Ex-Mormon Reveals SURPRISING Reason Mormons Always Smile

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 ноя 2022
  • Dan Beecher is an ex-Mormon who tells me the real reason Mormons act happy, and discusses 'bedroom' hangups from his childhood, and how he left the Mormon Church. From Joseph Smith and the Latter Day Saints Church to South Park Mormonism and the Book of Mormon, we cover all the bases. Not to mention the polygamy and polyamory! He's a great example of how to leave cults or leaving Mormonism.
    Links:
    Dan's podcast Thank God I'm Atheist: www.thankgodimatheist.com/
    His other pod, The How-To Heretic: howtoheretic.com/
    #mormonstories #mormons #cultsandextremebeliefs

Комментарии • 811

  • @AndrewGold1
    @AndrewGold1  Год назад +57

    Do you know much about Mormons? Enjoy this episode? Let me know below!

    • @CourageGraceandKickintheAss
      @CourageGraceandKickintheAss Год назад +7

      Just starting it but I do know Alot about the LDS.
      This should be interesting 🤔
      Done know and an interesting interview. His depiction is fair, especially the statement that if you're going to criticize them you need to get it right and know what you're actually knocking on.

    • @missyihunt
      @missyihunt Год назад +1

      Do you have merchandise these day? If so where is the link?

    • @AshtynJadeProduction
      @AshtynJadeProduction Год назад +13

      I’m less than 5 minutes in, and already so saddened by his perspective. This very well may be how he feels… but he’s inaccurate in so much of what he’s sharing. His take on “marked with darkness” being black people is asinine. So false. Ridiculously so. I’d love to see someone with actual knowledge rather than someone sharing his skewed opinions. My heart is sad for him that this is how he’s interpreted his experience.

    • @clairedelune6858
      @clairedelune6858 Год назад +8

      Ah, Utah. Home of the zombie mom. I lived there for 17 years and I know exactly what he's talking about. I saw it every day. I can count on one hand the number of Mormons I knew who were not on anti-depressants. Even the children are medicated. The county he talked about is called "Happy Valley" by Utahns. It's supposed to be the place in Utah where the Mormons are exemplary. Ironic that they have to be so highly medicated.
      I know that smile, too. I called it "the desperate smile". It's a forced smile that can be a little manic. I knew so many people who thought it was their fault that they weren't happy. They're taught that if they're living correctly, then they'll be happy.
      They're also desperate to be seen as happy. Appearances are very important to Mormons. They say that theirs is the only true religion, and they know that they need to be seen as perfect to keep up the image of having the true religion. That's also why they're so slow to change-change implies that they were wrong before, and they can't admit that. They get around it by announcing a "revelation", which is a message from God given to someone in the Quorum of the Twelve.
      The longer I lived in Utah, the less impressed I was with Mormonism. There is a dark side, and a certain amount of unethical behavior, and also polygamy. They're fine with it until you get caught and become news.
      I didn't like living there and moved back to my home state as soon as I could. So glad to be back in the free world.

    • @pevitzachast6892
      @pevitzachast6892 Год назад +10

      I am Mormon and it was interesting and cringe to listen to this. I hope he’s happy out of the church. I’m still smiling in the church. 😉

  • @kimmychan1967
    @kimmychan1967 Год назад +81

    I was a member for 52 years and realized only 2 yrs ago that the church all started with a huge lie. In seconds it’s foundation and my whole life as i knew it crumbled. I can understand why those who are still in are commenting here the way they are and those who are close friends with some are standing up for them. Most are truly the most generous people with hearts of gold. I live outside of Utah and that culture is very ingrained in being the perfect “Stepford wife” family. I lived in Provo for several years & it was complete culture shock. Outside of Utah there is not quite as much of the judgmental mentality. There is not as much pressure to live up to a certain standard and there is more diversity in the community. I definitely relate to most of what this guy’s experience is with the church.

    • @paulamacdonald7070
      @paulamacdonald7070 Год назад +2

      🤗

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      Thanks for your absence. We would have thrown you out eventually.

    • @kimmychan1967
      @kimmychan1967 Год назад +1

      @@johnlee1352 🤣 You must be from Utah, proving my point quite well. Thank you!

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      @@kimmychan1967 I'm from Arizona, dullard. I stand to judge your weakness and confusion...even though I'm not from Utah! Thanks again for ridding us of your presence. Your point is silly and can't be "proven". 2 years ago, you announced that you were leaving the church. 2 years later, here you are...pathetically bashing a faith you claim to have rejected years ago. Move on already! wow

    • @kimmychan1967
      @kimmychan1967 Год назад +1

      @@johnlee1352 you are more than welcome. ✌🏼😘

  • @vknglion
    @vknglion Год назад +65

    I took a coarse back in college in 1999 called phsycolgy of cults. The professor was great. We touched upon many different cults and scientology was one that was brought up even back then. I've been interested ever since in cults and mindsets. The last few years, BC of the internet and all the information available about Scientology, I've watched everything and anything about it. Mr. Rinder and Mrs. Remini with the show was fantastic in bringing to light what Scientology is al about. Thank you for all the research and info you and everyone puts out. Sorry for any typos, fat fingers, small screen.

    • @geekdivaherself
      @geekdivaherself Год назад +3

      I suggest Aaron Smith-Levin's Growing Up in Scientology channel for balanced discussions and analysis. He just passed 100k! You may have seen Aaron on joint interviews that take place half on Aaron's channel on half on this one.
      It was on his channel that I found the phrase, "The Aftermath Foundation can help you if you blow," which is more helpful than yelling "Xenu!" at people. Offering something helpful is better than confronting them with things that their training makes them shut down on contact with.
      Especially if people in the Sea Org leave or, in Scientology jargon, blow, they'll just owe even more money to Scientology, and will have difficulties finding a place to live, etc. The Aftermath Foundation can help them with that and a million other small difficulties that they'd run across outside of CoS, which can add up pressure quickly, especially if their family is still in Scientology and considers them suppressive people.
      Aaron's heart-rending story can be seen on Netflix (in the US at least) in the first season either episode three or seven. Their neighbor, who was a fellow Scientologist at that time, was more concerned about how their disconnection (shunning) was going to affect his dog rather than his small children! Sigh.

    • @GoldenMom815
      @GoldenMom815 Год назад +2

      That would be such an interesting class!

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад +1

      What "coarse" was that?

    • @ediereno4630
      @ediereno4630 Год назад

      @@johnlee1352 A rough one no doubt.

  • @nanasloves
    @nanasloves Год назад +28

    Wow…. I’m an ex-Morgan too. I was raised in a strong loving Mormon family and I raised my children the same way. I left when I was in my 50’s. Dan has a lot correct, BUT he must not gone to the same Wards/church I went to. So much of the weird things he talked about I’ve never heard of. I have a very dear friend who grew up in an LDS family that had interpreted thing in a weird way too. EVERY organization/religion has a mix of people with different interpretations of thing.
    There is a belief that within the religion that they are happier than everybody everybody else, but I never ever felt it was a judgement if you weren’t happy, but I did feel self judgement. Too bad Dane felt that judgement. There are so so many beautiful things I love about the LDS church, and in many ways I miss it. When I join my husband at a meeting, I still feel the love and care from the Ward/congregation. If anyone in our neighborhood/Ward area is in need, regardless of religious status, members jump in to help. It’s beautiful.
    Mormons are just people, most are trying to live a good life and be kind.

    • @lorimavity4160
      @lorimavity4160 Год назад +5

      Thank you! Life-long member. I smile at people so that they know I care about them. Nothing else. Nothing weird. Just cuz I want them to known that someone sees them. I have had many people thank me for being the only person to smile at them all day. If it does make me weird then let the weirdness reign. Do some research people. Smiling is good for you.

    • @nanasloves
      @nanasloves Год назад +3

      @@lorimavity4160 Agree! I do too! Mask were awful because I felt like I couldn’t connect with a smile. I’m happily In the weird club with you.

    • @nanasloves
      @nanasloves Год назад +1

      @@lorimavity4160 Well said! 😁

    • @rychei5393
      @rychei5393 Год назад +1

      Been to California, served a mission in the Baltics, now I'm in Utah and Dan has it nailed 100%. Your circles must not have judged you like this, or it went way over your head. Remember, it's passive aggressive, so it doesn't always hit paydirt on those it's directed at.
      People love bomb ne too, when I go, but I always suspect that ulterior motive of evangelism, unless proven otherwise. Most times that is exactly what it is, lately I have been praised by middle aisle Mormons for showing up as a loud and proud atheist former Mormon as being very brave. Made me blush. twas sweet.
      Mormons are were the cotton pickin flower of England, according to Dickens (myth)... always felt that was because they were the most innocent and naïve. So not just people: preyed upon souls.

    • @nanasloves
      @nanasloves Год назад +2

      @@rychei5393 I didn’t and don’t pay attention to the judgmental people. You’re going to find people like that everywhere. I see a lot of people who are sincerely kind, and you can find people like that everywhere too. What are you looking for?
      I’ve just dont believe some of the doctrine but one thing I do believe in is to love your neighbors so I’m going to look for the good in people and sincerely smile and care.
      BTW, there are a couple of people who still love bomb me and I think it’s funny because it’s so transparent.

  • @AmberBocks3000
    @AmberBocks3000 Год назад +92

    I had read on the LDS religion both in and out of college and briefly lived in Idaho with the Mormon Temple visible from my front yard. When I saw Book of Mormon in Texas (which is not known for a high Mormon population), I was laughing at jokes that were flying over the heads of most of the audience. One of my favorite memories about the show was the guy in front of me practically falling out of his chair laughing. I knew right away he had to have been a Mormon (most likely an ExMo) because he laughed at stuff even I didn’t get. He thoroughly enjoyed the show. I thoroughly enjoyed him enjoying the show.

  • @ellenflanery3363
    @ellenflanery3363 Год назад +25

    My Episcopal (Anglican) parish in southern Idaho built a new church building. Our priest knew a LDS Bishop through a clergy interfaith group. When it came time for our move, the LDS moved everything (pews, altar, all the trappings.) LDS women set up the kitchen and provided a potluck luncheon for everyone. After, we had a hymn sing in the sanctuary. An all around wonderful experience!

  • @tay-dor7147
    @tay-dor7147 Год назад +52

    I have family that are Mormon. I've always said that Mormon's do a better job of outwardly showing the Christian faith than other non-Mormon Christians. But I still think they're misguided.

    • @lloyannehurd
      @lloyannehurd Год назад +2

      They think that good deeds get them to heaven.

    • @nanasloves
      @nanasloves Год назад +10

      From my perspective, doing good deeds makes a bit of heaven here.

    • @lloyannehurd
      @lloyannehurd Год назад +2

      @gentlecoloncare
      But it doesn’t alone get you in to heaven there.

    • @cosmicmuffin322
      @cosmicmuffin322 Год назад +4

      But they're not just doing good deeds for the sake of doing them. They're doing it because they're told to, to look good to non-believers, etc. As an ex-fundamentalist I can say that the ulterior motives corrupt every single good deed you do.

    • @tay-dor7147
      @tay-dor7147 Год назад +4

      @@cosmicmuffin322 Knowing my cousins who are Mormon, I feel its safe to say that they don't all because they are told or to look good for others. Many genuinely care.

  • @pattymc4726
    @pattymc4726 Год назад +9

    I’m Canadian and can set something straight. We are not all nice. Some are nice and some are not. Many of us just like to feel smug about being so darned nice.

    • @erciliaflores
      @erciliaflores Год назад +1

      I'm raised Canadian- and I loved that jab you made Andrew, great timing! Ironically, those nice Canadians are also known for their passive-aggressiveness. LOL

  • @JoJoGranum
    @JoJoGranum Год назад +37

    Gee Andrew thanks a lot! I’m Canadian 😂 and I don’t smile much at all except now when you mentioned Canadians, I laughed my head off. The Mormons I’ve met weren’t so much smiley but more serious and polite. I’ve explained I’m not Christian and don’t intend to be. That usually ends it.

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +5

      Haha glad I made you smile then !

    • @JoJoGranum
      @JoJoGranum Год назад +3

      @@AndrewGold1 it did make my day lol

    • @athenaf8278
      @athenaf8278 Год назад +10

      They aren’t even considered Christian by other Christians fyi 😂

    • @ginamiller6754
      @ginamiller6754 Год назад

      @@athenaf8278 true!!

    • @jillruben8924
      @jillruben8924 Год назад

      Haha whenever they showed at my door I said I Jewish. Usually worked well. I'm not Jewish nor Christian.

  • @myBquest
    @myBquest Год назад +47

    I live in Mexico, and happen to have a lot of family in the USA that have been living there for decades now, and became Mormons in the way.
    Everytime they come here, they always end up talking about God and questioning our beliefs.
    But they totally lost me when I found out that right after my grandma's death (who was a highly devoted Catholic), they baptized her under their "religion" without the permission of her other six children.
    I don't really have a connection to my cousins, they have all usually judged my sister and me for not getting married and having a job instead of a family. Yes, my uncle has said some interesting things to my dad about it. Thank God my dad is a nice man, I would've never talked to him again. And thank God for the dad that I have.
    I feel very uncomfortable everytime they come around. It's like they are always full of joy, but also implicitly aggressive when it comes to talk about religion and other stuff.
    I don't even know how to explain that feeling.

    • @coletteduff2762
      @coletteduff2762 Год назад +6

      I was horrified to learn that the LDS ‘church’ was baptising holocaust victims.

    • @myBquest
      @myBquest Год назад +5

      @@coletteduff2762 yeah, they are still baptizing dead people nowadays. It is practically impossible to even find out when someone has been baptized after they die.

    • @realcanadiangirl64
      @realcanadiangirl64 Год назад +18

      @@myBquest My daughter joined the LDS after a couple of missionaries came to her door. I was already familiar with many of their practices as my SIL and her family belong to the church. One day my daughter asked me for the location of my grandparents graves as she was going to have a ceremony to "baptize" them. I refused to tell her telling her that they had all been baptized one hundred years before she was born and didn't need the help from Mormons. She told me that she was going to have me baptized after I died as well so I told her that I'd come back and haunt her if she did that 😂😂😂

    • @nanasloves
      @nanasloves Год назад

      @@coletteduff2762 Baptizing holocaust victims was stopped by the church. I googled it and the AP news article said, “After discussions with Mokotoff and other Jewish leaders, the LDS church in 1995 established a rule barring baptisms of Holocaust victims except in rare cases where they are direct ancestors. It also bars proxy baptisms on celebrities.” There is a firewall to prevent names of celebrities and holocaust victims being baptized now.

    • @myBquest
      @myBquest Год назад +1

      @@realcanadiangirl64 You just tell her that it doesn't matter as you are already baptized (in case that you are) and that God would've already received you as you are. Or just ignore her when she speaks about her church. Some of them just give up after a while.

  • @welshlady
    @welshlady Год назад +2

    Really enjoyed this interview...thanks both!

  • @user-yw1qb9rt4w
    @user-yw1qb9rt4w Год назад +18

    I am actually Mormon and found this to be one of the best interviews out there.
    Depends on where you were raised in the country what kind of Mormon you are and if you know you know, but I found him to be the most universal in the Mormon thought process. Well done.

  • @mattkaustickomments
    @mattkaustickomments Год назад +12

    Cognitive dissidence. A real deal breaker is The Book of Abraham. I don’t know how there is any way around that one. The story: some Mormon dupes bought an Egyptian scroll as a gift to Joe Smith. Since it was in hieroglyphics, and nobody knew or could ever know how to decipher it, Joe interpreted the scroll as “The Book of Abraham”. There were holes in one of the pictures in the ancient papyrus. So Joe also filled in the missing parts of the drawing which had figures cut off at the neck. As a foreword to the book Bro Joe says something like “This translation was dictated to ME, by God and is infallible. There’s no way it’s wrong so y’all better believe it!” Problem was: Dumbass did not know that Champollion had deciphered hieroglyphics 10 years earlier! Joe just didn’t know it. The papyrus wound up being a boiler plate page from “Book of the Dead”. Copied hundreds or thousands of times with minimal to ZERO debate in the actual meaning. The heads he drew on the figures and labels were ridiculous. And he named the canopic jars in the picture as gods. SO, if Joe is infallible yet it is provable he is 100% wrong… GAME OVER.

    • @ASMRyouVEGANyet
      @ASMRyouVEGANyet Год назад +2

      Do you mean cognitive dissonance?

    • @mattkaustickomments
      @mattkaustickomments Год назад +2

      @@ASMRyouVEGANyet Hahaha, Yes! But I’ll keep it because these people’s minds are dissident against reality.

    • @jacquelineleitch7050
      @jacquelineleitch7050 Год назад +1

      Joseph Smith’s funny book could be read with Aesop’s Fables and Just So stories. Take acid read the book out loud and laugh your ass off with some good friends. A night that I won’t forget.

    • @mattkaustickomments
      @mattkaustickomments Год назад +1

      @@lauraj8429 Thanks!

  • @stoppropaganda2573
    @stoppropaganda2573 Год назад +16

    I lived in Palmyra, NY for several years growing up back in the late 60's and the Mormon influence was all around but had very little impact on the town in general. Palmyra is known for having 4 churches on the 4 corners of the main town intersection and none of them are Mormon. The biggest event was the Mormon Pageant at Hill Cumorah once a year which would flood the town B and B's and made Mormonism a thing in town for a short time. As a joke we went searching for he golden plates similar to to Oak Island treasure hunt fantasy. They had very little secretive or culty activities and the kids went to public schools, but had no impact on the overall experiences of being a kid. We all knew who Joseph smith was though we knew little more than he was a conman ...

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +3

      Interesting thank you!

    • @anthonynettleton8346
      @anthonynettleton8346 Год назад

      Have u ever watched the fighting preacher .. its a mormon film and based where you are from

  • @Lepewhi
    @Lepewhi Год назад +5

    We are just apes with cellphones. I laughed so hard, I spit out my beer.

  • @DebraJean196
    @DebraJean196 Год назад +2

    I find it very humorous that almost all of the commercials that came up during this interview were for religious organizations lol

  • @auggiedoggiesmommy1734
    @auggiedoggiesmommy1734 Год назад +3

    After living in a 99% Mormon neighborhood for 24 years, I couldn’t take it anymore. My husbands boss, the CEO of a large company, called my husband a heathen in a staff meeting. And the Mormons I knew who had left the church said I was lucky that I had never been a member because it’s SO much worse when you have been a member and left.

    • @karmelicanke
      @karmelicanke Год назад +1

      I once read that the children of a catholic family in Provo experienced terrible bullying at school and snide remarks from adults. The kids were transferred to a private school.

  • @scottstringhamfacilitiesas3132
    @scottstringhamfacilitiesas3132 Год назад +47

    I was raised in the Mormon church and left a couple of years ago and I think the core of why Mormons are always happy is that we were taught that all negative feelings come from Satan. So if you didn't project happiness or if you weren't happy, you were being influenced by Satan. Couple that with the teachings of you can't have pure joy outside of the gospel by that they mean the church. So by admitting or showing that your life is imperfect or that you are unhappy you are saying that you are not living the Gospel and are being influenced by Satan.

    • @erciliaflores
      @erciliaflores Год назад +1

      So stressful

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      I'm sure I have read some bull shine that is more deluded and wrong...I just can't remember when.

    • @monalisa7954
      @monalisa7954 Год назад

      Same with us JW’s

    • @stardustgirl2904
      @stardustgirl2904 Год назад

      The statement you made is completely false! So many people make stuff up about the church I don't understand why people choose to lie about the church!
      If you don't like the church no one will force you to go! 👍🏻One of the core things the Church has always taught, is we all have our own free agency to choose for ourselves what life we will choose!
      I'm a member of the and a Temple worker and I have never once been taught what you mentioned ever! I don't understand the lie's ❗

    • @silvergirl7810
      @silvergirl7810 Год назад +2

      I grew up Mormon and never heard of such nonsense

  • @insearchoftruth7979
    @insearchoftruth7979 Год назад +4

    Dan nailed it concerning Mormon theology, behavior and practices. Very refreshing! I had myself excommunicated (now called taken off the roles or some other euphonism) from the Mormon church during the height of cultural upheaval and the sexual revolution in the early 70's. I was 23 and single, with a toddler, having married a return missionary in the temple at 19 and divorced at 21.
    Because I was curious, I looked into other religions and spiritual traditions from around the world, both past and present. It didn't take long to see that the "only true church" repetitious drone I'd heard from the time I could understand words was ridiculous. That, along with the racism, sexism and hypocrisy of church leadership sealed the deal.
    Still, it was hard to leave the religion because it was it was so infused into my upbringing. I had grown up hearing that there was only sadness and degradation on the other side, and leaving would destroy my family.
    Because of the insulated way I was raised within the church, I was somewhat naive, so integrating into the wider world was difficult at times. There was no internet to go to for backup. There were no safety nets. It was a complete life overhaul, but I have never regretted my decision.
    Mormons are taught to Obey, Obey, Obey ... so looking to oneself for guidance can be difficult. But, If there is one thing I would say to those who are on the fence about leaving it would be: The Holy Ghost, still small voice--or whatever you choose to call it--that you have been taught to listen to does not come to you from the outside. It is within you. YOU are your own guide. YOU hold the power in your life. Don't look outside of yourself for what is already within you. There is freedom and joy on the other side. Find it!

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      We have never regretted your decision either! Thanks for leaving and taking your weakness and confusion out from among us.

    • @insearchoftruth7979
      @insearchoftruth7979 Год назад

      @@johnlee1352 If that's the case, why does the church keep sending missionaries to my home. I guess they want me back.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      @@insearchoftruth7979 They think you're salvageable...you're not. Please stay out. You're not strong enough to be a Mormon anyway. BTW...faithfulness and loyalty obviously are not genetic. Your family weeps for you...

    • @ktrainbow9765
      @ktrainbow9765 Год назад +1

      Or as Mormons like to call it "personal revelation." You were 💯 right to listen to that personal revelation given to you by God through the Holy Ghost. 👍

  • @maggiej8411
    @maggiej8411 Год назад +5

    Excellent interview Andrew! There is a mini series my partner and I just finished watching called "Under the Banner of Heaven" from the FX channel, that is quite good, and details the corruption in Mormonism. I highly recommend it!

  • @kneekoo
    @kneekoo Год назад +3

    This was great to watch. :)

  • @QuixEnd
    @QuixEnd Год назад +3

    Dude when I lived on a commune we had church 6 hours a day 6 days a week. I broke a lot of rules which kept me sane but dang what a nightmare

  • @CharlyMooMoo369
    @CharlyMooMoo369 Год назад +20

    Discover your Chanel this week. I cannot be more happy. In the mountain of rubbish that YT is throwing at me I found a diamond. You deserve more suscribes and followers. Your videos are so interesting and informative that they should be in national TV. Many thanks again.

    • @CharlyMooMoo369
      @CharlyMooMoo369 Год назад +3

      Heard you are on Patreon. I am following you there now. Yeahhhh all the best!

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +3

      Wow, thank you Charly, so great to have you here!

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +3

      Ohhhh thank you I just saw it come through, I'll message you over there :)

  • @stockinettestitch
    @stockinettestitch Год назад +18

    I was raised Mormon, 4th generation, but left the church the month I turned 16. I remember the day my mom got the phone call saying that blacks can hold the priesthood. She was so happy she started bawling. I left the church after reading The Godmakers.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      Even pioneer genetics gets corrupted and weak. Sounds like you're on the weak end of that stick... BTW, your ancestors weep for you.

    • @giuseppemariocescutti-fitz5835
      @giuseppemariocescutti-fitz5835 Год назад

      What I don’t understand is why, people of colour, meaning African American or Latino, would want to join the church, where they teach you that people of colour are cursed. Way back from Adam and Eve days. Why join a church that teaches you that people of colour are lower than anything. Low of the low. And then all of a sudden, it’s okay to be black in the Mormon church….in the 70’s. Suddenly it was okay to be black in the church. Really. Why??????????? Vilified for centuries. Then suddenly okay because of human rights and all that. Stuff them, is what I would say. Black folk are marked with darkness …..really?

    • @llamamama2910
      @llamamama2910 Год назад +1

      So 1978-Were you living at home?

    • @rychei5393
      @rychei5393 Год назад

      Good for you!

  • @hauntedshadowslegacy2826
    @hauntedshadowslegacy2826 Год назад +5

    I remember this one time when my Mormon sister tried baiting me into dissing someone's clothing choice (the target of her comments was wearing short overalls with a tank top). She legit got *upset* with me when I told her that I didn't care what others wore. It really threw me for a loop, lemme tell ya. Passive-aggressive? Yeah, that's definitely the Mormon way. Dan is spot on with several other things, too, like the 'always happy' mantra. My mom spent nearly the entirety of my childhood scolding me for having normal emotions, a lot like how Abuela Alma treated Pepa in Encanto ('Pepa, you have a cloud.' 'I know, mama!').
    The one thing I'd like to dispute are his points on racism in the church. Not all members hide it. I grew up hearing my abuser (long story) saying the phrase 'pants up, don't loot' in response to the Black Lives Matter movement. Also, the demonization of PoC isn't just from the 'war in heaven'; it's also deeply tied into the Book of Mormon itself. The people who supposedly sailed to the Americas with a boat designed by god? Yeah, two of the brothers were 'good' and two of the brothers were 'bad', and the bad brothers' lineage became known as the Lamanites, and they were cursed with darker skin because of it. Aside from that, pretty spot-on.

    • @erciliaflores
      @erciliaflores Год назад

      Dan explained that in the story, the Jews that sailed to the Americas became the Indigenous peoples of America. I found that part of the story really interesting but confusing because wouldn't you then be recruiting- or making the Native tribes people your prophets and leaders? I have a feeling the answer is no, though, because they would be believed to be the descendants of the "bad ones". Another question, does this mean that Jews are viewed in high regard?

    • @hauntedshadowslegacy2826
      @hauntedshadowslegacy2826 Год назад

      @@erciliaflores Sorry, took me a while to notice your reply. No, Jews aren't regarded highly at all. Last I checked, most if not all of the quorum of the twelve and the quorum of the seventy (the highest-ranking members of the church) are white men. Some were white men from Europe, others white men who grew up in America, but essentially just white. I haven't ever heard of a black or indigenous member in the quorums, so if they exist, they're not widely acknowledged by members. As for bringing in indigenous Americans to be members in general, yeah, that's a thing, but it's not a focus. Back in the early days, Mormons did contribute to the erasure of indigenous cultures by way of missionary work, but it wasn't about revering the indigenous people in any way. Those that were brought into the church in the early days were taught to forsake their 'evil' heritage.
      One thing to keep in mind, though, is that it wasn't just about their ancestors being the 'bad ones'. It very much revolved around the idea that dark skin in general was a curse from Yahweh. That includes non-indigenous people who have dark skin. Slaves from Africa? Evil sinners because of their dark skin. It wasn't until after racism started dying down in general that the church switched from 'dark skin, evil people' to the 'new revelation' of 'just convert them'. Joseph Smith and Brigham Young were very much racist, through and through. Some church members use that as justification for micro-aggressions while others try to play it off as 'the past'.

  • @joyfurden8375
    @joyfurden8375 Год назад

    it’s nice to hear someone making sense. thanks

  • @pmshea63
    @pmshea63 Год назад +1

    Sorry I missed the live stream Andrew❣️ Great guest.. Your the best :)

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +2

      No worries , you're also the best :D

    • @geekdivaherself
      @geekdivaherself Год назад +1

      @@AndrewGold1 - Everybody is best! Yay!
      I'm here from Aaron Smith-Levin's Channel & I just subscribed. I didn't mean to listen to all of this video but I started and before I knew it I was done!

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад

      @@geekdivaherself haha that's great! it's an old episode that i re-uploaded, but i'm so pleased it is resonating with audiences. I love Aaron, we're doing some streams Monday night about NXIVM, hope you enjoy!

  • @deirdreaube
    @deirdreaube Год назад +9

    I grew up a Jahovah's witness. Didn't realize I grew up in a cult 😳
    Good thing I'm Canadian 😀

  • @micheleunterseher7013
    @micheleunterseher7013 Год назад +29

    I’m an x Mormon now Christian and fairly researched on both. Mormonism is closer to Scientology than Christianity. There are no similarities in the theological beliefs of Mormons and Christians.

    • @jeffreyp1855
      @jeffreyp1855 Год назад +3

      Michele, I always felt that LRH plagiarized the Latter Day Saints.

    • @mistiroberts1576
      @mistiroberts1576 Год назад +2

      Mormonism is also very close to Islam

    • @micheleunterseher7013
      @micheleunterseher7013 Год назад +2

      @@mistiroberts1576 Wow that is interesting. I don’t know anything about the Islam religion. I would like to though.

    • @mistiroberts1576
      @mistiroberts1576 Год назад +1

      @@micheleunterseher7013 let me see if I can find the resource that I got that from

    • @mistiroberts1576
      @mistiroberts1576 Год назад +1

      @@micheleunterseher7013 heres a video about how Islam started
      ruclips.net/video/QCmSBfVXEmA/видео.html

  • @ASMRyouVEGANyet
    @ASMRyouVEGANyet Год назад +5

    I'm not sure he has a full experience of the Relief Society. In my experience (and I was the first counselor in my Relief Society) anytime a sister would start to gossip she was stopped and reminded about how it's wrong to gossip and not to judge the other person.

  • @merrick4154
    @merrick4154 Год назад +1

    Love your show ❤

  • @jennebeattie3168
    @jennebeattie3168 Год назад +3

    ❤️ Just to help the algorithm. You SO deserve 1 billion subscribers!!!

  • @missyihunt
    @missyihunt Год назад +2

    Great job!

  • @drumstick74
    @drumstick74 Год назад +5

    He was a great guest, please have him back on. :)

  • @lesleyhibbert3338
    @lesleyhibbert3338 Год назад +2

    Hi Andrew:
    I have been at Hill Cumorah, the Mormon site. Quite beautiful actually. My Aunt lived in Palmyra and one year we watched the pageant they held but I was very young. I remember the colours and the lights and it was lovely to see but I had no idea what was going on. There is a monument on the hill also. There is a building on the site now that was not there when I first saw the Pageant.
    Hill Cumorah is in Palmyra, New York. Apparently people from all over the world go to see this pageant.

    • @Nutwhisperer
      @Nutwhisperer Год назад

      Girls as young as 13 were given to old men in that glen. It remains a horrible cult to this day.

    • @lesleyhibbert3338
      @lesleyhibbert3338 Год назад

      @@Nutwhisperer That’s horrible. No I had no idea. I was really young when I saw the pageant. I don’t know much about Mormons at all.

  • @AshtynJadeProduction
    @AshtynJadeProduction Год назад +2

    I’ve already commented so much in this video… But one question. I love that Remini & Rinder bring the receipts; Aaron Smith-Levin does as well. Can we get some receipts from this guy?

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +1

      Wait what does bring the receipts mean?

    • @equality379
      @equality379 Год назад

      What proof are you looking for, is there a paper trail? I'm an ex JW but I couldn't supply anyone with proof beyond saying yeah go ask my parents 🤷🏻‍♀️

  • @salattu
    @salattu Год назад +4

    Sounds to me like he has hopped right into woke. He was ticking the boxes of social issues and lifestyle choices.

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад

      I think he has done yes. But each to their own beliefs !

  • @purpurina5663
    @purpurina5663 Год назад +15

    We had a cleaning lady who was Mormon. They enrolled her whole family. She was clearly not a wealthy person and they made her pay more than tithe, and the youngsters work tirelessly as "missionaries" without pay -and made them think it was the best thing that could happen to them. But I about exploded when she said she was ecstatic that she was finally able to get her Bible... I didn't understand. Isn't the Bible a relatively cheap book? Nope, this one was about $150 😠

    • @marlabeard5352
      @marlabeard5352 Год назад +1

      Sounds like Scientology. Buying overpriced books.

    • @rychei5393
      @rychei5393 Год назад +1

      Wouldn't be a bit angry about that, she likely wanted that special bible. My first LDS was free as a gift, but it didn't cost more than 25 bucks for the full set.

    • @Plethorality
      @Plethorality Год назад +2

      Its not a real bible, though. Not the normal canon. The additions do not hold water with serious biblical scholars.

    • @bryas1455
      @bryas1455 Год назад +2

      Hahahaha. Wait what? You think ANY biblical passages hold water? It's all just bronze age nonsense!

    • @troysnuffles
      @troysnuffles Год назад +1

      And the Mormon church is currently hoarding $150 Billion, yet exploiting slave labour. They are no better than the Scientologists.

  • @patricianoel7782
    @patricianoel7782 Год назад +3

    Let me also recommend watching “ Mormon Stories” for a pretty good view of the cult. I’ve been a member for 65 years and found so much FACTS in the last two years that I quit.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      Thanks for taking your weakness and confusion out of the church! 65 years as a feckless poser is quite enough. Thanks for leaving before we had to throw you out.

  • @debbieklahn1263
    @debbieklahn1263 Год назад +5

    The first part of the interview with Dan Beecher was interesting as I learned of his experiences and views on Mormonism but by the end, I decided that I am not sure I would want to listen to him again. He is very nice and engaging but as my husband often says, so are serial killers! He lives life like a person that decided that diets don't work so not only am I going to eat a piece of cake but am going to eat the whole cake every night and then one day wonder why he is now 400 pounds. Healthy relationships consider how their actions affect others. Dan's quest for "freedom" has now made him self centered.

  • @harryabelpotter9630
    @harryabelpotter9630 Год назад +1

    My experience is somewhat different.
    I have heard it said that the type of happiness that the Church teaches is eternal happiness which translates to joy, as in, I've got that joy, joy, joy, joy ~ down in my heart ~ and, BTW, when did it become a sin to smile ???

  • @kathleenhartnellharper7234
    @kathleenhartnellharper7234 Год назад +30

    I took a vacation in the 90’s and Utah was one of the states I passed through. Yes , it’s true , everyone was happy and smiling. It was Creepy! It was like being in a , “ Stepford Wives” situation. In that movie the wives had been replaced with subservient robots. Always compliant, always ready to please and obey.

    • @athenaf8278
      @athenaf8278 Год назад

      Yes and drink coffee in restaurants by the gallon even though caffeine is prohibited!

    • @tiffprendergast
      @tiffprendergast Год назад

      Yup

    • @tiffprendergast
      @tiffprendergast Год назад

      @@athenaf8278 yup

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      Hey, Kathleen...should they have frowned instead? Satisfy you? wow...shallow

    • @kathleenhartnellharper7234
      @kathleenhartnellharper7234 Год назад

      @@johnlee1352 Fu, it was the “vibe .“ It was phony you stupid p…k

  • @caroljv33
    @caroljv33 Год назад +7

    This was very similar to The Way International. If you weren’t happy you weren’t “believing” properly which meant you were spiritually weak. If you became ill, you were spiritually weak. Etc. interesting how cults are similar in some ways. Always having to work to be good enough. When Jesus actually never needs you to prove yourself with works I finally found out.

    • @virginiasanderson519
      @virginiasanderson519 Год назад +1

      Carol Van Drie -- So happy to read your comment!!! I was in The Way International also. Everything you said is spot on!!! Thank God I got out when I did!! So nice to know that we NEVER have to prove anything to God. I am so thankful for my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ!
      God bless you! (I wish you and I could talk sometime.)

    • @caroljv33
      @caroljv33 Год назад

      @@virginiasanderson519 when were you in TWI? Sorry that happened to you. Such a terrible experience.

  • @highpsi11
    @highpsi11 Год назад +2

    A couple of young LDS men were told to contact a former Mormon who lived across the street from me. I told them that I didn't know where he lived, but it was obviously part of their assigned mission to locate this man and bring him back into the fold.
    He told me that when he was a child, someone in the Mormon church decided that he was a healer, so he had to pretend to be a healer. He knew that this was nonsense, and it helped to drive him away. And, he was gay, so I guess there was no place for him in the church. There's supposedly forgiving and forgetting, but it's more like "stay in the fold and we'll pray for you to not be who you are".

  • @JohnDoe-fu6zt
    @JohnDoe-fu6zt Год назад +2

    Bless his heart, but if he thinks that there is little difference between Mormonism and Mainstream or orthodox Christianity, then he really doesn't know much about Christianity. That really makes sense though. Why should he know a lot about orthodox Trinitarian Christianity, whether Eastern, Western, or Protestant? No reason he should. But I think it's more than "splitting hairs" to observe that the LDS are way, way out there away from mainstream Christianity.

  • @ASMRyouVEGANyet
    @ASMRyouVEGANyet Год назад +5

    I also remember being told that anyone who was neutral in the pre-existance also end up with a handicap...or they end up with lots of mental issues or drug issues... basically they struggle more than others.

  • @wendybond2848
    @wendybond2848 Год назад +7

    I have some Mormon friends. Wonderful people as there are with most religions. Odd aspects to the religion though. The story of the golden plates in America, is even more difficult to believe than golden tablets in a more ancient land. Like the flood memories through countless religions, I’m sure there is truth there and actual events shaped the stories. I think that it’s so important not to be too dogmatic in any faith. Live by the values which support each other and don’t hurt anyone. It shouldn’t be hard. There are so many similarities in belief across different religions if you choose to see them.

  • @gigi1332
    @gigi1332 Год назад +5

    Please interview the author of the CES letter or "New Name Noah" on this subject. Both are BRILLIANT. Thank you

    • @patricianoel7782
      @patricianoel7782 Год назад

      Yes! CES is the information that caused so many young people to quit in the past 5 years. It’s a big deal in SLC/Utah area. P

  • @stevesheroan4131
    @stevesheroan4131 Год назад +6

    I had a good chuckle when he was talking to a Brit about passive-aggressiveness.

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +4

      Hahaha!

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +6

      Or should I say.. ha…..😶

    • @stevesheroan4131
      @stevesheroan4131 Год назад +1

      @@AndrewGold1 All meant in good fun, sir. Love the channel, and I appreciate your dedication to true enlightenment.

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +2

      @@stevesheroan4131 haha thank you steve!

  • @bethmiller7544
    @bethmiller7544 Год назад +10

    Years ago I was I charge of hiring staff for a large gym. Mostly ages 18 to early twenties who wanted part time, decent pay, and a free membership. I am not Mormon and not in an area with many Mormons. Long story short, after hiring a young man who was Mormon, I never looked anywhere else for part time staff. Those young people were dependable, honest, friendly, smart, etc... They didn't proselytize, gossip, cause internal strife. Have never before or since had such a good experience with a group of young people.. I still run into some of them from time to time and they, like all young parents proudly introduce me to their offspring. I am surprised that the majority of them have left the Mormon religion though joined other Christian churches. They seemed so secure in their upbringing. I really did enjoy meeting them and getting to know them.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад +2

      Beth...you're going to get thrown off these sites if you keep saying positive things about the Mormons! It's a no-no...

    • @pechaa
      @pechaa Год назад

      @@johnlee1352No one is rejecting anyone for complementing LDS members. The interviewee is doing so himself.

  • @MichaelYoder1961
    @MichaelYoder1961 Год назад +29

    The comparison between LDS and Scientology is pretty close. Joseph Smith/LRH "discovering" the truth, controlling people's behaviour (including sex), the cosmology (Xenu and the battle in heaven, fallen angels, etc). Joseph and his "wives" and LRH was a womanizer with 3 wives and probably several mistresses. Great interview, Andrew - thanks!

    • @rhyker9597
      @rhyker9597 Год назад +1

      The big difference is that Scientology is NOT a religion. LRH never believed in god or had any spiritual elements in his policies. The only reason that Scientology portrays itself as a “church” is for the tax exempt status. It’s a billion dollar cult not a religious organization at all. If you consider LDS a cult it’s at least a religious one 😊

    • @ginamiller6754
      @ginamiller6754 Год назад +1

      Great points!

    • @lorimavity4160
      @lorimavity4160 Год назад

      If you compare the two religions as they are today, the dissimilarities are profound.

    • @blondequijote
      @blondequijote Год назад +2

      @@lorimavity4160 yeah but instead of apples and oranges it’s like comparing horseshit and bullshit.

  • @debbieklahn1263
    @debbieklahn1263 Год назад +2

    Andrew, another thought provoking interview. So many different areas were slightly touched on that could be topics by themselves. Dan Beecher mentioned that Christianity and Mormonism are similar. Christianity does not include Joseph Smith but has its own issues. Although a "christian", I am not sure that I like that word because it includes every church with walls that has abusive stories and has been inseluar. Both the Mormons and Christans have cases of abuse that could give you material for topics for years. More often than not people attend organized religions to serve themselves in some way rather than to look to meet the needs of others and so as I live outside of the church walls, I prefer to be known as a Jesus follower which emcompasses a broader diverse group. I have friends who are Mormon and Hindus who claim to be Jesus followers that are more kindred spirits to me than many "Christians" that I have known over the years. We see Jesus as our lifeline with nothing else added.

  • @Jsqared-aka-justjenn
    @Jsqared-aka-justjenn Год назад +9

    My folks used to get perturbed, because I always let religious people in (LDS& JW)
    when they came knocking. Told them it's their fault 🙄, manners, respect for my elders ect. Met some amazing people.
    My favorites by far.... an LDS family in California, and a really nice JW in Texas.
    The latter (Marissa) was from Italy married an American soldier and came to Texas after WW2. When I got her talking about food we never stopped 😋so many wonderful recipes. They ended up sending someone else with her (I suppose they wanted more progress), did not last long after that. The new lady and I had a disagreement and they took me off the list.
    I still let them in though.
    Loving the interview y'all 😁 very informative. The self torture and guilt thing... Can totally relate. Probably most religious people or church folk if you prefer, have a lifestyle or loved ones that don't fit). His folks are amazing!!! So wonderful 💓
    From what I've heard from some folks, not usually the case. Awesome 😎

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +1

      ha thanks jennifer!

    • @erciliaflores
      @erciliaflores Год назад +1

      I've made friends with a super nice Nigerian lady, a JW, but it is sad that she and I can't be friends unless she's pushing the doctrine on me. And yeah, I wondered if she had to be accompanied, either in person or by phone, by another JW member during her visits with me to keep an eye on her? Very controlling to say the least! Which is a shame because she's a genuinely kind person!

  • @caroldonaldson5936
    @caroldonaldson5936 Год назад +1

    We don't refer to 'shunning' in the secular world - but we 'cancel' or 'ghost' - same difference!

  • @heatherwhittaker6169
    @heatherwhittaker6169 Год назад +6

    My grandmother always told us that idleness was the devils workshop 😒...People need to be less lazy ,get off the duff..volunteer to make friends,take an extra job...get a hobby,study something...

  • @pixie3760
    @pixie3760 Год назад +9

    Omg I was getting the kids ready for a long flight. The dear Mormans arrived at the dooe and for the bloody life of me I couldn't get rid of them. Eventually after I made them promise to leave if I allowed them in to bless the house. The lunatic here in the house (me ) let them in.
    These maniacs blessed Everything even my flamin fridge. By this time I had no patience at all left notwithstanding the kids were gobsmacked. This was around 20 years ago, but I just went full Karen on them. They left. Needless to say I had to run around like a lunatic so we didn't miss our flight. Jebus H Christ I'll take that day to my damn grave.

    • @geekdivaherself
      @geekdivaherself Год назад +2

      I truly felt your pain! I wish you and yours well. This was very well written.

    • @pixie3760
      @pixie3760 Год назад +1

      @@geekdivaherself thankyou, lol I just noticed all the typos.

    • @geekdivaherself
      @geekdivaherself Год назад

      @@pixie3760 Hah! I had one as well because I had dictated it and Google dictate didn't understand me correctly. I fixed it just now, but, whatever!

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      Boasting of your callous unkindness, huh, Pixie?

  • @tareamcguire8984
    @tareamcguire8984 Год назад +7

    I used to speak wa nice couple. They were interesting. I was confused because she was a pharmacist which I didn't think went with their beliefs. It got to the stage I agreed to pray with them but I stopped midway. This was because the husband said I should repent for having my son. I was a single parent. He insisted I should state my son was a sin and that I should repent for having him. That was their last visit

    • @helenh20mo
      @helenh20mo Год назад +1

      That is disgusting they had no right to say that to you.. that is not what the church is about ... what they were doing was a cultural /personal thing

    • @tareamcguire8984
      @tareamcguire8984 Год назад

      @@helenh20mo they said this time here on earth was purgatory and unless we were free of sin we would go to hell

    • @bethmiller7544
      @bethmiller7544 Год назад

      What happened to you was horrible. I am a peaceful old woman but him saying that to you is...I don't have words. Big hug. So glad you're a Mom to a lucky young chap.

    • @tiffprendergast
      @tiffprendergast Год назад

      What

  • @bekkaadair854
    @bekkaadair854 Год назад +5

    I read Under the Banner of Heaven in college. It was mind blowing

    • @melbournebeedyeyes3181
      @melbournebeedyeyes3181 Год назад

      Under the banner of heaven is more about the off shoots of the Mormon church than the big corporation version that calls the shots in Utah. However, I will say that with the influence they have over the members thinking, most members would go along with the things in the book if the church leadership told them to move in that direction.

  • @jdr9419
    @jdr9419 Год назад +5

    Happy Smily people taking antidepressants.Funny!

  • @jeannedeshazer-ellsworth9995
    @jeannedeshazer-ellsworth9995 Год назад +22

    Wow. I've been LDS my whole life going back to the 1830s. I guess it's influenced a lot by how your parents present it. It's been a huge part of my life and has seen me through a lot of difficulty, but it's my relationship with God and Jesus Christ that means the most. People really don't know much about us and have some very weird ideas. But my friends know me and dont pay much attention to much that is negative. And they ask me if they want to know.

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +10

      fair enough, thank you! there must be branches of it that are different like in my own community of jews!

    • @BarryMaple
      @BarryMaple Год назад +12

      You've been alive since the 1830s?

    • @3aeren
      @3aeren Год назад +6

      @@BarryMaple yeah she's a vampire

    • @angelinaanderson481
      @angelinaanderson481 Год назад +5

      I have many friends who r lds and they r all wonderful people.

    • @mattkaustickomments
      @mattkaustickomments Год назад +3

      @@3aeren She’s become one of the immortal gods of her own universe as is promised to all faithful “Saints” of the church. Lol . But I’m not kidding about that part. THAT’S the payoff, and as far as I can tell for anyone to want to join… if you are a good Mormon, YOU, yes you, become a god in your own right. JC just happens to be god of THIS universe.

  • @jc1865
    @jc1865 Год назад +3

    LDS to this day has polygamy. I was at a Panera restaurant 4 years ago and listened to two LDS women talk about their husbands, their money issues, all linked heavily to this the --> "HE'S COURTING A CHEERLEADER! HE"S COURTING A CHEERLEADER!" problem going to lead to bankruptcy as the new wife needs her own fancy house. There are plenty of LDS around here in Denver Metro (Colorado) and I just smile, nod, and remove myself from their influence/impact. GAME ON with that crew.

    • @patricianoel7782
      @patricianoel7782 Год назад

      This is not regular LDS. Those ladies are Fundamental Latter Day Saints or FLDS. Interesting book though “Mormon Polygamy “ by Richard Van Wagoner. Well documented. Good facts about the origins and continuing polygamy. 😮

  • @KatJ3st
    @KatJ3st Год назад +8

    It sure didn't stop Chad and Lori!

  • @cherylbeckstrom8917
    @cherylbeckstrom8917 Год назад +2

    Christianity is based on grace, Jesus saves us through faith. Mormonism is based on works. The reason they take so many antidepressants is because you can’t do it on your own, its impossible! Most cults throw a little Jesus in there to make them a little light.

  • @BrianMax
    @BrianMax Год назад +2

    I'd been out of the church and was 90% Atheist for 20 years and still thought that being unhappy or lonely meant that I was spiritually or morally defective.
    This guy is not exaggerating. I grew up mormon, in Provo. The Church is the most important thing in my parents' lives, and has been since before I met them.
    Since their 9 children have all left the church, they believe that they failed in life.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      No...just children who chose poorly. God lost 1/3 of his children to free agency.

    • @BrianMax
      @BrianMax Год назад +1

      @@johnlee1352 It's so sad that grown adults believe in fairy tales.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      @@BrianMax Even sadder when they "outgrow" faith and think they're wise...

    • @BrianMax
      @BrianMax Год назад

      @@johnlee1352 Have fun following a scam from 200 years ago.
      And wearing ugly underwear.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад +1

      @@BrianMax It's actually 192 years. If you're going to hatefully mock me, at least have your information correct! Dullard. I guess I don't think or ask about your underwear because it's disrespectful, personal and none of my business. Apparently you have no such boundaries or filters. Good luck with that...I'll bet you're proud. Anything is fair when your hatred is so strong, huh, Brian?

  • @FalconOfStorms
    @FalconOfStorms Год назад +5

    "Mormons have some sliiight differences with Christianity"
    Like believing god is just a man? The reason Nelson hates the word Mormon is because he wants Mormonism to be included under the umbrella of Christianity. In terms of actual doctrine, the Venn diagram between Mormonism and Christianity is just two non-converging circles.

    • @reddwood4971
      @reddwood4971 Год назад

      Umm it’s literally called the Church OF Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. They are just as Christian as anyone if not more so

    • @FalconOfStorms
      @FalconOfStorms Год назад

      @@reddwood4971 Lol. And antifa is actually antifascist because it's in the name, and buffalo wings are made from the wings of buffalo. That's not how any of this works. There is such a concept as a misnomer.
      Mormonism violates the most basic beliefs of Christianity and Holy Writ, up to and including the belief in Monotheism.

  • @Truthatallcosts777
    @Truthatallcosts777 Год назад +10

    My friend the Mormon doctrine of God is completely different from the Bible so in turn Mormons are not Christian’s. And just because the name of Jesus is in their name means absolutely nothing. They believe God was an exalted man at one point and obtained Godhood, pure blasphemy.

    • @AshtynJadeProduction
      @AshtynJadeProduction Год назад +1

      This is funny… seeing as the Church of Jesus Christ of Later-Day Saints has spent this entire year deeply studying the Old Testament and are set to do the same for the New Testament next year. Every week members come together to share beautiful truths found within the Bible. But, you know… facts are overrated on RUclips, sooo…

    • @prettyinpinky5937
      @prettyinpinky5937 Год назад +1

      @@AshtynJadeProduction ex Saint with family still in and stop lying! The Bible is barely used and where in the Bible does it say you get a planet instead of going to heaven? You’re disgusting!

    • @prettyinpinky5937
      @prettyinpinky5937 Год назад +1

      @@AshtynJadeProduction you believe the words of a long dead conman and murderer! The Book of Mormon and Pearl of Great Price of what you use and the Bible is merely to pretend that this is a Christian organization! You’re sick

    • @angelinaanderson481
      @angelinaanderson481 Год назад +2

      Latter Day Saints whole premise is Jesus Christ…. I’m not sure where or who has given u this misinformation. Please read the Book of Mormon which is an account of Jesus Christ, (his birth and death and purpose) and the prophets in the Americas. At least educate yourself about whAt it is you are saying is not of Christ. 😊

    • @Truthatallcosts777
      @Truthatallcosts777 Год назад +2

      @@angelinaanderson481 King Follett Discourse….have you read it? Tell me what Joseph said about God being an exalted man. Here I will save you sometime. He said “God himself was once as we are now, and is an exalted man, and sits enthroned in yonder heavens!” That Angelina is not the God of the Bible. God has always been the “I AM”. No beginning, always God. The Alpha and Omega. The Bible and the Book of Mormon are not companions.The Lds don’t even trust the Bible.

  • @kimberlymason7080
    @kimberlymason7080 Год назад +4

    this guy is so lost. I was with him until he said he has a wife and gf and his wife has a bf.

    • @Shaunography
      @Shaunography Год назад

      I turned off the interview at that point.

    • @carolinecheatham1087
      @carolinecheatham1087 6 месяцев назад

      Yes completely agree with you. I stopped listening to him after that.

  • @Nutwhisperer
    @Nutwhisperer Год назад +12

    I am a psychiatric nurse who was married to a Mormon for years. I feel like I have alot of insight relating to this horrible cult. It cost me my marriage. My ex husband is black. I still don't understand how a person of color could possibly be a Mormon. Look into why Andrew.

    • @equality379
      @equality379 Год назад +1

      Acceptance?

    • @Nutwhisperer
      @Nutwhisperer Год назад

      @@equality379 I don't understand. (Acceptance) there was no guinuine Acceptance. My husband was their 'black friend'.. He was their proof of no racism. Do you know that as recent as 5 years ago an 8 year old boy innocently asked my husband if he was "black all over, or just his head and hands".
      Fun fact. According to the Book of Mormon, my husband is black due to his non valiant nature I'm the pre earth life. It's the mark of Satan. It is NOT like other churches.

    • @tiffprendergast
      @tiffprendergast Год назад

      @@equality379 no

    • @ASMRyouVEGANyet
      @ASMRyouVEGANyet Год назад +2

      Like, why would any woman be involved in any patriarchal religions? Any of them.

    • @Nutwhisperer
      @Nutwhisperer Год назад

      Agreed. The truth about that belief system is horrendous.

  • @JudyMenzel7
    @JudyMenzel7 Год назад +10

    I'm also an x mormon...I quit because women are so suppressed bc it's a total patriarchal religion.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      You quit because you're too weak and confused to be a Mormon...

    • @silvergirl7810
      @silvergirl7810 Год назад

      I grew up Mormon and my dad was the one who did the cooking and cleaning- my mom wore the pants- it may have been that way in the 1800’s but so was everyone else.

  • @allenschmitz9644
    @allenschmitz9644 Год назад +8

    Those kookie 1840 's 💜

    • @mattkaustickomments
      @mattkaustickomments Год назад

      What most people don’t realize is that there were HUNDREDS of cults/splinter groups/sects in the 1830s an 1840s - and the biggest hotspot for them was in Joe Smith’s neck of the woods in NY. But with extremely few exceptions they all died out as fads and/or when their prophet/leader was outed as a scammer/scoundrel. Mormonism held on almost as a fluke. They were helped by Joe being ‘martyred’. But I think the biggest reason was the promise that the faithful would become gods of their own universe was perhaps the main draw that allowed it to soldier on.

  • @rachelsande6741
    @rachelsande6741 6 месяцев назад +2

    Just here to say I’m a happy and proud Mormon.

  • @llamamama2910
    @llamamama2910 Год назад +11

    Cognitive dissonance in both my marriage and my religion was SOOOO painful!

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      I understand weakness and confusion can be painful...maybe that explains it.

    • @ginamiller6754
      @ginamiller6754 Год назад

      @@johnlee1352 you are such a troll! Get a life!

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      @@ginamiller6754 Trolling a "troll", huh, Gina? wow

  • @alyzu4755
    @alyzu4755 Год назад +4

    "Almost the same way we look at Canadians". 😂😂😂💙

    • @rhyker9597
      @rhyker9597 Год назад +1

      Ya Canadian Mormons are the happiest people on earth😂🇨🇦

  • @sproutsrevil6508
    @sproutsrevil6508 Год назад +8

    What a fabulous guest. Fascinating. The whole organised religion thing reinforces my atheism even more so

  • @eoinoconnell185
    @eoinoconnell185 Год назад +3

    This guy would be fun to be around.
    He knows himself.

  • @Rebeker
    @Rebeker Год назад

    it seems like trying to reverse engineering happiness
    amazing insight, thanks !!!

  • @gemsbokpan5062
    @gemsbokpan5062 10 месяцев назад +2

    The best intreview on Mormanism by an ex-Morman I have ever watched. This guy has spent an enormous amount of time understanding the cult he was brought up in. We benefit from his understandind and plain talk. Thank you my friend.

  • @sarahpiaggio2693
    @sarahpiaggio2693 Год назад +3

    Interesting. But he says at one point that mormonism is a kind of Christianity. To think such a thing, a person has to have no idea what christianity is. That's fair enough, since he was a mormon all his life, but let's put it on record that the reason that christians don't accept mormonism as being a kind of christianity is because it doesn't hold to any of the basic tenets. If a "church" doesn't teach that Jesus is completely God as well as completely man, born from a virgin and died in the place of all of us because we're all by nature sinners who need a saviour... then it's not christian. Mormonism is so far from this that it even teaches that satan was Jesus' brother. To a Christian, this idea is no less than blasphemous.

    • @blackalien6873
      @blackalien6873 Год назад

      Mormonism believe 2 out of 3 of those things. Who gets to decide whose Christian? Is there a committee?

    • @sarahpiaggio2693
      @sarahpiaggio2693 Год назад +1

      @@blackalien6873 Christians by definition are supposed to believe what the Bible says, and that it teaches us what Christianity is. Once a church starts valuing other books as highly or more so than what the early church and Jewish followers of God decided was God-inspired scripture, then that's a sign that there's something not christian about it. Added to this, if the additional "holy scripture" actually contradicts what the Bible says, then that clinches it: it's not christian.
      The fundamental issue in Christianity, according the Bible, is what to do about sin. The Bible tells us that sin came in through the first man and woman and that because of that, we all have it (like a genetic illness). So sin isn't fundamentally about the acts that we do, but about our nature, what we ARE (the acts are a consequence). And the fact is that although we can "behave", we can't do anything about what we ARE. This is why we need a saviour.
      The book of mormon says that the sin of adam and eve was a GOOD thing and that we're not all consequently tarnished by their act, so we're not by nature "sinners" but rather we choose to do wrong things sometimes. This is a direct and basic contradiction of the Bible which means that in fact human beings don't need "saving" at all, because we're not helpless. Therefore the purpose of Christ coming will necessarily be completely different. Mormons believe there is a god called the father, another one called the son and another one call the holy spirit. They believe that god is an exalted, perfect man, that human beings have the potential to become gods of their own planet (that's star trek level weirdness), that Jesus is the literal, biological son of God and Mary. This is all totally contrary to what the Bible teaches. Mormonism uses a lot of christian concepts and words, but their meaning is COMPLETELY different.

  • @pixie3760
    @pixie3760 Год назад +1

    I find these religious broadcasts fascinating. I did a B.A In religions and find all of these theological discussions extremely interesting, coming from the sources so to speak.
    Please remember to call Indian's Indigenous People.

  • @kellylouisebrown4954
    @kellylouisebrown4954 Год назад +13

    I asked a Mormon how they have their book of Mormon, when the Bible contradicts having other texts in addition to it. They just pushed their prophet to say it was ok.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад +2

      You really need to read more and educate yourself before blathering on the internet. The Book of Revelation is what you refer to and it warns against any addition to "this book". The Bible didn't even exist at that time. What "book" do you think he meant? Ignorance appears to be your constant companion.

    • @kellylouisebrown4954
      @kellylouisebrown4954 Год назад

      @@johnlee1352 excuse me?! I don't blather on and I am highly educated. I am a former Christian with a family member high ranking in the Church. I even have a Degree. I described a situation that happened in reality and the response that I got.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      @@kellylouisebrown4954 How could you be so careless with the truth? How did you not understand the glaring historical contradiction you spewed? Educated dullards...more common than you would think.

  • @Yikkoofficial
    @Yikkoofficial Год назад

    I’m an anthropology major and this video is very interesting.

  • @debbieklahn1263
    @debbieklahn1263 Год назад +9

    One other area that I would like to address is the image of nice, wholesome Mormons and its appeal. Like all organized religions, there are pockets of people who are genuinely kind and nice and want to love others well and others are drawn in because of this but that is more rare than not. More often the dynamics is that everyone wants the Hallmark story for their lives and so people within those walls are treated like figurines in a Christmas village scene that you set up for Christmas. All have expected roles to support their views of community(snow and all) but the real test of love comes when you ask the "why" questions pushing their buttons. Then do they still want you in their Christmas village?

    • @Nutwhisperer
      @Nutwhisperer Год назад +1

      MORMONISM IS NOT "Like other religions". However, that's part of the rhetoric that gets that 10% still comin in.

    • @debbieklahn1263
      @debbieklahn1263 Год назад

      @@Nutwhisperer I would love to know what you mean??? I am a bit cynical on my "church" experiences over the years and have started to wonder where is the line between a cult and religion. Neither should be a part of following Jesus.

    • @Nutwhisperer
      @Nutwhisperer Год назад

      @@debbieklahn1263 I will fight for your right to worship as you please. Can I suggest Heart of the Matter with Shawn McCraney? It's Mormonism as it relates to Christianity. No anger or bitterness. He was a faithful Mormon for 40 years. He became a Christian as an adult. He answered all my questions. I've learned more about the Bible and the Savior in 4 years than I ever did trudging through church. Give it a try. I love it. Good luck.

    • @debbieklahn1263
      @debbieklahn1263 Год назад

      @@Nutwhisperer I will look at it. Thanks for sharing.

    • @ASMRyouVEGANyet
      @ASMRyouVEGANyet Год назад +4

      I left the Christmas village due to exactly what you said. Nice analogy! Fits perfectly.

  • @shellnet411
    @shellnet411 Год назад +1

    Shunning is also in The Amish I've read the book of Mormon a couple pages it totally contradicted the Bible open read like two pages and it was so bad I may have missed context because it was like somewhere in the middle

  • @jillruben8924
    @jillruben8924 Год назад

    Great video. The best South Pak episode is on the Mormons, next Scientology.

  • @bernieblack1036
    @bernieblack1036 Год назад +1

    Interesting interview. However your guest is wrong about Mormons and JW being "Christians". When you change the core, you can't claim, it's the same, just because they are using the name of Jesus or "Bible", when the bible is change.

  • @danylleedson7170
    @danylleedson7170 Год назад +1

    I had a couple of female missionaries come and try to convert me. When they told me the story of the Jewish tribes coming over to the Americas and they said that they built temples in north America. I asked them where are the ruins? If the Wailing Wall has stood for 1000s of years, but there was no actual evidence of this story about the settlements of Jewish tribes in America . They told me that I must just have faith and I said that I couldn't do it. They never came back. I hope they are doing well.

    • @johnlee1352
      @johnlee1352 Год назад

      Thanks for staying out...we don't need the weakness and confusion.

    • @danylleedson7170
      @danylleedson7170 Год назад

      @@johnlee1352 Thanks for taking the time to respond to my comment 😉. I think you are right, you probably have enough weakness of your own. It seems like you are full of it 😂.

    • @JohnDLee-im4lo
      @JohnDLee-im4lo Год назад

      @@danylleedson7170 That's exactly what I'm talking about. Have a great unaccountable life.

    • @danylleedson7170
      @danylleedson7170 Год назад

      @@JohnDLee-im4lo 👍 you too baby 💞

  • @mylifewithmarmalade4624
    @mylifewithmarmalade4624 Год назад

    1:33 THIS exactly. Unhappiness as moral failure. Huge issue with toxic positivity both within the church and wider largely LDS communities. Could perhaps explain why Utah has one of the highest rates of antidepressant prescriptions in the country?

  • @cherylbetts7379
    @cherylbetts7379 Год назад

    Still addicted Andrew and I love it🥰👍🇬🇧

  • @jenniraanaes2531
    @jenniraanaes2531 Год назад +7

    I loved this episode! It was fun and for me educational! I still wonder how Mormons got this idea about the indigenous people where the once that was the first Mormons?! Because they don't have aa even similar religious belief, so I wonder how they explain that?! And I was chocked that they accidentally originally are racist 😮 had no idea! So very interesting! I had a good laughs true this interview so thank you Andrew 🙏🏻 yet again a great episode 😊

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад +3

      ah thank you jenni, so glad you enjoyed it!!

    • @geekdivaherself
      @geekdivaherself Год назад +3

      I think that there's always been some people have been fascinated by Native Americans, but that in the case of Mormonism, the origin of the point that you are wondering about truly lies in the idea that people back then in that area had of America as the New Jerusalem. So for America to be a holy location and yet still Christian, Jesus had to have appeared here. How do we get Jesus to visit? A bunch of Jewish people came over! Oh, and Eden was really in America, too.
      There was a guy in Australia who was I believe a Mormon Bishop who was so excited about DNA because now we can really prove that the Book of Mormon is true! But for some reason the people at Brigham Young University pushing back on the idea of doing a genetic study! And then he found out the groups were not related and in anguish turned to somebody higher up in Utah who basically told him to just play it off. I don't know if he's now a Christian or an atheist or an agnostic but something like that. I wish I could remember his name. I don't think he's on RUclips, I remember reading his story on some website and it was just fascinating! I really hope I can find his story again because the details were just marvelous and he sounded like such a great guy. It's too bad he had to go through that hell, if you'll excuse the expression.

    • @jenniraanaes2531
      @jenniraanaes2531 Год назад +2

      @@geekdivaherself omg! Thank you for that explanation! You really gave me a bigger understanding on their teaching, I have to say that I thought I knew what Mormons where believing but I realize that there is way more things then I could ever imagine 😱 you have a grate way to explain it! Thank you so much for taking your time to help me understand a little bit more 🙏🏻🤗

    • @geekdivaherself
      @geekdivaherself Год назад +1

      @@jenniraanaes2531 No problem! Both the content of this kind of thing and explaining this kind of thing is fun for me so I was glad to help. It's funny that I've never been a Mormon and I explained it better to you than they ever did! Thanks again!

    • @jenniraanaes2531
      @jenniraanaes2531 Год назад +1

      @@geekdivaherself 😅 well you might be a critical thinker?! So maybe you source your knowledge true more various ways, then Mormons for instance? 😅
      I'm glad you enjoy explaining, because I enjoy learning, that's why I like this channel for instance 😊

  • @StregaLeia77
    @StregaLeia77 Год назад +1

    mormons came around when i was younger to our house. their church had those women living in a literal chicken coop during their 2year mission. they told me that's how i know. i invited them to my little bday parties so they could see abit of happiness

  • @fallon7616
    @fallon7616 Год назад +5

    Their attitude towards sex created the situation with Jodi Arias and Travis Scott

  • @cohenlabe1
    @cohenlabe1 Год назад +3

    Old Jewish joke: why did God crate mormons so that Christians could know what Jews fill when Christians say they fallow the Jewish bible

    • @geekdivaherself
      @geekdivaherself Год назад +1

      That is hilarious! Sincerely, a Presbyterian.

  • @Hookythehammer
    @Hookythehammer Год назад

    A great listen! Andrew you might support the spuds and I might be a happy hammer (not Mormon induced happiness btw) but I'll still talk to you. Just not about footy 😂 keep up the top work dude 👊🏻

    • @AndrewGold1
      @AndrewGold1  Год назад

      Haha fair enough and thank you!!

  • @isobelswan
    @isobelswan Год назад +1

    Unhappiness is the other side of the coin to happiness; you can't have one without the other.

  • @Jsqared-aka-justjenn
    @Jsqared-aka-justjenn Год назад +1

    Actually made it early! 😳😆 Yaaaay!

  • @jerrimenard3092
    @jerrimenard3092 Год назад +1

    How many of us Ex Mormon people remember the song " no one likes a frowny face"? Toxic positivity in the face of abuse was the rule. If your not always smiling, then you were being punished for your negative mindset. What a load of crap it was.

  • @lesliewells1062
    @lesliewells1062 Год назад +3

    We addressed each other as brother and sister in the cult I belonged to also.

    • @erciliaflores
      @erciliaflores Год назад +2

      My church did, too, and that always rubbed me the wrong way. But then I'd scold myself because, obviously in the eyes of God, we are all his children and we shouldn't have to be blood- related and anyway it's just a form of affection...
      But it's really cringe

    • @lesliewells1062
      @lesliewells1062 Год назад +2

      @@erciliaflores It doesn't really bother me, not nearly as much as a lot of other stuff about it. People called me Sister Ann, because my husband told me I had to go by my middle name instead of my first name. It sounded like I was a nun!!

  • @mattkaustickomments
    @mattkaustickomments Год назад +4

    The stat about the anti-depressives is not too surprising. But I’ve also seen a stat that the most intensive porn viewing per capita is in Utah.

    • @ASMRyouVEGANyet
      @ASMRyouVEGANyet Год назад

      There's actually not that many Mormons in Utah. So, implying that the p. Or. N usage stats is an issue with them doesn't hold up. Now if the stats included which religion the users practice, then you'd be okay.

    • @blackalien6873
      @blackalien6873 Год назад +1

      @@ASMRyouVEGANyet 60.8% of Utah population is Mormon. The state is 3/5 Mormon. Stop spreading misinformation.

    • @mattkaustickomments
      @mattkaustickomments Год назад +1

      @@ASMRyouVEGANyet As of 2021, The Church itself claims 68.5% of the population of Utah is Mormon, and is by far the most concentrated location of LDS in the US. And the figure is number of online subscriptions to Pornhub from a study they conducted. Unsurprisingly, there’s a whole subgenre of Mormon porn which I think is hilarious ,…. They feature their magic underwear and the green aprons they wear for ceremonies…Or so I’ve heard. Lol.

    • @patricianoel7782
      @patricianoel7782 Год назад

      True. However, the moms seem allowed to have a glass of wine every evening.. so there’s that. 😂❤🎉.

    • @mattkaustickomments
      @mattkaustickomments Год назад +1

      @@patricianoel7782 Uh oh. They’re not supposed to have alcohol, or caffeine for that matter…

  • @vknglion
    @vknglion Год назад +2

    I definately want to know about Mormons as well as I've grown up not knowing much except, (from my parents) there bad. They are also the only religion which puzzled me BC they are they only ones that would show up at our door every Sunday knocking on our door and giving out pamphlets and trying to come in and convert us from Greek Orthodox. Even though every week, we kept telling them, no thank you.
    But every Sunday, they kept knocking. Manages to stop it finally though a , well, not a nice method. But it worked.

    • @ASMRyouVEGANyet
      @ASMRyouVEGANyet Год назад +1

      You have to ask to be taken off the route. Once you do that, you won't be visited by them for a while. You might get another visit when the next missionaries are sent to that area because they start over. But just tell those new ones you want taken off the route. It saves them the hassle as well.

  • @scottvance74
    @scottvance74 Год назад +1

    42:15 - While it is true that the Community of Christ (Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) denied that Joseph had plural wives through the 1960s or so, since the 1980s (aprox) they have admitted that Joseph Smith did indeed have multiple wives.