Tascam Portacapture X8 vs. Zoom and Roland recorders
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 май 2022
- I compare 5 different portable recorders. How does the new, expensive, Tascam Portacapture X8 stack up against the rest? Lets find out!
See these recorders on Amazon:
Tascam X8: amzn.to/3yl8FEW
Zoom H4N Pro: amzn.to/3MTzCUi
Zoom H5: amzn.to/3ykl9gf
Roland R07: amzn.to/3yqQvSj
Roland R26: (have to check Ebay for this)
Acoustic Guitar/singing - Forrest Kemper
(The Songman)
/ @thesongman4899
This is really a great video with effort, thank you very much!
~ Stereo XY no Processing
2:30 Roland R26
2:40 Roland R07
2:52 Tascam X8
3:04 Zoom H5
3:16 Zoom H4n Pro
~ Stereo XY with Processing
3:36 Tascam X8
3:49 Zoom H4n Pro
4:00 Roland R07
4:12 Roland R26
4:23 Zoom H5
~ XLR Input no Processing
4:44 Zoom H5
4:56 Tascam X8
5:06 Zoom H4n Pro
5:19 Roland R26
~ XLR Input with Processing
5:39 Roland R26
5:50 Tascam X8
6:01 Zoom H4n Pro
6:14 Zoom H5
~ Guitar sing, XY mic no Processing
6:47 Zoom H5
7:03 Zoom H4n Pro
7:20 Roland R26
7:35 Tascam X8
7:51 Roland R07
Thanks for the video. I used headphones to listen and ended up choosing the h4n and x8 every time but that could be because I actually own both of those units. Been using the X8 primarily since it came out. I also love my h1n and use that with a lav for most of the video on my channel.
The R26 still is up front in most of the scenarios what did Roland what the others did not? Great comparison thank you for sharing. It is so sad that the Roland I/O don't work anymore with the M1 series from Apple do anyone know if there's an update planned?
Roland R26 still the best for a voice.
Bro I was relaxing and really into the talking specs then BOOM!! "Yeah but how does it sound..." That got me haha Shoulda checked the channel name, SUBBED!
The best review I have ever seen.
I like the roland R-26 for voice but the Zoom H5 and Tascam x8 really captured a full sound of the guitar and vocal performance.
Solid video. Very helpful! Thank you. I would say the Roland is the weakest, however it's the most pocketable.
Very good job, excellent writing, and very Helpy process. Thank you and congratulation !
Questions::
1: Did'nt you think about comparing with the Sony PCM-D100 (whom Sony stoped manufacturing): more expensive but Mic and Preamps are a good comparition point.
2: What about quality of build and robustnes for everyday use ?
3: what about rumble sound when touching/manipulating X8 comparing to others ?
4: sensibility to wind hydrometry ?
Again many thanks for the nice work
Didn't have time to test all that. Wish I did. 😀
Roland 26 sounded pretty good when speaking.
Nice and funny review, thank you☺
Is it possible to simultaneously record sound to an SD card in 32 bit quality on the tascam device and record the sound of the camera on the smartphone when it is connected via usb c, when the smartphone automatically recognizes it?
Everytime I choosen 2x that sound the best that was a Tascam x8 & Roland x26 pair. Im no muscian and I have an untrained ear. I just like it bright & airy. This video reasured me that buying Tascam x8 a was good decision & I had fun in the meantime. :) Great quiz for my ears. Thanks!
Wybralem podobne jak ty😜😉
until it comes to the acoustic guitar and singing there I was without any doubt impressed from the Roland R26 it's such a great machine.
Tascam X8 is sounding good to me.. Good song and cool bike!
Yep, it does sound pretty good.
I want to record brass instruments: trombone. euphonium, tuba, or French horn. I will start with the on-board mics. which do suggest?
The guitar examples were interesting.
The Zoom H5 had a neutral sound, the Tascam x8 has prominent low frequency response, but it was the Roland R-07 that seem to capture the sound of the room, which to me, felt like a realistic representation of the recording!
It’s probably because the R-07 has omnidirectional mic capsules
Every video I’ve uploaded on my channel since 2014 was recorded with a Roland R-26. I’ve loved it personally
hello master, I need some advice, which recorder do you recommend to record live music directly from the mixer on which the band plays via rca cable?
Just need an adapter. Any but the small Roland would be fine. I'm partial to either the Zoom H5 or Tascam, myself.
Hi, thank you so much for this video!! I have a question, please? 🙂 I am a voice over artist, but looking to record in a more laidback way for making podcasts, whereby I don't have to sit at a desk. Which recorder to you think is best for bringing out the warmer and richer bass sounds of my voice, while at the same time not picking up every single 'S' or pop harshly? I like to be able to record close to the microphone like I am used to with "normal" microphones during voice overs to get a very warm and almost whispery sound, yet I don't like to have to edit out many unwanted "mouth sounds". Do you think any of these handheld recorders are good for this purpose? Thank you!
The tascam is the warmest by a little bit and would probably be the best of these for you. You will need a pop filter as well.
@@DarkStoneCastle thank you so much for this reply! That is very helpful, thank you. Have a lovely day
I Iistened at my best 5 times to the test with the XLR input. I found the same hum with each and every recorder. Could find no difference. If my ears are right, then the noise of your microphone drownes the noise of the pre amps of the mics. Or am i simply wrong, is there another explanation like a hum in the room?
When you taper yourself off benzos did you take a medication to help you with the withdrawal and what did you take. I'm am now tapering from Clonazepam. I'm not able to take other medication to help me with the withdrawal because I'm sensitive to these types of medication. Can I person successful come off these medication without a medication to help with the withdrawal
I used no extra medication when I weaned off benzos. If I had 2 really bad nights of virtually no sleep while weaning, I would bump the dosage up a little bit for one night before going back to where I left off with the taper.
Is Tascam X8 NOISE is good or bad? I can hear it :/
at a buffet, i personally sneak corndogs into the buffet so others can enjoy them. I hide 6 corndogs in my jacket pockets. it then, is a joy for me to see other patrons of the establishment eat my corndogs thinking they were part of the buffet.
Good poetry👍...I think you're a good songwriter too..😀
Thanks, 😁
It turns out, I always pick Zoom H5 and Tsacam X8, I am so used to with Zoom's warm sound. But X8 is quite a fieldlity.
The Zooms sound clearly better, and picks much more frequencies than the x8 which seems to sound like scooped n the mids, clearly
Not one person has recorded a band with the X8. This a bit dis-concerting ...I wonder why?
It's expensive and fairly new. Don't think a lot of people own an X8. Give it a few more months and you ought so see a video or two popping up on youtube of a band recording...I would think.
@@DarkStoneCastle Thanks :)
Dr Suess approves
LOVE the creepy vibes.
Nice poetry.
Thank you. 👍
@@DarkStoneCastle Did you notice Tascam X8 produces quite a bit of low frequency hum compared to other recorders? Thank you.
@@opheosmedia7809 No, I didn't notice anymore hum with X8 than any of the others.
Dr. Seuss would be proud!
Супер обзор
There is virtually no difference in the audio quality of these tests. This is especially true for the post-processed voice with separate mics. The X-Y mics offered similar sound quality also. I think that this test would be far better if two things were done:
1. Set each recorder individually to produce the best sound possible. Each of these recorders has a different array of settings that can dramatically change the sound. For example, the last test with the guitar and singer, each recorder needed the gain increased to better capture the guitar and vocals. Recording them at 6' simply tells us that all of them suck at the gain settings that were chosen for each recorder. We would learn much more if each recorder was correctly set up to record music and vocals according to their individual settings.
One example to illustrate this. I own the Tascam X8 and previously I owned the Zoom H8. If the mics on the Tascam are set in A-B configuration instead of X-Y, there is a considerable increase in recording quality. I write original songs and perform them. I was surprised at how much more "soundstage" and detail the Tascam X8 recorded when I used the attached mics in A-B configuration. Comparing it to the Zoom H8, the H8 did not pick up the sound of either the guitar or the vocals as well as the Tascam X8 at a distance of 2' - 3'. The Zoom H8 mics were far less sensitive.
A second critical example of this point is that the Tascam X8 can be set to record at 192 Htz and 32 bit sound quality. A good choice to check the music quality would be to record at 92 Htz at 24 bit audio. This is equivalent audio to high-quality streaming services like Tidal. At these settings, I am fairly certain that only the Zoom 4n, Zoom H5 and the Tascam X8 would remain in the competition, although I have no experience with the Roland recorders. In audio quality the Zoom H8 I did own and the Tascam X8 I currently own are very close to each other and I doubt that the human ear could detect much of a difference if both are properly set up. However, we MIGHT see a difference with complex music as described in Point #2 below recorded in ultra HD audio (92 Htz, 24 bit). This might flush out which of these audio recorders have the best amps and audio recorders.
2. It would be far more instructive to push these recorders to their limits, though I know that is not easy. For example, if each recorder was used to record a four-part string quartet or a full band, we would see much more differentiation in the quality of the recordings. As the recorders had to track a greater number of subtle and loud musical sounds, we might see which one is superior in audio recording.
That being said, this was a great video and interesting to watch. The Zoom H4n, H5 and H6 have been the gold standard for portable audio recording for a long time now but I think that the Tascam equals them or beats them based on my experience with the Zoom H8, which supposedly has better sound recording that its siblings.
Oh my lord, it's just a youtube video! Although I agree with the majority of the points you have made, this video is not intended for audio engineers. It is merely a simple run and gun comparison. Unfortunately, I have to work a full time job for now, so I don't have much time to do the extensive testing you recommend. (I wish I did...I really do) For instance, the acoustic guitar part at the end was done in 30 minutes on Mother's Day when I got together with my younger brother. Everything set up and recorded in 30 minutes. Lights, cameras, recorders, go!! Yes, the gain could have been a little higher but I had to avoid possible clipping and no time for a redo. But, going back to your first sentence... I think you pretty much summed it up. There's not a whole hell of a lot of difference. On a cell phone I can't even hear a difference. On high quality headphones, the Roland R26 stands out as being the most 'different' from the pack with the XY mics. Not necessarily better, but 'different'. Tascam seems to have a little fuller sound than the others but again...not necessarily 'better.' To each his own. I much prefer XY to AB, myself. That's just me, though. But I do appreciate your elaborate comment. I think that's the longest comment I've ever gotten on any video I've made. 😃😃😃😃
@@DarkStoneCastle Well your "just a RUclips video" doesn't really do much does it? It's my guess mediocrity is a specialty in your life.
@@franklong6269 🙄 Here we go...
@@DarkStoneCastle 😂there he is. The expert RUclips audio engineer has emerged to look down upon your creation. Now I will have to refer to this expert for my knowledge going forward........ Oh damn I looked, there's nothing on his channel. We can only study his knowledge here.
lol nice script