Ruger SFAR or SIG 716i??
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 сен 2024
- My thoughts on the Ruger SFAR and the SIG 716i. A quick look at pros and cons and which one I would recommend.
Instagram:
/ thebeardedwretch
AMAZON PRODUCT LINKS:
amzn.to/3NgB0nD
amzn.to/3NaXbLD
Been running the 716i for a couple deer seasons and am happy with it. I hated the factory trigger and charging handle. Swapped in the 308 triggertech and phase 5 and made a world of difference. The fact that only sig went through military testing speaks volumes. The world of "Ar10" is littered with failed models banking on owners that don't shoot often.
Have to say watching this i was also thinking there's no way that a 4moa group at 110 was acceptable. If it's the gun i wouldn't rest till i found the cause.
Would absolutley strap it to a lead-sled
Scope and mount?
Trigger?
Barrel nut?
Crown?
Gas block touching?
Something is not right.
How does it do without a 20 in barrel?
@@crazykev5 much more handy (especially with a vertical grip) in the field compared to rifles with longer barrels but the sig 716i is heavier. However, once in position (i.e. deer stand) the weight is less of a factor.
@rossdonaghy1748 the 716i's trigger out of the box is about an 8lb pull. Its heavy AF! He swapped the Ruger trigger with a Geisselle and left the SIG trigger stock. That says it all.
@michaelpereira808 EXACTLY! The SIG is heavier for sure but it has gone through more extensive testing that all but probably 3 other AR10 style rifles and those cost more than double or triple the 716I. Its a 1 MOA tool with a trigger swap, proper glass, and the right operator.
Love my SFAR! 500+rds through it so far and sub-moa@100yds! Definitely my favorite out of my bunch!
What ammo have you found that your SFAR likes?
@@keithwray9942 off the shelf Fed Power Shok 150gr works great on mine.. all I've shot so far only.
@@ozarkphoenix6615 Thanks! Haven’t tried that one yet, but I’ve heard several folks who’ve had good luck with it. Mine likes Norma 150 grain soft point.
@Keith Wray I have some Norma 150's also! But, i haven't shot them yet. I know they will give good results for sure! I've heard from way too many and the quality of Norma's are super smooth! Goodluck!
Sub MOA, really? I can't get better than 2 MOA no matter what ammo I shoot. It doesn't cycle 7.62 reliably on setting 3. It will shoot .308 on 3, but is unreliable on 2. Forget about 1. Yes I did break it in as recommended on 3. It will shoot 2 MOA with 150 gr Federal American Eagle and 168 and 175 gr Federal Sierra Match King. Everything else I've tried is 3 to 4 MOA. Yes I do know how to shoot.
Right on dude its good to hear prospective of people that actually use the 2 in comparison.
Really glad to see a follow up with the Ruger SFAR, watched your earlier videos on it and have one myself, really cool to see it getting more popular as I think it's very underrated for the price
Months ago, I commented on your SFAR videos. This past Wednesday I finally got one!
Congratulations!! Enjoy it.
I’m the same way I have the Sig and the Ruger SFAR by far
the ruger is the best rifle of the two and I would say best A.R. 10 I’ve ever shot
If you put a Geisselle trigger in the Ruger but not in the SIG then that would explain the group size difference...
Interesting info. Still think the Sig is more reliable over all but the price and features of the Ruger can't be beat.
Awesome video series. Thank you for the effort.
I agree with you with longevity being a concern and the only unknown with the sfar. If it runs long term ruger has a winner for sure.
I’ve got a heavier rifle already for sapr/sass duty. I’d use the sfar for plinking and hunting. I’m gonna go for it in part because of these videos.
I appreciate that! I’m glad you like the videos and I will definitely keep updating the rifle.
The 716i did you upgrade the trigger? If not wondering if the accuracy has anything to do with its crappy factory trigger.
It’s the factory trigger. And I agree. I do believe it hurts the accuracy.
@@TheBeardedWretch I am curious to see if it would perform better for you with a better trigger before you sell it.
Thank you so much for all your effort regarding the Ruger sfar!
I have the Sig 716 piston rifle I bought years ago. It's been flawless. I changed the charging handle and put a Timney trigger in it. My only complaint is its HEAVY. 12 lb out of the box. I just ordered the Ruger SFAR. Hopefully I won't have the issues many have had.
I love my Ruger mine is 20” barrel works great
I just bought the SFAR in 20" before seeing any review videos that explained much, and i feel like i made a good decision.
Thanks for ur review. I just want yo clear up some facts. As for the sig you can change out a lot more parts. I’ve changed trigger, muzzle device, safety levers, mag button, charging handle ,grip, stock. All ar15 parts. I’ve been running the 716i for a while and haven’t had any issues or inconsistent groupings. But even so thank you for the review.
I was really interested in the SFAR, but there wasn't a whole lot out there on them. Your videos put me over the top, so thank you for the review. Waiting on the optic, but I like what the SFAR looks like so far. Threw on a SD-E trigger like yours, BCM M-Lok Handguard, Seekins ambi safety, Radian Raptor, BKings Mag Release button and a BAD enhanced bolt catch. One note, all the parts are AR-15 compatible EXCEPT the bolt catch is AR10.
Noticed that the muzzle device was on there with a grip of death but the barrel nut was not tight at all, so I'm glad I replaced the handguard as a QC check. The castle nut was also loose when I torqued it checking and the one thing I was disappointed with was finding the butt plate is polymer (found this out when I tried to stake the nut). Anyways, thanks bro. Not for nothin, but your videos helped me pull the trigger on getting this before they jump in price to $1500-1600, so thanks.
I’m glad I could help. Comments like yours are why I do this! Thanks!!!
I, too, found that the SFAR endplate was polymer when I went to stake mine.
The Sig strongly prefers 175gr ammo. I was frustrated with mine until I tried both ammo weights back to back. What a difference! Both match loads from Sig. I've since found similar results with other factory loads using 175 Sierra Match Kings (same bullet Sig match load uses). I know both spec 1:10 twist rate. I don't have the Ruger yet, but I suspect based on all the lightweight parts the Ruger might need wear parts replaced more often. The Sig is used by the Indian military, so the toughness should be there.
Same for me 175s are the way to go
Yeah I’ve found the m118 for cheap online and that’s what I shoot exclusively from the sig. Pretty consistent 1.5 inch groups or better and at 300 hitting a 6 inch plate is pretty easy just using a simply hold for me.
For what it’s worth, I’ve had a few different AR-10s I just can’t get to group with the m80 ball stuff. It’s atrocious.
Yes I have the tread snake bite se. They are very ammo specific and when you find what it likes they are lights out. I have a buddy who hands loads and I would take my sig over the ruger everyday of the week
Good video. I have a 716i that consistently makes 2 - 3 inch shot patterns at 50 yards. Not happy with my purchase. Never thought I'd regret buying a Sig.
Did u swap the trigger
How are you that bad of a shooter? I shot sub 2 MOA with a M1A scout squad off my tailgate with iron sights…. @100 yards. You better tighten up on the gun, clamp that handguard, drive that shoulder forward, and crush the pistol
Grip, your groups wont suck as bad. People dont know how to shoot higher caliber semi autos for some reason. To everyone, everytime you shoot any gun, youre goal is to replicate a gun a vise, comfort is not the name of the game. Learned that on the M110.
@channeellll7623 I guess you didn't understand what I was saying. The gun is not good. I sold it and replaced it with a s&w that I get shot groups of .8 @100 yards with Winchester white box.
@ZS1736 I swapped the gun out for a S&W. That fixed the problem! LOL!
If you put a new trigger on the Sig all those accuracy issues will go away.
Nice, I am loving my SFAR. Don't get to shoot its as much cause of my job. But right now I have about 400 rounds through it. I went with a Blackout Defense AR15 3.0LB Zero trigger. STNGR 15" Handrail, Penguin Grip, H2 Buffer ,VG6 Gamma 762 Muzzle Brake, Bushnell Scope, and aftermarket stock(can't remember the name). One thing about the handguard, even though it might say it's for an AR15, it might not work on the SFAR. STNGR handguard will require you to change the gas block. The stock SFAR gas block is to wide at the top.
Nice build! I have a standard AR15 Midwest industries combat rail on mine with zero modifications to the rail or gun. Fits perfect.
What hand guard do you have on your SFAR? Did you mill out a notch for the ejector cover hinge pin?
My sig hates the Amax round but loves the sst rounds. Sig, in my experience, is much more picky as far as ammo is concerned if you want moa or sub moa groups with ga tory ammo. Good stuff, brother.
What bullets work best with your Ruger SFAR? This question is for everyone that has the Ruger sfar.
I am using Hornady 168GR ELD match. Haven't any problems with it.
Either the Hornady 168gr A-Max or the Nosler 168gr HPBT. Check out my ammo test video for more details.
Mine shoots anything after I polish the feed ramps! It shoots 150 grain steel ammo 168 grain 178, 125 , no issues! Did have issues before I polish the feed ramps!! My loads except for the steel ammo!!
Been considering between both and thank you for this.
Wow I get moa groups all day with mine but I installed a geissele ssa-e trigger. Mine seems to favor 168 gr bullets.
I sold my 716i before the Ruger came out. I just couldn’t run it like an AR15. Most people assume that means recoil but it’s like you said. The actual manipulation of the gun is where it starts adding up. My SFAR just came in and I laughed like a mad man at how light it was when I first picked it up.
My sig with gmm is a 1/2 moa rifle and there's too many other owners with the same report to blame the accuracy on the rifle
Awesome video! Got my Ruger in and it’s ready for the range. Hopefully this weekend. Took it apart and checked the common issues. Looks good.
I wanted the SFAR for my next hunt, but living in Washington I am not allowed by state law.
Magazine + “assault weapon” bans
I’m sorry for your loss brother. I hate that you have you live in a shit state.
Dictator Inslee and the rest of the democrats are treasonous.
They are complete hypocrites.
So I say do whatever you wish, especially since any “laws” they pass are unconstitutional period.
feel your pain brother . reason I am leaving the crap state of California myself. sick and tired of being infringed upon . and the SFAR is on my list.
@angermgt1 I'm also in California too, but you can buy SFAR in California with a complaint for about $1000.
Glade I came across your channel! You do an excellent job going into detail.
I've be very tempted to pick up a SFAR. I know some have had ejection issues. Did you experience that?
I’ve found to get the best groups and the most consistency on my 716i with 149 M80 7.62x51 nato. Matter of fact, I bought mine with the sierra 4x14 scope. I’m only 1 click off zero elevation with the 7.62x51. Everything else the scope has to be cranked. Coincidence?🤔
own the 716i and love it.
The Ruger bolt is certainly the area of concern for durability, but I like to think the numerous extra vents they designed into the front of the receiver and not using more gas than you need would mitigate that to a large degree. They talk about using some proprietary fancy alloy in the bolt's construction to address strength too but who's to say that's not marketing fluff.
Marketing fluff? From Ruger? On the rare occasions I have dealt with Ruger customer service they have been nothing but straight up honest and very generous. It is my belief that Ruger has the best customer service in the industry. Does that mean there is a lifetime guarantee? Of course not. But they stand behind what they build.
The SFAR bolt looks like no other bolt. The color, feel and all do not look like a standard bolt. I’d say it is for sure different, will it last? Who knows… no one on the boob tube has posted bolt failure yet… that I know of
How is the interchangability of the bolt carrier on the ruger? I don't have any experience with the AR 10's and the difference between the parts vs Ar 15's.
The bolt is proprietary. Which sucks and they don’t sell replacements at this time. AR-10s are confusing.
@@TheBeardedWretch That sucks, I have a couple of ruger MPR's that rock. I was looking to get a SFAR but I'm not sure about the bolt.
@@ungratefulpeasant8085 the MPRs do rock 🤘
Love the accuracy of my SFAR...BUT....My rifle would not cycle properly. Jammed up every few rounds once warm. Sent it back to Ruger, they returned it in ten days. I took it out and after about 60 rounds...it literally started smoking, bolt jammed shut, total failure!! Super disappointed...sent it back to Ruger AGAIN...we will see what happens.
Any news yet?
716i for sure, i love mine. I live in New Hampshire and have access to both companies and love both companies, but right now I'm saving up for the sig spear in 308
Same here. I have the 716I and am saving and raving for that good Spear in .308
@@kurtispaige732 hell ya, the spear is Awesome, have the spear lt in 5.56 I love but I'm drawn more to the 308 platform.
Hornady black, or ELDM?
How did you get the pic rail on top for your tape switch?
I have a Midwest rail installed not the factory one.
@@TheBeardedWretch oh that’s right, thank ya!
I got the 20 inch Ruger SFAR
I don’t understand why anyone would sacrifice the velocity in the .308 by running a 16” barrel. I like that at least the SFAR has an 20” option, Sig doesn’t for the 716i. Since this is about the only raving review in favor of the SFAR that I’ve seen (too many others have shown issues pertaining to the gas system w/ either over gassing on 3 or failures to feed on 2) I’m wondering how reliable it will be long-term.
You don't sacrifice that much when going from 20" to 16" barrel. You lose, what? 300 ft lbs of energy? On non-bullpup rifles though, the savings in weight and ease of movement can outweigh the loss of velocity.
I was having issues also with my SFAR polish the feed ramps!!!! No issues now! Use jewelers rouge and a dremel!
@@gregstone8891Did you have to remive the barrel?
Because freedom that’s why 🤷♂️ it’s their rifle they can do as they please 🤷♂️
Hi, amazing review! Question for you. How were you able to get the Rugar with the full picatinny railing?
Thanks! It’s a Midwest Industries Combat rail.
great video hey whats your 2cents on scopes for this rifle i wana shoot 100yard to 1000yard any recommendations
A 6-24 would be good. I got a Vortex Diamondback 6x24 on one of my bolt guns and it works well at range.
Great vid. Glad to see you picked the Ruger! I've just over a 100 rounds through mine with ZERO issues. I already really really like this gun....if it stands the test of time?? I'm gonna LOVE it!!! Actually I love it now & it looks damn good IMO?? I have a crappy vid up on YT if you wanna check it out?? Thanx again for the video & honest your opinion review!!! 👍
Thanks! its a great gun! Ill check it out!
Tbh I only shot 5 shots and the the third shot jammed on my ruger sfar but I think I wasn’t holding it tight enough I need to shoot it more to find out but I still love it.
I own the SFAR now im here because im thinking of picking up the sig
You and me both. I’m considering keeping mine now. I’ve only had issues with cheap saltech ammo. Runs great otherwise.
What about the multiple reports of the SFAR not cycling.
Iv had no issues with my rifle cycling with any ammo Iv tested. Both suppressed and un suppressed. I am doing more testing suppressed so that could change but so far no issues. Iv read and seen videos about people having issues but I haven’t had any.
My 716I has been very reliable. But I like to tinker so I built a couple AR308 DPMS builds. I like them better because I can buy lots of parts and different caliber uppers. Can't lie I may sell the 716I as well. Good gun just can't tinker with it like I want.
Would the SFAR do well enough in a heavy duty military environment to be selectable by the army ? Would people trust their lives on it ?
You didn’t watch the video obviously
Absolutely not.
I just purchased the 716i and now just waiting on the vcog
Just found your channel. Enjoyed the video. 🙏😀💕
I wish more gun tubers did this . Instead of just shooting but put the weapon through actual life moving events so they can feel the pain instead of just verbally explaining it from thier opion from thier mind how ut should be. Lmao. Kinda wordy but hopefully understood.
Bittom line great veido, love ut done in this manner 🍻💯💪👍
Thank you! I will definitely try and do more videos in this format. I enjoy it!
The stock SIG trigger is not my favorite. Try an upgrade.
Thanks for the vid. I have a M1a scout but I like to hear about the .308 AR platforms.
If you put a new trigger on that Sig all your accuracy issues would disappear.
Exactly what I experienced, went from 3 to 4 inches at 100 yards to less than 1.5. Mine is picky on ammo choice, Hornady Superformance Match 168g works best.
I like RUGEF and own several of their firearms BUT I'll take the SIG 716 with its short piston over the RUGER direct impingement. DI, especially in a larger cartridge like the .308/7.62 x 51 will get the bolt HOT after one 20 round magazine. DI is DUMB1
Love my SFAR after break in 200 rounds no problems at all!!
I think the group is not depend on the gun, it's depend on your constitution of the day.
Sig is a 308 so 300 is a min range should be hitting at 400-450 normal and 500 plus very doable everyone has had their expectations lowered with 556 almost of course unless you’re a marine
Thinking about getting the SFAR. How would u rate this rifle on a scale from 1 to 5? I've heard it's had issues and alot of the parts suck. Clue me in fellas
I also have both the ruger and the Sig.. if I could only buy 1 … that’s hard because they are 2 totally different guns IMO. But I would go with the Ruger .. I payed like 1500 for the Sig and 1000 for the ruger. You can take that 500 extra bucks and spend on a optic and sling and maybe a few boxes of ammo. The trigger on the sig need to be replaced. I really like the 716i but I would say I love my SFAR
I also agree that the Sig feels like it would live with a high round count … the SFAR I don’t believe can take a really high round count
100%
In my opinion, my ruger trigger is too good ( very light 2lbs)
Wondering why the POF Revolution wasn't mentioned in this.
Why would it be? Its a video about the Ruger vs the Sig.
Simple, the Ruger is almost a direct copy of the POF design. The Sig isn't. @@5jjt
whats crazy is with all the new tech we have an all the modern bullets a friggin brown bess flint lock still beats the modern gun even the 20 inch 308s ... pitiful
Neither. Sig is too heavy SFAR is poorly designed and built. Stick with POF or SCAR17. Lightweight, low recoil expensive. I don't want a cheap rifle to protect my life.
How reliable has the Ruger been
Besides the Freedom ammo messing it up it’s been 100% reliable.
@@TheBeardedWretch I am looking for my 1st rifle not in 556, and I have been looking at 308 or 300 blackout. And I don’t have a lot of money
@@mma709 i would recommend 308 over 300blk unless you have a suppressor. 308 is generally easier to find ammo wise but both are not cheap to shoot.
Shop around, I found mine for a grand whereas every other place I looked it was just over 1100 or more.
@@dodgeboy90501 so far in my area everyone is sold out
SIG 716i
Sig is a sob for making badass guns but then making it a coin toss whether you get a good one
You goy to find each rifles favorite ammo if your chasing accuracy...you have to pay for accuracy
Sorry I don’t trust the Ruger SFAR. No AR-10 style rifle has holes drilled into the upper receiver we’re the bolt locks to the barrel, like the Ruger has. Were upwards of 50k psi is going off in front of your face. I will take the SIG.
SFAR is one of the worst AR10s on the market... this review was basically just "choose the cheapest option"
If i wanted a light rifle id shoot my 556 in a ar plateform idk if its my American speaking but sometimes i just want a big rifle in a big caliber and for hunting you use a bolt thats the thing no gun does everything
I wanted the Sfar bad. Loved it. Couldn’t wait to get one. Then I read all the reviews. Then I went to the store and compared them side by side. There is no comparison. The Sig all the way. Quality. Build. Reliability. It was worth the few extra y
The Ruger hands down is better
Lol
Windham arms works with pof save your money an just buy a bush master
Thank you mr. Wretch, this was definitely an eye-opener for me.
Here in my country (Denmark) we are only allowed to own one semi automatic, centerfire rifle, and it has to be chambered in a cartridge that is legal for what is classified as "class 1 game" (meaning red and fallow deer, and wild boar) - energy at 100 meters must be at least 2000 joules (so basically .243 Winchester is the cutoff). This means I cannot own a semi automatic 5.56 or 7.62x39 rifle, but I can own one in .308/7.62x51.
My local store has the SIG 716i TREAD and the S&W M&P10 in stock, and they will be getting the Ruger SFAR home in both 16" and 20".
As the Rugers are by far the cheapest, I was looking for videos informing me exactly how much worse they are - but I am pleasantly surprised to see your video. My conclusion being that I can probably get a fine rifle for a lower price.
I can see that you have the 16". In your opinion, would the 16" be the better rifle, if we consider the fact that I can only own one semi automatic rifle? I will be mounting a A-TEC Optima Flow, and that will of course add to the overall length. It will probably end up wearing a Schmidt & Bender 1-8x24 Exos.
Thank you in advance.
So what you're telling us is you can't deal with a seven and a half pound trigger.
A lot of people hate heavy triggers, I can't stand anything over 5lbs
audio is terrible low
One is Ruger. One is Sig. That decides it right there for me.
There is so much negative write up about Ruger SFAR problems I would not touch one with a 10 foot pole. Ruger as lost its reputation with this gun.
tried watching but sound quality, nope
That’s to bad 😢