Yeah!!! Absolutely Truth!!! Josh brought RHCP to a new magikal dimention!!!! (It's just my opinion, the two albums that Josh made with RHCP are much cooler and more beautiful than "Stadium Arcadium" ..."The Getaway" is a pretty masterpiece. I still miss Josh...)
I'm concerned no one noticed Chad at this performance. Everyone is "i miss John" or "Josh is doing his job". But listen, Chad is playing just like his life depended on it.
Seriously. The getaway was amazing. And I was really looking forward to the next album with Josh. It just kept getting better. I thought John had given their his best with the group with stadium A. What now. As well as his guitar playing from BTW era to SA was insane. Wtf now!!!!! We already grew to Josh. It's been ten years. I love John to death and the biggest hardcore fan. But he had his run with rhcp. Yes he is the spirit and heart of the Chili's. But damn. This next album with Josh was gonna be fire
@@kevinmyrick218 they probably kept what they've already did with Josh. Which is kind of sad in a way. I just hope they tour for a little more and have Josh as a guest on one of those tours ♥️
Josh is a magnificent artist. Added something unique and his voice is amazing. Will be missed. Hopefully he tours with them in the future alongside John. Having both would have been perfect.
im glad im not the only one who noticed, it really reflects the insane chemistry between them all throughout the song - the way josh moves his guitar to the beat of the drums in that bit is awesome
Ali keeling After i watched it several times, i understood why Josh looked and smiled at Chad. Becouse Chad wanted to end the song there, listen carefully to the drums, he began to hit the brakes. Then Josh is like "i heard that" and Chad got out of it and continued like nothing happened becouse hes so good and actually that drum part was sick!
Nah, it looks like Chad started to put some extra “over the bar line” punches in there a couple nights prior and Josh began to piggyback onto it. Notice how his strumming matches the crashes then they smile at each other. Touring musicians mess with this kind of stuff all the time when you play the same songs night after night after night…. It keeps the songs fun and interesting.
To all the the people hating on Josh, give him a break. He try's to bring in his own style to the songs that Frusciante wrote. I think he does an amazing job, and his voice is incredible. On a lot of the songs that he has written with the band, he absolutely nails them because he can do more with it. Look at Frusciante with the band when they made Mother Milk back in '89. The next album they made was BSSM and it blew people's mind. Who knows what they'll pull off with the new album this year.
Exactly. Josh can't just copy what John does does, that would be stupid. People are expecting Josh to be exactly the same as John, and he's not and that's why people are hating. They just need to accept that John's not in the band anymore, and he has a perfectly good replacement! Josh is really talented
It's heartwarming to see Josh and Chad looking at each other and smiling of satisfaction while Josh sync his guitar neck moves to Chad's drum beats in 3:41 😂
I really don't get why people hate on Josh (and John leaving). John has gone on to create tons of really good solo albums (some of them with Josh and Flea) and Josh has given the Chili Peppers some new creative input. He's amazing in the new album The Getaway
moe5555 It's probably because both I'm with you and The Getaway don't have quite the same "feel" as the albums with john and this "feel" is the reason why a lot of people love the band so if this feel is gone, the band isnt really the same anymore
Yulvar Dacess dude, i never said their new albums are bad and even if, let us have our own opinion. If someone doesn't like the new albums they are allowed to do so. And it's not because we're "stuck to the past" but because we just prefer those songs but if you think that we just "can't" accept new things this is probably to complicated to understand
+Yulvar Dacess You not answering seems like either you realised you're wrong or just trying to find a way to not look like a douch who doesn't accept other people's opinions. Either way, just think before you type and you won't fucking embarrass yourself.
Nils Böker first of all its my opinion how you guys see josh cause its clearly the majority do so too and second i dont really need to reply to this comment its not really that important to me jeez (kinda ironic im replying) and third how can you declare yourself victorious when theres no competition in the first place i was simply stating that 90% of the guys i see in the comment said the same shit and theres no way in hell that 90% prefer the old stuff too, i watch some of josh and johns vid and i can say that both of them are good and theres no way that coincedencely 90% prefer john too its obvious that majority of yall need to stop being biased towards john
Good God some of you guys are clueless. This vintage Fender *stratocaster* is owned by Chad. He obviously lets Josh use it. It is similar to John's in that it is a sunburst finish, this is because all (most) strats in the early years of production (late 1950's/Early 1960's) were that style. John gave Josh his Fender telecaster, which is also a sunburst finish. But is not in this video.
Glad I saw this, I was just about to ask if that's actually John's 60s strat. It looks nearly identical to his, even has similar wear above the pick guard
I had to preform this in front of my whole school as the guitarist. I put all my energy into it and ended up pretty well known. I love and thank josh for my motivation. I miss you already!!❤️❤️🖤
SHUT UP!!! stop discourage osh, hate him or anything. He is NOT john frusciante, he's just a different person, with different guitar style, with different personality. He is doing well and he plays guitar well. He may not be Frusciante but he is himself! Continue Josh, you are perfect and me and many other people love you!!!
Ok I will just insult Josh instead. It's ok Osh, you did good. Josh Klinghoffer is the sleaziest douchebag I've ever seen. Learn to play fucking moron.
+Lawl ExDee Haha I'm laughing! You're calling me fat based on your knowledge of my previous comment! 😂😂 And no I don't "play" mayonnaise if you can even do that. I play guitar, saxophone, piano, bass (anyone who plays guitar can play bass so) and I also play slide guitar. (Yes it is still guitar but it's completely different than normal guitar)
gosto muito do josh, acho que ele trouxe um toque alegre e superpositivo pro RHCP, tem meu apoio e meu carinho!! e ao contrário do que falam ele é sim um ótimo guitarrista.
Acho ele um bom guitarrista só que para algumas músicas do RH exige solos que o Jhosh deixa desejar. Se talvez o RH mantivesse o Jhosh e o Frusciante para solos e riffs talvez a banda ganharia muito mais em qualidade .
I saw the last tour with John and the first tour with Josh. As much as I admire John, what he has done for the band, the ever lasting songs he wrote and as much I as I love him: This first tour with Josh I saw for me was like „Wow! This guy brings so much energy to the stage! Like a new love.“ I will never see Josh as a substitute for John. John and Josh are equally Red Hot Chili Peppers.
John Frusciante will be one of my favorite guitarists \ vocalists. But josh is crazy talented too. He brings a very strong energy to the stage with the chili peppers
If Josh imitated John, people would be mad. When Josh brings his own style, people get mad. You can't make everybody happy... so quit trying to convince these people riding Johns nuts that Josh is perfect for the band at this time. And this is coming from someone who is a HUGE Frusciante fan.
I'm sick of people dissing on Josh. We get it, he isn't frusciante! Would Anthony would've picked him if he was un-talented and worthless. I get that John was a big part of the band and Josh can't ever replace him, but he CAN bring the band to a new state of music. People might have been the same with Hillel and John. They could've said "No one will replace the original!" but he brought the band to a new state. So please cut him so slack even if you don't love him
Thank you, Josh
:"(
Go way now please
@John Henderson haahhahahahha
@John Henderson yaaaa la media volá en la que te vay
@John Henderson Y The Getaway? Me vas a decir que no es una obra de arte, sin Josh los chili Peppers hubieran caído bajo, y eso hay que agradecerselo.
Josh always looks like he's having so much fun on stage, it's fucking great
yeah, if I had to pick something that josh is better than john at, I would say he's more livelier
to me he looks like over acting.. it doesn't look natural
thats just how is it at all performances, he's like that with his other band, dot hacker
Leonardo Cordero i think he wants to be the complete opposite of natural
Leonardo Cordero watch him play keyboards for Gnarls Barkley. It’s natural alright
I never treated Josh as a “Substitute” for John. He really is a *RED HOT* Chili Pepper!
Mee to
My 5th, close 4th, favourite chili pepper!
Yeah!!! Absolutely Truth!!! Josh brought RHCP to a new magikal dimention!!!!
(It's just my opinion, the two albums that Josh made with RHCP are much cooler and more beautiful than "Stadium Arcadium" ..."The Getaway" is a pretty masterpiece. I still miss Josh...)
Sembarang👆💨💨💨💨💨
Yeah its True mate 👍👍
I'm concerned no one noticed Chad at this performance. Everyone is "i miss John" or "Josh is doing his job". But listen, Chad is playing just like his life depended on it.
nothing new. Chad always gives 160%
seriously you are right, he's possessed. he is one of the best.
I miss Will Ferrell
Bobby King h
así es la vida de un red hot jajaja constante peligro, no haz viso sus videos? joajaojajaojaoa
I’m happy john is back but man am I gonna miss Josh
Frynwik 7 same, he grew on me already :((
Seriously. The getaway was amazing. And I was really looking forward to the next album with Josh. It just kept getting better. I thought John had given their his best with the group with stadium A. What now. As well as his guitar playing from BTW era to SA was insane. Wtf now!!!!! We already grew to Josh. It's been ten years. I love John to death and the biggest hardcore fan. But he had his run with rhcp. Yes he is the spirit and heart of the Chili's. But damn. This next album with Josh was gonna be fire
@@kevinmyrick218 they probably kept what they've already did with Josh. Which is kind of sad in a way. I just hope they tour for a little more and have Josh as a guest on one of those tours ♥️
Yes. Seems like a nice person also. RHCP were very fortunate that he was there for them. I think he held them together.
I kinda wish they had both of them.
Josh is fucking awesome, I mean just look at that energy.
Ikr kinda reminds me of kurt cobain when he plays the songs he love.
Like a wet rag covering a tremendous flame
It's awesome to bounce around like you're playing the world's greatest solo when only pick scraping is going on?
Unreal
@@davemccombs hahaha thats what playing with emotion is didnt you know 😂😂😂😂 im kidding btw this performance is trash
Josh's harmonies in the chorus are on point
Stephen Scelfo Gives me goosebumps
Stephen Scelfo Funny for some parts he sounds almost exactly like John
fuckin beautiful
Absolutely
Sings better than Anthony to me
Not only a great guitarist but also a great singer
Brendony great drummer !
Ethan Klein????? :0
His singing is way too high and annoying
tantoxer you’re way too high and annoying tho so 🤷♀️
Tanguy Blanchard yeah. You’re a wise man
gotta love the smile josh and chad share at 3:39
Tobi Frey t
Tobi Frey G
Amazing
right in the heart
Chad is close to Josh in the band
chad looks like hes ready to battle Ryu with that Ken outfit. lol
best comment for today
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 GG
JAJAJAJA
The yellow cap is a nice touch.
Best comment ever hahahahaha
the fucking power chad gives in this song is unbelievable.. i was shaking in my chair
You're in a wheelchair?
JOSH VOCALS AT LAST CHORUS
THOSE VOCALS
Sounds like he had been choking on a turd 💩
@Paul Collinsworth I wish you were the one who replaced John then everyone would enjoy your farting vocals, right asshole?
@Paul Collinsworth OK Boomer
Josh sings amazing dude wtf
@Paul Collinsworth youre an idiot, josh is so clearly a better vocalist
One of their best live performances . Josh's vocals and outro to Drop whatever tune the song is . GOAT SHIT
He's got an amazing energy....
yeah what drugs can make to people is awesome !
***** hahahahaha you tell 'em John!!! when are you going to sober up and go back with the peppers?
***** jejejeje nice point.
EVLGTR he's sober
Josh acts like a fan got to join his favorite band and just wants to do his absolute best while having the time of his life.its great 👍🏼
We love you Josh.
Josh is really a great guitarist!!!
4:15 I love how Josh drops the tuning down to D to give the song an outro wall that drills inside your brain.
I love Josh's voiceeee
Josh gracias por estos 10 años y por esas grandes canciones y composiciones que nos dejaste en "The getaway" y en I'm with you
Mucho amor Josh♡
Y que se jodan los rhcp por botarte. O no? No mentira...
Josh ❤️
Al fin encontré un comentario en español. ✌️
I will never foget you josh!
Josh is a magnificent artist. Added something unique and his voice is amazing. Will be missed. Hopefully he tours with them in the future alongside John. Having both would have been perfect.
They toured with both on the stadium arcadium tour.
I hope Josh still play rhythm in live show after he gets fired
3:34 Josh looks at Chad like "This is fucking amazing"
im glad im not the only one who noticed, it really reflects the insane chemistry between them all throughout the song - the way josh moves his guitar to the beat of the drums in that bit is awesome
Ali keeling After i watched it several times, i understood why Josh looked and smiled at Chad. Becouse Chad wanted to end the song there, listen carefully to the drums, he began to hit the brakes. Then Josh is like "i heard that" and Chad got out of it and continued like nothing happened becouse hes so good and actually that drum part was sick!
Nah, it looks like Chad started to put some extra “over the bar line” punches in there a couple nights prior and Josh began to piggyback onto it. Notice how his strumming matches the crashes then they smile at each other. Touring musicians mess with this kind of stuff all the time when you play the same songs night after night after night…. It keeps the songs fun and interesting.
3:44
almost forgot to watch this today
This is probably Josh's best classic RHCP song that he plays live.
Dat chorus.
To all the the people hating on Josh, give him a break. He try's to bring in his own style to the songs that Frusciante wrote. I think he does an amazing job, and his voice is incredible. On a lot of the songs that he has written with the band, he absolutely nails them because he can do more with it. Look at Frusciante with the band when they made Mother Milk back in '89. The next album they made was BSSM and it blew people's mind. Who knows what they'll pull off with the new album this year.
But mother's milk was as awesome as BSSM
But you're right, the people are juste stupid hating josh
Exactly. Josh can't just copy what John does does, that would be stupid. People are expecting Josh to be exactly the same as John, and he's not and that's why people are hating. They just need to accept that John's not in the band anymore, and he has a perfectly good replacement! Josh is really talented
Clayton Klocke for me, IWY is their best album since BSSM. John´s second era was nice, but I love how they sound with Josh.
We don't hate Josh. We just wish he could play better and have more control over his guitar.
Clayton Klocke Josh is a good guy and good artist!
Josh killed it. Such talent. Love this guy
It's heartwarming to see Josh and Chad looking at each other and smiling of satisfaction while Josh sync his guitar neck moves to Chad's drum beats in 3:41 😂
They are very close friends.
❤
Thank you Josh, You're great musician and a good soul. I saw you in Poland, I hope to see you again someday.
He's got a beautiful voice.
I really don't get why people hate on Josh (and John leaving). John has gone on to create tons of really good solo albums (some of them with Josh and Flea) and Josh has given the Chili Peppers some new creative input. He's amazing in the new album The Getaway
moe5555 It's probably because both I'm with you and The Getaway don't have quite the same "feel" as the albums with john and this "feel" is the reason why a lot of people love the band so if this feel is gone, the band isnt really the same anymore
Nils Böker we all know you people just cant accept new things you are always stuck to the past that you dont gaf to new stuffs
Yulvar Dacess dude, i never said their new albums are bad and even if, let us have our own opinion. If someone doesn't like the new albums they are allowed to do so. And it's not because we're "stuck to the past" but because we just prefer those songs but if you think that we just "can't" accept new things this is probably to complicated to understand
+Yulvar Dacess You not answering seems like either you realised you're wrong or just trying to find a way to not look like a douch who doesn't accept other people's opinions. Either way, just think before you type and you won't fucking embarrass yourself.
Nils Böker first of all its my opinion how you guys see josh cause its clearly the majority do so too and second i dont really need to reply to this comment its not really that important to me jeez (kinda ironic im replying) and third how can you declare yourself victorious when theres no competition in the first place i was simply stating that 90% of the guys i see in the comment said the same shit and theres no way in hell that 90% prefer the old stuff too, i watch some of josh and johns vid and i can say that both of them are good and theres no way that coincedencely 90% prefer john too its obvious that majority of yall need to stop being biased towards john
Josh is incredible
Chad 03:54 "My work here is done"
Matt Denton looks like he had to shit real bad lol
Or maybe: man, I have to poop 💩 RIGHT NOW!!!
The percussionist is so damn committed. That was beautiful
Good God some of you guys are clueless.
This vintage Fender *stratocaster* is owned by Chad. He obviously lets Josh use it. It is similar to John's in that it is a sunburst finish, this is because all (most) strats in the early years of production (late 1950's/Early 1960's) were that style.
John gave Josh his Fender telecaster, which is also a sunburst finish. But is not in this video.
Good man! Tell those other people :)
helou josh
Glad I saw this, I was just about to ask if that's actually John's 60s strat. It looks nearly identical to his, even has similar wear above the pick guard
I had to preform this in front of my whole school as the guitarist. I put all my energy into it and ended up pretty well known. I love and thank josh for my motivation. I miss you already!!❤️❤️🖤
Motivation is everything when you are performing!
Love you Josh! ❤️
Maria Flores SAME 😭❤️🥰
Fuck that's an amazing live performance
pls comunnity sings a rhcp song
@@manuelvieyra6204 yes
Ngl I’m really gonna miss josh this performance was so incredible
While Frusciante was an amazing guitarist, I think Josh holds his own. His playing style is a bit different, but he is awesome nevertheless.
And bloody hell, Chad banged the shit out of those drums.
When Josh was inducted to the Hall of Fame he was the youngest member beating Stevie Wonder. Josh is a Fucking Legend.
Chad Smith at 3:57 "Fuck this, im out of here!"
josh is a very talented individual. sometimes Change is hard. Get fucking over it.
yeah nah
Josh is so great, I love his voice!
SHUT UP!!! stop discourage osh, hate him or anything. He is NOT john frusciante, he's just a different person, with different guitar style, with different personality. He is doing well and he plays guitar well. He may not be Frusciante but he is himself! Continue Josh, you are perfect and me and many other people love you!!!
Ok I will just insult Josh instead. It's ok Osh, you did good. Josh Klinghoffer is the sleaziest douchebag I've ever seen. Learn to play fucking moron.
+Mitch Kincaid You probably don't even play an instrument.
+Lawl ExDee Actually I play multiple so you can stfu and go to hell
Mitch Kincaid Mayonnaise doesn't count.
+Lawl ExDee Haha I'm laughing! You're calling me fat based on your knowledge of my previous comment! 😂😂
And no I don't "play" mayonnaise if you can even do that. I play guitar, saxophone, piano, bass (anyone who plays guitar can play bass so) and I also play slide guitar. (Yes it is still guitar but it's completely different than normal guitar)
I practically worship John, but this is one of the songs where I prefer Josh's backing vocals. They're perfect.
Agreed. 100%. Brought an extra level to the songs. It will be missed
I love Josh. He's so amazing and plays amazing. His voice is so sweet. They struck gold w him. I've always loved rhcp. Definitely an untouchable force
Chad's walk out was sick
Josh, I really wish you still stayed with the band. I can imagine John and you together as RHCP carries on.
josh is the best
Josh=Respect
Why can’t they just write new music with John and Josh would be incredible
cuz John I'd a whiney bitch. At least Josh brought some of the Navarro material back out live
Would be epic ❤️
as a person who tried performing you got to love this kid can play a guitar jump around and sing wow just to sing and play is hard
The way he sings the harmony line to "know you" at 3:51 sounded so heavenly
gosto muito do josh, acho que ele trouxe um toque alegre e superpositivo pro RHCP, tem meu apoio e meu carinho!! e ao contrário do que falam ele é sim um ótimo guitarrista.
5 anos dps... também gosto dele man, toca tão bem quanto o John... e tem uma voz incrível esse filho da mãe
Acho ele um bom guitarrista só que para algumas músicas do RH exige solos que o Jhosh deixa desejar. Se talvez o RH mantivesse o Jhosh e o Frusciante para solos e riffs talvez a banda ganharia muito mais em qualidade .
Josh is just wonderful
I saw the last tour with John and the first tour with Josh. As much as I admire John, what he has done for the band, the ever lasting songs he wrote and as much I as I love him: This first tour with Josh I saw for me was like „Wow! This guy brings so much energy to the stage! Like a new love.“ I will never see Josh as a substitute for John. John and Josh are equally Red Hot Chili Peppers.
We will miss you Josh! Thank you!
Holy shit Josh, you can sing yo. Great work, will be missed. Hopefully we still see ya on some of the shows. Love your live energy.
4.00
That's a nice touch riff to the guitar :)
I just love Josh's energy so much!!! ❤
Josh is amazing
this is my favorite version of By the way, so much energy and talent! would give anything to be at that concert
Josh’s performance is absolutely outstanding.
Josh ROCKS!!!!! Amazing guy!
John Frusciante will be one of my favorite guitarists \ vocalists. But josh is crazy talented too. He brings a very strong energy to the stage with the chili peppers
I'm with you josh
If Josh imitated John, people would be mad. When Josh brings his own style, people get mad. You can't make everybody happy... so quit trying to convince these people riding Johns nuts that Josh is perfect for the band at this time. And this is coming from someone who is a HUGE Frusciante fan.
Josh is great😍😍😍😍! By the way, great performance!
this is one of the greatest live performances by RHCP and i'm not even joking
Josh es de otra época, es la energia que la banda necesita, la sangre joven, una lástima q lo hayan dejado ir
Josh grazie per tutti gli anni insieme. Ti auguro ogni bene davvero😘
Do you know that when your attention is taken from flea and Anthony that you’re a true showman. I cannot take my eyes off Josh.
miss you josh :( thanks for the energy you bought to rhcp
Thank you Josh
Josh was a pepper. He earned his spot
John choose the best for rhcp. and Josh was picked up to change John... Because he know the best for RHCP
Josh have a good friendship with john and the band for years. He fits perfectly into the RHCP.. Can´t wait for the new Album to come!
John frusciante the BEST
Is no one going to talk about how good anthonies singing was here?
Josh is so much fun to watch
I think slash was better than Josh, I miss slash in this band.
Yeah... I also miss Kurt cobain on vocals
+al pugcino That band would be the most amazing thing in the frigin world
+al pugcino I miss Izzy on rhythm
+Pedro Manuel Ramon Villa a shame bonzo died so early... chad sux
Miss yoko ono on them drums....what the fuck is wrong with me
3:43 just shows that Josh is already in the band. I love the chemistry!
I love josh and this is just what I needed 😍
I like it so that Josh became so much better now!
Good luck Josh!!
Thank you!!
I really love John,
but Josh is awesome !
That "Muchas gracias" that Anthony said, was really cool
I really want this guys to come to Costa Rica
Jajajaja, que vengan a la Argentina papu
Joseph Marin A esto fue en Costa Rica?
Josh's magic!
I love both of them John and josh
John was one of the guys who inspired me to first play guitar but one thing Josh has on him.....DAT FUCKIN STAGE PRESENCE DOE!
why is there an old man shaking two stars in the background?
+Some Random RUclipsr chad 2.0
+Some Random RUclipsr Chad's drumming support
+Some Random RUclipsr Mauro, he is a brazilian drummer
+Some Random RUclipsr Chad's Mexican grandma, Morico.
lol
Josh was pretty f'n awesome, he has a lot of equipment acquired since his arrival in RHCP
I love so much Josh. The best musician who I know.
Holy shit Josh's energy was insane...
I'm sick of people dissing on Josh. We get it, he isn't frusciante! Would Anthony would've picked him if he was un-talented and worthless. I get that John was a big part of the band and Josh can't ever replace him, but he CAN bring the band to a new state of music. People might have been the same with Hillel and John. They could've said "No one will replace the original!" but he brought the band to a new state. So please cut him so slack even if you don't love him
man his energy is undeniable, he truly is a perfect addition to the band
Yo Josh is so good
I love Josh🇯🇵
Chad, a fucking god ._.
Thank you for last ten years josh
Love your perform
Josh you are my hero
After the John comeback, I've just realized that how good Josh actually is. I really miss Josh