Ya know, for ALL the people who rip on Gwen for the cover...a cover is the highest form of flattery for an artist can receive from someone else...this is nicely done
Screw the haters, Gwen and Eric did it really nice and besides, it's not an official recording so what's the point of bashing it. They were just playing around with the song.
okay people, it wasn't even a cover. it was just her and her brother playing a beatles song. she didn't claim it as her own or anything. just a fun testing demo. everyone needs to chill out. it sound lovely anyway!
God, listen to the audio quality, people. This is at least three years old and it hasn't made it's way onto any albums. She was obviously just having fun, calm down.
i agree, it a good song, i mean its better than mansons coverand avril's chop suey, but i still dont like it when random starts become famous and dont have nearly as much talent (because you dont need it that much to make it big these days) and decide to do a cover of a really good artist. but atleast she did a good job, if she did a bad job i actually be pissed
why are yo guys watching it if you don't like it? she sounds well.... not really good but she did not kill the song for saint god are you guys kids? :/
Interesting bit of audio. I'm impressed that she knows about The Beatles and Strawberry Fields Forever - and that she actually made this demo / tribute / recording. Not great, but then again, it's an early recording and probably wasn't ever intended to make it into the studio. Got to give her credit for her song choice though.
@ForTheBeatles4 Hey, buddy....How do I say this. The whole point of a cover isn't really suppose to try and do a song better. It's to show appreciation for the song, and try to put your own spin on it, kind of like the Johnny Cash cover of NIN's Hurt. Johnny Cash, took the song, and poured his emotions into it. Making it a different song. Now I do agree, this is a horrible cover, but It's kind of pointless to say she will never be better than the Beatles because she wasn't trying to.
Awesome gwen I love this song strawberry fields forever.special something in my heart .but you sound great .these vlpeople def. Have their eyes closed d .love your voice.its always so pretty nomatter w hat you sing .I lovr john Lennon and the Beatles. And you and NODOUBT. You rock andnomatter w hat you sing, its always AMAZING. Love you l.s.♥
Aye, Gwen Stefani's trying to sound like John Lennon here. Without a shadow of a doubt. She was probably dressed like him when they were recording this, Adrian Young was Yoko Ono. As always, excellent perception on the comments page.
All of the beatles songs are credited Lennon/McCartney except for those who wrote George Harrison or Ringo. To your information Michael Jackson sold back the 50 percent of that catalog to sony. And i said McCartney shoudl sue her in a form of joking not really mean it. He is the person with more rights to do things related to the beatles.
When the Beatles originally recorded it, they played it really fast and the slowed it down before they put it on the album to give it a weird, dreamy feel. Either ND did the same thing, or gwen sang like that on purpose to emulate that type of of sound. That's why she sounds stoned.
I love The Beatles, and I like Gwen. They're two different things, but I think this cover is nice :) because it's just that, a cover. Don't be so hard with her.
i love gwens voice and i have nothing against her but she killed one of the best songs ever. give me as many thumbs down's as you want but she ruined it. the original is way better than this.
HELL NO!! Today's songwriters can't even come close to the songwriting of the sixties. This particular song is by the Beatles. Yes those Beatles, the gods! You were born too late my dear. You missed the magic that was the sixties!
Respond to this video... Perhaps their style did change over time but that doesn't mean they ever reached a point where the sounded that good to mean. That being said even I have a favorite Beatles song. So I do appreciate their place in music history. They deserve it. But, I'd rather listen to THE DOORS any day. I'm sorry if the fact that I have a brain & was able to come to my own conclusion on whether I like something or not offends you.
I'm not sure but I'm guessing this is a very early track from before they made it. Possibly when she was a teen before her singing got better. I don't know for sure.
who in their right mind let gwen stefanie manhandle such a monumental song? what's next; mr. T and tom cruise doing a cover of hey jude?!?!?!? Screw this!
it's not an official cover, come on! this is just for gwen stefani fans who like to listen her idol having fun with his brother, singing another song that is not an ND one. so shut up.
The Beatles were one of the best bands in the world. How could you say they were "just a band"?! I could say that Shes just a singer!! Just a singer!! The original by The Beatles is much better, but this was alright.
I think John Lennon would have liked this. If you listen to the Anthology, this version is pretty much like the bare bones version John did. Ok shoot me!!! lol!!!
@MrMGD92 I was listening to their songs on here so I could say I gave them a fair chance. I don't dislike the Beatles because I want to piss people off. It's just my opinion that 99.9 percent of their music isn't my cup of tea. Yes I said they were overrated. I could've said something far worse but I didn't feel I needed to be that crass.
Oh, the original had more..you know...like it could make you cry. At 1:11 I was expecting some wicked drumming, or brass instruments, or something..but it didn't happen =|
Oh my god.. theyre not trying to be better than the beatles..nor better than the beatles i love the beatles and i'm actually also a ND fan its not as good as the Beatles version obviously, but it doesnt even sound as 'BAD' as you all say it is. Gwen stefani actually does have a really nice voice If you see anyone other than the beatles sing a beatles song of course everyones gunna say it sounds crappy most likely Is it so bad for someone to sing a beatles song?
Seriously, stop saying stuff like '' kill her'' & calling her names just because she convered a song that didn't suit her voice all that well. I'm a HUGE fan of The Beatles, & i also like No Doubt, but common, its a SONG. You don't like it, now move on.
Ya know, for ALL the people who rip on Gwen for the cover...a cover is the highest form of flattery for an artist can receive from someone else...this is nicely done
I like these obscure demos recorded by famous artists.
It's tough to try and cover a Beatles song, especially one written by Lennon.
She's got Balls!!
Screw the haters, Gwen and Eric did it really nice and besides, it's not an official recording so what's the point of bashing it. They were just playing around with the song.
i like it... love her voice
okay people, it wasn't even a cover.
it was just her and her brother playing a beatles song.
she didn't claim it as her own or anything.
just a fun testing demo.
everyone needs to chill out. it sound lovely anyway!
Wow. Really amazing, thanks Gwen wherever you are! Really
brings out the symphonic side of it.
God, listen to the audio quality, people. This is at least three years old and it hasn't made it's way onto any albums. She was obviously just having fun, calm down.
i agree, it a good song, i mean its better than mansons coverand avril's chop suey, but i still dont like it when random starts become famous and dont have nearly as much talent (because you dont need it that much to make it big these days) and decide to do a cover of a really good artist.
but atleast she did a good job, if she did a bad job i actually be pissed
she killed it
why are yo guys watching it if you don't like it? she sounds well.... not really good but she did not kill the song
for saint god are you guys kids? :/
I don't think she and eric are trying to be better than the beatles. It is what it is and I dig it.
i love that she sang this song! are you kidding me! i think she is spot on!
Interesting bit of audio. I'm impressed that she knows about The Beatles and Strawberry Fields Forever - and that she actually made this demo / tribute / recording. Not great, but then again, it's an early recording and probably wasn't ever intended to make it into the studio. Got to give her credit for her song choice though.
I know this comment is very old but how were you surprised a woman born in the late 60s knew about the beatles?
@ForTheBeatles4
Hey, buddy....How do I say this. The whole point of a cover isn't really suppose to try and do a song better. It's to show appreciation for the song, and try to put your own spin on it, kind of like the Johnny Cash cover of NIN's Hurt. Johnny Cash, took the song, and poured his emotions into it. Making it a different song. Now I do agree, this is a horrible cover, but It's kind of pointless to say she will never be better than the Beatles because she wasn't trying to.
all those dislike are not fair she did a good job
She has a nice unique voice. I think this sounds pretty good, actually. :]
Cmon stop bs her... she loves the beatles and I think so do we, she was just singing one of her favourite songs... nobody's perfect... ¬¬
This was CLEARLY done in the mid 90s. If she were to cover this song nowadays she would absolutely KILL IT. In a good way ;)
Awesome gwen I love this song strawberry fields forever.special something in my heart .but you sound great .these vlpeople def. Have their eyes closed d .love your voice.its always so pretty nomatter w hat you sing .I lovr john Lennon and the Beatles. And you and NODOUBT. You rock andnomatter w hat you sing, its always AMAZING. Love you l.s.♥
Aye, Gwen Stefani's trying to sound like John Lennon here. Without a shadow of a doubt. She was probably dressed like him when they were recording this, Adrian Young was Yoko Ono. As always, excellent perception on the comments page.
All of the beatles songs are credited Lennon/McCartney except for those who wrote George Harrison or Ringo. To your information Michael Jackson sold back the 50 percent of that catalog to sony. And i said McCartney shoudl sue her in a form of joking not really mean it. He is the person with more rights to do things related to the beatles.
When the Beatles originally recorded it, they played it really fast and the slowed it down before they put it on the album to give it a weird, dreamy feel. Either ND did the same thing, or gwen sang like that on purpose to emulate that type of of sound. That's why she sounds stoned.
Lovely song, never heard before.
I love The Beatles, and I like Gwen. They're two different things, but I think this cover is nice :) because it's just that, a cover. Don't be so hard with her.
You are right! This wasn't a original song just practice. !hanks for sticking up for gwen! I am a total fan too! Wind It UP!!! G
💖
i love gwens voice and i have nothing against her but she killed one of the best songs ever. give me as many thumbs down's as you want but she ruined it. the original is way better than this.
Sounds great to me. And there's no auto-tune that I can hear, just sounds like Gwen's regular voice.
well of course no one will compare to the original, but this is
a good version
HELL NO!! Today's songwriters can't even come close to the songwriting of the sixties. This particular song is by the Beatles. Yes those Beatles, the gods! You were born too late my dear. You missed the magic that was the sixties!
Love gwen she's beauty with babies♥♥♥♥♥!!!!
I like it. (:
why are you mean? it's a cool cover!!
Respond to this video... Perhaps their style did change over time but that doesn't mean they ever reached a point where the sounded that good to mean. That being said even I have a favorite Beatles song. So I do appreciate their place in music history. They deserve it. But, I'd rather listen to THE DOORS any day. I'm sorry if the fact that I have a brain & was able to come to my own conclusion on whether I like something or not offends you.
it's imperfect, but raw, i like it...
I'm not sure but I'm guessing this is a very early track from before they made it. Possibly when she was a teen before her singing got better.
I don't know for sure.
who in their right mind let gwen stefanie manhandle such a monumental song? what's next; mr. T and tom cruise doing a cover of hey jude?!?!?!? Screw this!
This, my friend, is one of the Internet's dark corners. Filled with trolls.
best comment evarrrrrr
your welcome! great that you can hear it again ^^
i agree.
it's not an official cover, come on! this is just for gwen stefani fans who like to listen her idol having fun with his brother, singing another song that is not an ND one.
so shut up.
The Beatles were one of the best bands in the world. How could you say they were "just a band"?! I could say that Shes just a singer!! Just a singer!!
The original by The Beatles is much better, but this was alright.
that song is just beautiful any way! >=/
i love u gwen!!!
i like this version!
I Love Gwen!!!!!
This own version is so beautiful...
:)
i totally agree with ya man.
GeneralSalt444 you are so right on!!!!
yes she can. this is like years,years ago...
Nice Job
oh and i agree with whoever said this is better than avril covering SOAD's chop suey hahahaha
I will give her this... It's better than The Black Eyed Peas....
@metriobigmactoknowme Have you heard Confortably Numb by the Scissor Siters?
I Luv It. I'd give a lot to be able to sing as good as Gwen ;-p
on what album is that song?
so pretty!!! :)
Hey xsandeex,
Could you also send me this song?
I can't find it on limewire
Greets
oh i ment to put theyre not trying to be better than the beatles once
my bad..
what have The Beatles ever done to her to make her kill their song ?!? :O x
@83GoldenGirl
true!
this is a surprise
i didn't know Gwen sang a beatles song? wow thats a shock
I know! she should've left the song alone!!! she like...killed it....=[
OMG GWEN YOUR MY FUCKING HERO :)
This is beautiful :)
aaaaaaaaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA WTffffffffFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
i like better, than da one form da beatles.. and u know, da beatles was just a band!! just a band!
I am a thumb up. It is a great cover. The title is a bit misleading.
My bad, I mean "the" not 'they'.
God fucking damn it.
@GeneralSalt444 LOL Maybe, Jerry Springer and Vin Diesel can remake No Reply. That would be phenomenal.
I think John Lennon would have liked this. If you listen to the Anthology, this version is pretty much like the bare bones version John did.
Ok shoot me!!! lol!!!
BLOODY HELL!!! BAD BAD BAD BAD.....
the song or the version??
better than avril lavigne covering system of a down's "chop suey"!!! lol.
i love gwen!!
@MrMGD92 I was listening to their songs on here so I could say I gave them a fair chance. I don't dislike the Beatles because I want to piss people off. It's just my opinion that 99.9 percent of their music isn't my cup of tea. Yes I said they were overrated. I could've said something far worse but I didn't feel I needed to be that crass.
not as awful as I thought it would be. glad she's a beatles fan, but that doesn't make up for 'sweet escape'.
million dreams
I thought rape was against the law. If I were McCartney I'd press charges.
whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit
Oh, the original had more..you know...like it could make you cry. At 1:11 I was expecting some wicked drumming, or brass instruments, or something..but it didn't happen =|
Oh my god..
theyre not trying to be better than the beatles..nor better than the beatles
i love the beatles and i'm actually also a ND fan
its not as good as the Beatles version obviously, but it doesnt even sound as 'BAD' as you all say it is. Gwen stefani actually does have a really nice voice
If you see anyone other than the beatles sing a beatles song of course everyones gunna say it sounds crappy most likely
Is it so bad for someone to sing a beatles song?
Seriously, stop saying stuff like '' kill her'' & calling her names just because she convered a song that didn't suit her voice all that well. I'm a HUGE fan of The Beatles, & i also like No Doubt, but common, its a SONG. You don't like it, now move on.
Oh wow, how old is this?
This doesn't even suck that bad :P
@anotherdeadperson she was probably really stoned when she made this..................i can hear it in her voice
completly murdered it.... :(
holy krishna!
Where´s the Beat here!!!!??
she did it as a favour to her brother
WTF SHE CANT DO THAT >:O
I like it, you may not. You have a choice use it and stop wasting your time listening to others actions when you can experience them.
@83GoldenGirl i agree 100% cythia.........
sii la cantan con debbie harry de blondie ^^ pero originalmente es de los beatles
:)
You must be a Gwen Stefani fan, right. If she would only open her mouth when she sings or talks it might help.
I wasnt such a big fan of the original and I dont really get this one :/ her singing voice seems so deep.
Its ok i guess :)
@BeatlesLover39 If she had her choice of drums it would probably be worse.
@ThisYearsGirl91
and they did it twice :D
its not a bad version... its strange...
but people, who can do better than the fab 4?
so we'll keep trying
She should be ashamed for ruining such a great song.... WTF O.o