How To Plagiarise A YouTube Video

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 фев 2025
  • kinda crazy that this is still happening after hbomberguy's video on plagiarism
    check out seamus' channel:
    youtube.com/@S...
    bobby fingers:
    youtube.com/@b...
    outro song is "sleeping on trains" by James Marriott
    the mrbeastification of youtube:
    • The MrBeast-ification ...
    edited by my brother and by me a little bit

Комментарии • 1 тыс.

  • @mrsundaymovies
    @mrsundaymovies Год назад +4141

    I dunno man. A lot of this plagurism evidence is really concrete and I prefer circumstantial

    • @Pinely
      @Pinely  Год назад +1404

      You're right. will try to learn and grow from this situation moving forward 🙏

    • @0NeeN0
      @0NeeN0 Год назад +562

      ​@@Pinely I on the other hand prefer uncircumcised

    • @CreeFalcon-219
      @CreeFalcon-219 Год назад +13

      💀💀💀🔥🗣🎯🕊🙏🏽❕🥇

    • @Gatorade69
      @Gatorade69 Год назад +37

      ​@@0NeeN0The first girl I ever got into bed with thought it was gross and turned me down. It effected me pretty deeply...

    • @bard2555
      @bard2555 Год назад

      @@Gatorade69 this is whats wrong with society fellas, make uncircumcised penises normalized (its natural and safer) also off topic I just find it really weird that you can just request doctors to mutilate your child's genitals without them even getting a choice in the matter

  • @HowardSkub
    @HowardSkub Год назад +6297

    “Younger kids have shorter attention spans, therefore less spending power” lmao bro was so worried about changing the wording that his sentence ended up making no sense.

    • @Imnotoook
      @Imnotoook Год назад +462

      this statement lobotomized me

    • @erinys2
      @erinys2 Год назад +552

      me paraphrasing in 8th grade:

    • @sanriobraincell
      @sanriobraincell Год назад +232

      ​@@Imnotoook now we both officially have less spending power

    • @Imnotoook
      @Imnotoook Год назад +97

      @@sanriobraincell cant spend if you cant think!

    • @silverandexact
      @silverandexact Год назад +237

      Hbomberguy's plagiarism video highlighted that that is a common issue with plagiarized statements-the bending over backwards to mix up the word order and use synonyms often leads to a different meaning or even a nonsensical statement

  • @StrawBeTea
    @StrawBeTea Год назад +7007

    But imagine plagiarizing a video about how people copy mr beast, as if that isn't what the whole video was about.

    • @peachykeen1409
      @peachykeen1409 Год назад +131

      fr it's very ironic lol

    • @capnbug
      @capnbug Год назад +143

      But imagine plagiarizing a video about how people copy mr beast, as if that isn't what the whole video was about.

    • @greenhowie
      @greenhowie Год назад +14

      Plag-ception

    • @charlulio
      @charlulio Год назад +68

      @@capnbug But imagine plagiarizing a video about how people copy mr beast, as if that isn't what the whole video was about.

    • @AaronReece
      @AaronReece Год назад +22

      Yeah, but when do we get a video about the "Pinely-fication" of YT?

  • @phyphor
    @phyphor Год назад +2722

    Ah, the James Somerton technique!

    • @jeel-7772
      @jeel-7772 Год назад +88

      It never.... succeeds!

    • @GenX_files
      @GenX_files Год назад +4

      Was just coming to say this lol

    • @Gatorade69
      @Gatorade69 Год назад +6

      Bimmy would also be proud. Actually he wouldn't he has no idea what's happening.

    • @aqueousmutivity
      @aqueousmutivity Год назад +1

      💀💀💀💀💀💀

    • @BluMndy
      @BluMndy 11 месяцев назад +52

      Thank you Tommy Tallarico for inventing plagiarism

  • @rainbowlack
    @rainbowlack Год назад +3488

    the chad Orr Pinely's bisexual lighting vs. the virgin Oscar Owen's "Star Wars sequel promotional poster" lighting

    • @reaverkai
      @reaverkai Год назад +46

      Lmao now i cant unsee it 😂

    • @TheSeaKND
      @TheSeaKND Год назад +148

      Ok, I just ate an edible an hour ago . And you just wrote the most confusing sentence in the history of time for someone like me. “Pinely Star Wars bisexual.”

    • @avedominusnox7344
      @avedominusnox7344 Год назад +48

      ​@@TheSeaKNDfrankly I dont see what's so incoherent about that. Makes total sense to me.

    • @Darkfyyre
      @Darkfyyre Год назад +22

      @@avedominusnox7344 do you know what an edible is my dude? they said "confusing", not "incoherent". i think we can infer that they are confused, not that OP is incoherent. i personally think OP's use of quotation marks is incomplete, potentially obfuscating the point, but i too understood it. of course i'm sober so that helps!

    • @immyg_563
      @immyg_563 Год назад +19

      @@Darkfyyre im pretty sure theyre saying that pinely star wars bisexual makes sense lol

  • @modelmajorpita
    @modelmajorpita Год назад +3806

    He even did the thing where trying to hide the plagiarism by rewording stuff ended up creating a sentence that is completely wrong - kids have less spending power because they don't have jobs, not because of a shorter attention span.

    • @WlatPziupp
      @WlatPziupp Год назад +299

      Kids these days can't even pay attention long enough to write down all the silly numbers on the back of the card

    • @lexirey430
      @lexirey430 Год назад +8

      @@WlatPziupp😭😭

    • @crazyowlgirlcncowner
      @crazyowlgirlcncowner Год назад +59

      ​@@WlatPziupp They're bored by the time they have to enter the zip code

    • @AlkalineandAcid
      @AlkalineandAcid Год назад +1

      ​@@WlatPziuppHey guys!! We should all prove that we're not like those stupid Gen Alpha kids who are totally DOOMED like those *extremely* intelligent and *based* "video essayists" say by typing those 16 waaaacky numbers on our credit cards, the 3 numbers on the back and the date of expiryyyy!!! Wouldn't that be awesomesauce and totally wholesome??? I read the Kama Sutra and I have sex so I would know what's awesome 😎

    • @mvrk4044
      @mvrk4044 Год назад

      i mean it could be argued they dont have jobs because of their stupid attention spans

  • @YourBuddyDinec
    @YourBuddyDinec Год назад +4032

    I think that "Evil Pinely" channel has been ripping you off too. He even ripped off your channel name and your look and everything. It's nuts

    • @rainbowlack
      @rainbowlack Год назад +371

      i think you're reaching tbh. i see no resemblance whatsoever

    • @KingKazon99
      @KingKazon99 Год назад +66

      Pine nuts...

    • @vulpevulpevulpevulpevulpevulpe
      @vulpevulpevulpevulpevulpevulpe Год назад +180

      @@rainbowlack what do you mean? evil pinely even uses a pinely deepfake for his videos, pinely's very existance is being ripped off by evil pinely.

    • @a3wagner
      @a3wagner Год назад +119

      He's LITERALLY wearing your skin too.

    • @imjustjk
      @imjustjk Год назад +40

      Nah, it’s very obviously an AI

  • @Kalitayy
    @Kalitayy Год назад +1024

    I love how a RUclipsr named Zackary Smigel and some guy on Twitter said the next era could be the “authenticity era” because people are just tired of optimized, hyperedited, manufactured content and crave for authentic content made by people who are unapologetically being themselves. And of course, just as we predicted, now all of these spineless, passionless hustle culture bros are jumping ship and calling it “the new strategy”. We’ll then see massive corporations create vlog style RUclips videos with their presenters holding their mics a la independent RUclipsrs, while their script and editing are done underpaid employees.

    • @Pinely
      @Pinely  Год назад +188

      Zackary is great, def a youtuber to pay attention to :)

    • @demetriam2408
      @demetriam2408 Год назад +89

      We're already seeing it! There's an interesting video essay done on "why RUclipsrs hold their mics" and it features a couple companies that are already doing this.

    • @Frankfurtdabezzzt
      @Frankfurtdabezzzt Год назад +19

      I'm all in on supporting authentic small channels, but this microphone holding fad needs to end.

    • @shanel4294
      @shanel4294 Год назад +11

      They already are, when the kardashians are trying to be relatable we know there’s a problem. Big brands are posing as small one person owned businesses and content farms are trying to portray themselves as one person in their room.

    • @v_bunny
      @v_bunny Год назад +13

      @@Frankfurtdabezzztwhy? genuinely curious, never heard anyone have issues with holding the mic.

  • @Caraviaggio
    @Caraviaggio Год назад +1134

    I love how Tommy Tallarico helped James Somerton make this new and original video

  • @Alex-cw3rz
    @Alex-cw3rz Год назад +1249

    I love how after the 15 minute mark you revealed thia video was actually about James Somerton

  • @SeamusGorman4
    @SeamusGorman4 Год назад +300

    what the hell that guy at 9:50 looks just like me

    • @demetriam2408
      @demetriam2408 Год назад +38

      He's plagiarising because you're so popular now, watch out he might get your skin

    • @atrapdr6251
      @atrapdr6251 Год назад +9

      I haven’t seen you in a while man

    • @SammyJay107
      @SammyJay107 11 месяцев назад +7

      Was fun seeing you in this video!

    • @picahudsoniaunflocked5426
      @picahudsoniaunflocked5426 11 месяцев назад +2

      Your guest spot was killer!

  • @Alferia
    @Alferia Год назад +3528

    I love (This is sarcasm) how Hbomberguy puts out a 4 hour long video on plagiarism and the issue becomes semi-mainstream (Considering there were news articles on the subject) because people are now being explicitly told about the issue that has been here since RUclips really began.
    Skip about a month, and nobody seems to care anymore and people continue to plagiarize other videos so blatantly it's not even funny.
    Note: Edited this comment after realizing some apparent mistakes I made in the original claim I made. Also the "I love" statement was complete sarcasm. Hard to tell through text but worth pointing out.

    • @LeonLein82
      @LeonLein82 Год назад +10

      Why would you love that?

    • @bumblenbee4013
      @bumblenbee4013 Год назад

      They're being sarcastic ​@@LeonLein82

    • @Nakix4
      @Nakix4 Год назад +206

      @@LeonLein82 It's funny to see how lazy can people be

    • @sophiathenas
      @sophiathenas Год назад +92

      Seriously! This! Maybe I'm just better at noticing it now but I feel like I see this blatant plagiarism more and more.

    • @bingus288
      @bingus288 Год назад +18

      wow its my favorite weather youtuber

  • @CatOperated
    @CatOperated Год назад +406

    “The art of deception?” He has a course on picking up women, doesn’t he

    • @pieflower6419
      @pieflower6419 11 месяцев назад +1

      😂

    • @name.333
      @name.333 11 месяцев назад +21

      yes but he's not savvy enough to do it w flirting so he literally has to resort to kidnapping

    • @ClayJoTheBurninator
      @ClayJoTheBurninator 10 месяцев назад +11

      The look at 5:10 when he's talking gives me angry Tinder bio vibes. Like that guy is definitely going to eat your skin if you let your guard down around him.

  • @bratatouille
    @bratatouille Год назад +297

    For a solid ten minutes I thought you were calling him a "youtube Gru" and didn't even question it 💀

    • @demetriam2408
      @demetriam2408 Год назад +91

      "here is a course on how to steal ze moon!"

  • @joearnold6881
    @joearnold6881 Год назад +798

    Pinely has that
    Somerton Sadness

    • @renexaa
      @renexaa Год назад +46

      he's got that
      somerton somerton sadness

    • @anomalousanimates
      @anomalousanimates Год назад +2

      upderrated joke fr😭

    • @titsoutforlusikka
      @titsoutforlusikka Год назад +2

      I've got my turtleneck on tonight, dancing in the overused bisexual light,
      plagiarised my script up, commentary queen style
      Monotone voice, I'm feeling alive.
      Oh my god, I feel it in the air
      Hbomber chain reaction getting to me and my misogyny
      Honey, they're onto me, I feel it everywhere
      No apology video can save me anymore
      ...
      I got that Somerton, Somerton sadness

    • @yesaterisk5641
      @yesaterisk5641 Год назад +2

      Upderrated joke fr 😭

    • @llynxfyre
      @llynxfyre Год назад +1

      underrated joke fr 😂

  • @GiganticPawUnit
    @GiganticPawUnit Год назад +683

    Wait, at 10:54 the guy stealing the other guy's script says "a younger audience, who's got a shorter attention span and therefore less buying power." He thinks kids have low buying power BECAUSE they have short attention spans? Or he's just like, saying stuff without even understanding the idea of what he's repeating.

    • @zubetp
      @zubetp 11 месяцев назад +14

      the original guy's point was just that A. children don't have total control of money - they can't decide when to spend money, how much to spend, or what to spend it on; and B. because they're viewers with shorter attention spans, they're more likely to click away from your video unless you keep their attention. you need the viewer to watch the whole video, engage with the content, and sit through ads. that's how you make money as a youtuber. hence mr beast or morgz spending their whole videos hooting and hollering.
      the plagiarist changed the phrasing trying to sound smarter, so he kind of bungled the point. not that he cares.

  • @cardiganweather
    @cardiganweather Год назад +337

    I guess Oscar Owen just thought you had a really killer intro

    • @albailey2346
      @albailey2346 Год назад +17

      Lmao killer comment

    • @tyler.vitelli
      @tyler.vitelli 11 месяцев назад +1

      lmaoo this should have more likes

  • @penguinthepurple
    @penguinthepurple Год назад +130

    TomSka presents the "Somerton Scale" of plagiarism in one of his recent videos. He talks about how he's been affected by it, but also how he's ended up being on the scale himself at times. The plagiarism Pinely talks about sits firmly at the upper end of the scale.

  • @Sylvie-th
    @Sylvie-th Год назад +622

    I saw the thumbnail and thought the guy was dream with a beard

  • @rainbowlack
    @rainbowlack Год назад +760

    i miss grumbo. someone make Pinely a slightly bigger grumbo puppet. please

    • @ryshow9118
      @ryshow9118 Год назад +20

      I second that

    • @seguaye
      @seguaye Год назад +20

      I think im missing some pinely lore because to me, grumbo is grian and mumbo’s robot son from hermitcraft

    • @rainbowlack
      @rainbowlack Год назад +3

      @@seguaye it's both to me

    • @seguaye
      @seguaye Год назад +6

      just got to the grumbo part in the video, lol. Nice to see another hermit fan in the wild

    • @Gatorade69
      @Gatorade69 Год назад +10

      My cat's name is Grumbo... I think Pinely plagiarized me.

  • @undeadsweetheart7508
    @undeadsweetheart7508 Год назад +180

    OSCAR'S COMMENTS ARE PAUSED ALREADY. This video came out 3 hours ago so he has to be waiting for whenever Pinely uploads. Hbomberguy should mention this if he makes another RUclipsr plagiarists video

    • @Elle-elle-elle
      @Elle-elle-elle Год назад +13

      It's so funny how he needed to do that after this here RUclipsr literally told y'all not to go harass the dude who copied

    • @kanjonojigoku8644
      @kanjonojigoku8644 Год назад +70

      ​@@Elle-elle-ellecommenting that the video is plagiarized isn't harassment

    • @undeadsweetheart7508
      @undeadsweetheart7508 Год назад +33

      @@Elle-elle-elle I didn't intend on harassing them, I was just curious if they were going to address the accusations in the comments or description of something. I don't think it's considered harassment if you're just making others aware that their content is stolen though.

    • @cats9994
      @cats9994 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@undeadsweetheart7508yea harassment is like "this person should die for copying someone else"

    • @zubetp
      @zubetp 11 месяцев назад +9

      @@undeadsweetheart7508yeah that's something i noticed a couple years ago - danny gonzalez made a video about a minor public figure who was acting a fool on twitter, getting into arguments with random users who were then teasing her about the arguments she was getting into lol. and then he explicitly told people not to harass her, but it was a funny situation.
      but he ended up taking the video down because he felt people _were_ harassing her. when somebody is inundated with comments - even if the comments aren't harassing in nature - the result is that the person is being harassed in practice. individually, the comments weren't harassment, but two thousand of those comments might not be necessary.
      having said that, i still think that inundation is earned in this case. rather than closing the comments he should have taken down the video. because he stole it.

  • @scorpionqueen11
    @scorpionqueen11 Год назад +507

    Here to watch Pinely be evil...wait, wrong channel.

    • @LittleHerdaz
      @LittleHerdaz Год назад +40

      They are 2 different people, like Big Joel and Little Joel 😂

    • @scorpionqueen11
      @scorpionqueen11 Год назад +9

      @@LittleHerdaz You are absolutely right! I get them confused sometimes. 😅

    • @vulpevulpevulpevulpevulpevulpe
      @vulpevulpevulpevulpevulpevulpe Год назад +18

      @@scorpionqueen11 how could you ever mistake pinely for evil pinely?

    • @scorpionqueen11
      @scorpionqueen11 Год назад +17

      @@vulpevulpevulpevulpevulpevulpe It's like when I mistake decaf coffee for regular in my pantry. I just need my glasses next time!

  • @yourcutejeans6359
    @yourcutejeans6359 Год назад +208

    If I find out this guy also has a minion phone case I might start war

    • @kirrb-dot-exe
      @kirrb-dot-exe Год назад +14

      Man, wait til i tell you about this other random youtuber called Evil Pinely

  • @JakeWeddle
    @JakeWeddle 4 месяца назад +6

    Your mrsbeastification video resonated with me as a current and ex employee and as some one whose worked at 5+ multi million youtube companies

  • @lemolea9571
    @lemolea9571 Год назад +77

    The coward paused comments, edited out the intro and you can no longer see the like to dislike ratio. This is why youtube shouldn't be trying to phase out feedback, it allows people to unwittingly support stuff like plagiarism and bullying. Open feedback is important but all youtube is concerned about is how creators might feel. They can see the dislikes anyway! It just lets bad youtubers control their 'image'. You shouldn't be able to stop comments or hide dislikes.

    • @zubetp
      @zubetp 11 месяцев назад +1

      i think they should be able to pause comments - other users who might genuinely be receiving a lot of harassment or trolls on a particular video shouldn't be punished just because beta cucks like this plagiarist hide behind the feature.
      but i do agree that the changes to users' ability to vet content is entirely an image thing. i've always hated that change.

  • @nickk.2055
    @nickk.2055 Год назад +148

    Man's out here stitching up the body parts of a dozen different videos to create his demented RUclips masterpiece

    • @saltations_
      @saltations_ Год назад +19

      Frankenstein's RUclips Video

  • @asaucezac8469
    @asaucezac8469 Год назад +243

    I'd like to thank Tommy Talarico for this amazing video

  • @krisdone
    @krisdone Год назад +85

    the pinelyification pf youtube

  • @DominicGreene72
    @DominicGreene72 Год назад +86

    i don't think this was petty at all. It's actually just unfortunate to be wondering, in the back of my mind, if or how many of the videos i watch are ripped off someone else i should actually be watching, or that i would possibly enjoy watching more. (edit: i mean, i was already wondering that after hbomberguy, but this is a great refresher on it)

    • @sabresister
      @sabresister Год назад +2

      I have not been able to stop thinking about it since hbomb’s video. It’s so insidious

  • @neorennn
    @neorennn Год назад +206

    nice moustache pinely, atleast the RUclipsr can't copy that !

    • @tristysstuff6664
      @tristysstuff6664 Год назад +24

      I can imagine one of thse guru channels going into a lecture about hiw you should present yourself as on camera and mentioning growing a beard to appear as a sigma male

    • @Rose_Castle
      @Rose_Castle Год назад +21

      ​@@tristysstuff6664I hate all of the words you said in the order that you said them, please remedy this situation.

    • @tristysstuff6664
      @tristysstuff6664 Год назад +22

      @@Rose_Castle sigma male a as appear to beard a growing mentioning and camera on as yourself present should hiw about lecture a into going channels guru thse of one imagine can I

    • @Rose_Castle
      @Rose_Castle Год назад +14

      @tristysstuff6664 ....you just made me read it backwards. That is a power move and I'll hate you forever for it.

    • @wallowake3747
      @wallowake3747 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@Rose_CastleI love this whole interaction 😂

  • @DanielTGaming
    @DanielTGaming Год назад +11

    I was literally just watching that video, and then saw your video, and genuinely thought I clicked on the same video. Not only is this plagiarism, but it’s also continuining the MrBeastification of RUclips, as his video is actually wanting to PROMOTE this kind of video stuff.

  • @raysofmariehere6441
    @raysofmariehere6441 Год назад +51

    In a post James Somerton world no less

  • @blugip
    @blugip Год назад +523

    You’re so underrated. It hurts.

    • @phantomhiphop
      @phantomhiphop Год назад +6

      400,000 subs

    • @blugip
      @blugip Год назад +49

      @@phantomhiphop He definitely deserves more than that tho

    • @phantomhiphop
      @phantomhiphop Год назад +12

      @@blugip yeah but being underrated normally means like 10k or something not almost half a mill

    • @blugip
      @blugip Год назад +10

      @@phantomhiphop understandable

    • @blugip
      @blugip Год назад +1

      @Glorg445 Are you trying to correct me?

  • @Shr0nk.
    @Shr0nk. Год назад +44

    I was drawing while watching this video and so when you asked Seamus to come watch the clip I thought to myself “man when I was in my Disney phase I used to watch a RUclipsr named Seamus. Cool coincidence”. Then I actually looked at my screen and realized it’s the same Seamus!! Didn’t know you knew eachother 😮

  • @ab_3963
    @ab_3963 Год назад +85

    the pink background looks like a rupaul's drag race confessional lol

    • @zubetp
      @zubetp 11 месяцев назад +12

      at the end of the day, pinely's not here to make friends. he doesn't get ready, he stays ready.

  • @scpWyatt
    @scpWyatt Год назад +37

    I can’t believe hit celebrity RUclipsr Evil Pinely would do this to you! I used to think he was a such an honest sincere trustworthy genuine guy! Very saddened by this 😔

    • @kirrb-dot-exe
      @kirrb-dot-exe Год назад +1

      Wait til i tell you about Evil Pinely…

  • @potface6445
    @potface6445 Год назад +50

    Ive been watching you since the original dobrr brothers video and i just wanna say im so glad that youve grown as much as you have, keep being awesome pinely

    • @Pinely
      @Pinely  Год назад +40

      That video did so badly i cant believe anyone subscribed off of it

  • @strawberrywheels
    @strawberrywheels Год назад +177

    not only is "killer" such a specific descriptor, but those 2 youtubers sound like they are from very different regions. so the likelihood that they both just happen to live somewhere (country, region, or even household) that they pick up the phrase enough to say "killer youtube intro" is so slim 😭😭

    • @millesmedegaard
      @millesmedegaard Год назад +14

      That AND the fact that the cadence of the sentences were the EXACT same

  • @fulcrum2867
    @fulcrum2867 Год назад +103

    Seamus jumpscare, peak content

  • @eddy_is_crunchy5593
    @eddy_is_crunchy5593 Год назад +52

    So happy plagiarism on RUclips finally getting called out how it should be

  • @Site_42
    @Site_42 Год назад +29

    Next, we see the true power of mocking plagiarists over at Evil Pinely

    • @LiterallyScarecrow
      @LiterallyScarecrow Год назад +2

      DR SHERMAN!??

    • @rice-and-despairagus
      @rice-and-despairagus 11 месяцев назад +1

      YESSSS! I love seeing how a large portion of the SCP community is actually based and not filled with bigoted weirdos!

  • @Alex-cw3rz
    @Alex-cw3rz Год назад +56

    If someone has plagiarised one there is a high chance they have done it before

  • @YearinLou
    @YearinLou Год назад +12

    He's trying so hard in his intro; you can tell it's inauthentic.
    You’re lounging on your bed while he stiffly sits up. The way you react is humorously exaggerated. You show commitment by the way you move your body and the fear in your eyes. His effort was half-assed. It’s as if he’s timing when he needs to make a reaction. Like seriously, his facial expression piss me off.
    How you edited the camera stare is amazing. You are blended into fast paced videos as if you are forever trapped there. The pain in your face works with the visualization. He stares at the camera blankly. He isn’t fearful of the videos. His is giving “you guys seeing this?”He’s not as blended into the videos because he thinks the point is for him to be front and center.
    Your intro evokes an emotional reaction. It's a hook to keep the viewer watching. His reminds me of those people who steal viral videos and put their reaction in. It's so similar to your intro that it's void of substance.

    • @zubetp
      @zubetp 11 месяцев назад +2

      right, i agree! comparing original material to plagiarized material, it doesn't come across as authentic because they're not emotionally connected to what they're saying.
      i notice that with illuminaughtii videos. she reads with this monotonous tone, inadvertently changing the meaning of sentences by emphasizing the wrong words.
      same with james somerton. he's deleted now, but the only time he would get passionate and animated is when he would break from the plagiarism to add in weird lies and comments about how much he hates women lol.
      you can tell what a person actually cares about because you can tell they're engaging with it on a more fundamental level - it's coming from a place of genuinity.
      it doesn't evoke the same response - but people still engage with it if they don't know it's stolen, because it's good content.

  • @janecheer
    @janecheer Год назад +14

    Lol, Oscar cut that video by around 20 seconds, completely getting rid of the intro, and paused the comments, this is hysterical

    • @Mortal209
      @Mortal209 Год назад +7

      @@oscar It's understandable to prevent harassment but you literally just copied others all while trying basically sell your own spiel. You're trying to market yourself as a RUclips guru who can help people grow their channel, you're not a guru and you can't help people grow their channels. You're lying to people and to yourself in order to get views on a second channel in hopes that it goes viral but it never will because you made the mistake of trying to become a RUclips guru - and they all have the exact same videos, all 1k+ of them, you're trying to mirror them while you were stealing content from others to make yourself look like some kind of editing genius for marketing. I've never heard of you until I saw this video but I have no interest of ever checking out either of your channels now because of it. There's a difference between "Hey I fully admit I fucked up, I'm sorry about that, from here on out I will be doing things differently" and "Hey, I'm going to quietly turn off comments to my videos because I'm getting a lot of abusive comments from people. I'm not going to address the fact that I fucked up except for in comments on the video exposing me days after the video had been posted". You could have addressed the situation, turned off comments and informed the people that you were contacting everyone you copied and were apologizing. There is so much that you could have done but you didn't because you want to pretend this never happened, but it did happen and it's on the internet forever now. You should have gotten out in front of it, admitted you messed up and just took it, but you seem incapable of doing just that. Also you have very low view counts on your videos meaning your clickbait thumbnails aren't working as well and RUclips is pushing you away from the algorithm, which is something people who understand RUclips far better than you do have been explaining for years.

  • @your-local-anon
    @your-local-anon Год назад +43

    its a good day to be a fan of the small channel in a situation like this

  • @unitedstatesofamericareal
    @unitedstatesofamericareal Год назад +45

    plagiarism on youtube: a 9 hour dissertation when

    • @bigpooper4156
      @bigpooper4156 Год назад +1

      I think hbomberguy did like 4 hours worth

  • @ko379
    @ko379 Год назад +18

    Pinely I found your videos a few months ago bc I was sick of true crime stuff being recommended to me and looked up anti true crime to see what I can find. I’ve enjoyed everything by you since, even the pickle Rick video, and I hate adult animation. You just have such a great tone and you feel very real and charismatic in your videos. Love your stuff!

  • @zimbu_
    @zimbu_ Год назад +22

    They're not copying because they like the video or because they want to be youtubers. The reason it's shot for shot and line for line is because they think most youtubers are suckers for focusing more on scripting and planning shots than on maximizing the monetization. They're not interested in watching RUclips videos or making videos to connect with an audience, they're just here to make money, they just work here.

  • @neivilde.1242
    @neivilde.1242 Год назад +9

    nothing could've prepared me for that seamus cameo. it's like on one hand, this is 2 different worlds i never expected to collab, and on the other, it makes the most sense

  • @ekitkatt
    @ekitkatt Год назад +19

    Can’t wait for “I’m pretty sure this guy plagiarised my video (Owen’s Version)”

    • @zubetp
      @zubetp 11 месяцев назад +1

      lmfao right! it would actually be kind of fire if he just copied _this_ video note for note, baselessly accusing pinely of plagiarism. i don't want him to truthfully, but it _would_ be kind of funny.

  • @ScrungleCat
    @ScrungleCat Год назад +25

    the british keep stealin'

    • @zubetp
      @zubetp 11 месяцев назад +6

      lmfao, catch those videos in the british museum

    • @KL6Soup
      @KL6Soup 10 месяцев назад

      🫳🏻
      🖼️
      🧳

  • @LukaDoncicLikesGiraffes
    @LukaDoncicLikesGiraffes Год назад +17

    He just paused all comments on his second channel. What’s crazier too is that he’s very clearly buying subscribers on his main channel. His most recent video has 7k views in 6 days with 1.3 million subs? That just doesn’t add up. And if you read the comments on any video there’s a lot of obvious bot comments.

  • @kweebec
    @kweebec Год назад +16

    Honestly this is just disappointing to see. The RUclips growth/strategy/advise space does have some really great thought leaders and people who haven't got a course tied to every tweet, but most are either drowned out by gurus and ex-dropshipping coaches or choose to stay quieter and converse with creators elsewhere.
    The space had really only just started to flourish around 2020 when a new wave of younger well-informed, and experienced creators started teaching what they knew, but it's so quickly become clouded by people who have no idea what they're talking about or just parrot the information of far more established sources.

  • @ninskdesign
    @ninskdesign Год назад +94

    There is a trend in the three examples shown that makes me incredibly uncomfortable… really hope he’s lifted from creators in his same demographic because otherwise the copying isn’t the worst thing about him. The irony of him discussing authenticity lol.

    • @doctorworm420
      @doctorworm420 Год назад +54

      I noticed this too I think stealing entirely of creators of colour factors in to the choices because he knows they are often underrepresented and that the algorithm will support him

    • @zubetp
      @zubetp 11 месяцев назад +2

      iiii noticed that too lol. 😬 i hope it's a coincidence and he's not _actively_ targeting them, but ultimately the result is the same regardless.

  • @esobelisk3110
    @esobelisk3110 11 месяцев назад +8

    he even falls into the trap that hbomberguy pointed out a lot in his video, where he tries to change up the words to make them sound different, and ends up saying something that doesn’t make any sense.
    at 10:55, he rewords a sentence about a correlation between attention span, age, and spending power, and accidentally says that younger people have “[…] a shorter attention span, and *therefore* less buying power,” which is a type of error that he probably wouldn’t have made if he was writing about a conclusion he had come to himself, as opposed to rewording someone else’s script.

  • @xolotl5224
    @xolotl5224 Год назад +35

    The dislikes are Oscar Owen and his 2 alt accounts

  • @xxvmvxx
    @xxvmvxx Год назад +63

    actually after matching with "Pinely" and going on a date, paying for the drinks then paying for the youtube course im actually directly harmed by this. only now do I realize

  • @kateolwill8645
    @kateolwill8645 Год назад +10

    the point made at 11:15 is so true like the term pester power has been around for at least 50 years. a major discussion in my children’s literature class was about how children a lot of access to buying power because they don’t understand the value of money or have other monetary concerns and they can wear their parents down until they get whatever they want. we don’t just have laws regulating advertising to children for no reason lmao

  • @area51l
    @area51l Год назад +3

    Most people probably won't notice, but I love that you used Coalescence from Risk of Rain as your background music at around 15:00. Great game, even better soundtrack! I had to rewind because my excitement at noticing the song distracted me from the point you were making lmao

  • @AngelOfUnseen
    @AngelOfUnseen Год назад +21

    Sir, how dare you steal this video from Tommy Tallarico, his mother was very proud.

  • @hell0mega
    @hell0mega Год назад +106

    maybe im looking too far into this, but i couldn't help but notice he copied an Asian guy, a woman, and you... "plagiarists copy those they believe are below them" -hbomberguy....

    • @_-Lx-_
      @_-Lx-_ Год назад +5

      That's probably overthinking it,
      Unless we see spesific evidence otherwise,
      No reason to play the race/gender card, more likely dude is just a serial theif, and views other creators in general lower, likely would have stole from many others too.

    • @arowace498
      @arowace498 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@_-Lx-_ isn't the fact that he happened to avoid plagerising from white men in itself evidence?

  • @shadowdecidueye
    @shadowdecidueye 11 месяцев назад +7

    I was NOT expecting Seamus Gordon to be in this video, I was thinking "that guy kinda looks like Seamus." Then I heard him speak and I was so shocked. First, these RUclipsrs aren't even both commentary RUclipsrs so I never expected to see them together, and second, it's not even a full collab it's like Seamus and Pinley live together. I am so confused...

    • @straww_berryyy
      @straww_berryyy 11 месяцев назад

      he reminded me of my cringe HP disney era

  • @kirbsplayer2098
    @kirbsplayer2098 Год назад +9

    It's insane how people still think they can get away with this. Especially after that bomberguy vid.

  • @Numptaloid
    @Numptaloid Год назад +8

    Just in case you guys get some bad ideas after seeing this: Oscar may be a horrendous thief, but he is also a human. Look, but don't touch.

  • @chromerot
    @chromerot Год назад

    BRO as soon as I saw the video you were referencing I received the whiplash too because just a few days ago I posted 4 links in my discord that were basically that exact same video about the editing style but by 4 different people all uploaded within the last few weeks jfc. these youtube "gurus" steal so much, I have more examples too

  • @sunflowervivids
    @sunflowervivids Год назад +19

    he's already removed the video and turned off all comments on all videos 😭😭😭😭😭 poor lil fella is scared of the consequences of his actions

  • @arlynnecumberbatch1056
    @arlynnecumberbatch1056 Год назад +11

    THE COMMENTS ARE PAUSED 💀💀
    i just realized he deleted comments calling him out by hand thats crazy

  • @GeorgeTheDinoGuy
    @GeorgeTheDinoGuy Год назад +21

    Pinely but I don’t have a crush on him

  • @Boggythefroggy
    @Boggythefroggy 11 месяцев назад +5

    18:35 I found Bobby Fingers from Tom Scott mentioning him on a podcast and it is really something special. I love that more people are finding his channel bc it is just pure art lmao.

  • @sad_doggo2504
    @sad_doggo2504 Год назад +8

    Art vs. business. These guys are such predatory shells, but you see them everywhere now, with the growing online industry.

  • @talonhammer
    @talonhammer Год назад +4

    Pinely, Orr (that's your real name by the way) I have been watching you for years and it shocks me how overlooked you are. The Pickle Rick video deserves a Tony Award.

  • @THEDeadSnake
    @THEDeadSnake 11 месяцев назад +6

    Looks like that channel pulled its own vanishing act!

  • @DrDiogoMoura
    @DrDiogoMoura 9 месяцев назад +4

    Aqui no brasil os RUclipsrs literalmente traduzem os vídeos de RUclipsrs americanos para o português e são aplaudidos porque ninguém nunca vai descobrir

  • @shuddabinswollode
    @shuddabinswollode Год назад +58

    this oscar guy is slimy as fuck, but the fact that hes seemingly consistently ripping off poc in particular??? what the hell

  • @rickytebbe
    @rickytebbe 9 месяцев назад +2

    Dude VidIQ, a month after this video. Same topic, same thumbnail. Lmao it's crazy!
    "This NEW Editing style is Taking over RUclips"

  • @naailasiddiqi
    @naailasiddiqi Год назад +2

    Omg a wild Seamus sighting!!
    Love that guy but haven't seen him upload in while
    Great to see him here!

  • @MG142-k9b
    @MG142-k9b 9 месяцев назад +1

    11:02. Purchasing power of children is small from a business point of view. The gurus point is valid, but your angles phinley are on point . Keep at it ! Nice video!

  • @hauntedsunsets
    @hauntedsunsets Год назад +4

    the point about how "fast editing isn't necessarily inauthentic" made me think about pointcrow and alpharad off the bat, two youtubers with relatively fast-paced and upbeat editing compared to a lot of the other youtubers I watch. their videos being quick and heavily edited doesn't prevent them from being authentic, because I can see so much how they often enjoy what they're doing. seeing that someone is passionate about what they're doing or even just enjoying themselves does so much work than the literal style of the video
    but if you're always stealing other people's work you can't be authentic! it is inherently inauthentic to present someone else's words or art as your own, let alone how disrespectful it is to do something like that. you'll never be truly passionate about something you've stolen, you won't look happy doing something that exists purely for manipulating the algorithm - so they have to turn authentic into an editing style to use it at all

  • @RadikaRules
    @RadikaRules Год назад +2

    I was thinking about the hbomberguy video when I started watching (On my TV) and was gonna comment
    about it, but turns out Pinely beat us all to the punch with the description. Well done, very well

    • @zubetp
      @zubetp 11 месяцев назад

      oh shit i didn't even see the description lmao!

    • @RadikaRules
      @RadikaRules 11 месяцев назад

      @@zubetp I used to always read it on every video years ago, nowadays I hardly even read it. So I get that

  • @okarthegreat
    @okarthegreat 11 месяцев назад +5

    As a member of the 'People named Oscar' association, I want to clarify that this guy's actions are of his own accord and do not reflect the beliefs or morals of the organization as a whole. Thank you.

    • @larissabrglum3856
      @larissabrglum3856 11 месяцев назад +6

      I know a dog named Oscar and he would definitely never plagiarize

  • @TheAsherShow
    @TheAsherShow Год назад +2

    8:40 All of these videos have been recommended to me. Little did I know they were all cookie cutter copies of each other

  • @thesingingtown
    @thesingingtown Год назад +8

    You don't seem petty. You came off as admirably forgiving tbh, far more than most would be!

  • @DonnaIRL
    @DonnaIRL Год назад +3

    So, what you're saying is the way to sell a course is plagiarize a Pinely video?

    • @iqzario4animations203
      @iqzario4animations203 Год назад +1

      Oh hey Donna! Your video on Fidias made me realise how much trashy RUclipsrs I used to watch and really tried to clean up my subscriptions😅

  • @05AT1
    @05AT1 Год назад +4

    Interestingly enough, Oscar Owen disabled comments on his videos not long after this video was released,

  • @jamespondy0
    @jamespondy0 Год назад +5

    I'm more surprised about how many RUclipsrs use the Risk of Rain soundtrack suddenly.

  • @josieschultz4241
    @josieschultz4241 Год назад +5

    I went to the guy's channel and he paused all the comments and looks like he deleted all the negative ones. I hate this guy so much

  • @izzybel9682
    @izzybel9682 Год назад +11

    bruh he PAUSED his comments after this came out

  • @poshdelux
    @poshdelux Год назад +18

    I understand that there is this unspoken/ spoken rule amongst RUclipsr's not to step on smaller channels. Yet calling out someone's wrongdoing should be necessary when it comes down to plagiarizing and copying.

  • @celetial3287
    @celetial3287 11 месяцев назад +5

    omg seamus gorman surprise appearance⁉️⁉️⁉️⁉️i didn’t know you guys were friends

  • @Theye101499
    @Theye101499 Год назад +11

    He even has the bisexual lighting, where is the shame

  • @cardianboardson
    @cardianboardson 11 месяцев назад +3

    seamus was a jumpscare, havent watched him in years

  • @victorparra5350
    @victorparra5350 10 месяцев назад +4

    Bro got James Somertoned

  • @Killysunt
    @Killysunt Год назад +2

    I find the idea of a RUclips guru so strange, it's easy to take influence from a bunch of stuff you watch, chuck your personality in & have it stand on it's own two feet without directly ripping anyone off

  • @lenapawlek7295
    @lenapawlek7295 Год назад +3

    I cant believe he legit thought this was okay - im so sorry this happened to you pinely :(

  • @MikeSmedleyOLDSCHOOLSTRIPERS
    @MikeSmedleyOLDSCHOOLSTRIPERS 6 месяцев назад +2

    GREAT! Now he’s gonna copy THIS video and call it “How to take the high road after a low-life THEIF has ripped you off”.
    Well done Pinely.

  • @Itsmyrap
    @Itsmyrap Год назад +14

    So nobody learned anything from Hbomberguy video ? Nothing at all?

    • @_-Lx-_
      @_-Lx-_ Год назад

      No, a number of people did, not all of course.
      Many such as myself, are more on guard and suspicious when seeing off details though.
      And more people are checking things they feel they may be noticing red flags on now.

  • @Wasa8i2
    @Wasa8i2 Год назад +4

    oh boy it seems like, super coincidentally, Oscar Owen turned off any new comments on his video's, preventing people from giving backlash! surely that is 100% coincidental and totally not him avoiding the consequences of his actions, it cant be! surely all these extremely positive comments on his videos must be telling the truth! what a genius internet guru that guy is!

  • @_Stagnate_
    @_Stagnate_ 10 месяцев назад +3

    He's still doing it. It sucks that he's getting away with it and that his main channel has such a high subscriber count.

  • @pestkaislearning
    @pestkaislearning 3 месяца назад +1

    that is so insanely embarassing, i am personally embarassed for this guy

  • @Moltens
    @Moltens Год назад +4

    seamus cameo ?!
    also banger video as always piney pine pineson pinester