I am musically illiterate, in a complete and total way. I don’t even hear half of what is offered in a song or performance. I first watched you in your recent Celine video. I was hoping that Celine was singing live, mainly because I am her age and was rooting for her health. But watching you was so riveting, engaging, endearing, that I got hooked on watching your videos. Many, many others have said it, and I echo it here: watching your joy while you listen to other performers is just so wonderful. In addition, I am learning how to hear and listen to music which is enriching my life so much1 Thank you ever so much, greetings from WA State USA
This is exactly why I suscribed to your channel, we are being lied to so much that an honest and truthful analisys is like a rare gem. Thank You for your integrity!
Your analysis combined with your objectivity is what makes your videos so appealing. You’re not bashing anyone you’re just pointing out the facts which is what makes your videos unique.
Please don't feel you must apologize for your honesty. Honestly is hard to find today and your loyal fans appreciate this attribute in you. Yes, it's called integrity.
Sadly, one of the biggest problems with the world is that people believe what they believe despite overwhelming evidence. People agree to agree to agree. Denial! That's why we drink, smoke, and destroy the planet . . . . and music! Much appreciation to Fil for the great analysis . . . always fair, honest, and transparent.
I agree with the point you're trying to make, but drinking and smoking are, at worst, coping mechanisms. Please don't put them on the same level as destroying the planet.
Majority of singers today would have failed in past and great singers like elvis fredie frank would been told must auto t7ne ans pitch correct now to make it today
They can't handle the truth. Thank goodness you're you. Integrity was the key take away. Integrity, what we seem to be losing at an alarming rate. Thank you for your Integrity! ❤ 🎉
A few months back I went to see Fairport Convention (well, most of it). Dave Pegg made a good point towards the end - live music is a communal experience, not just a crowd watching a band, but the two feed off each other - keep it live, keep it dynamic, have that band-audience relationship.
Your integrity has always been top drawer Fil. That is why I watch, learn and yes subscribed to your channel. Keep up the good work.Your objectivity shines through.
Anyone who argues or disagrees with your analyses are clueless. Being a musician of over 50 years I see and agree with everything you've stated. I understand it. I get it. Those who have no experience will never get it, and will probably be offended if you tell the truth about their favorite singers. Such is life, Fil. Keep doing what you do.
Great explanation of what you do and how you go about your analysis videos, Fil. You have so much integrity. It is sorely needed in today's world. You are a blessing to those of us with limited musical experience who need some extra information to understand what we are hearing and experiencing. 🎸🤘❤️. I am a FAN of yours!!! Keep it up!!👍
How ridiculous that you even have to make this video! You seem always honest and fair and that's why I watch. I hope you never change that just to please silly, immature people. Sheesh! As a music lover and (very) amateur singer, I WANT to know the facts of what's going on. I can't stand being lied to, especially if I'm paying for music or for a concert!
I’ve taken a deep dive into the music that Fil has analyzed. I would advise doing this instead of being upset. There are so many wonderful bands and singers that I guarantee will please you and also educate you. And to prove he’s not being malicious he analyzed Yoko and guess who wasn’t mean spirited. You have my continued support.
Fil I 100% appreciate you! You just verify musical truths. I learn so much from you, and I'm 67 years old, and I witnessed the greatest true music ever produced from the 60s till the 80s. I can hear what's pure, and what is manufactured.
I do medical performance analysis. I appreciate your accuracy, truth and integrity in all of these musical video breakdowns. You exemplify what data integrity means. AWESOME!!
Hi Fil, You are a man of integrity, and I appreciate you very much! If I thought you were dishonest, I wouldn't be here! Keep on doing what you do, you're doing an awesome job! Rock!
A couple years back I paid what I consider to be a pretty penny to attend a live musical ("Come From Away") and if I were to discover, even now, that any of the performers had been miming, I would be a little indignant and feel cheated. ~ And those were actors I didn't recognize singing unfamiliar songs.
Finding your videos has been a huge blessing for setting realistic expectations for my own Singing . Very much appreciate your honesty. All I can say is THANK YOU
Spencer Davis,Kinks,Who,,Doors,Stones,Beatles,Lovin' Spoonful,The Band,Small Faces,Jefferson Airplane,Love, Left a great legacy of forever music. Thanks for telling how it is Fil.
True. But ... also great "old school" bands sometimes used (without mentioning) studio musicians on their albums. You can find dubbed in applaus to suggest a “live” recording. You mention The Stones: almost every vocal you hear on their "live" album "Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out" is an afterwards studio-recorded vocal. As with so many things: something existed already, but the techniques have improved immensely.
Hi Fil, thanks again for the analyses and the honesty. The constant growth of your channel speaks volumes about how much people are fed up with lies and souless performances, especially those like us, who grew up listening to real music. Naturally, a wider audience also means more trolls and more delusional people who prefer to be told lies as long as it maintains their illusion alive. But seeing the many supporting comments of newcomers give me hope. Your polite, factual and pedagogic approach is widely appreciated by non-musicians listeners who wants to understand what it's all about, amateur musicians who find your videos and advices inspiring and also professional musicians. After all, whatever the trolls are saying, it's nothing in comparison of being called " a dope cat" by Morris Hayes, considering the over-the-top musicians he worked with. You rock, see you on next Saturday's live stream.
Fil, I respectfully suggest you run a scroll across the bottom of your screen:”WARNING, you are about to hear the absolute and unfiltered truth. Viewer discretion is advised!” Then, when you get complaints from the sycophants, just point out the text. Keep up the great work I learn a lot and always enjoy your work.
What narks me off is modern people pitch correcting my big heroes of the 70's and 80's (who got it right first time) and they do it saying the original sounded 'old' or like it was 'sung in a tunnel', Well perhaps it was! And they are old. They were also brilliant musicians and singers who did not depend on computers to get work.
Very well said, Fil! You have integrity, and you are honest! The way you presented this video was so kind and informative for your new viewers! We need more integrity and honesty in this world! I am wondering if you may have been given the last bit of honesty and integrity there was to give in the world of music!😅 Keep on keeping it real! Never change, Fil!💜💜
What you are doing is super important. I completely understand how disappointing it is to find out that your favourite artist is pitch corrected, though. Of course it is. But people need to chill.
'Sir Fil', you've always emphasized the importance of being authentic. That's why I watched and subscribed in the first place. BTW: I subscribed when you first did an analysis of one of my favorite guitarists, SRV. And yes, noticed the T-shirt. Have to get me one! Rock! Blessings, Marianne aka Celtic Gal ❤😇🤘 8:08
New subscriber here. I've only watched a few of your videos so far, but I really appreciate your experience and expertise when analyzing different performers. Most of all I appreciate your objectivity and honesty. That's why I subbed.
You provide technical Objective Truth, which is rare these days in the Orwellian world in which we live. Unfortunately, some fans of an artist simply will not accept the facts.
The many variations of the human voice are what make it unique and interesting. I have seen big bands live that have been spot-on and some that bombed. It's all good by me. Live is live.
It makes me sad that you even have to explain this. I love your analyses. There are some artists that are good at lip-syncing and some not so good, so you can tell right away. There are some artists that employ every technical technique known to mankind. I like singers who sing with no artificial help because I want to admire and appreciate their voice. I love Celine and I knew beyond a shadow of a doubt she wasn't singing live at the Olympics. She has a terrific voice but, like you said, there's a myriad of reasons for using a recording. I love Elvis. When he was live, he was singing live. You can see it. His ability to put emotion into every single song is what pulled me in and kept me there all these years. That ability can never be captured by any artificial enhancements. Please continue to provide your insights the way you do. I learn so much and truly appreciate it.
Those of us who watch regularly know that you will always be completely objective and unbiased, while remaining kind and respectful, in your analysis videos. Its why we've being watching for so long, and why we'll continue to watch. ❤️🇨🇦
My daughter is currently studying music for GCSE's (at BTEC level) and is on track for a distinction. One of the elements of the course is geared around analysis, so naturally I pointed her in the direction of your videos so she could see how you critically assess in a sincere and unbiased way. We love your videos, especially the ones involving artists that we're fans of. It's such a shame you're having to justify yourself!
Hi Fil. I just wanted to say I understand why you did this video, but your longtime subs know everything you said here is true. Having lived through the great music of the '50s - 90's, there is so much to have heard and watched being performed live. I haven't really ever found many (if any) bands/groups or appreciated music very much since the early 2000's. All of it is too perfect; the "life is gone." No soul or inspiration to me. Thank you for doing what you do. You are in the unfortunate position of delivering musical reality (to some) and therefore receive anger from fans who should direct it to the singers/musicians/producers. You are always fair and honest. Thank you for being you!
The first time I ever watched this channel, I'd previously watched some reaction videos, curious about how Gen Z'ers and millennials saw performances from the 60s and 70s in particular. It was immediately apparent that this is a channel that provides a technical analysis of music, and you are pretty clear that you are a musician looking at it from that perspective. So, a few things. 1. If someone doesn't want to look at technical details and just wants to enjoy a song, or doesn't care about the details, then watch something else--like the video of the actual song. 2. Analyses like these are good at illustrating why music these days feels and sounds "different" to those of us who grew up before autotune, pitch correction and the like. 3. I think you're pretty clear that using pitch correction, backing tracks, etc. is pretty standard these days--which is not a reflection on the artist. In short, it feels like a "listening" problem. Anyone's favourite artist is not some kind of superhuman being that transcends the limits of human vocals, and the fact that it is being pointed out is not "trashing" the artist. If anything, it advocates allowing in so-called "mistakes" because they give the song actual feeling. This is a very clear explanation of what you do, but sadly reflects how many of the angry commenters are shooting from the hip without actually listening to what you're saying.
These days it is about the dancing, costumes, the spectacle. The music serves that. Whether the music is actually performed live or not scarcely matters to the modern audience. They LOVE to be fooled.
When you have a blood test, you don't receive a report saying how amazing you are and how delighted they are with your health. Instead, you get specific results. It's the same here. We hope to discover aspects we're not aware of ourselves, which is the purpose of these analysis. And let's face it, most things are fake nowadays, which is why people struggle to accept the truth
I loved this talk, Fil, a perfect response. ❤ It's a little sad that so many people irrationally defend their idols. If it's all smoke and mirrors, say so in the first place.
You need to put the definition of analysis up at the beginning, really. That being said, you are by far the best teacher, and even though I don’t understand half of what your saying, you have always been kind, fair and focus on the voice, not the person. Honey, forget about those people. So silly to get upset about someone you’ve never met…..acting as if it’s their family member. So stilly silly……I love your channel and always enjoy when I can. Connie Michigan USA
People like me grew up with the dishonesty. People back in the sixties gave me a hard time because I couldn't hear the differences in drummer. Now we know that all of the drummers were Hal Blaine.
When ever I'm looking at a musician/band that is new to me I always try to find live footage. I want to hear what they can actually do before they are created by the studio, etc. It doesn't mean I won't listen to them again. It just means I want to know what's real. Your honesty and analysis have helped me so much with this. Stay honest and keep doing what you do. Thanks so much
Agreed Fil, you can't argue against hard data. That's why I enjoy watching your videos. When an artist you're critiquing gets exposed to be lip syncing or using one of the many other tricks of the trade their fans should see this as a good thing. A lot of artist use these tricks and your videos Fil, give the viewers the insight to what's actually happening. You give us the tools to know what to listen for so the next time we watch a live performance we will know if and how it's been altered. You know what they say, knowledge is power. Knowing this can really help put things in proper perspective. So for those who want to become a professional singer can understand why they don't sound like their favorite singer. After watching your videos now for years I have a much greater respect for those singers/musicians that just stand there and sing their as** off without the need of any tricks. These artist should be the ones we all aspire to become and what you're doing Fil is helping light the way. Thanks again for another inspiring conversation.✌️
I think you have done a more than adequate job explaining your ethical position. Admittedly, I am a 71-year-old musician. So it’s easy to recognize the truth of what you’re saying. So if you feel your audience needs to hear it more, then so be it. But at this point, you have to bear in mind. The fact that some people are not going to like what you say, and yet they will continue to listen and enjoy your show. They are going to enjoy it, even if they think they simply enjoy disagreeing with you. Fans are fans, the ones who don’t like you and the ones who do like you are equal in terms of numbers. Take care.
Too many people dislike such-and-such an artist or refuse to listen to a certain musical genre and then criticise them. I really like how you don't allow your own musical tastes to colour what you're saying about the performance or the voice. You feature a surprising range of performers, always objectively, and I always learn something new. Love it! Keep it coming 🤘
Hi Fil, most everyone has said everything that I would have said in the chat. I appreciate you and your channel very much. Blessings to you and your family.
I am a new subscriber and I appreciate your analysis, because, you use a protocol which is using the same tool to reveal the in each case the actual "ID/Signature" of a "Recording". I beleive your work reveals this exact point and you always highlight the quality of each artist voices. Really really great job. ps hope my english teanslate my thaught properly. 🙂
hey fil, thanks for that as mentioned before, honesty is the key to integrity.... if you ask for analysis dont be surprised that here you will get the truth
This is why I've been watching you for years, I know you're telling the truth. I can't deal with people who aren't honest. It's sad that some people would rather hear a lie. Hope you have a great week, Fil 💙
I def trust your analysis, Fil. I believe your integrity should be evident to anyone who will objectively watch just a few videos. You have explained things so well to those of us who struggled at first to understand the graphs, etc. I have been subbed for quite a while now because your analysis is objective, interesting, and well-informed. Thanks for doing what you do!
No fairy tales. Much appreciated by all the adults in the room!
🎯
Always fair and always honest. This is the reason I watch.
Well said and exactly my thoughts.
@@ivannovotny4552 Yeah. Me too.
Here here!
And respectful of honest and genuine performances as well.
Thanks, Fil.
I have zero musical ability.
But as a consumer, I WANT to know the truth about what is being "sold" to me.
And that's why I watch YOU.
Precisely!
but you'll never know
The thing is that to day,every recording are modified
This is the reason why I don't listen too much the to day music
You're an analyst. You do it incredibly well and we appreciate it.
Thanks!
Thank you for your work, Fil. We‘re living in weird times when „performing live“ does not mean „singing live“ in a concert anymore.
yeah, the normalization of b.s. by creating almost double-speak.
I am musically illiterate, in a complete and total way. I don’t even hear half of what is offered in a song or performance. I first watched you in your recent Celine video. I was hoping that Celine was singing live, mainly because I am her age and was rooting for her health. But watching you was so riveting, engaging, endearing, that I got hooked on watching your videos. Many, many others have said it, and I echo it here: watching your joy while you listen to other performers is just so wonderful. In addition, I am learning how to hear and listen to music which is enriching my life so much1 Thank you ever so much, greetings from WA State USA
Same. Very rarely do I hear what Fil hears, but my eyes were totally opened when he started doing the videos with the software.
We all know you have integrity. Trolls don't have any integrity
Your honesty is so appreciated in this world where too much is fake!!😊
This is exactly why I suscribed to your channel, we are being lied to so much that an honest and truthful analisys is like a rare gem. Thank You for your integrity!
Your analysis combined with your objectivity is what makes your videos so appealing. You’re not bashing anyone you’re just pointing out the facts which is what makes your videos unique.
Please don't feel you must apologize for your honesty. Honestly is hard to find today and your loyal fans appreciate this attribute in you. Yes, it's called integrity.
You are a stand up dude.
Sadly, one of the biggest problems with the world is that people believe what they believe despite overwhelming evidence. People agree to agree to agree. Denial! That's why we drink, smoke, and destroy the planet . . . . and music! Much appreciation to Fil for the great analysis . . . always fair, honest, and transparent.
I agree with the point you're trying to make, but drinking and smoking are, at worst, coping mechanisms. Please don't put them on the same level as destroying the planet.
Majority of singers today would have failed in past and great singers like elvis fredie frank would been told must auto t7ne ans pitch correct now to make it today
They can't handle the truth. Thank goodness you're you. Integrity was the key take away. Integrity, what we seem to be losing at an alarming rate. Thank you for your Integrity! ❤ 🎉
You are appreciated Fil because transparency is a noble gesture these days; in almost all platforms of media and the arts!
A few months back I went to see Fairport Convention (well, most of it). Dave Pegg made a good point towards the end - live music is a communal experience, not just a crowd watching a band, but the two feed off each other - keep it live, keep it dynamic, have that band-audience relationship.
One of the good guys - that's why we're here.
“And you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.”
Please keep doing what you are doing. Thank you for being honest and objective!
Your integrity has always been top drawer Fil. That is why I watch, learn and yes subscribed to your channel. Keep up the good work.Your objectivity shines through.
Anyone who argues or disagrees with your analyses are clueless. Being a musician of over 50 years I see and agree with everything you've stated. I understand it. I get it. Those who have no experience will never get it, and will probably be offended if you tell the truth about their favorite singers. Such is life, Fil. Keep doing what you do.
Well said, Fil. Your honesty is so refreshing and appreciated!
Great explanation of what you do and how you go about your analysis videos, Fil. You have so much integrity. It is sorely needed in today's world. You are a blessing to those of us with limited musical experience who need some extra information to understand what we are hearing and experiencing. 🎸🤘❤️. I am a FAN of yours!!! Keep it up!!👍
How ridiculous that you even have to make this video! You seem always honest and fair and that's why I watch. I hope you never change that just to please silly, immature people. Sheesh!
As a music lover and (very) amateur singer, I WANT to know the facts of what's going on. I can't stand being lied to, especially if I'm paying for music or for a concert!
Agree, he had to expend a lot of energy to justify his role for those who don’t get it. Don’t watch if facts and truth bother you.
Thanks for telling the truth and sticking to it. I appreciate that, plus I'm learning so much!
I’ve taken a deep dive into the music that Fil has analyzed. I would advise doing this instead of being upset. There are so many wonderful bands and singers that I guarantee will please you and also educate you. And to prove he’s not being malicious he analyzed Yoko and guess who wasn’t mean spirited. You have my continued support.
Thanks!
@@wingsofpegasusno reason to be mean spirited with Yoko
Her voice says it all.
You are one of the few that tell the truth and live the truth. Love you and your channel Fil!!!
Fil I 100% appreciate you! You just verify musical truths. I learn so much from you, and I'm 67 years old, and I witnessed the greatest true music ever produced from the 60s till the 80s. I can hear what's pure, and what is manufactured.
I do medical performance analysis. I appreciate your accuracy, truth and integrity in all of these musical video breakdowns. You exemplify what data integrity means. AWESOME!!
Your honesty is greatly appreciated. It is difficult to find these days. Please continue making your videos. ❤
Im here for the facts and the proof. You bring the receipts and present without bias. Never change. Much respect.
Hi Fil, You are a man of integrity, and I appreciate you very much! If I thought you were dishonest, I wouldn't be here! Keep on doing what you do, you're doing an awesome job! Rock!
A couple years back I paid what I consider to be a pretty penny to attend a live musical ("Come From Away") and if I were to discover, even now, that any of the performers had been miming, I would be a little indignant and feel cheated. ~ And those were actors I didn't recognize singing unfamiliar songs.
In the Old Days of Broadway the actors didn't even use microphones when singing. Of course, the auditoriums were much smaller back then.
Finding your videos has been a huge blessing for setting realistic expectations for my own Singing . Very much appreciate your honesty. All I can say is THANK YOU
Spencer Davis,Kinks,Who,,Doors,Stones,Beatles,Lovin' Spoonful,The Band,Small Faces,Jefferson Airplane,Love, Left a great legacy of forever music. Thanks for telling how it is Fil.
True. But ... also great "old school" bands sometimes used (without mentioning) studio musicians on their albums. You can find dubbed in applaus to suggest a “live” recording.
You mention The Stones: almost every vocal you hear on their "live" album "Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out" is an afterwards studio-recorded vocal.
As with so many things: something existed already, but the techniques have improved immensely.
I'm a classical musician its good to see evidence of what I know I'm listening to.
Not crazy at all, only brutally honest and thank you for it Fill.
Hi Fil, thanks again for the analyses and the honesty.
The constant growth of your channel speaks volumes about how much people are fed up with lies and souless performances, especially those like us, who grew up listening to real music.
Naturally, a wider audience also means more trolls and more delusional people who prefer to be told lies as long as it maintains their illusion alive.
But seeing the many supporting comments of newcomers give me hope.
Your polite, factual and pedagogic approach is widely appreciated by non-musicians listeners who wants to understand what it's all about, amateur musicians who find your videos and advices inspiring and also professional musicians.
After all, whatever the trolls are saying, it's nothing in comparison of being called " a dope cat" by Morris Hayes, considering the over-the-top musicians he worked with.
You rock, see you on next Saturday's live stream.
Fil, I respectfully suggest you run a scroll across the bottom of your screen:”WARNING, you are about to hear the absolute and unfiltered truth. Viewer discretion is advised!” Then, when you get complaints from the sycophants, just point out the text. Keep up the great work I learn a lot and always enjoy your work.
What narks me off is modern people pitch correcting my big heroes of the 70's and 80's (who got it right first time) and they do it saying the original sounded 'old' or like it was 'sung in a tunnel', Well perhaps it was! And they are old. They were also brilliant musicians and singers who did not depend on computers to get work.
That created hits and good albums for a reason so no reason to fix what didn’t need to be
@@DianeAvila-bv4fc As they say in the computer world "If it ain't broke, BREAK IT."
Very well said, Fil! You have integrity, and you are honest! The way you presented this video was so kind and informative for your new viewers! We need more integrity and honesty in this world! I am wondering if you may have been given the last bit of honesty and integrity there was to give in the world of music!😅 Keep on keeping it real! Never change, Fil!💜💜
Fair, honest and to the point.
What you are doing is super important. I completely understand how disappointing it is to find out that your favourite artist is pitch corrected, though. Of course it is. But people need to chill.
Love your analysis always dear FIL. It is a kind of music education for us! Gratitude to you! ❤
We get it Fil. Ignore the trolls. Keep on keepin' on. And if you are "old school", I am ancient school.
You are great !! Enjoy 😉 your knowledge and honesty and talent. The way you delivered this was so kind
'Sir Fil', you've always emphasized the importance of being authentic. That's why I watched and subscribed in the first place. BTW: I subscribed when you first did an analysis of one of my favorite guitarists, SRV. And yes, noticed the T-shirt. Have to get me one!
Rock! Blessings, Marianne aka Celtic Gal ❤😇🤘 8:08
Good on you Fil, this is why I watch.
New subscriber here. I've only watched a few of your videos so far, but I really appreciate your experience and expertise when analyzing different performers. Most of all I appreciate your objectivity and honesty. That's why I subbed.
Thanks!
@@mrbr549 Fil does it right. Glad you found him.
Thank you. It takes a lot of guts to tell it like it is. I believe it should be illegal to pitch correct an artist vocal without consent,
Thanks Fil, your honesty is always appreciated with your analysis videos. 😊🎸🎵
You provide technical Objective Truth, which is rare these days in the Orwellian world in which we live. Unfortunately, some fans of an artist simply will not accept the facts.
The many variations of the human voice are what make it unique and interesting. I have seen big bands live that have been spot-on and some that bombed. It's all good by me. Live is live.
It makes me sad that you even have to explain this. I love your analyses. There are some artists that are good at lip-syncing and some not so good, so you can tell right away. There are some artists that employ every technical technique known to mankind. I like singers who sing with no artificial help because I want to admire and appreciate their voice. I love Celine and I knew beyond a shadow of a doubt she wasn't singing live at the Olympics. She has a terrific voice but, like you said, there's a myriad of reasons for using a recording. I love Elvis. When he was live, he was singing live. You can see it. His ability to put emotion into every single song is what pulled me in and kept me there all these years. That ability can never be captured by any artificial enhancements. Please continue to provide your insights the way you do. I learn so much and truly appreciate it.
I always appreciate your transparency and in depth knowledge- thank you!
Always straight up brother! That's why I tune in every time! Thank you Fil. Keep it coming brother I dig it! So says the old rocker.
Keep doing what you're doing Sir.
Those of us who watch regularly know that you will always be completely objective and unbiased, while remaining kind and respectful, in your analysis videos. Its why we've being watching for so long, and why we'll continue to watch. ❤️🇨🇦
My daughter is currently studying music for GCSE's (at BTEC level) and is on track for a distinction. One of the elements of the course is geared around analysis, so naturally I pointed her in the direction of your videos so she could see how you critically assess in a sincere and unbiased way. We love your videos, especially the ones involving artists that we're fans of. It's such a shame you're having to justify yourself!
Hi Fil. I just wanted to say I understand why you did this video, but your longtime subs know everything you said here is true. Having lived through the great music of the '50s - 90's, there is so much to have heard and watched being performed live. I haven't really ever found many (if any) bands/groups or appreciated music very much since the early 2000's. All of it is too perfect; the "life is gone." No soul or inspiration to me. Thank you for doing what you do. You are in the unfortunate position of delivering musical reality (to some) and therefore receive anger from fans who should direct it to the singers/musicians/producers. You are always fair and honest. Thank you for being you!
The first time I ever watched this channel, I'd previously watched some reaction videos, curious about how Gen Z'ers and millennials saw performances from the 60s and 70s in particular. It was immediately apparent that this is a channel that provides a technical analysis of music, and you are pretty clear that you are a musician looking at it from that perspective. So, a few things. 1. If someone doesn't want to look at technical details and just wants to enjoy a song, or doesn't care about the details, then watch something else--like the video of the actual song. 2. Analyses like these are good at illustrating why music these days feels and sounds "different" to those of us who grew up before autotune, pitch correction and the like. 3. I think you're pretty clear that using pitch correction, backing tracks, etc. is pretty standard these days--which is not a reflection on the artist.
In short, it feels like a "listening" problem. Anyone's favourite artist is not some kind of superhuman being that transcends the limits of human vocals, and the fact that it is being pointed out is not "trashing" the artist. If anything, it advocates allowing in so-called "mistakes" because they give the song actual feeling. This is a very clear explanation of what you do, but sadly reflects how many of the angry commenters are shooting from the hip without actually listening to what you're saying.
I appreciate this astute comment, and agree.
These days it is about the dancing, costumes, the spectacle. The music serves that. Whether the music is actually performed live or not scarcely matters to the modern audience. They LOVE to be fooled.
Have you seen a Busby Berkeley film from the 1930s? It's all dancers and glitz the music is secondary.
When you have a blood test, you don't receive a report saying how amazing you are and how delighted they are with your health. Instead, you get specific results. It's the same here. We hope to discover aspects we're not aware of ourselves, which is the purpose of these analysis. And let's face it, most things are fake nowadays, which is why people struggle to accept the truth
Yep! And if you don't wish to know, you can opt out. But don't ask the questions and then blame the messenger.
Hi Fil,
All great points for new subscribers to consider. Your analysis videos are awesome cuz you tell it like it is… keep doing you! Debbie☮️
Thank you for your honesty and integrity. Much appreciated!
I loved this talk, Fil, a perfect response. ❤
It's a little sad that so many people irrationally defend their idols. If it's all smoke and mirrors, say so in the first place.
Thank you for your sharing your vast knowledge and integrity, Fil.
❤Bravo!!!As always upstanding and honest Fil!!!!
If I am paying $$$$$$, for a. Live concert. I expect actual live,real vocals
You need to put the definition of analysis up at the beginning, really. That being said, you are by far the best teacher, and even though I don’t understand half of what your saying, you have always been kind, fair and focus on the voice, not the person. Honey, forget about those people. So silly to get upset about someone you’ve never met…..acting as if it’s their family member. So stilly silly……I love your channel and always enjoy when I can. Connie Michigan USA
People like me grew up with the dishonesty. People back in the sixties gave me a hard time because I couldn't hear the differences in drummer. Now we know that all of the drummers were Hal Blaine.
Fil, you’re the best. As we say, “facts don’t care about your feelings!”
Fil is the most honest person and kind and close to perfect as you can get! He's an 😇
When ever I'm looking at a musician/band that is new to me I always try to find live footage. I want to hear what they can actually do before they are created by the studio, etc. It doesn't mean I won't listen to them again. It just means I want to know what's real. Your honesty and analysis have helped me so much with this. Stay honest and keep doing what you do. Thanks so much
Grear job. Keep it going. Integrity plus. Thanks very much
Hi, Fil. I appreciate you. Keep up the good work.
Great videos. Always objective & well informed. Breaks down what is going on.
Much respect, Fil ❤
Agreed Fil, you can't argue against hard data. That's why I enjoy watching your videos. When an artist you're critiquing gets exposed to be lip syncing or using one of the many other tricks of the trade their fans should see this as a good thing. A lot of artist use these tricks and your videos Fil, give the viewers the insight to what's actually happening. You give us the tools to know what to listen for so the next time we watch a live performance we will know if and how it's been altered. You know what they say, knowledge is power. Knowing this can really help put things in proper perspective. So for those who want to become a professional singer can understand why they don't sound like their favorite singer. After watching your videos now for years I have a much greater respect for those singers/musicians that just stand there and sing their as** off without the need of any tricks. These artist should be the ones we all aspire to become and what you're doing Fil is helping light the way. Thanks again for another inspiring conversation.✌️
Thank you ✨
Thank you, Fil.
Love your honesty Fil ❤️
I think you have done a more than adequate job explaining your ethical position. Admittedly, I am a 71-year-old musician. So it’s easy to recognize the truth of what you’re saying. So if you feel your audience needs to hear it more, then so be it. But at this point, you have to bear in mind. The fact that some people are not going to like what you say, and yet they will continue to listen and enjoy your show. They are going to enjoy it, even if they think they simply enjoy disagreeing with you. Fans are fans, the ones who don’t like you and the ones who do like you are equal in terms of numbers. Take care.
Keep doing what you're doing Fil. You're the best!
Too many people dislike such-and-such an artist or refuse to listen to a certain musical genre and then criticise them. I really like how you don't allow your own musical tastes to colour what you're saying about the performance or the voice. You feature a surprising range of performers, always objectively, and I always learn something new. Love it! Keep it coming 🤘
Fil, been watching for a long time, thru many different RUclips names and IPHONES, you've always been square up dude!
Hi Fil, most everyone has said everything that I would have said in the chat. I appreciate you and your channel very much. Blessings to you and your family.
I love your videos!!! Thank you. I have learned so much from you.
Appreciate your videos Fil.
I am a new subscriber and I appreciate your analysis, because, you use a protocol which is using the same tool to reveal the in each case the actual "ID/Signature" of a "Recording". I beleive your work reveals this exact point and you always highlight the quality of each artist voices. Really really great job. ps hope my english teanslate my thaught properly. 🙂
Thanks for the kind words and for subscribing!
Rick Beato is right there with you.
Thanks Fil, good video!
You do a very important work. Truth is paramount.
hey fil, thanks for that as mentioned before, honesty is the key to integrity.... if you ask for analysis dont be surprised that here you will get the truth
Fil you are the best! Fair is exactly what you are!
love your t shirt about time for another SRV review !!!??? Thanks Fil!!
Take care
I always appreciate your efforts. I've seen all the immature children cry on here telling you you're wrong. Ignore them. The faithful are here!
This is why I've been watching you for years, I know you're telling the truth. I can't deal with people who aren't honest. It's sad that some people would rather hear a lie. Hope you have a great week, Fil 💙
Lay it on the line Fil.
I'm so impressed with you Fil. I have been for a long time, but your candor is so appreciated. I hope your channel explodes in size.
I def trust your analysis, Fil. I believe your integrity should be evident to anyone who will objectively watch just a few videos. You have explained things so well to those of us who struggled at first to understand the graphs, etc. I have been subbed for quite a while now because your analysis is objective, interesting, and well-informed. Thanks for doing what you do!