Nightwish- My Walden. Reaction/Analysis.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 авг 2024

Комментарии • 130

  • @okiejohn3925
    @okiejohn3925 2 года назад +86

    If you want to see just Troy and Floor isolated, check out their acoustic version of "How's the Heart", Planet Rock recordings....they also do "Nemo" acoustic on the same set.

    • @gregjetnikoff7124
      @gregjetnikoff7124 2 года назад +9

      Best version of How's the Heart is this one mentioned. So personal.

    • @corsa180
      @corsa180 2 года назад +6

      Came to say the same thing. 👍

    • @mickoldbear3008
      @mickoldbear3008 2 года назад +6

      Third recommendation for this, they have a special vibe when they sing together, we all know the sound when Marco and Floor sing together.... In my opinion the Troy / Floor sound is equally as special.... Do, do please have that one soon, your ears will thank you.

    • @jensj.jensen5462
      @jensj.jensen5462 2 года назад +4

      Troy has been working with Nightwish for a longer time than Floor has. You can see Troy playing in the music video for The Islander. That was recorded when Anette was the lead singer. Floor and Troy became real members of Nightwish at the same time, I have been told.

    • @clivematthews5296
      @clivematthews5296 2 года назад +4

      Of course for Troy playing excellent acoustic guitar it has to be How's The Heart or Nemo on Planet Rock. Or for him singing lead it's Harvest on the latest album Human II Nature. You could also find him duetting with Floor in The Carpenter live in Buenos Aires 2019.

  • @NickBR57
    @NickBR57 2 года назад +27

    Troy is English from our Lake District. The accent is Cumbrian.
    Troy does everything.
    Troy is also with Tuomas on the Auri project.

  • @mattilindstrom
    @mattilindstrom 2 года назад +47

    Troy has the talent of being very present when he has vocal/instrumental parts. His voice is just gorgeous, I second the motion to have How's the Heart acoustic here. Thank you for giving love to the unsung hero of Nightwish!

  • @rdmrdm2659
    @rdmrdm2659 2 года назад +19

    Troy is like glue, he holds things together, contributes all over the place.

  • @electricivan3032
    @electricivan3032 2 года назад +22

    I suppose there's the Carpenter, from Buenos Aires where Troy is the lead vocalist. Harvest is a Troy song too, but that's lyric video.
    Appreciate your comment about the calming influence. He strikes me as a true bard.

    • @argantyr5154
      @argantyr5154 2 года назад +6

      There is also
      Nightwish - Edema Ruh (Live at Baltic Princess Cruise)
      ruclips.net/video/g3fjBAhOXIM/видео.html&ab_channel=EddJoss
      Where you can see them is a more intimate setting together with the others.

    • @Qwarzz
      @Qwarzz 2 года назад +3

      @@argantyr5154 Talking about bards and Edema Ruh :)

  • @RichardJones-rx2iz
    @RichardJones-rx2iz 2 года назад +6

    Troy is English, and he’s singing Welsh in the beginning! Well he’s having a go, I’m Welsh so it’s not dead on but not bad! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

  • @taurusguy9305
    @taurusguy9305 2 года назад +16

    If you want to hear Troy singing in NIGHTWISH, check HARVEST because he's the lead singer in that particular song. You must hear that masterpiece.

    • @marita2g
      @marita2g 2 года назад +1

      I LOOOOVE Harvest!

  • @Qwarzz
    @Qwarzz 2 года назад +18

    My Walden, Élan and Alpenglow are the Nightwish songs that give me the happiest feeling. Endless Forms Most Beautiful album as a whole is my favorite now.
    I might also add Edema Ruh to the previous list, especially the acoustic version from the Baltic Princess cruise. For those who love fantasy books and don't know who Edema Ruh are I would recommend King Killer Chronicles. Edema Ruh are travelling entertainers, there's a bit more to that but you'll learn to know them when you read the books.

  • @Kie75
    @Kie75 2 года назад +8

    Troy's English accent is more pronounced int he Vehicle of Spirit version where he says the most adorable version of "Good evening Wembley" ever.

  • @clemenstremens1940
    @clemenstremens1940 2 года назад +6

    If you like Troy going really low: Auri, Fireside Bard (Tuomas' side project with Johanna Kurkela, Troy Donockley and Kai Hahto)

  • @phils866
    @phils866 2 года назад +18

    Troy is like a medieval bard, or soothsayer, who the villagers would go to with their problems. He has that father-figure vibe about him. Like you say, he has been a great addition to the band, bringing years of experience and an astonishing variety of talent. I had to smile when you mentioned Floor's lashes, for I was thinking they were even longer than yours! Saying as how you love Troy, you might enjoy this lovely interview he gave to Breaking Absolutes. It's a long interview, but well worth watching. You will gain a real insight into Troy, what drives him, and his personality.
    Oh, and Troy is English. He was born in Cumbria.
    ruclips.net/video/ulytsQyu33w/видео.html

  • @JayJay-ex6yo
    @JayJay-ex6yo 2 года назад +2

    yes Troy! even though he dosent sing, troy is absolutely boss on "while your lips are still red" at wembly. he plays an electric guitar with an Ebow in place of the violin or pipes from other versions and its so powerful but melancholy he kinda steals the show

  • @dimitrisnikoloulis4071
    @dimitrisnikoloulis4071 2 года назад +2

    Troy has an incredible voice and is a multi - instrumentalist . Great combo.

    • @phillee2814
      @phillee2814 2 года назад +1

      Also a very skilled producer and composer, with 3 albums of choral and orchestral work in his own right as well as his punk and Celtic rock work. Oh, and the most in-demand session player of the Uilleann pipes in the world, even heard on Hollywood soundtracks.
      If it has anything to do with music, Troy is an expert in it.

  • @sindhatal7038
    @sindhatal7038 2 года назад +7

    For more Troy "Last of the Wild" or "Elvenjig & Elvenpath" at Buenos Aires or Bogota !

  • @kimfabritiusdetengnagel2038
    @kimfabritiusdetengnagel2038 2 года назад +20

    Yep, Troy is the perfect match in Nightwish - bringing all this Celtic and contrast into the "metal" - he adds an extra dimension.
    The next one with Troy as lead in the beginning and Floor backing - "Carpenter" from Buenos Aires 2018
    ruclips.net/video/Di197sOG21c/видео.html

    • @marita2g
      @marita2g 2 года назад +2

      Yess! Carpenter :D

    • @MsCatstaff
      @MsCatstaff 2 года назад +3

      I'll third The Carpenter... and I'll raise it to a double reaction, do the music video too, it's adorably 90s... Buenos Aires 2018 is a wonderful rendition, but The Carpenter was Nightwish's very first single from their first album, Angels Fall First... and Tuomas sang the male parts on that album! No, he's not a great singer, but it's pretty cool to hear all the same. Another fun fact, they didn't actually have a bass player yet when they recorded Angels Fall First, so Emppu supplied the bass tracks as well as guitars on the studio version.

  • @scottb.4472
    @scottb.4472 2 года назад +11

    Troy is so English that I would actually label him as the Obi-Wan Kenobi of Nightwish....... For some reason when you were talking about how he feels certain things and how he blends with floor so well I totally agree with you but all of a sudden I was getting this vision of Obi-Wan Kenobi and what he was like in Star wars and plus they both have beards and English accents LOL so it made me laugh but I like the analogy!!!

    • @AB-ez4rm
      @AB-ez4rm 2 года назад +2

      Obi-Wan Troynobi!

  • @stamasd8500
    @stamasd8500 2 года назад +10

    If you like Troy's singing, a good way to get a load of that is to check out Auri. That is a project by Tuomas Holopainen and includes his wife Johanna Kurkela and Troy. It is a very different sound from Nightwish, but Troy besides the many instrumental parts, has a lot more singing parts as well. For instance, the song Desert Flower which is a duet between him and Johanna. Sadly there is no live recording of that, only the studio recording.

    • @alexdoorn234
      @alexdoorn234 2 года назад

      There's also Fireside Bard from their second album where Troy is the main vocalist. I always use that song to calm down

  • @dolla3975
    @dolla3975 2 года назад +5

    You should definitely go for Harvest and How's the heart (acoustic version) next... Promise you will love them!
    Btw. Nice to see you back on Nightwish.

  • @AussieGoblin618
    @AussieGoblin618 2 года назад +5

    Harvest is a good one that features troy as the main vocalist

  • @silverblack5475
    @silverblack5475 2 года назад +4

    Underrated Song 🎵

  • @dinovassilakos6868
    @dinovassilakos6868 2 года назад +6

    If you like Troy's style check out a British band from the seventies called Steeleye Span. In fact Troy has worked with their lead singer Maddy Prior. Songs like One Misty moisy morning or Allison Gross to name a few.Dos Vidaniya Prokrasnya Gospodina!

    • @dinovassilakos6868
      @dinovassilakos6868 2 года назад +1

      @@Ravenhawk59 you might like this. Kind of sums her up.
      ruclips.net/video/PhiSwX95SVU/видео.html

    • @allenjohnstone9945
      @allenjohnstone9945 2 года назад +1

      The live version of Thomas the Rhymer is one of my favourite songs by them.

  • @mattgraham2835
    @mattgraham2835 6 месяцев назад

    she is quite a versatile singer rock, metal contemporary music I love enhancing and accentuating Finnish heavy metal sounds and colors of the symphony

  • @rainertuominen4242
    @rainertuominen4242 Год назад

    Great reaction! Funny coincidence you just happened to comment Troys accent seconds before he initiated the song in Welch. And yes, the Celtic folk music has very, very long history so medieval is no stretch. The Irish bagpipe, the Uilleann pipes, is from 18th-19th century though.

  • @572Btriode
    @572Btriode 2 года назад +3

    Crikey Anastasia !! You have almost started an international incident suggesting Troy sound American.
    Did you understand Troy's first verse in Welsh ?
    Sain y niwl,
    Gaunt y goydwig fwsog,
    Gwenithfaen, cen y coed, a'r lleuad,
    Un gway f'adenydd i dapestri bywyd.
    It rather sets the scene for the rest of the song.
    Anyway, a good job and a thumbs up from me.

  • @blueeyes1110
    @blueeyes1110 2 года назад +3

    You want more Troy try While my lips are still Red he's playing the Guitar , while Emppu is off stage taking a break I'm guessing

    • @blueeyes1110
      @blueeyes1110 2 года назад +1

      The Wembley arena from 2015 version of course

  • @josephschembri
    @josephschembri 2 года назад +3

    I don't know what to say, I just love your reactions! I also love it when you do your own music. And I agree Troy is great even when he sings not just when playing. I really do hope you get to see Nightwish live! Good luck stay safe.

  • @leftyme4568
    @leftyme4568 2 года назад

    Marko was always the face of nightwish, and we all hope he will come back....I am crushed by him not being there. But I wish him the best .

  • @charliethetraveller
    @charliethetraveller 2 года назад +1

    My Walden, I want My Tears back, The Islander, Harvest. I like the way Nightwish uses folk sound in their recent era but all those songs sounds very different between them. Troy is a genious.

  • @no_onein2024
    @no_onein2024 2 года назад +1

    9 people don't have a Walden lol. LOVED your reaction thank you!!!

  • @TheGrannyNut
    @TheGrannyNut 2 года назад +30

    "He sounds American" 😱😨 Please don't let Troy see that. He's a very proud Yorkshireman and very, *VERY* English!!

    • @northof4912
      @northof4912 2 года назад +4

      All due respect to a Russian interpreting a singer in a Finnish band from an English speaking country……

    • @geoffreymcdowall499
      @geoffreymcdowall499 2 года назад +9

      Since when is Cumbria part of Yorkshire?

    • @AussieGoblin618
      @AussieGoblin618 2 года назад +4

      He is not from yorkshire, the accents wrong for a start.

    • @KL-qy4ye
      @KL-qy4ye 2 года назад +6

      @@AussieGoblin618 he’s from Cumbria

    • @davidbarrass5210
      @davidbarrass5210 2 года назад +4

      Troy's actually Cumbrian, but we don't mind claiming him for our own.

  • @Dann66123
    @Dann66123 2 года назад +1

    Next EPICA 🙏🤘

  • @Thorgrim247
    @Thorgrim247 2 года назад

    Troy is British. He is from Northeastern England and now lives in Yorkshire. When Troy is a big part of Nightwish he brings out that Celtic folk quality in the band. A little feel good song that allows Troy be in the spotlight. Loved it!

  • @duncanwyer2460
    @duncanwyer2460 2 года назад

    Norfolk division signing in and ready to go! Nice to join you again 💕

  • @Mind-your-own-beeswax
    @Mind-your-own-beeswax 2 года назад +10

    "Troy sounds American" 😂😂. You couldn’t get anymore English sounding than Troy

  • @mikeleon5674
    @mikeleon5674 2 года назад

    You gushing over Troy is so cute. :)

  • @marianogonzalez1977
    @marianogonzalez1977 2 года назад

    Last of the wilds... give Floor some well deserved vacations and enjoy that great instrumental.

  • @v-mp2557
    @v-mp2557 2 года назад

    Thank you Anastasia for your video. Pleasant to watch when someone enjoys music. This song always comes in a good mood. The collaboration between Troy and Floor is now accentuated by live gigs when Marco is not in the lineup. Troy is a transformative multitalent.

  • @scottb.4472
    @scottb.4472 2 года назад +2

    Troy has actually been with the band much longer than floor but they both officially join the band at the same time...... I know I will be corrected if I am wrong about this but I think that's pretty accurate what I just said LOL

    • @Qwarzz
      @Qwarzz 2 года назад +3

      Yep, Troy was in a few songs in the Dark Passion Play album. The Islander wouldn't be the same without Troy.

  • @staceysmith6518
    @staceysmith6518 2 года назад

    Hi Anastasia, enjoy all your reactions Diana Akudinova has a brand new Cover, I can’t help falling in love with you by Elvis, you cannot leave this world without reacting to this song you will have chills from your toes to the back of your neck it’s that damn good and no one has ever changed it around and covered it like this please react to it

  • @RonniePeterson
    @RonniePeterson 2 года назад +1

    Seek out the virtual concerts for Troy coming to the fore. For me he shined throughout. Great reaction.

  • @michaelvandiermen
    @michaelvandiermen 2 года назад +1

    Oki John suggested it you must definitely see how is the heart ❤ from Planet Rock. It's an acoustic version, but it blow your mind !!!!

  • @petertyson2
    @petertyson2 2 года назад +12

    Troy is British, I don't hear anything in his voice that sounds close to American, guess that's all subjective though.

  • @honorarythamesman5732
    @honorarythamesman5732 2 года назад

    I concur with my fellow commentators, Troy is a fellow Englishman from the North East of England and I'm reliably informed that the language he sung in the intro is Welsh!

  • @karitilsala9297
    @karitilsala9297 2 года назад

    Greetings from Finland 🇫🇮 🤘.

  • @ralves4984
    @ralves4984 2 года назад

    The last Nightwish album (Human Nature) is up since last year, but not have much criticism since was released on covid, see some hits, worth it.

  • @SunOfTheSun
    @SunOfTheSun 2 года назад +1

    Great video! You remind me of the woman actor from Midnight Mass! :) love Nightwish

  • @paulmaxey6377
    @paulmaxey6377 2 года назад

    Just to let you know that if you look on their website they have 11 concerts/dates in North America including 9 in the US booked for 2022.
    I would link the site but RUclips isn't allowing me to.

  • @RichardJones-rx2iz
    @RichardJones-rx2iz 2 года назад +1

    Try ‘ How’s the heart, acoustic Floor and Troy on planet rock!

  • @denniseldridge2936
    @denniseldridge2936 2 года назад +3

    HI Anastasia! I agree that Troy is the true unsung hero of this band, and I personally would love to see him get more screen time. However, you can see much more of him supporting Floor when she sings How's the Heart for a radio show: ruclips.net/video/yYtkPpFYzOo/видео.html
    It's a fantastic performance, just Floor and Troy, and my favourite performance of that song.

  • @lydialaub5475
    @lydialaub5475 2 года назад

    I was going to be at that same concert. Such a shame it couldn't happen (but glad they're putting safety first)! Fingers crossed the new date will pan out 🤞

  • @joeyc630
    @joeyc630 2 года назад +1

    Welcome back to some more Nightwish, also keep checking out more Ayreon, awesome thanks 😀

  • @petervanloon7308
    @petervanloon7308 2 года назад

    In 2020 Floor and Troy did some interviews for promoting the new album just before the lockdown. So fun and interesting to watch. They really have a click together.

  • @leone.6190
    @leone.6190 2 года назад

    2:00 well ulian pipes are used not only in medieval Times, but allways since then untill today. :D

  • @grantharriman284
    @grantharriman284 2 года назад

    Naturally the moment you question Troy's British origin he rips into Gaelic

  • @MustaLaatta
    @MustaLaatta 2 года назад

    Try playig his acoustic Fylde Oberon with backup vocal and Floor singing as a duet, look for acoustic versions of, (by Planet Rock) "Nemo" and "How The Heart"...

  • @joebenoit4057
    @joebenoit4057 2 года назад

    I hope you're still planning Nightwish in NYC in May!! =D I'll be there still myself! :)

    • @asenka11
      @asenka11  2 года назад

      I will! For sure!

  • @alleninfinity6730
    @alleninfinity6730 2 года назад +1

    As an American, got to disagree with the Troy sounds American thing. I mean I would be honored if he were, but I can definitely hear the English accent with him. He is a good singer. Troy sings "The Carpenter" at Buenos Aires and also "Harvest" on the new album. But he like Marko, is mostly for backing vocals.

  • @larryd4352
    @larryd4352 2 года назад

    #AnastasiaLuna You really need to react to "Endless Forms Most Beautiful" it's an excellent song, that's a bit "heavier" than most others! Marco and Emppu get to show off their skills quite a bit more...and it's well worth your time! Then, you have from the same album, " Elan ".....which is also really good and has more of a pop music feel to it...but I really love the song!

  • @harshtiwari9163
    @harshtiwari9163 2 года назад +1

  • @joeyc630
    @joeyc630 2 года назад +1

    Try Endless forms most beautiful lyrical video with Floor Jansen and Troy, awesome thanks 😀or last of the wilds live show nightwish Buenos, Aires 2019, awesome 👌

  • @christophschmedes5975
    @christophschmedes5975 2 года назад

    Hey Ana check out the Decead live Show DVD Live in Buenos Aires Agentina in this Show sing Troy with Floor a Duett Calls The Carpenter have fun

  • @mikegershon8528
    @mikegershon8528 2 года назад

    Great reaction, Anastasia. This is one of my favorite Nightwish songs. Just a gentle reminder, please react to Blind Guardian's song Nightfall (the Wacken 2011 version) You won't be disappointed and there are some great lead guitar parts to get you going! (wink)

  • @ironhammer666
    @ironhammer666 2 года назад

    una de mis reactoras favoritas...te amo, pero amo mas a floor

  • @joeparker9516
    @joeparker9516 2 года назад +1

    Troy's last name is Donockely, I believe; which seems Irish to me. But he is definitely from the UK.

    • @davidhill7055
      @davidhill7055 2 года назад

      He plays the Irish version of the bag pipe so maybe Irish ancestors but family migrated to England?

  • @gillandianyt3920
    @gillandianyt3920 2 года назад

    Troy singing in Welsh!

  • @papaverweg
    @papaverweg 2 года назад

    Hear Troy Donockley together with Dave Brainbridge play ‘The Great Silky of Sules Skerry’ from album ‘When Worlds Collide’ ruclips.net/video/hZlrHZwnal4/видео.html
    Watch Troy prior to Nightwish within the band Iona: ‘The Night Sky’ and ‘Mostly Autumn’ ruclips.net/video/nPFWFe6e4ZY/видео.html or
    ‘Sights’ ruclips.net/video/5HWJILc8iqA/видео.html
    Troy is from Workington, a coastal town and civil parish at the mouth of the River Derwent on the west coast of Cumbria, England, historically in Cumberland (historical on the border with Scotland)

  • @allenjohnstone9945
    @allenjohnstone9945 2 года назад

    You think your unlucky. I had tickets to septembers show in Toronto last year and they aren't coming at all.
    PS: The day you recorded this is my birthday 😷

  • @johan7170
    @johan7170 2 года назад

    Youy wanna see Troy ?
    Nemo (acoustic session @ Planet Rock) : ruclips.net/video/FC7HYfc5y0A/видео.html
    How's the Heart (acoustic session @ Planet Rock : ruclips.net/video/yYtkPpFYzOo/видео.html
    Elan (Live @ Buenos Aires) : ruclips.net/video/8KOPvuKYIZA/видео.html

  • @arturama8581
    @arturama8581 2 года назад

    Troy Donockley (born 30 May 1964) is an English composer and multi-instrumentalist. Nothing American about him.

  • @phillipgross1887
    @phillipgross1887 2 года назад

    👍👍🤘🤘

  • @thisworldofwater8017
    @thisworldofwater8017 2 года назад

    Anastasia and Troy sitting in a tree, k-i-s-s-i-n-g...

  • @christiancouvidou4777
    @christiancouvidou4777 2 года назад

    Links for your requests, Anastasia :
    Troy and Floor acoustic session How's the heart : ruclips.net/video/yYtkPpFYzOo/видео.html
    and Nemo : ruclips.net/video/FC7HYfc5y0A/видео.html
    Suggestions of live duets :
    Paradise , Sharon and Tarja : ruclips.net/video/8vsKQTfxf80/видео.html
    Over the hills , Tarja + Floor. : ruclips.net/video/8vsKQTfxf80/видео.html

  • @ugk1106
    @ugk1106 2 года назад

    Troy is also doing "the carpenter" in Buenos Aires and gas a bigger part to sing there than on this. Watch this performance too.

  • @gigivanny3662
    @gigivanny3662 2 года назад

    dont be sad just wait. i waiting for 1.5 year

  • @KnghtRemains
    @KnghtRemains 2 года назад

    Try their song Shoemaker

  • @priscilla1986ify
    @priscilla1986ify 2 года назад

    Please react to Nightwish- Devil and the deep dark ocean live in Buenos Aires 2018

  • @funnyrailroadcrossing2767
    @funnyrailroadcrossing2767 2 года назад

    Great Nightwish reaction, please also react to LOVEBITES ballad song called "Epilogue"
    Thanks

  • @TimoArula
    @TimoArula 2 года назад

    Troy is such a Warm and wonderful human being 😊.
    This song is one of my happy songs !!!
    For more Troy : NIGHTWISH - Harvest (OFFICIAL LYRIC VIDEO) ruclips.net/video/Xy29T7LBM_I/видео.html
    Thank You Anastasia !!!!
    NWSU 🤘😎🤘.

  • @CanigoCatala
    @CanigoCatala 2 года назад

    Check The Warning songs Martirio and Disciples

  • @janihaavisto79
    @janihaavisto79 2 года назад

    October suck so bad. My Mother passed away 6th day. Even though it was a strong possibility that this would happen, it still hurts like a MF.
    Thx for your react. Hopefully next time in little better feelings. Huge mental huug from Finland.

    • @asenka11
      @asenka11  2 года назад

      I’m sorry for your loss😢

  • @1973HenkY
    @1973HenkY 2 года назад

    1 Guitar, Troy, Floor, both singing, duet: How's the heart or Nemo.

  • @addd717
    @addd717 2 года назад

    I am missing Marcos voice already :*(

  • @alexwens
    @alexwens 2 года назад

    Ты хорошо устроилась. Клоуны всегда нужны

  • @merqury5
    @merqury5 2 года назад

    The terminal 5 concert is rescheduled to may 22. Be there. Report back.

    • @asenka11
      @asenka11  2 года назад

      I will definitely be there!

  • @wanmac31
    @wanmac31 2 года назад

    😊🇫🇮🤘❤️🎶🎹🎸🥁✨🤘👍

  • @Colchan
    @Colchan 2 года назад

    Здравствуйте, Настя! Если вам не трудно, включайте русские субтитры в ваших реакциях. Многие почитатели творчества Димаша, являются почитателями Nightwish и наоборот. С уважением к вам!

    • @asenka11
      @asenka11  2 года назад

      Включу обязательно:)

  • @SamSam-bz1km
    @SamSam-bz1km 2 года назад

    How on earth do you hear Troy as American?

  • @starflare1971
    @starflare1971 2 года назад

    Check out the acoustic version of 'How's the heart' for more of Troy, ruclips.net/video/yYtkPpFYzOo/видео.html

  • @BigzampanoXXL
    @BigzampanoXXL 2 года назад

    Devil and deep dark ocean is awaiting you…

  • @adypendlebury3975
    @adypendlebury3975 2 года назад

    Troy is English and sounds nothing like a yank