Is Sailor Moon Crystal Season 2 True to the Source? Breakdown

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 сен 2024

Комментарии • 74

  • @mooncover7359
    @mooncover7359 2 дня назад +21

    I wish they had included the scene when Minako looks up at the sky worrying about Usagi and Mamoru and says “Don’t worry guys we’ll save you” (talking about the other sailors)

  • @SonOfGoth
    @SonOfGoth 2 дня назад +14

    i love seeing the differences made between the manga and anime. some of them you can tell are either influences from the 90's anime, like Demande saving Sailor Moon before dying, rather than just trying to kill Sailor Moon and dying by her hand instead, or just because they wanted to tone down certain elements, like the rotting corpses/vulgar death scenes or Sailor Moon raising her voice at chibi-usa rather than almost hitting her. I didn't realize how many conversations were changed, kinda makes me wonder why they would change it, though it did ultimately lead to the same ending.

    • @mooncover7359
      @mooncover7359 2 дня назад

      I wish Venus “Rolling Heart Vibration” wasn’t looking so shitty though. The attacks of other sailors looked so bad too

    • @SonOfGoth
      @SonOfGoth 2 дня назад +2

      @@mooncover7359 i wish Rolling Heart Vibration was used more than once. That's not a complaint against the anime either. I just realized that its literally used once. It was used only once in the manga/crystal. in the live action PGSM, it was used ONCE. 90's anime never got it. even the SNES game that included manga attacks from the death busters arc didn't have it as an attack for Venus. Sorry that was a tangent. I thought the first arc animations were mostly good for their attacks, i liked that they tried to make the attacks feel more in the moment, until Sailor Moon got her Moon stick. 2nd arc really didn't help at all, and their new attacks definitely didn't get the same attention, and then ofc they gave Sailor Moon's scepter attacks the same treatment as her Moon stick attacks... which was not great. At least after that they actually put some time and brought back the attacks like the 90's, where it's a separate animation, which I personally think was a better choice.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +1

      Sometimes I wonder if it is because of what they can air on television in japan. I wonder that with another anime I am currently watching now too.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +1

      I honestly thought both of venus attacks did not look good this season. When she is fighting Beryl in the last season I thought her fighting looked so cool. Season 2 comes around. What is this!?!

    • @helarymedina3139
      @helarymedina3139 2 дня назад +2

      ​@GodFireBreakdowns I was maybe thinking that maybe the timeslot for it airing in Japan, but then I remembered that the first two seasons were ONA (Online Net Animation), which means it only streamed on Niconico, which is similar to RUclips in Japan. So it couldn't really have been TV regulations as it didn't air on TV until season 3.
      Toei Animation has a history of toning down the dark and violent things from their anime adaptations of manga. They also do the same for One Piece and still do. I think Toei Animation wants their anime to appeal to a broader audience, especially children, so they tone down a lot of the more violent imagery. Other studios don't usually tone down the violence and dark imagery as much as Toei does from my experience watching a ton of different anime.

  • @DrawciaGleam02
    @DrawciaGleam02 2 дня назад +13

    Chibi-usa breaking free from Wiseman's influence is lovely in both the 90's anime and the manga!

    • @mooncover7359
      @mooncover7359 2 дня назад +5

      Yeah at least Crystal did that right despite the awful animation of the show

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  13 часов назад

      It did such a good job. When black lady started to cry. And you see those flashbacks. It was so sad.

  • @user-saraswatidevi
    @user-saraswatidevi 2 дня назад +6

    I love this series! Thanks for this hope you do it for the rest of the series

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +2

      That's my plan! I am excited to finally get into Sailor Moon third arc! It's one of my favorites!

  • @zinzolin14
    @zinzolin14 2 дня назад +5

    I can't believe I only just found out here that manga Motoki knew Usagi and the others were Sailor Guardians! I think it makes sense since he was saved from the brainwashing incident in the first arc. Overall, yeah I can understand cutting it out for Crystal. That would make Motoki the only civilian who knows of their secret, and would explain how easy it would be for them to get to the control center.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад +3

      @@zinzolin14 right? I thought it was a weird choice not to show that. But then show him at the end like he was glad to see Venus and mercury. Super random

    • @zinzolin14
      @zinzolin14 День назад +2

      @@GodFireBreakdowns maybe they were alluding to it in the end, like it's a secret Easter egg only the manga readers would get

  • @starbird3939
    @starbird3939 2 дня назад +11

    I think the name is supposed to be Diamande, french for Diamond, since everyone is named after gemstones (Sapphire, Ruby, Emerald)

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад

      That was the only thing I could think of. I was like Demande? Huh?

    • @lucth16
      @lucth16 2 дня назад +3

      @@GodFireBreakdowns Rather than french I think the author went to Spanish and changed a letter or two. Diamande to Demande. Works with Esmeraude and Rubeus too. Iffy with Saphir.
      BTW, chibi can be used on kinder-gardeners without "insulting" them, somewhat OK for 1st graders (as they are the youngest school age.) and then it become more and more of an insult as you go all the way to grade 6.
      BTW2, if you want the somewhat equivalent of "chibi" for school aged kids, it's "shonen".
      Chibi-chan, daijobu? Papa to mama sagashiteru no?
      Soko no shonen, daijobu? Papa to mama sagashiteru no?
      man, I'm bored... lol

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад +1

      @@lucth16 good to know! Thank you for sharing those details!

  • @talesyuki
    @talesyuki День назад +3

    This arc, I feel, is when we start getting how powerful Usagi is. I love it.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад +1

      @luhguren I feel like we saw it in the first season well at least the manga. But then they stopped. She was bringing people back to life in the first arc. But then queen serenity was able to revive everyone in the end of this season.

    • @talesyuki
      @talesyuki День назад

      @@GodFireBreakdowns True, true. I'd forgotten about that for a moment. She even healed the Shitennou kinda, now I remember.
      But her moment at Nemesis calling out her powers and the girls is so majestic! At that moment she looks like a goddess! I thought "hell yeah, that's a girl that can do anything she puts herself into!"

  • @Mysticgamer
    @Mysticgamer День назад +2

    It was neat to see the scouts have friends and even figure out their secret identities. I wish they could've done more with that. At very least I wish they were shown in the future or at the wedding in Cosmos.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  14 часов назад

      @Mysticgamer yeah the friends just dissappear after awhile sadly.

  • @hoop6725
    @hoop6725 2 дня назад +12

    Damn, am I really gonna sit and watch a 30m analysis about sailor moon?

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +1

      I hope you liked it!

    • @kelleygreengrass
      @kelleygreengrass 2 дня назад +1

      Yes.

    • @hoop6725
      @hoop6725 День назад

      @@GodFireBreakdowns I can safely say that I now know more about Sailor Moon then any of my friends. This information may save my life one day, thank you.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад +1

      @hoop6725 glad I could help! Haha I'm working on season 3. I'm only a couple episodes in and learned something new about tokyo and how they picked the names for some areas.

  • @noel4560
    @noel4560 5 часов назад

    This arc (specifically act 21 and 25) made me realized of why I had a love-hate relationship with the series' artstyle...
    When it comes to dramatic and sad scenes, Yukie Sako's crystal design SHINES beautifully. It's so expressive yet so elegant, just like how Takeuchi draws these scenes. In act 25, Pluto's last farewell, Black Lady's scream, and Usagi's expression to this situation are *mwah* kanpeki!
    However, when it comes to serious and intense scenes... Most of the characters look dead and inexpressive. In act 21, look at Neo-Queen Serenity's dead stare, Usagi's indifferent expression towards Demande, and more... Yeah. To me, it's not pleasant

  • @melonpeach9723
    @melonpeach9723 2 дня назад +1

    Venus should’ve gotten more to do. I’ll never understand why they felt the need to keep her around, if she wasn’t gonna have anything important to do.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад +3

      @@melonpeach9723 I think her animation just didn't do justice for her. But she felt the same at one point towards the end.

  • @Lucie.777.-
    @Lucie.777.- 2 дня назад +3

    I never understood how chibiusa has the legendary silver crystal if the crystal was surrounding neo queen serenity

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +4

      The crystal she had was the crystal but it had no power for her to use because it was protecting the queen. We saw a similar thing in the first season. And what I have come to conclusion on is. It is magic lol. Magic doesn't always make sense hahaahah.

    • @DrawciaGleam02
      @DrawciaGleam02 12 часов назад

      @@GodFireBreakdowns
      Similar thing in first season?? How??

  • @magicvalgirl2309
    @magicvalgirl2309 2 дня назад +2

    You're telling me that VINCENT AND RIKU HAVE BEEN IN SAILOR MOON CRYSTAL!? If I were to tell that to my younger self who didn't even know KH or FF, she wouldn't believe me.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +1

      Right!?!?!?!?! lol I was shocked when I saw that too.

    • @magicvalgirl2309
      @magicvalgirl2309 2 дня назад

      @@GodFireBreakdowns I knew I wanted the KH girls as Sailor Scouts. Great video! I'm looking forward to your recap of season 3!

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад

      @@magicvalgirl2309 I'm so excited. I am only 2 episodes in right now.

  • @KichiMiangra
    @KichiMiangra День назад +2

    If there was ever one single scene that I mourn the most for not being in Sailormoon Crystal, it's the 90s anime Dic english dub line from Usagi when they learn Chibiusa is their future child:
    Usagi: "THAT'S why she drives me nuts! SHE TAKES AFTER YOU!!" 😂
    This will prolly always be my favorite arc in any version of Sailormoon. Admitedly I miss 90's Prince Demande, but I love crazy terrorist Demande!
    (7y/o me shipped him with Usagi, and though I'm not sure if that was because of the Usa/Mamo breakup plot that went on faaar too long and made him feel like the way better choice, or if I just liked the Hero/Villain vibe, it very much influenced my shipping tastes later in life!)

    • @chriscassul9904
      @chriscassul9904 22 часа назад

      I love a &ood #ero X villain story....I even wrote one😅😂

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  14 часов назад

      @@KichiMiangra I don't remember that line. But that is such a good line!!!!! Such a realistic line too hahahahha

  • @ag9953
    @ag9953 2 часа назад

    Overall, Crystal is pretty faithful to the manga, with very few major changes to the storyline, really the only one I can think of happens in the first arc with the generals being kept alive longer and having their backstory explained (Which Takeuchi only cut out of the manga for time constraints).
    On the more minor side, the way Beryl dies is slightly modified as Usagi, and not Minako, delivers the final blow; there's also how Demande is slightly more heroic in season 2 as he attacks Death Phantom to protect Sailor Moon unlike in the manga where he attempts to attack Sailor Moon while she fights Death Phantom; and in season 3 the only change I can think of is the removal of the daimon form for Eudial.

  • @kelleygreengrass
    @kelleygreengrass 2 дня назад +2

    Demande is for Diamond. 💎

  • @SirSailorStar
    @SirSailorStar 2 дня назад +2

    Venus got so shafted in season 1 and 2. Girl cannot do anything without taking an L in some kinda way (animation or just in story loss xD).
    Venus is best girl so this is sad T^T

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  13 часов назад +1

      Season 3 so far is doing a much better job giving her attention!

  • @kelleygreengrass
    @kelleygreengrass 2 дня назад +2

    Sorry to spam thr comments but I just thought about how Ami is probably rich because Mercury is the god of money.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад

      @@kelleygreengrass oh really? Didn't know that was a thing.

  • @kelleygreengrass
    @kelleygreengrass 2 дня назад +1

    Rubeus is latin for red, but it's where Ruby came from.Diamond 💎 Sapphire💠 Emerald 🟩Ruby🔴

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад +1

      @kelleygreengrass that makes more sense then looking up demande in French. Although he was very demanding of the queen hahah

  • @ShinteiKun
    @ShinteiKun 2 дня назад

    Thank you for the breakdown!

  • @romeostruedude
    @romeostruedude День назад

    This is the best series. I wonder if it’s possible to even do a trifold graph. Which events happen where it doesn’t happen in the other. Or in 2 or all 3. But I get it. That’s asking for a lot. Just makes me think of you tubers who align events of Pretty Little Liars and Once Upon a Time. However we can all agree. We have 3 AMAZING solid entries in Sailor Moon: Manga, Anime Classic, Anime Crystal! Truly no one can complain.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад

      @romeostruedude since the original series is 200 episodes that is a lot. Hahaha. But that would be interesting to see!

  • @anthonythomas305
    @anthonythomas305 День назад

    Thanks for the breakdown
    I like this series and the arc

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  День назад +1

      @anthonythomas305 thank you for the support! Glad you liked it. I am working on season 3 next!

  • @galvatrix5817
    @galvatrix5817 2 дня назад +4

    This was amazing great job on this I really loved these comparisons I know this Season was rushed but I still really enjoyed it more than the original 90s SM not that the original was bad I still like it but I really love Crystals Version of it more super enjoyable also can't wait for the next vid for Season 3 the best season of all time ever in Crystal : D👍

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +1

      I am super excited!!! I love season 3 as well. It was my favorite in the original and this one!

    • @galvatrix5817
      @galvatrix5817 2 дня назад +1

      Oh Same here I loved the third Season in the OG SM 90s Anime too I like Crystal’s Version a little more but the OG will always be amazing too :D👍

  • @arcyarcanine
    @arcyarcanine 2 дня назад +2

    Why are we calling them scouts instead of soldiers or guardians?

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +4

      Force of habit. lol. That is a good callout though. It's just 30 years of calling them Sailor Scouts. Hard to break that habit.

    • @arcyarcanine
      @arcyarcanine День назад

      @@GodFireBreakdowns No worries, just a little odd especially when the DiC/Cloverway dub actors aren't even mentioned. 😅

    • @chriscassul9904
      @chriscassul9904 22 часа назад

      @@GodFireBreakdowns Preac#😝😅

  • @marvelboi3416
    @marvelboi3416 2 дня назад

    I have to say this second season of Sailor Moon Crystal is much darker than original 90s TV series.. Rubeus and the rest of them was taken out more faster than in the previous series.... By the way you had miss pronounced the character name on Attack on Titan that Matthew Mercer voiced. His name is Levi like the jeans😂 haha.

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +1

      Had a feeling levi name was pronounced that. I hadnt watched the series since season 1 when it came out in japan. Never did really hear properly how to say his name lol. but I agree it is 100% darker.

  • @stoggfoggn
    @stoggfoggn 2 дня назад +1

    hii can u please not mention the en or jp va’s going forward? i find its distracting and not really relevant

  • @user-saraswatidevi
    @user-saraswatidevi 2 дня назад +4

    I love how you mention the english and japanese v.as and their other roles

    • @GodFireBreakdowns
      @GodFireBreakdowns  2 дня назад +3

      Appreciate it! Since I am talking about the new show I figured might as well talk about the voices behind it as well. I try to throw in some fun facts. Like I did with some other details I learned making this video.