Faisal Warraich: Why Pakistan could not develop into a democratic state.
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 окт 2022
- Faisal Warraich is a youtube historian who has popularised history on a vast scale among the Pakistani youth. Here he shares his opinions with Taimur Rahman about the creation of Pakistan, military dictatorships, federalism, and religious extremism. Very candid and honest conversation.
Faisal Warraich's RUclips Channel:
/ faisalwarraichshow
------------------------------------------------------
🔔Subscribe to the Channel for More Content:
ruclips.net/user/TaimurRahman1975?su...
📺Watch More Videos on Current Politics:
• The Real News
------------------------------------------------------
Follow Dr. Taimur Rahman on Social Media:
Instagram:
/ taimur_laal
Twitter:
/ taimur_laal
Website:
laal.band
Video by Taimur Rahman & Team.
#faisalwarraich #interview #dekhosunojano #history #newspakistan #pakistanpolitics #quaideazam #pakistan #india #independence #gandhi #nehru 
Видеоклипы
The most honest account of historical review I've ever come across. May God protect Faisal!!
God blast you
Fsw vlog is amazing, this guy is very honest with facts
Protect
May Establishment protect him
@@dubaiwalavlog6777 to
I am from India and this is amazing. This kind of clarity and thoughtfulness is very rare. I wish both countries had more people like you
Both Countries ?`are u nuts .....They got separated based on religion---- not us .......Its their radicalism that got seperated.......They even raped, killed millions of innocent bengalis during the revolt of East pakistan.......Show your kindness elsewhere.......These pak speakers are intellectuals because they have read the History, Internet.....but 90% pak are still the same
India doesn’t have any dearth of intellectuals unlike Pakistan whose education system is highly religious influenced
Very good approach.
I appreciate you ♥️from Pakistan 🇵🇰
@@fahadvlogss thanks brother
That's called journalism, that's called truth, that's called illuminating people with correct information. Perfect!
Mr.Faisal
The man who showed the reality of pakistani society
Great Conversation, These type of intellectuals are much needed to ensure a healthy relationships between India and Pakistan.
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Intellectuals of both sides are needed.....aik hath sa tali nhi bjti ....lkin ya hota nazr bilkul nhi ata ..Pakistan znda bad
It couldnt be sir. That is impossible at all time. Your people still hate us. Pakistan too.
For that we need to understand religious differences.
@@mq5232 pakistan ko jarrorat h bosdk..
80% of Pakistani are brainwashed since childhood against India, whatever u are seeing here is people are just 3% in Pakistan who think rationally.
Faisal is a storyteller at first. That's what makes him special.
Yes, fairy-tale teller.
@@RevengeListt If you are referring to the facts he just mentioned then please read more.
@@latestnews6967 Why does it matter who ruled whom in the past? What difference does it make that who followed what religion in the past? Why are you guys so much obsessed with history. Humans live life for their families. Whether Indian, Pakistani or American they earn money, eat, sleep and die. That's it. Get a life my boy. Wishing you all the best.
@@latestnews6967 heard of tipu sultan? And all the other nawabs? We Muslims don't believe on nation or caste or ancestory we believe on religion. A Muslim is a brother of mine no matter from where he is in the world.
Islam is the reason of partition, not Muhammad Ali Jinnah.
Think about it, deeply. Blaming Muhammad Ali Jinnah is easy and lazy. If you are intellectually honest, you would realise Islam divided India.
خدا قسم، 20 سال سے جو میرے سینے میں سوال اٹھتے تھے اور وہ سوال جس سے میں پوچھ نہیں سکتا تھا آج آپ کی ویڈیو سے مل گیا،،، زندگی کی بہت خوبصورت ویڈیو،،،
True I’m living abroad and Indians and Pakistanis are good friends here . Faisal you are great men
I have never commented on you-tube. Ever. This is my first time. The honesty in this video evokes a response. I DO hope the truth lives. I live in the United States. My father and grandparents migrated from India to Pakistan. One grandfather had close ties with Bangladesh [pre 1971] and an aunt was born in Dhaka. My grandfather was a member of the Indian Civil Service and migrated to Pakistan in the 50s. I grew up in Pakistan labelled 'urdu speaking' and migrated out as soon as I could because i was pretty fed -up in Pakistan and rarely ever look back 20 years on. I studied with many Pakistanis over the years whose families were 'military ' families. Most of them had green cards and currently reside and thrive in the United States. These same families while enjoying the fruits of democracy here nevertheless appeared to support Musharraf during his martial law. The truth as told here is that there is no true animosity between people of the sub-continent. Pakistan's military unfortunately has to keep the kashmir issue and the 'other-ness' of the Indian narrative alive to remain relevant. I agree with Faisal that somebody in Pakistan should run a list of ALL the overseas pakistani military families. Its also time to shrink the influence of religion and the brainwashing that goes on. Pakistan has the hardest working people and they are honest. It would be a shame if we allow military and religion to hijack the fate of millions. If India had to take over Pakistan they could have easily walked over in 1971. They did NOT. South and Central Asia as a region should start to blur its boundaries and go the route of the european union. My grandfather during Ayub Khan's era had spoken and written about envisioning a common south asian currency [ including afghanistan]. We really do need to come together for the betterment of our people and the millions of Afghans who have made pakistan home since the 70s. We need to drop fear mongering by military and religious outfits like a dead weight and move on. Bring land and tax reforms and Pakistan will become unbeatable. Its people and its land are gifted. Open up the county to foreign influences. Let ideas and culture flow. Come into the 21st century and put the army back in the barracks for good.
Did the Holy Prophet (PBUH) live in the so-called 21st century? Do we know better than the Holy Prophet?
Farah, your good intentions and prescriptions cannot be implemented in Pakistan which is a highly radicalised society over which the shadow of an oversized military looms. The very raison d'etre of the concept of Pakistan was enmity with Hindus. Islamist radicalism was the seed from which the thorny tree of Pakistan emerged. It probably is too late to turn back.
It’s not late. On the contrary change is already afoot in Pakistan. There is a vibrant secular stream rising up even from amongst the military own ranks finally. Pakistan has made big strides despite being an infant on ventilators since 1947. I think the new generations are waking up to the realization that the job of the military is done. Pakistan is now too big to fail and by deepening its US alliance from military to economic priorities can hopefully come out from under military shadows. Still a tricky rope to walk given that’s Pakistan historically is also close to china. Pakistan’s future will become a reflection of how well the super powers of the 21 st century ( United States and china) care for its smaller sacrificial Allies.
@@farahsalahuddin Farah, if Pakistan is a sacrificial ally of China, why persist in this alliance?
@@farahsalahuddin A true democracy will never work in a country with religious extremist parties like TLP, JUI, PTI. If you want to enforce secularism. It needs to be done through a hardline Kemal Ataturk way. Otherwise pakistan will keep on destroying itself in the name of democracy. Musharraf literally saved Pakistan from Islamization by making it clear that Taliban is the enemy and by removing Zia's draconian laws which no political parties dare to do. Pakistan will not be fixed by democracy. It needs a secular autocrat like Ataturk otherwise TLP will continue to grow.
Democracy is not the end all be all answer to everything.
Mind-Blowing Knowledge Delivery by Sir Faisal...Ma Sha Alllah, May Alllah increase his knowledge and guard him. Jazak Alllah.
Watching two legends at the same time. Thanku JazakAllah for educating us...
Before this I thought reading history is useless but now I know even history is important if you learn lessons from it
Absolutely
I am regular Listener of his all channels , Dekho suno jano , Big socho , FS .. and I am proud of his follower he is great man with special abilities
Two favorite personalities together
So nice 👍👍👍
These are actual intellectuals of pakistan which are worthy of discussion, not their current, narrow-minded politicians. Excellent podcast .
We wish India as some even 1 but it’s pity that now a days indias are ruled by uneducated tea seller and terrorist mind set
@nadirali3923 Well, your argument itself shows how narrow-minded your thinking is. Btw even I have various critism about current government, but I won't break the realm of decency by speaking words like Teaseller. So please at least try to learn from this gentleman how to put your views in a civilized manner. But what can I expect from the citizen of a country who has a world record of nurturing the highest number of UN designated global terrorist 135 in the world ( even more than Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan). When you can't behave properly in comment, why would anyone take you seriously. Have a nice day.
@@dharmeshparikh7837 un means United nothing with your logic bagat Singh was terrorist ? Gandhi was terrorist fighting against West is not a terrorism.
@@dharmeshparikh7837hum Hindu mahan he tumhe in Pakistanio se seekhne ki jarurat nhi he Jai shree ram 🚩🚩🚩
This man speaks the truth! The reality and truth is always bitter. It's time for us Pakistanis to take the bitter pill of truth and move forward with open eyes instead of living in a fantasy.
I watched your vedios love from India 🇮🇳♥️ PYAR
Seeing two bright minds at a same place is blessings.
Why does no one apparently realize that Jinnah was a dying man and had known this for 12 years before he died. and kept it a secret. Of course he wd be desperate to get Pakistan .
Poor knowledge. He missed a lot of expalnations with regards to 71and kargil...
@@dourbeen he can educate you v well on these topics.. poor knowledge🙄🙄🙄🤗
we want another episode sir,you both are gems of Pakistan ❤️
absolutely true sister 👍
Islam is the reason of partition, not Muhammad Ali Jinnah.
Think about it, deeply. Blaming Muhammad Ali Jinnah is easy and lazy. If you are intellectually honest, you would realise Islam divided India.
@@RP027 And what about Muslims left behind in India ...??
@@ec19621 They also want separate rights. Don't want to live in secularism. When their population rises to 30%, they will again demand another partition
@@RP027 🙄🙄🙄🙄
What a person he is! Faisal, we are proud of you💗
1. The one who speak truth is a courageous person as truth is bitter.
2. The one who listens to the truth sensibly is even more courageous.
3. The one who swallows his ego and mend his ways post realization is most courageous.
I hope the pakistani people listen to people like him and prof. Ishtiaq etc. And plan their next steps accordingly.
The one who listens is more courageous and educated than him, I would say both are Lions ♥️♥️
What are your thoughts about indian political Sceniroes... It is reversing all the basis on which the state is standing..eg open talks about ammending the Constitution hindu rastra hate politics etc..who do you think will win..will india recover and return on its basis or it will keep it's journey towards a fascist state?
Few things better left to time for answers like your questions. Why not reflect on these questios post 25-30 years from now. Similar to the decisions Pakistan has taken in the past are now getting reflected upon. And moreover hindsight is 20-20.
In brief
From Iqbal to jinnah all were MI6 agents and Pakistan is until now a slave colony of western capitalist establishment...
British created a wahabhi radicalized Islamic wall to better USSR and south asia to counter the spreading wave of communism and after that the mulla military collaboration is the best of market industry to dominate on the region
@@maliksahil2407 that is misconception that hindu wants a Hindu rashtra... Hindus just wants constitution to respect the original religion of the land and it's laws just becoz some ppl decided to make this country secular u cannot tell only hindus to stop their religious activities so the concept of secularism prevail on the other hand u have one community which divided the nation and u give them special status and laws.... hindus are more willing to change or acceptance that's y there are so many religions co-existing in india but only one religion has problem with the Hindus becoz they even after independence thinks they are the boss of the land becoz they used to rule hindus ...that is the ego which is causing clashes in india between hindus and muslims ... Hindus could have easily asked for a Hindu rastra when country divided on the basis of religion as they were not the ones to ask for the division based on religion.. but they chose secularism becoz it's the nature of religion ..becoz hindus believes in all. Religions ..if u don't know research hindus go to every religious places in india irrespective of what background it holds ....
He deserve more than that.... He is such a good researcher and historian that we are proud of him.
A wonderful analysis by Faisal . I am an Indian and his great fan. A salute to this hero from the core of my heart.
Probably for the first time, a young Pakistani has spoken the truth. He has shown the mirror of truth to Pakistani elite. Kudos!
This country needs more honest, brave and intellectual people like Faisal Waraich ♥♥
Brilliant!!💯 Pakistani as a nation are very sensitive to critique and critical analysis of history. Which is not the right way to develop an understanding of historical events. We as a nation runs away from making tough decisions as making Reforms whether in Judiciary, Military, Burocracy, Police, Land, Economic or on Human Rights which is necessary for any nation to develop, perform & compete with the nations of it time. This is the truth that every person in any institution must have a say in decision making and it should not be controlled by one man only as the complete power has the chances to be misused & abused. Nehru was the most intelligent man to make reforms right after Independence which put India on the right track of democracy which strengthen it's institutions as well as made them accountable if anyone supercedes the laws!
Nehru stole democracy from Islam. More than Nehru it was his Islamic advisors that implemented democracy in India.
Because that conflicts with Two Nation Theory.
Assalamualaikum...I m not from Pakistan...but I would say there is still Hope. But it is ultimately people who have to Honestly work for development of Pakistan and also with forms in Army
He is the best, I have learned so much from him. May Allah bless him and his teem for remarkable work they are doing. I am from Canada.
no one can beat the level of faisal bhai. always lean new things while listening him .
What a bravery to describe the honest version of Pakistan...Long live Faisal... 👍
Faisal is best teacher.His way of explaining is wonderful.l m really thankful to his team for sharing so informative content.
27:52 what FW just said is gold. I wish more Pakistani’s knew.
What Musharraf did in Balochistan should be quoted as well because I think all the current situations and events happening in Balochistan currently are started from Gen Musharraf after assassination of Nawab Akbar bugti
But Faisal Bhai did a great job and I'm thankful to sir Taimur for this wonderful and informative talk . Stay blessed both of you ❤️
I am an Indian.I wish I come across such objective discussions in Indian channels too.
Watch vad or dostcast
Sir, there are hundreds of such Objective Discussion in Indian Channels also. Might be, you are unaware of them. And even heard some also, they might have sounded as Changing the History of India (written by the Leftist Historians)
Oh why did this discussion stop? I wanted to just keep listening to him! He has so much to share! Such amazing clarity!
Faisal is best RUclipsr in Indian subcontinent.....with unbiased videos
Two legends in single video👌
Love you sir Faisal Waraich❤️
Love you sir Timor Rahman❤️
As a muhajir I applaud the sagacity honesty eloquence and humility of our Punjabi brother Faisal warrachi
May he have a long prosperous life
What is a Muhajir?
The style is unique, " kaise hain dosto" and direct mooday pe, no lambi chori tamheed, no time waste. Worth watching
Such a learned and honest person, Faisal Warraich sb ! What a discussion! Keep it up sir. 🙏🏻
43:40 this brought tears in my eyes, very easily said, but I know how my forefathers had to struggle to move into India from Sindh.
From which city in Sindh?
@@surehbadshah221 Khairpur
@@rohitbhagchandani love from sindhudesh
❣❣FSW Sir is a Brand. ❣❣
Love from Sindh, Pakistan
Faisal deserves standing ovation. His Vlogs are much better than one offered by famous Indian vloggers.
In brief
From Iqbal to jinnah all were MI6 agents and Pakistan is until now a slave colony of western capitalist establishment...
British created a wahabhi radicalized Islamic wall to better USSR and south asia to counter the spreading wave of communism and after that the mulla military collaboration is the best of market industry to dominate on the region
This is what he is saying you to come out from.Come out of this comparisons
Get a life yr
Pakistan democracy problem is Pakistan political parties undemocratic Intraparty organisation. Political parties are not institutions, but personality dependent
youtube.com/@mohammadtariq1739
Seeing Faisal and remembering #ArshadSharif, Allah bless you. Faisal is covering thoughts of most educated Pakistanis who aren't influenced by birth imposed agenda by establishment.
Arshad Sharif the stooge of fauji boots blackmailer
Just finessed 75+ years of history in a splendid manner. Love it
Lots people know all this what you told in this session but the way you have narrated, thats Outstanding,,EXCELLENT 👍👍👍👍👍.Five stars.
He will be remembered as a social media Historian just wow❤
I remember in 2001, I used to travel to Delhi for my coaching, and there was enormous checking of almost all cars because Indian government was highly irritated at that time because of the attack on Indian parliament.
Imagine that you had a dispute with someone and that person is saying all the time that you are not interested in solutions. When you go to talk to that person to fix disputes, he takes out a gun and starts shooting you. After that there was an impression that Pakistan is not really a sensible country worth wasting time. Then 2008 Mumbai attacks, which were basically a war-like attack, was the end of it all.
Modi won't talk to Pakistan no matter what you do. It seems that the people in power in Pakistan are not really humans.
Faisal is a master story teller with excellent analytical mind
Above all Faisal is a brilliant story teller, his ability to package complex information in a simple yet interesting consumable format makes him one of the most brilliant folks on RUclips.
What a great intellectual debate. Not only FSW, we must appreciate Dr. Taimur Rehman for great questions which lead to such great answers.
Very honest narrative Bro ! Love from Indian ! 🇮🇳
Such an honest and blunt interview by Faisal Bhai, I wish you bring the next part as well.
Should be inviting in more educational institutions. ❤️
Such a great person you have invited to meet with. ❤️🔥
Both are heroes
I used to think that Parvez Hoodhboy and the people in his circle express his views objectively and with courage.
But i am very impressed with this young man.
Faisal sir lot of love sir from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳 people like you can really shape Pakistan ..
Two fav in one frame!! Great session. Much appreciated! We must learn and grow..
کاش کے ایسے young سکوھلر کراچی بی پیدا کرتا ۔both are great
Their are many similar people in Karachi. If they become vocal ultimately will be hanged. We don't want to listen Truth. Every one has VESTED INTEREST
@@ashrafalam6075 kindly advise their availability or chanel
No body wants to hang like ZAB. Silent people living all around karachi you have to search.
فیصل وڑائچ بہت محنت کرتے ہیں ۔ بہت کم لوگ کروڑں میں پیدا ہوتے ہیں ۔ فیصل وڑائچ کی ہسٹری میں ایک بھی جھوٹ نہیں ہوتی ہے ۔ یہ اتنی کوشش کرتا ہے کہ مکمل سچ پر مبنی ہو۔ کسی کی لحاظ نہیں کرتا ہے اور یہی ایک حقیقت ہے ۔ اس وجہ سے ساری دنیا سے لوگ بہت شوق سے سنتے ہیں ۔ خدا فیصل کو لمبی زندگی عطا فرمائے آمین ثم آمین یا رب العالمین ۔
Why didnt I stumble on this video earlier. The person asking the question and the one answering have discussed topics that I have pondered over throughtout my life. Thanks for this!
Faisal sahab ko dekhta hun:sunta hun:or hairaan hota jata hun:--Itna jaheen
Amazing conversation. Taimur and Faisal are two voices of sanity and logic.
With regards to Pakistan, I am now convinced that literally everything we were taught in school was a lie. Real history is learned through independent research and analysis. Pakistan's foundation was based on hatred of hindus and Faisal explains this in good detail using the "exceptionalism" attitude of the messiah seeking muslim community.
Past is prologue and I hope that in the future, Pakistan can learn the mistakes made that brought the entire nation on the brink of collapse in today's day and age.
Why hindu hatrate amonnge Muslims they are converted from hindus
This video changed my opinion on Pakistan radically.
Amazing discussion. I never thought I would sit through the whole thing, seemed very long. I was just glued to it and almost an hour long discussion passed through so quickly.
Awesome. Kudos to both of you for such recording such amazingly bold account of history.
Sir, you are the hero in Philosophy no one can beat in Philosophy. Your Philosophy series is the best
Excellent ! the information age is quietly transforming everything, without it these views could not be expressed and reach so many viewers. Thanks for the upload. 👍
I feel glad to be one of the initial followers of FSW. I have never followed anyone so passionately on youtube more than FSW. Dekho Suno Jano and FSW vlog are the greatest youtube channels coming out of Pakistan. Great work
I'm also
A great round of applause 👏 Zabardast... Maza agaya ... kese waqt or video khtam hui pata nae chala itni insightful knowledge ki humein ashad zarurat hai.
Faisal Sir I have no words to appreciate you ❤️❤️❤️you are my inspiration ❤️❤️
When Faisal say: "ghalat kr rha hun" That was epic 🔥🔥🔥
Muslim League at that time establishment ki party thi and the Britishers wanted to leave India after dividing it.
Pakistan a tool to serve their geopolitical objectives
1. Excellent narration Faisal. Clarity of thought & underlying principles .. chronology of events & their contexts .. & outcomes .. woven into 'matter of fact' narration .. Extremely engaging & informative.
2. 'Strong Man legacy' .. is inherited from 'commandments' based Islam. Islam has no legacy of discussion, debate & gives no value to opinion.. thus inherently limited in scope & obviously undemocratic. So, Pakistan is no exception to being undemocratic .. none of the Islamic countries is.
India's constitution may be western styled .. but democracy is inherently & civilisationally Hindu. There are no commandments in Hindu philosophy .. everything is debated, discussed & always open to exploration. Thus India, even after being the most socially vulnerable country in the world .. not just remains a thriving democracy, but also finds a release valve to some of its frustrations through it.
Only Muslims in India & those who formed Islamic pakistan had & have a problem .. coz they are inherently unfit for democracy .. Any democracy, not just Indian, but everywhere through the world , even their own democracy.
3. While the discussion was mainly an overview of weak foundation of Pakistan & it's u.healthy growth, the important chapter of becoming a terror manufacturer & exporter .. to India & the world .. has been ignored. In fact, the last 40 years of Pakistan's existence are nothing but a cancerous existence of terror.
4. Appreciation from India.
Agree with every point you made. If only our ancestors had heeded Ambedkar and insisted on full population migration!
No doubt I live in Canada and my next door neighbour is South Indian I think he’s better than my Pakistani neighbours friendly and caring I treat his parents with respect and they also love my family we also exchange food and sweets on festivities
Whenever I go out of town he take cares of my house he’s so trustworthy
بہت خوب اللہ تعالیٰ آپ دونوں کو اور ہمت دے
Wow what a candid review on pak history I'm proud of you Faisal bhai You're a brave man .
mind blowing conversation… whole nation need to listen this mind blowing conversation… highly appreciated ❤
I am from India living in Australia happy to see a Pakistani telling truth
بہت شکریہ واڑیچ صاحب
جب تک یہ باتیں عام بندے کو سمجھ انیں گی ڈر ہے بہت دیر نہ ھو جائے
We would love to watch another video of Sir Faisal Warraich with Dr. Taimur Rahman.
absolutely amzing and wonderful explanation,
in my paper i have mentioned the same things like we can't stabilise our economy without normal ties with our neighbours, mesmerising.
Two Legends in One Frame❤️ you guys are Amazing!
We are PROUD OF PEOPLES LIKE YOU ARE ONE IN MILLIONS
THE WORLD IS PROUD OF YOU
GOOD LUCK
SHARIQ
LOS ANGLES
السلام عليكم برادرم میں 20 سے سن رہا ہوں کمال شخصیت ہیں فیصل بھائی کو اور کمال تحقیق ہے
I was one of first 100 subscribers of Dekho Suno Jano.
At that moment, I was thinking why this channel has not good subscribers.
But latter came to know what It had done .
I have almost watched all episodes of every series.
I m from india to watch dsj last 4 years
After listening the facts and figures given by him; I am literally thinking that" my whole life was a lie" ... I agree to his point of view that strong men also made mistakes but , we are ignorant of these mistakes due to our lack of knowledge. No doubt he is a straight forward and a brave person , bcz unveiling such bitter facts in this society is very hard nowadays !!!
If u want to know more lies which have been told ABOUT Islam then read Dr Kashif Khan's ( Quran researcher ) articles on the internet. The real Islam is beautiful, liberating and progressive.
Seeing this masterpiece for the 3rd time and want every Pakistani to watch this..... Great Discussion 💯💯🚀✅
Absolutely incredible work accomplished by Faisal. Very proud of you. Ma sha Allah you have a nostalgic voice and way of speaking. I really like when you don’t get carried away, and raise your voice annoyingly, that with due respect some others do. Keep up the good work. I respectfully would ask you to be more honest when describing Pakistan’s history. Thank you. May Allah increase his blessings upon you. Ameen❤️
Great to see Both of you 😍
Very well elaborated, First Pregnancy, then after birth problems diagnosed. After 75 years Is anybody is ready for Treatment or going for Euthanasia. Their is Still Time and a lot of people ready for Treatment without charging any Financial/ Decorum benefits. They are true/ refined/ Qualified/ competent / fully integrated but required only Respect. Kindly create a Forum of these kind of people, and discuss issues on ZOOM or city to city conferences or any other systems for Sharing of information/ideas/ views can be evolved. Hopefully conveyed my point of view.
What a great effort.
Thank you Faisal ❤and Dr Rehman❤
Faisal have huge number of subscribers from India.... lot's of love from🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳....dekho Faisal Bhai ne aapka channel subscribe krwa dya
Kindly share what Thesis (Hamza Alvi's) both Faisal and Taimur are referring.
@latest news can you share the link to this thesis?
It is NOT that Jinna did not have any plan for Pakistan after 1947. He was hired by Nawabs/Zamindars and British to continue the status of British Colony which was beneficial to British and Elite Nawabs/Zamindars. Today's Pakistan is the proof. Poor Pakistanis who died in all the wars against India, Taliban etc will never understand this simple truth
Finally someone some thing which is a taboo in Pakistan.
بہت عمدہ کام کررہے ہیں فیصل بھاٸ۔اللہ پاک مزید ترقی دے
سیر حاصل گفتگو۔۔۔ مزہ آگیا ❤❤❤
Two Legends in One frame❤
The fact is that after 1857, it was more than clear to the British that the Hindus and Muslims should be made opponents. British also tried to create rift between Hindus and Sikhs through MacAuliff as well as between north and south Indian Hindus as Aryans and Dravidians through the writings of Caudwell. Muslims right from the beginning were far behind Hindus in every sense, but specially in education and were far more conservative than Hindus. Muslims were led entirely by ashrafia as the poorer Muslim masses had no voice and totally controlled by Mullahs. Separate electorate was the instrument which very well divided Hindus and Muslims. However, creation of Pakistan caused great harm and damage to Muslims of the subcontinent, but benefited Hindus, though emotionally Hindus were opposed to the creation of Pakistan. Imagine an Akhand Bharat with around 35 percent Muslim population ! And Pakistan suffered as the most educated and prosperous Hindus and Sikhs left from its territory for India.
Kindly share the teaming part as well , Qs & Ans session if available ...loved it
Allah ap ke hifazat kry.... Bhai yhn Sach bolny waly ko brdasht nhi kia jata.... Allah ap p krm kry
Never knew you stutter, and you are a great story teller. Man, you are a great inspiration for PWS...salute