ThinkPad P14s Gen 5 AMD vs Intel Comparison | Slap Tech

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 31 дек 2024

Комментарии • 60

  • @JackBurkhardt
    @JackBurkhardt Месяц назад +15

    Fantastic video as always man! One thing to note about the keyboards, the AMD model has a replaceable keyboard while the Intel does not (at least not easily). You can see the slight gap on the edge of the KB on the AMD where it slots in.

  • @ghostlyed8902
    @ghostlyed8902 Месяц назад +2

    Thank you so much man! I had already decided which one to purchase but it was still very helpful to get your thoughts since you own both of them. Excellent review!!!

  • @wallywal6139
    @wallywal6139 20 дней назад +1

    I have the AMD version in this exact configuration. It's a great laptop and I have zero complaints.

  • @mitch1981
    @mitch1981 29 дней назад

    Awesome! Exactly what I was looking for! Cheers.

  • @yoonvsaechao
    @yoonvsaechao 3 дня назад

    Ok so I am really considering pulling the trigger on this laptop, but can't decide between AMD or intel... overall which one would last the longest?

  • @puneetblog
    @puneetblog Месяц назад +2

    luv the dingle "slap tech" intro. years before anybody put so much into a youtube video

  • @Dr.H2O
    @Dr.H2O 16 дней назад +1

    nice review. got AMD version with IPS 100%. Cheap material but seems robust. We will see.

  • @gregthwuen
    @gregthwuen 14 дней назад

    Great video! Just one note: The amount of memory the integrated GPU uses from the system RAM is dynamically allocated, so 8 GB is very likely just the lower limit that was set in the BIOS. There's not really an upper limit as long as there's more RAM available. The problem is that a lot of games don't recognize this, but this is purely a software issue, and I'm sure there are workarounds.

  • @DenisFord-q3t
    @DenisFord-q3t 28 дней назад +1

    Great review and comparison - thanks!
    I'm refreshing my Gen 3 T14 with AMD because I can't stand how frequently it chokes on sleep mode, a well known issue on the AMD-based model. Any sign of sleep mode instability on this AMD?

    • @Slap_Tech
      @Slap_Tech  28 дней назад +2

      I don't endorse using sleep mode on any Windows machine. I'm a strictly on/off kind of dude.

    • @little_fluffy_clouds
      @little_fluffy_clouds 21 день назад

      @@Slap_Techokay, but it’s not 1999 any more, most laptops can sleep and wake successfully. I never shut down my MacBook since it can sleep and wake in less than a second - by the time it takes me to lift up the lid, it’s woken up from sleep and ready for use.

  • @protocolraptor2020
    @protocolraptor2020 Месяц назад

    Mad helpful thx! The chart at the end will help me decide:) You should do a Thinkpad P14s Intel vs Zenbook 14 next

  • @fretbuzzly
    @fretbuzzly 27 дней назад +1

    Great comparison. Intel must be throwing wads of cash at Lenovo to get these custom builds. That said, I recently priced out similar builds between the two and the Intel was at least $500 more. It's Lenovo, so it depends on the day of the week and the time of day as to pricing, but no matter there seems to be a pretty big price gap between the two. Only the buyer can decide if that's worth it given how close these are overall.

  • @JackD1311
    @JackD1311 Месяц назад

    great video im looking fora laptop mostly to run adobe illustrator and photoshoot. I'm considering the AMD without the oled. or the Yoga pro 7 AMD that has a dedicated RTX 3050 any thoughts?

  • @MnemonicCarrier
    @MnemonicCarrier Месяц назад +1

    It's a pity the AMD version only comes within a 52.5Wh battery (in my region anyway). I still have a P14s with the Ryzen 7 5850u, and it's still pretty good. I use it as a Linux workstation, and replaced the trackpad with a glass one (it make so much difference!). Even with its old tiny battery, I'm squeezing around 8 hours of light use out of it (just browsing, and doing stuff on the terminal). Looks like I might go for a TongFang GX4 this time around...

    • @gregthwuen
      @gregthwuen 14 дней назад

      Where did you get the glass trackpad? Sounds great

    • @MnemonicCarrier
      @MnemonicCarrier 14 дней назад

      @@gregthwuen I bought it from eBay. I think I found the model in some Reddit thread.

  • @mikaelahyakuya3485
    @mikaelahyakuya3485 23 дня назад

    If the newer gen comes with Arrow Lake-H, that's gonna be easy. but I'd choose the one without dGPU for less heat and more battery life.

  • @shathaomar1516
    @shathaomar1516 23 дня назад

    I have a query. Since everything is upgradable in this laptop, can we put battery of 75W in p14 AMD? just curious to know.

    • @Alpha8713
      @Alpha8713 22 дня назад +1

      No, the chassis design is different.

  • @nishiljaiswal2216
    @nishiljaiswal2216 Месяц назад

    Perfect timing to make use of the awesome sales on these rn

  • @dimml0r
    @dimml0r 15 дней назад

    very good video, but price should play a role in that ranking shouldnt it? :D

  • @user-ek8cd1he7p
    @user-ek8cd1he7p Месяц назад

    Great review!

  • @eiceys4612
    @eiceys4612 22 дня назад

    the amd version is a 700 dollars now on lenovo, any thought ?

    • @eiceys4612
      @eiceys4612 22 дня назад

      fck i just edit my commentary and lost your like ! great video btw really thanks you i love you kiss

  • @pouf-dk3nq
    @pouf-dk3nq Месяц назад

    Both amazing laptops, I would choose the Intel one for the nvidia graphics, it supports iommu and bunch of virtualization features (allows you to split the GPU for different guests) of course I would buy this laptop refurbished since they last for a long time. BTW will you review the gen6 T14 AMD ? its price is ludicrous right now though

  • @rdrachmanto
    @rdrachmanto Месяц назад

    Great review! what game is that at 07:16?

    • @Slap_Tech
      @Slap_Tech  Месяц назад +2

      Streets of Rage 4

    • @hokayson6518
      @hokayson6518 29 дней назад +1

      ​@@Slap_Tech First time viewer here, but seeing Streets of Rage 4 earned you a sub my friend 😄 also the informative & amusing comparison.

  • @lenoroshamann6679
    @lenoroshamann6679 Месяц назад +1

    Nice very helpful, gonna choose AMD

  • @gamewondertv7934
    @gamewondertv7934 Месяц назад +1

    First! Great video.

  • @hakaishin101
    @hakaishin101 5 дней назад

    Ports should have gone to intel. A 5 for each is kinda unfair

  • @Balu-1988
    @Balu-1988 19 дней назад

    Hello world. P14s gen5 Intel vs T14s gen6 Snap vs zenbook 14? For youtube and videocalls and typing. God bless

    • @MattJH
      @MattJH 18 дней назад

      You can watch RUclips, make video calls, and type on literally any laptop.

  • @PureLuck21
    @PureLuck21 Месяц назад

    I’ve read conflicting info about the intel version having a soldered battery, in your experience was that true?

    • @Slap_Tech
      @Slap_Tech  Месяц назад +2

      @@PureLuck21 Not in my experience. I was able to unscrew it. Unplugging it was too intimidating, so I didn't try. 😅
      The AMD is easier, not even a cable, it just plugs right in.

  • @arsicpedja
    @arsicpedja Месяц назад +1

    And AMD laptop is 200$ cheaper. So yeah, AMD is the winer here :)

    • @nhanNguyen-wo8fy
      @nhanNguyen-wo8fy Месяц назад +1

      No it's not just 200$. Ultra 7 cpu with bigger battery alone cost 200$ more 😂 let alone an Nvidia dGPU

    • @arsicpedja
      @arsicpedja Месяц назад

      @nhanNguyen-wo8fy I searched by exact model number and looking at prices at the same store, yeah it is 200 dollars difference.

    • @fretbuzzly
      @fretbuzzly 27 дней назад +1

      I priced out similar AMD and Intel versions of this just this week and the Intel was $500+ more. You have to play around with the Lenovo site to get the best prices. My first build comparison showed a $900 difference between the two.

    • @itsmilan4069
      @itsmilan4069 25 дней назад +1

      ​@@nhanNguyen-wo8fydon't forget the upgrade in build quality too
      have tried the AMD one and I don't know why lenovo did AMD dirty with the cheap build quality that makes it feel like sub $600 laptop

  • @diablorojo3887
    @diablorojo3887 7 дней назад

    Completly differente notebooks, give they the same name....
    I hate lenovo soooo much

  • @shathaomar1516
    @shathaomar1516 20 дней назад

    The AMD laptop heats up alot ..

  • @keev9882
    @keev9882 Месяц назад +1

    8 hours battery life for intel va 5 hours
    Intel totally demolished AMD in mobile this gen

    • @Jimster481
      @Jimster481 Месяц назад +1

      They didn't, just the 8845HS is a higher power CPU.

    • @mikaelahyakuya3485
      @mikaelahyakuya3485 23 дня назад

      ​​@@Jimster481but the intel one also comes with the H series CPU, not the U. so it's irrelevant.
      Battery size difference is around 40% but the runtime difference is 60%

    • @Jimster481
      @Jimster481 23 дня назад

      @@mikaelahyakuya3485 Things like the choice of the screen and the SSD matter a lot in terms of battery life as well as the Wi-Fi card chosen and the drivers and how much it puts it to sleep or not. There are lots of factors that affect battery life.

    • @Daniel-688
      @Daniel-688 18 дней назад +1

      @@mikaelahyakuya3485AMD has OLED display, hurry power than LCD in Intel version…

  • @roshanlalverma340
    @roshanlalverma340 Месяц назад

    They are nothing compared to apple M series laptop 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @Slap_Tech
      @Slap_Tech  Месяц назад +6

      @@roshanlalverma340 I'll say they provide a very appropriate amount of performance relative to their price tag.

    • @axtoncommander8312
      @axtoncommander8312 Месяц назад +2

      @@Slap_Tech A mac intruder ? ಠಿ_ಠ

    • @Jimster481
      @Jimster481 Месяц назад

      Apple doesn't have OLED screens, and getting 64GB of ram is basically out of the question...

    • @fretbuzzly
      @fretbuzzly 27 дней назад

      Yes, for 2x-3x the price you can get a Mac Pro.

    • @Jimster481
      @Jimster481 27 дней назад +2

      @@fretbuzzly Yep for 3x the price and no upgradable anything and no OLED screen.... also locked to MacOS which is horrible. No thanks.