Best 2 Person 4 Season Tent, Hilleberg Jannu | One killer feature not talked about on YouTube..
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 июл 2024
- In this video I have a first look and review the Hilleberg Jannu 4 season 2 person mountain tent. I take the tent on a field test to one of my favourite locations in the Mourne Mountains - Honestly very impressed and I find one feature so amazing that I am now adding this tent to my wish list... ATB Tom
If you have enjoyed this video you can help the channel and support this type of content by buying me a coffee using the link below... Many thanks Tom
ko-fi.com/tomheaneyadventure9...
Time Codes -
0:00 - Drone Footage
0.19 - Introduction
2.42 - Tent Design
3.49 - Tent Set Up
6:00 - A Little Negative
8:11 - Vestibule Considerations
9:36 - Some Technical Issues
12:50 - Interior Volume
20.23 - Durability
23:25 - My Favourite Subject
25:18 - Weather Resistance
27:26 - Final Thoughts And Tent Sum Up 
Спорт
Hi Tom. Having lived with this tent for a couple of years, I think you were bang on the money with all your observations. I did a lot of research before I got the tent and in my opinion you have created the definitive Jannu review, both in terms of detail and balanced content. A great reference point for anyone considering the tent. Very well thought out and put together. Cheers. gary
Hi Gary, firstly let me thank you again for borrowing this great tent and making this review possible. I hope that you enjoyed the video and great that as the tents owner you think about it in a similar way to myself. Its hard to totally get the feel of a tent in one outing but this Jannu certainly was very impressive in many other ways apart from the tension on the inner... ATVB and I am sure you cant wait to get out in it again.. Tom
Hi Tom, it's good to see you out again. I hope you're feeling ok now?
I just wanted to say there's many tent reviewers on RUclips and then there's you! Your reviews are absolutely amazing, indepth, honest and you pick up on every aspect of the tents that other reviewers seem to miss. Well done Tom, I hope your channel grows and more reviews are forthcoming.
Martin
Hi Martin thank you for watching and taking the time for this detailed positive comment.. Yeah the reviews are long but I try to cover everything that I feel is relevant. When you get home though you always think of something that you missed, but sure that's always the way. This one was a challenge for many reasons and its so much harder doing the review when you are out on camp. I have to be feeling ok as my pack for this one some how creeped up to 14kg... ATB and thanks once again. I hope you too are getting out for many camps as its so good for body and mind... Tom
Hi, Tom, great review. I love all your videos and appreciate the time and efforts you put into this amazing content. By the way, due to your great review I just bought the Hilleberg Jannu this week. Thanks again for what you are doing for all us who don’t have the time or money to review so many tents and gear. It sure helps pointing many of us in the right direction. All the best.
Hi Paul, thank you for your positive comments. Hey that's exciting news that you are going for the Jannu. I bet you cant wait to get it as its a fab tent. I loved testing it and it really feels very special... What colour are you going for?? ATB Tom
Hey Tom. Great to see another in-depth and quality tent review. I know that a lot of Jannu owners really love this tent. Thanks also for not subjecting us to yet another back yard review! Lol. Really good to see your vids and channel going well. I’m sitepping back into the ring with my next video today. It feel good to be back. Great work again, Tom. ⛺️👍🏼
Hi Barry, thank you for your comments and support like I usually say but it is appreciated. You are right in lots of Jannu owners loving this tent and I can see why. I don't think its one of the most popular Hilleberg models but maybe this review may help ha ha.. Really good news to hear that you are back making more content too... ATB Tom
Quite a lovely intro to this video, Tom. Nice work.
Hey Joshua thank you for watching and taking the time to comment on the video.. Great to hear you enjoyed the introduction.. I hope you are well and getting out in the mountains.. All the very best wishes Tom
I’ve had a Jannu for years, though I find myself using the Soulo more often than not these days, especially for alpine&winter overnighters. That being said, I’m very pleased with the Jannu and it is great to see a comprehensive review of it on RUclips(finally!)
Subscribed to your channel!
Hi Fritz, thank you for watching and taking the time to comment. It's always great to hear form users who actually own the tent. As I am sure you are aware I also have a Soulo but its the Black label so heading quite close in weight to the Jannu so if I had both I might actually use the Jannu more... ATB and thanks once again for the positive comments. I hope that you are getting out on many camping trips... Tom
Nicely done, Tom 👍 Anyone considering buying a Jannu should see this video from start to finish. Thanks for doing this 👍😊🐶
Hi Shamus, thank you for your comments I really appreciate it...yeah it might even make you think about buying one again... Great to hear your thoughts as a former Jannu owner and from someone who has so much experience of Hilleberg and other tents... ATB Tom
Excellent methodical analysis.
Hi Stephen, thank you and glad that you enjoyed the video. I have a review of the Hilleberg Nammatj 2 coming up shortly... ATB Tom
Great review Tom...... and nice to see some proper tension on an outer pitch first test 👍
Hi Neil, thank you even you would like this tent... Gives yr Super Quasar a run for its money... Catch up soon, Tom
Another great review. I had never really considered a Jannu before but I really like the way this type of tent can be pitched from the ground up in windy conditions. The tension on the inner was also surprisingly good. Had always thought I would be tempted by a nallo but would definitely consider one of these now too. Thanks.
Hi John, great to hear your comments thank you. Yes that tension on the inner was a very welcome surprise. The pole structure is a bit like a North Face tadpole but with the rear crossing point much higher giving greater internal height and space. The strength is moved up a bit to the roof but then the effective guying system supports the poles lower down. The tent feels very special and extremely well made with great attention to detail especially regarding the construction.. ATB Tom
Lol the title Tom 😁 jealous of the location!
Both this and your back yard 😉
Hi Rob, thank you for watching and hope you enjoyed the video as much as the title... Yeah its afab location and I will do a few more tent reviews here for sure. Less back yard reviews too now that lockdowns are past us.. Looking forward to your next video too.. ATB Tom
Great video as usual mate.
Hey, glad you enjoyed it and appreciate the positive feedback... ATB Tom
Great detailed video as usual Tom, loved the in-depth review. My 25 year old Terra Nova Voyager is still serving me well but if she ever gives up the ghost this would definitely be a contender to replace her! Working with batteries in the cold is so frustrating, had a similar problem a couple of videos back. Plugged my phone into my battery pack just to find the cold had completely killed it! Oh the joy! Thanks again and ATB!
Hi Gary, thank you for watching and your comments especially as a fellow content creator on RUclips... Yeah the pole structure is similar but with the Jannu having the rear poles cross tighter in the roof... The power banks can be slow to charge as well in cold conditions. I have filmed in much colder but this time for whatever reason all my batteries on everything I had suffered. I had plenty of power banks to recharge but not plenty of cables for everything at once ha ha.. ATB Tom
Finally a quality review of this tent! I’ve been looking at this as well as the soulo for a winter solo tent. I always trust your reviews, the devil is in the detail after all
Hi Ben, thank you for watching and your positive comments.. Just watching it again myself in case I made any mistakes ha ha. Under a bit of pressure to get it out at the best time on a Sunday.. This tent definitely has the space and many really nice design features. The Soulo is a bit more stable but suffers with space for organising gear.. Never an easy decision but you will be very happy with either.. ATB Tom
Brilliant video as usual,your attention to detail is second to none and your content is very professional and I always look to your channel when buying a new tent ,currently trying to decide weather to upgrade from my hilleberg akto to the black label soulo for summit camping in the uk and iv been watching a lot of your videos
Thanks for all the info and advice mate 👏👌
Hi Robology, thank you for watching and taking the time to comment. The BL Soulo is definitely a few steps up in the strength department than the Akto. Somehow thought it feels a bit smaller inside floor volume wise, and definitely is smaller in the vestibule. But for security and durability and less flappiness its a big winner.. ATB with your decision... Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 yeah i have scrutinised your comparison videos and that’s what lead me to buy my first hilleberg the akto ,that I absolutely love but I find myself wanting that extra bit of head room .a lot say the BL soulo is overkill but for the extra 400 grams and extra £100 I think why not have the strongest tent they make . They are like gold dust now tho and really hard to get hold of but … iv managed to pre order one in sand 😃
Thanks for the quality content mate look forward to your next video
Hi Tom - great video - like your attention to details - subscribed
Hey Hans, great that you enjoyed the detail... Thank you for watching and your comments... ATB and look forward to your next video. Tom
Looks a fantastic tent . Excellent review yet again, nobody does it better 😂 Getting ready to purchase a 4 season, this is on the list . Great video Tom . Atb Tony
Hi Tony, great to receive your support from watching and commenting on many of my videos.. Yes this is a really nice tent... Just a little complicated to pitch with all the guys and clips.. Easy enough but it takes time.. Make sure you look at my Nammatj 2 review as it's still my choice.. ATB Tom
I'm really confused so many good tent in the hilleberg range.
fantastic videos thanks very much !
Hey thank you.. It's a bit old now but still explains the tent pretty well I think. I have since purchased a Jannu and absolutely love it... best wishes Tom
Tom, every tent you cover becomes the benchmark for that tent. Keep up the good work and keep teasing us with all those lovely Hillebergs!
Hi Kevin, I hope that you are well and once again thank you for your support watching and commenting on my reviews. I have a few more Hillebergs that I can get my hands on but to be honest the views are not where I would like them so a little torn as I love to review high value quality tents an £1000 but I am limiting my target audience so much.... really appreciate the positive comments though... Tom
Oh please do reviews on them, I am sure the views will come more and more in time. I have shared many of your videos with friends looking for Hilleberg tents and they have all loved your reviews and your channel. All your videos are much appreciated! @@TOMHEANEY100
@@millieblue5014 Hey thank you for the positive comments. I really cant see me doing any more Hilleberg reviews on my channel unless a close friend has a tent that they want me to review.. Honestly as I have probably reviewed more Hillebergs than most and definitely influenced many sales for them they have gave me nothing in return so I will no longer promote their products.. there will always be more RUclipsrs who will review their tents and they know that.. best wishes...Tom
Hi Tom!@@TOMHEANEY100 Thank you for your reply. Yeah I understand that. Sad to see that they have not done anything in return to you. I am looking forward to watch more of your videos no matter what they are as they are so good and informative. Thank you for that and all the work you put in and that you share them with us. I and I am sure many with me really appreciate it. 🙂 Best wishes Millie
Hi Tom, Saw your video of new Jannu in green, has convinced me it is a great choice, mine arrives next week. I will be using the DD Hammocks mini caribiners as mentioned. I agree with the chap below it is a great reference review . Thanks for a great review. Laurence
Hey Laurence, that's great to hear thank you.. Mine certainly took a big snow load no worries at all. When I tested the Jannu and Nammatj in high winds I personally favoured the Jannu.. It's a really nice tent and I wish you all the very best with yours.. Great to hear once again of your choice.. Tom
A thorough review as ever Tom - nice to see the inner performing well having seen the comparison with the other Hilleberg tents you reviewed. I look forward to seeing your preferred tents and brands as we approach three season weather and can lighten our load somewhat 🤗 The Jannu looks a superb tent but not for my needs to date….maybe sometime 😉
Hi Miriam thank you for your support and comments... Yeah lighten the load yes please, this one was 14kg and I so look forward to reducing it.. Didn't get the drone up for long to get shots like yours so that was a pity.. ATVB Tom
Hello Tom, cuz of your videos I bought my ever first hillebergh staika. I am a woman like to camp so much solo. I must admit I really love the tent, I am afraid to not like any other tent anymore. Very easy to set up, so comfortable and the quality is superb. I used mine and cuz I love it so much I am afraid if I can tear it apart by tightening the guyline so much. But i should of just trust the quality. Over all hands down hillebergh😘🥰❤️
Hi Elirita, you are hooked and now like most Hilleberg owners you will be thinking about another one (why are you watching this video ha ha). I have used many many tents from different brands and honestly the materials, design and construction of Hilleberg tents is the best by a long way that I have come across.. I always give Hilleberg tents good reviews but that is because of my experience with them and other tents... Hilleberg do not cut any corners when making a tent and this is what you need if you are looking at long term durability. For example, the groundsheet on your tent is thicker than any other manufactures and this simply means it will last longer... ATB and hope you have many happing camping trips...Tom
Nice campsite and interesting roof for the night!
Yes it was! It's a great spot and super tent . Thank you for watching and taking the time to comment.. best wishes Tom
Great review Tom, and as always, really thoughtful camera angles and composition. I loved at the end how you blended the horizon into the top third of the frame. It was like a beautiful landscape photograph.
This is a tent I know very little about, so I really appreciated your excellent review. I had toyed with changing my Staika to a Jannu. Probably more so because I wish I had a red staika instead of a green one!
Would you prefer the Jannu to your Soulo BL? I like the idea of a bit more space for a solo camper.
Hi Phil, I hope you are well and thank you for your detailed comments as usual. Do you still have the Staika as I thought I saw you selling it somewhere? Must get a camp with you at some point... ATB Tom
Oh no .. now I really want this. I kite so this tent would be perfect for the winds I follow ❤
Hi Kyra, thank you for watching and commenting on this video.. This is a great tent just can be a little tricky putting up in high winds due to all the pole clips and number of guy lines . But a really fantastic tent for sure.. I really appreciate you buying me a coffee thank you. Out summit camping in 50 mph winds and lashing rain as I type this.. Have a look on my Instagram to see a couple of video posts.. ATB Tom
Brilliant Tom. Would of loved to have seen some alternative closer views but fab detail as per. Always fancied the Jannu.
Hi Dave, thank you glad you enjoyed the review. Appreciate the feedback and looking forward to your next one too. ATB Tom
Great review as always. I just need to remember - I don't need more camping gear 😅
Had a great camp on that beach a few weeks ago too - great memories.
Hey it's one of my favorite spots... Just tricky to get the pegs secured... You are wrong about needing more gear though.. You always need it..😁😁
Oh yes look out for one amazing feature in particular regarding this awesome tent.... ATB Tom
Been enjoying watching these reviews , very interesting and informative…
I had looked at the Janna so many times in the past, it does look an absolutely bomber tent, very solid shelter, I think anyone would feel safe in there on a wild night…
Thank you again Tom, ATB 👍
Hi Scots Nomad, thank you for watching and commenting very positively. Yes this is a bomber tent for sure and I had a super comfortable nights sleep in it... I hope this review answered any thoughts you had on the tent.. ATB Tom
Hi Tom! Cracking review although we would expect nothing less lol. Sounds like you could be adding a Jannu to your fleet?? As always the video quality, tent detail and knowledge is top tier. Cracking tent! Thanks SK
Hi Stuart, thank you for watching and thoughtful comments as you always do. I do want to see more of your BL Soulo in action though.... ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 you and me both!
One thing to note with guylines, attach them to mini caribiners and then you can clip them to the tent as required. Easy to unclip and tidy away ready for next trip. Makes guylines a doodle and the tent is always tidy.
Hi Laurence, I think I will try to rig something like this as it sounds like a very good idea... Thank you for the top tip... I like tidy too... ATB Tom
Thanks Tom, great review and thanks Gary for three lone of the tent and to make this review possible. Tom did you get any feed back from Hilleberge of pitching into wind question?
Yes I did and you got it... 😂😂
Like to have it in a Black Label version. Good presentation. Hard work to put it all together
Hey thank you Sam for the positive comments.. A Black Lable Jannu would be nice... The guy who owns this one now uses 10mm poles.. ATB Tom
Really enjoyed this, despite not being in the market for a two man 4 season tent as I have a Tarra. Since you have the contacts to get hold of all sorts of designs I would be really interested in your take on the Hilleberg Rogen. It has not been reviewed in depth anywhere that I can find.
Hey hard to beat the Tarra... I have sourced a Rogen but will wait a little to the season is more appropriate.. Appreciate your positive feedback and thank you for watching too.. ATB Tom
I am still favoring the Quasar despite it's inner first pitching and complicated set up. It's an absolute bomber. I have more flimsy tents if I need to go lightweight.
Hi Dave thank you for watching and commenting on many of my videos...I have owned a couple of Quasars over the years and thoroughly tested them in many Scottish winters.. I still have a liking towards them .. I just find the Jannu easier to pitch in high winds due to the pole sleeve and clip combination.. I am also a fan of 10mm poles which I use for my own Jannu. Some day I will maybe test them head to head as a friend won a 40 year anniversary Quasar.. Best wishes and thank you once again for watching my videos.. Out for an easy one tonight in my Scarp 1 Ultra as I now kinda favour Ultra light as getting to old to carry heavy tent s up mountain s.. Tom
Some great and detailed reviews of the tents, especially the weather/wind testing. Although there's not a 🐈 cat in hell's chance of me buying or using a bright red tent ⛺😂
Hey thank you for your positive comments.. Probably moving away from red myself to be honest.. My latest tent is a sand colour 😀 😊 ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 Everyone is free to their own preferences of colour. But personally I absolutely hate to see the mountains and wild places pepper-potted in ultra bright red, yellow, blue, orange and white tents and the mountains covered in people wearing garish, brightly coloured clothing. It is indeed a huge eyesore on the beautiful landscape. Everest now looks like a brightly coloured rubbish dump. The peaks of Scafell, Ben Nevis and Snowden look like Butlins holiday camp. Is there any wonder why I seek out the lesser known wild places, in my drab brown or black or green or khaki clothing and bivvies. Or maybe it's just because I'm a moaning old fart. 😂
@@Globetrotter-1 I know for a while safety was one reason that companies made colourful outdoor clothing. You are easier to spot if you need help.. I also suppose that a single coloured object in a wild environment isn't too bad but when you get a whole lot of them then its a bit different. thank you for sharing your POV... ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 The world has gone mad with 'Health & Safety'. If we wanted "safety" we wouldn't climb mountains.
Best review possible Tom! Have you tried the kaitum? I’m 6’3” tall and finding a 4 season tent with length for a tall person is difficult!
Yes I have and you watched the video too so thank you. The guy who lent me the Kaitum for review is 6 foot 7. He fits no problem at all. I have eventually bought a Jannu and had it out in epic snow if you want to see it tested under extreme snow loads.. Awesome to hear you are enjoying my content. ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 yup I’ve watched that too….epic!
@@stuartcrane9409 Great to hear Stuart.. ATB and thank you for the reply.. Tom
Hi Tom great video, if you could only pick one, would you have the Soulo BL or the Jannu?
Hi, definitely the Jannu.. The BL Soulo is too close in weight with such a reduced internal and vestibule space.. The Jannu is strong enough for 60mph winds and if you are out in more then that its no fun... I have owned both and just find the Soulo very small but its still a great tent... I hope this answers your question.... best wishes Tom
Great review. I really like what I see with Hilleberg tents and I keep coming back to them. The only thing that concerns me is the weight. 7+ lbs seems a bit high but I don't want to "cheap out" on quality, as my life may depend on it. Are my concerns misplaced?
Hi Major, thank you for watching and commenting. Hilleberg really consider function and durability of their tents so the materials and poles are stronger that many other brands. The groundsheet on this tent for example is 70d where some other manufactures use as low as 30 or even 20d fabrics to reduce the weight (low weight sells tents but reduces durability). Some will say its over kill but in my experience its definitely not. I have tested tents with thinner less durable fabrics and poles (look at my review of the MSR Access two). Hilleberg's also hold their value remarkably well and part of that is because they stand the test of time... I am not saying that they are perfect as some compromises have always got to be made. If you are going to camping in environments that are remote and you need to trust your tent then definitely worth it...Tom
Hello! Thanks for the great overview! Would you consider Hilleberg Tarra to be Jannu's big brother? Trying to decide between two tents (Jannu and Tarra) for our upcoming trips to northern Sweden (Abisko) is a challenging task. Do you have any thoughts on the Tarra tent for a 4-6 day trip for two people (and a dog)? Yes, extra durability and wind resistance come at a cost (both in weight and cost). I would appreciate your feedback on this!
Hi thank you for the comment.. Yes I definitely would consider the Tarra a big brother to the Jannu..I feel for the space comfort, two vestibules and durability it's worth the extra weight split between two particularly for a long trip...The Jannu is actually quite small for two, gear and a dog.. It's still never easy to choose between tents so I hope this helps... Best wishes Tom and let me know which one you go for..
Nooo Tom. I had finally come to terms with the Jannu being out of my price range for the moment and soldiering on with my current tent for awhile longer.. then I saw you're review pop up! I was kind of hoping you would find some major flaw in it but alas my internal torment seems destined to carry on. Great review as always.
How do you find the uberlight combined with the closed cell pad for warmth? And is the uberlight as noisy as it sounds in the video? Haha
Hi Yuffarium, thank you for watching and commenting. Sorry to hear that you torment still survives.. I am always tormented over my next tent.... The uberlite combined with the closed cell pad has kept me warm down to about -3 degrees centigrade with no worries at all. For me this is a great combo for comfort, weight and warmth. Yes its noisy and very slippy.... I had to do a retake of one of my topics due to the distracting noise and rustling from it.. But only really noticed it on camera but one to look out for if someone else is in the tent with you ha ha.. ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 I do tend to move around a lot during the night so noisy and slippery might be an issue but it seems like a lot of mats have these features so maybe something I just need to get used to. It's always puzzled me why almost everything in the outdoor industry seems to be made of the slickest/smoothest material known to man which feels like it can turn the inside of a tent into a slip n slide especially on angled ground but I guess there's some reason for it. Any way thanks for the reply and all the info.
A black label version of this would be ideal for me
Yes thank you for your comments.. That's why I bought a Nammatj 2.. Black label at the same weight although the design is obvious quite different... ATB Tom
Hi Tom! Your channel is excellent and very informative, thanks for all the effort that goes in to putting all down in to the well edited videos we can all watch, the best on you tube I feel... So in reviewing all your content on two man tents I am down to the standard Kaitam 2 and the Jannu. I live in the Rocky mountains of Canada where I usually find shelter out of the wind and generally extreme wind is not my usually my issue, (I see why your content is often flavoured this way.... N.I. must be tough when its blowing) but snow can be at times... so my real decision is livability of the tent, what feels better to sleep in, store gear, when there is rain front coming through for 5 hours and you need to prep food and drink etc etc..... what do you think feels most enjoyable? And one last thing, I like the sand colour but in the red label thickness you can see the inner colour it seems, and for me is not so great.... what is your favourite colour Hilleberg and why? I currently own a newer Nammatj 3 GT in green, but feel it is more of a car camping tent or winter pulk in tent because of bulk and weight, I really don't like the way the non vestibule end is so low, in bad weather/humid conditions it can wet my sleeping bag. Any help would be much appreciated. ATB.
Hi thank you for watching my video on the Hilleberg Jannu.. A very different tent that the Kaitum.. The Kaitum has much more space and storage and is in reality much longer too due to the vertical doors. The Kaitum is light and pretty strong and with the twin vestibules very versatile for different or changing conditions and also more liveable. If you are going to use it for two people then it will really excel. The Jannu is definitely stronger and can be made stronger still with 10mm poles. Its also freestanding and has more that enough room for one but a bit tight for two.. definitely less versatile with its lower profile and single vestibule... as to the colours then I have had them all and dont really have a favourite. Stock can be limited so colour wise you might just have to take what is available... best wishes Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 thanks so much Hi Tom, I decided to pull the trigger on the Kaitum 3 in Sand… the additional living space was a decider over the 2 for hardly any extra weight and no GT compromise. I have a dog with me most of the time so had to justify that and wanted this for 2 adults. Hoping it’s a great summer/autumn tent…. Keep up the awesome reviews !!
@@pbradventuresYou will be able to use the Kaitum in the winter as well. No problem. The design makes it capable to handle wind very well. And for the Kaitum 3 you will be able to get 10 mm poles , if you want to upgrade. Wise decision to go for the 3 man version if you expect to have company. Enjoy 😊
This tent looks really good, especially with such a perfect inner. Would you trust this red rated in extreme conditions or would something like a black nammatj fair better? I’d love to know your thoughts? Also what brand are your trousers? They look pretty nifty!
Hi Jordan, www.millet.com/eu_en/miv8500-7317-trilogy-adv-cordura-pant-m-men-navy-blue.html.... Thats the link to the pants. I love them and used them on a camp last night... Now on to the thoughts about the tent... Yes it's definitely as strong as the Nammatj IMO.... I tested it last night against the Nammatj and that will be my next video. Nammatj has more durable fabrics but this doesn't really matter. The inner of the Nammatj pops and flaps and cracks in the wind where the Jannu doesn't...The 3 pole structure and guying on the Jannu is very strong. I n all honesty I may sell the Nammatj after this side by side comparison.. Just bear in mind that as a two person tent it's really small.... ATB Tom
Hi Tom. Regarding the ventilation on the Jannu. There appears to be an inner vent at the top. Is there insect mesh integrated into this vent? cheers
Brent
Hi Brent yes there is a separate mesh behind the inner yellow vent cover which is on its own zips... Hope this helps.. Tom
It has always struck me how little appreciation most tent reviewers pay to the fact that some tents can be set up wit an external pole setting, so you can break down/set up the tent as a whole. I consider this a major benefit. I was wondering: have you ever reviewed a Helsport tent? Norwegian brand, I think they are really well made and not as expensive as Hilleberg. External poles, but in a full sleeve (I know, this needs extra care while setting up. Also, I always wondered if there's no risk of freezing poles to sleeves in severe frost/snow. Too old to to try that out now ;)
Hi thank you for this comment..Yes set up is very important that it can be done when its windy or wet... Many users though of 4 season tents actually dont pitch them in exposed locations so they never have the set up problem... I will try Helsport re sponsoring me a tent as they are hard to get here in the Uk. I have looked at them many times but now I will contact them thank you.. All the very best wishes Tom
Hi Tom. In your tent reviews one thing I never see you mention is lying down flat on a pad, how much space you have next to the inner above your head / face. That is one reason I am interested in a Scarp vs other tents, because of the vertical ends and I am 6ft3. Also, with any of the Hilleberg tents, have you ever had any water leaking through the seams? Because they don't seal them apparently, some people have had issues with that, water getting through the stitching. Thanks.
Hi Chris, I have actually mentioned this in many videos. If in a particular video I have not mentioned it then it's not an issue for me at 6'1 or 185 cm. My head will lightly touch the inner here on a pad but it's not an issue. If for you you really dont like this then consider a Kaitum 2, lie diagonal, or go for a 3 person version if they make one.. I have a Scarp and its definitely better than to Jannu here due to the vertical ends so definitely worth considering.. I hope that this helps... best wishes Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100Thank you :) Yes I’d be sharing with one more person sometimes so would need to fit sleeping straight instead of diagonally unfortunately. I think the sleeping bag pressed against the inner might result in it getting wet too so just wanted a tent which has a bit of space either end. Thanks for the info :)
Sorry Tom a bit off base, but what trousers are you wearing in this video. Thanks
Hi no worries they are made by Millet... www.millet.com/eu_en/men/clothing/pants.html?page=3
I cant find the actual ones and mine have no name on them.. Many in the range are very similar. Mine are stretchy soft-shell with Cordura reinforcements. Very happy with them... best wishes on finding something suitable if thats what you are after.. Tom
I’ve always wondered if the Jannu is better in weather than the Staika. I know the Staika is BL, but not too many videos of the Staika in bad weather.
Hi thank you for watching a number of my videos.... Thats a great question especially as the Jannu being stronger goes against the Hilleberg Label system. I have only used a Staika on one occasion and I also now have 10mm poles for my own Jannu. Set up like this I believe it is stronger due to the fat that you can orientate it vestibule into the wind (as Hilleberg recommend) where the brow pole supports the structure in addition to the other poles, making it semi geodesic. As per snow loading have a look at my video in the snow where the Jannu is buried and at that point it was using the 9mm poles and performed perfectly... best wishes Tom
Would you review cheaper makes like berghaus as these tents are c £1000. I’m looking at cairngorm 2 for sea kayaking as has big cooking area but it’s quite heavy for kayaking. Great video btw!
Hi I have reviewed some lower cost tents such as the Lanshan 2 pro and the Vango Banshee 300.. Honestly as I have a small channel I have to review tents that subscribers offer me.. It's not worth buying and selling tents for the few views that I get.. I will keep this tent in mind in case I get any offers.. Thank you for the positive feedback.. ATB Tom
EDIT: The title is explained at:
15:58 Inner volume / tautness is better than most tents.
Hi Bil not I understand.. Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 Sorry. Just making a note about the title in case I watch again in the future. Thanks doing this.
@@billb5732 hey no worries at all.. Tom
Awesome tent. Whenever I've seen pictures of it I've thought it's the kind of thing I'd want for a proper expedition into hostile conditions. But unless and until I'm in that situation, I couldn't justify the weight. Shared by two though...
Hi David, great that you are getting through a few of my videos so thank you for watching and commenting... This is a very nice tent and I almost bought one but decided to go for a Nammatj 2 instead. I have made some other massive weight savings and the Nammatj is only 200g heavier than my Black Label Soulo and so much more space... Tom
Have you compared tested kuiu storm star?
No no not yet... Thank you for the comments and thoughts 💭.. best wishes Tom
Nammatj 2-3 for the win or fjellreven keb/abisko endurance
Hi Audun, thank you for the comments and watching of course. Your recommendations are all pretty good. I recently had a look at a Fjallraven Abisko Shape 2 and was impressed... ATB Tom
Best inner tent of any hillieberg I've seen why all the others are so flappy I don't understand the single entry puts me off tho personally I prefer 2 doors and 2 vestibules
Hi Craig, thank you for watching and taking the time to comment. Yeah the tension is amazing which puts the other Hillebergs to shame in some ways.. Bad news for you though as I have tested the Tarra which has two doors and a really taught inner too so you might have to consider one.... Happy camping. ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 I've got the kuiu storm star that works for me I'm not denying the hillieberg quality but either the inner or the expense or just not suitable for my needs is what puts me off them there great tents just not for me
@@craig3401 Hi Craig, the storm star looks really good. I have considered one and would definitely love to get my hands on one to review at some point. ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 yea I really like it it's not perfect I don't think any tent is the door tie back are not the best and the inner maybe a bit close to the outer. But I'd like to see your review you do really good reviews
Щ@@TOMHEANEY100
any thoughts on this vs the Allak ? Same price and weight but slightly different design
Hi Kyle. This is actually my Jannu in the video. By chance I also owned an Allak 2. I literally just sold it this week. The main difference in the 2 is strength and functionality. The Jannu is by far the stronger tent and able to withstand significantly higher winds and snow loading. The Allak is less structurally strong (albeit still a very robust tent), but the extra internal height 105cm vs 100cm and the twin entrances and vestibules (with larger access) make it a more functional and comfortable 2 man tent. Ultimately it comes down to your intended use (solo or 2 person) and how harsh the conditions are you intend to camp in. If you favour comfort get the Allak. If you favour strength get the jannu. For me personally tho the Jannu is a bit more “special” in terms of overall design 👍
@@garynesbitt5078 great thanks!
Hi Gary, I really appreciate your input here and you have answered Kyle much better that I could as you have significant experience of using both tents... Like you I feel the Allak is very versatile with its vestibule options and greater inner height. Its just not as strong for exposed camping above or beyond the tree line... ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100
Hi Tom.
Everyones answers imho are spot on. Horses for courses. And now I have most (all) of the tents mentioned (and more) and cant bring myself to sell any now.. 🤣😇.
Your reviews are always great buddy. 🫵👍✊️
@@thomasomoore9252 thank you Thomas its always hard to sell a Hilleberg... I might have to make that decision soon and definitely not looking forward to it. Thank you for your comments.. ATB Tom
hi i cant find one to buy anywhere seems to be discontinued dose anyone know where i can get one thanks?
Hi Allison, yeah most Hilleberg tents are sold out. You just need to set up email notifications and then move quickly when you get the alert.. The is also a FB Hilleberg Tents For Sale which you could watch if you are happy with a good second hand one.. Hope you can source one soon.. ATB Tom
Thing is, its not just 4 season Hilleberg tents which are renowned for condensation its all Hillebergs..Being 4 season and keeping the cold wind out is no excuse for poor ventilation, there are many 4 season tents with proper ventilation options. Many tents have condensation but not usually in the inner and Hilleberg are the only company who recommend having a little towel and waterproof cover for the foot box of your sleeping bag.
Hi Chris, there is a lot to answer here so forgive me if its a little disjointed..... I have read about and used many many Hilleberg tents and properly tested them as you are aware. My experience is not having condensation issues or having ventilation issues with any. There is no doubt that the theory of bringing the flysheet right down to the ground definitely seals out weather but reduces ventilation. However that's why there are top vents. American designs such as The North Face have more air flow under the fly as it doesn't come right to the ground. This however can end up being very drafty in cold conditions. In my opinion 4 season tents should focus on strength and weather protection not ventilation.. Fjalraven have more venting options on some tents I will admit but I have had two issues with the only Fjallraven (Abisko Lite 2) tent I have tested. I had hoped it was the perfect tent but the tent itself had a fabric damage issue (not from my use), and the customer service was exceptionally poor. They offered to send me a repair kit or 3rd party repair with no mention of warranty. So for me and the kind of camping that I do I have much greater value in the fantastic durability strength and customer service from Hilleberg, than possibly better ventilation but poor durability and customer service from Fjallraven.. just my thoughts and thank you for yours... best wishes Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 Thanks for your Input. I'm still trying to decide what tent. The problem is I wanted to buy a premium tent, I'm lucky to be in the position of a very understanding Mrs and a near unlimited budget. So I thought straight off Hilleberg, but then read many complaints about condensation & wet sleeping bags. then discovered Fjallraven but your report of poor customer service is certainly a cause for concern..I'm also looking at a Nortent Vern 1 and maybe the Hilleberg Una too..Its anoying that there doesn't seem to be a 4 season tent, with decent ventilation, and a decent vestibule, with the ability to sit up. I'm same as you 6ft 1, all the tent makers seem to think campers are all 5 ft. Being indecisive & having OCD doesn't help.
@@TOMHEANEY100 RIGHT I 've decided its Hilleberg Dome and Nortent...You seem like a switched on guy and you genuinely test your tents. I'm off to Tesco now to buy a ridiculous amount of alcohol..Once again thank you very much for taking the time to give your valued opinion, very much appreciated.
@@Chris66able hi.. you are very very welcome.. The Nortent s look good... I asked them for one but they said no..🤣🤣
@@TOMHEANEY100 oh sad to hear that they said no. But hey that is their loss. You make so excellent reviews that I bet make people buy tents after they have watched them. You make such good reviews and help so many people make good informed decisions on what tent to buy. Thank you for that it is much appreciated!
My buddy has a Jannu Im just not a fan of vestibules' in expedition tents that dont have a pole structure
Hi thank you for your comments... Yeah definitely limited space but this tent is designed to have a minimum footprint for set up in narrow spaces etc... Kind of more a high camp tent more than a base camp tent... The set up for this tent also makes it seriously strong vestibule into the wind as you then have pole crossing points. This is not for everyone but when the conditions are really serious then the Jannu excels. ATB Tom
I love Saitaris yet way out of my reach.
Hi Memphis, thank you for watching and commenting. Yes I would love one too and I see that you have already watched my review on it... ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 yes I have seen the review several times.
Sit comfortably? Are you a giant or is that tent designed for midgets? All wall angles of that tent looks weird and vestibule looks miserable. I'd call that tent a design failure.
I have some experience of Saivo. Three person tent but it was so small and low in the vestibule it was difficult for two person to sit side by side for cooking food. And water from the melting snow dripped to the back of my neck and fabric hit the side of my head... Another vestibule in Saivo is ridiculously low, suitable only for some gear...
Also Staika has slanted side walls. For example compared to Keb dome it just looks bad. Long time ago dome tents had almost vertical side walls and were very spacious inside.
I guess Hilleberg does this to cut weight down. Bad shaped tents I wouldn't recommend to anyone.
Hi thank you for your comments. Surely you understand design trade offs... More aerodynamic makes it stronger to high winds but less space or height... This tent is not designed for volume it is designed to have a small footprint for locations where space to pitch is limited... Surely you also understand different people have different needs, but you state you would not recommend to any one? You talk about "midgets" not really appropriate language in our current society.... I contrast however I totally agree with your comments on the Staika slanted walls limit space but help it to shed wind.. I don't have experience of the Saivo but the low vestibule looks very aerodynamic making it super resistant to high winds which for me personally I would be prepared to live with. ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 High winds and snowfall press slanted walls even more down. Wind resistance comes mostly from the poles and their ability to support the structure and firm anchoring of storm lines to the ground. I don't see much sense to compromise the main purpose of the tent - which is to give usable shelter for users and their gear - for a bit smaller weight and quite a lot imaginary benefits for wind resistance because of slanted walls and low ceiling.
Real geodesic dome is a half sphere. It is the strongest known shape to cover area and to give a lot of living space. Side walls start vertical. I have to call it false to claim slanted walls are better. And they are not because when wind presses slanted wall down strain moves forward in the distorted structure. You can say slanted part of the wall has given up then.
Small footprint don't mean slanted walls or low ceiling.
Definitely Saivo is a very strong tent because it has five poles with many crossings. Materials and workmanship are very good also. Unfortunately when compared to traditional tunnel tent (Keron, Spitsberg etc.) it is a bit too much inferior when it comes to living space. Pitching Saivo is very certain but actually a tunnel is faster when used in expedition style
@@bekanav Ok some really great information shared here thank you. There are many variables here and I agree that sloping walls can allow the build of snow loads and also catch winds when they are blown flat if there is too much fabric... I suppose it can depend on the degree of sloping or amount of fabric and how much tension is on it.. Tunnel tents definitely add more living space but need managed more in heavy wet snow falls and as you say are super fast to pitch. Tent design is a long way off proper regulation as to how the tent will actually perform, but any time that I have contacted Hilleberg about a particular design they have significant reasons for it and they do produce so many different designs at a similar weight and the user can select which suits their particular needs. I am not saying that they are perfect as Hilleberg doesn't seem to want to make any changes to any of the designs but then if you are selling all the tents you can make why would you change... I have handled many Hilleberg tents and always found them very well made and constructed. I also like the fabric thickness for long term durability. So thank you once again for your detailed reply... ATB Tom
@@TOMHEANEY100 Thank you. It is of course true Hilleberg has high quality products, both workmanship and materials. Certainly there is no perfect tent and it is a matter of personal preference which qualities are the most significant to you. I guess I'm getting middle aged because I prefer good living space and no brainer pitching and kind of simplicity in design😂
One more advantage of quite vertical side wall is that storm lines attach to better angle than if wall is sloping. But of course wind pressure for more vertical wall is bigger also.
Thank you for your reviews which are well made and informative👍
I have had this tent for over 12 years now, did a lot of research before spending $, use if few times a year on solo hiking trips, all types of weather and terrain , mostly in australia and NZ, if you were looking for comfort for 2 people it’s probably bit tight but I used it with my son and it’s definitely doable. To me minor compromise of space is negligent comparing to confidence this tent will last in any weather, its super quick to setup, it’s self supporting frame, never compromise on quality when it comes to tents, shoes and backpack especially going solo multiple days, jannu easily towers above other expensive tents especially ones with multiple pole connectors/junctions creating weak points, low level vestibule on jannu can be tricky to get used to but when you do cooking under it is easy, thanks for good review
JEEZUS TOM;
You talk a lot and say Nothing!
Give us the Specifics.
Thanks for your feedback.. Tom