@@sera7500 I am torn between Slytherin and Ravenclaw on her, but I definitely don't see Gryffindor. She doesn't want to be the Hero or face the danger, she wants to support that person in the background, with her brilliant mind and amazing suit designs. The fact that she would rather play behind the scenes on the superhero game is so Slytherin it's wild. Like, everything we know about Slytherins that have graduated from Hogwarts (Snape, Slughorn, Lucius, etc.) shows that they do not want to be the visible face to the public. You never see Lucius run for Minister, after all. I think Jay was correct in that there would be a hat stall on her, but in the end she'd end up a Snake, imo.
Edna Mode - She is a Ravenclaw! I feel very strongly about this. She is driven by the intellectual challenge of designing for the Supers. She is incredibly thoughtful about her designs for each member of the family, solving challenges that come with each person’s individual powers. She gets a thrill out of solving the “tricky” problem of designing a fabric that will vanish when Violet does, for example. She is NOT trying to “collect” Supers. When she refuses to put a cape on Bob’s suit it is for a very logical, thoughtful reason. She doesn’t try to appease Bob’s ego to get in his good graces, she refuses because that would be the wrong design for him. She is successful, not because she is ambitious, but because she is truly the best at what she does BECAUSE she is so thoughtful about how she approaches it.
I agree, The thing that drives Edna is the challenge and puzzle of designing around the super's powers, personalities, and combat conditions (the cape thing). That's a very Ravenclaw way of looking at things.
Katy Netti I don’t know. I think fighting against an arranged marriage would be quite impactful on their culture. But she can be very selfish, especially with the bear thing! But I don’t think Gryffindors are incapable of being selfish. I feel like the main difference between Gryffindors and Slytherins are Slytherins actions are often calculated whereas Gryffindors are more impulsive.
@@katiekoo-koohead2551 True, but I think she fits more as a Slytherin because her ambitiousness comes from wanting to be free and do what she wants to do, not follow what others have in mind for her. I don't know that it was entirely impulsive either. She already argued the point to her parents and I dare say she was trying to figure out the best way to get out of this whole arranged marriage deal.
I would describe her character arc like this: she starts out perfectly capable of being brave on her own behalf (the archery feat was a carefully laid plan of hers to secure her own freedom, very Slytherin), and she learns to be brave on behalf of others. Admitting that you were wrong and you regret the harm you've done to one you love is a very different form of courage. Does that disqualify her from still being Slytherin by the end of the story? I think that's selling the Slytherins short. Who says being Slytherin means you can't form a healthy, equal relationship?
You should do a J vs Ben where minor Harry Potter characters are named, and you take turns saying facts about them - house, appearance, personality, etc, and the first person who can't name any more facts loses that round!
J:(explaining the rules of the game) J:If we agree great, but if we disagree,we shall argue our point. Ben:To the death!!! J:(continues with explaining the rules) Ben:(silently smirking at his own joke) 0:59
I think that Russel is a Gryffindor. I believe that he would be the Neville kind of Gryffindor, specifically how he continued being a scout even though he didn’t have anyone to lead or guide him. He reminds me a lot of Neville in the fact that he’s very loyal and always tries his hardest, but can also be very brave and greatly values bravery.
camhasproblems I feel Russell is definitely Slytherin. He's so incredibly ambitious! He has all but one badge, and he's willing to do anything to get that last one.
Snow White- Hufflepuff (7 dwarfs friendship) Cinderella- Hufflepuff (working hard) Aurora- Hufflepuff (loyal to her godmothers) Ariel and Jasmine- Slytherin (cunning, strong willed, and ambitious) Belle- Ravenclaw (witty and intelligent) Mulan and Pocahontas- Gryffindor (brave, courage, sacrificing for love etc)
I would say Mulan is a Ravenclaw (she solves every problem by finding a clever alternate solution overlooked by others) and Ariel is a Hufflepuff (a curious explorer) - she's neither clever nor ambitious, although she is VERY strong-willed Tiana - Slytherin (very ambitious, willing to "do what it takes" to make those ambitions succeed) Rapunzel - Hufflepuff - gentle-spirited healer who makes friends with everyone and just wants everybody to get along Anna - Gryffindor - bold, impulsive, puts self in harms way multiple time for Arendelle and for Elsa Elsa - Slytherin - she values control and reputation above everything else Moana - Gryffindor - brave - her compassionate heart sparks her to ACTION, and she puts the collective good before everything else
Edna is 100% Slytherin, she’s loyal, said things straight forward and no filter and also kind of collect relationships with supers like Slughorn.... and Wasowzki is definitely ravenclaw, no Slytherin will be happy if they put them in the cover of a magazine and cover their faces
Enda would definitely be a Ravenclaw. Think about it she's insanely smart and probably has done so much work to try and figure out which suits would best fit which superheroes, yet you don't see her working as a scientist but as a designer. Ravenclaws don't always have to be your textbook professors they can be anything I mean he'll most ravenclaw's probably don't do homework because they're more interested in the knowledge and they are in the practice. Plus you got to think she designed all the super suits including the ones with capes. She probably has this whole thing with the capes were after so many deaths she had a breakdown. I mean she probably blames herself for every single one of them and that's why she's so adamant about no capes. Of the traits for Ravenclaw she is very wise, what did that be of her years or of her experience or just because she is wise in general, I have no idea. She is insanely creative and original considering she's the only one that we can have a lead to on who makes the super Hero suits. She even refers to herself as the best which can be cocky or confident, but also makes us think that she's the first as well. She's not afraid to be an individual, the most importantly, even after she probably had this feeling of her being the reason that all the superheroes died because it was her designs, she learned to accept it and move on, also a trait of ravenclaws. My case is rested.
Your argument works evenly for Slytherin, just because you are intelligent doesn't mean you're a Ravenclaw. It's about what you value. Edna uses her intelligence to reach her goals, which she's almost obsessive about. Ambitious, cunning and determined describes her better than just being intelligent. Creativity isn't exclusive to ravenclaws either, even though they like to think that.
MetObsessed creativity isn't exclusive to ravenclaws but it IS a trait most commonly associated with them. I do see your point with everything else though.
I think that Ben was right. Merida is slytherin. She comes up with the archery contest among the firstborn children to win her hand knowing that she qualifies and can compete, which is cunning AF.
Edna is such a Ravenclaw. Very intelligent, very clever, and values success in others. The lady loves her craft, much like Oliveander. (Great reference Ben btw)
Haha I like the reference of Mike's face getting covered by the Hogwarts crest on the video thumbnail. "oh my god..........................................IM ON THE THUMBNAIL OF A RUclips VIDEO!"
I understand that I'm late watching this video, but just to say it J.K Rowling originally wanted to make Hermione a Ravenclaw but instead she decided to make her a Gryffindor so that her Harry and Ron could get closer and so that the books made more sense.
I love when you guys get a chance to argue!!!!! But why oh WHY do you ALWAYS post RIGHT when I start to get focused on my 4 hours of work 6 hours before midnight?!?
No, dogs are most definitely Hufflepuffs. Dogs are super loyal, friendly, hard working and everything Hufflepuffs stands for. Also, people use dogs to find lost people, so definitely good finders too.
You will tell us the results, yes? Both for who wins and, like, how people voted? That'd be super bloody interesting, to see, like, what the trends are. (Sorry, stats nerds) Yes, this would be cool to see again (even if I sometimes end up whispering "Slytherinnnn" at my computer screen and make my cat look at me like I'm such a weirdo).
Please do a video on Professor Trelawney's divination tactics. Are they mere muggle fortune tell scams or are they truly predicting the future at an inaccurate rate?
"almost all of her predictions came true" Almost all of her predictions was "Harry, you gonna die", I think she failed majestically ^^ Her two actual prophecies came true, okay (well, the first one is a self-acomplished, so it's easier that way XD), but the others? I mean, just look at her three first predictions "Neville will break a cup", "Lavande's worst fear will be true on October 16th" and "Parvati had to beware of a red hair man". Well, the Neville's prediction came true, but she just has to listen Snape once to know that, Lavander's thing... like Hermione said, she just received the letter the 16th and her worst fear was not of her rabbit dying, as he's only a baby, and finally Parvati was never troubled by a red hair guy ^^' " Most horoscopes, fortunes, any prognosticators are vague " Of course they are, or they will not work XD
Merida was very cunning in setting up the shooting for her own hand. Plus do you see Gryffindor cursing their own mother to force her to do their will? Slytherin
The first thing I thought was that Merida was indeed rather cunning (Slytherin) than Gryffindor. Sure she was a bit impulsive but hybris can be both Syth as Gryf. Cursing her mother ain't that royal to me... Her plan to fix it again is smarter.
She didn’t intentionally do that to her mother. She wanted to change her own fate. That’s like Harry blowing up Vernon’s sister in P.O.A. It was a mistake that was made in the heat of the moment
Merida is the Sirius of Brave. A Griffindor in a long line of Slytherins. Since the plot of the film is that she wants to dissasosiate herself from her family(specifically her mom) and you don't get any more anti-slytherin than refusing an opportunity for power(marriage into becoming queen). Idk I haven't watched Brave in a while.
But I think she wanted to earn power the way she wanted it - becoming queen/the prime minister/president aren't the only sources of power. Also power-seeking isn't one of the set traits of Slytherin - ambition is. That might involve wanting to find a cure for all ills, for example, which doesn't necessarily make you powerful, but it does make you ambitious. Nevertheless, it was important to her that she did life her way, herself, which you could actually say was very Slytherin. She refused to accept an offer that didn't match her personal ambitions. I do think she's probably Gryffindor, but I don't think refusing marriage was particularly un-Slytherin of her.
Hufflepuffs are an incredibly brave house because of their loyalty, thats why it becomes a gray area. The difference is hufflepuff don't do it for the glory. ie the battle of hogwarts
Yeah exactly. Gryffindors are more hot-headed, but Hufflepuffs are brave when it comes down to it. Hufflepuffs don’t wanna show off when they show bravery, they just wanna do what’s right.
Antonia Sirotich No, Cinderella is most certainly Hufflepuff. She's loyal, hardworking-the main traits of Hufflepuff. I never once saw her being intelligent-creativity wasn't massively in her either. Aurora-well, she doesn't do much. But I don't see Ravenclaw in her either(from someone who was sorted into Hufflepuff but believes she is Ravenclaw)!
Rose Glover Ok, I'll give you Cinerella because she hard working, caring and kind (even tho every princess is kind) but I think that Aurora is ravenclaw because we dont see her very much, the only trait we see she has is curiosity (exept for kindness) and curiosity is a trait of ravenclaw
guys, no one cares if someone did a similar video before they did. most of the time creators are flattered they inspired someone else to discuss the same content. and it’s hard to credit one person when you aren’t sure who was the true originator of the idea was. just let it be and enjoy their interpretation of the game! 💛
I thought Disgust was actually Ravenclaw. She's there to keep Riley from being 'poisoned' and to help her socially and came up with a lot of solutions/suggestions of solutions to problems.
"To the DEATH!" "No, to the pain." "To the pain?" “To the pain means this: if we duel and you win, death for me. If we duel and I win, life for you. But life on my terms. The first thing you lose will be your feet. Below the ankle. You will have stumps available to use within six months. Then your hands, at the wrists. They heal somewhat quicker. Five months is a fair average. Next your nose. No smell of dawn for you. Followed by your tongue. Deeply cut away. Not even a stump left. And then your left eye-" And then my right eye, and then my ears, and shall we get on with it?" the Prince said. Wrong!" Westley’s voice rang across the room. "Your ears you keep, so that every shriek of every child shall be yours to cherish-every babe that weeps in fear at your approach, every woman that cries 'Dear God, what is that thing?' will reverberate forever with your perfect ears.”
0:58 I don't know, for whatever reason this just reminded me of the book/movie. AS amazing as the movie is, book is 6 times better by the way. it's so funny.
Merida starts out a slytherin, but like Dumbledore said, people may take the test too early. I do agree she is a gryffindor in the end, but the majority of the movie is what matters
Try picking wands for the characters. That would be the real challenge trying to pick the right wood and core combination. Length and flexibility would be way too hard to guess but you can try it.
I’m a proud Hufflepuff and I’m glad there are new Hufflepuff in the house because people think we are nothing but if you think of Russell and he is brave and really funny
And I found out that Slitherin are really good friends with Hufflepuff and they have relationships with each other and Slitherin stands up for Hufflepuff
I think discuss is actually in Ravenclaw. She's the emotion that need to protect the body from poison, so she need to be very smart to choose what to eat. Also, she is the one that figured out how to bring Joy and Sadness back, in a brilliant and creative way.
What does your SquareSpace project look like?! Show us using the #PickMeSCB
SuperCarlinBrothers Hey Brother
SuperCarlinBrothers plz reply
Heyyyyyyyyy sister?
I feel like you should’ve mentioned this being done before.
SuperCarlinBrothers read a book called fableheaven
The guy behind the camera that is reading the questions NEEDS to record an audiobook! His voice is just so... so... perfect.
I was just thinking, "Carlin brothers, I love your content, but please re-release all your videos but with Derek reading out what you'd say instead."
Maybe they'll make that a patreon reward ;)
Alexandra Chris I know!!
we need to make this happen!
J
"What do Gryffindors value?"
"Red hair."
Oh, so _that's_ why the twins got in...
Timothy McLean lol
...and ron and ginny and percy and bill and charlie
Timothy McLean lol
Timothy McLean The twins should've been Ravenclaw
Lol
Edna: “I used to design for GODS!”
Yeah... I’d have to go with Slytherin on that one.
Chris Schoenthaler that’s too good 😂😂😂
GODric gryffindor
Chris Schoenthaler I think ravenclaw
@@abisadventures8693 same
@@sera7500 I am torn between Slytherin and Ravenclaw on her, but I definitely don't see Gryffindor. She doesn't want to be the Hero or face the danger, she wants to support that person in the background, with her brilliant mind and amazing suit designs. The fact that she would rather play behind the scenes on the superhero game is so Slytherin it's wild. Like, everything we know about Slytherins that have graduated from Hogwarts (Snape, Slughorn, Lucius, etc.) shows that they do not want to be the visible face to the public. You never see Lucius run for Minister, after all. I think Jay was correct in that there would be a hat stall on her, but in the end she'd end up a Snake, imo.
J: Gryffin-
Ben: Slytherin
J- No Ben-
Ben: *smiles rebelliously*
J- The movie is CALLED BRAVE. What do Gryffindors value?
Ben: Red hair.
Merida is Ravenclaw in my mind
I thought Merida would Ben Slytherin.i can see Gryffindor but I thought Slytherin more cause ambition rather than brave
f d
Definitely slytherin, the movie is about her LEARNING the value of bravery, but she herself values the individuality
Sorting hat: oooo another WEASLY
Her: no im merida
Sorting hat: 𝚃w𝚃
Chracter Timecodes:
2:04 Buzz Lightyear
3:25 WALL-E
4:48 Merida
6:14 Mater
7:28 Mike Wazowski
9:18 Edna Mode
12:45 Russell
14:39 Spot
16:15 Colette
17:15 Princess Atta
19:05 Disgust
21:13 Hector
Hello random stranger. You are awesome!!
I stand by the fact that Mater couldn’t get accepted into Hogwarts due to being a squib
Thank you so much!
Ur a year late im 4 years late
Oink
Edna Mode - She is a Ravenclaw! I feel very strongly about this. She is driven by the intellectual challenge of designing for the Supers. She is incredibly thoughtful about her designs for each member of the family, solving challenges that come with each person’s individual powers. She gets a thrill out of solving the “tricky” problem of designing a fabric that will vanish when Violet does, for example. She is NOT trying to “collect” Supers. When she refuses to put a cape on Bob’s suit it is for a very logical, thoughtful reason. She doesn’t try to appease Bob’s ego to get in his good graces, she refuses because that would be the wrong design for him. She is successful, not because she is ambitious, but because she is truly the best at what she does BECAUSE she is so thoughtful about how she approaches it.
Exactly! Not to mention her incredible wit and wisdom! There's no ignoring that!
WALLE also should've been ravenclaw.
I agree, The thing that drives Edna is the challenge and puzzle of designing around the super's powers, personalities, and combat conditions (the cape thing). That's a very Ravenclaw way of looking at things.
true
That was beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
You should do this with marvel and star wars characters.
Raptorus77 don't forget D.C.
Yes! Please do this.
MARVELLLLLL
Raptorus77 wolverine is a hufflepuff. i can prove this.
Plz do marvel
Meridas bravery is all self serving and not for a greater cause. Therefore SLYTHERIN
Katy Netti I don’t know. I think fighting against an arranged marriage would be quite impactful on their culture. But she can be very selfish, especially with the bear thing! But I don’t think Gryffindors are incapable of being selfish. I feel like the main difference between Gryffindors and Slytherins are Slytherins actions are often calculated whereas Gryffindors are more impulsive.
@@iLuvvYuuMjxXxLia and merida's decision was definitely impulsive
@@katiekoo-koohead2551 True, but I think she fits more as a Slytherin because her ambitiousness comes from wanting to be free and do what she wants to do, not follow what others have in mind for her. I don't know that it was entirely impulsive either. She already argued the point to her parents and I dare say she was trying to figure out the best way to get out of this whole arranged marriage deal.
I agree 100% percent
I would describe her character arc like this: she starts out perfectly capable of being brave on her own behalf (the archery feat was a carefully laid plan of hers to secure her own freedom, very Slytherin), and she learns to be brave on behalf of others. Admitting that you were wrong and you regret the harm you've done to one you love is a very different form of courage. Does that disqualify her from still being Slytherin by the end of the story? I think that's selling the Slytherins short. Who says being Slytherin means you can't form a healthy, equal relationship?
Nobody:
Literally Nobody:
Ben: TO THe DeATh
I caught that to I thought j would say something
C2 s2 not really that funny though is it
Same
@@blakjjags0697 more random funny than actual funny
“Ben, the movie is called Brave” 😂 I really can’t omg I’m dead
100th like 😊
Ya
What do Gryffindors value? RED HAIR
Well I see his point, but she isn’t the type of slithering that we think of she’s good.
300th like
You should do a J vs Ben where minor Harry Potter characters are named, and you take turns saying facts about them - house, appearance, personality, etc, and the first person who can't name any more facts loses that round!
+
Good idea
YESSS
“ILL BE SHOOTIN FER ME OWN HAND” that’s a Slytherin powermove
Also Edna is a slytherin, the ambition of “I’m the best darling” and the drive
Yeah, Edna is very ambitious
Bob: "You're the best E."
Edna: "Yes, I know."
For Edna,in my opinon she is a Slytherian because she is ambitus,a strong leader,and resaurceful
Same
Slytherin*
N.O .C.A.P.E.S
And she used to design for gods
*Resourceful
J: "(About Mater) You can say he does a lot of brave things in Cars 2, if you want to remember that movie"
I'M DEAD, that cracks me up
What do Gryffindors value?
Red hair
I died😂😂😂
Hi dead I’m dad
He isn't wrong tho
Well, it is truth.
Ben: That loyalty felt really gryffindory
Hufflepuff: am I a joke to you
J: Gryffindor! Ben: Slytherin! J: Ben, the movie is called BRAVE.
Carrie Walsh With him there I mean really.
Lol 😂 makes sense 😆
Carrie Walsh lol
Anybody can be called brave
Grace Taylor then I shouldn't be in Gryffindor 😂
Russellpuff is possibly my favourite term ever now and also I just need that “Pull Yourself Together” on a loop ALWAYS
Huffle puff get it right jk hi
Branson Plumb hiya XD
J:(explaining the rules of the game)
J:If we agree great, but if we disagree,we shall argue our point.
Ben:To the death!!!
J:(continues with explaining the rules)
Ben:(silently smirking at his own joke)
0:59
I know! It's so awesome xD
I agree with Wazowski being in Slytherin, but a more important question is: Does he wink or blink(?)
I KNOW RIGHT
He blinks
ikr!!!!! i was literally wondering that the whole movie!!!
Why does getting the cute girl show that he’s Slytherin.
@@williambroberg6746 because the cute girl has snakes for hair and he's apparently into that kind of thing. Lol
I think that Russel is a Gryffindor. I believe that he would be the Neville kind of Gryffindor, specifically how he continued being a scout even though he didn’t have anyone to lead or guide him. He reminds me a lot of Neville in the fact that he’s very loyal and always tries his hardest, but can also be very brave and greatly values bravery.
camhasproblems
I feel Russell is definitely Slytherin. He's so incredibly ambitious! He has all but one badge, and he's willing to do anything to get that last one.
*camhasproblems* I'm proud for Russel to be in Hufflepuff, but I agree! He reminds me a lot of Neville and would, in the end, be very brave.
YeA
So, he's basically Gryffindor's Hufflepuff?
Essentially, yes xD
"I like this! I like when we're on the same team!" -Ben...Ben the scarf is getting to you.
One of us...One of us...
One of us! One of us!!!
One of us ! One of us !
one of us! one of us! 😂
One of us one of us
Does anyone else want Derek to record the complete Harry Potter audiobook series? :D Best voice ever!
Lisa Tierney yes. If he had a killer English accent then yes. But like if not then he should voice like every other book.
Lisa Tierney
But
But
Stephen Fry ❤️❤️❤️
Hit me up, Pottermore!
But also, what Scarlett Close said, Stephen Fry!
i, DK I really miss hearing that voice explaining the origin/meanings of names
It would be like an episode of Oprah but with orgasms. "You get an orgasm! You get an orgasm! Everybody gets orgasms!"
"His loyalty to Eve" me: AND his cockroach!
#Russellpuff
I love it it's so funny and it's true he is a Hufflepuff
jigglypuff
#fascinating
YEEAAHH hahahahaha
Yes.
No capes
I saw her in the thumbnail and that was my first thought
broperson1 YAS
Emeraldlollipop they need to put that in the incredibles 2
#nocapes
Chloe Webber motto of 2018
Something Bella no capes
100% do this again. I loved hearing your arguments and following alone was fun.
It's not alone it's along😆 get it like what hermioni said lol
Agree; I want to hear them do this on the classic animated Disney characters next.
J: **says anything**
Ben: Fascinating
The "Pull yourself together!" part made me laugh so hard I got pains
DuMbO3 XtReMe iii
DuMbO3 XtReMe is. O
Paul Shepherd has I
DuMbO3 XtReMe it made me laugh so rd i snorted
DuMbO3 XtReMe pull your self together !
Wall-e is literally a robotic longbottom
Does Walle even have a bottom?
Andrew Hidden true...
Ravenpotter a robotic bottom, yes.
Andrew Hidden new theory:
Is Neville's soul trapped in wall-e?
I love Neville and Wall-E
This would be interesting with the Disney Princesses....
Snow White- Hufflepuff (7 dwarfs friendship)
Cinderella- Hufflepuff (working hard)
Aurora- Hufflepuff (loyal to her godmothers)
Ariel and Jasmine- Slytherin (cunning, strong willed, and ambitious)
Belle- Ravenclaw (witty and intelligent)
Mulan and Pocahontas- Gryffindor (brave, courage, sacrificing for love etc)
Sissy Dean
Nice.
and Moana is Gryffindor
How about Tiana, Rapunzel, Anna, and Elsa?
I would say Mulan is a Ravenclaw (she solves every problem by finding a clever alternate solution overlooked by others) and Ariel is a Hufflepuff (a curious explorer) - she's neither clever nor ambitious, although she is VERY strong-willed
Tiana - Slytherin (very ambitious, willing to "do what it takes" to make those ambitions succeed)
Rapunzel - Hufflepuff - gentle-spirited healer who makes friends with everyone and just wants everybody to get along
Anna - Gryffindor - bold, impulsive, puts self in harms way multiple time for Arendelle and for Elsa
Elsa - Slytherin - she values control and reputation above everything else
Moana - Gryffindor - brave - her compassionate heart sparks her to ACTION, and she puts the collective good before everything else
Edna is 100% Slytherin, she’s loyal, said things straight forward and no filter and also kind of collect relationships with supers like Slughorn.... and Wasowzki is definitely ravenclaw, no Slytherin will be happy if they put them in the cover of a magazine and cover their faces
Definitely.
Enda would definitely be a Ravenclaw. Think about it she's insanely smart and probably has done so much work to try and figure out which suits would best fit which superheroes, yet you don't see her working as a scientist but as a designer. Ravenclaws don't always have to be your textbook professors they can be anything I mean he'll most ravenclaw's probably don't do homework because they're more interested in the knowledge and they are in the practice. Plus you got to think she designed all the super suits including the ones with capes. She probably has this whole thing with the capes were after so many deaths she had a breakdown. I mean she probably blames herself for every single one of them and that's why she's so adamant about no capes. Of the traits for Ravenclaw she is very wise, what did that be of her years or of her experience or just because she is wise in general, I have no idea. She is insanely creative and original considering she's the only one that we can have a lead to on who makes the super Hero suits. She even refers to herself as the best which can be cocky or confident, but also makes us think that she's the first as well. She's not afraid to be an individual, the most importantly, even after she probably had this feeling of her being the reason that all the superheroes died because it was her designs, she learned to accept it and move on, also a trait of ravenclaws. My case is rested.
Your argument works evenly for Slytherin, just because you are intelligent doesn't mean you're a Ravenclaw. It's about what you value.
Edna uses her intelligence to reach her goals, which she's almost obsessive about. Ambitious, cunning and determined describes her better than just being intelligent.
Creativity isn't exclusive to ravenclaws either, even though they like to think that.
MetObsessed creativity isn't exclusive to ravenclaws but it IS a trait most commonly associated with them. I do see your point with everything else though.
Stacia Holmes NO CAPES!!!
AGREEEEDDDDDD
I saw her in the thumbnail and said “she’s in my house” 😂😂😂 now that I typed that it sounds weird 👌🏼
0:58
TO THE DEATH - Ben
To determine - J
Ben's face was priceless
he looked like jacksepticeye
CatGirl0099 oooooohhh yeaaahh..
He actually looks like he is contemplating it lol
It's just the letter J
Three of my favorite things SuperCarlinBrothers, Harry Potter, and Pixar!
I think the houses could also be based on the 4 male archetypes:
King: Slythrin.
warrior: Griffondor
Lover: Hufflepuff
Magician: Ravenclaw.
@Ali Malik maybe they try to bring peace? I love Hufflepuff as well. It is also my House
@Ali Malik I agree. I just tried to make it sound better.
Why is warrior lower case?
I think hufflepuff should be like a peasant or something
I like ravenclaw
"What do Gryffindors value?"
"Red hair"
OMG LMAO I DIED
Jeweliet no u didn't cause how'd u rite this coment
its called sarcasm here ill send you some
U didn’t send him any... Why’d you lie?
MP Studios I ran out cuz I used it all up
:(
when he paused when he said, "But what she values most" my first thought to what he was gonna say was "No capes?"
Liger Diamond 😂😂😂😂😂😂 me too!!!!
I love this! You should do this with Marvel! or Star Wars! or Disney!
Marvel and star wars are disney know so just say disney
HitMeWithABrick lol so is pixar but it's in this video they would definitely separate them
Emily Ostmeyer OR ALL!
Star wars and Marvel are both owned by Disney
or DC :)
“Gryffindors are basically dogs” I’ve never thought that, but it is so true 😂
I'd say Hufflepuffs are basically dogs because of the undying loyalty.
Muffin Sparks furry
@@GhastlyG ✨expelled✨
@@candykittenlove2504 no professor
Dogs are loyal, that’s the whole point of a dog
I think that Ben was right. Merida is slytherin. She comes up with the archery contest among the firstborn children to win her hand knowing that she qualifies and can compete, which is cunning AF.
No she’s a ravenclaw
yup she is a total slytherin
She obviously a slytherclawdor
ThE mOViE is CaLlEd bRaVE
Yeah. She’s slytherin.
Edna is such a Ravenclaw. Very intelligent, very clever, and values success in others. The lady loves her craft, much like Oliveander. (Great reference Ben btw)
Also Disgust is literally the female version of Malfoy. EVERYTHING pisses her off.
Are you going to reveal the final percentages?? I'm super curious about how other people voted
Ben: I don't think that im a Ravenclaw
Also Ben: FASCINATING
Haha I like the reference of Mike's face getting covered by the Hogwarts crest on the video thumbnail.
"oh my god..........................................IM ON THE THUMBNAIL OF A RUclips VIDEO!"
T.E.C._1 omg! I didn't even notice they blocked him out with the crest. That's hilarious!
I didn't even notice that! That is why I love this channel
T.E.C._1 Edna mode?
risk it for a biscuit Huh?
"Gryffindors are basically dogs." I found that very funny. It is usually Hufflepuffs that are referred to as pets, so this was quite refreshing.
Potter Nerd k
You’re right, I mean they are man’s best friend
Potter Nerd all Gryffindor getting offended (including me) in 3.. 2... 1...
@@qui1076 no one gets offended
#Slytherinforthewin
I understand that I'm late watching this video, but just to say it J.K Rowling originally wanted to make Hermione a Ravenclaw but instead she decided to make her a Gryffindor so that her Harry and Ron could get closer and so that the books made more sense.
I can't believe neither of y'all mentioned Wall-E's fervent plant hunt with the Hufflepuffs💛Herbology thing
Ben. A Slytherin wearing a Hufflepuff scarf.
**Kylo Ren voice**
TRAITOR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DrinkWaterOnce hahahaha
Kylo Ren did the same
I agree with you so much
Kaleb Pierce sorry to be picky, but I think you mean TR-8R when he calls Fin a traitor
My favorite line, “Ben, the movies called, BRAVE.” XD Couldn’t stop laughing
Edit: Never gotten this many likes omg xD
XD
GinnyGingers lol, my phone glitched out and your comment has no likes.
dayala singh same
Rip xD
OMG YES! Seamus did something like this, and I have been waiting for someone to sort pixar characters
Thomas sanders
Seamus Gorman did it a while ago
Thomas Sanders and Brizzy Voices did a few crossover videos where they sorted Disney and Pixar characters
One word: RUSSELPUFF
Its animal logo would be Kevin
Crystal Piper please don’t disrespect my house hufflepuff it’s jk rollings fave house
@@kaylibeech5308 Crystal was just making a joke from the video. I'm a Hufflepuff, so dont worry, I dont like people talking trash about ma house
@@kaylibeech5308 how?
Kayli Beech im a hufflepuff to
I would love to see more videos like this! This was awesome, please make it a recurring thing! :D
Fyrestorm24 its the nerdiest thing I've ever seen
I love when you guys get a chance to argue!!!!! But why oh WHY do you ALWAYS post RIGHT when I start to get focused on my 4 hours of work 6 hours before midnight?!?
Natalie for me it's 23 hrs before midnight.
Ricky wait a second
Same here. Just started my homework, took a break, and ended up here.
Same
PLEASE do this with more movies and characters!!
The movie is called brave. But Merida is a slytherin
Yep.
I liked it better when it was
"The bear and the bow"
I think ben said "Fasinating" every. Single. One... fasinating.
SillyGillyWater 1771 5v
So true.... it really fascinating
I KNOW!!!!
No he doesn't, he says "Interesting" more. I'm 10 mins into the video and he hasn't said "Fascinating" once......
Please do Disney princesses sorted into Hogwarts houses
Emily Clark OMG YESSSS
No, dogs are most definitely Hufflepuffs. Dogs are super loyal, friendly, hard working and everything Hufflepuffs stands for. Also, people use dogs to find lost people, so definitely good finders too.
I feel like ravenclaw is very underrepresented here
Disgust is literally an animated version of Pansy Parkinson... Pansy was even described as having a permanent look of disgust on her face
Yonathan Taye Totally what I thought!
You will tell us the results, yes? Both for who wins and, like, how people voted? That'd be super bloody interesting, to see, like, what the trends are. (Sorry, stats nerds)
Yes, this would be cool to see again (even if I sometimes end up whispering "Slytherinnnn" at my computer screen and make my cat look at me like I'm such a weirdo).
Please do a video on Professor Trelawney's divination tactics. Are they mere muggle fortune tell scams or are they truly predicting the future at an inaccurate rate?
Honnjyx VII but they where very vague and/or obvious to begin with
Most horoscopes, fortunes, any prognosticators are vague
"almost all of her predictions came true"
Almost all of her predictions was "Harry, you gonna die", I think she failed majestically ^^
Her two actual prophecies came true, okay (well, the first one is a self-acomplished, so it's easier that way XD), but the others? I mean, just look at her three first predictions "Neville will break a cup", "Lavande's worst fear will be true on October 16th" and "Parvati had to beware of a red hair man". Well, the Neville's prediction came true, but she just has to listen Snape once to know that, Lavander's thing... like Hermione said, she just received the letter the 16th and her worst fear was not of her rabbit dying, as he's only a baby, and finally Parvati was never troubled by a red hair guy ^^'
" Most horoscopes, fortunes, any prognosticators are vague "
Of course they are, or they will not work XD
Honnjyx VII yeah and in the goblet of fire ron and Harry LITERALLY predict the entire book
Krankar Volund no parvati was kind of troubled by a red haired man. Harry and Ron were horrible dates for the Yule Ball. Ron has red hair
For Edna I was also torn between Ravenclaw and Slytherin!😄
“We shall argue our point”
“TO THE DEATH!” Ben is me😂
Merida was very cunning in setting up the shooting for her own hand. Plus do you see Gryffindor cursing their own mother to force her to do their will? Slytherin
Georgia M but I feel like she might be too trusting to be a Slytherin
The first thing I thought was that Merida was indeed rather cunning (Slytherin) than Gryffindor. Sure she was a bit impulsive but hybris can be both Syth as Gryf. Cursing her mother ain't that royal to me... Her plan to fix it again is smarter.
That was an accidental curse, she didnt mean to do it
cough sirius cough lmao XD
She didn’t intentionally do that to her mother. She wanted to change her own fate. That’s like Harry blowing up Vernon’s sister in P.O.A. It was a mistake that was made in the heat of the moment
Merida is the Sirius of Brave.
A Griffindor in a long line of Slytherins. Since the plot of the film is that she wants to dissasosiate herself from her family(specifically her mom) and you don't get any more anti-slytherin than refusing an opportunity for power(marriage into becoming queen). Idk I haven't watched Brave in a while.
Eye Am Always Watching - CKA Her brothers seem more like Slytherins to me.
sillysiblingstuff I wasn't saying that they weren't, them being Slitherins actually furthers my point that she's the Sirius of her family :P
But I think she wanted to earn power the way she wanted it - becoming queen/the prime minister/president aren't the only sources of power. Also power-seeking isn't one of the set traits of Slytherin - ambition is. That might involve wanting to find a cure for all ills, for example, which doesn't necessarily make you powerful, but it does make you ambitious.
Nevertheless, it was important to her that she did life her way, herself, which you could actually say was very Slytherin. She refused to accept an offer that didn't match her personal ambitions. I do think she's probably Gryffindor, but I don't think refusing marriage was particularly un-Slytherin of her.
Ece I agree that my reasoning and wording wasn't the most correct but I was trying to compare her to Sirius black more than anything.
It's Slytherin
Sorry, that just really bothers me...
Loyalty is between Gryffindor and Hufflepuff, and cleverness is between Ravenclaw and Slytherin.
Slytherins are also loyal to other Slytherins.
Slytherins are loyal to those they care about and trust... Which is not many
When you're both loyal and clever:
.......
....
....
.......
RAvEnpUff?????
Yep
So...Gryffindors and Hufflepuffs are dumb now. I see. That’s just fine to all the Hufflepuffs and Gryffindors reading this.
Hufflepuffs are an incredibly brave house because of their loyalty, thats why it becomes a gray area. The difference is hufflepuff don't do it for the glory. ie the battle of hogwarts
YES!!!!!
THANK YOU
FINNALY SOMEONE SAYS IT!
Aya Beydoun well gryffindor is the bravery house, so na
Yeah exactly. Gryffindors are more hot-headed, but Hufflepuffs are brave when it comes down to it. Hufflepuffs don’t wanna show off when they show bravery, they just wanna do what’s right.
Can you do a video sorting Star Wars characters into Hogwarts houses?
I love how J just refused to acknowledge the 'TO THE DEATH' thing.
I agree with Ben when he says Ravenclaw for Edna.
I thought Edna would be Slytherin.
I also agree, but everyone has their own opinion.
@@hayzyhorses6899 that's true.
You guys should of worn Sorting Hats.
Sort Disney Princesses/Princes Into Houses!!!!!
Hashim ThaDream Not necessarily a good idea. I think all the older princesses would be Hufflepuff!
Rose Glover That's not true. Snowhite maybe, but I think Cinderella is a ravenclaw and so is Aurora.
Antonia Sirotich No, Cinderella is most certainly Hufflepuff. She's loyal, hardworking-the main traits of Hufflepuff. I never once saw her being intelligent-creativity wasn't massively in her either. Aurora-well, she doesn't do much. But I don't see Ravenclaw in her either(from someone who was sorted into Hufflepuff but believes she is Ravenclaw)!
Rose Glover Ok, I'll give you Cinerella because she hard working, caring and kind (even tho every princess is kind) but I think that Aurora is ravenclaw because we dont see her very much, the only trait we see she has is curiosity (exept for kindness) and curiosity is a trait of ravenclaw
Yesssss!
_"She's not that, like, clever about how she's cunning."_
Hewo
I like toydles
When they say that colette is slytherin because she loves the sound of bread:
Hmmm. Maybe I should be slytherin instead of gryffindor.🤔
That "Pull yourself together!" part X'D
Berry Disenka when was that?
I love Mike's placement in the thumbnail! Lol
Whitney Redmon I didn't even notice!!! That's amazing!!!
Good observation 😂👌
guys, no one cares if someone did a similar video before they did. most of the time creators are flattered they inspired someone else to discuss the same content. and it’s hard to credit one person when you aren’t sure who was the true originator of the idea was. just let it be and enjoy their interpretation of the game! 💛
I thought Disgust was actually Ravenclaw. She's there to keep Riley from being 'poisoned' and to help her socially and came up with a lot of solutions/suggestions of solutions to problems.
ben is a confirmed SLYTHERUFF!!!! welcome to the club mate... never been so proud
EDNA IS OBVIOUSLY A RAVENCLAW
Kim Henderson ikr she's so obvious about her smarts. NO CAPES!
"To the DEATH!"
"No, to the pain."
"To the pain?"
“To the pain means this: if we duel and you win, death for me. If we duel and I win, life for you. But life on my terms. The first thing you lose will be your feet. Below the ankle. You will have stumps available to use within six months. Then your hands, at the wrists. They heal somewhat quicker. Five months is a fair average. Next your nose. No smell of dawn for you. Followed by your tongue. Deeply cut away. Not even a stump left. And then your left eye-"
And then my right eye, and then my ears, and shall we get on with it?" the Prince said.
Wrong!" Westley’s voice rang across the room. "Your ears you keep, so that every shriek of every child shall be yours to cherish-every babe that weeps in fear at your approach, every woman that cries 'Dear God, what is that thing?' will reverberate forever with your perfect ears.”
0:58 I don't know, for whatever reason this just reminded me of the book/movie. AS amazing as the movie is, book is 6 times better by the way. it's so funny.
Yes👌
Schner1 thank you! "To the pain!"
"THE MOVIE IS LITERALLY CALLED BRAVE"
"What do Gryffindors value?"
"Red hair"
Also I think Gryffindor
Bravery
Saaaaame I seriously think that she is
YES 2 favorite fandoms combined, what could be better?
Speaking of harry potter, y'all should make a video on where Hogwarts actually is geographically!
Frn highlands Scotland
Frn Highlands of Scotland
Merida starts out a slytherin, but like Dumbledore said, people may take the test too early. I do agree she is a gryffindor in the end, but the majority of the movie is what matters
"Hector"
Me: the h is silent...
Ben: your pronunciation is great
I think he said annunciation. He was referring to the tone of voice.
@@quantumgirl3047 It's possible.
Ben... Are you channeling your inner Seamus Gorman today...
LPS PurplePAWS I like to pretend that Seamus is their younger cousin.
ArtLover Animation lmao
LPS PurplePAWS, your comment made me laugh out loud.
ArtLover Animation, your comment made me spit my drink everywhere!
I'd definitely love to see more of this type of video!
So, Harry Pixar?
James Shaffer
*Round of applause*
I don’t think I can say it better than this ^ guy/girl
YESS!
Ayyyyyyyyyy
J: "What do Gryffindors value?"
Ben: "Red Hair"
Me: *Literally Dying of Laughter*
I think Edna is ravenclaw
Try picking wands for the characters. That would be the real challenge trying to pick the right wood and core combination. Length and flexibility would be way too hard to guess but you can try it.
"She didn't need to be ambitious because she is already on top", what kind of Slytherin says that?
Russell is like Collin Creevey!
Ben’s scarf is cracking me up.
I’m a proud Hufflepuff and I’m glad there are new Hufflepuff in the house because people think we are nothing but if you think of Russell and he is brave and really funny
And I found out that Slitherin are really good friends with Hufflepuff and they have relationships with each other and Slitherin stands up for Hufflepuff
Heather Vicent really ?
Heather Vicent i am a slythrien but i loves ma hufflepuffs
Slytherin*
I’m glad you guys are replying 😁
I think discuss is actually in Ravenclaw. She's the emotion that need to protect the body from poison, so she need to be very smart to choose what to eat. Also, she is the one that figured out how to bring Joy and Sadness back, in a brilliant and creative way.