Was Gundam SEED Freedom Worth The Wait? - *SPOILER FREE* Review
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 авг 2024
- Gundam SEED and Destiny came out 20 years ago - so we've been waiting quite awhile to see what's next for Kira Yamato, Lacus Clyne, Athrun Zala and Shinn Asuka. The Gundam SEED Freedom movie has a lot to live up to, but the question is - was it worth the wait?
✅Support the Channel!
RUclips - / @gundamhq
Patreon - / gundamhq
Buy Gunpla with HLJ! - shop.hlj.com/gundamhq
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Check out our discord! - / discord
TikTok - / gundamhq
Twitter ( X ) - / gundamhq
Instagram - / gundamhq
Facebook - / gundamhq
--------------------------------------------------------------------
0:00 I saw Gundam SEED Freedom.
0:24 What is Gundam SEED Freedom?
0:38 My Problem with the Movie...
1:20 The Endless References
3:22 The Animation Wasn't What I Expected
4:10 The New Gundams
4:26 The Amazing Songs and Returning Artists
5:07 Kira Yamato is Back
6:13 My Thoughts on Lacus Clyne...
6:31 Athrun Zala is Better than Ever
6:51 Shinn Asuka's Redemption
7:22 Fixing Gundam SEED Destiny and Cagalli
7:48 What is the Movie's Reception?
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Music Used At Various Points:
Windmill Isle (Night)
Cool Edge (Night)
Empire City (Night)
Apotos (Night)
Into the World Type 2 - DWG3
#gundam #gundamseed #gundamseedfreedom #seedfreedom #gundamseeddestiny 
Кино
What did you think about the movie? Hoping for a sequel? (PS I'm using the old English Dub names not the new ones )
It became fun when I stopped thinking about how they messed up Lacus/Kira's strong characters.
yea give me seed justice. with a new ij backpack with guns that doesn't make the beams on the wings useless.
I hope there's more SEED honestly. Love the series as a whole. Lol, I haven't seen the remaster so when I heard them pronounce Lacus as Lacoos and Yamato was a bit jarring but apparently Lacus is pronounced like that in Latin?
Well, I can finally say that my love for this franchise is 100% over. Goodbye, Gundam. It's been fun. Time to move on.
The lah-koos killed it so bad let's be real
Them referencing Badriguel and Nicole is really good.
Also SEED is probably the last Gundam series with good battleship combat. This movie doesn’t disappoint on that side. That Millennium mid-air brake moment is so cool.
00 had OK in S2 although poltlmy is OP
Nothing outside of Ptolemy causing a tsunami by diving into the sea, and ptolemy gliding across the orbital elevator on (Arios) Transam and serve as cannon platform for Seravee and Cherudim. Season 1 Ptolemy was designed weapon-less and season 2 Ptolemy Kai also barely had any “standard weaponry”
IBO has that battering ram moment, and AGE has the battleship transforming, that’s it 😂
The whole Badgiruel tactic and the Artemis arc! That’s some of the best stories from way back
Yea its like nicole invented the myriad colloid system when it existed on gundam astray gold frame long before he got his hands on it. Badriguel head into all attack maneuver wouldnt work without the impenetrable shielding.
War tactic wise which is not in oo@@Matanumi
The Rising Freedom grew on me quite a bit. Also the music did fantastically.
Totally grew on me. My favorite freedom now.
And they completely trash it during that OP at the end of the first part
I liked it more than the upgrade
Agnes was the real Seed Freedom we made along the way.
ill give her my seed freedom
🤣 Omg I hate you
A worthy opponent to Quess Paraya.
an insert of the quess for the movie
She still alive though
In Japan during the release of the movie in January they passed out mini novels explaining some of the events that happened between Seed Destiny and Freedom. Like Athrun and Cagalli going on a date, Agnes backstory and some of the cast members just enjoying peace. I really enjoyed it and the few people with me who aren't Gundam fans enjoyed it as well.
Absolute Gundam Peak Cinema
I SEEDed inside the theater when I watched this and when Kira said "I am the Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Freedom" this made it the most mobile suit movie of all time
So funny
When Meteor Started Playing after 2 Machines Docked [[Goosebumps]]
Shinn's character in this movie was honestly the best part for me.
Seeing this soft dorky side of his as he tries his best to help Kira really warmed my heart. And I was jumping around happily when he was destroying the black knights in the destiny Gundam.
“And Destiny for the video I’m working on currently” oh my god thank you 🙏
I hope there will be a Gundam SEED Justice movie focusing on Athrun and Cagalli.
as a shinn fan since a child im glad he’s finally getting respect
The only thing I'm questioning is how they manage to repaired Requiem cannon without alerting either ZAFT or ORB
Any activities in Daedalus lunar base should alerting ZAFT or ORB and inspecting what they did on that base
at least they didnt pull a new genesis on this one
Shinn got redeemed! Love it.
Redeemed? He was exonerated. He kicked some ass in the movie. I enjoyed him so much as a character thanks to the movie.
@@setsuna200 agree 100%. Shinn is my favorite
He was funny because almost any event could make him a Tazmanian Devil :D
but now he got a daddy issue with kira LOL
@@WestbrickFansGotNoBrains Yeah it was like,
Shin: I want to kick some ass with you, please ? 🥹
Kira: No !
Shin: 🥺
100% agree, this needed to be a multi-part OVA.
I fell in love with the Gyan Strom.
Yeah. Breaking of the movie to 12-14 episodes is a great idea.
I'd also be glad if we get +40min episodes featuring Shinns mental and emotional recovery, formation of COMPS Freedom Hijack Incident, Foundation shock and Compasses early operations
The only thing I think this movie really needed was a 30-60 second narration at the start to recap how we got to the beginning of the movie from end of seed destiny. Both as reminders for previous fans who may have forgotten some points and to help new people be able to follow some plot points. This movie felt it at times couldn’t stand alone on its own on its plot especially with all the references thrown in for fan service. Still was very satisfied with the whole thing.
So this movie is basically bad despite it's spectacle? Exactly as expected.
@@myujokt733no
Destiny Gundam Spec 2 was my favorite mobile suit, but i'm a shinn fanboy lol.
Kira in an underpowered freedom really showcased his entire skills,
.
And everyone loves shin in this movie,
Rising freedom actually has better specs than destiny gundam. So, it's not like Kira was using a grunt suit like the Zaku.
@@khadz1705 no
@@khadz1705 how is that even possible when rising freedom has no njammer canceller
@@xiandiv9549 rising freedom has similar specs to Immortal justice gundam. Immortal justice is higher specs than destiny spec 2. So, it goes without saying that Rising freedom is also higher spec than Destiny Spec 2.
@@khadz1705 how do you find the specs?
the producers took the safest route with the least risk. im glad that they did. it was more important that they didnt mess up the movie rather than make a great movie. its been almost 20 years, almost anything they do will leave fans wanting more
Unlike the 00 movie
@@leo11lim Nah the 00 movie implied so obviously that it totally was the end and theres nothing else to add as a sequel anymore
@@leo11lim After that movie, I am glad they didn't milk the 00 series anymore. It's so milquetoast I lost interest in the series entirely lol
It’s way better than the 00 movie at least. I nearly plucked my hair out after watching that damn thing. My fondness for the 00 series was reduced by half because of that movie alone
Seed was a series that dropped and I grew up with. It is my UC timeline. Still love all the timelines but this is special, the first gundam movie I've seen in theaters. Animation was amazing and there was a nice piece from everyone before they bowed out each character.
It feels like a pilot movie to a 3rd season of Seed. I wouldn't mind if they did a 3 part OVA
Same a short series where they could expand on some characters would be cool
OUR LORD AND SAVIOUR IS BACK BOIS
Who?
@@xiandiv9549Kira (jesus) yamato
It was a super fun, fulfilling, and action-packed film! As a SEED fan since 2003, I loved every second of it. Every character was done right, and overall has a wonderful conclusion.
A bit slow for “GSF” cosplays to take off as of now. Oh and Orphee is based on Embryo from “Cross Ange”.
When I watched the movie, I was grinning from ear to ear, beginning to end. So many easter egg and throwbacks to the old series that I couldn't help but going "He/she/it's back!"
Maybe I'm just imagining things, but to me, it seemed like the writers actively used this movie as a way to correct all the things that fans criticized about Seed Destiny: the fact that they made Kira and Lacus into untouchable Jesus-like figures, how Athrun and Cagalli's relationship was screwed over, and Shinn not being able to be the hero in his own show. Add to this how the Destiny Plan was the bad guys' goal again, all the flashbacks to Durandal, and how the last scene with Agnes was a recreation of Shinn's defeat (but with him on the other side now), and it feels like they were trying to "correct" the way Seed Destiny ended.
This movie is fantastic, idc about other upgrades it's pretty much the same except the part where kira goes full franxx, but after 20 years shinn finally shine like the gold he is.
The best part is probably when ramius thrust her angry red rod and come inside Aura's ship. The theater goes wild at that point.
I hope the M.I.B amnesia rod is real so I could enjoy the movie again.
Kira finally got his bright slap
Yes, the answer is yes
Rising freedom really grew on me after the movie. When i first saw the design, I didn't really like it since it just felt off but seeing it in motion was a treat.
The movie was great 🎉
THE MUSIC IS HOLYYYYYYY
this whole movie is a big fan service and im all for it.
Quick fact for people, the script for the movie was completely all the way back in 2008,
the Rising Freedom, EASILY grew on me once more of the trailers came out and when I watched the movie its so peak.
spoilers
I wish IT WAS ON SCREEN MORE !!! FUCK MAN...
(edit: also was cool to see myself in the video ! appreciate you, great videos)
You know To me i think it was worth it because it just feels like a great tribute to how good that show was and how this gundam finally got a movie that featured in the big screen Because of how good it was back in the day and back in its remaster
We need a Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead of the movie following Yzak and Dearka stopping the military coup against the PLANTs. Those characters and that plot point are woefully underserved in the film.
The soundtrack is awesome. Its online now. As a Seed Fan, it was pretty perfect. It could have benefited from a 3 ep OVA like you said for sure but if this is the final time we see these characters, it is a fitting end.
Yes, The most important thing that they did to this movie is the redemtion of Shinn. The director and writer did a great job for him here. Thank you Gundam Seed franchise.
Just watched it today, literally the final theatre showing in my country. My friend and I were laughing throughout the entire movie. It was unexpectedly hilarious...in a perhaps unintentional way.😅 Definitely different than what we expected, but in the best way possible!😁
Slight spoilers: it's much more focused on romance this time around, which is honestly what I came for anyways.😂
It was in 2006 when they started the production of a sequel on Gundam Seed & Gundam Seed Destiny (the 2 Japanese anime series of Gundam) everything was going well for the production until postponement due to the health condition of the writer Chiaki Morosawa then sadly died in 2016. But despite this, in 2019 they resumed pre-production and then finally revealed to us on July 2, 2023 the title is the teaser trailer of the film which will be called "Gundam Seed Freedom".
Since its release in Japan on January 26, 2024, the film has earned over 32 million dollars at the box office, becoming the highest-grossing film in the Gundam series.
Since I learned that on May 14th they revealed that on June 15th & 16th it will be released at the cinema here in Germany I'm surprised that it will be released here in Frankfurt where I wasn't expecting it but in the end on June 16th (on Sunday afternoon) I saw finally at the cinema.
A curiosity that before seeing it at the cinema I had thought that I would be the only one to see the film in which there were not many people but no, in reality there were half people in the room who are interested in seeing this film on how it will end.
_ C. Atausupa 🤖🔥
SPOILER ALERT
The original char theme blasting when athrun comes to save the day in the Z’Gok was just so fun, it’s such a good callback and was one of my favorite moments
Imo worth 20 years maybe questionable but its def worth watching as seed fans. The graphics looks hood. Action scene is good without much reused stuffs. The mecha also nice in general. And shinn got justice he deserved now (not the mecha lol).
Lot references, funny moments, and easter egg which made for seed fans, which is cool. But yea as standlone movie to those who never watch seed, maybe its pretty meh movie lol.
The drawback is villains kinda forgetable (partly coz fast pacing of the movie), their mecha also meh tbh, basically 5 similar mechas. Also too much soap opera and power of love lol (even more than OG seed and destiny imo). And ofc fast pacing as u said, which is still kinda reasonable i guess as we got used to watching seed in 50 episodes......
The villains were a big part of what I was referring to with reused motivations sadly :(
Yeah they really needed to be fleshed out more. We got some Orphee and Shura, and maybe that's all we needed as far as personalities the others well they were there for the laughs and fodder, but still probably could have used a half hour more as far as their creation and their mothers motivations. Its kind of funny Shura is more remembered for what Athurn did to him rather than anything he did.
@@kathilmechworks4895Most of the Accords are just there to fill the role the EA Extendeds would have normally been used for.
Shura and Orphee aside, we got a lot of development out of Ingrid in the movie’s second half. Enough that I was saddened she didn’t survive since there was definitely a story still to tell with her.
you know the big part I liked about the movie was the plot that was going for the plot of lacus and Kira’s and their relationship where It’s being challeng for each of them.
I felt the first half was fuckin amazing and continue the World building of CE that I love so much about it....
The second half.... drops the ball a bit....
But you know what? Shit overall I'm happy with the characters, the world and the story MOVING FORWARD. This movie should have came out in 2008-2010 so we wouldn't be stuck murmuring over the ending events of Destiny and how awful it was ending
They did what they could with 2 hours time but ironically this would have been so much better as three long OVAS
Saying that because that's what endless Waltz was (although shorter OVAs) then it became better as a movie
Where can i watch Gundam series
Im new here but i watch the movie with my friend and im interested to watch the other series
I am indeed waiting on an opportunity to watch this movie. I enjoyed SEED and SEED Destiny. Thing is though, hoping to see it dubbed. Subtitles we do not do in our home. I am okay with that.
Loved the movie, want to watch it again, but have to wait.
This movie did need those 20-40 minutes to breathe, specially at the end, because that ending is fast and I mean super fast, they go from scene to scene to scene in the blink of an eye and it's insane how much action they packed in the least 35 minutes or so.
This movie could easily be expanded into a full series and more deeply go into the characterizations and motivations, not to mention give the battles time to breathe, as much as I love insane amounts of back to back action (I love the ending action completely, insane speed and all), but I also want time to process the combat, the feel of the battle, the flow of the conflict and while this move does an excellent job in doing that, despite the insane speed, those battle scenes could be expanded to give more time to develop and to enjoy them properly.
Specially ship to ship combat, which is one of SEED's surprising strong points, they know how to do space combat be both tactical and entertaining with all the nuances that ship combat entails, beyond just point and shoot the big guns.
Plus, the scenes with the Archangel and the Millenium could benefit from that time and give us the play by play of the tactics and strategies that make them such awesome warships.
I didn’t know the project existed until maybe 6 months ago, so for me I would say it was worth it but if I waited for 20 years I would probably be disappointed.
Everything was amazing i just wish they would hsve given us a sense of direction at the end of the movie on what they were gonna do next if anything
I DO wanna watch SEED FREEDOM, when it's available online. I love Hisashi Hirari's character designs.
The references and cameos were great. Nat/Flay, and other old stuff from OG seed like Tiger King/ Kira's friends. As a movie it really felt subpar. I think it's a watchable 5-6/10 for me. A lot of eye rolling contrived plot to make the conflict work. I really don't like how much Kira regressed in this movie compared to Seed. Sure he kept things bottled up, but he was vocal when he needed to be. They overused the exaggerated gasps way too much instead of just writing actual retorts. I'd probably put that at a 5/10 if it weren't for 2Mu and Cagthrun carrying their scenes. The Justice breaking out of zgok was really cool too. Plotwise, the ntr scenes got pretty tiresome cause you're just left waiting for the climax of Lacus joining up with Kira.
I will say that this suffers the same problem as the end of seed where, killing characters is not that interesting anymore. I would rather see them live and attempt to rebuild themselves with their new mindsets (My bias for wanting Flay and Nat to live at the end). And again, it was annoying how little Kira actually spoke in this movie until finally saying what the fuck he wanted in the first place after Athrun punches the shit out of him. Not gonna speak of Shinn cause all his scenes cement in my mind of how much of a whiny bitch he is 😂
Action wise, it was alright. It was mostly acrobatics with little tension. It felt like the fighting didn't compliment the dialogue. They overused the sixth sense detection to where I wish it was just mu and Rau having it. The telepathy + mind reading black knights was also really lame, But it did give us a glimpse as to how Athrun feels about Caga with the nudie thoughts 😂
Now I definitely feel like they lucked out with the OG Seed series with writing/action/visuals. It's hard to see a continuation of this universe without rerunning the nuke war angle yet again. This makes me hope that this will be the definitive finale and they put Seed to rest. Finally, the snippets of fan service was aight. Classic mecha cockpit angles. boobies, shower scene, and some lesbo hugs.I'm glad they got to close out the relationship arc for Lacus/Kira and snippets of the other relationships like Mu+Murrue. Especially scenes for Cagthrun, they cemented in my mind they're def together now.
Honestly, i loved it, but i was hoping Orphee was a Rau le Cruze clone. Is he?
Love the movie seed always be my favorite but I wish its a bit longer its feel a bit rush. Overall the movie is amazing.
What likely happened is the studio wanted to make a third series but the producing company refused, thinking it’s not worth it
Finally, after much delay and strong pulling by those who care, we got this
it feels like some of the dialogue sequence in the movie deliberately made faster as if they're trying to make it fit with the duration and also make some room for special edition release for the years to come with extra scenes
Overall amazing movie, it got a little stupid (in a good way) at the end, almost like the imagination of a crazy kid playing with gunpla kits but honestly for a show like this coming out so long after the original, it's great to have some fun like this. In some ways it retreads the same water as the later parts of Destiny, so it's kind of like a redo of Destiny which is good thing also, because it fixes a lot of the problems with Asuka and Lunamaria. My only complaint would be all the bad guys have really bad suits that are somehow simultaneously not cool, not memorable, and also don't look like Gundams.
BTW I can't wait for a new modern Lacus figure, they made sure that's going to be coming with this movie.
It wasn't worth it for several reasons. Biggest is the Dub not using the Ocean Dub voice actors. I hate they way they say characters name.
I wish they would have reference Rau More.
The plot is God awful. Honest replace the Villains with Al Da Flaga clones and I would have been happier. Honestly if you know the lore he has cased the most issues in all of Seed.
Also Kira is a dick for letting Lowes Sword get destroyed.
That's another thing we should have gotten a Cameo of the Astray characters.
Also I don't know if maybe a blinked but I feel there was 5-10 minutes missing from the Dub. Like the whole sequence Murrue using the Wired Dragoons was cut from the English Dub
I'm kind of mixed on SEED Freedom. There is some really good stuff, especially in the beginning, but they kind of went full ham near the end which...... I don't know. I think it's because I'm used to the more serious nature of UC and the original SEED series that certain things didn't work for me.
I would say that there were some missed opportunities to flesh out more of Kira's unresolved PTSD from the end of SEED, alluded to at the beginning of Destiny until abruptly dropped. They briefly hint at it in Freedom but never really drive it home. And what I mean by that is...... the death of Flay Allster, his first girlfriend. Granted it would seem a bit off for him to be dwelling on this especially when he and Lacus seem more perfectly united due to it being 4 years since Jakin Due instead of 2 like in the beginning of Destiny (which is why this should have been resolved then and not now). And before anyone thinks that Kira is completely over this, consider who he sees when he is told to "fall into darkness" and what the ramifications are. This does kind of come back later on the film when confronted with Athrun and was a good moment.
Just saw it last night and it definitely beat my admittedly kinda low expectations.
Where can I watch it?
I definitely agree with most points you have except for what the movie did to Kira and Lacus' character motivations/strength, but I do agree with it making sense. Overall, movie is 8/10 for rating me. Definitely liked how everything looked EXCEPT FOR EVERYTHING LACUS-RELATED (WTF is that outfit on the party/pilot suit monstrosity???)
I mainly only touched on her relationship with orphee which i only really understood because it wasn't her choice-- but yeah would've been ideal without for sure
@@GundamHQrelationship with orphee kinda like Judau with Haman.
I think it was great. Earned a lot of money to fund more gunpla. Not perfect obviously, but it delivered. I'd say it's a 8/10 overall.
I enjoyed the movie, it was totally worth the wait and its a good conclusion to CE and Seed Franchise. But if they ever release another series or movie i wouldnt mind at all the Seed Universe its still a lot of potential with other characters and other setting.
oh man i cant wait. Just watched the whole series again.
Bar none the best gundam movie. My only complaints is the pacing. It hits the gas peddle and just doesn't let up or let you breath. Bar none some of the best mobile suit combat and battleship combat in the series. So much so I want a Millennium model. Lot to like about this movie and hope there is a Seed Justice.
My favorite from seed is and always be anything Shinn pilots cause no matter what anyone says, Shinn started out as a interesting character in destiny, being different from your normal protag and I feel they had more planned for him and from what I heard I'm glad the redeem him in freedom. It's like I was saying, there is never a bad character, just bad story telling
Gundam SEED Freedom is not the worst Gundam movie, but for a movie that has been in production for 18 years (per the interview before the film), the animation is absolute shit. It's like they had their interns working on the film. There were scenes where the character heads were HUGE. An Evangelion-esque scene towards the end made Kira and Lacus look like they were skinny aliens with deformed propotions. It was awful.
The plot of the film could have worked if the new villains were given any sort of character development whatsoever. There was this really cool in concept group of knights who barely did anything beyond a couple of grunts and a girl who kept saying she was going to kill whomever she was fighting. In fact, pretty much all of the new characters were trash. Kira also got to pull out his last minute god mode scene that also felt like something ripped right out of Godannar. The fanservice on Lacus' suit was hilariously bad. Worse, Shin was a much better character than Kira in this. How the hell do you mess up so badly that you make Shin look competent?
Even the fights seemed to get progressively worse as the movie went on. First off, there was no oomph to any of the battles at all. The movie lacked bass, which is unacceptable for a movie released in 2024. The rear channels were practically non-existent. The opening battle at the start of the movie was by far the best fight scene while the fights kept getting even more fantastical than the last to the point where the final one felt like it was ripped out of a typical Shonen anime.
Finally, I hate to say it, but the dub kind of sucked in this one. Easily the worst Gundam dub in a decade, if not longer. It was like they decided to have the voice actors bring all of the cringy acting from the original SEED dubs back rather than giving it a proper one despite having the new voice actors. There is one crying scene of Kira (because heaven forbid Kira not cry like a bitch for once) that was just painful to listen to. He had no emotion, but had to force himself to provide one. Athrun was easily the best voice in the film, though that could be because he didn't have much dialogue. He did get the best line though.
Overall, I didn't hate the film, but I didn't particularly like it either. The rushed plot felt like this was supposed to be a full series that was cut down to a 2 hour movie.
Finally! Another Rising Freedom lover!
Please do a full recap of freedom
It was worth it, i enjoyed it so much till 4x times watching it. 😂
If the producer want to make another SEED series, i hope that they could explore other side characters like Lowe Guele (Junk Guild), Gai Murakamo (Serpent Tail), or even Canard Pars (an Ultimate Coordinator beside Kira Yamato).
They have so much materials to be explored.
Also, if they want to make love drama of SEED series, just make Yzak and Shiho to be the main couple.
Why do people hate Shinn:
-For blaming Athas and the Orb for the death of his family
He was 14 at the time and his isolation from the war made it so he didn't understand what was going on with the war. Put yourself in his place:
You live a happy life. Then suddenly war comes and you and your family are running for dear life while big giants fight all around you. And then, in 1sec, everyone you love perishes. And noone notices. Noone cares. Noone gives a damn. Everyone keeps fighting and killing for nothing. And you are left alone, sad and angry. And noone to help you through it.
He never saw who fired that shoot. He needed someone to blame but didn't know who or how. Only face involved in that battle he saw was Uzumis. So he focused his rage at Athas, blaming them for failing to protect his family and Orb. He was to young and at lack of understanding of the war.
Afzer Seirans runned Cagalli over, his anger was all about current, changed, corrupted Orb making his families death for nothing.
-For disrespecting Athrun
Athrun disrespected him 1..
After the Battle in Indian Ocean, Athrun saw why Shinn was so mad and what he did for those people, but he still over-scolded him out of fear. It was too soon after the battle with Sato and his men. Instead of admiting to Shinn that his actions were justifiable, but pointing out they are a team and had to work together and asking him to keep his temper in check, he started playing drill sargent, disrespecting him, belittled him, causing Shinn to lose his respect for him. Furthermore, instead of bluntly explaining to Shinn his anger may end up doing more harm to him than good someday, he kept giving him fortune-cookie styled stuff. Furthermore, despite the way Shinn meeting and falling in love with Stella mirrored how he met Cagalli and how their situation had simularities with how he and Kira ended on opposing sides, Athrun refused to acknowledge or understand Shinns feelings for Stella. He kept acting like a soldier instead of an actual person. And after her death, Athrun thought Shinn only wanted to kill Kira out of jealousy and gloryhoaging, and didn't try to find out more. He only ever saw worst in Shinn and tried to stomp it out instead of attempting to bring out and improve the best in him. He kept himself closed of, not letting Minerva crew truly know him. Also, Shinn didn't bother explaining Stellas death to Athrun since he already proved himself callous to the subject. Also, fan wiki confirms Athruns social skill in GSD was lacking
-For trying to kill Kira.
Kira had just ended the life of Shinns 1. girlfriend. Meeting her made Shinn fell the happines he didn't since he lost his family. Because of her, he truly realised what he desired in life. And losing her made him feel the same pain of having your heart ripped out. Yes, case could be made that there was no saving her at that point, that she was as good as dead the moment she became Bio CPU and that Kira just put her out of her misery, but he was still cullpable. And Shinn was in no state to think with logic (and I'll confess, he doesn't exactly have IQ to do that without help). So naturaly, he went after Kira.
-For almost ending Athrun and Meyrin
Imagine yourself in his sho- boots. You just received a great machine, you're feeling good, you've let out your rage, you think you are free of your demons and you are just taking a break and have just sworn yourself to a worthy cause. Then suddenly, you get news that 2 of your comrades have turncoated and you are sent to play executioner along with your BFF. 1 guy, who has by now only been making you pissed, is telling you you're being tricked and that the worthy cause you're fighting for and believing with all your hearth is a scam, while the other guy, your best friend who only did you good, is telling you the 1. guy is nuts and to do you duty. He was in no win situation where he had to choose between his friends, and siding with 1 would be betraying and turning on another. Add that to Shinns 2 previous highly heart-shattering moments, and you get the picture. The situation drove him mad so he attacked the side he disliked more.
-For attacking Orb
Orb had at that time, offered him and his comrades to EA, the same lot previously burned it down, after they saved them and rest of the Earth-based mankind, as a gesture of good will. Then they attacked them 2 times, causing many of his crewmates to lose their lives. And to add insult to injury, they, under Seirans control, let in, to say it shortly, THE WORST HUMAN BEING ALIVE AT THE TIME. Thus, regardless of his personal feelings, Shinn was a soldier carrying his orders to apprehend or eliminate the man who caused the war and all it had wrought.
-For choosing to side with Durandall
What Shinn desired and fought for was to make a world where noone would suffer like him. By then, Shinn had witnessed and expirienced all th horrors of war: innocent people, including a little girl (His family) being killed in crossfire with noone even noticing, an entire peaceful country being sacked merely for refusing to participate in the genocidal war, good men turned into genocidal lunatics by grief, political shenanigans, innocents being enslaved, abused and murdered in cold blood, children being turned into monsters and killers and used as weapons by madmen for the sake of sating their unreasonable hate and shear greed, people getting killed in vain, cities and everyone in them being burned to ash, his lover dying in his bare arms, having to expirience comrades ,,betrayal", be an executioner and tell a friend he virtually executed her only sister, superweapon being used on innocents. To him, DP didn't sound right, but it was by all means better than the hellish world he had witnessed. He wanted to change the world for the better, not for his sake but for everyone elses, so that things he saw never happened again. For things to turn out differently than after the 1. war. To end the pointless death and fighting. Durandall had promised such a world. Despite Athruns efforts, Shinn didn't know who he was at this point, not that he ever did. After Athrun came back from the dead, Shinn didn't know what was right anymore so he put all his trust in Rey, his closest friend. And he (R) led him (S) to believe DP was the only way to fix the world. Everything he had he owed to Durandall and Rey, and they made a lot of good points to back DP up, so he couldn't betray them.
-For losing his shit.
And who wouldn't lose his shit after living a good, careless, happy life only for it and everyone you love go out in a blast leaving you all alone, go through couple of months enduring a total war started and motivated by shear hate and injustice, enduring emotinal turmoil and traumatic expiriences at an ever increasing rate. Many people in Gundam SEED went mad or extreme for less: Patrick, Sato, those little kids in GSS, Durandall (he started his villain arc just because Talia left him 'cause he was infertaile). Yet noone writtes ,,I hate them". Heck, yesterday I saw a comment vindicating Patrick.
He knew that price DP extorted was far too much. He understood Athruns words, and he was angry he (A) was right. He knew it wasn't right but believed it was the only way to create a world where noone will end up like Stella and Mayu. If he agreed with Athrun, it would be betraying Rey, the 1. bond he forged after losing his family. He couldn't deny anyones reasoning and got conflicted over it all. SEED mode amplified that. Images of Stella and Mayu he saw were manifestations of his reasons for fighting, of what drove him on. Not to mention his previous traumas. He lost and suffered to much to fast, he didn't have a strong, tough and cold charachter and heart needed to endure it or the upbringing to prepare him for it. He hit his limit. It is amazing he held together for as long as he could.
Conclusion: Shinn did nothing wrong. He trusted and was loyal to a friend (movies bonus novels confirm Rey befriended Shinn honestly) who took advantage of that. He tried to protect his loved 1s anyway he could. He desired peace more than anything, and Durandall used that. He had an incompetent Bright wannabe for a mentor.
I mean, the things he did pale into oblivion in comparison to fragrant atrocites Nagato, Obito, Madara and Kaguya did and caused for what they deamed peace after enduring simular tragedies and losses, and everyone says they are GOATs.
So, the way people call Shinns charachter in GSD hatefull is unjust and it sickens me. Writters didn't redeem him. They redeemed themselves for screwing him up.
Opinions are free
watched the move last week in NL, was good, would not give it a high rating due to the fact so much CGI / stuff is happening its really hard to know WTF is going on but its still a good enough move to watch.
I wish to see the Gundam seed Next future Generation children main character & the support character or new character.ova,manga,art posted wedding event. Just wait in the future. ガンダムの未来
So the part where you said no one has actually seen it Yep, that’s me, because of like two things. 1. I didn’t have a car to drive me there and 2: some theaters were actually a bit far and showtime was at 7; which you might tell me this ‘so” yeah I mean who would go and that time of night? (No offense)
Agnes” story felt like a tribute to Zeta Gundam’s Reccoa Londe in terms of personality and and plot development though with a few differences.
She's more like combination of quess paraya and katejina loos.
Destiny as a whole was a bad homage to Zeta Gundam.
@@trollinoakenshield9822 That too honestly this movie literally takes shots from Char's Counterattack to sell along with its abysmal plot.
As long as you watch the Sub, all good. The Dub…. HELL NO.
Hot take shinn asuka was always a good character he is one of the reasons I tolerate destiny i prefer my protagonists with serious character flaws i prefer shinn over kira and athurn zala
Of course! - didn't mean to imply he wasn't a good character. Just that the writers continually jusy gave the audience more of a reason to dislike him as the show went on. So its nice to see him get a little bit of love
Name a couple reasons before stella died and kira became the main character again
@blackknight-oz8bi Just him non stop screaming and lashing out at cagalli/athrun etc. With some being warranted and others not at all. His hot headed temper specifically telling Athrun that "the higher ups think I was right" when he gets released after he freed Stella WHILE she is currently going on a massive murder spree and the audience knows it etc.
Plus just simply putting him at odds with returning cast / leads in every scenario possible is a good way to make him dislikable whether he's right or not and I think they knew that.
Ok fair points shinn is literally a kamille clone and was kamille really that different (every fist fight kamille gets into with the arguma's crew)
1 him yelling at cagalli is justified it was her family in charge orbs neutrality that left them practically defenseless and led to the death of his family i don't think anyone would act differently here from his point of view sure he didn't know all the details of what was happening at the time but we shouldn't expect him to know that
2 stella was literally dying what do you expect from shinn when athrun is acting like char during zeta about four of course he is going to yell at him kamille would have done the samething we shouldn't expect shinn to know neo was going to put her in a MA gundam (yes it was naive of shinn to trust him but so is a good chunk gundam mc's)
Ok now here is my last point shinn is psychology damage clearly suffering from survivors guilt and possibly other mental issues you made him sound like a pycho when he went after luna but left out that he was literally having a mental breakdown and lashing out at anyone near him that scene makes me at athrun more than anything (and personally shinn should have won so he could have a rematch with kira) he doesn't explain or truly reason with shinn he gives this half assed speech no matter how much you want you can't bring anything back and your going to kill the future to some how get him into joining the protags triggering his ptsd and Causing his mental breakdown here orb represent only pain for shinn why wouldn't he be ok with destroying it athrun dosen't try to argument that it his family's home he should remember the good times he had with his family and is ok with destroying his only last link to his family
@@blackknight-oz8bi The talk no jutsu Athrun was doing was a huge debuff on Shinn's mental state. Every victory Athrun had over Shinn is marred with an asterisk. Based on the movie, Shinn would demolish Athrun now if they were to fight 1v1
the lips man, why do they have to draw them like that, they pop out so mcuh
Seed Freedom was a true tribute to both the original series and seed destiny.
let me do you one better, where is gomorah,i mean meyrin..hahhaha ..really worth the wait. still having goose bumps if these things gonna be on its real deal with the tensions around the world.
If iv never watch Gundam seed/destiny before is this still worth my time? I have the general idea of the plot for seed but never watched destiny
You'll definitely get a lot more enjoyment if you know more from the shows - but it should still be pretty decent. You just won't catch most of the references which is a lot of stuff. If you want to know more about what happened in SEED you can watch my summary vid: ruclips.net/video/QyAFactK0DU/видео.html
I'll do Destiny in the future - but the movie is definitely better enjoyed with at least a decent understanding of the two.
@@GundamHQ thanks for the summary! Maybe I'll wait for your destiny video before I give the movie a go
It definitely scratched the fun gundam itch that g witch lacked.
It does gives me an annoyance with how they just gave up explaining any grounded tech work that gundam is known for in recent shows too.
I want to like the justice, but man the x wing backpack isn't it. I prefer the zgok.
plot was fine. echi ntr scenes were...laughable, but a staple to the director's work.
Overall fun.
Well im gonna watch the subbed version of the movie no point of watching the dubbed since how pronounce some of the names is off and biggest one is the they never brought back the old voice actors to reprise there roles
Old mu is back which for me who has only watched the new dub was actually a negative
its just more gundam seed. whether you love or hate seed, how you feel about it will remain the same
I loved the Seed series but the movie was a little too frantic in my opinion. The battles were just too fast and I felt like I was racing from battle to battle. They were trying to squeeze in all the characters and give them some screen time but the whole thing ended up feeling rushed to me.
I am not sure if i am the only one that feels this way, but i thought the latest Gundam movie was a joke. Like for example, the entire theme being “love” is already suspicious enough, and then them going to ridiculous lengths (to fight and kill) just for this so called “love” is high key cringe. At least the original series 20 years ago had better reasons to go to war. No offence, but my friends and I thought this was more of a comedy than Gundam 😅.
I wouldn't say love was the only reason - they jusy fired a death beam from the sky. They use it as motivation for Kira to get a grip in the moment more or less and thr obviously it ties things together at the end too
@@GundamHQ I mean that’s also true, the death ray was a very good reason for war. But don’t u find it a little over the top that Kira-lacus being the main theme of the whole show.
**Spoiler**
Like Kira was really being an insecure c**ck at the garden party, and how he just whines abt lacus not accepting him while getting his ass handed to Athrun.
Also Agnes, girl literally betrayed the team just cuz she fell for some hot guy, and fought Luna cuz she actually also loved shin.
And that scene when everyone’s bae came flying in naked mid battle was just hilarious.
And when mu blocked the entire Requiem?? Damm, I know bro has a lot of experience blocking laser cannons in the first and second seasons, but an entire requiem?
Like the entire set up made me wonder if the director and scriptwriter were high when they did the movie.
Cool!
Can confirm: I did in fact eat good - An Athrun fan 😂❤
THE WILL OF GOD YAMATO DEFEATS ALL FORCES
Beware some cultists might come here :D
It was worth waiting for this movie.
100% it was great!
biggest criticsm I had with the movie is we have no idea wtf happened to Michael, the supposed "Blue Cosmos Remnant" leader, like at least during the Black Knights ambush part of the movie, that's the last time we've ever heard from the man
He got obliterated by the nuke in Foundation
Just hope that organization was completely destroyed this time for good
fan service movie
Exactly - references were overflowing
What they need to do is turn the movie into a full on 50 episode series
I spoiled myself abit by reading a reddit thread... But at least I don't know the plot that made it reach the point 😂
Definitely worth it
To be honest I have mixed feelings about the movie. It's nice but I have some problems regarding a few plot éléments.
I loved the animation and even the style they renewed it, made beautiful things with it while being faithful to the original.
The movie have some funny moments.
I enjoyed the movie and most of the action was great 😊
My complaint section would have been longer if I could actually specify- but yeah overall it was fun
I think the story was good, but they were rushing it. What they could’ve done is to widen the story line and split it into 2 movies!!🙂
You forgot to mention Gundam Seed's the usual nude shots
Cagalli: What ?!
The movie should have Part 2 or Part 3; 1 year gap after the events of Destiny then suddenly Agnes appeared out of nowhere. When I was watching the movie, I keep on thinking who is this "Agnes"; did I overlook or forgot a character on Destiny ? Also the Rising Freedom didn't mentioned when Kira got the new Gundam.
Ingrid had character development but the movie already ended by the time it grew.
I mention it ar the end but they only really explain her in the prequel. I did a video on it that explains her relationship with Shinn and Luna
Agnes is a classmate of Shinn, Luna, and Rey, but because her family is rich, they don't send her to fight on Minerva but go somewhere safer.
to have anything seed without tmr would be a sin, that man LOVES gundam seed lol sucks both his characters were doomed to limited screen time (miguel & heine) though