Why couldn't Pakistan develop democracy?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
- The video argues that the elite, represented by the civil military bureaucracy developed during colonial times, is the principal hurdle to the development of democracy in Pakistan.
A summary of the work of Andrew Wilder, "The Pakistani Voter, Electoral Politics and Voting Behaviour in the Punjab" (Oxford University Press 1999).
------------------------------------------------------
🔔Subscribe to the Channel:
ruclips.net/user/Taim...
English RUclips Channel:
/ taimurrahman1975
------------------------------------------------------
Follow Dr. Taimur Rahman:
*Instagram: / taimur_laal
*Twitter: / taimur_laal
*Website: laal.band
I don't know why your videos are not going viral.....
The way you explain things is just awesome 💯❤
مطالعہ پاکستان میں1973کا آئین جو رٹا مار کے یاد کیا تھا۔اس میں سے ایک لطیفہ اپکو سناتا ھوں۔
"پاکستان میں طاقت کا اصل سرچشمہ عوام ہیں"
What isn't to be liked about this fantastic lecture, Dr. Taimur! I hope, in the next lecture, you can address change (2000-22) in dynamics vis-a-vis demographic change; media; social media, etc
Thanks a lot Sir for this wonderful narration . Really thought provoking.
شکریہ استاد محترم ❤️
Comrade taimur Lal Salam
MashaAllah sir......we want to see you as our leader of pakistan....inshaAllah
Sir It's an honour for me to say that You are my teacher....I have learnt alot from you....thank you so much 😊
Excellent Lecture.
I am your regular listener & your every lecture is very rational & informative. Thanks
This book should be recommended to CSS candidates so they can fashion a more informed article on the reasons why democracy hasn't prevailed yet in Pakistan.
And then the same bureaucrates later suck the blood of the poors.
Pakistan democracy fundamental problems are lacking Intraparty democracy in Pakistan political parties
youtube.com/@mohammadtariq1739
These csps are modern colonial bureaucrats an opposition to democracy in Pakistan
@@sameedahmad105 😂😂😂😂😂😂 whatsapp university?
VERY INFORMATIVE
GOT TO KNOW A DIFFERENT AND UNIQUE DIMENSION SUPPORTED WITH ARGUMENTS
TOTALLY ENJOYED THE LEC
This video is very informative in every aspect.
A lot of thanks sir
Sir u are an amazing teacher,
Thoroughly enjoyed difficult, twisted, multi layered history of Pakistan democracy!
Great video!
The question that comes to mind is, how then India managed to break free from the shackles of civil-military beauracray and the ingredients.
People of India are by nature are secular.
Thank you so much for your sharing this video.
i remain connect with you since 1 year ,now I have upgraded my knwdlge ..thank again for staying here ,,sir
Best ever teacher I have seen on U tube..❤👍👍stay blessed Sir
A true researcher he is.
May Allah Bless you sir, it's because of you and Faisal Warriach that I am able to understand this complicated and annoying situation of Pakistan and I now know how powerless we Awaam are.
Brilliant, sir. These types of videos are informative and amazing. Please, keep doing this. Also, sir, it will be really helpful for us(students) if you make videos on summaries and reviews of the latest, thought-provoking books.
Thank you so much, sir.
Thank you, I will
@@Taimur_Laal You are most welcome. Again, thank you so much!
not only pakistan almost all muslim countries except malaysia and indonesia
No, there are many countries like turkey, Morocco, Albania, Bangladesh (civilian supremacy is there), Herzegovina, etc..
Sir, I got my answer for CSS interview part...thank you
very weldon you tackle it brillantly
Excellent thesis. Interesting
you are like that grandfather who knows everything of history and narrate all that in an
interesting way
MaashAllah. Much needed mentor . kindly sir make a video on foreign policy of Pakistan from 1947 to 2022 plz give us an overview
Well done sir we enjoyed it , and we will wait for the next analysis
Sir, most of your lectures furnished my critical thinking , fan of your analysis of socio_political issues as well as on going governance issues.
You actually explained everything happening at the moment in punjab
Thank you
Good information the first time listened with details. Thanks
one and only man,with in-depth knowledge and impartial, researched, and facts-based opinion...
excellent sir
MashAllah such a good work in history of Pakistan for us . We are students of Pakistan studies ❤
Thumb up sir.
YOU HAVE SUM UP THE TOPIC VERY INTELLIGENTLY THAT EVEN A LAYMEN WILL UNDERSTAND THE ROLE OF CIVIL MILITARY BEAURACRACY IN POWER SHARING POLITICS IN PAKISTAN.
Such surprising facts you have shared sir ,always love to see your videos.
Keep it up😍🔥
You are doing a great service to us. Thanks and keep it up. 💯
Laal Badshah,
Well done ....
Thanks😊😊
If electing your leader means it's "democracy" (as Wilder would suggest) then why were Britishers ousted who introduced elections? Did we "elect" the British or the East India Company? That's the point! They gave us elections and electoral system. Why didn't we keep them here?
Elaborate please?
Excellent video. I have request for you though: please make a video on 1) how India developed democracy 2) what is the state of democracy in Bangladesh (historically as compared to Pakistan).
Thanks
Yes please
We need more teachers like him. ❤
Wonderful crash course in history with rational analysis of our failures. The same elite vadera class was the driving force behind One Unit because Bengalis wanted large scale land reforms based on Indian model. Obviously, whenever there was a clash of interest, this elite class won using army, bureaucracy and lately judiciary; at the cost of poor Awam (who are getting poorer and powerless with each passing day).😢
You are forgetting another important player: the Maulvi. Yes, it is true that only the elite benefits but the subordination of the masses is largely non-coercive and without apparent force. Religion is central to the enterprise. By a fascist reworking of Islam, people are divided into cults and any prospect of a united front is forever averted. The irrationality dominant throughout Pakistan has robbed people of any sense of themselves, their surroundings and history. It is really sad
@@chandionadeem Absolutely, I agree 100%
@@chandionadeem Islam IS fascism
Remarkable
Can we conclude that democracy is the idea to be implemented in a society where majority is educated and knows what best for it?
Population or you can say masses still needs to be educated regarding rights and duties to propel them to be able to understand the differences of the resulted outcomes.
Excellent lecture ❤️
Brilliant sir
Thank you so much, Sir!
Next topic" Pakistani Generals Akhir chahtay kia Hein"
Ty
Thank you ❤
یونیسک پارٹی اور آحمدئیہ کردار ان پراسس بھی بتائیں۔
The Nation feel proud to have Two Doctors in Feild of Education: Dr Taimur Rahman and Dr Pervez Hood boy! I read somewhere that a reader lives a thousand life before he dies...I have not understood the idea until now...
Please share more same info on these types of videos. Topic wonderful. I like it
You are outstanding
Sir, latest books k barae ma b apki rayae dain.. Bht zarurat ha
Simple answer is that Muslim league was dominated by elites from the start and when they got Pakistan, they imposed elitist mindset of holding power which lead to their failure. Elites in bureaucracy, military and other institutions never want to curb their power in interest of nation. Pakistan's first constituent assembly didnot have single person from worker class. You'll find sahibzada, chaudhary, sardar dominating all cabinets of provinces later on also. Elites can never solve problems of worker class.
Thank you sir for sharing the summary of the book in a very easy to understand interesting , and in relation to cause of political instability in pakistan. I hope that poltician will learn something from this though its unlikely to be. Thank you sir
ھم نالاٸق
Thanks a lot Sir for this wonderful narration
Excellent sir
Simply great
Thanks doc ❤
MashALLAH excellent lecture sir... It is suggested to please mobilize your ideas & movement on ground level also... I'm with you..... Whenever you get a chance to come fsd plz let me know.
Brilliant Sir
Much informative video 👍
excellent and fabulous remarks by the writer. kudos to u sir for book summary.
Analysis of remaining part of history and most recent past kb tk upload hoga...
Sir, you missed that in 'Tashkand Accord' Ayub declared the issue of Kashmir as a "bilaterali issue" between Pakistan and India. Although, we now claim that Kashmir is an international issue but fact is that Ayub declared it a "bilateral issue" between Pakistan and India in "Tashkant Accord".
Good work lad 👍
Just love ❤️
Kindly also do a series on why this didn't happen in india? And what model did indians follow.
Great sir
Yes, a good lecturer with eye-opening facts. Is decision-making power enough to get people out of poverty as witnessedd in China?
exceptionalism in muslims is the real problem
Excellent !
Excellent Presentation 🎉
The lecture's title can also be "The summary of the Book, 'Political and Constitutional History of Pakistan by Hamid Khan' "
Brilliant analysis ❤️
سر ہمارے فوجی بھای اتنے پڑھے لکھے ہیں نہ ہی اتنے تعلیم یافتہ۔ یہ سارے کرتوت بیوروکریسی کے نظر آرہے ہیں۔ ہاں البتہ بیوروکریسی کو فیس فوجی لیڈرشپ نے مہیا کی۔
Very informative sir❣️
Sir also make video on challenges of democracy from 2008 to 2022.
Great video!
Pakistani democracy is still unstable, basics not yet settled. It's a painful process but you will reach a position where you will have a solid foundation of democracy.
I appreciate your effort!! Very nice
The real answer pak is the Muslim majority country. And muslim country and democracy is opposite to each other. Look all around in the muslim world, how many have the real Democratic system
Love u taimur sb...Kya saaf Kya hai
*_The Lèft Suppòrted Crèatíon Of Pàk. But, Lèft Was Nevèr Accèpted By Pak. Whíle In Indía, Lèft Flourished Freely. Yet, Global Lèft Is So Antí-Indía._*
*_My Fàther Was Worker Of Communíst Pàrty. He Always Tells Me That Lèftíst “bítès the hànd that feeds them”. And When I Read Of Lèft, I Fínd The Same._*
*_Fífty Plus íslàmíc Countríes Has Nò Dèmócràcy & Nò Sèculàr Cònstítutíon & Hùmàn Ríghts._*
*_But Lèft Alwàys Cry That Indían Dèmócràcy Ís Dyíng, Indía Humàn Ríghts Víolàtíon, Indían Seculàrísm. I Accèpt That There Are Some Problèms In Indía Too, But No As Bíg As Thóse Islàmíc Stàtès._*
*_Why Lèft Don’t Campaígn Agaínst Them?_*
Exceptional sir ❤
Thanks for this 😊😊😊😊😊
Good work
This is enlightenment indeed but sir why again and again this...i mean even today this mentality of civil military confrontation exists and the system is operative?
Very good information
Greetings from Islamabad NUML , Dr. Taimur, I highly appreciate your efforts to make learning easy and accessible for everyone .Sir, I searched for the book online but can't get it for free . Can you help in this regard? Will be grateful to you.
Has the second part of this video come out yet??
Bhut knowlege hao
Sir kindly Hamza Alvi ka thesis upload kr dein
Sir, you presented it very well. I appreciate.
Has the referred author did not mention role of cold War politics in developing countries regarding socio-political processes?????
I love your videos
why children fail by john holt
was excellent
Sir... please!
Make a video about Pakistan's education system... specialy BS system.
Please also make comprehensive video about Balochistan problem.
Great informative 👍
Complete Democracy vs incomplete democracy :-- Compulsory voting 85% votes cast + 51% wins the race Vs Voluntary voting 30 % av votes cast . Baluchistan 5000 votes + first past the post wins the race ie Less than 10 % votes ..
The real problem lies in electrol system .. And is totally idnored by learned people .
same thing analysis done by ammar ali jaan in his book "rule by fear'
ہم اس سب سے کیسے جان چھڑا سکتے ہیں ؟ اور تقریباً کتنا وقت مزید لگے گا اگر نظام ارتقائی مراحل سے گزرتا ہے تو؟
یا پھر کوئی ریوولیوش ہی اسکا حل نکال سکے گا؟