Sony a1 vs Nikon Z9 vs Canon R3: Which Camera Should You Buy? (2024)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 окт 2024
  • This video is brought to you by Squarespace. USE CODE FroKnowsPhoto at squarespace.com... to get your 14 day FREE Trial.
    This video is the Ultimate Flagship Camera Battle. Which one is the right one for you, the Sony a1, Nikon Z9 or the Canon EOS R3. My goal with this video is to give you the pros and cons of each camera and help you decide which one might be the right one for you. Everything is based on my Real World Usage of each of these cameras.
    FROPACK3 is HERE with 15 all-new custom Lightroom presets!!! Check it out
    froknowsphoto.... (40% OFF)
    Canon R3 Hands on • OFFICIAL Canon EOS R3 ...
    Sony 1 One Year Later Review • SONY a1 One YEAR Later...
    Nikon Z9 Hands on • OFFICIAL Nikon Z9 Hand...
    Order the Sony a1 from Amazon amzn.to/2Yq4kNJ​
    Order the Sony a1 from Allen's Camera bit.ly/3ccKZrt
    Order the Sony a1 from B+H bhpho.to/3iQh7lT
    Order the Canon EOS R3 from Allen's Camera bit.ly/3hzfJVl
    Order at B+H bhpho.to/3z4TdcU
    Order from Amazon amzn.to/2Yq4kNJ
    Order Z9 Allen's Camera bit.ly/3pPa56q Pre-Order
    Order Z9 Adorama bit.ly/310k5PS
    Order Z9 Aamazon amzn.to/3jKT5KI
    Order Z9 B and H bhpho.to/2XUrxea
    Order a Bernie Photo Book right here www.berniephot...
    This video was filmed with the Canon EOS R5 Canon.us/r5fro
    Download MyGearVault, it's FREE and the best way to keep track of all your camera gear, receipts, prices paid, date purchased and more mygearvault.co...
    Get a FREE Guide To Capturing Motion In Low Light Situations froknowsphoto.... (look for the orange box)
    Want to send us gifts, swag, letters...here's our P.O. BOX
    PO Box 3715 Philadelphia, PA 19125
    Gear I USE
    I SHOOT RAW T-Shirts store.froknows...
    I support Allen's Camera a mom-and-pop Camera store that's been around since 1977. allenscamera.c...
    My Go To Mirrorless Camera for Stills
    Sony a1 amzn.to/2NHsm55 or bit.ly/3ccKZrt
    SIGMA 35mm f1.2 amzn.to/2rLO8Jr (FAVE LENS)
    Our go to Cameras for Recording Videos at FroKnowsPhoto
    Canon EOS R5 amzn.to/37GQQ5R or bit.ly/2Obaj40
    Canon EOS R6 amzn.to/3m6JHQ9 or bit.ly/38GIdXt
    The Microphone I use for Vlogging bit.ly/2LWGRPq
    My Rolling Bag Of Choice For Flying bit.ly/2LNsHRK
    Follow me
    ►RUclips: bit.ly/frotube
    ►Facebook: / froknowsphoto
    ►Instagram: / jaredpolin
    ►Twitter: / froknowsphoto
    Please help us continue to make FREE content
    by purchasing one or all of the FroKnowsPhoto
    Educational guides. To check out previews of
    each guide click here.
    ►froknowsphoto.c...
    #FroKnowsPhoto #JaredPolin

Комментарии • 691

  • @froknowsphoto
    @froknowsphoto  2 года назад +88

    Which will you take? Right now I'm taking the R3, that's changed slightly since filming this video. The Sony a1 and R3 are a toss up for me depending on the situation.

    • @TillGiesche
      @TillGiesche 2 года назад +26

      I´d take care of your Z9 😇

    • @navi6463
      @navi6463 2 года назад +9

      Sony didn’t deliver the money truck for this video I take it, lol

    • @Non_Member_13
      @Non_Member_13 2 года назад +12

      Z9

    • @victorng2996
      @victorng2996 2 года назад +3

      A7iv XD

    • @pixxelat
      @pixxelat 2 года назад +12

      Nikon Z9

  • @Strodav
    @Strodav 2 года назад +208

    I have been invested in Nikon since 2016 with 5 bodies ( Z9, D850, D500, D800, D7200) and a lot of glass including the trinity, a 600mm f/4, some other telephotos and a bunch of fast primes. I pre-ordered the Z9 on the day of announcement and it came a couple of weeks ago. The Z9 is an amazing camera with the most important features to me being the AF system, ibis, and ability to use my AF-S f-mount glass. It is the right decision for me.

    • @TqSNv9R0iG5Ckxew
      @TqSNv9R0iG5Ckxew 2 года назад +21

      Can I have your obsolete D850?

    • @afryhover
      @afryhover 2 года назад +4

      @@TqSNv9R0iG5Ckxew I want his D850! 🤣🤣🤣

    • @baljindersinghsidhu3959
      @baljindersinghsidhu3959 2 года назад

      Always..

    • @TqSNv9R0iG5Ckxew
      @TqSNv9R0iG5Ckxew 2 года назад +1

      @@afryhover
      After taking a glance at your youtube channel, I must confess that I am not worthy! The D850 belongs to people like you who can better appreciate it.
      Off-topic, I must ask you, as an astrophotography enthusiast... Do you think that a D810A variant of the D810 would be appropriate for 3D model creation with Photogrammetry software?
      My instincts tell me that the additional light spectrum available on the D810A would give my software more matching pixel pairs between a given pair of images.
      I'd love to try it out, but it would be an expensive experiment to try on just a hunch.

    • @markshirley01
      @markshirley01 2 года назад +1

      I'm relieved Nikon have a camera that now competes well with the other brands. I'm now keeping my fingers crossed a more affordable model is released soon.

  • @felm.974
    @felm.974 2 года назад +46

    Z9, love the Nikon Colors and Glass.

  • @JessDemant
    @JessDemant 2 года назад +30

    Hi Jared, I will never consider changing brand because the big three are constantly changing places in the battle to be the best, so my advice is, just switch from a DSLR system to mirrorless system, and then choose the mirrorless brand there at that point appeals to you the most, it's that simple!
    Cheers
    Jess

  • @bobylob4625
    @bobylob4625 2 года назад +53

    I used a Z6ii a few weeks ago for the first time after shooting on a Nikon DSLR for several years and it blows my mind. I don’t doubt that the Z9 is even more mind blowing and I can’t wait to get my hands on one.

    • @matsudakodo
      @matsudakodo 2 года назад +3

      Love my Z 6II once I got it all customized

  • @thomastarner8683
    @thomastarner8683 2 года назад +76

    Z9 here, I'm set for F mount glass and I have seen a couple reviews that stated the auto focus speed differences for adapted f-mount glass was negligible or actually improved even with TC's added. I've been a Nikon shooter from the start shooting D500, D810, D850 and soon to be adding a Z9.

    • @erichramone7812
      @erichramone7812 2 года назад

      Nice!

    • @GeertDelmulle
      @GeertDelmulle 2 года назад +6

      Indeed, Steve Perry tested that to great satisfaction.

    • @lekkerpruven887
      @lekkerpruven887 2 года назад +2

      I've seen a video about that too. The Z9 is just as fast as the D6. Matt Granger maybe? Ricci? Seen so many videos, don't know. I could still be the Sony is faster overal, because they have more glass with the newest AF motors. Nikon has the 400 TC now with the newest motor. Would love to see a 70-200 with new motors and about 300 grams less weight like the Sony g2.

    • @patrickng8328
      @patrickng8328 2 года назад +2

      Yes. I hav tried auto focus with the adapter mounted a F mount 50mm 1.4 G lense. The auto focus did not slow down as mentioned in this video. Not much difference with a DSLR.

    • @KBSheldon0926
      @KBSheldon0926 2 года назад

      That's great to hear. Could I also ask you about sharpness of your f mount lenses. For example I've seen a 70-200 z lens seems sharper than an f mount lens. How is the sharpness of your f mount lenses on your z9. Sharper or pretty much the same.

  • @baljindersinghsidhu3959
    @baljindersinghsidhu3959 2 года назад +43

    For me, It's always Nikon Z9, reliability, badass design, quality pictures, video functions, and much more to say. I'm a Nikon fan here..❤👌👌🧨🧨💥💥

  • @angelfoto4795
    @angelfoto4795 2 года назад +40

    The Nikon EVF is build around user experience while the Sony one is build to be impressive in a spec sheet

  • @w4dZ0o
    @w4dZ0o 2 года назад +16

    I'm sticking with Nikon. I was manual tracking subjects last month so I'm cool with slightly less sticky AF. Seems to win in most other categories.

  • @mike_s_media
    @mike_s_media 2 года назад +32

    I actually went with the alpha 1 for a multitude of reasons but to keep it simple, I'm already on the Sony platform and have a decent handful of lenses. I will say if I were starting based off of one of these three though that I would still choose the alpha 1 over the R3 for the higher resolution. It helps to have the larger image size when I need to do a crop in on live action and wildlife shots. However, they are all outstanding performers and the real differences are so minute that I don't think anyone would go wrong with any of these systems!

  • @mrCetus
    @mrCetus 2 года назад +10

    I think it is worth mentioning that the A1 mshutter can sync up to 1/400 in FF and 1/500 in crop mode. That is likely the most advanced mech shutter ever built a very valuable feature and probably a good chunk of the added cost of the A1. I often use non HSS strobes and it can be very useful to sync faster for more control over ambient light or freezing action in hybrid lighting conditions.

  • @AtaBoraBasar
    @AtaBoraBasar 2 года назад +65

    Nikon Z9 is the best choice for those looking for price and performance.

    • @bergerniklas6647
      @bergerniklas6647 2 года назад +19

      The best is probably the one you already have 10 lenses for. All three are great but also eye-watering expensive...

    • @IanHobday
      @IanHobday 2 года назад +5

      Most people buying at this price point are not going to be all that sensitive to a thousand dollar difference in body price.
      If someone is sensitive to price then E mount has tons of excellent third party glass such as Sigma's 14-24/2.8 and 24-70/2.8, not available to Z or R mount buyers. Also great options like the 85/1.4 DG DN which is also only available on E.

    • @AtaBoraBasar
      @AtaBoraBasar 2 года назад +1

      @@IanHobday You are absolutely right about the lens, but I would like to say that I wrote a comment in accordance with the subject of this video.

    • @IanHobday
      @IanHobday 2 года назад +1

      @@AtaBoraBasar If you're going to consider price the total cost is what matters, not the cost of just one part.
      It's less of an issue at the top end of the market but lower down the market the total cost of buy in is a really big thing. A7iv+Tamron trinity is cheaper than any comparable kit from Canon or Nikon by a really big margin.

    • @MartabakGurih
      @MartabakGurih Год назад

      How about performance? Unlimited budget and performance

  • @6gwilliams
    @6gwilliams 2 года назад +15

    I am a former longtime Canon and Nikon pro user (40 years using both brands) . But I will stay with my Sony A1, A7SIII, A7RIV and my host of E-mount lenses from Sony, Sigma and Tamron, thank you. My Sonys fulfill all my professional and personal needs. Not switching back to Nikon or Canon. But I do wish them well with their Z9 and R3 as true competition keeps them all innovating. Cheers and thanks Jared. Give a shout out to Brandon and all the folks at Allen's for me ,ok. Still my fav dealer.

  • @danieljung2810
    @danieljung2810 9 месяцев назад +6

    Given that Nikon now has the ability to AUTO focus MANUAL lenses with the Techart adapter is pretty insane for those of us with a lot of old Nikon manual lenses or really any manual lens from Leica or Canon. To me, the sensor distance for Nikon letting you adapt any lens greatly expands why it's a great system.

  • @troyphillips1077
    @troyphillips1077 2 года назад +6

    I’ll be getting this year a Sony a7iv and the Nikon Z9.
    I shoot live music photography and videography. My Nikon images usually beat out the Sonys, Canon , Panasonic we all have for Video.
    So now Nikon has upped its game its time for me to get a mirrorless Nikon .

  • @theartofimaging618
    @theartofimaging618 2 года назад +28

    All the way Z 9. The Nikon package gets most things right where it really counts. You didn't mention the Nikon dual stream technology which makes the viewfinder stutter-free and not dropping in resolution like the Sony.

    • @erichramone7812
      @erichramone7812 2 года назад +5

      He never mentions the amazing things on the Z9. And yes it was a D3 moment. Probably even more so.

    • @danieIlondon
      @danieIlondon 2 года назад +1

      Don’t agree. The 30fps compress raw is really useful for fast action. The EVF is amazing. And noticeably better focusing than Nikon.
      Plus you have the option to detach the grip and shoot light. And yeah the Sony drops resolution, but it has a higher resolution to start with.
      I sold all my Nikon gear.

    • @lumenspaul
      @lumenspaul 2 года назад +1

      Well they all perform similar in action scenes,the dual stream only makes up for the lack of refresh rate which the sony is better. if you was nit picky you could say the nikon does not have enough resolution which could be really important for manual focusing and macro work ,and the canon has eye af control but i have spoken to a few users of the r3 and in general not so keen on it.

    • @miked8121
      @miked8121 2 года назад +1

      @@danieIlondon .... I shoot college football and professional surfing and I don't know any photographer that shoots RAW, only jpegs.

  • @therealscoobydoo
    @therealscoobydoo 2 года назад +17

    Don't own a Z9 or any mirrorless, but I work with photographers who use all 3 of the cameras you compared. What I hear consistently is that the Z9 is the only one that works as well with native and non-native lens. I know a Z9 user who owns both the native 70-200 and the 5-year-old Tamron 70-200 G2 and he can't tell the difference. The A1 and the R3 users have had inconsistent results with non-native lenes. That's a really big deal for those of us who have invested a lot in their lens collection. I am an 850 user; I don't think either of these cameras produce better image quality than my 850; however, their autofocus capability is almost unreal. With the Z9 you are getting the best of the 850 and the D5.

    • @marcschweiz
      @marcschweiz Год назад +1

      Cant wait till its cheaper to buy it second hand. Very happy with my D850 right now

  • @FrancescoBorsotti
    @FrancescoBorsotti 2 года назад +34

    Z9. And the Z mount glasses are stellar. Even the adapted f mount glasses perform much better on it

    • @KBSheldon0926
      @KBSheldon0926 2 года назад

      thats good to hear. i have all f mount and was wary of how the f mount glass would perform on z camera.

  • @455LT1
    @455LT1 2 года назад +26

    Z9 for me. Best value and I still think Nikon's files look the best.

  • @nickwilliams6716
    @nickwilliams6716 2 года назад +9

    As a Sony shooter I would love the rear screen from the Nikon. You did not mention flash sync speed which is a big check mark for Sony. I do wish I could set the photos per seconds. Stacked sensors are great for weddings I just wish I had more control over the speed

  • @8by10byscott6
    @8by10byscott6 2 года назад +11

    Had my Z9 since late December. It's a beast and handles everything I need.

    • @ignorantboxing
      @ignorantboxing 2 года назад +1

      Would you recommend it?

    • @ScottSaldingerMktgMaster
      @ScottSaldingerMktgMaster 2 года назад

      @@ignorantboxing depending on your level, experience, and photographic needs, absolutely!

    • @ignorantboxing
      @ignorantboxing 2 года назад

      @@ScottSaldingerMktgMaster just because.. its overkill, but I want it. The last camera I used professionally was the canon 5d mark 2 when it 1st came out. I want to get back into it.

    • @ScottSaldingerMktgMaster
      @ScottSaldingerMktgMaster 2 года назад

      @@ignorantboxing then go for it if you can afford it!

  • @theartofimaging618
    @theartofimaging618 2 года назад +20

    Nikon users can have the best of both worlds: Using a D850 with optical viewfinder which is still preferred for nature and wildlife photography as it don't need any power consumption or a super modern mirrorless Z 9 for great video or action work. Both systems don't exclude each other and can be used easily in parallel.

    • @CaseyCJL
      @CaseyCJL Год назад

      Sorry but why does power consumption matter? i'm still learning. I don't understand why the D850 vf would be preferred over mirrorless vf

  • @philippkompa9794
    @philippkompa9794 2 года назад +30

    I've got a 5DSR with a 24-70 2.8 and 70-200 2.8 with which I am very happy. However, I think the Nikon would be the most appealing to me out of these three - because of the Resolution, Card Slots, low Iso 64, and having a HDMI Type A is also nice.

    • @whiterock1865
      @whiterock1865 2 года назад

      Video features of z9 are pretty great too

  • @MaverickChristian
    @MaverickChristian 2 года назад +18

    I'm going with none of the above because they're all too expensive for me. 😜 Given the option though I'd choose the a1 simply because I have so much glass invested in the Sony system. At this point, which to choose depends on which system you've spent money on lenses.

  • @imjooboy
    @imjooboy 2 года назад +20

    Preferring uncompressed raw over lossless compressed is kind of stupid.

    • @jarenplayz1083
      @jarenplayz1083 Год назад +1

      Gotta agree with you there. Literally 0.1% difference

  • @sithbk0075
    @sithbk0075 2 года назад +6

    I started with Canon platform 25 yrs ago then got into Nikon platform when Nikon D3 was released. Sold all Canon 1D series and all in with Nikon. Then got a D4 then noticed fir the last 8 yrs Nikon system was behind abs worried they might not lasted as a company.
    Last year i was ready for a new camera and wanted a good hybrid system for still and video. Nikon didn’t have anything comparable to Canon and Sony. Purchased Canon R3 last November and while i liked it the 24 megapixel was too low for cropping on some usage. What i liked was that the body was really light for the form factor and eye auto focus but i had a few issue calibrating with my eye. But when Z9 was announced and it fits my needs. So I sold the R3, RF 24/200/2.8 and 70/200/2.8 IS. My only complaint with Z9 was that it is heavy. Just a little lighter than my old D4 but not by much. Wished it would be a lot lighter especially when you pair it with pro lenses like 24-70/2.8 and 70-200/2.8 S lenses. Any way, I’m happy with my decision since i already have a few Nikon lenses but now I’m slowly replacing F mount lenses with S mount. It’s sure is a very expensive hobby for sure. Yes it’s probably more than my needs but life is too short so why not.

  • @phphoto
    @phphoto 2 года назад +15

    Hi Jared - Like you said, it really doesn’t matter wich camera you use. But I’ll stick with Nikon - because of the quality of the files. I find the nikon files so beautiful and sexy - So I can easily live with the lesser focus tracking and 20 frames a second. That is not a dealbreaker for me 👍🏼

    • @marcusaparham
      @marcusaparham 2 года назад +3

      I have watched different RUclipsrs and testers get different results as far as autofocus goes when testing these cameras. Some say the Z9 is the best and some say the R3 is the best. I think it comes down to the way you set it up. Mark Smith and Jared Polin are the only ones that I have seen that rank the Z9 as the worst of the 3. All are good but don’t just assume that the Nikon is the worst because of a couple of reviews when there are others saying the opposite.

  • @imjooboy
    @imjooboy 2 года назад +20

    Viltrox makes Z mount lenses. Saying Nikon has NO 3rd party support is incorrect.

    • @IanHobday
      @IanHobday 2 года назад +3

      Come on... No one is going to buy Viltrox lenses for a Z9. Viltrox has their place in the market but it's really close to the bottom.

    • @srbarber63
      @srbarber63 2 года назад +4

      The Viltrox glass is real! Superb optics.

    • @IanHobday
      @IanHobday 2 года назад

      @@srbarber63 Compared to mounting a coke bottle on your camera, sure. Everything is relative after all.

    • @Photomeike
      @Photomeike 2 года назад +4

      @@IanHobday I actually own a Nikon Z9 and have the Viltrox 24mm 1.8 and Nikon 24mm 1.8S lens and I prefer using my Viltrox over the Nikon. Although the Nikon is sharper. The Viltrox is plenty sharp and can hold its own and the autofocus work just as good. But the main reason I prefer the Viltrox is because of the more compact size.

    • @IanHobday
      @IanHobday 2 года назад

      @@Photomeike It's 1cm shorter and 80g lighter. In exchange you get more CA, worse IQ (especially at larger apertures), and no weather sealing. That doesn't seem like a great trade-off to me.
      Also, if compact size and light weight are you think it seems Sony would be a better fit overall.

  • @ralphblach2952
    @ralphblach2952 2 года назад +26

    Jared, Lossless compression is better in my opinion, because a compressed raw file and a non-compressed raw file contain the same information. Except the compressed raw file is smaller and that is better because it takes up less space

    • @erichramone7812
      @erichramone7812 2 года назад +8

      Your absolutely correct lossless compressed raw is just as good as uncompressed raw.

    • @TheDeltaMoo
      @TheDeltaMoo 2 года назад +2

      While saving space, it also takes less time to write to the memory card increasing buffer, so it's a win-win situation

    • @dragonnyxx
      @dragonnyxx 2 года назад +7

      Jared has never seemed to understand the word "lossless".

    • @tubularificationed
      @tubularificationed 2 года назад +4

      @Jared, "lossless" just uses the fact that two neighboring pixels are usually so similar, that it saves space to express their difference as a small delta, rather than full e.g. 14 bit values. If 3 bits are enough to express the delta, then only 3 bits will be used.
      Also with regards to "lossy" RAW compression, there are differences.
      Nikon e.g. just reduces the bit depth of pixel values where the excess bits would drown in noise anyway. So this is artifact free.
      Sony is "lossy" more aggressively, they reduce bit depth across contrast edges, where Sony assumes that the eye is distracted by the contrast so much, that it doesn't sense bit depth nuances. Unfortunately, if the contrast gets really big (e.g. stars in night sky, or night city scenes), then artifacts do occur across contrast edges.

    • @ralphblach2952
      @ralphblach2952 2 года назад +1

      @@tubularificationed Thanks, you have a much better understanding of this subject than I do. As an engineer who works in the storage industry, I see compression as a big plus if it is done correctly.
      1) it saves on space
      2) it saves power and thus gives a longer battery life.

  • @atrbear
    @atrbear 2 года назад +14

    When comparing total price you did not add in the additional cost of the battery grip on the Sony

    • @aboynamedjamil
      @aboynamedjamil 2 года назад +2

      Because most people won't buy the vertical grip.

    • @lekkerpruven887
      @lekkerpruven887 2 года назад +1

      Same for the system weight.

  • @thomastuorto9929
    @thomastuorto9929 2 года назад +11

    I still think the A1 wins out. I wish you would of mentioned low light or in the dark focus.

  • @benjaminzerhusen4941
    @benjaminzerhusen4941 2 года назад +12

    Just my 2 cents on adapted lenses with the z9:
    Z9 with my 500mm PF works like a charm, although its adapted.
    the other Z cameras struggled to drive the autofocus fast enough, but that is not the case with the Z9.
    I havent really tried a lot of other/older nikon glass though, maybe older lenses are still slower when adapted.
    On the other hand, at least here in Germany you will have a hard time to try to buy either the z9 or the R3 right now. Basically neither of them is available in stores.
    The A1 is at least "purchaseable" aka in stock.

  • @tannerjagim4241
    @tannerjagim4241 2 года назад +4

    Could you maybe do a video on the best non full frame flagships? I know it’s not particularly your thing but a comparison between the new gh6, om-1, x-t4 etc would be interesting I’m sure.

  • @theartofimaging618
    @theartofimaging618 2 года назад +6

    Great and objective comparison. But you got it wrong with the FTZ-Adapter on the Nikon. There is no slow down or speed decrease with F-Mount lenses on the Z 9.

    • @KBSheldon0926
      @KBSheldon0926 2 года назад

      How is the sharpness of the f mount lenses on the z9. I've seen the z lenses seem sharper than f mount lenses of the same length

  • @Tap-a-roo
    @Tap-a-roo 2 года назад +144

    The Canon feels light because it's missing all the megapixels.

    • @DESIGNS-vo1mt
      @DESIGNS-vo1mt 2 года назад +8

      Heck yeah. More megapixels make crappy images look like stellar shots

    • @Tap-a-roo
      @Tap-a-roo 2 года назад +4

      @@DESIGNS-vo1mt no it doesn’t. Most lenses can’t even resolve 45 megapixels.

    • @DragRacingTV
      @DragRacingTV 2 года назад +11

      @@Tap-a-roo that is total nonsense, lenses do not out-resolve sensors.

    • @Tap-a-roo
      @Tap-a-roo 2 года назад +3

      @@DragRacingTV You have no idea what you're talking about.

    • @DragRacingTV
      @DragRacingTV 2 года назад +7

      @@Tap-a-roo no, your post proved that you don't have any idea what you are talking about.

  • @Skye_the_toller
    @Skye_the_toller 2 года назад +6

    Récent lens like the 500pf focus faster with the Z9….

  • @vagabundian5457
    @vagabundian5457 2 года назад +8

    Thought i had to switch away from nikon, also because i make alot of video stuff
    But i think the z9 changed it for me. But im waiting for the huge video update.

  • @thesharpercoder
    @thesharpercoder 2 года назад +17

    I do not know why Jared always ignores the extra [weight] and cost for the Sony battery grip.
    Add about a half pound of weight, and about $500 for the Sony Grip and extra battery.

    • @DragRacingTV
      @DragRacingTV 2 года назад

      i do not own the sony grip and i'll never buy one, which is a huge advantage over the porky inflexible z9/r3 bodies, plus the a1 has better watt-hour battery life than those cameras, it's the most efficient despite having the highest rez evf.

    • @krishnastock
      @krishnastock 2 года назад

      Sony's battery grip for the A1 costs $398 to be exact! Used ones go for less than $300!

  • @marcusbeasley3212
    @marcusbeasley3212 2 года назад +18

    For me Z9. I have been using Sony since about late 2018 and after a shoot where the RII and RIII were not cutting it for me I bought a Z6II and D850 (been shooting Nikon since 2016) and ended up loving that combo. Traded my entire Fuji system in for a Z9 and I don't have any regrets with that decision. I have been loving the Z stuff since and even started reinvesting into F mount and got a 500PF for the Z9 after not enjoying the 200-500 on that camera.

    • @JohnHilario23
      @JohnHilario23 2 года назад

      Wow, where’d you get that R2?

    • @marcusbeasley3212
      @marcusbeasley3212 2 года назад

      @@JohnHilario23 I believe I bought it used at B&H. Did a corporate event where the RII was just not responsive enough for what I needed it for and just dropped that camera like a bag of hot potatoes and ended up going back to my combo of a Nikon D4 and D810 for the work, which honestly did that stuff just fine. RII at least for me is a poorly aging camera since you basically have to jury rig that combo to get it to change AF points and using the rear and front command dials for that is the most counter intuitive way to do it during a fast paced event.

    • @CaseyCJL
      @CaseyCJL Год назад

      How would you say your f-mount lenses are doing on the Z9? I have so many f-mount lenses but i'm worried they won't adapt well to the Z9? i have tamron's G2 trinity

    • @marcusbeasley3212
      @marcusbeasley3212 Год назад

      @@CaseyCJL Personally I'd only really adapt unique lenses like the 105 1.4, 58 1.4 and other exotics. Stuff like the 50 and 85 1.8's I would just buy the native versions of, same with the holy trinity zooms since the S versions out class them. They will work on the Z9 yes, but I really don't think you're maximizing the camera with the older F mount stuff. I remember using the 70-200FL on my Z6II thinking I was never going to get the S version and still ended up getting the S version like a month later. The new glass is worth the investment. Just read you have the Tamron G2 trinity...slowly but surely get the S versions and to even adapt most of them I think you have to update the firmware on the lens itself. I got rid of most of my Tamron stuff when I got the Z6II to be honest, not sure how the AF is going to react on that combo either.

    • @CaseyCJL
      @CaseyCJL Год назад

      @@marcusbeasley3212 Thanks for the reply. When you said move to S versions, did you mean to say the Z mount versions? i think Z is what it's called on Nikon mirrorless right? not sure what S version is?

  • @SplendidLP
    @SplendidLP 2 года назад +3

    I saw a comparison, that the F mount glass actually focuses faster with the Z9 than a D850. So don't get rid of F mount lenses when upgrading to a Z9 👍

  • @aaroneliawahl6393
    @aaroneliawahl6393 2 года назад +4

    Thank you Jared for this great Video!
    I‘ve been with Nikon since i was 15 and started with the D750. I‘m now shooting on the Z6 II and the Z9 is a dream for one day in the future.

  • @srbarber63
    @srbarber63 2 года назад +4

    Thanks Jared. I’ve been shooting Nikon since my FM film body. I have a Z9 on order, my glass will love it!

  • @skishades
    @skishades 2 года назад +2

    To use my Nikon glass is the only factor. I just dived into mirrorless with a Z9… which is my first professional camera. Still adjusting to the deep end but can’t imagine a better experience.

  • @CourtneyVictoria
    @CourtneyVictoria 2 года назад +3

    I'd love to play around with the Nikon Z9 sometime. I don't think I'll be purchasing one myself anytime in the near future nor would it be my next choice of camera because of the size.

  • @erichramone7812
    @erichramone7812 2 года назад +3

    Thanks Jared. Nice breakdown

  • @vageeshbabuhanur8769
    @vageeshbabuhanur8769 Год назад

    Hey Jared, your final decision on the right choice of camera system was unexpectedly masterstroke. Excellent.

  • @SquirrelE1
    @SquirrelE1 Год назад +1

    I'm going with the R3 because I like the feel, weight, looks and functionality for what I do. Great video comparison too! THANKS!

  • @estebanod
    @estebanod Год назад +7

    Specs wise, either the A1 or R3
    Can’t wait to see a A1 II with the A7RV tilting screen, AI AF, stabilization etc..

  • @justinjames403
    @justinjames403 2 года назад +3

    R1 entry into the market will be the REAL GANGSTER move!!.......with Quad Pixel AF tech......45-50MP (atleast) STACKED sensor .....30 fps burst mode (maybe even 40fps who knows!)......8K recording.....No Overheating ...NO record limit and single PRO body with integrated Vertical Grip that have big battery!

  • @Sulaksh007
    @Sulaksh007 2 года назад +5

    Nikon z system has 3rd party lens now ( by veltrox )

  • @xr3217
    @xr3217 2 года назад +3

    I love my Sony A1 with the 35-150. I also have the 150-600 and a couple others.
    Sony a1 i think will be the top camera for a while still. I think it is so advanced that there's no need to upgrade. If your pictures are not turning out with either camera it's the photographers error. I think the Sony is a little power house and if you need that extra grip you can put it on. You don't have to carry that extra weight especially when your hiking taking pics of wildlife and you have one of those huge lenses to capture your subjects. And don't forget Sony makes sensors for most of these cameras. As for working in the dark. It's called muscle memory. It's not hard to memorize the buttons. Plus all the third-party lenses. I just think people like to jump on the next new not necessarily the best thing.

  • @carlkristensen8398
    @carlkristensen8398 2 года назад +8

    The Z9 for me because of the lenses I have. But also for the focus-stacking ability, wich is awesome for both landscape- and macro photography, not to speak of foodphotography. Not sure if Canon has that or not, but to my knowledge, Sony does not have it. And then there is the raw files! Z9, no doubt.

  • @MatthiasAI
    @MatthiasAI 2 года назад +5

    Im giving that thumbs up for "I always liked a bigger feeling thing in my hand". Goodlord that caught me offguard haha~

  • @f1rstclass596
    @f1rstclass596 2 года назад +7

    Greetings 🖖🏽 plus Hello 👋🏽 I like the Nikon Z9.

  • @harryvuemedia5106
    @harryvuemedia5106 2 года назад +2

    I'm going with Sony A1 since i am a sony user and have E-mount lenses. I do like the flexibility of being able to take off the battery extended mount and being able to use SD cards. Other than that, 50 mp and 20 fps burst shooting is enough for me. Sony A1!

  • @EugenesVids
    @EugenesVids 2 года назад +1

    This is the review I've been waiting for, thanks!

  • @meyer2278
    @meyer2278 2 года назад +7

    I jumped from Nikon to Sony during the mirrorless transition too. I have some fantastic Sigma and Tamron glass as well. So, I am on Sony's bandwagon for that reason. Gotta say though, I'm kinda proud of Nikon. It's like someone said "Get your shit together" and they did.

    • @IanHobday
      @IanHobday 2 года назад +3

      Same here. Nikon to Sony. Am happy but am proud of Nikon for how fast they have gotten their shit together. Someone seems to have hit the panic button and everyone responded well.

    • @nickwilliams6716
      @nickwilliams6716 2 года назад +1

      I went from Canon to Sony but like you I love the fact the big three all make great cameras. Nikon still needs to improve AF in lower end mirrorless but I am sure than is coming very soon.

  • @livejames9374
    @livejames9374 2 года назад +3

    You comment about adapted lenses being slower only applies to Z5/6/7. I’ve found f mount lenses work even better than they did on DSLR now with the Z9. There’s third party lenses for Canon and Nikon, just not tamron and sigma.

  • @mcmoose64
    @mcmoose64 2 года назад +14

    All of these cameras can produce spectacular technical image quality . Some may be nominally better than others but I feel we may be bumping up against the law of diminishing returns .
    If I were in the market for a camera of this calibre, I think I would go with the Sony because of its removable grip. The Canon and Nikon are just too bulky for my day to day needs.

    • @VCBP-415
      @VCBP-415 Год назад

      I thought those were external grips 😮 to me its very ugly lol (sony user here)

  • @howardfielding922
    @howardfielding922 2 года назад +6

    Hi Jarod, have you had chance to test the Z9 with the latest version of the firmware? Aparently it has further enhanced the fliker free system and has improved again the AF.

  • @paulandpedro
    @paulandpedro 2 года назад +23

    Would have been curious to see the actual differences in the base ISOs 64/100. I always thought ISO was subjective to the manufacturers a little.

    • @ivorgottschalk6432
      @ivorgottschalk6432 2 года назад +1

      Agreed and also a high ISO comparison for wildlife/action shooters.

    • @Lofote
      @Lofote 2 года назад +1

      Dpreview has great comparison pics for that.

    • @Mr09260
      @Mr09260 2 года назад

      Are you SERIOUS !! Difference is like Night and day Bro

    • @MannsWoodlandPerspective
      @MannsWoodlandPerspective 2 года назад

      The dynamic range is far superior. There's dozens of graphs showing DR comparisons. Better DR and less noise induced into a file while editing.

    • @BobN54
      @BobN54 2 года назад

      The difference is that you get 2/3 stop more exposure with 64 ISO. ISO itself has little effect on noise. What has the effect is that the ISO setting determines which exposure you meter thinks is 'correct', so you get more exposure if you use a lower ISO. By and large ISO isn't 'subjective', most camera manufacturers follow the ISO standards closely, it's just that many people are misinformed about what ISO actually is.

  • @أديب-س1ض
    @أديب-س1ض Год назад

    I would like to do a comprehensive comparison and review between Nikon Z9 👈 Nikon D6
    And the full, deep and comprehensive difference between DSLR 👈 Mirrorless
    1_
    What are the problems and defects in the mirrorless system in depth?
    What are the problems and defects in the DSLR system in depth?
    2_ Orientation now to what kind and the future where?
    3_ Will production stop?
    DSLR or Mirrorless
    4_ Why are there two systems?
    DSLR and Mirrorless
    5_
    Mirrorless system who is targeting?
    Nidham DSLR Who is targeting?
    Thank you 🌹❤️

  • @marendradika
    @marendradika 2 года назад +1

    You gave Check Marks mostly to Z9 (7), and Toss Up both A1 (3) and R3 (3). Right?

  • @IanMacdonald02
    @IanMacdonald02 2 года назад +3

    Switched to Sony a few years ago with the great A7iii migration a lot of users did. I have almost moved to the R5 a couple of times, the A1 is just a bit too expensive for me to justify however the reason I stood and stick don’t, Is that E mount and the incredible lens selection. Glass is so vital, so I stick with the system that offers me the most. Canon, open up that RF mount, do the right thing. You’re losing customers that might but 3rd party today, but go L mount in the future. I’ve started with samyangs and Tamron, upgraded most to Sigma Art and soon, fingers crossed if business goes well there will be my first GM in the line up this year.

  • @nawusayipsunam1643
    @nawusayipsunam1643 2 года назад

    You are not bias. Nice real review and compare.

  • @MasterNothing
    @MasterNothing 2 года назад +8

    You rock fro! thanks for the content. I will stick with the Z9. Its simple. Im a pro enthusiast. cheaper and sleeker. Cheers!

  • @davidbozesan9310
    @davidbozesan9310 2 года назад

    1:05 bro has the smoothest game out there wit that tender talk😏😏😏😏😏

  • @Jespervangcom
    @Jespervangcom 2 года назад +2

    Being a Nikon user since 1987, Nikon is all I know. And should I buy one of these, the Z9 would be my natural choice. I have not a lot of lenses for Nikon, but as mentioned, I've known and followed Nikon for around 35 years, so that brand I would stick to .

  • @victoriasinda8050
    @victoriasinda8050 2 года назад +5

    Z9

  • @rickj.danger8933
    @rickj.danger8933 2 года назад +1

    I received my Z9 3 weeks ago. 🙌 I’m ecstatic

  • @Wallace0333
    @Wallace0333 Год назад

    Nikon Z9 for the layout of the buttons (and backlit), overall feel and love the results with the Z glass.

  • @tipushah7591
    @tipushah7591 2 года назад +2

    I started with D750. I'm not a pro. I have decided to wait for Sony, Cannon & Nikon to correct their mistakes before I jump in the realm of mirrorless cameras.
    They really need a lot of things before I'm ready to invest $10,000.
    Their fancy names and bodies are not working for me.
    I need 8k baby with 120fps raw uncompressed to start with. ❤️
    Let's see when 😬

  • @franktherabbit42
    @franktherabbit42 10 месяцев назад

    I have always shot Nikon. I have a Z7ii currently, but I cant wait to get my hands on a Z9

  • @amermeleitor
    @amermeleitor 2 года назад +1

    Knowing all three are excellent... Which one have the best picture quality? Not about the amount of pixels but the overall rendition of the images. I tend to think about Nikon, then Canon and then Sony. For me Nikon since years ago have the upper hand in image quality, near perfect in dynamic range, definition, colors, contrast, etc, Canon have its colors and a punchy less digital quality, and Sony is ok, but need more post processing work to get an appealing image

  • @DavidWilliamsPhotographer
    @DavidWilliamsPhotographer 2 года назад +5

    Already have the R3. Love it. Been shooting with it since November.

    • @froknowsphoto
      @froknowsphoto  2 года назад +2

      me too

    • @HeathBlythe
      @HeathBlythe 2 года назад

      @@froknowsphoto Jared, do you have an R3 real world review coming up, or did I just miss it from your uploads?

  • @Piros181
    @Piros181 Год назад

    Such a great review, totally entertaining and informative.

  • @Lofote
    @Lofote 2 года назад +1

    And you also forgot that the α1 also combines ibis with lens is, if available

  • @trumanhw
    @trumanhw Год назад

    Quick observation: Only the Canon and Nikon include HEVC
    (which is processor intensive encoding and definitely a valuable feature)

  • @Skye_the_toller
    @Skye_the_toller 2 года назад +10

    How the Nikon EVF is so good with significant less specs? I am so surprise how good it is!

  • @Jwitherow1964
    @Jwitherow1964 2 года назад +2

    I shot sony and Nikon still waiting on my z9 I pre order from Allens camera in oct.

  • @rumporridge1
    @rumporridge1 2 года назад +1

    Was waiting for this one Jared thanks.

  • @petersmeets3921
    @petersmeets3921 Год назад

    I bought my first Nikon in 1979, an FE, and it still works, although I don't shoot film anymore since the late nineties. I've never had a reliability issue with any of the 10 or more Nikon cameras (and the many Nikkor lenses) I have owned. Not once. So, even if the Z9 is not what I really need, I definitely would opt for the Z system the day I go mirrorless. But as the 'old'
    cameras don't break down, that won't be any day soon...

  • @MrDucatiPenigaleV4s
    @MrDucatiPenigaleV4s 2 года назад +3

    As a photography student, I can not afford any, but if I could it would be the Z9 with the f2.8 27-70 and 70-200 f2.8 Nikon.

  • @birdinginsingapore4884
    @birdinginsingapore4884 2 года назад +4

    z9

  • @goldencreekphotography
    @goldencreekphotography 2 года назад +1

    Hi Jared, love your videos, thanks for the review 👍😁

  • @NickHey
    @NickHey 2 года назад +1

    I love my D850 but I want to get a Z9 and do some sports photography in the near future.

  • @bertnase9933
    @bertnase9933 Год назад

    You can pretty well connect Sony e-mount glass with the Megadap adapter to Nikon Z. Works like a charme!

  • @robbiedeville
    @robbiedeville 2 года назад

    I'm glad that it doesn't matter what system you use there is a camera for everyone now and all of them are good and as time goes on it's only going to get better.

  • @DHAGMANN2
    @DHAGMANN2 2 года назад +4

    Great fairly explained comparison. I would go with the Nikon Z9

  • @Mr_D555
    @Mr_D555 Год назад +3

    I'm not a Pro so let's get that out of the way, I have a few (5) F mount lenses so I'm staying with Nikon. My current body is an older D700 I would never sell so my next purchase would most likely be a Z body and FTZ adapter. Will I buy a Z9, sure would be nice but I would need to sell something to justify that. Either way I see a Z7II or Z9 in my future.

  • @Mikegans1
    @Mikegans1 2 года назад

    Great Video!! I would love to see it again with the two updates that Nikon has done on the Z9 since the video was created. Good job.

  • @ntwoy2doubelgg44
    @ntwoy2doubelgg44 2 года назад +1

    Oh Wow!!! No doubt this is the bes t tutorial on the subject

  • @waynelytton7517
    @waynelytton7517 Год назад +3

    Absolutely enjoy your reviews and comments. I worked for National Geographic in the Photographic Lab . I was blessed to work with some of the best photographers in the world. Part of my duties was evaluating all new digital cameras and giving the OK when they finally reached the point where they were acceptable for producing NGS production image quality images.

  • @eric00214
    @eric00214 2 года назад +3

    Not all F-mount lenses are slower on the Z9. The 500PF is actually faster on the Z9. About .7 seconds on DSLRs and about .5 seconds on the Z9. These speeds indicate the time to rack focus from MFD to Infinity and back again.

    • @CaseyCJL
      @CaseyCJL Год назад

      How do you think Tamron's G2 trinity would fair on the Z9? i'd love to get the Z9 but don't want to get new glass. Thanks

  • @scherge
    @scherge 24 дня назад

    The R5 would have made more sense for this comparison, imo, just for the megapixel count alone. It's hard to compare shooting speeds and such when the camera sensors are so different.
    Anyhow, I guess, all three cameras produce great images if you know what you're doing, and you should probably get the one that you already own nice glass for.

  • @skolknocker
    @skolknocker 2 года назад +1

    So great job as always - but all things being equal especially in your summation -- my buddy consistently shoots at higher iso's in very low light with better focus and no noise than the same shots with my R5 -- would love to see you do the comparison for low light shooters

  • @kevingarciamurga6890
    @kevingarciamurga6890 2 года назад

    Amazing comparative, you are the best!

  • @maknifeandrods7701
    @maknifeandrods7701 2 года назад

    Wow faster than my 8x20 deardorff, most of your viewer don’t even know what I’m talking about. But my digital cameras are paper weights to these. And for pros this is where you are. Most think iPhones have the best cameras. lol I had followed you for years then got away from cameras. Now more amateur video but am happy to be back. Thanks for all the hard work.

  • @garymeredith2441
    @garymeredith2441 10 месяцев назад

    Jared take a look at the ISO setting on how it can be expanded on the Canon R3 if you get into the ISO setting's menu it will go all the way down to ISO 50 is what it says but just think about that it will go lower than both the Nikon and the Sony .

  • @Krwler
    @Krwler 11 месяцев назад

    I gave this video a like for the energy and passion alone.