Nice Vid the improvments are massive compared to your older videos .You have this possible History style Good job man:)(a ww1 part i smth i would see i would enyoyej
While your attempt at crafting an alternative history is notable for its creativity, it falls short in terms of historical accuracy and depth. Key events and dynamics appear to have been oversimplified or misunderstood, which undermines the plausibility of your narrative. Additionally, your argument lacks the nuanced exploration of cause-and-effect relationships that are essential for a credible alternate timeline. Without a deeper engagement with historical context and the interplay of political, social, and economic factors, the scenario feels more like a surface-level speculation than a well-grounded reimagining. A more rigorous approach could elevate your work from a rough idea to a thought-provoking piece.
@@cg8096 Those are extremely good points indeed. My videos are usually meant to be light hearted and fun because I genuinely enjoy making them, but I do see what you mean and I am trying to improve on them nowadays. Hope you enjoyed the video though and thank you for the respectful criticism.
@@Alternate-History-Chronicles While your attempt is intriguing, it could be significantly improved by focusing more on the cultural and ideological goals of the Tanzimat reforms and their long-term consequences. If, for instance, a Christian power had been involved in shaping this alternative history, the reform process might have progressed faster, but at the risk of provoking resistance or revolt from within the empire. You could explore how Turkey, empowered by successful reforms, managed to recapture key territories such as Bulgaria, Thessaly, Syria, Lebanon, and Kurdish regions, making these territorial gains a central part of the alternate history. Additionally, a pivotal shift in the region could involve the Ottoman Empire granting the Zionists a homeland in Israel as part of a life-debt agreement following significant assistance during the empire's time of need. This would have had profound implications on both the Middle East and European geopolitics. Furthermore, your depiction of the Crimean War outcome is somewhat unrealistic. The idea that Russia could suffer such a devastating loss with no significant military ramifications underplays the scale of reform that would have been required afterward. The war itself would have triggered major military and political reforms in Ottoman-something that was necessary to reshape their strategy and restore their position as a major European power. Focusing more on these internal consequences and the subsequent shifts in military doctrine would have provided a more grounded and compelling narrative.
Very good video in terms of idea and very improved material...
Man, you NEED to improve the audio.
Another good step towards ur goal..: every video is a step forward.:: keep it up❤
Thank you hope you enjoyed the content
Nice Vid the improvments are massive compared to your older videos .You have this possible History style Good job man:)(a ww1 part i smth i would see i would enyoyej
@@Pumkinguy-l2y Thank you. A part 2 is definitely gonna be in the works if this video preforms good. Glad you enjoyed the content
Do you watch synthist?
@yeetman4953 I'm sorry but what's that?
Make part 2
@@jackthompson2367 I intend to do that if this video preforms well
Your audio needs reforms
@@Kentuckyants It needs a system of reforms
Audio needs to be improved!
I know, besides that is there any criticism?
While your attempt at crafting an alternative history is notable for its creativity, it falls short in terms of historical accuracy and depth. Key events and dynamics appear to have been oversimplified or misunderstood, which undermines the plausibility of your narrative. Additionally, your argument lacks the nuanced exploration of cause-and-effect relationships that are essential for a credible alternate timeline. Without a deeper engagement with historical context and the interplay of political, social, and economic factors, the scenario feels more like a surface-level speculation than a well-grounded reimagining. A more rigorous approach could elevate your work from a rough idea to a thought-provoking piece.
@@cg8096 Those are extremely good points indeed. My videos are usually meant to be light hearted and fun because I genuinely enjoy making them, but I do see what you mean and I am trying to improve on them nowadays. Hope you enjoyed the video though and thank you for the respectful criticism.
@@Alternate-History-Chronicles While your attempt is intriguing, it could be significantly improved by focusing more on the cultural and ideological goals of the Tanzimat reforms and their long-term consequences. If, for instance, a Christian power had been involved in shaping this alternative history, the reform process might have progressed faster, but at the risk of provoking resistance or revolt from within the empire. You could explore how Turkey, empowered by successful reforms, managed to recapture key territories such as Bulgaria, Thessaly, Syria, Lebanon, and Kurdish regions, making these territorial gains a central part of the alternate history.
Additionally, a pivotal shift in the region could involve the Ottoman Empire granting the Zionists a homeland in Israel as part of a life-debt agreement following significant assistance during the empire's time of need. This would have had profound implications on both the Middle East and European geopolitics.
Furthermore, your depiction of the Crimean War outcome is somewhat unrealistic. The idea that Russia could suffer such a devastating loss with no significant military ramifications underplays the scale of reform that would have been required afterward. The war itself would have triggered major military and political reforms in Ottoman-something that was necessary to reshape their strategy and restore their position as a major European power. Focusing more on these internal consequences and the subsequent shifts in military doctrine would have provided a more grounded and compelling narrative.
Although I loved many of your points, I think you should create longer videos like this, as they suit your style perfectly.
@@cg8096 I am focusing more on creating longer videos nowadays and the next one will probably be a bit longer
@@Alternate-History-Chronicles Thanks for listening to feedback's.