Why Indian Cities Suck (But No One Cares)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 май 2024
- While the 2024 election campaign is dominated by polarizing communal debates, the real issues facing India keep being side-lined. In this video, I focus on the deplorable state of our cities: poor infrastructure and planning, trash on our streets, and exorbitant housing costs. From Mumbai to Delhi, our urban environments are failing us. Join me as I explore why our cities are in such a dire condition and what we can do to demand better living conditions. Why does your city suck, and what are you willing to do about it?
📃Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1o...
******
🔍✍️Research:
Mohit Priyadarshi: / mohitprior
Zaira Khan: / zaira-khan-7435a9189
Nidheesh Manipal: / nidheeshmanipal
Antara: / that_musical_note
✂️🎛️Editing:
Yash Vyas: / yashvyas24
CharanTej: / mograph.charantej
Utpal Singh Jadon: / utpalsinghjadon
Ajeesh Babu: / ajeesh_babu
Aditya Chowdhury : / infjt_me
Shreyas Jahagirdar: / shreyasnvids
🎨Thumbnail :
Aanchal Verma: / aanchal_creates
Want to work with us? Check this link!
tinyurl.com/22pxjjtv
******
🐦Twitter: / mohakmangal
📷Instagram: / mohak.mangal
👤Facebook: / sochyoutube
Do watch the solutions part at 25:42. It's important!
Okay 👍
I am first bhai
0:10
U r speaking in hindi and even the subtitle is also hindi....
Bro I watch your videos regularly even though I don't understand them completely. I am from Kerala and I don't know hindi. Atleast include English subtitles please so I can understand your videos completely.
"We the people of India" cannot take care of "people of India"
@@Constitution-at-work. that makes no sense
@@Constitution-at-work. lol
Because people are doing hindi Muslim and n number of things
Its NOT just cities. I am travelling theoughy punjab and himachal rn, their natural bequty is better than that of europe. But the difference between us and eruope is that you dont see random plastic dumps, soapless public toilets with piss and dirt on floors and broken roads every few hundred metres.
The Indian public will do all this, and still complain about "BuT The GoVerMenT SaaR"
of ppl by ppl for ppl
People throwing trash out of car : Educated
People collecting trash from garbage bins: Uneducated
This is a typical stereotype in India
💀so true
I can't throw garbage on the road. My consciousness doesn't allow me. Whenever I eat some snacks on the street and I can't find the dustbin to throw the wrapper in, in that case I put the wrapper in my pocket lol .
Irony ko bhi seema hoti hain
@@Mr.VAGlNA salute you. Very few people have this consciousness
@@Mr.VAGlNA Your comment: 😀
Your name: 💀
The saddest part is that if any politician talks about these civic issues during the election, most people will not vote for them!
Meaning of the India Flag: 🇮🇳
🪔 Begging Bowl
🔵 Coin falling in it 👏🏼😂❤️
really? that's unfortunate the denial people live in, I always wondered why we never address these issues with leaders
@@CurryScentedRedDotsIndiansBhai ye toh aapne ne pakistan ka introduction de dia 🤡
Koi bole to . Aur phir karne li strategy bhi dikhaye. Aur phir kare bhi - blame game ki baatein na kare. I think people in Delhi are smart enough to sense BS
@@Shxvxm bhai lekin hamare india ke 9 cities top 10 most polluted ki jagah leke rakhe he 💀
And indians talk about competing with china 😂😂😂. Even the chinese villages are better than top indian cities.
Right, we will not grow with this mindset and will fall
sad..... but true
You can not win a war by being clean
Indian villages r better then any indian cities
You are actually right but the solution is the current government which is investing in the infrastructure and better planning commissions to improve the conditions of indian cities like if you'll take bullet train project, Bharatmala, Sagarmala, Parvatmala, golden quadrilateral etc. which will improve India's connectivity and leads to FDI in backward areas also, real estate sector will also get a boom in the areas near to these infrastructure
It is also because we the citizens don't care.
The population control bill is the only solution.
True💯💯💯
We would care if government shows more care for environment and climate changes
I hated how foreigners stereotype us as dirty and unclean, but after road tripping through punjab and Himachal (and rest of india).
They are absolutely right.
Trash every few hundred metres, soapless - piss on seats- muddy floored toilets, broken roads.
The indian public will do all of this and still somehow blame the "GoverMeNt SAAr"
@@Oobservatory_X we the citizens elected this government. Don't play the blame game
Delhi has no air, Bengaluru has no water, Mumbai has no house and Kolkata has no more jobs.
Patna has all facilities
😢
India has huge population, which is difficul to manage. This guy looks sold out to malign India, as its not his first time.
@@patnametrocity2783 I am from Patna only. No doubt it developing at a very fast rate and I am hopeful in next 4-5 years it will have best of infrastructure. But only challenge is regarding jobs. There is a lack of enough private jobs. I hope scenario changes in few years 🤞
@@samar5992 Mohak raised the same concern. People always gets defensive whenever talks about India’s problem. Until we accept and acknowledge, we will never work for their solutions and will keep on getting contended with whatever is there
Cleanliness is not in Indian cultural ethos, unfortunately. We are so used to dirt and unhygienic conditions that we ignore it.
That's the problem there .but government should have to teach people education could make changes unfortunately education system is clipcying
🤢🤮🤣
No, it is in the cultural ethos, that is why almost all cultural capitals are cleanest in Bharat like Surat, Indore, Chennai, etc. It is just that woke cities like Delhi have such problems.
@@devamjani8041 been to Chennai it is not that clean, other two place I do not know
Once I thought about how Singapore became such successful country and wondered why India which has similar problems can't solve them, then i realised that it was easier for Singaporean people to accept each other's nationalities and thrive together, but here in India we can't even accept the people of different caste/religion/ background whatever. It all starts with us citizens of this country, untill we become broad minded, our politicians will live on to loot us. The worse thing is that in our country people don't realise that those loans taken up by politicians that didn't make any progress but some how the funds landed in their pockets, ya all that lost funds , we have to pay them not those politicians.
Don't be naive . Singapore history is different than India's history . So don't compare . There is a reason why religion and caste such a huge issue in India .
yes right, we don't have uniform identity, like chinese are hans, americans are white
@@suryakantibiswal They had a rougher history dear highly educated brother
Singapore is still almost a predominantly Chinese (75%-80%) racist country, which has developed a series of national strategies to keep the Chinese percentage above 70% for a long time to come, and regularly receives immigration of high quality Chinese talent from China. Similarly, Hong Kong's Chinese percentage is 95%, Taiwan's 98% and Macau's 94%.
These countries and regions have predominantly Han Chinese populations and rank 1st, 3rd, 5th and 11th out of 46 countries and regions in Asia in terms of GDP per capita. China (92% Han Chinese) ranks 20th among Asian countries in terms of GDP per capita. India ranks 37th out of 46 Asian countries.
One of the main reasons for racial harmony in singapore is the government's violent crackdown on racism in the early days. They have strong meritocratic policies and anti racism laws. Anyone who makes statements or do something that disrupts the nation's racial and religious harmony were and still are jailed or expelled from the country.
People care too much about what Foreigners think about India, but They never try to fix it.
they also don't understand why educated people want to leave India.
I do but I can't clean whole India
@@elanita71 it's still your responsibility to make others aware of the issues
@@GauravKumar-tq1kw we had an education event regarding garbage disposal, where people got angry cos they feel its shameful to carry garbage instead of throwing it on the spot.. they teach this to the next gen and this will go on..
They don't actually. The ones who care are a tiny minority. Most people don't care.
Not just the infrastructure, but the civic sense, cleanliness, hygiene, rationality, honesty and integrity suck too.
It starts with each and everyone of us.
@@serenity8145you are right 😢😢
100% agreed - thats why I HAPPILY gave up my Indian citizenship.
Control and limit the migration into Mumbai. Massive unchecked immigration puts a strain on resources for everyone. State government should have more power to limit immigration and look after the needs of Mumbaikars.
@@saum happy for your children he/she will not have to go through this cut through every field here
btw if you are comfortable where are you now
now i feel like world making fun of india's pollution and street food hygiene on twitter was not a bad idea
Thank you, Mohak and team, for saying the hard things that needed to be said, especially in regards to our attitude about hearing news about India's poor hygiene and infrastructure, and also the mindset while voting/seeking votes. Thanks also for the recommendations and solutions. Great job as always.
How's Much is 10 pounds in INR
@@Rahul-pro 1050
In India, some people try to clean city then there will be more people standing too seeing them instead of helping 😒
@HlNDUS_lN_MlNORITY_BY_2029_தயவு செய்து வெறுப்பை பரப்பாதீர்கள்
@HlNDUS_lN_MlNORITY_BY_2029_🙄
@HlNDUS_lN_MlNORITY_BY_2029_ tu hindu muslim karte reh jayega
@@venom6221 sahi heh
I went to a roadside restaurant just 20 mins ago , and went to the bathroom. There was yellow piss on the toilet seat. I couldn't even eat there after that
My neighbours don’t pay Rs150 to the garbage collecting truck and instead throw it in the open. Owners of 2-3 storied buildings, “civilised” and “educated people”, throw the garbage in the open lands. How long can we blame the government.
Educated on paper 😂
Well I try my best to not throw waste outside already things are worse
having a degree in india is not education
government has to impose rules, only that way it will change people's habbit. Its so simple.
Government should make waste disposal free it is free in gulf countries where i live
I left India 2016 i come back at 2024 India is more dirty then before!!
same, it's gotten wealthier, more expensive, AND dirtier. Hilarious.
PM says we are 4th biggest GDP .
@@xcel5203 we r. Population is high. People need to be the change and not throw dirt
I used to live in a very affluent south delhi neighbourhood. I started cleaning the area around my house regularly, seeing this, the people around me started throwing trash there expecting me to clean up after them. They were unreasonable to speak to. They even used public parks to dry clothes and threatened violence when confronted.
I think India should have a law about having to clean their neighborhood or specific areas in their city for small offences like in other countries, I have grown up watching popular media where the characters would hate the day they had this duty but did it anyway.
@@ish_oye exactly. in the US, you can't even have your slippers outside your door in the apartments. You will get fined
wow
Last year i was in Delhi preparing for UPSC. There was a park in front of my library, all the students so called 'UPSC aspirants' used to litter while there were 2 bins in the park. They can write an eight page essay on importance of clean environment but won't do their part. So it's not just the Government, we the citizens are also responsible.
When we see people throwing waste like this. We should call them out publicly then and there. But we don't want to make a scene there and tangle in unnecessary banter, so we sigh and ignore.
Same situation in my college where we study SWACHH BHARAT as paper.
True success of a country is cleanliness. Not its GDP.
That's the normal level of hypocrisy among most people in our country. Sadly!
Those people are not kids...that we have to tell them
....@@sriharshac673
In India development is fancy cars,houses, malls and expressway…….what we lack is safe and environment friendly cities
Yes😢
True success of a country is cleanliness. Not its GDP.
Rightly said. That too only a handful of people are getting rich, and those who are not getting rich are the ones taking loans just for iPhones and an expensive car.
We don't have enough cities. All jobs are being created in same few cities. Small cities need to be developed so that, jobs can be moved there. Smaller cities are easy to maintain than few overpopulated cities.
what we lack is BASIC CIVIC SENSE
We need more videos like this, that speak about REAL issues. Thanks Mohak and team 👏👏👏
You know you can't find a dustbin easily in India's maximum place.
Someone spoke about this. I literally hate that absolutely no one in Mumbai takes action against thisss.
@HlNDUS_lN_MlNORITY_BY_2029_ Nope.
@HlNDUS_lN_MlNORITY_BY_2029_ fatherless activities
Mumbai bekaar jagah hain
@HlNDUS_lN_MlNORITY_BY_2029_ kya un sab ke time pe Bharat ek republic tha? Uss samay constitution thi? Uss samay par election aur govt hoti thi?
Mumbai drains date back to 1800s!
I was shocked to see even educated people working in an IT park throw away their trash outside the company.
Because their ancestors bro, class is inherited
That is what you get when there's no consequence of punishment of doing bad things, government should learn to be strict like Japan, Singapore, China, etc, they heavy fines for such activities
my IT friend also does that
@@spreadpositivity1500 A guy whose name is "Spread positivity" spreading casteist hatred! Better join INC, youtube ain't for you!
Indian littering abroad is so true.
There is only one difference between kid and adult- Adults think about the consequences of their actions and can imagine how it affects others.
The point about local governments needing more power is SO important!!
You really changed my views on this problem.. awesome work Brother❤️.. Let's see where my country goes!
Man this is such an important topic. Not just the air pollution but demanding accountability for basic facilities that impacts 100% of the population. But is it also because we are too diverse which allows politicians to use a multitude of micro identities to create vote banks? I wonder.
Yes
Mere city ki municipality bankrupt ho gyi hai corruption ki wajah se . Jyada power dene se corruption hi badhega India me centralised system is best
@@Thepatriot8356Problem centralisation ya decentralisation ki nhi hai. Log municipality election mein vote hi nhi karte.
Jhuggi-waale daaru aur biryani ke liye, corrupt politicians ko vote dete hain, jo humhaara paisa lootkar, unhi gareebon ko freebie dekar, maseeha ban jaate hain.
The only person who's thoughts are like dhruve bhai...❤❤
Diversity is just an excuse, like colonialism, etc. We can come up with 100 excuses not to change.
Paise toh waise kharachta nahi, but itna accha video banaya hai ki jeb dheeli karni hi padi. This is the exact stuff that we need to look at while voting and I loved the research put into this video !!! Great job done by your entire team !!!
Respect 💯 brother👏
Respected brother 😊😊
Paying money where it does not make difference 😆. Your comment is the perfect example of exactly what he was saying about India that no one cares 😆
@@truthruster so giving money to talented video creators who are making videos to spread awareness and make the world a better place is useless according to you?
@@truthruster your words don’t make up a sentence and even if they do the sentence doesn’t make sense either … are kahena kya chahteh hoo ???
21:42 i m glad u talked about indore .........i am from indore and i can say that in my colony each every person not just cleans there home but also the front side street infront of their home which makes the whole colony clean and not at all dirty.......indore was once the same as the pictures in this video
.......things do change and i m saying this after experiencing not just for a show........u just have to keep your surroundings clean without any hesitation......indore municipal corporation does play a huge role as well in this❤
Which colony is there in Indore?
@@jaysolanki96 kalani nagar airport road
I am a student in japan.. it stands way apart in comparison to other countries.. the way people care for their country is inspirational definitely.. the way they respect their fellowmen... Damn.. something definitely to learn... For all the other countries
Did you experience racism ?
@@user-nk7qd9hy8x not really... I think it depends whom you interact with.. I have met some really nice people who are really cordial. If in case you have come across people who have abused you based on your race or colour I think he or she is just a shame... I have met some really good people here..
India has a judiciary problem. No one gets punishment, no one gets justice in time. Government, people, judges all have chlta h attitude. 😢
exactly
Government is responsible for this they made laws like these
Yep
India mai sabse bada issue hai ki logo ke demand hi galat hai
🤣🤣🤣🤣what?!judiciary itself is overburdened with cases how do you expect it to efficiently carry out punishments if majority of the cases are given dates and judges are more worried about the next hearing of another case, ever heard of judges to cases ratio and the amount fake cases which are very tough to give justice upon.
Comments section me photo upload karne ka option hota to hum sab apne ghar/ apartment ke Bahar Ka view dikha dete.. Very awakening video . But mostly people don't care because everyone is in hurry and race of stupid society
As person living in Bengaluru, as soon as you complain about any problem first thing localite say is "If you dont like it, go back to your home town". By saying that they are suppressing your voice and indirectly encouraging the people who contributing in ruining the city.
As person living in Bengaluru, as soon as you complain about any problem first thing localite say is "If you dont like it, go back to your home town". By saying that they are suppressing your voice and indirectly encouraging the people who contributing in ruining the city.
Yeah same with india when someone criticize something here they be like "if u really hate living here then go to Pakistan" does this even makes sense :/@@remonical11
true no one cares about country and not only country they don't even care about their surroundings
@@aditisharma1773ikr, they are quick to call us anti-national when we address the actual issues in the country
And they keep praising the government when basic cleanliness hasnt been addressed yet 😢
Amazing content. Your point about vote bank politics is absolutely bang on, which is why politicians don't care about civil issues, be it AAP or BJP. But I think decentralization is not the 'silver bullet'. Because there's another hidden reason which is causing these issues, that is corruption! It's not that local bodies don't have enough autonomy and budget, they simply don't want to work! Anybody who gets elected wants to benefit themselves and those around them. MLAs and Municipal Corporators look at the electoral term as their time to exploit the system! After feeding their belly, the leftover 10-20% is what comes to development.
Thanks! This is the first time I'm donating on RUclips. Because it's a cause that's very close to my heart and imo the main problem plaguing our country. Thanks for raising this issue. Hope I amplify your voice.
Badhiya bhai ❤
Woh already kamaa raha hai, yehi paisa ghhareebon ko de dete 😢
@@Living_Thingz Another problem in India, people care way too much what others are doing with their money. Maybe he also donates to poor people and moreover this 300 will still go to the cause which will fuel the creator to illuminate more people about the issue.
@@Living_Thingztuh khud de do na
@@Living_Thingzuska Paisa woh kuch bhi kare. Agya gareeb ka rakshak.
Being an Indian, I don't understand Why we people just want to see or listen good words/videos from foreigners..We just behaving just like a 14year kid..We should understand Most of time they are admiring us for just only views...And if by chance that foreigner criticize India/India's people we got offended like kids and use bad words.."We should always accept the reality and reality always harder"-R.Tagore
Truth is bitter and we have become intolerant. I love this country i but i acknowledged it's flaws.
And people are always comparing us with Pakistan. Always doing Hindu -Muslim. Blaming each other. Like come on Man,
People act like blind here. In reality foreginer is true. It's fact. If they see something good said by foreigners, Our indian people be like "Proud to be indian". But they will never accept the truth.
Totally true
Most of the time they are criticizing us, but we ignore that part.
This HAS to be the most important and amazing video you've made yet. THANK you so much 😭🙏🔥
I am from Bangladesh watching this video. TBH, at least India has got a person like you to say these are the real issues to deal with. We have the same problem as we are all same (indians IG). Hope many people from BD will watch too.
Nobody talks about pollution.. Water crisis.. Deforestation😢😢😢
reduce population and watch each of these issues go away
Why don't you?
Start your own channel and talk about it.
@@Nikhil99bro what about the representatives we chose by voting why won't they talk
@@Stickman-rz9nuCome I wanna reduce you at first 😂😂
@@Stickman-rz9nuIn that manner, China should be the worst. In fact, 90-95 percent of people live in 10-30 percent of China. Population density is even higher than India in that area. Instead we shall focus on banning Vimal, Gutka, Take fines if someone throws garbage like in Srinagar etc
I'm proud of my Indians who always show concern about their country in comment sections by not actually taking any actions...
Great Indians 👍😶
that is why we were ruled for more than 1000 years!!
@@anushpulsar you are right
100% truth, also no one is talking about how much we are consuming more than we want, end result : Uncontrolled Garbage and Climate Change and No one wants to talk about consumerism.
@@anushpulsar हमारी गुलामी का कारण धोखेबाज थे
lol so right, and the fact that I also come in this category
Amazing Mohak. The kind of effort in research, writing, graphical representation, editing etc that you put in your videos is mind blowing. I can understand how difficult it must be to make such short and precise videos on such vast subjects. Hats off man.
The best video ever made on internet goes to you. Really great awareness. Because of these problems it makes me wanna settle in foreign country but l dont want to run away.
The main thing is people's mindset. We teach our next generation about religion, caste and all that, but nothing to ensure them growing up to a civillian with civic sense.
because they are illiterate
We teach our generation that China se hun jyada developed hai par waha jana mat 😂😂😂😂😂
They are illiterate and The schools syllabus literally doesn't teach us the things we need. In Japan, till 4 grade, people are reached to clean their own school. Like You saw in shinchan
@@Anime_Watc29facts
😊😊😊
Indian People Logic:
Help social workers ❌
Become Civil and respectful ❌
Don't spit ❌
Blame Government ✅
(Edit: Not all people because good people are here too. Also Goverment has same faults too)
Right 👍
Indian people me government khud aata he 😂
Government is busy in doing Hindu Muslim 😂😂
Perfectly said..✌️
What to do if BMC allowed illegal petrol pump, big size ad board ?
What normal ppl have role here?
Bhai fire safety ke baare me bhi video banalo 1. Rajkot me game zone me fire se kaafi log mar gae. Surat me 4 years pehle tuition class me aag se 20-30 bachche mar gae. Vo tuition bhi illegal tha. Surat ke textile market me aag se log mar gae. Ese kaafi tier 2 and Tier 3 cities me fire safty ka na hona or illegal jagah pe construction karne ki vajah se aag lagti hai. Hamasre desh me log cigarettes se kam, ese accidents se jyada marte hai. Cigarettes se marna 1 individuell ki choice hoti hai. But ese accident se marna kisi aur ki laparvahi ka natija hai.
Appreciate your effort for focusing on issues that really matter and not the distraction thrown at us day and night , thanks brother
It's been over 2 years since I moved to Canada.
I visited India 2 months ago and I found very difficult to find a hygiene (usable) public washroom in Gujarat which is claimed to be developed.
Sad reality not many Indian citizens care about!
Canada is way more clean than india. I too am thinking to move there due to our garbage government and useless infrastructure. Reservation, And Many other factors. They don't care for our Citizens. All the parties are taking us for granted
I'll be moving to Canada next year my gf is living there already, I'm an Indian but sorry to say India stinks
@@CSAdityaHoonno one cares leave
@@unknown99712 mohak just said about this exact attitude in this video
@@unknown99712 why ? he exaplained his issue. India is pretty dirty if you are poor. Even rich people feel the stink on road. I try to maintain every bit of hygiene I can but I go on roads and there a rancid smell at many places. I am talking in south Delhi btw which is like " good " area of delhi. Tell me how would you feel when you take a bath everyday and clean yourself and do basic hygiene, it feels its all gone the moment you go outside
No city in India is hygienic or clean. No matter what anybody claims it's the truth.
Bro indore city can me considered 🙏
Have you been to Indore? India's cleanest city?
@@Pranay471India's cleanest city would be the most unclean city in Japan 😂😂
Mysore in Karnataka almost there .... Not perfect by any means but almost there
Lol Chandigarh suna he
Brother loved this video. Well done. Unlike some other RUclipsrs who only talk/moan about problems and accuse or point out perpetrators/dictators, etc., what’s unique about you is that you offer/suggest solutions to the problems we face which I really admire. Keep up the great work 🙏👏
It's so nice to see so many youtuber making videos on these issues.
I really want every indian youtuber no matter what type of content they make but it will be so better if they all make video on this topic, they have every type of audiences so it will be good if every person on earth will know what's going on.
I really want to help but im just a student, don't have job, don't have rich parents,don't have understandable friends, don't have good ministers in our state(country)
so my hope is only on youtuber ❤
"India is a rich country of poor people"
poor country of poor people
India is just popular n poor around the world
No civic sense
Money doesn't buy manners
Bro they should learn from Kerala it’s clean as hell
@@seshasaicreations834 Kerala is not a high density state, moreover population in also stable.
Thanks! Keep doing this good work. Raise awareness and make people realize that nothing will change until the change comes from within each person. Citizens have to band together and discuss how to improve their own neighborhoods and hold their politicians and local bureaucrats accountable for inaction and the apathy.
People throwing trash from train windows killing nature huge amount of trash is in all indian train tracks and throwing trash in gatars is the problem of floods in city😢
Thank you bro, keep making videos like these. The truth is if we as an individual can change then the society around us will change. It takes time but it is worth the effort.
Nice
Isko paisa Dene se sab changa ho gya namaste.. 😂😂
@@fcibhattu6483 Bass tumhare jaise logo ke wajah se hi log kch achha krna chahte h to kr ni paate h
I really don't like to throw plastics and cans outside but there aren't enough dustbins in our city. The municipality should provide dustbins everywhere.
Carry the garbage with you and plan your trip so you don’t have to throw it outside.
@@japjeetmehton9921 what about washrooms. How to plan for that? Should we carry our oun toilets also? Its government responsibility to provide those.
@@sourabhkejriwal5762 If u ever travel to japan in your lifetime u'll notice that dustbins are very scarce yet somehow the cities look squeaky clean hows that possible u might ask ? well, the comment u replied to explains this phenomenon.
Well, I just carry it back in my backpack, or my vehicle and throw in a dustbin if I find on my way back, or back at home, is it really dat difficult for us. If u go to Korea, u will see a lack of public bins, everybody carries the trash back to home
thats no excuse
So nice to see you raising these problems that affect common people in urban areas. Good job,brother!
I am proud that my city ,Thrissur, maintains respectable levels of cleanliness. Godspeed to all the workers
And when someone questions people get offended & will argue with nonsensical logic like ' Go to Pakistan n see they don't even have food n water ' Like wth!!
kuch logo ka competition bs pakistan hi rahega hamesha, europe japan nahi dkha hai isliye
Bhai tuje toh phir bhi ye baat kam sunne ko milta hoga.
Main muslim hu, mere kuch bolne se pehle hi yee baat aati hui dikh jati hai 😢
Bro agar wo angle se bhi dekhe tho pakistan has only one polluted city in top 10 rest all are Indian cities ..... Ye cricket ho ya kuch aur bas Pakistan se competition karke kush ho jayenge ....usse kabhi aage badhenge hi nahi
@@zebra2752😢
@@idrisahmed2659 Pakistan halat buri hai ab isme index bhi dikhana padega kya
Itna Sach To Sirf Kuch Hi RUclipsrs Bolte Hai Hats Off Bhai
Jo County ke bahar hote he wahi log
@@MR.11officialthanks to the "amazing" people of our country
@@MR.11official Like Whom?
@@aaryangotad335 i don't get it? what's that mean
@@MR.11official bhi online racism ka to alag ha, hum kal game khel rahe tha tabhi koi bola no one like india and Indian people don't know about hygiene and they are disgusting. Bhi ya sunn ka Jo bura laga ma bata nahi sakta kyu ke mujhe bhi pata ha ke ma is baat ko defend nahi kar sakta or log blota ha ke foreign ma hamara bahut respect ha bhi, bahar ma Indians ko bullie kya ja Raha ha vo Inko nahi dikhraha. Bhi ya ab hamara he Kaam ha ki india ka saf rakhna or kuch nahi kar sakte
Very well researched. Needs to be forwarded by every person watching this video which is apolitical, voices the truth, and also suggests a solution. Kudos
Best video on the most concerning matter of Indian cities and people of India❤
As a person living in Bengaluru, as soon as you complain about any problem first thing localite say is "If you dont like it, go back to your home town". By saying that they are suppressing your voice and indirectly encouraging the people who contributing in ruining the city.
But banglore infrastructure is improving centre govt always ignored cities state govt also responsible
@@filmyduniya4214 Mot true. I was recently in Bangalore and it is abhorrent. And it’s not the only one. Ahmedabad, Mumbai, Delhi, Lucknow, Kolkata etc all are absolute shit condition cities. Go look at any major city and it looks like dumpster.
See there's no issue if you complain legitimate things. People work and this city gives them money and decent life, The fact that they don't respect that makes locals angry that's all.
Every city has problems, and I completely agree that we need to speak on them but,
Many migrants use harsh statements against the city(Completely un-necessary), they don't respect the local language(forget learning lol) and no local would like that because they've grown up here and have a special connection. Think about it if someone does the same to your home-town.
This problem is relevant to all cosmopolitan cities and I understand
@@vrv5897 it’s not like the locals actually care about the city they blame the migrants for destroying. I’ve lived in Chennai and Ahmedabad. Neither the locals nor the outsiders care much for the city or their civic duties. Most people I met lack critical thinking and deductive reasoning. They lack any awareness about how their local municipal council works. Infact, most migrants strictly stick to the rules in the fear of being outcast and bullied. This whole rhetoric that it’s the migrants that disobey and cause problems is a myth.
@filmyduniya4214 I live in Bangalore and all the roads I've seen , have been the most filthy I've ever seen.
As an indian i feel incredibly ashamed of our government and lack of acknowledgement towards pollution and waste management every foreigner makes fun of us
It's dumb to blame this issue on the government
@@Rainyminylogo ko khud bhi kuch initiative Lena chahiye.
Ek traffic law aaya tha jisme jyada challan kt ta logo ka, usme bhi logo ko objection tha ki gareeb kaise bharega. Mtlb log law na tode, vo ni soch rhe thay, ki agar Tod Diya toh bhare kaise iska soch rhe thay!!
Government's primary aim is to fix issues like this, not aim to build temples or mosques@@Rainyminy
@@Rainyminy lekin bhai garbage waste treatment ka kaam toh Government ka hi hai na!! Usko aise landfills mein ni daal skte na!!
Bht desho mein toh Incineration plants laga rakhe hain, ya treatment plants hai, yha toh ni hai na. Ab yeh kaam toh aam janta ni kregi bhai!! Yeh toh government hi kr skti hai, lekin yeh mudda koi leke hi ni aata!?
@@Rainyminy12:56
Amazing work! This was such a well researched and delivered video. I hope this reaches more people and we can work towards making India the best it can be and give it the respect and care the people deserve.
Hats off to the research done for the video. Really informative!!
For a country of 1.4 billion people, there is literally 0 cities in India which I could say would even compare with a tier 3 city in the west. Thats the sad reality. Bad infrastructure, bad traffic conditions, no walkable and cyclable cities, thrash everywhere you go, worst air quality, and the highest weather temperatures in all of the world. There are literally no redeemable qualities in any of the Indian cities
Hum China se jyada aage hai, developed hai 😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
@@PMO_Narendra_Modi 🤣
Navi Mumbai is quite good.
We need to develop small cities and mive population out of big cities. Smaller cities are easier to keep clean.
Not just very informative, but a very emotional too in a way. Great Work Mohak. Keep Up.
This is really good man. I have been talking about this over the years most people dont even care these days
I remember visiting Shimla in 2014, and I was surprised to see that throwing garbage would result in a ₹500 fine and the action and responsibilities that people took amazed me. Never thought I would see that in my country. A similar attitude would be beneficial for the other cities as well
Yes. Sikkim is very clean too.. Kochi, Indore, chandigarh also clean.. if these people can care about this, why others can't? We need some strict rule for cleaniness.
Smaller states have better governance. Bigger states should be reorganised ASAP
@@RupsD319 chandigarh is decent but it has air pollution issues tbh
I'm glad you are talking about this issue, I've been talking about it to my friends and family, i had delivered a speech in front of my class and the topic i chose was "How badly planned Indian cities are?" I emphasized on pollution, traffic, lack of sidewalks
There is a street in Ranchi where thousands of students of age 8-18 pass by and there is no sidewalk for them, the roads are filled with trash and no one does anything
And when i tell people why our country is doomed they call me anti-national, if i tell someone to throw the waste in the trash can instead of railway platform they'll say "hame kya ye saaf karna govt ka kaam hai" I'm so sick of it i wanna leave India and flee to a country with better living conditions ASAP
"when i tell people why our country is doomed they call me anti-national" exactly bro... I get that a lot too and I hate it so much.
hating your country isnt anti national at all. if your parents hit you, does that mean they hate you? a true nationalist will point out the flaws instead of ignoring them. i dont blame you for wishing to move out of india at all, if you work hard you will. i also feel like our country is doomed, but i will be consider ed
"anti national"
very true. apparently, we should defend our mistakes. That's just stupid. India is pretty much gone right now and i don't think its gonna change soon.
Don’t leave India, please stay there and improve the country. There’s too many Indians migrating to the West.
@@MawaliMurtad why would we stay here? tell me? indians who respected this country received the worst treatment. A good example is Nambi Narayan who rejected NASA to develop ISRO and what did he get in return?
I've tears in my eyes. You are right brother. You got yourself a subscriber❤❤❤
Dear Mohak Mangal, I am watching from Europe Italy and your documentation is really brilliant. Yes the biggest challenges for your country in the coming years are exactly the problems you talk about: pollution, garbage, housing, infrastructure and may I add: birth control. I am very happy that young Indians like you are looking into the matter ❤❤❤ good luck
India's TFR is already 2 thats 0.1 less than 2.1 which is the replacement rate. Italy has a sub 2 tfr. Not good. You country(assuming you are italian) is literally dying out and you are forced to replace it with MENA immigrants leading to socio-political instability. no thanks.
Surat was one of the most polluted city of India in 1995.....
then, a flood hit it and many lives were lost....
The people and the government decided to change it completely🔥
and this year it was declared to be the joint winner of the CEANEST CITY OF INDIA along with Indore.....❤
Kash India ki har Shaher mein isi tarah ki Floods aur Bhukamp aajaye taki sabhi Shahar Develop hojaye
Please be clear. Pollution and cleanliness are not opposites.
Also air pollution or which?
@@yashagrawal88 what are you saying bro?
ground pollution
but what is the 1st line?
@@ruturajshiralkar5566 bhai mazaak mein bol raha hai to baat alag hai but agar nahi to ye kya hai 😂
I my neighbourhood there was this हड़ताल of Nagar Nigam and peiple shamelessly started to throw their garbage in some empty plot near my house, when I asked them to stop they started to argue ki tumhari jagah hai kya? The problem is 'Lack.of covic sense' in Indians. They just want their backyard to be clean and shiney baaki desh gya bhaad me.
Even cities municipal don't provide dustbin like European countries in every cities
Kya galat hain isme har jagah kachra fekna hain
People are selfish !!!
Exactly!!!
Rasta ke side mei ek dustbin lagana bhi bahut mushkil hai inn logon ke liye.
@@prathitprasadfir bhi log usme nahi dalenge.
Indian log bahot aalsi hai, dustbin tak jane ki mehnat bhi nhi karenge wo,
Include kota's no traffic light which reduces pollution
The simple solution is changed your thinking and indian will grow up definitely ❤
Thanks… i always think about this. Our cities are super dirty.
We are more developed than China 😂😂😂😂
bhai congrats modi ji himself padhare hai
We have few overpopulated cities, with continuing migration. So, no surprises about being dirty.
We need to develop smaller cities, encourage reverse migration, remote work from home, move jobs out if big cities to smaller cities.
@@PMO_Narendra_ModiAccording to andhbhakts
@@PMO_Narendra_Modi said no one ever
And us Indians can't take a joke or handle the truth when someone comments about it. Like do you see Indian comments on architecture of Europe too like ... everywhere everytime....an Indian has to say .bro it's better in India or something cringe like that always....it's become a trend 📉📈 now for people to hate and laugh at us 😅
Sadly, some of our people just have a competitive mindset. Some don't want improvement but rather show why they are ahead than others
Current govt is the realling claiming to be vishwaguru and all.
@@timmymannies6888 its good to be competitive but you also gotta do something
@@timmymannies6888competitive aur delusional me farak hota hai
Thanks! for making people aware...
So true! So thankful you posted this. We Indians are a very selfish group of people. We don't think of ourselves as a community, sadly. Or, even if we do, we're too much blinded by our castes that we hardly look beyond them. Cleanliness is not something that we're taught since childhood. You see - ever since we're children, our mothers do the job of cleaning up after us. They clean our beds, our tables and our rooms. They also manage the cupboards for us. We're not taught to do all this on our own. How do you think we'll ever get that in our ethics? We can't, in this fundamentally flawed cultural system. And we're selfish because no one wants to do any work that impacts other families - trash being one example. No one wants to get the trash lying around cleaned up because everyone's like why should I? It's not my responsibility.
Anyways, one thing I can say is that things are gradually changing. The new youth is more aware of the impact of their behavior, and at least in my friend circle, I hardly see anyone who doesn't look after their surroundings.
All Indian cities are on ventilator. Even Bengaluru, which was comparitively a paradise just 20-30 years ago is in a pathetic condition today. No water, overpopulation, terrible roads, 0 sewage and waste management, overall just disgusting.😢
Politicians have mainly just wreaked havoc due to their corruption and inaction.
We need to develop more cities in the north so that everyone doesn't just move to the south... because of migration cities like Bengaluru and Mumbai are on life support.
All Indian Cities are in Comatose state
Wao!! I casted vote today and was thinking why pollution, global warning, water scarcity and garbage dumb is not the political issue.. why none of the leaders talk about this and this video poped up.. typing this while watching the video.. watched only 2 mins yet but this video need more views and need to go viral.. other influencers need to talk about this too and media houses too.. but ofcourse nobody will talk about it... thank you mohak for touching upon this.. we need more folks like you.. all the best 👍🏻👍🏻
ye sab mudde par votes nahi jeete jate
even if koi is par try karega , opposition vote bank politics karke jeetegi
India is still poor so the priority is basic survival things roti, kapda, makan
Imagine lecturing about environment in rally to farmers 😂😂😂
Be greatful modi introduced something swach bharat, buliding toilets itne paise me itna hi milega
@@nishu_kmr tru
Modi ne 10 saal main kya kiya
The bridge in Maharashtra which didn't match was made by BJP government @@_AK-47.
@@sushrutsharma6927 India has grown into the fifth largest economy in the last decade. Just 10 years ago, it was ranked 11th economically. Implementation of GST, abrogation of Article 370, new law on Triple Talaq, Nari Shakti Vandan Act to enhance women's participation in the Parliament, the inauguration of a new Parliament building and strong steps against terrorism and Left-Wing Extremism and many more... 😑
Well done brother...thanks for highlighting this.
Thank you for your hard work.
Much appreciated.
Appreciate your hard work.
Thank you so much for your help.
Thanks for your dedication.
Your dedication is appreciated.
Thank you for your commitment.
Grateful for your work.
Thanks for going the extra mile.
This is video that Indians need to see in the stadium instead of ipl matches. Amazing work. You are definitely one of my most fav youtubers because of your topic selection. Please keep making such videos. I always thought why my area is so bad, I always thought why are we living in slums and I used to think it's because we are poor. But seems like we are poor in our judgement and behaviour. Even though we youth can change our financial situation by starting to earn, I used to think how will we ever change where we come from.. because slum peoples are looked down upon. As I am growing older I am starting to realise how we are made poor and dependent systematically and slums are definitely not created overnight. Thank you for this amazing video. Love you brother ❤❤
Fenku ko 100 smart cities ke jagah 2 hi banwa de jo role model ho jae banki cities ke liye. Kam se kam delhi ko hi bana de capital city hai first impression delhi se hi hoti hai india ki
@@KishanKumar-qz1kt true....2 hi ban jaye bas ki ek milestone ho hamare pas
The best youtuber right now no faltu ki controversies, criticizing all governments and appreciating every leader who's doing good work
Unfortunately it won't help
@@Sauravkumar-kt1td it can if us general public starts raising our voice on social medias instead of fighting in these religion and caste wars
@@aditisharma1773 do you genuinely think that decades of brainrot will just go away
Swati Maliwal case par video nahi banaya
@@Sauravkumar-kt1td it would help
Our Elders never Use Condoms and now we are facing all the problems..
Thank you for doing this!!
This is the topic that should be brought to mainstream media so that people understand this problem. It's degrading our country
The media is busy making us believe muslims are the biggest problem instead of focusing on the actual issues in the country
मै तो Biscuit खा के Biscuit प्लास्टिक कूड़ेदान में डालना चाहता हु, पर अफ़सोस Patna नगर निगम ने शहर के सड़को के किनारे एक भी Dustbin लगाए ही नहीं है, मजबूर होके मुझे woh प्लास्टिक जेब में लेके घूमना पड़ता है 😔😔
I'm also from Patna. This is serious issue even in our locality no any dustbin placed in street. Ultimately we have to throw garbage in nearby empty land. 😢
It is every city's problem...I normally keep those packets in my handbag itself...what else we can do...😢😢
Complaint number par information karo
Nagar nigam se baat karo
In trains too
India Can Only Compete with Pakistan and Not with Singapore or China 😂😂😂
I have my deepest respect for this man! good job Mohak, as always!
Previous generations who procreated mindlessly are to blame for this. They have blood on their hands. Due to this, the life of the average person in this country is simply not worth living.
Disadvantages of this extreme overpopulation:
1. Toxic and hypercompetitive education system that only focuses on marks.
2. Overcrowded classrooms, roads, hospitals, parks, public places, tourist places, etc.
3. Road accidents and road rages.
4. Unavailability of bus and train tickets, even during urgency.
5. No footpaths on most roads, severely restricting walking space.
6. No parking space due to which half of the road space is occupied by parked vehicles.
7. Rise of obesity in young Indians due to the unavailability or overcrowding of parks, open spaces or recreational centres.
8. Young Indians preferring to stay indoors because of the depressing crowd outdoors.
9. Auditorium-sized classrooms with 250-300 students preparing for competitive exams which have less that 0.5% selection rate.
10. Severe unemployment causing huge stress to students and young adults during their prime years and prompting them to take extreme steps.
11. Low, meagre salaries even when you are overworked because you are easily replaceable.
12. Rising obesity, diabetes and heart diseases because people only think about their careers.
It's madness all around.
Not related to this video, but when someone tries to implement a healthy (or at least, healthier) lifestyle, the same Aunties and Unkils (they may even be just 15 years old) have the audacity to comment on all this as 'Dramma'. The condition is already pathetic- such a hectic lifestyle and no encouragement toward what's right
The people who procreate more are the ones leaching the most out of the taxpayers.
Bhai it is sooo true. We fuckin need Thanos.
This is why I'm ageist
We hv small but with big urges to procreate
Cleanliness is Godliness. As a devout hindu, I see even most of our temples are unclean. We don't respect our own belief that goddess Lakhsmi resides in clean places. People just want to do their part like showering flowers and milk, placing oil lamps, etc, without any care about cleanliness. A temple I visited recently had flowers, kumkum, strewn around, agrabatti placed at random corners. They just want to show that they are doing something for their own peace of mind. Nobody is thinking about the place, but themselves.
Plus calling cow a mother but abandoning her after she stops giving milk and leaving her to eat trash on the streets. Calling ganga the holy river but still trashing it.
Hypocrisy is filled in our veins!!
Yeah, people are too selfish, be it on the roads or be it in the temples. They just don't care.
Nice to get a better perspective of the problems and solutions of modern day urban india. Thank you for the insights
Good presentation! I've, for the first time, seen your video;appreciable!
We leave everything to our government. 😢
Goverments are there for a reason: they are supposed to be for the common good.
1. They can spend our taxes properly on issues that affect common welfare
2. If they create good infrastructure, awareness and laws etc, then public will maintain it
Otherwise, why do we need govt
breh
Everyone has a role in economy bro everyone can't just throw their jobs and become a smaaj sevak that's why there are goverment to look onto these issues it's their job I'm not sayin that we shoud dump everything on government but atleast we are trying everything to support that's on our lavel.
First thing : reduce Population
@@chad_male01not everyone can be a samaj sevak but the least they can do from their part Is to not throw trash around a place randomly or spite gutka just anywhere ,but sadly the people don't follow this too .Also the government can make laws about this, but people don't obey it anyways and the government also cannot lock up everyone who does this kind of activity in the jail. So in India,what is most important that the people should themselves have the civic sense to keep a place clean ,if they do it then the government's job becomes easier in keeping a place clean
Thanks for bringing this. A larger group here in India is concerned about infra and cleanliness. But they never talk about it and end up leaving the country itself. As Mohak said , we should make it a topic.
I really like your videos Mohak. At least someone is giving a thought to these problems. Kudos👏
Thank you, Mohak and team for this video. This needs to be highlighted.
I live in Indore. I have lived in Mumbai for 13 years. I sometimes cannot believe how drastic is the difference between the two places on level of cleanliness. BUT, even in Indore, despite all the efforts by the government workers, some people are still throwing their trash on the roads. It is not a government or political problem, it is simply some people of the city who don't have enough brain cells to understand how to keep their surroundings clean.