I have talked to an ISRO scientist, they mentioned that even in just the 2 weeks time CY-3 has collected soo much data that it'll take 3 years to study it. So, definitely more scientific finding coming out of this.
Seems like ISRO science is not as transparent when we had rockets and satellites launched in the 80s, 90s and early 2000s. There were tangible results like live telecasts, long distance telephony, remote sensing etc … lately the outcomes and benefits of missions could not be verified as easily.
Im an American and have many friends from India. Im happy India is doing so well with this. Im also proud that India and America signed that trade agreement this past year. It is going to make both countries strong and unstoppable in the future. With India and America working together and off eachother only great things can happen for both countries!!!
The best thing about India is that they are sharing all the information gathered by them with rest of the world. Again kudos to this successful mission with a bare minimum cost of 75million dollars ONLY!!
As an American I am so proud of India they accomplished so so much cant wait to see what they will accomplish in the future. If we all can get together and discard our menial differences we can become a species that populates our solar system in my lifetime.
Too late dude. You fell for the space meme. They don't care. Its just a way to test weapons platforms, and it creates a fantastically impassible artificial asteroid belt to finally lock the door on a prison planet. Why are space people so gullible and ignorant?!!
The Chandrayaan 3 has a budget of 75 million dollars but the bank account of the current government the bjp is swelling at more than 1 billion USD. MODI IS THE WORST AND MOST CORRUPT PM OF INDIA!
Exactly. I'm fiercely proud of my country, but science is beyond all that stuff we should share everything as we move toward becoming one humanity. Bravo India.
@@johnmichaels4330 You hypocrite. And in the meantime, your country is one of the most poverty-stricken. Are you proud of that as well? India can find billions to launch rockets, but no money to feed and house its own people (unless you're rich, of course).
I continue to be very impressed with India. They are a much needed sane and positive influence on the world. And their technological expertise continues to deliver great results!
India! In my already long life of travel,India have attracted me 5 or 6 times,between 1month and 7 month .... I LOVE this country,for preseving it's cultural heritage,and at the top of new tech research... It's a Magical country,a need to know feelings.❤❤❤
What a fascinating mission. The scientists and engineers involved in Chandrayaan 3 made a lot of important discoveries and achievements with a light budget, and a short amount of time.
I have nothing but the utmost respect and admiration for Indian scientists, engineers and all the staff of ISRO and everyone involved in Indian space program. They've accomplished a lot with a limited budget, hope it's only the beginning.
@@elio7610 I'm not saying what they did wasn't impressive. I'm saying it's no more impressive then what other space agencies do. I don't think you understand what I'm saying. Lets say hypothetically they pay a physicist or aeronautic engineer 30k a year rather then 300k a year in the west. That 30k there buys the same quality of life the 300k does in the west. So on paper it's 10x cheaper but in reality it's the same thing.
@@Bitchslapper316 I don't think you understand. If two companies can offer you the same thing but one costs a lot less, are you not gonna prefer the cheaper option? Unless workers are underpaid or quality and safety is being neglected, doing the same thing but cheaper is just better.
Serious respect and kudos to India . . . well done! Not only excellent science and tech with limited budget, but unlike China, very openly sharing the data discovered with this mission.
I'm looking forward to India's next mission to the moon. I expect the rover will be called "Vandala" (shovel in Sanskrit)... Awesome times for INDIA!!! Congratulations!
Congrats India! I hope they can get some astronauts to the moon soon to be part of an exclusive group. Of course, I'm not talking about an exclusive group of countries that have made it, but an exclusive group of people. Space is for us all to explore, and if there is one place left in our reach that extends beyond politics and borders, it should be the final frontier.
The Indian people are natural mathematicians, for some reason they just get it. when math is chosen as a scoop of practice as a career, an Indian person always excel.most of my Indian friends did stellar in math compared to other subjects, both highschool and college
And I said that to say this, math is the basics to physics, and science and this is way ISRO can take half the budget of NASA and accomplish more based on solving the equations to more efficiently travel to the moon and accomplish it's goals with minimal resources in comparison to NASA. Great Job to ISRO and NASA for continued historic discovery
I was thinking the same. It makes sense instead of water ice being just exposed to the air, with all the meteors and stuff hitting the moon, it would make sense that the ice got covered by dirt overtime. Maybe even a lot of dirt so we might have to dig quite away before we suddenly strike some thing that we realize is not rock.
Imagine what we could accomplish if there was an International Space Agency where all the countries of the world collaborated, keeping aside their enmity, every country funding their bit as per capacity and all the technical minds in the world working on it.
yeah, all except the Indian people who dont even have flush toilets or healthcare and have to sort thru garbage dumps for enough scraps of things to sell to eat while the country throw away MILLIONS sending a ship to the moon
In 1969, Neil Armstrong spoke these famous words: "Houston, Tranquility Base here. The eagle has landed." Now we can say "The Tiger has landed." Serious respect to India for a successful mission to the Lunar south pole.
Armstrong being a devout Christian for the remainder of his life, refused to swear on a bible that he stepped foot on the moon. Not once did he ever do this. Even look at him in the interview upon "returning." Those aren't the emotional expressions of men that just made the exploration of an entire specie's history! It looks like men that are afraid for their lives for some reason....
The Chandrayaan 3 has a budget of 75 million dollars but the bank account of the current government the bjp is swelling at more than 1 billion USD. MODI IS THE WORST AND MOST CORRUPT PM OF INDIA!
It makes sense that the water ice would be buried under a few centimeters of dry regolith. The ice may have been there for millions of years but lunar dust is constantly moved around by static electric forces and micro meteorite impacts, which allows the stuff to cover every bit of its surface. Plus, a layer of regolith could prevent ice from instantly sublimating, much like on Mars.
The differences in temperature only going 8cm into the ground of the moon is astonishing to think about. Definitely gives me hope that our tricky friend, Hydrogen, is hiding somewhere below!
Why though? We can manufacture hydrogen here. What the hell is wrong with space people!? Is this the new capeshit? Or just a new religion for the cattle like you?
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi it's a well known phrase. Google it. It's not in any way patronising or degrading. It's a tip off to the brains of the past. The humans who discovered gunpowder laid all this down for us. We truly do stand on the shoulders of giants. Educate yourself .
As someone born after the first moon landings and severely disappointed that I’m not currently on Mars, I love that we can say, “Maybe Hollywood should consider filming their next moon film on site” and it’s actually a possibility.
@@thamasaurus What makes it not a possibility anytime soon? Maybe your "anytime soon" is different than mine. It's a multi-billion-dollar project, but the moon isn't that far away. Would you accept filming on an orbital space station?
Every single country that was part of the British empire is better off for it, not that negates some off the horrible things that were done, look at the countries in the third world that were with British or French territories( believe it or not the British weren’t the only ones who ruled other countries) and see how much better off they compared to those that weren’t. It’s amazing how you can make such a sweeping comment from a country that still thought that throwing yourself in airplanes at American aircraft carriers less that 80 years ago for an emperor who cared not one bit for them was a good idea. Or should we forget about the 20+ million the Japanese killed while looting china? Stones and glasses houses spring to mind.
I wonder if the ice underneath the regolith has its own crater structures from when the regolith was thinner, hiding impact sites that are previously unknown
I would say that it eroded by the time the regolith covered everything. Micro meteoric bombardment and radiation from the Sun and outer space are quite effective on the Moon surface. Though, big craters should remain I guess. I don't have the definitive answer and I'm not sure anyone has it yet. We shall definitely return there to answer this issue!
India is a nation I really hope to prosper and improve the world for them and for us, because unlike other big powers who are dreaming world domination, Indians are talented and yet good hearted people.
surely they would never be interested in world domination with how much corruption infects the indian government. What a laughable take. At least Americans arent stupid enough anymore to trust their own government anymore.
@@brokenSnakecry lol what to say your stupidity, even governments are busting the dens of them so don't be delusional come out and see it as a country,
Huge shout out to ISRO for such a successful mission on a tight budget. Much smaller shout out to NASA for leading the charge in developing spaceflight technology to the point where every nation can contribute to the scientific exploration of the universe. Bravo all.
Yes! Huge shout out to NASA for leading the charge in developing spaceflight technology to the point where every nation can contribute to the scientific exploration of the universe. Much smaller shout out to ISRO for such a successful mission on a tight budget. Bravo all.
@@qualat9340 Haha this is much more fair, but I didn't want to pull the spotlight so recently after success. They deserve it for a bit, was no small task!
@@zeusdeux I'm a very big proponent for reusable rocketry, but I also would LOVE to see some massive Saturn V esq mammoths with crazy payload capacities.
@@marktwain3820Humbly stating - greatness can’t be given or taken away by someone by turning on-or-off a spotlight. Factual Achievements/accomplishments are results of several hardworking individuals (scientists and support stuff) ably funded by public and enabled by govt. Thanks for your acknowledgement. But please note that it is still an incredible achievement even if if you did not 🙏
This is a fantastic achievement, huge congratulations to India! I’ve always been extremely skeptical about the presence of water on the moon. It’s certainly possible. But I’ll believe it when I see it
Imagine what they could have done with a budget like NASA'S! We need to get the Indians to collaborate more with ESA and NASA to spread the costs and share ideas
The amount of racism and hatred for India in the comment section by some westerners is just crazy. Thankfully, an equal (or more) amount of westerners cheering India's accomplishment is a positive for us and the entire world. Let's at least keep the field of science free of hate. Love from India ❤
i think westerners are stingy so as NASA for them it is a secret file. even area 51 is also out of touch for everyone. Well atleast India is different they share their discoveries.
in Past India was struggling with its economy..now economy is stable and as per world bank ,economy will go high by 2030 ..so their will lot of spending on space missions in future ..
It was the budgets. It’s pretty funny how everyone is appreciating the cost effectiveness of these space missions, where as most science enthusiasts in india are demanding that budgets be increased for more R&D. The entire budget for isro is like 1.3 billion usd. That’s it.
Actually Chandrayaan-2 was supposed to do this. We had the lander have uncontrolled descent and crash onto the surface unfortunately. Chandrayaan-3 was a daring attempt after that last minute failure of Chandrayaan-2. Now we have lots of missions on track. One to Mars, more to Moon, One to Sun (already present at L1 point) and more
we did this in 2008, chandryan 1 in 2008 first discover water on moon , then in 2019 we try to do this same thing but chandrayan 2 lander was failed , in chandrayan 3 we accomplish landing and now by 2027 India will send chandrayan 4 which will recover 5 kg moon land soil back to earth
Congrats India! All my respect to you all for showing the BIG guys how it's done. Thanks for sharing your data and showing us nonscientists what was brilliantly accomplished. Very good videography, too. 🙈🙉🙊 😎 🇺🇲
If water is allegedly found in permanently shadowed craters, then tautologically, a solar-powered lander will have quite some difficulty finding it. That said, it was a good mission and was quite successful. Low-budget space exploration has a lot to offer. Personally, I'd like to see NASA do more of it too.
To be fair the best way to find water on earth is also to dig down. When you showed the graph at 8:14 it seemed to me permafrost could only possibly exist a few inches below the surface, (on the daylight side) as you later suggested. The graph is totally wild by the way, it blew my mind! I'm subscribed now, having watched several videos on this channel all of a consistently high quality. Thank you for your work.
Blazing in the sun, freezing in the shade. It's a side effect of having no atmosphere. It actually shows just how good an insulator the lunar soil is. The surface daytime temperature is closer to 100C.
Congratulations India! Your nation came through with vaccine production during the pandemic. Now, this historic new chapter in Lunar exploration has changed the economic landscape of space travel before returning a single bit of telemetry! Bravo, fellow space folk, and the lifesavers down the hall in biochem! Thank you!
😲 it's insane to fund such a moon mission, complete with a rover and an impressive scientific mission (and all the requisite instruments!), for under $100m...
@@ryshellso526 There are no slaves....They are well paid...And westerners see the incomes of ISRO employees less because they compare it with their own country....In India everything is cheaper so you need comparatively very less money to have a great life....And all of ISRO employee do.
Thank you so much for this fascinating, informative and entertaining film. I have learned more about ISRA’s recent expedition from your film than many other media. My interest in the moon has been reawakened! 👍🏼
Wonderful video! What an exciting mission this was, and despite the obvious disappointment of not finding surface water ice in this small area, we have to give huge kudos to ISRO for executing an extremely successful and efficient mission which collected an enormous amount of data.
Thank you Alex. A wonderful presentation from you. Very interesting. Possibly daily temperature is too hot for water then However as you pointed out, where’s the Hydrogen? You’re great as usual. I enjoy your take on everything. It’s refreshing and honestly truthful. I appreciate honesty in these presentations however yours have a special place for me. Many thanks. Cheers Colin.
The people in Europe and US have to know that when your ancestors were learning to live in groups Indians with their Sanatan aka Hinduism had already known that earth is spherical and they already had named stars in constellation and planets. Indian subcontinent got under Islamic invaders and British rule for past 1000 years who burnt our universities and made our life hell. But the natural instinct to talent and to gain knowledge is still in our DNA
To everyone here who is sending respects and regards and congratulations to scientists of ISRO and people of India, I thank them personally on behalf of every citizen of India. We sure aren't that rich but have a heart full of hospitality. British looted us in every possible ways but we continue to thrive and grow. Thank everyone again.
What I gather was that permanently shadowed regions was not on the cards. Even if the landing had been closer to the south pole, to examine permanently shadowed regions, the landing itself would have to be inside a crater which could be several kilometers deep. Not sure if the rover would be able to navigate the slopes.
8:35 the lander performed a 40cm high hop as a test for future landers to propel back into orbit... Now why don't the Indians ask the yanks how easy it was to do this, considering (amongst other mind boggling achievements) they propelled a massive lunar module and its two occupants back into orbit, etc, etc. - AND even had a remote camera setup on the surface to capture that entire sequence!!! :D
He's comparing a cheap and expendable mission with an extremely narrow scope to the Artemis missions, which have resulted in a dramatic expansion in space lift vehicles and capacity, and which will place both humans and highly advanced robotic exploration vehicles on the moon, will create humankind's first extraterrestrial space station and place it in lunar orbit, and will pave the way for human settlement of the moon.
India has RTG technology but the mission is very cost effective + isro also wants to test the craft how it will survive the lunar freezing nights it was just a hope unfortunately it didn't waked up but anyways it accomplished it's mission 🙌 and gave valuable datas the future mission is ch4 India and Japan is working together on sample return mission
@@death_parade Chandrayaan 3 has a Nuclear Device but not in the lander but in propulsion module. Nuclear energy keeps Chandrayaan-3 propulsion module going. Chandrayaan-3 has an untold success: The mission’s propulsion module now orbiting Moon is powered by nuclear technology. Confirming it to TOI on Monday, Atomic Energy Commission chairman Ajit Kumar Mohanty said he is happy that India’s nuclear sector could be part of such an important space mission. Isro officials said the propulsion module is equipped with two radioisotope heating units (RHU) generating one watte designed and developed by BARC. RHUs keep the spacecraft at their operational temperatures. Chandrayaan-3 has an untold success: The mission’s propulsion module now orbiting Moon is powered by nuclear technology. Confirming it to TOI on Monday, Atomic Energy Commission chairman Ajit Kumar Mohanty said he is happy that India’s nuclear sector could be part of such an important space mission. Isro officials said the propulsion module is equipped with two radioisotope heating units (RHU) generating one watte designed and developed by BARC. RHUs keep the spacecraft at their operational temperatures. Chandrayaan 3 project director P Veeramuthuvel on Sunday said Isro may soon use nuclear resources to maintain instruments in future rovers. Isro officials said that the RHUs could not be installed on Chandrayaan 3’sVikram lander and Pragyan rover because it would have increased their mass. They were placed in the propulsion mod
@@death_parade RTG wouldn't be difficult. They stated they wanted the landing to be successful first. I heard one of their Project Managers say it made no sense to have a RTG on board before they were sure their lander would work flawlessly. Maybe they did not want to leave a radioactive debris in case it failed.
Thanks for making this video. I'm shocked I didn't hear about chandrayaan's discoveries on my other channels. Maybe the news of chandrayaan was clouded by the news of the war in Gaza-Israel. In my opinion scientific news should dominate as it is significantly more important and interesting than humans destroying eachother!
Chandrayaan mission handled out very much before the war recent mission isro conducted was gaganyan a testing launch for carrying human astranounts in a round trip around earth
Cy-3 landed on sept 23 on the moon. You didnt hear about it because most media doesnt showcase India's achievements in space. I mean how can a poor country like India achieve so much ....this baffles many western media outlets.
@@fun3721 What? It doesn't "baffle" western media outlets! 😂 Western media outlets are puppets whose job is to keep the citizenry in a constant state of emergency (which of course helps their ratings), to pit different groups against each other at every point, to distract us from the government's crimes, and to do a little social engineering. Baffles. That's hilarious.
Yeah while their people are still living 3rd world style and suffering like animals, SEVERE pollution, poop in the streets... they need to worry about fixing things there before they worry about spending BILLIONS more on space exploration.. -My opinion.
I have talked to an ISRO scientist, they mentioned that even in just the 2 weeks time CY-3 has collected soo much data that it'll take 3 years to study it. So, definitely more scientific finding coming out of this.
they should send some of that data to Nasa so the Artemis landers can confirm it. Great day for reawaking the space age.
@@sierracosta47India is a part of the Artemis accord, I am sure the data is being shared between them.
You talked to nobody. Stop faking it chapri!
That's great to hear. I wish we as a species could funnel more funding and effort towards scientific endeavors like this.
Seems like ISRO science is not as transparent when we had rockets and satellites launched in the 80s, 90s and early 2000s. There were tangible results like live telecasts, long distance telephony, remote sensing etc … lately the outcomes and benefits of missions could not be verified as easily.
Im an American and have many friends from India. Im happy India is doing so well with this. Im also proud that India and America signed that trade agreement this past year. It is going to make both countries strong and unstoppable in the future. With India and America working together and off eachother only great things can happen for both countries!!!
Ahha. So you think?
As a literal India, thank you.
@@supers0nic77 what do you mean?
As someone literally from India?
Or a Literate Indian?
You're mistaken. Only the US benefits from its 'agreements.'
Tell this to American deep state 😅
Thank you India! Much love from America ❤
I love seeing the faces of the scientists. One hundred percent concentration, facination, excitement and pride. Fascinating!
Too bad all they have is theories
@@Fuzzled369Look up scientific process. Theories are based on facts.
The best thing about India is that they are sharing all the information gathered by them with rest of the world.
Again kudos to this successful mission with a bare minimum cost of 75million dollars ONLY!!
That's kind of a rule , you learn anything you have to share it with the world !
Bless those guys!!
That's resulted in a severely limited time span and a limitation with data collection ...still ....was highly worth it
@@remainingcubea rule ignored too much sadly
75mil compared to NASAs 4.1bil. NASA budget smells fishy
Way to go India! I spent 3 months in India and it was amazing! “Tiki! Mein doctor whu! Sumja?!”
That means "Fine! I'm a doctor! Do you understand?!" (Menacingly)
@@rijulNangia tho kinda misspelled make it even more menacing
@@rustyschackleford7922 💯✨
Your hindi is very cute man 😅😅😂😂
As an American I am so proud of India they accomplished so so much cant wait to see what they will accomplish in the future. If we all can get together and discard our menial differences we can become a species that populates our solar system in my lifetime.
Peace my friend
Nah. India will trash it up... look at the country.
Too late dude. You fell for the space meme. They don't care. Its just a way to test weapons platforms, and it creates a fantastically impassible artificial asteroid belt to finally lock the door on a prison planet.
Why are space people so gullible and ignorant?!!
May things happen as you have wished.
Space is a limitless boundary there are many things to be discovered hope so India an US can get together to explore the space
Congratulations India!!!! The world is proud and thankful for your work!
The Chandrayaan 3 has a budget of 75 million dollars but the bank account of the current government the bjp is swelling at more than 1 billion USD. MODI IS THE WORST AND MOST CORRUPT PM OF INDIA!
You lie about landing on the moon 😂
Can't speak for the whole world
Dewitticus - S t f u, nobody is proud of the filthy fools
NO, CONGRATS TO THE WORLD, NO MATTER HOW MUCH WE FIGHT
AT LAST WE ALL ARE A BIG family
Woah, shout-out to India! I feel like this whole mission didn't get much recognition but is tremendous for our human species. Big respect, from Canada
🤡🤡🤡
@@poopiecon1489Wow. A poop emoji pfp, spamming clowns, and the username “poopiecon”. Also I’ve seen you commenting this on other vids too.
@@thatidiotoverthere6311 aww did i hurt your little feelings 😭
@@poopiecon1489 I’m essentially calling you a childish bot.
look whos projecting@@thatidiotoverthere6311
Any space research is a win for humanity. Great job, ISRO!
Exactly. I'm fiercely proud of my country, but science is beyond all that stuff we should share everything as we move toward becoming one humanity. Bravo India.
if is real not game made
@@gemini-sd420 get a life inginer😂
Rip education 😂
@goofballbiscuits3647.
You're talking out of your backside!
@@johnmichaels4330
You hypocrite. And in the meantime, your country is one of the most poverty-stricken. Are you proud of that as well? India can find billions to launch rockets, but no money to feed and house its own people (unless you're rich, of course).
I continue to be very impressed with India. They are a much needed sane and positive influence on the world. And their technological expertise continues to deliver great results!
Except the murdering people in other counties you might have a point.
@@tstorm3706unlike usa killing innocent civilians from different countries 🤡
@@tstorm3706 I guess you are talking about that Ak-47 wielding illegal Indian migrant Plumber ( mostly peaceful ) .
If only they could stop pooping in the streets and smearing cow dung on their body. Then the rest of society would take them serious.
@@tstorm3706You LOST or something ?
Surely you're talking about AMERICA !
India! In my already long life of travel,India have attracted me 5 or 6 times,between 1month and 7 month ....
I LOVE this country,for preseving it's cultural heritage,and at the top of new tech research...
It's a Magical country,a need to know feelings.❤❤❤
Welcome !!
@@kapilmaliwad1470 thank you!
Plz visit we welcome you 🎉
@@TrueFeelingsss I will!😁
@@olivier-pierredebelmont.3630 visiting would be your biggest regret of your life
What a fascinating mission. The scientists and engineers involved in Chandrayaan 3 made a lot of important discoveries and achievements with a light budget, and a short amount of time.
I have nothing but the utmost respect and admiration for Indian scientists, engineers and all the staff of ISRO and everyone involved in Indian space program. They've accomplished a lot with a limited budget, hope it's only the beginning.
It's not as "limited" as you think. Thier budget is less but so are thier operating and manufacturing costs
@@Bitchslapper316I am not really sure how that would make it less impressive.
@@elio7610 I'm not saying what they did wasn't impressive. I'm saying it's no more impressive then what other space agencies do.
I don't think you understand what I'm saying. Lets say hypothetically they pay a physicist or aeronautic engineer 30k a year rather then 300k a year in the west. That 30k there buys the same quality of life the 300k does in the west. So on paper it's 10x cheaper but in reality it's the same thing.
@@Bitchslapper316 I don't think you understand. If two companies can offer you the same thing but one costs a lot less, are you not gonna prefer the cheaper option? Unless workers are underpaid or quality and safety is being neglected, doing the same thing but cheaper is just better.
Get a room you 2
Serious respect and kudos to India . . . well done! Not only excellent science and tech with limited budget, but unlike China, very openly sharing the data discovered with this mission.
I'm looking forward to India's next mission to the moon. I expect the rover will be called "Vandala" (shovel in Sanskrit)...
Awesome times for INDIA!!! Congratulations!
Congrats India! I hope they can get some astronauts to the moon soon to be part of an exclusive group. Of course, I'm not talking about an exclusive group of countries that have made it, but an exclusive group of people. Space is for us all to explore, and if there is one place left in our reach that extends beyond politics and borders, it should be the final frontier.
The Indian people are natural mathematicians, for some reason they just get it. when math is chosen as a scoop of practice as a career, an Indian person always excel.most of my Indian friends did stellar in math compared to other subjects, both highschool and college
And I said that to say this, math is the basics to physics, and science and this is way ISRO can take half the budget of NASA and accomplish more based on solving the equations to more efficiently travel to the moon and accomplish it's goals with minimal resources in comparison to NASA. Great Job to ISRO and NASA for continued historic discovery
Our numeral system came from Northern India, not Arabians.
So at birth, people born within the borders of India or of Indian descent are simply better at mathematics than others ? Is this what you’re saying? 😂
@@magnusmagnus3336 Our numeral system although called Arabic, actually came from Northern India, not the Arab World.
@@jaymudd2817bro it's still called as 'Hindu-Arabic numerals'
i love all the love india is getting bro im indian and i feel amazing
I was thinking the same. It makes sense instead of water ice being just exposed to the air, with all the meteors and stuff hitting the moon, it would make sense that the ice got covered by dirt overtime. Maybe even a lot of dirt so we might have to dig quite away before we suddenly strike some thing that we realize is not rock.
Moon minecraft
This gives me hope. 😊
Its common sense. Hope nobody expected Chandrayaan 3 find Deception sleeping in south poll of moon. Ha.. Ha..
With air you mean space? :D
Bedrock
Imagine what we could accomplish if there was an International Space Agency where all the countries of the world collaborated, keeping aside their enmity, every country funding their bit as per capacity and all the technical minds in the world working on it.
i can only imagine how quickly that would get seeped in corruption and laundering.
i'm sorry, please imagine i said something optimistic here.
I think it would be harder to bribe a org that big@@the-letter_s
International Space Station *cough*
@@micbln8967 It is not the entire world. It was only a few elites like the veto holders.
@@micbln8967 Big, big difference between a space station and an agency.
We all are thrilled to have India become a space-faring nation 😀
This benefits us all
I am looking forward to the great things they accomplish
This benefits no one especially poor Indians who starve on the street
yeah, all except the Indian people who dont even have flush toilets or healthcare and have to sort thru garbage dumps for enough scraps of things to sell to eat while the country throw away MILLIONS sending a ship to the moon
Bit of a stretch
We are? lol
I was so happy for ISRO, what they achieved on a relative shoestring budget is absurd ❤
Better than we did in decades.
नमसते
"Namaste" to ISRO for your achievement!
Namaste ❤
GREAT JOB India, that is the most exciting stuff coming from another nation that is transparent about it.
ISRO is the pride of our country.
In 1969, Neil Armstrong spoke these famous words: "Houston, Tranquility Base here. The eagle has landed." Now we can say "The Tiger has landed." Serious respect to India for a successful mission to the Lunar south pole.
Armstrong being a devout Christian for the remainder of his life, refused to swear on a bible that he stepped foot on the moon. Not once did he ever do this. Even look at him in the interview upon "returning." Those aren't the emotional expressions of men that just made the exploration of an entire specie's history! It looks like men that are afraid for their lives for some reason....
Elephant has landed :)
The Chandrayaan 3 has a budget of 75 million dollars but the bank account of the current government the bjp is swelling at more than 1 billion USD. MODI IS THE WORST AND MOST CORRUPT PM OF INDIA!
I don’t believe it. This rover looks like a toy
How come these minerals weren’t found by the Americans?
It makes sense that the water ice would be buried under a few centimeters of dry regolith. The ice may have been there for millions of years but lunar dust is constantly moved around by static electric forces and micro meteorite impacts, which allows the stuff to cover every bit of its surface. Plus, a layer of regolith could prevent ice from instantly sublimating, much like on Mars.
Its so cool to see india developing so rapidly. Cants wait to see what india brings to humanity next!
But in this age of tiktok reels, Indians are also losing interest in scientific knowledge
@@quantum-222 tik tok is banned in India 😅
@@quantum-222 True but tiktok is banned in here but people are still losing interest thinking it's boring
@@quantum-222 fortunately tik tok is banned in India
@@facthub9964 what about insta reels???
The differences in temperature only going 8cm into the ground of the moon is astonishing to think about. Definitely gives me hope that our tricky friend, Hydrogen, is hiding somewhere below!
Why though? We can manufacture hydrogen here. What the hell is wrong with space people!? Is this the new capeshit? Or just a new religion for the cattle like you?
Thank you India, for showing the world how do do this without spending billions.
Whoop whoop
standing on the shoulders of giants
We already spent it all and they copied it. Dang you people are soo SIMPLE.
@@ThomasHaxleyWouldn't be nice for you people to shed your superiority complex and appreciate the space advancement for the good of all mankind.
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi it's a well known phrase. Google it. It's not in any way patronising or degrading. It's a tip off to the brains of the past. The humans who discovered gunpowder laid all this down for us. We truly do stand on the shoulders of giants. Educate yourself .
Go India!!! Woohoo! Great job.
Congrats India! 🇮🇳
In what faking geting to the moon like nasa and the rest of them fakers 😂😂
@@TheworldTheworld-wz7td bro you have ghosts in your head😂😂
NO, CONGRATS TO WHOLE WORLD
@@TheworldTheworld-wz7tdis education banned in your country brother
As someone born after the first moon landings and severely disappointed that I’m not currently on Mars, I love that we can say, “Maybe Hollywood should consider filming their next moon film on site” and it’s actually a possibility.
sorry to burst your bubble but that's not gonna be a possibility anytime soon.
Doubt this is real
Pretty sure in next decade and half there would be humans on mars!
@@thamasaurus What makes it not a possibility anytime soon? Maybe your "anytime soon" is different than mine. It's a multi-billion-dollar project, but the moon isn't that far away. Would you accept filming on an orbital space station?
@@adarsh4764 We can only hope. And, you know, hope that the mission is safe and successful.
I can’t believe india space program cost cheaper than marvel movie and actually gain benefit for society
it didn't gain anything it's garbage
Less than Martian movie too
@@birdnestratfestretard
That's sad
Yeah okay Indian. Y'all helped absolutely nothing.
India is just a 75 years old country Britishers looted every possible thing from them and they are back again. Respect from 🇯🇵
Every single country that was part of the British empire is better off for it, not that negates some off the horrible things that were done, look at the countries in the third world that were with British or French territories( believe it or not the British weren’t the only ones who ruled other countries) and see how much better off they compared to those that weren’t.
It’s amazing how you can make such a sweeping comment from a country that still thought that throwing yourself in airplanes at American aircraft carriers less that 80 years ago for an emperor who cared not one bit for them was a good idea. Or should we forget about the 20+ million the Japanese killed while looting china?
Stones and glasses houses spring to mind.
@@sticky70 well bro I'm not here for spreading any hate.... forgot the past and look forward to the future....
@@unknownboy8202 Love from India. This will be an Asian century.
@@SILOPshuvambanerjee it already is
"Britisheres"?
I wonder if the ice underneath the regolith has its own crater structures from when the regolith was thinner, hiding impact sites that are previously unknown
That's dumb. How many craters you fucking need?
I would say that it eroded by the time the regolith covered everything.
Micro meteoric bombardment and radiation from the Sun and outer space are quite effective on the Moon surface.
Though, big craters should remain I guess.
I don't have the definitive answer and I'm not sure anyone has it yet.
We shall definitely return there to answer this issue!
ice sublimates
the moon is our cautionary tale
Not as an American, but as a Human ....GOOD JOB!❤
Thank you from an another human being
India is a nation I really hope to prosper and improve the world for them and for us, because unlike other big powers who are dreaming world domination, Indians are talented and yet good hearted people.
Unless your Sikh and live outside the country. Then they kill you.
Thank you so much for your kind comment god bless the earth and every beings
surely they would never be interested in world domination with how much corruption infects the indian government. What a laughable take. At least Americans arent stupid enough anymore to trust their own government anymore.
Humanity first. Love from India ❤
Exactly that. We need to make a priority the humanity as a whole. We can't really be happy if our neighbor suffers. Love and peace from Greece!
Love these vids. The quality is better than many professional TV docs
Wow.Great India.Thank you.
If India had a major economy like the United States there’s no telling what these people could accomplish.
It'll be bigger
Much nicer call centers
@@brokenSnakecry lol what to say your stupidity, even governments are busting the dens of them so don't be delusional come out and see it as a country,
maybe they will finally stop shitting in the street
@@brokenSnake you racist!
Huge shout out to ISRO for such a successful mission on a tight budget. Much smaller shout out to NASA for leading the charge in developing spaceflight technology to the point where every nation can contribute to the scientific exploration of the universe. Bravo all.
Bravo all indeed! I can’t wait for every country to also have reusable rockets. That would be such a massive accelerant to space exploration!
Yes! Huge shout out to NASA for leading the charge in developing spaceflight technology to the point where every nation can contribute to the scientific exploration of the universe. Much smaller shout out to ISRO for such a successful mission on a tight budget. Bravo all.
@@qualat9340 Haha this is much more fair, but I didn't want to pull the spotlight so recently after success. They deserve it for a bit, was no small task!
@@zeusdeux I'm a very big proponent for reusable rocketry, but I also would LOVE to see some massive Saturn V esq mammoths with crazy payload capacities.
@@marktwain3820Humbly stating - greatness can’t be given or taken away by someone by turning on-or-off a spotlight. Factual Achievements/accomplishments are results of several hardworking individuals (scientists and support stuff) ably funded by public and enabled by govt. Thanks for your acknowledgement. But please note that it is still an incredible achievement even if if you did not 🙏
Great job India for an absolutely incredible mission and at an amazing savings compared to any other nations attempts! 🎉💥🔥
Congratulations and best wishes for the continued success of the Indian Space Program.
Merry Christmas from Matffew mahogany
Thank you. India for showing us the truth up there
No problem
Thank you for praising my country .
All are welcome to india to explore spiritual growth too ❤
This is a fantastic achievement, huge congratulations to India!
I’ve always been extremely skeptical about the presence of water on the moon. It’s certainly possible. But I’ll believe it when I see it
Imagine what they could have done with a budget like NASA'S! We need to get the Indians to collaborate more with ESA and NASA to spread the costs and share ideas
yeah! 1/50th the price for a super mission. Mad isn't it?
Or...we should budget better and cut waste.
@@gabrieldrumm2575best way to cut budget would be reducing our military spending. NASA gets >1% of US budget
@@gabrieldrumm2575cut waste yes
But also double the budget.
Well then how could US earn when it stops supplying weapons to Ukraine and Israel!
The amount of racism and hatred for India in the comment section by some westerners is just crazy.
Thankfully, an equal (or more) amount of westerners cheering India's accomplishment is a positive for us and the entire world.
Let's at least keep the field of science free of hate.
Love from India ❤
Where everyone is congratulating them
Sardar jee kindly delete this comment. It serves no purpose 🙏
@@SeachGateINDIA Then why are you wasting your time here anna
i think westerners are stingy so as NASA for them it is a secret file. even area 51 is also out of touch for everyone. Well atleast India is different they share their discoveries.
Physics and space exploration is where i run to when the news starts driving me crazy. You channel is my happy place. Thank you!
I'm suprised India didn't do this sooner. They're a country of Engineers and mathematicians!
in Past India was struggling with its economy..now economy is stable and as per world bank ,economy will go high by 2030 ..so their will lot of spending on space missions in future ..
It was the budgets. It’s pretty funny how everyone is appreciating the cost effectiveness of these space missions, where as most science enthusiasts in india are demanding that budgets be increased for more R&D. The entire budget for isro is like 1.3 billion usd. That’s it.
Budget issue they can make more powerful rocket as compared to ESA
Actually Chandrayaan-2 was supposed to do this. We had the lander have uncontrolled descent and crash onto the surface unfortunately. Chandrayaan-3 was a daring attempt after that last minute failure of Chandrayaan-2. Now we have lots of missions on track. One to Mars, more to Moon, One to Sun (already present at L1 point) and more
we did this in 2008, chandryan 1 in 2008 first discover water on moon , then in 2019 we try to do this same thing but chandrayan 2 lander was failed , in chandrayan 3 we accomplish landing and now by 2027 India will send chandrayan 4 which will recover 5 kg moon land soil back to earth
Good on our Indian cousins, much love from Australia.
Native Australian??
Very inspiring!
Great work India !
India is advancing pretty quick! I bet their next Rover will be nuclear powered and way more advanced for research.
yes it is coming. already at final stage. Will go to south pole again.
Congrats India!
All my respect to you all for showing the BIG guys how it's done.
Thanks for sharing your data and showing us nonscientists what was brilliantly accomplished.
Very good videography, too.
🙈🙉🙊 😎 🇺🇲
If water is allegedly found in permanently shadowed craters, then tautologically, a solar-powered lander will have quite some difficulty finding it.
That said, it was a good mission and was quite successful. Low-budget space exploration has a lot to offer. Personally, I'd like to see NASA do more of it too.
Congratulations ISRO for being praised so profusely by scientists of other countries.
To be fair the best way to find water on earth is also to dig down. When you showed the graph at 8:14 it seemed to me permafrost could only possibly exist a few inches below the surface, (on the daylight side) as you later suggested. The graph is totally wild by the way, it blew my mind! I'm subscribed now, having watched several videos on this channel all of a consistently high quality. Thank you for your work.
60^C at the surface? I had *no* idea it was as hot as that!
when the sun is up
Blazing in the sun, freezing in the shade. It's a side effect of having no atmosphere. It actually shows just how good an insulator the lunar soil is. The surface daytime temperature is closer to 100C.
In space if you were telepirted there with no spacesuit the side of you facing the sun will boil and cook while the side facing away will freeze solid
Well Done India
In an internet clogged with clickbait and scaremongering your videos are a breath of fresh air!
Cool. The rejection of a hypothesis is as much of a scientific advancement as the confirmation of it.
Congratulations India! Your nation came through with vaccine production during the pandemic. Now, this historic new chapter in Lunar exploration has changed the economic landscape of space travel before returning a single bit of telemetry! Bravo, fellow space folk, and the lifesavers down the hall in biochem! Thank you!
Good work India! Solid win!
As an 80s kid who hears "water ice in space" I can't help but think of Total Recall..... 😂😂
see you at the party richter! 🤣
@@PAUL-MH - How about "Baby, you make me wish I had 3 hands"..... 🤣🤣
@@xpndblhero5170 hahaha hahaha you think this is the real quaid it is! 🤣
@@PAUL-MH - SCREW YOU¡! 😂
(so many great dad joke moments in 80s movies, especially when Arnold is involved) 🤣🤣
@@xpndblhero5170 lol! 🤣
Go INDIA!
It's nice to see that Raj is still working in his field and bringing us great moments!!!
Raj?? Big bang theory?? 😂😂😂
Excellent presentation. Very informative. Congratulations dear friends in India!
😲 it's insane to fund such a moon mission, complete with a rover and an impressive scientific mission (and all the requisite instruments!), for under $100m...
Not when you have an entire country of slave robots in human form.
@@ryshellso526 pretty wild way to describe a billion human beings
@@ryshellso526 There are no slaves....They are well paid...And westerners see the incomes of ISRO employees less because they compare it with their own country....In India everything is cheaper so you need comparatively very less money to have a great life....And all of ISRO employee do.
@@deepakmeena7529well said. Thank you.
@@deepakmeena7529 cope...
I didn't know it was such a successful mission. Good little video, thanks.
Thank you so much for this fascinating, informative and entertaining film. I have learned more about ISRA’s recent expedition from your film than many other media. My interest in the moon has been reawakened! 👍🏼
ISRO - INDIAN SPACE RESEARCH ORGANISATION
Wonderful video! What an exciting mission this was, and despite the obvious disappointment of not finding surface water ice in this small area, we have to give huge kudos to ISRO for executing an extremely successful and efficient mission which collected an enormous amount of data.
They were near the south pole, not in the south pole -
@@RoboBozo-d4pSouth pole is too dark to even see anything which faces infinity space and extreme cold temperature to run any robot or device.
@@RoboBozo-d4pcry lol. every body consider India as the first country to land on the Moon's South Pole.
Liked this video a lot as it was well researched and/or informative.Two thumbs up etc. etc.!
Thank you Alex. A wonderful presentation from you. Very interesting. Possibly daily temperature is too hot for water then However as you pointed out, where’s the Hydrogen? You’re great as usual. I enjoy your take on everything. It’s refreshing and honestly truthful. I appreciate honesty in these presentations however yours have a special place for me. Many thanks. Cheers Colin.
First time watching a positive comment section for India 🥺🥺
The people in Europe and US have to know that when your ancestors were learning to live in groups Indians with their Sanatan aka Hinduism had already known that earth is spherical and they already had named stars in constellation and planets. Indian subcontinent got under Islamic invaders and British rule for past 1000 years who burnt our universities and made our life hell. But the natural instinct to talent and to gain knowledge is still in our DNA
Congratulations INDIAN Space exploration.
To everyone here who is sending respects and regards and congratulations to scientists of ISRO and people of India, I thank them personally on behalf of every citizen of India. We sure aren't that rich but have a heart full of hospitality. British looted us in every possible ways but we continue to thrive and grow. Thank everyone again.
Congratulation to ISRO for this great achievements 👏👏✨✨❤❤
Update: ISRO Brings Chandrayaan 3 back to Earth✨✨
Great work ❤ Proud to be an Indian 🇮🇳
Time to dig some moon wells. Go, ISRO!
This is super impressive. Congratulations India
"INDIA MADE IS THE BEST" period🎉
Space exploration is awesome! Thank you, India 🙏🏼
WOW WOW, AMAZING. WHY ISN'T THIS KIND OF THING ON MAINSTREAM MEDIA
What I gather was that permanently shadowed regions was not on the cards. Even if the landing had been closer to the south pole, to examine permanently shadowed regions, the landing itself would have to be inside a crater which could be several kilometers deep. Not sure if the rover would be able to navigate the slopes.
Less budget heavy success
8:35 the lander performed a 40cm high hop as a test for future landers to propel back into orbit...
Now why don't the Indians ask the yanks how easy it was to do this, considering (amongst other mind boggling achievements) they propelled a massive lunar module and its two occupants back into orbit, etc, etc. - AND even had a remote camera setup on the surface to capture that entire sequence!!! :D
At least they were able to do it on a cheaper scale but got important data gathered for scientists to study
He's comparing a cheap and expendable mission with an extremely narrow scope to the Artemis missions, which have resulted in a dramatic expansion in space lift vehicles and capacity, and which will place both humans and highly advanced robotic exploration vehicles on the moon, will create humankind's first extraterrestrial space station and place it in lunar orbit, and will pave the way for human settlement of the moon.
I want to see the first international moon rover drag race, circuit race and technical race held back to back to see who gets the title.
😂😜
India has RTG technology but the mission is very cost effective + isro also wants to test the craft how it will survive the lunar freezing nights it was just a hope unfortunately it didn't waked up but anyways it accomplished it's mission 🙌 and gave valuable datas the future mission is ch4 India and Japan is working together on sample return mission
India doesn't yet have RTG technology, BARC and ISRO only recently started co-developing it. There was an RHU onboard the orbiter though.
@@death_parade Chandrayaan 3 has a Nuclear Device but not in the lander but in propulsion module.
Nuclear energy keeps Chandrayaan-3 propulsion module going.
Chandrayaan-3 has an untold success: The mission’s propulsion module now orbiting Moon is powered by nuclear technology. Confirming it to TOI on Monday, Atomic Energy Commission chairman Ajit Kumar Mohanty said he is happy that India’s nuclear sector could be part of such an important space mission. Isro officials said the propulsion module is equipped with two radioisotope heating units (RHU) generating one watte designed and developed by BARC. RHUs keep the spacecraft at their operational temperatures.
Chandrayaan-3 has an untold success: The mission’s propulsion module now orbiting Moon is powered by nuclear technology.
Confirming it to TOI on Monday, Atomic Energy Commission chairman Ajit Kumar Mohanty said he is happy that India’s nuclear sector could be part of such an important space mission.
Isro officials said the propulsion module is equipped with two radioisotope heating units (RHU) generating one watte designed and developed by BARC.
RHUs keep the spacecraft at their operational temperatures.
Chandrayaan 3 project director P Veeramuthuvel on Sunday said Isro may soon use nuclear resources to maintain instruments in future rovers. Isro officials said that the RHUs could not be installed on Chandrayaan 3’sVikram lander and Pragyan rover because it would have increased their mass.
They were placed in the propulsion mod
Waked 😂😂😂😂. Its woke
@@death_parade RTG wouldn't be difficult. They stated they wanted the landing to be successful first. I heard one of their Project Managers say it made no sense to have a RTG on board before they were sure their lander would work flawlessly.
Maybe they did not want to leave a radioactive debris in case it failed.
Great video and great story telling. Kept me hooked till the end. Always proud of ISRO.
congrats to India's space program, we support!
⟒⌖⌿⌰⍜⍀⟟⋏☌ ⎍⍀⏃⋏⎍⌇
This is so fascinating! Hopefully with these findings the next ever lunar mission will have a shovel!!
Thanks for making this video. I'm shocked I didn't hear about chandrayaan's discoveries on my other channels. Maybe the news of chandrayaan was clouded by the news of the war in Gaza-Israel. In my opinion scientific news should dominate as it is significantly more important and interesting than humans destroying eachother!
Chandrayaan mission handled out very much before the war recent mission isro conducted was gaganyan a testing launch for carrying human astranounts in a round trip around earth
Cy-3 landed on sept 23 on the moon. You didnt hear about it because most media doesnt showcase India's achievements in space. I mean how can a poor country like India achieve so much ....this baffles many western media outlets.
Because it was an animation... laughable.
@@ryshellso526 Yes yes animation. Very good. You will make very good progress in life.
@@fun3721 What? It doesn't "baffle" western media outlets! 😂 Western media outlets are puppets whose job is to keep the citizenry in a constant state of emergency (which of course helps their ratings), to pit different groups against each other at every point, to distract us from the government's crimes, and to do a little social engineering.
Baffles. That's hilarious.
As indian I'm so proud,I felt like something has come to change.thanks ISRO.jai hind.
Best channel on YT, thanks Astrum, for the quality content
Just goes to show how much you can accomplish if you control wasteful spending and are honest about costs. Way to go India.
Yeah while their people are still living 3rd world style and suffering like animals, SEVERE pollution, poop in the streets... they need to worry about fixing things there before they worry about spending BILLIONS more on space exploration..
-My opinion.
Well done, India.. Respect from Sindh, pakistan ❤
The US suddenly can't even get a rocket into space.