How did the Nakba happen? | Al Jazeera English
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 май 2018
- 70 years have passed since the Nakba, the “catastrophe” in Arabic, took place in Palestine in 1948.
In which more than 750,000 Palestinians were forcefully displaced from their homes and pushed into refugee camps in East Jerusalem, the West Bank, the Gaza Strip and neighbouring countries.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
As a British citizen of Uk , I feel deeply embarrassed of what this country has done . I hope one day Palestine is Free and they do indeed get their land back.
Do you think the uk has responsibility to right it's wrong? Should (in your own personal opinion) england. Invade isreal?
@@ryanhawkins4548 UK was responsible in the partioning between Israel and Palestine.
When will you do your research and make conclusions on your own? Maybe you believe that a people who have a history of lying are not lying this time....
@@packerfan66 I'm not going to even bother spending my time on someone who is uneducated. On about go and do my own research when I get first-hand news. I don't follow sky news or BBC news and I've done my fair amount of research thank you very much. If you look at the protest happening all over United Kingdom that speaks volumes. Let me rephrase that.. THE WHOLE WORLD
@Johnnyprc incorrect, the deal that Arabs got was 56% go the jews while 46% go to Arabs, that was the deal. At the time there was 1.5 mil Arabs and 400k jews, you have to be crazy to accept a deal like that when jews were the minority.
My life stories with Israeli apartheid:
Since the Nakba in 1948, my Palestinian family has been displaced by Israeli forces from Jericho, their birth place, to three different refugee camps in the West Bank until they settled in one camp near Bethlehem, where they started their fourth new life after all of their assets they had in Jericho like houses, farms , shops, and lands were confiscated by the Israelis and simply given away to Israeli settlers who immigrated to Palestine from Eastern Europe.
After that my dad worked almost all of his life for Israeli building companies in the occupied West Bank to secure basic needs for his children. My mum and despite her mental illness caused by the displacement trauma, had somehow and miraculously managed to keep us all alive , and together.
However the saddest aspect of this brutal Israeli occupation was not the loss of our land in Jericho itself, but the overall poor living conditions we experienced under the apartheid military control where the Israeli soldiers can shoot and kill innocent Palestinians without being prosecuted. Of course, lack of basic human rights has been the main highlight of the Israeli occupiers who did not give neither my mum nor dad any health care, social care, life or health insurance , compensation for displacement , care home or even basic retirement salary as they later became frail and ill. My parents were lucky to bring up a family in such inhumane circumstances and for me they were my biggest heroes and without whom the story of my life would not be possible to tell.
The story of my family is just one of millions of similar stories in Palestine and I’m sure there are more horrific stories to be told, but there are also many that can never be heard as their heroes are no longer with us.
يعيش الفلسطينيون .... سبحان الله ~~~
I am very sorry. I simply can't understand how the leaders of these countries thought it was ok to give away land that was never theirs to give. Adding so much salt to the wounds is what we witness the last 70 years.
BlackDog Is It okay If you can analyse DerekD's comment about Arabs in the video of UATV English's Russian Volunteer Corps?It's in the comment section of BMPWR.
Wasn't Jericho Jordanian after 1948? What are you talking about?
you try to destroy us and to kill us in Israel before 1948, you confiscated jewish lands in Arab countries and now all of the sudden you are telling me abuot your family's property? You forgot what you did to the jews in Hebron in 1929? You forgot that your leader support the Nazis and planed to eliminate us? so now....keep crying my dear and learn a good lesson from the past!
I cried for the Palestinians.
Love from Vietnam
Go to Ku Chi tunnel. Remain there.
Go eat your rice and don't harass us.🤣🤣🤣
Britain has so much to answer for
No we dont
@@Want.abreak.from.the.adverts your government does
@@BenBorisenko Israelis were refugees from the holocaust and you went to war with them ffs
@@teegee7445 Refugees that tried to take over the land and those so called refugees were supported by the US and UK to colonize Palestine. Why don’t you guys just take them?
@@loudfiend4051 "palestine" was colonized by the Arabs and liberated by the Jews
They killed my dad's cousin in the street for having gold between her legs. They also hit my grandpa in the head with a gun. Having been forced out of their house and walk for 2 days to Jerusalem in the hot Desert. Unethical is beyond the word
Thank you for showing the truth
they're nazis and terrorists
@@ourlearningjourney9841the truth is been on the internet for over a decade
Crazy how they said Gaza was going to be unlivable in 2020. this whole thing is sad
I was searching for recent comment, same here,,,
She was so close.... tells you this had to have been planned ?
@@dmanskinny385 israel definitly was expecting this to happen , if gaza was unlivable in 2020 imagine how it had become in 2023 , totally understandable why the palestinian resistence force had to do something about it
70 years have not passed since it happened. 70 years have passed since it started. Don't kid yourself that what's happening today in Gaza, as I type this, isn't still the Nakba.
Where does the Britishers and Americans went they left destructions behind, whether it was Indo subcontinent, Palestine, Africa, Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan....
They are the people who preached human rights to others😢
Because they are gog magog/yakjuj makjuj descendent from European Caucasus Mountain escape from Zulqarnain gate... They are Kazarian/Scythians people known as Ashkenazi, later become Germanic and Viking whose conquer all European, then later to American then south African, New Zealand and Australia.. they are not original jews, they are Zionism..
Pity that in those countries they forgot the lesson!
we have failed Palestinians, we have failed humanity
How many displaced populations are there around the world? What about the Kurds? Turkey is currently killing them in northern Syria.
Al Jazeera is lying as always. Almost all of the 750.000 Palestinians left voluntarily because the Arab countries were going to attack Israel in 1948. What nobody expected is that Israel won the war. Of course they did not want these Palestinians back so they became refugees. The 160.000 Palestinians who stayed are the ancestors of the now 1.5 million Arab Israeli citizens.
When you always need a lie to smear Israel and can't stay on your feet with the facts then you know that you attack something good. The state of Israel.
Al Jazeera is lying as always. Almost all of the 750.000 Palestinians left voluntarily because the Arab countries were going to attack Israel in 1948. What nobody expected is that Israel won the war. Of course they did not want these Palestinians back so they became refugees. The 160.000 Palestinians who stayed are the ancestors of the now 1.5 million Arab Israeli citizens.
When you always need a lie to smear Israel and can't stay on your feet with the facts then you know that you attack something good. The state of Israel.
They did not favors for themselves
They failed themselves but no one
Wow its unbelievable to think This is about to happen again in 2023... may allah protect the people of Gaza especially the innocent children and mothers... all we can do now is pray 🇵🇸🤲
This video is missing a few key points -
When jews immigrated around 1900, they never intended to banish any arab. This is casually stated in the video in both showing the letter and also stating that the first immigrant PURCHASED the land in a way to grow their communities peacefully. and for a while - it worked.
When did it stopped working?
Once the arabs in palestine saw that the Balfour Declaration is getting real and half the land will be dedicated to jewish government.
So even though the UN gave the arabs states Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Palestine, for the arabs it wasnt enough. Also religious figures would state that according to Islam, moslem can NOT be the inferior religion. They can accept jews, but only under muslim law.
So they started fighting the jewish immigrants before the jews even had any militant capabilities. This is the reason the jews created the Hagana, which was their main militant force and was mostly passive.
The rejection of the arabs to a jewish state started before any form of zionist crimes.
They could have been a peacful jewish state next to a palestinian state if the arabs wouldn't resist the existence of israel from the get go.
This is the cause of everything - the desire to deny ANY jewish state in Palestine, even though Palestine is the origin of the jews.
These hostilities and attacks of arab villages and communities against the new jewish immigrents gave birth to the Etzel and Lechi, two radical and even terrorist like jewish groups. They were about 200 - 400 of them, compared to the hagana, which is 100000 strong. The Hagana was generaly far more peacful and far more into the diplomatic solution. The radical Etzel and Lechi were a minority but they made some crimes against the population, as the man in the video stated. Mostly in Deir Yassin in order to open up a path for humanitarian aid into the blockaded jewish jerusalem.
The evens in Deir Yassin cause the arab population to be afraid of the jews, assuming that the radical Etsel and Lechi represents the entire jewish military force, and they fled. Most of the 750000 fled on their own, just like the jewish population in the Negen in israel and the northern parts of israel now have fled. It's war. It's dangerous. they fled. So did most of the palestinians. Some where forced to bu jews, but mostly did the reasonable thing and fled.
So in conclusion - the arabs didnt like the idea of a jewish state even as a concept and started a rivalry with the jews to prevent the state from happening.
This rivalry cause a lot of arabs to leave. Israel won and didnt allow the return of the arabs, since they knew that if they return, they will be a hostile population that will try and destroy israel again.
And as you said - these events are the same -
The arabs (Hamas) start a war with with the jews with a desire to eliminate Israel, during the war arab population needs to flee they own homes because they started a war from their own land, and if the jews will win, they will take over the land to prevent future wars on it. It's the same mistake again.
@@joeirvine1033 I am fully against Hamas but I think your statement is irrelevant.
The Gazans elected Hamas in 2005. There were no elections since then, so if Hamas messed up in the past 17 years, it's not like anyone had a chance to replace him, even if support in Hamas is just 1%.
Also, Hamas will arrest people who are against them or against their way of acting.
On top of that, 50% of the population in Gaza is 18 or younger. so 50% of the population weren't even born when the last election took place. And many of the others were too young to vote. so maybe only about 35% of the population were of voting age when hamas last had elections.
So I don't think that your argument stands.
However, i am pretty sure [according to various factors I'm not gonna go into] that most Gazans support violence and killings against jews, so whether they support hamas or not is irrelevant. However, if they do support violence against jews than yes, they somewhat deserve it.
and yet again - I am going to counter my own argument. Unarmed civilians or civilians that didnt take part in violent acts are out-of-the-question in terms of international law, afaik.
Again? No. Still. It's never stopped in all these 75 years. Who was that guy from the UN who said October 7th didn't happen in a vacuum? He was right.
@@JayeEllis some (definitely not all) palestinians today want a two state solution - palestinians in the west bank and gaza, and israel on the shore, where they are now.
This offer was already there before 1947. If they only agreed there would have been no Nakba and no war and no problem.
The Nakba is the Arabs fault (Palestinians, but also Jordanian, Syrians, Egyptians and Iraqis) for denying jews a land and wanting to do Genocide and ethnical cleansing in 1947-48.
Arabs have proven to themselves that every time they want to hurt the jews or fight for a cause with violence, they will get a worse and worse living conditions, and they are still repeating this mistake for like the 8th time.
@@adarwinterdror7245 Inapposite.
History repeats itself
Once Europeans stop defending them. They will be screwed. They are sarounded by countries and people that hate them. This can only go one way.
It's not repeating; it's continuing.
Its insane just how clear cut this issue should be. Yet the palestinians are being slaughtered. If i was treated as such i would resist as well.
From what it looks like, both sides are at fault.
@@Punisher1830Yes, we Palestinians were wrong in that we received Jewish refugees from Europe and gave them safety. If we had expelled them and not received them, all of this would not have happened.
@@bahaaalnajjar9631 now we're seeing a similiar thing happening with migrants in Europe, Europeans are becoming 2nd class citizens in their own country by their treasonous government in similiar type of scenario.
Though politically incorect, Native American tribes stole from and murdered each other, white settlers stole from Native Americans, I'm unsure if it can happen in the U.S. today though.
@@bahaaalnajjar9631 Do you forget that your Arab brothers in the countries of North Africa, Iraq, Iran, Syria, and Yemen kicked out 850,000 Jews?
Incredibly sad, unjust, and inhumane 😢 I stand with Palestine and ending the apartheid, occupation, and discrimination they endure.
ruclips.net/video/H7FML0wzJ6A/видео.html
Melissa WE NEED TO ARM THE PALESTINIANS! THEY ARE USING SLINGS AND ROCKS AGAINST TANKS! THEY ARE A BRAVE PEOPLE!
First learn what apartheid is, then buy a ticket and stay in Israel for a month at least.. Then u talk with facts and not this hate propaganda. G'd bless u
gazapo y gazapa I've learned what apartheid is and I've visited occupied Palestine. Hate? To stand with people who are oppressed? To stand with people who lost their homes? That's hate? What facts do you base this 1 month in Israel? Do you understand that experience is subjective? That perhaps you've never been exposed to the Palestinian/humane side of the occupation? It doesn't look like you have anything of value to contribute to my thoughts and values.
Melissa omg so opressed they have luxury hotels and restaurants. Talk to your hamas parents so they give back themoney to the ppl and improve their lives.
Viva Palestina! ✊ 🇵🇸
As an American I feel entirely embarrassed, disgraced, and deeply sad.
Why?
Why are you embarrassed.
May Allah bless you with immeasurable favours throughout your Life n choose you one amongst the true fatih keepers.ameen
'As an American I feel entirely embarrassed, disgraced, and deeply sad.' (Klaus)
DO NOT PREACH MORALS UNTO OTHERS, NOT PRACTICED AT HOME
-LBJ invaded Vietnam. It is true that JFK left him no other choice. though
-USAF B-52's demonic carpet bombings in Vietnam
-Napalm bombs in satanic succession. BOOM BOOM BOOM. One huge ball of fire
-US exploits in Cuban & Vietnamese territorial waters to the rescue
-The infamous "Bay of Pigs"
-So much to emulate & be utterly 'embarrassed, disgraced & deeply sad'
-My beloved & belated grandpa once told me: "Hey grandson, don't you ever preach morals unto others, not practiced at home"
-Oh I miss him so much, you have no idea
-AGENT ORANGE - code names for Herbicide Orange (HO) and Agent LNX, one of the herbicides and defoliants used by the U.S. military as part of its chemical warfare program,
-Operation Ranch Hand, during the Vietnam War from 1961 to 1971. Vietnam estimates 400,000 people were killed or maimed, and 500,000 children born with birth defects as a result of its use.
-The Red Cross of Vietnam estimates that up to 1 million people are disabled or have health problems due to Agent Orange.
ABU GHRAIB WAR CRIMES BY U.S:
Human rights violations in the form of physical, psychological, & sexual abuse, including torture, rape, sodomy &homicide of prisoners held in the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq.
Acts committed by U.S soldiers.
Return Oklahoma, Kansas, Nebraska, Missouri, Colorado, N & S Dakota, Montana & Wyoming to brutalized & genocided indigenous INDIANS NOW
The time to return Nevada, California & Texas to their brutalized, traumatized & genocided indigenous MEXICANS is NOW
No amount of compensation need apply…. Have you no shame as an American?...
France subjugated, oppressed, raped, milked, exploited, molested & squeezed Algeria at its testicles .
More than 1 million Algerians killed
-Sweetie, condemn racist, arrogant & criminal France for arrogant crimes against humanity
- The French air force decimated the Ivory Coast's only air port killing dozens - for the accidental death of a few French colonialist, imperialist, arrogant & baguette devouring gendarmes (2004)
-BOYCOTT FRENCH WINE AT ONCE!!!
All Muslim nations must be united to support Palestinian rights
Why?
Palestinians in Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt, Syria? The living conditions of Palestinians in these muslim countries are way worst than those Palestinians living in the west bank... muslim countries think these people are a burden to the society
No Muslim state is going to sacrifice blood and treasure in order to give Suha Arafat a kingdom.
There is a contract between U.K./Israel and bin al saud family, but in the contract is written don`t to kill
Why, too, does none of the Arab nations take the current people? They don’t want them, their supposed Muslim brothers, because they threaten the stability of those countries; see Lebanon and Jordan. Egypt doesn’t want them because they would increase the possibility of the country falling into civil war.
We stand with the Palestinian People 🇮🇷💖🌺
no we don\t
🇮🇷🇹🇷🇵🇸
@@fisterklister I don't think you will . But We are with them .
@@fisterklister we dont need your support
Nop.
prisoners on their own land.
wasn't their own land, it was land that they stole from the Jewish people when they came during the roman empire
@@jonnajohnsons2684 you're well aware what world law position is.
@@jonnajohnsons2684 Are you kidding. 1948 is Modern times compared to Roman times. Arabs were there for thousands of years. So, the Jews did to palestinians what Germany did to Jews...Go figure?
@@jonnajohnsons2684 hahahah lol just lol.
@@vjk2242 what are you laughing at
The worst catastrophe in our life time. Often forgotten and sometimes purposely hidden.
More people have died in the Syrian civil war since 2011 than in the entire Arab-Israeli conflict since 1948 including all of the wars combined.
That's a ridiculous thing to say. Learn some history.
@@ranndino of course it is! Why do Palestinians always think they have a monopoly on human suffering? Yes Syria even worse and look at North Korea millions died of hunger
저는 이스라엘의 잔혹함을 기억할 것입니다......팔레스타인 대재앙(NAKBAH)을 안타까워하고 애도할 것입니다.
Like the Armenian genocide?
Who's here after watching this year's massacre??
Me
@@asmasspace1219 same here 😓
5:57 "Gaza is said to become unlivable by 2020". Yeah pretty much.
Massacres ?? Bombarding terrorists is a massacre ? Hamas shot at civilians, Israel bombarded terrorists. That’s the difference.
what massacre?
Salam from Malaysian. Freedom for Palestin
I'm Chinese. What is my status under the Malaysian Constitution?
@@robharris5467 nothing to do with you i guess.. U are Chinese as u said.. If u said you are a malaysian of chinese decent.. If would matter..
It like im saying im portugese.. What does it have to do with brazil constitution.. A brazilian with a portugese decent would matter😂😂
@@robharris5467you're a Chinese not Malaysian, right?
It was a hypothetical but for the purpose of the discussion I'm Chinese. Look into the Bumiputera regulations in the Malaysian Constitution. Lee Kuan Yew (a Chinese) removed Singapore from the Malaysian Federation, because as he said: 'I will not be a 2nd class citizen in my own country'. @@imazination28
@@robharris5467 Well, Chinese and others ethnic live very well and prosper in Malaysia... Everybody knows that... So what?
The indigenous people of turtle island and the people of Palestine are united in the cause against the militaristic colonial empire may we bring peace and justice to our homes 💕
Which tribe of Indians called the USA “turtle island”? I can’t remember
@@shanek6582 then maybe it’s not knowledge that is meant for you :)
@@user-dh6yv9uo4k no, it’s just you have no idea what you were talking about
@@shanek6582 colonizer tears :,)
We're all indigenous. I wasn't born on Jupiter.
Shame on israel
Before that shame on the british monarchy who made this happen
I stand with Palestine🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Than you believe liars.
@Imaan you know the Jews are the indigenous people who were displaced right? Palestinians were mostly immigrants who came in the 19’ and 20 century. Jews were also immigrants, but also the Palestinians. Jews are the real indigenous , they were there before Arab and were exiled. That’s the truth, face it.
@@hagitaleinikov8643 At least we dont believe J*wish Z*ionists
@@adoptbutler5224 what’s with the **? If you don’t believe Jewish Zionism than you escape truth.
I stand with israel 🇮🇱
The world allows this to go on😢
You forgot to mention the expulsion of the mizrahi jews from arab countries.
We are with u hero Palestinian
After the Nakba, villages were destroyed, settlements were built, returning Palestinians were shot at and not allowed re-entry.
I am with you my beloved Palestinian brother and sister
a "small number of jews"? please be serious 😂😂
Free palestine 😢❤🇵🇸
Free Palestine save the people of palestine
Wow. This is actually very sad 😞. Why didn’t they create their state somewhere in Europe?
Because funny enough Europe isn’t mentioned in the bible as being a Jewish homeland. Not that I believe the bible but the Jewish people do or at least the Torah.
What is turkey doing in Europe!
Almighty God gave that land to Israel. Palestinians occupied that land after the Jewish people. The Jewish people had it first. Read the Bible and check history. Palestinians claim to the land comes after Israel had it before them.
Just because ur people lived there like 3000 years ago doesnt make you its autocrat for all of eternity u know…
FREE PALESTINE🫰🇫🇯🇵🇸🇵🇸
Excellent piece on the history of the Nakba! We need to continue to support the Palestinian people and their right to return!
this isn't what happened, of course your gonna hear this bullshit from an anti-jewish news agency
Egypt and the Arab nations attacked Israel and Palestine and caused the Nakba. The Right to Return is a horrific suicidal insane idea.
When the Ottomans withdrew from Palestine, they instead slaughtered millions of armenians. Why do we never hear about that?
The Armenians like the Arabs revolted against the ruling ottomans as a result of British influence and manipulation, the ottomans tried to put down the rebellion on both the Arab and Armenian fronts, however they where unsuccessful.
@@vakasm8227 Genocide is genocide
This is so immoral and the fact that Americans can’t see how wicked this mess is , is crazy and complacent.
The problem is Islam. The US Navy was founded to repel muslim pirates. They will be slow to change sides. Like never.
Many Americans do see it. The problem is our government who has a vested interest in these conflicts💰
Liberdade para o povo Palestino!
Todays date is 2/05/2024 and this video is 5years old that's crazy
1948 Arab nations declared war with objective of "liberating Palestine" by throwing all Jews into the sea? 🤣🤣🤣🤣I cannot stop laughing.
Then they took Palestinian territories without any intention to create Palestinian state but to split them between Jordan and Egypt. Nice Liberation. Well done.
The Azzam Pasha quotation was part of a statement made by Abdul Rahman Hassan Azzam, the Secretary-General of the Arab League from 1945 to 1952, in which he declared in 1947 that, were a war to take place with the proposed establishment of a Jewish state, it would lead to "a war of extermination and momentous massacre which will be spoken of like the Mongolian massacre and the Crusades."
The Arabs are still talking of massacres; somethings never change.
"Objective of liberating Palestine"? ... That's one way of phrasing it
Yeah, liberating it from foreign immigrant religious fanatics called zionists. Who hadn't lived in the land for 2000 years and suddenly want to kill arabs and take over their lands.
Last I checked it was the Palestinians with the refugee status not the Israelis. Palestinians who were there prior to the current generation of Jews.
Who are watching in 2024 :(
You left a lot out. The Arabs fought against the Turks for the British and were promised their own homeland. Also the British troops later went house to house and disarmed the Palestinians while the Jews were coming in armed to the teeth.
The Palestinians fled not because they were kicked out, but because the Arabs told them to leave while they 'dealt' with Israel. Doesn't give Israel a right to keep expanding her borders though
Absolutely NOT TRUE.
The only borders it expanded after becoming an official state were territories it took over in Wars started by the Arabic countries surrounding it.
yes it does because they were defending their country which was attacked by Arab Armies that openly called for Jewish deaths
@@yoavrubin9845 That’s illegal. Occupying land through battle is illegal, regardless of whether or not it is done through defensive or offensive battles.
@@abdullahpatel6086 Not so. It's not public policy now but at the time 'Right of Conquest'.was part of international law. It's a central tenet of Islam that land once conquored by Islam is forever Islamic. This is a bit like descendants of Napoleon's army of 1812, still laying claim to Russia.
This is nearly 2023 and nekba continues...
Here in October 2023 💔
Thank you for al jazeera keep it up the truth always 👍
thank you Aljeeera, this puts it all into perspective...i feel for the Palestinians...its 2023 and ont the barbaric ages, nothing has changed..
In his memoirs, Haled al Azm, the Syrian Prime Minister in 1948-49, also admitted the Arab role in persuading the refugees to leave:
“Since 1948 we have been demanding the return of the refugees to their homes. But we ourselves are the ones who encouraged them to leave. Only a few months separated our call to them to leave and our appeal to the United Nations to resolve on their return.”
(The Memoirs of Haled al Azm, Beirut, 1973, Part 1, pp. 386-387.)
Wow i can now see why the karma is unfolding and the British descendants are feeling the brunt of the former colonists' invasion of Palestine
Britain created mess India vs Pakistan and Israel vs Palestine, both mess same year 1948.
Love from India
That is very unfair
brian awuor unfair for whom?!
ofir gabbay ,ofcourse unfair to palestinians.How can you have your land taken away from you like that??
yes it was unfair and totally biased..
if only the truth was as simple as this very problematic video. this is missing a lot of context and information, some numbers, some wars, some arab riots, some explanations about "historic palestine", is it british mendate palestine, is it ottoman empire palestine? is it roman empire palestine? many different things, none of them mean what people mean today when they say palestine. i dont even know where to start with this video.
Really it's sad what's happening and what was happened
FREE 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Nice and short information. Thank you.
Could someone point me to further reading, I am specifically interested in the part where she says Britain left Palestine without a political or military leader.
A good place to start in order to learn more about the basics and foundations of the conflict would be 'A History of Israel' by Ahron Bregman, a former Israeli lieutenant who fought in the Lebanon War, and the book 'One Country' by Ali Abunimah, a Palestinian-American journalist.
@@maxkemper1598 thank you sir
Didn't the outgoing British Army chief ask: Who do we hand over to? Should I just leave the key under the mat?
How did British even think the division was logical! splitting the same population in to two geographically diff sides. And especially based on religion!! They did the same with india, pakistan and bangladesh.Acted as if they gave us freedom to only push us into a never ending war. people suffer till date. There is no way either sides are going to give up .
The world is never fair. Every single race has been persecuted, conquered at some point in time.
Please Palestinian peoples save your future by avoiding futile war with Israel. There are brotherhood around you to embrace you please move there. Save your peoples.
G T don't speak like your a child playing mummies and daddies. Fool.
This is too brief. There is a lot more to this story. Neither side is innocent.
I'm still learning about the whole situation.
Read the Bible. It will inform you that that land belongs to Israel. Consider the location of Solomon's Temple. Also, particularly, the Western Wall. That land belongs to Israel.
@@carolynwilliams7414, that is kinda true but let me give an example: if you would be in a war and you flee from ur house to move to another country. You stay in that country for 5 years. The war is over and you go back to you home country. You see your house, but sadly others are living there now. What do you do? You cant really 'claim' your house and say that the others need to shut up, right? Idk if im right but thats pretty much what i think that happened to the Palestinians
@wilbertvanvulpen9553 is more than kind of true. The land belongs to Israel. Almighty God has fought for Israel. He is fighting for Israel and will continue to fight for them. Read the Bible. These are the last days. Almighty God will keep His covenant that He made with Israel. Period.
@@carolynwilliams7414 yeah i know, im a christian myself. But i dont think its so one-sided. If you read the Bible you know that you should always seek the good of your loved ones
@wilbertvanvulpen9553 you don't think. God doesn't care what we think. The truth is what matters. Not what we might think. Your opinions mean nothing. You claim to be a Christian. You should know the scriptures. That land belongs to Israel. Almighty God will not break His covenant.
when justice will come,on one could not say,i have not getten my justice.
Let's not forget the Arabs declared war on Israel and lost.... Had they have won that war the consequences for any Jew would have been dire.....I don't necessarily support the state of Israel but the Arab nations lost terribly with an overwhelming advantage in numbers.
If someone comes to you and says, "I'm gonna take by force your home and property, let's negotiate". What would you do?
Hush, its natural fellow Arabs would aid Palestine, though some like Jordan had self motive.
“Palestinians were killed” and the Jews and British “died”. I support the plight of Palestinians but this shows that there’s bias everywhere
that is incorrect, but you wouldn't listen because your brainwashed and it clearly shows
Nakba brief history:
The Arabs launched a war of extermination against the nascent Israel
They lost
Ever since then, they have been crying victim.
European Jews do not have a single right to this land before you talk about anything.
you ignored the British occupation.
You ignored the crime that happened by Zionists during the British occupation.
You ignored the fact that this land belongs to Palestinians.
You ignored that they got kicked from their own land to other places.
You ignore the genocide they attempt try to find an other justification for Israel complete this
I like how you call them Terrorists when they even do a peace protest
and at the same time you call them crying victims.
Palestinians are real victims and nobody can deny that.
Pro-Genocide can deny that by lies and racism
If it happened to you I know that you would not accept it and would fight back to get your land back.
whether you liked it or not Israel is,
A Terrorist state, an apartheid state, an Occupying Force, Grandsons of Nazzis and a Peace of garbage state.
Stop being a Savage Pro-Genocide Person
@ 5:59 "Gaza is said to become unlivable by 2020"
The source: The UN.
The UN "suggested" dividing Palestine? That phrasing is deliberately misleading. UN Resolution 181, which partitioned Mandatory Palestine into Jewish and Arab territory, was voted on and adopted in late 1947. Leaders from most Arab-majority countries chose not to vote. Instead of voting, the Iraqi Prime minister vowed to "obliterate every place the Jews seek shelter in."
I think this was a response to David Ben Gurion's comment that europeans zionists are superior to Arabs and have the right to kill Arabs and take over Palestine, so they can build the second temple and messiah comes.
You really expect unbiased news from Al Jazeera?
The UN is controlled by chósenitè filth
Didn't know this. Thank you random stranger.
@@Bolognabeef @tackytaco8133 nice little circle-jerk zionism going on here. You lot seem to keep forgetting why the war actually started (ethnic cleansing of Palestinians). How much are you guys getting paid for this propaganda, disinformation campaign?
And yet the British left them without giving the punishment they deserve for betraying the Brits
😢😢😢
Are you telling the story of Hindus in Islamic countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh??
wow, are we now in a competition, great job lindus, everything is about yoi😢
The Balfour decelaration clearly states it a home land for the Jews & not a state, the colonial masters did a lot of gerrymandering type of process and the Arabs lost big time by not being united during the Arab Israeli war
Thats bullshit colonization. That is arab land.
3:48
وَلاَ حَوْلَ وَلاَ قُوَّةَ إِلاَّ بِاللَّ
Spiderman is pretty tough too
This is terrible!!!
I’m sorry but didnt Palestine and Egypt and Jordan all call war to on Israel and lose and that’s why they lost the land . What a bunch of cowards you forget to mention the main part of how that out come came to be.
InshaAllah, one days the Palistine will get their rights, InshaAllah.
it was a tragedy to see this and I believe many other ethnicities such as in Africa had faced the same problem but they moved on from the past and lived better in other countries. Palestinians also have to realize that this is a reality and stop living in delusion, they should give a better future for their young generation. Israel has a very strong clear vision, mission, and determination and they plan and execute it accordingly, on the other hand, Palestinians had no clear picture of what they want to do, no plan. All Palestinians want is to get their land back, and old folks want to have nostalgia with their own fellow people which I think is almost impossible as things have changed a lot.
No mention of the kippur war, for example. Why?
When your land is seized, dispossessed, occupied and you are expelled. The only natural thing to do is to resist and defend yourself. Only people not in the right mind says the contrary
So the end of the Caliphate is indirectly responsible for the Nakba, this implies that a continuation of the Caliphate is mandatory to safeguard Muslim societies in the near future. How can this currently be established ?
impossible
No more caliphate but Imam Mahdi will save us soon insyaAllah. Be a good muslim and mukmin, insyaAllah we will be among the righteous and will help Palestine free
Arabs army asked Arabs to leave the country and to come back after the war against Israel 🇮🇱 but Arabs army lost the war
🇵🇸🇹🇷
God knows the best of this solution
Yep, this crusade will fail because the Palestinians are not Arabs. The Quran forbade Arabs settling in Palestine/Israel.
DNA tests show that so called Palestinians are ancient Hebrews and are closely related to Safadi, Mizrahi, Druze, Samaritans and other Middle East Jews.
However, European Ashkenazi Jews are 50% Slavonic. So are Zionists really Jews according to the Talmud?
Allah is the best of planners:
1. Christians believe Jesus will return and they will rule the world/paradise at the end of time.
2. Jews believe a messiah will come when Jews are pious and the whole world will be Jewish, but it will not the end of time. That must mean no Zionism present.
3. Islam believes the Messiah will return as a Muslim and Islam will become the dominant religion, which will be plainly apparent, but it will not the end of time.
The Geneva Convention doesn't apply to Civil Wars (1947-1948) between two independent factions.
You have to be a signatory party. Israel signed them in 1951, long after the Nakba.
The Geneva Convention was created in 1949. Nakba took place in 1947 or 1948 depending on whom you ask.
Everywhere in Planet where war , if you dig hard, you can find their trace
I'm learning a lot about the nakba as a jewish Israeli. I am doing a lot of reading and watching videos like this to become more familliar with the attrocities that were committed by the jewish side, but when this video states that Israel received foreign military, political and financial support I get immediately suspicious of this particular video's credibility. (This is not at all to say that I don't think the Nakba happened) but stating that Israel received foreign aid seems extremely disengenuious. Israel took over many/most (not all I don't think) British weaponry and equipment - true. Israel imported arms from Czeckoslovakia - they smuggled secretly purchased weapons into Palestine when the british blockade ended- I don't know if that counts as aid. Israeli agents bought aircrafts and bombers from overseas as well. Israeli arms were mostly produced in the Ayalon Kibbutz. Most of the Israeli army was funded by the Jewish National Fund if I'm not mistaken. If anyone received foreign aid, it was Palestine.
You're worried about how they were financially backed instead of seeing it as they bought weapons to kill and forcefully move people that were living in an area so they could take it. Wow. The justification is just amazing.
If what are you claiming is true then why didn’t the jews fight Germans and Nazis with it ?
@@Darthmaull0101 lol typical...only caring about the finance side of things and not the human side
They got aid from where, may I ask?
you’re just realizing you were brainwashed. keep the good work ;)
Actually most of them just ran away because of the fear of war (when 5 arab countries fought Israel).
All this ethnic-cleansing thing is kind of bs.
SOME RAN AWAY BECAUSE THE ZIONISTS HAD BEEN CONDUCTING BRUTAL EXPULSIONS AND ACTS OF TERRORISM AS PER THE DEIR YASSIN MASSACRE FOR YEARS
It wasn't only the fear of war, the Arabic countries told them to leave and that they could come back after Israel was destroyed.
@@yoavrubin9845
Are you guys crazy? I don’t know how hasbara used agents with that stupidity. Read something about deir yassin, even einstine in US has talked about this massacre.
I find it difficult to believe that jews migrated and simply lashed out violently at local palestinian communities.
Makes more sense that locals were xenophobic towards immigrant jews and lashed out at them first. More in line with human nature.
They didn’t want the Jews there !!! They had every right not to want them controlling power hungry people there
once victims of war now perpetrators
once perpetrators now victims
does power ensure peace
or delays it
This comment section is going to be so much fun. Btw, why don’t the Saudis, Qataris, etc. allow Palestinians to immigrate to their countries? They’ve been bringing in people from Asia for labor. Why not tap a ready supply of fellow Arabs? That would solve the Palestinian question and fill Gulf labor shortages at the same time.
I really think no other Arab country will accept Palestinians because they want them to stay in Israel to continue the conflict.
because they are smart and don't want to deal with all the bullshit that Palestinians love making
Similar to why British and Americans, who love the Jews so much, that they wouldn't give them a piece of land from their own vast territories but will get them one from Arabs. Because they love the Jews so much, they will defend them to steal Arab lands
Why should they leave their land in the first place is the question. Why didn’t Britain create state of Israel in Europe?
@@aeeshachan3265 because Israel is not in Europe...only the people were in Europe
We are also in prison untill Palestine is not librated.
🇵🇸
Most of the 'refugees' were not forced out. They left voluntarily because they were told their land and property would be returned to them when Israel was destroyed.
That simply didn't happen as planned.
Free Palestine ❤
Why didn't you mention that Egypt, Jordan, Iraq, Lebanon, Jordan - ALL attacked Israel, thus beginning hostilities? It may put a different light on the Nakba which is after all a commemoration of a defeat. None of this would have happened if the Arab world has abided by the UN resolution. The whole Nakba syndrome is a whining of a people who, if they had won the war, would have put the Jews to the sword. My sympathy, I'm afraid goes elsewhere.
THERE ARE MANY NARRATIVES IN HISTORY
THE REASON THE ARABS ATTACKED ISRAEL IS BECAUSE THEY HAD ALREADY TASTED JEWISH RACISM, FOR INSTANCE JEWS WERE NOT ALLOWED TO EMPLOY ARABS, AND MANY JEWISH KIBBUTSIM WERE ERCTED ILLEGALLY ON PALESTINIAN LAND AND IT WAS OBVIOUS THAT A JEWISH STATE WOULD BE BUILT UPON JEWISH RACISM
THE ARABS WERE NOT OBLIGED TO PAY FOR HITLERS CRIMES
@@anthonykenny1320 RACISM that never existed in the first place, another thing they invented to blame the Jewish people, Palestinians came to Israel during the roman empire era and started stealing what the Romans gave them and changed historic names for example the West Bank, it's really called Judea & Samaria, look in any bible you'll see it. in every bible, it says the land belongs to the Jewish people, Palestinians also forced h!tler to kill the jews weather than deport them to another country like he planned, but Palestinians wanted him to kill them. How about you go get educated kid and go back to school
the UN resolution ? lol you mean them giving israelis the land of palestine when people already live there, there were already hostilities before egypt jordan iraq and lebanon went to war with israel to DEFEND palestine from the ethnic cleansing the israelis were doing. you guys make me sick. you guys feel so high and mighty thinking the UN deserves to just offer up someone’s land and country. make that make sense. bigot. the holocaust was a heartbreaking catastrophe , why on earth would jewish people want to put anyone else through what they’ve been through. so hypocritical.
Zionists hostilities started post WW1 since Balfour, not the attack on "Israel". The attack on "Israel" was a response to the British mandate of Palestine ending and Zionist declaring it Israel.
Your argument is they
1. formed Israel
2. in a response to the Israel being attacked for it's formation.
You can't have 1 happen before 2,its completely illogical.
Yeah bt Israel kill them in desert al those Arab nations surrender. Israel do it alone while whole world was watching. If Palestine think they get that land Israel has taken back then it b the end of these world Wth Nakba or not it al the same! Israel is going no where it there to stay, is either u r with them or against them.
No word on Palestinian support for the third Reich? Weird how they skipped over that...
Plz Explain How did the Palestinians support the third Reich
If this Nakhba narrative is true why was the Union of Jewish Workers formed in 1920? The reason being the huge influx of Arabs seeking work in Jewish enterprises. It's not unreasonable for Jews to expect that employment for Jews should be first priority. If there had been a large existing popn of Arabs, then they would have been absorbed into the new work opportunities. In the late 1800s i.e. before WW1 Arabs migrated into what was Turkish territory not British. Central to the establishment of Jewish industry in Palestine was the establishment of electric power generation in the region which eventually centred on Jordan hydro generation - again ALL JEWISH. As Winston Churchill said: 'The Arabe would have sat in the dark forever..' Problem is they're still doing just that and blaming the situation on others.
Forcefully displaced, sometimes yes, sometimes no.
Here is the bottom line you attack you lose you lost. Don’t come crying for second chance