Seriously though the song is catchier than even the Triple Dent Gum song... Pixar Theory Song ::: music.apple.com/us/album/the-pixar-theory-song-single/1504208243
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
I just want to imagine that at Pixar when they are pitching new movie ideas, a new employee is like, "wait how does this fit in on the time-line" and someone says, "Don't worry the Carlin Brothers will figure that out for us"
I honestly think they’re actively trying to disprove this theory by making new and wild stories. I thought it was over when they made onward but apparently it fits right in with the rest
@@squamousthomas3267 in toy story 4 the directors deliberately wanted to squash the Pixar theory by putting in all kinda of Easter eggs and things that should end it
If I had a nickel for every time there was a Pixar movie that involved a complicated mother-daughter relationship and a character that turned into a bear, I'd have two nickels, which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice.
I will never not get chills at the conclusion of a Pixar theory video where you get to the point about memories keeping people alive. Not only does all of the movies finally culminate at a single point and makes the whole thing make sense and serve a purpose, but it’s also just such a strong and powerful message in real life. Nothing is really gone until it is forgotten and I can only hope that if humans do figure out time travel at some point, someone will figure out this same exact thing and create their own loop to insure that humanity and life and love will always exist and always be remembered.
This guy quickly go over and distorts the REAL Pixar Theory where "BUY n LARGE" starts off as a battery company in Toy Story, and "BUY n LARGE" takes over the world by WALL-E. It makes me question this guy.
They talk about A Bug’s Life in more depth in most of the other Pixar Theory videos, but basically the plant that Wall-e finds that is planted at the end of the movie is shown growing into a massive tree, that tree is identical to the tree the bugs in a bugs life colonize around
Is it thought that BingBong is/was Riley's memory of her Monsters Inc. monster? That's always the sense that I got. Riley lives during the time of funny monsters, hence the Richard Kind of it all.
A lot of people are saying "it takes place after walle plants the tree and life comes back" but I don't see why it couldn't have took place before the events of walle
Well, there's the exact same Pizza Planet truck and a trailer in Bug's Life as in Monster's Inc. Which I found interesting. Even has the same wood board to the left.
@@locomotivetrainstation6053 think the reason that people came up with the idea of it being after Wall-E is because humans are only referenced one time, when we see a homeless bug with a sign that says “kid pulled my wings off”. (And honestly, even then, there’s the potential that it’s just referring to a bug and not a human, since the species of the “kid” isn’t specified.) So, since it’s implied that humans do exist, the fact that they’re never mentioned, even when listing all of the dangers in the world “snakes, birds, and bigger bugs”, implies that it’s a time period where there are very few humans so the bugs aren’t worried about running into them. Plus, the bugs are a lot smarter than normal, shown by all the things they’ve invented, including cities made of trash that the humans left, and one ant says that he “feels 90 again” implying that they’re able to live longer than they normally would. So, it’s most likely in the future, and the fact that humans are apparently around but it’s not very common for bugs to interact with them, the only place in the timeline where that could fit would have to be after the humans return at the end of Wall-E.
You also have a cutscene from toy story 2 during the end credits where you see Flik and Heimlich knocked off a leaf as Buzz walks through a bush. Since it's those characters specifically, I imagine that their story happened some time between toy story and toy story 2.
I love how this all goes full circle which makes it the most believable theory out of any. There are so many branches of the story that connect together to make a full blown tree (perfect analogy). I love this video so much and it was definitely worth the 47 minutes and 55 seconds.
honestly, even if the pixar theory has become a bit overly-forced, i will forever grateful of the one thing that ACTUALLY glue them all together, the theme of remembering. pixar made me aggresively think about my old dead toys all the way to my actual deceased love ones. pixar gave me hope that the stuffs i have physically lost, isn't actually dead yet, and will never be as long as i keep remembering them. i love this studio so muchhh and carlin bros just remind me that
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
@@SuperCarlinBrothers Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
I love coming back to this channel every year or so to check up on it/update myself on the pixar lore, one of my OG youtube channel staples, I remember those og daily vlogs/the pokemon play throughs
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
This is amazing. The only issue I have with this is the sea monsters evolving into monsters because of a banished monster...sounds like a bootstrap paradox.
Yeah, but the idea of Boo going to the past to invent bear magic and ensure Sully exists is also a bootstrap paradox. So maybe those paradoxes aren't really a problem.
My problem is that all the magical races in Onward have human parts, so I say that humans did survive but they just forgor about the Axiom. And maybe some of the monsters found their way there
Don't know if anyone else knows this but according to a Monsters, Inc. DVD bonus feature, the city that they live in, Monstropolis, was founded after all of the monsters (originally a race of creatures similar to neanderthals called Mons), who once co-existed with humans, were all chased off the mainland, and eventually moved to an island in an unknown part of the world (which Monstropolis is implied to be located) where they have lived ever since and evolved into monsters by eating the strange fruit on the island (possibly the fruit sold at Tony's Grossery), and that the only way for them to enter human-inhabited areas was via the doors. This is one of the plot holes I have with the Pixar Theory.
@@intro8172 I'm pretty sure these guys already covered that, saying that they're not considering it canon. I can't remember the specific video but I think it had to do with Luca 😁
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
@@dottthemovie Why don't you just make your own video explaining everything and post it instead of copy-pasting on every comment? You're irrationally invested in this.
Honestly how are they going to fit Elemental in that? 😂 They aren’t just monsterized humans they’re literal elements that inhabit what I assume is Earth. Of course we’ll just have to see when the movie actually comes out, but I can’t wait to see how the Carlin Bros try to fit that one!
I didn't think I'd learn anything new after having kept up with your explanation of the Pixar Theory for years, but there were actually some fun nuggets I hadn't heard before. Can't wait to hear how the next movie fits in!
Here is something to consider; Mei Lee has an extraordinary power that can be passed on through generations, needs time to develop her powers, and her ancestors once hid these powers out of fear that the world would not accept them. Mei Lee is a super. Mind blown.
Lightyear could have been much better if after the main movie was done, it zooms out to Andy and his mom and Andy is telling his mom about how he wants the toy for that movie.
Wow. I watched the first Pixar theory when I was in elementary. Now this one, I’m a freshman in college. It makes me so happy these Guys are still making great content. What a fantastic channel.
did you ever think that all the cars movies are movies in the movies like lightyear? the bandaid could be merch, and the actor that played buzz in lightyear could have played lightning mcqueen
I am a big Pixar fan and a strong believer in this Pixar theory. Pixar theory videos are easily one of my absolute favourite videos you guys do. Respect to you guys for taking so much time and effort to connect all these films cos I could never do this. I've been wanting an updated Pixar theory video for the longest time. I'm very interested to find out how elemental fits in. That will be a tricky one but you guys will do it cos you always do!
you guys make my childhood skepticism come back and hit me in my face. and I love it. been here since the first Pixar theory video and I’m glad I’m here till this one. oh and harrmione till I die.
Wow. Great video. Here's a thing though that also ties in to the Pixar Theory. If any of you played Disney Dreamlight Valley, it, too, plays into the memory/remembering trope. There (no spoilers), the Valley is populated by you and you have to gradually find characters and make them remember each other and you, all the while trying to figure out who made everyone forget in the first place. So interesting.
you guys have been fueling my pixar obsession for over 7 years and im so happy to see you again, knowing ive grown up alongside both of you makes me really happy. these videos have inspired me so much and have made me love pixar and have fueled my art and creativity and im incredibly grateful :)
I remember watching the first Pixar Theory video when I was very young and now I’m in the middle of high school and found this video and it’s bringing back so many memories!!
This video is a sign for people to be kind to everyone else cuz who knows someday someone might create an infinite loop in time so that you're never ever forgotten.
3:44 Did anyone notice that the continents are slightly closed? Because 65 mya, the continents were much closer to one another than it is today. I love that tiny detail.
The part about the memories and not forgetting makes so much sense when you think about Disney’s new game (Disney Dreamlight Valley). In it you are the main character fighting back against “The Forgetting” and one of the main things you need to find are memory orbs. Just the like ones in Inside Out.
Overall I'm pretty impressed how well you made this all work and for the most part not seem to be stretching, however every time you compared the magic of Brave to Turning Red I found myself shouting at the screen, "RED PANDA'S AREN'T BEARS!!!!" It's not a red giant panda (which is a bear) it's a red panda which is more closely related to (and more closely resembles) a raccoon. On that note Boo doesn't think Sully looks like a bear, she thinks he looks like a "Kitty" If the witch is Boo then she logically should be obsessed with big cats not bears.
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
The monsters from Monsters, Inc. can't be hybrids of humans and sea monsters if sea monsters are just monsters taken into past. It just makes an impossible time loop. I like the theory of monsters actually being evolved animals much more. It fits the whole idea how animals advance through time and it also ties very well to the concept of A Bug's Life where insects, now obviously evolved (they walk on two legs now), build their own society (which, by the way, you omitted in the video).
Yeah, I agree. Like it’s fine if that’s the explanation for how and why they continue to survive and yada yada yada. But there does need to be an isolated “start” point, the first monster, of the sea or not. I suppose you could say we just don’t know who it is yet, as in the movies have not revealed that, or we don’t realize, but that’s not an overly satisfying answers, either.
The humans return to Earth and they restart to live on Earth. The nature return to grown and animal life begun to come back. But the animals (mammals, birds, fishs and BUGS) are more intelligent than their predecessors (Dory, Marlin, Nemo, Remy etc...) Here's where A Bug's Life events play out. The humans will leave Earth to colonize space giving the Animals the Planet earth and over the next 2000 years or more they evolve Into Monsters Inc the same process of humans evolve and became Monsters. They also discover time travel to collect "human energy" through emotions. The Sea Monsters are still From the future relocated in the Past cause of their biology are toxic for the Monsters (this Is why they believe that humans where toxic). Then when the Axioms leave Earth in 2105 the Sea Monsters are or still on Earth and extinct cause of the pollution or are all in the Axioms and in 700 years Lost their monster gene until they're back on Earth.
"real sentences I say for my job." LOL. I love SCB! And thank you for the updated video because this just makes it easier to understand how it all comes together!
I’ve subscribed to this channel since the first Pixar theory video. I regret to say I haven’t watched many episodes in the past year or so. Was nice to see y’all again tho
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
Fun fact for all: there was a man named B.F. Skinner who worked and did psychological studies with rats. He worked to condition the rats to navigate mazes and press levers or bars. He’s also known for the creation of the operant chamber box which helped with these studies. So with a movie such as Ratatouille why not name the one crazy person who believes Linguini is being controlled by a rat, chef Skinner
I enjoy pixar theory videos from the super carlin brother more than any videos I ever seen on youtube!! thanks for putting in the work and laying it all out wonderfully :)
Also could the monsters be afraid of touching humans and interacting with humans in monsters inc because the butterfly effect of messing with something in the past and permanently affecting it? 🤔
So if Boo prevents Sully from experiencing the final death by keeping him alive with her own memory, does his own memory of her in tern keep *her* from experiencing the final death as well?
wow ... i completely forgot about this channel. i was obsessed with it back in 2014-2015 when i was 10 years old , probably one of the things that made me want to become a filmmaker in the first place - wanting to someday create a cinematic universe this complex and interesting. this video appeared on my recommended feed this morning and when i saw the channel name , memories immediately started flooding back! i am now re-subscribed and halfway through this AMAZING video. thank you so much super carlin brothers !! i am now 18 years old , and a film student . it seems that my dream of making an amazing cinematic universe is everyday closer to becoming real !!
@@re_patel It's from "The Incredibles" when Helen and Dash go to the principal's office because "Dash put a tack on the teacher's chair during class." Bernie is Dash's teacher, who caught speedy Dash on camera. (You really have to watch it again to get the full effect.)
What would you think some of the biggest continuity errors there are across Pixar movies? I wouldn’t expect all the movies to be perfect, so at least one detail must drive you guys insane lol
I'd love if they made a video on this! My best guess would just be how many alternate connecting explanations one may be able to make if you took into account every single easter egg inclusion, and how easily that can create confusion in the timeline. For example, since there's Lightyear (an in-universe movie), it could also be theorized that The Incredibles is also just an in-universe movie (which is a convincing take due to an Incredibles poster seen in Coco), which would cause a lot of issues for the timeline as a whole.
Dang has it really been a decade already? How have I been watching you guys for so long without noticing? Lol time flies when you’re theorizing I guess, happy 10 years bros!
Ok so have a question that’s almost a theory I suppose. So if the monsters can only go back a certain amount of time in the past, does that mean they’re doomed for death? Because what happens when they’ve progressed so far that the doors send them to a time where the humans no longer exist? Like if time progresses and it’s during the age of Wall-E through the doors, they just can’t access kids anymore, and are just forever out of energy.
A theory I have for Turning Red and Brave is that someone in Merida’s family (most likely Merida) moved to somewhere in China, which eventually started Mei Lin’s bloodline, and that Merida somehow learned to use the magic that Boo used, which is how Sun Yee got her bear powers. Kind of a stretch but I like it
this DEFINED my childhood, and i live revisiting it, because i was 7 when i started getting into this side of youtube, im 16 now, and much has changed, but iys great to see how these people that formed me (without knowing who i am) remained the same in essence.
Sully's memory is only guaranteed within the time loop you mention. This doesn't mean Sully will "live" forever, it means there is a known point in time when the last person who remembers Sully is no longer in the same space-time
I know the OG Pixar Theory vid was a lot of current SCB fans initiation into the SuperCarlinBros (myself included) and I still remember the visceral reaction I had when J first revealed Boo was the witch. Like genuine jaw drop moment. That video got me into this channel and also for at least a little while I did not realise Ben existed bc I thought it was only J 😂 J and his blue shirt. Which is why I was so confused by their intro that featured a dude with sunglasses. Now that dude with sunglasses also has a beard and we’re here 11 years later 🥺
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Seriously though the song is catchier than even the Triple Dent Gum song...
Pixar Theory Song ::: music.apple.com/us/album/the-pixar-theory-song-single/1504208243
I clicked this faster than a mf
The Pixar Theory song is awesome, I put in my random mix of music playlist and it's always great when it comes up in my shuffle
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
Kingdom Hearts.
@@dottthemovie how does that show break the Pixar theory???
sully single-handedly carrying an entire universe just cause he was nice to a little girl is the biggest flex ever
Conversely, the girl carries the entire universe by creating a bear that was nice to her as a little girl
Kindness goes a long way. And every once a while? A reeeeaaaallly long way
Have to wonder if the missing A-113 in Monster, Inc. is related to it being Boo's original time.
The context from Monsters university also fits Mike and Randolph into the picture nicely they’re also a big part of it
Nux vibes
I just want to imagine that at Pixar when they are pitching new movie ideas, a new employee is like, "wait how does this fit in on the time-line" and someone says, "Don't worry the Carlin Brothers will figure that out for us"
I honestly think they’re actively trying to disprove this theory by making new and wild stories. I thought it was over when they made onward but apparently it fits right in with the rest
@@squamousthomas3267 I think it's just that outlandish and unique concepts generally make for better animated movies.
@@squamousthomas3267 in toy story 4 the directors deliberately wanted to squash the Pixar theory by putting in all kinda of Easter eggs and things that should end it
I'd like to believe they actively try to break the Pixar theory with every release
Just wait until I buy Pixar from Disney.
If I had a nickel for every time there was a Pixar movie that involved a complicated mother-daughter relationship and a character that turned into a bear, I'd have two nickels, which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice.
dr doofenshmirtz🐐
Not exactly the same but I feel brother bear deserves an honorable mention
@@thefandombard4774 true. It’s also not Pixar though.
Red pandas are ailuridae, not bears, but I get the joke.
I got a charmin ad right after he said that, with a red bear to boot. Huh.
Dude the fact that Mr. Incredible just casually changed the entire fate of the world with one small action feels unreal to me
A.I would have been invented by some point anyway.
With great power comes great responsibility!!!
That's honestly how pretty much everything works irl too honestly.
1) why I'm always nice to everyone the best I can and
2) why I believe whole heartedly that you should never ever meet your heros
I mean, both world wars started because of one man's assassination
I will never not get chills at the conclusion of a Pixar theory video where you get to the point about memories keeping people alive. Not only does all of the movies finally culminate at a single point and makes the whole thing make sense and serve a purpose, but it’s also just such a strong and powerful message in real life. Nothing is really gone until it is forgotten and I can only hope that if humans do figure out time travel at some point, someone will figure out this same exact thing and create their own loop to insure that humanity and life and love will always exist and always be remembered.
humanity does not deserve to exist forever
I like how he goes into SUPER detailed length about every single movie and then throws a bugs life of a cliff
but it was just a colony of ants that lived next to a tree
This guy quickly go over and distorts the REAL Pixar Theory where "BUY n LARGE" starts off as a battery company in Toy Story, and "BUY n LARGE" takes over the world by WALL-E. It makes me question this guy.
@@MoCa5545 I feel like you didn't watch the video
@@mogy7331 I did. He barley went over the topic while making a quick excuse as to why BnL took over the world.
@@MoCa5545 why are you so hurt, over bugs life not being talked about enough? Lol
Everyone just seems to forget about A Bug's Life. That was one of my favorite Pixar movies
A Bug’s Life is probably why I have a crippling fear of bugs tbh
They didn’t forget lol, he talks about it at the end of the vid
@@miing3683 he just tossed it in there like oh yeah and this movie happened too
They talk about A Bug’s Life in more depth in most of the other Pixar Theory videos, but basically the plant that Wall-e finds that is planted at the end of the movie is shown growing into a massive tree, that tree is identical to the tree the bugs in a bugs life colonize around
And what about antz?
Is it thought that BingBong is/was Riley's memory of her Monsters Inc. monster? That's always the sense that I got. Riley lives during the time of funny monsters, hence the Richard Kind of it all.
ruclips.net/video/6zYon5d4q5M/видео.html
woah this is a really great idea and it makes tons of sense, definitely my headcanon now
I don't get the Richard Kind part.
Richard Kind is the comedian and character actor that plays BingBong.
Generally known for being a goofy screwball type.
How does he become a tourist car or a grasshopper then?
"these dogs are capable of cooking food and flying airplanes."
*shows clip of dog planes crashing into each other*
He never said they did those things well 😂
It's crazy how WALL-E uses real people as animation in their animated world
What u mean? The people in it are people in real life?
@@jasonatencio3971On the screens and advertising in the film they showed real humans, not animated ones
It's like in Chicken Little at the beginning of the movie with the Indiana Jones clip in the movie theater.
And they have Fred Willard who plays phils dad in modern family i think too which is cool!
oh, i thought you meant the Walmart people.
I love how a bugs life can just be thrown pretty much wherever within the whole timeline lol
A lot of people are saying "it takes place after walle plants the tree and life comes back" but I don't see why it couldn't have took place before the events of walle
Well, there's the exact same Pizza Planet truck and a trailer in Bug's Life as in Monster's Inc. Which I found interesting. Even has the same wood board to the left.
@@locomotivetrainstation6053 think the reason that people came up with the idea of it being after Wall-E is because humans are only referenced one time, when we see a homeless bug with a sign that says “kid pulled my wings off”. (And honestly, even then, there’s the potential that it’s just referring to a bug and not a human, since the species of the “kid” isn’t specified.) So, since it’s implied that humans do exist, the fact that they’re never mentioned, even when listing all of the dangers in the world “snakes, birds, and bigger bugs”, implies that it’s a time period where there are very few humans so the bugs aren’t worried about running into them.
Plus, the bugs are a lot smarter than normal, shown by all the things they’ve invented, including cities made of trash that the humans left, and one ant says that he “feels 90 again” implying that they’re able to live longer than they normally would. So, it’s most likely in the future, and the fact that humans are apparently around but it’s not very common for bugs to interact with them, the only place in the timeline where that could fit would have to be after the humans return at the end of Wall-E.
You also have a cutscene from toy story 2 during the end credits where you see Flik and Heimlich knocked off a leaf as Buzz walks through a bush. Since it's those characters specifically, I imagine that their story happened some time between toy story and toy story 2.
@@jamiepenman1070 ahh yes, true!
I always thought the use of real actors and animation in WallE to emphasize the change in humanity to be so unsettling
And the music choices.
It was weird but still wall-e is one of the best Pixar movies ever.
yeah the first captain looked so realistic that it kinda got uncanny when compared to the fat humans.
@@jiji7250 I liked the use of real humans. Made it more scary and much real.
Yesss, always made it seem so much more cryptic to me
I am so immeasurably happy that there’s a new version of this to obsess over
I love how this all goes full circle which makes it the most believable theory out of any. There are so many branches of the story that connect together to make a full blown tree (perfect analogy). I love this video so much and it was definitely worth the 47 minutes and 55 seconds.
honestly, even if the pixar theory has become a bit overly-forced, i will forever grateful of the one thing that ACTUALLY glue them all together, the theme of remembering. pixar made me aggresively think about my old dead toys all the way to my actual deceased love ones. pixar gave me hope that the stuffs i have physically lost, isn't actually dead yet, and will never be as long as i keep remembering them. i love this studio so muchhh and carlin bros just remind me that
I did a paper on the Pixar theory this past month and oh I am so glad y’all did this! I included so many things y’all have talked about!
That's awesome! I'm sure you found a bunch of stuff we missed too!
@@SuperCarlinBrothers I bet this was insane to do.
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
@@dottthemovie You really care about this don't you with your same reply all over the place.
@@coconuts2513 lol your right, this person rlly likes wasting their time “discrediting” a RUclips channel with 2 million subscribers.
At this point Pixar waits for these videos to find out how the movies connect
I mean.. that's our theory anyway 😉
they are so famous they influence disney’s shedual
@@SuperCarlinBrothers Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
I feel like they do the opposite. Like they think “how can we try to make it as hard as possible for the Carlin brothers”
Man I love these videos and the way Pixar intentionally puts us on a goose chase. And The Carlin Brothers are here for it
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
This is so frickin epic. Great job, really enjoyed it, thank you.
I love coming back to this channel every year or so to check up on it/update myself on the pixar lore, one of my OG youtube channel staples, I remember those og daily vlogs/the pokemon play throughs
The sequel we've been waiting for. Never thought they'd make it
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
3Rd one
@@dottthemovie well maybe that’s how cars are designed
@@HSingingTree Watch Cars on the Road Episode one. It shows life millions of years ago, and there are dino cars. Broken. Theory Debunked.
@@dottthemovie well how do you know it’s cannon ?
I've always known there was a theory that all the Pixar movies were connected somehow but this breakdown is absolutely glorious. 48 minutes well spent
Actually 47 minutes and 56 seconds
@@kohenstanscheit9170 the extra 4 seconds were for my internal processing lol
This is amazing. The only issue I have with this is the sea monsters evolving into monsters because of a banished monster...sounds like a bootstrap paradox.
Yeah I think it would be easier that the dinos that didn't die off continued to evolve and moved to the sea as humans became a more dominant species.
I remember someone pitched that the sea monsters could have been supers or something, so that could explain it
Yeah, but the idea of Boo going to the past to invent bear magic and ensure Sully exists is also a bootstrap paradox. So maybe those paradoxes aren't really a problem.
My problem is that all the magical races in Onward have human parts, so I say that humans did survive but they just forgor about the Axiom. And maybe some of the monsters found their way there
@@marcushankins8171 well then how could they interbreed
That’s crazy how u explained all this very well making it make sense inna hour….. incredible
Don't know if anyone else knows this but according to a Monsters, Inc. DVD bonus feature, the city that they live in, Monstropolis, was founded after all of the monsters (originally a race of creatures similar to neanderthals called Mons), who once co-existed with humans, were all chased off the mainland, and eventually moved to an island in an unknown part of the world (which Monstropolis is implied to be located) where they have lived ever since and evolved into monsters by eating the strange fruit on the island (possibly the fruit sold at Tony's Grossery), and that the only way for them to enter human-inhabited areas was via the doors.
This is one of the plot holes I have with the Pixar Theory.
Cool as. Wonder how this affects the theory.
@@intro8172 I'm pretty sure these guys already covered that, saying that they're not considering it canon. I can't remember the specific video but I think it had to do with Luca 😁
The original theory was how I found this channel. And now it is one of my favorites
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
@@dottthemovie
Why don't you just make your own video explaining everything and post it instead of copy-pasting on every comment?
You're irrationally invested in this.
Yep
Same!! I’ve been watching ever since
@@rainynight02 Yes that is the plan for my Pixar Channel! :D
Honestly how are they going to fit Elemental in that? 😂 They aren’t just monsterized humans they’re literal elements that inhabit what I assume is Earth. Of course we’ll just have to see when the movie actually comes out, but I can’t wait to see how the Carlin Bros try to fit that one!
Don’t worry they’ll always fit it
I feel the same way. I cannot wait for them to theorize my fixation.
Another planet (like Onward)
maybe way, way back in time. there's still a big gap leading up to the dinosaurs
@@peytoncoates1104 though we see monorails, cities, headphones, hear music that’s more modern, see fashion that’s modern
I didn't think I'd learn anything new after having kept up with your explanation of the Pixar Theory for years, but there were actually some fun nuggets I hadn't heard before. Can't wait to hear how the next movie fits in!
Here is something to consider; Mei Lee has an extraordinary power that can be passed on through generations, needs time to develop her powers, and her ancestors once hid these powers out of fear that the world would not accept them. Mei Lee is a super. Mind blown.
Huh
These guys are the matpats of the Pixar theory. Like I will be SHOCKED if one of them at the end of a video says: “but hey that’s just a PIXAR THEORY”
Lightyear could have been much better if after the main movie was done, it zooms out to Andy and his mom and Andy is telling his mom about how he wants the toy for that movie.
that doesn't make sense 😭
@@ratluvrr15 why not
@@ratluvrr15 it does, though because light year was the movie in the toy story timeline
Was legit about to ask about A Bug's Life when you said "At some point there was a colony of ants, and they lived by a tree." 🤣
Legit my favorite line of the whole video 😂🤣
Time stamp pls
@@zerodiversion4509 47:46
Wow. I watched the first Pixar theory when I was in elementary. Now this one, I’m a freshman in college. It makes me so happy these Guys are still making great content. What a fantastic channel.
I remember being so mind blowing watching the first Pixar theory video you guys made. It’s so fun putting the new Pixar movies into the universe
I've always thought that shrimp were just sea cockroaches.
did you ever think that all the cars movies are movies in the movies like lightyear? the bandaid could be merch, and the actor that played buzz in lightyear could have played lightning mcqueen
Bro this comment needs more recognition it makes a lot more sense then what he said
Ya this makes more sense because there is absolutely no way the cars world is the trash covered mess from WALL-E
Makes SO much more sense! Phenomenal thinking
Yes! It makes more sense that the bandaid the truck driver wore was just merchandise from a movie
that makes so much sense
I am a big Pixar fan and a strong believer in this Pixar theory. Pixar theory videos are easily one of my absolute favourite videos you guys do. Respect to you guys for taking so much time and effort to connect all these films cos I could never do this. I've been wanting an updated Pixar theory video for the longest time. I'm very interested to find out how elemental fits in. That will be a tricky one but you guys will do it cos you always do!
No your not a Pixar fan your iron man
@@kohenstanscheit9170 lol
you guys make my childhood skepticism come back and hit me in my face. and I love it. been here since the first Pixar theory video and I’m glad I’m here till this one. oh and harrmione till I die.
I have a headache
Wow. Great video. Here's a thing though that also ties in to the Pixar Theory. If any of you played Disney Dreamlight Valley, it, too, plays into the memory/remembering trope. There (no spoilers), the Valley is populated by you and you have to gradually find characters and make them remember each other and you, all the while trying to figure out who made everyone forget in the first place. So interesting.
I love how they turned Pixar easter eggs into a whole theory that I fully believe is possible!!! It just makes sense
you guys have been fueling my pixar obsession for over 7 years and im so happy to see you again, knowing ive grown up alongside both of you makes me really happy. these videos have inspired me so much and have made me love pixar and have fueled my art and creativity and im incredibly grateful :)
I remember watching the first Pixar Theory video when I was very young and now I’m in the middle of high school and found this video and it’s bringing back so many memories!!
Make me feel old why don't you
Skipped Bugs Life, therefore this entire video is null and void.
This video is a sign for people to be kind to everyone else cuz who knows someday someone might create an infinite loop in time so that you're never ever forgotten.
3:44 Did anyone notice that the continents are slightly closed? Because 65 mya, the continents were much closer to one another than it is today. I love that tiny detail.
You don't even have to believe in the pixar theory, it's fun to watch them try to fix it all together
I agree. It is not realistic to me, but it is fun to think to put the films together by any creative means.
The part about the memories and not forgetting makes so much sense when you think about Disney’s new game (Disney Dreamlight Valley). In it you are the main character fighting back against “The Forgetting” and one of the main things you need to find are memory orbs. Just the like ones in Inside Out.
Overall I'm pretty impressed how well you made this all work and for the most part not seem to be stretching, however every time you compared the magic of Brave to Turning Red I found myself shouting at the screen, "RED PANDA'S AREN'T BEARS!!!!" It's not a red giant panda (which is a bear) it's a red panda which is more closely related to (and more closely resembles) a raccoon. On that note Boo doesn't think Sully looks like a bear, she thinks he looks like a "Kitty" If the witch is Boo then she logically should be obsessed with big cats not bears.
He definetly did this video with a lot of heartsfire... with passion!
I love how at this point, every new movie is just a clip for you to use as a joke, plus a new thing to somehow figure out.
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
@@dottthemovie I don’t care. Leave people alone.
@@Fanwithnoimator Still I proved it wrong.
@@dottthemovie when was it proved canon? Stop replying to random people and leave my comment alone. Now I have to delete the comment so you dissappear
@@Fanwithnoimator 👍
The monsters from Monsters, Inc. can't be hybrids of humans and sea monsters if sea monsters are just monsters taken into past. It just makes an impossible time loop. I like the theory of monsters actually being evolved animals much more. It fits the whole idea how animals advance through time and it also ties very well to the concept of A Bug's Life where insects, now obviously evolved (they walk on two legs now), build their own society (which, by the way, you omitted in the video).
It's just akin to the bootstrap paradox. Time travel fuckery being part of a theory alone does not disprove it.
Someone obviously didn’t watch the last 10 seconds of the video…
Yeah, I agree. Like it’s fine if that’s the explanation for how and why they continue to survive and yada yada yada. But there does need to be an isolated “start” point, the first monster, of the sea or not. I suppose you could say we just don’t know who it is yet, as in the movies have not revealed that, or we don’t realize, but that’s not an overly satisfying answers, either.
The humans return to Earth and they restart to live on Earth. The nature return to grown and animal life begun to come back. But the animals (mammals, birds, fishs and BUGS) are more intelligent than their predecessors (Dory, Marlin, Nemo, Remy etc...) Here's where A Bug's Life events play out.
The humans will leave Earth to colonize space giving the Animals the Planet earth and over the next 2000 years or more they evolve Into Monsters Inc the same process of humans evolve and became Monsters. They also discover time travel to collect "human energy" through emotions.
The Sea Monsters are still From the future relocated in the Past cause of their biology are toxic for the Monsters (this Is why they believe that humans where toxic). Then when the Axioms leave Earth in 2105 the Sea Monsters are or still on Earth and extinct cause of the pollution or are all in the Axioms and in 700 years Lost their monster gene until they're back on Earth.
"real sentences I say for my job." LOL. I love SCB!
And thank you for the updated video because this just makes it easier to understand how it all comes together!
Poor bug's life, always being the underrated masterpiece 😭😂
Best theory of ALL TIME! I love you Super Carlin Brothers!
Be prepared for the next few years. Ya'll are gonna be adding Elemental, Elio and Inside Out 2 onto this list.
WE ARE READY!
@@SuperCarlinBrothers at the moment all are movies in universe
@@SuperCarlinBrothers elementals is going to be really tricky to figure out
@@husaynbootwala1729 I thought the same thing.
@@husaynbootwala1729 And that's why I'm extremely looking forward to seeing it actually figured out.
I’ve subscribed to this channel since the first Pixar theory video. I regret to say I haven’t watched many episodes in the past year or so. Was nice to see y’all again tho
Cars on The Road is canon to Cars, but they aren't doing it because it broke the Pixar theory. They are being selective with plot points and stuff to suit themselves. The the episode Salt Fever. It breaks the Pixar theory. Cars are NOT machines in Cars. They are, but have human like inner workings.
I'm intrigued as to how elemental will fit into this theory.
Great job guys!!! Fantastic video
It's probably another world where another Axiom Ship crashed into. that's my guess
@@RaixsOreh Uhmmmmmmmm interesting!
Maybe it takes place in another realm like soul or coco. Or it's like inside out but for the earth
@@mistermelty1578 That is possible.
I think it's like onward a planet far away
Every time Pixar does a new movie you will need to do more mental gymnastics to make it fit.
Fun fact for all: there was a man named B.F. Skinner who worked and did psychological studies with rats. He worked to condition the rats to navigate mazes and press levers or bars. He’s also known for the creation of the operant chamber box which helped with these studies. So with a movie such as Ratatouille why not name the one crazy person who believes Linguini is being controlled by a rat, chef Skinner
I enjoy pixar theory videos from the super carlin brother more than any videos I ever seen on youtube!! thanks for putting in the work and laying it all out wonderfully :)
Also could the monsters be afraid of touching humans and interacting with humans in monsters inc because the butterfly effect of messing with something in the past and permanently affecting it? 🤔
So if Boo prevents Sully from experiencing the final death by keeping him alive with her own memory, does his own memory of her in tern keep *her* from experiencing the final death as well?
Yes, exactly.... Talk about mind blowing Infinite loop.
Ergo, the timeline constantly resets from the moment the monsters die, back to Brave, over and over.
This was WILD guys thank you so much for this video!
I’m really curious how Pixar’s new elemental movie is gonna fit in
I love the inclusion of a Bugs Life, one of my favorite pixar films and so slept on but truly that is its place
There is the theory that the plant that Wall-E finds is the tree from A Bugs Life.
@@Karia_Winchester gosh I hope so, that would tie in perfectly
No way creators are still working with better help thats crazy
right? good point
They are slowly making a comeback in RUclips sponsorships :/
@@jamesss8656 there have been a lot of scandals regarding unprofessional & bad therapists
I loved the pixar theory but over the years it’s become more and more far fetched 🤣
The onward one literally only slides because the mountain looks like the ship 😆
You take this too seriously. Lol. Just enjoy it.
@@guitarbass22 ok
@@stevegfx9312 And he said it was a perfect fit, but while similar, its not.
@@stevegfx9312 Since it's not on Earth, then it doesn't really need to connect the others. And there's one one movie that's actually in space.
this theory makes me cry because it can one day be a thing. and we will all just be “memories”
It’s pretty interesting how all Pixar Movies may be connected to one another.
wow ... i completely forgot about this channel. i was obsessed with it back in 2014-2015 when i was 10 years old , probably one of the things that made me want to become a filmmaker in the first place - wanting to someday create a cinematic universe this complex and interesting.
this video appeared on my recommended feed this morning and when i saw the channel name , memories immediately started flooding back! i am now re-subscribed and halfway through this AMAZING video.
thank you so much super carlin brothers !! i am now 18 years old , and a film student . it seems that my dream of making an amazing cinematic universe is everyday closer to becoming real !!
"2014-2015 when i was 10 years old"
Good god im old.
Bernie's "Coicidence? I think not!" never gets old!
I always see this reference, but which movie is it from?
@@re_patel It's from "The Incredibles" when Helen and Dash go to the principal's office because "Dash put a tack on the teacher's chair during class." Bernie is Dash's teacher, who caught speedy Dash on camera. (You really have to watch it again to get the full effect.)
@@LukeMaps ok. I guess I'll need to watch that movie again.
The feeling when it all comes together is why the pixar theory is so amazing
I need to know how elemental fits into this! One of Pixar’s best movies honestly.
38:27 “he falls victim to-“ (gets USAA add) oh he falls victim to usaa. Relatable
What would you think some of the biggest continuity errors there are across Pixar movies? I wouldn’t expect all the movies to be perfect, so at least one detail must drive you guys insane lol
I'd love if they made a video on this! My best guess would just be how many alternate connecting explanations one may be able to make if you took into account every single easter egg inclusion, and how easily that can create confusion in the timeline. For example, since there's Lightyear (an in-universe movie), it could also be theorized that The Incredibles is also just an in-universe movie (which is a convincing take due to an Incredibles poster seen in Coco), which would cause a lot of issues for the timeline as a whole.
i think it would have to be the various easter eggs teasing the next movies.
For me it’s how the trash disappears while cars happens
@@itsBASILLICUS nah, bc the incredibles were a well known super family - it makes sense that there would be posters for celebrities
@@phantom_dragon they literally explained that in the video you are commenting on 😅
Can't wait for the 3 hour version in 2032
Dang has it really been a decade already? How have I been watching you guys for so long without noticing? Lol time flies when you’re theorizing I guess, happy 10 years bros!
It’s Been A Min Since I Dove Into This Theory. Refreshing 💯
This was an incredible video! Thank you for all the awesome work.
I always loved this theory, and you made me like it even more!
Ok so have a question that’s almost a theory I suppose. So if the monsters can only go back a certain amount of time in the past, does that mean they’re doomed for death? Because what happens when they’ve progressed so far that the doors send them to a time where the humans no longer exist? Like if time progresses and it’s during the age of Wall-E through the doors, they just can’t access kids anymore, and are just forever out of energy.
Good point.
I liked and subscribed because thinking how long all this actual took to gather and put together definitely deserves it. You are very entertaining
A theory I have for Turning Red and Brave is that someone in Merida’s family (most likely Merida) moved to somewhere in China, which eventually started Mei Lin’s bloodline, and that Merida somehow learned to use the magic that Boo used, which is how Sun Yee got her bear powers. Kind of a stretch but I like it
Or the witch is just one of Meilin's anscestors who moved to Scotland
Thank you for this update and all the years of awesome videos.
“Think about that next time you’re eating a big ol’ sea roach, served at premium” 😭😂🤦🏾♂️ that one had me @SuperCarlinBrothers
I love how they included a bugs life at the end
I've been waiting for this to get updated for years now! Thank you for doing so!
I'm writing a paper on the Pixar theory and the rough draft is due today... your timing is amazing! Thank you so much, great video!
"Says Brave is next on the timeline"
"Proceeds to compare turning Red to Brave for almost the entire spot on the timeline"
this DEFINED my childhood, and i live revisiting it, because i was 7 when i started getting into this side of youtube, im 16 now, and much has changed, but iys great to see how these people that formed me (without knowing who i am) remained the same in essence.
So basically, Sully is the centre of time and space in the Pixar Universe. I’m okay with this 🙂
Sully's memory is only guaranteed within the time loop you mention. This doesn't mean Sully will "live" forever, it means there is a known point in time when the last person who remembers Sully is no longer in the same space-time
Can't wait to see how Elementals will impact the Pixar Theory.
The Pixare Theory makes SO MUCH SENSE, especially with this evidence!
just clicked on this vid bc i needed something to watch, come to find out it’s this guy, he made my childhood omg it’s nice to be back
The ants live in the same time as Boo. Randall is banished to the same trailer that's seen in a bug's life.
Your channel was such a big part of my childhood. Now I'm having a rough time and here is this video to cheer me up
The witch/boo reveal always gets me
I know the OG Pixar Theory vid was a lot of current SCB fans initiation into the SuperCarlinBros (myself included) and I still remember the visceral reaction I had when J first revealed Boo was the witch. Like genuine jaw drop moment. That video got me into this channel and also for at least a little while I did not realise Ben existed bc I thought it was only J 😂 J and his blue shirt. Which is why I was so confused by their intro that featured a dude with sunglasses. Now that dude with sunglasses also has a beard and we’re here 11 years later 🥺