Who Was Carl's Monster? | Pixar Theory
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 июл 2019
- Today J dives into the world of Pixar’s Up to try and determine the identity of Young Carl’s Monster from Monsters Inc.
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► bit.ly/2oDIxOL
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..) 
Кино
Which other kids should we try and find the monsters for?!
Miguel Rivera!
What about Bonnie?
@@dcbarck did you not see the beginning of the video?
who is boo's monster lol
Bonny
Mike be like: I can’t believe it. I was in a youtube thumbnail
🤣🤣🤣 this comment is underated!!!
Priceless XD
I mean... he got on it sooo good for him lol
And so the curse lives on.
Didn’t even notice it until I read this comment 😂
Ellie: sees the monster “ohh fuzzy”
Tonya Middleton She was the kid leaving socks on Georgie’s back
Also Ellie: You don't talk much. I like you!
M_Lynx VA
Don’t u get it tho?
Ellie not having a monster is a protective measure for the monsters
Tonya Middleton dtsfsfbsffa was gags but ggafgs again hshhhhsh I tsigs was the way to the end the night was fun lol
Imagine pixar actually doing all these calculations for their movies to get everything to fit into the timeline😂
I would lol
Imagine watching these videos and getting a job at pixar and stressing out quietly about this
I think it's on accident but that would be funny
They don't even need to, whatever they do people will just make it fit
True 😆
Also Earl has four eyes and Carl wears glasses... FOUR EYES
Thats hmm mean i wear glasses
When he wears that aviator hat it's 6 eyes
__ ABitofaByt3__ and C*arl* and E*arl*
__ ABitofaByt3__ maybe it was perfect for Carl because maybe Carl got bullied for it or something
@@DreamerKinz ok snowflake
The Pixar theory videos have always been so entertaining to watch
That’s a hot profile pic
@@blod9862 furry detected
Floda Reltih
Wha- a
No idea what your talking about *shuffling and trying to hide papers with my fursona s on it*
Matthew Morales Pixar theory sucks
Yeah, and it seems like they've been doing less of them.
Notice how Mike Wazowski is concealed by the SCB logo in the thumbnail LOL.
i didnt notice. LOVE it tho!!! lol
"I can't believe it IM ON THE THUMBNAIL!"
@@pizzamaster355 underated comment
I CANT BELIVE IM ON A MAGAZINE OWWW
That’s genius
Hey, maybe the Abominable Snowman was Ellie's, as maybe he was banished as he inspired her to be adventurous.
You never know.
Ooooooooooooh i LOVE it
The Smart-Casual Gamer.
I don’t think Snowman was a scarer at all. He was banished for tampering with mail
Blue Topaz more specifically, he could have been tampering with the bills send to monsters Inc. free equipment that I used to help build the scream extractor. Mr. Waters didn’t want to admit to what he was doing, Mr. abominable yeti snowman was the only other monster in the company with any awareness of what was going on, So he vanished him to the Himalayas.
He WAS in monsters INC by the time mike and Sully begin working there but he seems to only be working in the mail room.
nah, he tampered with the mail
But what if Carl's monster was some bird-like creature and that's how he came up with the Snipe?
The snipe is actually a common fake thing, Carl didn't make it up. It's how dumb boy scout troops would send their friends on a wild goose chase by telling them there's a snipe. I've never seen it specified as a bird though.
Omg that would be so cool
At 6:28 you will see a red monster with wings practicing his scare before going into the door and that might actual be carls monster
@@erinhollow773 well there os a bird known as the snipe en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snipe
Carl didn’t make up the snipe. It’s a real bird, too,
@@MaraFitzyStruck those are the wrong type of wings
WHEN DID YOU GET A NEW INTRO
I LIKE IT BUT IT SCARED ME
Couple videos ago.
SAME MAN SAME
They started using the new intro in their last Toy Story 4 video and how it fits in the Pixar theory
Same😭
Same.
First: who was Andy’s monster?
Second: who was Carl’s monster?
Third: who was Riley’s monster?
Next....
Who was Miguel’s monster ?
Bob the Dog his grandma
That's a good question I'm gonna try and figure it out
Who was boos monster is the real question
Un Poco Loco
Reoma Randall, it’s in the movie
who is:
Russels monster
Miguels monster
Bonnies monster
Sids monster
Hamish, Hubert and Harris' monster(s?)
Sid is his own monster
Who is my monster...
Oh yeah...
Its my mom
Woody is sids monster
Sids monster is his dad
Who is wall-E’s monster though
The moment I saw Earl and those eyebrows I was like "Him. It's that guy."
So I was really happy when J narrowed it down to being Earl xD
Wait so if Boo was alive in 1950's and Andy was a kid in the 90's how is Randall Andy's monster? Would he still be scaring? Wouldn't it be a new set of monsters we've never seen?
Thank you!!! and then what about Reily as it clearly shows she is in the 2010s or at least the late 2000s
Yes, they're changing the rules on us here! In the video on Riley's monster, they even made a point about how, since the movie took place after 2001, her monster would be a comedian instead of a scarer. Apparently they should have said 1955. And whoever Andy's monster is, it would also have to be a comedian by this new timeline.
Backwards and forwards the same range?
(Eh, I’m not big on Pixar Theory.)
Boo was 1990s you can see the year on a random scare file
@@mackenziehimel4666 : The video is claiming that 2001 for a Monster corresponds to about 1955 for a human. Which we're complaining about here, but a date on a Monster document won't settle that.
"who is Carl's monster?"
His age
Edit:wait how did my dark comment get so much likes?
this comment is underrated
I agree. Old Carl looks like my 79 yr old grandfather lol
oof
Crazy Crew that’s deep
@@mepholies yup
Earl "The Terror" Thompson is a greatly designed monster! And is fluffy.
You ruined the whole video
@@aidenricke7838 ? Lol.
For a split millisecond, I was thinking of Fluffy from Harry Potter.
He'd make a great teddy bear
When he says 1987:
Me: WaS tHaT tHe BiTe Of 87
87 Jermey dies from mangle *CHOMP CHOMP*
83 Chris gets bitten by Fredbear *CRUNCH*
Idk :/
What if the fnaf and Pixar worlds where the same! Just a thought
@@glaceongirlakasusie4961OMG! I can just imagine if Sully or Randall or whatever monster came through the door to the room of Fnaf 4 and the Nightmare Animatronics Come Up and Say: “HEY! This is our Gig!”
Haven’t watched it yet, but I know you’ll sell me.
haha thanks!
Same if they can get you excited about some random McDonald's sauce this should be a walk in the park
Like always
Ya that’s true
@@anjalidavid8499 yes
i just imagin one of the monsters goes to jackjacks room and then...
AHHHHH HELP BABY MADE ME CATCH ON FIRE!!!!
Remember in Monster's Inc one of the witnesses told the reporter "A kid flew right over me and blasted a car with it's laser vision." He might have been talking about JackJack. He was probably Jackjack's monster.
Actually, Seamus gorman made a video about it. I won’t spoil it
Lord Diamond 92 ok 6 year old
And this is how 2319 came to be.
D'ona English when?!
Sully and Randall: Jim Halpert and Dwight Schrute
Kazuki Iimura 𝚒 𝚕𝚘𝚟𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚒𝚜 😂
Kazuki Iimura Yes!Lol
So is Mike Pam and boo Cece?
Don’t ruin Pixar for me.
Disney Theory:
Mickey Mouse Is From 1928 So, Who Is His Monster?
Are you implying the he himself wasn't a monster, hes a bipedal mouse that's bigger than a dog (pluto not goofy)
Mickey Mouse is not from the Pixar universe
Bendy from Bendy and the Ink Machine.
Aditya Narasimhan manthri oswalds a bipedal rabbit thats bigger then a dog
He is a monster
Earl “The Terror” Thompson? More like Earl “The Lorax” Thompson
Pikapika1717 lol
Who is the Karl's monster?
Industrialization of the city
1987...?
*Scott Cawthon would like to know your location*
was that the bite of 87?
Nobody:
Not even a soul:
SCB: WHO WAS CARLS MONSTER
If Monsters Inc. happens in human time 1985, then Randall can’t be Andy’s monster and the orange one can’t be Riley’s monster, because the timelines wouldn’t add up. I hate to poke holes in theories, but this one jumped out at me pretty hard. Also, the theories that Boo is in one of the Toy Stories wouldn’t add up either.
They jump up and down monster Inc stuff since they also keep changing how they met. For all we know the monsters live long af
It's monster time, he said it himself, and even if he didnt, you should have been able to guess.
+
@@mynameis4080 But J establishes that the monster and human timelines are always a set amount of time apart. That's the basis for this theory--that that set time apart always remains the same, even as time progresses in the human or monster timelines, so monsters will always go back in time the same number of years. That can't be possible for Carl, Andy, and Riley simultaneously.
Thanks for ruining the theory for me ( jk )
Going back to classic Pixar era SCB, I love it :)
Oh my god you could say that boo was Andy’s sister and people would believe you because she had the Andy doll in her room
Welcome to the channel. he’s not your normal who makes 10 video that’s says the things you know.
Maybe boo was andy's dad's sister?
Wow I am actually absolutely shocked about this, my jaw has literally dropped to see and hear all the facts just seamlessly fit so well into place! Great Job too with the calculations! 😯
I love how deep you guys think. Even when the writes don’t even think about this stuff.... ❤️
yes they do
There's no reason for the writers to think about this. The two movies aren't canonically connected in any way. The Pixar Theory is a fan-generated story. It would be like expecting the Harry Potter movies to consider which wizards were affected by Thanos' snap.
@@SgtSupaman They've got things like Emma Jean going on in the background. They had plenty of time to consider the characters from all their other movies by the time they made MU. They didn't have to add the easter egg of Andy's wallpaper on Randall's transition test screen and a Lizard Crossing sign on Andy's closet door, but they did.
@@Mr12Relic , they enjoy throwing in easter eggs, certainly, but easter eggs are not plot related. A nod to other movies they've worked on or will work on is not a story connection (for example, E.T. is in Star Wars, but those movies happened many generations and thousands of light years apart, and, while fan theorists can, and have, come up with an explanation, the intention was not to actually connect those separate movies). I'm not necessarily saying they haven't thought about random things like this, because I don't know those writers or what they think about in their spare time; I'm just saying there is no reason for them to consider all the implications of trying to connect two unrelated movies.
Exactly!! 😂😂
When I saw the title, The Terror popped in my mind. So apparently, he does give off “Carl vibes”
6:58 Who says you don't spend enough time on research!?
That's pretty hilarious how theres an Earl Thompson! My middle name is Earl, last name is Thomson. 😂😂
Greg Thomson Who was your monster
Is your nickname "The Terror" also?
It was then he realized, he was the real monster all along.
Greg Thomson
very, very interesting information young man....
lol I’m not a stalker but don’t share this kind of information. I don’t think your father or whoever account your using would want you to reveal your name
Image him coming out of your closet saying I AM YOUR FATHER.
I may have caught an error in your logic.
In the "Rileys Monster" episode, you stated that it was 2001 on both sides of the door, but here you are stating that it is 2001/1955 ...
So which is it?
70th liked
The Riley video was made in 2015. It was the second they did after Andy's monster. They hadn't done much research on the timeline. They just assumed the monster and human worlds were congruent with each other, and we know that Monsters Inc takes place in the Monsters version of 2001. It wasn't until they did the Boo's parents video in 2018 that they finally revised the human timeline after noticing that the posters in kids rooms were cleary 1955.
@@JH-ng3hj so this should mean that neither Riley or Andy had monsters since they would have made the switch to laugh energy by then right?
mr.cool they would still have monsters tho no? They would just being trying to make them laugh instead of scared
mr.cool Andy’s Father could have been scared by Randal though.
Remember in the "Bloopers" of Monsters Inc, Rex from Toy Story makes a cameo and messes up so they had to record all over? Does this affect the time line in any way?
Ivan Valencia I doubt bloopers are canon.
Love these 'who was their monster' videos! You've got to admire these guys dedication to find the answers! Please do more who is so n so's monster videos, they're very interesting!
it's crazy how much you research. how many hours does it usually take you? or at least this video?
Doesn't this information that "present day" for the "current" monsters is 1950s ruin the predictions of the other younger Pixar kids?
Yes
It does that why I believe they are wrong about boo's time period, especially since the pizza planet truck, which is shown during randall's "mama another gator got in the house" scene, implies somewhat of a modern time, I would say minimim of 80s-90s for boos time period
The whole fact about Carl being scared by silence and sudden noise really sold it for me
Also, Earl's scare tactic could be why Carl is so quiet. He could be afraid to talk, always on the lookout for his monster. The quiet could be an escape as well as a cage. If his monster's silent, why would Carl fill the silence? His monster could catch him off guard.
Donald Duck & Goofy’s Monsters Are Also Earl The Terror
No one:
SuperCarlinBrothers: How many pairs of pants did Andy have when he went off to college?
😂 I’ll watch it though when it comes out 🤪
Phil Carlin anyone that uses the 🤪 emoji is cringe
The Proton cringe cultures dead bro
@@theproton5837 I mean you used it, even if you were using it to make a point. Same logic applies to you!
I love your vids soo much, my parents are annoyed at me cause I randomly explain one of your theories 😂 ❤️❤️
I didn’t know the gta San Andreas protagonists gone to monsters university
Usually when I see these videos I don't know it, then I watch and understand it. Now when I see this one, and I don't know, and then I watch the video, then I think, this took this a lot of work.
You guys are great! Been watching for years! Any Harry Potter theories coming soon?
My question too...
I just got back from seeing The Lion King, so I was about to watch your review of it, but a new theory video comes first!
I just saw it too
I saw it to yesterday it was really good lol
The fact that you are able to go from thousands of candidates and be able to pick one out perfectly is still mine blowing
Your passion for these movies and all the studying you do for these videos really shows. Keep up the good work!
When you said the Jessie doll came out in the fifty’s I got very confused then I realized you were talking about in the Pixar universe 😂
These are the old school type vids that I used to binge and love seeing😌
I think you should find out who Miguel’s (from Coco) monster is!
We can all agree that the film Up has some of the saddest scenes/storyline in the entire filmography/Pixar Universe
I LOVE SCB AND SCB GAMING!
Thanks Accelgor!
@@SuperCarlinBrothers No, Thank you for naming a pokemon after me!
As a math teacher, I am incredibly stoked that you use math to justify your logic. Totally using that next time a kid asks me when they will ever use math in life.
Who was Miguel's monster? Do kids in another country have monsters?
There’s a problem with this, if you remember, in monsters university, mike and sully both go to the human world, and it looks like in the human world it’s maybe the 70s or 80s, just because of how the park rangers are dressed, and there cars, so if that’s the case then I don’t know how all of this would add up
I think that as the door that mike goes through was only for tests, he returned less time to the past
I’d be interested to know who Miguel’s monster was
I don't buy it. Boo doesn't act like a kid in 1955, nor does her room look like it's in 1955. Faulty beginning = results that aren't results.
Yea plus doesn't it show a kid from the human world in a commercial in the Monsters world who is watching TV? The TV looks more modern.
@@TECfan1 In the commercial though it said "simulation - not actual child" so that doesn't really count. The people making the commercial probably just thought they would grab any commercially available TV found in the monster world instead of fact checking and spending more money to come up with a TV that looks like one from the human world.
What do you mean by her not acting like a kid from 1955?
Yeah she doesn’t dress nor does her room look like that
Yay! I’ve missed these videos. Glad they’re back!
I’ve been waiting years for this video to come out thank you so much
Earl looks like blue Lorax
Yeah!
I didnt understand half of this video but I like it 😂
Been a while since I’ve watched this channel, and I just wanted to say the new intro video is AWESOME
This is my favorite series on your channel!!! Please make more!!!
Actually, during bthe credits you see that they got promoted a few times before scare floor.
Love the shirt! I'm wearing a Pixar shirt too (Wall-e giving Eve a pinwheel).
CMC 123 me too!!!! I’m wearing a Russel t-shirt cuz every body says I look like him 😝.
*Eve
Awwwwww, it sounds so freaking CUTE!
@@eva.b5354 THANK YOU. my name is eva and my friends always do the Eee-vaaa thing and I always correct them.
Frida Jo_ No problem! Just doing my daily justice to the Disney/Pixar world. 🤪😊
As soon as you were narrowing them down I was going it's got to be the blue one with the giant moustache!
I could never figure this out and do the information and stuff. You are a genius! Love your videos
Monsters Inc related question: i have a closet with a sliding door, so how would the monsters go about scaring children with closets like mine?
NOW we’re asking the real questions!
My cousins Hector, Andy, and Frankie have a sliding closet and they were wondering that too XD
My closet doesn't have a door......it's a door-shaped hole in one of my walls if that makes sense....
Idk how you keep figuring this stuff out but please keep doing it. This was fantastic 🙌
As always, well delivered!!!
10:27 earl the terror Thompson must have been jealous while he was waiting in the closet to find Carl getting scared by a little girl before he got the chance to scare him
MY guess was Earl the Terror Thompson, so you can imagine how excited I was to see you guys predict Earl was Carl's monster! First time getting it right
They predicted your Prediction. This is getting scary.
Same
Also if you change the first letter Earl = Carl
When your job is to have too much time 😂
Did he say CARL JOHNSON?!??! YOU KNOW THAT WASN'T AN ACCIDENT
that is a lot of work to put into this! thanks for doing it for us :)
My head is about to explode with all that math and aligning and charts and KABOOM. 🤯
I wish my brothers would get along with each other like these brothers
I love this series, please do more !!
J, wow! That chart has me impressed. Good job!! Thanks for the awesome theories!
Who else noticed that in the thumbnail, their logo covered Mike's eye? Just me? Okay.
I love this new intro! But the old one is nostalgic.😁
Each monster is a special picked out for each kid, Thompson looks like a spider in order for me to completely agree with you, you would have to prove that coral is afraid of spiders
That thumbnail is perfect btw. I love how you positioned Mike
Cool video! Super Carlin brothers rock
Agreed. I love this series!
Hey Wotso! I’m a fan!
Plz make a vid on who is miguels monster
it makes sense he'd make a perfect monster for him. in Monster university it was introduced to know what the kid fears and who they are and what tactics to use for a grand result...and Earl whos card says "relies on a brief silence to execute roar" and carl being "not so much a tallker" he uses that as advantage to scare him which made carl jumpy at times of Ellie surprises
the cutest part of your guys videos is that your always like "Hey brother" and reffering to us as Ben so thats cute
me: about to go to sleep
i see this video
me: */I D O N T N E E D S L E E P I N E E D A N S W E R S/*
I just noticed that my mom worked at Disney AND SHE DOESNT EVEN KNOW THE PIXAR THEORY 😱😂😂😂
She did? That's pretty cool did she work on any movie's?
Returning fan and I’m really enjoying the new content! So addictive
i think this is one of my favorite theories ever. great job!
My monster is a rocket that failed to launch
4:55
Boo also has a Nemo toy, which Finding Nemo came out two years after Monsters, Inc. in 2003... Which comes to an interesting Finding Nemo fact, that the Sydney Opera House is imaged by those fish talking to Dory and the Sydney Opera House wasn't opened until 1973, with work beginning in 1958 and wouldn't appear complete. So Boo has a Jessie doll, which dates back to the 50's (another hand-me-down?), but also the Nemo toy, where Nemo was the next movie in the Pixar release schedule and took place sometime after the Sydney Opera House was completed and in the dental surgery the kid is reading a Mr Incredible comic, which would be mid-late 60's, but still the Sydney Opera House wasn't finished until the 70's and everyone knows how old some waiting room comics/magazines can be (maybe it was a reissue?)... Plus there was a Buzz Lightyear toy in that very same waiting room that the kid is seen reading the Mr Incredible comic, where in Toy Story 2, Stinky Pete said kids lost interest in cowboy toys with the introduction to space toys, which Buzz Lightyear is (presumably/rumured to be) named after Buzz Aldrin and the Moon landing took place in 1969, before the SOH was completed and Boo has a Nemo toy and a Buzz Lightyear appears in the movie of a fish which is probably long since deceased... Which opens up the timeline of Toy Story possibly happening sometime in the 80's (I need to watch more of your videos if you've ever mentioned the TS timeline), because Rex and Buzz are playing a Super Nintendo (and not a PlayStation or Nintendo 64) in Toy Story 2.
Pixar have broken their own timeline. 😂
EDIT: I forgot to mention that Buzz Lightyear was the cool new toy in Toy Story, which would pre-date Mr Spell (1970's) if there wasn't a cool space toy before Buzz.
I’m too lazy to read all this I’m so sorry
@@frijoles82 then don’t and move on???
You're SO GOOD at what you do!
Boo being born in the 50's actually matches with your theory of Edna being Bo's mom since the incredible takes place in the 50's
The time travel concept is the same one in “The tomorrow war” with chris pratt. Neat
I just had Déjà Vu of me getting a notification for this video.
Yes I agree with you because I don’t wanna take the time to do that much research
Some of my two favorite Pixar movies combined together. Amazing