Old MagBox v NEW MagBox Pro 24 - which is better?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 окт 2024

Комментарии • 57

  • @salvamando1
    @salvamando1 2 года назад +2

    I love your videos, always so informative! I am just beginning to learn how to work with softboxes and the practicality of the MagMod ecosystem. I hope as an ambassador they treat you well, you’ve convinced me to go with MagMod all the way! Please keep them videos coming and cheers from San Francisco!

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  2 года назад

      Thank you so much! I am sure you will really enjoy using MagMod, the MagBoxes are awesome :) thank you again

  • @SeanThurston
    @SeanThurston 3 года назад +5

    I love the original with the focus diffuser. It really allows me to add so much more flash power if I need to from two AD200s. I also ordered the 42" for an on-the-go softbox because... 42".

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад +2

      You are correct Sean, if you want more flash power, especially to overpower the sun, then the focus diffuser is awesome! Personally I rarely use off camera flash in bright conditions but that is just a personal style thing, if you do then like you say, the focus diffuser is like magic!

    • @RobertoCienfuegos
      @RobertoCienfuegos 2 года назад

      @@NeilRedfern any difference in the color
      That generates. Same light temperature or the newest version is more to the cold side ???

  • @CamperVanTango
    @CamperVanTango 3 года назад +1

    I love your videos Neil. Would be great to see a video about group shots. Do you do family formals? If not how do set up a large group, any good tips?

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад +1

      Thank you very much! There is a great suggestion - please watch this space 🙂

  • @myk3al1
    @myk3al1 11 месяцев назад

    great vid neil, i just bought the original,, think setup is very minor, concern tho iwith the new version is if the white cloth fabric some how gets dirty, are you able to unzip and seperate it and clean it easy, or is it actually buit in and cant sepaerate.

  • @ndavies8
    @ndavies8 Год назад

    Appreciate you! I am rocking the OG

  • @David-Craig-76
    @David-Craig-76 3 года назад +1

    Hi Neil. Sorry to hijack your video a little, but I'm just wondering whether you have ever had a banding issue with you A9 in HSS when using an Ad200?
    I did a wedding yesterday and every sunset shot is unusable due to banding. This is mostly for shots that are high SS, like 5000 or 8000.
    Ive read that electronic front curtain may cause this?
    I was also using a focus diffuser, but can't imagine that would cause it.
    I never noticed this issue when using A7R3's
    Cheers!

  • @aznoy
    @aznoy 3 года назад +5

    What happens if you damage your diffusion panel on the pro? Do you have to replace the whole unit?

    • @androcci
      @androcci Год назад +1

      YES, I own one and it is a weakness.

  • @CamboMeng
    @CamboMeng Год назад

    Thank you, Neil! I was wondering what the difference is.

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  Год назад

      My pleasure! I hope you found the video useful

  • @robsmith6794
    @robsmith6794 3 года назад +1

    So now, if the regular diffuser gets damaged, you have to buy a complete Magbox rather than just buying a replacement diffuser that just fits on the end?

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад +1

      Hi Rob, the original diffuser fits on the new MagBox so you could just put that on - the same applies to the original diffusion panel - so it's exactly the same as the first one in that sense :-) for me though I love the fact it's all one unit. I've been using it at weddings for a month now and the chances of it being damaged seem very small

  • @DuronStudio
    @DuronStudio Год назад

    You should do a light test with full length of the model and give more distance between the light to the model! That will give more accurate results!
    Thanks for all your videos education! 👍

  • @Rmce1005
    @Rmce1005 Год назад

    Hello, is it possible to use the grid on the old one, even if you put inside?

  • @jolamulder4176
    @jolamulder4176 2 года назад +1

    Thank you for your explanation! Is it possible to shoot full body with the Magbox24? That the light is even? Because the softbox is not that big. And is it possible to use my Godoxflashes with this system? Thanks you!

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  2 года назад

      Hi Jola! You could do but it wouldn't be ideal - the new MagMod Strip Box would be far better for full length portraits. And yes, you can use your Godox speedlights - that is what I do 🙂

    • @jolamulder4176
      @jolamulder4176 2 года назад

      @@NeilRedfern Thank you for helping me out!

  • @tombic6373
    @tombic6373 8 месяцев назад

    Question: Neil, I have the old magbox. I want to put a grid on it. Do you know of any grid that will attach to the old magbox 24? Thank you.

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  8 месяцев назад

      I don't I'm afraid, sorry

  • @edellington
    @edellington 3 года назад +1

    I use the
    Flashpoint XPLOR 600PRO TTL Battery-Powered Monolight. I would like to use the MagMod diffusers because of their design. Is there a model for strobes and not just speedlights?

    • @Whyducry
      @Whyducry 3 года назад

      yes you just have to buy the magbox speedring for your strobe mount

  • @marksimmons8162
    @marksimmons8162 3 года назад +2

    I can guess the answer from looking at the videos but can the new grid be used on the old box alongside the fabric diffuser. That would make an all in one kit for me of choosing between fabric diffuser, focus diffuser and the grid option when i needed it indoors.

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад +3

      Hi Mark, I have tried this now - it is possible but it's clearly not designed for this as the grid doesn't attach to the original MagBox very well - it takes a little bit of time to attach it because the magnets are in slightly different places so it's not easy. It can be done but if you want to have the choice of using all three it is easier to use them on the new MagBox Pro

  • @dayleyhighlights
    @dayleyhighlights 3 года назад +1

    Well done Neil

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад

      Thank you very much Trevor! I am LOVING the new MagBoxes!

  • @pegshealth
    @pegshealth 2 года назад

    Did you possibly compare putting a grid on the flash instead of using the more unwieldy grid over the front of the softbox?

  • @indrajitadvani3742
    @indrajitadvani3742 2 года назад

    Thanks for this. You mentioned a MagMod 42 inch softbox. I have never seen that. Do you have any videos of that?

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  2 года назад

      Hi Indrajit, yes, I have a couple of videos on my channel about the MagBox Pro 42 Octa - if you search back a couple of videos earlier than this one, you will find a couple of videos about it :)

    • @indrajitadvani3742
      @indrajitadvani3742 2 года назад

      @@NeilRedfern Much appreciated Neil

  • @DjDupree
    @DjDupree 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for this!

  • @mimstyle
    @mimstyle 3 года назад +1

    With the new if the zipper fabric broke I'm out... With my original in bright days sun I can save the day with the focus diffuser even with only one Ad200 because + focus = 400w with two, you can reach 800w !!
    It can't focus a lot but compare to fabric spill the light at 180° it's better.
    The interesting one for me is the 36"
    The new model is yes.. Very fast to set up.

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад

      The thing to remember is, even if the zipper did break (which I think is very unlikely - I have been using them pretty intensely at weddings for a few weeks now) you can just use the fabric panel and focus diffuser from the first MagBox if you have them - they fit on the new MagBox perfectly

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад +1

      But the panels from the first MagBox 24, fit the new one MagBox Pro 24 perfectly. The chances of anything happening to the zip must be very small though. Obviously time will tell but they are very well made

  • @BlaqViper
    @BlaqViper 2 года назад

    Like zippers sometimes, what is the recourse if the zipper malfunction?

  • @papsny
    @papsny 2 года назад

    If you want to control the spill indoors, just use a mag grid instead of the magbox

  • @RobertoCienfuegos
    @RobertoCienfuegos 2 года назад

    Any difference in the output color temperature from one to another or the read out is the same on both. ???? Any one noticed any difference

  • @lindajonasson4129
    @lindajonasson4129 2 года назад

    what happens when the zipper brakes? love the magnets on the old one.

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  2 года назад +1

      I guess you could say that about any part of any equipment? I have been using them for months now and no issues at all. Personally I much prefer the integrated nature of the new one but it's all personal choice :-)

  • @benyb7727
    @benyb7727 2 года назад

    Does it comes with tripod stand? If not where can I buy one and how is it called, thanks

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  2 года назад

      No, you would have to buy a light stand separately

  • @BizonURS
    @BizonURS 2 года назад

    It's just to small .... light looks harsh in my opinion. Thanks man :) I was thinking about buying, but now I know it's not for me.

  • @manu.pixels
    @manu.pixels 3 года назад

    Can you pl give link of which light stands are those you using outside?

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад

      Of course - I use these heavy duty light stands: amzn.to/3eyTXj5

  • @joshhernandez232
    @joshhernandez232 2 года назад

    Ill stay with my old kit no biggie maybe update the a few hardware with the old kit due to better and stronger.

  • @lorraine6185
    @lorraine6185 3 года назад +1

    I’m waiting for a 32.

  • @mohanrajganapathi3195
    @mohanrajganapathi3195 3 года назад +2

    It looks like our old magbox focus diffuser not doing its job. :)

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад

      Hi Mohanraj, sorry, I am not sure what you mean?

  • @ashishmzn0979
    @ashishmzn0979 3 года назад

    which camera🙄

  • @cmjamil
    @cmjamil 3 года назад +2

    Very overpriced , lots of alternatives are available at 1/4 of the price

    • @NeilRedfern
      @NeilRedfern  3 года назад +4

      It's a matter of opinion. I do not know of any other alternative which can be set up in seconds like the MagBox? And if you are a wedding photographer like me that time saving is massive on a wedding day. For me, as with all my equipment, I would prefer to buy the best I can afford knowing that the advantages they gives me over years will be well worth it