The book's better. It's not sad a story. Inman was a dead man already. He redeemed himself. All the other characters developed and moved on, died or were killed.
It's a very under rated film. I think it was held back from popularity only because of its slow pace. If there isn't a substantial amount of explosions and flashing colors the majority of people get bored. Following stories and multiple characters in a period based drama is hard for the "popcorn film" enthusiasts.
I love this soundtrack! Very few film soundtracks leave indelible marks in my head and this whole soundtrack is one of them. From Alison Krause and Sting, Gleeson’s own musical talents, Jack White, Ethan Suplee. Awesome soundtrack.
It was true at that time...just shows how detached people are...you aren't drafted. Into a war where you might kill your own family members in this day
@@ouuumnia4990 probably figured it out by now but the song is called "I wish my baby born" . I believe there are many variants for it though since it is a folk song , but you can pull up the full version played in the movie by searching that name
The scene, only lives up to what in essence was, is and will continue to be the man misnamed white,Ruthless even with his own motivated by those cravings for power
If you want a great scene with the same essence check out the eggplant scene from True Romance. Terrific performances by Chirstopher Walken and Dennis Hopper. True Romance is a Tarantino script directed by Tony Scott.
This is definitely one of the est films of all time I love it. This scene is brilliant when Teague starts singing you can tell Stobrod Thewes thinks he is off the hook. Also when Pangle gives the game away great acting.
A friend and I saw this movie just to kill time while waiting for our friend to finish work. Both her and I were blown away by it. Did not expect to get so emotionally caught up with all these great characters. It really is an underrated film.
I wish, I wish my baby was born And sitting on its papa's knee And me, poor girl And me, poor girl, were dead and gone And the green grass growing o'er my feet I ain't ahead, nor never will be Till the sweet apple grows On a sour apple tree But still I hope, But still I hope the time will come When you and I shall be as one I wish, I wish my love had died And sent his soul to wander free Then we might meet where ravens fly Let our poor bodies rest in peace The owl, the owl Is a lonely bird It chills my heart With dread and terror That someone's blood There on his wing That someone's blood There on his feathers
When the owl sings about the owl, knowing that he is about to have someone's blood there on his feather -- that's what gets me every time. Amazing writing, directing, and acting. Pangle is perfect.
I think he finds his misery in it "the owl the owl is a lonely bird, someones blood there on his wings" he is the owl in my culture the owl ho-ho at night by the house represents "death has come to this house"
I think he showed some mercy to Pangle esp with the cover your face part. They all knew except him what was going to happen, I think that was a mercy in itself to make it quick and without him being scared.
A good scene from a very underrated film. Good soundtrack too. If anybody knows the history of north Carolina then they know all about bushwhack killings and family feuds during the civil war. Very sad.
Members of my family going way back were involved in the partisan killing in North Carolina. One of the worst incidents was the Shelton Laurel massacre. People in western NC, VA, and eastern TN and KY were either Secessionist or Unionist for various reasons, and when you found people in your same county had donned a different color uniform than you, killing got really personal and brutal undoubtedly.
I went to the Jefferson Library in DC and on presentation for all to look and read was hundreds of letters from soldier's and family of soldier's. I read a few, and the saddest one's I noticed was the one's from the conferates wives. The letters simply express the empty heart. It was as if the Civil War took there soul and left them with nothing to look forward too. Just one of many hardship of war.
@@MrDrake390 in case you didn't know, Georgia is the name of the character that's hiding. In the prior scene, they had cooked and eaten a rotting deer and Georgia (played by real life musician Jack White) got up to go puke in the woods. That's partly why he looks so sick. That...and the abject terror and horror of seeing his friends shot.
Remember, before the war, Bodie was an outcast. When the war broke out, the Confederate Home Guard recruited him and for the first time in his life, he felt accepted and valued. As such, he relished in his ill-disciplined, criminal duties. He knew at that point he could basically get away with anything under the veneer of valor and duty. While the rest of them are nostalgic for pre-war camaraderie and solidarity, Bodie never experienced any of that. His reaction is only appropriate once you understand his worldview. When he tells Inman that he has the "confidence of youth" on his side, he's admitting that he has nothing else. Shorn of his militaristic bravado, he's a consummate nihilist.
@@princegalenagreat analysis!. Sadly, there are people with enough vocation for domination and tendency towards sadism to commit this type of crimes that war itself legitimizes veiledly.
Oh my gosh this movie has multiple scenes that made me bawl. This is one. Its pretty messed up how the captain Teague is even disgusted with himself for shooting them esp the simple guy. Albino guy was cold as ice .
Look at the way the albino guy (Bosie) is closely watching Teague the whole time too. As another commenter said, he’s watching him like a hawk. It’s like he’s restlessly uneasy at even the slightest possibility that Teague’s heart might soften and be merciful in that moment.
I was shocked when I saw Hunnan on some talk shlw. He sounded like a straight-up John Bull! How the hell do these guys copy our English, let alone regional dialects?!!
@@rev.redhand6205 You know what's crazy. I believe you are right! I saw a neat show once, maybe on the History Channel or something like that. "The History Of The Hillbilly"! Or something like that anyway! So, they said the actual accent, like you say, is from Scottish origins! Which is of course British Isles! They went on about the moonshine history, going back to the 1700s! Plus a whole lot of other neat stuff!! They did mention that the Appalachia area was once one of the most remote isolated areas in the U.S., along with the Cookson Hills in Missouri. They mentioned that so closed to outside intrusions was the Cookson Hills area, that Pretty Boy Floyd was utterly safe as long as he stayed in this area. The FBI wouldn't even venture there. Outsiders were immediately flagged, and everyone soon know they were around! Bonnie and Clyde once made an attempt to shelter there, and Floyd's friends and family members told them to leave, as unwanted. Floyd was eventually killed in Ohio. Appalachia had a similar reputation. Outsiders had no chance to blend in!
Thank you for the intelligent and insightful observation. I like the movie. This is a moving scene addressing the complexity of Captain Teague’s conscious. I never quite picked up on the song’s reference to the owl and it’s allegorical association to the cruelity of man.
The Southern Accent is very close to the British Accent. It's more closely related to it than any other American accent. Additionally the Appalachian Accent, is a remnant of old Elizabethan English, so that accent is even closer.
It's because they tend to be formally trained in accents, much more than Americans. There's a higher standard to be an actor there. Half the cast of Band of Brothers was British or Irish.
Read the book and seen the movie and I love Charlie Hunnam's character (can't remember the name at the moment) it just seems that nothing touching phases him whatsoever makes you wonder what is going through his mind.
Yeah his character name was 'Bosie' I didn't realize it was charlie until I heard the voice and I was like 'wait a minute thats Jax Teller's voice' but his performance was so chilling to me during this scene I felt my stomach drop a few times and alot of goosebumps charlie made me hate him in this film 😆
SPOILER: All these years...this movie has been one of my all-time favorites and I am just realizing that hunky Charlie Hunnam was that creepy Bosie that killed Jude Law! Wow, did he do a great job in that part!
This is totally random and unrelated to the topic but I have to say it - I noticed from your picture that you are one *extremely - beautiful - lady*, straight beauty.
If you ever get the chance get the book on cd, it is long and worth the listening, much more detail, better than the movie, I loved the movie. Iman was a real man who lived during the Civil War.
That is a good observation. I wondered about this part too, I didn't see it that. I would have liked the writer or producer to delve into his memory about why he was so moved by this song.
I've wanted to watch this movie for quite some time. For one reason or another, it just didn't work out. Until I find myself in possession of this movie, thinking with my luck it's be scar arched and unwatchable, I tried it. Looking back (after watching it) it was a beautiful movie, to say that it was quality in every aspect (not like many movies nowadays). It's a story of love, torn apart by war, life and evil. Through it all, they fight to be with one another. Great characters (except the Joker-like Bosie). A few unnecessary scenes amd lines that take away from the story and potential of its greatness, but other than that it's almost perfection. A movie I'd definitely re-watch, but hesitate to keep. If you enjoy a struggling romance or sad films, this might be the watch for you.
The worst part is Capt. Teague struggles with the decision and then truly believes he made the right decision...I respect him, he was misguided but his heart was in the right place.
Teague was a piece of shit. He was murdering his fellow citizens and he tried to steal the woman of a soldier and neighbor while the young man was away at war. His heart was NOT in the right place.
You're wrong. Teague went up there to commit murder. He did just that. You can call it what you want, or rationalize it however you wish, but Teague looking into the distance, longing-like, don't make the killing he did any more right. He can't have a heart in the right place if he doesn't have fucking heart to begin with. . . but maybe there is some piece of him that isn't a murderous son of a bitch. that sings along to a song. But it doesn't redeem him or excuse his murdering of two good innocent people.
phillygirl06 I heard & read up on IMBb that Charlie did some research into his character Bosie & Albinos are very prone to nosebleeds, so they 'the production team' decided that'd be good to add that into the movies. Clever thinking on Charlie's part! He's AWESOME at playing this cold, twisted character.
Cold Mountains one of the best Movies ever made, and its the sadest as well...
The book's better. It's not sad a story. Inman was a dead man already. He redeemed himself. All the other characters developed and moved on, died or were killed.
It is my favourite also x
It's a very under rated film. I think it was held back from popularity only because of its slow pace. If there isn't a substantial amount of explosions and flashing colors the majority of people get bored. Following stories and multiple characters in a period based drama is hard for the "popcorn film" enthusiasts.
@@baahs101 Indeed Blake. This was mine and my mother's favorite film.
Really Great Movie... This part was always beautiful to me
I love this soundtrack! Very few film soundtracks leave indelible marks in my head and this whole soundtrack is one of them. From Alison Krause and Sting, Gleeson’s own musical talents, Jack White, Ethan Suplee. Awesome soundtrack.
I love it too. One of my favorites
"I told him aint nothing in this world, worth a smile!!!" my favorite line in the entire movie because it's so damn true
That's a terrible thing to believe.
@@HazeGreyAndUnderway it's a terrible reality
@@jimbob465 so then change your own reality
Came here for this comment. It’s true for many people.
It was true at that time...just shows how detached people are...you aren't drafted. Into a war where you might kill your own family members in this day
Made me tear up n I was like 10 years old at the time. One of the best movie scenes of our era
He sung his greatest for he knew he would die that day. Amazing. Simply amazing.
What's the name of the song
Please
@@ouuumnia4990 probably figured it out by now but the song is called "I wish my baby born" . I believe there are many variants for it though since it is a folk song , but you can pull up the full version played in the movie by searching that name
Det er kun en film.
He doesn't die..
@@uwemaxjensen3028 Yet, still..
Man.... He's playing that fiddle like he knows he's a deadman. FUCK. This scene is sad. This.... there's a lot of life in this movie. Decades later.
The scene, only lives up to what in essence was, is and will continue to be the man misnamed white,Ruthless even with his own motivated by those cravings for power
If you want a great scene with the same essence check out the eggplant scene from True Romance. Terrific performances by Chirstopher Walken and Dennis Hopper. True Romance is a Tarantino script directed by Tony Scott.
He doesn't die in the film. Watch it.
@@SStupendous
Yeah but still, in that moment, he was 100% sure that he was about to die.
I agree with every word
The part where the devil hates that something so beautiful is touching the soul. Great direction and acting
This is definitely one of the est films of all time I love it. This scene is brilliant when Teague starts singing you can tell Stobrod Thewes thinks he is off the hook. Also when Pangle gives the game away great acting.
That's probably one of the best tunes I've heard on a fiddle ever
this scene is the most saddest . I cry everytime I here this song . gosh
I fell you... damn this scene is pure art, cold, raw art. Them singing even they know they will die
@@mohamedirksousi4396 soo sad aye
I laugh every time I watch this movie
@@MrDrake390 I have seen many internet tough guys in my years online. You, sir, are the toughest.
It's hear
A friend and I saw this movie just to kill time while waiting for our friend to finish work. Both her and I were blown away by it. Did not expect to get so emotionally caught up with all these great characters. It really is an underrated film.
Damn, the look on Stob's face after Teague tells them, "Stand over there..." gets me every time.
He’s like a kid that thought the principal wasn’t going to give him detention after his lecture.
I wish, I wish my baby was born
And sitting on its papa's knee
And me, poor girl
And me, poor girl, were dead and gone
And the green grass growing o'er my feet
I ain't ahead, nor never will be
Till the sweet apple grows
On a sour apple tree
But still I hope, But still I hope the time will come
When you and I shall be as one
I wish, I wish my love had died
And sent his soul to wander free
Then we might meet where ravens fly
Let our poor bodies rest in peace
The owl, the owl
Is a lonely bird
It chills my heart
With dread and terror
That someone's blood
There on his wing
That someone's blood
There on his feathers
digger678 w
Sad song :”(
you got it wrong
@@tbngeorgetown what is wrong?
Bonjour
Qui chante cette chanson ? Ne ne la trouve pas dans l album musique du film !!!! Merci
one of the best scenes in film.beautiful and chilling all the same.."cover ya face with yer hat"
When the owl sings about the owl, knowing that he is about to have someone's blood there on his feather -- that's what gets me every time. Amazing writing, directing, and acting. Pangle is perfect.
Even Teague is amazing, his hardened heart gets soft for a few seconds when the song brings childhood or youth memories, perhaps
amazing film with an amazing soundtrack. and many lessons on war, human nature and looking at the past, the resilence of the heart.
This is my fav. part of the movie. I thought that that draconian bastard was finally going to show mercy when he began to sing.
I think he finds his misery in it "the owl the owl is a lonely bird, someones blood there on his wings" he is the owl in my culture the owl ho-ho at night by the house represents "death has come to this house"
I think he showed some mercy to Pangle esp with the cover your face part. They all knew except him what was going to happen, I think that was a mercy in itself to make it quick and without him being scared.
@@ShaunMAndCrystalS True, he spared poor Pangle the horror that was coming.
A good scene from a very underrated film. Good soundtrack too. If anybody knows the history of north Carolina then they know all about bushwhack killings and family feuds during the civil war. Very sad.
Members of my family going way back were involved in the partisan killing in North Carolina. One of the worst incidents was the Shelton Laurel massacre. People in western NC, VA, and eastern TN and KY were either Secessionist or Unionist for various reasons, and when you found people in your same county had donned a different color uniform than you, killing got really personal and brutal undoubtedly.
I went to the Jefferson Library in DC and on presentation for all to look and read was hundreds of letters from soldier's and family of soldier's. I read a few, and the saddest one's I noticed was the one's from the conferates wives. The letters simply express the empty heart. It was as if the Civil War took there soul and left them with nothing to look forward too. Just one of many hardship of war.
God Bless these musicians. Great song
Bet Georgia is really happy that his name isn't Jack.
Bet ifn his name was texas hed have saved his buddies
You could see the sadness in Teagues eyes when they started singing. I think he just realized how fucked up of a man the war made him.
Triage was a bitter asshole before the war.
I thought this scene would turn out good, you know cause the music was uniting them. boy was I wrong.
I know, it made me cry...anyone who isn't affected by this needs to pay more attention IMO...cause it should affect them.
I too had the same thought
It made my eyes watery, this scene. Greetings from Cali, Colombia.
@@rommeldavidzambrano1260 nice and warm there!
@@MrDrake390 in case you didn't know, Georgia is the name of the character that's hiding. In the prior scene, they had cooked and eaten a rotting deer and Georgia (played by real life musician Jack White) got up to go puke in the woods. That's partly why he looks so sick. That...and the abject terror and horror of seeing his friends shot.
"Broke my young heart"
Charlie hunnam's sarcasm when saying it makes that line so much better, too.
Funnier too because he looks 30
Remember, before the war, Bodie was an outcast. When the war broke out, the Confederate Home Guard recruited him and for the first time in his life, he felt accepted and valued. As such, he relished in his ill-disciplined, criminal duties. He knew at that point he could basically get away with anything under the veneer of valor and duty. While the rest of them are nostalgic for pre-war camaraderie and solidarity, Bodie never experienced any of that. His reaction is only appropriate once you understand his worldview.
When he tells Inman that he has the "confidence of youth" on his side, he's admitting that he has nothing else. Shorn of his militaristic bravado, he's a consummate nihilist.
@@princegalenagreat analysis!. Sadly, there are people with enough vocation for domination and tendency towards sadism to commit this type of crimes that war itself legitimizes veiledly.
Broke my young heart
Oh my gosh this movie has multiple scenes that made me bawl. This is one.
Its pretty messed up how the captain Teague is even disgusted with himself for shooting them esp the simple guy.
Albino guy was cold as ice .
Look at the way the albino guy (Bosie) is closely watching Teague the whole time too. As another commenter said, he’s watching him like a hawk. It’s like he’s restlessly uneasy at even the slightest possibility that Teague’s heart might soften and be merciful in that moment.
Man I love this movie
It's a good movie
I was shocked when I saw Hunnan on some talk shlw. He sounded like a straight-up John Bull! How the hell do these guys copy our English, let alone regional dialects?!!
Tne English have always played us better than we play them. We can't win EVERYTHING.🤣🤣🤣🤣😃😃
@BBSTJ Lucky Ours is still better HA-YUK!!!
Our accent in Appalachia stems from those in the British isles.
@@rev.redhand6205 You know what's crazy. I believe you are right! I saw a neat show once, maybe on the History Channel or something like that. "The History Of The Hillbilly"! Or something like that anyway! So, they said the actual accent, like you say, is from Scottish origins! Which is of course British Isles! They went on about the moonshine history, going back to the 1700s! Plus a whole lot of other neat stuff!! They did mention that the Appalachia area was once one of the most remote isolated areas in the U.S., along with the Cookson Hills in Missouri. They mentioned that so closed to outside intrusions was the Cookson Hills area, that Pretty Boy Floyd was utterly safe as long as he stayed in this area. The FBI wouldn't even venture there. Outsiders were immediately flagged, and everyone soon know they were around! Bonnie and Clyde once made an attempt to shelter there, and Floyd's friends and family members told them to leave, as unwanted. Floyd was eventually killed in Ohio. Appalachia had a similar reputation. Outsiders had no chance to blend in!
@@junkdeal yes sir
Very sad scene. Weak men with no rules become evil.
Great song and movie! One of the best scenes
Thank you for the intelligent and insightful observation. I like the movie. This is a moving scene addressing the complexity of Captain Teague’s conscious. I never quite picked up on the song’s reference to the owl and it’s allegorical association to the cruelity of man.
Cause he is a loner
It also is clear the song meant much to him, but it’s not enough to save the deserters.
best part of the movie
Still remember this classic hit song and film movie. Use watch it over and over again movie theater., few part of film was really sad.
I love how British and Irish are impersonating southerns, (better than several Americans) That is the beauty of acting I suppose.
well there is a lot of British and Irish in the south
The Southern Accent is very close to the British Accent. It's more closely related to it than any other American accent. Additionally the Appalachian Accent, is a remnant of old Elizabethan English, so that accent is even closer.
Not all Southerners are British and Irish. There's also French, German, Native, African, and even Chinese!
Infinite Sky but German, native, and Chinese don't contribute to the accent.
It's because they tend to be formally trained in accents, much more than Americans. There's a higher standard to be an actor there. Half the cast of Band of Brothers was British or Irish.
You have to be a soulless demon to kill someone with a voice like that.
Read the book and seen the movie and I love Charlie Hunnam's character (can't remember the name at the moment) it just seems that nothing touching phases him whatsoever makes you wonder what is going through his mind.
xbandit1000 Hi there. It's Bosie in the movie, but Birch in the novel. Still exactly the same characteristics though. AMAZING acting by Charlie!
Yeah his character name was 'Bosie' I didn't realize it was charlie until I heard the voice and I was like 'wait a minute thats Jax Teller's voice' but his performance was so chilling to me during this scene I felt my stomach drop a few times and alot of goosebumps charlie made me hate him in this film 😆
He’s likely a psychopath.
Love this song and the movie as well!
"Where's Georgia?" ....Where's Georgia? hahaha
LMAO
SPOILER: All these years...this movie has been one of my all-time favorites and I am just realizing that hunky Charlie Hunnam was that creepy Bosie that killed Jude Law! Wow, did he do a great job in that part!
This is totally random and unrelated to the topic but I have to say it - I noticed from your picture that you are one *extremely - beautiful - lady*, straight beauty.
I love his performance classic
Man I can't get tired of this scene
Super underrated movie
this is one of my favorite parts of the movie
One of the saddest scenes in that movie for me.
My first thought was "It's Randy!"
I don't even blame the big guy, I blame the others.
They know exactly how he is and should've trained him on what to say if anyone asks any questions
When I first saw this, I was so glad Jack didn't die.
One of my favorite movies...
Tim Ericson is the original singer of the opening vocals. He's an amazing singer
One of my favorite scenes of all time
I think my heart stayed in cold mountain
If you ever get the chance get the book on cd, it is long and worth the listening, much more detail, better than the movie, I loved the movie. Iman was a real man who lived during the Civil War.
I love how Fraiser made the mountains a character in the book.
one of my favorites of all time
Jackson Teller
Esta es una de mis partes favoritas, buena película
Only one that's tooken the most precious in life, can understand..someone's blood on these feathers
So happy they wrote a book based on this movie
Love this song !
what a great song
Damn, I love this movie.
So much love this song❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
he was amazing
Ray winstone always plays the perfect badguy
My favorite movie of all times.
This scene was heartbreaking. Excellent flick.
A great movie from a great novel 😍🥰
Best scene in the whole movie.
That is a good observation. I wondered about this part too, I didn't see it that. I would have liked the writer or producer to delve into his memory about why he was so moved by this song.
@agkistrodoncrotalus
For me, it's one of the best movie scenes ever. Part of the reason is this truly great song voices.
This scene is a punch in the stomach, I always hope they are spared in the end
Heart Wrenching.
When you on the run never a lit fire. And if you do post a guard.
There's an actual cold mountain in western north Carolina....its beautiful!
Volume UP man, and listening caling hills and after lifes
Volume UP man, and listening caling hills and after lifes
Such a touching scene
Best song ever.
Pretty heavy scene. Well acted Sweet and Creepy.
aint nothin' in this world worth a smile
Really fantastic
Melhor cena music fantastic
The albino is in your fav he plays in the biker show lead sons of anarchy
I've wanted to watch this movie for quite some time. For one reason or another, it just didn't work out. Until I find myself in possession of this movie, thinking with my luck it's be scar arched and unwatchable, I tried it. Looking back (after watching it) it was a beautiful movie, to say that it was quality in every aspect (not like many movies nowadays). It's a story of love, torn apart by war, life and evil. Through it all, they fight to be with one another. Great characters (except the Joker-like Bosie). A few unnecessary scenes amd lines that take away from the story and potential of its greatness, but other than that it's almost perfection. A movie I'd definitely re-watch, but hesitate to keep. If you enjoy a struggling romance or sad films, this might be the watch for you.
افضل مشهد في الفلم
One of the best movie I ever seen. #FanFromPH
The worst part is Capt. Teague struggles with the decision and then truly believes he made the right decision...I respect him, he was misguided but his heart was in the right place.
+tracy craig One of the best scenes ever made.Teague had a moment there that reminded him that once way back he was a good human i think.
+Thomas Evolve and that made him angry I think. I believe that the song struck a nerve with Teague
Teague was a piece of shit. He was murdering his fellow citizens and he tried to steal the woman of a soldier and neighbor while the young man was away at war. His heart was NOT in the right place.
I am not sure Teague was EVER a good human
You're wrong. Teague went up there to commit murder. He did just that. You can call it what you want, or rationalize it however you wish, but Teague looking into the distance, longing-like, don't make the killing he did any more right. He can't have a heart in the right place if he doesn't have fucking heart to begin with. . . but maybe there is some piece of him that isn't a murderous son of a bitch. that sings along to a song. But it doesn't redeem him or excuse his murdering of two good innocent people.
I was sad when he shot Pangle ;(
I love Jack White!!
Man. Good shit. Gnight from IL. 5:30am.
Um bom filme,...❤❤❤
Com certeza ! Um dos melhores que já vi !
Sadest scene I've ever saw and I've seen it all
By the way the opening credits is originally indumea....a cherokee song of death and resurrection.
***** I Wish My Baby Was Born is about a stillborn.
+Seth Going
no...its a hymn by charles wesley, am i born to die. idumea is a biblical kingdom.
man fucking love this movie!!!
Deep song...
Love it
I think my heart stayed in cold Mt
Charlie Hunnam is by far one of the sexiest men alive. I could watch him knit a sweater...
Eew really? This film made me kinda hate him lol
great film
nothing is stated in the special disc feature why Bosie gets nose bleeds everytime He shoots a gun.
phillygirl06 I heard & read up on IMBb that Charlie did some research into his character Bosie & Albinos are very prone to nosebleeds, so they 'the production team' decided that'd be good to add that into the movies. Clever thinking on Charlie's part! He's AWESOME at playing this cold, twisted character.
Amen.
Great movie