The North Indian has always found it difficult to digest the succees of the South !!! So never mind... Just come to kerala and we will show you our love of tolerance and the exposure we have compared to the north
@@prakkulmapillai Yeah, for you that has caste name etched in your name, being one of the saffron-clad trouser boys should help, Pillai. Keep rocking. Don't worry about Kerala -- we Keralites are more than equipped to handle ourselves. Also, I too love and respect the North Indians, especially the ones that migrated to Kerala to find jobs that pay at least thrice the money they get in their North Indian lands.
@ For your kind knowledge Pillai is not a caste . It’s a sir name . So, I understood how well versed you are about Kerala . I am a nair . A proud nair . Everybody has right like you put Joseph in your name if it’s true . Thank you
All are concerned about the malayalis leaving out side India... I and lakhs of malayalis left kerala and migrated to other states in India due to the extreme poverty and unemployment...it is irrespective of cast and religion... Today we are like Gypsies...no connections in kerala...We lost everything..
Sorry to hear, but one tends to take roots where one is. Given the propensity of Keralites to migrate, they will soon envelop you where you are. Don't give up, wish you success
@@LukoseJoseph007 I am not joking... I left kerala 1978 after completing my ITI..I went to almost all states for job. About 4 years I was working on daily wages..In a small room we all together lived..RSS...CPM...CONGRESS..CHRISTIAN...HINDU. We never fight each other... Supported each other...still we love ... I got a job in Indian Railway and retired as a senior section engineer..in mumbai.. MAHARASHTRA..AMCHI MUMBAI.. The world is not like you think... And also not I think. .
In the 1960’s Keralites were migrating to Persia, Malayasia and Srilanka! Those days Malaysia was known as Penang and Srilanka was known as Colombo..Well presented episode, Joe.💐
@@joe-metricview6035world war three is going on, Ukraine Russia war, middle east on fire, soon all nations have to pick one or the other side. Forget about the old days. After korona kutivep do you know how many people are dying? Maggie noodles pole raktam katta pedech erekne sadnam poost moortem chaiumbe porte docctor edekwa. You have no idea what mess the world is in.
It's because of red tapism by the Government in everything. It's very difficult to setup businesses, companies, acquire land in Kerala, hence, no company would want to setup business there, if there's no employment Youth will obviously move out, they used to go to Bangalore and other cities across India, later Gulf, now most of them are targeting western countries, they get IN via student VISA and never return while their ageing parents will be all alone in their lavish bungalows back in India, Kerala had severe fiscal deficit and things will only get worse as the Tax paying population is moving out
Feel proud in knowing and doing business with Mr Ramachandran, Choppies Botswana [3.41mark]. Wonderful human being. Despite his success in varied fields,he remains simple down to earth. What a gentleman
I am truly a fan of the positivity around you! Its nice that we are doing good. One of the motivating factors I feel is that we know that salaries in India will never match with what we get abroad.
The most spoken Indian language in UK is Bengali. 38 Durga pujas in New Jersey alone. Bengali was in top 3 most spoken Indian languages in US, now fourth after Hindi Gujarati and Telugu the recent entrant.
No buddy, this is pertinent. What he's trying to say is that Kerala is empty. Look around and all you'll find are mostly senior citizens or school kids. This state doesn't allow entreprise to flourish thanks to its residents who keep voting for the Left and Congress. Needless to say, the state is content with foreign remittances and doesn't want to develop and evolve. I've always had this theory that Kerala is the Germany of India minus the technological evolution. Sadly, this will continue for decades into the future unless the people develop a sense to progress. For the average keralite, progress means going abroad and getting a job and sending home money. The young generation of kerala only care about how much mayonnaise is provided with their Mandhi rice. Trust me, they actually don't care about pathetic roads, rampant student politics or lack of job opportunities. Ultimately they know that they have to leave this place and come back perhaps once a year and brag about the tranquility of this place. Yes, it's tranquil, but at the cost of a dying population.Fin.
Many Keralites have done well within the country too. That is something that isn't appreciated well enough. Analysts like Joe focus a bit too much on Malayalis abroad, probably because that's more glamorous. Malayalis within India have excelled in various fields and not just some limited fields like nursing in which Malayalis living abroad seem to thrive. I have lived most of my life in India and worked outside Kerala. Only foreign stints I had was when my employer sent me for short periods. That was good enough to get a boost in income. This has meant that I have kept a regular cultural contact with Kerala. With India poised to rise economically, the opportunities are right here for educated people which most Keralites are. Investment returns are also much higher in India. Malayalis must look within India before having this obsession to go abroad. Everyone who goes abroad isn't making it big. Joe's video has too much survivorship bias. Sometimes talk about those who didn't make it.
His videos also reek of bias against Hindus and favouritism towards christians. He has made countless videos against Modi and BJP’s policies but not a word about the italian Sonia and the devastating levels of corruption under her govt
He was born in kerala brought up in Houston n TN. His only connect with kerala is his birth place. his culture his ethos are all multicultural and influenced outside kerala. No offense, but keralites cant pick n choose based on who is successful n not.
Similar situation here in srilanka. Majority of eelam tamils have migrated to west . Other communities like sinhalese Buddhist, Indian orgin tamils are also migrating.
born and raised in Pune. She does not go chasing maloo onatomatopoeias like our host does. Met an Ex IPS officer who left the profession saying that the UPSC squad is utilized for opening doors for the ministers. The colonial imperialistic thought process needs a millennial X's axe to break down at the top while gen z is embracing it all and marching forward fearlessly.
@lailasiddiqui263 it seem like you have a hard time accepting Malayalee's are the best people in India by all metrics .. surnames and identity remains..
@@ShortsTV-p1p . They have made a few dents here and there,. But they are NOT the movers and shakers of society . Most are administrators , NOT entrepreneurs. _*I am sorry I will have to disagree with you*_, if you insist that they are the best people by all metric" - thats being very clannish.
Thank you. That was an important point I missed. In the 1950s, 60s and 70s there were many Keralites who went to African nations, including many teachers
@ My father and his 3 brothers were in Africa. I think they went in the 40s. My dad came back in 1955. Don’t know which year he went to Africa. Just my opinion it must have been early 40s or before.🙏
Keralites don't wait for jobs, they go towards jobs, that's why so many migrate. If the Kerala governments, both past and present had done something about it, this emigration could have been stopped. But the political parties are only interested in coming to power and making more and more money.
My senior developer used to travel a lot of countries . Once he travelled to south america he went to visit a dangerous ganga territory while he was walking through he saw a sign board "oonu ready" which means lunch ready in malayalam lol. He met a malayali guy over living with a family have a small restaurent in the middle of that gang territory lol. There is saying when niel amstrong landed the moon they had chai from a malayali tea shop over there😂
My great grand uncle migrated to Malay ( present Malaysia and Singapore ) in the early 1960s and another one went to Ceylon. Kerala geography is only good for early and retired life . Today kerala is the most costliest place in India with average manual labour wage INR1200 per day compared to 400 in Bengal or UP.
Really little more than making the best of a bad situation. The opportunity cost of moving abroad is real and felt very deeply, especially among the aged.
Your observation is always correct, with statistics and data. Unfortunately the Kerala State is lacking visionary, well educated and qualified leaders.
The vision of great leaders is the reason why any normal Keralites are qualified to travel anywhere. Thanks to an education system that allowed me-and countless others-to complete 10+2+3+2 years of education without incurring a single rupee in tuition, I can stand shoulder to shoulder with people from any background. This speaks volumes about the quality and inclusivity of the education we receive here. Unlike the Gujjus dunki migrants, Mallus don't have to wait at Canadian and Mexican borders to get shot at or be frozen to death midway infiltrating another country. In a state that was at the time of Independence, one of the poorest states with a literacy rate of under 50%, we have come a long way. Who do you call a good leader, if not the people that have led this dramatic change? We've had plenty of exceptional leaders, and we still have.
@@LukoseJoseph007this is the fact … but these idiots think those Gujjus frozen to death are the successful model .. joemetric, ithu pole oru pittan vere illa 😝😝😝
Kerala lacks the ability to influence the nation and bring together the resources to develop thos state. All the money is from outside the state and thats we see people have built big houses and own big estates but the roads are in poor condition. People developed but state didnt. Reality is we lack something.
I moved to the U.S. in 1969 and never looked back. However, i spend 6 months annually in india because i love Kerala with all my heart. I only wish Keralites would allow new industries and tourism to flourish. Instead, they do everything to fight them. It is outrageous and disappointing that sundry items are imported from China, instead of being created by local talent and industries. They do manufacture gheraos, disruption, and protests. While other states and nations progress, Kerala and India stagnate in these aspects. Karma is always around the corner. I hate to be the Devil's Advocate. When will they ever learn? I guess, never. Hence, the brain drain.
There is a recap of the Armstrong story.....he actually met a Sardar making Nan on the moon who told him that he took over from a Malayali who had hence proceeded to Pluto to check out business prospects.....😂😂😂.
@@tdharan2991 true despite huge houses one can only imagine what they had to endure in places like middle east where workers rights are non existent to build a lifestyle in Kerala that becomes a source of envy for neighbors
I heard some positive news from you about us. Keep it up when everyone else only promote bad news, negative reports, slandering talks.. am an NRI people says am successful, we all have issues, but let’s spread peace and harmony, positive news. So that others get inspired and changed. Few years back I visited Georgia and went to a remote skee trip at Gadovi mountain top. When we reached at peak we were approached by two young boys to our surprise- “sir, chai..coffee? Choodu vada sambar? Parotta?”. It’s pleasant and shocking to our family at that icy mountain.
Kerala's government has yet to establish a practical system to regulate the influx of people from other states, making it an open destination for those seeking entry. In contrast, Western countries are proactively implementing legal and practical reforms to manage incoming individuals.
Drive through villages of Central and Southern Kerala you would be hard pressed to find anyone in age group 18-50. Earlier gulf migrants came back after retirement or after their contract ended. Today a whole generation is leaving for Canada, UK, Australia, US and EU and have no plans to return. In my family I am the only one staying in India
@@joe-metricview6035 my brother migrated in 2016, cousin in 2015, 2 more cousins in 2018. In my age group iam the only one left in India but even iam contemplating moving out
USA gave the first 100 visas to Indians in 1966. And then they increased the numbers, because India had a large population that could ably be used in the US and they send out the visas and the very qualified Indians who would not get jobs in India came - especially those who were qualified in ISI's , IITs etc. We know 3 of them who came in 1969. One is the very famous guy Raghu who got the fields medal in Math
Pls call spade a spade and share the hard facts of the agonies and disillusionment of these students going abroad. You have a social responsibility towards that rather than showcasing the success stories.
Those who migrated 70s and before. For them Kerala is just like any other part of India. So they wont come back and their kids don't know to read and write Malayalam and those who migrated are now in their last stage of life or alredy died and their grand kids struggle even to speak Malayalam so those guys will lose their malayali identity within 20 years. Those who migrated in 80s and 90s majority will come back except those who are highly settled and those who got citizenship. For them Kerala is an okayish state. Those migrated after 2000 will mostly comeback after their aspirations. Because Kerala right now is comparatively better state to live in India. Thanks to the great leaders we have in past and present times. If nothing happens to our foreign remittance and simultaneously we should focus on the development of micro manufacturing units accross the state along with continue the growth of service sector and if we don't face any major distasters or wars in next twenty or thirty years i think we will continue to thrive do better as society. Finger crossed 🤞 We can proudly say that not even single Malayalam speaking family lies on roads or streets who others can say like that.❤ Happy Kerala piravi all❤ ഇന്ത്യയുടെ തെക്കേ അറ്റത്ത് സ്വർഗം പോലെ ഉള്ള സ്ഥലം ഉണ്ട് മാലാഖമാരെ പോലെ ഉള്ള മനുഷ്യർ ഉണ്ട്. പൊതു പരിസരം വൃത്തി ആയും ഭംഗി ആയും സൂക്ഷിക്കുക. രാഷ്ട്രീയം പറഞ്ഞു കൊണ്ടേ ഇരിക്കുക. വർഗീയത പ്രചരിപ്പിക്കാതെ ഇരിക്കുക. പണി എടുക്കുക പണി ഉണ്ടാക്കുക. കഴിയുന്ന പോലെ മറ്റുള്ളവരെ സഹായിക്കുക. സ്നേഹം കൊണ്ട് ലോകം കീഴടക്കുക❤
I agree. My dad moved out from Kerala in 1965. My grandfathers sisters moved out in 1947. and 2 others followed in 1951. We are happy where we are. The next generation like us have mixed marriages and next next generations are getting into mixed marriages. So we have lost the language but come back to Kerala for the beautiful screens. Everything is a frame
But now the condition is are gloomy, no jobs for youth, party goons wil never allow small scale entrepreneurs to prosper.. I wrk in govt job, no proper hike in wages, feels stagnant
@@sree716 Kerala is a state very resigned, retired . it is a state that is dead in terms of economy, but nothing actively promoted. There are no priorities or goals set up by the state.
@@sree716 1. no job for educated youth. That's true. I work in North India right now. Conditions are same here also. Migrate or do business are better idea right now. At least Kerala government is in top in PSC placements comparing to other states. 2. Party goons are now became a myth Kerala is the best state to start MSMEs. First in neethi aayog this year. 3. I think you're a contract employee if you're a permanent employee then you are one of the luckiest guy in the state. Be grateful
@@joe-metricview6035really? 1000s of Britishers “migrated” to Australia, the US. But does it make Britain inferior in any way? People migrate, everywhere, in search of what they “think” is best for them. Some make it, some do not. It’s true for those who are happy with their home too.
It does. Older people are lonely and mass migration from backward states will change landscape of Kerala. Guess which state people commit most crimes in Kerala
Politics has become a dirty word because of the attitude of the Malayalee politicians. I hope they don't bring the same mindset to other countries where they are elected.
Why do you want to stop those who are going ? Let them all go.. Atleast the rest of us can live peacefully in Kerala.. less traffic. All those that went to Canada are already fed up with the high rent, homelessness and living on the sidewalk.. 😂😂😂 PS - I live in Middle East myself.
That will be a far fetched dream. Nowadays companies in Kerala are hiring north indians and even those who live right next to these companies are not able to get jobs there. Kerala workers are generally cleaner and the same can't be said for pan gutka chewing workers from outside. We will have to practice obstacle courses to navigate roads full of paan and spit like we have to do in other states.
@@monishthomasp and the government is treating migrant workers like royals and giving them quality education and healthcare along with replacing malayalam with hindi boards. So they're settling there with dozen children who all will be eligible to enter state government jobs. Once they do, they'll give preference to their kind like it's already happening in Central government jobs. One can only imagine what will happen when these pan gutka chewers take over Kerala.
Kerala state is mostly covered by western ghats, so it has less land for cultivation and industries. So people started migrating to other places. Keralites have inborn wisdom and thirst for hard work. Many a I A S officers are from Kerala. Some of them have made lasting legacy in our country's economic and foreign policy . V. K. Krishna Menon is one of them..
LIFE ADVICE: Leave kerala, settle anywhere except Kerala. Its not about Job. Its just about ur generations will thank you for the steps u are taking now.. in next 10 Dacades also Kerala will never develop. Same politics, strikes, unemployment, same dirty roads, no welcoming business projects (take Kitex as example) ..,.. etc etc.. Migrate n save urself
Raj Subramaniam Fedex is a Tamil Saiva Vellalar Pillai and not Mallu from TVM. Likewise, a dozen of other popular people from Kerala such as Vidhya Balan, Singer Hariharan, Infy Krish Gopalakrishnan, Vivek Ramaswamy, TN Shesan, TS Kalyanraman, JC Daniel the father of Mal cinema are all Tamils ,mostly Tamil Brahmins. Interestingly the Travancore rulers themselves claimed descent of Tamil Chola kings and as Tamils
Sad to say but, such a beautiful place like Kerala where foreigners would pay 1000's of dollars to visit and stay is governed by a bunch of corrupt, illiterate, foolish ministers. They don't know that Kerala is like a Jewel. Most educated people but, without proper infrastructure and opportunities will only want to leave Kerala. The minimum basic requirements are hard to achieve. Such attitude from govt officials and locals will never let this land prosper. Sometimes I wish if the we were governed like Singapore, we would be like the "Jewel on the necklace" worn by our Mother Earth.
I have seen a lot of videos from you, basically scaremongering on what has happened and continues to happen about economic migration. This economic migration is not limited to Kerala ..it is happenign all over the world..rural and semi urban areas are vanishing faster than expected, due to multiple factors. If you really wish to see Kerala flourishs , spread some positivity at some point. A lot of Industrial, IT and Infra development has happened in the recent past and encourage youth to stay in the state or country rather than migrating to do care home jobs. Do some good to the society. Maybe the target audience might not be happy with it.
You are not highlighting why keralites are moving out of Kerala You are showcasing everyone who moved out as yusuf ali What about the millions of keralites doing labor jobs in gulf? You are missing the point for the reason why there is unemployment in Kerala Highlight why keralites are moving out but people from other states have jobs in their own land I think Keralites have no self respect.. hence they go begging for jobs in other states No jobs , no industry, no roads in Kerala Highlight these points too
@joe-metricview6035 they l realise, going to west is not like going to gulf. They won't get PR. Once they return, they l break back of trade unionists (like how one film star fan was neutralized). And then, naadu nannavum. End of vigadan vaad, Badal Rekha 🙅♀️. Howzzat umpire ?
In Hindi there is a saying that Dogs dont have the ability to digest Desi ghee. Most of Kerala society suffers from that syndrome. Prior to outward migration Mallus where scattered all over India, escaping poverty in Kerala. The same people when they became somewhat stable, they started boasting about theirr pedigree, everyone was claiming that he has Nallukettu in his ancestral land . The kerala society is a remiitance based society full of pomp and false ego. It is not self sufficient in food production, if mallus make a course correction then only they can survive, if they continue the show off culture , thinking that they r the superior people, it will be no good for them. A bit of humility and humbleness will do no harm
@abiisaac: By attitude, Mallus are way more arrogant than the Gujjus. Atleast Gujjus have something to be proud about their state, what does kerala have other than these 3 - lottery, liquor, tourism ?
@@third3eye26 Mallus: Kerala no. 1 Also Mallu abroad: Saar, give me job saar. I do all job, i don't want to go back to kerala. I will be ur slave. Mallus bragging about Kerala is like someone bragging about a house made of straw which can be blown away in a storm.
As a Keralite I agree with your observation. I have seen many malayalis belittle people from other states .. why the treatment we give to our labourers from other states is proof enough .. if everything is so no 1 here then why are people migrating? That’s a question most malayalis will not give you a straight answer for
Just wondering is this exodus needs to be celebrated or are we digging our own graves. The latter seems more probable. If only our idiotic politicos u'stood d ramification of talent outflow!!
Now we keralites feel the loss of our great kingdom Travancore the legacy of united Kerala Travancore Cochin and Malabar…. In present being downtrodden under Indian colonization and infiltrations we have to move to a better territory not for us but for our forthcoming generations …. Lest there won’t be anymore Keralites there will only be Indians living in Kerala. In fact we keralites lost our motherland United Kerala 😢😮😢
My great grand uncle migrated to Malay ( present Malaysia and Singapore ) in the early 1960s and another one went to Ceylon. Kerala geography is only good for early and retired life . Today kerala is the most costliest place in India with average manual labour wage INR1200 per day compared to 400 in Bengal or UP.
Famous saying Keralites are the laziest in kerala and most hard working outside
😮
Every success story of a Keralite outside the state reinforces that saying
What else can Kerlaites do when filthy Commies stand in the way of progress and prevent malayalees from progressing in life?
@@majok4898 The Laziness is caused by the tropical climate. Its called "chilled out"!. I
Keralites are treated like shit in Kerala. So when they runaway from Kerala, they have respect to everything outside their state.
The North Indian has always found it difficult to digest the succees of the South !!! So never mind... Just come to kerala and we will show you our love of tolerance and the exposure we have compared to the north
Grow up dude . I am a malayalee and I love North Indian brothers . Don’t tarnish the name of Kerala and don’t think malayalees are like you .
@@prakkulmapillaidont stay a fool in the name of nationalism. There nationalism is limited to godly worship. Go and check the numbers
@@prakkulmapillai Yeah, for you that has caste name etched in your name, being one of the saffron-clad trouser boys should help, Pillai. Keep rocking. Don't worry about Kerala -- we Keralites are more than equipped to handle ourselves. Also, I too love and respect the North Indians, especially the ones that migrated to Kerala to find jobs that pay at least thrice the money they get in their North Indian lands.
@ For your kind knowledge Pillai is not a caste . It’s a sir name . So, I understood how well versed you are about Kerala . I am a nair . A proud nair . Everybody has right like you put Joseph in your name if it’s true . Thank you
Onnu pode....Malayalis oru mayirum alla....Indians aanu best.
All are concerned about the malayalis leaving out side India...
I and lakhs of malayalis left kerala and migrated to other states in India due to the extreme poverty and unemployment...it is irrespective of cast and religion...
Today we are like Gypsies...no connections in kerala...We lost everything..
Sorry to hear, but one tends to take roots where one is. Given the propensity of Keralites to migrate, they will soon envelop you where you are. Don't give up, wish you success
@@johnabraham6402 Which is the Indian paradise state that you left to? I wanna escape extreme poverty and unemployment. 😭
@@johnabraham6402
This really is an eye opener, leaving Kerala and still being in India. Anywhere you go India or abroad we guys have done well.👍
@@LukoseJoseph007 I am not joking...
I left kerala 1978 after completing my ITI..I went to almost all states for job.
About 4 years I was working on daily wages..In a small room we all together lived..RSS...CPM...CONGRESS..CHRISTIAN...HINDU. We never fight each other...
Supported each other...still we love ...
I got a job in Indian Railway and retired as a senior section engineer..in mumbai..
MAHARASHTRA..AMCHI MUMBAI..
The world is not like you think...
And also not I think.
.
@@johnabraham6402 so you did well.
In the 1960’s Keralites were migrating to Persia, Malayasia and Srilanka! Those days Malaysia was known as Penang and Srilanka was known as Colombo..Well presented episode, Joe.💐
Sri Lanka known as cylon
Yes, to Sri Lanka, too
That's right -- Ceylon
@@joe-metricview6035world war three is going on, Ukraine Russia war, middle east on fire, soon all nations have to pick one or the other side. Forget about the old days. After korona kutivep do you know how many people are dying? Maggie noodles pole raktam katta pedech erekne sadnam poost moortem chaiumbe porte docctor edekwa. You have no idea what mess the world is in.
70s and 80's to US. Nurses and academic professionals
Keralites so intelligent and educated.big salute jerala
Joe .. you missed Pamela Radhakrishnan from North Paravoor who was elected to New Zealand Parliament five years ago.
Thank you, Ramesh. Was only talking about recent achievers
Her name was Priyanka Radhakrishnan. She was a minister in New Zealand between May 2020 and November 2023.
It's because of red tapism by the Government in everything. It's very difficult to setup businesses, companies, acquire land in Kerala, hence, no company would want to setup business there, if there's no employment Youth will obviously move out, they used to go to Bangalore and other cities across India, later Gulf, now most of them are targeting western countries, they get IN via student VISA and never return while their ageing parents will be all alone in their lavish bungalows back in India, Kerala had severe fiscal deficit and things will only get worse as the Tax paying population is moving out
You said it
Feel proud in knowing and doing business with Mr Ramachandran, Choppies Botswana [3.41mark]. Wonderful human being. Despite his success in varied fields,he remains simple down to earth. What a gentleman
Thank you
I heard appreciative opinion about him from Singapore, too
Atlas Ramachandran, who introduced rate tag for all jewellery
He was also the mastermind of Dubai Grand shopping festival
I am truly a fan of the positivity around you! Its nice that we are doing good. One of the motivating factors I feel is that we know that salaries in India will never match with what we get abroad.
Sweet of you 😌
Important point you said on the salary front
My salary 600000 per month with all other facility I was in Mumbai 1990 to 1998 but no any saving
It's not just Keralites. We are so self centered. Punjabis, Telugus, Tamilians Gujaratis have similar or bigger diasporas.
We need to think first about our community our country
Kerala and Keralites accordingly we should also think about others in the next lap that’s
Thats what, mallus r obsessed about mallus. We are this we are that. Rubbish.
The most spoken Indian language in UK is Bengali. 38 Durga pujas in New Jersey alone. Bengali was in top 3 most spoken Indian languages in US, now fourth after Hindi Gujarati and Telugu the recent entrant.
No buddy, this is pertinent. What he's trying to say is that Kerala is empty. Look around and all you'll find are mostly senior citizens or school kids. This state doesn't allow entreprise to flourish thanks to its residents who keep voting for the Left and Congress. Needless to say, the state is content with foreign remittances and doesn't want to develop and evolve. I've always had this theory that Kerala is the Germany of India minus the technological evolution. Sadly, this will continue for decades into the future unless the people develop a sense to progress. For the average keralite, progress means going abroad and getting a job and sending home money. The young generation of kerala only care about how much mayonnaise is provided with their Mandhi rice. Trust me, they actually don't care about pathetic roads, rampant student politics or lack of job opportunities. Ultimately they know that they have to leave this place and come back perhaps once a year and brag about the tranquility of this place. Yes, it's tranquil, but at the cost of a dying population.Fin.
Many Keralites have done well within the country too. That is something that isn't appreciated well enough. Analysts like Joe focus a bit too much on Malayalis abroad, probably because that's more glamorous. Malayalis within India have excelled in various fields and not just some limited fields like nursing in which Malayalis living abroad seem to thrive.
I have lived most of my life in India and worked outside Kerala. Only foreign stints I had was when my employer sent me for short periods. That was good enough to get a boost in income. This has meant that I have kept a regular cultural contact with Kerala. With India poised to rise economically, the opportunities are right here for educated people which most Keralites are. Investment returns are also much higher in India. Malayalis must look within India before having this obsession to go abroad. Everyone who goes abroad isn't making it big. Joe's video has too much survivorship bias. Sometimes talk about those who didn't make it.
If Pakistan becomes a rich country because of it's oil and gas discovery (if true), Keralites would be desperate to go there also.
Well said 👏
@@arjunps6776
Going to other states (of India)
His videos also reek of bias against Hindus and favouritism towards christians. He has made countless videos against Modi and BJP’s policies but not a word about the italian Sonia and the devastating levels of corruption under her govt
.. and ‘Hanumankind’, Sooraj Cherukattu 😊
Yes, forgot to include him
He was born in kerala brought up in Houston n TN. His only connect with kerala is his birth place. his culture his ethos are all multicultural and influenced outside kerala. No offense, but keralites cant pick n choose based on who is successful n not.
Similar situation here in srilanka. Majority of eelam tamils have migrated to west . Other communities like sinhalese Buddhist, Indian orgin tamils are also migrating.
Thank you for commenting
Demography changing with Chettiar, rajasthanis, settling for business,with increased Muslim population
Leena Nair - CEO of Chanel .
born and raised in Pune. She does not go chasing maloo onatomatopoeias like our host does. Met an Ex IPS officer who left the profession saying that the UPSC squad is utilized for opening doors for the ministers. The colonial imperialistic thought process needs a millennial X's axe to break down at the top while gen z is embracing it all and marching forward fearlessly.
@lailasiddiqui263 it seem like you have a hard time accepting Malayalee's are the best people in India by all metrics .. surnames and identity remains..
@@ShortsTV-p1p . They have made a few dents here and there,. But they are NOT the movers and shakers of society . Most are administrators , NOT entrepreneurs. _*I am sorry I will have to disagree with you*_, if you insist that they are the best people by all metric" - thats being very clannish.
There were many who went to African countries in the 50s. It is just a note. Good video and great job done.
Thank you. That was an important point I missed. In the 1950s, 60s and 70s there were many Keralites who went to African nations, including many teachers
@
My father and his 3 brothers were in Africa. I think they went in the 40s. My dad came back in 1955. Don’t know which year he went to Africa. Just my opinion it must have been early 40s or before.🙏
@@joe-metricview6035
Joe is a forum or group of RUclipsr creators who can meet up so that new insights can be shared.
@@joe-metricview6035Which African countries do they like to go to?
Next they will go to East Asia and Latin America.
Very interesting episode. Sharing with my friends
Thank you so much
Keralites don't wait for jobs, they go towards jobs, that's why so many migrate. If the Kerala governments, both past and present had done something about it, this emigration could have been stopped. But the political parties are only interested in coming to power and making more and more money.
They go towards jobs... interesting
while marwaris, Sindhis, gujurathis, parsis create jobs
Well presented dear Joe....articulate indeed
Thank you, Francis
My senior developer used to travel a lot of countries . Once he travelled to south america he went to visit a dangerous ganga territory while he was walking through he saw a sign board "oonu ready" which means lunch ready in malayalam lol. He met a malayali guy over living with a family have a small restaurent in the middle of that gang territory lol. There is saying when niel amstrong landed the moon they had chai from a malayali tea shop over there😂
Interesting info from LatAm 😊
. Excellent presentation, Joe❤
Thank you, Noble
My great grand uncle migrated to Malay ( present Malaysia and Singapore ) in the early 1960s and another one went to Ceylon. Kerala geography is only good for early and retired life . Today kerala is the most costliest place in India with average manual labour wage INR1200 per day compared to 400 in Bengal or UP.
Kerala good for early and retired life. Interesting observation
Really little more than making the best of a bad situation. The opportunity cost of moving abroad is real and felt very deeply, especially among the aged.
Yes, migration doesn't come without its price and seniors may pay more
Your observation is always correct, with statistics and data.
Unfortunately the Kerala State is lacking visionary, well educated and qualified leaders.
The vision of great leaders is the reason why any normal Keralites are qualified to travel anywhere. Thanks to an education system that allowed me-and countless others-to complete 10+2+3+2 years of education without incurring a single rupee in tuition, I can stand shoulder to shoulder with people from any background. This speaks volumes about the quality and inclusivity of the education we receive here. Unlike the Gujjus dunki migrants, Mallus don't have to wait at Canadian and Mexican borders to get shot at or be frozen to death midway infiltrating another country. In a state that was at the time of Independence, one of the poorest states with a literacy rate of under 50%, we have come a long way. Who do you call a good leader, if not the people that have led this dramatic change? We've had plenty of exceptional leaders, and we still have.
Interesting viewpoint
Thank you
@@LukoseJoseph007this is the fact … but these idiots think those Gujjus frozen to death are the successful model .. joemetric, ithu pole oru pittan vere illa 😝😝😝
Kerala lacks the ability to influence the nation and bring together the resources to develop thos state. All the money is from outside the state and thats we see people have built big houses and own big estates but the roads are in poor condition. People developed but state didnt. Reality is we lack something.
I moved to the U.S. in 1969 and never looked back. However, i spend 6 months annually in india because i love Kerala with all my heart.
I only wish Keralites would allow new industries and tourism to flourish. Instead, they do everything to fight them. It is outrageous and disappointing that sundry items are imported from China, instead of being created by local talent and industries. They do manufacture gheraos, disruption, and protests. While other states and nations progress, Kerala and India stagnate in these aspects. Karma is always around the corner. I hate to be the Devil's Advocate.
When will they ever learn? I guess, never. Hence, the brain drain.
Welcome home every year!
Great 👍
Thank you
Educationist- Siddique Kadambot, Director, The University of Western Australia
Thank you for the input
There is a recap of the Armstrong story.....he actually met a Sardar making Nan on the moon who told him that he took over from a Malayali who had hence proceeded to Pluto to check out business prospects.....😂😂😂.
😊
😂
You missed Google cloud CEO and oracle cofounder, brother NetApp CEO
I was talking about the latest achievers, therefore. But thank you for pointing that out.
Wow yes yes even today many nurses are from Kerala
Yes, nurses hold forth the Brand Kerala flag in many places across the world
The reality is that most malayalys dont want to go abroad.
And an irony that they do, going against their heart's desire
No one will stay in a place with no future.
@@SathyaswamyS Very true.
@@joe-metricview6035 My dad never wanted to return. Even the relatives who have not left kerala become very indignant. so why return.
@@tdharan2991 true despite huge houses one can only imagine what they had to endure in places like middle east where workers rights are non existent to build a lifestyle in Kerala that becomes a source of envy for neighbors
How about rapper Hanumankind? Its a global hit even in top hit charts in the USA
Good one
Let me admit, I forgot
Migration is a phenomenal from all over india. This is due to our population
Keralites always vote with their legs. My father did that in 1967. He never went back after retirement.
Thank you for commenting
Yes, many choose to locate in the places they migrated to
I heard some positive news from you about us. Keep it up when everyone else only promote bad news, negative reports, slandering talks.. am an NRI people says am successful, we all have issues, but let’s spread peace and harmony, positive news. So that others get inspired and changed.
Few years back I visited Georgia and went to a remote skee trip at Gadovi mountain top. When we reached at peak we were approached by two young boys to our surprise- “sir, chai..coffee? Choodu vada sambar? Parotta?”. It’s pleasant and shocking to our family at that icy mountain.
Thank you
Interesting anecdote from Gadovi 😊
Kerala's government has yet to establish a practical system to regulate the influx of people from other states, making it an open destination for those seeking entry. In contrast, Western countries are proactively implementing legal and practical reforms to manage incoming individuals.
We are a state; cannot be compared to countries that put up barriers for migrants
Demographic shift can cause social tensions akin to other areas where such things happen/ happened
🎉🎉
Thank you
You don't worry, people will migrate, through out the world, because Kerala is number one
😊
I think his guy lives alone in Kerala 😝😝😝
No
Drive through villages of Central and Southern Kerala you would be hard pressed to find anyone in age group 18-50. Earlier gulf migrants came back after retirement or after their contract ended. Today a whole generation is leaving for Canada, UK, Australia, US and EU and have no plans to return. In my family I am the only one staying in India
First sentence captures the mood 👌
@@joe-metricview6035 my brother migrated in 2016, cousin in 2015, 2 more cousins in 2018. In my age group iam the only one left in India but even iam contemplating moving out
Could you do the history of first malayalies in USA?
Will try
USA gave the first 100 visas to Indians in 1966. And then they increased the numbers, because India had a large population that could ably be used in the US and they send out the visas and the very qualified Indians who would not get jobs in India came - especially those who were qualified in ISI's , IITs etc. We know 3 of them who came in 1969. One is the very famous guy Raghu who got the fields medal in Math
Pls call spade a spade and share the hard facts of the agonies and disillusionment of these students going abroad. You have a social responsibility towards that rather than showcasing the success stories.
Thank you for commenting
Interesting information about malayalee people
Thank you 😊
There are many keralites doing well in foreign countries.
Yes
The ones who went abroad through their hardwork and merit earned the jobs and positions they deserved.Would it have been possible here???
That's an important point. Kerala has to be a meritorious society. Sadly, backdoor appointments are the norm now, dispiriting youth
Encouraging
Thank you
Haven't watched video....hey I am here in Saudi 😅
Thank you for the advance comment before watching
Those who migrated 70s and before. For them Kerala is just like any other part of India. So they wont come back and their kids don't know to read and write Malayalam and those who migrated are now in their last stage of life or alredy died and their grand kids struggle even to speak Malayalam so those guys will lose their malayali identity within 20 years.
Those who migrated in 80s and 90s majority will come back except those who are highly settled and those who got citizenship. For them Kerala is an okayish state.
Those migrated after 2000 will mostly comeback after their aspirations. Because Kerala right now is comparatively better state to live in India.
Thanks to the great leaders we have in past and present times.
If nothing happens to our foreign remittance and simultaneously we should focus on the development of micro manufacturing units accross the state along with continue the growth of service sector and if we don't face any major distasters or wars in next twenty or thirty years i think we will continue to thrive do better as society. Finger crossed 🤞
We can proudly say that not even single Malayalam speaking family lies on roads or streets who others can say like that.❤
Happy Kerala piravi all❤
ഇന്ത്യയുടെ തെക്കേ അറ്റത്ത് സ്വർഗം പോലെ ഉള്ള സ്ഥലം ഉണ്ട് മാലാഖമാരെ പോലെ ഉള്ള മനുഷ്യർ ഉണ്ട്.
പൊതു പരിസരം വൃത്തി ആയും ഭംഗി ആയും സൂക്ഷിക്കുക.
രാഷ്ട്രീയം പറഞ്ഞു കൊണ്ടേ ഇരിക്കുക.
വർഗീയത പ്രചരിപ്പിക്കാതെ ഇരിക്കുക.
പണി എടുക്കുക പണി ഉണ്ടാക്കുക. കഴിയുന്ന പോലെ മറ്റുള്ളവരെ സഹായിക്കുക.
സ്നേഹം കൊണ്ട് ലോകം കീഴടക്കുക❤
Thank you for the detailed response, highlighting multiple points
I agree. My dad moved out from Kerala in 1965. My grandfathers sisters moved out in 1947. and 2 others followed in 1951. We are happy where we are. The next generation like us have mixed marriages and next next generations are getting into mixed marriages. So we have lost the language but come back to Kerala for the beautiful screens. Everything is a frame
But now the condition is are gloomy, no jobs for youth, party goons wil never allow small scale entrepreneurs to prosper.. I wrk in govt job, no proper hike in wages, feels stagnant
@@sree716 Kerala is a state very resigned, retired . it is a state that is dead in terms of economy, but nothing actively promoted. There are no priorities or goals set up by the state.
@@sree716 1. no job for educated youth. That's true. I work in North India right now. Conditions are same here also. Migrate or do business are better idea right now. At least Kerala government is in top in PSC placements comparing to other states.
2. Party goons are now became a myth Kerala is the best state to start MSMEs. First in neethi aayog this year.
3. I think you're a contract employee if you're a permanent employee then you are one of the luckiest guy in the state. Be grateful
As usual. With such huge number of youth migrating, won't it affect the state?
Large numbers of people migrating out obviously does not speak well of a place
N o
@@joe-metricview6035really? 1000s of Britishers “migrated” to Australia, the US. But does it make Britain inferior in any way? People migrate, everywhere, in search of what they “think” is best for them. Some make it, some do not. It’s true for those who are happy with their home too.
It does. Older people are lonely and mass migration from backward states will change landscape of Kerala. Guess which state people commit most crimes in Kerala
How are the students who reached Canada doing today? Next episode.
Thank you for the suggestion
Politics has become a dirty word because of the attitude of the Malayalee politicians. I hope they don't bring the same mindset to other countries where they are elected.
If you go to moon you can see a malayali
All states have same thing happening
At a time when we are supposedly on course to becoming developed country
Why do you want to stop those who are going ? Let them all go.. Atleast the rest of us can live peacefully in Kerala.. less traffic. All those that went to Canada are already fed up with the high rent, homelessness and living on the sidewalk.. 😂😂😂
PS - I live in Middle East myself.
No one's stopping them; that's why they are in Canada and Middle East
@ No need to stop. Please encourage.. 😀
That will be a far fetched dream. Nowadays companies in Kerala are hiring north indians and even those who live right next to these companies are not able to get jobs there.
Kerala workers are generally cleaner and the same can't be said for pan gutka chewing workers from outside. We will have to practice obstacle courses to navigate roads full of paan and spit like we have to do in other states.
@@sgsan705 This is a genuine problem but yes I feel our municipality cleaning services are far more efficient compared to the North.. 😀
@@monishthomasp and the government is treating migrant workers like royals and giving them quality education and healthcare along with replacing malayalam with hindi boards. So they're settling there with dozen children who all will be eligible to enter state government jobs. Once they do, they'll give preference to their kind like it's already happening in Central government jobs. One can only imagine what will happen when these pan gutka chewers take over Kerala.
Nobody is thinking about Kerala residents, trying hard to reach a stage.
Where have all the keralites gone?long time citizening.
😊
Everyone is migrating. All odia people are in bngle. All telugu people are in bangalore or in US. Same with many other states
That's an irony for the world's fastest growing large economy
Kerala state is mostly covered by western ghats, so it has less land for cultivation and industries. So people started migrating to other places. Keralites have inborn wisdom and thirst for hard work. Many a I A S officers are from Kerala. Some of them have made lasting legacy in our country's economic and foreign policy . V. K. Krishna Menon is one of them..
Good points 👍
It has less industries because of communist shit show
Kerala has no better job opportunities even good colleges for higher studies. Or professional courses.
LIFE ADVICE: Leave kerala, settle anywhere except Kerala.
Its not about Job.
Its just about ur generations will thank you for the steps u are taking now.. in next 10 Dacades also Kerala will never develop.
Same politics, strikes, unemployment, same dirty roads, no welcoming business projects (take Kitex as example) ..,.. etc etc..
Migrate n save urself
There are many who think so, which explains such a mass migration
Is it really so many malayalees living in Western Countries than Gulf..?
only because they get a paltry sum in Kerala and their puffed ego do not allow them to take all roles
Raj Subramaniam Fedex is a Tamil Saiva Vellalar Pillai and not Mallu from TVM. Likewise, a dozen of other popular people from Kerala such as Vidhya Balan, Singer Hariharan, Infy Krish Gopalakrishnan, Vivek Ramaswamy, TN Shesan, TS Kalyanraman, JC Daniel the father of Mal cinema are all Tamils ,mostly Tamil Brahmins. Interestingly the Travancore rulers themselves claimed descent of Tamil Chola kings and as Tamils
JC Daniel is tamil brahmin 😂😂😂😂
And when NRI's will return after decades finding bengawlees as their neabours, how is that 😊
If they return, that is
Sad to say but, such a beautiful place like Kerala where foreigners would pay 1000's of dollars to visit and stay is governed by a bunch of corrupt, illiterate, foolish ministers. They don't know that Kerala is like a Jewel. Most educated people but, without proper infrastructure and opportunities will only want to leave Kerala. The minimum basic requirements are hard to achieve.
Such attitude from govt officials and locals will never let this land prosper.
Sometimes I wish if the we were governed like Singapore, we would be like the "Jewel on the necklace" worn by our Mother Earth.
A jewel whose value isn't tapped. Well said
I have seen a lot of videos from you, basically scaremongering on what has happened and continues to happen about economic migration. This economic migration is not limited to Kerala ..it is happenign all over the world..rural and semi urban areas are vanishing faster than expected, due to multiple factors.
If you really wish to see Kerala flourishs , spread some positivity at some point. A lot of Industrial, IT and Infra development has happened in the recent past and encourage youth to stay in the state or country rather than migrating to do care home jobs.
Do some good to the society. Maybe the target audience might not be happy with it.
To Timbaktu 😂😂😂 except their dear state 😢
Their state + Timbuktu
You are not highlighting why keralites are moving out of Kerala
You are showcasing everyone who moved out as yusuf ali
What about the millions of keralites doing labor jobs in gulf?
You are missing the point for the reason why there is unemployment in Kerala
Highlight why keralites are moving out but people from other states have jobs in their own land
I think Keralites have no self respect.. hence they go begging for jobs in other states
No jobs , no industry, no roads in Kerala
Highlight these points too
These points highlighting the reasons for Keralite migration and millions of other Indians leaving India are covered in other Joe-metric videos
Cpim communist ideologied and Congress vote bank politics!!!
When people vote for candidates not for party then kerala will start growing...
Thank you for commenting
My home state has become a big ghost town courtesy the leftist politics 😢
The non-Left parties have hardly helped the cause
I like this trend. In 20yrs, these zen z will be in depression in west and will return. 😂
Return to a non-existent home base?
@joe-metricview6035 they l realise, going to west is not like going to gulf. They won't get PR. Once they return, they l break back of trade unionists (like how one film star fan was neutralized). And then, naadu nannavum. End of vigadan vaad, Badal Rekha 🙅♀️. Howzzat umpire ?
No sane non Malayalam business group or entrepreneur set up any business in kerala
Greed 😂😂😂
See for migration of keralite different story so don't lie , orginal truth is because of Dharawad Culture
In Hindi there is a saying that Dogs dont have the ability to digest Desi ghee. Most of Kerala society suffers from that syndrome. Prior to outward migration Mallus where scattered all over India, escaping poverty in Kerala. The same people when they became somewhat stable, they started boasting about theirr pedigree, everyone was claiming that he has Nallukettu in his ancestral land . The kerala society is a remiitance based society full of pomp and false ego. It is not self sufficient in food production, if mallus make a course correction then only they can survive, if they continue the show off culture , thinking that they r the superior people, it will be no good for them. A bit of humility and humbleness will do no harm
@abiisaac: By attitude, Mallus are way more arrogant than the Gujjus. Atleast Gujjus have something to be proud about their state, what does kerala have other than these 3 - lottery, liquor, tourism ?
Poor gujjus can't keep up with malayallees... 😂😂😂😂😂
@@third3eye26 Mallus: Kerala no. 1
Also Mallu abroad: Saar, give me job saar. I do all job, i don't want to go back to kerala. I will be ur slave.
Mallus bragging about Kerala is like someone bragging about a house made of straw which can be blown away in a storm.
@@abiisaac1953 this is what I pointed out the exceptionalism and supreme racist attitude. They r just like others nothing special about them
As a Keralite I agree with your observation. I have seen many malayalis belittle people from other states .. why the treatment we give to our labourers from other states is proof enough .. if everything is so no 1 here then why are people migrating? That’s a question most malayalis will not give you a straight answer for
So what is your over all point 😅 why this video 😂
Just wondering is this exodus needs to be celebrated or are we digging our own graves.
The latter seems more probable. If only our idiotic politicos u'stood d ramification of talent outflow!!
Ignorance of the ramifications of talent loss. You said it 👍
Now we keralites feel the loss of our great kingdom Travancore the legacy of united Kerala Travancore Cochin and Malabar….
In present being downtrodden under Indian colonization and infiltrations we have to move to a better territory not for us but for our forthcoming generations …. Lest there won’t be anymore Keralites there will only be Indians living in Kerala.
In fact we keralites lost our motherland United Kerala 😢😮😢
@@noblemottythomas7664 Travancore was not America or Singapore in terms of economy or standard of living.
@ Travancore was above Singapore before joining Indian union pls seek true history not Indian scrap history
😊
@@noblemottythomas7664No. Travancore was good only for a few upper castes.
@ so it should be corrected by internal revolution not a foreign encroachment
Kerala beautiful place but worse people living there due to communism who want to grow they all left
It just shows how the state of Kerala failed its people. Such a sad state of affairs. It’s ridiculous politics has killed a state.
Politicians haven't been particularly helpful
Keralites so intelligent and educated.big salute jerala
😊
My great grand uncle migrated to Malay ( present Malaysia and Singapore ) in the early 1960s and another one went to Ceylon. Kerala geography is only good for early and retired life . Today kerala is the most costliest place in India with average manual labour wage INR1200 per day compared to 400 in Bengal or UP.
Nobody is thinking about Kerala residents, trying hard to reach a stage.