Josiah Trelawny - The Van Der Linde Gang's Outcast
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 мар 2024
- Josiah Trelawny Dutch's rare and odd exception to what it means to be family and what it means to be loyal to the van der linde gang. Why did Josiah trelawny have such a unique spot in the heart of red dead redemptions most famous narcissist?
Join the discord here:
/ discord
Follow me on twitter:
/ cynicalgaming13
Follow me on instagram:
/ cynic.the.original
Consider supporting me on Patreon & checking out the unique perks that come with it:
/ cynictheoriginal 
Игры
![Kehlani - Next 2 U [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MpI7ekFG8A0/mqdefault.jpg)
Trelawney reminds me so much of Red Dead redemptions version of Saul Goodman
Josiah Goodman
Saul Trelawny
"Fact is Dutch couldn't have done it without me"
Josiah had good intentions though. He had a family. Saul/Jimmy was just doing it because everything went wrong in his life and the only thing he enjoyed anymore was dressing like an inflatable tube man and cheating the law.
For me, I think of dr.swultz from Django
Better Call Trelawny
*Trelawny was basically the non murdering version of Dutch...*
I was going to publish a comment but this was too accurate.
Well actually- a… ummmmm…. Shit you’re too accurate mate
I was thinking more like Hosea without guns. Great with his words and an even greater con-man
@@nahueeiglesias6088closer to that, Dutch is psychotic, that trait is his most inprtant trait, trelawny is very elegant.
@@PufflePufflePuffle yeah Trelawny certainly has a more genuine sense of morality and integrity.
This man has a family of his own that’s why he comes and goes during the story. Riding around in Saint Denis you can overhear him having a convo with his fam.
Really?! Damn that's cool may I ask where and when you get this encounter?
@@Mr.Capitalismit’s the apartment right above the E in Denis. You can actually call out to him and he will pretend that you’re an office coworker
Nice try, one more question does it happen at any given time?
@@Mr.Capitalism I went there in Chapter 3 at around 1 am, so yeah, I guess so.
There‘s a cigarette card too. Don‘t miss it.
I think one of the reasons Trelawny keeps disappearing from the gang is because he has a family of his own back in Saint Denis to attend to.
Trelawny was probably the only person that was allowed to leave the van der linde gang when he pleases because he plans the exact same plans Dutch makes. Both are perfect at seducing others with words. And are obsessed with reckless heists. Take for example the casino boat heist was perfect but there was no escape plan. Leaving poor Strauss to swim back to shore. Reckless behavior Dutch was known for too. Dutch probably has a soft spot for him, because Trelawny offers him exactly what pleases Dutch.
"Leaving poor Strauss had to swim back to shore."
Nah man fuck Strauss he had it coming just like the death he had
"Every time we are about to cut him loose, he brings us something good. Must be his special talent. Keeping fish on the line."
Trelawny was amazing at planning and setting up robberies but he lacked escape plans, seen mostly during the casino boat heist. Trelawny set up the whole robbery but forgot to think of an escape plan for the gang if things went south
You’re basing that statement off of one standalone event
@@goodgenes0He also got arrested in one of the first Lemoyne missions.
Because Trelawnys heists usually don't go south if he does them properly. On the boat Javier didn't secure the guard he took the uniform from and Arthur didn't thoroughly search the pit boss missing his second gun.
As for Lemoyne, he was involved in an illegal prospecting enterprise, a crime so whitecollar it would have barely resulted in a fine had the Sheriff not just let him go out of gratitude to Arthur.
@@goodgenes0 arthur himself said it, i don't remember the exact place but it was during the same mission as he forgot a escape plan
Trelawny is the single criminal with a brain in the whole game. He actually plans and doesn't just constantly spouts about having a plan, he robs without people even knowing they got robbed, he puts his earnings to good practical use, has a working façade as an upstanding member of society and his pull-out game is world class.
He's got the cunning Dutch wishes to have, the charm and eloquence Hosea probably once had and the patience and self control Mikah so desperately lacks.
Dutch's voice when he tells the story about trelawny is hilarious
One of the most interesting characters on the game. Also a peaceful man.
I loved Trelawny, I was so sad when he left.....😢❤.
Josiah Trelawny might be more strange to us then any other gang member, but my god he has an amazing mustache.
I'm glad Trelawny made it out alive
You just made me imagine a deleted scene at the end of RDR1 where he just pops up when Jack is looking for Ross and is like "Oh hello there Jack!"
@@bigrigjoe5130imagine if at the end of American venom he just appeared out of nowhere and was like “bro micah just died!”
Imagine if when Arthur is dying on the mountain, Trelawny comes out and says "Oi, you alright, lad?"
"You've forgotten far more important things than me"
@@siyacertrelawny and the strange man aren't the same person
Him and the gang have a symbiotic relationship. Trelawny himself can't pull off half of the scores he finds without the gang, and the gang can't find the type of scores Trelawny does. That's there main connection, and yes there is an obvious from of kinship with him and the gang like you mentioned in the video. However if were to compare the gangs relationship with themselves, they serve as immediate family, brothers and sisters. I'd say Trelawny is more akin to the gang as a "Cousin", that being he's apart of the family just not a close member of it.
“Sometimes months would go by without trelawney returning”
My Arthur: that’s cute
Pfft, Trelawny is one of only five people in that camp I'd trust at my back, he may be shifty, but he's loyal and has more courage and ingenuity than he's credited with. In case anyone is curious, the other ones are Charles, Sadie, John, and Mrs. Grimshaw. In that order.
I thought the views said 4 Million views, I was like damn people love Trelawny
Everyone does love trelanwny
i wish we could meet trelawney in the epilogue
When I was a kid playing rdr2 for the first time, I thought Trelawny was just Dutch doing a voice
When going through the game with trelawny I always thought of dr.swultz from Django. A smooth talker, and if you analyze both of their mannerisms, personality, and the theatrical appeal, you'd never assume they're in the deadly lifestyle of dealing with the law( both involved but on opposite sides). I'd like to think rockstar got their inspiration from dr.swultz
They keep him around because Hosea, Dutch and Arthur all have bets on what his accent is, and he hasn’t slipped up yet.
This Song from the Doors Explains Trelawny better then anything
People are strange
When you're a stranger
Faces look ugly
When you're alone
Women seem wicked
When you're unwanted
Streets are uneven
When you're down
When you're strange
Faces come out of the rain
When you're strange
No one remembers your name
When you're strange
When you're strange
When you're strange
Trelawney is underrated
I think there was mutual respect between the gang and Trelawny. But they both lacked trust, the gang had suspicions of him, and he hid his family in saint denis from the gang
"a WHHHaaat?" lol I love Arthur
Trelawny, he's a strange man...
But there ain’t no way he’s THE Strange Man. That or he had a major accent change, and John has dementia.
well huim and authur, the gang knows that authur go out for long periods, as he is a adventurer
Josiah is super underrated, I was a fan as soon as I heard that one line "and miss all this glamor??" while Arthur is covered in sopping wet mud after a fist fight
I've viewed him as what Dutch always wanted to be: a true gentleman who had a plan.
he was smarter than the gang
Common fact
Great video never thought about trelawney’s significance like that
I love this channel
Bruh the background music for the video makes me Def wanna rest by the fire
Trelawny’s voice reminds me of darkviperau
The fact that people are still making RDR2 videos is a testament to rockstars superior game design.
He’s my favorite non Arthur character in the gang.
Gosh we needed more from him.
NEW CYNIC VID 💗work gon be bearable 💗
i love how he speaks he seems like such a nice guy
What is also interesting is how Trelawny will never really shut up and runs the risk of running his mouth if he gets caught but what’s interesting is what he was doing the year before Red Dead Redemption 2 takes place. Red Dead online takes place a year before the events of the game and Trelawny could be seen frequently in front of the Fence near Rhodes. Often offering work to the silent protagonist (RDO player) work in regard to rob stagecoaches and things of that nature. If anything the reason why Josiah asked Arthur and Charles to bring him back to Rhodes is because he probably planning on doing it again. This is also taking into consideration that the train station depot clerk in Rhodes has also offered dirty work for Arthur in the same town. Makes you wonder…
22 seconds after posting. lol.
Too slow iam 20.69
@@user-hu7gp8fy6b no way
Bro looks like the strange man
Trelawny is to the gang what Nigel West Dickens was to John in part one. An associate who likely helped with scams and schemes over the years when they needed someone with a bit more finesse than their typical brute force methods would allow for. Not part of the gang, but an ally nonetheless. Like how you're friends aren't necessarily family.
Could you do a more in-depth look at Sean? I loved him and his character when he died I was heartbroken
Trelawny was like.... the Gang's only way of being able to get to tahiti or just change their identies and having land to live or whatever. Specially with 10s of thousands of dollars i gave in camp funds.
Such a strange Man...
Best Call for Josiah!
i feel like you should talk about the plot holes in this game one that always got to me was Arthur's tuberculosis, do you realise just how contagious that is? everyone that Arthur shook hands with or coughed around would have caught it.
In real life, Doc Holiday spent tons of time around the Earp brothers and their families. Not a single one of the people that survived the mess in Tombstone caught it.
Doc Holiday, a real life gunslinger who had the disease and died of it, spent a ton of time around the Earp brothers and their families. None of them caught it.
TB lies dormant in most people that have it. And even when you do get active TB, that’s usually something that occurs after years of it being dormant. Since RDR2 is contained entirely within spring-fall 1899, Arthur simply couldn’t have caught TB from Downes and gotten fatally ill from it in that time span.
I loved trelawny his goodbyes hurt my heart I wish there was an option to give him some money and send him on his way
Back to back video days🔥
I think Trelawney is the mystery man in RDR 1, they look just as the same character, and they both show up in mysterious ways.
Idk why but I love trelawny
The man is a literal magician!
theres a big difference between john and trelawny. trelawny collects knowledge for them while he's out, and the more successful robbery attempts are because of him. he is a valuable asset to dutch and the rest of the gang. john tried to run away from his problems, and his duties as a father and as a gun man of the van der linde gang.
Trelawny would be my third favorite character given he always attempted to avoid leaving a trail of bodies unalived unlike the other members. His cunning and marvelous efforts at entertainment was to better the gang at being able to steal without problems.
Unalived really
@@puhffy Habit of mine
Am I the only one that thinks Trelawny looks like the strange man
And yes I know they aren’t the same person since the strange man’s house is available in red dead redemption
His role was akin to the women of the camp. He worked and earned with them, but he was not a fighter. (and that is not a slight towards him)
Ms.Grimshaw pulled a gun, and was ready to fight, and for that she died. But the non combatants is the ones that got away. (mostly)
Look at Swanson and Pearson. The ones that had or was willing to get blood on their hands seems to be the ones that was taken out.
20 sec is crazy
Second, Trelawney is my fav "member" of the gang
Seems like trelawny is more so a friend of the gang rather than a bonafide member. That’s why he’ll work with the gang and spend time with them but doesn’t actually live with them full time.
He had the highest $/heat ratio of any gang member.
Isn't that the mysterious man from Red dead 1?
I love trelawny need a trelawny dlc
Question I always had was were was trelawny at during the black water massacre I don’t think he ever spoke about once in rdr2
he wasn't there since he was in black water after it to see all the wanted posters
"how to get a hair cut, how to present himself" your character with a foot long beard, and unpomaded hair.
I wonder if Dutch knows he has a whole family in Saint Denis lol
What if red dead 3 was about trelawnys story omg that would be amazing
Lore of Josiah Trelawny - The Van Der Linde Gang's Outcast momentum 100
Yeah
N ironically he really didn't talk
Trelawny's revolver is in the game files.
Trelawney was one of my favorites. I was glad he made it out of that mess alive. Hes just such a likeable little cockroach.
Holy crap I’ve never been this early it’s been 2 minutes
most based member along with uncle
For some reason that "what" from Arthur during the intro killed me 😂
I have my own theories about his past and the whole “family” thing, which feels super fake when you hear it.
Shocking i am hear early
His voice always reminds me of tom hardys bane
i love trelawny sm
Love him characters
I wouldn’t really call him a member of the gang so much as an ally
Ally, member, they're really not that different, Trelawny just doesn't really stay with them because he's more useful out and about
Pretty much an associate
He was great with gathering information for the gang.
actually the first one
yo
im early
Watching this early
Ok
11 minutes
Would make a really cool protagonist if they ever make Red Dead Redemption 3. 😎
Why does he look identical to the Strange Man
He doesn't. Get your eyes checked.
Trelawny is the Strange Man!!!
(Jk ofc)
Idiot...
I want RDR3 to be a prequel to RDR2
Who gives a f*** what you want...
@@johnaustin209ooh well hard mate
@@exceppi1477 Who tf asked you anything? 🤣
@@johnaustin209RUclips shorts kid
@@exceppi1477 Riiiiight.
All your videos ask a question, ramble about nonsense, and don’t answer the question you asked.