so boring and I would have fallen asleep otherwise. This voice doesn't stick in your memory because there's just nothing special about it. For me, Nightwish died with Tarja's inglorious departure, because without her it's just a normal band without a soul. You don't have to answer anymore either, your first statement was embarrassing enough. Thank you, at least you made me laugh.🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@tommyr.6473 You say you listened to only two songs of one of the greatests and most versatile singers alive, who is hailed by millions not only because of her great technique, but especially because of her enormous versatility, her ability to emotionally connect and tell the story of the song, and bringing millions to tears by doing so. I literally have more then 1500 reaction to Floors version of GLS here, and in more then 90% comment are like "WOW..." , "It is so effortless.."", "I don't what to say after that", "I need a cigarette", "Thanks Floor, now I am a blubbering mess for the rest of the day", etc, etc.
Yet, you listened to only two(!!) songs of her, and you are already able to tell that she is "forgetable" and "boring". Wow man, I must say that I admire the accute power of observation of that brilliant mind of yours! Few are to able make such astute observations as you are!
But now back to reality. If you listen to this video, you will simply hear that in the parts between 8.82 and 9.13 Tarja seems to run out of ideas and sounds boring and flat untill she throws a handkiss and walks of the stage (... leaving the song to peter out) , then Floor comes on again with her unique power and gives us the spectacular ending that she invented and that made the song world famous.
But also in the other parts of the song, Floor simply sounds better, and especially more fluent and better integrated with the music. Floor is simply the better singer.
So I remain with my view: Tarja has a certain special sound, that a certain group of people (like you) seems to like very much. Well you are welcome to it (!). Taste and preference are personal, and I wont fight you on that. I personally don't like that sound however. To me it sounds like an empty trick, that she repeats again and again, without any real personal or emotional involvement
That is why I say that Tarja is OVERRATED. Tarja is a great singer, but LIMITED (partly by her own choice) and she will never become a true great opera singer. For that she has too many technical shortcommings. And the things that she can do well, I simply don't like... (taste and preference!)
That brings me back to you. Pittyfull are people who can not see greatness because they are blinded by empty spite.
This is perfect for someone like me who prefers this song with Tarja's operatic vocals and Floor's ending. Just my personal opinion, of course. These two make my favorite singers of the genre. Also, good job to Spydee RAJAONAH. I like this video very much. :)
Thanks Gresa ! :) It's my pleasure
Щощщ
I love the emotion in Floors voice. Just stunning.
I don't know if it's nostalgia but when I hear Tarja I want to cry, she makes me feel so many emotions with her voice and I feel like I'm transported to a different era. Floor is amazing but Tarja for me is hands down the best in Nightwish.
С ума сводит эта красота , мощь , неподражаемость , это на самом деле просто космос !!!!👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Man, Floor knows how to hit some wicked notes. She's also hot as hell itself. Burn baby burn!
Тарья безусловно моя богиня навсегда, ее песня, ее душа, ее атмосфера, Флор очень классная, тоже люблю ее, но немного другой любовью😊
Просто мураши по коже .. от красоты и мощи !!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️😍😍😍😍😍😍
Где есть настоящие мужчины, там будет много женщин поющих
На урале например, из женщин делают рабынь
@@ЛекцииСАдель Женщин нужно любить , !!!!
@@sniperpx4996 но их гасят выходцы из азии, и восточные славяне, снг пришельцы за хлебом в рф
@@ЛекцииСАдель никогда нельзя допускать такого !!
9:14 is all I have to say. Does anyone remember that one time Tarja sung this song absolutely belted the end and then headbanged until the song finished? Me neither. I absolutely love Floor so much energy and passion.
Ahimoth (Jack Irving)That scream ? Floor only sing for interest and not for passion.
TheOther98 Just like Tarja showed so much passion to the nightwish fans toward the end ... right on.
Ahimoth (Jack Irving) I know right. I can't believe he ever got out of the womb, even with help.
So Tarja should have foreseen years into the FUTURE and should have performed this NEW version?? Is that what are you trying to say?? Do you think it was Floor idea to do that finale?? hahaha
Classical singers don't belt 🙄
Оказывается, финны совсем не холодные,а очень даже горячие и талантливые ребята! И трудолюбивые!!! Молодцы!!!
👍
@@user-1953. Олег! Страна большая! Путин за всеми не успевает! Это не Сталин,которому никто не был указ, и который расстреливал, когда хотел, и для него не было никакой Америки. Сейчас две правящие силы- деньги и лицемерие! И обе очень опасны и ядовиты!!!
А ты думал поговорка: "горячие финские парни" родилась на пустом месте?
Floor Jansen.....
For the love of God I hate the argument! The truth is that these two ladies have & would work together again. Perhaps even on the same stage! I'll point a finger of blame at the mad genius Tuomas, for he was the one to have needlessly
complicated an iconic band & concept! Personally, I am glad the two ladies appreciate each other's God-given gifts & it's only the fan factions who "wish" to kill each other! I love this Tribute to both!!!
They singing Over the Hills and Far Away together gives me life. They're amazing. They're different and shouldn't be compared since they have different signatures di their singing
Thanks for putting up this wonderful show with two of the greatest icons. Love them both.
Say what you will about either singer, but Floor and Nightwish have carved themselves into history as creators of the most majestic metal moment ever. There's no need to link to it. You all know that moment.
🤣🤣🤣
i always thought that it was a great loss, that Tarja stopped. Nightwish has never been the same again, but with Floor, the band is back on track.
Go Nightwish !!!!
Very good choice for the band that Floor is ! ;)
Duas Deusas do Metal juntas... Uau!! Curto a Voz e Performance impecável de Floor Jansen...
Mas Tarja turunen é a Deusa com Voz de Anjo... Belíssima!!
Dois estilos distintos e magníficos...
Mas Tarja é Inigualável!!! Parabéns às duas talentosíssimas cantoras...
Tarja turunen é de Outra dimensão!!!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🍷🍷🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤💙💙💙🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩✌🤟🤘
penso o mesmo, as musicas escritas na epoca de tarja são outro nivel, espero que nightwish escreva músicas para a Floor agora, por que essa cantora é muito boa, só que me parece que a banda ainda tenta implacar uma tarja turunen, e não devia, tem um diamante bruto ali, não sabendo usar....com asaida do marco hietala então....nem se fala
@@marcosroliveira360 Discordo bastante na verdade na questão de fazerem dela uma nova Tarja considerando que boa parte das músicas dela sem usam a voz operística, fora que o alcance e a versatilidade da Floor é maior até do que a Tarja, não é a toa que até nas músicas da Anette ela arrasa, sem dúvida minha favorita, principalmente ao vivo!
Jansen just blows this song away!!!!!
Just recently crawled out from under the rock I apparently live under and discovered Nightwish. I've compared them for days now. In my opinion, Floor easily wins. Tarja has a beautiful voice but Floor just has an air about her that takes it to another level. She can bring a grown man to tears with ease. Tarja just doesn't have that.
I disagree. In fact, I feel the opposite way. Tarja has a magical quality in her voice that Floor doesn't have.
I agree. Love them both tho! Tarjas technique always wins. They both have their own magic
Beyond the two incredible vocalists, the perfection with which the band plays is such that the changes between videos are almost imperceptible.
TARJA DOMINATES IN SOME PARTS AND FLOOR DOMINATES IN OTHERS. STOP COMPLAINING WHICH ONE IS BEST AND JUST THINK IF BOTH WERE IN THE BAND. \m/
Amen! Nightwish wouldn't exist without Tarja but this song was made for Floor! Both would be incredible.
man you just blew my mind
Ok
E6fz
nah, I prefer Floor wholeheartedly, I wouldnt want Tarja back
Tarja es la única que le da esa magia a esa canción. Ya no se puede comparar nos acostumbraron a lo sublime las canciones que ahora canta floor ya son. A su estilo es y es bueno a secas Nightwish ya no es mágico ya no te transporta como con Tarja
Es cierto Tarja es única jamás la podrán igualar y nightwish nunca sería igual sin ella
Pues tengo otra opinión sobre eso, sobretodo porque la primera vez que escuché nightwish ha sido con Tarja, pero no he podido sentir toda esa magia de la que tanto se habla...
Había escuchado Nemo y me gustó, así que me puse a investigar un poco más, pero lo que parecía bueno, la verdad era lo más aburrido que había escuchado. En esa misma época descubrí Within Temptation y Epica, solo después Afterforever y Floor Jansen... El estilo de voz de esas tres bandas me gustaba más que Nightwish, pero cuando escuché a Floor cantando Ghost Love Score, me he dado cuenta de que la música era buena, pero el estilo vocal de Tarja no...
@@carlosjj662 cada quien con lo suyo pero la mayoría prefiere a Tarja por algo será ps 🤷🏻♀️
Carlos jj para mí estas equivocadisimo tarja es baritono y jansen comercial tirándole a pop como la otra ex vocalista.
И я снова здесь...
" - После стольких лет?"
"- Всегда."
Мои любимые два состава группы. Золото и платина
✨❤✨
Thanks for this mix, I rather love both singers than comparing who's the best, they have unique voices and unique style and listening them together....oh god, truly amazing!!!!!!!!!! \m/ 😎
looks the best is floor and its the truth but tarja's fans don't want to admit but i love them both so dosen't matter
Wow!!... that's it. 😘😘😘😘
Metallosaurus Rex :PACIA are also Floor friends too.
Metallosaurus Rex :Floor voice are more. Deeper but Tarja voice is abit lighter anyone notice it ?
You should hear their colab of over the hills
This is what Floor means to us. Not trying to start a war here or anything. Just wanted to share some things I've noticed in these boards in my short time here. And also to drop a bit of reasoning as why us Floor fans are just as passionate about our superwoman as Tarja fans are.
Tarja fans, for the most part, don't seem to know a whole lot about Floor, otherwise they would probably treat her with a little more respect. And for that we do have to cut them a little slack. They only judge her by her live performances with NW and usually the earlier ones when she'd only been in the band a month or two as opposed to 10 months or so by the time she performed at Wacken. Floor's work ethic alone and what she was able to accomplish in so little time is unspeakable.
Sadly, we think of Tarjaholics as snobbish bullies who are stuck in the past and who think they are vastly superior about their knowledge of singing than the rest of us are and take every moment to put down anyone else that is not Tarja. Obviously I do not think all Tarja fans think like this but the very vocal ones you see popping up in every video don't help matters.
Anyone who knows anything about Floor realizes this woman has it all. Rock, metal, classical, contemporary and that stage presence is second to none. Us Floor fans don't care if Tarja's classical voice is technically better. She's not a classical singer like Tarja is and we don't expect her to be. But when Floor comes soaring in with her operatics we appreciate Floor's softer and prettier voice just to have her turn around and growl and snear and then belt out an insanely pitched note.
We love how she takes a song like Ghost Love Score and uses her voice and body in unison to portray a variety of emotions. The way she just adds her own flair to the end and turning it from a great song into a true epic. There is a reason that the last 90 or so seconds of this video end with Floor. She continues the note that Tarja left on, stretches it out 2 to 3 times longer and then just launches into this unworldly vocal assault that left the audience screaming in delight and wonderment. And these moments we call Floorgasms. When the hair stands up on our skin, get chills down our spines or when we are suddenly moved to tears. This is why we love Floor.
09:13, nuff said.
Comments are welcome just don't be an a-hole trying to start a flame war. I would truly love to read a well thought post about why you like Tarja better.
All that, plus the song was written with Tarja's voice in mind -- not Floor's. That she adapts it so well is truly remarkable. Tarja's rendition is powerful and still very much worth listening too -- particularly the studio version -- but ultimately nothing beats the ending of Floor's live version: simply astounding.
***** there is one thing that beats this ending: the one in the Buenos Aires version. Holy shit!
Hail to all Nightwish fans from Germany!
Josefine Seyfarth
Indeed! Although I think the Wacken version is better up until that point.
Yeah..why argue about both when both are so different? And many Floor fans also often argue about Tarja being bad (because of the letter which called her a diva which means they don't know alot about Tarja because Tarja is one of the kindest musicians out there..she is so cute xD) so ...yeah if just fans of both sides would stop being ignorant and would stop judging without reason it would be realy cool..but we can't have nice things can we? :/ Also going back to the letter thing, Tarja is not anymore like in nightwish..since the break-up she has never been like that..people often forget that over the time stuff changes. Tarja also has stage-presence now and interacts alot with her fans. But people often ignore that. Floor and Tarja are both great singers and I think they don't deserve the hate...
TheOther98
Seriously get a life instead of posting the same comment over and over again. And please, Charlotte Wessels, if that's the Charlotte you are referring too, isn't even in the same league as Floor or Tarja.
Tarja has that thing that makes me love her😍😍WHAT A VOICE
I can't believe the primal scream from Floor at 9:29!!! A ten second ripping her guts and voice out of her body. WOW!
The range of Floor is incredible. Low, metal grunting, screaming, pop, opera...she can do everything. Tarja is great too, but only in opera/soprano. And here english is not that good. Besides the volume from Floors voice is much betterand louder, she owns the band, like a goddess!
skinnybmw Agree. Both are amazingly amazing ! Personally I prefer Floor though. She seems to cover the whole spectrum incredibly well. God this was insane to watch !
Floors control of her voice is incredible
still love Floor but her mainstream vocals are lady gaga like, lazy grunting,too much screaming and thin operatic utterances..far cry from her glory days with After Forever and REvamp..hope she goes back to that model...Tarja is operatic but with a myriad of equally powerful flavors
Floor nails it like nobody else!
I would never deny Tarja's talent, and she had the history behind her of course. But I feel like her style is overly affected. Floor is a force of nature. Its almost unfair to compare her to any other mortal in the genre. I love metal opera jazz you name it; my impression is that she has very few peers across history and the various disciplines. At the very least she absolutely dominates and owns this song. One can still appreciate Tarja while allowing this.
Tarja end Nightwish is nightwish!!!!Old Nightwish best!!!
I love both Tarjas and Floors voice. Both of them fit Nightwish. Both of them have classically trained voices which is what I appreciate in Nightwish music. Anette was a sweet girl with a good voice, but for me personally the classical touch is a must in Nightwishs music.
Anette's big problem is when she's on stage ... in Live singing
Spydee RAJAONAH
ye lmao, her voice tends to " run out ", in all honesty anette has a good voice but not for a band with this style of music, bands like this need a good soprano
Tarja tiene la voz perfecta para el estilo sinfónico, es por eso que si estilo resalta más. Las dos cantan exelente.
Eso, Tarja tiene la voz para el metal sinfónico. Floor es versátil y eso hace bueno para varios géneros y estilos, pero no el mejor para uno.
Lo contrario es cierto. El problema de Tarja es que ese amplio vibrato 0-0-0-0-0 choca con los fuertes y complejos ritmos del Metal, impidiendo que fluya. Además, el sonido del paladar hueco de Tarja tampoco suena bien.
@@jeysonsoto5343 Por eso la voz de Floor es mejor. Tarja solo puede hacer un truco y se vuelve molesto. Floor puede expresar cualquier cosa que el compositor le pida, Y tiene el sentido de entender cómo capturar y transmitir ese sentimiento.
Тарья найкращий
Виконавець рокопера . Неперевершиний голос
@@proonia У мене була ця річ, поки я працював. Щоразу, коли я чув жахливий голос, я дивився. Це була Тар'я.
Those two Lady's are out of the other Space 👍👍👍🖤🖤🖤🖤
Am I the only one who cryes in the end of this song!? Floor is just so AMAZING!😍😭
Paulina H. No you are not the only one.
@@troyjankauskas8944 I heard that 100 times and cried 100 times. Just beautiful
Floor owns the end of the song.
Nope I cry every time!!!
That's the power of the Floorgasm.
How the hell did you merge the 2 VID's so seamlessly?!!
A TRUE work of art Sir!
>BOWS with respect
Спасибо, Тарья,за то что когда-то исполняла эту песню.
Спасибо Анетт, которая тоже когда-то постаралась и исполняла эту песню.
Спасибо Флоор Янсен, за то что сейчас исполняешь эту песню.
Спасибо Вам: Эмпу, Марко, Юкка, Кай, Юкка( новый басист) и Трой(?) , за то что играли и играете эту песню.
И огромное спасибо уважаемый маэстро Туомас Холопайнен, за создание этого шедевра, за создание всех песен Nightwish. За Ваши идеи, за Ваши труды, за Ваши упорство и за такие потрясающие результаты.
Спасибо тебе большое Nightwish.
Подпишусь под каждой Вашей буквой!!!
Tarja: Sorceress
Floor: Amazon
You misspelled that, it's A-m-a-z-i-n-g, understandable she is kind of a force of nature and it is only expected you'd get distracted.
+haleskiss I think he really did mean amazon because Floor is so tall and beautiful and her voice is very feminine and rich. Tarja could be compared to a sorceress because of her style of dress as well as her voice which sounds like it came straight from a fantasy its so beautiful. Really both of them have such great voices.
+Virginia Harp was just making a play on his choice of words, If I thought he was being an ass in his word choice, my response would have been very different. cheers and keep rolling with the music😃
oh.....Yeah I didn't know you were joking around XD woops
tarja the queen floor the princess
Floor Jansen forever !!!!. Goddess. Valquiria
The sync between the two versions of this masterpiece is godly!!!!! My goodness I'm simply not emotionally prepared for this... Got goosbumps over goosebumps over goosebumps. And I don't know if that is even possible
OMG YES!! I feel this way too, this video is a precious gem!!! I just found out now, and HOW GREAT it would be these two at the stage together!!
Nightwish , it is a dream. And I am very glad that I can share it and dream.The best band in the world.
Floor is the Goddess of Vocals
El lugar que Tarja dejó en Nightwish es demasiado grande y no lo pudieron llenar nunca más. La potencia y la tecnica de Tarja la hace simplemente la mejor.
En mi opinión Floor es mejor por su dinamismo vocal (ns si existe eso) lo único esq no explotan bien eso. En mi opinión
@@sarayo7017 diria que no canta mal floor .. pero aun asi nightwish para nuchos murio en el 2005... que queres q te diga :D
@@nahumdiaz4167 totalmente dé acuerdo con vos!!!
Итить да это просто словами не передать как это Божественно звучит
I absolutely love Floor.. but when I was introduced to Nightwish Tarja was Nightwish for me. Even loved Annette. All 3 bring their own and love that We shouldn't compare them which we do but Nightwish and the music is what makes us happy.
" They're Totally, Awesome " . !!! I get chills. 👍😵💫🤘
For the first half of the song, both sound amazing, but after the interlude, Floor dominates, what's amazing, this song was written with Tarja in mind, yet Floor just makes it hers.
On the first half floor is not amazing
@@Lesandwish shes not amazing in the second half either. Has similar traits to a generic pop singer who strains her voice to change it at specific tones... nothing bad about it tho it sounds great but Tarja just keeps it clean and only widens her voice instead of using the more generic tricks to make it glorious, she has stronger voice for sure.
@@Otakahunt Tarja just keeps clean and boring as always... Her dynamic didn't change in the second part: all the instrumentation got more heavy, but she couldn't match the same with her voice... in other words, she can build up a song from soft to heavy,she is always soft and that's it!!!
@@Otakahunt Do you have any type of musical training with an opinion like that? I’m not sure what you’re hearing, but maybe your eardrums don’t work the same way the rest of our do?
@@Otakahunt The only thing we can actually argue about is range, and Floor’s range is much wider than Tarja’s. Phrasing and “beauty” in voices is all subjective and preference. I prefer Floor’s phrasing and think her range opens doors this song never had with Tarja, but again that’s my opinion
They're both amazing, with a few special voice characteristics each.
Both hit the highest notes but Tarja's lower range is better.
However Floor as a growl in the angry rocker phrases that Tarja doesn't have.
You can't see it in this version, but Floor has a special ability for adding her own creation/improvisation at the end of Ghost Love Score, not so much in this Wacken version but especially the orgasmic end in the Buenos Aires Live DVD. The audience sure noticed it there chanting her name.
And then Tarja invented the *whole genre* herself!!
I can only imagine a NW + Floor studio album will be amazing, and Tarja's solo albums are getting better all the time.
Impossible to choose one over the other. Hope I will see more of the two singing together one of these days, like that gig in Belgium.
Imposible no emocionarse con esta banda y sobre todo con esas dos mujeres cantantando tan dulce, las escucho a las dos y no puedo decidir cual me gusta más, dos grandes de verdad
It's the first mix of Tarja and Floor I really really like (in general I like Tarja's original version more than any other version) 🤟🤟😍😍😍🤟🤟
Amazing editing holy shit I had goosebumps like the entire time. You should do more of these. I'm pretty sure you're the only one that mixes them together this good.
Thank you Hilary! I just tried my best. I'm greatful you appreciated at this point
Spydee RAJAONAH
thank YOU for sharing this. quick question, did you edit the audio together first then the video? or did you do it all at once?
***** My pleasure dear FlapFlap ! ;) thank you so much
Impressive!!
I will and always will be in love with Tarja first and foremost ❤
Сделано с любовью к группе.
И с уважением к солистками.
Спасибо за проделанную работу.
Удивительно, нет русскоязычных комментариев, Nightwish , вы очень талантливы, ваша музыка завораживает, спасибо. Тарья и Флор как всегда на высоте !
Da mosci
А вот и есть 😁 от музыки аж мурашки пошли
Мы не палимся,по английски пишем)
isn't the Fins kind of close cousins of you Russians? im from the extreme west of the continent ( just for reference) and on my modest opinion Finland produce some of the best heavy metal in the world
the queen of heavy rock metal music.
These two are the perfect combination,.....
I like Floor and i LOVE Tarja,....
Two diferent eras but a single sound!!!!!!
JUST PERFECT!!!!!!
I never thought I would like anyone, other than Tarja, performing this. Floor Jansen proved me wrong! What an amazing performance :-)
Brilliant edit and mix up of the two RAJAONAH.
I believe that all three nightwish singers should do a show together. I think comparing them is foolish. Nightwish is a living entity that changes over time like you have. We get to see the band from tarja to floor and ŵe get to enjoy the entire life span. Be thankful.
Just a Jot:
No one comes close to Tarja's melodic depth!
Leave modulation to key changes.
She's highly skilled not wild in any way.
All the best, Jamieson.
Please remember...there's a natural silence to melodic depth.
You can hear it. You can feel it. But, most of all it's an awakening
to the sound & enjoyment of melody and orchestration.
All the great composers would die for the depth
Tarja brings to melody & orchestration.
hedwegg Tarja is awful. Horrible pronunciation, uncontrolled vibrato, zero versatility and can't stop fishing for her notes. Thank god they kicked her to the curb. The era of the Nightwish began when Floor joined. FLOORGASM!!!!
+Dave Mason to be fair, when Tarja sings in Finnish, her voice is quite lovely...and there is very little misplaced vibrato or that horrendous mashing of vowels. And you sir are one funny man, thank you for spreading your humor liberally through these comments. It does help lighten the Tarjaholic fog.
But Tarja does not sing that great at times. It even falsh at times I just heard
I love them both and I am happy that Nightwish have Floor now. Floor is cool and has by far the best stage presence of all the 3, and she sings some old songs really good. She is Metal, and she is domination and sweetness as well :(I say this as a girl!!!) :))) But sorry, if anyone listens to this mix and then seriously says that Floor is a better singer than Tarja, (s)he must simply be deaf or be driven by personal sympathy (or most likely deafened by personal sympathy). As a person I also like Floor more than Tarja, but as a singer Floor is not anywhere near Tarjas ability (as everyone not deaf dumb blind can easily notice by hearing this mix). I actually don't know why Floors performance of this song gets praised so much, as in this mix its undeniably obvious how limited her skills are, compared to those of Tarja. And now, may you believe or not: Still I am absolutely glad that Floor is in Nightwish, and may they be as happy and successful as possible (and the same for Tarja and her band, of course) :) :.. Btw fanboys on each side, Tarja and Floor are close friends, and the hate is only in your heads - definitely neither in Tarjas nor Floors heart. Think about it.
@@davemason4055 What?!!! Tarja is very trained opera singer, try to compare Wishmaster of both and you'll understand something about music! Kind regards
Просто слов нет одни зашкаливающие эмоции, талантище, мурашки аж под кожей бегают. Спасибо Вам за то что вы есть и радуете нас.
Sin ofender tarja es la voz suprema! De la emoción y sentimiento
i like both versions. floors is amazing cause its an iconic moment where she hits insane notes, but tarja is more enchanting and operatic, which is funner to sing along to :)
Tarja Turunen is the greatest vocalist Nightwish ever had. She's unique, like a Goddess singing, and the songs recorded with her voice belong to the golden age of Nightwish, but the best live version of Ghost Love Score is definitely this version With Floor.
Mega kocham ich ❤ Floor końcówka utworu powaliła mnie na kolana ❤
FLOOR JANSEN EXCELENCE , VOICE PRESENCE, AND MOST COMPLEETE 9:29 ....GODESS
y en el minuto 8:12? escucha la version de tarja y la de flor, terrible derrape de flor horrible le sale este tema! por que grite en el 9:29 no hace que sea mejor jajajaja!
Floor is the best
@@JesusGDiaz-rj2cu Definitivamente, no sabes de lo que estas hablando!!!
@@juanmendez3770 jajajaja jajajaja jajajaja si claro
A versatile voice, ideal for NIGHTWISH
Both are absolutely bone chilling voices to say the least. I personally like Floor better, but Tarja truly is something special too.
the 2013, more rolling baseline Floor fit beautifully, but in the earlier, more orchestral, symphonic version, Tarja's angelic fluidity was so perfection
Both are oprah singers and their voice range is jaw dropping. They are two most powerful and explosive singers. Tarja phantom of oprah and Floor Ghost love score are two masterpieces can never and ever be copied or attempted.
OpEra, not OpraH 🤣🤣🤣
Epic video! I have to admit that I prefer Floor Jansen, can't wait for their next album!!!
For sure ! The next album with Floor should be something special ! Thanks for your comment !