Coleman tent vs Magellan pop up tent
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Which one would you choose? 🤔
Coleman 4person tent amzn.to/3q43BQ2
A-Frame 3 person pop up Tent ⛺️ amzn.to/3TOsvB0
Portable shower bath tent amzn.to/3Rutgx1
Songmics POPUP portable shower bath tent amzn.to/3QanjEn
Which one would you choose? 🤔
Coleman 4person tent amzn.to/3q43BQ2
A-Frame 3 person pop up Tent ⛺️ amzn.to/3TOsvB0
Portable shower bath tent amzn.to/3Rutgx1
Songmics POPUP portable shower bath tent amzn.to/3QanjEn
Because of my height & age, I would choose the popups. I have used Coleman tents for 25 years. I made a change to popup last year. Always use a small accessory tent for bathroom.
Are you kidding? I'm on my way to NC and watching your videos with my son lol at your frog rib joke!!
I'll take the older model, Mr. Lead
Mr. Lead did you ask me to email you ? If so it's not going threw the yahoo. It fail 2x
Coleman. If I need to leave quick I’ll just throw that sucker in the back of my truck. Lol! I think the Coleman is a lot nicer.
The Panning of the camera to show Lady Lead Admiring Her World was Excellent !!!
So for the first one bathroom, I choose the old one because I like the sturdiness, taller, and more room for the bathroom situation. For the second test, I choose the Coleman, what is 10 minutes, has more room, can stalk to the ground, and is light to carry. Thank you for all your prep ideas.
Thank you Carrie!❤ I love the details in your comment. That is what I was looking for. Thank you 🙏🏽
I like the sturdiness and compactness of the tents with the poles. And I know me, I would blow a fuse trying to remember how to put that springform genie back in its pouch. I’ve been thinking about shower tent for a few years, and your video has made up my mind, so I thank you very much! Have an awesome weekend 👍🏽💕
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 you got me spitting out my water laughing!!!🤣 I agree 100%
I just love you LeadFarmer because you have common everyday survival sense.
In my heart you are a good teacher.
God bless you and your beautiful wife with her gorgeous hair.😇🤗😇
I don't know about you sometimes Lead, you are so Crazy Funny!!!!!!! The ending was awesome!
😂😂 believe it or not…. That was my crazy wife idea😂😂😂😂 we were. BOth laughing hysterically through the whole thing. I had to edit out the laughter😂😂😂
@@leadfarmer73 You guys are my DREAM TEAM! Love Y'all
😂🤣🤣 Lead! It don't make no sense how crazy you are! You had my husband laughing so hard I thought I would have to get help for him! Great video and such good visual instructions! I think the non pop uo would be efficient for us! Thanks so much!
Like the old school one looks like more room. Also I can get them back in the bag way quicker than the twisted one.Still seems like you didn't fiddle that much with the first tent and just like that kind. Ending was epic. Thanks for showing the differences
I have the shower tent. It's cool, but no joke when taking down.. Setting up is easy, but I had to master that twist when taking it down. Once you master that twist to take down, it's all pretty cool. I'll say, practice now before you actually need it. Thanks again Bro. Lead!👑💜
You are so right. I’ve been putting these things together for over 20 years and the ease of putting them up and taking them down is getting better and better by the year.
I’d roll with the pop up tent but my wife ain’t going for no bottom in the tent. I have the Colman tent on the left. You were on point and kept my attention from beginning to end.
Thanks Lead for the video. I've been wrecking my brain looking for a tent based on what I need. A lot of research, but I found that I want more space, head room and 2 doors in my tent, PLUS an easy, instant setup. Yo homegirl is getting too old and my nerves too bad to play Kinect and Tetris with some tent poles 😂😂....so POP, CRACKLE and POP for me! I hope my bathroom don't fly away like Mary Poppins though 😳😳😂😂
I would go with the popup tent....the ending 🤣🤣🤣 THANKS FOR THE LAUGH
🤣🤣🤣 I’m glad you hung in there to catch that bit of madness🤣
The end had me rolling Uncle Lead 🤣🤣🤣! I’m sold on the Magellan in both cases because of the ease & convenience. If the 💩 hit the fan in a bad weather situation, I need for my family to be out of those elements ASAP. Thanks for sharing and stay blessed fam!
-Calvin
I choose the Magellan Popup tent all the day long! Thanks for this detailed video. Have a safe and happy Labor Day weekend. 😊
We go old school for both. If the shower tent is still wet when you get home you hang it on the line and it dries fast. Also love the floor in it cause with the mesh on all 4 sides it’s still easy to drain it plus you don’t have to remember to pack a floor like the pop up one. The Coleman tent is no joke and can handle winds off Lake Superior. We did have a pile break once but super easy and cheap to get a replacement pole. We’ve had our shower tent and pup tent for close to 20 years and they are still going strong. Only thing we’ve changed is we don’t use the sun showers anymore. Much nicer shower with a mug and 5 gallon bucket filled from the river with a boiling tea pot of water added. But for potty we just use our outhouse. Lol
This may be slightly off topic. I have several tents BUT they are all for warm weather. Please do a video on winter survival tents preferably with stove top roofs. Thanks
I'm old school myself. I don't mind spending a little more time setting up something that I'm going to be sleeping in if I can save some $... Appreciate that video
Haaaaaa! So funny! Aaah! Ha! Woohoo. Whatever doesn't blow away is what I want. Whatever doesn't blow away! Oh my goodness. Funny! In a grid down situation, the one that fits a 6'5 hubby is what I would choose. Coleman?????
I will pick the pop up bathroom tent and Coleman Tent seems to have more room and more steady. Thanks for sharing Mr. Lead. ❤🤗
Man you be on it. I would chose the Coleman. You are such a great instructor. Thank you so much.
Thank you murcry 🤣
Pop up. Faster when traveling with kids. Love the ending of your video. 😆 🤣
YOU WIN! EMAIL ME AT LEADFARMER73@YAHOO.COM AND USE YOUR RUclips NAME AND REAL NAME IN THE HEADING.😂 seriously
Lol, great content. I prefer the popup tents. I have no patience for all those poles in the the Coleman tents.
I have used a pop up potty tent for 12 years. It is fast to set up but flimsy. Mine came with 4 bags that you can fill with sand and a detachable bottom. It does have 2 pockets on the inside for tissue, wipes or toiletries. Mine has 1 strip of fabric that is like a towel or wash cloth bar. If you put too much in the pockets, the potty tent gets wonky. So even I do the two sandbags in the back pocket and 1 on both sides, you still must use the rope to secure it. Even with the rope, stakes and sandbags it is not as sturdy. Since there is a detachable bottom, there were bugs and snakes getting in. So you are trying to do your business and you got critters and insects all up in your business. I know you are out in a situation but come on now.
The potty tent that you put up with the poles it legit. It takes a minute to put together but it is sturdy. The floor is attached. We sprayed the inside and outside with water repellent. You can hang up the towels, wash clothes, toiletries, tissue, wipes, baking soda, etc. The rain fly is easy to put up. You do have a peace of mind when going to the bathroom in there knowing there are no snakes or bugs. The pop up was just too flimsy staked down, tied down and with sandbags. We made it work for 12 years because we paid $90 for it.
So overall, the potty tent you put together is the way to go to me.
🤣👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
I’d choose the it costs a lot less for the main tent. For the shower toilet one, I’d probably choose the instant one so in a pinch we could get set up and have that as a quick standing shelter.
I'm going to watch the ending again. Funny!
🤣🤣🤣🤣
I forgot i had the shower/outhouse until i started redoing my bug out bag. Pop up tent 100%
I'd take the blue Ridgid utility tent ,When I was in the army we had a blast tearing down the gp medium in the pouring rain
Straight up video - I'd go for the pop-up models myself.
I like the old fashioned ones myself personally. I think the ridged bathroom one would be nice for showering because theres more room and air flow amd maybe the pop up one would be good for a toilet type of situation. I have the same tent as the one that took you a little longer and im ok with it, once you do it so many times, you can do it in like 5 minutes, so its not bad, its perfect for 2 or 3 people like my family. Plus i like the sturdiness of it. I just feel like the pop up stuff isnt as sturdy, and maybe one day, those metal pieces in em will rust and possibly snap and itll be worthless. Idk though. They both have their pros and cons, but i do think having both of the shower tents would be beneficial, can shower and poo at the same time and never have to wait on someone. I loved the ending 😄 🤣 😂 never had that happen, thank God! ✌🏼❤
I like the first one the best!
Maaaan your are funny yet wise beyond your years...Lady Lead is completely in the zone chilling and enjoying that beautiful the view...love your very informative and relevant content.👍🏽
She ain’t in the zone!🤣 she’s the one that came up with the idea of me sitting on the pooper!🤣🤣🤣 I love her but she’s nuts!🤣🤣🤣
I wish I had that bathroom tent when I 1st moved back off grid in 2007. Good to Know! TFS 💜💜💜 AuntieEllen
At First, I was no way with pop-up shower. Had # of pop-up hunting blinds that constantly failed when trying to twist to refold; But saw yours doesn't twist, just folds. But do prefer stability of the other shower tent & floors. That megallan 3 man pop tent looks appealing though. Need look at a 2 man version. I have Napier Full Sports truck tent that I love. But few times; when just wanted to boondock for few hrs, wo6have liked a small fast set tent.
Thanks for sharing. Great site!
Thanks for comparing these two tents, Brother Lead.
I’m doing my best bro✌🏽✊🏽
Coleman for both, I can barely wrestle the sun shade for my windshield into submission!
Yeah but size difference and door way size I would go with the blue one as far as shower. I would go with the Coleman. More head room and space. Good reputation, cheaper and lighter. If your setting up a shower or bathroom you will be there for a little bit. I would rather have sturdy and well built even if it takes a little longer to put up. Also more head space if the ground foot print is the same. It will make it feel bigger in there and changing or moving around is easier. Even just getting into bed or sleeping arrangements.
Caught with your pants down 😂 but for real, in terms of the bathroom/ shower tent, I would go with the one with the poles. It seems sturdier! For sleeping, I like the pop up tent, but will it hold up in the rain and wind?
🤣🤣🤣 pants down Literally! 🤣 yeah I’m with you. The popup tents do t seem like it but they can hold up to high winds and rain just as good as any other classic tent that I have owned.
id use the pop up for using the bathroom. If i was going to actually use it for showering with a shower bag, I would use the other one because if you dont have trees near by you can hang the shower bag on those sturdy poles. I think it depends on how long ur staying and how much you care carry or transport to camp. thats a hard decision for me... i say pop up for short trips or (popping up to the grounds) lol 1 or 2 day over nights and the other for long trips and actual showering. as for the tents i like the stick tent.
Thanks, Lead!!! I’d prefer the pop-up bathroom tent. Both are flimsy, however can become more stable staking it down. I’ll definitely need ventilation in the pop-up bathroom tent lol.
😂😂😂 💩 💨
I do like the more durable one but I already have the popup and it came with stakes that can be hammered into the ground to hold it in place.
It does hang on good when it is staked down. But it still wiggles in the wind a bit 😅
I prefer popup bathrooms after years of doing it the hard way, stabilized it w/stakes & made a critter free floor. I like the Coleman connected poles & weight. On my last camping trip the Coleman doubled as the bedroom & bathroom, so I had no cold nite walks.
To be totally honest you definitely need both. I like the Coleman but me personally I wouldn't want to be in one place to long and that 20 min break down could be costly. But an extended camp Coleman all day.
Very true 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
I like the pop-up big tent because it would be faster to get down. Coleman for the bathroom tent. Just seems more sturdy.
My choices exactly Colette 🌹👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
Thank you brother You always keep us in the know!!! Especially us single moms!! 💚💚👑👑
Thank you Mskels. I hope I am giving people something to think about with all that’s going on with the housing situation and the displaced families from the floods.😉
In regards to your first setup..
I'd still prefer the 25 second woodline walk with the bucket.
Enjoying the natural breeze and a nature view.
😂
The Coleman tent, the sturdy parlor room.
LOL you crazy Lead! Thanks so much for all of the survival information ... love it!!!
Great video old school more sturdy both larger 👍🏽 even though they took a little more set up time.
When I saw that tent lift up and expose you 😳🤣🤣
I would choose the Coleman for the bathroom tent fo sho!! It definitely comes across as more sturdy and I wouldn’t want to spend a lot just for a bath tent. I also like the Coleman for the sleeping tent because of how easy it is to carry. The Magellan would be worth the money if it wasn’t so cumbersome.
🤣🤣🙏🏽🙏🏽
Great video! I'd choose the Coleman for both bc a little work never hurt anybody😂😂😂
Amen 🙏🏽 🤣🤣 I really like all of my popup tents but I wouldn’t get rid of my old Colman for one. 😉
@@leadfarmer73 right on! I'll probably never get to go camping, but in my mind when I am watching you and lady Lead, I can adventure with y'all!
Hi Sir Lead! Good to see you! Your banana trees look amazing and so peaceful! Love to Lady Lead! God bless and keep you both and your family and everyone on this page!
Thank you so much Keisha ❤
I've seen a few tents rolling over the Dunes because they didn't stake them down. Ihave an older tent , that stays darker & is thicker that use to tricks the kids it's later . Getting older the pop up tent looks real good tho, but are very thin material .but speedy set up that's a thumbs up
Both for different needs.The one without a bottom I would hook a shower bag to it. Then the other for the port a pot aka camp toilet
Exactly 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Hello. Funny I just purchased privacy tent for a road trip. God bless
If there's an old customary way of doing things...leave it to you to find it...thnx for showing us...I like the blue, it's durable and firm and I'm squeamish with bugs so I like the floor...😁
Diggin those tunes in the back!
Thank you Chris
I’d pick the Songman
I still have my halfshell from the army ,just have to find a buddy with the other half .lol
For a long stay- I get the blue one and Coleman tent. For short/quick stay or get the GTFO here, I get the gray one and pop up tent.
I can't even comment from laughing!! 🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂 that was lady leads idea😂😂😂😂😂 she’s crazy. We had to edit out 80% of that part because we both couldn’t stop laughing 😂😂😂
@@leadfarmer73 Once Again Lady Lead is a genius 🤣🤣
I already have a tent pretty much like the Coleman tent. It takes me about fifteen minutes to put up. But for extra weather security reasons I would put up a strong tarp with tent pins over either tent.
The good ole Coleman can’t be beat😉 it’s still a great tent.
Great demonstration thank you for sharing 😊 🙏🏾
Thank you Erica🌹
I would invest in both so I can use one for certain and specific reasons. But if I hade to choose it would be the pop up tent. Like you said a tarp and tent pins would suffice.
You are so right. I say get both. I have one for my food and cooking and camping equipment and one for the family.
hilarious on the end! good video!
Regarding the housing tents, I’d choose and pay more for the pop-up tent for convince.
Amen 🙏🏽 me too! 😊
I like the sturdiness of the Coleman for the bathroom tent, I think mentally it has more "coverage" LOL but the Magellan tent is very CONVIENENT! So maybe I would pay a little more for the tent I sleep in...
I agree with you 100%!👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽 that’s my choice
I like sturdy. So it's Old school material.
I guess it would depend on the situation,. Both are great to have.
Exactly 😉 depends on what you need it for.
How can I make a decision on with you 2 clowning y’all straight crazy that why we love yall😍🥰🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣 QUEEN ESI!!!!❤ I’m telling you! The end was all her idea!🤣🤣🤣 we laughed theough the whole thing! That skit was way longer but I had to edit it out because we just could not stop laughing!🤣🤣🤣
I KNOW IT WAS🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hi Leads 🤗!!! Pop up tents for me, if I am already tired, those ⛺ sticks are gonna make me 🤯 lose it. Thx y'all🤣!!
😂😂😂😂😂 those sticks are a headache but easily replaced if one was broken or lost.
At age 66 is a no brainer for me pop up for both👍🏾
Love the pop up but they are hard to collapse
Not this one. It’s not bad at all. I have a couple different brands of popup tents and this one is super simple.
Team Coleman 100% quality 👌🏽
Amen 🙏🏽 ✌🏽
Pop up tent! Easy! I'm old!
Thank you.
You are so welcome 😊
The first one for bathroom tent
I agree ☝🏽
Thank you and God Bless you 😊
Thank you Marianne ❤
Haha funny stuff on the end of the video bud good content!
Coleman tent...popup pooper..thank you!
The one that takes longer to assemble.
I bought the Coleman for my bug out tent
Mary, that’s exactly what I use it for. Great minds think alike.
I’ll take my Coleman, mainly because I already have it lol
🤣🤣🤣exactly
Songmic is cool for me
I'm taking the one that takes ten min
Hi Leadframer 73 how are you. Love you banana trees!! ♥️❤️♥️🐩
Thank you Shelby
I got the bigger Songmics and Kipida solar bag.
What do you think of them?
@@leadfarmer73 I like that the tent is lined with a material that others can’t see a silhouette when someone is inside. The tent is pretty big and would be great for someone tall. Only downside is that you have to stake it up real good. Has a rain cover and an opening for a hose for like a shower water bag. Quick set up and breakdown.
The water bag works great just like the one they sell at the big box store but has a better sprayer. I bought a long hose to replace the one that it came with. Also you can control the sprayer, flow and on/off.
I will pick the blue one more sturdy not the pop-up one
I totally agree👍🏽
Thanks for sharing! Great Info
Thank you Melissa
Neither, I’d pick a Joolca, I love mine it has beat out all the others I’ve tried.
Thanks bro for sharing leadfarmer73!!!!
Thank you bro
Definitely the Coleman and heavier pottery
😂😂😂😂 I wonder why you chose the stronger potty😂 I tell you what, I went out to check on the camp and the pop up potty had blown all the way across my yard😂😂😂
@@leadfarmer73 Lead I was thinking “what if I was in there and a strong wind came😂😂😂
I’m not sure if this is the right place to comment, but I want to thank you and Lady Lead again for teaching me and everyone else to practice their preps. My son gave me 50 gallon drums months ago. I waited on he or my husband to turn them into what I wanted, today in the pouring rain I decided to fix them myself. I have already caught 100 gallons of water in the course of an hour. I thank the Lord for your dedication to teach teaching even when some act like trolls.
Magellan
Coleman
@leadfarmer73 getting Tabernacles ready huh?
What would be the use of one of these? To stand in?
Sturdy
I go for sturdy even though it takes some work.
I bought a pop-up
Love you show.
And we love you right back ❤
Hello Wow ok 👌
Need tents to put in my 1 ac piece of land!!
That’s what I plan to do.😉