@@larrymaulsby1711 Stop being jealous. You could also become a doctor, engineer, or college professors by studying as hard as they do. I'd rather celebrate an accomplishment from India than Beijing or Moscow.
Foundation laid by late and first prime minister of India Mr. Jawaharlaal Nehru..Present India because of Jawaharlal Nehru ,a highly Educated and Well Mannered Person of India..
@@anandtobraI've seen isro using cycle at that time to transport their space rocket😂 Nehru and gandhi family were busy partying on the private jet rather than investing in space and tech🤣
@@anandtobraoo that's why isro used bullcart and cycle to transport its equipment while they were having countless vehicles parked in their mansions back in 1960s
it's a simulation because there's no reporter on a helicopter outside. The simulation tells us more than some blinking lights inside the canopy. In the end it can never be proven, but the simulation isn't intended to be the "real" footage.
@@Kenneth-nVA You needa look for the real video, and you'll find that too, coz ISRO can't send another module to record the main module for your enjoyment,😂😂 there are other footage avilable, you can check that.
India's Chandrayaan 1 mission in 2008, was the one that first detected water on the Moon. I don't see many acknowledge this crucial fact. It's high time space experts talk about it when & where relevant.
Gold Spot Not true. Apollo detected traced of Vapor near moon not on moon surface. It was actually Luna24 that detected traces of hydroxyl in the moon regolith. However, it was Chandrayaan 1's Moon Impact Probe that clearly detected water ice, which NASA's M3 also confirmed days after.
it's a simulation because there's no reporter on a helicopter outside. The simulation tells us more than some blinking lights inside the canopy. In the end it can never be proven, but the simulation isn't intended to be the "real" footage.
Have you asked your parents to give you the actual footage when they conceived you if they can't give the footage then you're fake living in a simulation.
Literally, the implication of this event are great i hope as an Indian that India can play their part in this all research in the space, moon etc.., quite significantly in future. All luck and genuine wishes !
ALL indians' HIGH TECH SECTOR from the space to the pharmaceutical even to the moto bike parts etc. are all EITHER IMPORTED or TECH TRANSFERED FROM OTHER HIGH TECH COUNTRIES , this is NOT A SECRETE but an OPEN ACKNOWLEDGEMENT !
india can NOT BUILD their own coal fire power station, india can NOT MAKE their own working train signal system, india can NOT EVEN BUILD their own ORDINARY ( we are not even talking about the high speed rail ) rail YET india can get to the moon ???????????????
ON AUGUST 23, 2023..."INDIA IS ON THE MOON" ..BHARAT IS THE FIRST & FOREMOST COUNTRY WHO HAS LANDED ON THE "SOUTH-POLE" OF THE MOON.... CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL ISRO TEAM MEMBERS, CITIZENS & PM MODI OF INDIA FOR SUCCESSFUL LANDING OF CHANDRAYAAN-3 (PRAGYAN) ON THE MOON..JAI HIND..JAI BHARAT..🙏🇮🇳
Nonsense person it was made to show scientists and people so that they can understand through animation, ofcourse it's not real The real footage you will find in ISRO office website
@@MikeJones-ht7fbhere’s something for you to digest. Whether you believe it to be true or not, from now on every book of history that will record the human’s endeavour to reach the Moon will write that India was the first country to reach the south pole of the Moon, and the fourth country to safely land on the Moon. This is done and nothing will change it. So, whatever you believe, just know that history doesn’t give a rat’s a*s.
Fantastic achievement even if they had spent twice as much money! India is on the space exploration scene in style now. It is already a historic event, but they are going to be doing a bunch of ground breaking science as well. Congratulations!
India has spent only 74m ... the movie gravity's cost was 120m ... ISRO's objective has always been cost effective and human centric. Cheers and thanks 🇮🇳🙏
@@__daddy__really but still a third world country 💀 this is surprising your government is focusing on landing the moon instead of decreasing the poverty rate in india
@@BitchuteBetterThanRUclips of course they're censoring it because we all know it's true. Well, except these clowns in the comments. Completely computer generated.
@@BitchuteBetterThanRUclips I thought it was just me! I swear I just answered a comment the other day, went about my business, went back to RUclips, comment gone. Then I see weird usernames or just not like old days screen names you know. I’m so glad I read your comment bc I would have never known others were also experience similar things
@@firefei87 Another method is to open the video you commented on in another browser incognito mode, you'll know then if your comment got censored altogether or just pushed to "the back" (shadow banned).
@@ajohal5471lol do some reading. The rover will explore south pole which we believe has water ice. Which means earthians can setup a space station there for further exploration into the space and beyond
@@nelldavila3261yes. Better late than never. But mind u, 10 years ago we sent our mars orbiter mission. 15 years ago our moon mission was done and we detected water on moon
Lmao Soviets and Americans did it in the 60s. India still has human sewage flowing through their streets. Maybe clean that up first before faking a moon landing?
India themselves and mankind when completing such great and lofty goals. We live in such cynical times, and it’s about time mankind once again looked to the stars
For all the dumb racists in the comments. Its a simulated video. Actual real footages from the chandraayan is released in their official website and later on
You should be celebrating the technological accomplishment and progress in space exploration instead of letting racist trolls distract from the celebrations. No serious person believes that any lunar mission has ever been faked. It would be nearly impossible for that to go unnoticed. Some of the people who you are probably assuming could be White Americans and Europeans could be from Pakistan, Russia, or the CCP.
@@larrymaulsby1711why don't you go to their official website for more information??😑 Btw NASA and ESA were also part of the mission they were providing signal cover to the lander, were they also lying??😑😑
Chandryaan-1 -1st spacecraft to detect water on moon Chandryaan-2 -World's best lunar orbiter with world's most powerful camera Chandryaan-3 -World's first space probe to land in the moon's south polar region
dawg its a simulation using the live data coming from the craft, they can't show strings of digits/ coordinartes for you to understand now can they?, also its the dark side of the moon, by definition there is no light / has ever been light there so cameras wont really work.
Really impressive feat and kind of strange that even all these decades of technologically advancement only US, Russia, china and now India have managed to achieve this. sidenote: I always believed Japan would had been in this exclusive club when I was a kid
Could not resist commenting. Strange to me as well that we could overtake a country like Japan in the space domain. We Indians always respect them as a technical powerhouse. Really proud of our people.
US media will not say that aloud but they will say India as 4th country to land on moon because they want to showcase that yes u landed on moon so what, we landed first! That's why all news in US have this as tag line whereas others who truly respect India have tag line as "India becomes first ever country to land on South pole of the Moon"! They can't digest someone else getting some appraisal for something that they themselves cant do even after having better technology.😂😂
@@IndoSB Well nobody in India including me care about what foreign media thinks of our achievement but its always a fun to see their reactions because deep inside they're burning!😂😂😂
You're delusional if you think we have better technology here. It's a good achievement landing on the moon but the US is decades ahead of us in terms of technology and science.
@@adarsh4764 Your assumption is correct for some people. But let's not jump the gun & assume everyone is the same ! I've seen multiple foreign scientists and cosmologists legitimately happy, lauding this great achievement.
@@amalgovind9851 Why didn’t India send to robot golf car to moon for collect to ice of water?India did not send astronaut but also did not send robot.India could borrow to Moon car robot from USA.
dawg its a simulation using the live data coming from the craft, they can't show strings of digits/ coordinartes for you to understand now can they?, also its the dark side of the moon, by definition there is no light / has ever been light there so cameras wont really work.
www.isro.gov.in/media_isro/video/chandrayaan3/Ch3_Video_LOI.webm that is a cgi representation the news agencies did not even do the basic research to find the actual videos
I was so freaked out seeing Neil Degrasse Tyson actually doing an interview about it on the news, and dude was totally serious about acting like it was real. What the hell is going on in the world?!
it's a simulation because there's no reporter on a helicopter outside. The simulation tells us more than some blinking lights inside the canopy. In the end it can never be proven, but the simulation isn't intended to be the "real" footage.
I really hate to be the little boy in The Emperor's New Clothes, but have any of you commenters congratulating India on its moon landing actually viewed this footage?
he says india becomes 4th nation to land on moon , he doesnt say first nation to land on south side of moon, he says that later, can be seen clearly how Americans are so unhappy
Everybody that I watch just has the same three clips, the two CGI models depicting a lunar landing, and the clip of everyone in the little computer room clapping. Does anyone have a link to the good stuff, you know, the actual camera footage?
Video footage is still not available, as ISRO was saving bandwidth for the transmission of the actually useful stuff (Attitude, Altitude, Horizontal/Vertical Velocity). Although, Pictures of the descent were shown during the live broadcasting.
The lack of even a low resolution video stream - even of just the descent and rover deployment is a massive missed opportunity. Watching a 3D render of what the craft is doing instead of a video feed is anticlimactic. Huge missed PR/prestige opportunity (and let's face it, that is the secondary purpose of the mission after the science).
Only the state-run television network had exclusive rights (and it is an organization stuck in the Jurassic era). Some "genius" high up on their food chain thought showing an animation would be the best idea. A lot of Indians (including myself) are furious about this. But, our frustration with the media is minuscule compared to our joy surrounding the success of our scientists and engineers.
There were live photos after every second or two from the lander...😅 though yes, the live stream from ISRO headquarter could have been better🥲. I was discussing the same with my family that broadcast things should be given to private players.
why waste money on showing ppl who dont understand basic physics a simple landing when u can confirm that thru other comms devices and can spend that on useful thing like studying the composition and elements in the crust of the moon.@@abhijeetbaruah8536
@1_Noone yeah i just searched a bit on reddit about it... its an animation. Many people are questioning why no better cameras where there, like the livestream on Elon Musk his car in space had..
Why does it look so fake. The blast go past the ground level before landing. The lander should not be so bright. Why is there no dust while landing. Look at shaddows in the craters, the sun should be from behind and there are no shadow from the lander or shodow on the lander????? Please correct me if I am wrong.
Really?! It's 2023 and they are using computer-generated images from an old Arcade 8080 from the game "Space Invaders"?! Is it too expensive to set up a few 4K cameras so we could see this landing live from the spacecraft itself? GIVE ME A BREAK!!
@@mooglemy3813 ask your leaders is we're playing video So, why are your leaders congratulating to us You know what? Actually, you don't have an proper knowledge from this field as you guy's don't care about study and you do nothing actually
@@leetaaprayzaanio4751 because the footage was a simulation shon to the public of how it landed. the actual footage is not yet ti be released and still in the hands of ISRO
@@leetaaprayzaanio4751 no, everybody was celebrating the landing of Chandraayan 3. ISRO just had not released the rights for the real video to be broadcast to the public yet. They said it will take 10-12 days or such or maybe even longer for the ISRO officials to approve of the landing to be shown to the public. there is however, a video of the rover on youtube so you can go and watch it. the video shows the rover dropping to the lunar surface. that is the only real video available of the chandraayan 3 landing as of Aug 27, 2023. i recommend you go watch it.
By reading the comment section, I really have to thank all who supported , encouraged and felt happy about India's achievement. But there are few comments that badmouthing India's achievement in space. Our scientist were really talented and experienced,there is no need for them to edit a graphic landing .we Indians are not that much free to edit fake video about moon landing . If we are that much capable of editing a fake video, we would have done it in CHANDRAYAAN -2 itself. There is no need to Accept a failure and work on the same project under the name CHANDRAYAAN -3 . You people can't accept the fact that India's CHANDRAYAAN -3 succeeded in it's mission, that's all. Please respect other people hardwork . It's a basic thing we have to learn.
@@rorschach1848 yeah it's not a spinning water ball. It's a sphere of matter. Matter that is made up of Electron , proton and neutron . These further form the elements with their arrangements with each other that then form the basis of life. This planet is a sphere because of the gravitational pull that every body possesses. This sphere revolves around another sphere which is mainly made up of Hydrogen and helium and is known as sun to humankind. You are correct earth is neither a water ball in space nor a floating flat surface. It's a complex body made up of Electron , proton , and neutron on the atomic level.
Actually if it were to be some commercial organization it would make sense. But here people opinions doesn't matter to scientists they got the samples and experiments, the things they were rooting for and that's it.
WOW! I'm so impressed by our Indian cousins that they finally pulled the trigger and went to the moon! This is an outstanding feat of human ingenuity and persistence of the highest degree. I can't imagine what the entire team must have felt when the module touched down successfully with no incident! Truly an amazing day, no just for India but for all of mankind!
Can we see camera footage from lift off to landing all the way? And sun included? This should always be possibly this day and age? If not then the doubters will always ask those questions
Currently it's not possible for India to shoot such a video from the lander or orbiter cuz we have a lot of limitations. It requires a huge amount of data to be used and transmitted and a high resolution video cam is required. Also much for effecient antennas needs to be incorporated. This would exceed the Mission budget and make the craft more heavier. It will affect every parameters used. Even any of the other orbiters including NASA's are incapable to do the video capture of a craft landing in the moon surface.
@@dhanyanair111 budget?? For an extra few cameras? I don't think so. Until they provide this then this mission is deemed false. How can a project worth millions of taxpayers money be limited for a real time or even lagged time camera from liftoff to landing. Doesn't make any sense. Regards
@@graemeb3521 The "Cameras" u are talking abt tht easily are not the simplest cameras which we use in mobiles or other high definition cameras which are used here in Earth. We r talking abt space and moon. They need to be so specialised to withstand the harsh environments of space.There are so many other 100s of precise parameters to be put into place. For ur information, currently it's the NASA's LRO which has the camera of highest resolution ever used in the moon. Even LRO doesn't have a video camera. They avoided it cuz it's just an unnecessary expense. And u talked here about the taxpayers money. India is a developing nation not lyk USA or Russia. We can't spend so much on programmes lyk space missions. Even then we are trying our level best to do something big by using our limited funds. So we will hv to compromise on less relevant equipments and concentrate more on wat is really needed for the mission to be successful. I am proud abt my nation who used its middle class budget to became the FIRST NATION to land on the south pole. If this doesn't make any sense for you... I dnt hv anything else to say. CONTINUE DOUBTING. And it WILL NOT BE DEEMED FALSE as far as it A TRUTH... Regards..
The rover has cameras in it. The rover was paked inside. The camera were only activated once it landed. That footage is an animation the real footage is out now
This whole thing is laughable. There's zero proof that India or anyone else actually landed on the moon. And that awful Gameboy or Nintendo 80's-style animation is just making a mockery of anyone that actually believes this crap.
dawg its a simulation using the live data coming from the craft, they can't show strings of digits/ coordinartes for you to understand now can they?, also its the dark side of the moon, by definition there is no light / has ever been light there so cameras wont really work.
Russia is very, very happy with the achievement of Indian scientists and engineers. Congratulations.
We love Russia
Not as happy as the CCP , they made the cartoon for India ....LOOKS FAKE like a CCP space mission in 3D .....Is it real ?????
We love russia and best of luck on your next endeavors.
Love russia. From India
And we are very sorry you failed. We would have been equally happy if you succeeded ahead of us.
ISRO is like a Middle class kid doing better than Rich kids in class.
🎉
well put my dear friend
😂😂 very true
Middle class always bears rich kids in brains dept😀😀😀
''If everything fails, we'll still land on moon safely''
- ISRO
😅😅😊😊
Indians always believes that Kharme phali…so they knew their hard work will never fail at any cost… west r crying inside but Fake smiling outside 😂
Starving kids belive in kharme phali too...
@@Wukillabeatz it's very bad to keep your kids starving.. Go n feed them. I'm waiting here
Don't expose your cowardice. Everyone understood ISRO's point. So please remove the word "safely" that you intentionally inserted to defame ISRO.
So where is actual footage? I did animations more complex than that on my old commodore amiga 500.
I can Link you to the videos, unfortunately the news agencies did not look at the isro website
www.isro.gov.in/Ch3_Video_Lunar_Orbit_Insertion.html scroll down to find all the concerned CGI depictions and yes on board footage
@@SwiderLbn no, they never went anywhere near the moon
From India : my gratitude to all who celebrated India's success. This is your success too. We believe in seeing the earth as one family.
yes . absolutely
No success is permanent,no failure is permanent. Its just a step in series of steps. We have failed last time. We learnt and improved. Thats important
Come on. You know it's fake. You're smart, right?
@@TheSaintberzerkerwhy are you being a joker?
@@TheSaintberzerker whatever you're smoking is very potent .
Finally you are talking about this. Go India this makes me happy. I always believed in India
Yeah, go India, great cartoon, it looks sooo real.😂😢😅
@@larrymaulsby1711 Stop being jealous. You could also become a doctor, engineer, or college professors by studying as hard as they do. I'd rather celebrate an accomplishment from India than Beijing or Moscow.
Thank you for support , it is all our victory together ,cheers 😊
@@saikrishnathiwakarrk i love India
@@dritemolawzbks8574 why are you getting so grumpy, I complimened the great work.
Congratulations India!
Foundation laid by late and first prime minister of India Mr. Jawaharlaal Nehru..Present
India because of Jawaharlal Nehru ,a highly Educated and Well Mannered Person of India..
@@anandtobraI've seen isro using cycle at that time to transport their space rocket😂
Nehru and gandhi family were busy partying on the private jet rather than investing in space and tech🤣
@@anandtobraoo that's why isro used bullcart and cycle to transport its equipment while they were having countless vehicles parked in their mansions back in 1960s
Thank you
Does anyone else think this looks like a 1980's cartoon?
bro its laughable. this whole thing is a farce
Yes
The very first pong video game was more realistic.
@@floor5173 because they never went
Yes because we built the set on the moon in the 80s.
Why does this landing look like video game!? 🤔
Because it's fake
@@ChrisC-fp9quno, get an education
it's a simulation because there's no reporter on a helicopter outside. The simulation tells us more than some blinking lights inside the canopy.
In the end it can never be proven, but the simulation isn't intended to be the "real" footage.
They need a award for worst cgi
It's live visual representation for scientists not to entertain you
Check out china, very bad also
It’s a visual representation of, nobody said It was the real footage
@@Mayan_88694then where is the real footage? Does it exist? Didn’t they record the moon landing in 1969 with little technology?
@@Kenneth-nVA You needa look for the real video, and you'll find that too, coz ISRO can't send another module to record the main module for your enjoyment,😂😂 there are other footage avilable, you can check that.
India's Chandrayaan 1 mission in 2008, was the one that first detected water on the Moon. I don't see many acknowledge this crucial fact. It's high time space experts talk about it when & where relevant.
American satellites detected it back in 70’s.
@@GoldSpot-pf1ybno, it was never revealed it's only speculation... scientifically it was proven by Chandrayan -1 in year 2008.
Gold Spot Not true. Apollo detected traced of Vapor near moon not on moon surface. It was actually Luna24 that detected traces of hydroxyl in the moon regolith.
However, it was Chandrayaan 1's Moon Impact Probe that clearly detected water ice, which NASA's M3 also confirmed days after.
@@trollingdeep2080how USA confirm it but we found it
@@ajohal5471 first America detected, then American instrument detected. Next what detected due to American prayers? 😂
A great day 23August2023 for India 🇮🇳 ISRO on achieving a soft landing of a lander when others have failed ❤ …a big salute 🫡
OPEN TECH TRANSFERRED every country knows
😂😂😂😂
@@brittanyannnicholson534why r u laughing?
素晴らしいニュース。
おめでとうございます。
Thanks from India😊😊😊😊
धन्यवाद(Arigatou Gosaimasu) 🙏
ｨﾝﾄﾞからおめでとうございまお客さま.
Why's is there not actual footage? Looks like a N64 screen graph landing.
www.isro.gov.in/media_isro/video/chandrayaan3/Ch3_Video_LOI.webm
it's a simulation because there's no reporter on a helicopter outside. The simulation tells us more than some blinking lights inside the canopy.
In the end it can never be proven, but the simulation isn't intended to be the "real" footage.
Because they never went
You can search for the video of rover rolling out from the lander which is captured by one of the camera installed on the lander.
Have you asked your parents to give you the actual footage when they conceived you if they can't give the footage then you're fake living in a simulation.
CONGRATULATIONS INDIA GREETINGS FROM Philippines
Literally, the implication of this event are great i hope as an Indian that India can play their part in this all research in the space, moon etc.., quite significantly in future. All luck and genuine wishes !
Genuine fake BS more like
ALL indians' HIGH TECH SECTOR from the space to the pharmaceutical even to the moto bike parts etc. are all EITHER IMPORTED or TECH TRANSFERED FROM OTHER HIGH TECH COUNTRIES , this is NOT A SECRETE but an OPEN ACKNOWLEDGEMENT !
Thank you
They should have called Lucas Films to help them with those graphics. No way you people believe this is real.
india can NOT BUILD their own coal fire power station, india can NOT MAKE their own working train signal system, india can NOT EVEN BUILD their own ORDINARY ( we are not even talking about the high speed rail ) rail YET india can get to the moon ???????????????
ON AUGUST 23, 2023..."INDIA IS ON THE MOON" ..BHARAT IS THE FIRST & FOREMOST COUNTRY WHO HAS LANDED ON THE "SOUTH-POLE" OF THE MOON.... CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL ISRO TEAM MEMBERS, CITIZENS & PM MODI OF INDIA FOR SUCCESSFUL LANDING OF CHANDRAYAAN-3 (PRAGYAN) ON THE MOON..JAI HIND..JAI BHARAT..🙏🇮🇳
Bro its so fake
@@ElselchoGamingno it was not like Russia's failed moon mission
@@ElselchoGaming like the so called landing which NASA did ?? 🤣🤣
@@ElselchoGaming we are not NASA that realises fake lunar landing videos...guess u are too used to NASA 🤣🤣
@@pradiptasarkar3308 Bro look at it, it looks like a video game are you blind lmao.
I love it. Russia fails, and they win. Peace and love to India from America.
We all as a human have a proudly moment it doesn't matter if you are american Or Russia.. 🙏
India win = Russia win
We don't view Russia the way Americans view Russia. We Indians are sad that Russia failed.
Russia is our brother nation- much closer to us than USA will ever be, so I'd say Russia's loss= Humanity's loss.
Eventually, humans win
Thank you,
everyone for your congratutions and support. Love from india. Small pleasures,small victories ,but very inspirational.
Looks like an old atari video game
Nonsense person it was made to show scientists and people so that they can understand through animation, ofcourse it's not real
The real footage you will find in ISRO office website
That's exactly what it looks like
@@cerialspiller22 yeah same like Apollo 11
@@cerialspiller22because thats exactly what it is
Respect Button for ISRO & INDIA❤
Congratulations India! 🇮🇳❤
thank you , where you from ?
@@saikava5946 not your business
@@impactcreator2015-nq8xu Keep it up
It’s fake
Proud of Indian scientists...jai hind
0:17 that's literally computer generated graphics 😂. India's taking the world for a ride.
That is a computer generated graphics yes for representation purpose only can watch real footages on the official pages of ISRO and NASA
@@Buzz_on_yt I'm still curios why there are no real footages. And why they didn't take a single real picture with the automation tech
What a feat! Congratulations India
🎉congrats India🇮🇳. This is the most proudly moments to be an Indian. Keep it up. waiting and excitement next project. Go ahead to find new horizons.
So you think that’s real….😂😂
@@MikeJones-ht7fbhere’s something for you to digest. Whether you believe it to be true or not, from now on every book of history that will record the human’s endeavour to reach the Moon will write that India was the first country to reach the south pole of the Moon, and the fourth country to safely land on the Moon. This is done and nothing will change it. So, whatever you believe, just know that history doesn’t give a rat’s a*s.
Meanwhile kim Jun un is trying to be the first to send men women and children to the sun.
@@MikeJones-ht7fb do you believe in the us moon landing
@@Alpha_Online No they wont, because they never did, because its fake dude.
Fantastic achievement even if they had spent twice as much money! India is on the space exploration scene in style now.
It is already a historic event, but they are going to be doing a bunch of ground breaking science as well.
Congratulations!
Atleast their are some people who appreciate the mission, or else I'm just observing butthurts in comment section of every news channel.😒
Twice as much? Its not even half as much as other agencies did
India has spent only 74m ... the movie gravity's cost was 120m ... ISRO's objective has always been cost effective and human centric. Cheers and thanks 🇮🇳🙏
India spent less than other space agency, not more
Saber I see only postive comments. Ignore jealous paxtanis in fake id trolling..today they are in pain so they will vent
India is first nation to land in South pole of the luner surface
lndia is 10 years ahead of USA in space technology. Jai Hind
@@__daddy__ 54 years ago USA had men on the Moon. Apparently!
@@__daddy__really but still a third world country 💀 this is surprising your government is focusing on landing the moon instead of decreasing the poverty rate in india
@@__daddy__definitely not
Puahahaha 😂😂😂😂😂
??? Where is the proof? All they ever show is animated clips.
thats their proof!
@@Skipbo000telling this people is useless if anyone had hd images they would still say it's fake
Stray Dogs bark even you feed them food
I can't believe how many people actually believe this😂😂😂
RUclips shadowbans all the comments saying how fake it looks. Sort comments by "newest" to see true commentary.
@@BitchuteBetterThanRUclips of course they're censoring it because we all know it's true. Well, except these clowns in the comments. Completely computer generated.
@@breezy8814 Its hilarious people are still falling for this
@@BitchuteBetterThanRUclips I thought it was just me! I swear I just answered a comment the other day, went about my business, went back to RUclips, comment gone. Then I see weird usernames or just not like old days screen names you know. I’m so glad I read your comment bc I would have never known others were also experience similar things
@@firefei87 Another method is to open the video you commented on in another browser incognito mode, you'll know then if your comment got censored altogether or just pushed to "the back" (shadow banned).
Congratulations from Germany! Very cool stuff, looking forward for all the groundbreaking new science from the pole! 🔭🤗
Aber sicher... 😂
Hahahahahha BOT
Would have been cool if they named their spaceship Vimana
I think Mothra is more appropriate.
In sanskrit:
Vimaan : means aircraft
Where as
Chandrayaan: means 'moon craft'
I hope you got that chandrayaan is more appropriate than vimaan..
He didn’t say more appropriate, he said cool.
@@savvy7737Vimaana*
@@larrymaulsby1711Hello, Larry Mothra. 😅
Congratulations India 🇮🇳 🎉🎉🎉
Are those images from 80's Atari game?
Where is the footage? Not the cgi animation.
It's a huge achievement for mankind, congratulations India and ISRO 🎉
India is catching up 60 years later
@@ajohal5471lol do some reading. The rover will explore south pole which we believe has water ice. Which means earthians can setup a space station there for further exploration into the space and beyond
@@nelldavila3261yes. Better late than never. But mind u, 10 years ago we sent our mars orbiter mission. 15 years ago our moon mission was done and we detected water on moon
@@nelldavila3261Still far ahead than uk and all those European countries 🤓
Lmao Soviets and Americans did it in the 60s. India still has human sewage flowing through their streets. Maybe clean that up first before faking a moon landing?
Love you India 🇮🇳🇮🇳🌍
India themselves and mankind when completing such great and lofty goals. We live in such cynical times, and it’s about time mankind once again looked to the stars
Crucial
@fallenofftop7181watch the real landing touchdown video from the lander that they released only later, then comment
@fallenofftop7181 do you think the us got to the moon
Why is nobody saying it looks fake. Because it looks super fake
that’s because it is
It's just simulation vedio to understand common people
Their video looks like a video game from 1998 😂
www.isro.gov.in/media_isro/video/chandrayaan3/Ch3_Video_LOI.webm the news agencies failed to find the relevant videos
@@rae_of_light It is a visual representation not the footage.
wheres the music and the dance number?
whats a bollywood production without those?
Congratulations ISRO
Proud to be an INDIAN
#Chandrayaan3
You know its fake right?
@@ElselchoGamingmore real than your life son.
@@ElselchoGamingyup.. I was the moon
@@ElselchoGaming like your mom?
Proud to be an Indian.....maybe ur stomac is full
Tel be bro wts in the moon for India where people r hungry n sick
People are suffering in India..
For all the dumb racists in the comments. Its a simulated video. Actual real footages from the chandraayan is released in their official website and later on
You're living in a simulated reality if you think they landed a rocketship on the moon.
You should be celebrating the technological accomplishment and progress in space exploration instead of letting racist trolls distract from the celebrations.
No serious person believes that any lunar mission has ever been faked. It would be nearly impossible for that to go unnoticed.
Some of the people who you are probably assuming could be White Americans and Europeans could be from Pakistan, Russia, or the CCP.
@@BlackbirdSSR They did. You can't take out your frustration on Indians. They weren't the ones responsible for humiliating the Russian space program.
Well, post that on RUclips, do you expect people to believe what you show here.
@@larrymaulsby1711why don't you go to their official website for more information??😑
Btw NASA and ESA were also part of the mission they were providing signal cover to the lander, were they also lying??😑😑
Congratulations India
Chandryaan-1
-1st spacecraft to detect water on moon
Chandryaan-2
-World's best lunar orbiter with world's most powerful camera
Chandryaan-3
-World's first space probe to land in the moon's south polar region
Why isn't anybody explaining why it looks like a Playstation 2 rendering?
dawg its a simulation using the live data coming from the craft, they can't show strings of digits/ coordinartes for you to understand now can they?, also its the dark side of the moon, by definition there is no light / has ever been light there so cameras wont really work.
Playstation is way better than that! Even N64 games are better than this!
Cause they know its a visual representation not the actual footage 😂
What a time to be alive 🤗🤗
Not russia, but USSR
Russia was center for all USSR scientific progress.....even your periodic table in chemistry is made by a Russian.....google it 😂
What are you talking about
Really impressive feat and kind of strange that even all these decades of technologically advancement only US, Russia, china and now India have managed to achieve this. sidenote: I always believed Japan would had been in this exclusive club when I was a kid
Could not resist commenting. Strange to me as well that we could overtake a country like Japan in the space domain. We Indians always respect them as a technical powerhouse. Really proud of our people.
its literally CGI its fake and millions fell for it HAHAHAHHA how can you not see how fake this is, theres no wayh real people actualyl believe this
Big countries have more taxpayers, that's the only reason why big countries can afford big things
@@BoringAaronindia is a direct contradiction to that notion. The annual budget of isro is 1/5th of JAXA
Probably because most governments think it's an expensive and mostly pointless endeavour.
If i was indian i would be mad at the lack of evidence
0:18 how spacecraft was recorded from this perspective?
US media will not say that aloud but they will say India as 4th country to land on moon because they want to showcase that yes u landed on moon so what, we landed first!
That's why all news in US have this as tag line whereas others who truly respect India have tag line as "India becomes first ever country to land on South pole of the Moon"!
They can't digest someone else getting some appraisal for something that they themselves cant do even after having better technology.😂😂
right
Dude there are so many US news channels which said this. Why are you so eager for firangi thappas on our achievements ?
@@IndoSB Well nobody in India including me care about what foreign media thinks of our achievement but its always a fun to see their reactions because deep inside they're burning!😂😂😂
You're delusional if you think we have better technology here. It's a good achievement landing on the moon but the US is decades ahead of us in terms of technology and science.
@@adarsh4764 Your assumption is correct for some people. But let's not jump the gun & assume everyone is the same !
I've seen multiple foreign scientists and cosmologists legitimately happy, lauding this great achievement.
Glory to India to become one and only nation to land on moon's difficult to land South Pole.
Yes but where are Indian astronauts?Who will erect to flag without astronauts ?
@@Sirius-Voyagerwe imprinted the national emblem on moon. And in this age of tech , human presence isn't required as such
@@amalgovind9851 Why didn’t India send to robot golf car to moon for collect to ice of water?India did not send astronaut but also did not send robot.India could borrow to Moon car robot from USA.
@@Sirius-Voyager Instead of embarrassing yourself here in public, go study something for ur exams in school
@@amalgovind9851 🤣But I want to see Indian astranouts moon walk as Michael Jackson.
How does anyone think this video is real???????? Please, this is a joke, right?
dawg its a simulation using the live data coming from the craft, they can't show strings of digits/ coordinartes for you to understand now can they?, also its the dark side of the moon, by definition there is no light / has ever been light there so cameras wont really work.
www.isro.gov.in/media_isro/video/chandrayaan3/Ch3_Video_LOI.webm that is a cgi representation the news agencies did not even do the basic research to find the actual videos
They definitely are trying to pawn this off as real. 🤦🏼♂️
I was so freaked out seeing Neil Degrasse Tyson actually doing an interview about it on the news, and dude was totally serious about acting like it was real. What the hell is going on in the world?!
it's a simulation because there's no reporter on a helicopter outside. The simulation tells us more than some blinking lights inside the canopy.
In the end it can never be proven, but the simulation isn't intended to be the "real" footage.
I saw that same spacecraft on Space Invaders
0:17 Why did they use an obvious video game looking icon to show they 'landed on the moon'?
This report puts India's space mission, program and achievements in clear perspective.
Massive achievement! And, gotta dig Leroy's jam for space travel. Go 'Gateway'!
I really hate to be the little boy in The Emperor's New Clothes, but have any of you commenters congratulating India on its moon landing actually viewed this footage?
I think they are bots or paid commenters. It is clearly fake. View comments as newest first.
I honestly doubt it
he says india becomes 4th nation to land on moon , he doesnt say first nation to land on south side of moon, he says that later, can be seen clearly how Americans are so unhappy
They live-streamed the 1969 Apollo moon landing.. it’s 2023.. what am I looking at right now? PlayStation 1 game footage?
Everybody that I watch just has the same three clips, the two CGI models depicting a lunar landing, and the clip of everyone in the little computer room clapping. Does anyone have a link to the good stuff, you know, the actual camera footage?
Isro’s website and their youtube channel
Video footage is still not available, as ISRO was saving bandwidth for the transmission of the actually useful stuff (Attitude, Altitude, Horizontal/Vertical Velocity).
Although, Pictures of the descent were shown during the live broadcasting.
Isro website
@@IndoSB The cartoon descent?
Ok cool but wheres the actual footage of the moon landing?
Yes, We did it ✌️😎
Proud to be an Indian 🇮🇳 JAI HIND
Congratulations to the Whole World 🌍
Haha fake cartoon.
@@m.b5777when jealousy has a RUclips account 😅
@@m.b5777when jealousy has a RUclips account 😅
@@m.b5777 do you think USA got to the moon
@@CoolAnimation-ld6jrusa did get to the moon?
Well done to all the Indian scientists who worked on this project
The CGI is like in the 70’s.. looks worse than American moon landing videos
This is not your pizza delivery job kiddo! Google is free, educate yourself!
The lack of even a low resolution video stream - even of just the descent and rover deployment is a massive missed opportunity. Watching a 3D render of what the craft is doing instead of a video feed is anticlimactic. Huge missed PR/prestige opportunity (and let's face it, that is the secondary purpose of the mission after the science).
Only the state-run television network had exclusive rights (and it is an organization stuck in the Jurassic era). Some "genius" high up on their food chain thought showing an animation would be the best idea. A lot of Indians (including myself) are furious about this. But, our frustration with the media is minuscule compared to our joy surrounding the success of our scientists and engineers.
They are not as cool as Nasa or Space x. Indian govt agencies are always on survival mode.
There were live photos after every second or two from the lander...😅 though yes, the live stream from ISRO headquarter could have been better🥲. I was discussing the same with my family that broadcast things should be given to private players.
So you want Christopher Nolan to shoot it with imax 70 mm
why waste money on showing ppl who dont understand basic physics a simple landing when u can confirm that thru other comms devices and can spend that on useful thing like studying the composition and elements in the crust of the moon.@@abhijeetbaruah8536
Is nobody wondering how they filmed that landing? How did the camera get there?
@1_Noone yeah i just searched a bit on reddit about it... its an animation. Many people are questioning why no better cameras where there, like the livestream on Elon Musk his car in space had..
maybe you are confusing the cartoons meant to illustrate the landing with the video shot from the spacecraft
@1_Noonelinks to real one ?? This is the only video I can find.
@1_Noone we get called conspiracy theorists for pointing that out ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@@thewanderingartists There is no real one.
Love from India 🇮🇳. Russia India’s true friend 🤝
Why does it look so fake. The blast go past the ground level before landing. The lander should not be so bright. Why is there no dust while landing. Look at shaddows in the craters, the sun should be from behind and there are no shadow from the lander or shodow on the lander????? Please correct me if I am wrong.
This is not your pizza delivery job kiddo! Google is free, educate yourself!
Really?! It's 2023 and they are using computer-generated images from an old Arcade 8080 from the game "Space Invaders"?! Is it too expensive to set up a few 4K cameras so we could see this landing live from the spacecraft itself? GIVE ME A BREAK!!
Fake as there economy is in India too 😂
@@jeepheat55 the economy you are holding today is fake
As it is looted from India
Got it?
Give us a break. Go back to playing your game(s)!
@@jeepheat55then what's their gdp doing now?
@@mooglemy3813 ask your leaders is we're playing video
So, why are your leaders congratulating to us
You know what?
Actually, you don't have an proper knowledge from this field as you guy's don't care about study and you do nothing actually
No one can travel passed the dome
This is the space journey for the mankind. Jai Hind.
It's a hoax. There's no way that footage was real lol
@@leetaaprayzaanio4751 because the footage was a simulation shon to the public of how it landed. the actual footage is not yet ti be released and still in the hands of ISRO
@@imfrommars7362 that's ridiculous, so everyone was celebrating a video of a simulation?
@@leetaaprayzaanio4751 no, everybody was celebrating the landing of Chandraayan 3. ISRO just had not released the rights for the real video to be broadcast to the public yet. They said it will take 10-12 days or such or maybe even longer for the ISRO officials to approve of the landing to be shown to the public. there is however, a video of the rover on youtube so you can go and watch it. the video shows the rover dropping to the lunar surface. that is the only real video available of the chandraayan 3 landing as of Aug 27, 2023. i recommend you go watch it.
@@leetaaprayzaanio4751 do you think the USA got to the moon
Atari 2600 called. They want their graphics back. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
U know we care more about the QUALITY OF OUR MISSIONS,
rather than the Quality of SHOWING OFF.🙂👍
(NO HARD FEELINGS TOWARDS U MATE, JUST CLARIFYING)
@@zexer_ity There is ABSOLUTELY no way that is real, come on, use your brain!
@@grimthreeper1173 what do YOU mean!? Do u mean these gralhics doesn't real?!
@@grimthreeper1173 like you are using your brain huh? 😂😂
This video will look great in 1970 but won't fool many now
Something sounds fake
1st nation to be on the south pole which requires precision manouevering to land unlike conventional bumping on the surface directly.
I wanna hear the flat earthers now ;) Congrats India!
It can be locally flat 🙃
what has flat earth got to do with Indias landing on the moon ?
Show me any good footage of this historic event please.
why? You think its a hoax?@@arborian2112
They would say that the video footage looks fake.
wtf🤣😂 looks like atari footage
😂there is no reporter in space bro that' graphics
By reading the comment section, I really have to thank all who supported , encouraged and felt happy about India's achievement. But there are few comments that badmouthing India's achievement in space. Our scientist were really talented and experienced,there is no need for them to edit a graphic landing .we Indians are not that much free to edit fake video about moon landing . If we are that much capable of editing a fake video, we would have done it in CHANDRAYAAN -2 itself. There is no need to Accept a failure and work on the same project under the name CHANDRAYAAN -3 . You people can't accept the fact that India's CHANDRAYAAN -3 succeeded in it's mission, that's all. Please respect other people hardwork . It's a basic thing we have to learn.
Jealousy and envy are the best compliment
Why is it that nobody ever asks where the camera man is who is taking photos of ships flying through Spase
So India has a pretty good sound stage to pull this off just like we did, and the USSR and China. Lot of work there to keep all those secrets....
No one has ever been to the moon. There is extensive evidence of this. Stanley Kubrick directed the American movie of landing on the moon.
@@erikwalls8733flat earther spotted
Someone is jealous and burning from bottom 😂😂😂😂
@@OptiSuS If you genuinely think that the earth is a spinning water ball then there's no hope for you, lmao.
@@rorschach1848 yeah it's not a spinning water ball. It's a sphere of matter. Matter that is made up of Electron , proton and neutron . These further form the elements with their arrangements with each other that then form the basis of life. This planet is a sphere because of the gravitational pull that every body possesses. This sphere revolves around another sphere which is mainly made up of Hydrogen and helium and is known as sun to humankind. You are correct earth is neither a water ball in space nor a floating flat surface. It's a complex body made up of Electron , proton , and neutron on the atomic level.
Nobody can leave this planet.....
Plane* not planet. Earth is not a spinning space ball with curved water
@@LJ...69.flat earth believers are real😮😮
FAKE moon landing module looks like an old retro atari game 🙂
Do u think they might be this dumb to not comment on the graphics had it been fake? Cmon its just a visual representation of the landing.
FILMED IN A BOLLYWOOD STUDIO
You were also born in a mental hospital
@@ThomasShelby-c6s I actually was born in a gifted hospital so Stay in your lane to save yourself from embarrassment.
Actually if it were to be some commercial organization it would make sense. But here people opinions doesn't matter to scientists they got the samples and experiments, the things they were rooting for and that's it.
@@blinger4080 if you say so
@@ACommenterOnRUclips Let me like your comment too. We'll have 2 likes to justify your statement is true .
WOW! I'm so impressed by our Indian cousins that they finally pulled the trigger and went to the moon! This is an outstanding feat of human ingenuity and persistence of the highest degree. I can't imagine what the entire team must have felt when the module touched down successfully with no incident! Truly an amazing day, no just for India but for all of mankind!
@Truth_ExposedFr tho
India's cousin 🤔 where are you from 🤔🙏
@@SeachGateINDIAIndio CA 😂😂😂
@@The40Glock1 California 🤔
I'm the UK, take care man.@@SeachGateINDIA
I hope the footage is a recreation of the actual landing.
it's not. People actually believe this is real.
Yes, it is a recreation.
@@eldritch6871 No, not at all... Its a recreation only.
yup same
It's a Fake recreation of the Fake landing
Big achievement for Indians. ❤
There is no way anyone is watching that footage and thinking it is anything else than a PS1 render
@cloudyy-iscool then why is this news if I wanted to see a fake space-craft land on a fake planet I'd play star citizen/field
That footage is about as resl as the average Indian H1B Visa applicant's resume and academic record.
Here all we need is the Burnol 😂
Why does the video look fake?
Because no one has ever been to the moon. Not in 1972, not now. This is all part of the charade...do some digging
First country on South Pole 🎉🎉 🇮🇳
But where ara Indian Astronauts?Who will do moon walk? who will erect to flag without astronauts.?
How come the first landing had better graphics?
First landing? This is India’s first and only Moon landing so far.
@@JohnHazenhousen I was taking about the alleged landing by the USA
@@jamesfriedman4645 Which one?
Can we see camera footage from lift off to landing all the way? And sun included? This should always be possibly this day and age? If not then the doubters will always ask those questions
Currently it's not possible for India to shoot such a video from the lander or orbiter cuz we have a lot of limitations. It requires a huge amount of data to be used and transmitted and a high resolution video cam is required. Also much for effecient antennas needs to be incorporated. This would exceed the Mission budget and make the craft more heavier. It will affect every parameters used. Even any of the other orbiters including NASA's are incapable to do the video capture of a craft landing in the moon surface.
@@dhanyanair111 budget?? For an extra few cameras? I don't think so. Until they provide this then this mission is deemed false. How can a project worth millions of taxpayers money be limited for a real time or even lagged time camera from liftoff to landing. Doesn't make any sense. Regards
@@graemeb3521 The "Cameras" u are talking abt tht easily are not the simplest cameras which we use in mobiles or other high definition cameras which are used here in Earth. We r talking abt space and moon. They need to be so specialised to withstand the harsh environments of space.There are so many other 100s of precise parameters to be put into place. For ur information, currently it's the NASA's LRO which has the camera of highest resolution ever used in the moon. Even LRO doesn't have a video camera. They avoided it cuz it's just an unnecessary expense. And u talked here about the taxpayers money. India is a developing nation not lyk USA or Russia. We can't spend so much on programmes lyk space missions. Even then we are trying our level best to do something big by using our limited funds. So we will hv to compromise on less relevant equipments and concentrate more on wat is really needed for the mission to be successful. I am proud abt my nation who used its middle class budget to became the FIRST NATION to land on the south pole. If this doesn't make any sense for you... I dnt hv anything else to say. CONTINUE DOUBTING. And it WILL NOT BE DEEMED FALSE as far as it A TRUTH... Regards..
The rover has cameras in it. The rover was paked inside. The camera were only activated once it landed. That footage is an animation the real footage is out now
Dude, don't even think to disagree with the diarrhea people...
This whole thing is laughable. There's zero proof that India or anyone else actually landed on the moon. And that awful Gameboy or Nintendo 80's-style animation is just making a mockery of anyone that actually believes this crap.
This is not your pizza delivery job kiddo! Google is free, educate yourself!
They didn’t have real time footage this was meant to just be a real time video representation of what was actually going on 😭
Only problem is it looks completely fake.....😱
No one has ever been to the moon
@@BC-nl9phThe US SIX times❤
Who put the camera there to film it?
dawg its a simulation using the live data coming from the craft, they can't show strings of digits/ coordinartes for you to understand now can they?, also its the dark side of the moon, by definition there is no light / has ever been light there so cameras wont really work.
Where’s the footage?
This makes me question if the United States even landed on the moon
Proud of 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳