@@t.c.9029 you really cannot defend her just by saying that she is just a child. That is the reason why I barely like kids at all. Kids don't have morals and even common sense.....
He literally never lived again after what she did. His entire life ended in suffering and misery. I would say all the 3 lives was never the same again.
if briony drowned (bc of her stupidity), the family 100% wouldve blamed robbie for not looking out for her. Hence why he's so frustrated bc briony intentionally jumped just for funsies 💀
I agree Briony ruined his life but if he had let her drown her parents would've probably held him responsible and fired him and his mother but I guess that would've been better than what happened.
I know Briony made a very serious mistake, wich has marked her for life, but sometimes, our instinct tends to do impulsive things, especially when it comes to "revenge". What Briony did is unforgible, but imagine the scene: a thirteen years old girl, who is in the library of her home and sees the boy she loves kissing her beloved sister. How would she feel? Be trayed. Hurt. Humiliated. I'm sure that you, finding yourself in the same situation, would do to exact same thing. Am I right?
Nah. 13 years old is old enough to know right from wrong. Sure if you put yourself in her shoes you'd feel humiliated and angry for seeing your crush kissing your sister. But briony is a smart child, she 100% knew that robbie would be jailed for her lies. And yet she still went with it. What briony did is evil.
I always thought she actually believed that it was him who molested that guest girl. Briony had rich imagination and that's shown in the beginning of the movie. So her hurt ego imagined the whole thing AND she believed it was real. She realized what she did only when she grew up. And she didn't only feel hurt and humiliated, she was afraid of what she saw in the library. No sexed back than, and her sister didn't explain her what tf happened. She was a child who witnessed adults having sex. It must have been traumatic and shocking. Which added to her believing her imagination.
@@walkingwith_dinosaursshe already believed him to be a pervert after the naughty letter slip-up + seeing her sister undress in front of him. The sex scene in the library just sealed the deal for her, which may be why she confused him for Cumberbatch. Atonement is just a sad tale about how there are some fuck-ups you can’t fix or compensate for no matter what we do. All you can do is move on from it, or in Briony’s case, let the guilt consume you. Her only escape was literal dementia.
She never returned the favour and instead ruined his life
Yes but she was a child
@@t.c.9029and?💀
@@t.c.9029she should’ve known right from wrong
@@t.c.9029 you really cannot defend her just by saying that she is just a child. That is the reason why I barely like kids at all. Kids don't have morals and even common sense.....
He literally never lived again after what she did. His entire life ended in suffering and misery. I would say all the 3 lives was never the same again.
And Robbie’s mother’s life.
And Lola's, she married her rapist😢
one thing i love about this scene is how well it's acted. She believes this is flirting and living a rom com while you feel his frustration.
Man, what a freacking great performance!!
Oh lord i hated briony so much... should have let her go with the flow 💀
if briony drowned (bc of her stupidity), the family 100% wouldve blamed robbie for not looking out for her. Hence why he's so frustrated bc briony intentionally jumped just for funsies 💀
whenever i think of atonement and sersh this scene comes to my mind
One could tell, even then, that Ms Ronan would grow into a great beauty.
Weirdo
He!! hath no fury as a Briony scorned.
Should of let her drown
What happens in this movie
Lmao😂😂
@@KatsAguilarshe falsely accused him and ruined his life
I agree Briony ruined his life but if he had let her drown her parents would've probably held him responsible and fired him and his mother but I guess that would've been better than what happened.
I think she's simply Gorgeous 🤩🥰❤
They should have called this movie The Horrid Bones
Вроде невзрачная, но очень красивая актриса. 👍👍👍
I think she’s a fantastic actress.
whats the context?
She’s got a crush on him, but he’s smitten with her older sister. he and his family work for her family, but they seem pretty tight.
Have you considered watching the film?
@@issimondias no
@@S_J_banana You should! Be aware though, it's not for the faint of heart 🤧
I know Briony made a very serious mistake, wich has marked her for life, but sometimes, our instinct tends to do impulsive things, especially when it comes to "revenge". What Briony did is unforgible, but imagine the scene: a thirteen years old girl, who is in the library of her home and sees the boy she loves kissing her beloved sister. How would she feel? Be trayed. Hurt. Humiliated. I'm sure that you, finding yourself in the same situation, would do to exact same thing. Am I right?
Nah. 13 years old is old enough to know right from wrong. Sure if you put yourself in her shoes you'd feel humiliated and angry for seeing your crush kissing your sister. But briony is a smart child, she 100% knew that robbie would be jailed for her lies. And yet she still went with it. What briony did is evil.
@@hajimeoikawa1892 So you're telling me you wouldn't do the same thing?🧐
I always thought she actually believed that it was him who molested that guest girl. Briony had rich imagination and that's shown in the beginning of the movie. So her hurt ego imagined the whole thing AND she believed it was real. She realized what she did only when she grew up.
And she didn't only feel hurt and humiliated, she was afraid of what she saw in the library. No sexed back than, and her sister didn't explain her what tf happened. She was a child who witnessed adults having sex. It must have been traumatic and shocking. Which added to her believing her imagination.
@@walkingwith_dinosaursshe already believed him to be a pervert after the naughty letter slip-up + seeing her sister undress in front of him. The sex scene in the library just sealed the deal for her, which may be why she confused him for Cumberbatch. Atonement is just a sad tale about how there are some fuck-ups you can’t fix or compensate for no matter what we do. All you can do is move on from it, or in Briony’s case, let the guilt consume you. Her only escape was literal dementia.
Hated her character 😂
A very depressing movie. Not Recommended.
This movie ruined me
i think he over reacted.