GIVEAWAY ALERT Our team is giving away free access to a language learning app/program every month to one of our subscribers. It only takes a few seconds to join! More details here: ruclips.net/video/YjXSjaSeA4w/видео.html
It’s interesting how many similarities Catalan has to both Spanish and French. That makes a lot of sense geographically, since Catalonia shares a border with southern France.
Beautiful video, only a retification, catalan doesn't comes from french never, catalan comes from occitan and spanish comes from toledan, and occitan and toledan comes from Vulgar latin, catalan and spanish are from differents, spanish is central iberic, catalan is gallo occitan iberic, a strong difference between both. Kisses.😘😘😘😘😘😘🍻🍻🍻🍷🍷🍷🍷🍷🍷
Castilian doesn't come from Toledo, as Toledo was conquered afterwards. Castillian is actually the romance language that romanised Basques spoke in the area that was between Cantabria, la Rioja and Burgos. That's why Castillian has 5 vowels only, being those 5 vowels a basque substrate. Catalan is not phyllogenetically Iberian. As you stated, it is Gallo-Occitan, but not Iberian.
You are a liar the first grammar organized and explained in a logical and easy way appeared in Toledo, in the era of Old Spanish. You use the lie as an argument, the translators of Toledo and others banned Mozarabic from Spain, you lying scoundrel. The Catalan is an Occitan rooster because it was born from the Occitan in France but developed and separated from it, migrating to Spain and interacting with the Spanish and Aragonese, that is, Iberian. The Catalan is an Iberian Occitan rooster. If you're going to shit on your finger, don't use the keyboard, keep quiet and don't write son of the devil made in hell!
@@TuaTeMauAkauAtea Castilian doesn't come from "Toletan". In Toledo, the language was just given an orthography. Castilian originates from Northern Spain, in an area that was bilingual in Romance and Basque. Many districts in the area have a Basque substrate: Burgos, La Rioja ect... By the time orthographic norms were established in Toledo, Castilian had been spoken between Cantabria, Burgos and the lower Navarre through centuries. And no. Catalan is not an Iberian language in origin, as you stated. Spanish, Galician and Portuguese are. Catalan is phylogenitically a Gallo-romance language. That has already been accepted in the science of linguistics. I wish you would stop swearing and inmerse yourself in a more academic debate.
don't use that flag it's the flag of a political movement that strives to create an ethnostate including all the places that speak catalan, even the ones that don't have cataln culture but they do speak varieties of the language. Just use the senyera it's what most people use, shouldn't be mixing politics and languages like that. Also catalan does not have french influence, it has occitan influence from a thousand years ago just like Aragonese my language ;))))))))))
GIVEAWAY ALERT
Our team is giving away free access to a language learning app/program every month to one of our subscribers. It only takes a few seconds to join! More details here: ruclips.net/video/YjXSjaSeA4w/видео.html
Nice video
very useful video to understand the differences
Never realised that there was that many Catalan speakers. Great video
Thanks! 😃
It’s interesting how many similarities Catalan has to both Spanish and French. That makes a lot of sense geographically, since Catalonia shares a border with southern France.
Thanks for watching and sharing!
Beautiful video, only a retification, catalan doesn't comes from french never, catalan comes from occitan and spanish comes from toledan, and occitan and toledan comes from Vulgar latin, catalan and spanish are from differents, spanish is central iberic, catalan is gallo occitan iberic, a strong difference between both.
Kisses.😘😘😘😘😘😘🍻🍻🍻🍷🍷🍷🍷🍷🍷
Castilian doesn't come from Toledo, as Toledo was conquered afterwards. Castillian is actually the romance language that romanised Basques spoke in the area that was between Cantabria, la Rioja and Burgos. That's why Castillian has 5 vowels only, being those 5 vowels a basque substrate.
Catalan is not phyllogenetically Iberian. As you stated, it is Gallo-Occitan, but not Iberian.
You are a liar the first grammar organized and explained in a logical and easy way appeared in Toledo, in the era of Old Spanish.
You use the lie as an argument, the translators of Toledo and others banned Mozarabic from Spain, you lying scoundrel.
The Catalan is an Occitan rooster because it was born from the Occitan in France but developed and separated from it, migrating to Spain and interacting with the Spanish and Aragonese, that is, Iberian.
The Catalan is an Iberian Occitan rooster.
If you're going to shit on your finger, don't use the keyboard, keep quiet and don't write son of the devil made in hell!
@@TuaTeMauAkauAtea Castilian doesn't come from "Toletan". In Toledo, the language was just given an orthography. Castilian originates from Northern Spain, in an area that was bilingual in Romance and Basque. Many districts in the area have a Basque substrate: Burgos, La Rioja ect...
By the time orthographic norms were established in Toledo, Castilian had been spoken between Cantabria, Burgos and the lower Navarre through centuries.
And no. Catalan is not an Iberian language in origin, as you stated. Spanish, Galician and Portuguese are. Catalan is phylogenitically a Gallo-romance language. That has already been accepted in the science of linguistics.
I wish you would stop swearing and inmerse yourself in a more academic debate.
don't use that flag it's the flag of a political movement that strives to create an ethnostate including all the places that speak catalan, even the ones that don't have cataln culture but they do speak varieties of the language. Just use the senyera it's what most people use, shouldn't be mixing politics and languages like that.
Also catalan does not have french influence, it has occitan influence from a thousand years ago just like Aragonese my language ;))))))))))