"China did not sign on the Artemis project"... Well, china has been excluded from any American space program since decades. Just to say how bias this film is...
Artemis “Accords” not “project”. It’s a legal framework that sets the rules for the extraction of resources in space. That’s what China didn’t sign. They were not excluded from this.
@@gabrielgustavson22 Wikipedia: The Wolf Amendment is a law passed by the United States Congress in 2011, named after then-United States Representative Frank Wolf, that prohibits the United States National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) from using government funds to engage in direct, bilateral cooperation with the Chinese government...
You excluded China from ISS, and you think China would be accepted to your moon club without major sacrifice of it's own independence? How hypocritical!
Do all the analysis from any angle, just one thing guys - there is no race on China side. The road map of Moon Exploration was setup a decade ago, they are just progressing as planned.
Chinese built a new Space Station, landed on the dark side of the moon, got the world's first samples from there. Serious how can you call it a competition when they are way way ahead.
I honestly hope China can actually accomplish something. Maybe that will convince the West, mostly America, to finally get off their butts and take space seriously again.
@ar1sm70 far side of moon sample return. That is an accomplishment. 2028 propose tianwen 3 mars sample return mission. Nasa msr doesn't even a launch date
As a person who watches China's development, I'm amazed at how different China and the West is in terms of managing society. The West tends to let private sector decide, and its society is "gone with the wind". They go through history typically aimlessly. In China, the government is the leading force. They have plan and long-term vision. No one can predict the future, but by having long-term vision, one can follow through challenging goals. The leadership (in China) can adapt to new circumstances quickly if it is worth it. For example, Fusion tech is far from reality (it may take 40 years more). So China now focuses on Green Energy (Solar, Wind) as well as Thorium-based nuclear power. But if someday someguy figures out how to exactly solve Fusion issue, China can rapidly adapt to the new direction. And in this case, no one in Chinese society would complain (or be allowed to complain) about wasteful resources for Thorium-based ones.
You see how China, uses competition, and competitive education to put people in the right place to outcompete US. While America uses it's power to bend rules to slow down China's progress. China was banned from ISS and then it made it's own space station. If everyone else is allowed to learn, why can't China? Because China could actually become better? China should continue what it is best at, observing, re-engineering, innovating and competing.
The reason I struggle to believe the Lunar landings actually happened is, when Nasa decided to go back to the moon in 2012 or whenever it was, they should have been able to do it in easily under 5 years...and yet we are still waiting for them to return. I mean they had the launch, ferry and landing tech sorted in the 1970s, knew how much it costs, and basically knew everything else. Lets assume 1-2 year for redesing and modifications, 1-2 year for testing, another year for fixing any bugs, 3 years of astronaught training alongside it. Thats 5 years. They dont need to wait for launch windows either. There is only minor RnD extra costs...it just doesnt make sense.
We had told that Americans went to the moon in 1969. How come after 55 years later, we all have difficulty to back to moon again including the u.s even with more advanced technologies today???
Today, we give 4 years to NASA, Space X and India to land an unmanned craft on the far sight of the moon. Sprouting nonsense everyday how powerful their rockets are. Landing on the moon is not easy for America. Talk is no use.?? China is the leader in space.
"for all mankind" NASA conducted the entire Apollo mission in the open for everyone around the world to see both their successess and failures. The Soviets conducted their programs in secret, only revealing what they had done after of it was done and if it worked out. America showed that an open society could work better than a closed one.
When Bill Nelson said, “A giant leap for all humanity.” That “humanity” didn’t include China(because it is the US’s adversary) and countries from the global south(because they don’t have the science and financial capabilities). Probably nothing 🤦🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️
I want to know why the United States landed on the moon more than 50 years ago but can't now. Has space technology stopped developing for more than 50 years?
The Artemis Accords is nothing to brag about as most of the signers have nothing to do with space like Angola, Armenia, Dominican Republic, Liechtenstein, Luxemburg, Nigeria, Rwanda, Cyprus, Peru, Columbia, Ecuador
USA is concerned about China because China has its own independent Baidu, Alibaba, Huawei, its Beidou Navigational system, her own Space station, etc...
Thank you for specifying that the first ones were all white men whilst showing a picture of all white men. Don't think i would have come to that same conclusion without Bloomberg's help
i thought the same when they said the next mission has a woman and a person of colour. I thought that was clear when we saw the woman and black man on screen but I guess it needed to be explicitly called out
India is in the club ? India is 50 years behind USA & 30 years behind China in space. China landed rovers on planet Mars & send samples from Moon's far side back to earth. ISRO should be compared to & Competes with JAXA ( Japan's space agency ). It's nowhere close to China or NASA
Let's say if America won this round of space race against China, the real question is will America continue the space exploration and beyond, or simply ignore it again just like after winning of the last space race against USSR?
I don't think they will, cuz even if they landed people first. Remember China is not in the race, the Americans are calling it a race. China is just minding their business in achieving their goals and plans. So even if they so called win the race they will have to continue cuz if they leave it China will surpass them and they don't want that and i don't think China will stop at the moon cuz they already have plans for mars.
The new race to the moon is not just about reaching it again; it's about establishing a sustainable presence, unlocking scientific and economic opportunities, and ushering in a new era of human space exploration.
Bollywood scripts changes all the time. Prior to NASA and China's statement that India never reached the South Pole of the Moon, Indians say that they are first country to reach the Moon's South Pole. Now, P.Veeramhthuvel, director Chandrayann-3 project, said: We became the first country to go to the, *Near* to the South Pole of the Moon . Notice how fast Bollywood script changes so quickly? Honesty Issues. USA -> NASA specifically said "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located about 600 kilometers from the Moon’s South Pole.". This is just another diplomatic way of saying India did not land on Moon's South Pole. If India had landed on on Moon's South Pole, NASA would have simply said that "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located at the Moon’s South Pole" instead of "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located about 600 KILOMETERS FROM the Moon’s South Pole. China -> Dr Ouyang Ziyuan, lauded as the father of China’s lunar exploration programme, told the Chinese-language Science Times newspaper that the Chandrayaan-3 landing site, at 69 degrees south latitude, was nowhere close to the pole, defined as between 88.5 and 90 degrees.
China just rescheduled its moon mission. Manned missiion will be in 2028, 2 years earlier than the previous plan. All the research of needed equipments and hardware has been finished. Now they enters prototype stage.
It's bizarre that USA lost the technology and know how as to how to go to the moon. Now they say that today's technology can't be used to cross the Van Allen belt safely, but how did they do that in the 60s and 70s ?
They landed at 69 degrees South latitude. That's nowhere near the South Pole. They were many hundreds of kilometers from the actual Pole. That's like going to Norway and saying you're at the North Pole or going to Texas and saying you're at the Equator.
When US was confident: ...a giant leap for mankind. Nowadays: I don't want China to get there first. Also, China: let's send our best astronauts. US: let's make sure a woman stands at the front, followed by a black guy.
@@gives_bad_advice AI is not there yet also the lunar soil is greatly damaging to electronics so they will need constant maintenance, this missions will occur relatively pretty soon now so there is no point in reinventing the lunar mission so late in development also sends a more powerful message than simply having some robots that can't even work anyways
@@justinandreiminatejada So the motivation to send men to the moon, since 1972 would be to send a message? What would the message be and who would it be for? Want the message sent to the Soviets in the first 9 manned missions enough? I'm not convinced that there has been enough reason to go in the last 52 years, considering the cost and danger of attempting it.
@@gives_bad_advice the reason to go to the moon is because lunar ice has been found on the polar south of the moon in 2009 starting the second space race cause water could make a permanent moonbase the problem is if china wins is unlikely they will allow any more countries to participate, so the stakes are even higher than the space race
'You can't claim territory on the moon. So anyway, we made 'the artemis accords' where we say we can claim territory on the moon. But for some reason, china thinks we're claiming territory on the moon' Yeah, its hard to figure out where they got that idea.
I don't know about oil but there's an infinite universe with infinite resources out there and mining in other planets wouldn't be as harmful as in Earth
Two out of the best 3 space agencies of the World (Russia/USA/China) said India did not land on Moon's South Pole. 1) NASA specifically said "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located about 600 kilometers from the Moon’s South Pole.". This is just another diplomatic way of saying India did not land on Moon's South Pole. If India had landed on on Moon's South Pole, NASA would have simply said that "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located at the Moon’s South Pole" instead of "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located about 600 KILOMETERS FROM the Moon’s South Pole. 2) Dr Ouyang Ziyuan, lauded as the father of China’s lunar exploration programme, told the Chinese-language Science Times newspaper that the Chandrayaan-3 landing site, at 69 degrees south latitude, was nowhere close to the pole, defined as between 88.5 and 90 degrees. What does that mean? Some country (IN) has honesty issues?
china isn't really racing though, we've already won the space race by getting there first. They've been planning this since 2000s and aren't going to stop until they go or die trying
You're not wrong per se, but there are different forms of race. If China manages to establish a permanent presence on the moon, that will be a significant first too.
@@nuppalap I do believe it happened I was 9 growing up during the Cold War. I truly believe the USSR would not have let us fake it and get away with it. They were the Evil Empire for real They be screaming to the high heavens it was not real But even Putin doesn’t dispute it happened
@@nuppalap We know, 100% that the original moon landings were real. It’s literally impossible to fake, especially in 1969. Think about a football stadium. 60,000 people in the stands. You claim that you will walk from the goal line on one side to the goal line on the other side. Except you don’t actually do it. I’m pretty sure the people in the stands would notice that you didn’t cross the field. THAT is how difficult it is to fake going to the moon.
China recently indicates all the preparation for his men moon landing project has gone very smoothly so that his first mission could start as early as 2028.
After watching this program, we actually should worry about US intentions. Not China’s. US is planning commercialise moon for the benefit of few companies. Thanks for opening up our eyes.
it looks to me like NASA had no choice but to use private companies. some private companies eclipse their tiny budget many time over and because politics, its nearly impossible to match what China can do with their government backed version of NASA. remains to be seen if relying on private companies was a great idea.
CNSA ( CHINA's counterpart of US's NASA) too distribute their projects and launch vehicle development to Private companies. Infact INDIA & JAPAN too di that to an fair extent.
Truly amazing that after 50 years of science we are on the cusp on developing the technology to not only send a woman, but also a person of color to the moon.
India lost the space race ages ago. *Rovers on Mars:* China: Yes India: No *WORKING Rovers on the Moon:* China: Yes India: No *Humans in space:* China: Yes India: No *Space station in space:* China: Yes India: No *Lunar samples:* China: Yes India: No *ISS membership* China: What? India: No and nothing. *7nm Chips mass production* China: Yes India: Potato chips *Methane rocket in space orbit:* China: Yes, first country to do it India: No. Yet, the Indian bots think they are better.
And ironically America as a nation is the biggest dictator on this planet.They banned NASA from cooperating with China,they don't want China to compete in space exploration in the first place, It's not China wants to compete with the US in a race of bringing human back to the moon, it's the US wanna maintain its hegemony,so they can't be inferior in any field,which makes them look weak,it exactly is a cold-war ideology.But China doesn't even say it's competing with USA in space exploration since they clearly know they are behind.
The winner focuses on winning. The loser focuses on the winner
You cannot focus on two things in your life?
@@gives_bad_advicehere comes the loser 😂
@@daneNoza Nice of you to announce your arrival.
@@gives_bad_advice to be fair, he does gives bad advice.
No, the winner focuses on itself, winning isnt the purpose, keep exceeding itself of yesterday is
China have never said the race of landing lunar ,but the western media is keen to rendering the competition
我们不参与竞赛，因为我们不是发达国家，我们的人民还没有全部脱离贫困，我们按照计划前进，其他国家的快慢和我们无关，成为第一名不是我们的目标，不断前进才是
everything is race from western perspective
以前一直被媒体宣传中国喜欢排名，比较，但是现在越来越觉得西方特别是美国就喜欢在那里鼓吹排名竞争。实在看不出他们所谓的松弛感在哪里。
It’s all over Chinese Medias 😅
@@yeshao-ml7sk 但我遥遥领先，我要为世界新秩序指明方向， 东升西降。 时和势在我方。 责任全在对方。
"China did not sign on the Artemis project"... Well, china has been excluded from any American space program since decades. Just to say how bias this film is...
yes, ture
Artemis “Accords” not “project”. It’s a legal framework that sets the rules for the extraction of resources in space. That’s what China didn’t sign. They were not excluded from this.
@@gabrielgustavson22 Wikipedia: The Wolf Amendment is a law passed by the United States Congress in 2011, named after then-United States Representative Frank Wolf, that prohibits the United States National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) from using government funds to engage in direct, bilateral cooperation with the Chinese government...
What do you expect from this propaganda piece?
@@qinxinghuawumao
You excluded China from ISS, and you think China would be accepted to your moon club without major sacrifice of it's own independence? How hypocritical!
Do all the analysis from any angle, just one thing guys - there is no race on China side. The road map of Moon Exploration was setup a decade ago, they are just progressing as planned.
有趣的是美国60年代就登月了，并且在月球上开车😂他们还告诉世界月球的另一边是黑暗的😂，而今天中国刚登月，就发现了地球未见过的新矿石，并且还发现月球有水存在
Well~ all bad students do not do their homework, the one who does looks odd~
@@xwqiThis is misinformation
Leave the moon problem to China, and let Amurica focus on the more important issues like toilet choices...
Americans are worried someone gets to the moon first and realizes there is no American flag
😅😅😅😅😅
There are six flags. And China is one of four countries to have photographed them in the past 20 years.
@@gives_bad_advice哪里？
The Chinese government literally confirmed the usa flag on the moon🤣 Don't you think they would've tried outting the usa if they faked the landing?
That would a bummer no doubt
I wish China succeed in that.
They don’t want China to get there first but then they are like: it’s too expensive we don’t know if it’s worth it. 🤡
True, the trillions for war isn't expensive =/ but ya war big business
I would rather see my tax money wasted on possible frontier tech, rather than seeing my country miss megatrends of history. Germany can relate here...
laughable indeed. I feel China will overtake us at some point we only have our inept gov to thank for it.
Ong they had half a century
Non-human bases on far side
Why do US care so much about China?? Just leave China alone!!
and than, what can they do?
我懒得翻译英文了，就用中文说吧。中国从来不搞什么军备竞赛，太空竞赛，很早就说了，我们是一步一个脚印的发展，其实就是人类正常发展罢了。当年西方也是这么搞工业革命的，只是美国走歪了。你看看美国太空都半个世纪没进步了，甚至宇航服都还是用50年前的产品，也就是材料学一点进步都没。这就是资本社会的弊端了，没利益就不发展，一直吃老本，人类再不走出太空，真就要卡在地球一辈子了，毕竟地球资源就这么多，不蹭着还有石油的时候出去，等再过百年，就难了。还有真别以为中国科技是突然爆发的，事实上光是一个登月车，从8年前就开始研究了好几代了，只是我们不会好大喜功，不像西方那样，做个PPT都要大肆宣传。搞科研就要这样沉下心，而不是做出点什么就要满世界都知道一样。
US: banned China from ISS
China : developed its own SS
US: you started a war!
Ccp bot?🤡
@@Aadarsh__purush "@elonmusk: Indian nationalist bots are at work!"
@@Aadarsh__purush American bot😂
Cia bot🤡🤡🤡🤡@@Aadarsh__purush
@@Aadarsh__purush CIA bot 🤣👉
Sorry but not sorry, I kinda root for China
Chinese built a new Space Station, landed on the dark side of the moon, got the world's first samples from there. Serious how can you call it a competition when they are way way ahead.
Thank u!
But, this is bloominberg.
@@DorJinTango china ! ❤ From India instead of fighting we can co-operate in science and technology it could help the humanity 😊
@@adityakumarranjan4429 yes bro
DARK SIDE?
There no dark side genius
I honestly hope China can actually accomplish something. Maybe that will convince the West, mostly America, to finally get off their butts and take space seriously again.
@ar1sm70 far side of moon sample return. That is an accomplishment. 2028 propose tianwen 3 mars sample return mission. Nasa msr doesn't even a launch date
They are
As a person who watches China's development, I'm amazed at how different China and the West is in terms of managing society. The West tends to let private sector decide, and its society is "gone with the wind". They go through history typically aimlessly. In China, the government is the leading force. They have plan and long-term vision. No one can predict the future, but by having long-term vision, one can follow through challenging goals. The leadership (in China) can adapt to new circumstances quickly if it is worth it. For example, Fusion tech is far from reality (it may take 40 years more). So China now focuses on Green Energy (Solar, Wind) as well as Thorium-based nuclear power. But if someday someguy figures out how to exactly solve Fusion issue, China can rapidly adapt to the new direction. And in this case, no one in Chinese society would complain (or be allowed to complain) about wasteful resources for Thorium-based ones.
I hope China's success on the moon will help the US space industry get out of the handcuff of FAA.
@@oceanwave4502 I'm a Chinese living in China. The CCP's way is not sustainable.
“We haven’t been to the moon in decades” Bruhh we haven’t been there at all😂😂😂
You see how China, uses competition, and competitive education to put people in the right place to outcompete US. While America uses it's power to bend rules to slow down China's progress. China was banned from ISS and then it made it's own space station. If everyone else is allowed to learn, why can't China? Because China could actually become better? China should continue what it is best at, observing, re-engineering, innovating and competing.
❤🎉
China is expansionist danger for neighbour's countries
你不光漂亮，而且很有头脑，赞
Who cares? All nations should be more worried about this Planet instead of wanting to destroy others.
China is more a Meritocracy than the USA. Notice how so many East Asians in USA still encounter a Bamboo ceiling in the US corporations.
MWF, China is collapsing; TThS, China is threatening. Sunday, take a break😂
媒体这一行业真是让人无语😅BGM选择，画面构图，将美国当做英雄和希望，中国给予紧张和不安的BGM，编造事实，不知不觉进行美式宣传😂中国媒体的宣传实在不如呀，不知道官媒来学习不？😂
大学急需开一门西方新闻学😂
学习这些做什么？为了什么？会产生什么？为了制造“中国优先和例外论”?脚踏实地做好我们应该做的事，让结果来验证就好。这就是萌芽，自然的力量。
@@rayhuang6155 学习这些不一定是以牙还牙，而是学会如何预防西方媒体的造谣，不然有些被动。
不能学这个，因为中国社会不如美国经折腾，带节奏发动群众式的宣传手法容易被反噬。
整个有关都是西方价值体系的体现，没封了中国媒体账号已经是白左网开一面了。真让美国优先把控了喉舌你看看整页都会给你推荐自由亚洲等一堆狗屎内容
If all goes well...the Chinese will actually be the FIRST 😂 on the moon
I guess we're slowly reaching next season of "For all mankind".
we have not even started it yet
Another FAM fan!
story of Season 2 or 3 right, after water its Helium 3 😆
@@tonystark2115 yep season 1 water is found, season 3 helium 3 is used for nuclear fusion
Yeah, on the moon, not in hollywood
Dont make me laugh
What U.S space program 😂
NASA cant even get their own men back from ISS
Its Elon's space program 😊
The first moon race was done in a Hollywood movie studio.
The reason I struggle to believe the Lunar landings actually happened is, when Nasa decided to go back to the moon in 2012 or whenever it was, they should have been able to do it in easily under 5 years...and yet we are still waiting for them to return. I mean they had the launch, ferry and landing tech sorted in the 1970s, knew how much it costs, and basically knew everything else. Lets assume 1-2 year for redesing and modifications, 1-2 year for testing, another year for fixing any bugs, 3 years of astronaught training alongside it. Thats 5 years. They dont need to wait for launch windows either. There is only minor RnD extra costs...it just doesnt make sense.
But wouldn't the Russians be the first to point it out if they didn't?
We had told that Americans went to the moon in 1969. How come after 55 years later, we all have difficulty to back to moon again including the u.s even with more advanced technologies today???
So Bloomberg only mentions India when they specifically get negative topics.
yep they did not mention the discovery of water and first to reach on south pole by india.
@@rajsharmaaaaaaaaaa You lost the race ages ago. China/Russia/US reaches Moon far earlier than India.
Today, we give 4 years to NASA, Space X and India to land an unmanned craft on the far sight of the moon. Sprouting nonsense everyday how powerful their rockets are. Landing on the moon is not easy for America. Talk is no use.?? China is the leader in space.
you thought western media gives credit to anyone but themselves? the west is not your friend
Typical western media
America should bring home the two stranded astrounauts in ISS.
Stranded because of reliance on Indian engineers with fake degrees.
When Americans say for all mankind, they mean that they are the greatest of all mankind.
"for all mankind"
NASA conducted the entire Apollo mission in the open for everyone around the world to see both their successess and failures. The Soviets conducted their programs in secret, only revealing what they had done after of it was done and if it worked out.
America showed that an open society could work better than a closed one.
When Bill Nelson said, “A giant leap for all humanity.” That “humanity” didn’t include China(because it is the US’s adversary) and countries from the global south(because they don’t have the science and financial capabilities). Probably nothing 🤦🏼♂️🤷🏼♂️
The introduction of private companies in exploration is like the exploration of the "New World" in the 1600s like the Dutch East India Company
👍 history is repeating itself in another dimension
No, it isn't. Please explain because I'm not seeing the similarities at all beyond the very basic and obvious business instead of government.
又一次殖民主义么？别忘了带上鸦片和枪炮，对了，还有胡说八道的圣经
just no natives to exploit this time
@@Global-yt 🤡
China's success in moon exploration will ensure a gaint leap towards humanity
The usa alway assumed that the moon belong to them only.... hahaha.
Wow. He had to emphasize "white" Americans...
yes, its shameful that only white men were sacrificed for expirimental and deadly forms of travel.
Yea, what’s the deal with that , why they make it sound like that
It's how they promote the continuance of racism. Like how this vid distracts us from the aliens at play.
Racism 101
They don't like the fact first human on moon was a white man. They can never change that for all eternity@@robertojofre15
I want to know why the United States landed on the moon more than 50 years ago but can't now. Has space technology stopped developing for more than 50 years?
The Artemis Accords is nothing to brag about as most of the signers have nothing to do with space like Angola, Armenia, Dominican Republic, Liechtenstein, Luxemburg, Nigeria, Rwanda, Cyprus, Peru, Columbia, Ecuador
USA is concerned about China because China has its own independent Baidu, Alibaba, Huawei, its Beidou Navigational system, her own Space station, etc...
Thank you for specifying that the first ones were all white men whilst showing a picture of all white men.
Don't think i would have come to that same conclusion without Bloomberg's help
Color of skin is meaningless, we are all the same. Unless of course white ppl did something first. Then its important to point it out.
@@stevefink6000 but it was always the white people who started racism against other skin colour people.
i thought the same when they said the next mission has a woman and a person of colour. I thought that was clear when we saw the woman and black man on screen but I guess it needed to be explicitly called out
It amazes me how much more difficult it's become getting to the moon when we did it in the 60s.
US: banned China from ISS
China : developed its own SS
US: you started a war!
I'm starting to think the 60"s landing was faked!
@@BrunoDias1234 you ok bot? You keep repeating the same things 😂
@@elpenprice679 "@elonmusk: Indian nationalist bots are at work!"
No, it's orders of magnitude easier now in a lot of ways. We're just spending a LOT less money now is all.
Wasnt it Chandrayan 1 that discovered water on moon?
yes it was....but sushh US is all focused on beating China right now, it doesnt need any distractions from India 😂
Yes it was isro
India and the US spotted water from far. China found the H2O molecule in the sample brought back from the moon.
@@kalipotmengincorrect
@@Cryspio Did India bring any lunar sample back on earth to find physical water molecules?
India must feel like Milton from the Office Space, after watching this joke of a documentary.
India is in the club ? India is 50 years behind USA & 30 years behind China in space. China landed rovers on planet Mars & send samples from Moon's far side back to earth. ISRO should be compared to & Competes with JAXA ( Japan's space agency ). It's nowhere close to China or NASA
Nobody have ever been on the moon.china maybe the 1st
Let's say if America won this round of space race against China, the real question is will America continue the space exploration and beyond, or simply ignore it again just like after winning of the last space race against USSR?
I don't think they will, cuz even if they landed people first. Remember China is not in the race, the Americans are calling it a race. China is just minding their business in achieving their goals and plans. So even if they so called win the race they will have to continue cuz if they leave it China will surpass them and they don't want that and i don't think China will stop at the moon cuz they already have plans for mars.
They will have to keep going, because last time the USSR dissolved.
The new race to the moon is not just about reaching it again; it's about establishing a sustainable presence, unlocking scientific and economic opportunities, and ushering in a new era of human space exploration.
Bollywood scripts changes all the time. Prior to NASA and China's statement that India never reached the South Pole of the Moon, Indians say that they are first country to reach the Moon's South Pole. Now, P.Veeramhthuvel, director Chandrayann-3 project, said: We became the first country to go to the, *Near* to the South Pole of the Moon . Notice how fast Bollywood script changes so quickly? Honesty Issues.
USA -> NASA specifically said "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located about 600 kilometers from the Moon’s South Pole.". This is just another diplomatic way of saying India did not land on Moon's South Pole. If India had landed on on Moon's South Pole, NASA would have simply said that "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located at the Moon’s South Pole" instead of "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located about 600 KILOMETERS FROM the Moon’s South Pole.
China -> Dr Ouyang Ziyuan, lauded as the father of China’s lunar exploration programme, told the Chinese-language Science Times newspaper that the Chandrayaan-3 landing site, at 69 degrees south latitude, was nowhere close to the pole, defined as between 88.5 and 90 degrees.
"we are in a space race" lol. I think China is jsut doing its own thing
China just rescheduled its moon mission. Manned missiion will be in 2028, 2 years earlier than the previous plan. All the research of needed equipments and hardware has been finished. Now they enters prototype stage.
When I did chemistry, Lithium wasn't a rare earth metal. Has it muscled its way across the Periodic Table?
It's about demand and supply! Today's world runs on battery!
An arts graduate wrote the script. Says all you need to know.
Lithium is so valuable, its worth mining it on the moon and shipping it with a rocket to earth to process it. It's not even that heavy.
Lithium is one of the most abundant elements on earth and the solar system. its not rare at all.
India discovered water on the moon
Are you the one from Microsoft computer service call centre in California ?
@@jer33.33Ah you mean that Microsoft whose CEO is an Indian
@@jer33.33 but he is definitely not one who participates in mass school shooting
yes in 2008 by chandrayan 1
@@jer33.33 no most probably he is some IT ENGINEER working in google or mircosoft
It's bizarre that USA lost the technology and know how as to how to go to the moon. Now they say that today's technology can't be used to cross the Van Allen belt safely, but how did they do that in the 60s and 70s ?
They didn't. They're still trying to figure out how to cross the VARB safely, because no one (in history) ever has.
Deliberately ignored India's discovery of water on moon's South Pole.
Americans discovered it, yall are our customer support staff 😂
@@nathan4648You know nothing, do you?
@@nathan4648 say's someone who doesn't know anything about space missions
@@nathan4648india was the first one to land on south pole. Of moon moreover finding proofs of water
@@nathan4648 I dont think your joke was taken lightly seeing those comments later. lol
So they hyped up the Lunar South Pole throughout the video and didn't even mention India already landed there!??
They landed at 69 degrees South latitude. That's nowhere near the South Pole. They were many hundreds of kilometers from the actual Pole. That's like going to Norway and saying you're at the North Pole or going to Texas and saying you're at the Equator.
Talking about humans
India didn't land on the South pole
😅Indians have their standard about pole
Didn't land on the South Pole but the closest one yet
When US was confident: ...a giant leap for mankind. Nowadays: I don't want China to get there first.
Also, China: let's send our best astronauts. US: let's make sure a woman stands at the front, followed by a black guy.
所以那么多次阿波罗任务，一次都没有发现水的证据么？
If US NASA had landed on the moon some 50 year ago, it is not logical US can't do it now unless it really hasn't landed at all !!!
What would be the motivation to do it again? What can a man do on the moon that a robot cannot?
@@gives_bad_advice AI is not there yet also the lunar soil is greatly damaging to electronics so they will need constant maintenance, this missions will occur relatively pretty soon now so there is no point in reinventing the lunar mission so late in development also sends a more powerful message than simply having some robots that can't even work anyways
@@justinandreiminatejada So the motivation to send men to the moon, since 1972 would be to send a message? What would the message be and who would it be for? Want the message sent to the Soviets in the first 9 manned missions enough? I'm not convinced that there has been enough reason to go in the last 52 years, considering the cost and danger of attempting it.
@@gives_bad_advice the reason to go to the moon is because lunar ice has been found on the polar south of the moon in 2009 starting the second space race cause water could make a permanent moonbase the problem is if china wins is unlikely they will allow any more countries to participate, so the stakes are even higher than the space race
Bring back my sister, Sunitha Williams
7:14 'rare earth metals like lithium' suddenly I'm sceptical about how well researched this is
Ikr lithium is neither a rare earth metal nor abundant on the moon
The only reason American going back to moon is because Chinese is going.
India found the water on the moon
印度人喜欢制作假新闻，印度人却信以为真。
印度人是觉得其他国家的人都不知道真相吗？印度啥都没有，都不具备登陆月球和获取月球土壤并带回地球的能力。却在这造谣说印度最先发现水。
谎言说一万遍也是谎言，印度人应该改变说大话的习惯。
@@polestarli3091 fake chinese
You are not even living in china 😢😢😢
No water was found sorry
Curry, not water.
@@GovtExamPrepHub yep, the author of this video should apologize to India & change the title to "India has won the second space race to moon" 😮😮
‘Second' Moon Race...hmmmm👏👏👏👏👏
'You can't claim territory on the moon. So anyway, we made 'the artemis accords' where we say we can claim territory on the moon. But for some reason, china thinks we're claiming territory on the moon'
Yeah, its hard to figure out where they got that idea.
Indian cabinet finally approved Chandrayaan 4 today 😊❤️🇮🇳👍
Also approved Venus orbiter mission, and construction of first module of Bhartiya Antriksh Station
It will be delayed by 20 years. Not the scientists but the politics will fail the mission.
ISRO's been cooking a lot lately and I'm here for it!
What's the mission goal, a workable rover?
@@rupertgarcia chandrayan 2 failed, chandrayan 3 achieved in landing but their rover failed.
Dont let the hype blind you
We just need to find oil on the moon and the race will be over with the obvious winner ;)
Oil is helium. ❤
I don't know about oil but there's an infinite universe with infinite resources out there and mining in other planets wouldn't be as harmful as in Earth
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤❤
Question should really be, did the Americans really go to the moon in the 1960s and 70s?
Water was first discovered by India in 2008 probably.
water is actually one of the most common elements in the universe
@@blakespower do you understand the meaning of 'discovered'? Have you ever been to a school?
@@NeilBiswasT90 go and edit your orginal comment. You didn't mention moon
Also mention it was American equipment btw
@@blazer9547 तो..?
भारतीय चंद्रयान ने ही पानी की खोज की चंद्रमा पर
@@NeilBiswasT90 no I grew up with a roaming band of chipmunks we got intelligents by eating nuts
This video is about China's leap towards the space dominace why Indian are so buggy in comment section ?
Water on moon discovered by india (ISRO) in 2008, jealousy can be seen in your video 😂😂😂
No. Apollo 14 did it way earlier. Lying is considered a virtue as per Indian culture.
@@INDIANSARESICKMENOFASIA user name checks out
@@-Blue-_ The national average IQ of India is 76. This fact, checks out.
Water on the Moon was first definitively detected by India's Chandrayaan-1 mission in 2008.
@@Amoghavarsha. Apollo 14 did it in year 1971. Try harder.
Two out of the best 3 space agencies of the World (Russia/USA/China) said India did not land on Moon's South Pole.
1) NASA specifically said "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located about 600 kilometers from the Moon’s South Pole.". This is just another diplomatic way of saying India did not land on Moon's South Pole. If India had landed on on Moon's South Pole, NASA would have simply said that "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located at the Moon’s South Pole" instead of "The Chandrayaan-3 landing site is located about 600 KILOMETERS FROM the Moon’s South Pole.
2) Dr Ouyang Ziyuan, lauded as the father of China’s lunar exploration programme, told the Chinese-language Science Times newspaper that the Chandrayaan-3 landing site, at 69 degrees south latitude, was nowhere close to the pole, defined as between 88.5 and 90 degrees.
What does that mean? Some country (IN) has honesty issues?
India is the first country to find traces of water on the surface of moon back in 2008. Why you people always whitewash history?
Leave it bro. Let them claim it. They already washing most of the history and have no guts to accept the actual truth.
looks like brown washing to me
ISRO launched it equipment was from NASA
they also did land on their first attempt
@@gameplayguru5805yup.. thematn the precise definition...
India achievement currently is hv cheap a space robotic mission can be.
Win second moon race ? That title made me laugh because you don't win when you came in second place after many many years after that.
Again and again, on the moon, we have already been there more than 50 years ago...
china isn't really racing though, we've already won the space race by getting there first. They've been planning this since 2000s and aren't going to stop until they go or die trying
You're not wrong per se, but there are different forms of race. If China manages to establish a permanent presence on the moon, that will be a significant first too.
US: banned China from ISS
China : developed its own SS
US: you started a war!
By that logic the soviets won the space race lol. When does it end? At Mars? At Europa? At Titan?
@thunbearables China tianwen 3 mars sample return mission to be launch in 2028 while nasa msr doesn't have a launch date
@@DudeNoEdge FTL.
Are you sure the moon landing in 1960s was not a movie? How come the American could do that ages ago but can't do that again now?
You lost me when you complained the moon astronauts we’re all white Americans men. Yes so what ? It was a different time
The media can’t let an opportunity go, to do some race baiting
Exactly. Feel like this is BS. First of all, we still don't know if the "original" landing is even real. Conspiracists say otherwise.
@@nuppalap I do believe it happened I was 9 growing up during the Cold War. I truly believe the USSR would not have let us fake it and get away with it. They were the Evil Empire for real They be screaming to the high heavens it was not real But even Putin doesn’t dispute it happened
@@nuppalap
We know, 100% that the original moon landings were real. It’s literally impossible to fake, especially in 1969.
Think about a football stadium. 60,000 people in the stands. You claim that you will walk from the goal line on one side to the goal line on the other side. Except you don’t actually do it. I’m pretty sure the people in the stands would notice that you didn’t cross the field.
THAT is how difficult it is to fake going to the moon.
I thought the exact same thing and made a similar comment.
Really?? How was the technology in USA back in the 60’s enabling astronauts to reach and land to the moon??
South Africa is joining the race to go the moon as well 🇿🇦💪🏿
When bro
Hah hah hah, pull my other leg too. They only will get there by piggybacking on the back of a more successful, less corrupt nation.
Whoever gets to the moon first second or third will carve it up just like they did the New World between Portugal, Spain, France, and Great Britain
the moon is a spaceship with an owner, and no one will divide the moon
Still no one can explain to how we went to moon in the 1960s but cannot go back before anyone else? Could've been fake?
Water on moon -india
First country to land on south pole -india
Wake up jealous 😂😂😂😂
Ya
It's not it's just 3rd confirmation 😕
Absolutely right 👍 Western media is always biased.
Did a person from India confirm this in person? Uhh, no.
India is No 1, 20 years ahead of China, What so said Race between USA and China are nonsense! India rules the space. 😎
China usa russia and now india
We come here in Peace, for all Mankind. ❤
China recently indicates all the preparation for his men moon landing project has gone very smoothly so that his first mission could start as early as 2028.
With Bill Nelson as Chief of Nasa, He doesnt even know the dark side of the moon is bright lol
Lithium may be rare on Earth, but it is not a rare earth metal
Lithium is not rare at all. Its one of the most abundant elements on earth and the solar system.
Lithium is not rare....
It's not rare, I take lithium every day.
It’s the same thing all over. First the rush to own the oil, now to own the water in moon.
Stop faa from slowing spacex progress. And you will get there first
After watching this program, we actually should worry about US intentions. Not China’s. US is planning commercialise moon for the benefit of few companies. Thanks for opening up our eyes.
Sounds like the main goal here is to mine the moon😂😅😂
Competition with China is one of the only reasons NASA gets funding these days. 😂
China will beat the U.S to the moon hands down.
it looks to me like NASA had no choice but to use private companies. some private companies eclipse their tiny budget many time over and because politics, its nearly impossible to match what China can do with their government backed version of NASA. remains to be seen if relying on private companies was a great idea.
CNSA ( CHINA's counterpart of US's NASA) too distribute their projects and launch vehicle development to Private companies. Infact INDIA & JAPAN too di that to an fair extent.
I always baffled the term person of color. Don't we all have colors? Last time I check. Europeans and their descendants are not transparent.
Companies like Rocketlab, Intuitive Machines and SpaceX will create the landscape for our future on the moon. Exciting times!
YES. the latter two are publically traded companies. Get them while they are young.
US is ahead now in space technology, why is it so concerned that others may catch up?
Truly amazing that after 50 years of science we are on the cusp on developing the technology to not only send a woman, but also a person of color to the moon.
The issue is, USA never been there
Because others are catching to America. Done, saved you the whole video.
If oil is discovered on the moon, the U.S. military will be the first to arrive。lmao
India lost the space race ages ago.
*Rovers on Mars:*
China: Yes
India: No
*WORKING Rovers on the Moon:*
China: Yes
India: No
*Humans in space:*
China: Yes
India: No
*Space station in space:*
China: Yes
India: No
*Lunar samples:*
China: Yes
India: No
*ISS membership*
China: What?
India: No and nothing.
*7nm Chips mass production*
China: Yes
India: Potato chips
*Methane rocket in space orbit:*
China: Yes, first country to do it
India: No.
Yet, the Indian bots think they are better.
मंगलयान 2 मंगल ग्रह पर रोवर उतारेगा और चंद्र यान 4 चंद्रमा पर रोवर उतारेगा और साथ मे सेंपल भी लायेगा
गगनयान मिशन जल्द ही शुरू होने वाला है देखता रह बेटा
मैथेन रोकेट बडी चीज नही है देखता रह बेटा
@@Sanatani_kattar Sorry, I do not understand 3rd world languages, especially Hindi or any other Indian languages.
中国有句话说的好，等你做到了再和别人说话，而不是空想未来。@@Sanatani_kattar
The most funny is if china say i don't want go to moon again. Suddenly US also canceled to go moon 😂
I hope China or India or any private companies can stay on the moon and mars, to show to the west aka USA, how it's done.
India is planning to establish a permanently manned Moon base in the 2040s.
@death_parade yeah it's a little late but it's worth the wait.
It's sad that it needs to be a competition with dictators in order for us to explore space. Whatever it takes, I guess.
And ironically America as a nation is the biggest dictator on this planet.They banned NASA from cooperating with China,they don't want China to compete in space exploration in the first place, It's not China wants to compete with the US in a race of bringing human back to the moon, it's the US wanna maintain its hegemony,so they can't be inferior in any field,which makes them look weak,it exactly is a cold-war ideology.But China doesn't even say it's competing with USA in space exploration since they clearly know they are behind.