IRELAND vs FIJI | FULLTIME HOT TAKES

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 414

  • @IrishInsomniac76
    @IrishInsomniac76 11 часов назад +74

    The respect shown by the Fijian players to President Michael D Higgins was heartwarming. They are tough as nails when the whistle is blown but gentlemen outside the game.

    • @alanmulcahy7749
      @alanmulcahy7749 10 часов назад +11

      Yes, It was a joy to see. Thank you Fiji.

  • @101MIGHTYJOE
    @101MIGHTYJOE 13 часов назад +103

    Re the ref decision not to award the Fijian's a try, i think she said that after consulting with lineman that ball was grounded short then knocked on. On a seperate note, massive respect to the Fijian's, as they met president Higgins they bowed. Just shows the character of the Fijian people. Thank u from an irish fan

    • @OskarBosco-o2w
      @OskarBosco-o2w 10 часов назад +3

      There was something really nice about that. Those dude are huge but gentlemen to a man. Pity about the handbags at the end, may have been our fault (Ireland) 😳

    • @alanmulcahy7749
      @alanmulcahy7749 10 часов назад +5

      Yes, She said short & knock on (therefore blew whistle). I think she is 1 of the better refs.

    • @101MIGHTYJOE
      @101MIGHTYJOE 10 часов назад +2

      ​@alanmulcahy7749 that was make understanding aswell, blew for knock on but decided to check to make sure try wasn't scored first. Overall I thought the ref was good and she took a big hit at one stage and took it like a champ, not sure I'd be up as quick if I got hit by one of tge Fijian forwards

    • @canyonsurfer2426
      @canyonsurfer2426 8 часов назад +4

      The ball was indeed grounded short - no try.

    • @PieterGildenhuys
      @PieterGildenhuys 5 часов назад

      Agreed! But another factor is that they are so huge and he was so small that in order to shake his hand they probably had to bow!

  • @Goldenship-h3w
    @Goldenship-h3w 12 часов назад +106

    As a Fiji fan, say what you will about moral victories but I’ll take 17 points all day. It’s Irelands time right now. We have a young team and the test rugby experience itself is super valuable. Congratulations Ireland.

    • @bernieob9577
      @bernieob9577 12 часов назад +12

      @@Goldenship-h3w you guys played a brilliant game today 👏

    • @lizzyhanahoe4197
      @lizzyhanahoe4197 12 часов назад +5

      Thank you, it was a good game. Fiji have so many exciting players, I wish you well, but half of me is thinking “not too soon please”

    • @aidanmasterson50
      @aidanmasterson50 12 часов назад +4

      Getting better and better. Not your day today. You get criticised for no structure, then get criticised when you add it. Keep on the structure path as flare is just in your DNA.

    • @Camcolito
      @Camcolito 12 часов назад +4

      @@bernieob9577 Nah they didn't. Fiji are a better side than what they showed today. Penalties killed them. But thanks to OP for the gracious comment.

    • @charliebannon5489
      @charliebannon5489 11 часов назад +4

      Fiji are my next favourite team after my home country of Ireland.
      Fiji showed a lot of respect today and it was very much appreciated. Ronan O'Gara has been on holidays to Fiji, and he has a lot of praise for your country and the people there.

  • @lizzyhanahoe4197
    @lizzyhanahoe4197 12 часов назад +29

    I really liked watching Gus McCarthy, he seems quietly confident and I thought he had a good, solid game. I also loved his emotion during the National Anthem, nothing wrong with a few tears ☘💚🇮🇪

  • @Natedawg38
    @Natedawg38 10 часов назад +14

    Huge respect to Fiji 🇫🇯 They bowed to Michael D Higgins and their fans even joined in during our anthem! Both the team and supporters really showed their class and character. Come visit Ireland anytime. They never gave up and really beat the shite out of some of our players, especially frawley lol wouldn't want to be his rib cage tomorrow 🤣
    🇫🇯 🇮🇪 🏉

  • @davidwalker2402
    @davidwalker2402 13 часов назад +39

    The Irish defence was awesome, they stood up to a huge Fiji team. So many new players given lots of time. If you thought Ireland were finished , think again.

    • @cateym
      @cateym 9 часов назад +1

      There'll be some very sore bodies in the morning.

  • @LeMerch
    @LeMerch 9 часов назад +10

    always love Fiji rugby and fans..
    Great people ❤

  • @OranBurns-r7c
    @OranBurns-r7c 10 часов назад +11

    First 2 Ireland tries straight from the Andrew Goodman playbook. Good to see the new attack coach having an impact.

  • @alcoyne3333333333333
    @alcoyne3333333333333 9 часов назад +7

    Thank you fiji . What a wonderful people . I'm definitely going there for a holiday..

  • @bernieob9577
    @bernieob9577 13 часов назад +41

    Casey is just brilliant 👏 well done lads

    • @lizzyhanahoe4197
      @lizzyhanahoe4197 12 часов назад +2

      So gutsy, just gets in there.

    • @barryb90
      @barryb90 12 часов назад +7

      I thought he was Man of the Match.

    • @bernieob9577
      @bernieob9577 11 часов назад +3

      @barryb90 absolutely 💯

    • @cateym
      @cateym 9 часов назад +4

      Stringer used to be called Scrappy Doo and I think Casey is of the same stuff. Took some serious hits and kept coming back for more.

  • @Frankabagnale33
    @Frankabagnale33 10 часов назад +11

    Thank you to Fiji for the respect to our head of state, president Higgins 🙏🏼

  • @ChaunceyGardner100
    @ChaunceyGardner100 13 часов назад +42

    good review. Sam Prendergast has a composure and calmness about him that instils confidence around him. His delayed flat pass is a joy to watch. Crowley is bulkier and has different attributes but there's a touch of class about Sam. Great debut from Gus mcCarthy too.

    • @Camcolito
      @Camcolito 13 часов назад +11

      Prendergast was ok, not great. Lots of mistakes. Not the finished article by a long way, but great for him to get minutes. Could easily have been far fewer minutes because that tackle was idiotic and worthy of a red imo.
      (Gus McCarthy was incredible).

    • @ChaunceyGardner100
      @ChaunceyGardner100 13 часов назад +6

      @@Camcolito agree about the tackle. his trademark delayed flat pass opened up the rush defence so often it was a joy to watch. he needs to bulk up a bit imho but you can tell he's not just shipping on the ball. he always passes with purpose and his ability to spot space out wide and nail the pass is underrated. we're lucky to have both him and Crowley in our squad.

    • @amantedellopera1681
      @amantedellopera1681 13 часов назад +3

      ​@@ChaunceyGardner100why needs to buulk up,those fijians were monsters and they never layed a glove on him or rattled him.

    • @Camcolito
      @Camcolito 13 часов назад +2

      @@ChaunceyGardner100 True.

    • @johnmarshall6629
      @johnmarshall6629 13 часов назад +3

      cant tackle cant defend lucky with a cheap shot and not the only time he did it ,so calm he kicked a 10 meter kick out on the full missed conversions from the touch line ,threw at least 3 passes ,he will be great but will never be able to defend no bottle .

  • @raymondsherry2330
    @raymondsherry2330 11 часов назад +15

    How good was Mc Carthy to day on his debut, absolutely brilliant

  • @plutopulp
    @plutopulp 12 часов назад +19

    No need to apologise for not knowing our presidents name, but appreciate it buddy ❤. Beautiful respect also shown by the Fijian's towards him!

  • @martyodoherty4236
    @martyodoherty4236 13 часов назад +13

    The young lads were class. Great to see Gus,Cormac,Cian and Casey getting more game time. Ireland abu.

  • @aidanmasterson50
    @aidanmasterson50 12 часов назад +8

    I also believe a yellow was appropriate, but that where we stop agreeing. Quinlan and Irish pundits were saying also that it could be upgraded and the ref was great. I’ve never found him remotely near as biased as the English commentators commentating on English games. It was knocked on. Good performance from Ireland but even with 8 tries, you were left feeling that the left 4 more behind. Irelands defence had more to do with the lack of Fijian attack than their efforts in trying to do so.

  • @RoyBattyLives
    @RoyBattyLives 13 часов назад +21

    Casey was flying it. Literally and figuratively.

    • @lizzyhanahoe4197
      @lizzyhanahoe4197 12 часов назад +7

      Bless him, he did get knocked around a fair bit, but it doesn’t it stop him, fair play to him. I thought he had a great game., and a try to go with it. ☘👍

    • @colmgeiran3476
      @colmgeiran3476 10 часов назад +6

      Casey played a blinder.

  • @jean-michel.a
    @jean-michel.a 8 часов назад +4

    Thank you Tim for sharing your passion for rugby

  • @PaulKavanagh-i6k
    @PaulKavanagh-i6k 11 часов назад +6

    Tim, great to see Ireland 🇮🇪 back to normal . The president is Michael D Higgins

  • @savagej2
    @savagej2 12 часов назад +17

    Sam delays his pass long enough to cause defenders to bite in. This competition will make Crowley better. Great to have competition at 10

    • @DM-rp9ik
      @DM-rp9ik 9 часов назад +1

      I've never seen Crowley or many fly halfs execute that skill as well as Prendergast. Larkham was the last guy I've seen do it that well

    • @savagej2
      @savagej2 9 часов назад

      @DM-rp9ik I'm a Leinster fan so all for Sam being the future answer to Johnny. However, we need two good 10s.

    • @DM-rp9ik
      @DM-rp9ik 8 часов назад +1

      @savagej2 Crowley is a very good 10 I'm not saying he's bad.

  • @damienmcclave5143
    @damienmcclave5143 11 часов назад +6

    Game against Figi so don't want to get ahead of thongs. All-round good performance. Ireland are better when other provinces are involved. Ulster guys looked good. Ireland are better when the mix up the players. New #6 watch out for this guy, big and athletic, super impressive. Mc Carthy great game. What a future that guy has. I wish Farrel would give more opportunities to more players from all over Ireland.

  • @Aladinsarsipius
    @Aladinsarsipius 11 часов назад +5

    Micheal D Higgins As much a Giant of a Man as Doris Aki and Porter. Though seeing him greet
    Devon Toner was always a good Laugh

  • @dazza4345
    @dazza4345 13 часов назад +26

    😮Im not looking forward to the incoming Irish 😕 hate on here.I thought Ireland deserved to win despite what the trolls will say.I think Figi are an exciting and really strong team.Great respect to Figi in the prelims for their courtesy 👏

    • @thomaslequesne5475
      @thomaslequesne5475 13 часов назад +11

      52-17 and some people still think the refs handed Ireland the match...

    • @Camcolito
      @Camcolito 13 часов назад +8

      The Fouling Fijians really sabotaged any chance they had with penalties. Ireland meanwhile had much better discipline. Shows you how critical that part of the game is.

    • @Irish780
      @Irish780 13 часов назад +4

      We are they new England in rugby 🏉 😀 anybody but Ireland.... success brings envoy

    • @savagej2
      @savagej2 12 часов назад

      Embrace it. Nobody likes us....we don't care. Saffas hate us because they can't beat us.

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  12 часов назад +9

      The more fans of other nations have a pop, the more of a threat it means you are.
      Ok that basis, France and Ireland are very good teams.

  • @darrenbyrne5465
    @darrenbyrne5465 13 часов назад +13

    When Davidson called for the TMO she said i have grounded short and a knock on, which was from the fiji grounding it and rolling it forward a bit on the ground who any scrumhalf knows is a knock on

    • @EolasColas
      @EolasColas 13 часов назад +3

      But it was short

    • @allisterhunter1976
      @allisterhunter1976 13 часов назад +3

      @@EolasColas called knock on Tim

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  12 часов назад +3

      That explains stopping the game. (Not sure it was knocked on, but makes sense!)

  • @justRedDevil
    @justRedDevil 13 часов назад +22

    In fairness to Hollie, she thought it was short and lost forward. She's a young ref and will undoubtedly learn from that.

    • @aonghus3860
      @aonghus3860 13 часов назад +8

      Yeah she called it as short and a knock on from the beginning

    • @Stephendenham
      @Stephendenham 13 часов назад +3

      +1 you're off the mark there Tim

    • @hanoitripper1809
      @hanoitripper1809 12 часов назад

      She qs awful

    • @RossoVerdeNero
      @RossoVerdeNero 12 часов назад +2

      I thought she had a decent enough game, although I do wonder about the experienced Irish legends saying that Prendergast should have had red. Sounds like she got that one wrong.

    • @justRedDevil
      @justRedDevil 11 часов назад +7

      @RossoVerdeNero personally, I thought it was a yellow. However, she can't be faulted. She gave the yellow with an off-field review. Upon review, it remained a yellow. She did everything exactly right.

  • @BaneofBalor
    @BaneofBalor 13 часов назад +15

    I think the Prendergast/Crowley debate is similar to the England Smith/Smith debate. Why not both? They're both young, talented and simply offer something different. Neither one is better than the other imo, just different styles.

    • @michaelcoyne3700
      @michaelcoyne3700 12 часов назад +1

      That’s the issue with out half’s though, it’s hard to expect every other player in the back line to totally change out their style to suit during the game or week to week.

    • @Ollyk1
      @Ollyk1 12 часов назад +3

      @@BaneofBalor Crowley is better no question. Sam will be really good (injury permitting) by the time he’s 24.

    • @BaneofBalor
      @BaneofBalor 12 часов назад +1

      @Ollyk1 Yeah I really meant from the perspective of the future of the 10 jersey

    • @barryb90
      @barryb90 12 часов назад +4

      Crowley currently has bigger games under his belt including a URC final and a regular for Munster. As a Leinster fan, Prendergast needs is not at that level yet.

    • @DM-rp9ik
      @DM-rp9ik 9 часов назад

      ​@barryb90 It's clear to anyone watching he's just better. Might be a bit younger and less experienced but he is better

  • @RossoVerdeNero
    @RossoVerdeNero 12 часов назад +5

    My thoughts on Izuchukwu: not sure what to make of it. He did OK and he didn't make any significant mistakes, so he didn't do himself any harm. But for the most part, the game just seemed to pass him by. I was getting frustrated by his lack of involvement as he has been a major ball carrier for Ulster, but then the light dawned: whether by design or not, the ball was hardly ever given to him to carry. Was this again, a subconscious result of the experienced players preferring to stick to the guys they normally play with? His carry stats will probably look poor, but it's hardly his fault if he's never picked out.

    • @sinking1902
      @sinking1902 12 часов назад +3

      Don’t worry he’s young. The plays just go with the tried and trusted Doris, VDF, Big Joe. I thought he was solid. He’ll get more chances.

    • @alanmulcahy7749
      @alanmulcahy7749 9 часов назад

      I think he played reasonably well in his first international, I would hope he is happy with his performance. I don't think that the coaching team would feed him to the wolves, by asking him to make the hard yards.
      The X factor is always there & available. I think he needs to keep improving on the basics to get into the matchday squad. There are some serious athletes competing for a few places (including Lions, world player of the year nominees, Ryan Baird, etc.). Hopefully he keeps improving & has many more days in Green.

  • @jasonwall5012
    @jasonwall5012 12 часов назад +11

    6:14 his name is Michael D Higgins, he's our president of the Leprechauns.
    It wasn't a struggling Fijian side trying to play, its a matter that Ireland didn't allow them to play.
    Sam was class, the passing, 1, 2's and cross field kicks, bringing the ball to the line and slip. Making and taking tackles when A LOT of people said he wouldn't be able to.

  • @9502937
    @9502937 12 часов назад +6

    Some brilliant offloads from Gus McCarthy. Hooker is not exactly a position where Ireland were lacking depth, but the future looks promising.

  • @davidanderson5517
    @davidanderson5517 10 часов назад +2

    First time for new players. Just remember Johnny Sexton wasn’t really good on his Ireland exposure. Players will be phased when playing international rugby. What a brilliant place to do it. Well done AF! Ageing Ireland team refresh absolutely needed.

  • @gezzarandom
    @gezzarandom 13 часов назад +20

    Good moral boost BUT will need to be better next weekend against a resurgent Australia.

    • @x-latetv-x6816
      @x-latetv-x6816 13 часов назад +4

      They need to work on their passing, atrocious at times

    • @davidwalker2402
      @davidwalker2402 13 часов назад +3

      @@x-latetv-x6816atrocious give me a break , take your head out of your arse, some forward passes “just” but some sublime passing. I suppose you think you get to score 8 tries passing atrociously 😂😂

    • @x-latetv-x6816
      @x-latetv-x6816 13 часов назад +2

      @@davidwalker2402 they butchered a few scores with sloppy passes

    • @davidwalker2402
      @davidwalker2402 13 часов назад +2

      @ yes they did but equally they scored 8 tries with some sublime passing. There was a totally different Irish team out there and many early injuries lots of position changes. There seems to be an ignorance about Ireland going on , but they turned up today and beat another tier 1 team easily. Fiji had won 6 of their last 7 games. Scotland beat them by a similar score with all their first team out and it was seen as a great win.

    • @Camcolito
      @Camcolito 13 часов назад

      @@davidwalker2402 Scotland celebrate losing by a couple of tries at home to SA, that's not where we're at.
      It was a good performance and great to get minutes in the young guys.

  • @owenoneill8173
    @owenoneill8173 10 часов назад +5

    If youve followed the U20s you'll know all about Gus. Class operator.

  • @Cpchurch87
    @Cpchurch87 13 часов назад +19

    That’s Michael D Higgins, the Irish president

    • @mylesbyrne5287
      @mylesbyrne5287 13 часов назад +4

      Maura's uncle 😂

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  12 часов назад +6

      Only ever seen him when the rugby's on...always a pleasure.

    • @Cpchurch87
      @Cpchurch87 12 часов назад +4

      @EggchasersRugby he's a gentleman. Fantastic human rights activist, and a very good poet by all accounts. Lovely to see the respect between him and the Fijians

    • @FR-je9bw
      @FR-je9bw 10 часов назад +1

      ​@@mylesbyrne5287The apple doesn't fall far from the tree

    • @johncahalane7327
      @johncahalane7327 6 часов назад

      ​@@EggchasersRugbyHe's a very interesting man a human rights activist speaks fluent Spanish and French, he should not be around he was in the church in Nicragua when Archbishop Romero was murder with other by a death squad..he had a stroke in March and was very lucky again...Michael D Higgins has two years left as President, the respect shown him by the Fiji players was something to behold

  • @tommartin7333
    @tommartin7333 5 часов назад +1

    Welcome to Fijian players snd fans such humble people.exciting game big hits and niggle.

  • @quentinquentin6752
    @quentinquentin6752 13 часов назад +3

    Ireland fan here and this was a much better game today. I felt for Fiji, were they just tired? Agree with you Tim we left several tries out there that went begging.

  • @richy3084
    @richy3084 13 часов назад +5

    She stopped as she thought it was a knock forward, she said it live

  • @RossoVerdeNero
    @RossoVerdeNero 12 часов назад +4

    My thoughts on big Jacob: the big lad is BACK! He made a real impact coming off his wing into midfield, and if some of his supposedly more illustrious colleagues could pass, he was itching to let fly. Hanson butchered chances to give both a Jacob and Cormac a score. Maybe I'm being hyper-critical, but although Aki rightly got MotM, there were at least two occasions where Jacob was steaming up on his left and Aki chose to go inside and take the contact, when Jacob only had one or two to beat had he received it, and we know that's not necessarily a problem when his dander is up, as it clearly was. Particularly in this sort of match, just going into contact rather than rolling the dice for a true strike winger; I thought those were real missed opportunities. I was left wondering, would Aki have made those passes if Lowe were outside him? Was there a lack of trust or familiarity?
    Oh, by the way, for all those anti-Stockdale genius posters in advance of the game - he didn't put a foot wrong in defence.

    • @sinking1902
      @sinking1902 12 часов назад +2

      Jacob looked great I thought. He was unlucky not to get on the scoreboard himself. Good to have him back in the mix.

  • @kiaoragin
    @kiaoragin 8 часов назад +2

    Was most impressed with Sam P's passing. He will beef up as he has a big frame and will add muscle in the next few years. I think we see him as number 22 next week. I think Crowley will start.

  • @Irish780
    @Irish780 13 часов назад +9

    Best part was Ireland youngsters looking good

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  13 часов назад +5

      They really did!

    • @LeMerch
      @LeMerch 6 часов назад

      @@EggchasersRugbybut against a tired looking Fiji.

  • @TheIrishYoshi
    @TheIrishYoshi 13 часов назад +19

    I missed the first twenty minutes, so I may have missed something, but I think Hollie Davidson had a really good game. More consistent and attentive refereeing than I've seen recently.
    She needs to be careful with her positioning though, she'll get knocked out

    • @GoldenbanjoDJ
      @GoldenbanjoDJ 12 часов назад +5

      I thought she was terrible. Missed a lot that she should have given, gave a lot that she shouldn’t have

    • @lizzyhanahoe4197
      @lizzyhanahoe4197 12 часов назад +2

      @@GoldenbanjoDJ Bla Bla blah

    • @GoldenbanjoDJ
      @GoldenbanjoDJ 11 часов назад

      @ oh here she is. The most pointless commenter on RUclips. You’ve managed to say something even stupider than ‘and?’ this time

  • @t3lurid3
    @t3lurid3 13 часов назад +38

    Irish commentary feed were saying Pendergast was lucky it wasn’t a red too Tim.

    • @SMacCuUladh
      @SMacCuUladh 12 часов назад +3

      Yep the commentary team said that and Trimby said the same in the studio afterwards.

    • @RossoVerdeNero
      @RossoVerdeNero 12 часов назад +7

      I don't know the laws well enough (who does?), but O'Driscoll's point was that the mitigation of "not a high degree of danger" shouldn't have applied as it was deemed to be deliberate foul play. If that's true, then, even as an Irish fan, Im would have to wonder did he get a "home town big nation" benefit of doubt.

    • @cheesecake6696
      @cheesecake6696 10 часов назад +3

      2 years ago that's a red and a 3 week ban, but I think yellow was fair.

    • @pudwellion
      @pudwellion 10 часов назад +2

      Could have been a red, it was a lazy tackle. Other than that there was a few times where he was undecided what to do, a sharper team would be all over him.

    • @davidwalker2402
      @davidwalker2402 9 часов назад

      @@t3lurid3 Irish media are bunch of whining clowns .

  • @fincorrigan7139
    @fincorrigan7139 13 часов назад +9

    Sorry Tim, they said here on TV in Ireland that Prendergast was v. lucky (Quinlan himself)

    • @danielokeeffe6358
      @danielokeeffe6358 13 часов назад +1

      Quinlan is famous for being fair towards Leinster players when he isn't trying to play opthamologist with them.

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  13 часов назад +8

      I stand corrected then! My apologies to Alan Quinlan :)

    • @dazza4345
      @dazza4345 13 часов назад +2

      ​@@EggchasersRugbythere was no intent .

    • @fionnmckool
      @fionnmckool 13 часов назад +2

      Quinny does not like Pendrergast cause he is not munster.

    • @GoldenbanjoDJ
      @GoldenbanjoDJ 12 часов назад +1

      I often feel that Quinlan over-eggs it to be extra extra ‘fair’

  • @lizdaly7533
    @lizdaly7533 12 часов назад +7

    Alan Quinlan did actually say Sam's card could be upgraded to a red at the time...just FYI 😊

  • @jamescody2003
    @jamescody2003 10 часов назад +2

    Alan Quinn was honest when I listened, he said “that easily could have been a red, he got away with it”, I think he was honest

  • @RossoVerdeNero
    @RossoVerdeNero 12 часов назад +20

    My thoughts on the Young Prentender: he had a shocker at the start. A stupid shoulder to the head, rightly a yellow, could have been a red. As soon as he got back on, he kicked the ball dead while going for the corner, then 2 minutes later he kicked a straightforward one out on the full under no pressure. But, to be fair to the lad, he regrouped and looked the part for the rest of his game. Nothing special, but good experience for him. Perhaps the Dublin media will ease off on anointing him for a bit while he gains more experience.

    • @eamonkelly36
      @eamonkelly36 11 часов назад +2

      Great to see yoings kids playing u will learn much more playing than training 😅😅

    • @SmashboiSchwift
      @SmashboiSchwift 8 часов назад +2

      Salt from the South as always

    • @electric69irl
      @electric69irl 8 часов назад

      @@SmashboiSchwift You can sense the gritted teeth thru which it was typed. called out every tiny error and baying for a red card."nothing special"...these clows will be very very confused when they see him starting ahead of Jack very soon. i love it.

  • @Cgoggin100
    @Cgoggin100 12 часов назад +4

    I thought Izuchukwu was unlucky not to get the try. The pass looked very flat, could have at least checked it as it would have resulted in a try.

  • @charliedale2477
    @charliedale2477 12 часов назад +2

    Was there for the game, have to say I did feel the ref was giving a lot of calls irelands way that shouldn’t have been. Lots of instances I saw Ireland players diving into rucks from the side or being in offside positions that weren’t called at all, and the ref told Hansen not to run after one breakdown as she wanted to stop play, but he ran and scored and she didn’t do anything. All this coming from a neutral fan too

  • @charliebannon5489
    @charliebannon5489 12 часов назад +9

    Irish commentary said Prendergast could have had a red card upgrade. No bias there. As for Alan Quinlan, I've heard he's a really good fellow from someone I know who met him, but I get what you're saying Tim. I rarely listen to him as it's uncomfortable. Somehow, he always brings it back to, "When I used to play for Munster in the good old days". The match could be Mongolia v Bangladesh, but Alan Quinlan will end up talking about Munster back in his playing days😂

    • @hasparov
      @hasparov 11 часов назад +2

      Yeh he’s a good bloke and no doubt fine in real life but he is over-visible in the media - problem is he is just not a very good analyst.

  • @nialldaly7108
    @nialldaly7108 4 часа назад

    You are correct It is Alan Quinlan on commentry on Virgin Media in Ireland... But he also thought that Sam Prendergast yellow could be upgraded to a 20 min red and nobody could complain.

  • @ColmOCallaghan-i6b
    @ColmOCallaghan-i6b 13 часов назад +5

    Good game. Must say Prendergast was lucky not to get red. Some lovely passes and mccarthy had a great game

  • @Ollyk1
    @Ollyk1 13 часов назад +5

    You’re wrong on the short call Tim. She said it was short and then a knock on. She said that from the start. Listen back.

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  13 часов назад

      Fair enough. Wasn't a knock on though, was it?

    • @Ollyk1
      @Ollyk1 13 часов назад +2

      @ tbh I groaned when I saw Hollie was reffing the game BUT we have to give up and coming refs games like this to develop and she will improve over time. She’s very new to this level and I’m not sure Sam Grove white was a great refs assistant. I think some experienced refs on the line would have been more help to her.

    • @Ollyk1
      @Ollyk1 13 часов назад +2

      Her positioning can be very poor at times. Lucky she only got hit once tbh.

    • @hanoitripper1809
      @hanoitripper1809 12 часов назад

      @@Ollyk1she can develop in 2nd tier or women’s tests if they want to go that route. She was condescending to the Fijians and poor overall.

    • @Ollyk1
      @Ollyk1 12 часов назад

      @@hanoitripper1809 we could say the same about a few other refs as well. It’s tough as we’ve had a number of really good refs retire recently and the quality isn’t as good and as widely spread as it once was in my opinion. Plus I think the game needs something more than one ref at the professional level. It’s far from easy.

  • @readesiun988
    @readesiun988 6 часов назад +1

    Prendergast was well able for the big hits from the big Fijians, this guy is a real talented 10

  • @ChristoDiedericks-f9g
    @ChristoDiedericks-f9g 13 часов назад +32

    Rugby must be the game with the most inconsistent refereeing in the world…

    • @ChaunceyGardner100
      @ChaunceyGardner100 13 часов назад

      Agree with this and it's the reason it won't grow outside a niche audience. the rules are very difficult to understand. Soccer, golf, tennis, even curling is so easy to understand TV viewers can engage with the drama unfolding. apart from a last minute drop goal or try, it's really hard to understand what's going on.

    • @matthewvanrensburg3824
      @matthewvanrensburg3824 12 часов назад +3

      ​@@ChaunceyGardner100 Rules not complicated, the referee quality standards are just shit

    • @deeperanddown
      @deeperanddown 12 часов назад +1

      @@matthewvanrensburg3824 The "laws" are too interpretative that's the problem. That makes the refs job difficult they are trying to create a perfectly safe game and the loses both the spirit of the game and can be counterproductive for safety ( low tackles = more concussions ).

    • @matthewvanrensburg3824
      @matthewvanrensburg3824 12 часов назад

      @deeperanddown "Interpretive" is in the application and attitude from WR and their ego is the problem. Son busy studying coaching and its been an interesting journey discovering just how inept and complicit WR truly have been, the rules are not the problem, its the story they keep selling to hide their ineptitude and the absolute absymal quality of refs they have been producing. The entire WR board needs to go for rugby, thats the real and ONLY change the sport needs, everything will flow naturally from there, a professional sport run by inept amatuers

    • @jacques136
      @jacques136 12 часов назад +1

      1 set of rules for ireland and another set for the rest of the world. Ireland is where nz was a few years ago. Just do what they want and get away with it

  • @Camcolito
    @Camcolito 11 часов назад +4

    Fiji couldn't get their running game going at all because of their atrocious penalty count. Completely killed off the game for them.

  • @joanlarkin7808
    @joanlarkin7808 13 часов назад +13

    Prendergast was very lucky it wasn't a red but he will know that himself, and Andy will remind him. It's only the beginning of his career so no rush.

    • @GoldenbanjoDJ
      @GoldenbanjoDJ 13 часов назад +4

      Nowhere near a red card

    • @GeorgePlaten
      @GeorgePlaten 11 часов назад +2

      It was dirty and cynical, if Andy doesn't beat that out of his game, he's not much of a coach.

    • @Cmac7898
      @Cmac7898 11 часов назад +3

      @@GoldenbanjoDJbased on the rules he was lucky not to receive a red. Once you tuck your arm like he did it’s deemed as always illegal. There was no malice but he was fortunate not to receive a red

    • @laoch5658
      @laoch5658 10 часов назад

      just like barret against Ireland two weeks ago

    • @GoldenbanjoDJ
      @GoldenbanjoDJ 10 часов назад +2

      @@laoch5658 Barrett was a clear red. This one was a yellow at very best

  • @andreroberts7569
    @andreroberts7569 11 часов назад +1

    If roles were reversed and that was a Fijian... red for sure. It's the little things that can change momentum. For sure, Ireland was the better team and deserved the W. 4:53 I also feel they brushed over that vd Vlier finish... in the highlights, he definitely tries to dot down after 'losing' the ball.... TMO said,'It's fine...without the ref taking a loo

  • @peterdcrowley
    @peterdcrowley 11 часов назад +2

    Even the Irish commentary thought the yellow for prendergahst could have been a red

  • @aonghus3860
    @aonghus3860 13 часов назад +5

    President Michael D. Higgins, who makes Craig Casey look tall

  • @Comerford1986
    @Comerford1986 9 часов назад +2

    As a pessimistic Irish fan, I am shocked at how bad Fiji were.

  • @awf-l3684
    @awf-l3684 11 часов назад +3

    That was a red card, if it was a Fiji player guarantee they would have given red card. The ref was shocking and Ireland didn't need all her bias calls to win

  • @threadmillrunning7619
    @threadmillrunning7619 10 часов назад

    Good match report and insightful comments. On a separate note, I did cringe a bit when you patronisingly referred to the "the wee chap" as a 'lovely elderly gentleman". He happens to be a distinguished intellectual, a poet and an extraordinary orator.

  • @padawan9127
    @padawan9127 13 часов назад +16

    Came to the comments to find the saffa's, the bitter boks that follow EVERY Ireland win or loss. I'll stay scrolling 😂😂

    • @giddygiddy85
      @giddygiddy85 12 часов назад

      😂😂 yeah it's crazy lad, especially when some lad called Mbonobi starts giving Ireland shit... Hang on there for a minute Mbonobi, Ireland were fighting for your fucking human rights while that same team you support did apartheid to you... Those Mbonobi lads need a history lesson 😂

    • @wot4922
      @wot4922 11 часов назад +3

      Such a wasted life. Ah well if our "bitterness" brings you joy, them please go ahead, keep scrolling. Somebody is bound to make you happy. Btw, 1st 4 times WC winners and
      No.1 ranked team. 😂💚💛🇿🇦

    • @one_eyed_odin
      @one_eyed_odin 11 часов назад

      Why would you summon the third worlders here

    • @one_eyed_odin
      @one_eyed_odin 11 часов назад

      Why summon the 3rd worlders here ffs

    • @hasparov
      @hasparov 11 часов назад

      Too bad you couldn’t win your home series against us

  • @Colm-wk9zw
    @Colm-wk9zw 13 часов назад +8

    Gus amazing debut, definitely surpassed Herring now IMO, Izuchuckwu fairly quite debut, but held his own, Casey with a good outing aswell with Sam they had all so far had errors creaking in but that's to be expected.
    Aki x Henshaw rolling it back to Connacht 15/16! Unfortunate for cube with another injury, speedy recovery! Hansen almost back to his best, not far off.
    Kelleher, Cian, Murray were OK from the bench, Stu and Frawley less so.
    My team for next week
    1. Porter
    2. Kelleher
    3. Furlong
    4. J. McCarthy
    5. Beirne
    6. Baird if not, if not Izuchuckwu
    7. JvdF
    8. Doris
    9. JGP
    10. Crowley
    11. Lowe
    12. Aki
    13. Ringrose
    14. Hansen
    15. Keenan
    16. G.McCarthy
    17. Healy
    18. Bealham
    19. Ryan
    20. Izuchuckwu/C. Prendergast
    21. Casey
    22. S. Prendergast
    23. Osborne if fit, if not Henshaw

    • @Camcolito
      @Camcolito 13 часов назад +2

      McCarthy looked like he had been playing hooker for Ireland for years. That kid could be something special. Pity we seem to be collecting loads of top talent at hooker, would be nice to spread it around to other positions!

    • @Colm-wk9zw
      @Colm-wk9zw 13 часов назад

      @Camcolito yeah, Loosehead, Openside, and perhaps left wings are the most needed atm.

    • @alanmulcahy7749
      @alanmulcahy7749 9 часов назад

      Hoping Healy starts.

  • @timmado8441
    @timmado8441 11 часов назад +2

    How was that not a red card on prendergast. The tmo and ref got this completly wrong

  • @unleashedmystery
    @unleashedmystery 13 часов назад +2

    Frawley with his forward passes... honestly he just missiles the ball to Murray because he didn't want to get minced again resulting in a forward pass

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  13 часов назад +3

      Probably right actually.

    • @GoldenbanjoDJ
      @GoldenbanjoDJ 13 часов назад +2

      I thought that was harsh given the momentum rule. Hands went backwards

  • @JohannesMahlangu-y2f
    @JohannesMahlangu-y2f 13 часов назад +5

    Ireland Are Still Too Strong I Can't wait to See them Meet France in six Nations

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  12 часов назад +4

      That fixture has been BOX OFFICE in recent years

    • @sinking1902
      @sinking1902 12 часов назад +1

      France will take it. They’re looking super strong. I think they’ll build and win the next WC.

    • @OskarBosco-o2w
      @OskarBosco-o2w 10 часов назад

      Ireland will beat France in Dublin and win the trophy despite losing to England OR Scotland. You read it here first.

    • @cateym
      @cateym 8 часов назад +1

      ​@OskarBosco-o2w I'd be content to finish 3rd this year if we put some serious effort into rebuilding.

  • @28copland
    @28copland 10 часов назад +2

    Gus mccarthy, Ronan kelleher and Dan Sheehan share the love lads (munster fan)

    • @DM-rp9ik
      @DM-rp9ik 8 часов назад +1

      One of them could end up at Munster for sure.

  • @eamonkelly36
    @eamonkelly36 11 часов назад +2

    Figis won the dancing and respect for me great people😅😅

  • @beerdedirish1563
    @beerdedirish1563 12 часов назад +3

    I can't get the welsh game! This paywall is really annoying.

  • @ChaunceyGardner100
    @ChaunceyGardner100 13 часов назад +2

    Our prez is called Michael D Higgins

  • @davittoshannon5770
    @davittoshannon5770 6 часов назад +1

    I always find the minutia around scoring a try frustrating. It was short, ref did well to ping it in real time but neglected to say “On field no try, looks short then knock on” Reality is we all know what she meant but because it wasn’t said a certain way we’re all letter of law legal eagles 🤢

  • @tomlanex
    @tomlanex 10 часов назад +1

    Don't worry Tim, The irish president is michael d Higgins. He isn't prime minister and the beauty of this channel is that it comes off the cuff.. and it's rugby you are covering so no worries from this irish man

  • @IrlDave71
    @IrlDave71 13 часов назад +1

    Thats a very flashy top!! I'm sure I one similar going to school in the 1970's.

  • @blitz8279
    @blitz8279 13 часов назад +4

    I know we talk about the ref every week but that was disgusting
    Especialy with a team like ireland who wil punish you fiji was getting blown out of the game

    • @Camcolito
      @Camcolito 13 часов назад +3

      They were blowing themselves out of the game bro, they just kept giving away clear, stupid, penalties. Much like Ireland for the past two weeks, but worse.

  • @ICantSplel
    @ICantSplel 2 часа назад

    1:30 Nail on the head. Of course you gotta get the fundamentals right, but it seemed like they just wanted to bosh through us. And they've the players to do that to a degree, but it fairly one dimensional from the usual chaos you got from Fiji.

  • @TurtleFPL
    @TurtleFPL 12 часов назад +6

    Short and lost forward was what was said. Hollie had a great game. Shes getting a lot of unjust grief online purely because shes a woman. Top young ref

    • @paulwalsh598
      @paulwalsh598 6 часов назад

      She is the best referee in the URC and rapidly becoming one of the better at international.

    • @FNQKiwi
      @FNQKiwi 5 часов назад

      I thought she had a reasonable game but spare me the victimhood. She can be criticised just like other refs.

  • @mountainsofelysium7379
    @mountainsofelysium7379 7 часов назад

    I am Irish and felt that Prendergast should have got a red... it was deliberate foul play, even if as they said "not a high degree of danger"
    I was not alone in this, the pundits on the tv said it could have been red and I was watching the game at a friend's house and we all called it should have been red.
    There was no intention to cause an injury but it was deliberate and a bit careless.
    Still delighted Ireland won, Fiji are a fantastic side and I would love to see them get far more success (except against Ireland of course)

  • @LomuHabana
    @LomuHabana 11 часов назад +6

    Gus McCarthy such a freak. At times you thought he was a fly half.
    Actual fly half wasn’t bad either. What a delight to watch is Sam Prendergast. The true heir of Sexton. So creative and evasive. So composed and clean under pressure. For the Australians and other afl fans here. He reminds me of AFL star Nick Daicos.
    Also the sub bringing on a hooker for a 12. I love teams breaking the Rugby habits.

    • @fishyq5077
      @fishyq5077 11 часов назад +1

      The hype about Prendergast and Daicos are definitely similar. Daicos is the AFL's second coming of Christ. In the AFL, it would have been a free to Daicos for the equivalent of that yellow card offense.

    • @LomuHabana
      @LomuHabana 10 часов назад

      @ Haha. I am not a Collingwood fan you know and I agree that he is overprotected and the AFLs poster child. Still a terrific player, undeniable.
      The hype, the style of play, and even a bit of look. So much in common.

    • @peterm..6981
      @peterm..6981 10 часов назад +1

      ..Oisin Mullen The New Daicos !!
      _____________________

    • @LomuHabana
      @LomuHabana 10 часов назад

      @@peterm..6981 Great example too. Terrific footballer.

    • @alanmulcahy7749
      @alanmulcahy7749 10 часов назад +1

      I was disappointed that they did not put Gus at 12 or 13 when Doris moved there.

  • @iankavanagh9174
    @iankavanagh9174 10 часов назад

    Irish commentators said it could easily have been a red. Said if the player was wearing white or a couple of stone heavier it was 100% red. As an Irishman I’d agree.

  • @colmgeiran3476
    @colmgeiran3476 10 часов назад +1

    Is it too early to say "we're back"? Probably. The test against the Aussies will give us a better idea. That said, Prendergast was more than competent at 10. Onwards and upwards.

  • @cedricpicard9016
    @cedricpicard9016 13 часов назад

    nothing about the game, haven´t watched it yet, but love that jumper, it has this 80´s vibe to it. what brand is it?

  • @loco19800
    @loco19800 6 часов назад

    TBF the Irish commentators are pretty one eyed.
    Irish myself. I’m torn on this because I think as a small island nation where historically it’s been watched mostly in Ireland it kinda makes sense.
    My favourite commentators are the kiwi ones. Murray mex head etc.
    Not as biased as ours but also insular.

  • @foodfordudes
    @foodfordudes 9 часов назад +1

    Your right
    It was clumsy

  • @lizzyhanahoe4197
    @lizzyhanahoe4197 12 часов назад

    I actually like your jumper Tim 👍

  • @Dreyno
    @Dreyno 7 часов назад

    Hansen’s non-forward pass hasn’t stopped Munster fans hammering him for it because they want the extremely one dimensional Calvin Nash ahead of him in the pecking order.

  • @onlookervb
    @onlookervb 13 часов назад +1

    Jesus Fiji couldn't stop giving away penalties, the game was stop start but if anything she could have given more it was like the game after a big team night out proper shocking

  • @mickser101
    @mickser101 12 часов назад +4

    Where's all the Saffer trolls?

    • @SMacCuUladh
      @SMacCuUladh 12 часов назад +3

      their game is on now, they'll turn up after that

    • @lizzyhanahoe4197
      @lizzyhanahoe4197 12 часов назад +2

      In hiding no doubt.

  • @dazza4345
    @dazza4345 13 часов назад +1

    Figi were clearly short of the try line Tim as seen by ref Holly Davidson.Very conclusive Tim its the rules.

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  13 часов назад

      I agree it was short. What I didn't understand is why, if it's short, you stop the game as the ball is therefore still live. But others have said she thought it was knocked on (not sure it was but it explains it)

  • @eamonkelly36
    @eamonkelly36 11 часов назад

    Men playing with boys some talent coming through😮😮

  • @Paul-te8mz
    @Paul-te8mz 9 часов назад +1

    Many thanks for the vid. Credit Fiji players for kind curtesy and respect of President Michael D. Higgins (an example here to Martin Johnson?). Some observations. Completely agree Fiji seemed reluctant to play the inventive adventurous unstructured rugby which is so enjoyable to watch, and apart from the two tries, only towards the end started playing to their strengths, sniping forward with the ball in one hand. In contrast in the second half Ireland played well from unstructured play with Fijian style basketball passes. Agree red would have been very harsh for Prendergast. It seemed more like obstruction and leaning in with the shoulder, rather than intent, with a low level of danger. Hence no HIA. Ref did the right thing, yellow and left it to the bunker to determine, which had the advantage of viewing numerous replays in reaching their decision. I was also initially confused at the call on the Fiji try which was short, but the ref clarified immediately, in effect: my view short, then lost forward, - and sought TMO confirmation, which confirmed. Game restarted with Irish scrum consistent with call. Van der Flier try also referred to TMO. Didn't see much wrong with ref, who calmly explained all decisions, and I thought all the forward passes called against Ireland were reasonable calls, (though unforgiveable as AF will explain on Monday). Again, ref showed common sense approach by not following up on handbags in the last minute, I thought initiated by Fiji player's afters on try scorer, in what was otherwise an even tempered, if bruising, encounter. Kudos to Fiji but with due respect, Australia will be a much bigger challenge next weekend.

  • @mickinoz2005
    @mickinoz2005 8 часов назад +1

    Figi we're terrible ire made lots of errors and left a lot of points on the field. Not sure Ireland camp will be happy. Great to blood new players though.

  • @Deadlift14
    @Deadlift14 8 часов назад

    What is everyone's opinion on Beirne at lock opposed to 6?

  • @mawc92
    @mawc92 8 часов назад

    For a lot of youngsters out there, it was a mix bag but the positives outweighed the negatives. Inexperienced Half backs never played with each other, young hooker, 6 was good - when they tighten up the skills they will come good. Poor Frawley will need a serious ice bath after that one, he got ended several times. Thought Osborne looked very assured for his short time on the field and delighted to see stockdale put himself around - looked dangerous with his Carrie’s and hungry for work. On another day prendergast would have seen red

  • @LittleBigMediaCo
    @LittleBigMediaCo 10 часов назад

    Before today I was a big fan of how dear Holly handled her matches ... but she burnt all that goodwill in just a single match. She was abysmal. As for the 'yellow' ... it was a straight red, and not of the 20min red variety. That was a deliberate shoulder put there. Agree with you on the game being stopped for a "ref thought" ... surely you let it play out in that situation, and then go back and check what really happened.

  • @marcobucceri8530
    @marcobucceri8530 11 часов назад +1

    Fiji didn’t turn up for this game. Ireland is a strong side and Fiji lost the plot completely. Very disappointing!

  • @kieranodwyer4108
    @kieranodwyer4108 7 часов назад

    As an Irish fan I have to say I think Prendergast was very lucky to get away with yellow

  • @quinnsa27
    @quinnsa27 8 часов назад +1

    Prendergast is in the O'Gara/Sexton mould of not offering a running threat of his own. This is one reason I like Crowley, he offers Ireland a different dimension (Leinster fan btw)

  • @lizzyhanahoe4197
    @lizzyhanahoe4197 13 часов назад

    Tim, you don’t need Michael D Higgins (Ireland’s President) to show you stature difference when Craig Casey is there. MDH is 5’4”, CC 5’5”. You have to be very gutsy to play this game at that height surely?

    • @EggchasersRugby
      @EggchasersRugby  12 часов назад +1

      100%. The bravery of guys like Casey is next level!

    • @cateym
      @cateym 8 часов назад

      ​@@EggchasersRugbyScrappy Doo

  • @bernieob9577
    @bernieob9577 13 часов назад +2

    Really tim you don't know our president's name. Tut tut .

  • @ritchiebirnie6124
    @ritchiebirnie6124 11 часов назад +2

    She said short then knocked on