Josh from On Killing |
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Watch More #TBT: • #TBT | Cut
About #TBT:
A walk down memory lane with notable Cut alumni.
One-click YT subscribe: bit.ly/CutSubs...
✨ Keep up with us! ✨
- Official Site | cut.com
- Instagram | cut.com/ig
- TikTok | cut.com/tiktok
- Facebook | cut.com/facebook
- Twitter | / cut
- Snapchat | @watchcut
About Cut:
Small questions have powerful effects when they go viral. Cut spreads stories for fun, for serious, and for real- bringing the internet together one awkward moment at a time.
Produced, directed, and edited by Cut.
Want to work with us? cut.com/jobs
Want to be in a video? cut.com/casting
Want to sponsor a video? cut.com/sponso...
Josh from On Killing | #TBT | Cut
• Josh from On Killing |...
Cut
/ watchcut
Love this guy or hate this guy, you have to respect his brutal honesty.
I was just about to type nearly the same thing... "You don't have to like the content of his truth, but you damn sure better respect it."
I actually agree, its rare seeing genuine honestly.
rapists can be honest too
Coke Vallejo well, gotta respect it then
@@cokevallejo7458 would you rather all people who have done bad things lie? What are you trying to say
This guy clearly is one of the most interesting characters here on this channel. Not because he's the funniest, but because he's the most honest. He's not playing some kind of role to hide his true self. He's just speaking out clearly what he thinks.
Even if you don't like his view on these topics, you should be thankful to have the opportunity to listen to a veteran who is completely honest about his feelings. This is what interviews are about
In my opinion he's just putting on a persona to convince himself he's ok
This man is the fakest amongst all of them. It surprises me that his tough guy persona manages to fool you.
He's clearly traumatized as hell.
Maybe we don't like how he expresses himself because it reveals an uncomfortable truth we don't wanna face.
We are just animals.
@@Ivan-ow5xc Truth as hell and clear as water.
And people dont want to accept the truth, thats why they call him a psycopath, retard and so.
"In my opinion he's just putting on a persona to convince himself he's ok
"
"He's clearly traumatized as hell."
No shit Sherlocks.
You want this dude by your side on the battlefield.
fr the morale is massive
Stay away from war and the battlefield. It's nothing but political spin
Yeah he’s not a pussy
@@MrKarlozz,
One day he might learn about Smedley Butler, and he will be faced with rethinking his entire life.
This is a guy who was awarded two MoH's. And he came out of it saying exactly what you're saying.
This guy would get his ass kicked in my unit lol
If we build a clone army, please clone him
OORAH
Fuck are u doing here lol
@@ViolentGenius bruh this dude has almost 2 mil subs wtf
Nah we must clone jango fett
No, get Jocko Willink
People are upset he’s actually speaking the truth without sugar coating it. If more people did this in all scenarios there would be way less confusion in the world
Casey Norman exactly!
For example females
Yeah we all would kill eachother yall are fucking psychos and need to check in in a asylum
But the civility throughout the world would change if everybody was like this guy talking. Heck, he straight face strangle you in your bed if were drunk or on drugs. War in the beginning was supposed to be like.... Let's go back to the revolutionary war, most of the Americans were complete sane volunteers who didn't want to kill nor murder. But rather they just wanted to suppress and not actually kill anybody. But once you go to towards the civil war era, it all gets in their mentality that they just want to kill kill and kill. You have to remember yourself, who you really were in front of holy God's eyes. He would be disgusted to even look at you, Holy God creator himself would rather turn his back upon you then to look at you doing these corrupt ill minded things.
part 3 and you probably never serve to the army and you have to be so confortable in your home...so stfu please
Army: *teaches us to kill effectively and steals a large chunk of our emotional sensitivity*
Soldiers: *have fun*
The rest of the world: *😧😧😧*
The rest of the world be more like: Pikachu face
It's called sociopathy. Idiot.
@@saeedvazirian no
War is addictive and this guy is an example of it
Louis van Dijk Ikr
I cant wait to join
Levi Combs same
Louis van Dijk for some people, especially sociopaths/psychopaths. Look up the warrior gene.
"It is good that war is so terrible , else we should grow to fond of it." Robert E. Lee.
It is so interesting to see this kind of perspective on life, it is fascinating to see how our life experiences drastically change how we view the world. Huge props to this guy for sharing how he feels without editing it to make it more agreeable to everyone.
Thank god someone with an un-biased opinion around here...
True I just hope he gets better because his mind set isn’t the healthiest
I thought the same thing
Thank you these comments are an example of why Wars start in the first place people can’t fucking get along
Like he said it’s hard for vets to get over everything or cope because they can’t talk about it and these most the comments are the very representation of exactly that everyone calling him psycho because he can express the truth what do y’all want him to do lie and just say oh all we did was chill nothing happened like many vets do or say oh it’s so bad if they don’t truly mean it you should be able to express your true feelings without receiving shit for it
People saying they wouldn't be like this are naive. You can never say that unless you've been to pushed to the edge. Most humans have this capacity to kill, but they would rather not think about that too long because it's uncomfortable.
Yes of course most people could kill another human being if they are put in a position where they have to safe them or a loved one. But no one should be that excited to kill someone. It almost sounds like he celebrating the act of killing people... "I had a rad fucking time" (1:31) This is not normal behaviour and people should not tolerate it.
Matsurie N. I'm betting it's partially a coping mechanism, but also just try getting in his head and following his reasoning. Imagine being young, the adrenaline, walking on a razor's edge, the feeling that everything in your life before you has led to this moment. You'll feel a sense of purpose never before felt. He might express it in a way that feels foreign to you but just try to getting into his head.
Another important part, imagine getting a bond of brotherhood with your peers that's unexplainable in civilian life, being able to trust people _unconditionally_ (even if you dislike said people) and then see them killed before you, for no reason. Witness civilians getting killed for no reason. Then find the people that are to blame for that (I don't want to get into politics and who is to "blame"). Of course you will want revenge, or feel righteous for killing them. Some will act like they would stand above that but they'll never know for real. All these feelings he expresses might not be as unthinkable as you may feel, he just expresses them more bluntly. As I said, people don't want to think about these things, because it scares them. Everyone has this potential.
I definitely have to agree with you on the coping mechanismand and I can totaly see where you come from.
Of course everyone deals differently with a past like that but the things he says and tone in his voice is just wrong. I know everyone is diffrent and everyone has a diffrent upcoming and past but he seems like a dangerous and unstable person who can snap anytime.
Sorry, if killing gets easy for you, maybe its time to seek some help but as he said its a taboo topic.
Most humans CAN kill if driven to the edge of self-preservation. But we are designed for empathy and cooperation. Night terrors, ptsd, coping mechanisms (like alcoholism) are all signs that we damage ourselves when we kill.
"Designed for cooperation and empathy." What a load of BS. The entire reason racism and wars even exist at all is because of our tribal instincts that tell us not to trust people that aren't apart of our tribe.
War is a part of our nature as much as love is.
A man like Josh would have been a proud and venerable warrior in a different culture.
What I like about this guy is that he breaks the "broken vet" stereotype. We get to see another perspective of the aftermath of going to war.(not saying that he may not have his own demons, just that is not the only thing being put out on display)
I like this guy. He's brutally honest. No bullshit, sugar-coating, or tying things up with a neat little ribbon. Just his pure truth.
Kristy Salgado yeah but he says he enjoyed the murder it’s creepy
The Wheat Is Growing Thin serious what the fuck is wrong with you dude are you incapable of empathy or have you been brought up/trained/brainwashed to think that way, you're going to live a very closed off and lonely life if you don't try to think a little
I like the honesty too. That is.....if he is being honest and not putting on a tough face, I mean....I imagine in the military you HAVE to think differently and coming back into normal life (like he said) it's not easy and you so make changes
I like honesty but it's easy to pretend, very very easy
yeah, brutally aggressive and brutally violent
Kill or be killed. Just the way life goes. Sucks it has to be this way but, I mean shit, if they deserve it they deserve it. No use in feeling bad.
This guy is brutally honest no sugar coating anything.
Moral of the story: War is hell and affects those involved in different ways. Whether you agree with it or not, at least this dude is being completely honest with his experiences.
"A Lion does not care for the opinions of sheep"
Exactly, I find it funny how people saying he’s putting on a tough guy act. This actually went through war
hHAHAHAHAHAHAHH
The lion doesn't care for the opinions of sheep yet he relies on the sheep and other related prey to make sure he doesn't starve and die. One way or another the lion is dependent on the sheep and its kind for its most basic function.
More of male lion doesn't care what lionesses and his cup said
Flatbush Zombies
I fw this guy heavy he's so honest
This guys honesty is comforting. Thanks for keeping it real dude.
when i first saw josh’s take on killing i was a bit taken aback. such a contrary opinion than the ones of the world war 2 and vietnam vets who typically speak on these things. he deserves a bit of respect and sympathy. he was a young man, a kid who’s whole life revolved around eat, sleep, kill, and dream about coming home. josh is fresh out of doing possibly the hardest job a man can do. i respect josh. hooyah, from one branch to another.
I half think the differences between them are a generational one. Josh describes shit almost as if it was Call of Duty. Maybe it's worked better than expected for acclimating people to the brutality of war.
Or maybe we're just murder monkeys and seeing someone's insides blown out was always rad lol.
“I’m not gonna change the truth. I had a rad fuckin time.” I love this dude
this man is absolutely fascinating to me - I will never forget seeing him in the war video years ago and seeing this video checking in with him again I was so excited to watch. The way he talks about war is a completely heartbreaking in such a different way than I've ever heard other veterans speak. This man, I will argue, is extremely intelligent. He sees war for what it is - nasty, sickening, and brutal and speaks about it in such disgusting ways and so bluntly that it really makes me believe that it is a part of humanity that I will never experience that cuts to your core and makes you evaluate every part of the human spirit. I don't support or believe a thing that he says in my personal core. I am a pacifist at heart, but damn...he's been places in his psyche and has had war pervade his body in ways we as civilians will never know. I would love to just sit down, and have dinner with him and just listen to him speak. There is so much pain, anguish, and intelligence in him that I want to understand.
Could not have summarized it better.
So a psychopath is fascinating to you? Interesting..
@@AgressiveSillence In what way is he a Psychopath...? Not to mention real Psychopaths can be pretty interesting anyways.
@@AgressiveSillence Its people like you (who don't fucking know shit) why veterans don't wanna come out and talk about their experiences, because some fuckhead like you will call him a psychopath.
@@Top.Ramin.Noodles people killing other ppl are psychos by definiton dude. XD gtfo war was evil always there is not a single good thing in war youre either a psycho, in for the money or dumb asf.
The way some Americans talk about the war in Irak or Afghanistan creeps me out. They seem to generalize the whole population to be Taliban and use it as an excuse to justify why they are leading a war. But they often forget or ignore the fact that the Talibans are minorities in those countries. Meanwhile the civilians are not only victims of the Taliban but also the foreign military "trying to save the world".
Celia B america is built off of racism and generalization
Iraq* and your point isn’t wrong but soldiers can’t tell who’s Taliban and who’s not Taliban so I suppose they would treat the whole population as threat which is understandable
Nothing this guy said seemed to generalize the entire population of Iraq and Afghanistan. He was commissioned to talk about killing and combat, and that is exactly what he talked about. It's indescribably dangerous to paint him as an indiscriminate killer, without consideration of the rest of the population. American soldiers aren't just running around, gunning down everyone they feel like.
All in the name of elite bankers and our fucked up lieing government
One reason for this is the fact that you don’t know if the person you just shot was actually a Taliban soldier or some farmer with a gun to protect himself
Any one know Josh’s full name? I would love to buy this dude a beer. I met him in Qatar in 2011 I had to go over there after getting and infection removed and he was at the medical site with me. If anyone could help me reconnect with him that would be amazing. Also what you are seeing of him in this video the intensity is truly how he is Nothing has changed in that aspect.
Contact the channel
U mean the country Qatar?
pulp fiction yes and I found him shortly after this video he is doing great. We were both there for a short period of time.
craig terry 🍻 killers 🤣
@@sunnyj4226 You are such an idiot its disgusting
This guy sounds like someone I'd like to hang out with and pick his brain.
Wow, there's a lot of people not understanding where he is coming from. do yall not understand that he had to make himself think that way in order to survive?? having sympathy towards the enemies that will kill you with no question is bound to get you killed. so much ignorance in this comment section. People love to judge others when they haven't been what they have been through. smh
He enlisted himself. That's a choice. If you are a psychopath and u want to find a reason in your life, go to the military. If you want to actually benefit anyone, become a doctor.
Only safe space liberals don't understand what he's saying and as he said fuck'em.
Johannes Araya so u think soldiers don’t benefit people?
Bob Newhart he said war was awesome, then 5 seconds later says, “they weren’t there pulling their buddy behind cover while bleeding to death.” That seems contradicting
@@bobnewhart4318 Your filling this comment section with comments about how triggered liberals are exacly what triggered people do
I love how honest he is about it and not afraid to talk about his time serving. Thank you for serving us! He tells from his points of view when he was in combat but it’s not everyone’s view when they served and that’s what people need to understand like he said in the video
Is Ben Shapiro was a soldier
Dont compare ben bitchboy to a Veteran
Good on Josh for going towards a PhD in Psych in order to help out his fellow vets! This is also a prime example of the phrase, "You can't criticize what you aren't actually involved in." People who've never been involved in life or death situations like war, myself included, will never know what it's like to experience that type of situation until we're actually in it. Frankly speaking, I hope I never have to experience something like that. War is scary...and the loss of lives is disheartening.
yes you can, you can criticize murderers without doing any yourself.
Before you scroll down any further just be warned that this comment section is absolutely *Toxic*
I’m going at my own risk
iKonatt good, I’m diving in head first!
Chuck Norris cover me
@@soldierside365 I got your 6!
Chuck Norris i finally found my brotherhood 😭😂
Much respect to this soldier. Thank you to all who serve.
Please interview this guy in twenty years time if/when his walls ever come down.
Cait Porter ,What do you think about animals killing each other?
Do you think animals have the same mental capacities as humans? Because that's the only way your argument isn't the dumbest logical fallacy ever.
Yeah, honestly, I want this guy to write a memoir when he gets older. Doubly so because he has decided to pursue psychology to the PhD level. I'm viscerally repulsed by the things he says here and (in my extraordinarily unprofessional opinion) I think those things are indicative of unhealthy coping mechanisms, but I'd still read the crap out of what he had to say.
You prove what he said. “You’ve never been there. You’ve never seen a buncha kids step on landmines.” You’re in a cozy safe environment and have never experienced something so desensitizing before. Be disgusted if you want but do realize this shit is what war does to people. The human instinct has the ability to kill. We are homo sapiens. The most intelligent species of animals or in a more scientific term organism to ever exist. We since the stone age killed eachother. Our ancestors did it and we still do it now. I would like to see a memoir when he’s older as well. Although I don’t think he’ll change all too much. People are to numb and baby’ed since their civilian birth that they literally can’t come to terms with the fact someone could just have no remorse for killing another. Some individuals are more mentally desensitized than others.
Midnight Kat How do I prove what he said by requesting a follow up interview? You also have no idea what my history or personal experience is.
This guy is a badass. Thanks for your service. I could listen to his stories all day.
There's nothing rad about the killing of a person regardless of who it is. He doesn't strike me as a sympathetic person.
Still definitely appreciate hearing his thoughts though. Politics and ideology are always influencing how we talk about war, with one side trying to ignore the horrors of it and another side forgetting that there is glory in it as well. It's good to be exposed to honest perspectives like this.
Because he's became a hardened man through his experiences. You think the enemy would be sympathetic on you? When it's flight or fight, you have to have the mental capacity to subdue certain emotions, and it's not easy to become balanced again after you leave the service.
Sir Torrance You make a good point. Experiences of tragedy and war can make one become inured to tragedy and veer to callousness. It can certainly mess with your psyche which is unfortunate.
INTP female have you ever served though? Genuine question
I think you're right it's not cool to kill another being but unfortunately that's our society and I don't think our world will get to such a lev3l or peace where people do not have to kill another to save the masses.
I think he might not be saying killing SOMEONE is rad but I think the enemy. I do not condone killing but people like him have are everyday to protect our lives.
personally it's a bit disturbing tbh but it could be a way for him to cope with the experience - everyone has their own coping mechanisms.
but I'm not supporting his views at all lol
1:59
That smile, that God damn smile !
I love this guy attitude and his honesty in order to win a War YOU HAVE TO HAVE THIS GUYS PERSONALITY AND FRAME OF MIND
This man is the definition of positive military MORALE. Good on you mate, and thank you immensely for your service.
I'm pretty sure 90% of the infantry and SOF guys have this attitude, I've never met anyone who didn't (and I've met plenty when I worked at an airport).
I respect this guy for his decision to join the ARMY and his willingness to be on the front lines, truly I do. HOWEVER his opinions and views of war and the decision(s) to kill insurgents are merely that, opinions. I can say this because I too am a fellow service member (Proud member of the Marine Corps) with multiple combat deployments under my belt (07-2, 09-1) and though I myself engaged the Taliban on many occasions, killing others ALWAYS, regardless of reason, leaves an impact with an individual. There is no exception....
Omg dude you go! Love love love your honesty and realness. The world needs more. No doubt you'll save many lives
All Vets thank you so much for your sacrifice
The things he says are chilling, but the point is that it's also deserving of some sympathy. This "war is rad" mentality was his personal way of getting through it. Maybe he needed it, maybe he didn't, but it got him through. Then when he comes back home he's expected to pretend he didn't enjoy any of it in order to fit into society. You can imagine there must be a lot of urges and reinforced habits he has to suppress in day to day life now just to avoid being an outcast, so it's important that he has a space like this where he's allowed to really talk about it. There are definitely moral questions that can be asked about why he joined in the first place and whether Cut should try giving more of a voice to soldiers from the other side. But there's also no denying that he's had traumatic experiences, so I don't think it helps anyone to assume he is entirely at fault for ending up this way.
His mind is just objective thinking, if you applied objective thinking to situations like your job, you would be so much better at your job.
Nothing about this guy seems off, he's just an objectively truthful person... What's so hard to understand... He's not wrong in the head at all, are you saying that anyone who looks at things from an objective stand point in their day to day jobs is wrong in the head? I don't get it...
War is just a job, it's not really a good one but it still is a job, but this job just so happens to evolve killing, how do I make sure I do my job in the war, by killing my target, and making sure that things don't get close that I consider a threat, that way of thinking isn't bad at all, that's how it should be in fact... for jobs at least
This job isn't to base morals man, that will and can get you or others killed in the military, if people based their decisions on morals in the military, all because they didn't want to shoot a teenage boy with a gun because they didn't think a kid was capable of killing, wrong kiddo, that kid will behead your ass and put it on LiveLeak for everyone to see.
It's war man, if you don't shoot because of morals, you will get yourself or your teammates killed.
I've heard shit about how people will say "It shouldn't be a game", you're right, it's not a game, it's an objective, if I don't kill the target in war, I die, and everyone else who doesn't dies as well, and then you'll have no military to defend yourself from Russia, then Russia will invade and take away your freedom, is that what you want? No? then shut the fuck up.
Azusa AKA pragmatic way and frankly there isnt any better way as a soldier you just gotta listen to your orders
he is 100% at fault for being a sociopath. lol.
Love this guy, brutal honesty, and to be honest America NEEDS soldiers like this, we don’t need knee knocking quivering candy asses, we need killing machines, and at its core that’s what anyone who’s served is ultimately trained to do............ kill, no more, no less. Kudos to this kids searing honesty
I love how you guys show people and their mindsets. Not only the once you like.
I really dislike Josh's mindset. Still I liked this conversation.
Thanks for sharing your story Josh. Hope you'll help more people. ✌
Have you served ?
Why do you dislike Josh's mindset?
His mindset is objective, he sees that he has to kill a target, and the way he's made that easier for himself is reminding himself that those type of people are absolutely bat shit insane, who will use children to suicide bomb him, just to kill him.
If you looked at everything in life, and saw all the objective right and wrongs in life, you wouldn't step out of line at all, he doesn't lead by subjective or morals, he leads by objective values, and that's something that everyone should understand, use objectiveness in your jobs rather than deciding on morals, he used objectiveness on his job, and that's good.
@@AzusaNym His mindset isn't objective. Nothing is. Now fuck off.
people are so soft and always disregard reality and I love this guy
I understand where this veteran is coming from, He found a way to mentally not feel bad for taking a life. Which honestly these men and women in the military are giving up their mental health along with time with there own family TO PROTECT OUR COUNTRY and others. So if a vet has to find a different perspective to look at what he has done to mentally cope and not feel guilty then that shouldn't bother anyone. He's going to school and growing as a human being to help support other vets just like him. He wouldn't be able to do this if he sat at home and beat himself up about every life he has had to take.
GenJea latte this is the best comment on here. Of course I don't agree with anything he's saying but he's here, getting his education and has a genuine desire to help people. He's not hurting anybody here as far as we know so if this mentality helps him cope, so be it
How is going to a backwater country and killing their people protecting our country?
That’s understandable. Still, not gonna lie, the things he said made me feel really weird.
@WisestWiseGuy101 Our country is the one that deployed them so that is a question we as a nation need to answer. If they are deployed they better be deployed for a damn good reason. But his job is to protect our country so there's your answer. lol We shouldnt shame those who find different ways to cope instead we should help them get better. Unfortunetly we are regular civilians cannot relate to his or any other service men sent to fight.
Protect our country? You mean to steal oil 🛢
Major respect to this dude. Straight talker and no bs. I’d have him on my side when it hit the fan, that’s for sure.
Love this guy, History channel give him a show now, we can loose those gold digging shows
This guys is psycho
Falcao Falcao no dude you’re just a pussy
@@patman3310 umm he's a murderer, dumbass.
@@saeedvazirian he’s a bad ass. You’re just a pussy
@@saeedvazirian he’s a bad dude. You’re just a beta
Ive been watching RUclips a long time and this is the first video I thumbed up. This guys first interview helped my cope with my own demons from my time in Afghanistan. Thanks brother!
I appreciate his unrepentant honesty. Also "ancestors inside me" is the best quote on war I've ever heard.
This guy is such a BADASS. I mean, who did you expect to see? Another broken vet who feels sorry for those who he killed? And what if he's not? People join the military for a reason.
This man is a straight up hardass/badass I could listen to his stories all day everyday
I love his how honest he is to. himself. I have a lot of respect for people like this. Be you
I'm not going to lie, I'm very interested to see if there's anything more about this guy online. He seems like a really interesting guy, whether you agree with his sentiments on life or not.
If I don't agree with someone, they're definitely not interesting.
Kiira Korpi If I don’t like something, everyone doesn’t like something
I respect this dude’s honesty. He’s pretty intense but I can understand why.
He’s so real, I love him
Guy is on point on many things war is like. I can relate and agree with most if not all. It is fun but not your same fun like playing a game or enjoying a day out with your friends on a Saturday night. It’s fun in its own way. It builds connections deeper than anything else you’ve ever had or will have. It gives you a purpose in life and every time you cheat death you feel a little bit more invincible. War is beautiful yet chaotic. It is missed by many and I guess only people that have seen it will understand this. As a fellow infantryman I can say Josh knows what he is talking about and I also share the same goal that we are the only ones that can help our brothers. None of us should be dying from our own hands.
May God bless this brother.
So proud to have this guy representing veterans.
I'm sure most veterans would disagree, especially the older ones... (40+). Killing other humans for fun? That's who you would like to represent you?
Iffy50
If you were familiar with some of the evil atrocities performed by extremists/insurgents that this man & those like him have witnessed first-hand, then it would be easier for you to understand why he feels the way that he does.
I’m not a combat veteran.
I shouldn’t judge how this man feels about his personal experiences of war. It’s not my place, or yours.
I am just proud of men like this who are still willing to step into harm’s way to help rid the world of evil.
@@internet_internet You know, I did some research on Josh specifically. He was stationed in Sarawbi, and it seems like he wasn't fighting against an army of a specific country, he was fighting against Taliban. I guess he was lucky in that way, because if I was in war against *only* people that joined an organization that was devoted to killing a specific sector of society (like the Taliban) I could do it. If I was fighting in any war where the enemy combatants were just residents of a certain country I couldn't. (Iraq)
He is definitely brutally honest and he should. The best way to overcome trauma is to speak about it. Specially if it is something you had no power over, you had no choice. Now, the first time he was definitely on something. He not only looked high; he looked psychopathic. He looks much better now. Hope he is doing fine.
I moved to DC from Ireland last year and immediately noticed the culture change being surrounded by so many military, feds and vets. It was a bit of a shock at first hearing (mostly) men talk like this but I really grew to respect those people. There was something just very raw and real about them. We can't shame them for having these views when realistically unless you were there you're just never going to fully understand.
Very true. They don't need judgment but understanding. You have a very nice smile by the way
I saw his video a few months ago and at first thought he was batshit, but after watching it again I kind of respected his opinion on war. After all, and just like he says in this video, most of us weren't there. Despite the fact that I may not agree with what he says, war is something I will most likely never experience, I will never really be able to stand in his shoes. And his opinion is as valid as Lonnie's or as the opinions of the other vets. I'm glad to see Josh recognizes that his opinion is his own and doesn't reflect how all vets think about war, and that he genuinely cares for the mental health of veterans.
The problem with this guy's point of view is that the people he fought also felt the same way. The Americans were the intruders they were "bad men". This is why there will never be an end to war.
The Wheat Is Growing Thin and how many civilians do you think we're killed by American soilders. Should they suffer for an action if a few. Is that justice.
The Wheat Is Growing Thin you know we Americans have killed civilians before too right?
The Wheat Is Growing Thin have you never heard of blood lust? Do you think all soilders are pure and righteous? You seem very naive so I'll stop there.
Tsunade Sama You’re demeaning our own military who fought for your rights. Comparing them to terrorists and justifying what they do indirectly just to prove a point. That’s a bit... Dark if I must say. The US military isn’t innocent by any means. I’m sure the mass majority don’t just want to slaughter everyone they see. But you don’t see American soldiers beheading their own people. As well as record it. But no our big bad military is so unjustified for going there as intruders when we wouldn’t be there if they hadn’t intruded on our own soil. *cough 9/11 cough* The terrorists got what they deserved and lost. Going so low as to use children against our troops forcing our men to kill them or be killed. Your superior orders you to do so. If you think they’d choose to just die your wrong. That’s called defying orders and a one way ticket to a court martial. You lose a lot of rights in the military. You don’t have the luxuries of freedom in some cases. I’m sure a lot of troops wouldn’t have killed the kids or civilians they killed. But majority of the civilians that were killed in that war were by their own people. Pretty pathetic.
Killswitch Annihilator where did I say I blame America, although the Iraq war was proven to be falsely started. Remember those weapons of mass destruction that didn't exist. It was a lie soilders and innocent civilians alike lost their lives, and are still suffering because of that war. But yea I'm done commenting rant away.
I like this guy, he’s not annoying. I respect his honesty. What’s annoying is people in the comment thinking they’re badass for thinking he’s badass.
What happend to "keep it 100" episodes? I really miss them
Josh a wild boy 😂😂😂
War is absolutely the most addictive drug.
War is such a crazy experience, so far away from our civil society it's really impossible to imagine
I think his whole “war is awesome” attitude is really just a front. By some of the things he said about kids dying and not believing in God it sounds like it wasn’t as much fun for him as he’s making it out to be.
Ethan H. True. Denial.
underrated comment
Why couldnt it have been?
Serving with real brothers is the biggest honor in our lifetime
I think he thinks it's awesome because he became addicted to adrenaline.
“Fvck them. They’ve chosen their path.” Has been living in my head rent free since I saw the first video.
I love this guy. Even though I don't agree with everything he's saying I still respect him. You can tell he's been through some rough shit but he's still trying to better himself and others. There's something about the way he carries himself that I find oddly refreshing.
"WaR is CoOL i wAnt tO go TO WaR"...
Statements like that show this world is going crazy, no more fooking wars
Shut up
@@pantherbeast8413 that's what they want right?
HES GETTING A BACHELORS DEGREE IN PSYCHOLOGY.... *wow*
This guy is like harsh bitter TRUTH thrown right at your face. The world is not rainbows and angels
I don't think he's insane he's a complex guy I kind of get feeling rush and glory from war to try to calm the trauma of constantly being on high risk situations and seeing death and despair
To everyone saying this dude is crazy or a psychopath. you need to understand how perspective changes things. He went through a very extreme experience. He learned to cope by holding on to his current perspective. I think the military teaches this mentality to people who are going into combat.
some have mention they want to see a video of him 20 or 30 years down the line and I think that would be interesting. The walls will come down at some point he will eventually start to second guess everything, however for now this is his instinct to survive and it got him through the war.
_one day this war is gonna end_ FMJ guy reminds me of this dude
THIS IS WHAT A SOLDIER SHOULD BE LIKE, since you became A SOLDIER.
but this is not a guy that is supposed to come back in the real world...
I am going to the army hopefully soon and been thinking about how I should feel if I hurt civilians and tbh it's a gutting feeling "mind you I witnessed two war zones before during my life" I have seen people who have nothing to do with fighting turned to charcoal and it was a feeling I don't want anyone else to feel. I think my way of leading that life of being a soldier would be to always remind myself that I am not just there to only serve my country but to help these people that we came to help in the first place and do all I can to help them lead a better life while destroying what stands in the way of their progression. Maybe it's a naive way of living my life but I think that's the soldier I will be when I join.
issa osama good for you brother. Hope it all turns out well in the end. This piece of shit in this video should not be promoted. Not sure why they give sociopaths like this time.
Raytheon Orion I don't think he is bad tbh I think he will grow out of that feeling. I have seen many soldiers go thro the same thoughts. The best way is to support these soldiers and help them thro their time of need cause war really messes you up. No one comes back normal.
issa osama well then you're a better man than me. The moral high ground belongs to nobody. Least of all this fool. He doesn't deserve air. If you have murdered and you are penitent, redemption is always possible. This dude has pride. Fuck him.
Good. All soldiers have their own reasons for serving and ways of viewing it.
In America, Patriotism is treated as a virtue. Patriotism is looked at as a mental illness by the people who run the show. America is not controlling its own destiny. When you put on your costume, you are serving bankers agendas not the American people. Tons of Israeli dual citizens in the American government....and guess what, they are NOT patriotic Americans. Get the picture.
I think it's funny how people believe that everyone is unique, yet when someone clearly is, like this gentleman in the video, people say that there must be something wrong with him.... This guy is a true combat soldier, fights to live and lives to fight. He still has a good heart with love for his fellow man. War is where some people thrive and are at thier best, combat and fighting is thier profession. NOTHING PERSONAL, NO REAL HATRED FOR YOUR ENEMY, THERE IS A RESPECT FOR YOUR ENEMY THAT EXISTS FROM ONE COMBATANT TO ANOTHER. Most people even other soldiers wont understand this philosophy....
I've also served in the army and the best way to avoid depression and the post traumatic things just have a mentality like his when I was deployed in Kabul i left as a different person
I know vets in the worst of it, plus a lot in Vietnam...special units and all. They have all told me the biggest braggers are the biggest liars. Not 1 or 2 people, all.
“Your boys are out there” fucking love that, just gives the light of hope
I fw this guy right here💯
Everyone is giving this guy shit and criticizing him for being too intense... As he said, YOU'VE NEVER BEEN TO WAR. You can't get in and out of it with the same mind set that we have to function in regular society. That's why they train the military the way they do. Open your minds.
sarahxspooner yes yes yes yes thank you for saying this!
This guy seems kinda insane
Martin Wurlitzer He seems like the kind of guy who joined the military because he liked war video games.
Ethan H. I may have to make a slight correction. This guy seems like the kind of sociopathic person who happens to enjoy war games simply because he already has a desensitized and apathetic personality. Many people could enjoy war games, but simply because of the thrill and skill, not because of the "adrenaline" of killing.
Hes a warrior through and through
war fucks you up almost permanently seeing people die around you all the time and seeing innocents getting killed would fuck anyone up
Ethan H. Wtf? Don't even go there
I love this guy. He gives the no bullshit truth about what he feels and doesn't give a damn what people think because it's the truth but of course you people are going to call him a maniac and crazy just because you can't face reality.
I can just imagine him doing psychology XD
Teacher: What would an insane person believe?
Student: That killing is fun
Teacher: Correct
This guy: *Slowly sneaks out of class*
XD
i think he's seen and experienced a wider gamut of human emotion than 99% of society. maybe a psychology degree is perfect for him
This guys kinda cool. He survived the war. Not many can say that.
Can you guys do kids meet suicide attempt survivors. If you can, please use Kevin Hines, he has an amazing story and has travelled the world telling his story, he has worked with buzzfeed and I’m sure he will work with you guys too.
It's that brotherhood that camaraderie...these guys miss..It' means so much more
There is something very sickening about his bloodlust.
James Parlier there are many soldiers who have gone through all you describe but they don't cone out of the other side saying "killing is fun"
Down to the individual soldier is it not? Sure some may enjoy and even thrive in that environment (ground for war heroes?), just as others would dislike or even fear it. Having had family serve in Afghanistan, this mans attitude towards war is only 1 of many others. Think of it as a spectrum, One side likes it, one side hates it and the middle is a cluster fuck of mixed opinions/feelings. I wouldn't take his approach as the normal soldiers mindset.
Nah. Its his job.
Go risk your life during your youth to protect Americans and see them post on youtube about how you're a psychopath for gunning down people who have historically murdered your people for thousands of years. See your friends die to the people you're shooting at. See children get blown up by mines. See a culture which makes women dress in black bedsheets in some of the hottest areas of the world. Oh wait, you live in a bubble protected by the warriors like Josh who just want the people at home to have a democratic system to live in where we elect our officials and have freedom of speech, freedom to protect ourselves, freedom from government based persecution on race and religion. You don't care because you take for granted what others spill their blood for. There's something sickening about our societies indifference to those who protect our values and fight those with fucking horrible values. I guess we should leave and let them just butcher and destroy their people huh? Guess we should let extremist fascist radicals try to unify the Middle East to move toward global domination huh? That's what their ideology calls for, and now that they're weak and they can't march over the bodies of Israelis and Austrians or Greeks or Romans who supported democratic values that we enjoy today we should just leave them alone and let them unify to bring us into a world war with nuclear implications. Great plan.
Sometimes, people are meant to be in danger.
I feel the same way civilians shouldn’t judge you if they didn’t fight or do shit for their country, and I love the honesty of this veteran that shit is awesome!!!
People in the comments don't realize that calling him crazy is literally the worst thing you can do.
When you are in a war zone you have to learn to kill or be killed, you have to witness people die and it will be people you know.
You grow a hatred for the enemy on the other side and that is really good during a war for the soldiers, nobody will stop any soldier from thinking they are worse than animals since it makes them fight better, it's not weird or wrong that he enjoyed killing because that´s what he did from 18 - 24 which is a really fucking long time to be in that mindset. Nobody should blame him, he even admitted his own faults in this video yet 90% of the comments are how this guy is insane and should be "monitored closely".
My father has talked a lot about my great grandfathers time in WW2 and how it effected him. He apparently even during his death bed (old age) died with a disgust and hatred for Germans. It was so filled in his mind the hatred he felt when he lost friend after friend on the battlefield and with all the propaganda it stuck with him. If you think its not normal for soldiers to feel this kind of disgust for the enemy you haven't talked or read into war from a soldiers perspective.
Josh I know you won't read this but I want to say you are a true legend for coming out and talking and advocating for mental health especially for soldiers I have PTSD as well but from non war related things and it was extremely hard for me to accept the fact that I needed help and that came from the fact that I have always been taught that men are supposed to suck up and take it in my family.
Great video Cut I really appreciate you making another one allowing him to further explain his stance.
Most of these comments are just basing their opinions on morals and subjectiveness rather than objectiveness, they think being nice to the enemy will help in war, and sadly those soldiers learn the hard way that isn't going to work.
I honestly just see war as a dangerous job, that has an objective, kill your targets and win the war, that's it... that's it, and hating the enemy and loving to kill the enemy is even better, because then you grow a passion to be the best at killing those targets, it's the same as hunting...
that's all it is, I don't understand why it's always morals with these people, this wasn't vietnam people, this was iraq war, where they used children as suicide bombers, those people were terrible people.
Azu Nyan I agree with you but the government defines the objectives. I think by now it’s pretty easy to see we can NOT trust our government. These people are simply pawns. No matter the reason for joining they willingly sign their lives away to be pawns of the government and their agenda. I have the utmost respect for veterans and the military but I never forget who they work for.
I would always want someone like this fighting beside me. He's always honest and it's HIS honesty. No one interviewed you.
"shooting people was fun" Ik he is allowed to have an opinion but wow that is really wrong.
It's wrong to your mentality, but to him it was awesome that he was in power and could at certain circumstances, control somebody's life. A lot of corrupt people have this mentality but just be glad he's on our side
Maximum Truce it’s a fucked mentality to want to control sombody’s life. That’s legit the same arguement you could use to support slavery, homophobes or transphobic ppl
Yeah dude his feeling is "really wrong" , its not like there are hundreds of people playing through some simulated reality or situations in which they find enjoyment out of killing people, he is the only one that feels that way....
O wait video games.
Albatross ok but he actually killed people and said that he enjoyed it. Killing a simulated person can be satisfying but that’s not even near the same thing
Hey i see your point and i get it I'm just saying it shouldn't seem that strange if people are purposely going out of there way to try recreate some primal feeling in them that most vets do feel when they take another life its kinda like a power high and playing most FPS's which is one of my favorite pastimes gives you this feeling i mean that;s what most of my family who served thought. Killing a person is wrong and fucked up but its not that surprising if someone finds enjoyment in it during war its the adrenaline and knowing your got the better of someone.
"they weren't there, they weren't running through mine fields picking up kids, they weren't there pulling their buddies, 19-year-olds behind cover while they were bleeding to death, so what the fuck do they know" - a perfect reply to all the comments down there judging this dude.
What’s this guy social media
Tanker here with a titanium shoulder... Loved supporting you guys...
I would have to say my time in Afghanistan was amazing but I'm talking about the scenery, the experience and the friendly people I met both locals and soldiers from other forces.
I'm sorry mate I think you glorifying war is way off the mark however I respect that you have right to have your opinion. You've earned it the same way I have earned it.
Remember that they shall grow not old, as we that are left grow old;
Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn.
At the going down of the sun and in the morning
We will remember them. Lest we forget.
Thank you Sir. I appreciate your service and sacrifice.
You know I’m glad he’s blunt because people need the hard truth nowadays. At the same time even though he has said he has made progress and has become better I worry that he’s lost just about all his sympathy and or empathy towards another human. War obviously hardens you but usually those people that come back are completely different. I hope but nothing for the best for this guy. 👍
"Killing people is fun." This rarely happens to me but, I'm at a loss for words...
Ive heard alot of the critics critique you! Im glad i saw this 2nd interview, shows how damaging an how prosperous surviving war can be!!!! THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE
He’s like a low rent Ben Shapiro 🤦♂️
People coming up with all these theories and misconceptions about Josh. HE'S A WARRIOR THROUGH AND THROUGH. A SAVAGE. WHAT WE NEED. LOVE THIS GUY!!