As an American, I finally took the time to find out the question of why, why are the Palestinians so upset. We don’t ever see the other side. I’m finally starting to get the answers starting with this documentary. Thank you
??? This is a biased documentary. You might be getting answer, but you're not getting the whole answer. All this mess starts with the Arab-Islamic invasion of Palestine, where they stole Palestine form teh Jews and Christians. Knowing this, one can understand why the Jews were driven out of thier homeland of Palestine and left stateless, and why the Jews had to suffer so much discrimination and genocides that they decided to return to Israel-Palestine and settle/liberate Palestine from the Islamic invaders once and for all. If documentaries don't tell you about the arab-Islamic colonization and oppression of Palestine that started all this, you know it's going to be a propaganda or biased video against the Jewish right of return.
good for you! i visited israel in college and that trip made me realize just how hateful and wrong israel is, i had no clue! it takes years to unravel and rid yourself of all the lies israel and the us gov/news feeds us - the real history is there and it does not lie. keep learning more! sadly there is so much to learn about israel's terror....
@@pichepc7796 khazarians have no rights to Palestine lol. Your jealousy and envy of the Arabs, and of all other groups, not of your own, is so old and tired - you should be exhausted by now.
This is an important piece of work, I am a Jewish South African and a supporter of Palestine. Tonight, I watched this for the second time, and with my father. Our relationship had almost completely broken down from a month of continuous and loud arguments. I can see he has forever been changed by watching this. Thank you
@nicksearra Is supporting “Palestine” a kosher idea? Nehemiah 2:18-20 Genesis 21:8-13 Doesn’t the land of Israel belong to the Jews? Exodus 32:13 Romans 9:4 Psalm 105:8-11 Genesis 13:14-16 Joshua 1:1-6
I'm also an Athiest, so I'm sure you can imagine how ridiculous I think it is that someone's God would favor one people group over another, condone an apartheid system and encourage the behavior seen in this documentary. If I was a believer, I would understand that radical interpretations of a book written by men a few thousand years ago from story's told way before could be wrong
@@Nicksearra An atheist? You said you were Jewish. Where does that word come from? Ezra 6:7-14 Nehemiah 4:1-2 Esther 4:1-16 Matthew 27:37 Acts 21:39 Apartheid? Do you not keep the murderers, rapists, and kidnappers in your own country behind locked walls in the prisons? Wouldn’t it be hypocritical to criticize Israel for doing the same?
@@johnmann8659 you know the Bible/Thora/Mose very well, it seems ??? Can you, honest question, tell me if Christans are also children of Abraham and part of the people of God? ... coz we read the same book, pray very similar prayers, sing the same songs in church... Shall we go to the Holy Land as well? All Christians? Coz it's our promised land also?
@AnnettSchwarz-sheepos_negros Well said. Muslims are also children of Abraham. We believe in all the prophets of the Old Testament(Torah), new and testament (bible) and the final testament (Quran). So if he is saying the children of Abraham have a claim to the land then Jews, Christians and Muslims have a claim. I feel so sorry for the Christian and Muslims communities in the holy land, they are persecuted on a daily basis. So sad to see nuns being spat on and worshippers prevented from praying at the Al Aqsa mosque. It's beyond deplorable. God didn't ask us to fight. I wish for a world where we can all co exist in peace. Inshallah (Godwilling).
This movie focuses a lot on fanaticsm - which is the minority in Israel. Everyone should already know this but judging from the comments here, they know nothing about Israel. As a documentary maker Doran has a responsibility to be unbiased and he shouldn’t assume that everybody knows the fringe the fanaticms and that his movie won’t fuels hatred even further. So he failed.
when that was written in the constitution that was written by slave owning white men and it did not consider women who weren't even allowed to vote until the 19th amendment in 1920 as a muslim myself I disagree with the U.S. constitution because Islam guaranteed equal rights for women and minorities and even non muslims just look at Spain before the conquistadors took over the only tax they had to pay was 2.5% the jizya tax and they didn't even have to serve in the military so I would take Islamic law before man made laws because clearly man made laws don't work.
M.L.K. was also a communist. Look up the secret documents that reveal his true motives. Everyone they tell you is a saint, the opposite is usually true.
@@charleslozada5829When the transgressors and the worst people in deeds in God's eyes label themselves as "The chosen ones." The audacity claiming that God pertains to them transgressors as "the chosen ones." Don't know if i'm gonna be pissed or roll over the floor laughing. 🤬🤣🤣🤣
Wow! A settler said: "The Palestinians are creating the Israeli expansion by their resistance". If they do not resist the occupation, then all is well. That is what the South African white European settlers were saying to the black Afrikans.
not to comment on your point of view, just to say that some white european settlers in SA are who became the afrikaners. to express your point of view accurately you therefore need to say: ‘That is what the south african white european settlers were saying to the black africans’, not black afrikaners. you’ve mixed two groups of people into one. which, by the way, is likely what will inevitably naturally happen, and we will be like about 88% of mexicans, for example: beautiful mestizo], all believing and being whatever they, our descendents, want to believe and be, so long as they allow everyone else the same right …
It's like offering a homeless man (Israel) to stay at your house for the night, but the man takes over your house by force and doesn't understand why you're ungrateful when he offers you to live permanently in "his" basement with no water, food or electricity while locking the door, preventing you from getting out.
It's like homeless man returning home (Israel) that has been taken over by colonizers. The homeless man purchases land to themselves and when his exiled family is killed and oppressed all over the world, they plan to established their home to be here, where he returned to live in peace. The people who had built houses in your tribes lands decide they do not want to live by the homelss man as equal to them. Homeless man (Jews) have always been seen as lessers and undeserving of equal human rights to Arabs and Muslims, so they decide to murder every single homeless man they can find instead of peacefully living together. If you missed Jordan occupying and cleansing Jewish pepople from Judea and Samaria (what Jordan called it's West bank) you missed quite a lot of information about the whole thing. The Arabs (Palestinians) being settlers in the Jewish land. Jews who had returned to their land, trying to establis a home being pushed away and Arabs "settling in the conveniently empty houses, takign their possessions. You know, what Arabs have been to the Jews in every single Arab colonized/cleansed land.
But we didn't offer. The britains who didn't own anything, just colonize and rob, offered. Truman did finalize the deal with a land that he didn't own. It's like offering a home to someone you did steal...
the amount of archive footage, the panoramic landscape shots, the range of views expressed, the subtle reveals.. a masterpiece of a film and mammoth of a documentary
Heartbreaking that some actually believe the settlements are okay. That the brutality, cruelty & evil perpetrated is justified somehow. It is sick. Genuinely sick.
This is a documentary about a few lunatics that are randomly doing their own thing. Also, the documentary leaves out all the displacement of the native Jews from Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Egyp, and Yemen, who lived there for millennia and centuries and were kicked out by Islamic extremists, a lot of them came to settle in their homeland, is a very complex history and this documentary leaves all out by playing demon. The director is obviously leftist and took a couple of Wacos and did a documentary on it. But Israeli are not like that , @@MuniS90
I used to defend Israel, I am so ashamed of myself after watching this, I never read a book about the conflict and since I'm from Argentina the press used to push towards to Israel and his right to "self-defense", but in the last weeks and what the IFD has done in raffa make me feel sick so I start to listen to the "other side". Thank god for the internet. I can only say sorry to Palestinians for not putting me in their shoes.
This is a good lesson for you to be honest with yourself and gain knowledge before supporting something you know nothing about. You supported evil unknowingly and so have many like you because they didn't do the work to read an learn.
All we need is only sanity, logic, history and ofcourse a lot of great documentaries like these to see CLEARLY the truth...sadly many are still in blind and deaf about this 😢
hazlo viral amigo, la gente debe saber quien es su enemigo, esto es alarmante gente que dice que dios les dio, le otorgo imaginate que al rato digan, dios nos otorga cada mujer arabe y las tomaremos, esto esta para locos y en cualquier momento su mesianismo les puede llevar a cometer peores crimenes y no solo contra palestinos, si no contra toda la humanidad, despues de todos ellos se creen herederos de la tierra misma y todo lo que hay en ella porque son los "escogidos de dios"...
I am both speechless and horrified by what I've just watched! May God help the Palestinian. They've been through so much. May he grant them strength and patience. I pray for their freedom and for their mental wellbeing before anything else, because I can't even begin to fathom, how one can deal with such lunatics!
I think that is exactly the problem. There is no god to 'help' either one but the human belief that there is a god and it gives their tribe a special right to kill, and steal at all costs that is the problem. God can't help the palestinians just like he can't help the Israelis but humanity and the rest of the world can, starting with America.
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in a society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it." - Frédéric Bastiat
By the way, they also grant settlement entitlement to those who just convert to Judaism. If I choose do this I could be living in a settlement in Israel in the Occupied territories inside a month. Yet people who are from here and whose great grandparents, grandparents and parents owned land cannot be here if they are Palestinian, Palestinians born here and displaced cannot come back. It is diabolical.
@@anabarjonadefreitas6071 why do u insist on dealing with us as stupid n blind?! Oppression produces oppression, n if hams is bad then the reason for their creation was much worse, that's the kinda reality we need to recognize in order to find real solutions !
Do you even understand the topic? No. You simply don't have a grasp of the subject matter. Present day "Palestinians" are in fact Arabs from Jordan and Egypt. The original inhabitants were Philistines (tribes from Crete who migrated to Levante after the Bronze Age collapse around 2,500 BC) were gone by the time of Jesus. The name Palestine was used by emperor Hadrian 100 years after Jesus as a slur against the Jews. The land was back then called Judaea, Samaria and Galilee. The Arabs came to Levante 600 year later from the Arabian Peninsula thousands of km away after Islam was created around 700AD. They were invaders and colonisers who displaced the indigenous people of Levante (among them the Jews and the original Christians, the Assyrian People). The Arabs didn't call themselves Palestinian until the 1960s after Arafat founded the PLO. So, calling Palestine occupied is ignorant. You want me to move forward to the more recent past? Go back to 1909 when the land was SOLD to the Jews by the wealthy Arabs. They were sold the worst land at the highest prices. Swamp land basically. They then had to defend it with their lives until the British Mandate was enacted prior to WW1. After WW2 and the holocaust they were given somewhere to live, in 1948. The very next day, 15 May 1948, war was declared on them by multiple Arab states in the name of Islamic ideology, and they have since multiple more wars and destroyed everyone on the battlefield. This mind you after the land was historically stolen by the Arabs as I've mentioned. Please update your grade school understanding. This DID NOT start in 1948. As I said, Palestine wasn't even a term used in recent times until the 1960's.
Even in the comment section of a documentary showcasing the cold, hard, irrefutable truth, there are hasbaraists saying, "No, actually, it's the Arabs fault." *heavy sigh*
“The last paradox is that the tale of Palestine from the beginning until today is a simple story of colonialism and dispossession, yet the world treats it as a multifaceted and complex story-hard to understand and even harder to solve.” ― Noam Chomsky.
@@broz1488 That’s right. They’d only one reason why Arabic, other than that of commerce and tourism, is spoken there, as if it is an indigenous language from there.
Very informative and detailed about the settlers' colonial project and I very much admire the mountain-size patience and resilience of the Palestinian people! Thanks.
@@SneakyKestrel. But no, actually you couldn't say that. You couldn't say that at all. Claiming a land from a 3000 year old fictional story, and doing so by force and murder. No. It's madness. It's indefensable.
@@iamjanedoe4real you know,for them it's not a fictional story, the Thora is terribly serious, is the fulfillment of a prophecy. They live the fulfillment of a dream.To understand the settlers you should understand the Thora.
United States has a hand in these settlements as well. CUFI is just one of many entities that supports in the form of large donations of money, supplies, and even armaments.
SALaM, SHLAMa, SHLOMo, SHALoM, NAMASTe, PEACe. The Zionists Do Not Believe In God, But They Believe God, Gave Them, The Land Of Israel. Torah [Old Testament]: Thou Shall Not Steal. Thou Shall Not Kill. Rabbi David Feldman.
@@Tabc1979 Christians United For Israel. The evangelical supporters of Israel do so with the religious interest of fulfilling prophecy (Second coming of Christ / Armageddon) & in general the public sphere aligns politically with with the Israeli lobby (bipartisan), other American Zionists, & the arms industry...
Surely, I've seen this docu back in 2016/2017 on the Dutch TV and seeing it again. Without doubt in my top 3 BEST documentaries ever seen, and I am a true watcher over many chanels! Thank you so much for sharing this art-piece of footage collected over the last decades! Especially now, how important it is to share different point of views.
The documentary, testimonial and historical value presented in this video is priceless. I only hope that one day justice will be done with the Palestinian people and with the ethnic cleansing to which they have been subjected since 1948, 75 years ago... While Israel commits genocide against Palestine, it has the tireless support of the USA, vetoing all resolutions in the UN security council, being the maximum facilitator so that this injustice can be carried out. Thank you for this great work, very brave ❤👏👏👏
Because the Palestinians did not want their own land. They just tried to stop Israel from being born, Jews from gaining equal human rights and having their own state, where they would not be under Muslim rule. Because Jordan controlled the entire area (Judea and Samaria, or Jordan's west bank) and then gave it up.
@@philipkozely3768seeing their nerve to lie so blatantly … I guess,not …plus I am afraid about that stuff “from Nile to Euphrates” might become reality one day,seeing how things are going. They’ve been able to cancel from the map a whole country (Palestine) so I guess their horrendous dream can come true… one day !😢
@@SBF2025 Lets hope not. but for as long as the US sends them money then who knows. Maybe Hezbollah will have something to say about this. they have more weapons than Hamas. So who knows what tomorrow till bring. it is the 10-01-2024 today. Will be fun to look back on this and see how things change from this date on.
As long as society is divided into Palestine v Israel, Jews v Muslims. The issue will never be solved. If Palestine is in power Jews die, if Israel is in power Palestinians die. No solution.
Videos like this are important to understand the conflict. While Hamas is an evil organization, people should realize Israeli government is not innocent either. If you want to go deeper into the history of this conflict, you will see that Hamas in its early days was actually funded by Israeli government. Israeli leaders back then were against the idea of a democratic Palestinian government because they needed evil Palestinians narrative. So when Hamas was founded, Israeli government thought it was a good idea to arm Hamas to topple the democratic Palestinian government. Ex Israeli PM confessed to this as well, you could find it on RUclips if you search for it. Also, current Israeli PM Netanyahu was the one who kept pushing USA to invade Iraq, the intel report about "weapons of mass destruction" in Iraq came from Mossad. Not sure if you seen Netanyahu's recent visit to US senate but he is trying very hard to get USA to attack Iran now. Saying Iranians are behind the USA college protests against Israel and how Iran is preparing to attack USA. More wars, more suffering, more immigration, more hate towards immigrants, bigger internal conflicts in western countries because of the immigrants. This is all win-win scenario for Israeli government. Note: I'm only talking negative about Israeli government, not its people. Which is why I mentioned the government every single time.
Its bizarre - my nieces are South African Jews, red haired, blue eyed of German/Danish descent - their families settled in Israel even though their family trees back two hundred years place them from central Europe...but an Arab Palestinian, who probably does have the blood of Ancient Israel in her or his veins, is dispossessed and expelled as a "foreigner"...oh....and many settlers abused my nieces when they did their military service on the West Bank when they found out they were "reformed faith" Jews, not Orthodox, and said they were not "real" jews....go figure.....
Your point is the most significant fact bearing on the question of Zionism. Ashkenazi Jews are genetically substantially Eastern European. Therefore, the Zionist occupation of Palestine that began in the late 19th Century is the last example in history of European colonization of the territory of militarily weaker peoples. It even mirrors the Spanish conquistadors' rationalization that they were bringing the Chistian God and salvation to heathens. Invoking God to do evil is disgusting.
As you can see they want all the land to the nile..we know their story since we weee kids..let me tell you something the settlers are growing in numbers they have 8 kids and so on vs the normal israelis …so they will be the majority in israel and this will only lead to more wars, every arab knows this..
@@chriss2452 And What? They left the lands ,either sold everything or abandoned it for better pastures and have no claim to Palestine ,Palestinian have lived on the land ,owned the land and built on the land ,so don’t tell anyone that after 3000 years of absence the have any rights to the land .NONSENSE in every way possible.
and how many wars have Israel started, exactly? And how many wars of annihilation of dirty-Jews have these Palestinians started? The latter a lot. The former none. Scary, I know.
Do you even understand the topic? No. You simply don't have a grasp of the subject matter. Present day "Palestinians" are in fact Arabs from Jordan and Egypt. The original inhabitants were Philistines (tribes from Crete who migrated to Levante after the Bronze Age collapse around 2,500 BC) were gone by the time of Jesus. The name Palestine was used by emperor Hadrian 100 years after Jesus as a slur against the Jews. The land was back then called Judaea, Samaria and Galilee. The Arabs came to Levante 600 year later from the Arabian Peninsula thousands of km away after Islam was created around 700AD. They were invaders and colonisers who displaced the indigenous people of Levante (among them the Jews and the original Christians, the Assyrian People). The Arabs didn't call themselves Palestinian until the 1960s after Arafat founded the PLO. So, calling Palestine occupied is ignorant. You want me to move forward to the more recent past? Go back to 1909 when the land was SOLD to the Jews by the wealthy Arabs. They were sold the worst land at the highest prices. Swamp land basically. They then had to defend it with their lives until the British Mandate was enacted prior to WW1. After WW2 and the holocaust they were given somewhere to live, in 1948. The very next day, 15 May 1948, war was declared on them by multiple Arab states in the name of Islamic ideology, and they have since multiple more wars and destroyed everyone on the battlefield. This mind you after the land was historically stolen by the Arabs as I've mentioned. Please update your grade school understanding. This DID NOT start in 1948. As I said, Palestine wasn't even a term used in recent times until the 1960's.
It is stealing land, also they have ties to it. They were kicked out from the land. Is the west coast of the US the west coast or Comancharia? It’s both
1:34:49 its seriously disgusting how a father like him is teaching his kids to beat Arabs shame on him for brainwashing his kids to hate others just because they are of a different race.
This has nothing to do with race, but with territorial conflicts & religious extremism. That's why he said it. Stop superimposing these American ideas where they don't belong.. It is also worth noting that at least he didn't say "k*ll the Ar*bs", like the other side teaches their kids about Js...
Thank you for this documentary! You showed us the mentality and real truths about occupied Palestine. Thank you for getting this information out for everyone to see who is causing the issues.
This documentary omits many facts and only shows one narrative. It doesn’t tell you about the 1929 massacre of Jews that were living in Hebron over 800 years. Don’t be so damn gullible
They have same mentality of a killers based on fanatics believes like others before killed millions of them . But they forgot...now they are the killers of this poor Palestinians
Who is Palestine occupied other than the Arabs? Palestine was reed when the PAlestinians freed the land from Anglo-Arab occupation and named the land Israel. Muslims got 80% of British controlled land (before that it was Ottoman land) as their part of the Palestine. Jews were supposed to get the 20% on the west side of the river, what happended? Did they Arabs tried to kill all the Jews and occupy Judea and Samaria? How long was the land under Muslim rule... was it occupied then? Did they free the "Palestine" they occupied after 1948?
Surah al-Isra - 4. Verse﴾4﴿ We informed the Children of Israel in the book as follows: “You will surely create mischief on the earth twice and be very boastful. While the book in this verse is generally explained as the Torah, there are also those who understand it as the reserved tablet. According to this understanding, the verse means the following: It is written in the protected tablet that you will cause corruption twice, that is, it is available in our knowledge, we knew that you would do this. As a matter of fact, you did both. It was mentioned above that sending the book to the prophet Moses and making him a guide to the Children of Israel was a divine blessing. The prophet Moses saved the Israelites, who had been subjected to humiliating treatment for hundreds of years in Egypt, from the hegemony of the Pharaoh, liberated them, took them to their homeland, and conveyed the Torah to them. However, as stated in both the Quran and the Bible, they often broke their covenant with Allah and committed sins, and therefore were subjected to divine punishment (for detailed information on this subject and explanations in the Bible, see .Baqara 2/74, 100-101). What is meant by "corruption" in the verse is that the Israelites generally violated the provisions set by Allah in the Torah. In the commentaries, one of the two mischiefs is killing the prophet Isaiah or imprisoning Ermiya (Jeremiah); The second is explained as their killing of Yahya and their attempt to kill the Prophet Jesus by collaborating with the Roman rulers (Şevkânî, III, 327).
Great documentary. Quite eye-opening to see how the troubles started and have been escalating ever since. I needed to see this. Great mapping in the beginning, the best I've seen.
And if you think that Hebron has a continuation from the second Temple till 1929 with Jews that have been murdered by the Arabs… maybe you could see the other side of the coin.
Do you have any idea that Hebron was the first capital of Judea and then David the king decided to make Jerusalem the eternal capital? Do you know that from the period of the second Temple till 1929 the Jewish community was living in Hebron? And because you asked, do you know who massacred this Jewish community? The arabs. So maybe, just maybe is not so disgusting to come back to your home and celebrate?
@@battzion7918 I want to Ask you one thing do u think Jewish homeland is viable 15yrs to come Do u think a Jewish home land is viable even today. Do u think the ruling of the scholars of Islam has changed a little bit since the first settlement. Take heed from history before its late
They dont know any better my Jewish friend. Most likely have not heard of the history or even read the bible. I think what he was getting at was like the silly masks of the palastines and just the gloating of it all. But they will do what they want. No need to start a war over a silly mask. I thought it was funny myself lol but its not funny. Anyways God bless you. PS you should play warhammer 40k :)@@battzion7918
I'm 47 and as a child, they made it look like Gaza destroyed the settlements. Isreal dismantled the settlements because they didn't want to leave anything
@@dyawrno they did not. I watch a documentary only on that here on RUclips and they said there that Arabs cannot take over their homes so they send in their famous big bulldozers
Ariel Sharon destroyed the settlements. They quickly were rebuilt so I don't even understand why he did that. Entire Palestinian communities have been displaced by these settlements. Their homes and livelihoods have been destroyed, they’ve had restrictions enforced on their movement, access to their own water, land and other natural resources. The communities have also been violently attacked by the Israeli military and settlers We must act now. We must Stand in solidarity with the palestinian people until they are able to regain their land and live in peace. I don't understand why anybody would think that is Riley's where victims of anything.
@patriciaherrera193 exactly, I don't understand how anybody would support this. We have been brainwashed for far too long. Watching this makes my blood boil. Its unjust,cruel and evil
@@hairandcia2028 because of what they say and what they do, because of their sense of entitlement and superiority. Because they are not hiding their racism and supremacist attitudes
in 2023, it is illegal to steal land by force. it is in violation of international law. what happened in USA history is irrelevant because it predates the laws we now have. your attempt to justify genocide, landtheft, and the expulsion of people from their land does not hold up to today's standards.
@@ronaldsmith6161. First of all, those settlers right there are Europeans, so no. You're objectively wrong. Second, nobody is allowed to repossess land from 3000 years ago maps. Nobody. You live in fantasy land.
It’s strange to think about. The Jewish people went through so much hardship, you want to root for them and give them a safe place to live and prosper… than you look deeper and see they are perpetrating just another form of extreme racism and oppression directed toward another type of people, a people that we would ignore for decades until now….. at a time where the people of Palestine have had enough.
The world is now opening its eyes on this country. So happy to see alot of young people are witnissing this. hopefully big changes are coming and we will end the atrocities commited by the zionist on the native people of Palestine
@@ezechiele.6001there's a time and place when secularity is required for proper dialogue to take place. Interfaith discussions are one such example...
Watching this makes my blood boil. How dangerous the settlers are, they are not even come from Palestine and born there, they are from mount Sinai and Eastern Europe and yet the world supports these kind of people and legitimate them as an Israel country. Western countries need to be sue on this. It started from British to be sue.
The Israelites are the owners of the land, Bethlehem was where Christ was born, Rachel' is buried there, jacab and Sarah all buried there, why do you say jews are thieves
and Palestinians don't come from Palestine. They are the descendants of ARABS CONQUERERS who stole the land from the Jews. They arrived to Israel after Jews stared returning in the 1800s and cultivate and develope the land. They come the surrounding Muslims countries, from Egypt, from Syria, from Jordania and oroginally they come from the Arabian peninsula, where they started sprearing the Muslim religion by sword.
@@SgtHawk13 I don't mean to excuse the Hamas and palestinians for supporting what they've done. I can see that palestinians also have legit grievances and that among jews there are bad actors too,like the guy who teaches his kids to beat up arabs. But at least his culture is not celebrating him and naming a school after him,for example but instead he goes to jail. I can imagine, there are others like him and they should face consequences. I feel sorry for all involved, who just want to live in peace- who are definitely not Hamas and it's followers. For me the whole thing is heartbreaking,because they live in that amazing place,surrounded with all the amazing culture and they can't deal with each other and it looks quite hopeless.
11:20 Viewers should note: this doc is from 2016. There are more more than 500,000 settlers in the West Bank (+ about 200,000 in East Jerusalem) as of early 2024. The rate of increase since about 1980 has been basically a straight line (+11,000-ish/year).
This is an amazing piece of work. What an insight. I've learnt so much yet as I watched I get sadder by the minute because how can peace between the two peoples be achieved when a people believe so deeply in the prophesies of a book of fiction? Thank you Shimon Dotan for making this. If I feel this way, I cannot imagine how you must feel while making this.
I don’t think it’s a book of fiction. But I believe Israelite never understood the prophecies. In fact they killed the prophets who warned them and denounced their violence and despised for the poor. Back in Deuteronomy Moses prophetically traced the who history of Israel with scary precision including the diaspora. Especially they don’t understand that z gods promises were conditional to their faith and obedience. It’s obvious that their stand in persecuting Christ and the whole Christian’s fledgling church says a lot about them. Yet there are sincere sounds there
As an Israeli myself I am not crazy about the whole idea of settlers These people who see themselves as religious patriots of the Jewish state often times provoke many problems between two nations by not respecting their neigbors of different religion Their main excuse is based on Old Testimony stories and believes, however we are people of 21 century and face a totally different reality where the Land is divided and expect us to respect each other
@@FOXELLA2000 sadly and much omitted is the fact that in the Old Testament God specifically instructs Israelites also to be kind to their neighbors to care for the orphan and all those who want to walk the higher life. It is true that some nations in ancient times degraded themselves so low that they became brutalized and perverted. But even within those there were people who knew Israelite life was upright and that were catptivsted by their lifestyle and wanted those higher principles for their lives. An example of this is the prostitute of Jericho. Even though Jericho came to ruins, because of their debased and degrading type of religion that they had with sacrificing children on the fire and total immortal lifestyle were destroyed. The prostitute aimed for something better and hid the spies from Israel, and when the city fell, she was spared multiple are the passages where in the Old Testament God saysto love the neighbor to be kind to them into the stranger. I don’t think people got what God was trying to do in the world.
@@wiltonpt1 you are wrong, my friend. When Jews were liberated from egiptian slavery and came back to Khanaan, God ordered to free this land from other tribes and nations because it meant to the Land of Jacob's descendents only Nevertheless, we should stop citing Torah and faxe the reality
@@FOXELLA2000 oh I do not deny God wanted them to dispossess and the land. What I am saying is that this is often read superficially. The whole intent of God is what people reading the Torah miss often. It was a missionary project. For instance Jebusites. They fooled the people of Israel saying they were from a far country. Israel beloved it and swore to not war against them. But everything came out later. However even though they used deception Israel was true to their word. Jebusites ended up leaving their detestestable idolatry ( a lot of sexual perversion mixed in the religion of Khananites) and started praying to the true real God Elohim creator of all. Interestingly, when Midianites wanted to destroy the Jebusites Israel interposed and defended them. But I believe like you. Those times under prophets and miraculous divine manifestations or a “theocracy” are not our situation today. And the Ben Gurion Israel is not the one from the Bible either. Reality has to be read the way it is today.
Her response from 51:25 says everything. I was speechless watching this. She doesn't even acknowledge Palestinians as humans. God told her the land was hers and that one day she would be tending the olive trees. I mean W.T.F. did I just watch. It's like a brainwashed cult.
Because it is. The REAL QUESTION IS who are those who are PRIMARILY BENEFITING FROM THIS HENIOUS ATROCITY. That's the curtain that needs to be pulled back. THOSE ARE THE NAMES that need to be exposed. WHO ARE THEY?
Do you know what esle says everything? Listen to Arab Palestinians who wanted to kill the Jews, even before Israel existed. You are aware how the Palestinians have treated Jews, right? And how many of them are not acknowledging Jews as humans, right? But most people are not fanning hate and racism by taking these fringe opinions as representative of people in large (though how Jews have been and are still treated in Muslims lands, where they have been ethnicly cleansed from is horrifying).
Heartbreaking when oppressed turns into oppressors. Their ancestors would turn in their graves.... I pray in our lifetime Palestine will find justice and freedom :-(
This period is only a blip in time of history the Jews have been in the land of Israel far longer than the Arabs. The Jews have had many hiccups in their history timeline this is just one of them.
@@Pintocaleb256 The enemies of God are the Zionists who practise and are proud of their racism and their fascism, its just a fact. I think God would not like these kind of attributes.
@@Catmac2000 I cannot believe how tolerant the Palestinian people have been? If the israelis react to this one day horror attack with the calling for genocide, can you imagine how they would behave/react after 75 years of persecution? Not my words, but the words of Gideon Levy, an Israeli Journalist and an honest, brave man.
What an eye opening! thank you Best Documentary. That s always difficult to find a channel that tells the truth away from the narratives that the mainstream media tells
Disgusting! In the past I was pro-Israel, I even helpen Likud NL. Now I regret having done so after what those "settlers" do to expand their territory. And please don't come to teach me what to think. Or saying I am an anti-semite. But tbh...the way Israel is dealing now with Gaza makes ppl more anti-semite. And I completely understand that.
Spot on. I was pro Israeli all my life .and I'm not a young man. I never really dug into this issue. But recently I started doing my research and found out that I was supporting fanatics .Which is present day Israeli government and settlers and US sionists with deep pockets and western media who are run by them too. It will be hard to reverse this.
I also think that the ‘group’ that one young man leads of teens- 20 somethings is a gang of thugs, at best. No good can come of groups like this! At some point, they will cause the Israeli’s problems of their own. Looks to me like the ‘outposters’ and the evangelical Christian Zionists will be a major problem, as who is going to control the ‘hate’ and ‘elitists’ feelings of both groups? It will come to that; it has already started when the Zionist Jews spit on the Christians coming in to tour the Holy Land. And the Middle Eastern countries bordering Israel better wake up; they are already in the crosshairs of the outposts!
I recommend watching these films on RUclips to better understand the Palestinian issue: -Creation and catastrophe -israel-palestine,60 years of violence -Tantura massacre -palestine is still the issue -Frontiers of dreams and fear -To rachel
Don’t you find it? Interesting that the question, “Are you a settler?“ makes so many of them feel uncomfortable? They are right to feel uncomfortable. Disgusting.
I think this (the palestine/israel conflict) is the best proof, that God (if he/she/it exists) will not save anyone. We have to free ourselves from religion and we have to fight for the freedom of everyone. We ourselves have to do it. Us and our reason and conscience.
@@mimimimimi..according to the Holy Quran "We also informed the Children of Israel in the book that: 'You will create mischief in the land and commit open tyranny twice. When the time comes for the first of them, we will send our powerful and violent servants to attack you. They will even enter the houses and search everywhere to catch you. "They will investigate. This is a promise that must be fulfilled." (Isra, 17/4-5).
@@mimimimimi..Surah al-Isra - 4. Verse﴾4﴿ We informed the Children of Israel in the book as follows: “You will surely create mischief on the earth twice and be very boastful. While the book in this verse is generally explained as the Torah, there are also those who understand it as the reserved tablet. According to this understanding, the verse means the following: It is written in the protected tablet that you will cause corruption twice, that is, it is available in our knowledge, we knew that you would do this. As a matter of fact, you did both. It was mentioned above that sending the book to the prophet Moses and making him a guide to the Children of Israel was a divine blessing. The prophet Moses saved the Israelites, who had been subjected to humiliating treatment for hundreds of years in Egypt, from the hegemony of the Pharaoh, liberated them, took them to their homeland, and conveyed the Torah to them. However, as stated in both the Quran and the Bible, they often broke their covenant with Allah and committed sins, and therefore were subjected to divine punishment (for detailed information on this subject and explanations in the Bible, see .Baqara 2/74, 100-101). What is meant by "corruption" in the verse is that the Israelites generally violated the provisions set by Allah in the Torah. In the commentaries, one of the two mischiefs is killing the prophet Isaiah or imprisoning Ermiya (Jeremiah); The second is explained as their killing of John and their attempt to kill the Prophet Jesus by collaborating with the Roman rulers (Şevkânî, III, 327).
An extremely wrenching Deep dive into the heart of 'Settler's-mentality'. As represented by the single-minded dedication of its founding rabbi, who led his army of early illegal settlers by a fierce determination to battle not only resistant Arabs but also his own government whose laws he was violating... The kind of fierce determination and Will To Power whose only parallel I could think of in the example of the equally fierce Evangelisms of Christian Pastor Hagee or David koresh of the Branch-Davidians, both from Texas.
Outstanding powerful documentary. An assault on the senses in many ways. There are moments that hit hard, expressed by some of the people. They can see beyond, can see its a deeply flawed situation and their conscience is tested. That really takes some doing, surrounded by such brutality, intimidation and inhumanity.
Yep. The Jews suffer because of their kindness and refusal to lower them to the levels of their Arab neighbours. Instead of cleansing the land of these Arabs (just like the surrounding Muslim countries cleansed Jews off their lands, stealing their lands, houses, farms, shows, savings, poseessions etc.) - note, the tiny Israel managed to absorb the displaces Jewish refugees from the dozens of Muslims countries, somehow no one want this litle amount of these specific Mulims, and Jews let them stay, now they are millions of Muslims who want to destroy the one Jewish state.
😂 who can respect your lack of faith, your need to use violence and intensive control over education and media in order to maintain a presence in an area supposedly God given?? @@Hshdzsskidi
@@Hshdzsskidi I can show them respect but that is not even in Torah,and it doesn't matter your religion you can't kick someone from their houses like that
Similar to the settlers that were given land taken from the American Indians, and now many are living on Reservations. 😢 I don't think any Country is guilt free of this type of thing.
You're right. But it wouldn't be so difficult for America to reverse course, try to rehabilitate indigenous communities, and simply stop funding israel or fund it only with conditions. that would help
I think of it that the state of Israel isn't any worse than anywhere else, the disappointing thing is that as a 'new', 'modern' 'democracy', it's no better.
@@TonyShephard-w4mit is worse though. Where else on earth is it legal to murder? Where else does a government hand out weapons to civilians so they can shoot whoever they like almost as a sport? It's a twisted, sadistic place, is what has become evident to the world since October.
Netanyahu is born to Mileikowsky, a squatter from Poland, Ben Gurion is Polish, Golda Meir is Ukrainian, Moshe Dayan is Ukrainian, Shimon Peres is from Belarus. They say they are Jews but are without Semitic lineage. They're descended from Khazars who converted en masse to Judaism, to avoid taking sides between the Ottoman and Byzantine empires. These who say they are Jews but are without Semitic lineage were transplanted to Palestine starting from the early 1900's to 1948 by the Rothschilds and British empire, from places like Kiev, Bucharest, Berlin, Budapest, Warsaw, and Moscow, to displace Palestinian Jews, Christians, and Muslims who had lived in peace for centuries.
Just don’t lie about the Khazars. Both Ashkenazim and Sephardim have the same genetics, and 50% of the Israeli population comes from the countries of the Middle East: Syria, Iraq, Tunisia, etc. As are the Palestinian Arabs, by the way. Yasser Arafat was born in Egypt.😉
That would include the head of the PA, PLO and Humus, right? I mean they stole billions. Now the Israelis, what they're doing, is taking back what billy clinton made them give up in the Oslo Accords in .
1)Before the modern state of Israel there was the British mandate, Not a Palestinian state . 2) Before the British mandate there was the ottoman empire, Not a Palestinian state . 3) Before the ottoman empire there was the Islamic mamluk sultanate of Egypt, Not a Palestinian state . 4)Before the Islamic mamluk sultanate of Egypt there was the ayyubid dynasty, Not a Palestinian state .Godfrey of bouillon conquered it in 1099. 5) Before the ayyubid dynasty there was the christian kingdom of Jerusalem, Not a Palestinian state . 6) Before the christian kingdom of Jerusalem there was the Fatimid caliphate, Not a Palestinian state . 7) Before the Fatimid caliphate there was the byzantine empire, Not a Palestinian state . 8) Before the byzantine empire there was the Roman empire, Not a Palestinian state . 9) Before the Roman empire there was the hasmonean dynasty, Not a Palestinian state . 10)Before the hasmonean dynasty there was the Seleucid empire,Not a Palestinian state . 11) Before the Seleucid empire there was the empire of Alexander the 3rd of Macedon, Not a Palestinian state . 12) Before the empire of Alexander the 3rd of Macedon there was the Persian empire, Not a Palestinian state . 13) Before the Persian empire there was the Babylonian empire, Not a Palestinian state . 14) Before the Babylonian empire there was the kingdoms of Israel and Judea, Not a Palestinian state . 15) Before the kingdoms of Israel and Judea there was the kingdom of Israel, Not a Palestinian state . 16) Before the kingdom of Israel there was the theocracy of the 12 tribes of Israel, Not a Palestinian state . 17) Before the theocracy of the 12 tribes of Israel there was the individual state of Canaan, Not a Palestinian state . In fact in this corner of the earth there was everything but a Palestinian state!
I just don`t understand how people don`t see the similarity between this and ISIS, the only difference is that this type of extremism is supported by the governments of the so-called free world
The big difference is the population of extremist Jews is a very small percentage compared to extremist Islamists. There almost 2 billion Muslims and 15 million Jews in the world. If you give each population one percent as extremists you can see a HUGE disparity. I certainly feel less threatened by these settlers than Isis. How many radical Jews cause terrorist attacks in Europe and anywhere compared to Muslims? 9/11 ring a bell? Charlie Hebdo, Paris attacks, Barcelona to name a few.
Bingo! One who is getting it. Research a bit more, and you'll find out who lSlS really is, it started as: lsrraeI's Secret lnteIIigence Service. Spell it correctly and look up the real story, they are the same people.
My father was born in colonial guinea ecuatorial. They got kicked out and had to come back to Spain as new poor. It was traumatic for that generation, as they kept this ignorant arrogance of the landlords who think they had it because they deserve it. They were self absorbed and never really admit that they were taking advantage. Next generation we are growing up learning about decolonization and realizing why our parents suffer from colonial narcissism. It’s hard to make understand a supremacist that he is not smart. They become a parody of themselves. Fortunately the next generation we became decent people who know that otherism is fascism. I hope something similar happen there and we can decolonize the whole world. Starting on our minds
@ginolitvak1791 you do not have any voice man, your brutalities are so evident. Palestinians welcomed you and provided you shelter when you were oppressed in Europe and now you are committing and killing innocent Palestinian children. how cruel you people are
SALaM, SHLAMa, SHLOMo, SHALoM, NAMASTe, PEACe. The Zionists Do Not Believe In God, But They Believe God, Gave Them, The Land Of Israel. Torah [Old Testament]: Thou Shall Not Steal. Thou Shall Not Kill. Rabbi David Feldman.
Why aren't news allowed to live there? Palestinians settle in the area which is according Oslo agreement under Israeli control. Arab/ Palestinians Israelis can live wherever they want. Why jewish Israelis don't have the same right?
@@Chroniclesof_pain you cannot kick someone from their house. I am not sure why you're trying to justify it. As covered in the documentary, they literally took arab buildings for themselves.
Perhaps BOTH sides should take heed of this great , most marvellous commandment. This is hard commandment to fulfill , but Jesus was right . BOTH sides should listen to him .
@@American_patriot110 he wasn't talking about a particular nation, pay attention, he was talking about land. People in Tel Aviv can have an opinion that is divided.
I can't help it but this documentary is so eyeopening and beautiful at the same time! And the wonderful people who have the right kind of thoughts and heart according to living in peace with each other is truly amazing, like the person speaking @1:21:41 he is such a beautiful soul!
Great documentary! I’ve read in many comments “Jews have a right to return to their homeland, it’s their home”. 1) Zionism is a secular movement. Its founder Theodor Herz would have been happy with Argentina too. Zionists in Hitler’s Germany were quite happy with Madagascar too. Zionism has become increasingly religious over the last decades. Because religion doesn’t need explanation and has always been a good cover-up for atrocities from the Crusades to the Spanish genocide of pre-columbian peoples, from the great inquisition to the Yugoslavian conflict. 2) according to ultra-orthodox Judaism Jews people will be given their kingdom when the Messiah comes. Apparently not a material one. “Forcing the Messiah” to come earlier by occupying Palestine is seen as an offence to God, as a blasphemy. 3) The majority of the Jews doesn’t live and does not intend to live is Israel. Demography and expansion that is outnumbering the Arabs and taking their land, this is the real credo of Zionism. Nothing to do with the romantic “our ancestral homeland”.
1:15:09: Ancient law? Who has given Israel Jews the right to apply ancient law in the West Bank? Clearly an extreme and massively discriminatory law that impacts so many people.
No you are conflating settlements in occupied territory with the state of Israel. The League of Nations (precursor to UN) passed 33 votes to create Israel by division of the British Mandate of Palestine. The states of Syria, Iraq, Transjordan and Lebanon likewise created from the break up of the Ottoman Empire. By your logic, we should delegitimise all of those created Arab states too. Israel has every right to exist within its 1967 borders. Palestine rejected every offer of its own statehood since the establishment of Israel in 1948. Israel then took in 800,000 Jews banished in pogroms from surrounding Arab states, including Yemen, without requesting to increase its borders.
@@ritamanessis146 then as I already stated, if you refuse to apply the same standard to the likewise created Arab states- Iraq, Syria, Lebanon and Jordan and their rights to exist, that would reveal you apply a double standard. There is a name for people with this particular double standard and although we hoped this would end with the destruction of the Nazis in 1945, but unfortunately your kind are ever numerous. Israel is a state with 20% of its citizens (not to be confused with settlements outside of its sovereignty) being Arabs who enjoy equal rights under the law, high status professions and seats on the Supreme Court. Arab Israelis recently polled ranked their quality of life as high and were happy to be Israeli and disgusted by the barbarism of Hamas - there were Bedouin who bravely fought against the terrorists’ invasion. That doesn’t sound much like an apartheid state to me.
@@alanargent5676It is apartheid. There are 61Israeli laws imposed on Palestinians who live in so-called Israel. You might not like to call it apartheid, but that:s exactly what it is - not my words, but numerous human rights organizations, including B'Tselem. Israel is an occupying force and you can rationalize and justify it all you like, and call all those who oppose it as anti-semites. But, you cannot justify one Holocaust with another.
When thugs have been given power to rape a whole nation for self-determination. The delusion of geniunly believing that they could be the people of the light, while commiting all these clear crimes against humanity. is absolutely insane, how can a whole nation be THIS delisional.....
Imagine people with roots in Eastern Europe or the US coming to your land to violently push you out whike using some ancient scrolls as an asinine alternative to a title deed, absolute madness
*"That which we dislike most in others are the things we dislike most about ourselves"* The things that trigger the strongest emotions in us -- are often reflections of our own character flaws; _exposing our deepest insecurities to the world in the form of hatred._
You don’t have to be a murderer to abhor murder ! You don’t have to be a ‘brain scientist’ (apologies to Rippley’s Game) to see that Israel is a terrorist state. You just have get your head out of social media and other hedonist pursuits.
Really high quality documentary in both picture, sound, illustration, archival footage and writing of the narrative. A deep dive into the world of the settlers, without all the politics being rammed down the throat.
This documentary gave you the sugar coated version . The settlers themselves said they don’t believe in geo-politics and if they could or had their way by expanding settlements/ outposts they would expand into lrak ! …
I thought it was very political, but a mild take of how Euro-supremacist, bigoted and eliminationist most settlers are. They didn't show how viciously Palestinians are treated daily by settlers in Hebron, for example. It didn't mention that Palestinians are not allowed to defend themselves against Israeli Jews, and how infrequently the IDF reacts in defense of Palestinians. Non-Jews are not truly human to most of these older colonial leaders. A good example was Danielle Weiss' arrogance in thinking it was entirely appropriate for her to speak to the village heads as if they were misbehaving children, rather than saying "Hey, some of the kids here may be throwing rocks. Is there something we can do together to keep this from happening?" THAT is how genuinely good neighbors speak to one another.
This is truly horrific and a crime against humanity. These people think they are going to bring redemption to israel but will intstead lead it to destruction. It breaks me to think of the many decades the Palestinian people have had to live under the boot of these folks. It has to end now.
im absolutely caregorically againt the settelments that was an israeli made fuck no palestinian is to blame for that ..but israeli territorial exoansion was trully allwys prescipitated by arab aggresion ..1948 allthough not 1956 ..1967 and the lebanon war ...had yasser arafat excepted ehud baraks deal settements would be a thing of the past ...
no it wasn't. it was precipitated by Israel always - from day 1 of negotiations- trying to take more than its fair share. SHAME ON YOU for lying. @@ashley-fk6dp
Present day "Palestinians" are in fact Arabs from Jordan and Egypt. The original inhabitants were Philistines (tribes from Crete who migrated to Levante after the Bronze Age collapse around 2,500 BC) were gone by the time of Jesus. The name Palestine was used by emperor Hadrian 100 years after Jesus as a slur against the Jews. The land was back then called Judaea, Samaria and Galilee. The Arabs came to Levante 600 year later from the Arabian Peninsula thousands of km away after Islam was created around 700AD. They were invaders and colonisers who displaced the indigenous people of Levante (among them the Jews and the original Christians, the Assyrian People). The Arabs didn't call themselves Palestinian until the 1960s after Arafat founded the PLO. So calling Palestine occupied is ignorant.
This is an amazing piece of work. Stunning cinematography and production. Artful and profoundly revealing interviews, brilliant editing. One of the best documentaries ever.
"The last paradox is that the tale of Palestine from the beginning until today is a simple story of colonialism and dispossession, yet the world treats it as a multifaceted and complex story-hard to understand and even harder to solve." - Noam Chomsky, On Palestine Amazing Documentary! Very eye-opening.
As an American, I finally took the time to find out the question of why, why are the Palestinians so upset. We don’t ever see the other side. I’m finally starting to get the answers starting with this documentary.
Thank you
??? This is a biased documentary. You might be getting answer, but you're not getting the whole answer.
All this mess starts with the Arab-Islamic invasion of Palestine, where they stole Palestine form teh Jews and Christians. Knowing this, one can understand why the Jews were driven out of thier homeland of Palestine and left stateless, and why the Jews had to suffer so much discrimination and genocides that they decided to return to Israel-Palestine and settle/liberate Palestine from the Islamic invaders once and for all.
If documentaries don't tell you about the arab-Islamic colonization and oppression of Palestine that started all this, you know it's going to be a propaganda or biased video against the Jewish right of return.
@bgiangrosso1229
What answers did you arrive at?
Judaism
Exodus 32:13
Psalm 105:8-11
Genesis 13:14-16
Joshua 1:1-6
Nehemiah 2:18-20
Christianity
Romans 9:4
Islam
Surah 5:19-22
🙄@@johnmann8659
@@johnmann8659
Matthew 23:39
Tested and reinforced with three crushing defeats and expulsion from the land. They’re still in rebellion against God.
good for you! i visited israel in college and that trip made me realize just how hateful and wrong israel is, i had no clue! it takes years to unravel and rid yourself of all the lies israel and the us gov/news feeds us - the real history is there and it does not lie. keep learning more! sadly there is so much to learn about israel's terror....
By civilized standards people who "settle" other's lands, homes possessions and properties are called thieves.
Yes! And this is are israelíes land, not Arabs Palestinian.
@@pichepc7796😂
@@pichepc7796 You're sick ...lying jews
Agree
@@pichepc7796 khazarians have no rights to Palestine lol. Your jealousy and envy of the Arabs, and of all other groups, not of your own, is so old and tired - you should be exhausted by now.
This is an important piece of work, I am a Jewish South African and a supporter of Palestine. Tonight, I watched this for the second time, and with my father. Our relationship had almost completely broken down from a month of continuous and loud arguments. I can see he has forever been changed by watching this. Thank you
@nicksearra
Is supporting “Palestine” a kosher idea?
Nehemiah 2:18-20
Genesis 21:8-13
Doesn’t the land of Israel belong to the Jews?
Exodus 32:13
Romans 9:4
Psalm 105:8-11
Genesis 13:14-16
Joshua 1:1-6
I'm also an Athiest, so I'm sure you can imagine how ridiculous I think it is that someone's God would favor one people group over another, condone an apartheid system and encourage the behavior seen in this documentary.
If I was a believer, I would understand that radical interpretations of a book written by men a few thousand years ago from story's told way before could be wrong
@@Nicksearra An atheist? You said you were Jewish. Where does that word come from?
Ezra 6:7-14
Nehemiah 4:1-2
Esther 4:1-16
Matthew 27:37
Acts 21:39
Apartheid? Do you not keep the murderers, rapists, and kidnappers in your own country behind locked walls in the prisons? Wouldn’t it be hypocritical to criticize Israel for doing the same?
@@johnmann8659 you know the Bible/Thora/Mose very well, it seems ??? Can you, honest question, tell me if Christans are also children of Abraham and part of the people of God? ... coz we read the same book, pray very similar prayers, sing the same songs in church... Shall we go to the Holy Land as well? All Christians? Coz it's our promised land also?
@AnnettSchwarz-sheepos_negros Well said. Muslims are also children of Abraham. We believe in all the prophets of the Old Testament(Torah), new and testament (bible) and the final testament (Quran). So if he is saying the children of Abraham have a claim to the land then Jews, Christians and Muslims have a claim.
I feel so sorry for the Christian and Muslims communities in the holy land, they are persecuted on a daily basis. So sad to see nuns being spat on and worshippers prevented from praying at the Al Aqsa mosque. It's beyond deplorable. God didn't ask us to fight. I wish for a world where we can all co exist in peace. Inshallah (Godwilling).
best unbiased fact based documentary i watched in last 2 decades... kudos Shimon Dotan
This movie focuses a lot on fanaticsm - which is the minority in Israel. Everyone should already know this but judging from the comments here, they know nothing about Israel. As a documentary maker Doran has a responsibility to be unbiased and he shouldn’t assume that everybody knows the fringe the fanaticms and that his movie won’t fuels hatred even further. So he failed.
Any belief system that does not believe all men are created equal should be rejected by humanity
but are all men equal?
Humanity is the problem. It lacks any ability to live as one ..if only
@@Jcoke2201God says so
which one?@@m.c.5459
when that was written in the constitution that was written by slave owning white men and it did not consider women who weren't even allowed to vote until the 19th amendment in 1920 as a muslim myself I disagree with the U.S. constitution because Islam guaranteed equal rights for women and minorities and even non muslims just look at Spain before the conquistadors took over the only tax they had to pay was 2.5% the jizya tax and they didn't even have to serve in the military so I would take Islamic law before man made laws because clearly man made laws don't work.
“Nothing in the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity.” Martin Luther King Jr
and ideology
Emboldened by the belief that God is on one's side.
@@norrsken1828 AND MYTH! Moses never historically lived. The Chosen Ones" is the greatest psychological tool! Kudos to the Jews!
M.L.K. was also a communist. Look up the secret documents that reveal his true motives. Everyone they tell you is a saint, the opposite is usually true.
@@charleslozada5829When the transgressors and the worst people in deeds in God's eyes label themselves as "The chosen ones." The audacity claiming that God pertains to them transgressors as "the chosen ones." Don't know if i'm gonna be pissed or roll over the floor laughing. 🤬🤣🤣🤣
Wow! A settler said: "The Palestinians are creating the Israeli expansion by their resistance".
If they do not resist the occupation, then all is well.
That is what the South African white European settlers were saying to the black Afrikans.
It's like police here in the US punching you in the face and saying "Stop Resisting!"
@@andresgilrod1
This settler situation is completely out of hand at this point.
Resolving this issue is going to be extremely costly.
@@MagdiNonDuality Still necessary to resolve it, no matter how expensive.
And here we are just days away from South Africa taking Israel to court over genocide. What a twist of events.
not to comment on your point of view, just to say that some white european settlers in SA are who became the afrikaners.
to express your point of view accurately you therefore need to say: ‘That is what the south african white european settlers were saying to the black africans’, not black afrikaners.
you’ve mixed two groups of people into one.
which, by the way, is likely what will inevitably naturally happen, and we will be like about 88% of mexicans, for example: beautiful mestizo],
all believing and being whatever they, our descendents, want to believe and be, so long as they allow everyone else the same right …
It's like offering a homeless man (Israel) to stay at your house for the night, but the man takes over your house by force and doesn't understand why you're ungrateful when he offers you to live permanently in "his" basement with no water, food or electricity while locking the door, preventing you from getting out.
It's like homeless man returning home (Israel) that has been taken over by colonizers. The homeless man purchases land to themselves and when his exiled family is killed and oppressed all over the world, they plan to established their home to be here, where he returned to live in peace. The people who had built houses in your tribes lands decide they do not want to live by the homelss man as equal to them. Homeless man (Jews) have always been seen as lessers and undeserving of equal human rights to Arabs and Muslims, so they decide to murder every single homeless man they can find instead of peacefully living together.
If you missed Jordan occupying and cleansing Jewish pepople from Judea and Samaria (what Jordan called it's West bank) you missed quite a lot of information about the whole thing. The Arabs (Palestinians) being settlers in the Jewish land. Jews who had returned to their land, trying to establis a home being pushed away and Arabs "settling in the conveniently empty houses, takign their possessions. You know, what Arabs have been to the Jews in every single Arab colonized/cleansed land.
But we didn't offer. The britains who didn't own anything, just colonize and rob, offered. Truman did finalize the deal with a land that he didn't own. It's like offering a home to someone you did steal...
the amount of archive footage, the panoramic landscape shots, the range of views expressed, the subtle reveals.. a masterpiece of a film and mammoth of a documentary
Yes I agree.
Heartbreaking that some actually believe the settlements are okay. That the brutality, cruelty & evil perpetrated is justified somehow. It is sick. Genuinely sick.
I do not think the settlements are OK, but this is a very biased documentary
@@marinacalo9044 can you explain a bit more
and cruel and evil and ...
This is a documentary about a few lunatics that are randomly doing their own thing. Also, the documentary leaves out all the displacement of the native Jews from Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Egyp, and Yemen, who lived there for millennia and centuries and were kicked out by Islamic extremists, a lot of them came to settle in their homeland, is a very complex history and this documentary leaves all out by playing demon. The director is obviously leftist and took a couple of Wacos and did a documentary on it. But Israeli are not like that , @@MuniS90
Sick society, corrupted by zionism
"Most Israelis do not believe that God exists, but most Israelis believe that the land of Palestine was God's gift as a promised land" - Ben Gurion
Yes, they are about as two-faced as the ignorant Evangelicals here in the USA, say one thing do the opposite.
I believe that Israel should not exist. They created a country on stollen lands
Isn't that an Ilan Pappe quote?
No such thing as the land of Palestine. Never has been.
@BenState I think you mean Israel, look on any older globe or map, Israel is not on the map Palestine has always been there.
I used to defend Israel, I am so ashamed of myself after watching this, I never read a book about the conflict and since I'm from Argentina the press used to push towards to Israel and his right to "self-defense", but in the last weeks and what the IFD has done in raffa make me feel sick so I start to listen to the "other side". Thank god for the internet. I can only say sorry to Palestinians for not putting me in their shoes.
This is a good lesson for you to be honest with yourself and gain knowledge before supporting something you know nothing about. You supported evil unknowingly and so have many like you because they didn't do the work to read an learn.
All we need is only sanity, logic, history and ofcourse a lot of great documentaries like these to see CLEARLY the truth...sadly many are still in blind and deaf about this 😢
🇵🇸
hazlo viral amigo, la gente debe saber quien es su enemigo, esto es alarmante gente que dice que dios les dio, le otorgo imaginate que al rato digan, dios nos otorga cada mujer arabe y las tomaremos, esto esta para locos y en cualquier momento su mesianismo les puede llevar a cometer peores crimenes y no solo contra palestinos, si no contra toda la humanidad, despues de todos ellos se creen herederos de la tierra misma y todo lo que hay en ella porque son los "escogidos de dios"...
Be ashamed.
I am both speechless and horrified by what I've just watched! May God help the Palestinian. They've been through so much. May he grant them strength and patience. I pray for their freedom and for their mental wellbeing before anything else, because I can't even begin to fathom, how one can deal with such lunatics!
Very sad ,, They are victims of a Jenno Cydal de a th cult . Absolutely horrifying
I think that is exactly the problem. There is no god to 'help' either one but the human belief that there is a god and it gives their tribe a special right to kill, and steal at all costs that is the problem. God can't help the palestinians just like he can't help the Israelis but humanity and the rest of the world can, starting with America.
These people are in a cult. Seriously. They all seem deeply, foundationally unethical.
@@silversurfer249 it’s called Islam even when they just kill each other
Im glad you're a nationalist. Free Europe.
"When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in a society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it."
- Frédéric Bastiat
Most were born in nice countries without problems - why do they need Israel and only Jewish = when they - can live anywhere.
it makes them, feel like,special people, however this attitude goes against any agreement that they may have, had with god!
I will remember it.
Yeah , Muslims invaders did it in India.
@@NadiaStepanek-p8w Everytime you repeat the lie that the Jews stole someone else's land, you prove why the Jews need a land of their own.
By the way, they also grant settlement entitlement to those who just convert to Judaism. If I choose do this I could be living in a settlement in Israel in the Occupied territories inside a month. Yet people who are from here and whose great grandparents, grandparents and parents owned land cannot be here if they are Palestinian, Palestinians born here and displaced cannot come back. It is diabolical.
Indeed
Exactly. Only recently did i learn that about 60,000 Americans have moved to and settled in the occupied territories. Ancestral lands my ass.
Makes my blood boil!!! I cannot help but put myself in their place. How would I react? My children my grandchilden, my neighbours, family...Vile
Because the very premise of their entitlement is a big scam from the beginning
there's no way someone could convert to Judaism within a month.
They came to my land
They stole my home
They killed my family
When i fight back
They call me terrorist
It was their land, land of their ancestors.. they came back to settle.
@@TupacMakaveli1996 so give the USA to american indians, and all of white americans should come back to europe
It was not only your land.
@@TupacMakaveli1996part of the cult arent ya
@@TupacMakaveli1996it was never settlers land will never be their land , a theive never becomes an owner
Settlers are the worst neighbors you can imagine.
They are fanatics.
Unsettlers.
Cause two days later they will be your house new owners
No, Hamas are
@@anabarjonadefreitas6071 why do u insist on dealing with us as stupid n blind?! Oppression produces oppression, n if hams is bad then the reason for their creation was much worse, that's the kinda reality we need to recognize in order to find real solutions !
It makes me contemplate what would be my reaction if these people decided they want to take my house, property, and rights.
😡 ✅
You become H*mas.
Do you even understand the topic? No. You simply don't have a grasp of the subject matter. Present day "Palestinians" are in fact Arabs from Jordan and Egypt. The original inhabitants were Philistines (tribes from Crete who migrated to Levante after the Bronze Age collapse around 2,500 BC) were gone by the time of Jesus. The name Palestine was used by emperor Hadrian 100 years after Jesus as a slur against the Jews. The land was back then called Judaea, Samaria and Galilee. The Arabs came to Levante 600 year later from the Arabian Peninsula thousands of km away after Islam was created around 700AD. They were invaders and colonisers who displaced the indigenous people of Levante (among them the Jews and the original Christians, the Assyrian People). The Arabs didn't call themselves Palestinian until the 1960s after Arafat founded the PLO. So, calling Palestine occupied is ignorant.
You want me to move forward to the more recent past? Go back to 1909 when the land was SOLD to the Jews by the wealthy Arabs. They were sold the worst land at the highest prices. Swamp land basically. They then had to defend it with their lives until the British Mandate was enacted prior to WW1. After WW2 and the holocaust they were given somewhere to live, in 1948. The very next day, 15 May 1948, war was declared on them by multiple Arab states in the name of Islamic ideology, and they have since multiple more wars and destroyed everyone on the battlefield. This mind you after the land was historically stolen by the Arabs as I've mentioned. Please update your grade school understanding. This DID NOT start in 1948. As I said, Palestine wasn't even a term used in recent times until the 1960's.
To gRape women & behead babies?
You should do absolutely nothing. Their ancestor live there, 3000 years ago and they were gods chosen people and they were promised your house.
This doc should be submitted to the ICJ to support the extent of illegal activity that has been occurring for so long.
Yes. Submit a false document
Do you not understand what occupied territories mean?
the world has always known it but pretended not to see
@@ddeitchIsrael will take care of that and apparently it is able to convince its own people too
Yes agreed!! Go South Africa 🇿🇦
Even in the comment section of a documentary showcasing the cold, hard, irrefutable truth, there are hasbaraists saying, "No, actually, it's the Arabs fault." *heavy sigh*
I feel like I've just watched a documentary about a cult.
You did
yes, you just did.
100% accurate
Yes a cult called Zionism.
It is ! …
“The last paradox is that the tale of Palestine from the beginning until today is a simple story of colonialism and dispossession, yet the world treats it as a multifaceted and complex story-hard to understand and even harder to solve.” ― Noam Chomsky.
Lot of things make sense in Chomskyland. He‘s right about the West Bank settlements but wrong about loads of other things.
@@domsnow6418 I recall Chomsky fateful triangle never referred to that west bank place as Judea and Samaria
It is simple. The Jews have returned to reclaim their ancestral homeland from the Arab colonists.
@@broz1488 That’s right. They’d only one reason why Arabic, other than that of commerce and tourism, is spoken there, as if it is an indigenous language from there.
@@broz1488'ancestral homeland'? What does that even mean?
Very informative and detailed about the settlers' colonial project and I very much admire the mountain-size patience and resilience of the Palestinian people! Thanks.
Arab settler-colonial project deserves a movie too
I can say the same thing for the other side. Both sides do not accept each other under the delusion of imaginary sky-dad.
👏👏
Muslims supposed to have respect for our beliefs like we respect theirs.Its that simple.
This was done by lefties propaganda
This is so revolting... That's why I admire the Palestinian people more for their courage and resilience.
The brutality and arrogance of the settlers is hard to watch...how is this ever allowed...
I could say the same of the arabs...they are two faces of the same medals
@@SneakyKestrel shame on you
These are the ones who came from Europe to Palestine, not the other way around
The Zionists control all these UN states.
@@SneakyKestrel. But no, actually you couldn't say that. You couldn't say that at all. Claiming a land from a 3000 year old fictional story, and doing so by force and murder. No. It's madness. It's indefensable.
@@iamjanedoe4real you know,for them it's not a fictional story, the Thora is terribly serious, is the fulfillment of a prophecy. They live the fulfillment of a dream.To understand the settlers you should understand the Thora.
United States has a hand in these settlements as well. CUFI is just one of many entities that supports in the form of large donations of money, supplies, and even armaments.
SALaM, SHLAMa, SHLOMo, SHALoM, NAMASTe, PEACe.
The Zionists Do Not Believe In God, But They Believe God, Gave Them, The Land Of Israel.
Torah [Old Testament]:
Thou Shall Not Steal.
Thou Shall Not Kill.
Rabbi David Feldman.
Both the Kushner family and that of Trump's ambassador to Israel have a great deal of money invested in building more illegal settlements.
For those in the nosebleed section can you explain who CUFI is and how they play a part in this? I think more people should know
A hand? A whole entire body... and more!
@@Tabc1979 Christians United For Israel. The evangelical supporters of Israel do so with the religious interest of fulfilling prophecy (Second coming of Christ / Armageddon) & in general the public sphere aligns politically with with the Israeli lobby (bipartisan), other American Zionists, & the arms industry...
Surely, I've seen this docu back in 2016/2017 on the Dutch TV and seeing it again. Without doubt in my top 3 BEST documentaries ever seen, and I am a true watcher over many chanels! Thank you so much for sharing this art-piece of footage collected over the last decades! Especially now, how important it is to share different point of views.
I didn't see it on Dutch TV in those years, but I'm glad a Dutch friend recommended watching this docu on RUclips.
Didn’t see it either on the Dutch tv tbh. It’s a miracle this was even aired out on Dutch television. I found this on my own.
The documentary, testimonial and historical value presented in this video is priceless. I only hope that one day justice will be done with the Palestinian people and with the ethnic cleansing to which they have been subjected since 1948, 75 years ago...
While Israel commits genocide against Palestine, it has the tireless support of the USA, vetoing all resolutions in the UN security council, being the maximum facilitator so that this injustice can be carried out.
Thank you for this great work, very brave ❤👏👏👏
Babe.... occupier Arabs going from 100 000 to MILLIONS is hardly genocide. I think you are sounding like you are listening to Islamist propaganda.
Fantastic documentary. It really is eye-opening. I often wondered how the settlements were allowed. This doc. Needsvto be shared world wide.
Because the Palestinians did not want their own land. They just tried to stop Israel from being born, Jews from gaining equal human rights and having their own state, where they would not be under Muslim rule.
Because Jordan controlled the entire area (Judea and Samaria, or Jordan's west bank) and then gave it up.
Their reaction while asked if they consider themselves settlers….speaks volumes!!!
Will this kind of people ever have the humility to confess that they are profiteers exploiting the weakness of human beings to get free land ?
@@philipkozely3768seeing their nerve to lie so blatantly … I guess,not …plus I am afraid about that stuff “from Nile to Euphrates” might become reality one day,seeing how things are going. They’ve been able to cancel from the map a whole country (Palestine) so I guess their horrendous dream can come true… one day !😢
@@SBF2025 the beast knows no limits
@@SBF2025 Lets hope not. but for as long as the US sends them money then who knows. Maybe Hezbollah will have something to say about this. they have more weapons than Hamas. So who knows what tomorrow till bring. it is the 10-01-2024 today. Will be fun to look back on this and see how things change from this date on.
@@vickib4063 I hope to look back and realize I was wrong ! Palestinians deserve to live a normal life on their land ! ❤
I was looking for a long time detailed documentary about Israeli settlements. Best documentary about settlements so far.
Thieves
Interested to watch it now. It just showed up in my feed, but watching now.
@@ManiSilva-qw6vo You were robber who tried to loot Jews in 1948 and lost your own land and now crying
@@educationinnovation2454 Jews lie and lie and lie and lie...
You should also take a look at 'brides of Allah's and see how Palestinian woman are taught hate and destruction.. there are two sides to every story
We need more documentaries like this!
This conflict can never be solved when dealing with such a deluded bunch of demonic fanatics
well said
As long as society is divided into Palestine v Israel, Jews v Muslims. The issue will never be solved. If Palestine is in power Jews die, if Israel is in power Palestinians die. No solution.
You're right, it's so sad... these Zionists are hateful people.
Settlers or palestinian?
@@hjhsdujh settlers
Watching in Feb 2024. This is an important documentary.
Videos like this are important to understand the conflict. While Hamas is an evil organization, people should realize Israeli government is not innocent either. If you want to go deeper into the history of this conflict, you will see that Hamas in its early days was actually funded by Israeli government. Israeli leaders back then were against the idea of a democratic Palestinian government because they needed evil Palestinians narrative. So when Hamas was founded, Israeli government thought it was a good idea to arm Hamas to topple the democratic Palestinian government. Ex Israeli PM confessed to this as well, you could find it on RUclips if you search for it.
Also, current Israeli PM Netanyahu was the one who kept pushing USA to invade Iraq, the intel report about "weapons of mass destruction" in Iraq came from Mossad. Not sure if you seen Netanyahu's recent visit to US senate but he is trying very hard to get USA to attack Iran now. Saying Iranians are behind the USA college protests against Israel and how Iran is preparing to attack USA. More wars, more suffering, more immigration, more hate towards immigrants, bigger internal conflicts in western countries because of the immigrants. This is all win-win scenario for Israeli government. Note: I'm only talking negative about Israeli government, not its people. Which is why I mentioned the government every single time.
Its bizarre - my nieces are South African Jews, red haired, blue eyed of German/Danish descent - their families settled in Israel even though their family trees back two hundred years place them from central Europe...but an Arab Palestinian, who probably does have the blood of Ancient Israel in her or his veins, is dispossessed and expelled as a "foreigner"...oh....and many settlers abused my nieces when they did their military service on the West Bank when they found out they were "reformed faith" Jews, not Orthodox, and said they were not "real" jews....go figure.....
Your point is the most significant fact bearing on the question of Zionism. Ashkenazi Jews are genetically substantially Eastern European. Therefore, the Zionist occupation of Palestine that began in the late 19th Century is the last example in history of European colonization of the territory of militarily weaker peoples. It even mirrors the Spanish conquistadors' rationalization that they were bringing the Chistian God and salvation to heathens. Invoking God to do evil is disgusting.
As you can see they want all the land to the nile..we know their story since we weee kids..let me tell you something the settlers are growing in numbers they have 8 kids and so on vs the normal israelis …so they will be the majority in israel and this will only lead to more wars, every arab knows this..
What is an orthodox jew? Someone who comes out of any of the twelve tribes?
It never was about blood ...If it were the case... Arabs terrorist are the experts on bloody matters
@@chriss2452 And What? They left the lands ,either sold everything or abandoned it for better pastures and have no claim to Palestine ,Palestinian have lived on the land ,owned the land and built on the land ,so don’t tell anyone that after 3000 years of absence the have any rights to the land .NONSENSE in every way possible.
I can't believe these people have nukes, crazy af.
and how many wars have Israel started, exactly? And how many wars of annihilation of dirty-Jews have these Palestinians started? The latter a lot. The former none. Scary, I know.
Can't settle land already owned by somebody else. This is called thef, thieves not settlers.
the God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob does not approve of what Israel is doing
Do you even understand the topic? No. You simply don't have a grasp of the subject matter. Present day "Palestinians" are in fact Arabs from Jordan and Egypt. The original inhabitants were Philistines (tribes from Crete who migrated to Levante after the Bronze Age collapse around 2,500 BC) were gone by the time of Jesus. The name Palestine was used by emperor Hadrian 100 years after Jesus as a slur against the Jews. The land was back then called Judaea, Samaria and Galilee. The Arabs came to Levante 600 year later from the Arabian Peninsula thousands of km away after Islam was created around 700AD. They were invaders and colonisers who displaced the indigenous people of Levante (among them the Jews and the original Christians, the Assyrian People). The Arabs didn't call themselves Palestinian until the 1960s after Arafat founded the PLO. So, calling Palestine occupied is ignorant.
You want me to move forward to the more recent past? Go back to 1909 when the land was SOLD to the Jews by the wealthy Arabs. They were sold the worst land at the highest prices. Swamp land basically. They then had to defend it with their lives until the British Mandate was enacted prior to WW1. After WW2 and the holocaust they were given somewhere to live, in 1948. The very next day, 15 May 1948, war was declared on them by multiple Arab states in the name of Islamic ideology, and they have since multiple more wars and destroyed everyone on the battlefield. This mind you after the land was historically stolen by the Arabs as I've mentioned. Please update your grade school understanding. This DID NOT start in 1948. As I said, Palestine wasn't even a term used in recent times until the 1960's.
It is stealing land, also they have ties to it. They were kicked out from the land. Is the west coast of the US the west coast or Comancharia? It’s both
@@Tripple_Threatt92yeah they were kicked out by God, also labeled Satan's sons
Arabs muslim occupy and settle the land of jewish during muslim occupation 600AD..are they thieves?
1:34:49 its seriously disgusting how a father like him is teaching his kids to beat Arabs shame on him for brainwashing his kids to hate others just because they are of a different race.
race? maybe "his father" had his family or friends beheaded or killed by palestinians. just maybe, as jews are all for eye for an eye.
And here I was, thinking, to be a Jew was to practice Judiaism, not that they are a race. Silly me 🤷🏼♀️
Bless your heart and mind my friend bc we see the truth. God is love.
unfortunately he is not the only, it is the Israeli ideology and what their state is built on
This has nothing to do with race, but with territorial conflicts & religious extremism. That's why he said it. Stop superimposing these American ideas where they don't belong..
It is also worth noting that at least he didn't say "k*ll the Ar*bs", like the other side teaches their kids about Js...
Thank you for this documentary! You showed us the mentality and real truths about occupied Palestine. Thank you for getting this information out for everyone to see who is causing the issues.
Please spread it to other people too,for awareness
Nothin'yahoo Is a BAD man, Buydem is no better, Before the Jews ask for aid, he asks, "D'ya need more money, bunk buster bombs? anything?
This documentary omits many facts and only shows one narrative. It doesn’t tell you about the 1929 massacre of Jews that were living in Hebron over 800 years. Don’t be so damn gullible
They have same mentality of a killers based on fanatics believes like others before killed millions of them . But they forgot...now they are the killers of this poor Palestinians
Who is Palestine occupied other than the Arabs? Palestine was reed when the PAlestinians freed the land from Anglo-Arab occupation and named the land Israel. Muslims got 80% of British controlled land (before that it was Ottoman land) as their part of the Palestine. Jews were supposed to get the 20% on the west side of the river, what happended? Did they Arabs tried to kill all the Jews and occupy Judea and Samaria? How long was the land under Muslim rule... was it occupied then? Did they free the "Palestine" they occupied after 1948?
They changed the meaning of the “settler” to justify their wrong doings when in fact it is simply called as “thieves “
Robbers
Ah well as an African we can recognize colonizers and settlers
As someone who didnt grow up with religion I find it so bizzare. Creeps me out.
May God bless these settlements and may God stand on our side 🤝,I pray i will be among the zionist army that will confront the enemies of God
@@Pintocaleb256 who do you consider enemies of god?
@@Pintocaleb256 you are very unwell and at the same time dangerous. Shame on you.
Surah al-Isra - 4. Verse﴾4﴿ We informed the Children of Israel in the book as follows: “You will surely create mischief on the earth twice and be very boastful. While the book in this verse is generally explained as the Torah, there are also those who understand it as the reserved tablet. According to this understanding, the verse means the following: It is written in the protected tablet that you will cause corruption twice, that is, it is available in our knowledge, we knew that you would do this. As a matter of fact, you did both. It was mentioned above that sending the book to the prophet Moses and making him a guide to the Children of Israel was a divine blessing. The prophet Moses saved the Israelites, who had been subjected to humiliating treatment for hundreds of years in Egypt, from the hegemony of the Pharaoh, liberated them, took them to their homeland, and conveyed the Torah to them. However, as stated in both the Quran and the Bible, they often broke their covenant with Allah and committed sins, and therefore were subjected to divine punishment (for detailed information on this subject and explanations in the Bible, see .Baqara 2/74, 100-101). What is meant by "corruption" in the verse is that the Israelites generally violated the provisions set by Allah in the Torah. In the commentaries, one of the two mischiefs is killing the prophet Isaiah or imprisoning Ermiya (Jeremiah); The second is explained as their killing of Yahya and their attempt to kill the Prophet Jesus by collaborating with the Roman rulers (Şevkânî, III, 327).
as a muslim men ı dont hate anyone inc jews
Great documentary. Quite eye-opening to see how the troubles started and have been escalating ever since. I needed to see this. Great mapping in the beginning, the best I've seen.
The behavior of these settlers in hebron during their 'celebration' is totally disgusting and unacceptable
There even worse now...
And if you think that Hebron has a continuation from the second Temple till 1929 with Jews that have been murdered by the Arabs… maybe you could see the other side of the coin.
Do you have any idea that Hebron was the first capital of Judea and then David the king decided to make Jerusalem the eternal capital? Do you know that from the period of the second Temple till 1929 the Jewish community was living in Hebron? And because you asked, do you know who massacred this Jewish community? The arabs. So maybe, just maybe is not so disgusting to come back to your home and celebrate?
@@battzion7918 I want to Ask you one thing do u think Jewish homeland is viable 15yrs to come
Do u think a Jewish home land is viable even today.
Do u think the ruling of the scholars of Islam has changed a little bit since the first settlement.
Take heed from history before its late
They dont know any better my Jewish friend. Most likely have not heard of the history or even read the bible. I think what he was getting at was like the silly masks of the palastines and just the gloating of it all. But they will do what they want. No need to start a war over a silly mask. I thought it was funny myself lol but its not funny. Anyways God bless you. PS you should play warhammer 40k :)@@battzion7918
This reminds me of apartheid in South Africa
I'm 47 and as a child, they made it look like Gaza destroyed the settlements. Isreal dismantled the settlements because they didn't want to leave anything
Gaza did destroy part of them
@@dyawrno they did not. I watch a documentary only on that here on RUclips and they said there that Arabs cannot take over their homes so they send in their famous big bulldozers
Correct, the Jews destroyed or dismantled anything of value as they left
Ariel Sharon destroyed the settlements. They quickly were rebuilt so I don't even understand why he did that. Entire Palestinian communities have been displaced by these settlements. Their homes and livelihoods have been destroyed, they’ve had restrictions enforced on their movement, access to their own water, land and other natural resources. The communities have also been violently attacked by the Israeli military and settlers We must act now. We must Stand in solidarity with the palestinian people until they are able to regain their land and live in peace. I don't understand why anybody would think that is Riley's where victims of anything.
@patriciaherrera193 exactly, I don't understand how anybody would support this. We have been brainwashed for far too long. Watching this makes my blood boil. Its unjust,cruel and evil
THESE PEOPLE ARE SCARY
Fascists are scary, and dangerous.
Why?
@@hairandcia2028 because of what they say and what they do, because of their sense of entitlement and superiority. Because they are not hiding their racism and supremacist attitudes
@@hairandcia2028cos they're diabolical.
This people are sick
We have settlers living in the US as well. In fact they occupy our government
Very well said .From South Africa 👍
in 2023, it is illegal to steal land by force. it is in violation of international law. what happened in USA history is irrelevant because it predates the laws we now have. your attempt to justify genocide, landtheft, and the expulsion of people from their land does not hold up to today's standards.
Free the United States from AIPAC
And child sx trafficking in uk
well said
Best documentary on settlers so far!
Diabolical that this is occurring with the absolute and unconditional support of our governments
Ваши правительства тоже состоят от этих безбожников сатанистов.
It’s like in America where we gave back lands to the Indians. This land was stolen from the Jews first.
Judea and Samaria have been part of Israel for 3800 years.
@@ronaldsmith6161. First of all, those settlers right there are Europeans, so no. You're objectively wrong. Second, nobody is allowed to repossess land from 3000 years ago maps. Nobody. You live in fantasy land.
@@ronaldsmith6161the white settlers occupiers in Palestine have no connection to the land,the Palestinians have lineage to the ancient Israelites😂
It’s strange to think about. The Jewish people went through so much hardship, you want to root for them and give them a safe place to live and prosper… than you look deeper and see they are perpetrating just another form of extreme racism and oppression directed toward another type of people, a people that we would ignore for decades until now….. at a time where the people of Palestine have had enough.
Watch ‘son of Hamas’…please
dig deeper and you'll be horrified what zionist prepare for all of us
Its their culture, everywhere they've ever been they've been pushed away.
Revalation 3:9
@@johnhume4346 I’m not a huge fan of people who turn on their own kind to make them look like savages. I think the rest of the world does that enough.
@@nicolecastrogiovanni385 They cannot all be wrong about these people?
The world is now opening its eyes on this country. So happy to see alot of young people are witnissing this. hopefully big changes are coming and we will end the atrocities commited by the zionist on the native people of Palestine
This film MUST WATCH BY all people on EARTH because dont know nothing about this horror life for palestinian people on theyr country : slaves 😢😢😢😡😡😡
Sadly it never will be figured out and the conflict will never permanently end.
How do you un-brainwash a whole people who think they’re superior to everybody else?!?!?!
At NO point did it talk about the Palestinians being native to the land! Not once!
wrong chief we Yehudis have been their for 3700 yrs... Read the bible and yes even the koran... no mention of the brits word palastine phillstine...
this channel called "best documentary" for a reason 👌
This is what will happen when you misintepret the teachings of ur religion and consider violence and stealing other people land as lawful.
Arabs are the master of this. Difference being, they are following their corrupt book to the letter.
No one has land, it belongs to God !
@@ezechiele.6001 ok tell me where u live and I will ask someone close by to come and occupy it since it sits on land that belongs to God.
Aran settlers on Jewish land - they can not last there.
@@ezechiele.6001there's a time and place when secularity is required for proper dialogue to take place. Interfaith discussions are one such example...
Watching this makes my blood boil. How dangerous the settlers are, they are not even come from Palestine and born there, they are from mount Sinai and Eastern Europe and yet the world supports these kind of people and legitimate them as an Israel country. Western countries need to be sue on this. It started from British to be sue.
There are other Israelites.
And France
The Israelites are the owners of the land, Bethlehem was where Christ was born, Rachel' is buried there, jacab and Sarah all buried there, why do you say jews are thieves
and Palestinians don't come from Palestine. They are the descendants of ARABS CONQUERERS who stole the land from the Jews. They arrived to Israel after Jews stared returning in the 1800s and cultivate and develope the land. They come the surrounding Muslims countries, from Egypt, from Syria, from Jordania and oroginally they come from the Arabian peninsula, where they started sprearing the Muslim religion by sword.
The whole thing is heartbreaking.
Blame that on Hamas
And horrible…
@@SgtHawk13 I don't mean to excuse the Hamas and palestinians for supporting what they've done. I can see that palestinians also have legit grievances and that among jews there are bad actors too,like the guy who teaches his kids to beat up arabs. But at least his culture is not celebrating him and naming a school after him,for example but instead he goes to jail. I can imagine, there are others like him and they should face consequences. I feel sorry for all involved, who just want to live in peace- who are definitely not Hamas and it's followers. For me the whole thing is heartbreaking,because they live in that amazing place,surrounded with all the amazing culture and they can't deal with each other and it looks quite hopeless.
@@agnesberes4084 yes it is sad to see a state full of children controlled by j.i.h.a.di.st.s
@@agnesberes4084palestinains have been suffering when even there was no Hamas so please stop this Hamas bs
11:20 Viewers should note: this doc is from 2016. There are more more than 500,000 settlers in the West Bank (+ about 200,000 in East Jerusalem) as of early 2024.
The rate of increase since about 1980 has been basically a straight line (+11,000-ish/year).
This is an amazing piece of work. What an insight. I've learnt so much yet as I watched I get sadder by the minute because how can peace between the two peoples be achieved when a people believe so deeply in the prophesies of a book of fiction? Thank you Shimon Dotan for making this. If I feel this way, I cannot imagine how you must feel while making this.
I don’t think it’s a book of fiction. But I believe Israelite never understood the prophecies. In fact they killed the prophets who warned them and denounced their violence and despised for the poor. Back in Deuteronomy Moses prophetically traced the who history of Israel with scary precision including the diaspora. Especially they don’t understand that z gods promises were conditional to their faith and obedience. It’s obvious that their stand in persecuting Christ and the whole Christian’s fledgling church says a lot about them. Yet there are sincere sounds there
As an Israeli myself I am not crazy about the whole idea of settlers
These people who see themselves as religious patriots of the Jewish state often times provoke many problems between two nations by not respecting their neigbors of different religion
Their main excuse is based on Old Testimony stories and believes, however we are people of 21 century and face a totally different reality where the Land is divided and expect us to respect each other
@@FOXELLA2000 sadly and much omitted is the fact that in the Old Testament God specifically instructs Israelites also to be kind to their neighbors to care for the orphan and all those who want to walk the higher life. It is true that some nations in ancient times degraded themselves so low that they became brutalized and perverted. But even within those there were people who knew Israelite life was upright and that were catptivsted by their lifestyle and wanted those higher principles for their lives. An example of this is the prostitute of Jericho. Even though Jericho came to ruins, because of their debased and degrading type of religion that they had with sacrificing children on the fire and total immortal lifestyle were destroyed. The prostitute aimed for something better and hid the spies from Israel, and when the city fell, she was spared multiple are the passages where in the Old Testament God saysto love the neighbor to be kind to them into the stranger. I don’t think people got what God was trying to do in the world.
@@wiltonpt1 you are wrong, my friend. When Jews were liberated from egiptian slavery and came back to Khanaan, God ordered to free this land from other tribes and nations because it meant to the Land of Jacob's descendents only
Nevertheless, we should stop citing Torah and faxe the reality
@@FOXELLA2000 oh I do not deny God wanted them to dispossess and the land. What I am saying is that this is often read superficially. The whole intent of God is what people reading the Torah miss often. It was a missionary project. For instance Jebusites. They fooled the people of Israel saying they were from a far country. Israel beloved it and swore to not war against them. But everything came out later. However even though they used deception Israel was true to their word. Jebusites ended up leaving their detestestable idolatry ( a lot of sexual perversion mixed in the religion of Khananites) and started praying to the true real God Elohim creator of all. Interestingly, when Midianites wanted to destroy the Jebusites Israel interposed and defended them.
But I believe like you. Those times under prophets and miraculous divine manifestations or a “theocracy” are not our situation today. And the Ben Gurion Israel is not the one from the Bible either. Reality has to be read the way it is today.
Very well made and extremely interesting. And brings up again and again how this movement has always been completely illegal and based on violence.
THEY MUST BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE AND LEAVE THOSE TERRITORIES, PERIOD.
Her response from 51:25 says everything. I was speechless watching this. She doesn't even acknowledge Palestinians as humans. God told her the land was hers and that one day she would be tending the olive trees. I mean W.T.F. did I just watch. It's like a brainwashed cult.
Because it is. The REAL QUESTION IS who are those who are PRIMARILY BENEFITING FROM THIS HENIOUS ATROCITY. That's the curtain that needs to be pulled back. THOSE ARE THE NAMES that need to be exposed. WHO ARE THEY?
Because it’s a cult
Do you know what esle says everything? Listen to Arab Palestinians who wanted to kill the Jews, even before Israel existed. You are aware how the Palestinians have treated Jews, right? And how many of them are not acknowledging Jews as humans, right? But most people are not fanning hate and racism by taking these fringe opinions as representative of people in large (though how Jews have been and are still treated in Muslims lands, where they have been ethnicly cleansed from is horrifying).
Heartbreaking when oppressed turns into oppressors. Their ancestors would turn in their graves.... I pray in our lifetime Palestine will find justice and freedom :-(
This period is only a blip in time of history the Jews have been in the land of Israel far longer than the Arabs. The Jews have had many hiccups in their history timeline this is just one of them.
@GenieHermoso. Their ancestors would turn in their graves to clap and cheer them on. Just like the Palestinians did after they massacred the Israelis.
May God bless these settlements and may God stand on our side 🤝,I pray i will be among the zionist army that will confront the enemies of God
@@Pintocaleb256 The enemies of God are the Zionists who practise and are proud of their racism and their fascism, its just a fact. I think God would not like these kind of attributes.
@@Catmac2000 I cannot believe how tolerant the Palestinian people have been? If the israelis react to this one day horror attack with the calling for genocide, can you imagine how they would behave/react after 75 years of persecution? Not my words, but the words of Gideon Levy, an Israeli Journalist and an honest, brave man.
What an eye opening! thank you Best Documentary. That s always difficult to find a channel that tells the truth away from the narratives that the mainstream media tells
Disgusting! In the past I was pro-Israel, I even helpen Likud NL. Now I regret having done so after what those "settlers" do to expand their territory.
And please don't come to teach me what to think. Or saying I am an anti-semite. But tbh...the way Israel is dealing now with Gaza makes ppl more anti-semite. And I completely understand that.
Arabs are the true semites, not these fake imposters from Europe colonizing Palestinian lands
Spot on.
I was pro Israeli all my life .and I'm not a young man.
I never really dug into this issue.
But recently I started doing my research and found out that I was supporting fanatics .Which is present day Israeli government and settlers and US sionists with deep pockets and western media who are run by them too.
It will be hard to reverse this.
Cope.We on the side with the ones who tried to make things work.
I also think that the ‘group’ that one young man leads of teens- 20 somethings is a gang of thugs, at best. No good can come of groups like this! At some point, they will cause the Israeli’s problems of their own. Looks to me like the ‘outposters’ and the evangelical Christian Zionists will be a major problem, as who is going to control the ‘hate’ and ‘elitists’ feelings of both groups? It will come to that; it has already started when the Zionist Jews spit on the Christians coming in to tour the Holy Land. And the Middle Eastern countries bordering Israel better wake up; they are already in the crosshairs of the outposts!
I recommend watching these films on RUclips to better understand the Palestinian issue:
-Creation and catastrophe
-israel-palestine,60 years of violence
-Tantura massacre
-palestine is still the issue
-Frontiers of dreams and fear
-To rachel
Don’t you find it? Interesting that the question, “Are you a settler?“ makes so many of them feel uncomfortable? They are right to feel uncomfortable. Disgusting.
YES! I saw the same reaction.
So evil,may God save the world from this kind of people, they have no love for others.
I think this (the palestine/israel conflict) is the best proof, that God (if he/she/it exists) will not save anyone. We have to free ourselves from religion and we have to fight for the freedom of everyone. We ourselves have to do it. Us and our reason and conscience.
@@mimimimimi..according to the Holy Quran "We also informed the Children of Israel in the book that: 'You will create mischief in the land and commit open tyranny twice. When the time comes for the first of them, we will send our powerful and violent servants to attack you. They will even enter the houses and search everywhere to catch you. "They will investigate. This is a promise that must be fulfilled." (Isra, 17/4-5).
@@mimimimimi..Surah al-Isra - 4. Verse﴾4﴿ We informed the Children of Israel in the book as follows: “You will surely create mischief on the earth twice and be very boastful. While the book in this verse is generally explained as the Torah, there are also those who understand it as the reserved tablet. According to this understanding, the verse means the following: It is written in the protected tablet that you will cause corruption twice, that is, it is available in our knowledge, we knew that you would do this. As a matter of fact, you did both. It was mentioned above that sending the book to the prophet Moses and making him a guide to the Children of Israel was a divine blessing. The prophet Moses saved the Israelites, who had been subjected to humiliating treatment for hundreds of years in Egypt, from the hegemony of the Pharaoh, liberated them, took them to their homeland, and conveyed the Torah to them. However, as stated in both the Quran and the Bible, they often broke their covenant with Allah and committed sins, and therefore were subjected to divine punishment (for detailed information on this subject and explanations in the Bible, see .Baqara 2/74, 100-101). What is meant by "corruption" in the verse is that the Israelites generally violated the provisions set by Allah in the Torah. In the commentaries, one of the two mischiefs is killing the prophet Isaiah or imprisoning Ermiya (Jeremiah); The second is explained as their killing of John and their attempt to kill the Prophet Jesus by collaborating with the Roman rulers (Şevkânî, III, 327).
@@AhmetTugrulGULEvery religious book contains vile crap like that. Its how you can tell they were writren by fallible lying humans.
Their day will come! God does not sleep.
An extremely wrenching Deep dive into the heart of 'Settler's-mentality'. As represented by the single-minded dedication of its founding rabbi, who led his army of early illegal settlers by a fierce determination to battle not only resistant Arabs but also his own government whose laws he was violating...
The kind of fierce determination and Will To Power whose only parallel I could think of in the example of the equally fierce Evangelisms of Christian Pastor Hagee or David koresh of the Branch-Davidians, both from Texas.
fascism supported by state
they only gain traction in a place where systemic racism is endemic tho
And thoroughly DECEIVED.
Outstanding powerful documentary. An assault on the senses in many ways. There are moments that hit hard, expressed by some of the people. They can see beyond, can see its a deeply flawed situation and their conscience is tested. That really takes some doing, surrounded by such brutality, intimidation and inhumanity.
An assault on the senses, I might borrow that some time if you don't mind :)
@@Isoroku1983 You can if you want. Oh I wish this would stop.
Wow brilliant documentary. Everyone should watch this. Changed my mind about this situation.
You reap what you sow.
Yep. The Jews suffer because of their kindness and refusal to lower them to the levels of their Arab neighbours. Instead of cleansing the land of these Arabs (just like the surrounding Muslim countries cleansed Jews off their lands, stealing their lands, houses, farms, shows, savings, poseessions etc.) - note, the tiny Israel managed to absorb the displaces Jewish refugees from the dozens of Muslims countries, somehow no one want this litle amount of these specific Mulims, and Jews let them stay, now they are millions of Muslims who want to destroy the one Jewish state.
Shouldn’t the title be ‘The thieves’?
I believe "The Lunatic Thieves" is more appropriate.
or "The violent thieves"
Lunatic thieves
Thieves and terrorists.
@@thecheshirecat999 The foaming spitting thieves.🤤
Imagine claiming that God himself granted you a piece of land some 2000 years ago!
If u show Muslims respect for their beliefs why can we have the same?
@@Hshdzsskidirespect? You arent settlers. You are squatters. A nation of almost all sociopaths.
😂 who can respect your lack of faith, your need to use violence and intensive control over education and media in order to maintain a presence in an area supposedly God given?? @@Hshdzsskidi
AND AISHA WAS ONLY SIX YEARS OLD WHEN THE FAKE PROPHET MUHAMMAD MARRIED HER???
@@Hshdzsskidi I can show them respect but that is not even in Torah,and it doesn't matter your religion you can't kick someone from their houses like that
Similar to the settlers that were given land taken from the American Indians, and now many are living on Reservations. 😢 I don't think any Country is guilt free of this type of thing.
You're right. But it wouldn't be so difficult for America to reverse course, try to rehabilitate indigenous communities, and simply stop funding israel or fund it only with conditions. that would help
@@crackthefoundation_ In about 200 years there will be no indigenous anymore they will intermarry with the surrounding population.
I think of it that the state of Israel isn't any worse than anywhere else, the disappointing thing is that as a 'new', 'modern' 'democracy', it's no better.
I don't know that every country has done this, but that still does NOT make this right.
@@TonyShephard-w4mit is worse though. Where else on earth is it legal to murder? Where else does a government hand out weapons to civilians so they can shoot whoever they like almost as a sport? It's a twisted, sadistic place, is what has become evident to the world since October.
Netanyahu is born to Mileikowsky, a squatter from Poland, Ben Gurion is Polish, Golda Meir is Ukrainian, Moshe Dayan is Ukrainian, Shimon Peres is from Belarus. They say they are Jews but are without Semitic lineage. They're descended from Khazars who converted en masse to Judaism, to avoid taking sides between the Ottoman and Byzantine empires.
These who say they are Jews but are without Semitic lineage were transplanted to Palestine starting from the early 1900's to 1948 by the Rothschilds and British empire, from places like Kiev, Bucharest, Berlin, Budapest, Warsaw, and Moscow, to displace Palestinian Jews, Christians, and Muslims who had lived in peace for centuries.
Just don’t lie about the Khazars. Both Ashkenazim and Sephardim have the same genetics, and 50% of the Israeli population comes from the countries of the Middle East: Syria, Iraq, Tunisia, etc. As are the Palestinian Arabs, by the way. Yasser Arafat was born in Egypt.😉
SHAME ON ANYONE WHO STEALS FROM PALESTINIAN'S
Robbers speak Arabic.
That would include the head of the PA, PLO and Humus, right? I mean they stole billions.
Now the Israelis, what they're doing, is taking back what billy clinton made them give up in the Oslo Accords in .
1)Before the modern state of Israel there was the British mandate, Not a Palestinian state .
2) Before the British mandate there was the ottoman empire, Not a Palestinian state .
3) Before the ottoman empire there was the Islamic mamluk sultanate of Egypt, Not a Palestinian state .
4)Before the Islamic mamluk sultanate of Egypt there was the ayyubid dynasty, Not a Palestinian state .Godfrey of bouillon conquered it in 1099.
5) Before the ayyubid dynasty there was the christian kingdom of Jerusalem, Not a Palestinian state .
6) Before the christian kingdom of Jerusalem there was the Fatimid caliphate, Not a Palestinian state .
7) Before the Fatimid caliphate there was the byzantine empire, Not a Palestinian state .
8) Before the byzantine empire there was the Roman empire, Not a Palestinian state .
9) Before the Roman empire there was the hasmonean dynasty, Not a Palestinian state .
10)Before the hasmonean dynasty there was the Seleucid empire,Not a Palestinian state .
11) Before the Seleucid empire there was the empire of Alexander the 3rd of Macedon, Not a Palestinian state .
12) Before the empire of Alexander the 3rd of Macedon there was the Persian empire, Not a Palestinian state .
13) Before the Persian empire there was the Babylonian empire, Not a Palestinian state .
14) Before the Babylonian empire there was the kingdoms of Israel and Judea, Not a Palestinian state .
15) Before the kingdoms of Israel and Judea there was the kingdom of Israel, Not a Palestinian state .
16) Before the kingdom of Israel there was the theocracy of the 12 tribes of Israel, Not a Palestinian state .
17) Before the theocracy of the 12 tribes of Israel there was the individual state of Canaan, Not a Palestinian state .
In fact in this corner of the earth there was everything but a Palestinian state!
@@BenState so israel perished in number 14...thanks for your information.
@@janisberzins8408... Arabs are semites.
I just don`t understand how people don`t see the similarity between this and ISIS, the only difference is that this type of extremism is supported by the governments of the so-called free world
The big difference is the population of extremist Jews is a very small percentage compared to extremist Islamists. There almost 2 billion Muslims and 15 million Jews in the world. If you give each population one percent as extremists you can see a HUGE disparity. I certainly feel less threatened by these settlers than Isis. How many radical Jews cause terrorist attacks in Europe and anywhere compared to Muslims? 9/11 ring a bell? Charlie Hebdo, Paris attacks, Barcelona to name a few.
suicide bombing is the difference. jews have never indulged in such dastardly deeds.
Because they have bigger guns than isis. If you have bigger guns you are "in the right" because you make the rules.
Bingo! One who is getting it. Research a bit more, and you'll find out who lSlS really is, it started as: lsrraeI's Secret lnteIIigence Service. Spell it correctly and look up the real story, they are the same people.
Spot On
That was so interesting and in formative, thank you for making it. I hope that the whole area finds peace.
My father was born in colonial guinea ecuatorial. They got kicked out and had to come back to Spain as new poor. It was traumatic for that generation, as they kept this ignorant arrogance of the landlords who think they had it because they deserve it. They were self absorbed and never really admit that they were taking advantage. Next generation we are growing up learning about decolonization and realizing why our parents suffer from colonial narcissism. It’s hard to make understand a supremacist that he is not smart. They become a parody of themselves. Fortunately the next generation we became decent people who know that otherism is fascism. I hope something similar happen there and we can decolonize the whole world. Starting on our minds
THIS SHOULD BE TITLED "THE COLONIAL SETTLERS THAT COMMIT GENOCIDE "
@ginolitvak1791 get an education.
@ginolitvak1791 you do not have any voice man, your brutalities are so evident. Palestinians welcomed you and provided you shelter when you were oppressed in Europe and now you are committing and killing innocent Palestinian children. how cruel you people are
@ginolitvak1791 are you speaking on behalf of the people there because you are a native North African or just because you want to make "a point"?
When you judge a situation with your feelings instead of using logic and knowledge
@@toxiczion4635 logic says the same.
Absolutely incredible documentary
SALaM, SHLAMa, SHLOMo, SHALoM, NAMASTe, PEACe.
The Zionists Do Not Believe In God, But They Believe God, Gave Them, The Land Of Israel.
Torah [Old Testament]:
Thou Shall Not Steal.
Thou Shall Not Kill.
Rabbi David Feldman.
Why are the settlers angry when their homes are taken away when they took other people's home to begin with?
Because they are fanatic lunatics. There's not other logical explanation for this.
Because they're the chosen one, so they can't be wrong :D
Why aren't news allowed to live there? Palestinians settle in the area which is according Oslo agreement under Israeli control. Arab/ Palestinians Israelis can live wherever they want. Why jewish Israelis don't have the same right?
@@Chroniclesof_pain you cannot kick someone from their house. I am not sure why you're trying to justify it. As covered in the documentary, they literally took arab buildings for themselves.
@@Chroniclesof_pain under israeli control? no wonder they have been kicked out of 109 countries.
‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ There is no commandment greater than these.” -Jesus
Perhaps BOTH sides should take heed of this great , most marvellous commandment. This is hard commandment to fulfill , but Jesus was right . BOTH sides should listen to him .
Jews are not Christians
It's a lesson in practical narcissism. It's a demonstration of entitlement far beyond the limits of reason or sanity.
I and Me was used a whole lot. That's a telling sign.
3 mins in and it’s as if someone has emptied an insane asylum
😂😂
They are insane, deluded people. Brainwashed beyond repair
Straight up, psych 101 simple chit
😆
The most truthful comment of all.. no sane minded human can be this way.. absolute textbook case of insanity.
Thank You, millions of people would benefit from watching, I am one of them. I didn’t realize Israel was so divided.
I bet there are 40 million arguments as to whom is divided.
It was the land of Palestine that was divided, pay attention.
@@American_patriot110 he wasn't talking about a particular nation, pay attention, he was talking about land. People in Tel Aviv can have an opinion that is divided.
@@elimaurer9491 you right absolutely, i was just shedding light on the land part only.
@@American_patriot110 Free Palestine from Hamas ❤️
I can't help it but this documentary is so eyeopening and beautiful at the same time! And the wonderful people who have the right kind of thoughts and heart according to living in peace with each other is truly amazing, like the person speaking @1:21:41 he is such a beautiful soul!
settlers lives in different dimension
Great documentary! I’ve read in many comments “Jews have a right to return to their homeland, it’s their home”. 1) Zionism is a secular movement. Its founder Theodor Herz would have been happy with Argentina too. Zionists in Hitler’s Germany were quite happy with Madagascar too. Zionism has become increasingly religious over the last decades. Because religion doesn’t need explanation and has always been a good cover-up for atrocities from the Crusades to the Spanish genocide of pre-columbian peoples, from the great inquisition to the Yugoslavian conflict. 2) according to ultra-orthodox Judaism Jews people will be given their kingdom when the Messiah comes. Apparently not a material one. “Forcing the Messiah” to come earlier by occupying Palestine is seen as an offence to God, as a blasphemy. 3) The majority of the Jews doesn’t live and does not intend to live is Israel. Demography and expansion that is outnumbering the Arabs and taking their land, this is the real credo of Zionism. Nothing to do with the romantic “our ancestral homeland”.
The UN needs to use peacekeepers to carry out the ICJ order - to protect the Palestinians and provide humanitarian and medical assistance
How tragic. For the real differences between these people are only few. But the spirit of entitlement to what another has always breeds this conflict
1:15:09: Ancient law? Who has given Israel Jews the right to apply ancient law in the West Bank? Clearly an extreme and massively discriminatory law that impacts so many people.
We also have to think of Palestinian children, they are human like anybody else and they live with us sharing this world.
No no, they are KHamas terrorists clearly 🥸
Not a war of 'independence '. An occupation facilitated by the British. Language matters.
No you are conflating settlements in occupied territory with the state of Israel. The League of Nations (precursor to UN) passed 33 votes to create Israel by division of the British Mandate of Palestine. The states of Syria, Iraq, Transjordan and Lebanon likewise created from the break up of the Ottoman Empire. By your logic, we should delegitimise all of those created Arab states too. Israel has every right to exist within its 1967 borders. Palestine rejected every offer of its own statehood since the establishment of Israel in 1948. Israel then took in 800,000 Jews banished in pogroms from surrounding Arab states, including Yemen, without requesting to increase its borders.
@@alanargent5676It is ALL occupied territory. And it is ALL an apartheid state.
@@ritamanessis146 nonsense, there are plenty of Arabs living as Israeli citizens with full rights in Israel. Jews don’t exist in Gaza
@@ritamanessis146 then as I already stated, if you refuse to apply the same standard to the likewise created Arab states- Iraq, Syria, Lebanon and Jordan and their rights to exist, that would reveal you apply a double standard. There is a name for people with this particular double standard and although we hoped this would end with the destruction of the Nazis in 1945, but unfortunately your kind are ever numerous. Israel is a state with 20% of its citizens (not to be confused with settlements outside of its sovereignty) being Arabs who enjoy equal rights under the law, high status professions and seats on the Supreme Court. Arab Israelis recently polled ranked their quality of life as high and were happy to be Israeli and disgusted by the barbarism of Hamas - there were Bedouin who bravely fought against the terrorists’ invasion. That doesn’t sound much like an apartheid state to me.
@@alanargent5676It is apartheid. There are 61Israeli laws imposed on Palestinians who live in so-called Israel. You might not like to call it apartheid, but that:s exactly what it is - not my words, but numerous human rights organizations, including B'Tselem. Israel is an occupying force and you can rationalize and justify it all you like, and call all those who oppose it as anti-semites. But, you cannot justify one Holocaust with another.
When thugs have been given power to rape a whole nation for self-determination. The delusion of geniunly believing that they could be the people of the light, while commiting all these clear crimes against humanity. is absolutely insane, how can a whole nation be THIS delisional.....
Imagine people with roots in Eastern Europe or the US coming to your land to violently push you out whike using some ancient scrolls as an asinine alternative to a title deed, absolute madness
*"That which we dislike most in others are the things we dislike most about ourselves"*
The things that trigger the strongest emotions in us -- are often reflections of our own character flaws; _exposing our deepest insecurities to the world in the form of hatred._
You don’t have to be a murderer to abhor murder ! You don’t have to be a ‘brain scientist’ (apologies to Rippley’s Game) to see that Israel is a terrorist state. You just have get your head out of social media and other hedonist pursuits.
Really high quality documentary in both picture, sound, illustration, archival footage and writing of the narrative. A deep dive into the world of the settlers, without all the politics being rammed down the throat.
This documentary gave you the sugar coated version . The settlers themselves said they don’t believe in geo-politics and if they could or had their way by expanding settlements/ outposts they would expand into lrak ! …
I thought it was very political, but a mild take of how Euro-supremacist, bigoted and eliminationist most settlers are. They didn't show how viciously Palestinians are treated daily by settlers in Hebron, for example. It didn't mention that Palestinians are not allowed to defend themselves against Israeli Jews, and how infrequently the IDF reacts in defense of Palestinians.
Non-Jews are not truly human to most of these older colonial leaders. A good example was Danielle Weiss' arrogance in thinking it was entirely appropriate for her to speak to the village heads as if they were misbehaving children, rather than saying "Hey, some of the kids here may be throwing rocks. Is there something we can do together to keep this from happening?" THAT is how genuinely good neighbors speak to one another.
@@supernova7848They will not stop until they're stopped.
This is truly horrific and a crime against humanity. These people think they are going to bring redemption to israel but will intstead lead it to destruction. It breaks me to think of the many decades the Palestinian people have had to live under the boot of these folks. It has to end now.
It's hard to watch this documentary without feeling angry. The Palestinians always have the right to resist their brutal occupiers.
Fascinating and depressing. The sickest part was seeing the young child being indoctrinated to beat up Palestinians.
that was heartbreaking!😢
they are indoctrinating children to kill arabs and palestininans in sionists schools too that remember to hitler youth on nazi germany...
Israeli : " They (Palestinians) are creating the Israeli expansion By their very resistance"
TOTAL MADNESS
im absolutely caregorically againt the settelments that was an israeli made fuck no palestinian is to blame for that ..but israeli territorial exoansion was trully allwys prescipitated by arab aggresion ..1948 allthough not 1956 ..1967 and the lebanon war ...had yasser arafat excepted ehud baraks deal settements would be a thing of the past ...
no it wasn't. it was precipitated by Israel always - from day 1 of negotiations- trying to take more than its fair share. SHAME ON YOU for lying. @@ashley-fk6dp
Present day "Palestinians" are in fact Arabs from Jordan and Egypt. The original inhabitants were Philistines (tribes from Crete who migrated to Levante after the Bronze Age collapse around 2,500 BC) were gone by the time of Jesus. The name Palestine was used by emperor Hadrian 100 years after Jesus as a slur against the Jews. The land was back then called Judaea, Samaria and Galilee. The Arabs came to Levante 600 year later from the Arabian Peninsula thousands of km away after Islam was created around 700AD. They were invaders and colonisers who displaced the indigenous people of Levante (among them the Jews and the original Christians, the Assyrian People). The Arabs didn't call themselves Palestinian until the 1960s after Arafat founded the PLO. So calling Palestine occupied is ignorant.
Total narcissism
@@muddydog6605 maybe but ill tell you if there is culture that is entirely narscissistic even more so then the jewish one id say its the arab one ...
This is an amazing piece of work. Stunning cinematography and production. Artful and profoundly revealing interviews, brilliant editing. One of the best documentaries ever.
"The last paradox is that the tale of Palestine from the beginning until today is a simple story of colonialism and dispossession, yet the world treats it as a multifaceted and complex story-hard to understand and even harder to solve." - Noam Chomsky, On Palestine
Amazing Documentary! Very eye-opening.