Why most visual effects suck--but some don't | Wren Weichman | TEDxPenn
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 окт 2019
- Why can't we stop noticing bad visual effects whenever we go to the movies, even though VFX technology has never been better and film budgets have never been bigger? RUclips star Wren Weichman is an engineer turned self-taught visual effects artist. As a crew member at Corridor, Wren makes cinema-quality videos chock full of eye-popping visual effects. Drawing on the experience of his movie fandom and professional career, Wren details the visual effects pipeline to shed light on how even well-intentioned effects can go wrong and why the very best effects may have the ones you never even noticed at all. As a crew member at Corridor, RUclips’s premier cinema quality channel, Wren Weichman has seen more than his fair share of visual effects. Since their inception, visual effects have constantly grown more prominent in film and other productions, to the point where we can’t stop notic- ing them. Backed by his years of real-world experience in the field, Wren will unpack how and why visual effects are ruining movies but also how the very best effects can be an art form that you may have never noticed. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at www.ted.com/tedx
*wren:*
talks about complicated video editing
*tedx:*
doesn't even sync the audio
It keeps bugging me, I wanna watch this but the desynced audio is infuriating.
@@IncredibleFlyinSquid Just listen to it, they forget to show most of the clips he's talking about anyway.
@@IncredibleFlyinSquid Watch him cover it on Corridor! It's basically the same talk.
Noticed the same thing.
@@IncredibleFlyinSquid Just have it playing in the background while you're doing something else. They don't really show anything visual that is relevant to his discussion.
"No film is ever finished, it just gets released."
Great Quote
Books are the same. All the authors I heard talking about it say that at some point they must stop working on their book, stop rewriting passages, stop refining it, and just release it.
@@bobiboulon same with music
I went down to the comment section and saw this comment exactly when he said it. Wow
@emilio robles Actually, since George was constantly unsatisfied and re released edited versions of his films, I think George is a very big user of that mindset.
Oh man no.... Look at what George Lucas did. 40 years later and Star wars still not finished and it never will. One day Leia will shot Han in the Cantina scence, trust me
Wren: "If something is slightly off, audiences can tell that it is fake"
TED: *audio begins to not sync*
It really makes his point, though.
It was messing with my mind.
Especially at the parts where he was talk fast
Yeah lol
It looks like a frame rate issue? They kept the lav mic audio but the other clips were in different frame rates, I’m guessing. Don’t think there’s any way to fix this without distorting video or audio.
It sucks that most of the clips he’s talking about aren’t even shown...
Brandon Gregory they have an actual video with this stuff.. they reused the script
@Keita Lafleur élève Copyright laws in America (both where this talk was given and where the companies were based which made these movies) allow for brief clips for illustration. So this would have gotten around those laws.
@Keita Lafleur élève copyright
@@andrewsparkes8829 That may be true, but tell that to TED Talk folk. Wren (the speaker here) has said that the reason his video took soooo long to come out compared to other videos from the same show was because of the video material he used being copyrighted.
@@andrewsparkes8829 yes but people will still strike you for those copyright infringements and it can be very difficult to get around them even with the law on your side
Plot twist: Wren is CGI the whole talk
Dun dun DUUUUUUUUUNNNNN!!!!!
Wren IS CGI. He doesn't exist.
Vsauce music starts...
its just a deepfake, lol
Now that you mentioned it I can definitely see it.
I feel all the Corridor fans are just Wren’s mom being like: THATS MY SON RIGHT THERE!
Hi
Totally
Proud
I love all the corridor guys, but I have a soft spot for Wren. Such a pure dude.
Hahaha you're so right
Are we all corridor fans here in the comment???
😂
Yes
Yep
Uhm yes 😁
animalamu yep
Yesirino
Epic talk, unepic editing
Hey Dude, nice singing🌚
watch the edited version on Corridor Digital where all the shots they did cut out here are still in.
@@eziothedeadpoet where is that?
@@thatpianoboi4082 at the Corridor Crew channel
@@thatpianoboi4082 on their channel. It is 10000x better.
Waiting for the episode, " VFX artists react to ted talk."
Ravi Shirpali waiting for curry 🍛
@@jake_runs_the_world , Spicy one. 😅😅
They would be reacting to themselves... Corridor crew does those reactions :D
Yes
@@jake_runs_the_world CGI curry
Wren: Look at this!
Camera: no, i dont think i will.
Cringe
Eskiela Vatsabel he’s right tho
Nice captain America reference
The stuff were copyrighted so they couldn’t show
@@eskielavatsabel2842 he's right
It's fine, i didn't want to see the slides anyway.
Hey I made it 400 likes
@Barry Mahoney epic😂😂
@Barry Mahoney it was 421 I removed my like just like Elon removed some price from Tesla
copyright reasons perhaps
@@MrHerecomesjohnny the clips are used for educational purposes, so it shouldn’t really fall under copyright abuse
Wren: "Take a look at this shot from 'Logan'.
Camera man........"what year is it?"
@Corby Dorian No that guy above u said better
they couldn't show the shots for copyright reasons
@@orionsebastian1375 Yep
Hahahaha
@@orionsebastian1375 @Nate C Wrong, this would be the perfect case for "educational use" of copyrighted material, which would fly under fair use
*"No Tedx talk is ever edited completely, it just gets uploaded"*
@Kalle Nilsson I thought exactly the same.
Kalle Nilsson education
QuantumBullet ✔️ doesn't matter if it's educational auto bots will still claim it so it's better to not do it
Didint he say that about movies
meanwhile the audio is not syncd
wren: look at this great example
camera:
wren: artistry
camera; * shows the slide with the text "artistry" *
It's probably because they were worried about copy right claims
For a version with the clips intact and the sound synced, you can find it on the Corridor Crew channel titled "VFX Artist Explains What's Wrong With Modern CGi".
@@Epicurus341 yeah I saw that. thank you
@@Epicurus341 That's not the TED talk version tho. It's just a shortend version recorded in their studio.
@@annekedebruyn7797 Actually it's the other way around - all those examples are showed in a lot more depth in their own videos.
For all the anxiety Wren went through to prepare for that moment, this vid is just not serving justice ... duh. You should ask the Corridor to edit it, for real.
They did actually, check it out on the corridor crew channel.
@Ervin rahmanovic Search for “What’s Bad About Modern CGI”
Audience: Laughs
Wren: Smiles and looks up at slide show
Camera: Stays perfectly still
Me: Wow I enjoyed that funny joke...
@El Señor Xan that 8snt how copyright works
@El Señor Xan yea but it's being used in a transformative wayb
@@MrGameManIsCool no, it isnt.
@@Han-pd8rw You dont know what he means by transformative because it definitively is
@@Han-pd8rw Transformative refers to using content in a educationally way, such as with Wren here, who is using content in a transformative, educational perception. They can show this, cause it's for educate purposes.
Sound: Not in sync
Slides: They existed in this talk?
What the cgi TED???
Saksham Dwivedi It’s almost like a bad visual effect...
They remade the video on the CorridorCrew channel. It's fantastic.
Yeah, bad just bad
Dude its because of copyright issues from all shots from movies. Wren talked about it on corridor crew. Why does no one get that in this comment section.
That's why it took this long to upload. They weren't allowed to use any of the slides for RUclips.
Wren was so stressed for this. Proud of my boi
He was Stressed, Bruised and Almost Having a Panic Attack...😂😂
Ikr I am so glad it went well
This is easily the most poorly cut together Ted talk I have ever watched, change angles when appropriate, insert shots of the projector dammit! Wren deserves better.
Yes.
Wren: "Do you notice anything strange abot this shot?"
TED: Shows nothing...
oh i get it lol
Wren: "If something is slightly off, audiences can tell that it is fake"
TED: Biting their nails
i read the quote as he said it.. i swear this happens every bloody time XD
Ocealot P DUDE ME TOO
mouse mice the audio is slightly off in the video. That’s the joke
i think we should actually see the slides when he’s describing them.
They couldn't show them for copyright reasons, I think.
you can find the whole thing on the corridor crew channel
@@stephaniebaker1975 idk i really cant. Link? Went to the channrl i only found the documentary
@@bonzwah1 it's called "vfx artist explains what is wrong with cgi" or something similar to that. It's not explicitly stated to say ted talk on it.
@@bonzwah1 lookup the corridor crew channel, theres a full video there with video examples.
“THOSE PORES STRETCH”
Anakin,”I don’t like pores. It gets everywhere.”
I can hear Niko's voice, my god
Who else watched this even after having watched the Corridor Crew video?
Me
Yessir
Me
I realized half way through but I gotta finish it for my boy
@@niteoflite3903 dude same
Amazing job by Wren though I wish they had showed more of his slides.
(I realize now that they could not show his slides becouse they would get copyright striked and that the full Talk is on the corridor crew channel)
not syncing up his slide show to the video makes this a fail, where it would have been very interesting.
Could be TED taking the safe route not showing any unlicensed images.
Well he posted the talk on the corridor crew channel with the slides
@@James-ho5teI saw their video first actually.
I'm saying it could be TED leaning on the side of caution.
I was also thrown off because it's not the polished production quality normally seen from a ted talk video.
@@thenakedcableguy That's pretty much correct. Wren commented on the making of video that them getting this video up would take a while longer as they had to figure out what to do with all the licensed imagery in his slides. This was the only way they could comfortable upload the talk.
This was a TED talk about bad CGI, but it turned into a TED talk about bad audio.
The sync goes off pretty quickly.
I’m proud of Wren being on stage on Tedx Talk
Leonardo da Vinci: “Art is never finished, only abandoned.”
Dicaprio*
@@Sanstiag0 *when the FBI responds*
Me: time to go underground.... Bravo six going dark.
Dude am such a corridor fan that I already know 99% of his references
I know, I was thinking that that's the only thing they can say but it's because there is probably who haven't seen them
I heard his speech before in their channel
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
F***ing same dude!
The man, the myth, the Wrender
When your documentary on how to do a Ted talk gets more views than the Ted talk.
Oof
Well this videos only been out 2 days
I mean most people probably already have seen this ted talk since he made the talk in video format, too.
haha
Truth.
When Wren makes a joke but nobody laughs:
"DisaPPOINTED"
I’m pretty sure the audience was laughing, TED just records the presenter and the audience separately so you can only hear only the presenter and not the audience.
@@totallynotmatt7407 but i can hear them sometimes
@@sjaplayz8281 that means the audience made so much noise, it got picked up by the mic on Wren
Everytime
Editing wise this has to be the worst TED talk I have seen to date.
You've heavily edited out content that is key to the talk - It really doesn't work without it. And yes there is a definite copyright issue, but you don't have to argue hard for educational and critique here. You're more than big enough to have your lawyer contact theirs and get a license deal going if need be.
The heavy editing has left the audio and video completely out of sync - Which is impressive for a FIFTEEN MINUTE video. How did you not spot and handle this?
That audience was really not buying his jokes huh.
It's okay Wren, I laughed 😉
It's conceivable they are so taken with him & his talk.
That's what happens when you take a very lively and humorous guy and tell him he was to suppress some of his natural personality to fit the formal standards and time limits of a TedTalk. For his first time ever, the boy was riding the high waves, and staying there
Audience wasnt micd. They laughed at a lot of his stuff dude
@@KZ-hu9uj I'm glad to hear it. He's always really fun to listen to.
That's because the audience was cgi too
I don't know what is it, but I feel nervous watching Wren performance like myself on the stage in front of people. Maybe it's come after watching Wren's video about preparing for this.
The fear is relatable we have all been there at some point
Same. I think it's because I sensed his nervousness at the start of his talk.
Without prior knowledge of Wren (outside of seeing some of corridor digital’s viral videos), I could also sense his nervousness. The tone here was a bit off. Almost as if he cared more about giving a good talk and being liked than expressing thought provoking ideas. Not to say he failed at either. Just a little different.
yea haha
That would be called "empathy"
Out of everyone on the corridor team I would of never thought Wren would do a TED Talk.
Super glad he did tho. I would love to sit down and just spend a day talking to him, and learn just what goes on in that mind of his.
I could have kinda seen it; he knows how to articulate what he wants to say and talks about it with so much passion. But yeah, Niko or Jake could have been on that stage.
@@kylewitter2806 Definitely Niko, Jake would've told everyone to get a corridor code and have a discount on squarspace
He is most engaging and enthusiastic, so makes sense. If Nico did one, it would probably end up being a bit dry.
We should stop complaining about all of it and congratulate Wren for getting a TED talk in the first place.
Damn, this audio is more out of sync than my life.
I'm saying lmao
Wait that wasn't just my device???
Wireless microphone delay
@@Wooktent lol i was confused too
Rock Animations my isn’t?Oh I see it now
I'm missing a couch. Also, would've been really nice to see what he's talking about considering he's talking about *VISUAL* effects.
He has made the same video on his channel corridor channel
@@snehchao8042 Did not know that, only seen the crew channel. thanks
@@jojokob5182 Wait, you really haven't heard of the Parent Channel to Corridor Crew? Dude, I'm actually jealous, because you can watch all of their videos for the first time.
TED won't show it because of copyright reasons
@@SleepinGriffin Just never bothered to check it out for some reason but what you just said is a great selling point. gonna go check it out!
*Wren talks about a video*
Camera: ”I’m gonna end this TED Talks career”
Editor: I'm about to end my own career
I only came here for Wren cuz I respect him and the rest of the crew at Corridor
Giving a Ted speech is quite the task, specially when you never gave a speech before. It's obvious that Wren struggled, but he did it. Well done.
TEDx*. It's far from the same.
They posted a bts video in preparation for the talk. He got hella stressed
If you want more of Wren, then google "corridor crew vfx artist". There are a couple of videos where Wren explains things, like the size of planets for example
The VFX artists did a great job with compositing Wren onto the stage. Kudos to you guys!
XD
It's Wren yay
I love the whole corridor crew and I’m so proud of Wren!!!
"do you see this shot?"
no Wren teddy is only making me love your side profile
😂
Ted stands for technology, entertainment, design , not someone’s name
jerrod anderson whoosh
@@buffoonbeats1314 Teddy told us otherwise
@@buffoonbeats1314 You just can't stand a joke, do you?
Wren deserves some props for his video on how he prepared for this Ted Talk, it was extremely informative, relatable and motivational. Having the confidence to speak in front of large crowds is no easy task, well done.
I literally have the beginning of this memorized because I watched wren practice it so much in the corridor video 😂
Same
Everyone : *Normal Comments*
Me : I KNOW CORRIDOR CREW , I KNOW...
Is this CGI?!
No lip sync...
and where did all his slides go?!
Fix it and reupload it so we get the whole feeling!
Hugo they removed most of the slides for copyright reasons, try watching the video diary of it on the corridor care channel, all the slides and bts of this talk is there and it’s just amazing
Corridor crew made their own version of this mess of a video, go watch that
Yeah, I've seen that video it was cool. Sad they had to remove it from the real thing due to copyright though...
They released their own form of it with all the slides feel free to go check out corridor crew for it
can someone drop me a link i cant seem to find it
To anyone that wants to see the version with the slides, Wren made a video essay based on this talk over on the Corridor Crew channel with the video clips that were edited out.
It's titled: VFX artist explains what's wrong with modern CGI
+
^
I love how camera-man/stream-guy of tedx shows presenter when he is commenting something on presentation and shows it when there is noting interesting in it.
When wren said 💦 I felt that
🤣
relatable
I swear ted talk mics pick up all the spit
Who else here is a corridor fan and have waited for this for months?????!!!! Awesome job Wren!!!
The Raven right? They told us about it like a year ago. And I messaged wren on Twitter about it like 2montjs ago and he said it’s gonna be released any day now. And now finally months later -.- and then the editors mess up :(
Me :D
yes!!!
Me
"No film is ever finished. It just gets released" - I like that:)
TED Talks - Extremely professional, perfect audio, and perfect video
TEDx Talks - "Just make some intern do it"
“If you look at this image”
Doesn’t show image
*Wren talking about amazing CGI*
Look at this shot from this movie!
Camera: *...*
Sound: *out of sync*
I love how the Wrender sorta did the talk the same way he does his breakdown videos :)
"The wrender", I love that
it’s almost like there’s an entire video about it
@@LittleBit0Everything The video is based off this talk
@@LittleBit0Everything The video is based on this. It even says its the TED talk in video essay form.
Jeez! No way it's been 4.5 years since this released! Time flies!
Wren: _makes a joke_
Audience:
Wren: "Well anyway..."
Fun Fact: Wren's last name translates to "Softman" in German
tinyruin sounds accurate
Hes a soft boi
That's explain a lot
It also could be translated to "begone Man"
And probably a lot else, if you'd dig deeper into old germanic language 😊
Think he puts to much into his VFX career and his identity at Corridor to compensate?
Team Corridor !!
Wren: "No film is ever finished, it just gets released"
Only meant to watch a little of this, ended up watching all of it. Wren’s passion is infectious, and I’m here for it.
You did amazingly wren, props to you and stomaching all the stress it took to achieve this
*VFX* ARTIST Reacts to *GREAT* & *BAD* *TED* *TALKS*
Well, the talk is great but this video doesn't do it justice.
Damn that Jurassic Park quote went right over the audiences head
I laughed Wren, I laughed
Love you wern
Its wren xD
who is wern?
and I love YOU Pikapetey Animations
"wern"
Wern is mi faovurit vfx artuist
Gotta love Wren, had severe anxiety all the way up to this TED talk and smashed it
I had the video at 1.25x speed before it started and didn't realise. I thought he was just THAT amped for this.
Wooooo! Been waiting for this video
I'm so happy for our little Wrender! So happy his anxiety and fear leading up to this gave way to an amazing talk.
I liked 14:50 how he realized he is at the end of the talk here, how he just has to say "thank you" and it filled him with so much relief and joy
I'm amazed by his knowledge and how he can express himself so well
If you look on the Corridor Crew channel, you'll find a version of this talk that they turned into a little visual essay, with all the clips and examples we didn't in this video. Also, the performance is a lot smoother as Wren isn't exactly happy talking to an auditorium, but if genuinely fantastic talking to a camera. And to be fair, both Corridor and Corridor Crew are channels that are worth checking out anyway if you're even remotely interested in cgi and cinematography!
Watched all of him and his friend's reaction videos to good and bad CGI. This guy knows what he's talking about.
have u read quran annie
The editing behind this video is soooo bad.
SP3CTR0M_Brendan X has nothing to do with it, editing on this video is bad. Try to be on topic kid.
@SP3CTR0M_Brendan X Okay, better than our editing skills but it doesn't make the editing good lmao
@SP3CTR0M_Brendan X Doesn't mean that they can't criticize someone's mistakes. Just because someone can't edit doesn't mean that everything they say about something is automatically void, whoever edited this video didn't show the slides and didn't sync the audio. That's a mistake on their end, this doesn't mean a professional editor is the only person with permission to criticize.
@SP3CTR0M_Brendan X So? Who knows, the person who made this comment could be more competent in editing than whoever the paid professional is if there is one. Just because someone is "better" than you doesn't mean you can't call out their terrible mistakes.
SP3CTR0M_Brendan X you act like editing clips like this is difficult 😂 they couldn’t even sync the audio.
Wren you killed it man. It was so fun watching your video then seeing the full talk come out.
*RE-UPLOAD the video:* almost no slides got to it, it is useless!
They remade the video with all the clips and slides on the CorridorCrew channel. It's fantastic. Go check it out.
considering that most of the slides are movie clips, they can't really upload it to avoid copyright claims.
V dB where?
@@nicholasmeara6869 Search "VFX Artist Explains What's Wrong With Modern CGi"
I'm assuming they couldn't clear copyright and show your slides? Bummer. Way to totally negate the whole talk.
Check out the video with the full content on the Corridor Crew channel :) some of the other comments on this video have the link/title of the vid
Well done Wren, you explained our industry really well and it's great listening to your enthusiasm! VFX artists are so talented but often overlooked and underappreciated, with so much expected these days in so little time. I really felt sad for everybody at Rhythm and Hues. Keep up the awesome work!
Go Wren! From making a duplicate of yourself inside of your bedroom to presenting a TED talk!
i’m so proud of our baby boy! great job, wren!
OH MY GOD, WREN FINALLY!!!! I've been waiting for soooo long.
Also, Привет из России!
So proud of you, Wren, and the team at Corridor Digital!!
i just love coming back to this video
Normal ted talk: wow I'm so clever listen to my fancytalk
Wren ted talk: GUYS THIS IS SO COOL DON'T YOU THINK
corridor crew👍👍
Wren being more nervous than he's ever been in his life, but still nailing it with his talk. I saw a couple of his near stumbles, otherwise, well composed after hours of practice!
"You can tell it's off" just like the sound in this video
Been watching corridor for the past 7 years, it's been a joy seeing Wren grow as an artist and as a person
"They were so preoccupied with whether or not they could they didn't stop to think if they should"
- Ian Malcolm
Am I the only one who got the quote
I'm scrolling down the comments to see if anyone else got it too. I have a feeling only a few audience members caught that too.
Well done, Wren. *golf clap
I seriously was laughing when he said that because I got the reference. I'm surprised I didn't here anyone laughing
I think everyone got it
Omg it finally got released!! So happy for you when. Well done!!
This!!! Been waiting so long for this talk!
Been waiting for this one eagerly...🙃
Edited: audio goes out of sync, plz reupload
Wren you are amazing. Keep doing stuff like this. You have the most amazing voice and energy and enthusiasm.
If you wanna see all the slides and clips they recorded the whole thing again on Corridor Crew. GREAT JOB WREN.
Imagine having a talk about visual effects and almost all visuals are left out of the recording.
If you want to see a great version of this talk, go to their Corridor Digital Crew RUclips channel. This is a great talked that becomes even better with video/images.
Who else sees that the screen and sound aren't synced well.
Or is it just by me?
Sorry for bad english
Nowpe i see it too, would it be CGI?
I wish he had shown the examples referenced.
You're right. Its slightly off.
Kind of ironic huh? Ole murphys law put in overtime one this one.
Sound is slightly slower...which can be pretty annoying
Finally, I’ve been waiting for this to come out.
I've been waiting for this. I love this guy and the channel he is in.
Wren's quote "no film is ever finished. It just gets released."