Her description of Jamie was too accurate like I know I should be bringing Emmett home but before that I might get my heart annihilated by Jamie first you know?
Honestly J.D. is the greatest. I would die for him even though I shouldn't. Like he's awful but I love him. Is there something wrong with me? Do I have a savior complex? Okay, I just googled it and I definitely have a savior complex. Go figure.
My thing with Jason Dean; He’s a psychopath. But But But To be fair he *did* watch his mom die right in front of him. He moved around a lot and his dad is a jackass. He’s also a source of the dark humor Heathers is known for. He’s mentally unstable from when we hear him sing about the healing powers of numbing yourself with gas station beverages (to each their own I guess) Now, that brings me to Christian Slater’s JD. He shows signs of a psycho even *before* we see him in the gas station. He fires blanks at students in the SAME SCENE we meet him in. Also in the movie he um..kinda sexually assaults Veronica, so for me that was, first of all, a wake up call to the fact that JD is clingy as fuck, but on the other hand, Veronica is the only person he feels loves him (then he tries to kill her?) and in the end he trades his life for hers. Also Kurt and Ram were gay all along.
@@heartears In the myth he was so sad and swore to never love again and became super sad and depressed and only sang sad stuff and wherever he went everyone else was also sad until he was murdered by Dionysus’ groupies because he wouldn’t party with them and oaky happy upbeat music anymore 😳
He’s also dumb as hell, was so distracted by writing his song that he let his fiancée starve, and he was so insecure that he looked back. I love him to death but he’s B tier at best
@@bibliophilecb The cons of dating a musician but no one's perfect when it came down to it he went to rescue Eurydice and I really can't blame him for his insecurities. He was making a deal with a god, something very few heroes could do let alone a common musician?
@@amphitritemists4595 haha as a musician myself, fair, but that doesn’t excuse his friend Hermes literally saying “it’s not a trick dumbass” and then him still going “hmm must be a trick” 😂
Omg, he’s so clingy that he hangs outside your house all night... so that he can kill you and explain his plan to bomb a pep rally, BUt the mAin thing is the clinginess
"Don't let me drink wine and talk about musicals on the internet ever again." Ok so we definitely need to get Kat to drink wine and talk about musicals on the internet again...and again...and again
Enjolras is just literally the perfect man. That’s part of why he could never be the perfect boyfriend because he’s so much better and above all that. Still S tier though because I’m willing to be the unrecognized supportive wife as long as it’s Enjolras.
The fact that “he would murder for you” came us SO MANY TIMES is concerning And honestly? I get it about Enjolras, especially Aaron Tveit as Enjolras. I’ve had a crush on that man since 2012 because of the Les Mis movie 😂
I feel this! I started reading the books when I was the same age as Percy is in the first one and now I'm too old to read the Lightening Thief and sigh over him! It's super weird.
Enjolras’s to-do list 1. France 2. His hair 3. Revolution (for France) 4. Grantaire (putting the bottle down) 5. Falling out a window (preferably with flag of France) 6. Idk prob France (or Grantaire)
More people I’d like to see on the list: fiyero, rapunzel’s prince, Aaron from mean girls, frank butler, Henry Higgins, Anthony from Sweeney Todd, Rodger from Rent, Tony from West Side Story, and Dmitri from Anastasia
Part 2 should include: Evan Hansen, Davey, Crutchie, Bert, Fiyero, The Baker, the guy from Pippin (I forgot his name,) the beast, Aladdin, Lucas from the Addams Family, Aaron Samuels, Dmitri from Anastasia, Christian from Moulin Rouge, Charlie from Kinky Boots and Kristof
You know you’re watching a good production of les mis when you see enjolras and think “well guys that’s it, guess I’m going to die because there’s no way I could not join this revolution”
K: *says how romanticising Phantom is bad* Also K: *confesses her crush on fictional characters who also done bad* Me: Katherine, you're drunk, please sleep. XD
Kinda sad that she said that cause Phantom was judged all his life just for his face and it was sad that noone loved him and that all people did was cower in fear cause of his face. All Phantom wanted was love, but all people cared about was looks. And I bet that if Phantom was real and he was in todays society he would still get judged even now. Sure he did bad things but everyone does something bad in their life. So for me I felt bad for Phantom cause people just judged him without even taking the time to truly get to know him. I know deep down that Phantom is actually a pretty sweet guy if you ever get to know him.
Idk if anyone has pointed this out yet but ~technically~ Seymour didn’t really kill anyone. The dentist killed himself (after trying to harm Seymour through unnecessary mouth surgery) and Audrey II killed the shop owner. If anything he’s an accessory to murder. This is the hill I will die on
QOTD: emmet from legally blonde, Link Larkin and seaweed, JD but he’s hella problematic, honestly Jeremy from be more chill but like, after the squip, I just like the nerdy boys, and the problematic bad boys. 😅 EDIT: And model from fiddler Edit again: literally any of the newsies boys
Oh my word I would cry. I feel like Timothee would be a better NYTW Orpheus than a Broadway Orpheus. Broadway Orpheus is a total dork and I personally feel like Timothee doesn’t fit that vibe? But him and Damon in the same role ... 🥵
I know this is a weird specific thing to ask, but I would be interested ti see you do a video on the sexism within musical theatre. I know that sexism is akward to talk about, but I would like to hear your thoughts on the repetitive sexist troopes. Such as the naive pretty woman who are just like the old 'ideal woman'; the Madonna vs. Whore complex (like in Les Miserables or Hamilton); the idea of the female muse to a man; the over perfect persona in many females; how so many females big song and character drive is love. I would love to hear you talk about that as well as maybe sexism offstage? A topic I want more people to talk about.
@@enzojose4001 Well it isn't completely accurate. For instance Angelica was already married before Eliza and Alexander married, and also it was Peggy who helped Alexander and Eliza get together, not Angelica. And with the topic of sexism in the show, Peggy wasn't the seductress as in Say No To This. She also did know about the letter from her husband and wrote to Alexander beforehand to warn him. It seemed she even blamed herself and felt guilt as in one of her letters to him she wrote something along the lines of "I wish I did not exist". (There is a video somewhere on RUclips that gives a historic account of Maria's situation.) And yet she is reduced to a women who is only seen as sexy, and not a young mother in a abusive marriage trying to help her daughter. So the Madonna Whore complex is still there. And it's sad how much Maria is reduced to in the perspective of the show.
@@annarose932 And 90% of the characters are racist and supported slavery in real life. I really hate Hamilton musical because it's just an united states fairy tale.
@@enzojose4001 Yeah I think I do understand that. It does point out slavery but focuses on the privileged white people of the era, and although it doesn't shy away from the problems of the men in power, it paints them more as a hero. I don't think Lin meant to cause harm, and I feel that casting mainly non-white performers to play these historic figures was a help in giving more people of colour thr spotlight in which they don't deserve. And of course turning the roles around as it has been white people playing people of colour, as Cleopatra has been so many times consistently. Of course currently now the focus is to create more stories about people of colour.
How is Fiyero from Wicked not on here? The guy’s a smooth dancer and has proven his ability to grow as a human being and love someone well. And if we could date anyone and make them love us, I’d have to say Peter from Bare. Great call on Seaweed Stubbs, by the way. 👍🏻
QOTD: Benny from “In the Heights” (or am I just in love with Chris Jackson??). Either way, my heart flutters at the end of “When You’re Home” every time!
QOTD: so the baker, is pure bb and I love him Also OGIE FROM WAITRESS, I want him to recite poetry to me because he’s the best poet ever And I want to be friends with Babara and Adam Maitland because I feel like they’d give great advice
I think you just like Jeremy Jordan in general because you just put him on that list THREE TIMES!!!😂 plus two other roles that he has played or is going to play in the future, but I won’t judge😂
Emmett Forrest - the guy who cares enough to push you to reach your true potential knowing you have it in you, realizes he can learn a thing or two from you, and stands up to his boss after said boss sexually harasses you - is absolutely S tier.
WHEN YOU SAID ENJOLRAS’S TIER LIST WITH GRANTAIRE AS HIS NUMBER TWO PRIORITY I NEARLY CHOKED REMEMBERING ALL THE LES MIS FANFICTIONS I READ IN MIDDLE SCHOOL
My Broadway crushes: Dewey Finn - School of Rock Emmet Forrest - Legally Blonde (And I don’t have to hit on interns will never not be iconic) Nick Bottom - Something Rotten Nigel Bottom - Something Rotten The Baker - Into the Woods Mendel Weisenbachfeld - Falsettos Henry - Next to Normal Boq - Wicked Fiyero - Wicked Davey - Newsies Dmitri - Anastasia Christian - Moulin Rouge Also, would being in love with an anthropomorphic cat be classed as Beastiality?
It wouldn’t, because they’re still basically humanoid. It’s more in line with having a crush on a furry, or even a like catboy depending on how realistic the costume is. So if you do, it’s fine. Kinda weird, but fine.
The issue with beastiality is a lack of consent, not that they're anthropomorphic, and it would probably be easier to list anthros who aren't able to consent. So, don't worry, let your love for anthros run wild and free.
Emmet’s comeback line in legally blonde comes right after he volunteers to help Elle in the courtroom and says , “and I don’t have to hit on interns, professor” for anyone else who was wondering
Honestly I think most Heathers fan girls live in the fantasy that if THEY were dating JD like they could change him and he'd be a better person because of them (at least I know I do...)
Me: I mean like JD would be a S tier My internal voice: He is a fucking serial killer and a sociopath Me: But... But... Ryan McCartan is hot My internal voice: Yes but JD is psychotic Me: Well you say tomato I say "tomato" My internal voice: Stop quoting Heaters he is a serial killer arguement closed Me: But... Ok you are right.
The great thing about online class is that you can be watching something completely different in another tab and as long as your mic is off, no one will be the wiser.
I realized what having a Stage-Crush was when my high school did Les Mis. HUGE crush on the kid playing Enjorlas, but only when he was playing the part on stage lol
This is so fun!! Oh man there's alot of Broadway crushes lol Okay so: and the list keeps getting longer Dewey Finn (School of Rock) Frank Abignal (and yes he has a tough name!! Abig-nail is how Ive heard its pronounced lol Catch Me If You Can, and hes real so I know hes a good man whose happily married!) Seaweed (Hairspray) Usnavi (In the Heights) Harold Hill (Music Man) Christian (Cuz Aaron needs to be on this list twice 😂) Emmet!! ("And I don't have to hit on interns." Best line!! Legally Blonde.) And my OG crush Raoul!! Oh my gosh how could I forget Percy!! Scarlett Pimpernel is amazing. My favorite book and now I can add Percy on the list of musical dream dates!!
Ok look, I started watching this and was reminded how much I thought I would want to date you because you're wine-d up chaotic energy is cute as hell. By the time you gave the warning about not watching this, I was already too far in and had to see it to the end, this was brilliant
If i could hang out with a broadway character, I’d hang out with Orpheus. We are very similar personality wise and I also think we’d just understand each other. A lot of people always blame him for the whole writing a song while starving thing. but to me it seemed like he was hyperfixating on the song and that’d be okay for me because I too, hyperfixate on stuff... so yeah
Ok just let’s be honest king George III would be the best. He would even send a fully armed battalion to remind me of his love... a true man
Y E S
JONATHAN GROFF STANS UNITE
excuse you?
King George loves America, I would NEVER be in the way of a beautiful love story ✨✨
He’d kill all my friends and family, now that’s devoted.
@@bayleecubbfrazette YAAASSSS oh my god! Someone who loves Groffsauce too! Also Memento Mori friend!
@@emilywhitehouse2768 *GAAASP* I FOUND MY TWINN
The Hamilton fandom doesn't give Aaron Burr enough credit for being such a husband material
YESSSSSSSSSSSSSS
ikr
YES (LESILE IS A GREAT HUSBAND AND FATHER)
EXACTLY
AND HE WON’T LET ANYONE MAKE AN ORPHAN OF HIS CHILDREN
Alternate title: Katherine being the biggest mood for nearly twenty minutes
Her description of Jamie was too accurate like I know I should be bringing Emmett home but before that I might get my heart annihilated by Jamie first you know?
Not when 4/5 of her F tier are my A and S tier :( (I’ve only seen one scene with Billy Bigalow but even he I’d D or C tier)
Yes lol
“These are all fictional”
Ah yes my favorite fictional characters: Clyde Barrow, Alexander Hamilton, and Lin-Manuel Miranda
Yes
Very fictional
Lin is not a man.
He is a legend.
Frank Abagnale is also not fictional. The original book (which the movie is based on) was his non-fiction memoirs.
uNUs aNnUs
So very fictional
“Pros: he’s a musician. Cons: he’s a musician.” When I tell you this describes my first relationship... 😂😂😂
oooof 😂😂
now i want a story time 😭
@@dasty3314 yes, I wanna hear this!
Lol that somehow describes my dad perfectly...lol
I’m a musician and I totally get what she means
"Pros: He would murder for you
Cons: He will murder"
Me- Pro: He wants to cuddle by a fire
Honestly J.D. is the greatest. I would die for him even though I shouldn't. Like he's awful but I love him. Is there something wrong with me? Do I have a savior complex? Okay, I just googled it and I definitely have a savior complex. Go figure.
My thing with Jason Dean;
He’s a psychopath.
But
But
But
To be fair he *did* watch his mom die right in front of him. He moved around a lot and his dad is a jackass. He’s also a source of the dark humor Heathers is known for. He’s mentally unstable from when we hear him sing about the healing powers of numbing yourself with gas station beverages (to each their own I guess) Now, that brings me to Christian Slater’s JD. He shows signs of a psycho even *before* we see him in the gas station. He fires blanks at students in the SAME SCENE we meet him in. Also in the movie he um..kinda sexually assaults Veronica, so for me that was, first of all, a wake up call to the fact that JD is clingy as fuck, but on the other hand, Veronica is the only person he feels loves him (then he tries to kill her?) and in the end he trades his life for hers.
Also Kurt and Ram were gay all along.
@@olliedean4070 He’s actually a sociopath. But I understand the confusion.
@@rileyd593 I say tomato, you say Tamato.
@@rileyd593 (that was a reference form the movie lol)
You are Sandy. I am Sandy. WE ARE SANDY.
The cult is in this together.
S M NEW CULT: S a n d y c u l t
What about
Patrick’s colt
Sandal
I didn’t know I was Sandy until today
Edit: forget it, I just realized that I already knew that I was like her
I wish I was Rizzo, but I know I am such a Sandy
“The FBI might want him, but I want him more.”
-Katherine 2020
QOTD: i’d say emmit from legally blonde. also because it’s christian borle
YES JUST YES
If there ever was a perfect boyfriend this one qualifies. OMG you guys!!!🎶
does no one remember christian borle cheating on sutton foster with LBB?? no ? just me ??
Claire Beirne thought that was just a rumor
Approved! 💗💗💗😂💗
The fact that Orpheus from Hadestown is not S tier. He literally would go to hell for you! Smh
Okay but imagine being Orpheus next girlfriend though...
@@heartears In the myth he was so sad and swore to never love again and became super sad and depressed and only sang sad stuff and wherever he went everyone else was also sad until he was murdered by Dionysus’ groupies because he wouldn’t party with them and oaky happy upbeat music anymore 😳
He’s also dumb as hell, was so distracted by writing his song that he let his fiancée starve, and he was so insecure that he looked back. I love him to death but he’s B tier at best
@@bibliophilecb The cons of dating a musician but no one's perfect when it came down to it he went to rescue Eurydice and I really can't blame him for his insecurities. He was making a deal with a god, something very few heroes could do let alone a common musician?
@@amphitritemists4595 haha as a musician myself, fair, but that doesn’t excuse his friend Hermes literally saying “it’s not a trick dumbass” and then him still going “hmm must be a trick” 😂
“he’s also really clingy” yeah, i could take the murder stuff but being clingy... oof
Julia THE swiftie 😂😂
SIS I- 😂
A Taylor stan AND a musical theatre enthusiast??
@@gordby5013 you okay?
Omg, he’s so clingy that he hangs outside your house all night... so that he can kill you and explain his plan to bomb a pep rally, BUt the mAin thing is the clinginess
I lost it at Pros: He's a musician. Cons: He's a musician.
"He is a literal con man, and worse than that, he's a musician." It got better
Even as a lesbian, I just KNOW that Enroljas goes above Marius, that just makes sense
Enjolras can wife me any day
I mean I'm pretty sure he mostly goes above Grantaire :3
@@kjelfalconer SBHSHSKDJK
"Don't let me drink wine and talk about musicals on the internet ever again."
Ok so we definitely need to get Kat to drink wine and talk about musicals on the internet again...and again...and again
“Stop romanticizing phantom. You deserve better”
Me: *sniffle* thank you 🥰
I wouldn’t even want better though ;-;
Enjolras is just literally the perfect man. That’s part of why he could never be the perfect boyfriend because he’s so much better and above all that. Still S tier though because I’m willing to be the unrecognized supportive wife as long as it’s Enjolras.
Yeah in the book he is described as not caring about any romance, only caring for France and the revolution.
@@luthientinuviel3883 and in the musical he only cares about revolution AND Grantaire
The only problem is he is in a very serious relationship with Grantaire
"The FBI might want him, but i want him more" LOL
I loved that so much cuz Frank is my biggest broadway crush 😂 thanks to it being Aaron Tveit.
Me: **silently moves Clyde up a space solely because Jeremy Jordan**
For real tho
Well... If you Want another Character from The same actor but with a healthy option you can Look up to Jack Kelly
Confession i can't take Jeremy Jordan as Clyde seriously because I've heard that voice from a alchemy teenager but Jeremy Jordan is top teir
Like I didn't mentally move up Elder Price and Marvin from Falsettos because they're played by two of my favorite actors.
Why wasn’t fiyero in here he is a dream boyfriend
he’d be B tier ngl
he’s charming, funny
but the cons are that he will probably find another girl who’s better than you and leave you
Yasss agreeable
Cuz he’s been thinking 😔
@@purpleisraiyen he did that ONE TIME 🤣
"pros: hes a musician cons: hes a musician" as a musician- FELT THAT
Oh yeah it's a little too accurate XD
The fact that “he would murder for you” came us SO MANY TIMES is concerning
And honestly? I get it about Enjolras, especially Aaron Tveit as Enjolras. I’ve had a crush on that man since 2012 because of the Les Mis movie 😂
SAME. and when Brain Dead came out I was so excited. Gareth is awesome.
There are many a comment under my favorite Next to Normal bootleg talking about shirtless Aaron.
@@Blue-xt7kc I may or may not be one of those comments 😂
Me: WhAt AbOuT pErCy JaCkSoN! Completely forgetting he’s 12 and it’s creepy for Kat to rate him
I feel this! I started reading the books when I was the same age as Percy is in the first one and now I'm too old to read the Lightening Thief and sigh over him! It's super weird.
@Farabee Pushpita Right?!
OH MY GOSH IM NOT THE ONLY ONE!!
Yeh lol
Enjolras’s to-do list
1. France
2. His hair
3. Revolution (for France)
4. Grantaire (putting the bottle down)
5. Falling out a window (preferably with flag of France)
6. Idk prob France (or Grantaire)
Omg! That is perfect!
underated comments yesssss
Yep
Anshsjskj yeah
more like jefferson or lafayette’s to do list
Can we just take a second to appreciate the perfection that is Dmitri from Anastasia???
"Hi, I'm Kat, and I really like musicals"
The Girl Who Really Likes Musicals vs The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals
XD I'm sorry
Paul is A tier.
Pros is pretty nice, will respect your boundaries, is a lovable dork.
Cons can be kind of boring, does not like musicals.
@@rockassassin64 AGREED!!
@kevin willems ...yes, I know that..
Usnavi deserves to be in the upper tier, he's such a sweet guy! Plus, he'll always give you your coffee for free.
More people I’d like to see on the list: fiyero, rapunzel’s prince, Aaron from mean girls, frank butler, Henry Higgins, Anthony from Sweeney Todd, Rodger from Rent, Tony from West Side Story, and Dmitri from Anastasia
THIS!!!
Tony!!! Yes!
Dimitri! Yas!
ADD GLEB PLS
Henry Higgins is toxic garbo, give me Freddie!!!
How dare you, Jack Kelly is ABSOLUTELY S tier.
IKRRRR
Part 2 should include:
Evan Hansen, Davey, Crutchie, Bert,
Fiyero, The Baker, the guy from Pippin (I forgot his name,) the beast, Aladdin, Lucas from the Addams Family, Aaron Samuels, Dmitri from Anastasia, Christian from Moulin Rouge, Charlie from Kinky Boots and Kristof
and dmitri from anastasia!
Evan Hansen is surely F or even worse.
YES WE STAN LUCAS!!!!
ALSO DMITRI
lola rose YESS
"Pros: He will love you so much he will commit murder for you."
"Cons: He will commit murder..."
I died
enjolras does have a vibe, there's something about leading a revolution that is very very very hot
George Washington...
You know you’re watching a good production of les mis when you see enjolras and think “well guys that’s it, guess I’m going to die because there’s no way I could not join this revolution”
it helps that aaron tveit has played him
K: *says how romanticising Phantom is bad*
Also K: *confesses her crush on fictional characters who also done bad*
Me: Katherine, you're drunk, please sleep. XD
Facts
Kinda sad that she said that cause Phantom was judged all his life just for his face and it was sad that noone loved him and that all people did was cower in fear cause of his face. All Phantom wanted was love, but all people cared about was looks. And I bet that if Phantom was real and he was in todays society he would still get judged even now. Sure he did bad things but everyone does something bad in their life. So for me I felt bad for Phantom cause people just judged him without even taking the time to truly get to know him. I know deep down that Phantom is actually a pretty sweet guy if you ever get to know him.
@@robloxiangameplay6972 Me too. Phantom/Erik deserves better.
@@superdisney5535So true he definitely deserves better. Every time I watch the show I cry every time and want to give the Phantom a hug so bad
very specific but jelani alladin’s kristoff in frozen is everything i’ve ever wanted
YESSS THAT KRISTOFF ACOUSTIC GUITAR SOLO ♥️♥️♥️😭
Yes he is so GREAT!
seaweed and emmett being at the top is perfection. because they are perfection.
IF YOU ARE READING THIS YOU ARE LOVED. DON'T LET ANYONE TELL YOU OTHERWISE.
You too! You are enough! Your are so enough! It's incredible how enough you are!
I actually needed to hear that today. Thank you ❤️
@@kandyappleviewawww of course!! i will keep you on my mind and in my heart!!
I like ur user name
YOU TOO! YOU ARE ALSO ENOUGH AND CAN DO ALL THE THINGS!! I BELIEVE IN YOU!
Idk why that pic of LMM is in there... but he's 100% S tier.
I’ve never been this early to our cult meetings
Edit: thanks for the likes omg I’ve never gotten more then 10
sameee
Neither have I
Yeah, its a first for me to
Abigail Keehn she liked it but then it unliked ☹️
he's young scrappy and hungee--
😳
*_hungee???_*
I’d go with Jack Kelly. Because, I mean, Jeremy Jordan has the voice of a literal angel. That’s all it takes for me
I also love Jeremy as Varian. Been a fan of him since 2012
I’d go with Jack Kelly because he’s Jack Kelly
Lisa D Love your profile picture. I’m a Dodgers fan too
Same, but for me it’s Christian Bale.
any character played by Jeremy Jordan is s tier no discussion
kat talking about fictional broadway men? i came as soon as i heard
"Theyre still fictional regardless so your decision is arbitrary and you're still hauntingly alone" I feel called out on a deep emotional level
I gave this a ‘like’ the moment she said, “still hauntingly alone”. Girl, I feel that.
My favorite line from Legally Blonde, "and I don't have to hit on interns professor" especially if the Emmett kinda makes fun of the word "professor"
Yes. One of my fav lines from Legally Blonde.
Best line.
The one dislike is the Rum Tum Tugger lmao
Zachary Walker and his stans like me>:(( (I didn’t actually dislike the video for different opinions though)
Rip there's way more than 1 now 🤦🏼♂️
I'd only put him in D tier because he's played by Terrence Mann looolll
Love how Jeremy Jordan plays three of the characters in this tier list 😂😂
Talking about boys, drinking Rosé whine and no pants is giving me girls night nostalgia... Oh God I'm lonely right now
QOTD: I'mma say Persephone. Hades, I'm stealing yo girl, fite me.
“The FBI might want him, but I want him more”
Idk if anyone has pointed this out yet but ~technically~ Seymour didn’t really kill anyone. The dentist killed himself (after trying to harm Seymour through unnecessary mouth surgery) and Audrey II killed the shop owner. If anything he’s an accessory to murder. This is the hill I will die on
He still chops up the bodies and feeds them to the plant.
Personally, I am not in the mood for dating. I would love to hang out with Heather Macnamara. She seems nice.
Ya same
What about Heather Chandler?
Heather Chandler I’d love to hang out with you, too
Just make sure it's post musical Mac
Saaame. I just want to hang out with Heather Macnamara and Karen to form our own non-toxic female power group
QOTD: emmet from legally blonde, Link Larkin and seaweed, JD but he’s hella problematic, honestly Jeremy from be more chill but like, after the squip,
I just like the nerdy boys, and the problematic bad boys. 😅
EDIT: And model from fiddler
Edit again: literally any of the newsies boys
I never realized that Orpheus could be played by Timothee Chalamet and now I wanna cry. I don't know if this is a good or bad thing
Oh my word I would cry. I feel like Timothee would be a better NYTW Orpheus than a Broadway Orpheus. Broadway Orpheus is a total dork and I personally feel like Timothee doesn’t fit that vibe? But him and Damon in the same role ... 🥵
As soon as you pulled out the wine I thought “well she can’t drink by herself” and poured a glass 🍷
QOTD: jeremy jor- jack kelly. I meant jack kelly.
Honestly me with Ben Cook
Spot c Collins he’s so muscular
Maddie H he’s a flirt, a complete egomaniac, the fact is he’s also the face of the strike
@@HeatherChandlerBQ what a face- Face the fact
Katara Lynn that’s a face that could save us all from sinking in the ocean
I know this is a weird specific thing to ask, but I would be interested ti see you do a video on the sexism within musical theatre. I know that sexism is akward to talk about, but I would like to hear your thoughts on the repetitive sexist troopes. Such as the naive pretty woman who are just like the old 'ideal woman'; the Madonna vs. Whore complex (like in Les Miserables or Hamilton); the idea of the female muse to a man; the over perfect persona in many females; how so many females big song and character drive is love. I would love to hear you talk about that as well as maybe sexism offstage? A topic I want more people to talk about.
Hamilton is an historical "accurated" musical, so your comparison doesn't make sense.
@@enzojose4001 Well it isn't completely accurate. For instance Angelica was already married before Eliza and Alexander married, and also it was Peggy who helped Alexander and Eliza get together, not Angelica. And with the topic of sexism in the show, Peggy wasn't the seductress as in Say No To This. She also did know about the letter from her husband and wrote to Alexander beforehand to warn him. It seemed she even blamed herself and felt guilt as in one of her letters to him she wrote something along the lines of "I wish I did not exist". (There is a video somewhere on RUclips that gives a historic account of Maria's situation.) And yet she is reduced to a women who is only seen as sexy, and not a young mother in a abusive marriage trying to help her daughter. So the Madonna Whore complex is still there. And it's sad how much Maria is reduced to in the perspective of the show.
@@annarose932 And 90% of the characters are racist and supported slavery in real life. I really hate Hamilton musical because it's just an united states fairy tale.
@@enzojose4001 Yeah I think I do understand that. It does point out slavery but focuses on the privileged white people of the era, and although it doesn't shy away from the problems of the men in power, it paints them more as a hero. I don't think Lin meant to cause harm, and I feel that casting mainly non-white performers to play these historic figures was a help in giving more people of colour thr spotlight in which they don't deserve. And of course turning the roles around as it has been white people playing people of colour, as Cleopatra has been so many times consistently. Of course currently now the focus is to create more stories about people of colour.
QOTD: Seaweed or Emmit 100%. They're nice, supportive, funny, smart, and would absolutely stand by your side through thick and thin.
I love them too
How is Fiyero from Wicked not on here? The guy’s a smooth dancer and has proven his ability to grow as a human being and love someone well. And if we could date anyone and make them love us, I’d have to say Peter from Bare. Great call on Seaweed Stubbs, by the way. 👍🏻
QOTD: Benny from “In the Heights” (or am I just in love with Chris Jackson??). Either way, my heart flutters at the end of “When You’re Home” every time!
One of my favorite songs
The smoothness of his voice & his beautiful Smile! Come on! ❤️
And then he tries to learn Spanish to impress her parents 😍
disGraced ape Ninas parents you mean
I’m shocked and offended that Rum Tum Tugger was not in the S tier.
Finally, someone in this comments section with taste and culture!
Same
SAME
ITS A CAT THAT IS A CRIME
@@idontknowanymore9966 nonsense
QOTD: so the baker, is pure bb and I love him
Also OGIE FROM WAITRESS, I want him to recite poetry to me because he’s the best poet ever
And I want to be friends with Babara and Adam Maitland because I feel like they’d give great advice
Let me say this, I’ve had a crush on Jermey Jordan/ Jack ever since I first watched Newsies, but Davey is just as cute and dependable
This video has such chaotic energy and I’m honestly here for it
"The FBI Might want him, but I want him more."
I would hang out with basically all the Newsies, Mostly Race, Crutchie, and Albert.
Oh and I would date Enjolras...
👉🏻👉🏻
@@asexualbert7262 my life is complete
enjolras would cheat on you with france. and grantaire. risky choice there, broski.
"He is a literal con-man and WORSE than that... He is a Musician!"
I wouldn't mind being in a one-sided relationship with Enjolras, after all he is a total badass
I would just enjoy sitting back and watching him fight for france.
I think you just like Jeremy Jordan in general because you just put him on that list THREE TIMES!!!😂 plus two other roles that he has played or is going to play in the future, but I won’t judge😂
*hang out/go on a date with a broadway character OH HELL YES IM HANGING OUT WITH BEETLEJUICE-*
Yep! Exactly! 😏💚💜
Jasmien Debonnet
*IS IT BAD I FOCUS MORE ON BEETLEJUICE THEN THE TEST THAT LITERALLY DECIDES MY FUTURE-*
@@crawley.crowley4630 Maybe... It's very understandable though 😌😉😅
Jasmien Debonnet
*screw the test, the musical changed my life-*
@@crawley.crowley4630 Yeah mine too 😊😃
Emmett Forrest - the guy who cares enough to push you to reach your true potential knowing you have it in you, realizes he can learn a thing or two from you, and stands up to his boss after said boss sexually harasses you - is absolutely S tier.
WHEN YOU SAID ENJOLRAS’S TIER LIST WITH GRANTAIRE AS HIS NUMBER TWO PRIORITY I NEARLY CHOKED REMEMBERING ALL THE LES MIS FANFICTIONS I READ IN MIDDLE SCHOOL
I can’t stop romanticizing Erik. I know I deserve better, but if I get the romanticized version, I don’t want better. Give me the Phantom, I want.
I'm in geometry rn but neverless this is the quickest I've been to click on a new video haha
Yup
Me too 😭😭
I left my biology class for Andrew Feldman's insta livestream with Rob Manion...
IM IN SCIENCE NOW
I'm in geometry too rn 😂
Seaweed as S tier is such a no brainer; that boy is just *chefs kiss*
You're not alone. Enjolras is my love, both because of who he is as a character, and because Aaron Tveit is gorgeous and talented!
enjolras definitely has a vibe. it doesn't hurt that he always seems to be played by the most attractive man in the cast lmao
Question of the day answer: Dimitri from Anastasia!! (TBH just because Derek Klena)
I saw Derek in a production of Hairspray my senior year. He was Link
What's Enjolras' priority?
Madison: France
My Broadway crushes:
Dewey Finn - School of Rock
Emmet Forrest - Legally Blonde (And I don’t have to hit on interns will never not be iconic)
Nick Bottom - Something Rotten
Nigel Bottom - Something Rotten
The Baker - Into the Woods
Mendel Weisenbachfeld - Falsettos
Henry - Next to Normal
Boq - Wicked
Fiyero - Wicked
Davey - Newsies
Dmitri - Anastasia
Christian - Moulin Rouge
Also, would being in love with an anthropomorphic cat be classed as Beastiality?
It wouldn’t, because they’re still basically humanoid. It’s more in line with having a crush on a furry, or even a like catboy depending on how realistic the costume is. So if you do, it’s fine. Kinda weird, but fine.
The issue with beastiality is a lack of consent, not that they're anthropomorphic, and it would probably be easier to list anthros who aren't able to consent. So, don't worry, let your love for anthros run wild and free.
omg i have an unhealthy crush on davey too
DMITRI DESERVED BETTER
I really wanted Kath to talk about Fiyero, because I'm so interested in her take on him. Almost marry one woman even though you like another?
Emmet’s comeback line in legally blonde comes right after he volunteers to help Elle in the courtroom and says , “and I don’t have to hit on interns, professor” for anyone else who was wondering
QOTD: I would die for Aaron Tveit. So I'm gonna say Enjolras but like to hang out because Enjoltaire
And I would die for Jamie Muscato
ikd if it's just that I love Newsies, but Jack seems perfect to me!
"Because the FBI might want him, but I want him more"... Omg, that is such a mood, haha
QOTD: Christian from Moulin Rouge as in AARON TVEIT, just lemme dream it oKAY?!
QOTD: anyone, literally anyone, even JD, because I'm ✨lonely✨
What about Heather Chandler?
Honestly I think most Heathers fan girls live in the fantasy that if THEY were dating JD like they could change him and he'd be a better person because of them (at least I know I do...)
*slushy noises intensify*
Abigail Warner I’m a super fan of Heathers but why do so many people love JD
@Heather Chandler YES
“That’s me. I am girls.”
-Drunk Kat 2020
Oh great cult leader, give us strength
Me: I mean like JD would be a S tier
My internal voice: He is a fucking serial killer and a sociopath
Me: But... But... Ryan McCartan is hot
My internal voice: Yes but JD is psychotic
Me: Well you say tomato I say "tomato"
My internal voice: Stop quoting Heaters he is a serial killer arguement closed
Me: But... Ok you are right.
@@tatianagois7291 Lmao glad I am not the only one or I would feel really weird.
I’m supposed to be in school right now... well actually I’m in a google meet right now but this is more important so I’m gonna watch this
The great thing about online class is that you can be watching something completely different in another tab and as long as your mic is off, no one will be the wiser.
I’m only six minutes in, but I’m already in love with this video. Everything you say is so relatable
I think Emmett's big line is "and I don't have to hit on interns, *professor* "
"Is that just me defending my crush to my friends??"
Me: ooh so that's what I do.... it all makes sense now 😂😔🤦🏼♀️
I realized what having a Stage-Crush was when my high school did Les Mis. HUGE crush on the kid playing Enjorlas, but only when he was playing the part on stage lol
KAT NOW YOU HAVE ME THINKING ABOUT TIMOTHEE CHALAMET AS MARIUS OR ORPHEUS AND I CAN'T STOP
QOTD: Marius or Orpheus! The Timotheé Chálamet joke you made called me out! I also love Emmett, the way he was there for Elle!
@@madisonh.2992 haha true dat, when I first listened to Les Mis, I was like why don't Cosette and Eponiné go after each other and leave Marius alone!
I saw Jeremy Jordan and was like “oooooo” I didn’t even read the title
This is so fun!!
Oh man there's alot of Broadway crushes lol
Okay so: and the list keeps getting longer
Dewey Finn (School of Rock)
Frank Abignal (and yes he has a tough name!! Abig-nail is how Ive heard its pronounced lol Catch Me If You Can, and hes real so I know hes a good man whose happily married!)
Seaweed (Hairspray)
Usnavi (In the Heights)
Harold Hill (Music Man)
Christian (Cuz Aaron needs to be on this list twice 😂)
Emmet!! ("And I don't have to hit on interns." Best line!! Legally Blonde.)
And my OG crush Raoul!!
Oh my gosh how could I forget Percy!! Scarlett Pimpernel is amazing. My favorite book and now I can add Percy on the list of musical dream dates!!
I’m glad I’m not the only one who had a crush on Harold Hill 😳 lol
@@leo8812 right?! I just find him so....clever? And fun. I know hes a con artist but as far as bad boys go I could do worse!! 😂
Yeah, Harold Hill is attractive. I even had a crush on the Matthew Broderick Harold Hill as a kid 😂
@@gracieliz95 Me too!!
Dewey will definitely be a good dad.
Ok look, I started watching this and was reminded how much I thought I would want to date you because you're wine-d up chaotic energy is cute as hell. By the time you gave the warning about not watching this, I was already too far in and had to see it to the end, this was brilliant
If i could hang out with a broadway character, I’d hang out with Orpheus. We are very similar personality wise and I also think we’d just understand each other. A lot of people always blame him for the whole writing a song while starving thing. but to me it seemed like he was hyperfixating on the song and that’d be okay for me because I too, hyperfixate on stuff... so yeah
QOTD: Raoul. Specifically Hadley Fraser’s Raoul 😍😍😍 he would literally DIE for you!!