Learning about other cities . Kolkata now seems like heaven . Any mishap here we blame the mayor and th mayor is constantly under attack ... not to say.. Kolkata has a pretty good zoning pattern....⚫⚫⚫⚫
We just have 7-8 stretches of 1km which look international from certain angles. Indians are not civilized. There is no point having a beautiful well built city when citizens are trashy. We need dictatorship. Both ways. Strict citizens who keep government selfless and corruptionfree, and a wise government which keeps citizens disciplined and civilized.
When politicians eat up a majority chunk of the infrastructure project budget, then you don't have enough money to build quality infra, as a result, we have sub-par infrastructure.
Not true. I'm not saying there's no corruption in India, I'm saying the effect of corruption on India's situation is minimal. Even if there was no corruption in India, it would have look nearly the same becuase we are too many people with too little money. It's that simple.
In the west I always heard China this China bad, but when I visited months ago with a diplomat, oh my god it was sooo clean, the people were friendly and curious, it was awesome. Now I almost don't listen to western media anymore because of it.😅
all those things can be true at once. Are you simple minded? A place can be clean, people appear friendly (because you don't speak their language), and organized. It can also be authoritarian and doing bad things against other nations. Those things are not mutually exclusive...well maybe in a child's mind they are.
It would be a miracle if India come close to China’s infrastructure. As a foreigner, I have visited both countries. Mindset of Indian, work ethic, integrity, civic sense, corruption, etc
Europe developed because they were ruled by Kings for 100s of years, but now Europe is degrading after democracy. India directly got democracy after British rule, hence we never got a chance for proper development. Across the world, the vast majority of bigger nations that transformed from Colonies to democracies have such poor infrastructure. There is only one solution to this problem, India should be ruled by a dictator.
You have to remember China is not a democracy. They used to just put a cross on buildings in old Shanghai and the next day this was demolished. There was no worry about the people. India is democratic and thus has to abide by the people's wishes. So, changing the look of any city in India is difficult. On top of this we were run for over 75 years by a Government that did not care for the people and just let the country continue. They did not instill any passion in the people about their country. So when the people have no pride they live by this.
@@learningmaster8060 Hey, bro. If you believe western propagandas on 'Democracy' or 'Dictatorship', then you will never find the way out. Because that's total wrong. There is no democracy in the west at all. And meanwhile, what works in China is not dictatorship at all. The system in the west, is a company-like structure. The stockholders hide deeply at the back, put several statues in the front, to manipulate and cheat on the crowd. What a shame! Also, China is not like the west propaganda only have one party, actually, Chine has 8 more parties out of the CPC, let's not count the Taiwanese parties as Chinese parties, which basically protect only U.S. interests. You want the truth, then find by yourself, media is only worked for the people who paid on them.
@@sunilthakore5715 Don't people this, people that. If following your rule, government won't be able to help 99% of the people. Then *don't be an @$$ like your media, blaming government not help people, because it is people like you who make it impossible.* The essence of democracy and human right simply can't coexist, go figure out why. BTW, are there SIG in your country? if there are (I am sure there are), there is no democracy in your country.
@@learningmaster8060 North Korea is ruled by a dictator, it is not better. South Korea and Taiwan are the only major economies (Hong Kong and Singapore are too small) that transformed into advanced economies after ww2, what they had in common is one party rule and state capitalism, combined with meritocracy, Taiwan and South Korea both taken a hit after transforming into liberal democracy under US pressure, their growth almost immediately flattened. So I think one party rule and statement capitalism are the keys for development. For leaders to perform, meritocracy I think is the key. All the large corporations do it, why not government? Elections depends on money and media image, performance was never even a factor.
My first visit to India was in 1960 I travelled by land route from Madras(now Chennai) to Pakistan and beyond. The condition was shocking even from a Singaporean like me! Then about ten years ago, I visited Mumbai albeit for a day, what I seen in the streets of this so called modern city by Indian standard, except for the most affluent part of the city, the rest were reminiscent to what I remembered seeing the first time I went there, the street was full of cows, telephone and power cables jumbled up in bundles hanging precariously on poles and houses, beggars and homeless lined the streets, cow dungs rubbish strewn across everywhere! I thought to myself, India has not changed much. India needs a good government and changed attitude !
In Dec 2023, I had the unfortunate commute in Singapore MRT to "Little India" for a toilet stop en route to the airport, and it was not pleasant to say the least compared to other areas/facilities in Singapore, so what does that tell you?
@@tonywatt3281at least there are toilets, u don’t hv to do it in the open(common for most in dians). Any way, the filth n smell of superpower inn dia is out of this world
its far better than what it used to be 10 years back..10 years back fast internet was luxury for us,now we are the pioneers of digital payments.India is spending much more in capital investment than it used to be back then
@@Gop101 I would've agreed if you asked few years back. But if you think about it it has more to do system rather than blood. If people of india were inherently corrupt non hard working and uncivilized then how come these Same act like most civilised law-abiding and hardworking community when they move to other countries? You may say because they are educated but that's not the case. Even less educated labourers are much better in these countries. And highly educated bureaucrats act like most corrupt species in india. It's our British era system that never lets honest person survive in the system. And it our fault that we never cared enough to change it in almost 8 decades of independence
Anyone that keeps claiming India is overtaking China or close to catching up to China in terms of economic prowess is eating propaganda so hard. Literally watch any recent youtube vlogs of tier 2-3 cities in China and compare it to tier 1 cities in India, the gap is wider than you'd expect.
They are just brainwashed by the IMF. The Anglo Saxons want a useful idiot as a buffer to fight China. Who else serves best the purpose of being useful idiots, than the Indian far right groups of India? Those IMF numbers about India's GDP are totally fake. India's vast majority of the GDP is from the informal private sector. It is not at all accounted, and no one knows how much income is generated exactly in these private sector. It is all a speculation.
@@somakchatterjee6429 Ah yes, having human feces and some of the worse city slums literally next to a billionaire's 1 billion dollar mansion is a sign of healthy economic development. Wake up!!!!
Ok Not totally agreeing with you. As good and well planned cities plays the key role to make that city liveable and also it generates capital when tourists visits those places as it enhances the beauty of that city..for once just type europe and watch any video of any random city in europe and the way they are organised and you will get to know why people love to visit europe or any hill station in india as beauty and cleanliness equals more tourist and money so yes it contributes in the economy
Every City Can be Nice in India but people lack civic sense. People freely urinate in open, Throw Trash in Water Bodies, Defacate on Railway Lines, Throws the Waste Unsegregated. This is a HUGE Problem in India. People blame Population but Hong Kong and Singapore have one of the highest population density in the world and yet those cities are one of the cleanest. People blame poverty but Poverty doesnt give you license to Litter around and Defacate in Open. The Attitude of Indian People must change. This civic sense should be taught in schools from a young age. Trash Segregation should be taught in Environmental Studies Subject
Yes, all these are true, you and I are the same product of our society that lacks civic sense but why has nobody taught us about civic sense nobody has shown us our parents, teachers or government. Poverty and corrupt governments are the two biggest problems. Poverty restricts people from getting the right education and knowledge and our government or you can say these politicians do not care about poverty they want power in every election and pocket large sums of money....even we don't have a proper waste management system is...
I agree about lack of civic sense, however these same people observe the civic laws with utmost sincerity when they go to other countries. It's the combination of availability of infrastructure, awareness of cleanliness and threat of fines/action that allow people to follow the rules. For example, in Dubai, there are dustbins every few meters. These dustbins themselves are regularly emptied and maintained in a clean way. With such a level of availability, it becomes very easy to ensure that any rubbish is always discarded in dustbins. Plus there's the constant threat of heavy fines if someone is found littering or spitting in public places.
I started my career in Delhi thinking there is hope when I was 22. Today I am 44, and let me tell you things have gone from bad to worse. There is zero accountability with the thousands of ppl in state and central govt, and life here is horrible. The story is same in each and every city of India. This you realise when you see how the rest of the world lives.
I guess that is difference between India and China, Chinese officials have KPIs (Key Performance Indicators), their promotion and demotion depends on their performance, that is the meritocracy they talked about. That is why they built infrastructures, because it is good for economy and GDP is a very large weighting in their KPIs. KPIs are used in 100% of the large enterprises, and KPIs in government are not invented by the Chinese, they learned that from Singapore government. Meritocracy however is never applied to governments in liberal democratic countries.
@@joseph_weiYou still don't understand? Is Western-style democracy really democratic? Can the various parties and factions, with their supporters, really choose a person who works for the development of the country? The people are short-sighted. Can a country develop by doing things according to the people's wishes?
@@chinchin8084 Political parties in the west are built on money from rich people and corporations, so the viable candidates people can select from are all chosen by money, and none of them is really working for people. BTW I don't think what we have in the west is democracy.
I am just a couple of years older than you and cannot agree more than your comment. Only difference is now I see India as an NRI and it doesn't hurt that much
Exactly look at any other nation in asia pacific they all are doing well. We indians havnt even figure out basics and people are ready to argue how we are gonna lead world in next 20 years or theyll point at Britishers they the reason we behind.
@urdailygamr9229 🤡 Mughals just plunder the wealth of India When marco polo visit India's chola empire and hindu empire He referred them as land of richest Many oriantalist historians has already conclude that gupta empire was India's golden period After fall of chavan empire India's economy has declined for next 800 year's..
Exactly. I find it funny when people say "Bharat is the oldest civilization yadayada" and in my head I'm always thinking, doesn't that mean we've failed as a civilization😂?? We had a head start and yet we fall behind to other countries big or small in terms of a lot of aspects. It's so bad that we fall behind 30-80 years in some aspects. The only thing Indians do after that is complain about colonization etc etc. It's funny cuz I find a lot of the British built infrastructure from back in the day way safer and better tha modern Indian ones 😭
As a Chinese, that has been what the West has mocked China for the past century of humiliation. Many Indian people I've met are hardworking and intelligent. Unfortunately the country is held back by too many dissenting voices aka democracy. It's up to the Indian people whether they want to forgo a little political freedom in exchange for greater personal and economic freedom.
WOW SARRR VERY DANGEROUS !!!! 😠😠 IN INDIA WE ONLY FLY ON VIMANA 🇮🇳🤗 THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA 🤗🇮🇳 THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD , WE NEVER DO SCAM AND WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗
why because if it costs 100 Rs to build they'll charge 500 Rs & still put low quality lobour & materials because who's there to keep a check on them? ofcourse this had to happen
No because we follow the L1 system of giving contracts. Whoever states the cheapest price, we give the contract to them. Shockingly, even Defense follow L1 system
Your right. Typical indians think that "We have most population so we are going to overtake china" its like you have 1000 chickens that most lay eggs (china) and 1100 chickens that most don't lay eggs (India)
Of course this is a negative video, we are talking about a poor country that just recently starting to become self sufficient. Funny she compares with South Africa and Brazil. Brazil had higher GDP than India less that two decades ago, now India has double the GDP. While India is the fastest growing major economy in the world South Africa is falling back to become a third world country. Well, at least it's not CCP paid propaganda. Talk about China, their cities are full of suddenly imploding roads due to bad quality. Their highest buildings are unsafe to use so they are largely empty. Parts of their buildings fall on the street with strong winds. Currently another huge flooding problem in China that is much worse than India because dams release water without warning, so you can have meters of flooding within ten minutes. So for all the bad publicity, India is doing relatively better than China, just have some patience.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE 🥰🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🥰 🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🥰 🇮🇳 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN 🥰THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🥰 🇮🇳, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🥰🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳
@@indiasuperclean6969 Hey Big cap writer , understand the negative tone of the video to make monetization easy and to resonate with such people , you need to know china i in downfall and there sub par buildings do collapse which is ture . Keep your sarcasm to yourself . Woh dhanda kar raha aur tu tere time waste .
@@SandeepMeena79 agree Europe pays 50 percent tax of their income .and these buggers need to know this same buggers looted the world and hence the infra and richness and capablity to spend more . leftist saare commenters like YOLO
My wife did graduation in town planning from school of planning and architecture. Its a 4 year course. She was in a small class of 30 people. 27 out of 30 are now no longer in india because there weren't enough opportunities for them. Most are in europe or US. My wife moved to IT because she didn't want to leave.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE 🥰🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🥰 🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🥰 🇮🇳 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN 🥰THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🥰 🇮🇳, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🥰🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳
Definitely, because of so many ethnicities and crab mentality, china could unite whole country because everyone belonged to same ethnicity, but it's impossible in India to unite everybody through nationalism, Unity in diversity and nationalism in India are the biggest fake ideas I have ever heard of
@@Vaibhav6384oh religion is bad yes the religion told you to throw garbage, also we dont worship dogs, you dont even know shit but of course you have to sound like you know everything also why do we worship a cow yes you dont know so shut up
@@sadmikewazowski7754 Im an indian too and honestly, it's not worth engaging with someone who just wants to argue for the sake of it. Better to focus on meaningful discussions than get caught up in endless back-and-forth.
This is just a cope. Japanese instilled senpai discipline within it's populace during meiji era through primary and nationslistic education. Can we guarantee the same in India without protest from right groups.
This is the non sense filled by bikau media in peoples brain...many indians go to foreign country and obey its rules and when come back to india they become same...so strict rules make the diff..not some sense...and many people wont develop civic sense at all. And no school gives this training..so rules are necessary
A 1.4 billion careless population is the biggest reason of india being unorganized. No moral responsibility, no accountability and here we are talking about government 😂😂😂
One of your biggest problems is this smug Malthusian notion that the reason your country does not work is because of too many people. 😂 China has lifted 850 million people out of poverty. Your problems are a backward culture, callous elites, and bec of these facts, you’ve not created an egalitarian just society.
👉🏻 We Indians don’t give a damn about how our cities look or functions. Pollution, Institutionalised Corruption, illegal settlements, rampant cutting of trees, industrial waste, adulterated rationing and food, garbage piling and failed govt. system that’s how I describe people here.
I am Singaporean. Look at the way we do things and learn from us. Start by saying "zero" for 0 without saying "jeero" for a starter. How can the people who don't have any respect for spellings have respect for quality huh? This is why in developed countries when you say Indian the people go like "yukkk".. I don't even wanna sit next to one
@@yevanyevan7238you say zero as jeero in Hindi. It's called Hinglish though you are not wrong but it's all about government. I'm not joking at all Singapore would still be a poor city if that one person wouldn't dare to come forward for the betterment of his country's people
Doesn’t matter how much right wing bhakts curse china, China is and will be an inspiration for the world including India, centuries to come. They set an unprecedented example of human capabilities. Long live Indo-China brotherhood
Dictatorship in China and just now reading that in china too intrafracture are destroyed by massive floods so why target India Only.In USA too and even New York will need 19 billions dollars
@@surajitmondal823 you are forgetting that china is undemocratic, persecutes his own people, occupying South china sea, grabbed Tibet, undermining Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia in the region.Attaking India in Ladhak from time to time. Using developing countries by looting them after lending them with advantage to them and Look how Sri Lanka and African countries effected..And what to invade Taiwan which is democratic country.Inspite of massive trade with India USA west, china is underming stability.I hope you have not forgotten Nehru stabbed by Chu en lai.And i hope you have not forgotten treatment of Ujbers.
India’s system is all crroupt from basic level workers to top tier officers. For instance im from a small town and town got 2cr. grant from government but all muncipal members take it a bribe and used only 20 lacs on infrastructure….20/200lacs …same on our system
Real bro government gave 2cr in my area to built water tanks but 1cr direct took buy engineers then took buy other people 50 lakhs then 20 lakhs workers left only 30lakhs for material bought cheap material now after rain water tanks are laekaing now 4-5 tanks to supply water in area
Politicians are policy makers. Caste and all can be eliminated with simple laws but do they want it. Big noo. Divide and rule is the motto of Indian politics and no legislation will be passed to bridge it
@@democracy123 you can't make laws to eliminate caste. It's like we already have anti caste discrimination laws. The way to solve this issue is through massive industrialisation, economic reforms, urbanisation . Turning india frm primitive agrarian society to post industrial society
You mean the people with no compulsory working hours, no minimum education level, no performance requirement. If they don't show up at all nobody would even know? From what I understand politicians in US mostly work one day per week. Yeah, of course we can't blame people like that.
Thirty year ago I came to the US to study economics. At the time, there was a Chinese professor who achieved very high academic status in MIT's Sloan Business School. His name is Yasheng Huang. His research focus is on the comparative development models of China and India. At the time, I admired him a lot and read many of his papers. One of his very consistent thesis is that China is wasting money on infrastructure and he predicted that India would do a lot better economically since it did not waste money on infrastructure. Now thirty years have passed, I am glad that China's government did not listen to him. I am afraid he may have misled many Indian politicians since he was an accomplished academia in MIT with many joint research with Indian scholars. Now when I think about it, if he did not shit on China's development model, he probably wouldn't have reached his level of esteem and status in the West.
Welcome to China. We like friends from India. Please don't hate us. Most Chinese people are just normal and worried about their life, just like people from India.
We, the people of India, killed our own rivers, cut down our trees, stripped the hills of their flora and fauna, made every corner into a dump yard, preferred ignorance over awareness and sympathy towards our surroundings and yet we wonder what caused our once great nation, which had one of the best drainage systems in the whole world in early ages, to become a collection of tobacco stains, dust, noise and air pollution, trash and uncivilized people.
China is not developed, it is a developing country and does not have the potential that India has. China's pollution is far more serious than India's. Don't worry, it is impossible for China to catch up with India in the next ten years.
@@policiasando4358agree on that too😂 I have seen south africa,rawanda,Kenya vlogs and seriously as an Indian I feel ashamed for what my country has become... can't do anything also... without dictatorship handling billion population is impossible
an ideal city for me is a city that is made for the people to comfortably live, the space is green and clean with proper drainage system, water harvesting system and sustainable sources of electricity generation. a city where in the citizen can simply walk or bike to places rather than using vehicles fueled by non renewable fuels and also has well developed public transport! And, is safe. (so, basically a mixture of Singapore and Germany ) (a youtube channel i'd like to recommend is " *Not Just Bikes* ")
STILL WANT TO COMPETE WITH CHINA ???!!!!!??? COULD NOT EVEN COMPETE WITH MALAYSIA, THAILAND, VIETNAM, INDONESIA, PHILIPPINES, NOT EVEN CAMBODIA OR LAOS !!!!!!!.....😂😂😂 From :Singapore 🇸🇬
I have friends from all around southeast Asia and tbh their very well educated and very kind and funny too, bro their infrastucture and cleanliness and aesthetics is on another level, Philippines being a country where people earn just like an average Indian but still they look so clean and futuristic, cities like Cebu, Manila and Laguna and soooo beautiful. Damn, I wanna visit these places aleast once in my life.
I think the comparison was made based on the population size India and China's population size is quite close as compared to the other countries you mentioned
The late PM Rajiv Gandhi once said that for every rupee alloted by the govt for a project only 15 paise actual goes to the project. Rest 85 paisa is stolen in between. Situation has not changed even after 30+ years
A small suggestion: There are munipal swepers and cleaners all around our cities deployed. They must be trained and given little power and ownership of a particular area they must take care of in cleaning and beautification in a small extent. Also to get the municipality attention on the issues. They must be trained like a team leads in corporate.
i don't nor any one in my area do but municipal corporation wale naali se saaf nahi krte or jab krte to usko uthana bhul jaate h 🙂🙂 there are many ppl who don't litter @@hr_47
Let's hope Amaravati, Andhra Pradesh's capital, learn something from this. The masterplan is of the Grid model, and some of it is now visible in Google Maps.
@@okayaresd bhai current affairs follow nahi karte kya- andhra pradesh election mein nda ki victory ho chuki hai isliye amravati phir se shuru ho gaya hai jo jagan ne apne ego ke karan band karva diya tha
I'm Chinese (live in Hong Kong). I really like this video. Everyone should watch this video. This is excellent video on urban planning. Everyone deserve to live in cities which are well designed. I wish our neighbours in India enjoy better living conditions, like us in China.
Don't be naive. India bullied China in the 1950s and 60s and is occupying a piece of China as we speak. India invaded and annexed Tawang, South Tibet in 1951. Tawang is the Sixth Dalai Lama's birthplace and home to the four hundred years old Tawang Monastery. In 1987 India renamed the area to the so-called Arunachal Pradesh. South Tibet is three times the size of Taiwan, rich in biodiversity and with large area of primitive forest.
@@idkhowdumblingare South india cant survive a week without the free resources you get from north. Coal mica etc all from Jh chh orrisa rajastahm etc South india has no resources. Also just because those american companies set up in south doesnt mean you are better 😂😂😂 South indians have sla*e mind.
I mean... Indians literally INVENTED the grid pattern, urban sanitation, and high-level urban planning. The fact that we can't do it better than our ancestors 5000 years ago is appalling.
Is that the propaganda they teach you? Don't you realize that Indians never had a civilization? The British came and gave India whatever little civilization that they possess now.
As a Chinese based on what i experienced in last decade, Most of chinese people's civic sense were getting better AFTER the infrastructures have fast developed. Within a much clean and neat and well organised environment, People become much more civilized spontaneously.
As a Chinese citizen living in Canada now, I would say that our excellent infrastructure has a lot to do with our political system and economic development strategy where local governments borrow a lot of money to accelerate infrastructure projects so that they could further boost the economy. And that’s why China has one of the best infrastructure systems in the world although its downsides like local governments debt crisis is appearing now. I think that Indian government should learn our models in this stage as good infrastructure could be a key accelerator for your economic growth in this stage although it’s hard to achieve.
@@Dharma_and_Ahimsa unfortunately I agree with your assessment, there are lot of Chinese people just left radical speech that means nothing but export unnecessary hatred. And what I could do is stay sane to others while disregarding my radical counterparts.
This Infrastructure problems video is a trending contect in youtube now, but the elaborateness of your content, the brief explanation of understanding the core issues, instead of pin pointing just 'government', connecting past and all that, and the comparative details of why we lack behind from others, is very gripping to watch, and very educative. A very interesting explanation, very different approach from other vids I seen recently. Thanks.
i am from a small city in Indonesia, and we have mayor that is being elected every 5 years. So, these mayors can secure a position for 2 terms, they must do their best to get re elected again. Our current mayor have built proper drainage and sewage system accross the high streets and enlarge the pavement for pedestrians, they also built kilometres of beach promenades, built parks and they rebuilt the old wet market area to be a modern building with much cleaner system and more parks. They also reharded many small alleys with proper asphalt or bricks. When they renovate these stuff, the city becomes much cleaner automatically. People tend to keep the city cleaner and it becomes more organised easily, despite our nongrid system, because it's an old city. The mayors did many things, one of the breaktrough to alleviate traffic was to build the 4 lanes orbital road. it is super efficient.
Indonesia is way better and ahead of India. I visited Bali, Jakarta, Java, Komodo, and your new Bullet train is amazing. Better than what we have in USA!
Utopian Idea: Make a list of city problems. Public vote from their phone apps to decide priorities. Planners find solutions and list them. Use AI to allocate budget. Make bidding transparent. Visible to public. Have audit teams to overlook progress. Do we need politicians here?
I'm proud as an indori but we want every city to be as much clean as possible even if its not developed it shouldn't be compromized with the cleanliness
Very nice. The master planning used to be there till 1960..but then it got lost. With india being the most populous nation, this is the need of the hour.
This video really opened my eyes to why India’s infrastructure is struggling. The comparison with international cities like Tokyo and the insights into the deep-rooted issues in Bangalore, Mumbai, and Delhi were spot on. The lack of civic sense, rapid unplanned growth, and restrictive land use policies are major hurdles. The example of Tokyo's zoning laws and mixed-use buildings was fascinating. It's clear that our cities need better planning and regulations to manage growth effectively. The traffic problems in Bangalore and the challenges in expanding Mumbai vertically due to restrictive FSI rules were especially illuminating. The piece on Mumbai's outdated drainage system and the recurring flooding issue highlighted the urgency for infrastructural upgrades. Delhi's water crisis and pollution problems further emphasize the need for sustainable urban management. Overall, this video provided a comprehensive look into the complexities of urban planning and the unique challenges faced by Indian cities. Great job!
It is so interesting that you'll see a youtuber from a developed country like the US and UK complain about how every road in the city is just planned for cars. How smaller roads and closely packed spaces are much better.
@@dandyperry1207that's why every stinking paper wipe of your kind dreams about but India is still growing and west is falling which you lack intelligence to see
Public transportation is really important for a city as it lowers traffic. The problem is that in some cities buses look cheap and downgraded. So, only lower class ppl use them while middle class and upper middle class use vehicles leading to more air pollution as well as traffic congestion.
Wow, as an Indonesian...Indian problems are exactly what us Indonesians experience, albeit on a smaller scale cause we have smaller population and land areas. I guess we are really "Indian islands" lol
In our Howrah Municipal Corporation of West Bengal, last elections were held in 2013. It's term expired in 2018. So it's next term was supposed to be held in 2018 but it wasn't in last 6 years. So just imagine - a term last for 5 years but whole 6 years void of elections. As a result it's now also void of waste management, public hygiene & sanitation services, one of nation's worst sewerage, garbage capital of East India . Illegal construction & ecological sensitivity destruction & syndicate everywhere which was even accepted by our CM!🤦 And was one of dirtiest cities of India. But we know even if elections are held nothing will change because they will be in only name- we couldn't cast our own vote but it'll be ballot rigged by booth capturings by local strongmen and goons & mafias of the state ruling party. When even formed undemocratic like rest of 100 municipalities of the state u cannot expect them to provide civic facilities. So first reforms and then fund flow is necessary or else it will go to the pockets of strongmen instead of our gully-mohallas.
West Bengal is a lost case thanks to Mamata. Support her and she will give you Bangladeshi Miya with 4 wives 30 children. Kolkata is going to Bangladesh soon don't worry
@@rishavkumar1250 that's the only problem all are corrupted maal of TMChii and Scamgress and Youth don't want to become politician and leaving the state
i have a college in Mumbai and live in Navi Mumbai, there are atleast a few weeks of non functional days in my clg because of rain over my course and not many for Navi Mumbai clg of my friends
Political will is the biggest hurdle. Take example of Amaravati, the city whose masterplan was build by Norman + Partners. Investment offered by World Bank. Singapore as mentor.
CLICKBAIT! she is talking about urban planning and not so much about infrastructure. We have design and implementation challenges which are causing these issues.
As an Architect Watching this video, It really gives a new perspective about the Infrastructure in India, there are N number of things which constitutes to the crumbling of the infrastructure. As a civilian, we need to have a conscious mindset on how we pollute the place we live in, The CHANGE starts from us. This is a beautifully explained video about the crisis of the Major cities and why their infrastructure seems to be questioned, complained and made fun of. The population in India doesn't really help too, irrespective of how much people are educated, we also need to practice what we have been thought of. Sure Chandigarh is one of the planned cities and is beautiful in its own way, but few of the disadvantages would be 1. Scale and accessibility 2. Social Inclusion 3. Climate consideration 4. Modernization demands 5. Environmental Stress Every planning has its own advantages and its disadvantages, but one of the greatest challenges we face would be the planning for future. Despite being one of the few nations who has people in powerful places across the World, we still are developing to become the better version of ourselves, Being a Urban planner trying to do the better for the city and focusing on how the future and predicting it is solely a very difficult task, We are trying our best to do a lot to this world, we will get there eventually until then we need to keep educating, sharing the knowledge of what we learnt and how we can transform the Country, Maybe even the world. Now this is all my take on the topic, I might be half right, could be completely wrong on some things, but the content that was put in the video was amazing and to the point and made sure that a layman could understand what was being said. Thank YOU AEVY TV, Looking forward for more.
First of all it's politicians fault, India also needs more land. How can you expect an uneducated leaders to properly understand the development process when all they think is of religion
Cultural Diversity: India is known for its rich cultural heritage and diversity. It is home to a wide variety of languages, religions, traditions, and festivals. Historical Landmarks: India boasts a rich history with numerous historical landmarks such as the Taj Mahal, Qutub Minar, Red Fort, and many others that attract tourists from around the world. Cuisine: Indian cuisine is famous for its diverse flavors and spices. It offers a wide range of delicious dishes that cater to various tastes and preferences. Spirituality: India is known as the birthplace of several major religions such as Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and Sikhism. It is also home to many spiritual practices and traditions. Democracy: India is the world's largest democracy with a vibrant and diverse political landscape. It has a robust electoral system that allows for peaceful transitions of power. Economic Growth: India has experienced significant economic growth over the past few decades, making it one of the fastest-growing major economies in the world. Information Technology: India is a global hub for information technology and software services. Cities like Bangalore and Hyderabad are known for their IT industry and innovation. Education: India has a strong emphasis on education and is home to many prestigious educational institutions like the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) and Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs). Art and Literature: Indian art and literature have a rich history and have made significant contributions to world culture. Indian literature, music, dance, and cinema are celebrated worldwide. Natural Beauty: India is blessed with diverse landscapes ranging from the Himalayas in the north to the beaches of Goa in the south. It also has rich biodiversity with many national parks and wildlife reserves.
Because the modern nation of India did not form through a Revolution: the old systems are still there, the goverment is a mixture of many diverse interest groups, this slows the decision making.
In varanasi also they gave free dustbins to everyone. 1 for dry waste and 2nd for wet waste. Almost all of them used those dustbins to plant some plants and throw wastes on the road. Even tho the garbage dump truck or van comes daily.
Varanasi is one of the dirtiest cities I have visited. I'm even more shocked after learning its PM Modi constituency. On what basis do people vote for him.
@@smiphel20lag72 Because varanasi is very clean compared to before 2014. Also before 2014 electricity was a huge problem. No electricity for 2-3 days straight. And now sometimes there's no power cut for 1-2 days, even if there is it for 5-10mins. Also now there's street lights everywhere, underground electrical wires. Better road (still not the best)
Problem of india is that india didnt deserve democracy,we are unruly stratified indisciplined corruptive chaotic society,and we need someone oppressive and strict to rule over us ..we are bad at deciding whats good for us,thats why under mugol rule india prospered and British ruled india easily by pitting one against others. Europeans or east asians can take care of themselves we cant..
ur history is really weak right??have u even read history??please don't tell me ur source is our school history books cuz these history has factually wrong texts
India progressed during mogul rule? India's decline started from arab invasion, And don't worry India is going to be in even worst shape as it will become muslim majority nation and then islamic Republic like other arab countries, and then India will again have dictatorship like you mentioned in mogul rule and witness new lower lows
People often blame a lack of funds or corruption, but the real issue is the absence of proper urban planning. India has never had a comprehensive master plan for its cities. What passes as “planning” is merely the division of farmland into clusters with no real strategy. There’s no proper building code or logical framework-just poorly thought-out, ineffective plans.
Yes I agree with you bro india will never change, we Indians are not taking any responsibility to take care of our city throwing waste here and there we need and simply blaming the government for not cleaning the city. Every Indian is the same. Even the educated or uneducated all are the same as like foreigners statement "filthiness is running in their blood"😢😢
Japan is better than western countries, but china and russia no, india is already better for living than russia and china. Russia and China have the same problems but the citizens can't complain because the government doesn't allow them to.
Just a suggestion. It'd be really helpful to provide English subtitles too. As a non Indian, I find it rather exhausting to understand such thick Indian accent. No judging here, just stating my situation.
Central Bangalore is messed up because it was planned almost 2 decades ago. Currently there is good planning and development of infrastructure going on towards North Bangalore, Airport road. In fact there is a new and much bigger business park than Manyata opening next to KIA.
@@rohankamble9595 Check infra reports properly recent reports of delhi ariports terminal collapsywas also used to mislead people, in reality the terminal that collapsed was buil before 2012 ( u can check the date, 12, 13,14) however media has been used to propagate misinformation such as it was the newly built terminal. Similary, if u have any idea about the commonwealth games that were supposed to be held in india under congress and the amount of projects that collapsed making ot one of the biggest scams, nothing even close to that is happening in India rn, and thats not even the biggest scam from before. In the name of opposing Modi, dont oppose India.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE 🥰🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🥰 🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🥰 🇮🇳 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN 🥰THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🥰 🇮🇳, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🥰🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳
Well said at the end, its also about the severely lacking civic sense of indian citizens who never care about the cleanliness of public spaces. I guess lack of education and social moral values is one of the major reasons why people act like that.
Coz of indian diversity just like Myamar More diversity in ethnics groups and languages, More difficulties to unite and more chance to disintegrate and differ and deray
In Bengaluru intitaly created areas such as basavanagudi, Malleswaram, jayanagar were are in the form of grids but later on other areas were randomly without any plan it was converted into living place
Blaming people is not gonna solve the problem. Because people lack civic sense but they are not aware of that. The government should spend money on spreading public awareness about these things. Im pretty sure it will work.
As a non-Indian who has only visited this beautiful country, this video is absolutely amazing! I can't wait to go back soon to India, it's developing at a very rapid pace, many highways are under construction, the road conditions are improving, and I'd love to try the new Vande Bharat sleeper trains. I won't even talk about the telecom infrastructure, even in villages I somehow got 5G signal. That being said, the city planning leaves a lot to be desired - even though the densest cities are in India, the walkability isn't great, so I had to resort to Ubers or rickshaws a lot of times just to get to a store only 1 km away. I found it strange but your video explained the issues clearly, and it seems a combination of rapid development, urbanisation and legal red tape. Just one complaint, the music is way too loud, and it was sometimes hard to hear what you were saying.
Saying this very responsibility that India can never be like other countries offcourse we will have some of the biggest companies in the world and richest people in the world.
I dont understand why none of the videos on indian cities use hyderabad in any of their case studies or examples. There are definitely a lot of things to learn from hyderabad too.
Hyderabad is a US wannabe car-centric dystopia. The metro is half-baked and the pedestrian experience is horrible, even in rich neighbourhoods. The walking trail around Durgam Cheruvu is the only nice urban planning I've seen in Hyderabad, but even 6+ years from when it was started it still hadn't been finished when I last visited. Also like Mumbai, it lacks proper drainage and gets flooded during rains.
1. Government need to do something about population control 2. People need to be deciplind 3. People need to have basic education 4.people thinks now days education is totally useless that's why most children not educated
We just need scapegoat.. The scapegoat is Politicans and Corruption. but We the People are equally part of it. but no ones likes to be blamed, so we collectively never blame ourselves as well.
I remember my economic teacher saying. China also has corruption there building also crumble but a dictatorship is good in something and is punishing. And i was like why that make so much sense here the one's who are supposed to take action against the corruption are the one's who are involved in it . Yeah with our lifestyle and different style we could just create our own designs just making our own living a sight to see. But all that will happens when our mindsets changes at all levels and there are many more steps to take but this is the very first step we should try to achieve.
Not necessarily. It’s a misconception that larger population is the problem. Human Resource is always a blessing provided it is properly utilised. Because cities in our country are managed like this, we have this pre conceived notion.
Chandigarh is also a good example of how Indian cities could be planned. It has markets in every sector, grid pattern roads, no residential house has more than 3 floors. Everyone follows traffic rules because there are speed cams and other cameras installed which captures you and challan is issued instantly if you jump zebra crossings, if you over speed or jump lights. Separate cycle tracks are there and proper infrastructure for hiring e bikes. Good public and private infrastructure. Now they have an IT park as well in both Chandigarh and Mohali so it has got everything
If you want to learn how to edit videos like AevyTV, sign up for our FREE editing masterclass: bit.ly/editing-masterclass :)
Learning about other cities . Kolkata now seems like heaven . Any mishap here we blame the mayor and th mayor is constantly under attack ... not to say.. Kolkata has a pretty good zoning pattern....⚫⚫⚫⚫
off topic but not all of china is like that,i'd love to see a video from you guys on ChinaInsiderbyDavidZhang
We just have 7-8 stretches of 1km which look international from certain angles. Indians are not civilized. There is no point having a beautiful well built city when citizens are trashy. We need dictatorship. Both ways. Strict citizens who keep government selfless and corruptionfree, and a wise government which keeps citizens disciplined and civilized.
China is discipline & local municipalities r not corrupt, China has municipality election every 4 years.
India can't look like anything like those cities. Our PPL sucks. Too much corruption.
When politicians eat up a majority chunk of the infrastructure project budget, then you don't have enough money to build quality infra, as a result, we have sub-par infrastructure.
India: making Infra by counts
China : Casually demolishes a series of apartments
Not true. I'm not saying there's no corruption in India, I'm saying the effect of corruption on India's situation is minimal. Even if there was no corruption in India, it would have look nearly the same becuase we are too many people with too little money. It's that simple.
What about roads? Don't we have enough money for it?@@abhisheksoni2980
I think permanent government employees are more corrupt than politicians.
People are corrupt. The workers, engineers, and local people are mannerless and corrupt.
In the west I always heard China this China bad, but when I visited months ago with a diplomat, oh my god it was sooo clean, the people were friendly and curious, it was awesome. Now I almost don't listen to western media anymore because of it.😅
Yeah, same goes for anywhere, ignore the propaganda and see for yourself
😂you foreigners are so cute and you are so smart to know the truth that western media never tell you the truth about China from a chinese perspective.
Same except I never got to visit China
Good. The West and many other places are going nowhere. Fast.
all those things can be true at once. Are you simple minded? A place can be clean, people appear friendly (because you don't speak their language), and organized. It can also be authoritarian and doing bad things against other nations. Those things are not mutually exclusive...well maybe in a child's mind they are.
It would be a miracle if India come close to China’s infrastructure. As a foreigner, I have visited both countries. Mindset of Indian, work ethic, integrity, civic sense, corruption, etc
Europe developed because they were ruled by Kings for 100s of years, but now Europe is degrading after democracy. India directly got democracy after British rule, hence we never got a chance for proper development. Across the world, the vast majority of bigger nations that transformed from Colonies to democracies have such poor infrastructure. There is only one solution to this problem, India should be ruled by a dictator.
You have to remember China is not a democracy. They used to just put a cross on buildings in old Shanghai and the next day this was demolished. There was no worry about the people. India is democratic and thus has to abide by the people's wishes. So, changing the look of any city in India is difficult. On top of this we were run for over 75 years by a Government that did not care for the people and just let the country continue. They did not instill any passion in the people about their country. So when the people have no pride they live by this.
@@learningmaster8060 Hey, bro. If you believe western propagandas on 'Democracy' or 'Dictatorship', then you will never find the way out. Because that's total wrong. There is no democracy in the west at all. And meanwhile, what works in China is not dictatorship at all. The system in the west, is a company-like structure. The stockholders hide deeply at the back, put several statues in the front, to manipulate and cheat on the crowd. What a shame! Also, China is not like the west propaganda only have one party, actually, Chine has 8 more parties out of the CPC, let's not count the Taiwanese parties as Chinese parties, which basically protect only U.S. interests.
You want the truth, then find by yourself, media is only worked for the people who paid on them.
@@sunilthakore5715 Don't people this, people that. If following your rule, government won't be able to help 99% of the people.
Then *don't be an @$$ like your media, blaming government not help people, because it is people like you who make it impossible.*
The essence of democracy and human right simply can't coexist, go figure out why.
BTW, are there SIG in your country? if there are (I am sure there are), there is no democracy in your country.
@@learningmaster8060 North Korea is ruled by a dictator, it is not better. South Korea and Taiwan are the only major economies (Hong Kong and Singapore are too small) that transformed into advanced economies after ww2, what they had in common is one party rule and state capitalism, combined with meritocracy, Taiwan and South Korea both taken a hit after transforming into liberal democracy under US pressure, their growth almost immediately flattened. So I think one party rule and statement capitalism are the keys for development.
For leaders to perform, meritocracy I think is the key. All the large corporations do it, why not government? Elections depends on money and media image, performance was never even a factor.
My first visit to India was in 1960 I travelled by land route from Madras(now Chennai) to Pakistan and beyond. The condition was shocking even from a Singaporean like me! Then about ten years ago, I visited Mumbai albeit for a day, what I seen in the streets of this so called modern city by Indian standard, except for the most affluent part of the city, the rest were reminiscent to what I remembered seeing the first time I went there, the street was full of cows, telephone and power cables jumbled up in bundles hanging precariously on poles and houses, beggars and homeless lined the streets, cow dungs rubbish strewn across everywhere! I thought to myself, India has not changed much. India needs a good government and changed attitude !
In Dec 2023, I had the unfortunate commute in Singapore MRT to "Little India" for a toilet stop en route to the airport, and it was not pleasant to say the least compared to other areas/facilities in Singapore, so what does that tell you?
@@tonywatt3281at least there are toilets, u don’t hv to do it in the open(common for most in dians). Any way, the filth n smell of superpower inn dia is out of this world
Indian mindset never changes so shouldn’t be surprised at all.
its far better than what it used to be 10 years back..10 years back fast internet was luxury for us,now we are the pioneers of digital payments.India is spending much more in capital investment than it used to be back then
@@tonywatt3281 at least there are toilets, not open air toilets…..
Corruption is in the blood of Indians. No political party, IAS, IPS etc can solve this problem.
So blood of western countries is of diff group?
@@yashpalchaudhary9752 Yes just look at the infra of China Japan South Korea and Australia
@@yashpalchaudhary9752India is a cursed land
@@yashpalchaudhary9752even central asian, north africa middle east are more developed.
Indian cities are destroyed due to indian mentality thats it
@@Gop101 I would've agreed if you asked few years back. But if you think about it it has more to do system rather than blood.
If people of india were inherently corrupt non hard working and uncivilized then how come these Same act like most civilised law-abiding and hardworking community when they move to other countries?
You may say because they are educated but that's not the case. Even less educated labourers are much better in these countries.
And highly educated bureaucrats act like most corrupt species in india.
It's our British era system that never lets honest person survive in the system.
And it our fault that we never cared enough to change it in almost 8 decades of independence
Anyone that keeps claiming India is overtaking China or close to catching up to China in terms of economic prowess is eating propaganda so hard. Literally watch any recent youtube vlogs of tier 2-3 cities in China and compare it to tier 1 cities in India, the gap is wider than you'd expect.
They are just brainwashed by the IMF. The Anglo Saxons want a useful idiot as a buffer to fight China. Who else serves best the purpose of being useful idiots, than the Indian far right groups of India? Those IMF numbers about India's GDP are totally fake. India's vast majority of the GDP is from the informal private sector. It is not at all accounted, and no one knows how much income is generated exactly in these private sector. It is all a speculation.
Not even US cities look as good as China, yet their economy is much more stronger than China.
Cities are not measure of economic development
@@somakchatterjee6429 Ah yes, having human feces and some of the worse city slums literally next to a billionaire's 1 billion dollar mansion is a sign of healthy economic development. Wake up!!!!
Ok Not totally agreeing with you. As good and well planned cities plays the key role to make that city liveable and also it generates capital when tourists visits those places as it enhances the beauty of that city..for once just type europe and watch any video of any random city in europe and the way they are organised and you will get to know why people love to visit europe or any hill station in india as beauty and cleanliness equals more tourist and money so yes it contributes in the economy
Every City Can be Nice in India but people lack civic sense. People freely urinate in open, Throw Trash in Water Bodies, Defacate on Railway Lines, Throws the Waste Unsegregated. This is a HUGE Problem in India. People blame Population but Hong Kong and Singapore have one of the highest population density in the world and yet those cities are one of the cleanest. People blame poverty but Poverty doesnt give you license to Litter around and Defacate in Open. The Attitude of Indian People must change. This civic sense should be taught in schools from a young age. Trash Segregation should be taught in Environmental Studies Subject
Yes, all these are true, you and I are the same product of our society that lacks civic sense but why has nobody taught us about civic sense nobody has shown us our parents, teachers or government. Poverty and corrupt governments are the two biggest problems. Poverty restricts people from getting the right education and knowledge and our government or you can say these politicians do not care about poverty they want power in every election and pocket large sums of money....even we don't have a proper waste management system is...
Educated guys/couples throwing garbage when going to work is unique in India..
In HK and Singapore also the areas populated by the people from subcontinent are the dirtiest.
Indians will never change
I agree about lack of civic sense, however these same people observe the civic laws with utmost sincerity when they go to other countries. It's the combination of availability of infrastructure, awareness of cleanliness and threat of fines/action that allow people to follow the rules. For example, in Dubai, there are dustbins every few meters. These dustbins themselves are regularly emptied and maintained in a clean way. With such a level of availability, it becomes very easy to ensure that any rubbish is always discarded in dustbins. Plus there's the constant threat of heavy fines if someone is found littering or spitting in public places.
Hats off to the video editor! He/she has done a remarkable job at editing this video! I'm blown
Apart from the sudden CC change at 19:31 the editor did infact do a great job!
I agree. The animations, content and arguments were great. However the background audio was a bit too loud in contrast to the narrator's voice.
*I'm blown away
"I'm blown" might insinuate an entirely different thing 😶
Thank you 🙏
Why she wants our cities to be a Concrete Island/JUngle ?
You can't compare India to China. China is on a different level
It’s disrespectful even to consider the word “compare”.
@@HanumanDas-s1n True .. China invented corona .. legendary level
as an Indian you are right
It seems they love to compare themselves to China,literally everything 😂. Indians are not the same race as Chinese or Japanese.
@@Hamui-kk8mw dumb if you don't compare t someone who is above us how will we learn
I started my career in Delhi thinking there is hope when I was 22. Today I am 44, and let me tell you things have gone from bad to worse. There is zero accountability with the thousands of ppl in state and central govt, and life here is horrible. The story is same in each and every city of India. This you realise when you see how the rest of the world lives.
I guess that is difference between India and China, Chinese officials have KPIs (Key Performance Indicators), their promotion and demotion depends on their performance, that is the meritocracy they talked about. That is why they built infrastructures, because it is good for economy and GDP is a very large weighting in their KPIs. KPIs are used in 100% of the large enterprises, and KPIs in government are not invented by the Chinese, they learned that from Singapore government. Meritocracy however is never applied to governments in liberal democratic countries.
@@joseph_weiYou still don't understand? Is Western-style democracy really democratic? Can the various parties and factions, with their supporters, really choose a person who works for the development of the country? The people are short-sighted. Can a country develop by doing things according to the people's wishes?
@@chinchin8084 Political parties in the west are built on money from rich people and corporations, so the viable candidates people can select from are all chosen by money, and none of them is really working for people. BTW I don't think what we have in the west is democracy.
I am just a couple of years older than you and cannot agree more than your comment. Only difference is now I see India as an NRI and it doesn't hurt that much
Exactly look at any other nation in asia pacific they all are doing well.
We indians havnt even figure out basics and people are ready to argue how we are gonna lead world in next 20 years or theyll point at Britishers they the reason we behind.
Mumbai having little bit flood at the same time this video is airing, makes the timing perfect!
Har baar ki tarah 😫
Correct
little bit?? 😂
Har saal ka hi hai bhai, barish aayi nahi ki pani bharna chalu hota hai😂
True
The Oldest civilization yet the farthest from developed civilization.
🙂👍🏻
@urdailygamr9229
🤡 Mughals just plunder the wealth of India
When marco polo visit India's chola empire and hindu empire
He referred them as land of richest
Many oriantalist historians has already conclude that gupta empire was India's golden period
After fall of chavan empire India's economy has declined for next 800 year's..
true words.
Exactly. I find it funny when people say "Bharat is the oldest civilization yadayada" and in my head I'm always thinking, doesn't that mean we've failed as a civilization😂?? We had a head start and yet we fall behind to other countries big or small in terms of a lot of aspects. It's so bad that we fall behind 30-80 years in some aspects. The only thing Indians do after that is complain about colonization etc etc. It's funny cuz I find a lot of the British built infrastructure from back in the day way safer and better tha modern Indian ones 😭
@@Ro-chanKamui
Finnally someone with brain...
As a Chinese, that has been what the West has mocked China for the past century of humiliation.
Many Indian people I've met are hardworking and intelligent. Unfortunately the country is held back by too many dissenting voices aka democracy. It's up to the Indian people whether they want to forgo a little political freedom in exchange for greater personal and economic freedom.
india talks a big game but is fruitless in all aspects. china talks little but lets its action and progress speak for itself....
Because Indian people wants to do action by others
If politicians are corrupt then people should take pledge
WOW SARRR VERY DANGEROUS !!!! 😠😠 IN INDIA WE ONLY FLY ON VIMANA 🇮🇳🤗 THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA 🤗🇮🇳 THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD , WE NEVER DO SCAM AND WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗
Because it's easy to fool us 🙃
India should bring in American companies to build. We are the best infrastructure guys.
@@StanleyJohnson-b4v 50 YRS AGO, SILLY.
why because if it costs 100 Rs to build they'll charge 500 Rs & still put low quality lobour & materials because who's there to keep a check on them? ofcourse this had to happen
No because we follow the L1 system of giving contracts. Whoever states the cheapest price, we give the contract to them. Shockingly, even Defense follow L1 system
@@ku5285 that's part of the business to find cheaper contractors but the question is who's checking the quality of the work?
@@SuplexCityF5 There is actually system of check and balance in Indian bureaucratic system but corruption in our bureaucracy is rampant.
@@ku5285 lmao the contract is handed to the friends of IAS and politicians. You must be young
@@gimei-chan usually the ones with the lowest bids are often the friends and relatives of politicians only 😂😂😂😂
Being an Indian I must say we are almost 200 years behind China and we can never ever compete with them in any aspects
Your right.
Typical indians think that "We have most population so we are going to overtake china"
its like you have 1000 chickens that most lay eggs (china)
and 1100 chickens that most don't lay eggs (India)
We have european level taxes while living is still equal to third world 😢.
Of course this is a negative video, we are talking about a poor country that just recently starting to become self sufficient. Funny she compares with South Africa and Brazil. Brazil had higher GDP than India less that two decades ago, now India has double the GDP. While India is the fastest growing major economy in the world South Africa is falling back to become a third world country.
Well, at least it's not CCP paid propaganda. Talk about China, their cities are full of suddenly imploding roads due to bad quality. Their highest buildings are unsafe to use so they are largely empty. Parts of their buildings fall on the street with strong winds. Currently another huge flooding problem in China that is much worse than India because dams release water without warning, so you can have meters of flooding within ten minutes. So for all the bad publicity, India is doing relatively better than China, just have some patience.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE 🥰🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🥰 🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🥰 🇮🇳 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN 🥰THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🥰 🇮🇳, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🥰🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳
What European level taxes ?? 40% European population pay direct taxes while indian only 1-2%
@@indiasuperclean6969 Hey Big cap writer , understand the negative tone of the video to make monetization easy and to resonate with such people , you need to know china i in downfall and there sub par buildings do collapse which is ture . Keep your sarcasm to yourself . Woh dhanda kar raha aur tu tere time waste .
@@SandeepMeena79 agree Europe pays 50 percent tax of their income .and these buggers need to know this same buggers looted the world and hence the infra and richness and capablity to spend more . leftist saare commenters like YOLO
My wife did graduation in town planning from school of planning and architecture. Its a 4 year course. She was in a small class of 30 people. 27 out of 30 are now no longer in india because there weren't enough opportunities for them. Most are in europe or US. My wife moved to IT because she didn't want to leave.
if there are no opportunities, none of these 27 created opportunities? That's called entrepreneurship. This is the easy road.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE 🥰🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🥰 🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🥰 🇮🇳 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN 🥰THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🥰 🇮🇳, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🥰🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳
@@sancatheone6258 Not everybody has a business mindset. Is it so hard to ask of our government to create opportunities for such talents?
@@vedgupta1686 You know what Kennedy said: Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.
@@indiasuperclean6969 Nobody gets your sarcasm, just stop it.
Call me cynical, but anyone who thinks that the situation is going to improve in India - just needs to wake up from their dreams!
Dumb if you think you are right
Definitely, because of so many ethnicities and crab mentality, china could unite whole country because everyone belonged to same ethnicity, but it's impossible in India to unite everybody through nationalism,
Unity in diversity and nationalism in India are the biggest fake ideas I have ever heard of
India is basically more than 100 years behind china and this is true.
@@styles_mufasa3106bro we are not even in that race yet people in India literally worshiping dogs and cows 😆
@@Vaibhav6384oh religion is bad yes the religion told you to throw garbage, also we dont worship dogs, you dont even know shit but of course you have to sound like you know everything also why do we worship a cow yes you dont know so shut up
Everything about india that doesn't Suck, has left india.
Stinking Paper wipe who takes his knowledge from Instagram reels🤡🤡🤡
@@rhythmkhandelwal2940 do you have any better argument than these "bro get knowledge from certain place"?
@@rhythmkhandelwal2940 he is right, most of intellectuals in your country just started leaving your country
@@sadmikewazowski7754I am Indian and I agree with you
@@sadmikewazowski7754 Im an indian too and honestly, it's not worth engaging with someone who just wants to argue for the sake of it. Better to focus on meaningful discussions than get caught up in endless back-and-forth.
First we indian need to develop civic sense
Not only Indians,almost most country citizens 😂😂😂😅😅
learn from northeast
Last 10-20 saal civic sense ki baat ho raha hai. Par laato ke bhoot baato se nahi manenge
This is just a cope. Japanese instilled senpai discipline within it's populace during meiji era through primary and nationslistic education. Can we guarantee the same in India without protest from right groups.
This is the non sense filled by bikau media in peoples brain...many indians go to foreign country and obey its rules and when come back to india they become same...so strict rules make the diff..not some sense...and many people wont develop civic sense at all.
And no school gives this training..so rules are necessary
A 1.4 billion careless population is the biggest reason of india being unorganized. No moral responsibility, no accountability and here we are talking about government 😂😂😂
Don’t count Kerala and North East in. 👍
@@tech9896True,Im thinking to skipping going for articleship in North India. Breathing will give me health hazard
One of your biggest problems is this smug Malthusian notion that the reason your country does not work is because of too many people. 😂
China has lifted 850 million people out of poverty.
Your problems are a backward culture, callous elites, and bec of these facts, you’ve not created an egalitarian just society.
👉🏻 We Indians don’t give a damn about how our cities look or functions. Pollution, Institutionalised Corruption, illegal settlements, rampant cutting of trees, industrial waste, adulterated rationing and food, garbage piling and failed govt. system that’s how I describe people here.
I am Singaporean. Look at the way we do things and learn from us. Start by saying "zero" for 0 without saying "jeero" for a starter. How can the people who don't have any respect for spellings have respect for quality huh? This is why in developed countries when you say Indian the people go like "yukkk".. I don't even wanna sit next to one
@@yevanyevan7238 : can you tell me the dirtiest area in Singapore ? every Singaporean will know.
singapore is future indian colony anyway😂@@yevanyevan7238
@@LimWeeChoon Little India. Yukk
@@yevanyevan7238you say zero as jeero in Hindi. It's called Hinglish though you are not wrong but it's all about government. I'm not joking at all Singapore would still be a poor city if that one person wouldn't dare to come forward for the betterment of his country's people
Doesn’t matter how much right wing bhakts curse china, China is and will be an inspiration for the world including India, centuries to come.
They set an unprecedented example of human capabilities.
Long live Indo-China brotherhood
Dictatorship in China and just now reading that in china too intrafracture are destroyed by massive floods so why target India Only.In USA too and even New York will need 19 billions dollars
Chinese leaders want to be friend with India. Does Modi want the same???
Supporting your country isn't right-wing bot
PRC is a particracy🤦🏼
India and PRC can be siblings
if there are no disputes
Indo China brotherhood? really. That is funny.
@@surajitmondal823 you are forgetting that china is undemocratic, persecutes his own people, occupying South china sea, grabbed Tibet, undermining Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia in the region.Attaking India in Ladhak from time to time. Using developing countries by looting them after lending them with advantage to them and Look how Sri Lanka and African countries effected..And what to invade Taiwan which is democratic country.Inspite of massive trade with India USA west, china is underming stability.I hope you have not forgotten Nehru stabbed by Chu en lai.And i hope you have not forgotten treatment of Ujbers.
correction, Chongqing is still not a tier1 city. China only has 4 1st tier city Beijing Shanghai Shenzhen Guanzhou
不了解的话就不要乱给别人科普，重庆是中国4个直辖市之一
@@周龙哥 别人说的一线城市 你的英文不行就别乱说
not Guanzhou, it's Guangzhou
@@ftu2021 你们两都是s b 好好闭嘴就行了谢谢配合
@@周龙哥 天津也是直辖市，但它不是一线城市。
India’s system is all crroupt from basic level workers to top tier officers. For instance im from a small town and town got 2cr. grant from government but all muncipal members take it a bribe and used only 20 lacs on infrastructure….20/200lacs …same on our system
Real bro government gave 2cr in my area to built water tanks but 1cr direct took buy engineers then took buy other people 50 lakhs then 20 lakhs workers left only 30lakhs for material bought cheap material now after rain water tanks are laekaing now 4-5 tanks to supply water in area
It is now not a problem but a culture
@@ariyanghadei6462 what culture our culture dont tell these things to do
Why is it corrupt and solution?
@@yageshgupta8598 bhai mera bolne ka matlab yeh hai ki ye ab ek culture ban chuka hai
People are blaming politicians
They represent indian voters who want caste and freebies. Don't blame politicians
Politicians are policy makers. Caste and all can be eliminated with simple laws but do they want it. Big noo. Divide and rule is the motto of Indian politics and no legislation will be passed to bridge it
@@democracy123 you can't make laws to eliminate caste. It's like we already have anti caste discrimination laws. The way to solve this issue is through massive industrialisation, economic reforms, urbanisation . Turning india frm primitive agrarian society to post industrial society
Mainly by UP bihar
You mean the people with no compulsory working hours, no minimum education level, no performance requirement. If they don't show up at all nobody would even know? From what I understand politicians in US mostly work one day per week. Yeah, of course we can't blame people like that.
Better to have royal king in India, then fake democracy and politic parties who are fully corrupted.
Thirty year ago I came to the US to study economics. At the time, there was a Chinese professor who achieved very high academic status in MIT's Sloan Business School. His name is Yasheng Huang. His research focus is on the comparative development models of China and India. At the time, I admired him a lot and read many of his papers. One of his very consistent thesis is that China is wasting money on infrastructure and he predicted that India would do a lot better economically since it did not waste money on infrastructure. Now thirty years have passed, I am glad that China's government did not listen to him. I am afraid he may have misled many Indian politicians since he was an accomplished academia in MIT with many joint research with Indian scholars. Now when I think about it, if he did not shit on China's development model, he probably wouldn't have reached his level of esteem and status in the West.
西方只想听他们想听的，因为目的是唱衰中国，所以中国选择什么不重要，重要的是：无论中国选择什么，都是错的。当然不能只说中国是错的，还要拉来一个别的国家，做对比，然后告诉大家，中国是错上加错。最终还是要：实践出真知。
这哥们现在还在到处混。
其实他是中国间谍派去西方去忽悠它们！
Welcome to China. We like friends from India. Please don't hate us. Most Chinese people are just normal and worried about their life, just like people from India.
North Indians🤡. we South Indians always like Chinese❤.
We, the people of India, killed our own rivers, cut down our trees, stripped the hills of their flora and fauna, made every corner into a dump yard, preferred ignorance over awareness and sympathy towards our surroundings and yet we wonder what caused our once great nation, which had one of the best drainage systems in the whole world in early ages, to become a collection of tobacco stains, dust, noise and air pollution, trash and uncivilized people.
China is not developed, it is a developing country and does not have the potential that India has. China's pollution is far more serious than India's. Don't worry, it is impossible for China to catch up with India in the next ten years.
united india is only good for big enterprises tycoons,india should better separated developing
@@siemens-vip god i wish i was this delusional
@@siemens-vipStay deluded
@@siemens-vipchina is 1000x more developed than India
Comparing india with china is China's disrespect please compare it with African countries
I agree.
@@harjitatwal7918 do you really feel that India can compare with African Countries in term of infrastructures? We African countries are not so bad.
@@policiasando4358face slap......lots of African infrastructures are build by China
@@policiasando4358agree on that too😂 I have seen south africa,rawanda,Kenya vlogs and seriously as an Indian I feel ashamed for what my country has become... can't do anything also... without dictatorship handling billion population is impossible
Rwanda is my favourite country, they can't be listed in the African stereotype
an ideal city for me is a city that is made for the people to comfortably live, the space is green and clean with proper drainage system, water harvesting system and sustainable sources of electricity generation. a city where in the citizen can simply walk or bike to places rather than using vehicles fueled by non renewable fuels and also has well developed public transport!
And, is safe.
(so, basically a mixture of Singapore and Germany )
(a youtube channel i'd like to recommend is " *Not Just Bikes* ")
add safety
Australian cities are prime best example of this they are magnificent in every parameters.
@@xen5917 good point. done👍
@@tooflowery very good👍
Australia is still very car dependent. Can't get better than the Netherlands @@vibhutisrivastava2789
STILL WANT TO COMPETE WITH CHINA ???!!!!!???
COULD NOT EVEN COMPETE WITH MALAYSIA, THAILAND, VIETNAM, INDONESIA, PHILIPPINES, NOT EVEN CAMBODIA OR LAOS !!!!!!!.....😂😂😂
From :Singapore 🇸🇬
I have friends from all around southeast Asia and tbh their very well educated and very kind and funny too, bro their infrastucture and cleanliness and aesthetics is on another level, Philippines being a country where people earn just like an average Indian but still they look so clean and futuristic, cities like Cebu, Manila and Laguna and soooo beautiful. Damn, I wanna visit these places aleast once in my life.
@@RitaDey-hr5pc have you ever visit KL?
Lol Insane superiority complex over here.
I think the comparison was made based on the population size
India and China's population size is quite close as compared to the other countries you mentioned
False pride of indian masses and leadership.
The late PM Rajiv Gandhi once said that for every rupee alloted by the govt for a project only 15 paise actual goes to the project. Rest 85 paisa is stolen in between. Situation has not changed even after 30+ years
A small suggestion: There are munipal swepers and cleaners all around our cities deployed. They must be trained and given little power and ownership of a particular area they must take care of in cleaning and beautification in a small extent. Also to get the municipality attention on the issues. They must be trained like a team leads in corporate.
Stop littering public places
They shouldn't be picking up trash from public space that's thrown by ppl, rather cleaning up leaves and landscaping, emptying trashcans, etc
@@hr_47exactly fight the root cause no use cutting the leafs, should fine people who litter
i don't nor any one in my area do but municipal corporation wale naali se saaf nahi krte or jab krte to usko uthana bhul jaate h 🙂🙂 there are many ppl who don't litter @@hr_47
Even those cleaners cant do anything if people dont have civic sense and accountabiity. people just throw waste everywhere
Let's hope Amaravati, Andhra Pradesh's capital, learn something from this.
The masterplan is of the Grid model, and some of it is now visible in Google Maps.
gujurat's dholera as well
Amaravati isn't happening bro, that project has been stalled.
@@okayaresddidn't the governance go back to NDA?
@@okayaresd bhai current affairs follow nahi karte kya- andhra pradesh election mein nda ki victory ho chuki hai isliye amravati phir se shuru ho gaya hai jo jagan ne apne ego ke karan band karva diya tha
Hope they don't change road plans to go right beside their own lands 😀
I'm Chinese (live in Hong Kong).
I really like this video.
Everyone should watch this video. This is excellent video on urban planning.
Everyone deserve to live in cities which are well designed.
I wish our neighbours in India enjoy better living conditions, like us in China.
South India Can but begger shi* north India eat our south Indian money . We want separate country 🤩. Love China❤ from South India
Don't be naive. India bullied China in the 1950s and 60s and is occupying a piece of China as we speak. India invaded and annexed Tawang, South Tibet in 1951. Tawang is the Sixth Dalai Lama's birthplace and home to the four hundred years old Tawang Monastery. In 1987 India renamed the area to the so-called Arunachal Pradesh. South Tibet is three times the size of Taiwan, rich in biodiversity and with large area of primitive forest.
@@idkhowdumblingare
South india cant survive a week without the free resources you get from north.
Coal mica etc all from Jh chh orrisa rajastahm etc
South india has no resources.
Also just because those american companies set up in south doesnt mean you are better 😂😂😂
South indians have sla*e mind.
@@idkhowdumblingare
Mauryan empire 🔱
I mean... Indians literally INVENTED the grid pattern, urban sanitation, and high-level urban planning. The fact that we can't do it better than our ancestors 5000 years ago is appalling.
comeon man... you guys just brag how "we invented all of that in ancient times"
No one gives a shit.
Is that the propaganda they teach you? Don't you realize that Indians never had a civilization? The British came and gave India whatever little civilization that they possess now.
Did you see any cities 5000 years ago
@@ShajahanE4 just check mohenjo daro
@@ShajahanE4 he's referring to cities of mohanjodaro, which were known for their drainage system and planning .
It's a marvel
As a Chinese based on what i experienced in last decade, Most of chinese people's civic sense were getting better AFTER the infrastructures have fast developed. Within a much clean and neat and well organised environment, People become much more civilized spontaneously.
As a Chinese citizen living in Canada now, I would say that our excellent infrastructure has a lot to do with our political system and economic development strategy where local governments borrow a lot of money to accelerate infrastructure projects so that they could further boost the economy. And that’s why China has one of the best infrastructure systems in the world although its downsides like local governments debt crisis is appearing now. I think that Indian government should learn our models in this stage as good infrastructure could be a key accelerator for your economic growth in this stage although it’s hard to achieve.
They won’t because it’s china they have a china phobia even this woman didn’t mention china 🙄 china cities are modern and they are well planned !
@ankitakumari1366 each country has pros and cons, this rule applies to every country. :)))
You are right
@@Dancinginthesnow737 yes but most your fellow mates here are commenting with racial hatred that doesn't even help anybody.
@@Dharma_and_Ahimsa unfortunately I agree with your assessment, there are lot of Chinese people just left radical speech that means nothing but export unnecessary hatred. And what I could do is stay sane to others while disregarding my radical counterparts.
Before your country make any improvements, India must find a way to change its morally twisted culture.
This Infrastructure problems video is a trending contect in youtube now, but the elaborateness of your content, the brief explanation of understanding the core issues, instead of pin pointing just 'government', connecting past and all that, and the comparative details of why we lack behind from others, is very gripping to watch, and very educative. A very interesting explanation, very different approach from other vids I seen recently. Thanks.
i am from a small city in Indonesia, and we have mayor that is being elected every 5 years. So, these mayors can secure a position for 2 terms, they must do their best to get re elected again. Our current mayor have built proper drainage and sewage system accross the high streets and enlarge the pavement for pedestrians, they also built kilometres of beach promenades, built parks and they rebuilt the old wet market area to be a modern building with much cleaner system and more parks. They also reharded many small alleys with proper asphalt or bricks. When they renovate these stuff, the city becomes much cleaner automatically. People tend to keep the city cleaner and it becomes more organised easily, despite our nongrid system, because it's an old city.
The mayors did many things, one of the breaktrough to alleviate traffic was to build the 4 lanes orbital road. it is super efficient.
What city is that, I'm Indonesian too🇮🇩
Indonesia is way better and ahead of India. I visited Bali, Jakarta, Java, Komodo, and your new Bullet train is amazing. Better than what we have in USA!
Even chennai corporation wasted chennai rivers and turning them into dumpyard
every single city in India is guilty of completely ignoring the future for money in the present.
Utopian Idea:
Make a list of city problems.
Public vote from their phone apps to decide priorities.
Planners find solutions and list them.
Use AI to allocate budget.
Make bidding transparent.
Visible to public.
Have audit teams to overlook progress.
Do we need politicians here?
Who is the public? Public can only be seen through media. Media can easily be bought with small amount of money.
Using AI 😂 don't make me laugh! AI tends to give poor results
One difference, "the people are retarted"
fantastic except instead of AI we have many people who would work for that... i actually really like this idea...
@@jeonxkook5447 The problem with using people instead of AI is that it will eventually become politicians' own people, which is the current practice.
I'm proud as an indori but we want every city to be as much clean as possible even if its not developed it shouldn't be compromized with the cleanliness
Very nice. The master planning used to be there till 1960..but then it got lost. With india being the most populous nation, this is the need of the hour.
This video really opened my eyes to why India’s infrastructure is struggling. The comparison with international cities like Tokyo and the insights into the deep-rooted issues in Bangalore, Mumbai, and Delhi were spot on. The lack of civic sense, rapid unplanned growth, and restrictive land use policies are major hurdles. The example of Tokyo's zoning laws and mixed-use buildings was fascinating. It's clear that our cities need better planning and regulations to manage growth effectively.
The traffic problems in Bangalore and the challenges in expanding Mumbai vertically due to restrictive FSI rules were especially illuminating. The piece on Mumbai's outdated drainage system and the recurring flooding issue highlighted the urgency for infrastructural upgrades. Delhi's water crisis and pollution problems further emphasize the need for sustainable urban management.
Overall, this video provided a comprehensive look into the complexities of urban planning and the unique challenges faced by Indian cities. Great job!
forget those cities if we need to compete with other cities then make new cities in each states
It is so interesting that you'll see a youtuber from a developed country like the US and UK complain about how every road in the city is just planned for cars. How smaller roads and closely packed spaces are much better.
Suddenly all the youtubers are making videos on India infrastructure.....woow Good job 😊😊😊
lol. they can do all videos they want. Feels good to watch. But outcome wont' change. India infrasturure will still be the same dacades later.
@@dandyperry1207that's why every stinking paper wipe of your kind dreams about but India is still growing and west is falling which you lack intelligence to see
Our grandchildren will watch this and wonder why, in spite of these videos, things stayed the same.
Public transportation is really important for a city as it lowers traffic. The problem is that in some cities buses look cheap and downgraded. So, only lower class ppl use them while middle class and upper middle class use vehicles leading to more air pollution as well as traffic congestion.
I traveled throughout India for 2 months and I was amazed because there was not one city that was truly beautiful.
Lol I bet you didn't go south , north east and extreme north of India. Bet you traveled Golden triangle and came back.
Lies
India cities looks untidy. Dusty too. Not well kept.
Visit GIFT city 😌
Notice a lot of indian don't take truthfull simple opinion too well
Another great example of careful planning and development of an Indian city by Govt. is Gandhinagar.
Great city to work and live in.👍
Doesn't make a difference
So far one of the best video talking about our urban plan issues....good video. I believe planning indian cities well will solve 60% problems.
Thanks Achina & Aevy Team! Sadly, such things are needed to be pointed out by the media. I hope your distribution reaches maximum people.
Still nothing will happen..reason ? You tell.
You still expects from media?
Wow, as an Indonesian...Indian problems are exactly what us Indonesians experience, albeit on a smaller scale cause we have smaller population and land areas. I guess we are really "Indian islands" lol
In our Howrah Municipal Corporation of West Bengal, last elections were held in 2013. It's term expired in 2018. So it's next term was supposed to be held in 2018 but it wasn't in last 6 years. So just imagine - a term last for 5 years but whole 6 years void of elections. As a result it's now also void of waste management, public hygiene & sanitation services, one of nation's worst sewerage, garbage capital of East India . Illegal construction & ecological sensitivity destruction & syndicate everywhere which was even accepted by our CM!🤦 And was one of dirtiest cities of India.
But we know even if elections are held nothing will change because they will be in only name- we couldn't cast our own vote but it'll be ballot rigged by booth capturings by local strongmen and goons & mafias of the state ruling party. When even formed undemocratic like rest of 100 municipalities of the state u cannot expect them to provide civic facilities. So first reforms and then fund flow is necessary or else it will go to the pockets of strongmen instead of our gully-mohallas.
West Bengal is a lost case thanks to Mamata. Support her and she will give you Bangladeshi Miya with 4 wives 30 children. Kolkata is going to Bangladesh soon don't worry
@@RikMahanta BJPee is no better
@@counterpoint9260 Better than TMChii or Khangress
@@RikMahantalol, bjpee bengal is made of Ex TMC, CPM and congress people...
They are no different
@@rishavkumar1250 that's the only problem all are corrupted maal of TMChii and Scamgress and Youth don't want to become politician and leaving the state
i have a college in Mumbai and live in Navi Mumbai, there are atleast a few weeks of non functional days in my clg because of rain over my course and not many for Navi Mumbai clg of my friends
India should fix food hygiene in their streets first, let them start at that.
Political will is the biggest hurdle. Take example of Amaravati, the city whose masterplan was build by Norman + Partners. Investment offered by World Bank. Singapore as mentor.
How to solve that will?
Isn't it restarted by Chandra Babu Naidu
@@srilakshmidevanathan8334 Work has restarted, but the precious time has been elapsed and cost has escalated to almost 50%.
When Congress came to power they played politics and shit down the plan, this is the beauty of democracy 😂😂😂
CLICKBAIT! she is talking about urban planning and not so much about infrastructure. We have design and implementation challenges which are causing these issues.
Agree
Then talk to architects of indian schools and change it. Work together to change minds of politicians. Stop corruption
As an Architect Watching this video, It really gives a new perspective about the Infrastructure in India, there are N number of things which constitutes to the crumbling of the infrastructure. As a civilian, we need to have a conscious mindset on how we pollute the place we live in, The CHANGE starts from us.
This is a beautifully explained video about the crisis of the Major cities and why their infrastructure seems to be questioned, complained and made fun of. The population in India doesn't really help too, irrespective of how much people are educated, we also need to practice what we have been thought of.
Sure Chandigarh is one of the planned cities and is beautiful in its own way, but few of the disadvantages would be
1. Scale and accessibility
2. Social Inclusion
3. Climate consideration
4. Modernization demands
5. Environmental Stress
Every planning has its own advantages and its disadvantages, but one of the greatest challenges we face would be the planning for future. Despite being one of the few nations who has people in powerful places across the World, we still are developing to become the better version of ourselves,
Being a Urban planner trying to do the better for the city and focusing on how the future and predicting it is solely a very difficult task, We are trying our best to do a lot to this world, we will get there eventually until then we need to keep educating, sharing the knowledge of what we learnt and how we can transform the Country, Maybe even the world.
Now this is all my take on the topic, I might be half right, could be completely wrong on some things, but the content that was put in the video was amazing and to the point and made sure that a layman could understand what was being said.
Thank YOU AEVY TV, Looking forward for more.
First of all it's politicians fault, India also needs more land.
How can you expect an uneducated leaders to properly understand the development process when all they think is of religion
Mesnwhile mr yogi visiting temple with an army of paparazzi.
Problem 1: Caste system
Problem 2: Modi busy serving US interests
Problem 3: Hostile to China.
Problem 4: No safety for women
Cultural Diversity: India is known for its rich cultural heritage and diversity. It is home to a wide variety of languages, religions, traditions, and festivals.
Historical Landmarks: India boasts a rich history with numerous historical landmarks such as the Taj Mahal, Qutub Minar, Red Fort, and many others that attract tourists from around the world.
Cuisine: Indian cuisine is famous for its diverse flavors and spices. It offers a wide range of delicious dishes that cater to various tastes and preferences.
Spirituality: India is known as the birthplace of several major religions such as Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and Sikhism. It is also home to many spiritual practices and traditions.
Democracy: India is the world's largest democracy with a vibrant and diverse political landscape. It has a robust electoral system that allows for peaceful transitions of power.
Economic Growth: India has experienced significant economic growth over the past few decades, making it one of the fastest-growing major economies in the world.
Information Technology: India is a global hub for information technology and software services. Cities like Bangalore and Hyderabad are known for their IT industry and innovation.
Education: India has a strong emphasis on education and is home to many prestigious educational institutions like the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) and Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs).
Art and Literature: Indian art and literature have a rich history and have made significant contributions to world culture. Indian literature, music, dance, and cinema are celebrated worldwide.
Natural Beauty: India is blessed with diverse landscapes ranging from the Himalayas in the north to the beaches of Goa in the south. It also has rich biodiversity with many national parks and wildlife reserves.
@@somikkundu6316aur iska kya karu? Bande ne 4 line me sahi baat kiya. Aur tu paragraph likke bhi point click nahi kiya🫠🫠?
@@somikkundu6316 "hey gpt, write 10 positive points about india"
@@somikkundu6316living in the past
Because the modern nation of India did not form through a Revolution: the old systems are still there, the goverment is a mixture of many diverse interest groups, this slows the decision making.
In varanasi also they gave free dustbins to everyone. 1 for dry waste and 2nd for wet waste.
Almost all of them used those dustbins to plant some plants and throw wastes on the road.
Even tho the garbage dump truck or van comes daily.
india ke logu me accountability naam ki chij hi nhi h.
Sb pe fine lgana chahiye
Varanasi is one of the dirtiest cities I have visited. I'm even more shocked after learning its PM Modi constituency. On what basis do people vote for him.
@@smiphel20lag72 Because varanasi is very clean compared to before 2014.
Also before 2014 electricity was a huge problem. No electricity for 2-3 days straight.
And now sometimes there's no power cut for 1-2 days, even if there is it for 5-10mins.
Also now there's street lights everywhere, underground electrical wires. Better road (still not the best)
@@anshulsingh8326we Hindus consider Varanasi to be the most sacred city, then why do we kreep it dirty, same with Ma Ganga 😢
Problem of india is that india didnt deserve democracy,we are unruly stratified indisciplined corruptive chaotic society,and we need someone oppressive and strict to rule over us ..we are bad at deciding whats good for us,thats why under mugol rule india prospered and British ruled india easily by pitting one against others. Europeans or east asians can take care of themselves we cant..
ur history is really weak right??have u even read history??please don't tell me ur source is our school history books cuz these history has factually wrong texts
India progressed during mogul rule?
India's decline started from arab invasion,
And don't worry India is going to be in even worst shape as it will become muslim majority nation and then islamic Republic like other arab countries, and then India will again have dictatorship like you mentioned in mogul rule and witness new lower lows
Are u also one of them...and ur family relatives?
People often blame a lack of funds or corruption, but the real issue is the absence of proper urban planning. India has never had a comprehensive master plan for its cities. What passes as “planning” is merely the division of farmland into clusters with no real strategy. There’s no proper building code or logical framework-just poorly thought-out, ineffective plans.
Mark my words, India can never be like Japan, China and Russia.
Yes I agree with you bro india will never change, we Indians are not taking any responsibility to take care of our city throwing waste here and there we need and simply blaming the government for not cleaning the city. Every Indian is the same. Even the educated or uneducated all are the same as like foreigners statement "filthiness is running in their blood"😢😢
Japan is better than western countries, but china and russia no, india is already better for living than russia and china. Russia and China have the same problems but the citizens can't complain because the government doesn't allow them to.
wow, indian life better than china and Russian. wow, wow wow @@cordisdie8109
😂😂😂@@cordisdie8109
@@cordisdie8109China is way way richer than India 😂😂😂😂😂. But we can beat US/UK/UAE for sure
Just a suggestion. It'd be really helpful to provide English subtitles too. As a non Indian, I find it rather exhausting to understand such thick Indian accent. No judging here, just stating my situation.
Bold of anyone to assume India has an infrastructure.
Because our Indian per capita IQ is only 82 while Chinese per capita IQ is 107😢😢😢
IQ level in my opinion makes no sence at all.
Humans are just slaves of institution.
aevy tv editing is like♥
Amazing video! Actually floored on the depth of research done along with nicely covering all important aspects. Keep it up.
Central Bangalore is messed up because it was planned almost 2 decades ago. Currently there is good planning and development of infrastructure going on towards North Bangalore, Airport road.
In fact there is a new and much bigger business park than Manyata opening next to KIA.
lol. wait for next decade . you will lot of movies coming on banglore
THAT'S THE CONTENT WE NEED ... THANKS FOR EDUCATING US
Ayyy nice pfp matches your comment also 👍
She herself lives out side india
@@arnav_negi2005not in Bangalore?
She can't even enunciate properly.
@@arnav_negi2005 we stay in bangalore guys :p
In India, we build houses first and then roads. We are not the most “proactive” bunch of people out there. We are merely “reactive”.
Fun fact: The infra projects build or under maintenance for last 10 years have been collapsing
Everything? Stop bringing politics into this dude. People like you are one of the reason most of the public infra projects never see the limelight
@@hr_47even some infra collapsing in within a span of mere 10 years is a matter of concern
You know this results in death right?
@@rohankamble9595 bridge collapse incidents were like 45 in a year in 2012 and 8-9 in 2020-21.
If I will show you the collapse of infra during 2004-2014. You will start crying. Balak buddhi
@@rohankamble9595 Check infra reports properly recent reports of delhi ariports terminal collapsywas also used to mislead people, in reality the terminal that collapsed was buil before 2012 ( u can check the date, 12, 13,14) however media has been used to propagate misinformation such as it was the newly built terminal.
Similary, if u have any idea about the commonwealth games that were supposed to be held in india under congress and the amount of projects that collapsed making ot one of the biggest scams, nothing even close to that is happening in India rn, and thats not even the biggest scam from before. In the name of opposing Modi, dont oppose India.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE 🥰🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🥰 🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🥰 🇮🇳 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN 🥰THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🥰 🇮🇳, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🥰🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳 🥰 🇮🇳
Mast joke mara re. 😅😅😅😅😂😂😂.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂
You happy, I'm more happy than you
India got independence just 75 years before , people taxes have been eaten by politicians & corruption everywhere.
China is 2 years younger than india
Well said at the end, its also about the severely lacking civic sense of indian citizens who never care about the cleanliness of public spaces. I guess lack of education and social moral values is one of the major reasons why people act like that.
Coz of indian diversity just like Myamar
More diversity in ethnics groups and languages, More difficulties to unite and more chance to disintegrate and differ and deray
Very well made, no bias or bs, right to the point!
thanks for helping us understand more about our country
In Bengaluru intitaly created areas such as basavanagudi, Malleswaram, jayanagar were are in the form of grids but later on other areas were randomly without any plan it was converted into living place
Blaming people is not gonna solve the problem. Because people lack civic sense but they are not aware of that. The government should spend money on spreading public awareness about these things. Im pretty sure it will work.
No amount of public awareness can replace quality education from a young age. Our whole system is fucked.
how are people responsible for shoddy infra and poorly planned roads?
@@counterpoint9260cause they build their houses till the road level despite it being illegal, they open up small shops anywhere on the road.
As a non-Indian who has only visited this beautiful country, this video is absolutely amazing! I can't wait to go back soon to India, it's developing at a very rapid pace, many highways are under construction, the road conditions are improving, and I'd love to try the new Vande Bharat sleeper trains. I won't even talk about the telecom infrastructure, even in villages I somehow got 5G signal.
That being said, the city planning leaves a lot to be desired - even though the densest cities are in India, the walkability isn't great, so I had to resort to Ubers or rickshaws a lot of times just to get to a store only 1 km away. I found it strange but your video explained the issues clearly, and it seems a combination of rapid development, urbanisation and legal red tape.
Just one complaint, the music is way too loud, and it was sometimes hard to hear what you were saying.
its crazy how most of us viewers know more than actual lawmakers. I bet that a random viewer will perform better than politicians.
Not quite
It's easy to comment when one is not in the position of power.
@@parvadhami980Oh the one who is in position of power literally became businessmen thesedays
Maharashtra,Karnataka,tamil nadu and west Bengal have to shift their capitals and build new green field capitals
Saying this very responsibility that India can never be like other countries offcourse we will have some of the biggest companies in the world and richest people in the world.
I dont understand why none of the videos on indian cities use hyderabad in any of their case studies or examples. There are definitely a lot of things to learn from hyderabad too.
Hyderabad is a slum outside cyberabad
@@Sathish_12 I agree some areas are, but same is the case with other big cities like Bombay and delhi
Hyderabad fell behind in the 90s and now is the same as kolkata
@@jinxed4lyf763You havent visited hyderabad. I agree, some places are dirty. But lets hope for good
Hyderabad is a US wannabe car-centric dystopia. The metro is half-baked and the pedestrian experience is horrible, even in rich neighbourhoods. The walking trail around Durgam Cheruvu is the only nice urban planning I've seen in Hyderabad, but even 6+ years from when it was started it still hadn't been finished when I last visited. Also like Mumbai, it lacks proper drainage and gets flooded during rains.
This video had the best content when compared to other similar videos from Mohak and others. Perfect !!
1. Government need to do something about population control
2. People need to be deciplind
3. People need to have basic education
4.people thinks now days education is totally useless that's why most children not educated
but proud indians dont care about these stuffs they are just proud
What a cinematic experience the video was, crazy!
Corruption. The curse of the Indian mindset. Due to centuries of foreign rule.
We just need scapegoat..
The scapegoat is Politicans and Corruption.
but We the People are equally part of it. but no ones likes to be blamed, so we collectively never blame ourselves as well.
I remember my economic teacher saying. China also has corruption there building also crumble but a dictatorship is good in something and is punishing. And i was like why that make so much sense here the one's who are supposed to take action against the corruption are the one's who are involved in it . Yeah with our lifestyle and different style we could just create our own designs just making our own living a sight to see. But all that will happens when our mindsets changes at all levels and there are many more steps to take but this is the very first step we should try to achieve.
India is just acting as a growing superpower
The brutal consequences India faces for being the no.1 most populated country
Not necessarily. It’s a misconception that larger population is the problem. Human Resource is always a blessing provided it is properly utilised. Because cities in our country are managed like this, we have this pre conceived notion.
@@gshen231 it ain't being utilised and teenagers are becoming chapris
@@auritrocalebbaroi91 I agree with you on the issues plaguing But just wanted to say that big population itself is not problem
India could've used a One Child Policy. Population is good but a burden if they're not fed, educated, civilized
@@gshen231 who say
Chandigarh is also a good example of how Indian cities could be planned. It has markets in every sector, grid pattern roads, no residential house has more than 3 floors. Everyone follows traffic rules because there are speed cams and other cameras installed which captures you and challan is issued instantly if you jump zebra crossings, if you over speed or jump lights. Separate cycle tracks are there and proper infrastructure for hiring e bikes. Good public and private infrastructure. Now they have an IT park as well in both Chandigarh and Mohali so it has got everything
Chandigarh ranks top 10 polluted among major cities.
Well mind you. Chandigarh city is planned by the British.