What is the percentage of state board students who were enrolled into medical colleges between 2007-2014 and now in TN? That answers the point about NEET.
yealy 30 to 40 govt school students got seat before neet. after neet, only 2 - 3 got seat. so TN intro reservation and gave them both seats.. its all there in his report itself. read the report before commenting
Dear Friends! We are pioneer in medical field and so many specialists in the world are from Tamilnadu. In order to occupy seats in Tamilnadu the "NEET SCAM" is formed. Why NEET exam all services given to private people. Search the Past History of Tamilnadu Doctors how much we are helping the society. Because of the heredity and humanity in Tamilnadu doctors serving the society. What is the lack in the skills of them? Let them have NEET exams in other states not here. We are having so many sources of people here, why it is looted by others.
Lol. You losers are fighting to have a medical seat because you know at all India level, you have no shot of getting one. So just taking the easy way out which is state board. Then Don't ever compare the half baked graduates from TN colleges to the graduates of AIIMS, MAMC , Or any other top colleges.
So many specialist from Tamil Nadu? Then why our leaders and celebrities fly to London, USA and other countries for medical treatment, why can't they take treatment here if we have so many specialists.
If a graduate is qualified by getting a degree from tamilnadu University then why they should appear for tnpsc. Why to burden them. Why they should study separately for tnpsc. Give them job directly as sub collectors based on their marks. Wow what a retired judge. Half baked irrational speech.
Aren't you ppl ashamed to do politics in students Life, compared to the previous system neet is better in all ways! Even judges are openly falling for money!cheap stunt!
@@basketbal1433 which state ? Which state has given the data . Let them publish the data of their state board students entering medical colleges before and after NEET.
NEET marks are not at all an indicator of true learning and knowledge. Coaching classes simply teach the tricks to score high marks. People lack awareness and think too high about NEET. But, NEET does not bring out real talent and knowledge. This is the truth. It's sad people don't understand this fact. TN syllabus is good but question paper pattern should be changed like CBSE.
Is this gentleman really a justice? His lack of understanding the core issue is jus baffling to me! Looks like his only motive is the support the present DMK government and also the politicians who were running most of the medical colleges in Tamilnadu and was earning crores and crores of money every year! With introduction of NEET, the playing field fir students has been leveled. The political parties of Tamilnadu ensured that government schools are kept at the lowest in standards and they were running the majority of the CBSE school, including the daughter-in-law of the present chief minister! With money lost in the capitation fees these politicians are shedding crocodile tears and want to abolish NEET! This so called judge who can’t even articulate the points raised by the interviewer coming up with nonsense! Parents are smarter now and they know what to do with their kids. Let the government enhance the standards of the government schools with their ill earned wealth - if they have a mind to do that!
Film actors charge in crores in TN. Music directors can amass wealth. Broadcasting channels are in plenty in TN making enough. Liquor is with Govt? Importantly DMK gave about 500 crores to Prashant to script a victory and come to power - ALL THIS IS OK Coaching centres employ middleclass TAMILS only. They should not make money. The standard of secondary education is abject state.teachers are selected based on the contact with MLA's. Excellence cannot be compramised in Education. Employment is different - locals and social upliftment is agreeable.
Mr. AK Rajan did not provide important statistics in his Report: How much did the Medical colleges charge before NEET - how much do they charge after NEET? Which CASTE paid how much before and after NEET for the Management Quota and how many of those were First Generation Graduates (FGG) and how many were Non-FGG? What is equality? What is Social Justice? 1 Are MLA assembly tickets allowed only on the basis of caste? Is only OBC dominating 76 +% MLA seats equality? 2 is Only 5% representation of women in the assembly equality? Are agricultural women getting much lower minimum wages than men for the same job equality? Are very few women have the right to own agricultural lands equality? 3 Is only a few from the Powerful and rich families hereditarily inherit important top positions in the party equality? 4 Of the total 2.01 lakh fishing families, 91 percent are below the poverty line? 5 Is about 1.5 crore people (almost 20% of TN Population) living in unsanitary conditions in slums in Tamil Nadu? 6 Is targeting and demeaning particular community equality? 7 While all the Party members owned private schools teach Hindi, German, French, and many other languages, restricting Government School students to only bilingual (Tamil and English) is social justice? 8 Is allowing only companies that are paying commission to politicians allowed to bid for Government Tenders democracy? 9 Is looting assets of 36,000+ Hindu Temples (land and other properties without showing any accounts and not doing any external audit) for other purposes other than Temple use in spite of Court ruling and not appointing trustees. I would be glad to correct if any of the above statements are proven incorrect with data.
NEET is against the rural and urban poor as they are not afford to go to coaching centres. NEET encourages coaching centres to loot money from the students
The study by Justice( Retd) Mr. Rajan appears to be sketchy on very few facts and study has not recommended how the rural students can be empowered by state to have coaching facility?. No answer for how corrupt practice can be controlled in direct admissions? Study is for how not to have NEET? how rote learning can have good students?
Mr.A.K.Rajan ,the nemesis of NEET goes back to a circular of Karnataka of 1989 regulating the differential fee structure for Karnataka Government Medical colleges, Karnataka meritorious student admitted in Private medical colleges and those selected by Private Medical colleges. This was challenged by a UP student Mohini Jain vs Karnataka in 1989 and the subsequent Unnikrishnan Judgement of 1993. The Government was asked to regulate the fee and admission by holding one test . Thus from 1994 the Common Enterance Test was held .The private colleges were unhappy and went to court to get a favourable Judgment in 2002 ie T.A.Pai Judgement accordly the private medical/Engineering colleges had separate admission test called COMED- K and Government virtually lost the seats for its meritorious student in Private medical colleges. Next was when world famous Dr.Devishetty a renowned Cardiologist was appointed as Chief of MCI a question was posed by many Medical students going abroad for higher studies to solve the long pending demand of upgrading their MBBS degree on par with international standards. He extensively discussed with his other members of MCI, VC ,Dean's of Medical colleges and suggest for improvement of Medical education. Their suggestion resulted sought for 2 changes in the Medical education ie some of the subjects studied in 1 year to be relegated to 11 & 12 and up grading the MBBS syllabus.There was little change to be made in CBSE but the State Government required considerable change. Further there were 22 written exams to be written to get admission to medicines which was misused and scams like VYPAM took place involving IAS/IPS/Judges/Ministers children getting admission by dubious means .Hence the need of the hour was to up grade the education system. You have not addressed the issue of ability of teachers to prepare students for Enterance exam. The CM of Karnataka Veerappa Moily noticed that there was very few students from Government schools could crack CET. Hence a training for teachers of 11 & 12 was conducted and it was found the teachers ability to motivate the students in teaching and their ability to crack Enterance test before training was far from satisfactory. But their ability improved after the training at IISC Bangalore. One more thing you should know most of the students fail to pass the test conducted by Infosys in the final year because the students have not faced any test.N.Narayan Murthy has said 75% of our Engineering graduates are unemployable because of the weak foundation. If our Doctors are able to shine a road why are they shy to face a Test ? The 2002 T.A Pai Judgement is pro Private and made private to collect fancy donation and fees. In fact Private medical colleges /Engineers is first introduced in Karnataka much before TN
Things i cannot understand at all what this guy is saying. 1. Students from Behar, Naga Land etc and tamilnadu have different cognitive skill because of the place they are born and not because of the quality of education provided by the government 2. He is completely ignoring the fact that students writing the 12th exam is not focused just for medical or engineering but all other fields so it cannot be structured to meet the needs of competent medical students and 12th mark persentage is the average of all the subjects where as a medical students aptitude should be focused of biology more then chemistry then physics and for engineering it should be maths, physics then chemistry. 3. He is not at all considering the difficulty of different exams written by the 12th students. The CBSC students need to appear for a national exam with stringent marking system where as state syllabus students receive simpler paper with liberal marking system. The fact that results of 2 completely different question paper is considered as equal itself is contradicting what he is describing about equality. 4. Backdoor entry. Since it is easy to get 50% in 12th there are a large number of rich students entering the medical Colleges paying large sum of money. But getting cutoff for neet is very hard for these students so they cannot enter college even if they have truck load of money. 5. Since there 12th paper is very easy since the exam is very generic. The difference in mark is very small for top students. If my knowledge is correct the merit cut off was 99-98% this cannot measure the actual worth of a student because a single qs or a single mistake can take you out of the game. And it is impossible to attend 12th exam again. Where as in neet since the question paper is hard the will be a wide range of mark different between each students so the selection will be fair and the person who did the mistake has an option to attend the exam in the coming years. These are very few points i find that this narrow minded justice is completely ignoring. There are few points he mentioned i find credible like the scarcity of doctors in rural areas. And for these issues government can give local quotas or mandatory rural service which is already in effect.
Tamil nadu need to give 15 % of its medical seats to other state candidates I.e 540 seats. Total medical seats of all colleges put together in Jharkand is 520. First build medical infrastructure in your states and conduct NEET.
Central gov has abolished a system of selecting student by 12th marks... does central gov has guts to abolish neet coaching centers... will law in parliment be enforced to enact it...
In essence he says our power of looting cores of rupees as capitation fees is curtailed. That is the reason for opposing neet. Thru neet merit students get MBBS with reasonable fees
@@krvijaay9250 I think it 13000 in govt colleges. 400000 in private colleges. people with illgotten money and without merit they pay crores to get mbbs seat.
Tamilnadu plus 2 syllabus is on par with CBSE syllabus. Tamilnadu students are far better than other states students in terms of hardwork and intelligence. Don't insult the curriculum and ability of Tamilnadu students without knowing anything about it. People from other states totally ignore board exams and simply prepare for NEET by attending coaching classes and they sit for multiple attempts. This is unfair. Also, NEET exam puts lot of pressure on students. Both economically weaker sections and middle class students ( of all boards including CBSE) cannot afford high fees for attending coaching classes. A student with a cut off of 198 out of 200 in board exam will be definitely a far better doctor than a student who has scored 720 out of 720 in NEET. That is why we oppose NEET. Don't underestimate the capabilities of Tamilnadu students without knowing anything about Tamilnadu.
The other arguments given by retired justice of Madras High Court Mr Rajan is regarding the usurping of state authority by the central government in the education which is a state subject. If that be the case then why the state government couldn’t control the capitation fee mafia and corrupt practices in medical admissions, during those days also sufferer were only the poor, underprivileged students. Despite scoring good marks they were not getting any seats in the medical colleges specially in the government aided/private medical colleges, because of corrupt and malpractices with nexus of politicians and state health department officials.
A student got 198 mark out of 200 in +2 of TN board exam, can't score sufficient mark in NEET means the problem is with TN board exam... Mainly due to that here it is followed blue print system and unable to answer analytically.. If we fix the qualifying exam as enough one for medical admission, then why the TN govt running TNPSC for recruitments...
So then TN students should be barred from taking seats via AIQ in states anywhere except in TN. In fact they won't even be able to take states in AIIMS, JIPMER Puducherry also.
I think u have understood it a little differently. The exemption TN government is seeking is for its 85% seats. The 15% it continues to give it to NEET. But, the larger perspective is NEET is anti federalism and seeks to consolidate powers in Delhi.
@@dss6838 What is your understanding about federalism and state autonomy? Every state and its people aren't subjects to be ruled by an authoritarian, central hindianised structure. While admittedly, the constitution has cheated the union of the diverse ethnic nationalities by vesting more power to Delhi , this needs to change! Yes, if your state and its people want a certain change that would benefit them, it should be granted. Do not confuse coexistence with cohabitation. Our union wax voluntary not by blood and iron!
The argument given in the report submitted by retired justice of Madras High Court Mr Rajan is not tenable at all in the court of law. As in his arguments he says that urban children have access to the good education and coaching which students from rural area are not able to get it. But this can’t be applicable to only Tamil Nadu state but for all the other state as well. In comparison to Northern States, Southern State especially Tamil Nadu has a very well set education and coaching system which can easily be extended or might be made available to rural areas also.
Admission to any college including medical colleges should be based only on the performance of the students in board exams. Only then really talented and hardworking students would get admission to colleges. In board exams, there is always a guarantee that systematic and dedicated learning attributes to success and high marks. NEET on the other hand requires extra coaching and is associated with probability (no guarantee of success) and luck. This is why there are increasing number of repeaters in NEET. This puts lot of pressure on young children. Competitive tests are a good choice only for employment. In case of tests for jobs, already the candidates would have taken up semester exams in their college and they would be well versed in their curriculum. In this case, conducting tests for jobs will help to select best candidates for jobs. To sum up, there should not be entrance tests for admission to educational institutions. Competitive exams are a good choice only for job recruitments.
Tamil Nadu objecting the NEET because the government not having control over teachers to teach a standard lessons like private techers .He never talked about the standard of education in government schools, biased man favour to DMK,
For all those who support this AK.Rajan's NEET committee, I would suggest you all to search and read the verdict gave by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, and this was given by the Constitution bench of SC of India. I bet you all, NEET will and cant and never be scrapped. People we are living in the 21st century. Don't compare on 18-19th century. Parents should prepare their kids rather than positioning their mind. This committee is real waste and TN people will soon realize that this was a lies said by ruling DMK. #DMKFails
What is the percentage of state board students who were enrolled into medical colleges between 2007-2014 and now in TN? That answers the point about NEET.
they won't discuss that, because it will expose the pathetic quality of government schools
yealy 30 to 40 govt school students got seat before neet. after neet, only 2 - 3 got seat. so TN intro reservation and gave them both seats.. its all there in his report itself. read the report before commenting
Almost 80 to 90 percentage because all the seats were filled by state board
Dear Friends! We are pioneer in medical field and so many specialists in the world are from Tamilnadu. In order to occupy seats in Tamilnadu the "NEET SCAM" is formed. Why NEET exam all services given to private people. Search the Past History of Tamilnadu Doctors how much we are helping the society. Because of the heredity and humanity in Tamilnadu doctors serving the society. What is the lack in the skills of them? Let them have NEET exams in other states not here. We are having so many sources of people here, why it is looted by others.
What nonsense are u talking?
Lol. You losers are fighting to have a medical seat because you know at all India level, you have no shot of getting one. So just taking the easy way out which is state board. Then Don't ever compare the half baked graduates from TN colleges to the graduates of AIIMS, MAMC , Or any other top colleges.
So many specialist from Tamil Nadu? Then why our leaders and celebrities fly to London, USA and other countries for medical treatment, why can't they take treatment here if we have so many specialists.
Nonsense, i see mallu everywhere, even in Tamil Nadu.
@@gurujii8884 because they know Tamil curriculum isnt advanced
If a graduate is qualified by getting a degree from tamilnadu University then why they should appear for tnpsc. Why to burden them. Why they should study separately for tnpsc. Give them job directly as sub collectors based on their marks. Wow what a retired judge. Half baked irrational speech.
Because_of SOCIAL JUSTICE
TAMILNADU LAND OF SOCIAL JUSTICE
Mayiru da Mayiru😂😂😂😂😂
@@basketbal1433எல்லாம் நன்மைக்கே சகோதரரே
Make anyone a doctor...doesn't matter.
Usa:-land of deserved
India:-land of reserved. .
This interview shows the
Law course is also of poor quality in Tamil Nadu.
Aren't you ppl ashamed to do politics in students Life, compared to the previous system neet is better in all ways! Even judges are openly falling for money!cheap stunt!
It's time for other states to question NEET.
#BanNEET
mokka comedy pannadhe. Un moonjila Kaari thuppidi vaanga
@@basketbal1433 students life ungalukku comedy pola ..un moojilae neeyae karithuppikko da vengayam
Ethukku pa neet ah ban pannanum.... Karanam...?
@@rameshcpr yenpa unakku ezhudha padikka theriyum la interview full neet ban panna dha Karanam sollirukkanga kekalaiya ila keka manam ilaiya 🤦
@@arunkumarps9701 ivanga soldra entha kaaranamum crt kedeyaathu.... totally wrong...
There are Issues for NEET EXAMS in other states also but those state Gvts are not taking the issue much seriously like Tamilnadu Gvt
which state? Don't just do blah blah blah....
@@basketbal1433 which state ? Which state has given the data . Let them publish the data of their state board students entering medical colleges before and after NEET.
Bravo to Justice AK Rajan committee and hope NEET is scrapped asap. #banneet
That bill will be thrown out like the trash it is xD
@@giankawasakixo9554 along with that gomutra govt at the union 😂
@@ajsrinath no shortage of retards in Tamil Nadu
@@gudguy97 says the ISRO scientist 🤦♂️ look at yourself in the mirror dumbass
@@ajsrinath dmk cannot throwout central government lol
NEET marks are not at all an indicator of true learning and knowledge. Coaching classes simply teach the tricks to score high marks.
People lack awareness and think too high about NEET. But, NEET does not bring out real talent and knowledge. This is the truth. It's sad people don't understand this fact.
TN syllabus is good but question paper pattern should be changed like CBSE.
😂
Is this gentleman really a justice? His lack of understanding the core issue is jus baffling to me! Looks like his only motive is the support the present DMK government and also the politicians who were running most of the medical colleges in Tamilnadu and was earning crores and crores of money every year! With introduction of NEET, the playing field fir students has been leveled. The political parties of Tamilnadu ensured that government schools are kept at the lowest in standards and they were running the majority of the CBSE school, including the daughter-in-law of the present chief minister! With money lost in the capitation fees these politicians are shedding crocodile tears and want to abolish NEET! This so called judge who can’t even articulate the points raised by the interviewer coming up with nonsense! Parents are smarter now and they know what to do with their kids. Let the government enhance the standards of the government schools with their ill earned wealth - if they have a mind to do that!
He is tamilian first, shows his incapability to think.
Or had deep pockets.
He says we have good doctors in TN then why our leader fly to London and USA for treatment
Film actors charge in crores in TN. Music directors can amass wealth. Broadcasting channels are in plenty in TN making enough. Liquor is with Govt? Importantly DMK gave about 500 crores to Prashant to script a victory and come to power - ALL THIS IS OK
Coaching centres employ middleclass TAMILS only. They should not make money.
The standard of secondary education is abject state.teachers are selected based on the contact with MLA's.
Excellence cannot be compramised in Education.
Employment is different - locals and social upliftment is agreeable.
He says MCQ based tests are lottery. Really funny
Mr. AK Rajan did not provide important statistics in his Report:
How much did the Medical colleges charge before NEET - how much do they charge after NEET?
Which CASTE paid how much before and after NEET for the Management Quota and how many of those were First Generation Graduates (FGG) and how many were Non-FGG?
What is equality? What is Social Justice?
1 Are MLA assembly tickets allowed only on the basis of caste? Is only OBC dominating 76 +% MLA seats
equality?
2 is Only 5% representation of women in the assembly equality?
Are agricultural women getting much lower minimum wages than men for the same job equality?
Are very few women have the right to own agricultural lands equality?
3 Is only a few from the Powerful and rich families hereditarily inherit important top positions in the party equality?
4 Of the total 2.01 lakh fishing families, 91 percent are below the poverty line?
5 Is about 1.5 crore people (almost 20% of TN Population) living in unsanitary conditions in slums in Tamil Nadu?
6 Is targeting and demeaning particular community equality?
7 While all the Party members owned private schools teach Hindi, German, French, and many other
languages, restricting Government School students to only bilingual (Tamil and English) is social justice?
8 Is allowing only companies that are paying commission to politicians allowed to bid for Government Tenders
democracy?
9 Is looting assets of 36,000+ Hindu Temples (land and other properties without showing any accounts and
not doing any external audit) for other purposes other than Temple use in spite of Court ruling and not appointing
trustees.
I would be glad to correct if any of the above statements are proven incorrect with data.
The man who says NEET is not required based on data, does not remember any data 😂
They published a report. You can check that on the TN gov website.
@@abishaek6760 the report is bullshit and fake data
Should USA also abolish MCAT exam for admissions in American medical colleges?
#BanNEET
So to improve the capacity please cancel cast based rijarvation system
NEET is against the rural and urban poor as they are not afford to go to coaching centres. NEET encourages coaching centres to loot money from the students
True Sir
So another entrance exam is done without coaching? You don't study for other exams?
Then have good teachers in school. My school has good teachers, no need of coaching, it's literally government aided school
and how much u scored in neet?@@dss6838
The study by Justice( Retd) Mr. Rajan appears to be sketchy on very few facts and study has not recommended how the rural students can be empowered by state to have coaching facility?. No answer for how corrupt practice can be controlled in direct admissions? Study is for how not to have NEET? how rote learning can have good students?
Mr.A.K.Rajan ,the nemesis of NEET goes back to a circular of Karnataka of 1989 regulating the differential fee structure for Karnataka Government Medical colleges, Karnataka meritorious student admitted in Private medical colleges and those selected by Private Medical colleges. This was challenged by a UP student Mohini Jain vs Karnataka in 1989 and the subsequent Unnikrishnan Judgement of 1993. The Government was asked to regulate the fee and admission by holding one test . Thus from 1994 the Common Enterance Test was held .The private colleges were unhappy and went to court to get a favourable Judgment in 2002 ie T.A.Pai Judgement accordly the private medical/Engineering colleges had separate admission test called COMED- K and Government virtually lost the seats for its meritorious student in Private medical colleges.
Next was when world famous Dr.Devishetty a renowned Cardiologist was appointed as Chief of MCI a question was posed by many Medical students going abroad for higher studies to solve the long pending demand of upgrading their MBBS degree on par with international standards. He extensively discussed with his other members of MCI, VC ,Dean's of Medical colleges and suggest for improvement of Medical education. Their suggestion resulted sought for 2 changes in the Medical education ie some of the subjects studied in 1 year to be relegated to 11 & 12 and up grading the MBBS syllabus.There was little change to be made in CBSE but the State Government required considerable change. Further there were 22 written exams to be written to get admission to medicines which was misused and scams like VYPAM took place involving IAS/IPS/Judges/Ministers children getting admission by dubious means .Hence the need of the hour was to up grade the education system. You have not addressed the issue of ability of teachers to prepare students for Enterance exam. The CM of Karnataka Veerappa Moily noticed that there was very few students from Government schools could crack CET. Hence a training for teachers of 11 & 12 was conducted and it was found the teachers ability to motivate the students in teaching and their ability to crack Enterance test before training was far from satisfactory. But their ability improved after the training at IISC Bangalore.
One more thing you should know most of the students fail to pass the test conducted by Infosys in the final year because the students have not faced any test.N.Narayan Murthy has said 75% of our Engineering graduates are unemployable because of the weak foundation.
If our Doctors are able to shine a road why are they shy to face a Test ? The 2002 T.A Pai Judgement is pro Private and made private to collect fancy donation and fees.
In fact Private medical colleges /Engineers is first introduced in Karnataka much before TN
Tamil butts will hurt after reading this
Things i cannot understand at all what this guy is saying.
1. Students from Behar, Naga Land etc and tamilnadu have different cognitive skill because of the place they are born and not because of the quality of education provided by the government
2. He is completely ignoring the fact that students writing the 12th exam is not focused just for medical or engineering but all other fields so it cannot be structured to meet the needs of competent medical students and 12th mark persentage is the average of all the subjects where as a medical students aptitude should be focused of biology more then chemistry then physics and for engineering it should be maths, physics then chemistry.
3. He is not at all considering the difficulty of different exams written by the 12th students. The CBSC students need to appear for a national exam with stringent marking system where as state syllabus students receive simpler paper with liberal marking system. The fact that results of 2 completely different question paper is considered as equal itself is contradicting what he is describing about equality.
4. Backdoor entry. Since it is easy to get 50% in 12th there are a large number of rich students entering the medical Colleges paying large sum of money. But getting cutoff for neet is very hard for these students so they cannot enter college even if they have truck load of money.
5. Since there 12th paper is very easy since the exam is very generic. The difference in mark is very small for top students. If my knowledge is correct the merit cut off was 99-98% this cannot measure the actual worth of a student because a single qs or a single mistake can take you out of the game. And it is impossible to attend 12th exam again. Where as in neet since the question paper is hard the will be a wide range of mark different between each students so the selection will be fair and the person who did the mistake has an option to attend the exam in the coming years.
These are very few points i find that this narrow minded justice is completely ignoring. There are few points he mentioned i find credible like the scarcity of doctors in rural areas. And for these issues government can give local quotas or mandatory rural service which is already in effect.
85 percent are from Tamil naidu.15 percent from other states.Tamil naidu government has to change subject of maths and science set according to ncert.
how much shooting effec( in NEET ) will attract in AK(47) Rajan report/ solving this mega medical issue.
Tamil nadu need to give 15 % of its medical seats to other state candidates I.e 540 seats. Total medical seats of all colleges put together in Jharkand is 520. First build medical infrastructure in your states and conduct NEET.
Your people are in Maharashtra to study medical, call them back
Central gov has abolished a system of selecting student by 12th marks... does central gov has guts to abolish neet coaching centers... will law in parliment be enforced to enact it...
does the Tamil Nadu government have the guts to ban private schools to maintain samooga needhi?
@@basketbal1433 now central gov is the big boss ... let it lead the game...
Because we are easily influenced by the less educated politicians and film actors!
What about UPSC Exam ?
Next this guy will say stop UPSC
In essence he says our power of looting cores of rupees as capitation fees is curtailed.
That is the reason for opposing neet.
Thru neet merit students get MBBS with reasonable fees
reasonable fees? 25 l per year if u just pass the neet. do u think this is equality?
@@krvijaay9250
I think it 13000 in govt colleges.
400000 in private colleges.
people with illgotten money and without merit they pay crores to get mbbs seat.
He is talking on behalf of the ruling party's opinions. Blabbering at its best
Justice says education is state subject....but actually it is in the concurrent list....changed from state to concurrent by Indira ji during emergency
This person become Is a Judge by this +2 scam. Now he Is trying for his son to become MBBS :)
Tamilnadu plus 2 syllabus is on par with CBSE syllabus. Tamilnadu students are far better than other states students in terms of hardwork and intelligence. Don't insult the curriculum and ability of Tamilnadu students without knowing anything about it.
People from other states totally ignore board exams and simply prepare for NEET by attending coaching classes and they sit for multiple attempts. This is unfair. Also, NEET exam puts lot of pressure on students. Both economically weaker sections and middle class students ( of all boards including CBSE) cannot afford high fees for attending coaching classes. A student with a cut off of 198 out of 200 in board exam will be definitely a far better doctor than a student who has scored 720 out of 720 in NEET. That is why we oppose NEET. Don't underestimate the capabilities of Tamilnadu students without knowing anything about Tamilnadu.
The other arguments given by retired justice of Madras High Court Mr Rajan is regarding the usurping of state authority by the central government in the education which is a state subject. If that be the case then why the state government couldn’t control the capitation fee mafia and corrupt practices in medical admissions, during those days also sufferer were only the poor, underprivileged students. Despite scoring good marks they were not getting any seats in the medical colleges specially in the government aided/private medical colleges, because of corrupt and malpractices with nexus of politicians and state health department officials.
I as a student of biology, am impressed by neet curriculum, it much better than previous state syllabus
Truth from Mahabharatha: If you only believe in intellect alone then the whole community will be destroyed.
A student got 198 mark out of 200 in +2 of TN board exam, can't score sufficient mark in NEET means the problem is with TN board exam...
Mainly due to that here it is followed blue print system and unable to answer analytically..
If we fix the qualifying exam as enough one for medical admission, then why the TN govt running TNPSC for recruitments...
tnpsc is for job recruitment. neet is for ug. dont confuse
Kindly remove your mask when you are speaking to public. your communication should reach.
So then TN students should be barred from taking seats via AIQ in states anywhere except in TN. In fact they won't even be able to take states in AIIMS, JIPMER Puducherry also.
It is stop looting by NEET based institutions ..
I think u have understood it a little differently. The exemption TN government is seeking is for its 85% seats. The 15% it continues to give it to NEET. But, the larger perspective is NEET is anti federalism and seeks to consolidate powers in Delhi.
@@drvenkateshsrenalclinic6156 how is it anti federalism? Just because uniform law is made, it's anti federalism? Tamilian really need to think.
73rd amendment is anti federalism then. Because it tells my state to have only 3 tier local government, what if we want 5 tier government?
@@dss6838 What is your understanding about federalism and state autonomy? Every state and its people aren't subjects to be ruled by an authoritarian, central hindianised structure. While admittedly, the constitution has cheated the union of the diverse ethnic nationalities by vesting more power to Delhi , this needs to change! Yes, if your state and its people want a certain change that would benefit them, it should be granted. Do not confuse coexistence with cohabitation. Our union wax voluntary not by blood and iron!
The argument given in the report submitted by retired justice of Madras High Court Mr Rajan is not tenable at all in the court of law. As in his arguments he says that urban children have access to the good education and coaching which students from rural area are not able to get it. But this can’t be applicable to only Tamil Nadu state but for all the other state as well. In comparison to Northern States, Southern State especially Tamil Nadu has a very well set education and coaching system which can easily be extended or might be made available to rural areas also.
Admission to any college including medical colleges should be based only on the performance of the students in board exams. Only then really talented and hardworking students would get admission to colleges. In board exams, there is always a guarantee that systematic and dedicated learning attributes to success and high marks. NEET on the other hand requires extra coaching and is associated with probability (no guarantee of success) and luck. This is why there are increasing number of repeaters in NEET. This puts lot of pressure on young children.
Competitive tests are a good choice only for employment. In case of tests for jobs, already the candidates would have taken up semester exams in their college and they would be well versed in their curriculum. In this case, conducting tests for jobs will help to select best candidates for jobs.
To sum up, there should not be entrance tests for admission to educational institutions. Competitive exams are a good choice only for job recruitments.
This is a fake Chanel
He talks only DMK's views....he is not neutral my honour
Justice, what about 65% of seats were going to Namakkal and Krishnagiri prior to NEET?
Horrible English. Thanks to the subtitle. I have no clue what’s he talking about
Tamil Nadu objecting the NEET because the government not having control over teachers to teach a standard lessons like private techers .He never talked about the standard of education in government schools, biased man favour to DMK,
hopeless report provided by a.k rajan . . .
For all those who support this AK.Rajan's NEET committee, I would suggest you all to search and read the verdict gave by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, and this was given by the Constitution bench of SC of India. I bet you all, NEET will and cant and never be scrapped. People we are living in the 21st century. Don't compare on 18-19th century. Parents should prepare their kids rather than positioning their mind. This committee is real waste and TN people will soon realize that this was a lies said by ruling DMK. #DMKFails
More than a retired judge this gentleman Mr.A.K.Rajan is talking as if he is the propaganda secretary of the D.M.K. party!!!