The Music of the Night (John Owen-Jones vs Ramin Karimloo vs Gerard Butler)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 авг 2024
- "The Music of the Night"
Sources:
John Owen-Jones (John Owen-Jones) 00:09
Unmasked (John Owen-Jones) 05:14
The Phantom of the Opera at the Royal Albert Hall (Ramin Karimloo) 10:51
The Phantom of the Opera (2004) (Gerard Butler) 16:31
---
Related:
"Till I Hear You Sing" by Ramin Karimloo, John Owen-Jones and Ben Lewis: • Till I Hear You Sing (...
---
Uploader's comments:
I'm sorry to have to break this into two parts because of the length. There are two different versions of JOJ's The Music of the Night, and I put them both here because he actually sang them quite differently.
JOJ is my favourite POTO Phantom and Ramin is my favourite LND Phantom.
---
Lyrics
Night time sharpens, heightens each sensation
Darkness stirs and wakes imagination
Silently the senses abandon their defenses
Slowly, gently night unfurls its splendor
Grasp it, sense it, tremulous and tender
Turn your face away from the garish light of day
Turn your thoughts away from cold unfeeling light
And listen to the music of the night
Close your eyes and surrender to your darkest dreams
Purge your thoughts of the life you knew before
Close your eyes, let your spirit start to soar
And you'll live as you've never lived before
Softly, deftly, music shall caress you
Hear it, feel it secretly possess you
Open up your mind, let your fantasies unwind
In this darkness that you know you cannot fight
The darkness of the music of the night
Let your mind start a journey to a strange new world
Leave all thoughts of the life you knew before
Let your soul take you where you long to be
Only then can you belong to me
Floating, falling, sweet intoxication
Touch me, trust me, savour each sensation
Let the dream begin, let your darker side give in
To the power of the music that I write
The power of the music of the night
You alone can make my song take flight
Help me make the music of the night
The emotion that Ramon Karimloo put into the role is unmatched. You can hear the pain in his voice, the longing.
I grew up with Gerry, fell in love with Ramin's voice, and JOJ gives me chills. They all have their own way of singing this song, although some are better than others. I can openly say I love all three.
Madison Bailey 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Madison Bailey joj voice isn't strong enough
Madison Bailey same
Maddie BChiefin You just perfectly described why each one should be respected
For an actor Gerard Butler is brilliant, sings with feeling
Ramin's "Silently the senses, abandon their defenses" is sung so hauntingly and also sweetly it takes my breath away. We love you Ramin!
This is my favorite line in the entire production. Close second to when he reprises “All I Ask of You” after Point of No Return
I’ve never heard vocals that clear before in my life. I could listen to that one line on repeat for the rest of my life
Heaven has blessed us with Ramin Karimloo and his soul-shattering voice
Jenna Lawrence Amen 🙏🏻👏🏻🙌🏻
My first phantom was Gerard and I love the feelings he gave to Erik... but then I saw Ramin and it was a revelation!!! He has me spellbounded... I mean come on... who would listen to him singing music of the night and not fell under his spell??!!! Truly the voice of an angel!!!
The way Ramin draws out the notes in lyrics like “defenses” and extends that high note while managing to maintain such expression is one of the many reasons I love his version of the song and Phantom. I won’t be so arrogant as to say that he sings everything perfectly, or that he’s the best (although he is for me), but he certainly makes me feel more for the character than any other actor I’ve watched in the role. I feel more compassion and could easily see a young woman being drawn in by that voice and persona, even if though I know he’s done terrible things and is not a good choice for Christine.
All have qualities in their voice. Ramin is Strong and high pitch John is soft, romantic, and Gerard has a rugged which isn't bad at all. To say who the best is depends on how I'm feeling on that day.
I discovered Ramin recently ... I just can't get over him. Not only has he made me cry but he has shaken me with his voice and his acting. It has really conquered my heart !!! He has a tenderness that other phanton did not have.
Few singers have produced chills with which Ramin produces !! insuperable!!!
Ramin forever !!
Eugenia Marques Sameeee ever since I watched the 25th when they made it free recently here on YT! I’ve just been obsessed with Ramin and Sierra 😍😍😍 Absolutely adorable together! 💕💕
@@pseudonymousanonymous5829 I can't stop thinking about them !!
I really believe that they have a higher spirit than ours and have been able to unite it without the cliché.
His attraction is hypnotic ... his gestures and looks simply have a beautiful tenderness. It is difficult to find partners like this!
Good luck for them and for us to meet.
Eugenia Marques agreed! Their chemistry is just amazing! I wish to have a friendship like theirs! Indeed, goodluck to them! And goodluck to us, stay safe in this time of crisis as they bless us with their music and voices! ❤️🙏🏻
I had tickets and then came lock down. I discovered Sierra and Ramin very recently, I hope they haven't ruined it for me when I do get to see it. I can't imagine anyone else being as good.
JOJ is the best. His voice and so his singing techniques are so well-dosed so he transfers all the emotions the best. His voice is so soothing and romantic and then so passionate, then all of a sudden so haunting (and yes, I love the colour in his voice most). I wished I could watch him live - I'm so sad, he doesn't perform in Germany :-(
Ramin and Gerard are my favorite. Ramin has an emotional strength to his voice, while Gerard has raw intensity. Both have a great and powerful acting skills. Shivers time and time again...
Ramin is the Phantom. Without him the play looses that deep dark emotional side. His powerful male voice leads the way into the play.
How many have you seen?
JoJ - Sweet , Love
Ramin - Strong , Drama , Love
Butler - Cool guy
yes! hahaha
Ramin is something magnificent.. His voice... makes me tremble inside . I suffer with him.
His voice is like God crafted it to be like his chorus of angels. If music was a person, it'd be Ramin Karimloo.
@@kendallthompson2027 You just put the thoughts I've been struggling to say into words
He sounds like he's singing at me... sounds like he's trying too hard.
I have to agree he’s the best other than the Man himself
Ramin is the best ever
For me John Owen-Jones has the perfect voice for the Phantom's songs. I hope he gets to play the role again in the West End.
1 Ramin Karimloo
2 John Owen Jones
3 Gerard Butler
Other actors play the role, but Ramin becomes the Phantom... He is unmatched! No one can compare to him, to me he is one and only Phantom. Ramin THE KING! ❤️
I think I'll always prefer Ramin, but I can't deny that JOJ and Gerard Butler sing this song brilliantly. For sure Gerard Butker has less experience than the other two, but he manages to share the passion of this song. JOJ has a beautifu voice, can reach super high notes and makes you shiver, but I didn't found in his interpretation the emotion I was looking for. Finally, Ramin has the voice and the emotion, that's why I prefer him. But they're all amazing as the Phantom, the Phantom seemingly being an extremely hard character to perform as!
Isaure ALW settled the disputes once and for all. He never openly said that he prefers Ramin, but he requested that he played the phantom in the anniversary concert and wrote the LND play with Ramin in mind as the role
11:14 the way he sings "senses" gives me chills everytime
Comparing these legends never means one is better or disparage others, they all have their own unique voice and emotion but for me Ramin Karimloo and the way he transfer feeling and how he play with his voice is amazing and extraordinary he sings this song perfectly , every time he sing this song he sinks in the character and you can feel how phantom feels ... GOD bless them for all these good memories
Wow! John Owen-Jones has a great mix of power and seduction. Never gave him a real listen before. I'm a new fan. Thanks for posting!
I have to say Ramin Karimloo! His voice, to me, is perfect! It screams Phantom on so many levels and just the way it seems to blend with the music makes me fall more and more in love with him! Honestly he's the best Phantom, not only when it comes to his voice, but also because of his acting! I Love Ramin Karimloo so much!
I recently fell In love with Ramin but I grew up with Gerard. Although I know all the technical issues as to why Ramin and JOJ are preferred by most, I can’t get over my first love of Gerad. For me he will always be my first and last phantom. Although Ramin certainly shook my resolve and JOJ is undeniably amazing
Ramin and Gerard are my favorites. They both bring amazing things to the stage. Ramin brings a sense of relaxation into his voice that soothes you as you listen to it whereas with Gerard, the rawness in his keeps you on edge. Both Gerard and Ramin are capable of expressing immense emotion through this role. Both performances are beautiful.
when ramin sings u can almost feel the pain that phantom went through, he does a phenomenal job at putting emotion into his singing. ramin’s voice is also so mesmerizing & angelic. in my opinion ramin is by far the best phantom. but john owen jones is very good as well:)
I totally agree about Ramin but if you watch Gerard Butler in the 2004 Phantom he was defo sex on legs 🥰😁😁😁
@@tracypriest4386 but he sounds like he’s gargling salt water…
also have you seen the man in the chinese production(ayanga)
and LND ramin both are so HOTTTTTTTTTTT OK TED TALK OVER 😂
@@naomiheng3205 😆 The movie is not a concert! The movie is a more realistic version of the musical! Butler sung with so much passion, a great deal more compared to any of the other phantoms who were more focused on their vibrato....He, in my opinion, was able to show the pain the phantom feels and struggles with.... A lot of people I know also really like his voice so not sure what you are talking about as he sounds good and did a great job.
12:20- 12:26 how could you not fall in love with that voice😍
My God, have I just died and gone to Heaven, anyone expects me to choose????????? Yeah right.
Gerry seduced me.
Ramin seduced me much further and deeper on a physical and emotional level and made me understand Erik for the first time.
John is like a fine wine.
JOJ seduced me. Ramin made me feel whole. Gerard makes me feel empty.
Jo-J's voice is just grrrr. Ramin had the passion in his acting too. But I have to listen to them sing past the point of no return. Emmy takes the female voice and emotion.
Ok Gerard and John both seduced me. It's the tenderness in their lower and softer notes while picking exactly the right words to use their power on. John seduced me the most though, second only to Sir Crawford. I loved the gruff tone in Gerards voice, which is why I think his whispers were so seductive. Ramin was just raw power.. Still seductive but the other boys seduced me harder.. 😂😂😂
I love singing voices of John Owen-Jones
I like Gerard butler, but l think that they all have a way of singing that's beautiful
I love the chemistry between Sierra and Ramin, but the voice for the phantom is JOJ
I'll have to go with Ramin because of how emotional and powerful his amazing voice is, but i also love John's soft and haunting singing. Gerard, on the other hand...
The first Phantom I was exposed to was the movie version with Gerard, which I thought was great, and certainly was good enough to get my fanatical interest in the POTO going ever since. Since then I've listened and watched Michael Crawford, Ramin's stage performance in the 25th anniversary, John Owen Jones, Colm Wilkinson as much as I could. I have to say that Ramin is by far the best Phantom in my opinion, voice and acting wise. He has the voice that Gerard doesn't, and the acting in his Phantom in my opinion is mesmerizing, if not better than Gerard's. The others, e.g. John Owen Jones, Wilkinson, even Crawford, might have superb theatrically /technically better voices than Ramin's, but Ramin's performance and voice in the role somehow possessed an earnestness, and he was able to deliver a despair and rawness of emotion which the others lacked.
I'll agree on all but Ramin being better than Michael Crawford... Crawford is legitimately the perfect Phantom for me (obviously you have your own opinion) and revolutionised the part (think he originated it musically too)
Major reason I think he is the best is because he had currently been playing an on-screen comedic idiot called Frank Spencer and his casting as Phantom in Webber's new big thing shocked people who said "he'll never do that justice" but he did! His Music of the Night and the title song are perfect renditions, Ramin's are far too strong and loud when they should be soft and seductive. (Ramin's is amazing, just he's missing the soft, seductiveness you get from Crawford) Despite me hating Butler's singing, I can't disagree that he got every other part of the Phantom spot on. As an Irishman I also have to talk about Colm Wilkinson who I think was a better Valjean than Phantom but I still loved his performance.
Yes. Yes! YES!
The more I watch Ramin the more I agree with you!
@@TriggaHappy19 I agree Music of the Night must be seductive and not too strong.
@@TriggaHappy19 I got to see Wilkinson as Valjean and the Phantom and loved both. Michael Crawford is the original and best Phantom. Somewhere I read that Andrew Lloyd Webber liked Butler's rendition very much. I like Gerard's acting as Phantom, he makes one feel so much for that tormented man, his performance is so compelling and captivating, you want to hold and console him.
JOJ - definitely the more commanding of Phantom. What I mean by that is he can be soft but very firm when he sings.
Ramin- he basically is my depiction of what a young Phantom sounds like and he really puts a lot of emotion into his singing.
Gerard- I will say that he does a really good job of being a threatening Phantom and while he is not a singer he does do a good job.
I saw him in London and in the rooftop scene as he was crying, the entire audience was weeping and sniffing. Amazing.
Ramin will be my first place, then JOJ, then Gerard Butler, Ramin has always been my favorite phantom for both POTO and LND....I love his emotions putting into Music of the Night.
I was first exposed to Gerry and though he's the least classical of the three, I think his deep, rough sound is very appealing and he brought a lot of emotion to the song. JOJ has a somewhat darker, richer timbre which is beautiful but in these recordings he didn't bring as much emotion. Ramin has a lighter, 'pingier' sound and is a perfect mix of beauty and emotion. Any of them could be my phantom!
All of the Phantoms are very unique in their own way, but in my opinion Ramin’s voice is just the perfect combination. Soft, romantic, and tender like JOJ, mixed with the power and slight anger of Gerard Butler. Love them all but Ramin is just 😍 💕
JOJ- creative romanticism with gentle tone but with strong empowerment at different high and low notes. He's gentle yet demanding.
Ramin-💖I love his voice his commanding basically his everything he's a great phantom with much emotion he demands and understands. He is in fact gentle to like JOJ
He is my personal favorite💖
Gerard- He's different but in a good way. I've seen the movie and honestly I'm impressed he left an emotional mark I just respect them all so much!!
My lord.. Where to start?
Guess I'll do Gerard first. I used to love his performance, because he was my first Phantom. But, he just doesn't have the same compelling thing going on that JOJ and Ramin do. I definitely don't hate Gerard, in fact I kinda like his deeper rougher voice, and his very slow and calm way of singing Music of The Night. His version also has some really good memories attached to it for me, so that helps. But he just doesn't make me gape in awe at his voice.
Ramin. God, I love his voice. It's powerful and emotional, and is completely different from any other Phantom I've seen.A great interpretation and I love it!
John Owen Jones.. Man oh man. I love his voice too! The way he goes from soft to loud and makes it sound so great is astounding. His higher parts are beautiful too, practically breathtaking. The control he has in his voice is amazing. Hey take my opinion with a grain of salt though. I know nothing about opera or anything like that, I'm just Phantom trash.
Ramin. I love JOJ, I appreciate Gerard for introducing so many people into the POTO world, but it's Ramin I truly and deeply love. He's so intense, sensetive, emotional and profound. Nobody do it in such exquisite, sharp way he did Music Of The Night in my opinion.
I love both JOJ and Ramin, but Ramin edges out the win for me. I grew up watching Gerard, but after watching the actual Broadway performance, I just wasn't impressed with his anymore. I love him as an actor and singer in general, I just don't like him as the phantom because the phantom is supposed to have an angelic, memorizing, and yet powerful voice, and I think Gerard lacks that. I also know that Ramin and JOJ's performances were live and not auto tuned or anything. Gerard, on the other hand, did a recorded performance with lip syncing that he probably had numerous times to redo if he messed up. I LOVE him as an actor, I just don't think he had the voice for the phantom. Don't get me started on Emmy...
Lauren Beth emmy was awful
@@chloenkitty I don’t think she did awful
He absolutely didn’t and I just can’t get why people think his growling, groaning Phantom is even passable. Phantom is supposed to be a flawed dude in almost every way, except his singing. Ghostly, inhuman, almost too perfect, softly haunting and regal. None of which Gerard is. They should have dubbed.
My main problem with Gerard Butler is the fact that he probably had numerous takes to try and get that note right along with the numerous times he can sing the song. He will also have his vocals smoothed over to ensure it was film worthy. Like props to him for actually singing and being able to use his own voice. But he cannot even begin to be compared to people like Ramin and JOJ, because he simply would not be in their league if they had a 'sing off'. For me Ramin is my favourite due to the emotional aspect of his performance but JOJ is amazing. Because essentially Gerard is doing a movie which is singing it in a day and having it cut together. Whereas Ramin and JOJ are singing live in 1 take.
LOVED THEM ALL , MY FAVOURITE OF ALL OF THEM IS MICHAEL CRAWFORD WHO I ,LOVED , FROM IST TIME HEARING AND WATCHING HIM THE OTHERS ARE ALL WONDERFUL, AND SO CLOSE TO THE Michael . GERARD IS GREAT FOR 1ST TIME VERSION, MAKES IT DIFFICULT. LOVE THEM ALL. LOVE TO WATCH MICHAEL,AND GERARD AS HE GOT ME STARTED ON THIS TYPE OF MUSIC. (MEDALS) TO THEM ALL).
John Owen- Jones every time.
I can't choose because all their voices are unique and each one of them portray the phantom in a different way. Over all they all sound beautiful and I have to admit I grew up with the 2004 film which introduced me to the Broadway's. I've grown to love them all, but if I had to choose I think it would be Gerard Butler and Ramin.
People seem to forget that Gerard Butler was in a movie and that means that he gets autotune, now don't get me wrong he can sing. But its different, he could gp numerous time over. whereas JOJ and ramin had one take to get it perfect.
Ramin will always be my favourite. He just has that something special that is so breathtakingly beautiful.
John owens jones is the best phantom
RAMIN KARIMLOO, YOU NEVER LISTENED TO RAMIN I BET. MUCH BETTER
+Dalek Supreme better singer maybe all around though John Owens jones is better for the role older ,nice balance between higher and lower range , and does a lot better job at projecting
wrathofscorpias liar. RAMIN IS PERFECT
HOW DARE YOU! YOU EVIL PERSON, HOW DARE YOU! Ramin Karimloo is THE BEST Phantom that will ever live! Sierra Boggess is THE BEST Christine that will ever live and if you don't agree, you know nothing of music.
wrathofscorpias Ignore those others. They have no sense of maturity or respect.
All amazing in there own way, however Ramin gives me the chills when I listen to it every time.
For me there is no winner as these 3 gentlemen are my favourite Phantoms, so having them in one video is my idea of heaven 🥰
I feel so privileged to say I have both seen and met Ramin and JOJ.
Yes, Geread is not as vocally trained as the other two but he makes the role his own, his acting is on point...and you have to admit he looks really good in those costumes 😉
JOJ will always have a special place in my heart though, he always makes me smile and he is so lovely....he has a lot of time for everybody!
such a tough decision! I've yet to watch JO J version of the POTO but I have watched Ramin and Gerard and they were both amazing!
Ramin Karmiloo is amazing but the sentimental part of me screams "Gerry forever!!" Gerard Butler as The Phantom was an amazing (and bold) casting choice! The rough, (operatically) untrained quality of his voice made me fall in love with The Phantom as a kid and made me love musicals in general. There is often too much stress on being note perfect in the world of musicals and almost a fear in singers voices of missing a note so the emotion is compromised. I will always take a performance that is rich emotionally over a note perfect performance! But maybe that's just me!
Callie Walsh I would normally agree, but the Phantom is the kind of character who HAS to be near perfect. If a singer such as JOJ or Ramin (who in an interview stated he had never had a vocal lesson) misses a note or has a voice crack it's different to Butler who has little skill as a singer. Although, with many other characters (and certainly in the medium of film) I would normally agree. But the Phantom is the "angel of music", and his musical talent is an important part of his character, even outside of the musical.
+Callie Walsh Agreed. I'd take emotion over that any day. Gerard does that amazingly. His voice is just so raw and natural and he has immense control over it. Just beautiful. Coupled with his wonderful acting, he breaks our hearts even more; especially the roof top scene after Christine and Raoul sing "All I Ask of You." That part always tears me to pieces the way he does it. His voice has a haunting quality that is shown when he sings the line "I am you angel of music".
+bleachfreak811
Agreed, but Ramin impregnates my ears man. Sierra was a lucky girl, god damn my darkest dreams are filled with Ramin singing this to me over, and over, and over again.
Me too 👏🏼
I agree completely .
Nice job done here. The audio quality is exceptional for a RUclips video. Thank you.
I do not believe there is any comparing between or among these performers. They each bring a uniqueness to the song with their interpretations. Each listener will invariably appreciate the interpretation(s) which resonates with the listener's sense of what is beautiful. As the cliche goes: Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. And a thing of beauty is a joy forever.
John owen jones so effortlessly outcompetes the rest of the phantoms... He's a legend!
hithere
Matthew Cammelle's version is better than JOJ. And many times better than Ramin Karimloo.
Ramin hands down! His operatic emotive voice is a joy to the senses
Erik, the Phantom in the book was a skilled singer and teacher and a brilliant musician. His entire life was music. To have an okay singer like Gerard sing the Phantom was a disservice to the character he was portraying. He hypnotized people with his voice. You have to have both the voice and the emotion. It wasn't awful, it wasn't even bad - it just wasn't the quality one would expect from a virtuoso such as Erik.
I just have to say that Gerard is my absolute favorite. Not for anything but he isn't a trained singer and to take on this iconic role was a very brave decision. I also want to say that in case no one else has been listening, you don't hear him catching his breath between lines....he belted out that BE more powerfully than the others....then went into the softer tones of this song effortlessly....and he held that note at the end of this song for 23 seconds. And btw Andrew Lloyd Weber wanted a more rock n roll quality to the voice in the movie and he brought it all to the table and then some. ...I love him as an actor...love his singing voice and he's a great person
@@jmfalz6198 You can't hear Gerard catch his breath in between lines because he sang in the studio. There was probably a stationary microphone and he moved away to breathe. JOJ and Ramin sang live, so they probably had a microphone attached to them. In this case, they can't move away from the microphone to breathe, so the microphone captured each breath.
John Owen Jones
Ramin Karimloo
Gerard Butler
JOJ is the best.
Gerry's still my favorite. He has that rawness and purity that I believe the Phantom would've had.
No, the phantom as written in the book, had such a hypnotic and captivating voice that even Christine fell in love with him. Also, he had an operatic voice not rock quality as Gerrard possesses.
Ewa Sadowski It's all fine, to each their own preference, I always say.
The thing is, the original story by Gaston Lerou has been twisted and turned into other stories entirely. Either the Phantom was taken around the world to be an architect, or he was taken into the Opera house at a young age by Madam Giry. No tale ever comes out the same. Books and movies end up being completely different. Movie adaptations can make the story better or worse. In this case, people fell in love with Gerard's voice because, well, he gives you a sensation that the book Phantom didn't. In my opinion, the movies pulled everything off spectacularly. I doubt that this Phantom wears gloves cause his hands are cold as ice. And I also doubt the movie Phantom was tracked down by a Persian. It's just that Gerard takes you into a different world, where the voice may sound musically untrained, but has something in it that you cannot pull back from.
Combination of vulnerable, sad, gentle, yet possessive, obsessive, wounded angry soul is found in John Owen-Jones'. He's the true Phantom's voice. Ramin 's superb vocal is way intense and obsessive, tends to compete with Christine's voice. Butler's voice tend to succumb in the mighty orchestra.
in my opinion, John Owen-Jones is the best.
Ramin Karimloo Is magnificent .
Ramin - he is my phantom
Ramin has always been my favorite. I fell in love with his voice! ❤❤❤
I'm so obsessed with the clarinets that play at 00:33, its in the other versions but I think bringing it up so high in the mix was a cool choice. I think it makes the song so much softer and innocent
I grew up loving Gerard Butler as Phantom until I found Ramin Karimloo last week here in youtube! LOL! I bought Royal Albert Hall Performance and OMG! I don’t want to see other Phantom of the Opera without Ramin anymore. LOL! But seriously, love the 3 performers. I just love Ramin more and obsessed with him!
I once listened the record of JOJ's stage, I think that is the best version. Unfortunately I haven't got the chance to watch the recorded performance...Ramin, I like Ramin's emotion on the stage at 25th anniversary. Butler is the first phantom I met, his act is brilliant
Ramin always be my favorite phantom of all time cause tbh he's the one that made me got into musical opera but don't get me wrong joj and gerard are awesome too❤️
I love how different they are and how they sound. JOJ's is very soft like he is singing a lullaby with a few powerful moments that really wake you up. Ramin's is so soothing which calms one down and sing the words different and with a lot of emphasis that makes this song the most unique. He puts more emotion behind it as well sort of like making it a bit more of his own song and the emphasis he puts on some lines makes it sound like he's actually trying to get you to listen to the message. His voice is beautiful and soothing which is why a lot of people, including me, like him. Gerard's is the one that is most emotional, seductive, and powerful which is why a lot of people dont like this version (I love it) because it's not about the singing and getting it to sound perfect as much as it is about the emotion and passion behind it that Gerard placed in his interpretation and it also sounds like he is seducing Christine. Overall of everyone who has played the phantom. not just in this video, John is very talented but Ramin and Gerard are both my favorite phantoms!
John will always be my favorite phantom.
gerry’s is the only version that can make me cry
I never get when people say they prefer Gerard over Ramin (leaving JOJ out of it, as wonderful as he is) because of his "untrained" quality. Ramin has stated to never having a singing lesson, so while he may have more experience at singing, he's actually had less training than Gerard (who I believe had 4 voice lessons before playing the role). The argument is invalid when comparing these two performers.
Lucy Wallis JOJ is not trained in vocals either and never had a vocal lesson. Gerard was a singer in a band before he became an actor but I agree, his vocals were sub par.
Yvette Campos I didn't know that, thanks for the info. So that makes the argument invalid for the entire video then. I see a lot of people using that to defend Gerard.
Lucy Wallis Even though Gerard was a singer in a band he doesn't consider himself a "singer". The studio worked A LOT with Gerard in reference to his vocals. Though he is a good actor he should not have played the Phantom. Just my opinion.
Yvette Campos I agree. Sometimes I don't mind if someone isn't a great singer in a movie (like Johnny Depp in Sweeney Todd) but the Phantom has to have an amazing voice, and Gerard just doesn't.
***** Except he wasnt good, and as someone else said, hed sung in a band, so he had experience. But he was off key and had trouble projecting, whereas someone like ramin karimloo and joj never had a singing lesson (gerard had 4, so actually had more training than them) and yet sing with much more strength and stability, that the "he hadnt sung much" argument doesnt have any weight. Besides, the character is supposed to have some heavenly voice, even outside the musical context.
B/c Gerard was my first Phantom, he'll always be my favorite🖤🖤 but I love Ramin's voice as well. JOJ sings beautifully too. I mean they all have their own twist to it which makes the song that much better
Ramin is Amazing he sings it so powerful
Oh, who to choose?! Gerard was my first Phantom and holds a special place in my heart, good voice or not. Ramin teleports me to the eighth dimension and makes me sob and feel amazingly happy with just his voice. John’s voice is smooth and rich, with control that Ramin sometimes lacks. Ahh I can’t pick
Pick one? Good lord I could listen to these men put different spins on the character all day long and never pick one. All uniquely beautiful!
Gerald is always going to be my fav. I grew up with his version and to this day it hypnotizes me still. The others were magnificent too. I just will always be captured by Gerald’s voice. Keep in mind that Gerald did that with out any musical background which just made me admire his talent more.
Me to
ramin's and JOJ's voice are very similar that is why i cant choose who is better phantom
What Grace to be able to listen to these Heavenly music and voices!and people like Andrew who received the talent to compose it!
I really like Ramin’s voice
Thanks for upload one of the best song ever written, sang by two of my all time favourites. For my opinion, Ramin is the best actor. His performance at the 25th anniversary is marvellous. But I like to say JOJ is the better singer.
Ramin is my fave Phantom overall, but I gotta give the best specific MOTN to 2012 Jones. There's a softness the others can't quite match
Ramin will always be my favourite... what a singer. What an actor.
Ramin is my favorite hands down
true that
Gerard will always be my favorite as the all-around performance character. I never took notice of him or thought he was hot until that role. I really want to see Ramin live. As a singer, Ramin could sing the alphabet and it would sound lovely.
I actually really like Gerard Butlers version , where he may lose out vocally to the other two who are professionally trained singers , they in turn don,t have the acting talent of Gerard who really does act the song and phantom out.........great effort vocally .
Roy Stone Except Ramin is self taught and doesn’t really know how to read music. Literally watch the 25th anniversary edition and say Ramin can’t act again, smh. JOJ is amazing as well. Butler also had the benefit of redos when both of them never did. There’s no excuse.
Ramin's acting as the Phantom is excellent. The way he emotes deep sadness behind that mask is utterly incredible.
i respect ur opinion but ramin is PHENOMENAL at acting. especially acting as phantom.
actually ramin was never professionally taught. he taught himself by reading books and replicating what he heard. and while i agree gerard did an amazing job showing the passion of the character i feel like ramin did a better job representing the vulnerability
Ramin will always be #1... nothing else is needed to be said
I imagine John and Ramins voices on stage, but I hear Gerard's voice in a place like Lurray caverns. Love love love.
YESSS THATS WHAT I WAS THINKING
John Owen-Jones: Sweet & Smooth. I feel like he’s just singing to Christine to impress her or possibly convince her. Either way, his voice was soft, almost like a more sensitive Erik.
Ramin Karimloo: Strong & Bold. I feel like he’s trying cast a spell on Christine and possibly seduce her. He knows what he wants, and he’s going to get Christine one way or another. He seems like a confident Erik.
Gerard Butler: Older. He sounds like he chose accent and his own interpretation of Erik over vocal quality. Not to mention he sounds older. Like reaching grandpa older. He sounds almost like he’s pleading to Christine, and that he’s possibly a more insecure Erik.
Hands down, my favorite is Ramin Karimloo. However, I wanna hear Ben Lewis sing this song.
John Owen-Jones 2012 version was easily the best, to my ear. He’s the only one with mastery of his voice.
WOOOOO!! GERARD #1!!!💖💖💖
Gerard Butler is my favorite. His voice is natural, raw and quintessential masculinity, without being forced, contrived or artificed.
As a singer, I know the difficulty of controlling a diphthong. This work is full, "night, flight, write" et al. Keeping the 'i' without allowing it to slur in those long sustained notes requires tremendous technical skill. Kudos to everyone who has sung it correctly!
I hate how Gerard just refuses to open up the vowels, instead he chooses to close his jaw as much as possible.
In my opinion,
John Owen-Jones: 8/10
Gerard Bulter: 7/10
Ramin Karimloo: 12/10
I feel that Ramin is the best:)
***** Gerry is 5.5 for me.
Agree with Ramin's point, he's amazing. and my ranking will also be Ramin first, John Owen Jones second, Gerard third....
2/10
50/10
-90/10
Yes! What I would do to sing with Ramin Karimloo just once.
Gerry is the best looking Phantom! And the best Phantom of all time! I am madly in love with The Phantom of The Opera!
Ii say Ramin 10/10 they should have had him do the movie
He is actually Christine's father apparently if you look at the picture she has of her father in the movie
Delta Kennings He makes a wonderful Gustave Daae. Best actor in the movie! 😂
I cannot get enough of the movie and Gerard. He seems to me to be a more realistic phantom. He has a soft then rugged then innocence that a phantom who is alone in his space under the opera house would sound like. Perhaps because it’s a movie. Karin a d Sarah Boggess are a perfect match up when it comes to Broadway. Each I can listen to repeatedly.
But isn't the Phantom the ACTUAL genius of music? He is also so gifted that he had the capacity to tutor Christine. He is the 'Angel of Music' -- voice hauntingly similar to that of chorus of Angels on a singular man. Refined, polished, metallic, angelic, and smooth. That's Ramin Karimloo for you. He IS the Phantom.
I love the overwhalming emotional vocal of Ramin. In my mind, that is how Phantom should be. JOJ is perfect in pitch and expression but Ramin is my ATF.
WOW, all three were fantastic! I just love tenors
1 Ramin because he has a strong voice
John Owen Jones, best ever. Seen him perform in POTO many times. Ramin 2nd, strong and beautiful. Geared Butler, sorry but just no.
My number one is Jon Owen Jones
Love them all!
As far as high notes go, JOJ has the best out of all of them, but that's about the extent of it. There was absolutely no emotion in his version of it and was, in truth, kind of boring. Now, as far as technique goes, Ramin would win this hands down. He is everything that an Angel of Music SHOULD be, even if he IS just a tad bit over-dramatic (though, honestly, I kinda like that because he shows the most emotion, as far as this song goes). However, having seen the 2004 movie version of "Phantom," I think I fell in love with Gerry's voice the first time I heard it. Yes, I know his vocal technique leaves a lot to be desired, but to me, he IS the embodiment of what I think the real Phantom would be. I love everything about his voice, including the rawness of it. So, for me, Gerry's Phantom is the winner here, with Ramin coming in at a close second, and JOJ last. That's my opinion, though.
Take a look at his performance at the Llangollen music festival. I PROMISE you'll change your mind! It gave me chills, and it was just a performance of the song, not from the show
I agree completely
Yeah, they didn't pick a good performance for JOJ. He's got such beautifully raw emotion when he's actually *in* a performance.
I'm not musically trained and was exposed to Gerard's version through the movie and loved it.
I like John Owen Jones, 2012 version. I could feel the emotions well.
I like Gerard version next. For non musical person like me, I find it really good as well. I guess only musical person and perfectionist can tell what is wrong with his version.
For me Ramon Karimloo feels a bit operatic. There's nothing wrong with it, it's just different style and some people really like it.