How Islam and Christianity entered Kerala
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 июн 2024
- Read my newsletter: www.sochbymm.com/subscribe
Follow me on Linkedin: / mohakmangal
******
📃Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1w...
******
🔍✍️Research:
Zaira Khan: / zaira-khan-7435a9189
✂️🎛️Editing:
CharanTej: / mograph.charantej
Mohit Bharti: / mohitbharti_
Chief of Staff:
Ajeesh Babu: / ajeesh_babu
🎨Thumbnail :
Aanchal Verma: / aanchal_creates
Want to work with us? Check this link!
tinyurl.com/22pxjjtv
******
Like the background music? I use Epidemic Sound. You can get a 30-day free trial using this referral: bit.ly/3A7bUx7
******
🗳Support on Patreon: / sochyoutube
👾Discord: / discord
🐦Twitter: / mohakmangal
📷Instagram: / mohak.mangal
👤Facebook: / sochyoutube
******
Kerala has been in the news this year- mostly because of the Kerala story. Based on this movie, Kerala was subject to a lot of criticism. Some said that Kerala is poised to become an Islamic state and something needs to be done about it. Yet there are people who maintain that Kerala is different from other states - That Kerala is truly the most "secular" state in India. So, what is the real Kerala story?
In this video, we dive into the history of Kerala and the relationship between the communities that exist there. We take a look at the local customs, traditions, and festivals and try to analyze how Kerala has been different from the other states, particularly in the north of India- when it comes to communal harmony.
But, that being said, Kerala is not totally free from communal violence- there have been cases of communal violence here as well. We take a look at what’s changing in the state and what could possibly be the reason behind this
Playlists
🇮🇳Indian Society: • Hijab: Ban Right or Wr...
🗺Geopolitics and Foreign Affairs: • Will China Invade Taiwan?
🧍🏽♀️Issues of a Young Indian: • Are Indian Girls Bad a...
💰Economy: • How Kerala Changed its...
🗳Indian Politics: • UP Elections: Why Are ...
🇮🇳 Discoveries of India: • How Goa Joined India
📈Money, Stocks, and Crypto: • Why Indian Youth is NO...
Markers
00:00 Introduction
02:36 Trade Ties
10:03 Cultural Integration
12:46 Architecture
13:27 Social & Political Factors
16:30 Communal Violence
17:47 Increased Gulf Influence
Read my newsletter: www.sochbymm.com/subscribe
Abhi aayaa yaad is per baanaana ka 😂
One video on soveit union disintegration or Yugoslavia
Mera first comment delete kyu kiya 😡
Maine likha tha kitni kerala Story laoge bhai
😡Ye video Soch bymm mohak baahut pahel AA Jaana Chahiye tha dhurv rathee ke propegenda ke video byaan only three women Ka rep hua tha us par Soch mohak video laa dete expose karte Bollywood ko dhurv rathee ko,ya yehi reality bataate 😡 ab the Kerala state India 🇮🇳 par opinion de rahe ho ki kaise kya hua tha problem kaha se hua kaise violence hua
Channel bohot comments delete kar raha hai
Dislike and report
As a Muslim from Kerala who studied in a Christian missionary school, I can say Kerala is the best example for secularism.
@@anantbhushangaur1972secularism left the chat for real
@@anantbhushangaur1972Like how Bajrang dal,VHP,RSS all goons came from cowbelt and maharashtra lmfao.
@@srikrishnak196THEY ARE NOT TERRISOST ORGANISATION BUT ISIS IS AND MOST RECRUIT OF ISIS COME FROM KERELA
@@srikrishnak196lol it's because of muslim radicals there are RSS and other organizations
@@hello-dt6gq Maybe but 2 wrongs dont make a right. I'm also glad PFI is banned so dont throw the "anti national,go to pakistan" dialogues on me .I'm indian btw and wish all extremists are banned no matter the religion
Keralites don't need North Indian Certificate
Yes they want halal certificate 😂
@@zelontusk north indians = somalians
kerala = american
@@razikchembilode we are all Indians north south east west. It's just that madarsa chaps want a 3rd nation like Pakistan and Bangladesh.
Like Hindu beef exporters from UP@@zelontusk
@@rasputin774 or Muslim pork exporters from gujrat.
Iam from kerala My father is a Christian and my mom is Hindu. Our neighbour's daughter is my best friend and she is a Muslim ❤
what are you?
@@AyushKumar-fo5yu A human💯
@@Bantump4. Best reply anna, best reply
@@Bantump4 😁🤣😂 ithin nalla marupadi vere ilal
Exactly 💯... that is kerala...
As a Muslim from Kerala, I can say from the bottom of my heart that i love all my Hindu and Christian brothers and sisters. My best friends are Hindus and i wish our love and kindness towards each other continues.
You name is daisy Rose? And you are a Muslim??
@@kevinfernandez9999that's a serious confusion for me 😅
They are forming an altogether new thing. But that is definitely not Hindu 😂
Than try going to a mandir and try taking your friends to a mandir also , same as many hindus are already visiting masjid
@@kevinfernandez9999Is it compulsory to put real name😂😂
The Kerala story
As a person from Kerala, I would like to request everyone to understand that Kerala is a beautiful state like many others. Unfortunately, some controversies have caused people to develop negative perceptions about us. Let me share a personal experience: I am a student from Bangalore, and while traveling to Mumbai, I encountered an incident at the airport. I met a lady from Jaipur who, upon learning that I am from Kerala, decided to change her seat. It felt like she judged me based on stereotypes portrayed in movies, which is unfair to most Malayalis who are not like that. I want to assure everyone that the people in Kerala are diverse and safe. It's not right to generalize or believe that everyone is the same, as each person's actions should be judged individually. Let's promote understanding and unity instead
Agree bro, I also have mallu frds and we are united as one
Well said bro 💯💯
Love from odisha ❤
Bro just ignores people who can't understand doesn't value us
But still fact is ur state is isis hub state after Sweden if we talk about secular non Muslims state than after Sweden mostly join isis from ur state but today ur state counter is also fact and now karnataka, TN or up is radar on isis recruitment ur state isisi join declining and in up,TN, karnataka increase
"For great men, religion is a way of making friends; small people make religion a fighting tool."
APJ Abdul Kalam (Former President of India)❤
unfortunately this what only the hindus think not muslims.....open your eyes to reality...i as a hindu support your statement
south indian
And The Great Men are always few, the sad fact that can't be ignored 😢
I really don't have any problem with Dharmic religions, Judaism and Christianity
But Islam has many serious problems, the problem is Talking about reforms in Hinduism like caste and all is good ( I accept that )
But If I do the same for Islam
I am called communal I mean
How can I point out a problem if I am being denied the right to speak critically
@@_kartik_chauhanJust like any other religions, the reforms in Islam must happen... A UCC is the key to efficiency of governance and the need of a reformed Bharat!!
During floods in 2018, there is this mosque in Ernakulam district of Kerala was flooded with water and Muslim brothers didn't have a place to do their ritual prayer on Friday. So a nearby Christian Church opened their main prayer hall so that they can do Nishkaram.
But mosque didn't do so, please inform that also. Hindus and christian are secular but not the muslim one
@@indianhacker1958 it’s ok mithr. Keep crying
@@indianhacker1958 hey muslims also helped other religions in kerala
@@AnirbanGhosh-vo9vs 💣💣 making training..
@@ajayyadav17AP I have been to Kerala once but the muslims are nice i have no hate for them , yes definitely against radicals
As a Hindu Nair, I’m proud to say that my state is extremely secular. Lot of my closest friends are Muslims, Hindus and Christian’s . We will never become like North Indian states which lack education and have extremes in radical Hindus and Muslims . Proud to say that I’m a Malayali .
Brother there is difference between Kerala and other states. Include South India also Hyderabad and Karnataka also were forcefully converted via Sword or Invasion. No one has the right to go and destroy temple and change religion in name of Islamic state. You might have not seen genocide of Kashmiri Pandits because as usual you want to create a controversy of North and South India in Name of Religion and Language. We have been taught all Indians are my Brothers and sisters in Pledge at School. Please read the history of India don't follow Communist who has taught everyone wrong history that Akbar the great. Why no Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Great, why no Maharana Pratap Great? Your local Channels specially in Kerala and Tamil Nadu are fully organized by politicians. And by the way do you know our National Song Vande Mataram was fully played on Saturday at school, not just the first verse all verses were completed.
Secular?are you sure?
Prof T J Joseph biography tells a different story.Kerala was secular but not any more and how can some one forget the slogan of that child in Alappuzha.
@@jayarajnair give instances where it is not secular . So one child in alapuzha which is isolated incident means it isn’t secular ? Do you have logic ?
& One day you Keralite hindus will be a minority community in your state then you people will face the same situation like Kashmiri pundits & Pakistani hindus ..
@@arupkantipal3662 Neither we are Pandits nor we are Pakistanis.
Learn about our history , noone can play games with us
I am Kerala Hindu ….many place travelled in India. …..but Kerala is unique culture…..all religion harmony ❤❤❤
മലയാളി ഡാ❤
😂😂😂 what about malappuram and kasrod
@@Jan32116I was going to say that
@@Jan32116 always welcome to Malappuram i can show anything you want
@@Jan32116വളിതാങ്ങികളില്ലാത്ത നാട്. എടപ്പാളോട്ട൦...🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣
People in Kerala eat beef with Paratha. I went there last year. In almost every restaurant they serve this particular food. I asked a Hindu uncle why they eat beef. He said we should not mix religion with food.
@@animedc69 No . We eat all type of beef. One cannot understand which type of beef he is eating. When we ask for butcher give us either cow or ox. When we ask for buffalo he gives us that. Most hotels serves cow or ox as beef as that is cheaper.
@@johnyv.k3746cow meat is more expensive 😊
@@animedc69 that is for his comfort. Almost all hotel serves cow or bullock meat as beef cose its a bit cheaper than buffalo meat.
Not only beef
We eat chicken pork fish mutton peacock (notlegal) Woodpecker Wildcat Frog Snake etc
Compared to all over the India Kerala is unique
@@oasis2690 peakcock, snake , woodpecker wtf? Are you even from kerala? Malayali aano
i'm a human from kerala. I prefer humanity over religion.
Human...❤️
Me too❤❤
❤️❤️❤️ Same here, much love.
Me too
Me too
As a Muslim we needs to understand Kerala story is s not against Muslims it’s against ISS because it’s growing and the youths are becoming the victims 😊
Good thought
Currently Living in Kerala, I appreciate how people here don't judge me based on my religion, color, or birthplace.
I was in Mumbai with my Muslim friend, and I noticed that taxi drivers were treating Muslims poorly.
Here, we are fortunate to live in harmony without experiencing such incidents.
This happens with muslim people not only in Mumbai but in whole India .
@@Pan21335bro come to Kerala here religion doesn't matter
Hindu Muslim and Christian all are considered humans
@@Pan21335that's not true
@@sriganesan8237 it is true!!!
@@Pan21335so what. Terrorists should be treated like that
My family is from UP, I was born in surat & grew up there & in Ahmedabad, I completed my education from kerala (nit & iim), and Kerala is the most wholesome & tolerant place where I've lived...India needs to learn from kerala about secularism, accepting different religion, and coexisting peacefully!!!
are you talking about IIM in kunnamangalam, kozhikode, right ?
@@hammadraza9255 yes
@@00mpa1oomp4 mopalah massacre of hindus also happened in Kerala
First love jihad of Christians also happened in Kerala
@@shanuyok615 not against hindu.
Lower caste majority was not against it:)
Package ?
“മതമേതായാലും മനുഷ്യന് നന്നായാല് മതി”
: ശ്രീനാരായണഗുരു
🕉️+☪️+✝️+........=🇮🇳
As a Christian from kerela, more secularism and diversity are found in Kerala.
The funniest fact is that after Kerala Story movie was released, communal tensions rose in the rest of India, whereas all that happened in Kerala was opposition to the movie, irrespective of religion
It's not funny. Subjugation and deracination has reached such a level that our leaders themselves can't speak up against Islamism.
Ask any doctor specialised in sexual diseases, you will find that most cases are from Madrassa.
Yet nobody is able to stop such rapes of boys because Islamic clerics are powerful in Kerala.
One of the reasons politicians couldn't spread hate was due to the film 2018
True ❤
Communal tensions rose because some people's sentiments were hurt by the movie.. in Kerala it didn't release, else theaters would burn
@@nishanthreddy9397 yea that's the problem and not that the film was made to directly increase communal VIOLENCE 🤣
I'm a christian girl from kerala.... During my school days i had two friend,one a hindu and the other a muslim. Recently i even went to the wedding of my muslim friend..... Here everybody is allowed for everything. No boundaries that discriminate people based on religion. We judge people based on their charachter......not religion
Christian girls being kidnapped and rapd by Muslims
You are a Christian and your name is Shruti? 🙄
@@tejaswinimokase420 indian catholic
@@tejaswinimokase420 My surname is Johnson....
@@tejaswinimokase420 tf is even in a name?
Reality is Kerala is no.1 state love Kerala from West Bengal
But harmony is good but Don't try to hide the bad things
I am also from west bengal
And I can see the increase in the number if Bangladeshi immigrants and I am pretty sure you agree on this
@@MrDg05 where you see?
@@iyi232 bro I have heard the news that kerela minister told in parliament back in 2009 that about 9k girl were missing
You can find in yt too
@@MrDg05 no Bangladeshi lives In kolkata
No 1 in isis???😂😂😂😂😂😂
"Thank you, Mohak, for this inspiring video. I'm watching it from Pakistan, and we take immense pride in having young individuals like you who are the flagbearers of education. It's crucial to remember that education has the power to eradicate hate and violence, and with remarkable young minds like yours, I'm hopeful for a brighter future. Blessings upon you, young one."
As a Hindu who studied in a Christian school, I can proudly say that we are so diverse. During prayers, Religion neutral + Christian prayers are used to prevent alienation by other students. My Best friend is Muslim, My school is Christian, My teacher is Hindu. Everyone respects each other and I have never seen anyone shame others on their religion. I'm proud to be a Keralite. ❤🎉
Hii fake I'd abdula
secularism scam lead this to brain rot
@@swatipriya562In kerala all are lived peacefully
@@rijojohn7218 and we are not foolish like you ; conversion racket and terror links are coming to surface ; and we cannot risk whole country due to story of peace you are selling
well i am as lucky as you !
In kerala Malappuram district the district which has the most number of Muslims like 65% around and iam a Christian who is living there for past 18 years since i was born .and i studied 12 years in a Muslim school,in my sslc i were the only non Muslim student in the class.but even there there is a lot of Christian churches hindu temples etc..in Christmass we everyone wait for Christmas Carols similarly all the people will dance in poorams(hindu festivals) .. Thrissur pooram is the biggest festival in India with 100 elephants .and also we celebrate eid together.and i swear that kerala is the best state in india to live. North Indians pls remember that we don't have dharavi like slums here,no one will change our food style according to their belief,and also our superstars are not ambassadors of pan masala packets
No one will change our food style? Do Kerala mu-slims eat pork?
And this is the real 'Kerala Story'. Love from Tamilnadu ❤
Why always bring North and South India. Even Muslims in Hyderabad and Karnataka are forcefully Converted via Sword and Invasion. So don't say North India and South India. Only say Kerala bro. We here in Maharashtra celebrate Onam during Ganesh Chaturthi we also know how to treat someone.
@@Adity2223no you are not 😂
Nammude naad 😍😍 kerala always 🔥🔥😍
As a keralite I really appreciate your effort for this video..Every point you said is absolutely true.Hats off for your research work👏
As a Keralite the story you published is 100% accurate. Keep up the good work Soch & team.
If you live in Kerala you will know that, there’s no religious distinction, people are forward thinking, well read and practical.
if The Nayar and Ezavas never Existed, There won't be a State Called Kerala.
Source Malabar riots of 1921 , Victims from Hindu/Christian Communities are Still Alive. The Genocide is Rewritten as a Mopilah Farmers Moment in The History Books and In the Movies At Same time Thulu Nadan History has been Completely Erased . If Malabar Nayar and Ezavas Didn't Fought Back We Could Have been Seen a Country Called Young Turkey ( because The just wanted to build a Utopian Country for Turkish Khalifa ) .
Mallu people are Forward Thinking That's why The Sate Police Gave physical Training To The PFI member So They Can Eliminate us faster Than Ever.
Njanum Ningale pole Kannu adachu Irut akarulla Pathiv Undayirunu 2018 Asifa Yude Peril Nadana Harthal inu Collage il ninu varuna enikum friends inum PFi Karunde Kayeen Nalonam kitti , avar kollathe jeevam mathram baki vach .
Yeah yeah , I recently spotted potraits of the terrorist Ashraf madni during my recent road trip on nh 66 near kollam so much for the secularism. Stop fooling people
Hindus are discriminated in Kerala.
Lol I'm a Keralalite I can see that well ! One way secularism is in place here ! Anything happens from love jihad to terrorism recruitment but no one asks !
@@mangopudding5979Exactly and nowadays christians as well ! Bible burning in many places in Kerala😢
So happy to see a non-keralite analyse the real Kerala❤.we are not perfect but we are much better than rest of the country
But in kasargod worst
@@ganeshnaik9463 no
Because muslims are minoriry in kerala
But like all others states we also suffer from corrupt politicians aur koi bhi secularism corrupt politicians se nahi baacha sakta
No kerala isn't "much" better.. Kerala is actually getting worse day by day.. check the statistics before posting such nonsense.. finance, crime, corruption, pollution, waste disposal, water distribution issues, electricity generation issues, communal disharmony and everything is getting worse.. I have felf that most people who say Kerala is great are either Muslims or Communist party workers.. I am a Muslim by birth, I do not have any party affiliations.. But I understand the problems kerala is troubled with..Muslims say Kerala is great because the narrative now is that Muslims are making Kerala worse, so Muslims try to counter this by saying Kerala is great. the same with Communist leaders. they have ruled this state for the longest and yet they have just run the state to wall.. I am sincerely sick of these "proud of kerala" thing, when most Malayalis don't even understand the issues that are there in Kerala. Most malayalis don't even know that the actual forest cover of Kerala is less than 25% when the forest cover has to be at least 33% for environmental safety.. Malayalis don't realise that crimes against women are growing in kerala. Child abuse cases are rising in kerala. Corruption is more institutionalised today than ever before. People these days have started saying "corruption is OK".. that alone shows how far out state has degenerated. Please stop making these stupid comments, just to make yourself feel good.
Kerala story was such a pain to watch. If they don't know a crap about Kerala, why making such a controversial film? It's just MADE to degrade Kerala. Such crappy politics.
Because they are andhabhakths🙂
kerala is far better than other indian states
As a hindu from kerala i can say from my heart
that we hindu, muslim, chritians live peacefully together close to each other
Dawg like do Hindus actually eat beef
@@DonEduardo69yup all my Hindu friends do. So keep your opinion to yourself
@@DonEduardo69Yupp , it’s a good item that’s cherished , Hindu Brahmins of the south especially Kerala eat beef and have been for the longest time
@@DonEduardo69beef and Cow are different fool
Saw it on twitter yesterday! How they were chanting we will b@rn you ! My Nani Maa is from Kerala and currently working in Kolkata High court as an advocate she clearly stated how peaceful people were in nineties and it has significantly changed with time.
I did a bicycle trip across kerala. Traversing 800 km's covering 90% of remote areas of districts. Needless to say, kerala felt magical, unlike anything I have ever felt in any other state of India. Mallapuram was the safest I felt while riding my bike
I hope one day I do that as well.
Bro that's awesome. I am a malayali living in US since 9, and every time I visit kerala it is magical place. Beautiful land and people.
From malappuram ❤
omg thats so cool, if u post any vlogs ill watch em fs
@@tguptahaahhaha Could not afford a GoPro and the logistics of carrying a camera setup on my first bicycle trip
I am from Karnataka, last yr when i was in 12th, my school taken us to a trip to Wayanad,Kerala. Its just phenomenon, the people,the place and the culture. Rich heritage. I don't know everybody thinks kerala is a ISIS state. But do visit one time, you will get to know the truth. Coastal areas, the culture, the ethics, the most imp is secularism. But I don't know the conversion and all. I didn't get it. All communities are in their own place and living in harmony. They won't forget their identity. Just like in karnataka, kerala is also rich heritage state for Hindus.
Kerala is most super secular state say whatever just ask any kerala hindu, our coexistence is WAy above you thinking
@@FRieza207after 10 year . Please help me. Very soon. Next Kashmir
@@ajayyadav17AP we don't let that happen
Hindutwa goons will ask soon from north India @@ajayyadav17AP
@@FRieza207 open your eyes .. 2011 kerla Hindu population 65% and now 25% .. please save Hinduism in South India .. 🚫👺☪️✝️
Being a Goan I really appreciate people of Kerala they help each other no matter your religion if you know Malayalam he or she will help you. I have experienced it in the Gulf.
True
Plz don't eat beaf
@@relaxingsongs5098we like beef bro
@@anandjainishereI like aayesha. I like PORK 🐖 🍖🥓
I wish you included concept of Onam also, which is celebrated by every Malayali across the world irrespective of their gender/caste/religion. Thanks Mohak and team for telling the real story. Visit Kerala when you get a chance.
Happy 🌼nam :) here everyone is welcome.
It's similar to Pongal in tamilnadu which is a festival for harvest. It's a universal festival here everyone celebrates Pongal.
Even Christmas is largely a secular festival in Kerala and is celebrated by all communities. Kerala's probably the best Christmas destination in India. Muslim festivals are also celebrated but it's not quite there yet.
Christmas,Onam and perunal all this are celebrating by each malayalees without looking at the relegion.
Yeah right. 😂😂 Kerala is one of the most homophobic and extremely religious states in the entire India. There are people who say don't celibrate onam in Kerala.
@@Y______K lol .
As a person from Northeast I can confidently say that Keralites are very nice and educated people. Our regions share many things including passion for football⚽ from people who I have met and my friends, relatives never have I heard a bad thing about Kerala people.
But now a days good news are not coming from northeast firstly assam then Manipur and now mizoram what is that ????
@ShubhamKumar-vd9xy as if good news are flooded from North India. Every state has some complex conditions which others don't know and locals know better than outsiders.
@@josejoseph8725 I am just saying random and disturbing fact!!!
@@ShubhamKumar-vd9xy shit happens.
@@ShubhamKumar-vd9xywhat mizoram? There is nothing happening in mizoram wtf 🤣🤣🤣
Most importantly we don't go around identifying ourselves as Christians, Hindus, Muslims etc. which is why we stand united.
😂😂😂 biggest joke
@@AdvaiticOneness1what ur stats buddy? In which development index ur state is better than Kerala
@@1x1x1is1 in from Kerala itself. Lmao
Kerala is a dream State for me 🇮🇳
I'm from Telangana,
I have studied in a school run by CMI foundation based in Kerala.
In the year 2000 itself our school had Fully equipped computer lab with 30 computers. We were taught Java basic in class 9.
Our principal used to conduct free class where we just discuss various topics. The hot topic is always religion and mythology.
We were exposed to Greek and Roman mythology. Indian religions and culture.
We had a Library with books ranging from Comics to Scientific Journals.
I completed my SSC in 2015 and the fees was 10,000 rupees.
The role of CMI in Indian education is criminally underrated
@@TheRishijoesanu criminally underrated...?
@@TheRishijoesanu true
@@davidalexsebastiank6250 "criminally underrated" is just a saying/phrase. There is nothing criminal about the foundation
@@sindhurtej9638 ohhhkk got it, thank you 😊
I am a keralite by birth. I have friends who belong to Islam faith and Hindu faith. Religion, even though we can become a topic of discussion among us, but it never came to divide us. I believe Kerala is a true secular state, even though there are small scale, tensions arise here and there. by the spirit of India is stand for. We should celebrate every religions of India. We have achieved so much great things over the last 75 years of independence but it would be a various sad story if it ends in a communal violence and tear the country apart. So we should work for the harmony and make India greet.
Truth is always bitter
❤️
If it's true then why Hindu population decreasing..now only 52%.. while Muslim and Christian increase rapidly
@@sougatmohapatra8540your question is so ridiculous, u already know the real answer behind it.
Your way of questioning is like y is hindu population increasing in UK and America and all other western countries, y is sikh population increasing in Canada in the last 100 years. Y did the native white population fall down in the last 100 years in most western countries?
If u know y white people are decreasing in western countries in the last 100 years, then u will also know y hindu population is reducing in Kerala .
Lastly Kerala has a fertility rate of less than 2 , which means that the entire state is reducing its native population not just hindus. Many are working abroad.
😂 nice joke a true secular state. I never hear such jokes, you made my day.
You forgot to mention Onam, which is the most popular festival in kerala, which is celebrated by people of all religions
Onam and Christmas ❤
As a Keralite, I personally think that Keralites nowadays are not as religious and are more secular-minded which is great. Our future would be great if we overcome our differences and unite as one community. Now personally being born into a Christian family I later became agnostic as my father who taught me from a young age to respect all religions and see people as humans before their religion. I hope we all get together as a community and prosper
I invite you to study Islam
@@lvi25 Thank you for the offer but I have to refuse because I quite like the person i am now and would like to keep following my way of life.
@@EvanTomy suluclar not Hindu not other.
When this movie came out, social media was full of hate comments against kerala and malayalis. As a Malayali, I felt really sad. But now it is not like that,because I realized that half of the people in this country are full of the poison of religion. In this comment section itself, North Indians are standing to correct the Malayalees who say that Kerala is safe. So what I want to say to my fellow Malayalees is that we know how our Kerala is, what are our problems and priorities. Don't take anything they say seriously, just ignore all these hate .I am still proud of being born in Kerala and thankful to God that I was not born anywhere else in India.
Its not that big of a deal dude, chill out.
Exactly!! The same thoughts were going on in my mind.. I just didn't comment bcuz these people will surely come to reply with their hate comments.. That's now in their habit.. Anyways just like u said, we keralites know how our Kerala is and how we live here.. Let the others speak or propagate negative statements about it due to a movie, we just don't care:) they won't see the good comments made by the North Indians who lived here and knows the truth :|
It's due to wahabism imported from saudi and radicalization of Kerala Muslims from the past 50 to 100 years. Otherwise Kerala is mostly peaceful.
hate only for muslims not kerala and malyali, plz dont spread misinformation.
@@Sanjaypatelxm why hate all Muslims? Many Muslims are also among Malayalis. There are people who happen to born in Muslim families but the extend of their faith is very different. Imagine people in low caste say that they hate higher caste people because of how they exploited their community. Imagine people in higher cast say that they hate low caste cast because they are ruining their opportunities through reservation. 'hate' is a word which can kill an entire nation. If now people are hating other people of a particular religion, what about in future when they start hating people of other states, other castes, other cultures? It's very easy to hate.
Don't generalise people. Imagine a stranger comes to you and say that whatever religion you believe in sucks. How do you feel? I don't think anyone will be indifferent if someone talks ill about their faith which they believe in from birth. Same goes with Muslims. Some of my muslim friends are non believers, they just take part in the community for the sake of it. (kind of scared to say that they are athiests lol,) All muslims are not very conservative. But I should say that there is an increase in conservative Muslims recently. One of the major reason for this is increasing anti muslim sentiments among people. They are forced to group together. I even heard some people saying that Muslims don't belong here. These kind of words will only make them hate our country and its citizens. One of the major reason for youngsters in joining terrorist organisations is this hate.
I am a Hindu from Kerala. Christians and Muslims are an integral part of my Life and my Society and I love and respect them .
I bet second to that
@@shubham-oh4ki i don't care what's written in their book. I respect them by the way they behave and involve in my life
@@shubham-oh4ki I have enough knowledge in Qur'an, Bible and manusmriti. So you better not teach me
@@shubham-oh4ki In this country, I fear Hinduism more than any other ideology.
@@shubham-oh4ki And what gave you that conclusion?
I am a Muslim who studied in both Christian and hindu educational institutions.
I have gone to many North Indian cities and i could feel the haterd for Muslims in those cities and that makes kerala different from other.
No one here ask what is you religion but i and my friends have gone through this situation in North even from the well educated and reputed people.
I am from jammu we also live happily.... :) I am from hindu majority district but seriously before entering in social media I didn't knew that hindu and muslim hate each other .. : but I will not lie seriously here tribal people(Gujjar) are muslim and in my area they give shelter to territories for money and I don't like it 😭(I never judge them as a Muslim but as a anti national)
Sorry for poor English 😅
@@kritikasharma6304gujjar community toh sabse patriotic community ha kashmir ki
@@goku9554 Jammu* ki .... :) But some people do for money 💲
@@kritikasharma6304 aap kashmiri pandit ho kya fir, jammu ma muslim nehi ha kya???
@@goku9554 No I am dogra from jammu....Yes mostly tribal people (Gujjar) from jammu are muslims ....vaise or bi bohat muslim ha jammu division me
മതം ഏത് ആയാലും മനുഷ്യൻ ഒന്നാണ് ,
This slogan we spreading in kerala we all are friends and we are still human no need for any religions wall , no need for north and west ,east indians worries we know how to handle here problem 🙌
Loved Kerala in my bike travel late 2023. It was the cleanest, most disciplined and enjoyable state to ride in. Loved the food, the scenery, talking to the sensible people there. Only drawback was the heat, but we can manage. Super state, and ranks way above than the so-called Indian culture states.
Kerala is called the God's Own Country because all gods have been coexisting peacefully in Kerala since the Bronze Age Collapse. It's a model community not just in India but in the world.
Excellent observation.I personally experienced the same.But kerala is often underated when it comes to national level talks and government policies.
@@TheRishijoesanuIts a ad tagline
Hi bro.. You are from?
Hindu, muslim, Christian no matter. Human is matter
🗿🗿
Iam a Christian from kerala and my best best best friend is a Muslim and lot of hindu & Christian friends... we live here peacefully... Our land (kerala) is the best in the country 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 proud to be a malayalee 😍😍😍😍
Nice Joke 😂😂
@@ajayyadav17APU just don't understand anything. Come to kerala and explore yourself. That's all I have to say
I am a christian from kerala, its like near the end of my clg that i found that some of my friends were actually hindus not christians😂😂. Its because we never spoke about religions with each other and they kind of had christian sounding names.
I am from up and I study in kerala and believe me it's the most secular and the most peaceful state in India... This is the reason why BJP tactics don't work here
this is how the main stream media should do research ......your research are damn solid .....very welll
Only because of hindu ancestors in Kerala its secular, the hindus welcomed the islamic traders and merchants, the jews who ran away from their land and the christians who came in search of spices! All because of the open minded hindu kings! It's only because of open minded hindus kerala is secular even today! This is a fact!
I feel sad for kerala hindus
As a Hindu and a non-Kerlaite ( Native of Bihar) who lived in Delhi , I myself studied in a Christian school owned by Malayalis , and I can proudly say that the culture of communal harmony of Mallu's impacted the environment of our school alot . We celebrated Diwali as well as Christmas , Eid and Gurupurab also with utmost joy and excitement . Every student from each religion and community took these festivals as their own and also took part in it . I myself have two best friends one of whom is a Muslim and other is a Christian and the most shocking thing is that these two are not even from Kerala , they are from UP where religion is always a hot debate of politics . So we can see how the impact of the culture of Malayalis can improve the situation in North India .
The problem is not with people, but ideology.
What does qu'ran say about non-mu-slims?
What does C'ianity say will happen to u if u don't believe in je-sus?
@@mlg1279 this one right here facts
@@rix1c992 Another fact: Kerala has two radical is-lamist organizations - Muslim League and SDPI (PFI). Luckily, the BJP government has banned PFI - whose principal aim was to make India into an is-lamic country by 2047. So much for "culture of communal harmony"!!
@@mlg1279, You are a result of propaganda dear
@@MithlajManzoor Truth is bitter. Learn to cope! 🤡🐷🤡
I am from Karnataka a frequent visitor to Kerala, but it's something very different from other states.
They have unity between the religions & they never complain to each other, they live together peacefully.
Silence is not peace,
Lets talk about karnataka then,
Udupi washroom video case,
The administration maintained peace by granting bail to the 3 accused girls, but they had videos of girls doing things in bathroom, they already send the video to their majhabi friends , it can ve used for many thing now, karnataka has fallen to desert cult worshipers,
I hope you enjoy you crooked version of 'peace' in which you will be in piece
@@eee9034 that's correct
If they are so fond of unity why did pakistan form
@@advait_enthusiast Pakistan had nothing to do with Kerala? The entire concept of Pakistan came from northern and eastern states. None of the southern states ever had any concept of a separate muslim homeland. Nor did any significant migration happen from the south to Pakistan, because their cultural identity was more important to them than their religious identity.
@@zetaforever4953
Then why did not nizam of hyderabad accept to join Indian union post independence ?
Why Sardar Vallabhai Patel had to fight with Nizam
@@advait_enthusiastyou're not making any sense.. Please keep this "bhadas" upto yourself!
As a person from Kerala I proudly says that we live here happy and respect eachother and we don't care about others religion we care about either he is a good person
Am a muslim from kerala, staying in gulf country.. whether in kerala or over here we keralites muslims, hindu or Christians live together with harmony, As all human beings with different beliefs. And Religion is a way of life , who ever can choose it what they find is suitable and its very personal. If its harming other human either the religion is wrong or you have No knowledge of it or not practising the way it should be.
Islam says that Jews and Christians are not to be friends to Muslims.
Last month only, I visited Kerala's Thirissur. What a place! Good food, good people, plus the scenery I wish I could have stayed there for almost a week or 10 days, but I was there for a wedding, and I stayed there only for 3 days. People talking sh*t about Kerala are jealous of how one state can live peacefully and in harmony.
I have a friend named Manisha Singh who fell in love with a Hindu guy in Kerala and after some time they had a sexual relationship and when the boy told her that he was a Muslim and not a Hindu, Manisha wanted to break up with him. But that boy blackmailed her by showing her nude and forcibly made her a Muslim and sent her to Pakistan, she is exploited daily. She somehow contacted me and told me that help me, I cannot bear it any more.....
@@lolxd926 bro if it was true why isn't he informing Officials? He's making this shit up
Bro but Kochi is completely different especially some areas there
@@lolxd926look at his comments history and saved playlists, it screams extremism
@@hustler2847are you writing a script for sudip sen😃
I'm a gov employee from Rajasthan, working in kerala , I can say for sure kerala is very beautiful and people are the most friendliest which I have ever seen I can say in respect to North Indians.
In terms of safety I initially feel uncomfortable, but now I can it is good in comparison to north
Go to Muslim areas and celebrate your festival to know the meaning of secularism.
@@Contractor48I am hindu myself and I celebrate many of my festivals in muslim areas..and apart from my head getting chopped off, nothing much has happened...all my muslim neighbours are peaceful😊
True
@@Contractor48if you are not from kerala shut up. We malayalees celebrate every festivals together. You can even see a temple , church and mosque existing together in a compound in kerala.
@@7weeks817 lol, thank you for educating me. I learned a lot about peacefulness today.
How come only the Hindu population is declining from 69% in 1901 to 61% in 1951 to 54% in 2011 in a secular state Kerala which is secular for all. Whereas Foreign monotheists religions r increasing who using their foreign gods name brutally wiped out all ancient polytheists pagan civilizations killing over a billion people all over the world. How many institutions are working for doing this job of reducing Hindu numbers.🤔🤔
😂it's once freedom to convert or not .Better uh Go with ur own business 😂
OK LETS TALK ABOUT THE NO OF DECREASE OF MUSLIMS IN MAHARASHTRA MUSLIMS ARE BECOMING MINOR AND HINDUS ARE BECOMING MAJOR WHAT ABOUT THAT 😂?
@@user-tk7dv6tv1e The question still remains why only the Hindu population is declining in a secular state which is said to be secular for all?? Foreign monotheists religions r groomed to convert others..but Hindu which is a polytheist pagan civilization where Hindus r not groomed to spread Hindu culture as Hindu is not a religion so how is this called equality or freedom to convert when Hindus r not groomed for this act of converting others. What about Muslim population grew 5x times from 3.5 cr in 1951 to 17.5 in 2011 whereas Hindu population was controlled just 3.2x times rise from 31cr to 100 cr in 2011 which should hve been 155cr ..same like muslim 5x rise. A massive loos of 55 cr Hindus in Bharat. Leftists cangress wiped out 55 cr Hindus using its system & laws. What abt Jammu & Kashmir Hindu genocide.. wher art 370 was itself made o that Hindu population doesnt increase per 100 person?? In 200 districts Hindus have become minority since independence what about that?? Hindu population was 85% in 1951 & now is 78%..muslim population was 8% now doubled 15%...what abt that?? Use Hindu money and increase Monotheists foreign religions numbers.. great strategy being used under the blanket of secularism. So don't teach me my business..see what happens after conversion we get Afghanistan, Kashmir , Pakistan Iran, Iraq, libiya, etc 🤣🤣🤣🤣who wer all great civilizations when they were polytheists pagans but now r begging after conversion.
@@rahuljagarwal153most Hindu in Kerala is atheist ( communist ) and Hindu is much more secular than other religion like islam and in the some Islamic tradition of giving birth to more kid increasing Muslim population in Kerala.
Hindu population is not decline rather Muslim population is more increasing.
Like in 1901 Christians are in 13% and now is 18% not much growth compare to Islam
@@Malayil._.Fandom. right .. so here only the question rises how only Hindus hve become atheist Hindus why monotheist religions have not become atheist. One Monotheist religion is increasing its numbers while other Polytheist Pagan culture isnt. This itself is inequality what is th state govt doing for this inequality. Even Amir khan makes serials, movies like Satyamev jayate wher he targets only Hind culture like rakshabandhan, karwa chauth but doesnt target his own monotheist religion. There is a huge network running this agenda. Hence m saying this is all done by foreign religions funding where Hindus r brainwashed towards atheism while others r made more religious a long term planning of reducing Hindu birth rate & increasing Foreign religions birth rate. Same foreign monotheist religions who hve brutally wiped out all ancient Polytheists pagan civilizations killing over a billion people. The state should actually encourage Inclusive Polytheists pagan culture and not foreign religions & if it doesnt it means the system is controlled by Foreign religions. Foreign religions use Hindu money to build ther religious institutions & infrastructure to increase ther numbers while same Hindu money is used to reduce Hindu numbers per 100 person. Hindus r not groomed to convert or give message of ther gods/goddesses to others but foreign religions r groomed to convert others. So how is this equality when we talk of equality of freedom in propagation of religion
@@rahuljagarwal153 like we are living in Christian World so most atheist was Christian in case of Kerala it is a Hindu majority state most Kerala atheist are Hindu personally I know some atheist who was Christian but now is atheist.
I don't know much about Aamir Khan films like I am not a North Indian so I cannot say much about Bollywood.
I can see Hinduism getting targeted by the left party because of opposite is a religion based party.
Problem with the left party they calling out everything like even good things the party did ( i am not BJP supporters).
Well researched. Appreciate the conclusion you brought out, that the communal harmony that has been existing in Kerala for thousands of years was, is, and will always be fragile and something to be taken care of. And not to be taken for granted. Thanks.
actually those who are minorities wants secularism, like hindu in bangladesh, or pakistan, and muslims in india.
I'm from Bangladesh. One of my cousin is a travel vlogger, visited India couple of times. After visiting some major provisions, he said Kerala, Manipur, Mizoram are the best among all. The other states may be more beautiful on the basis of natural resources, but the behaviour of the natives, the atmosphere, the tranquility was overwhelming. He faced some difficulties & few derogatory remarks in some particular states. Once he was even told to get out from a restaurant by the owner just because he's bengali. The owner said Bangalis (not just Bangladeshi) aren't welcomed here. In the contrary some Malayali offered him shelter as there was no hotel nereby. They never discriminate knowing that he's Bengali.
Even staying thousands miles away, Bangladeshi people are well known about the beauty of Kerala & Malayali people's generosity. We often give example whether it's about education, women empowerment, cultural diversity, secularism & what else. I hope Kerala remains beautiful forever. The religious conflict may not reach there.
@@nausaadzaman1805 off course for radicals like you you will support things that fall in your interest
@@nausaadzaman1805 so sad to here islamists in kerala I'd targeting Hindu girls & boys and we are also facing illegal bangladeshi infiltration issue
@@swatipriya562 your instant attacking comments are the proof that India has changed. & in near future you will be first one to feel the hellfire because of inter-conflicts which already have started.
@@nausaadzaman1805 and your instant victim card shows how mullahs try to divert when questioned about facts
@@nausaadzaman1805 I understand mullahs are afraid of one thing about truth ; don't worry about my country better try to stop illegal infiltration
As someone living in Kerala and not from here, I can tell you the tolerance and acceptance is unlike anywhere else in the country
He said that communal harmony is just like a cob web..is it true?one or two incidents of communal harmony don’t justify the nature of communal situation all over Kerala..
There definitely a few places where there is dispute between different communities but it's mainly politically instigated. As such the people are very much secular and accepting.
Professor's hand was cut by muslim. Still they are tolerant.
You haven't heard recent Muslim legue slogans.
@@niharranjanmahunt4102 And even then, the “communal” violence could be misrepresented. Imagine you have 2 groups of friends. One is Hindu and the other is Muslim. A guy from the Hindu group is upset that a Muslim guy made a joke about his mother, so he punches him and the 2 groups fight. This fight has nothing to do with religion but the media will say, “Muslim group ambushes Hindus” to get a headline.
Mumbaikar North Indian Muslim from Dubai , ( more than decades we north & South Indian staying together in gulf countries together).
We always received positive vibes from keralite people in Gulf ❤
More than North Indian food we enjoy South Indian food ❤
We Love the Nature beauty of Kerala , Safety , peace 🕊️ and discipline of life it’s makes the Land of progressive India .
Infact we feel sometimes that if we wants to return our motherland we would wish to settled in Kerala ❤
Life is too short for hate , Hate 2 Hate & Love 2 Love 💕 and stop spreading negativity and hatred .
I am a settled Mumbaikar and a Hindu born in a Christian trust hospital in Kerala at my mother's place which has 'pre dominant' Christians staying and my father's place has 'pre dominant' Muslims around... however there's a catch here... 'pre dominant' is just a word here...in fact all Hindus, Muslims and Christians stay together as a community without any prejudice. They just coexist and enjoys each other's community. Even to Shabarimala any religion follower can visit with 41 days 'deeksha' or 'vrat' or 'vratham'. So I feel it's just that more human than religion when you are in Kerala.
Same in Mumbai
I have been to kerala multiple times because my mother is from kerala..... I agree there are few bad people. But most people in kerala are really good. It's a state where you can find temple, church, mosque at the same place... The people have better communal harmony. There is no discrimination and religious conflicts.... It's truly God's own Country
It's not about people, it's about the ideology. The mu-slims in Kerala follow the same I-slam that's followed elsewhere. I-slam is a regressive c-ult which causes problems
@@mlg1279 every religion hitherto does same thing
Mohak was late to this topic but he presented both sides of Kerala with such in-depth and well researched video. This is what the whole country needs to know. And please support creators like the whole Soch team so that we will get such well informed videos with no bias.
Thanks to the whole Soch team for presenting the actual Kerala Story and educating on several other topics.
Couldn't agree more
No he isn't late to the topic, infact this assures us that he is not the one who jumps on the hype and narrative based videos like others including dhruv as well.
Taking time in thorough research and multifaceted perspective is what this channel offers us. Kudos to him and his team!
He is late just to avoid critism which is disgusting... If you really want to bring change you can't be fearful of critism
Timing is perfect. We have another state burning because of hatred between two communities.
@@negi-jiin
A very well researched video. My only concern is towards the end when you relied on the views of only a few individuals with extreme views to generalize the situation. And to say that the movie depicts the reality of Kerala was indeed silly.
As a keralite i can say that we aren't facing any problema on behalf of religion. The main problem we are facing now is unemployment even the literacy rate is the best in India
As a keralite I want to say something that nothing can divide us ....we are one ....we are Kerala......we are just human beings.... people who carrying religious poison please leave us alone.
Yes bro🤍
❤
DICLAIMER: BJP supporters should not see this video, you may get offended😂😂
I think anti bjp people.Because this shows that kerela too have problems which are increasing.
@@Harshit09877What problems dude, its all propaganda no real issues
@@omar_vlogger no big issues??😂😂 one of the most troubled state in this decade
@@iitnakanpur.. Yes dear im keralite , I've heard none, you tell me then..
@@iitnakanpur....pls explain the issue which kerala is facing
I'm a Malayali who has studied and worked on different parts of India. Many North Indians struggle to understand the religious harmony in Kerala. They are so used to the political conflicts in their states, they believe it is impossible, but what's worse is they end up making up or taking up weird theories of their own. My husband is also from North he has explained how he also learned this about the Kerala community after spending so much time in different parts. Kerala isn't perfect but the society we have achieved is truly worth understanding and learning from, for the rest of the country, especially today. That's also why Kerala is attacked so much by RW.
I don't care what other people think about kerala, nevertheless i feel so blessed to be here. If there's communal tension in a state there's no winner on both sides, both side loses, no matter it's the killer or the victim, both won't have peace of mind or good living condition. Nothing beats kindness and living in a kind environment is the best thing one could ever wish for.
The question your raised - Which of the movies was more closer to the truth - Kerala Story or 2018?
The answer is 2018.
As someone who went through the college system in Kerala, and witnessed first hand the devastation and ensuing events of 2018 floods, i can confidently say that 2018 was a must better depiction of Kerala.
2018 is closer to reality for a short term.
In long term Kerala story is closer.
Islam is a slow poison. It takes decades to change the demography and initiate violent separatist movements.
But what about islam coming to India before Arabia? 3:40 😂 almost 100 years before.
@@bowxfire5275This video is not 100% facts. He done some research. But half of the things from statements done by some politician or leaders and not by any Historians. I'm not telling Historians are also not always correct(As new proofs unearthed always) and Scientific discoveries also(Pluto was a planet before). It's like 'Flat Earth' mind. Some people still not believe Spherical Earth 🌎.
Both are correct depictions of kerala
@@alanjohnson7994 From Supreme Court case 'Kerala State vs Kerala story Producer' on defaming a State, verdict was Kerala Story was a work of Fiction. Producer accepted it as Fiction. Actual Girls conversion to Islam and joining ISIS as per Indian Government records says from Kerala merely 7 did that, compared to 80-90 from Gujarat. As per movie, the number provided is 100x higher than the whole India data.
I'm from Northeast , India and I have many teachers from south India mainly from Kerala and Tamil and they were one the best teachers. I love south India and always long to visit once after I complete my studies.👍
You are always welcome❤️
It's not about kerala ❤, it's about manipulating peoples bro
Sai vikas se ho kya?
From Kerala
As a Kerala Hindu, I am proud of the culture, religious harmony of Kerala and absolutely resist hate speech against Kerala and it's minority Muslim and Christian citizens.
But I stress on the fact that Hindus should think exactly like Christians/Muslims and not to let liberal thoughts invade themselves because no Christian/Muslim is that obsessed with Kerala's unique culture that they want to sacrifice or make progressive changes in their religion, let alone dissolving the faith and allowing things like inter-religious marriages. Hindus should be concerned about safeguarding all people with Hindu names, abolish caste and solve caste-related issues, and think like one people of one community. Some fringe minority radicals and woke submissive Hindus might flag my comment as hate-speech, but I want to remind them all that I am simply asking them to do what the other communities do, that's all. This has nothing to do with supporting BJP/RSS as these are just dangerous political schools of thought which would do absolutely no good to Hindus.
കേരളത്തിലും വർഗീയവതികൾ ഉണ്ട് പക്ഷെ എണ്ണത്തിൽ കുറവാണു, വർഗീയത പറഞ്ഞാൽ ഇവിടെ എല്ലാരും കൂടി പൊങ്കാല ഇടും 😂 അതിപ്പോൾ ഏത് മതക്കാരൻ ആയാലും 😂
😂😂
Kerala: We are happy.
Rest of India: No.
As a kerala women i feel very safe and secured , No gujarat chai wala can divide unity between muslim Christian and hindu in kerala
Is Kerala story false??
@@manashprakash3776 absolutely false 💯
Pehle hum Indian hai uske baad Hindu Muslim Christian
😂😂😂 that's why pFI cut hands and kill people in daylight. And most terrorist are from Kerala . All terrorist organisation headquarters were based in Kerala . Kerala High , court is false central agency is false , old cm is false 😂😂. Sunshine is true 😅😅
@@manashprakash3776 obviously!
The question doesn't even make sense.....
Im a born christian who studied with muslim and Hindu friends. My aunt adopted islam and i got married to a hindu girl. Actually i think it is so stupid to fight on religion ! Life is too short to fight on such silly things. I am sad that such people still exist even in 2024 😢
As a Keralite im sooooooo proud...we don't fight for religions aaah
I have met Kerelite colleagues from all the three religious backgrounds and honestly, I found them to be the some of the most polite, disciplined and gentle people in India. Offcourse, there will be some bad apples, but they do not define the entire malayali population.
True
mani pfi is the main culprit the nia has got proofs..but again what to say.
@@Shalu_Kashyap.. Thanks ! Corrected
@@Shalu_Kashyap.. Malayalam is the language and malayali is the word for people who are native Keralites.
@@mansibisht8589Bjp rules India what more do we need to have, atleast pfi is banned
We are living in kerala and we know how peaceful and harmonious our state is and also we know that the people who hates kerala will become a fan of Kerala if BJP get some seats but we are helpless for you because kerala people are well read and educated ,they always see both sides and judge and they can’t be easily swayed away by fake news ,RSS has a very strong base in kerala and they have the maximum number of shagas in kerala when compared to other states ,but the irony for them is even BJP people won’t vote for BJP in kerala just because they don’t want to destroy the religious harmony of the state …It’s a fact and as keralites we don’t need anyone’s certificate about state ,there are lot of North Indians living in kerala and they know what’s the true fact ,we need the testimony from them only ..
Bhakts are just severely jealous of Kerala,because of their education, rich culture and class.
They are not jealous, they are worried!
i watched kerala story and realised it have nothing to do with kerala and it is just a conception of north indians
Bro I'm your subscriber for 2 years and I'm from Kerala
Thanks for promoting 2018 movie, it's based on real events and yes it's our story ..
All Indians please watch it..
This movie proves humanity is necessary for our survival during catastrophes ❤
Sure
Humanity cannot come from a religion which considers other religion people as worst creature
If you say some muslims are good and helping others they are actually disobeying quran
They are not muslims according to Islamic standards
@Sasuke-vx1cesham Sharma show is totally politically motivated channel
@Sasuke-vx1ce Jaipur dialogues, sham sharma are wrost
@Sasuke-vx1ce Sham sharma, aktk, jaipur dialogues are politically funded channel lmao
The reason why Kerala is different from north India is most of the Kerala muslims were traders and not invaders unlike in North India which was highly effected by Afghans and Mongols
Mongols?
@@deku006 yeah , later Mongols were converted to Islam.
@@deku006Mughals means Mongols in Persian
@@TheRishijoesanu they claimed they were Mongols due to Babar's mother , she was apparently a mongol they say
* Churches in kerala till 15th centuary had the same ceremonies of the temple. Portuguese stopped them calling it as heresy. This was the main reason why the split happened in the Christian community.
* Christians had an old ashrama in Angamali in Ernakulam which taught foreign languages specially their syriac language till 14th centuary. It was believed to have kept a high standard of teaching then. Eventually this place remained as just a place where christian priests were trained.
* Knanaya Syrian christian community keeps marrying within their community(endogamous). They are the children of the traders who came to India from Persia.
* Syrian Christian community of the Christians have highest influx of foreign ancestry in their DNA.
* One of the kings in 14th centuary was a Christian named King Thomas. The kingdom was called Villarvattom. One of his ancestors became Christian and the kingdom became Christian.
* Devasahayam Pillai the first saint of christians in india was born as a hindu to a temple priest. He was as an official in the kingdom of Travancore.
I’m a Tamil Muslim, my professor Swaminathan and his wife Malathi are Brahmins but they took ashirvad from my parents during their anniversary. Btw the presentation was formal and amazing brother, keep up the good work 👍
Personal experience of Kerala , it has it's own vibes no one can beat..... thankyou for being a part of our country
Lot of us don't want to be a part.
We are very different from hate spreading northies. We don't want to associate with that.
Actually me as a Keralite don't want to be part of India which is sucking out South India only for corruption.
@@Wiela4015 maybe instead of spreading hate back just try to make them comprehend...lmfao "wE dOnT wAnT tO aSsOcIaTe wIth tHaT"
@@Wiela4015 now you are spreading hate. he is spreading love and you are spreading hate
@@vmsterna1933 read the comment above. Everything is mentioned there
Recently a hindu couple got married in a mosque in the traditional hindu ceremony, this is largely because they all have only one mother language be it hindu, Christian or muslim, they all speak only malayalam and generally they are helpful to others in their malayali community outside Kerala.
I've been to Kerala, and i found the most disciplined and honest people there...
brother, the kerala story is made by hindu extremist thats why its like that i would like anyone from any other states to live in kerala for not more than 1 week they will realise the amount of secularism enjoyed in india. kerala has the most literacy in india and thats why BJP is not coming in power in kerala where modi is trying to spread hate between illiterate hindus and other reliegion and make it hinduist country. the secularist kerala proud to be a malayali😍😍
My family was on the verge of suiside, I was in 6th standard or some thing, father lost everything in real estate . I remember my nri uncle and aunt daily calling and abusing my mom for a gold chain she borrowed from them. We were living on a rented house. They some how managed our muslims neighbours phone number and daily calls them for my mom.
One fine day the neighbour called my mom and gave all her gold and told her to sell or pawn or do what ever with it. My mom never shared any of our problems with them btw.
This is my Kerala story
Yes but do you see that everywhere? These extreme thoughts, my religion is the best, killing people in name of religion. These are new to us now, it's surprising to see how we have arrived here from those peaceful days. The only thing we can hope for is things getting better or religion gonna end humanity
@@me_and_theother_mecan't agree more
@@me_and_theother_me there is noting for the ruling party to show as their achievements. so this is the simplest way to get votes. divide and conquer. bristish did it now they are doing it. even though there is no food in the plate, uneducated youth with their WhatsApp is happy with playing along
Both are real story. Extremism exists is every religion every ideology. It's our responsibility to counter it
@@jaymahakaal5354 yes how do we counter it is important. Life, humanity, is bigger than religion. Religion is man-made, no God has ever told to kill in his name.
as a south indian, i can conform that kerala is one of the most secular state in india. These film directors try to discriminate the people of kerala by making these films.Kerala is and is gonna be the most diversified state no matter what happns
As a Muslim from Kerala,I don't experience the difference because I have both Hindu and Christian friends...I studied in other states ,like Tamil Nadu ,I felt people there show slight difference, especially elder people,not my college mates...anyway till now Kerala is safe for all religious people....
U people cant…… destroy the equality of KERALA😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎!!!!!
As a Malayalee, am really glad someone decided to make a video about this. May this be one of the first steps toward a better Kerala. And man if you folks have like a Patreon or something, I'd be more than happy to support there.
It's the same video as Dhruv Rathee and several other youtubers. It's all based on the state agenda and research they funded.
@@rutvikrs am really sorry as I have no idea who Dhruv Rathee is but I would check out his videos too for sure
Dhruv rathee videos are also gud but I think mohak mangal videos are more better but dhruv rathee is also good
@@manasasrinivasan1423 DR educational videos are good but when it comes to political view he's a leftist
mohak is neutral in my opinion
@@rutvikrs dr is biased and leftisit while mohak is not the difference is very clear
As a north Indian I really do have alot of respect for my brothers and sisters in kerala and I do want to visit it some day
❤❤
I have to say I don't have the similar respect to North because of u know what. I wanted to work in NI state just a few days back then I saw a video of a foreigner walking through dirtiest of places and then I thought my place is not perfect but way better than many North States. I rather stay in my home than there.
You are always welcome brother 🙏❤️
Any time ❤
Aaavo bayya
I a Kerala hindu girl. I studied my high school and plustwo in a Christian school and used to go church and prayed there. I used to read Bible then.
I have a Muslim best friend who provide me beef biryani on every eid and i give her kerala chips as a part of onam celebration.
In my 5 th standard i am still remembering going to sabarimala temple and prayed at erumely mosque.
When it is Christmas we buy cake and celebrate it. In eid we celebrate it by making biriyani
In inside kerala bus i saw many times a picture of three gods together.
We eat food not mixed it with religion.
During festivals in temple, mosque and church all gathered together and enjoying it.
I still remembering i used to go arthunkal church very famous and give candles there.
In my 26 years of existence in Kerala i have never experienced any communial discrimination.
Dont believe what u saw in media.
If u don't believe just come to kerala and feel free to observe it. Then say.
I am betting my life on this.
Have you said these three religions are living there and cooperating it's very nice that you all are living and cooperating but you also have to see that you all are humans let's say if hindu religion people are not able to develop that much and other two religions develop than the hatred will start
@@ashjustborn what's the relation bw development and religion. Development only come with our education. Bro the day everyone realise this hatred will disappear. Kerala found it a long time ago brother.
@@aswathykrishna9157 no you didn't understand my statement I was talking about human nature
@@aswathykrishna9157 and you are right religion doesn't have anything to do with development infact there should be a boundary so that you won't be an extremist religion is there for celebration learning lessons and manners but if you will attached with it more than you need that it will backfire
Indeed people in Kerala are lucky to have natural environment & good education And Unity of all religions that's why kerla is Educated State in India 💯✅