You know what every passage of this concerto tickles the corner of a pianist's mind that's about their intimate relationship with their piano, fingers and the piano itself. I can't explain how exactly it does, but it's just there that lights up the tip of the right side of your brain like a bulb, and it makes you remember the time you practice Chopin and Schumann concertos but with a new melody, and that's how it gives comfort to us pianists, and that's why I need to learn it, even tho I know there will never be a day I get to perform it with an orchestra, but I just have to.
jose Eduardo Simoes, True, but not by this piano artist and definitely not this orchestra. Neither of these artists have cohesion going for them. The pianist is off key quite often. Yikes.
What a magnificent concert, what sensibility, what lyricism, what harmony, what grace. Clara Schumann fully incorporated the characteristic spirit of the Romantic period. The pianist is exceptional in sensibility, taking from the piano an amazing sound.The orchestra and direction are fantastic.
Actually when she wrote this concerto she wasn't Clara Schumann, but fräulein Wieck, a 16 year old teenager. Unfortunately she had to marry, take on family chores and live in the shadow of her husband. But her music proves how gifted she was. Many thanks for making her young again.🙏
In 19th a pianist like Frau Clara is most overrated than a composer. He just a great renown composer 'cause her recitals. For some times, he have been known the pianist husband.
she didn't have to marry -- she chose to marry and fought against her father for years so she *could* marry schumann. she was overshadowed by her husband only in composing, as most of her career was spent performing she only picked up composition again shortly before her husband's death, but went back to performance shortly afterward
@@nothisiskas in those days, she is paired with many great pianist like Liszt. See int his days Liszt was the greatest pianist and wasn known like a great composer. Great composer seldom was a estimated musician. Clara payed her bills trough concertos.
This Clara Schumann concerto is extraordinary. A sixteen year young woman who was evidently gifted with a notable musical muse. The level of inspiration is sustained and expansive throughout. She conceived and ignited a worthy idea ; fleshing it out with gracious talent and fragrant emotional content. The cello duet is especially soulful. The polonaise dances and sways with dashing color and splash. Perhaps she was prescient of the effect of her future husband’s compositions? You never know how things will turn out? PWG
I love that she is hugging conductor and concertmaster. Usually they just shake hands. I hope my local symphony orchestra plays this piece one day, would love to listen to it live.
Belo Horizonte Que ótimo poder assistir a concertos com obras de Clara Schumann ! Obras de grande valor. Há que se divulgar obras compostas por mulheres!
Maravilhosa composição de uma linda, talentosa e super esforçada mulher. Ao mesmo tempo que compôs, era pianista concertista, mãe de 8 filhos e de um marido complicado. Quanta honra escutar essa maravilha. Se não tivesse tantas outras ocupações, ela teria destaque na história como teve Chopin....❤❤😊😊
Клара Шуман, как и Шопен, находятся под сильнейшим влиянием шедевра Гуммеля- фортепианного Концерта N°2 (1816 г.): ruclips.net/video/8UPMZm3PLIs/видео.html
Cuantas mujeres se les impidio mostrar sus grandes obras musicales de sus genialidades por la epoca de sometimientos? Es una gran justicia empezar a conocer y mostrar estas grandes mujeres geniales ! Mas vale tarde que nunca.
Yes, this episode is similar in texture and intonation to a Chopin concert. And the fact that the key is the same in E minor, and the same instruments sound.
Who is the lady conductor here ? I just finished seeing the first lady conductor at Bayreuth, and on Thursday at the Hollywood Bowl, another lady conductor will conduct this specific piano work. So who is this lady doing a great job conducting ? And what's the orchestra ?
《要做個快樂歌手》，走遍那天涯～ 且讓深知著『海內存知己，天涯亦比鄰』的無比素樸、簡單、逍遙的，天地當中微笑著的小我，在人群之中，做那最最暢所欲言……… ～ 歡快的 孩子氣的 有如 17 ～ 更甚 18 ~~ 的 Lady in terribly 🙂 Horribly 😂 Incredibly ❤️ Fabulously ☺️ Genuinely 🥰🥰 most colorful Eye-catching Prettiest gowns Really elegant :P So Plentiful, Walking here 💓 and running there 😀😀 No worries 🙂 Never mind 😏 Forget that 😌 《Memory》 💗 full of my favourite childhood ☺️ Youthful pretty girl 🐱 in yellow/green/light blue gowns. 😹😹 And wearing that awesome 😉 quality hat 😂❤️ You couldn't find any other one which can beat my beautiful one 🥰 as it's well worth my supremely shining hair... You can not imagine, yes！！！ 🤣🤣🤣
Es cuestion de talento y genio. No de tener pene o vagina. Si te parece genial este concierto deberias esperar unos 20 años más a que tu oído madure. Y no te tengo lástima ni respeto exacerbado solo porque seas mujer, te hablo como le hablaría a cualquiera. Precisamente por lástima u orgullo ciego hoy en día las mujeres estan escuchando cualquier estupidez solo porque lo hizo una mujer... Imaginate si los hombres tendríamos que escuchar cualquier estupidez solo por el hecho de que lo hizo un hombre. Es mas ni siquiera nos interesa lo que piensen otros hombres, es decir no pensamos en manada. Con el feminismo estúpido de hoy en día estais idolatrando cualquier pieza mediocre. No confundas la Clara pianista con la compositora. Por mas lobby y propaganda izquierdista progresista feminista que haya la mediocridad siempre será mediocridad. Y la mediocridad no tiene sexo. Puede ser también producida por mujeres.. no solamente por hombres... Y viceversa. Saludos.
@@noelleon2115 No és cap mediocritat. La seva música és preciosa. Més mediocritat és Mahler o Bruckner que Clara Schumann. Si a vostè no li agrada no la senti. Però no ha de discriminar a ningú per això. No la sento perquè sigui dona. La sento perquè m'agrada y prou
Parece que a Noel León nadie le dijo que en la historia de la humanidad hemos tenido qué escuchar, leer, ver, a hombres cuyo trabajo es mediocre. Y ha sido así porque sí, fuimos oprimidas y lo seguimos siendo. En aquellos tiempos podías ser una genia, pero la sociedad nisiquiera te veía como un ser humano. Clara fue, es y será una genia, por dónde quieras verlo. Y si tú machismo no te permite verlo, no hay nada más que decir. A oídos sordos, palabras necias.
Although Clara was already a highly accomplished pianist in her mid-teens, the material of her piano concerto is not outstanding. It's all rather workmanlike and not particularly inspiring. Pleasant enough but it hardly ranks with other concertos of the period.
@@benebacher2470 An amateur pianist. The orchestra is forced to slow down in virtuoso passages, the pianist has a lot of mistakes. A very strange performance. The orchestra is excellent, the pianist is mediocre.
The lovely thing of this performance is: a woman composer, a conductor woman and a pianist woman! This is amazing! Bravo!
Uhh...these are ladies....make that Brava, not Bravo.
@@timmellin2815 Brave (plural of brava)
The fact that a musician is a woman or a man is irrelevant. What matters is the music.
@@agarber1932 You're right. The fact is that woman composers have often been neglected.
You know what every passage of this concerto tickles the corner of a pianist's mind that's about their intimate relationship with their piano, fingers and the piano itself. I can't explain how exactly it does, but it's just there that lights up the tip of the right side of your brain like a bulb, and it makes you remember the time you practice Chopin and Schumann concertos but with a new melody, and that's how it gives comfort to us pianists, and that's why I need to learn it, even tho I know there will never be a day I get to perform it with an orchestra, but I just have to.
This recording is one that I listen to at least once a week. It's a wonderful recording! Thanks for making this available!
Clara Schumann definitly deserves better attention. Wonderfull!
jose Eduardo Simoes,
True, but not by this piano artist and definitely not this orchestra.
Neither of these artists have cohesion going for them. The pianist is off key quite often. Yikes.
I believe that this pianist does not know what she is doing.
you are so right
Worse than balin
There are a few enlightened people working on getting her a higher profile.
What a magnificent concert, what sensibility, what lyricism, what harmony, what grace. Clara Schumann fully incorporated the characteristic spirit of the Romantic period.
The pianist is exceptional in sensibility, taking from the piano an amazing sound.The orchestra and direction are fantastic.
Actually when she wrote this concerto she wasn't Clara Schumann, but fräulein Wieck, a 16 year old teenager. Unfortunately she had to marry, take on family chores and live in the shadow of her husband. But her music proves how gifted she was. Many thanks for making her young again.🙏
In 19th a pianist like Frau Clara is most overrated than a composer. He just a great renown composer 'cause her recitals. For some times, he have been known the pianist husband.
she didn't have to marry -- she chose to marry and fought against her father for years so she *could* marry schumann. she was overshadowed by her husband only in composing, as most of her career was spent performing
she only picked up composition again shortly before her husband's death, but went back to performance shortly afterward
@@nothisiskas in those days, she is paired with many great pianist like Liszt. See int his days Liszt was the greatest pianist and wasn known like a great composer. Great composer seldom was a estimated musician.
Clara payed her bills trough concertos.
Not 16 - as I know she was 14 or 15 yo when she had written this amazing concert..
@@КириллЧе-я5ы Yes, you are right. According to Wiki she wrote this concerto at age of 14 which is even more amazing.
00:00 Allegro maestoso
06:46 Romanze: andante non troppo con grazia
11:08 Finale: allegro non troppo - allegro molto
Очень красивый концерт! Спасибо большое за прекрасное исполнение! Браво!
This Clara Schumann concerto is extraordinary. A sixteen year young woman who was evidently gifted with a notable musical muse. The level of inspiration is sustained and expansive throughout. She conceived and ignited a worthy idea ; fleshing it out with gracious talent and fragrant emotional content. The cello duet is especially soulful. The polonaise dances and sways with dashing color and splash. Perhaps she was prescient of the effect of her future husband’s compositions? You never know how things will turn out? PWG
Maravilloso!! Clara es una gran Maestra y la orquesta, solista y Directora le hacen un merecido homenaje a su música y talento.
I woke up this morning humming the introduction of this piece, so i just had to listen to the whole thing! Lovely performance!
Holy cow, what a fantastic performance of this piece! The energy of the soloist, conductor, and orchestra is palpable
Beautiful piano concert. Clara Schumann was really inspired when she composed this great concert.
I love that there is a female conductor for this wonderful piece by a female composer!
Per quante volte possa ascoltarla, questa esecuzione mi prende sempre l'anima
I love that she is hugging conductor and concertmaster. Usually they just shake hands.
I hope my local symphony orchestra plays this piece one day, would love to listen to it live.
Bravas, Tal, Kagarlitsky and Clara Schumann !!!!!
Stunning conduction, regards from Mexico
For some reason today, I was thinking about Clara Schumann. This is great, thank you! And yes, Clara definitely deserves more credit as a composer.
Belo Horizonte
Que ótimo poder assistir a concertos com obras de Clara Schumann !
Obras de grande valor.
Há que se divulgar obras compostas por mulheres!
I listened to many pieces of this and this performance has been done most beautifully and gracefully, small mistakes don't matter.
Brillante interpretación de un concierto compuesto por una mujer admirable
Maravilhosa composição de uma linda, talentosa e super esforçada mulher. Ao mesmo tempo que compôs, era pianista concertista, mãe de 8 filhos e de um marido complicado. Quanta honra escutar essa maravilha. Se não tivesse tantas outras ocupações, ela teria destaque na história como teve Chopin....❤❤😊😊
WONDERFUL ‼️Especially the dialogue between the cello and piano, start dreaming…
Beautiful Michal!
Fantastic i gracies per aquesta maravella. Desde Barcelona 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏💐
Прекрасный концерт и великолепное исполнение.
Клара Шуман, как и Шопен, находятся под сильнейшим влиянием шедевра Гуммеля- фортепианного Концерта N°2 (1816 г.):
ruclips.net/video/8UPMZm3PLIs/видео.html
Пианистка- любитель. Множество ошибок, "сажает" оркестр в виртуозных местах. Отличный оркестр, посредственная пианистка. Очень странное исполнение.
Obrigada Vini por me indicar uma coisa linda dessas, que é maravilhosa tanto quanto um filme de natal❤️
Hahahahah espero que tenha te feito sorrir tanto quanto!
Das dunkle Blau steht ihr hervorragend! bin hin und weg von ihrem Spiel.! Danke!
Highlights and hiccups overall inspiring concert
Cuantas mujeres se les impidio mostrar sus grandes obras musicales de sus genialidades por la epoca de sometimientos? Es una gran justicia empezar a conocer y mostrar estas grandes mujeres geniales ! Mas vale tarde que nunca.
C’est extraordinaire!
Clara Shumann something special
Гениальная музыка завораживает!!!
Bravo ! Very impressing performance ! At : 19:50 : Chopin op.11, e-minor ...
That's not Chopin, its still the concerto
As I told the other Bravo person...these are ladies....make that Brava.
Yes, this episode is similar in texture and intonation to a Chopin concert. And the fact that the key is the same in E minor, and the same instruments sound.
A hoover
@@Pianist_24680 , maybe she quoted Kalkbrenner. He is a composer that have some influence in Chopin.
Literally written by a 15 year old
As the kids say, "levels to this game"
Una meravella
Això és música. I a més escrita per una dona. Perquè els homes es donin compte del valor de les dones. Dones al Poder!!!
Very enjoyable performance.
Wonderful orchestra, conductor and pianist. But who is the pianist? Seems very strange not to include her in the credits.
Sí dice, ahí está el nombre de la pianista. Michal Tal.
Clara Wieck-Schumann
Good, pity the ending was messed up 22:03 it's almost funny
Who is the lady conductor here ? I just finished seeing the first lady conductor at Bayreuth, and on Thursday at the Hollywood Bowl, another lady conductor will conduct this specific piano work. So who is this lady doing a great job conducting ? And what's the orchestra ?
《要做個快樂歌手》，走遍那天涯～
且讓深知著『海內存知己，天涯亦比鄰』的無比素樸、簡單、逍遙的，天地當中微笑著的小我，在人群之中，做那最最暢所欲言………
～
歡快的 孩子氣的
有如
17 ～
更甚
18 ~~
的
Lady in
terribly 🙂
Horribly 😂
Incredibly ❤️
Fabulously ☺️
Genuinely 🥰🥰 most colorful
Eye-catching Prettiest gowns
Really elegant :P
So Plentiful,
Walking here 💓 and running there 😀😀
No worries 🙂
Never mind 😏
Forget that 😌
《Memory》 💗 full of my favourite childhood ☺️
Youthful pretty girl 🐱 in yellow/green/light blue gowns. 😹😹
And wearing that awesome 😉 quality hat 😂❤️
You couldn't find any other one which can beat my beautiful one 🥰 as it's well worth my supremely shining hair...
You can not imagine, yes！！！
🤣🤣🤣
特に2楽章はロマンを感じますね。
🙏🙏🙏❤️🔥❤️🙏🙏🙏
13:32
6:53
22:04
21:45
10:40
Quien diga que componer es cosa masculina que oiga esto y después decida
Es cuestion de talento y genio. No de tener pene o vagina. Si te parece genial este concierto deberias esperar unos 20 años más a que tu oído madure. Y no te tengo lástima ni respeto exacerbado solo porque seas mujer, te hablo como le hablaría a cualquiera. Precisamente por lástima u orgullo ciego hoy en día las mujeres estan escuchando cualquier estupidez solo porque lo hizo una mujer... Imaginate si los hombres tendríamos que escuchar cualquier estupidez solo por el hecho de que lo hizo un hombre. Es mas ni siquiera nos interesa lo que piensen otros hombres, es decir no pensamos en manada. Con el feminismo estúpido de hoy en día estais idolatrando cualquier pieza mediocre. No confundas la Clara pianista con la compositora. Por mas lobby y propaganda izquierdista progresista feminista que haya la mediocridad siempre será mediocridad. Y la mediocridad no tiene sexo. Puede ser también producida por mujeres.. no solamente por hombres... Y viceversa. Saludos.
@@noelleon2115 No és cap mediocritat. La seva música és preciosa. Més mediocritat és Mahler o Bruckner que Clara Schumann. Si a vostè no li agrada no la senti. Però no ha de discriminar a ningú per això. No la sento perquè sigui dona. La sento perquè m'agrada y prou
@Joaquín Amaya estic d'acord amb vostè
Parece que a Noel León nadie le dijo que en la historia de la humanidad hemos tenido qué escuchar, leer, ver, a hombres cuyo trabajo es mediocre. Y ha sido así porque sí, fuimos oprimidas y lo seguimos siendo. En aquellos tiempos podías ser una genia, pero la sociedad nisiquiera te veía como un ser humano. Clara fue, es y será una genia, por dónde quieras verlo. Y si tú machismo no te permite verlo, no hay nada más que decir. A oídos sordos, palabras necias.
@@guadalupesalmeron5203 molt ben dit senyora!!!
Although Clara was already a highly accomplished pianist in her mid-teens, the material of her piano concerto is not outstanding. It's all rather workmanlike and not particularly inspiring. Pleasant enough but it hardly ranks with other concertos of the period.
Ng
Girls riding horses bareback are
Pianist 🤮
What’s wrong with her?
@@benebacher2470 An amateur pianist. The orchestra is forced to slow down in virtuoso passages, the pianist has a lot of mistakes. A very strange performance.
The orchestra is excellent, the pianist is mediocre.
I believe that this pianist does not know what she is doing.
What do you mean? She sounded great.
The ending was pretty flawed
@@guimapg10 I agree. What a pity
She played every note correctly in the coda. The orchestra lost her, it wasn’t her fault.