Minecraft Bedrock Is Being RUINED by Parity
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 июн 2024
- Chapters:
0:00 - Intro & Overview
0:55 - BAD Recent Bedrock Parity Changes
2:24 - GOOD Recent Bedrock Parity Changes
3:21 - GOOD Existing Bedrock Features
16:45 - BAD Existing Bedrock Features
17:58 - MEDIOCRE Existing Bedrock Features
19:15 - The Solution
21:19 - Outro
If you liked this video, here are some others you can check out! ↓
• Minecraft's New Snapshot BANS Many Skins → • Minecraft's New Snapsh...
• 10 Minecraft Survival Challenges → • DON'T Load Up Another ...
• I Bought The 5 Best Selling Minecraft Maps - How Bad Are They? → • I Bought The 5 Best Se...
• You're WRONG About These Minecraft Features → • You're WRONG About The...
Follow my Twitter for video updates and early news! → / ibxtoycat
Become a Channel Member to access exclusive videos & community posts, special emojis to use in the comments or live chat, as well as a unique badge next to your name! → www.youtube.com/@toycat/membe...
Minecraft Bedrock is the same as Minecraft for Xbox One, Xbox Series S, Xbox Series X, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch, Windows 10, Windows 11, iOS/Android (Pocket Edition), and Chromebook.
This Video Was Edited By:
@HarrisonGray
If you came to read down here and you enjoyed this video, please consider subscribing, and thank you for watching! :) 
Игры
Despite supposedly being indestructible, mojang sure loves to go out of their way to break bedrock
It seems they like breaking both Bedrock itself and the morale of the people who play it.
Good poem
Mojang are in creative mode
Kogasa speaking facts
They sure do.
I actually really liked the red sunset clouds on Bedrock, it kinda makes more sense. Clouds at sunset irl don't stay white, they turn a pinkish or yellow colour.
Ignore the previous comment, I read your comment wrong. I do think itd be nice to have more color in the sky
Adding to the idea of having a colorful sky, an occasional pinkish sunset sky or a very rare aurora that only happens in certain biome would be pretty cool.
yeah i don’t understand why he just wants there to be a basic blue sky all the time
And it doesn't have to be realistic to make sense if it's good it good and they should probably keep it
The main issue is that you only see the colour change when you look at the sun at sunset/rise. What they should have done is made the whole sky change uniformly and then made it a bit more pronounced when looking at the sun.
This whole 'the sky is blue when looking just to the side of the sun and rapidly changes bright red/pink when turning' is too jarring as it currently is.
16:45 you forgot about the fact that pausing in bedrock is nonexistent, you can still get killed while being afk for a long time and I wouldn't even call it a "feature". I shouldn't have to leave my world to pause the game, Mojang desperately needs to fix this 😭
even without the multiplayer setting being on????
@@tinmanneyeah. It's really annoying
lol i remember over a decade ago i died on pocket edition because i didnt understand that, comical its never changed
Bro I noticed that too haha
A solution to that is to block yourself
the one parity feature that i have wanted for Years is the ability to put and use items in the offhand, the almost uselessness of the offhand in bedrock currently is extremely frustrating
Blame mobile. Duel wielding items would be difficult on touchscreen, so it’s not in the game.
@@imghostkitty7297There's a million ways they could add a button to mobile so it'd be really dumb if that's the reason
@@imghostkitty7297 theres no reason to not add dual wielding after the new mobile movement ui was added
@@adityaramadhan1708theres still the old ui
@@rickroller1566 it sucks everyone who still uses it sucks too /s
I think Minecraft has become a textbook example at this point of how NOT to bring feature parity across your games. Instead of adding the best features from each version to the other, they keep removing all the good features from one version (Windswept Savanna grass) and adding all the worst features from that version to the other (player reporting and overbearing moderation) instead. I THOUGHT PARITY WAS SUPPOSED TO MAKE THE GAME BETTER FOR ALL OF US
Dont be silly, microsoft doesnt care if you like it or not
I think Mojang has become a textbook example of how NOT to do anything at this point.
@@StackND we all know this, don't worry
All of us TM is a Microsoft concept
@@reedy_9619 dang it
If they take away winter mode I would riot
I love the winter biomes and how white it looks during snowstorms
Yes😊
They better not. 😤
I wish they'd add it to Java edition. Winter mode looks amazing actually.
Winter mode is INSANELY nostalgic for me. I remember my sister and I constantly trying to find ways to spawn it into the minigame lobby, because fun fact, randomly after a round wintermode may enable and you'll have white trees and snow particles in the lobby :D
A lot of shaders add it too
The paper doll is useful when trying to glide efficiently with the elytra. It kicks it's legs when you start to stall, indicating you need to lower your aim / increase your glide angle a little.
I always just thought it was there so players can appreciate their own skins. Most of the time people play in first person mode, so the skins they made are meaningless. But with it, you'll always be seeing your skin.
@@Kamorzythats what i thought lol
It was quite useful to me back in the day when playing splitscreen xbox 360 on a small tv. Because crouching was a toggle, there was no way to know if you were going to fall from a ledge without moving and the speed difference between walking and crouching is pretty difficult to estimate on s small screen when you only have one block of space to move in.
it is useful for me as unlike java bedrock doesnt have the armor mods that let you see your armor at the right of the screen so it is good for skywars sometimes
As a Java player I'd kill for it in ancient cities. Accidentally set off shriekers because I thought I was crouching too many times
Playing Bedrock for about 5 years has really made me want a few features from Java put into Bedrock, and that is being able to put multiple tools and items into you offhand. The other being able to see chunks to make mob farm building more efficient.
Offhand really needs to be in Bedrock. They even show it off in the Caves and Cliffs Part 2 trailer, Alex and Steve are both seen with torches in their offhands. (Also handheld torch lighting plzzz)
The textures are randomly rotated to reduce the appearance of texture tiling, which is usually considered ugly when it affects organic textures like grass and dirt.
That’s what I figured. It does make the textures seem less repetitive and more natural when placed next to each other which I like. It’s definitely a subjective feature and can be considered bad or good depending on who you ask.
It's also a cool thing that texture pack creators have taken advantage of to create variety in the world. They made it so the "rotated" textures are actually a slightly different, but noticeably different texture.
Some dirt has rocks, some wood has weathering, some grass has sticks.
It definitely should not be removed.
Make it optional as in optifine
Personally I think mushroom trees in swamps are bad
It's really annoying because it's barely noticeable in base game, but if you want to make a custom tileable dirt texture, you have no options
my friends and I had a survival world. And we collected skeleton horses and put them in boats on a pond. We had like 7 skeleton horses on our year old survival world until one day, when we logged on, they were ejected out of the boats. I was so mad because we had been collecting them for months. We lost a few horses because they either despawnes or got stuck somewhere else.
Biggest L a video game has ever had
at least you still had them. i went on an old world and all my skeleton horses became normal horses
I had a Pillager Patrol stuck in boats at one of my bases. I had no plan for them, I just thought it was fun to race by them every time I entered my base. Then Mojang did whatever it was to get horses out of boats, and ANY mob that I had in a boat in every world I made got ejected from captivity. I didn't expect that to happen (because Pillagers aren't horses), so I couldn't get the Pillagers back in a boat before my armor with Thorns III took them out.
@@penguinpenguinpenguin pillager horses are overrated they're slow asf
Reminds me of how such BS can happen. I remember making a cage for a teen magma cube that I wanted to keep as a pet in the overworld. Eventually when I leave the chunks and come back later, it always disappears and hits me when I enter the Nether. Have lost 2 of these already and it kept happening..
I just don’t understand this like I understand not being able to ride in the boat with a horse but a horse should fit
Also Trident Killers would be an insane loss for basically every mob farm since we cant really use any other fully afk way to kill large amounts of mobs (especially with looting)
"They could have just added horses in boats to Java, and everyone would be happier." As a Java player, I can confirm that
Meh. I've never found horses to be worth the effort.
@@jursamajthen obviously this problem doesn’t affect you personally but plenty of people would like it as a feature
I did since im a slow player and getting to the end is pretty lengthy for me. @jursamaj
About the Dying Trees, Minecraft doesn’t have Ivy, but Ivy is a plant in real life that eats away at trees by growing on them. Pretty sure vines are being used to replicate this effect.
The more you know 💫
Interesting...🤔😎
I kinda figured they were trying to replicate something from our world. 🤗
Oh god I've been in a 5 year battle with ivy in my yard. Stupid weed is damn near impossible to permanently get rid of.
Hey! I remember you. You're that guy that hated my comment in the phantom short
I'm so mad about the fence button thing. I used it for a realistic ender dragon statue. I didn't even realize it was removed, I thought it was a bug when it stopped working!
I think the reason people don't complain about single page view book & quill is because how their use for getting simple 1:1 redstone comparator signals out of them. Page 1 is strength 1, page 15+ is full strength, page 5 is 5 strength etc. One redstone parity change they COULD make is letting you use redstone components underwater in Java
It'd still work fine with 2 pages, though it would be less intuitive to be on pages 5/6 with a power of 3.
Bedrock redstone works underwater!?
As someone who greatly prefers Java Edition, I'll be so sad if they remove Winter Mode from Bedrock, it looks so pretty!!
As a Bedrock player, I currently (Jan 2024) haven't seen Winter mode despite having the proper Biome.
@@dragonmaster613 NOOOOO.
@@dragonmaster613 it takes time to form the white leaves. I'll do some testing
Edit:It does work. It just needs to snow
IF THEY TAKE AWAY LEADING BOATS SPEEDBRIDGING AND BONEMEALING SMALL FLOWERS I WILL RIOT
I think they should add good bedrock stuff to Java, not take it away from bedrock
SpEaDbRiGiNg
@@bombardellimartin2971if youre gonna mock them at least spell it right 🤨
@@bombardellimartin2971 blud can not spell.
I swear to god if they take my flower feature!! I refuse to collect flowers any other way
I feel like the paper doll is actually very helpful. Say you run forward and jump, try to activate your elytra, but instead you fall to your death because you forgot you were wearing a chestplate instead. The paper doll lets you easily view your character and the armor you’re wearing without going into your inventory.
Huh, but imagine someone ignored the “paper doll”, barely even noticed it existed… 😏
I always use it to see if bedrock is being buggy, such as when you could crawl on ceilings.
Exactly, especially on mobiles because they don't have the F5 key to switch perspective between First Person to Third Person.
You know what i think your right just because someone might not be looking at it means it could be clutter, lets just do away with being able to see your health bar too while we're at it since people could be looking away from it when checking it could be helpful :D
Personally, I find it useful for double checking whether or not you're sneaking (say, to find out whether you're failing to back away from the horde of enemies because you've hit a wall, or because one spider managed to hit you at the beginning (probably because NO SUBTITLES ON BEDROCK!) and forced you into sneak mode and you're in front of a one-block drop...)
(Yes, that situation has happened to me before...)
Paper doll is super useful for determining your pitch while flying high up where you can't reference the world, as it isn't visible.
And it would also show your armor making it easier for mobile players
I would get irrationally angry if they removed paper doll, it is such a fun whimsical joy seeing your character on screen i would unironicaly campaign on getting it back
I really hope mojang watches this and adds it to java edition, as I really don't want any of these features to go, especially the white leaves, snow logging, and snow having gravity. Mojang should learn that many bedrock features are loved by the bedrock community and removing them can actually affect bedrock edition negatively. (Pomegranate) also, I LOVE phantoms. :D
I swear if they take my snowy leaves, they'll receive a very verbose letter from me in the mail
I’m not going to argue with you about Phantoms, I’m just going to say that forcing you to go to sleep is forcing you to play a certain way and that’s why the Phantom sucks. Not because it’s impossible to deal with (the AI is a buggy mess that likely only took a day to code.) but because it just doesn’t really add to the game other than adding an even more annoying hunger bar. It also seems that nobody loves the Warden, even though it’s a very high effort mob that really had a lot of care put into it unlike the Phantom. The Phantom is literally the epitome of what Minecraft should not be- a game that forces you to play a certain way and makes several play styles terrible. Honestly the Warden needs more fans because unlike the Phantom the dev who coded the Warden actually put effort into it.
@@HungryWardenThe Phantom does have the phantom membrane drop which can be used to make feather falling potions and an alternative to repairing elytra wings, but I can see what people mean about the phantom causing you to play a certain way, but for me personally, it doesn’t bother me too much. I usually just carry a bed with me if I’m going to be doing something that’s going to take many days to do so I rarely even encounter phantoms.
@@HungryWarden i agree, but i think he just thinks phantoms are a cool mob. thats not wrong.
@@HungryWardenHey, at we least we didn't get a mob who eats enchantments, imagine getting max enchantments only for them to get eaten
I genuinely find the paper doll useful as a crouch indicator. Also it's nice to see my pretty trimmed armor in the corner sometimes heh
The keep it off but I've also died after towering up a number of times because I hadn't realised I wasn't crouching and just walked off the edge.
Yeah the paper doll is actually useful. If im in a tight spot, it nice knowing if im crouching swimming, also flying with an elytra.
i keep it on so if i need to i can quickly see what armor im wearing
I’ve found that the paper doll has been useful from time to time. Knowing what armor was so good and I also have a tiny shield addon and knowing if it’s up or not is incredibly useful before 1.5x block height.
paper doll helps me know if my parrots are on my shoulder or have fallen off. also seeing the little birdy on my character in the corner brings me joy. it really is a good feature
I'm glad you mentioned the button on fence problem. I have a server were certain parts of my decoration includes buttons on fences to add detail. I was so confused when I got on one day, and couldn't do it, thinking it was a glitch. Then found out it was removed, and got kinda angry about that. like, why!?
Here's a major idea, ALLOW US TO SWITCH AND PLAY ON OLDER VERSION'S IN BEDROCK This drives ppl up the wall and it's a major reason people don't even want to test beta for them as you can't play with anyone else while beta is activated
This is niche but I use the paper doll while flying. Specifically while flying in the end. It’s really useful for making sure you maintain orientation while flying off of the main end island. Since if you accidentally start going down it’s really easy to lose yourself without watching coordinates carefully.
Btw the reason we had the feature to place blocks in front of us on bedrock was because back in earlier pocket edition days we didnt even had the option to crouch lmao
I actually didn’t know that one. I just heard that they did it to make placing blocks easier to do on mobile devices which was still kinda true but I didn’t know PE had no crouch feature.
@@elijahsmall5873 here is another one for you:
I may be remembering it wrong but right when pocket edition got potions (and I guess enchantments) we were able to use fortune pickaxes on iron ores, and one ore would drop 2 or more ores making so you could basically get infinite iron and any other one that dropped the ore like gold too.I dont think it was possible but if we could get a pickaxe with both fortune and silk touch we probably could have got infinite diamonds too.
@@jonnevitu4979 y’know, as someone who grew up on Pocket Edition, I had no idea about the bridging feature until just a few years ago. I always did it the hard way of trying to get as close to the edge as possible without falling off.
Love the OG Minigame music in the background. Also, as a bedrock player, I agree with everything you said in this video. The Savannah grass and horse boat changes effected my world specifically because i used those features and now they are gone. I’ve been waiting for the 1.5 block sneaking for a while and i’m glad it’s finally here.
don’t diss the paper doll 😢 he’s been here from the start
One of the big things about a book in Java is that the page number you are on is the strength of redstone signal in a lectern. I have this in an automatic brewing station where I turn the page the potion I want and it brews it. 2 pages would be weird. What I really want is redston to work like Java with movable furnaces and such and nether roof building on bedrock. If bedrock restore was like Java and I could build on the roof I might try bedrock but honestly with the amount of mods on Java I probably wouldn’t
The paper doll is super useful in games like Skywars, and can be used to quickly check what armor you’re using and what needs to be upgraded.
That's a fair use case, one I actually use too lol
I also use the paper doll when flying in the void to know whether I’m actually flying up or down because stuff appears very slowly on my phone
@@wpxtimberwolf4214I also use it like that, especially when flying in the giant void to and from the main island
What might be concerning is that some Mojang dev could very well see this video and start taking notes on the Bedrock exclusive features that you mentioned, to remove them later so it matches Java.
There is already an official list they they have in their documentation for creators so I imagine that’s where he got his list from
Paper dolls are nice because most first-person games have an issue where your character can get cosmetic changes, but, since you're playing in first person, it doesn't matter to you. Being able to see your player at all times in a non-obstructive way is just a nice QoL feature to have
“You can’t reach equality by dragging everyone down, you can only reach true equality by lifting people up” HOW IS THIS A QUOTE IN A MC VIDEO
Minecraft Ruined Edition!
nah minecraft deadrock is better
@@zapthecat0XD
Minecraft Ruined, huh...
🐻🐔🐺🐊
Minecraft bedrock edition: RUIN
What a hilarious poem that You have scribbled down😂 this will go straight in to my museum of funny scriptures
This man didn't even attempt to mention the massive parity difference of redstone.
I'm pretty sure that's because Mojang said they won't be changing the redstone for either Bedrock or Java.
better to leave this way cause the java players like the bug that is quasi connectivity. it make the redstone worse, but they could fix it by adding a piston that have quasi connectivty in all possible directions that the player can choose with a right click.
Redstone Is something very hard for mojang to touch haha. Probably the biggest reason you couldn't do full parity
@@toycatindeed for pistons I saw a dude sugesting mojang to add new pistons just to have both java and bedrock piston mechanics so it won't break any complex structures in neither version
If you introduce Redstone parity for either version, millions of contraptions would suddenly break overnight. Though I think Bedrock could do with some Redstone tweaks anyway, like removing some random elements.
I play java (modded) and I agree that bedrock should be getting improvements for parity, because you cannot mod the game to get these improvements, unlike java. For example, I use mods to add the bedrock-style bridge placing but ppl on bedrock cannot do the same for hunger or combat mechanics (or any parity difference)
Imo, some of the "bad" and "mediocre" features from bedrock are good, like the clouds tinted red on sunsets and sunrises and looking at the sun making the sky darker, or the randomly rotated blocks
I love that the clouds tint red at sunset. I’m not sure why that’s a complaint since it’s what real clouds do at sunset 😭 (it is helpful to me during rainy weather too because I can tell it’s getting late before it gets too dark, though they do look a lot more out of place there)
Having played Bedrock more recently and having played Java for a long time.. The main things I miss are in-line chat, debug keys, the graphics options (brightness level especially), equiping more things to my off-hand (torches especially), food saturation, and all the missing tricks I could do with redstone. I do think as they introduce parity they need to focus on what would be an improvement to bedrock other than just "different" like the color of grass.
You can adjust brightness level in Bedrock.
@@B463LHe is most likely taking about optifine.
@@lordturtle5680 no bedrock is just much darker at max brightness for some reason
Literally all I want from Java is offhand use and map markers / custom shields
When I played Java for the first time being a Bedrock player I felt the same way. I missed certain features I was so used to and it bothered me that I couldn’t do the things I was used to doing on Bedrock.
Projectiles ring bells and buttons can be placed on pistons on Java Edition. Unless the buttons are on the back of the piston, they will break when the piston extends, which has a redstone use for generating zero tick pulses with minimal setup.
Weirdly Java has fully featured armour stands, with names, posing, arms, and all sorts of stuff, but you can't access it in survival. I think it's an interface thing, but hopefully one day we'll get that in vanilla.
What did they do to the graphics engine that makes night time on bedrock light up random areas? I can no longer navigate at night because I cant find villages, lava, or all the torch paths I laid across my worlds. This one change has made Bedrock maddeningly unplayable for me.
I have no idea about that, it might be a bug, after all there was once a bug that caused a barrier block to sometimes spawn in bastions, maybe they really screwed up and accidentally made light blocks spawn everywhere.
i actually really like the paper doll and bed textures. the paper doll just makes the game feel a bit nostalgic and the bed textures just feel more natural. paper doll also gives another time that you can see your skin/armor trims
One other interesting thing to mention: movable tile entities (Hoppers, Furnaces, Chests, Dispensers, etc.) can be made movable using the Carpet Mod that was originally created by a group of kidders headed by Gnembon. He is now working for Mojang… I would not be surprised if this doesn’t get added to Java sometime soon.
There's a good reason to not add it. Being how it would break a lot of redstone, unless they made it a game rule, or they made an item to made tile entities movable and unmovable
I think the primary function of the paper doll is to remind players during pvp whether they’re crouched or not. At least it’s the only reason I’ve ever used it. Maybe as well in the deep dark for the same reason.
What's great about java is that we don't have to worry about these features getting removed to begin with because of the existence of mods
accurate block placement, bridging, bedrock biome waters, 1.8 combat, and things like winter leaves and 3d fishing rods are an optifine texturepack.
Mods exist on bedrock as well
@@klingynot for everyone. People say that and completely forget about other consoles
Fun fact: you use a mod called optifine bc Java is so bad you need a mod to even play it
@@monodoe761Not exactly bad, more like too laggy and optifine makes it run smoother if you have a good Pc
I wish the shattered savanna still had green grass! they are litterally taking away the good features from bedrock :(
5:10 one thing about vines, they climb up trees, and then cover them completely, so that the trees get no light, so then the trees die
yeah I think ibxtoycat should have looked up how trees die.
Or, for instance, strangling figs.
Strangling figs start as a vine that slowly wraps all around the tree, and as the name says, strangles it
I have been complaining about Bedrock Being RUINED by Parity for a long time now but it still keeps happening.
10:26 okay i dont know the language but i have a gut feeling that is the big poem you see after killing the dragon XD
11:15 "Who is this guy and why is he such an essential part of the bedrock experience?"
**paper doll having a seizure**
"I really don't know why this thing is here."
I definitely agree that parity for coordinates is a necessity. If I want to see coordinates on Java I have to use a debug screen full of information I don't need, that covers 75% of the screen in moving white text. It's nice to have the debug screen as an option, but having another way to see only coordinates without a ton of information covering the screen would be great. On the other hand, bringing features like being able to see what biome you are in to bedrock would be great as well.
It would be great if Mojang focused on making both player bases happy, rather than deciding which version "got it right". I really don't like looking at the F3 screen just to see my coordinates, because it covers so much of the screen and makes it hard to continue moving when I'm on land. I don't like coming to a complete halt just to figure-out where I want to go simply to avoid falling into a hole in the ground that I can't see.
I miss the coordinates on maps from Legacy Console whenever I move to Java or Bedrock.
@@THE_bchat Java edition is Minecraft
Was literally just struggling w this today lol
there is a debug command you can use to show your coordinates above your hotbar
I like the paper doll because sometimes i can't tell if i'm running or walking, and might keep trying to sprint when i'm actually already doing that.
I find the paperdoll useful when I'm flying with the elytra, because in bedrock you can stop flying by hitting the spacebar again. Which in itself is a feature that I would like to see in Java.
5:19 this would actually be an incredibly large change to the Java community since a lot of people play minigames, Mojang should add it in an experimental snapshot and see how it does first before they put it in the game.
When in doubt, make it a toggle.
I agree, the upset from the java community would be insane. There are whole communities around it that would be destroyed
The paper doll is useful when I’m switching back-and-forth between a chest plate and my wings. So I don’t jump off a cliff with a chest plate on.
Also, removing the ability to put a horse in the boat is kind of a pain because I’ve had issues in the past with my horses disappearing, so I would always put my horse in a boat because animals in boats never seem to disappear.
They don't despawn if in boats
@@ExpertN317 yeah
I actually really enjoy having the paper doll there! I personally don't use it for much, but it's nice to have a little friend there! also reminds me what I'm wearing lol. though, I'm pretty sure the reason it exists is to aid players without dynamic FoV on. people who get motion sickness and turn it off, can't easily tell if they're walking or sprinting or what, so the paper doll helps alot!
Also, I personally really like the beds having the 2d textures, I just wish the colours actually matched up, though...
I love having the paper doll. When flying high enough to not have the ground render, or flying over void in the end, you can see the angle you are at so you don't nosedive on accident.
I feel like they should stop treating Java as the “default” edition and start adding good bedrock features to Java instead of just taking good features from bedrock away and adding bad features from Java. (Edited for bad wording)
Either way it makes the community mad. If they remove the feature from bedrock to match java, then they have a smaller community protesting than if they do it the other way around.
it should be OBVIOUS to not remove features, ain't no way Mojang actually thinks we want unique features removed like that. they aren't dumb, i think they're probably just trying to parity everything from java to be easier, without Caring what we have to say about it...
Mojang needs to be reminded by their bosses which version is still making money. It's not java btw.
@@IrisThatOneGothMfI just think they should be adding features to each version rather than be removing features from certain versions
@@thecatmanagerI’m pretty certain there are more bedrock players than Java players
What a great coincidence. I was just binging your Bedrock VS Java videos yesterday and here you are uploading a similar type of video - this happens to me so much on RUclips haha.
They almost wanted to remove trident killers from bedrock, but thankfully they marked it as "works as intended" in the bug tracker. So I dont think its going anywhere, which is good because we don't have sweeping edge and offhand to repair our tools.
8:10 because then you'd be breaking all java redstone machines. Any farms or devices built in java that depend on the idea of a certain block not being movable would be broken by making those blocks movable.
It seems like Mojang loves to remove features instead of just adding the beloved features
11:25 the paper doll was originally a console feature, so youll have to ask 4j studios about that one
Mojang got rid of horses in boats in Java as well (used to be able to let them grow up inside the boat) so it's a change on both versions
I actually love having the paper doll because it helps me realize if I'm crouched or not. I have vision problems and with swift sneak I can't always tell very well. It has literally saved me many times.
I always use the paper doll when play bedrock mainly so I can see my skin lol
But I do think it has its uses I see no downsides to it so why not add it 🤷🏻♀️
So I’ve been playing on a Java based cross-platform server and the placing blocks farther away thing is something that makes me so mad because my bedrock client says you can still place it far away sometimes and then the Java based server is like oh no you don’t and takes away the block so now there’s a ghost block that no one but me can see
I can't help but feel like that vibrant green grass in the windswept savanna was unintentional... Its a _savanna,_ they're not supposed to have mushroom island/jungle colored grass. And if it _was_ an accident, then I think Bedrock players should just have to deal with it, because it makes no sense being that green.
Of course it was unintended. But why does that mean it should be removed? Quasy connectivity was an unintentional bug yet now its a core part of all Java redstone. Why make the game worse when you could just keep it and make it better. Bug or not doesn't matter.
@@duggggggg Because _savannas don't have vibrant green grass_ that's why. 🙄
I don't like the "placing blocks while facing at an empty space" mechanic. It's unrealistic and breaks the beautiful tension of having to be careful and shifting. It's one of the more funny and crazy moments of minecraft. I mean, if you want to build as if you were flying...then use creative
It was originally added to make it easier for mobile players to bridge, so it makes sense so they aren’t outclassed by a PC player on the same version
Great video as always, I’d love to see more uses for cauldrons on Java. Also might have to get that future me’s problem hoodie, I appreciate not having to explain merch to my parents haha
They should have the community vote for java and bedrock separately, so they get even more different
USES FOR PAPERDOLL:
I actually have a few uses for the paperdoll. If ur in a dangerous situation, such as loads of hostile mobs fighting u and u hear something break, like an armour piece, rather than having to open ur inventory and taking a tonne of damage and possibly dying, u can run away and look at the paper doll to see which armour piece has just broken so that when u go to equip another one u can do it faster because you already know what needs to be made and repaired. This works well as the paperdoll shows up when u sprint, sneak, swim or crawl so if u r running away quickly from dangerous mobs you can check what armour u have equipped. Aslo if u wanna know what you look like to other players… ig u can use the paper doll lol??? It’s kinda like a replacement in pocket edition from not being able to quickly change to third person mode ig. (I aslo don’t know if this works because never tried it but maybe it could be useful if u r invis??? Idk if it shows the player on the paper doll or not lol but if it doesnt then u can see when the invis runs out ig although u would see that anyway, and if it does show the player then u can see whether u r sneaking so that when it runs out no one will see ur name tag before u drink another pot or retreat, and aslo the paper doll could be used to see any visual indicators when ur invis to show signs that ur there, eg maybe u forgot to take off ur shield and then if u didn’t see it on the paper doll u would’ve completely forgot, although this is a bad example because u can see shields anyway, but maybe for armour, idk just feels like it can help u not forget stuff as easily lol.)
for the paper doll, it something that i find very nostalgic, this being my first time i ever played mc was on the xbox and just so happened to obviously have the music and paper doll, now you need to download the separate pack for music and turn on the paper doll. buth are small things, but are VERY nostalgic
Paper dolls are useful because if chunks don't load fast enough when you're flying you can see what angle you're facing so that you don't fly into the ground and die
I use the Paper Doll to let me know when my Elytra has activated so I don't waste rockets on a bad jump. I also tend to look at it as I'm flying as a way to figure-out what angle I'm at to get the most out of each rocket.
I actually look at the paperdoll a lot and can be useful if you have parrots as you can see if they're on your shoulders if you're running or crouching and if you loose them it's much easier to notice right away that they aren't on your shoulders, especially when transporting them very large distances, also sometimes in water you aren't actually swimming even when you're underwater but looking at the paperdoll helps me see if I am or not so I can swim faster if I need to, plus you can see if you're wearing armor or your elytra, it can be useful in a few ways lol
The only use for the paper doll I can think of is that it tells you if you're looking straight up/down when flying over the void in the End.
My thoughts on each change as a Java player:
Coloured water - Please add to Java.
Dyed water cauldrons - Meh. Don't really care, but prefer the current Java method.
Potion cauldrons - Again, meh. Rather wouldn't have it but if it came to Java it wouldn't upset me.
Fallen trees - Please add to Java
Dying trees - it's ok as long as vines don't get out of control
Bedrock block placing mechanics - Please add to Java!
Skeleton horse mechanics - Eh. Bedrock's mechanic doesn't make sense.
Baby aquatic mobs - Don't care but would rather have it than it removed from Bedrock
Movable block entities - PLEASE MOJANG ADD TO JAVA
Snow mechanics - Please add to Java
Coordinates - Java is fine the way it is with this.
Bone meal on sugar cane - Java's fine the way it is.
Grass Path Silk Touch - Please add to Java.
Armour Stand Arms - You should be able to choose whether they have arms or not.
Armour Stand Poses - should be more customisable on both editions.
Cakes stacking - Wouldn't be mad if it got added to Java
Potion of Decay - Well, it's already a creative-only thing. So you could just use commands to get it.
Desert well chances - Like Java mechanics the way it is.
Rarer nether fortresses - Make it between the two. They are way too common on Java and too rare on Bedrock.
3d fishing bobber - Should be made smaller but I do like it
Sponges drying out - Annoying cause then you can't build with them in certain biomes
Leads on walls and boats - Yes please.
Strongholds under villages - I like strongholds the way they are on Java
Netherrack portal base - It would be cool to make netherrack renewable
Drowned and ghast eyes glowing - Wait Java drowneds' eyes don't glow? Also ghasts' eyes glowing looks weird.
Two page lecterns - Would cause problems with redstone. Prefer it is kept the same on Java.
Sheared sheep colours - Makes sense, but Bedrock sheared sheep are SO UGLY
Dead coral - Wait again, that's not in Java?
Paper doll - it's cool, as long as they make it toggleable.
Bamboo in sparse jungle - nah.
Buttons on walls and fences - this was cool, why was it removed from Bedrock?
Bells - Wait for a third time, Didn't realise this wasn't in Java!
Dye shulkers - You should be able to do this in survival too on both editions
Skeleton melee - Yeah, please fix on Java, they literally just shoot themselves and it's really dumb.
Small flower bone meal - I like Java mechanics because it gives flower forest a use, and the gradient is too cool to ruin.
Fishing rod durability - Like Java the way it is. I mean, you usually you have Mending and you get XP from fishing anyways, so is more durability really necessary?
Empty Map - It would be nice to have a map without the little character icon!
Baby zombie jockeys - It would be cool if it was SUPER rare, like 0.01%. Otherwise it would just be like oh. ok. why does that exist?
Sky differences - I like the sky differences on Bedrock, as long as it doesn't wreck the nostalgia I get from playing Java
Phantoms - they do need a buff on Java. Maybe split the difference.
Nether caves without lava- THIS IS SO ANNOYING on Java. Please remove.
Nether forest generation - They are a disaster on Java. Doesn't help that hoglins can hit from behind walls.
Less tall grass - Yes please. I hate tall grass.
Random rotated textures - some look weird (magma block, terracotta, etc) but others look cool
Lack of combat changes - I prefered 1.8 combat and still do to this day, so if they'd finally implement the combat test snapshots I'd appreciate it.
Nahh bonemeal for sugarcane is the best thing ever
Potion cauldrons on bedrock can be used to tip arrows.
No dragon breath required.
The potion of decay which is usually a creative item can be obtained in survival on BE from witch hut cauldrons, which is a fun Easter egg and should come to java. Also, with a full potion cauldron, you can turn arrows into tipped arrows with none of that hassle with lingering potions.
@@jetho9859 yeah i was disappointed when i tried that on a java-bedrock server
Along with other things like bonemealing sugarcane and individual flowers, leading boats, horses in boats(at the time it was still a thing in the base game) and the cost of doing business on anvil
"Doesn't help that hoglins can hit from behind walls"
This is no longer the case with the latest snapshot
The top left thing is helpful for elytra bugs. Where you use the trident to glide up but it kicks you out after a second or so. Shouldn’t need to be that way cause of the insane number of bugs Bedrock has, but there’s your use case.
As someone who has always & will always play Java, I love that Bedrock has unique features & I'd really love if they leaned more into it. Having cool things that you don't experience makes it so the things you do experience feels more unique. Your experience in games is improved by having more content that you never touch.
Paper dolls are really useful to me when I’m moving parrots anywhere. It makes it easy to check if they’re still on my shoulder by just sprinting so I can keep them from deloading or getting hurt :)
the paper doll is very helpful when flying in the end, so that you can tell what direction you are flying when you cant see anything but void
7:56 I’ve heard this might take a lot more coding than you might expect. My theory is that they didn’t add it because of duping glitches involving pushing a chest with a piston while opening and closing it.
as a bedrock player no we dont have any of those bugs and i don't belive we have ever so no
@@Pyrothepyro1The glitch Codeblank said was once in bedrock edition, I believe
once not anymore so u know give java players our feature@@SummerJaguar
@@Pyrothepyro1 we always have a new duplication glitch with chests and pistons. In 1.20 it involves chunk borders.
If you watched some of IBXtoycat’s really old realm experiments, you would know.
I would love for the block placement mechanics to be added to Java. Building bridges between the End islands is *terrifying* when you're constantly crouching over the edge with nothing but void below.
The "paper doll" in the corner I have found useful only when I turn the "FOV altered" toggle off because you cannot tell when you are walking or sprinting because they both look the same, then.
A use for the tiny paper doll in the top left corner is when flying when chin is aren’t loading. It tells me whether or not I’ve hit an invisible wall while flying
I like the paper doll thing, it makes me think of the old console edition so I keep it enabled because nostalgia lol
about the paper doll, me and my friends use it to find out if we are in swimming mode when leaving 1 block places because of no crawl mode🤣😅
Great video man I've been having this on my mind as well happy to see someone put it out there like this
On Java, you can get invisible item frames because they’re entities. I’m not much of a Java player so I’m not sure on the specifics of how it works but this would improve the game, considering how ugly item frames look, it feels like I should just be able to hang the item I want on a wall without the ugly item frame behind it.
there's texture packs for it on bedrock
They should just add hooks to the game for people to hang stuff on. Item frames would still have a use (maps or marking the contents of a chest/barrel), but hooks would allow people to have better options for decorating.
You can use the paper doll for sky wars to see what kind of armor you have equiped
What they need to do is remove the hated features in bedrock only and add the liked ones to java
Vice versq
Have to say, As an old Java exclusive player (began playing around Alpha 1.0.5), Searching youtube for minecraft videos and getting bedrock videos not clearly labeled as the bedrock version is frustrating. I have to remember channel names to avoid when wanting relevant information for the version I play. There's far too many differences between all the versions to not warrant specifying in the video title the version the video is about. I did find myself recently while playing modded with serene seasons wanting the heater block from bedrock to keep snow from piling up on my paths, without spamming torches.
Though lots of bedrock features feel... strange and right out of left field.. The fact that anything from Java is missing from bedrock or vise versa is ridiculous... Java is the original and any other versions should have all its features. Shouldn't have to be picking and choosing which features you want in each version, they both should be identical. It's supposed to be same game after all, But with all the differences, It really feels like an entirely different experience with the same name. It's a bad look in my opinion. Not to mention having both versions being identical, Bedrock centered channels would actually gain more java player viewership on their channels, since the information would actually be relevant to them..
Two features currently exclusive to bedrock I am genuinely worried about them choosing the Java version are the Wither and Bonemealable sugar cane.
When someone Asked on Twitter when are we on Java going to get bonmealable Sugar Cane Kingbdogz responded. "We don't want all crops to be bonemealable."
Also when it comes to parity my viewe has always been I support it within reason. with features being carefully considered that do both communities want a specific feature on both or do they like the feature they have on the version they play and want it unchanged. Making everything the same on both versions without any input from both communities just feels like a sure fire way to annoy people. for example while I would love the above features on Java the stronghold generation and the nether portal generation I don't want as a Java player.
4:42 us java players use cauldrons for lava farms and undoing actions on things like banners
We use them for lava farms. Not sure about banners cause I've never cared but you do you.
both on bedrock
i never thought id see a checkmark next to java edition in one of toycat's thumbnails
meanwhile, on the java side, mojang removes important mechanics that everyone loved (for example the 1gt delay for copper bulbs in snapshots, everyone thought it was good, literally no one complained about it, and it was still removed. Still no idea why it was removed, might be for bedrock compatibility, might be for consistency with other redstone components (which is exactly what we don't want, duplicate component is the most useless thing ever))
11:18 DON'T DISS ON THE PAPER DOLL I LOVE HAVING IT
I love the Paper Doll. If you don't want it, there's a toggle. But I love it. It's probably because I have a special animations resource pack on that makes the animations fun to watch, but still, I love the Paper Doll.
As a Java player who is just now learning about the existence of the Paper Doll in Bedrock, my gut feeling is that its main function is to allow the player to see their own skin. I almost exclusively play singleplayer, so for years I've had literally no reason to change my skin from the default Steve. Just a few months ago I decided to make a custom one, just for fun, but still, for 99% of the time I never get to see it. So I guess the Paper Doll is kinda nice for this kind of situation haha!
In modded Minecraft, a Paper Doll could also let you see custom player animations from mods like Not Enough Animations and ParCool w/o going first-person.
Most people probably haven't noticed the paper doll because in instances like MCPE you have to enable it to be able to see it as it isn't enabled to start.
I don’t agree with you on savannas, as a Java player, I love the fact that they look different from normal biomes, they should be even more gold coloured, so no, I don’t want every feature coming to Java.
11:41 it has actually been very helpful in seeing which armour I have on without having to check in my inventory both on servers and in survival