IGN Review Scores For Racing Games Make NO Sense

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 авг 2023
  • IGN is a major player in the game review scene. Despite that, they often fall under scrutiny by the gaming community for their review scores. How did IGN rate various racing games? We are taking a look at their very own Top 100 ranking of racing games.
    ▼ MORE INFO DOWN BELOW ▼
    ► Catch me live on Twitch!: / dustineden
    Watch my Gaming Challenges live and interact with me!
    ► Join our Discord!: / discord
    Get notified about everything I'm up to such as new videos and livestreams!
    ► Follow me:
    Twitter: / dustinedenyt
    Instagram: / dustinedenyt
    Xbox Live Gamertag: EdenGamingYT
    ► Edited by: JamesVariety - / jam35var1ety
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 470

  • @robby-8625
    @robby-8625 11 месяцев назад +248

    List of red flags:
    Narcissism
    Doesn’t like my friends
    Distrustfulness
    Takes IGN as gospel

    • @pixelluka07
      @pixelluka07 11 месяцев назад

      So its fine if im a nazi

    • @CyanRooper
      @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +12

      Also doesn't think that the Golf is better.

    • @jonatanrobledo9812
      @jonatanrobledo9812 11 месяцев назад +3

      ​@@CyanRooper
      And if they deny that Yugo is better. RUN AWAY

    • @plsdontbanmeagainyoulibtards
      @plsdontbanmeagainyoulibtards 9 месяцев назад

      anyone who uses an IGN score or review to recommend or not recommend a game is an immediate red flag and you should call the psych ward on them for their own safety.

    • @THEREALTICKLEMYELMO
      @THEREALTICKLEMYELMO 7 месяцев назад

      1: sure 2: maybe you got shit friends 3: Refer to #1 4: IGN does not even think their word is true

  • @existentialselkath1264
    @existentialselkath1264 11 месяцев назад +405

    I think they backed themselves into a corner with forza especially. The games kept being 'more' so they got higher and higher scores almost out of obligation, irrelevant to whether they actually got better.

    • @bigsmoke5814
      @bigsmoke5814 11 месяцев назад +5

      They fh5 10 meanwhilenit doesn't deserve 10 out of 10. its for me is 8. forza horizon 4 is 9.5 and better gane than fh5.

    • @tippiebekfast
      @tippiebekfast 11 месяцев назад +22

      ​@@bigsmoke5814 fh3 is a 10 fh4 is 7 and fh5 is 6.5

    • @cjskater2006
      @cjskater2006 11 месяцев назад +9

      All of them are extremely overrated except for the first one, which is underrated. People like to pretend like their first FH is the best one but honestly, if it wasn't FH1 then its the same game as all the rest. I own and have played all of them. If you've played FH5 you've played FH2 because it's the same game but with less features and a much more annoying open world experience. If they made a FH that included every previous map there would be no reason to play any FH 2-5.

    • @bigsmoke5814
      @bigsmoke5814 11 месяцев назад +2

      @@cjskater2006 yeah i heard lot of people even youtubers.saying that the first fh is so much better than what we have now.

    • @mtho3509
      @mtho3509 11 месяцев назад +10

      I feel like the game hasn't gotten better, just bigger. they do however keep giving FIFA the same score, despite it having the same thing to it

  • @itsgiants150
    @itsgiants150 11 месяцев назад +511

    Imagine listening to IGN

    • @liesideways
      @liesideways 11 месяцев назад +19

      Luke Reilly though😢

    • @Jar3xe
      @Jar3xe 11 месяцев назад

      Imagine if someone in this world does in the past.

    • @CyanRooper
      @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +2

      I Guess Not (geddit?)

    • @beautyisontheinside
      @beautyisontheinside 11 месяцев назад +10

      Even if you don’t, thousands of people unfortunately do. And that can be deadly for smaller studios.

    • @thisemptyworm4677
      @thisemptyworm4677 11 месяцев назад +2

      or any other major reviewers...
      Just judge the games yourself

  • @katarn109
    @katarn109 11 месяцев назад +174

    In defense of F355 there was almost nothing really like it. And the arcade cabinet was a a full sim with FFB.

    • @THENAMEISQUICKMAN
      @THENAMEISQUICKMAN 11 месяцев назад +33

      F355 is a seriously underrated game. It's super fun, not many racing games in the arcade actually tried some simulation stuff aside from the odd... you know. Hard Drivin'. Blegh.

    • @SteveBrandon
      @SteveBrandon 11 месяцев назад +8

      F355 Challenge had a generous amount of tracks for a Dreamcast racing game (eleven, albeit one was just a "short" version of Suzuka obviously using a different configuration of the same map as the full Suzuka and the Fiorano test circuit was time-trial only). It's still one of my favourite racing games from the "turn of the millennium" era. Granted, it only had one car but when that car is a Ferrari, a game only having one car isn't so bad (and that's one more Ferrari than Gran Turismo had up until the PS3).

    • @Butterbean32
      @Butterbean32 11 месяцев назад +2

      I adore the F355 arcade cabinet, so much fun

    • @kekke2000
      @kekke2000 11 месяцев назад +11

      I am old enough to be slightly offended by his lack of knowledge about 355 Challenge. This was THE Racing Sim. We drove for hours to get to an arcade hall that had the good 355 cabinet with 3 screens. Then the comments about Micro Machines on Gameboy. Dustin has no conception of what that era was like. Which is fair because how would he, he wasn't there.

  • @CyanRooper
    @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +86

    "Need for Speed Prostreet just has a 7"
    You have to remember that Prostreet received mixed reviews when it came out unlike the previous games. Some liked it while others didn't. The Xbox 360 version in particular was hated because it had microtransactions (yes, microtransactions in 2007) where you could buy cars and upgrades using Microsoft Points (look them up).

    • @Hamisxa
      @Hamisxa 11 месяцев назад +5

      I remember, also remember the Wii version being better

    • @richardbhagan8949
      @richardbhagan8949 11 месяцев назад +5

      ​@Hamisxa You might be looking through rose-tinted glasses

    • @scottthewaterwarrior
      @scottthewaterwarrior 10 месяцев назад +6

      If only we could have kept up that mindset...
      Well, I mean I did, not just microtransactions, but any game that even includes them! But the general public didn't. Only game I even own with microtransactions is GTA V, but I don't actually play it, it just came with my PS3.

  • @dextera808
    @dextera808 11 месяцев назад +83

    "Too much racing"
    Score 7,8
    IGN moment

  • @ThunderTHR
    @ThunderTHR 11 месяцев назад +147

    My feeling has always been 'don't take review publications seriously'.
    Its hard to trust sources when it comes from multiple members who share differing opinions, but still treat it as if its the website as a whole. Thus resulting in many.. *questionable* review scores.
    *The only source you should trust is your own.*

  • @t4styp0t4t0
    @t4styp0t4t0 11 месяцев назад +84

    Not having a single GRID game on this list is criminal

    • @lshalo3
      @lshalo3 11 месяцев назад +2

      Which one would you like to see on it? Personally the original and the sequel were quite nice, like around 8ish. Top 100 is maybe a bit much

    • @dyaanahmad5079
      @dyaanahmad5079 11 месяцев назад

      Ah yes Grid 2

  • @shoonenur5679
    @shoonenur5679 11 месяцев назад +80

    I think for a finale to this series Dustin should make his own top 100 racing games of all time

  • @Lucas17031
    @Lucas17031 11 месяцев назад +132

    Can't spell Ignorant without IGN after all

    • @SonicBoone56
      @SonicBoone56 11 месяцев назад +6

      My favorite saying

    • @Jar3xe
      @Jar3xe 11 месяцев назад

      Clever

    • @CWINDOWSsystem32
      @CWINDOWSsystem32 11 месяцев назад

      I first saw this in the comments of their TDU2 review back when that game was new. I don't remember what they scored TDU2, but they didn't like it at all.

  • @thetexanhusky
    @thetexanhusky 11 месяцев назад +49

    1:06:48 - I wholeheartedly agree with this. Yearly games just don't cut it anymore. Whether or not it'll make just as much money as yearly games, I don't really have a concrete answer. The gaming industry should at least try this again.

    • @CheapBastard1988
      @CheapBastard1988 11 месяцев назад +3

      Charge $100 and update the game for two more seasons...

  • @SteveBrandon
    @SteveBrandon 11 месяцев назад +31

    OutRun 2 (or 2006 Coast 2 Coast) seems like the biggest omission to me, unless we're splitting hairs about what constitutes a "racing" game since the main mode was just racing against the clock (however several games that were on the list including Crazy Taxi were also "race against the clock" kind of games).

    • @paulnoell39
      @paulnoell39 9 месяцев назад +1

      OutRun 2 is a hugely slep on game. I loved it

  • @CyanRooper
    @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +27

    The reason why there used to be so many rally games back in the day is because rally as a sport used to be immensely popular during the 80s and 90s thanks to Group B and Group A regulations respectively. The popularity of rally racing died out in the 2000s as a result of Sebastien Loeb's insane dominance during that time period. He won the championship 9 times. And people complain about Hamilton and Verstappen's dominance in Formula 1.

    • @b.1570
      @b.1570 11 месяцев назад +2

      Not to give any demerit for Sebastien Loeb or anything. The guy is an absolute beast of a driver. Funny how the WRC from the 2000s and 2010s were dominated by two frenchman with name Sebastien.

    • @b.1570
      @b.1570 11 месяцев назад

      But I honestly don't think this was the main cause of rally racing games stopped from being popular. the DiRT series was still around on the late 2000s.

    • @CyanRooper
      @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +4

      @@b.1570 The FIA denied Loeb a Superlicence because he would have demolished most F1 drivers and he would have been a championship contender in F1 from the get-go. His most recent win was last year at the Monte Carlo rally near the age of 50.
      His dominance was terrible but I have immense respect for the man and I think he's one of the best drivers period.

    • @CyanRooper
      @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@b.1570 Rally games continued to be made moreso due to the popularity of things like the Gymkhana videos and other extreme sports being popular on RUclips.

    • @elizacevert4017
      @elizacevert4017 11 месяцев назад

      @@CyanRooperthey denied him a super license because he had basically no single-seater experience whatsoever aside from a few test days he did with Red Bull. He probably would’ve done well, sure, but so would’ve Valentino Rossi, and he also had only done a few private tests with Ferrari and was still denied one.

  • @Aidan_-_
    @Aidan_-_ 11 месяцев назад +23

    We are missing :
    - GT4
    - GT1
    - Racedriver Grid (best game ever)
    - Grid 2
    - NFS Carbon
    - NFS Pro Street
    - Mario Kart Wii
    - Dirt 3
    - Nascar Thunder 2004
    - Nascar 14
    - Driver San Francisco
    and probably more that i forgot.

  • @apaceofchange94
    @apaceofchange94 11 месяцев назад +7

    That Rick and Morty joke almost went over my head until I looked at the author of the review lol

  • @ItsJabo
    @ItsJabo 11 месяцев назад +18

    Mario Kart 64 being 110th is a crime. ALSO the Stuntman games are super fun!

    • @ittylink
      @ittylink 9 месяцев назад

      Mario Kart 64's score shows something is definitely wrong with IGN.

    • @turkeyman631
      @turkeyman631 5 месяцев назад

      Lol it's actually crazy

  • @MSX
    @MSX 11 месяцев назад +8

    34:44 It's not a prototype, it's a pre-production video, a concept so to speak, which outlines the developer's plan and vision for the project. The prototype of the second Blur has already been leaked on the net, and it looks different. I once did a review of the whole Blur series, and focused on the sequel. You should watch it, it has English subtitles.

  • @cylintruclemachin9560
    @cylintruclemachin9560 11 месяцев назад +8

    Not a single Trackmania games....
    What a shame

  • @fishiii2648
    @fishiii2648 11 месяцев назад +29

    Man this editing is just on point. You're the Real Deal. Keep it up champ

  • @badandens
    @badandens 11 месяцев назад +7

    Beetle Adventure Racing is one of my faves. please stream it. tracks are very unique with lots of side paths. Please stream it!

  • @blinkachu5275
    @blinkachu5275 11 месяцев назад +5

    What's important to realize is that games like Dirt Track Racing were rated years ago. So while an 8.7 seems high for a game such as that, when it was released in 99 it likely was quite a quality release.

  • @InternetMouse
    @InternetMouse 11 месяцев назад +11

    Welcome back dustin eden. Your viewpoints on racing games as whole has more weight, authenticity and accuracy than i ever did listening to. Half of IGns Ratings/review

  • @Blaza303
    @Blaza303 11 месяцев назад +10

    I'd like to see Edens personal top 100 list

    • @user-pm3nh5ww1q
      @user-pm3nh5ww1q 11 месяцев назад

      YES

    • @CyanRooper
      @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +1

      The first 15 places would be filled with Gran Turismo, Burnout, Midnight Club, Need for Speed and Forza games respectively. Beyond that would probably be stuff like Test Drive Unlimited, Grid, Blur, Split Second, Driveclub, Driver etc.

    • @Blaza303
      @Blaza303 11 месяцев назад

      @CyanRooper everything in it's right place

  • @ArbitraryOutcome
    @ArbitraryOutcome 11 месяцев назад +6

    Never forget when TXR Zero got around an 8 but every subsequent Shutokou/Kaido game got around a 6 or less despite being generally decent (Kaido Battle 3/TXR Drift 2 notably was hit with a 4 despite probably holding up the best of any of Genki's racers imo).

  • @darkprincesora8091
    @darkprincesora8091 11 месяцев назад +29

    IGN can never be trusted, also now you know we have to do what IGN consider to be great racing games

  • @collincreeden2862
    @collincreeden2862 11 месяцев назад +8

    Real racing 2 was my game in middle/highschool, I played that game for hours and for a mobile game, it felt fantastic

    • @LotsOfToubleUsuallySerious
      @LotsOfToubleUsuallySerious 11 месяцев назад +1

      The 3rd one is also really great in handling, gameplay graphics and overall content, but i guess great cannot be written without EA...
      The progression was just not good, maybe better than ehatever the fuck was NFS No Limits, but it was still essentially a free-to-*pay* mobile game with EA behind most of the monetizing decisions

  • @JinteiModding
    @JinteiModding 11 месяцев назад +8

    That intro is so terrifying, amazing 🗿

  • @jlcool13
    @jlcool13 11 месяцев назад +3

    Ferrari F355 has a console and a arcade cabinet the cabinet is actually crazy it’s designed with 3 screen setup in a first person pov

    • @roflBeck
      @roflBeck 10 месяцев назад

      I've seen that cabinet running before, looks really cool.

  • @Stormkrasher
    @Stormkrasher 11 месяцев назад +2

    Fun fact on Project Cars 2, there was an overclocking bug on PC1 where if you were running your CPU OC'd, then you'd be faster than the genuine aliens of the game. This was eventually patched (as you'd expect) and that was the end of it (or so we thought). Then along comes PC2 and somehow of all bugs to carry over to PC2, the OC bug was back, but only for AMD processors. I found this out by accident half a year after PC2 had launched (that's just when I got it as a gift and wild that the bug still persisted) as I was just doing random online lobbies to get accustomed to more cars and was immediately framed as a hacker because a bug from PC1 that was patched, had somehow made its way back into PC2 and had to be patched a second time over.

  • @justletitsliiide
    @justletitsliiide 11 месяцев назад +8

    Stuntman is super fun! I havent played it since I was a little kid but I used to spend hours in the sandbox mode (or whatever its called) you can use whatever vehicle and make crazy setups like ramps and what not

  • @drift_works
    @drift_works 11 месяцев назад +5

    missing games in my opinion:
    -MotorStorm Pacific Rift (probably the best in the series although i prefer apocalypse personally but thinking that PR came out way back in 2008.. just wow)
    -Driver San Francisco, a masterpiece of a game
    -Test Drive Unlimited 1&2, need to explain?
    -Split Second, not a fan of the game, but I still understand the importance of the game
    -Driveclub, every time i play driveclub i can feel the love and the passion of all the developers dedicated into the game...sony i hate you
    -Dirt 3, dirt 2 is still the goat, it doesn't have the same character as the previous one, but they have come very close, I really like the game
    -Baja edge of control, a weird one yes, I never played such a unique game, it's not a 10/10 game, but I recommend to try it for anyone who wants a completely new experience!
    -NFS MW2 BETA, I close the comment with this last game, few will understand what I mean...
    "driver is suspected to be the Rockport Fugitive, driver Remains Most Wanted"
    do i need to say anything else?

    • @CyanRooper
      @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +2

      The Most Wanted 2 beta doesn't really count as a "game" as it's just a beta and not the actual game that we got (still agree with you though that the beta is what we should've gotten).

    • @FurryestX
      @FurryestX 11 месяцев назад

      DriveClub still has Better Visuals than GT7 or FM8, and the Gameplay and Control is Awesome
      Even with "Hard Control" and A SimRacing Wheel, it still XTREME POTENTIAL for a Simulation game

    • @drift_works
      @drift_works 11 месяцев назад

      @@FurryestX yea thats the point

    • @xdog12
      @xdog12 11 месяцев назад

      At 21:26 you can see a thumbnail for Motorstorm PR. Not sure why Wipeout HD used that thumbnail.

  • @An94boi
    @An94boi 11 месяцев назад +3

    I'd love to see a playthrough of both Stuntman and Stuntman Ignition! Both are such unique games that deserve a look at.

  • @themightymitsubishilancere8027
    @themightymitsubishilancere8027 11 месяцев назад +3

    Dustin Eden ur my fav gran turismo 4 RUclips, I used to watch ur gt4 vids and saying that I want a ps2 with gt4 so badly, and thanks to u they gifted me a ps2 and gran turismo 4 [PAL] in my bday,
    Eden if ur reading this remember that, ur thr best gran turismo 4 RUclipsr in the world and have a good day
    Edit: he hasnt Still readed comment :(

  • @THENAMEISQUICKMAN
    @THENAMEISQUICKMAN 11 месяцев назад +5

    LONG OPINION THREAD AS I WATCH THE VIDEO -
    If you play fighting games you know just how useless mainstream ratings are when it comes to genres that aren't the typical action, adventure or RPG.
    Noticing chat and a lot of comments not getting that a lot of these reviews were done on RELEASE DAY, so anyone complaining "HOW CAN OLD JANK GAME HAVE HIGHER SCORE THAN NEW GAME?" is stupid. They also take into account consoles, which is why games on stuff like GBA or shitty handhelds can get high scores just as much as something on modern systems. Literally the first game of this type and everyone in chat is already going "RATED HIGHER THAN MIDNIGHT CLUB LA?!!!!!" Yes, because it takes into account release date and platform.
    YES, absolutely play Stuntman. That game was one of my childhood favourites. It is absolutely *brutally* difficult, though. It's legit one of the hardest driving games ever made in terms of completing it.
    "THIS WAS 1989, THERE WAS NOTHING TO COMPARE IT TO" Racing games did exist before the fucking PS2, Eden, mate. Like there are classics from the mid 80s to early 90s that still stomp the majority of racing games being made today lmao.
    "You can differentiate between racing and driving games" Agreed, this was pretty much coined by Yu Suzuki when making the original OutRun in 1986. He didn't want people to think of it as a racing game but a driving experience.
    F355 Challenge is a really fun game, the reason it seems so "bare-bones" is that it's an arcade port. The arcade release actually had a "deluxe" cabinet with three screens that I have gotten to play a handful of times. It was very ambitious to release a sim racer, but as an arcade machine. I really don't care if a game only has one car and a few tracks, to be honest, because I'll play Daytona USA or F355 a thousand times each but not even touch some modern racing games more than once. It's all about the gameplay and how fun it is to replay.
    Eden confirmed to seriously not know any racing game from before, like, 2005.
    BLUR STANS RISE UP
    "Micro Machines 1 and 2 for Game Boy Color" Hey, remember what I said about console being taken into account in the score?
    "We haven't had a single Forza game yet, only DLCs. No Horizon or Motorsport." I haven't looked but I'm calling it now that all the mainline Forza games are just going to smother the top 20 and make the list entirely pointless.
    Wave Race: Blue Storm is a FANTASTIC game. I highly recommend it. One of the only games I gave a damn about when I owned a GameCube.
    "Where did the F-Zero franchise go?" I dunno, Nintendo just randomly decided they didn't want to make games that could convince me to buy their consoles anymore. Seriously my favourite Nintendo franchise and they just don't care because they've got 50 Mario, Zelda and Kirby games to make. And maybe a Metroid if you're a good boy this year.
    I'm surprised Daytona USA 2001 is on here and not the original. Even though the original was initially released in 1993 it still handles a lot better than 2001. Doesn't matter to me how shiny you make the visuals or if you add new content, if one simply plays better, that's the better game.
    Ridge Racer Type 4 is Gran Turismo 4's biggest competitor for "greatest PS exclusive racing game" for me. Super good to see it so high.
    Hell yeah PGR2. I like PGR4 more but PGR2 was so unique and special.
    FORZA FORZA FORZA FORZA FORZA
    Crazy Taxi is straight GOATed, I played it for hundreds of hours. I at one point had a top 10 score on the Xbox 360 leaderboards in it, before all the hacked $999,999.99 scores came in.
    FORZA FORZA FORZA FORZA FORZA FORZA FORZA FORZA FORZA FORZA
    Checkered Flag for Atari Lynx, greatest game of all time. God, I'm surprised they didn't put the Atari Jaguar version too. It's just as great! (Mediocre)
    POST LIST COMMENTS:
    Somehow these lists keep fucking sleeping on Outrun 2/Outrun 2006, literally a top 10 racing game of all time. There's also no Sega Rally or Sega Rally 2, two other legendary hits. However, the biggest exclusion... is that GRAN TURISMO 4 is not on this list. But it got a 9.5! They literally just randomly chose games and ignored higher rated ones! So this top 100 list isn't even close to correct!

    • @CyanRooper
      @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +2

      A lot of racing games from the 80s and 90s aren't appreciated as much these days because you need to have the proper hardware those games were designed for to enjoy them (arcade cabinet games or sim racing games like Grand Prix Legends, Geoff Crammond's Grand Prix series etc).
      Edit: I'm the same age as Edna so I don't know that much about all of the racing games from that time period but I can acknowledge that they were better than they look and were extremely influential.

  • @PieZello
    @PieZello 11 месяцев назад +2

    0:03 it’s so surreal seeing the track mod I made for Trial Mountain on Dustin’s intro WTF?

    • @JamVar
      @JamVar 11 месяцев назад

      Ayyy, great work on that track. The environment is stunning. Also, Autumn Ring and Midfield 👌

    • @PieZello
      @PieZello 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@JamVarthat’s awesome thank youu I’m curious how you got the AI to sit still like that on the track?

    • @JamVar
      @JamVar 11 месяцев назад

      @@PieZello ​ That's actually a track day session with "walking_out" from Assetto Corsa's config folder enabled so I can jump from car to car in the pits and set them up myself.

  • @roydied15
    @roydied15 9 месяцев назад +2

    I vividly remember “stuntman” as being the first of two games ever that actually made me so mad that I broke a controller. The other was “Tourist Trophy” Lmao

  • @HammMann
    @HammMann 11 месяцев назад +3

    20:31 The iPod you're most likely talking about is a 5th Gen Nano, that's the one with the most features. If you still have that iPod though, i would put it far away from any of your drawers... Because nowadays, ESPECIALLY on the 5th Gen, the batteries have a tendency to explode.

  • @CristianSandovalC
    @CristianSandovalC 11 месяцев назад +1

    Son las 1:45 am donde vivo y Dustin cree que me veré un video de 1 hora y media? Por supuesto que si.

  • @breannathompson9094
    @breannathompson9094 9 месяцев назад +1

    Bruh why did i think the intro was just an intro from one of the need for speeds i didnt play?

  • @BananaChair89
    @BananaChair89 11 месяцев назад +14

    I think the only place where you can really find a realistic score for games in general is steam, because there you'll find people who know the genre, played the game to its full potential and compare it to the other experiences with other games of the same type. obviously there you'll not be able to find playstation exclusives or older games that did not get released on steam, but for the games that you can find you'll have the most realistic rating.

    • @almightysamwhich4203
      @almightysamwhich4203 11 месяцев назад +3

      Steam also has some of the funniest ratings

    • @CyanRooper
      @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +15

      "The people who make Overwatch porn put in more effort than the people who made Overwatch 2" - Chad Steam reviewer

  • @transam33o
    @transam33o 11 месяцев назад +12

    TDU2 being rated 5.5 actually kind of shocked me

    • @crispybottom
      @crispybottom 11 месяцев назад +15

      Nah, it makes sense, TDU2 at release was an unplayable, buggy mess with terrible physics, non-functioning online and awful, grindy progression. It took a decade of work, first by the devs, then by modders to fix the game, add missing content and get it to where it's at right now, and nothing can 100% fix the physics or the progression (IMO TDU1 is still a much better game, if only it wasn't so constrained by technology of the time)

    • @CyanRooper
      @CyanRooper 11 месяцев назад +1

      All of the people that praise TDU 2 are the ones who played the game after installing a metric fuck ton of mods to make the game enjoyable.

    • @ThunderTHR
      @ThunderTHR 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@crispybottom This is something I feel a lot of people have forgotten about. As someone who also played the game at launch, it was a disaster. The fixes from both the devs and later the modders, made it a much more enjoyable experience.. even if I think TDU1 aswell was also better.

    • @GTPlanetFamine
      @GTPlanetFamine 11 месяцев назад +1

      because it isn't good no matter how much revionism is being done by TDU SC fanboys

    • @BDozer666
      @BDozer666 11 месяцев назад

      Deserved score for being such a bad sequel.

  • @InsanityPrevails
    @InsanityPrevails 11 месяцев назад +2

    Micro Machine's review was for the Game Boy Color version of the game like you saw the gameplay of, but Mickey's Speedway's review was also for the Game Boy Color, not for the N64 version :P

  • @r3mx556
    @r3mx556 11 месяцев назад +4

    A round of applause for our saviour - Checkered Flag!
    👏

  • @Dr.Stoeffloev
    @Dr.Stoeffloev 11 месяцев назад +4

    I think Richard Burns Rally deserves a spot. It’s very unknown compared to most on the list but it’s to this day pretty much the best rally sim ever made and has a huge modding community. It’s difficult af for me and it’s a bitch to set up but I don’t think that you can get much better than RBR in terms of rally simulation.

    • @SupernovaeTech
      @SupernovaeTech 8 месяцев назад

      With the RallySimFans installer it's extremely easy to set up. It's wild how much better the modern modded version is than the original though.

  • @Flinnowaty
    @Flinnowaty 11 месяцев назад +9

    I expected this list to be bad, but holy shit. The fact that TDU 1 & 2 are not on this list is criminal. Also not a single GRID game.
    Imagine listening to IGN when it comes to games, or anything.

  • @percher4824
    @percher4824 11 месяцев назад +1

    I'm hella looking forward to seeing a video on Wreckless: The Yakuza Missions if that was the plan

  • @DatWut
    @DatWut 11 месяцев назад +3

    33:36 - didn't Blur kinda market itself like a "Mario Kart for big boys"? I mean, the TV spots kinda did that at least.

  • @Sparkcell275
    @Sparkcell275 11 месяцев назад +1

    Nothing like coming home to an eden video lol!

  • @thomadan000
    @thomadan000 11 месяцев назад +1

    Hey I’ve got that Heat board game, that shit is actually super fun. They basically turned 1960s Formula 1 into a tabletop game.

  • @MHoang1312
    @MHoang1312 8 месяцев назад

    Anybody know the background music from 1:19:12 to the end?

  • @napsterbg
    @napsterbg 11 месяцев назад +4

    IGN also gave Driver2 5/10, ridiculous.

  • @ballman6821
    @ballman6821 11 месяцев назад +1

    22:41 vehicular manslaughter

  • @AJellieDonut
    @AJellieDonut 11 месяцев назад

    To give some more context for the motorcross/atv games at least personally no one I talk to about those games ever even touched the races in them. We all just loved goofing around in the open world modes, especially Mx Unleashed

  • @ventilo1825
    @ventilo1825 11 месяцев назад +2

    Some levels of stuntman don't work on emulator sadly :(

  • @Dikucow
    @Dikucow 11 месяцев назад +2

    I love your longer videos!

  • @KenBladehart
    @KenBladehart 11 месяцев назад +2

    Playing Blur in a LAN party is crazy fun
    Highly recommend if theres a chance to do it

    • @roflBeck
      @roflBeck 10 месяцев назад

      It is mad fun, I used to do that a lot.

  • @benjaminzarkhin1293
    @benjaminzarkhin1293 11 месяцев назад +16

    Playing Horizon 5 for me by this point is like CBT- constant pain, but every picosecond now and then I feel something. Shoutout to them recycling models from Horizon 3, removing car modifications from Horizon 3 (Lancia Delta S4 is supposed to be twin-charged, is only turbocharged in 4 and 5), using similar sound effects between cars from the same company (Lancia Integrale and S4 sound share sounds) AND keeping cars out from the game that were promised at launch (Lancia Stratos and its 'immersive soundscape').
    If you could tell I'm a stickler to Lancia cars, and Horizon constantly butchers it.

    • @istvanlorinczi2817
      @istvanlorinczi2817 11 месяцев назад +2

      My favorite super(/arguably hyper) car is the Saleen S7, so you could imagine how much of a turn off the new Motorsport game's trailer was, when they showed that car, and it STILL has the same model from Motorsport 2. A game from 2007...

    • @alexsmith5584
      @alexsmith5584 Месяц назад

      I only played FH5 up to the part where you get to drive the parade float, because that was pretty much the only feature interesting enough to make me play it lol

  • @mullittmustang256
    @mullittmustang256 11 месяцев назад +2

    I’m glad Dustin likes Driver San Francisco, I played that a lot back in the day

  • @lucasLSD
    @lucasLSD 11 месяцев назад +1

    28:50 Always thought that the 2D asphalts were more fun back then, the 3D ones didn't really hit a nice point until 5 or 6 I think, the first one on a smartphone.

  • @simla5
    @simla5 10 месяцев назад +1

    It was super nice to see Blur on the list, that game truly is super underrated and to this day it's one of my favorite racing games. On the other hand some really great games were missing.
    Spilt/Second had on of the most unique concepts I've ever seen in a racing game. While the driving could've been better, it definetely made it up with pure chaos. The power plays are just insane especially the route altering ones.
    Driver: San Francisco is another pretty underrated gem imho especially considering the shift ability. I've never really seen anything quite like it.
    Pretty much any early GRID game should be on the list as well. Just all around very polished and fun racers.
    The fact that FlatOut 2 is not on the list also baffels me. It might be very easy game, but damn it pays it off with some of the wildest and most over the top destruction ever put into a racing video game. Smashing through the field in that game never gets old.
    And finally - to this day I'm not really sure if this is a hot take or not, because I've seen a fair share of people saying this - the best Burnout game is missing on the list. And that game is Burnout: Revenge. It took everything great about the series and enhanced everything. To this day it offers unrivalled sense of speed with adrenaline levels going through the roof, very challenging gameplay that rewards skill and track knowledge, absolutely killer soundtrack, great tracks with tons of traffic and god I love the addition of traffic checks. Easily in my top 3 of best racing games ever!

  • @fuzzyplays2321
    @fuzzyplays2321 11 месяцев назад

    Hey I just wanted to ask if you're gonna be at Gamescom this year?

  • @drift_works
    @drift_works 11 месяцев назад +8

    47:50 if u want try some old classic rally games i recomend so much the wrc evolved and the others on the ps2 developed by Evolution Studios (the motorstorm and driveclub developer)

    • @Tumppiasd
      @Tumppiasd 11 месяцев назад +1

      I think WRC 4 was the peak. They had some new features in evolved but mostly WRC 4 stages but shorter. Atleast that's how I remember them after all these years. WRC 4 stages felt really long

    • @drift_works
      @drift_works 11 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@Tumppiasd i loved that game

  • @supercrash131
    @supercrash131 10 месяцев назад

    are you planning on talking about the new "tdu sc freeroam trailer" on your second channel?

  • @csongorduka7125
    @csongorduka7125 11 месяцев назад

    49:08 MCII also had rave music which was really fitting to the game and also to the car culture of then, underground 1/2 should have been taken notes from MCII for the soundtrack

  • @Duckzy7
    @Duckzy7 11 месяцев назад +3

    1:03:26 As a rocket league player, even I don't understand why he's in the top 18 on this list.

  • @andipajeroking
    @andipajeroking 11 месяцев назад +2

    What you need to understand is this is reviewed by different people.
    Now, these people should have some gaming history notions, to better put into context the games.
    Most probably that guy played FH5 as his first racing game and he said wow, this is awesome, for an below average game.
    Where the fuck is Driver SF. Where is TDU. Where is the GrandPrix series, best F1 sim series ever.
    I won t expect people knowing NFS 2, or Stunt.
    Where is Driveclub, ffs.

  • @CMDRSweeper
    @CMDRSweeper 11 месяцев назад +1

    Not surprised Porsche Unleashed got a bit nuked on the review scores.
    Back when it came out, it was... crash central and unplayable.
    Both due to game bugs and bugs in the operating system, so I can totally get the low score for that, at the time.

  • @sekutofu6471
    @sekutofu6471 11 месяцев назад +1

    the intro deserves an Oscar award.

  • @grazie375
    @grazie375 10 месяцев назад +1

    18:16 hey RR2 was a marvel of racing game for a phone back in the day, im still trying to get it to run on newer phones.

  • @LW21_Coaching
    @LW21_Coaching 11 месяцев назад +2

    so dirt 2 and racedriver grid just don't exist 💀

  • @WaterDispencer519
    @WaterDispencer519 11 месяцев назад +2

    This list is already criminal but the fact that some games are not included in the list that should definitely be in the top 100 in the list (as of you making this video) is just unbelievable, here are some of them: (I checked them just now and it has been on the list and idk why it didn’t appeared in yours when you checked them out lol)
    - Gran Turismo 4 (9.5)
    - Gran Turismo 1 (9.5)
    - Forza Motorsport (9.5)
    - Mario Kart 8 Deluxe (9.3)
    - Forza Horizon 2 (9.0)
    - Forza Horizon (9.0)
    - Need For Speed Most Wanted (2012) (9.0)
    - Hot Wheels Unleashed (9.0)
    - Inertial Drift (9.0)
    - F1 2012 (9.0)
    - Mario Kart 7 (9.0)
    Also, The Need For Speed Most Wanted 2005 in the Top 100 list was actually the mobile game version. They have the audacity to give the console version an 8/10 lol

  • @Pupp3tCl0wn
    @Pupp3tCl0wn 10 месяцев назад

    CMR 2005 is just CMR 04 but upgraded in every possible way. I still really enjoy this one even today

  • @shun0825
    @shun0825 8 месяцев назад

    now I wanna see dustin do a video like this for gameranks if gameranks has

  • @JDumbz
    @JDumbz 11 месяцев назад +1

    My Real Racing 3 profile got glitched when I downloaded the app when they launched, I ended up getting infinite currency in that game and didn't need to spend on anything ever lmaoo

  • @Glacelica
    @Glacelica 8 месяцев назад

    If you make a GBA video please include the Choro-Q series. They have a lot of different names like Penny Racers, Gadget Racers and Road Trip so you need to do some research to get them in order, but for me they're sure worth checking out. I also recommend the PS1 and some of the PS2 games.

  • @father042
    @father042 11 месяцев назад

    You should do video about top rated racing games on Glitchwave

  • @scottthewaterwarrior
    @scottthewaterwarrior 10 месяцев назад +1

    Colin McRea Rally 2.0 for the GBA might not look like much, but it had one of, if not the best physics engines in a GBA racing game!

  • @dragonspear570
    @dragonspear570 11 месяцев назад +1

    General rule of thumb for IGN is if it is a mainstream franchise release the game immediately gets 7 points and from then on any and all negatives don't count towards the tally

  • @dougiehobbs1519
    @dougiehobbs1519 4 месяца назад +1

    CRASH TEAM RACING WAS INSANELY REPLAYABLE, unironically my all-time favorite video game

  • @scottthewaterwarrior
    @scottthewaterwarrior 10 месяцев назад

    I can respect that Lynx game for being at the top. I haven't played it myself, but been collecting a lot of Sega Genesis racers lately and some of them are really impressive for the time and still insanely fun. Think my favorites so far are Formula One, Super Monaco GP, and Road Rash II.

  • @shadowspike74
    @shadowspike74 11 месяцев назад +2

    Don't play pgr1 on xbox 360. It suffers from slow down compare to original xbox hardware

  • @yracpontiferous4846
    @yracpontiferous4846 7 месяцев назад

    16:25
    I have a complete copy of the Mint 400 game. It was kinda fun as a kid, haven’t played as an adult.

  • @DoctorReto
    @DoctorReto 9 месяцев назад

    After watching both of the Metacritic 100 videos i was glad to see that "Crazy Taxi" and "Driver" got some praise but...man...
    No mention of any Hot Wheels games, Enthusia, Juiced and don't get me started about Carmageddon..
    All in all, i got hooked on your videos and i decided to get back to GT4 which i played so much back then.

  • @ElektrikMuffins
    @ElektrikMuffins 11 месяцев назад +1

    Splashdown and the sequel Rides Gone Wild slaps hard brother

  • @possibly_ben
    @possibly_ben 10 месяцев назад

    6:43 oh shit eden's a fellow november boy

  • @KentishZombie
    @KentishZombie 9 месяцев назад

    1999 - that'll be when they made the website/changed host.. pretty common

  • @bazzgaming27
    @bazzgaming27 8 месяцев назад

    my goat racing games growing up was SegaGT 2002 & the online variant from the OG Xbox

  • @gamernaut8864
    @gamernaut8864 8 месяцев назад

    Those top 2 final entries were probably the greatest rug-pullin', plot-twistin' endings ever. I think IGN is trollin the racing community bigtime. Cool video Dustin! That was crazy and confusing and fun.

  • @hegyak
    @hegyak 11 месяцев назад +7

    The "Behind the Curtin" of this is simple.
    "Talk bad about company. Company doesn't give you early access to review the game. And you lose out to competitors."

  • @GabrielGames100
    @GabrielGames100 7 месяцев назад +1

    midtown madness is crazyyyy that was my childhood

  • @hi_tech_reptiles
    @hi_tech_reptiles 9 месяцев назад

    The Mickey game was GBC too, not N64. The GBC version is crazy, it has really well done animations and stuff. The GBC was twice as fast as the og GB, with double the RAM and VRAM. It can do crazy stuff.

  • @enzostabile550
    @enzostabile550 11 месяцев назад +1

    Why you don't test split second and motor storm any of the series because all off different to burnout and the skate games all of them are good really good

  • @SpiderMax95
    @SpiderMax95 11 месяцев назад

    Checkered Flag came out 1991, so gotta keep that in mind. but tbh, i cant see what people saw in those games back then...

  • @jesseleblanc8445
    @jesseleblanc8445 11 месяцев назад +1

    Please please play stuntman, one of the best car games hands down and one of the hardest games ever but so much fun l!

  • @chesterfieldmcfistycups2836
    @chesterfieldmcfistycups2836 11 месяцев назад +2

    Missed an “8.8” score:
    Not sure why NO ONE mentions a certain game that was given away with a few hundred thousand xbox consoles. Sega GT 2002 was not epically exciting but it introduced a TON of Xbox kids to simulation racing. It included over 100 cars and not all were standard: see the 1978 Dome Zero… I don’t need it to be included in these lists; I just want to know why it isn’t included while every single lesser game is. Is it too much of a GT knockoff? All I know is that without a free copy of Sega GT 2002 at an impressionable time in my friends’ and my childhood, we might not have become car enthusiasts.

    • @THENAMEISQUICKMAN
      @THENAMEISQUICKMAN 11 месяцев назад +1

      I'm always a big Sega GT 2002 defender. I feel the only major gripe behind it is a small amount of tracks, but I still played it a ton as a kid.

  • @poopmaster137
    @poopmaster137 10 месяцев назад +1

    IGN is like the entire gta online IGN crew they cant agree on anything

  • @Bo0dy095
    @Bo0dy095 11 месяцев назад

    Of you want challenge I dare you to complete TOCA Race Driver 2, as kid it was hard at formula ford, then at mustang races rubber branding was too much. Still great game

  • @Cobra_427
    @Cobra_427 11 месяцев назад +1

    I really wish Stuntman was more popular, glad some mad lad is making Stuntman inspired scenarios in BeamNG

  • @ahenci
    @ahenci 4 месяца назад +1

    9/10 missed Big Mutha Truckers 2

  • @koybze
    @koybze 11 месяцев назад +2

    speed punks soundtrack goes stupidly hard, really good dnb gotta love 90s videogames

    • @koybze
      @koybze 11 месяцев назад

      also a very rare irish videogame