the new Avatar remake is kinda dumb
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 фев 2024
- Use ALEXMEYERS to get 55% off your first month at Scentbird sbird.co/3vSZHj2
This month I received...
Cobalt Patchouli & Cedar by Jo Loves sbird.co/3HPA9GB
Pure Emerald by Avant sbird.co/3S6W3K5
Sexual Steel by Michel Germain sbird.co/4b0xTcG
★☆★ Help Me Get to 4,000,000 Subscribers! bit.ly/1Iqsdaq
★☆★Buy some Merch: alexmeyers.teemill.com
★☆★PLEASE SHARE THIS VIDEO!!
★☆★PREVIOUS VIDEOS:
Spy Kids 4
• Spy Kids 4 is worse th...
One Piece
• One Piece is a weird show
Disney's Wish
• Disney's Wish is kinda...
Thank you so much for 3,000,000 subscribers. If you like what you see, please share these videos with your friends to show support! 
Развлечения
![T.I., & YoungBoy Never Broke Again - LLOGCLAY [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3sqqBjGByXI/mqdefault.jpg)
Use ALEXMEYERS to get 55% off your first month at Scentbird sbird.co/3vSZHj2
Is it really that bad? I like it. I will continue to watch it! 😍💖🔥
The videos only been out for minutes
🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯😅❤😢😂😅🎉😮❤😅😂😢❤😅😅😢😢❤😢❤🎉😂😢😂🎉😮😂😢😂🎉❤😢❤😢❤😂❤😂😊😊❤😊🎉😊😂😊❤😊🎉😊😊🎉😊❤😊😂😊😊❤😊🎉😊❤😊🎉😊😂😊🎉😊😊❤😊❤😊😊🎉😅😂😊😊❤😊🎉😊❤😊🎉😊😊❤😊😂😊❤😊🎉😊🎉😮🎉😅😂😊😮❤🎉😊😊🎉😮😂😅😂😢❤😊🎉😅😂😢❤😊🎉😮😢😂😅❤😅😂😅🎉😊😮❤😢❤😅😂😊🎉😮😂😢❤😅😅❤😮😂😢😅❤😊❤😅❤😢😂😂😅😊❤😮🎉
please watch the 2010 movie cause it's the stupidest movie you will ever see it will be so funny
Hiiiiiiiiiiiii Alex
I HAVEN"T HEARD ZUKO SAY HONOR ONCE THIS ENTIRE SEASON
He says it. One time. Which is about as many times as he says 'Uncle!'
It's like they knew he had to say those two things, so they made him say each once to get it out of the way.
RIGHT
So what does he call iroh?@@PedroBenolielBonito
@@theredandblueyakuza9256he mostly doesn't. And he especially doesn't in THAT WAY. You know, with THAT inflection? Not even once.
The one time he does say it, he pauses right before, as if saying 'are you ready, people? Here it comes!' You can hear the ellipses. It's really cheesy lol
It was a complaint about the show forever is Zuko talking about his honor, kinda like how Katara talked about her mother every. Time.
Talking about it and dealing with the trauma after some time with progression makes up for the flaws of the original
I didn't like how Aang just went for a late night flight on Appa. In the original he was actually running away when he got caught in the storm. And later he struggles with the guilt, which helps in his character development
Specifically running away from the reality of being the avatar.. One of my favorite episodes is when katana and sokka get sick and aang has to wrestle with the guilt. In doing so, accidentally helping zuko out... Could have been cool to see his guilt expanded upon, but instead he just "went out for a fly" like come on!
This is exactly how I felt with multiple scenes in the show, like when Aang is able to fully pull himself out of the Avatar state when he discovers the destruction of the air temple. All he has to do is think back to his mentor and he can suppress his rage. In the original show, his rage consumes him and physically pushes Katara back. Katara talks to him about her own experiences with loss and talks him down enough for Aang to be approachable once more, where she takes his hand and fully takes him out of the Avatar state, showing that Aang has no full control over his true power and needs the help of friends to guide and ground him (plus the determination of Katara to get back up and try again to help him etc.). But nah, Aang is a genius monk able to do it all himself... what a joke or a script lol
THIS!!! Especially because everyone seems to be trying to guilt trip him in the Netflix show for being trapped in ice, which would make more sense if it happen like in the original show with him running away.
@@Conquereddid we watch the same show or not? Aang was about to throw sokka and katara off the cliff. It was katara yelling out to him in pain, that he realized he needed to be there for his friends and stopped. He didn't want to hurt them
@@mewtwomotherfuka You must be watching the wrong show. It was Aang remembering Gyatso's words that allowed him to snap oit of the Avatar state in the Netflix show. You do know that we're talking about the Netflix show, right?
Bro i hate that zuko didn't say the word HONOUR throughout the entire live action while it was like his only line in the original show
I missed that so much 😤
It was replaced by the word GLORY which changes the story more than the writers think.
Omg I literally waited and it never came :(
my HONOR!!!!
oh my gosh he never says it?!?!? Episode one was so bad, mostly all in the dialouge department, that I'm not motivated to watch any more... :( That sucks!!
WHY IS GRAN GRAN NARRATING THE ENTIRE HISTORY? HOW DOES SHE KNOW AANG IS THE AVATAR?
Exactly...their logic is If she's old = she knows everything thts going on ,and she straight up tells the audience 😂😂😂
That might be the thing that bugged me the most in the first episode. It felt like they stripped all the character out of Gran Gran and just had her be exposition. Yeah, she was wise and clever in the original, but she wasn’t omniscient. I could not think of anything that would justify her knowing that Aang is the Avatar.
I guess it could only be explained by supposing that it is common knowledge that the next avatar had to be an Airbender and that another one was never born. So by that you could assume, that the last Airbender avatar must still be alive somewhere. So when she saw an Airbender, she thought "huh, guess he must be the avatar, since he is the only Airbender we've seen in forever". But yeah, it is still ridiculously mentalist of her. Who would put all that together in like 10 Minutes
@@Ayla7650Possibly, but the thing is that the Airbenders were very isolated and it had been 100 years, nobody knows they look like let alone identify them. And when an Avatar is reborn, no one really knows about it except at most word of mouth, which you're not gonna get alot from the southern water tribe because it doesn't get a lot of traffic. Granted even if she noticed he was an airbender, that doesn't mean he would have been the Avatar because he would have been too young. Most people assumed he would have been like ancient, which Zuko actually did.
Grandma ex machina
Okay but Alex.... You HAVE to watch the OG animated show. It's phenomenal. You don't need to do an episode on it, but you should watch it for yourself.
Yup, that actually made me drop my jaw, that he never actually watched it!
I took a long time to sit down and watch it in order, too, but still.
Then again he watches so much for the channel, and if he knows he's never gonna make a video about it...
@@BixLovesMiley i get that for sure. But considering his fondness for animation and the quality of the show it for sure belongs on his watch list
This 100%
yes he needs to watch it before he continues this live action cause it would spoil it for him
I can't help but notice they didn't make any of the characters black or gay.. apparently it's only okay to do that when the characters were originally white? 🤔
The problem with this show is they fix problems that weren’t actually problems, like Sokka’s sexism, which they eliminate, but there’s a whole arc about him being humbled and learning he isn’t that guy
And its clear in the show that Sokka's sexism was a part of an established culture of the water tribe when they went to the North pole and saw that women were not allowed to learn fighting. It appeared because most of the men left and the women remained in the south that the women took more dominate roles, but I still think they shared similar culltures in that regard making Sokka more of a cultural problem than anything.
They're practically skipping character development. You're forced to be accepting and 'respecting' from the very beginning regardless of the natural circumstances in the location and time period of the show, never earning it. Just following a doctorial path that was set to you. Such ideal paths are artificial when it isn't based on learning and growing but simply following it. Reminds me almost of that anime when there was a program to literally destroy consciousness in the population in order for a ideal world. Void of complaints. A lifeless utopian world.
The anime movie I'm referring to; *Harmony*
Disclaimer: very disturbing. Viewer's discretion.
I love how simplistically people look at this stuff. Like small tribal cultures have the luxury of letting their women die in combat. Sorry folks but when you have a small population each woman is ten or twenty times more important for the survival of said tribe.
the character growth was great :(
Right. I found it quite jarring during the interaction and fighting scene with Suki, it was forced and unnecessary, like, "why is she even trying to prove anything to him, he NEVER said anything offensive or remotely sexist?", it was just mostly awkward. They could've left that out like they did so many other parts (that could've been put in).
Aang needs to master all 4 elements, but throughout the first season, he never tries to learn waterbending
YES!!! YES EXACTLY
OMFG THANK YOU!!!!!!!
Katara tried to teach her but he was like "nah thanks". Like wtfff
Fr
I thought it was just me that noticed 😅
I like that he said “Cosplayers” because some of the characters ABSOLUTELY are cosplayers picked up at a convention by the casting director. 😂
Like Sokka, i can't see the guy as a real version of Sokka, just a cosplayer
Aang's acting is so bad!
@@jonal5126I feel like… he’s exactly what Sokka should be. 😂😂 His like, borderline drama school final project performance makes him seem more accurate
@@jonathan-us5jmI’ll say, I think he does a great job… for what he’s given. You can tell the writing, with them not trying to repeat lines 1 for 1, is a little messy. But he’s doing great with it imo.
@@iitstre_4550yh
sokka being robbed of his sarcasm in every remake is the real downpoint
I mean he wasn't robbed of it. He just didn't crack the jokes nearly as much as he used to. I will say overall the series definitely could be improved very much such as give them back their key traits but it wasn't done as bad as I expected
Fr
@@doriankamanzi6874
Bro ALL your comments on this matter are cope, just stop. “It’s not THAT bad” yes it is. If you even have to say that, yes it is.
He was still lively asf, a very memorable character in the show. And he could deliver the jokes but some of the ones written for him were meh
Yeah 🤦🏾
In the original, they already knew he was the avatar,and they told him when he was 12 despite his mentor wanting him to have a childhood first. Thats literally what made everything else in the story possible
Don't read my name.
they also gave him his appa whistle strait away rather then him getting it at the market place
Not to mention the grandmother just... _knowing_ he was the avatar? In the show they didn't figure it out until things got desperate and the power kicked in. The grandmother just showing up and saying, "You are Avatar!!" just feels so much more like random exposition.
(I'm betting they didn't want to spend the money on the CG so they found a way to not have to have that happen.)
Uh okay so
@@VraerynDaDragonespecially considering it’s been a century. It would just be folklore at that point, he could be any airbender. Netflix made it a generic superhero show lol
Azula's first major appearance in original:
-Scary and demanding
-Threatsns someone's life
-Lightning
-Her plan to capture zuko only fails because of some idiot soldier
Azula in remake:
-Fails at convincing Ozai that Zhao, not Zuko, found the avatar
-Inferiority complex with Zuko
-Throws a hissy fit and nearly burns someone in rage (regular color fire, btw)
-Needs to be stopped by Mai and Ty Lee
In the original, we are promised a much more scary villain. Someone who is capable, manipulative, and incredibly intelligent. That's because... She is.
In the remake, however, we meet a spoiled brat who fails at even just buttering up her father, and reacts so emotionally she needs to be kept in check by those around her.
Wherever they take her character, that's the first thing they show us. That's what they promised her character is. You can't take that back.
When she’s talking to Ozai was horrible. In the animated series she’s so powerful and crazy that when you see her bowing down to her father “THE FIRE LORD” every time they interact you can, without even see him move a finger, what kind of tread he represents. Now he looks so approachable and Azula is so meh. They put them so down to earth that they don’t even impact anymore.
Azula never was capable of "buttering" up her father. I guess you didnt read the comics.
In book 4 Azula is mentally broken and Ozai speaks about how he always played the 2 siblings against each other.
It is canon that Azula was always outplayed by Ozai. The cartoon just didnt show many moments of it.
I am glad that the netflix show shows her insecurity. Although i personally dont like the way the actor looks.
Yeah I agree also They did Azula mei and Ty lee so dirty with the casting 😭😭 I didn’t think it was possible to be so unintimidated by a show villain
In the original she was actually cold and calculated and incredibly skilled. She mostly just seems emotional now, and not really scary. We’ll see what they do with it I guess
@@duukm Have you not watched the original. Or do you just have selective memory? Because everyone was constantly on edge around Azula afraid of her ( emotional) outbursts.
Not to mention after her friends betrayed her or at the Last Agni Kai.
This show comes off as a chat gpt summary of the original
@UncleTom854-bm5lvif you want to waste time and doesn't care about the lore.. It's fine and the bender fight are cool ngl.
I asked chat gbt to give me a summary of the first season of Avatar and this is what it said.
The first season of "Avatar: The Last Airbender," also known as Book One: Water, follows the journey of 12-year-old Aang, the last surviving Airbender and the long-lost Avatar, whose destiny is to bring peace to the world by ending the Fire Nation's war against the other nations. Aang is discovered frozen in an iceberg by Katara and Sokka, siblings from the Southern Water Tribe. As they travel, Aang learns that he must master the elements of Water, Earth, Fire, and Air to defeat the Fire Nation.
The season chronicles Aang's quest to master Waterbending, starting with their journey to the Northern Water Tribe. Along the way, they encounter various challenges, including run-ins with the Fire Nation, led by Prince Zuko, who is determined to capture Aang to regain his honor. The trio also encounters other characters, such as the rogue Earthbender Toph and the mysterious Blue Spirit.
As they progress, Aang and his friends face complex moral dilemmas and experience personal growth. The season culminates in the Siege of the North, where Aang and his friends defend the Northern Water Tribe against a major Fire Nation attack. Aang taps into the Avatar State, merging with the ocean spirit to repel the invaders. The season ends with the Fire Nation retreating, but with hints of greater challenges to come, including the rise of a more menacing antagonist, Azula.
@rayanvij3457 this is actually better than the remake😂😭
Why is every adaptation of avatar literally just the bad fire nation play.
Ember Island players was legendary, who knew they'd treat it as the mood for the show 😂
Naaa... Ember Island Players was peak😂
It holds up waaay better than all these remakes
This comment is top tier
it’s like there foreshadowing that people would try making terrible remakes 😨
That’s not fair. At least the Ember Island Players understood pacing & characterization.
One thing I love from the original's pilot episodes was how Sokka and Katara explained waterbending. Katara starts to say, "It's not magic, it's waterbending..." like she's about to go into an expository spiel about it, but then Sokka cuts her off and mocks her for it. But in mocking her, he ends up explaining waterbending himself. Then, just a couple of minutes later, Katara gets frustrated with Sokka, and we get this neat shot where we can see the water all around Katara follow her movements. At the height of her anger, she accidentally destroys a large iceberg with her waterbending, which presumably caused/allowed the iceberg that Aang was trapped in to surface.
First, they made fun of shows that like to just throw exposition in your face, then they told us what waterbending is, then they SHOWED us what waterbending is, all the while establishing the personalities and relationship of these two characters, before seamlessly introducing Aang. It's fabulous.
Exactly! The original was ALL about the little things and that’s what made it literally amazing. This one glosses over so many details and intricacies, it’s sad..
I miss the sexism in the show.
Adding: I'd also mention that this aspect of Sokka and considering his environment he grew up in, all played a role in his character development. Taking away this early flaw is the equivalent of taking a piece of Sokka's identity and his character growth. He's now less narrow minded and thus, is flatter as a character. The show was amazing for the struggle and learning throughout the series. If we take away the struggle aspect and only learn, then how can we appreciate it without earning/experiencing it?
@@VinnyUnionsounds bad out of context 😂
@@lmnop29 it sure does. Either way I dislike changes that abbreviate wrongfully from the original source.
For instance in the show Aang had his tongue "frozen" while he was playing with the water tribe kids and it wouldn't had harmed to include a scene like that exactly like in the original material. It doesn't has to be a 1:1 replica motion to motion, at the very least it could've added these details. Actually, I'm not even inclined to call "details" because it was a literal scene. To Netflix:"get'cho shit together."
the original show has had an excellent writer. sad, he didn’t work on Korra with them
Why does it feel like the studios remaking certain popular series always miss the point in what made them great.
One piece is the only exception
Because they make them for money. That’s all they want. Not authenticity, just greed.
The funniest part is that Aang never once learned water bending the entire season 😂
fr. and it is called water
One of the things I immediately did not like was Katara's quietness and complasaintness with Sokka. She would even lower her head a bunch of times when he spoke to her throughout the first episode. I was like WHO IS THIS WOMAN?
Her character keeps being portrayed as this fimble character. But she really is an outspoken, young girl who doesn't let anyone talk down on her or anything. She always stood her ground, idk why they keep making her this weak female character smh!
Fr I actually said “why is sokka acting like he’s the oldest” then I remembered he is actually the oldest. In the animated version, you’d easily forget katara was the youngest. It’s not hard to miss in this series.
@@AyeleyokiedokieSame I just thought Sokka was younger but got taller because he is growing into a man after all he certainly doesn’t act older.
Sibling rivalry was portrayed well. They bikered with each other and katara even said “youre not dad”. Its just that whenever sokka spoke they intentionally made it sound bad with the framing and silence. When katara spoke it was sokka who was complaisant and was made to be the fool. Damn even in episode 8 they made katara the rey skywalker of the show. Not sure what you’re talking about.
@@thesis-and-nieces6722funny bc in the OG Katara would never seriously undermine Sokka in that way, but we did have an ep with Katara being humbled in that way about mothering the team. They've inversed the roles.
You have no idea how much I agree with the costuming. Like, they look like costumes rather than actual clothes.
It seemed like they actually got more pristine as the show went on, like they swapped in new sets that weren’t worn in at all lmao
I think this also plays to his point about animation. Technically, the clothes in the animated shows were clean looking, but it’s a cartoon so your mind fills in the blanks. It’s the same thing with everyone wearing the same color when they are from the same place. In a cartoon, sure! In live action, what is this, communism? Or having a character wear the same clothes every day.
@@vonsowards1297 i agree, some things should just be animated, it's better that way
Especially since they look at least for the ice nation cheap and flimsy they don't look like something that would keep someone warm, get some hide not perfectly dyed blue.
I do like the Asian traditional clothes worn by some of the background characters. They event though just costume feel match the upbringing. The main character costumes I agree with how they look like costumes instead of clothes
0:29 that girl was gold. She introduced you to something awesome!
I'll admit the idea that ANY fan of 2D animation hasn't seen the original Avatar the Last Airbender is mind blowing.
The show is bottled lightning.
The first book is a little slow, but by the time you get to the end of the series you REALLY appreciate where it comes from.
Animation still holds up over a decade later. Beautiful character development. A story that is woven like a tapestry. I genuinely don't believe there is true filler.
Every episode builds character or the world or parts of the story.
Thing that pisses me off so much about the show is that it does not trust the audience.The original avatar did a great job of showing character motivations. The show just tells you.
Looking at the comments people still don’t listen they are asking questions the show literally answers
@@bluecyclone7077 Well that's their problem. Doesn't mean that shows should just tell everything that happens.
given ppls reactions to the show they were completely right in not trusting them
Was looking for this comment! It’s one of the best things about the originial show, I wish they would just trust the audience to understand!
@@bluecyclone7077I think one reason why that’s the case is because the large majority of media that’s been made for the past few years are all tell not show. Hollywood has been dumbing down their movies for a while now and as a result we see viewers who are unable to think for themselves and put 2 and 2 together based on subtle cues and micro expressions
the live action looks better than i expected, but the writing is SO disappointing. it’s not just the plot points they’ve changed, the whole essence of the show feels gone. the brilliant wisdom of the original seems lost, it’s like the people who made this version never really understood the point of the original at all.
Exactly, it seems as if they barely looked at what made the show great. Basically, thought they could make a better adaptation Imo. I don’t think it’s awful but it’s not great that’s for sure.
will you just stop ranting on garbage live action adaptation on beloved animation!? this is still garbage than one piece! please netflix let it flopped!
Better than expected only bcuz we had that 2010 movie first otherwise from a CGI perspective it looks terrible. The way Appa and Momo look and the other animals is demonizing and not realistic in the slightest
In their so brilliant wisdom business executive way, they actually said that it needed to be more game of thrones like for the audience. And it feels like it lol. That alone ruins it for me but the tone and overall vibe is bad beyond that idea even.
It lost ALL of its ambiguity. I can’t stand when the writers treat the audience like they’re stupid
The scene when Avatar Kyoshi takes over Aang's body was so badass tho
I really hated it personally because it should have looked like Aang still with ghost Kyoshi over him. It all felt pretty cringy
@@ashesandposies And it takes so much away from Roku's dynamic with Aang imo. It felt meaningful when Roku was the first and only Avatar to ever take over for Aang and specifically during the solstice only.
Instead we got whatever this was.
@@samirraza9069 Agreed. Another commentator made the point that they spent _so much_ screen time with Kyoshi showing how awesome being "powerful" is, and then the counter point to that idea provided by Roku was barely visited at all.
just few dialouges ago kiyoshi was saying how ruthless avatar needs t o be and when she comes to fight fire nation soldiers she just.....drags soldiers by grabbing them by their legs????? and shows a lil fire circle and then leaves even before zhao left? where he could have easily turned back and beaten avatar.
@@samirraza9069it pissed me off. They destroyed kyoshi character by changing her
Ty Lee never moves beyond walking a few feet. She’s an acrobat and is constantly jumping and stretching. It was strange to see her so still.
i guess you can say Netflix didn't capture the avatar very well
Don't read my name.
Yes they did I give 7/10 same most fans I talk to say the same thing
took me a sec xd
No, shut up
Get out. Now!
I do not like how Katara's grandma is like the wise old lady in this new show. In the original she was so chill
Plus I think Macaulay Caulkin in Home Alone was a better actor than she is lol
@@davidkimpton6775no idea how this is supposed to be an insult because macauley is one of the world’s most famous and iconic child actors of all time?
@@marissa5664 he’s still a child compared to a 60-70+ year old woman who should be able to do better
All the funny characters act too seriously, the only one that acts like the actual cartoon is the freaking cabbage dude.
@@Dragonk116 And he killed it
I love that the arrow on your cartoon drawing for Aang gets bigger and bigger as the video goes on
This is our the gag with the sheriff's hat in Scary Movie 3 😂
They could have used all that money to make a continuation of the last air bender with team avatar working to restore the world post war.
"But the effects were decent!" - Sokka
Could've sworn he said at least
Lmaooo
Lmao 😂
They were not sadly
Were they tho
That clip of Sokka and Katara from the animated series was so refreshing. It reminded me of how good the dialogue is in the original and made me realize how truly awful it is in the Netflix adaptation. Even though the voice acting is exaggerated because it's a cartoon, it still sounds way more like real conversation between actual siblings.
i wouldn't even say it's that exaggerated lol, sokka just has personality there lmao
As someone who really enjoyed the new adaptation, I 100% agree with you. Aang and Katara are both far cries from their original selves. Aang is far too serious, and Katara has none of her blind optimism, or even her attitude towards the boys. They’re both very hollow versions of the characters we knew imo.
Zuko and Iroh’s actors understood the assignment imo, they got the characters “right” to begin with (like got their basic energy and vibes down pact) and also managed to add more at the same time.
EXACTLYYY!
Tell me about it. You know you're better off just taking this opportunity to rewatch the original show again. That's what I did. Instead of watching the live action when it released I just started watching the animated one again with a newfound appreciation of just how gosh dang good it is the whole way through. I'm not even that disappointed that the live action couldn't live up to the original, because we still have the original, and it's just as great as it always has been. I really don't think it's possible to capture the personality and magic of the cartoon in live action, even with the best script and actors imaginable. You just can't reach the same levels of expression in live action without it feeling uncanny. I will never understand why Hollywood keeps trying and failing this same schtick. None of the recent live action remakes have got anywhere close to the quality of the originals.
@@highdefinition450 True actually. Just the other day I was having an argument with my younger brother and in the middle of it I was thinking "why tf am I acting like a cartoon character"
Tbh I still don’t get why we need a live action version of every series. It’s clear that no matter how good it will be, it won’t outshine the original, since everyone has a picture on how it “should be”
The thing I didn’t like about the show was the old avatars have like hatred (BARELY except roku) and are constantly telling Aang to do it himself when I’m the animated show it’s more like a flow of past avatars actually helping him with the avatar state and what to do. Roku especially in the cartoon bc of Sozins comet, but in the irl series it’s more like everyone hated Aang for being there but he was like literally a child so like it didn’t make any sense when it’s right in front of they faces
Now that you mention it, no air bender should be able to fly. It’s established in the lore that they lost their ability to fly and now use the gliders to propel themselves. So I hope aang is just gliding in the air temple and not actually flying
He is, he’s just using air to jump high.
I was told their earthly attachments to sky bison’s is what stopped them from flying. Zaheer was able to fly after having no earthly attachments
In Legend of Korra, airbenders can straight up fly
@@trexasaurus5322that’s only zaheer, because he let go of all earthly attachments
@@trexasaurus5322 Zaheer, Guru Laghima can fly unassisted as they are the only ones who let go of their earthy attachments. Airbenders from the age during/before Wan(origin of Avatar) can create cloudlike formations to float for a time. However no on else can fly unassisted, as Aang and any other airbender has to use a glider or if you watched all of ATLOK. You'll see some can actually glide downwards with a specialized wing suit akin to Momo/Lemurs. .
In the animated show when aang was told he was the new avatar he was alienated by the other kids and was told he would have to leave his home in order to train. That being "special" wasnt cracking up to what it sounded like. Like imagine telling a child he has to move away from all his friends.
maybe the live action didn't communicate that aspect as well as it could have lol
@UncleTom854-bm5lv Agreed. They should have just made a whole new story. But considering the current state of the entertainment industry, that probably would have been worse than Legend of Korra; and I liked Korra despite its downsides.
They also insinuated that he will be separated from his father figure, and in a way alienated from all he knows and loves.
So, the air nomads were going to help the Earth Nation against the Fire Nation, while also celebrating the comet's passing, while also knowing it gave firebenders the power of a thousand suns??? Make it make sense...
fr
Weren't the Air Nomads pacifists? I haven't seen the remake, but I'm a fan of the original. The reason they were killed was because they refused to fight.
@@LeedleLee457 I don't think so, if the mountain of fire nation corpses around Gyatso's skeleton is anything to go by.
It's so true though, why do companies here absolutely hate animation??? 😭 It's so amazing, and I feel like you can get a ton of emotion especially from the voice actors themselves. It's exactly why so many people love it so much, but companies choose to ignore it for some reason-
OG show is phenomenal!
One of my biggest critiques with the Netflix version is Aang never actually waterbends. Or tries to. That makes no sense.
Let's not forget him suddenly water bending when the avatar state kicked in was _the_ signal to everyone about what he was when he didn't tell them. Because no one else can do that.
Lol literally Book 1 is water.
Didn’t watch the live action yet, but if Aang never or didn’t tried to waterbend yet, Netflix miss the point unless they are doing it over multiple seasons.
In the animated, Aang at least tried to waterbend with Katara’s teaching and even tried to firebend in 1 episode.
No it's overrated
My guess is that season 2 will begin with them staying in the north for a whole year learning water bending, which will explain the kid growing up and why they removed learning water bending from season 1
I kinda wished you’d seen the OG first. Kataras character is so lame now
yeah like atleast they got her clothes right but she barely vocal
They were so worried about sokka being sexist but then made the entire movie sexist by removing any real role for katara. Her ability to do anything is limited to only after being told by a male character how to think or what to feel. Wtf?
@@andyf7027 ironically sexism is the reason why they discovered aang and how suki and him developed at the firstplace. live action lowkey got woke for this
@@juanchoresultay2704 while I agree on the sexism thing, I resent you using the word woke in a derogatory way. Saying that makes it seem like it's marginalized communities fault media is portrayed in certain ways when corporations are just scared to take risks so it won't affect their bottom line or whatever they call their earnings stuff. Denoting something as woke is actually causing more harm to marginalized communities and impedes actual progress.
That said, this show ruined my babies and I am so pissed
@@jackieroberts2625 my apologies about that but as you said the studios are playing things safe , I mean I have no hatred in other communities and minorites but if its forced and use for clout, it might not work right and that’s not my point . what I meant in lowkey woke is how they hindering the sexism of sokka and changing it to play it safe its like its already illegal to show it (like not justify obviously but its one the things that developed the story ). And please don’t resent/deem me like this, and I know you have every right to say that to me but don’t project me like this too quickly. Sorry to say that…I was trying to make a point here ,not to attack the show or anyone. I guess I said it in a wrong way but thats are the words I can think of for now
Part of the problem I think is that there are less episodes and longer episodes. They merged multiple episodes together and also completely removed story lines.
episodes usually follow natural progression with a climax of the story somewhere in the middle and then the resolution at the end. they didn’t do that well for the combined episodes, they didn’t actually combine them properly into 1 story they were just two or three separate stories in the same episode. Which makes the longer episodes useless in several cases.
I think the series feeling rushed is the main problem here. It was 8 whole episodes almost 1 hour each and yet, i felt like i didn't "see" any of the characters enough. Zuko and Iroh maybe yes but the main 3 characters just got lost on me. I just couldn't understand their essence. There was so much happenning in such a short time so I couldn't connect to the characters or feel their emotions. Or even the destruction of the war that had been going on for a 100 years... Like, come on.
Avatar was one of my favorite cartoons growing up and it has too much depth and creativity to be captured in 8 episodes.
this is my main gripe with it as well, constricting a story into 8 neat episodes often stunts the progression and ruins important arcs. now that we're out of the pandemic and the SAG-AFTRA strike has been resolved, scripts will likely be better quality and things won't feel as rushed (especially because atla specifically got confirmed for 2 more seasons, so they no longer have any excuse to chop up storylines)
Man, they did Gyatso dirty in that first episode. When they see his body in the original series his skeleton is sat against a wall, looking almost meditative, while the ground around him is absolutely covered with the corpses of dead firebenders which he presumably killed before succumbing to his own injuries. In the live action he knocks a few grunts to the floor, then dies screaming at the hands of a single firebender.
They did the same thing with Iroh, too (and presumably Bumi, but I missed that episode). The dude fired off a few missed shots to scare away Zhao at the Spirit Oasis in the live action, whereas in the original he managed to body 4 soldiers and forced Zhao to flee in the space of a few seconds. The old masters got no respect in the live action.
also seems like theyre totally tossing out the white lotus storyline which kinda sucks imo
Jongjong is missing. The white lotus will never form.
Also, pakku didn't notice katara's necklace. What a sham.
I mean, that "single firebender" was Firelord Sozin. So...
@adamisajoker Huh, guess I must've missed that detail. In any case, it doesn't change the fact that Gyatso was done dirty.
In the first episode, there's this very weird out-of-place question Aang asks Gyatso. After he's told he's the Avatar, he asks "Can't I just keep pretending to be your friend?", which is exactly what every friendship in this show feels like, pretend. The friendship- and character development of the original show are *chef's kiss**😙👌
When I heard that line I was immediately reminded of Man of Steel. When Clark says "can I still pretend Im your son?" And Jonathan replies the same way, "You are my son." 😅
Pretend in what way
Also I feel we all knew how special Gyatso and Aangs relationship was through the small flashbacks in the animation. This show waters it down with so much in your face stuff. Aang was supposed to feel immense guilt for shouting at him and leaving. But in the live action they reunite in spirit world which feels unearned. It was touching but it happened in like ep 5 instead of near the end of show.
The "best" part for me is that in the cartoon, everytime that a flashback of the air temple happens, aang is gooffing around, but in Netflix series he litteraly says that he likes to goofy around and we never see that. Its exactly the opposite of show not tell, its so "good" man
@@shawerful5209 sarcastic right
This is why I watched the first season without watching or reading any reviews, yes I did notice the changes they made from the original show, but some of them I actually like for example Iroh and Ozai actually interacting with each other, and finding out the Zukos crew was the crew that was supposed to die when Zuko spoke out in the war meeting
@@UncleTom854-bm5lv unfortunately we don’t live in a world where everything revolves around your opinion 🤷🏻♂️
The visual are great. They should have never tried to do the last air bender story. There are so many other avatars they could have and should have shown us. Anytime you do a remake you are gonna be held to the standard of the original material.
11:25 You're pretty spot on about the inconsistency with Aang's flying. In the shows and books Air Nomads lost their ability to fly after they befriended the sky bison. This is because flight is tied to a spiritual practice involving severing emotional ties that keep people's souls bound to the physical world.
Most Air Nomads are able to imitate flight though by bending air currents around their gliders but actually being able to fly is something you only see a character from the LoK series be able to do.
It makes sense for them to use gliders for more sharper and direct flying, and use air bending for more free and graceful gliding and hovering. I don’t think he was really flying, as he appeared to be bending the air around and below him to glide and catch himself, but with Zaheer we doesn’t appear to bend the air at all, he just starts flying
Since Ang (i forgot how to spell) had to sever his ties to the mortal world to go into tge avatar state, cab he fly?
@@louisecram2616 I don't think he ever actually did in the series. He tried to meditate with the old man but couldn't finish his meditation and training after realizing he would have to let go of Katara. Then he still got into a relationship with Katara after everything was over and had Teshin and Boomie.
@cram2616 Nah, to master the avatar state, you need to learn to let go. Because you can't save everyone. Avatar can never sever their ties to the world because they need to care about the world ( thus earthly attachment ) to save it.
They really need to stop telling actors to look directly into the camera. Unless your Deadpool.
*you're
@@akademischungebildet5564 A Grammer Nazi. Good to know.
I made a drinking game for whenever someone says some variant of the phrase "We're not in Wolf Cave anymore." It wasn't dozens of times, but it was enough to make me yell at the screen saying "No fucking shit you're in the spirit world dumbass." or "Do you not know where you are right now?"
You are so right about the old people, that granny in this series was like "Listen dude, your whole race was wiped out and you're next! Also you are the avatar, now go and save the world and grief later, I don't care that you are still a little child with a fragile mind!"
The main issues is they cut roku moment when he told Aang that he needs to master 4 element before the summer end because sozin's comet will arrive at that time. Without it, the live action loses the purpose of the story. Because of it, Aang never really trying to study waterbanding. We need season 1 studying waterbanding, season 2 studying earthbanding, and finally studying firebanding. All of this is because Aang must defeat Ozai before the comet comes at the end of summer, and LA didn't do it
They did this in case the LA show got cancelled. So they made s1 about saving northern tribe from invasion when the only reason they went there in animation was to get a water bending master. Its crazy, because they are all supposed to be so inexperienced even by end of s1. As Sokka does nothing but guard Yue, Katara gets better and proved her self to Pakku and Aang gets angry and becomes that ocean spirit. They all still have so much to learn. But in live action Katara is already a master? Nooooo.
@@Natta44it is Not completely right either. They did it, bc the actors are still kids and getting older. So thats why the comet has to arrive later. Therefore needs to be introduced later in the story. It also wouldnˋt be smart to change the Prophecy and make the comet arrive 4 years later instead of 6 Month, bc then the ugency to master all the Four elements in a short amount of time will be Gone.
This story won’t take place over months, it will take places over years to account for the aging of the younger actors
@@cookietaste although they changed the arrival time of then sozin's comet, Roku encourage Aang to master 4 element is a must. Because that's what forms the rest of the story. In live action, Aang always confused and don't know what he must to do. if only he met roku, roku will calm Aang down and say "I know you can do it, for you have done it before" it means a lot. But live action change it with angry screaming avatar instead, and comedian Roku, what a shame
@@runredmedia167 although they changed the arrival time of then sozin's comet, Roku encourage Aang to master 4 element is a must. Because that's what forms the rest of the story. In live action, Aang always confused and don't know what he must to do. if only he met roku, roku will calm Aang down and say "I know you can do it, for you have done it before" it means a lot. But live action change it with angry screaming avatar instead, and comedian Roku, what a shame
animation offers SO much freedom. you can have characters do things or have their faces do things that just SUCK live action. you can have characters WAY more animated and emotional than live action can.
and yeah. those clothes are so pristinely clean that there's no way they've ever been used before.
Damn, you people just cry about everything
@@liver6513 begone troll. return to the cave from whence you came!
@@liver6513you telling me bushy brow flying, baby ass kid is your avatar?
@@liver6513youre just ok with garbage and we’re not
@@fatnerd2005 nah, i just get why they are not doing the exact same thing, its an adaptation, not a 1:1 recreation of the animated series, there’s not point in staying 100% loyal to the source, what would be the point on watching the live action if you know literally every single detail of the story and characters?.
I was very irritated by the non-stop psuedo-motivational rants in this adaptation
Omg finally someone mentioning this thing about the costumes!! It drives me crazy…
Like, I would enjoy the show but these little details are turning me off and I stop watching
4:15 aang never wanted to be special, because being special means being different. This is shown in the cartoon when other kids don't want to play with the avatar, not because he would be better at the game but because he is different than them.
Yeah but the show doesnt give us that context within itself so it just comes off as goofy writing
Uhhh no the reason the kids turned away aang when he asked them if they wanted to play was becuase he was the AVATAR and the team that get him as a member would have a unfair advantage agaisnt the rest of the group
Nah the kids literally say its not fair on them to play with him in the cartoon
Yeah but the cartoon showed us. It didn't tell us using clunky dialogue. We KNOW Aang never wanted to be special because he shows us through the way he acts. This one? We know because he told us.
Meh.
@@Cunnyfuntstunts Ye but then it shows them playing with a kid that is kinda stupid and doesnt even know how to airbend properly. So the avatar thing being unfair was a lie.
My least favorite thing is how they rushed anng finding out the airbenders died. In the show, he only found out after spending time with sokka and katara. But in this show he pretty much knew that the 2nd he woke up
Yep I agree! Everything was rushed
That is not how you use 2nd lmao.
@@ChronicSynchronizerit is now 😂
Thank you exposition grandma lol
Kmg sammeeee!! I did feel like it was so so rushed!!! They had so much more story in there in the anime 😞😭💔
Live action creators didn't want to copy paste the animated series as it is and few of the plot changes made by them are pretty good and welcoming as well. I did enjoy watching many of the changes (like Azula and Sozin's intro) as they offered different and fresh perspectives.
But it has its own demerits as well:
1) Characterisation is something that was extra ordinary in the OG series (Aang was goofy yet wise and brave but here he is shown to be always frightened and somewhat coward, Katara was passionate, strong willed but here she almost carried the same expression throughout and why on Earth did they tone down Sokka's sarcasm. He was such a lively guy.) Honestly actors playing main characters seriously needs to improve especially Aang and Katara. (PS: Maria Zhang’s acting stood out for me as she portrayed her interest in Sokka quite perfectly. Actors playing Zuko, Iroh and Ozai acted brilliantly as well.)
2) And why is the casting overloaded with Chinese origin actors? The main theme of the original series was peace and harmony between extremely diverse nations. Probably this is why the original creators left this project sighting creative differences.
3) The OG creators had excluded visual references of the genocide against air nomads for a purpose as it was meant to be a kids show. But in netflix without such restrictions they could have explored it much deeper and it would have been fresh for us as well. I was expecting to see more of Aang's past and the wiping out of air nomads. The genocide portion could have been longer considering the effort they had put to show it visually. At least 1 episode dedicated for it would have given ample time for the buildup. However it lasted only for 25 odd minutes so it felt rushed to me.
4) There is no suspense at all in the writing. Everything was just direct and linear.
5) This has very less humour than the animated one.
Comparison with original is inevitable as the bar is set so high that it's very difficult to match those standards. So considering the above mentioned issues, the OG stands miles ahead than this live action at least for me and I wouldn't agree with anyone calling this as better than the original itself..
For a live action adaptation, it isn't bad. The only issue is that ATLA is considered to be one of the best animated shows of all time by most people. It's really hard to meet that, especially when you change the entire personality and traits of a character.
In a world where so many movies are butchered due to trying to put a "strong sarcastic female lead" in what should be a "motherly figure" how the hell did they turn the strong female lead into meek homely type?
I completely agree. I don’t hate the new show but it’s missing the charm. Especially a few of the actors, I also wish sang was more easy going he seems to get upset more often if I’m recalling right than he did In the original
It's actually not overloaded with Chinese-origin actors. Almost all those portraying the water tribes are Indigenous; the earth kingdom is indian and/or south asian. The fire nation and air nomads are east asian with a focus on those who could pull off Tibetan for the air nomads.
They're not perfect all the time but they're not all "chinese"
I don’t understand why they can never get Sokka & Kataras skin tones right either
Please tell me you're gonna react to the original show after this! I can't stand the thought of this being the only version in someone's head!
10:22 THANK YOU!!! i dont know why the costume designer never have the idea to design some worn out clothes, they all like brand new, its just a cosplay fest and everytime someone got attacked by waterbending, they didnt get wet....like, u just need to spray some water dude, no tricks...gawd
They seem to have a hard time with that always, like when they used to go the other extreme, when they adapted those Superhero comics back in the day and made everything super gritty and such. While here they try to stay faithful to the source material, so everything just looks like plastic, basically like in the cartoon, which gets away with it, because it's a cartoon. Like you think there has to be a way, to reinterpret the clothing of the cartoon in a way that they on one hand are still recognizable as such, but on the other hand still look realistic. Like it also kind of defeats the purpose of a live action adaptation, what little there is, when you try and make it look as close to the cartoon as possible, might as well stick with the cartoon at that point.
The costume was the only thing I compared a lot to the movie, because like Katara's necklace and the blue spirit mask, they look so cheap, bright, and plastic-y it's really just like a cosplay prop. The costume itself really be looking clean and crisp all the time
You said it perfectly, I mean they arel also always attacked by fireballs, how is there no sign of burnt fabric or even ash on them.
Also the time where I was crying laughing was when they introduced chubby Azula, chubby Tai Lee and especially chubby Mai in their Cosplay outfits which looked so damn uncomfortable and in no way remotely flexible enough to fight in 💀😂
@@ASal-co2gvThey were so horribly done i cannot believe directors saw what they looked like on screen and went with it. Same for Yue.
@@amanette Honestly, after watching other live-action remakes, vibrancy and plasticity don't really bother me cause it feels like it reflects the comicky nature of the original animated show. I also had similar feelings about the special effects cause sure they're not hyperrealistic but all things considered, it seems like more of an intentional art style, and kind of reminds of c- and k-dramas set in a false historical time period. Especially looking back on other pieces of media originally geared towards a younger audience which have come out in recent times, I'm happy it hasn't been dulled down, cause it made the show more visually interesting imo. To be fair I was never expecting realistic costumes out of this, and am just happy that as a whole the pacing isn' t totally shot and while the overall tone is more serious it doesn't seem like it takes itself overly serious or is going full-on grim dark.
The reason Aang went into the Avatar state at the Air Temple is because he was hopeful that the Air Nomads had escaped from the Fire Nation, that just because people hadn't seen them, it didn't mean that they weren't in hiding. When he came across his dear friend Gyatso's skeleton, he realized that everything he heard was true... that all his people did in fact perish. He felt immense guilt from his decision to run away when he could've been there to help, and this combined with the grievance of his people led him into the Avatar State. He realized that he is indeed the last airbender. But the live action took all this content away.
There was also no bonding between Aang with Sokka and Katara that led them onto "saving the world together" in the live action - Sokka wanted to hand Aang over to the Fire Nation even after finding out he's the Avatar... like what? Katara shared her grievance when Aang had his outburst in the cartoon- she was there for him. Both her nurturing personality along with her unwillingness to forgive her mother's murderer made her who she was. And the live action took that all away from her...
Once again, the avatar remake has failed to combine the realities of war with the innocence and fun of childhood that the cartoon manages to showcase.
it felt like the script was written during the writers strike. it was the opposite of “show don’t tell”
They announced it way back in 2018, they had plenty of time for good writing.
@@6thgraderfriends i don’t want to believe you. i want there to be a reason for the script being so trash
@@6thgraderfriends but then just passed it off to a couple of sixth graders to do it. 😝 And didn't bother to review it when they handed it in.
@@6thgraderfriends riddle me this, when did they START filming hm??? Surely not 2022
@@babs_babsI think that's a subjective take,the script wasn't thrash
"Aang, you have always been special" great subtle writing!
I swear some of the least cringe like deliveries were the ones they pulled straight from the original
Thank you for calling out the age thing with ancient rulers etc, because half the time you read about a ruler doing something and go “but that doesn’t really make any sense” or “wow that was blown out of proportion” but factoring in the number of teenage boys who were made rulers makes it all make sense lol
The show falls into the same trap that I’ve seen a lot of new shows fall into is they don’t seem to understand “show don’t tell”. There’s SO much exposition that there’s no place for subtlety or to leave the audience to fill in the blanks. (I’ve especially seen this with Netflix)
You don't need to cover the animated show but oh my god you need to actually watch it. I got my dad to watch it with me as it was airing. He was so invested. Then when I got married and it came on Netflix, I got my husband the watch it and he loved it too. And he's not generally a fan of children's media. Its just...so good.
I second this. Even if there is no video made about it, it's still well-worth a watch on its own. It's a masterpiece. There's a reason they keep trying to recapture the lightning in a bottle with a live action series.
Same!! I never grew up on it but I watched it all finally over the past few years and OMG IT IS SO GOOD????
usually i HATE kids anime's. but ATLA does a fantastic job of threading kids cartoon with plot and story that i can't help loving it
this show feels like walking into comic con and seeing people dressed up and acting as their favorite avatar characters.
That sounds like a lot of fun.
I mean isn't that every live action adaptation??
Exactly. It feels like a school play at times
looks more fan made than an actual big production..
@@DarkShadow-hy6iqno live actions are supposed to feel real
Yeah you can definitely tell you’ve never watched Avatar.
That's a great point about the costumes! Also bothers me a ton!!
Also...wish they'd stop making live EVERYTHING 😵💫🤦♀️
My issue was the dialogue. Every time someone spoke they had to explain everything you would learn throughout the show in one sentence. Also they said the intro at least three times in the first episode like people wouldn’t understand it. Or how Zuko explained painfully why he needed to capture Aang instead of having the arc of going from just “honor” to fixing the whole fire nation as a leader. Idk to me they had a great thing on a silver platter and changed random things that didn’t work.
I thought I was da only one that was thinking this I was like wha??
Like we know it and good writing takes building but I’m tired of all the exposes n shit
Yes! They kept repeating things over and over, like we are dumb. I don't need every character announcing their motivations to me, let me figure that out myself. The animated show treated its audience more like adults than the live action.
And they want to make it for the mature audience. Smh
@@RahulSingh-zo7sm they failed at most parts cause it wasn’t giving “mature”
It's so ironic that they made all the characters into the ember island players characters 😂
But the effects are decent and like zuko said they do get worse every year
perfect way to describe it lol
I felt like I was watching kids on a playground reenacting their favorite show during recess 😆 The costumes are super nice, the special effects and all that are well done, love the CGI like how great the Sky Temple and Appa look and all that, but.. the acting.. 😬 I'm sad about it. Was really looking forward to this but it's too cringy to watch.
At least in the Ember Island Players Katara has some defining character traits.
omg nooo XDD now that i think of it...
11:17
I expected that type of transition and I still laughed at it.🤣🤣
Same
You've never seen Avatar the last airbender the animated version?? Dude you should see it. I watched it as a kid and then at 22 and it was even better when I was older.
I hope we as people now realize some things need to stay animated. The writers leaving the live action makes so much sense now
Don't read my name.
Those same showrunners* were behind the 2010 movie. Whats that say about the showrunners if this live action was good?
To be fair we can still just watch the animated TV show. It's on DVD and Netflix in full season right now. I personally am not against having live action things, but I do agree that there are some things that don't need to be live action. This show probably being one of them. However there's really nothing stopping me from appreciating the animated show over the live action TV series
I was so hopeful. I was like "yeah they definitely wouldn't have made the character's as intersting as sand paper. They wouldn't get rid of Sokka's misogyny, and the characters would surely have meaningful interactions. Surely that's not too hard to ask for"
The creators left because they wanted to change the story and Netflix said no. It’s a perfectly inoffensive/gorgeously made adaptation.
i like that the voice actor that did the cabbage merchant in the animated show reprises his role as his live action counterpart
That's really cool🤣
that's pretty much the only good thing the show's got going for itself.
@@derg6222cap
I love how the Netflix show manages to fell rushed but also moved a lot slower than the original and did less w/ the characters and story
I love how in TLOK Zaheer was the only Airbender being able to fly by himself because of Guru Laghima and him reading some old dude's books and it was a big deal
But here Aang just flies for no reason.
The thing I hated most about the 2010 movie is that the firebenders couldn’t create fire out of nowhere. They needed to have a fire source nearby, making it the most situational bs ever. Some dude invents electric lighting and you’re done for.
But they did the same thing with Katara in this series. There was always a pond or fountain near her. She only got her satchel bottle bag in episode 8! Tell me why the pond water she used was never dirty and full of grime? Annoying.
I weirdly enough actually like the idea the fire benders needed to carry their element with them. The only one who could self generate it that was seen was Iroh. It suggests their bending was corrupted and weakened as a result, but Iroh learned it correctly. That’s actually interesting. Only compliment the movie gets.
@@JoshWise1010 I see what you mean but the fire benders being able to generate there own element at will was the reason they were so feared and powerful ,that's also another reason while they went after the air nomads first
@@JoshWise1010if fire benders needed to have their own fire or were unable to bend without fire being near them… that totally nullifies the whole point of why they were feared. Basically surround them in a place without fire and they’re dead meat
@@Andreii07hes saying the opposite mbruhhhh this argument
*My biggest issues are only two:* how they portrayed Bumi, and they completely benched Avatar Roku. Avatar Roku is a critical character to the overall lore. It's one thing to have Kyoshi be the narrator of the intro, which I did like. Her voice is amazing, but to take Roku's big possession scene and give it to Kyoshi, AS WELL as give her the dialogue of what the Avatar is...I can't get behind that. Avatar Roku had personal stake in this whole venture, Kyoshi did not. It makes sense for Roku to essentially raise and train Aang as an Avatar so Aang could be better than he was. The two have an incredibly close connection in the OG. To remove that here? I can't forgive that.
Then there's his whole personality shift in the remake. I don't know why CS Lee decided to go overboard on the humor. Yes Roku does have a sense of humor, but it's kind of like Dumbledore's, subdued. In the animated version, when Roku says "What took you so long?" that tells you everything you need to know about the past life, because of how it was delivered. He's kind, warm, inviting, has a playful side but would probably only show that to those he's close with. He's stern, but not overly harsh. He comforts vs berates Aang when Aang is at a low point. He doesn't yell even when he and Aang disagree. He's wise and that came from him traveling all over the world. He understood people, listened and heard them.
To bench Avatar Roku now, is going to create huge writing problems for them later down the line if they do get a season 2 or 3. There's no relationship between him and Aang, and that is a HUGE misfire.
Then there's what they did to Bumi, turning him into a bitter man who berates Aang for something outside of his control, just like Avatar Kyoshi, which is something she wouldn't do. People too often think she's like the Punisher of ATLA...When in reality she's more like Wonder Woman in terms of personality.
What they did with Bumi and Avatar Roku _infuriates me._
And yet I can't get THAT mad at the WHOLE show cause there ARE really good elements. Such as seeing Avatar Kuruk for example, more sides to Azula and Iroh, seeing more of the Air Nomads was wonderful, and the actual Genocide itself was not just epic, but tragic. June was fantastic. The action is wonderful, the CGI incredible, the costuming is incredibly on point, it's nice to see COLOR again in fantasy.
It sits at a C for me. Average.
The Roku Slander was High
It also makes sense for Roku to appear because he was the avatar directly before Aang so why would he be skipped as asking the avatar directly before you for help makes more sense and be used as your guide
Avatar Rokku helped Aang realize that the fire nation is not evil, their rulers are. With their relation sacrificed to the gods of equality and inclusion, the show loses a lot.
Bumi was ruined indeed. Crashed in 1 second instantlt staying who he is... Also being annoying and overplayed. I hated him in Netflix series! 😢
From the third episode forward it was a complete nightmare. Nothing made sense at all
i'm never watching the live action but katara is so CALM what's wrong with her
Wait wait wait! I’m sorry…they discuss the power of the comet IN THE FIRST EPISODE?! Why in the ever living fuck would they do that 😩
They don't have a discussion, it was one line.
Because the comet is what powered the airbender massacre. It’s not a full discussion, it’s just mentioned
Gearing the remake towards an older audience really dumbed down the character’s original personalities into serious, mature, and frankly boring shells of their former selves. It was also announced before the show’s remake that the creators were making Aang more “serious” , which takes away 90% of this character that we know and love from the original show.
His goofiness and curious personality is what made the original episodes so heartwarming and funny, and the team’s shenanigans so comical and cartoony. Maybe making everyone more light-hearted would’ve brought back the 2D animation “magic”.
i also don't think it makes much sense to make aang more serious, since the boy who plays him seems to perform better in comedic moments. i think making the show more fun and lighthearted could have helped the child actors feel more comfortable.
Yeah they really neutered aang and Sokka
Toning down Azula also makes no sense if they were going for a serious tone. Plenty of shows like GoT had female characters with sociopathic traits
Live action adaptations is Hollywood copying someone else's homework. They just either change the words a little or gut the whole thing and just keep the title and character names. The original of any work will always be the definitive version.
What do you think an adaptation is? It's like y'all don't know what you want. An exact copy of the original? Then you'll still be mad it's the same as the original. They do something different like what the creators wanted and you will still be mad because it isn't like the original. At this point y'all are just hating for hating sake. Y'all are stuck in 2005.
@@lulu_Lm Yeah nah, thats not the problem here. I like last airbender comic books, the novels, I even like the Legend of Korra. Novel authors and comic artists have passion for their craft and respect for the source material. Like the guy in the video said, Live action creators have an undeserved superiority complex.
i liked the one piece one
@@walmartiancheese4922same lol
@Luke-ow9ku right, it's about Hollywood taking established IP and trying to milk more money out of it instead of trying to make something creative
I actually hate that they reveal 100-years twist so early... Like seeing Aang heartbroken at southern temple HIT different
They made Azula an insecure kid... People ask to wait bc there's more to develop, but this isn't Azula. She was always more capable than Zuko and always more manipulative. I can't see this Azula conquering Ba Sing See at all
Azula was insecure in the cartoon too. Thats shown when she is betrayed by her friends and during the last Agni Kai.
@@RK-cj4ocshe only ever became insecure after her friends betrayed her, I would get pretty insecure too if my friends followed me halfway around the world tryna catch that avatar just for one of them to betray me the save her boyfriend.
@@botdetector9494 No she did not.
In Book 4 (that did not get animated because it dealed with more adult topics) Ozai speaks out that he always played his childeren against each other.
Azula always had to compare to Zuko, and Zuko to Azula. The creators of the cartoon litterally wrote this, it is canon. We just did not get to see it in the cartoon. You now get to see it in the live action.
@@RK-cj4oc okay? That literally doesn’t disprove anything I said. if the creators themselves wrote that and then chose to not add it as a part of the show it clearly wasn’t very pivotal in anyones character arc. Azula spent pretty much the entire series fighting for one thing, her fathers approval you think the creators would put it in somewhere if that drive started to disappear. I’ve always believed she knew the fact her father played her against her brother but that didnt matter to her because she knows she’s better than zuko and is more than happy to prove it
@@botdetector9494 I never said it was pivotal.
And Azula is still fighting for her fathers approval. We now just see how he is flaming hatred against Zuko in Azula by talking down to her " because of his actions" Which makes alot of sense.
The detail about the clothes looking too new and clean is on point. I couldn't put my finger on what looked off about them, and it was absolutely that.
Same I kept thinking something is off
Especially Ang happily running around in the south pole in super crispy clean ironed monk clothes not freezing at all
yess
Oh yeah. Totally. As opposed to the cartoon where the cloths look worn out. Oh wait. The costumes are extremely well done. And it’s a fantasy show. If you’ve seen any length of fantasy shows, especially ones from the East then this would be nothing new. They want you to see and appreciate the designs of the outfits. This isn’t a show about being musky and grimy. It’s an eastern inspired fantasy show.
even the movie did this better ....
How many remakes and sequels do we really need?
Not a remake
Just..no
@@peteryanes3413it's not that different from a live action remake
Disney: yes
@@peteryanes3413semantics. You know they just mean adaptation
One of my biggest complaints with the show was the exposition dumps because it’s the exact opposite of what the original show achieved. Sure it had some explaining like the intro, but usually just enough to get you interested without being boring. In the live action intro for example, they added a bunch of extra stuff that 1. Og fans already know so it becomes boring and 2. New fans would’ve found out anyway if they had actually handled letting The audience discover things well. Also Zuko didn’t say the word honour ever which sucks because it’s actually super important for his character as a whole for him to be obsessed with in in the beginning.
the old guy actually didnt want to tell him, the council wanted him prepared early, the monk still wanted him to be a kid
with all the budget that went in to this they could have made a new animated avatar series instead of piggybacking off of old ip 😭
Why do that though? What would be the point?
Not even a "new" show can save their asses from shitty writing, we've seen it happen already (the trash known as "korra"), and they didn't even have the "writer's strike" as an excuse back then🙄
@@TheMindofagenius1I liked Korra and so did a lot of other people
@@theroyaljules39 well, of course everyone is entitled to their own opinion, however wrong it may be.
@@TheMindofagenius1 oh you’re one of those whiny annoying little pissbabies. Got it
I think it’s wrong to show the fate of the Airbenders at the beginning. It ruins the shock of finding out what happened to them later. 😢
I'd even say that showing Aang leaving before we had time to know and connect with him as a character makes him look like kind of an asshole. (especially since in that version it doesn't look like he was shunned by the other kids for being the Avatar)
Tbf tho, it's likely because most people watching this series already watched the show as kids and already KNOW about the Airbender genocide, so that's why they did it sooner. There's not really much shock when the show is pretty well-known by now.
I mean, maybe from Aang's perspective but not really the audience's.
Right?! The fact that (presumably) Gran-Gran tells Aang that the Southern Air Temple was hit first doesn't give it as much impact when he actually goes there and sees the devastation.
It hits harder in the animated show because everyone tells him no one has seen airbenders in a century and Aang waves them off saying just because no one has seen them, doesn't mean they're not there. Katara actively tries to hide evidence of the Fire Nation having been to the Air Temple while they're there, so when Aang finds Monk Gyatso's skeleton surrounded by dead Fire Nation soldiers, it makes sense why he loses control and goes into the Avatar state.
I understand how stupid it would be to do a one-to-one remake of the animated show with live actors, but their biggest mistake is sacrificing good storytelling/writing for some lame "coolness" factor. The audience isn't stupid; you can show things, imply things, without having to dump exposition in our faces every five minutes.
I heard this show is aiming for the game of thrones crowd 😅
@@13CrystalHeart Yeah but the OG series trusted its audience and didn't spoon-feed them, that's good writing. And even if they wanted to lead with the genocide, I feel like it should have been restructured in a way where the whole episode focuses on Aang's life before he was crystalized or whatever happened to him in the iceberg. I just feel like there's a better way to do it than how they went about it
Please do Middle School: The Worst Years of my life next, I think it's a movie you would have fun making fun of
I don't remember where I heard this but I agree that Netflix ought to have adapted the siege of Ba Sing Se.
No child actors, visually the easiest to depict elements, established event but not seen in the show, involving characters and locations we want to see. Plus, huge emotional possibilities as well as political intrigue and great battles.
My biggest complaint are the endless exposition dumbs. The writers of this show haven't heard about the "show, don't tell" rule I guess.
This is so annoying, they literally treat viewers as dumber than the original target audience for the cartoon.
It was way worse in percy i already know everything jackson.
I guess its better than the text scroll exposition in the beginning of the 2010 movie. idk
@@javierlopez9789
If I had a nickel for every time some company felt the need to remake a classic piece of children’s media into a more “mature” live action show that’s better than the horrible movie adaptation but still not that great and full of exposition dumps, I would have two nickels.
@@nixxdra Which isn't a lot but it's weird that it happened twice
1:00 alex might not be part of the fandom but he sure knows the rules
THERE IS NO MOVIE IN BA SING SE
I just stumbled onto your channel.. you're so funny my dude, and your art style is so goofy and adds to your humor xD. Subbed!
Alex, I need you to rewatch the OG animated series in full😭
Where is the Agni Kai??? Why is the cave of lovers already being shown? I’m confused about some elements and people from book 2 showing up in book one. It sort of feels like they are trying to put as much as possible in the show because of the possibility of being cancelled.
IKR zuko entire attitude with zhao has changed 😭 also why is his dad actually acknowledging that he found the avatar???
This is EXACTLY the take i get from all these netflix adaptations
@@OdinsSageis that good or bad
@@khizarali8087eh, could be better but hollywood i guess.
@@saydie6646no it hasn’t he still hates him idk what show y’all watched. And his dad is being the manipulator that he is, if you think that makes him a better dad idk what to tell you because that’s still abuse
8:22 gran gran wasn't supposed to lore dump on aang like that though 😂😂
That's why they were supposed to explore and learn that on their own that ruins the rest of the season because now I'm gonna be only interested in the action parts
Yeah it took away form Aang being sent into the avatar state upon seeing the dead air benders. It also removes one of my favorite aspects of Katara which is her maternal nature. She calmed downs aang in the air temple like someone would their spouse or child. In the la i didn’t feel it at all.
I know right? there was sooo much exposition in the live action.
Hollywood: "Cartoons are for kids!"
South Park: "Am I a f*cking joke to you!?"
THANK YOU for mentioning the costumes!! I haven't seen anyone else point out how they look like cosplay.