Natalie Portman’s courageous stance on Palestine is a reminder we must stand up for what is right.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
  • Natalie Portman’s courageous stance on Palestine is a reminder that even in the face of adversity, we must stand up for what is right. Inspired by the wisdom of Amos Oz, who said ‘The only way to defeat darkness is to make its darkness visible.’ Let’s shine a light on the struggles of the Palestinian people and work towards a more just and peaceful world for all. #NataliePortman #AmosOz #Palestine #Justice #Peace

Комментарии • 605

  •  28 дней назад +77

    She basically put the oppressor in the same position of the oppressed
    This is the root cause of the problem

    • @AyshaA-ml2rd
      @AyshaA-ml2rd 8 часов назад +1

      Whole lot of umming and arring. Just static.
      What’s europes abuses got to do with doing Palestine dirty.
      And what’s Europe doing you (Israelis) dirty got to do with taking it out on Palestinians.

  • @GrumpX
    @GrumpX Месяц назад +149

    Yes. Same abusive father. However one sibling grew up to emulate the father by being abusive to his sibling.

    • @basilalfehaid4423
      @basilalfehaid4423 29 дней назад

      didn't grow up on their own israel was and still defended funded and backed fully by the UK and America if the money and the weapon flow stops the genocide will stop

    • @Sikyu-ye4ns
      @Sikyu-ye4ns 13 дней назад

      arabs ARE the abusers from which europeans defended themself

    • @basilminhas7179
      @basilminhas7179 12 дней назад +4

      Exactly

  • @growthandunderstanding
    @growthandunderstanding 18 дней назад +20

    Great point, Natalie, except one child has stolen the land of the other child, and has killed or exiled most of that poor child's family!

    • @Free_Falastin2024
      @Free_Falastin2024 7 дней назад

      You forgot to mention that Arabs never wanted anything to do with europe or their backward ways.

  • @jsmith5951
    @jsmith5951 Месяц назад +104

    Read between the lines: Israel isn’t responsible for the genocide in Gaza, Europe is, says Israeli-born, Israeli citizen, Natalie Portman. How courageous: deflecting the blame for the genocidal actions of your homeland to a group of countries who are presently calling for an end to the genocide in Gaza.

    • @stevecarson4162
      @stevecarson4162 29 дней назад

      They want "an end to the genocide in Gaza" so they can continue with their ongoing genocide in Israel. Not going to happen. Anyone who thought Israel would not defend itself hasn't been paying attention.

    • @mr.iiconic
      @mr.iiconic 23 дня назад +5

      The British are absolutely responsible for this situation

    • @stevecarson4162
      @stevecarson4162 23 дня назад

      The problem is that the ignorant people "calling for an end to the genocide in Gaza" were sound asleep during the *genocide in Israel* that led to the Israelis RETALIATING. Suddenly they wake up and think Israel is the bad guy, when it's the victim.
      Look up what happened on Oct.7th and see if you're still surprised that Israel is fighting BACK. It has no choice. Thugs and terrorists who pretend to live in a non-existent country have been attacking innocent Israelis for a very long time now. What did they think was going to happen?

    • @beachpicnicjoy
      @beachpicnicjoy  22 дня назад +4

      @@jsmith5951 europe and colonialism is the source of the problem. The weapons come from them

    • @ssb1056
      @ssb1056 22 дня назад

      @@beachpicnicjoy no, it is the people who began the colonization by murdering, pillaging and expelling the native population to take their land. The self professed victimization while being the genocidal victimizer gets a bit old!

  • @malcolmtyler1673
    @malcolmtyler1673 24 дня назад +3

    I'm missing the 'courageous stance' bit.

  • @ethicalmemeing7060
    @ethicalmemeing7060 26 дней назад +3

    This is far from a courageous stance. This both-side-ism is sickening. You literally have a genocide going on.

  • @mohammedhussain939
    @mohammedhussain939 6 дней назад

    So many people in this comment section are clueless about what israel truly is and how true natalie portman is with her quote.

  • @arbozaliyan
    @arbozaliyan 25 дней назад +2

    What stance? She talks about big bad europe, that is good and all but that is not a stance. It is not even barely an opinion

    • @TOFKAS01
      @TOFKAS01 25 дней назад

      Well, Portman was always overrated in terms of her intellectualism.

    • @arbozaliyan
      @arbozaliyan 24 дня назад +1

      @@TOFKAS01 I liked her performance in leon but nothing else.

    • @TOFKAS01
      @TOFKAS01 24 дня назад

      @@arbozaliyan Thats true. Unfortunately, her talent peaked at 12. After that, she became a pretentious peace of wood in terms of acting. She is definately not an idiot, but overrated as an actress and as an intellectual.

    • @arbozaliyan
      @arbozaliyan 24 дня назад +2

      @@TOFKAS01 I don't know about her intellectuality nor have any idea about it. She spoke about a conflict between two states but said nothing about none of them. This means she is a coward. Not everyone has to take a stance but pretending to take one to appease some demographic is pathetic.

    • @TOFKAS01
      @TOFKAS01 24 дня назад +1

      @@arbozaliyan Well, her public Image is heavily influenced by the fact that she is having a Harvard B.A. in psychology. And she always played the "sophisticated hollier than you" attitude. But when you read or Listen to her interviews in the past 20+ years, she always talked out of a rich girl bubble without much contact to the real world.
      For me, she is quite bland and quite fake.

  • @ChicagoThomas
    @ChicagoThomas Месяц назад

    Wow...

  • @mdsamshuddin
    @mdsamshuddin Месяц назад

    Most beautiful actress I have ever seen

  • @geoffreydarwentartconnexu
    @geoffreydarwentartconnexu Месяц назад

    We can go on and on about this wrong done and that wrong done but in the end, it all boils down to the hatred between people who claim their religion supersedes all others. It is not about land. It is about hatred.

    • @maziarfarzin3911
      @maziarfarzin3911 Месяц назад

      This is a common misunderstanding. I recommend reading some history. The early zionists were pretty much secular, and the Palestinians reacting to getting their land stolen weren't reacting to religion.

    • @ThatOneRussianTank
      @ThatOneRussianTank 23 часа назад

      @@maziarfarzin3911 Try saying that to a Pro-Israeli and they will start crying the Jordanian River to you, calling you anti-semitic for making an irreligious point

    • @ThatOneRussianTank
      @ThatOneRussianTank 23 часа назад

      Again, alot of people like you just blame religion. It's nothing about religion, Jews and Muslims coexisted in Palestine for thousands and thousands of years until the arrival of the Zionists

  • @xxxyyy4668
    @xxxyyy4668 Месяц назад +3

    How the hell can you cheat on a beauty like that..

  • @sameenfatima143
    @sameenfatima143 Месяц назад +1

    Bullshit

  • @mohamedlangry5425
    @mohamedlangry5425 Месяц назад

    Bravo Natalie you deserve the Nobel Peace Prize ❤

    • @jovannacarranza1881
      @jovannacarranza1881 Месяц назад

      No, she deserves been canceled for supporting an apartheid and genocide.

  • @thomasmueller8116
    @thomasmueller8116 Месяц назад +52

    Change the title, please. It is a joke.

  • @Alainh19623
    @Alainh19623 Месяц назад +208

    Where is the courage here?

    • @someonefourth
      @someonefourth Месяц назад

      I know, right? That's both-siding in a tender tone. As if 76 years of brutal occupation is a misunderstanding of some sort. Zionists are indeed colonialists!

    • @Research0digo
      @Research0digo Месяц назад +11

      Because she is a very devout Torah Jewess who knows Jews are never to call anywhere their homeland. Palestine was stolen by deception, and everyone knows theft by deception is illegal. She has also turned down lucrative gigs in Israel. She waited until marriage to have intimate relations, she was a model daughter, but with her own voice, and she feels for others. It's not a bad quality.

    • @celidagolobic2156
      @celidagolobic2156 Месяц назад +20

      @@Research0digo she may have qualities but the most essential quality would be to denounce the genocide of the Palestinian people. And her statement dilutes Israel actions. Not courageous to me.

    • @enf.j1830
      @enf.j1830 Месяц назад +10

      @@celidagolobic2156 agreed , also her belief in Torah would require her to differentiate between Jews and zios, I mean she even called Palestinians Arabs , the same way Israelis do to conceal their identity

    • @celidagolobic2156
      @celidagolobic2156 Месяц назад +3

      @@enf.j1830 absolutely. One of the main problems I see is that if you exclude any and all people that are not Jewish, it establishes prejudice, arrogance and the syndrome of the “chosen people” at the implying that no one but “us” is worthy as humans or at least not as supreme as “us”. That is exactly the contrary of inclusiveness and being human. The interdependence of all beings. The extreme Zionism is the antithesis of any interdependency. They are supremacists. Judaism is religion and they oppose Zionism.

  • @khan.riyadh
    @khan.riyadh Месяц назад +272

    Still she has not criticize the occupation.... so no courage here

    • @procheathepitai
      @procheathepitai Месяц назад

      Even if her stance on the issue is soft, she isnt lying about the dilemma. And the Zionists dont like her for that, and that's good enough for me.

    • @f_youtubecensorshipf_nazis
      @f_youtubecensorshipf_nazis Месяц назад

      She called it colonialism which is exactly that.

    • @myenglishgig5182
      @myenglishgig5182 Месяц назад +11

      Agree. Disappointing actually. Misleading title.

    • @samb.4913
      @samb.4913 Месяц назад +4

      So true

    • @1525boy
      @1525boy Месяц назад +2

      What about “Pakistan?”

  • @warmperson2007
    @warmperson2007 Месяц назад +35

    She is not particularly pro-palestine. She doesn't believe that arabs are nazis and that Israel is a colonialistic country. That's all she says.

    • @DotHacker99
      @DotHacker99 Месяц назад

      And that's wrong. Apartheid isr@3l is absolutely a colonial regime.

    • @warmperson2007
      @warmperson2007 Месяц назад +1

      @@DotHacker99 Israel is not an apartheid state. And it's not a colonial regime. Get your facts right !

    • @Tech-Corner2023
      @Tech-Corner2023 29 дней назад +7

      ​@@warmperson2007hahaha

    • @warmperson2007
      @warmperson2007 29 дней назад

      @@Tech-Corner2023 You may laugh ! You are still a useful idiot. Hahahaha !

    • @farhanahmad6316
      @farhanahmad6316 28 дней назад

      @@warmperson2007 except it is. Your actions have made you into the ultimate pariah state. If you dint have the backup of america. You would be right up there with North Korea. Slaughter 15000 children in gaza and expect the world to treat you as a normal. You people are living in a dream world.

  • @Gunzo568
    @Gunzo568 Месяц назад +16

    😅 i can still feel a hypocrite lurking

    • @TOFKAS01
      @TOFKAS01 Месяц назад +2

      Portman is a hypocrite by nature.

    • @saidamhamad8793
      @saidamhamad8793 26 дней назад

      😂😂😂☑️☑️☑️👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻♥️

  • @billjenkins2503
    @billjenkins2503 28 дней назад +15

    Hollywood needs to go away. Thankfully that is happening within our lifetime.

    • @saidamhamad8793
      @saidamhamad8793 26 дней назад +3

      💯💯☑️☑️👍🏻👍🏻♥️

    • @slartibartfast7921
      @slartibartfast7921 19 дней назад +1

      Yeah, my viewing habits have been far more selective post genocide.

  • @Lala-f4l
    @Lala-f4l Месяц назад +62

    What courage? She's saying both sides are at fault which is not true. There's clearly a colonized and colonizer dynamic here. Israel was built on occupation and ethnic cleansing

    • @thorpatriot8735
      @thorpatriot8735 Месяц назад +2

      Read history again

    • @Lala-f4l
      @Lala-f4l Месяц назад +12

      @aitorsporar8735 what part? The Jews coming on a boat from Europe to Palestine? The Nakba?

    • @thorpatriot8735
      @thorpatriot8735 Месяц назад

      @@Lala-f4l Maybe the ethnic cleansing of Jews of Africa and Iraq by Arabs? Is that a Jewish Nakba ? Or the war declared on Israel by Egypt Iraq Jordan Lebanon and Syria ? Or the fact that west bank was conquered by Jordan not Israel,and Gaza was conquered by Egypt not Israel

    • @Blue5890
      @Blue5890 Месяц назад +5

      @aitorspora apply that to yourself first...!!!

    • @captainmajed2078
      @captainmajed2078 28 дней назад

      @@thorpatriot8735 Enlighten us if you're so sure

  • @Boubouledu54
    @Boubouledu54 Месяц назад +101

    But the Palestians actually welcomed the jews of Europe (read Roald Dahl's autobiography: going solo. Where he went to Palestine and saw that) so what she's saying isn't accurate. Arabs never saw the jews as the colonizer at the beginning...

    • @jal1860
      @jal1860 Месяц назад

      that's right. It's the Europeans Zionists that are the colonisers. Middle Eastern Jews and Palestinians shared the land for centuries.

    • @TheFailedmessiah
      @TheFailedmessiah Месяц назад +10

      The jews see themselves as superman but in reality they are homelander.

    • @H_B_R
      @H_B_R Месяц назад +6

      well to be fair, she is a zionist, or was, now i am not sure which

    • @foxgirl1822
      @foxgirl1822 Месяц назад +7

      They are nothing without america behind them

    • @Stevef2022
      @Stevef2022 28 дней назад

      This is completely untrue. The Arabs despised the Jews and actively protested against allowing any more immigration - that is why after the 1929 Hebron Massacre (when Arabs r@ped and murdered hundreds of Jews and looted their businesses), the British Army restricted immigration to Judea.
      After WW2 the British realized the error of their ways and allowed more immigration, which drove hostility among the Arab Supremacists and set about this conflict.
      Oh - and Dahl was known for his virulent Jew hatred.

  • @zzahidi7700
    @zzahidi7700 22 дня назад +5

    Where is the courage? She hasn't called out Israel or voiced anything regarding years of murder, theft and occupation...

  • @Sabrina-tv3gl
    @Sabrina-tv3gl Месяц назад +3

    Bla bla bal. rambling. This is what we call a word salad.

  • @marshmellow.2886
    @marshmellow.2886 24 дня назад +3

    Honestly, when self-worshipping Jew like this one talks, the most they can do to look humble is to narrate the occupation as if both sides are in the wrong. Meanwhile, one occupation force grew to be a bully after being bullied and the other is being bullied after offering generosity for a society rejected by the whole world. HUGE difference. This is not display of courage. It is display of hypocrisy.

  • @redl1ner170
    @redl1ner170 25 дней назад +5

    Where's the "courage" in here? Pure demagogery.

    • @TOFKAS01
      @TOFKAS01 25 дней назад +1

      Its Portman. A pretty facade but not much behind it.

  • @samlebon9884
    @samlebon9884 28 дней назад +4

    This lady is swimming in a dangerous lake.

    • @TOFKAS01
      @TOFKAS01 26 дней назад

      I think she is not just very good at swimming...

  • @Gle-lv2fm
    @Gle-lv2fm 25 дней назад +3

    It’s more like Europe is the abusive father, and Israel is the abusive big brother, yes the big brother got abused by the father long time ago, but it’s still not an excuse for his abuse today.

    • @israhelldid9116
      @israhelldid9116 14 дней назад

      Europe never abused jews. -it's the other way round. -why do you think they have been expelled over a thousand times in history ? because they are nation destoryers.

    • @ThatOneRussianTank
      @ThatOneRussianTank День назад

      It's almost like William and Micheal Afton bullying Evan Afton

  • @hasanjamil3969
    @hasanjamil3969 Месяц назад +40

    One is occupying and colonizing the other. What makes it so difficult to understand who is right and who is wrong?

    • @everfree2532
      @everfree2532 Месяц назад +2

      Yes. Palestine is occupying Israel.

    • @hasanjamil3969
      @hasanjamil3969 Месяц назад +4

      @@everfree2532 Look in the mirror and keep saying that to yourself 😂

    • @Methne555
      @Methne555 Месяц назад

      @@hasanjamil3969How about “Palestine” is occupying Israel.

    • @Burrburrcloud
      @Burrburrcloud Месяц назад +3

      ​@@everfree2532 Indigenous people are occupying their own land? 😂😂
      Name 1 influencial Israeli from 200 years ago.

    • @Burrburrcloud
      @Burrburrcloud Месяц назад +2

      ​@@Methne555 Name 1 influencial Israeli from 200 years ago.

  • @mariovicente
    @mariovicente Месяц назад +9

    Literally nothing to see here. As a European I say to Arabs and Jews to grow up. History is not an excuse for your current abuses.

    • @Burrburrcloud
      @Burrburrcloud Месяц назад +5

      Victim blaming.
      Palestine will be free. ❤🇵🇸
      You need to grow up 180 000+ Palestinians have been unalived in this Genocide.

    • @Blue5890
      @Blue5890 Месяц назад +3

      @mariovicente as european i also remind you to stand with the international law when a genocide is happening and to stop making irritating comments !!

    • @AnuraUkulele
      @AnuraUkulele 25 дней назад

      I don't know that "grow up" is sage advice for people being murdered by European Zionists who have invaded their country.

    • @TheStraightestWhitest
      @TheStraightestWhitest 18 дней назад +1

      ​@@Blue5890 Stop hating yourself.

    • @ThatOneRussianTank
      @ThatOneRussianTank День назад

      Jews? Sir those are Zionists, and maybe have those European Zionists back? You expelling them led to all these problems

  • @fouedfoued5692
    @fouedfoued5692 Месяц назад +3

    *_Beautiful oratory to whitewashing a 6EN0- SIDE.._*

    •  Месяц назад +2

      WELL SAID. She is vile and despicable

  • @other7128
    @other7128 17 дней назад +3

    I mean, she is right in a way, BUT I don't think this is a case of both sides refusing to accept that they are two victims of the same abuse. In fact, Palestinians are very tolerant people. They told my uncle, *"We don't hate the Jews. We just want our land back. If my brother stole my land, I would fight him for it back."* Wouldn't you do the same? It's as simple as that.
    The Palestinians had been incredibly kind and accepted my uncle when his fellow Jews rejected him for his closeness to "dirty Arabs." Struck by the kindness of the Palestinian brothers, he embraced Islam and now strongly advocates for the freedom of Palestine.

  • @pkoven
    @pkoven Месяц назад +3

    what she is saying is total nonsense and if you understood the history of the Middle East you'd know that. just because it's sounds original or sophisticated, or blames a third party, doesn't mean it's true. and just because she was born in Israel or a movie star also doesn't make it true, and doesn't make her an expert.

    • @beachpicnicjoy
      @beachpicnicjoy  Месяц назад +1

      What she says is along the lines of what some historians say about World War II. If we want to give land as a compensation, then why not give a piece of Germany? Why give a piece of the Middle East for what Germany did? The Zionist movement originated in Europe.

    • @pkoven
      @pkoven Месяц назад

      @@beachpicnicjoy if you have any real intent to understand the Arab-Israel conflict, and certainly to convince other people, then you need to study more, write less, and stop being ignorant, and first of all stop writing half-baked ideas that you read somewhere from someone who is ignorant like you. what an incredibly silly claim you made about Zionism originating in Europe. Zionism is intrinsic to the identity of the Jewish people, and the idea and the word itself is all over the Bible, which is about 3000 years old. The State of Israel existed for 1200 years over 3000 years ago [when your "Europe" was just a forest and the French, English and Germans ran around in the forest]., until its destruction in 70AD. was Jesus a "Colonialist" back then? Since the late 19th century the Jewish people are merely coming back to their ancestral homeland. they are the indigenous. The "colonialist" narrative is something the Arabs invented as a PR scheme to undermine the historical connection of the Jews to Israel, in the same way that they deny that the Temple ever stood on the Temple Mount. by writing nonsense like that, you are serving as their useful idiot. Your compensation narrative is also subjective Arabist PR and has no connection to the historical reality of the Jewish people. Spend about 1/2 hour studying on Wiki and you'll be embarrassed by what you wrote.

    • @julienpique7415
      @julienpique7415 Месяц назад

      @@beachpicnicjoy Germany did the worst but we all in the EU were swimming in common antisemitism as it was an ordinary racism deepely rooted at the time, just like now nationnalism and supremacism is growing back and migrants, brown people, and muslims are pointed and get legislations against them voted in many countries.
      It is a collective guilt wich lead to the nazi holocaust, and it is still a collective guilt wich lead to palestinian genocide today as the majority of our representants are too feared or bounded to ACT against it, or they consider palestinians sub humans enough to agree that theyr genocide is the price to pay to end this forever war in Palestine, as the Israel project need to prevail in any of theyr conceiving theories.

  • @bebopkirby
    @bebopkirby Месяц назад +2

    Equating the current plight of these two groups as in someway having a similarity is not only not courageous, but muddled headed in the least, and disingenuous in the worst.

    • @beachpicnicjoy
      @beachpicnicjoy  Месяц назад

      @@bebopkirby Europe committed a holocaust against Jews. And now America has committed a genocide against Arabs. It is the same. And it’s from the same source of colonialism.

    • @bebopkirby
      @bebopkirby Месяц назад

      @@beachpicnicjoy One of us has to be drunk. She did not bring up America at all. She was seeking sympathy for the oppressors by implying what they have suffered... oh never mind,I give up.

  • @TOFKAS01
    @TOFKAS01 Месяц назад +10

    An intellectual stance from a very rich woman who had not many problems in her life.

  • @BramSLI1
    @BramSLI1 Месяц назад +10

    I find it fascinating that the woman who played the part of a people that were nearly colonized by the Trade Guild in Phantom Menace, completely missed the point of the entire story. It's no different than how Mark Hamill has joined the Empire by giving praise the very same administration funding a G-cide. He played the part of a resistance fighter against the Empire and completely missed the entire point of the first three movies. There will soon come a time where the psychology of these people will be scrutinized for how completely obtuse their thinking was during a time where the facts were right in our faces.

  • @NoCluYT
    @NoCluYT Месяц назад +3

    This is kind of BS, but she's in hollywood and of ashkenazi jewish background, so I cannot be too harsh on her. This is probably the worst thing she's allowed to say about israel.

    • @beachpicnicjoy
      @beachpicnicjoy  Месяц назад

      But she is saying that Jews, and Arabs should focus their energy on the source of their trauma and grievances: Europe

    • @captainmajed2078
      @captainmajed2078 28 дней назад +1

      @@beachpicnicjoy Ya but it deflects from the main issue. Palestinians do not see Europeans colonizers when they look at their Jewish brothers. They see actual colonization taking place for the last 100 years. I do agree there are grievances both people should acknowledge and deal with to heal and co-exist. And yes European/US played a massive role in all of this. But none of the trauma can even be addressed if Palestinians cannot return to their rightful homes.

  • @mafiosoginger
    @mafiosoginger Месяц назад +15

    More than 75 years after Israel declared statehood, its borders are yet to be entirely settled. Occupation will extend to the map that exist in their agenda. Yet we have to respect accept Israel, agree on the genocide. Otherwise we are antisemitic

    • @Straight_Talk
      @Straight_Talk Месяц назад

      76 years after Israel's creation, the Palestinians, and much of the Arab/Muslim world, refuse to accept it in ANY borders.

    • @Straight_Talk
      @Straight_Talk Месяц назад +1

      You raise the issue of Israel’s borders. Please advise the borders in which you recognize as being Israel.

    • @Burrburrcloud
      @Burrburrcloud Месяц назад +2

      ​@@Straight_Talk None

    • @mr.iiconic
      @mr.iiconic 23 дня назад

      ​@@Burrburrcloud where do you think a Jewish homeland should be?

    • @Burrburrcloud
      @Burrburrcloud 23 дня назад

      @@mr.iiconic No ethno state has the right to exist precisely because of what we see them doing in Gaza.
      All people are equal no one is special and deserves a country to themselves. Everyone must live together.
      So I think their fascist homeland should be in hell.

  • @LeydenAigg
    @LeydenAigg Месяц назад +7

    "Fine people on both sides."

    • @saidamhamad8793
      @saidamhamad8793 26 дней назад +1

      الناس المنافقة على كلا الجانبين .. 😡

  • @judasthepious1499
    @judasthepious1499 Месяц назад +10

    I'm gonna watch that Leon movie again..

  • @enf.j1830
    @enf.j1830 Месяц назад +37

    Yes to some extent u're right but u can't equate zionist viewing arabs as nazis with arabs viewing zionists as what they're (colonizers) "supposing that zionists are representatives of jews and jewish belief and calling palestinians arabs and concealing their identity is blatant ignorance"
    Only the second view is true on the ground , finding a solution forwards requires recognizing the tragic horrendous situation that palestinians have been put into due to european radicalism and zionists greeds , describing it as if the two sides are equally a victim is basically denying what zionists have been doing to palestinians for over 75 years ! Maybe what she mentioned is an overview but it's absolutely not enough for tagging it with "finding a solution forward"

    • @mapsut77
      @mapsut77 Месяц назад +5

      100% right !

    • @Research0digo
      @Research0digo Месяц назад +1

      She is one person - a very devout Torah Jewess - who knows Jews are never to call anywhere their homeland. She has bravely turned down giga in 'Israel' because of her convictions. I applaud her.

    • @warmperson2007
      @warmperson2007 Месяц назад

      Hamas are worse than nazis. That's a fact ! The nazis at least cared for their own people, while Hamas uses their own people as human shields for their own agenda.

    • @enf.j1830
      @enf.j1830 Месяц назад +2

      @@Research0digo it's her choice in life which is for sure respected , I never discussed her whole personality only the points she addressed in the video, if a Palestinian was describing things the same way she did , I'd have clarified it the same way too, also for her following Torah teachings should I guess make it necessary to differentiate judiasm as her religion from Zionism ideology so ..

    • @timothykassisieh9701
      @timothykassisieh9701 Месяц назад

      Exactly, you stated the facts and exactly what I interpreted in her opinion, she denied the true facts of the history. Let alone she characterized Arabs characterized seeing Jews (Zionists, in this case) as colonialists and Jews see Arabs as Nazis. Why not use the same language on both sides and not dehumanize the other? OMG.

  • @sarahnassar9427
    @sarahnassar9427 19 дней назад +2

    This would be true if it weren't for the fact that one group of Jews is currently being (and has been for the past 76 years) abusive towards Arabs in the same way and maybe even worse than the Europeans were. So, no, that is not a courageous stance.

    • @ThatOneRussianTank
      @ThatOneRussianTank 23 часа назад

      Again, not actual Jews, but Zionists. Ilan Pappe, an ex-Israeli historian, made a fantastic quote: "Most Zionists don't believe God exists, but they believe he promised them Palestine"

  • @supergroovy8346
    @supergroovy8346 3 месяца назад +53

    Can't imagine what its like for Israelis like her who desperately want togetherness and equality over apartheid but are powerless.

    • @beachpicnicjoy
      @beachpicnicjoy  3 месяца назад +11

      she was born in israel. so abandoning your family is not the easiest thing. we all have a family member thats brainwashed but we dont wish death on them

    • @danielburger1775
      @danielburger1775 Месяц назад +23

      Israel was founded on a sense of "racial superiority".
      Israeli Laws have Jews as being superior to the "Arabs".
      The reason Palestinians are called "terrorists" is because Palestinians want to be treated like human beings, and live in a country where no group is discriminated against simply for being the "wrong" ethnicity or religion.
      As long as there is a "Jewish state" in Palestine, there will never be peace in the region.
      What Arafat wanted, why he was killed, is one state where nobody is treated as better or worse than anyone else, solely based on race or religion.
      And that's what the IDF has always fought against.
      The last thing an Israeli wants, whether it's Netanyahu or Portman, is to accept non-Jews as their equal fellow human beings.
      That's why actual Orthodox Jews in the Middle East often identify as "Jewish Palestinians" rather than as "Israelis".
      Palestine would be a state for everyone. Israel is For Jews Only.

    • @aryehhawbaker104
      @aryehhawbaker104 Месяц назад +2

      What? 23% of Israel's citizens are not Jewish, including 21% arabs, including 16% Israeli-Palestinian who live with equal rights under the law.
      There might be something to say about the differential effect of certain laws in practice in the same way we can talk about districting in America affecting some minority negatively but that's about it.
      Israel was founded as a refugee project, Hertzl literally started thinking about it in reaction to the European pogroms that killed some 100000 Jews prior to the holocaust. What are you on about?

    • @danielburger1775
      @danielburger1775 Месяц назад +9

      @@aryehhawbaker104 Wow! You just can't help but lie, can you?

    • @aryehhawbaker104
      @aryehhawbaker104 Месяц назад

      @@danielburger1775 Is Haifa born Arab-Israeli Yossef Hadad lying too? ruclips.net/video/nBwlc6YfDs8/видео.htmlsi=2gGQ1jyQNZvpxfyf
      Now if you want to argue about the occupied territories that's a whole other debate.

  • @DjMcFly69
    @DjMcFly69 29 дней назад +1

    except one of them don't truly want the total cleansing of the other

  • @macncheese3598
    @macncheese3598 29 дней назад +1

    No one is the abusive father and the other is the abused child

  • @syedshayan9223
    @syedshayan9223 Месяц назад +5

    I believe everyone knows that Natalie is a Lady of Jewish Background, Still this Bravery and courage, Salute My Lady

    • @Burrburrcloud
      @Burrburrcloud Месяц назад

      Salute for what? She's done NOTHING and said nothing worthwhile.

    • @ThatOneRussianTank
      @ThatOneRussianTank 23 часа назад

      what is she being saluted for again?

  • @richdespiseus6243
    @richdespiseus6243 Месяц назад +17

    1945, the horrors exposed - solution - 1948, displace other people by occupation. Really?

  • @haroonamin3617
    @haroonamin3617 20 дней назад +1

    I think that was the most uneducated commment ever as well as her not taking a stance this video was a long time ago and she never represented anyone till date there is no courage here I mean read the room she is promoting a movie for crying out loud

    • @TOFKAS01
      @TOFKAS01 18 дней назад

      Her political activism was mostly just personal networking and image. There is not much behind Portman.

  • @mistertamura6190
    @mistertamura6190 Месяц назад +1

    This is just a generic observation by someone who owns a history book. I was more impressed when she turned down that $1 million "Jewish Nobel" award and refusing to travel to Israel.

  • @iliya2010
    @iliya2010 29 дней назад +1

    Boy what a mess is going on in her head!

    • @TOFKAS01
      @TOFKAS01 26 дней назад +1

      Well, its Portman. Hollywood pretentiousness at its best.

  • @Aladin-r8t
    @Aladin-r8t 27 дней назад

    Yeah well, learn about the Corporate origin of colonialism...educate yourself about the kosher BoE...

  • @_l3m35_
    @_l3m35_ 6 дней назад

    Strange title. She's just being practical about it. There are two sides that hate each other and want to see the other disappear. She didn't delve deeply into the causes, who is the oppressor or the oppressed, etc.

  • @aekta888
    @aekta888 Месяц назад +5

    I call bull $hit on her explanation. Just like a jew to liken their vague history to the current genocide and still continue to ask for sympathy.

    • @Straight_Talk
      @Straight_Talk Месяц назад +1

      What do you find vague about the fact that the Jewish people are the original occupants of Israel, having lived there continuously for 3,500 years? Seems perfectly clear to me.

    • @celidagolobic2156
      @celidagolobic2156 Месяц назад

      @@Straight_Talk it is still bull shit. The Palestinians were the habitants when Israel was “created” my the British occupiers. This biblical fairy tale that the Jews should expel the Palestinians from their land is sheer indoctrination and propaganda of Zionism at its worst. The proof is the current genocide. The only solution is to give back the Palestinian Territories to the Palestinians and Israel stay out of Gaza and the West Bank. Free Palestine from apartheid , ethnic cleansing, colonization, occupation, blockade and genocide. Never Again!

    • @giodigiand6529
      @giodigiand6529 6 дней назад

      ​@Straight_Talk what a poor argument, for oppressing and killing humans. You don't deserve better.

  • @hussainalheidary5139
    @hussainalheidary5139 Месяц назад

    I bully you because i have been bullied by someone else how is supporting me to bully you and that is good for me as long as i am not the victim , It is not my fault that God made me bully you .

  • @mememefinally
    @mememefinally 27 дней назад

    The difference being most of the jewish ppl in Israel ARE Europeans /Russians (1st, 2nd or 3rd generation) and their government is and has alaways been colonialists.

  • @habib88dc
    @habib88dc Месяц назад +1

    She seems neutral

  • @DildoraDaleyva
    @DildoraDaleyva 24 дня назад

    Undan kunglim qoldi.uyatsiz ayol

  • @JammieFortier
    @JammieFortier 22 дня назад

    i don't think courage means what you think it means.

  • @contentconsumer487
    @contentconsumer487 Месяц назад

    No read the Bible the had issues before. The courage to claim victim hood?

  • @carlosacta8726
    @carlosacta8726 День назад

    Shes Brave!! Bravo Natalie!!!!

  • @no-brakes
    @no-brakes Месяц назад

    Ummmm.... Douchewitz prodogy?

  • @rachellee.9389
    @rachellee.9389 Месяц назад

    Kamala, be the first U.S. President to say NO to Israel.

    • @sagatuppercut2960
      @sagatuppercut2960 29 дней назад

      I doubt she can find Israel on a map. 😜

    • @rachellee.9389
      @rachellee.9389 28 дней назад

      @@sagatuppercut2960 I doubt you can find a map.

    • @AnuraUkulele
      @AnuraUkulele 25 дней назад

      It doesn't look very likely that Kamala will. In fact, if she even looks like saying no to Israel, the massive Zionist lobby group in the US will swing behind Trump. This is the type of "wedge politics" that pro-Israel supporters have successfully used in the US for years.

  • @AIZIkino
    @AIZIkino 3 месяца назад +12

    She is right of course, but the small difference is that there is only one side that is always ready to reach out for peace

    • @beachpicnicjoy
      @beachpicnicjoy  3 месяца назад +2

      Do you believe jerusalem should be shared between Israel and Palestine? Palestinian Jews believe this

    • @CheatOnlyDeath
      @CheatOnlyDeath 3 месяца назад

      There are a variety of people on both "sides". Those who want peace and denounce violence are a "side". Those who use violence against innocents to further their goals are another "side". Conflict, hate, and distrust are intractable, but Natalie is brilliant to recognize that resolving any conflict begins with recognizing that there are things that everyone has in common. She would make a fantastic diplomat.

    • @derknusperhase_ivi
      @derknusperhase_ivi 2 месяца назад

      @@beachpicnicjoy muslims of all sort shouldnt get any land. only the arabian pelinsula. because this is the only place they get with arguments. muhammad was a warlorld and his religion is and was a doomsday cult. every todays muslim country is jewish or christian and was conquerd with the sword. israel is to the jews, god promised them. also every wise man and women should put theyre trust in israel. because its the only ancient civilisation that exists these days. since the dawn of civili. to this day. all others ALL o them, are coming and going. only israel stands forever and ever. and there are no palestinian jews.

    • @NC1195_
      @NC1195_ 2 месяца назад +11

      Yeah the non stop illegal settlements shows that.

    • @derknusperhase_ivi
      @derknusperhase_ivi 2 месяца назад +1

      @@NC1195_ its legal

  • @Panos-xo9rc
    @Panos-xo9rc Месяц назад

    The moment any holywood actor/actress condemns the occupation he or she will be able to work only in the San Fernando Valley side of movie business , if you know what i mean. And if at that. But i agree with the comments below , no courage here.

    • @warmperson2007
      @warmperson2007 Месяц назад +1

      Why ? There are many Holywood actors who condemn the occupation. For example Suzan Sarandon. And she is acclaimed for it. Today, being courageous is standing for Israel. Portman does it in this short clip, but she doesn't do it strongly enough in my view.

  • @martythetickler
    @martythetickler 24 дня назад

    Well, shit... the lady's got a good point.

  • @maryamabdulrehman8059
    @maryamabdulrehman8059 23 дня назад

    Someone below said read between the lines... I agree

  • @peterjanjanin9883
    @peterjanjanin9883 Месяц назад

    Her real last name is Hershlag....

  • @abstract7073
    @abstract7073 Месяц назад

    Why is she beating around the bush!

  • @SelmaHafizovic
    @SelmaHafizovic 28 дней назад

    Wow it's complicated 😮

  • @KathyZ-y8b
    @KathyZ-y8b Месяц назад +1

    She's coming a little late to the party.

  • @janozcan3060
    @janozcan3060 9 дней назад

    Free Kurdistan

  • @divinhaquem
    @divinhaquem 25 дней назад +1

    It is not Europe who raises a flag as a country in Palestinian land.

  • @Methne555
    @Methne555 Месяц назад

    She was always a horrible actress.

  • @PhilMoskowitz
    @PhilMoskowitz 14 дней назад

    Misplacing blame so as not the to put either Israel or the Islamist.

  • @thelonewolf1894
    @thelonewolf1894 3 месяца назад +30

    Shes a smart cookie

    •  Месяц назад

      And you are a fool.

  • @mario_uzumaki
    @mario_uzumaki 29 дней назад

    equality in apartheid 😂

  • @fmimi72
    @fmimi72 27 дней назад

    Elle soutient le génocide

  • @Outdoorshuntingshooting
    @Outdoorshuntingshooting 9 дней назад

    actors should keep quiet on such matters.

    • @yvngdxtr6166
      @yvngdxtr6166 4 дня назад

      If she cant speak on it you cant either mate

  • @S3Cxb
    @S3Cxb Месяц назад +1

    ❤D❤A❤A❤S❤A❤A❤S.❤
    ت❤ي❤ت❤و❤ن❤ه❤ سعديشن❤دعسيشن❤تيتونه كيان فرح❤ قبل اول ممثله في مقابله وقطع النت وبعده صارت المظاهرات❤ د ع س❤
    ❤. تيتون ❤
    ❤ تيتونه ❤
    ❤ فرح ❤
    ❤. كيان ❤
    ❤ س. ❤
    نجوم القطب حرف السين في درس االعلوم والمقلوبه على متوقع بكتاب حرف س رقعه
    ❤ سين 4❤
    ❤سين ٤❤
    ❤سين 3❤
    ❤ فاء 4❤
    ❤فاء ٤❤
    ❤ ف. ❤
    ❤ سعد❤
    ❤كيان❤. ❤تيتون❤. ❤كيان❤
    ❤س ع د❤
    ❤فرح❤. ❤تيتونه❤ ❤فرح❤

  • @geoffholmes5663
    @geoffholmes5663 9 дней назад

    ❤Is Nat😎

  • @marwanbytes
    @marwanbytes 11 дней назад

    Nonsense.

  • @Makelifecount.
    @Makelifecount. 25 дней назад

    Courage ? 😂

  • @SA-yy1qn
    @SA-yy1qn 15 дней назад

    Bla bla bla

  • @guymalach5710
    @guymalach5710 Месяц назад

    Get played

  • @binthamadicamara2077
    @binthamadicamara2077 Месяц назад

    Nonsense.

  • @petes5041
    @petes5041 Месяц назад +1

    To finish the reference! "is a FARCE!"

  • @chuckles3265
    @chuckles3265 Месяц назад

    Seems like a inciteful take.

    • @beachpicnicjoy
      @beachpicnicjoy  Месяц назад

      Always try to explain how you come to your conclusions. Communication is key!

  • @Whitesilver1970
    @Whitesilver1970 25 дней назад +1

    What a coward!

  • @dewanafzal9857
    @dewanafzal9857 2 месяца назад +3

    Thanks

  • @naeembux-f6h
    @naeembux-f6h 3 месяца назад +3

    Thank you

  • @gino2211
    @gino2211 3 месяца назад +7

    Smart and intellectual personality makes you a good person…a divine goodness
    I watched a clips of her interview with David Letterman when she still 13-14, many times, she is not that kind Hollywood crowd, and great to see that she still keeps and shows her quality.

  • @1973Eliman
    @1973Eliman Месяц назад +1

    Fabtastic woman. She is so truthful.

  • @Stephen-sr2pb
    @Stephen-sr2pb Месяц назад

    There probably will be a good solution in time. The English and the Irish took 800 years. Israel and the Arabs could take longer.

  • @kpg1973
    @kpg1973 28 дней назад

    ITS DE BOTH SIDES!!

    • @beachpicnicjoy
      @beachpicnicjoy  28 дней назад

      @@kpg1973 she’s saying if europe didn’t commit the holocaust, and Arabs were not colonized, then they would not be at war with each other

    • @kpg1973
      @kpg1973 28 дней назад +1

      @@beachpicnicjoy If my grandmother had wheels she would be a bike

  • @sinead7215
    @sinead7215 Месяц назад +11

    Stop the genocide.

  • @pimentoso
    @pimentoso 29 дней назад +2

    That's actually a very good point. And coming from an actress born in Israel, it's huge.
    👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

  • @GeopoliticalInsights-i5o
    @GeopoliticalInsights-i5o Месяц назад +1

    Smart woman!

  • @abdullahasanovski4091
    @abdullahasanovski4091 Месяц назад +1

    She has balls. 💪👏👏👍

  • @b.pradhana_ol660
    @b.pradhana_ol660 Месяц назад

    I have to bookmark this video! This is very interesting and insightful assessment..

  • @paulgodbey304
    @paulgodbey304 Месяц назад

    Biblically, the land Israel occupies is theirs plus more land that is in that region was given to them. The Arabs disputing this really don't have a good argument other than Ishmael was the older son so he should have inherited the land. The problem with this argument is that Isaac was the son given to Abraham by God, while Ishmael was Abraham trying to make it happen himself. The second argument is that Arabs were on the land in 1948 when Israel fought and occupied the land for the first time in nearly 2000 years. Please refer to the above explanation. By the way, I am not Jewish.

    • @_l3m35_
      @_l3m35_ 6 дней назад

      Nobody cares what the Bible says, it's a fiction book. And being in a land 3 thousand years ago is not an excuse to bomb the hell out of children to kill 1 target.