those bands have nothing in common the holy trinity as u call it would be joy division, the sound, the chameleons, and the cure between 80 and 82 thats where this sound started and none were considered goth bauhaus was good but more of an art school band nine inch nails while also good was just the first wave of industrial pop bands incorporating more catchy guitar rifts to be accepted by the main stream crowd
The crowd had no clue of the band -- JD -- that inspired these guys. But thanks to Trent and Peter for exposing them a little to the music of the band that influenced many.
Awesome P M and the banda too! So this is permanent, love's shattered pride. What once was innocence, turned on its side. A cloud hangs over me, marks every move, Deep in the memory, of what once was love. Oh how I realized how I wanted time, Put into perspective, tried so hard to find, Just for one moment, thought I'd found my way. Destiny unfolded, I watched it slip away. Excessive flash points, beyond all reach, Solitary demands for all I'd like to keep. Let's take a ride out, see what we can find, A valueless collection of hopes and past desires. I never realized the lengths I'd have to go, All the darkest corners of a sense I didn't know. Just for one moment, I heard somebody call, Looked beyond the day in hand, there's nothing there at all. Now that I've realized how it's all gone wrong, Gottas find some therapy, this treatment takes too long. Deep in the heart of where sympathy held sway, Gotta find my destiny, before it gets too late.
Horrible that he kills himself not long after writing this when if he'd meditated enough to feel bliss and did that often he'd still be with us IMO. Therapy Shmerapy he's right that treatment takes too long.
This is pretty cool, but whats ironic is that JD and Bauhaus came out at the same time and probably weren't even aware of each other, as JD was a Manchester band and Bauhaus was a Northampton band. And both totally rocked.
I recently read Peter Hook's book and you are right, no mention of Bauhaus. Joy Division were really late 70's whilst Bauhaus never really peaked till 81 - 82, so a bit of a gap; also Bauhaus got lumped in with the whole Goth thing
Actually, Ian did know of Bauhaus. In a rare audio interview he is asked what music he likes and he said he mostly buys singles and he mentions Bauhaus.
I saw pete Murphy in Christchurch 2017. Alongside Permanent a JD cover band. Both on the level when it comes complementing Joy divisions Brilliances!!!!
I was at verizon ampitheatre for this concert. My wife bought us tickets for my birthday. Fucking amaaaaazing...as usual. Marked the 7th time I've seen them, Trent Reznor is a musical genius...
Was this ever given an official release? Too bad, because this is one of my all-time favorite JD songs (even if it's really depressing as hell,when you really listen to the lyrics.) NIN couldn't have picked a better vocalist to cover any JD tunes,anyway.
There is no future, the bones are cast, the melancholic repast, descent into sanity, please leave our halls and take repose as the masters assemble for the mystic circumabulation.
:).•♪·°* Así que esto es permanente, el orgullo destrozado del amor. So this is permanent, love's shattered pride Lo que una vez fue inocencia, se puso de lado What once was innocence, turned on its side Una nube se cierne sobre mí, marca cada movimiento A cloud hangs over me, marks every move En lo profundo de la memoria, lo que una vez fue amor Deep in the memory, what once was love Oh, cómo me di cuenta de que quería tiempo. Oh, how I realized how I wanted time Puesto en perspectiva, intenté con todas mis fuerzas encontrar Put into perspective, tried so hard to find Sólo por un momento pensé que había encontrado mi camino Just for one moment, thought I'd found my way El destino se desarrolló, lo vi escaparse Destiny unfolded, I watched it slip away Puntos de inflamación excesivos, fuera de todo alcance Excessive flashpoints, beyond all reach Demandas solitarias para todo lo que me gustaría conservar Solitary demands for all I'd like to keep Demos un paseo, veamos qué podemos encontrar. Let's take a ride out, see what we can find Colección sin valor de esperanzas y deseos pasados. Valueless collection of hopes and past desires Nunca me di cuenta de hasta dónde tendría que llegar I never realized the lengths I'd have to go Todos los rincones más oscuros de un sentido que no conocía All the darkest corners of a sense I didn't know Sólo por un momento, escuché a alguien llamar Just for one moment, I heard somebody call Mirando más allá del día en cuestión, no hay nada allí en absoluto. Looked beyond the day in hand, there's nothing there at all Ahora que me he dado cuenta de cómo todo salió mal Now that I've realized how it's all gone wrong Tengo que encontrar alguna terapia, este tratamiento lleva demasiado tiempo. Gotta find some therapy, this treatment takes too long En lo profundo del corazón donde dominaba la simpatía Deep in the heart of where sympathy held sway Tengo que encontrar mi destino antes de que sea demasiado tarde Gotta find my destiny before it gets too late
@oramikleepunk Yeah. I saw one of the shows where Bauhaus toured with NIN. It was pretty clear which band the other audience members were there to see...
feels like there are two kinds of NIN audiences-one who know what time it is and acknowledge that NIN come from a lineage including Cure, Bauhaus, Joy Division, Bowie etc (and of course including Ministry, industrial et all) and the other that seems to just be there to be Trents cult. its a shame, you get more out of NINs music when you can see how its connected to a rich past.
So true. But I love Peter Murphy.. His voice is still mesmerizing, and he DOES sound good on this track...I have not listened to NIN in twenty years, he just doesn't do anything for me anymore. Most of the kids there probably never even heard of Joy Division (gasp! ) and just thought it was an original NIN song. What a tragedy.
How do you know that? I like Joy Division as much as NIN and Bauhaus. I have listened to JD and Bauhaus and lot of bands, I could swear you had notice ever,since I was 5 years old because my sister. Then with time I discovered NIN. F.Y. and all the people who thinks they are experts on music.. By the way, Im not a teen, Im 31 yo.
Well as I se it, talent is TALENT and it't just quite right if it gets through different generations of musicians, so wtf should be wrong with Trent Reznor covering Joy Division??? :-) have a nice time, man...
Well seeing as how one of Ian's biggest musical being Jim Morrison, and how Ian was strongly influenced off of him: the answer would be not at all. Joy Division would sound no where near as good if they had a raspy singer. Ian's influences didn't have raspy voices. There is only a couple good bands that are okay to good with raspy voices, like Nirvana, because it was it's own thing. It was mimicking anything else.
Joy Division one of the greatest and most influential bands to exist.
This a very rare Joy division cover covering by 2 real JD fans.
The Holy Trinity : Bauhaus, Nine Inch Nails, Joy Division......Just Fantastic !!
those bands have nothing in common the holy trinity as u call it would be joy division, the sound, the chameleons, and the cure between 80 and 82 thats where this sound started and none were considered goth bauhaus was good but more of an art school band nine inch nails while also good was just the first wave of industrial pop bands incorporating more catchy guitar rifts to be accepted by the main stream crowd
@@aaron1888 It is HIS holy trinity, let him be
@@aaron1888 keep the chameleons out of your mouth with that kinda elitism lmao
Bauhaus + Nine Inch Nails performing Joy Division!!! This is ABSOLUTELY PERFECT!
...in absence of the Fab Forth: David Bowie...
Always impressed by Peter Murphy - Trent Reznor collaborations.
Jim Morrison, Nick Cave, Peter Murphy, Ian Curtis and Brendan Perry (Dead Can Dance)...they are my religion.
The crowd had no clue of the band -- JD -- that inspired these guys. But thanks to Trent and Peter for exposing them a little to the music of the band that influenced many.
Thank you guru Jeremy.
Agree 100%
Totally agree, what a shame they can't appreciate the tribute to a great band in their own fantastic way.
Murphy and Trent can be electric . Keeping important music alive . Loved Joy Div since the start . Very happy with this .
A great cover of a fantastic song…..love this.
My brother was the biggest NIN fan, don't get me wrong, I'm a fan too, he thought NIN wrote Dead Souls, absolutely crushed him when he found out.
I love JD and Bauhaus..I think Pete Murphy does a great job on this
excellent version of a brilliant song by geniuses
So friggin good. Love Joy Division . Best of the best
I'm impressed - a very respectfull and authentic tribute and done with conviction.
Hermoso cover. Muestra amor y respeto. Muchas Gracias.
I always thought Peter steele and type o negative would have done a magnificent cover of this song....
Excellent stuff Pete Murphy and NIN spot on
He's saying that cuz when they said we're gonna play some JD, there was like 3 people in the crowd going "wooh". WTF
ikr?
Lol well some people are Zappa fans. Can you blame them?! :P
That broke my heart
Great cover! Peter lands the eerie voice of the words of Ian.
Nicely done. Captures the atmosphere completely.
Thanks for posting. NIN does a great job covering Joy Division. I like their/his version of Dead Souls too.
Awesome version of this classic tune. Thanks for the upload!
Awesome P M and the banda too!
So this is permanent, love's shattered pride.
What once was innocence, turned on its side.
A cloud hangs over me, marks every move,
Deep in the memory, of what once was love.
Oh how I realized how I wanted time,
Put into perspective, tried so hard to find,
Just for one moment, thought I'd found my way.
Destiny unfolded, I watched it slip away.
Excessive flash points, beyond all reach,
Solitary demands for all I'd like to keep.
Let's take a ride out, see what we can find,
A valueless collection of hopes and past desires.
I never realized the lengths I'd have to go,
All the darkest corners of a sense I didn't know.
Just for one moment, I heard somebody call,
Looked beyond the day in hand, there's nothing there at all.
Now that I've realized how it's all gone wrong,
Gottas find some therapy, this treatment takes too long.
Deep in the heart of where sympathy held sway,
Gotta find my destiny, before it gets too late.
Horrible that he kills himself not long after writing this when if he'd meditated enough to feel bliss and did that often he'd still be with us IMO. Therapy Shmerapy he's right that treatment takes too long.
I would kill for a version of this song with Peter singing the way he used to sing in Bauhaus.
This is a great cover! It only seemed right for these two bands to do this, Bauhaus and Nine Inch Nails. Good Job guys!
Great cover. My favorite JD song.
what a voice!
This is surreal and very good!
This is magnificent...
This is pretty cool, but whats ironic is that JD and Bauhaus came out at the same time and probably weren't even aware of each other, as JD was a Manchester band and Bauhaus was a Northampton band.
And both totally rocked.
I recently read Peter Hook's book and you are right, no mention of Bauhaus. Joy Division were really late 70's whilst Bauhaus never really peaked till 81 - 82, so a bit of a gap; also Bauhaus got lumped in with the whole Goth thing
Ian Guy
Joy Division got put into 'gothic rock' more than a few times, actually
Ian Guy
but they more specifically presaged the style, not inhabited it
Actually, Ian did know of Bauhaus. In a rare audio interview he is asked what music he likes and he said he mostly buys singles and he mentions Bauhaus.
JD No Ian Curtis was very aware of the Bauhaus, and actually liked them.
Nice job Peter M on a great song
I saw pete Murphy in Christchurch 2017. Alongside Permanent a JD cover band. Both on the level when it comes complementing Joy divisions Brilliances!!!!
Amazing no one picked up what was coming for Ian. Lyrics to this song are hauntingly foreshadowing
I was at verizon ampitheatre for this concert. My wife bought us tickets for my birthday. Fucking amaaaaazing...as usual. Marked the 7th time I've seen them, Trent Reznor is a musical genius...
Was this ever given an official release? Too bad, because this is one of my all-time favorite JD songs (even if it's really depressing as hell,when you really listen to the lyrics.) NIN couldn't have picked a better vocalist to cover any JD tunes,anyway.
There is no future, the bones are cast, the melancholic repast, descent into sanity, please leave our halls and take repose as the masters assemble for the mystic circumabulation.
Damn! this is Perfect!!
NIN should release an album of Bowie & Joy Divison covers
:).•♪·°* Así que esto es permanente, el orgullo destrozado del amor.
So this is permanent, love's shattered pride
Lo que una vez fue inocencia, se puso de lado
What once was innocence, turned on its side
Una nube se cierne sobre mí, marca cada movimiento
A cloud hangs over me, marks every move
En lo profundo de la memoria, lo que una vez fue amor
Deep in the memory, what once was love
Oh, cómo me di cuenta de que quería tiempo.
Oh, how I realized how I wanted time
Puesto en perspectiva, intenté con todas mis fuerzas encontrar
Put into perspective, tried so hard to find
Sólo por un momento pensé que había encontrado mi camino
Just for one moment, thought I'd found my way
El destino se desarrolló, lo vi escaparse
Destiny unfolded, I watched it slip away
Puntos de inflamación excesivos, fuera de todo alcance
Excessive flashpoints, beyond all reach
Demandas solitarias para todo lo que me gustaría conservar
Solitary demands for all I'd like to keep
Demos un paseo, veamos qué podemos encontrar.
Let's take a ride out, see what we can find
Colección sin valor de esperanzas y deseos pasados.
Valueless collection of hopes and past desires
Nunca me di cuenta de hasta dónde tendría que llegar
I never realized the lengths I'd have to go
Todos los rincones más oscuros de un sentido que no conocía
All the darkest corners of a sense I didn't know
Sólo por un momento, escuché a alguien llamar
Just for one moment, I heard somebody call
Mirando más allá del día en cuestión, no hay nada allí en absoluto.
Looked beyond the day in hand, there's nothing there at all
Ahora que me he dado cuenta de cómo todo salió mal
Now that I've realized how it's all gone wrong
Tengo que encontrar alguna terapia, este tratamiento lleva demasiado tiempo.
Gotta find some therapy, this treatment takes too long
En lo profundo del corazón donde dominaba la simpatía
Deep in the heart of where sympathy held sway
Tengo que encontrar mi destino antes de que sea demasiado tarde
Gotta find my destiny before it gets too late
When he said joy division one dude was like woo wtf people cmon
Peter Murphy and Trent Reznor covering a Joy Divsion song... what could be more goth than this?
I DO like the way you put it : "both of these artists have done plenty to earn the right to cover whoever the fuck they want" :-)
I can't believe these never got the same video treatment as the other songs they collaborated on during the same tour cycle.
Definitely one of the better Joy Division covers.
thanks for sharing, thank you peter and trent
Excellent! In a mosh - in my mind...
@oramikleepunk Yeah. I saw one of the shows where Bauhaus toured with NIN. It was pretty clear which band the other audience members were there to see...
I liked that a lot.
I'd love to hear Neil Young - cover - this
+candyfingerss - yes, with Crazy Horse - it'd be great!
:-)
didn't know i needed this until now
Действительно Кёртис как мистик жутко холодный текст не говоря уже о стиле и подачи материала. Респект ...
SO EPIC!!!!
Awesome ! Thank you awesome cover
Excellent song
Legendary
They covered Joy Division for the soundtrack of the movie The Crow
Very tight performance.
The crowd sounds like they're ... dead souls
the missing boy...18-5-80
"shut up and play" comes to mind
Right on!
fantastic stuff ,thanks!
IAN OJALÁ ESTUVIERAS ACÁ PARA ESCUCHAR ESTA OBRA DE ARTE Y PRESENCIAR ESTA EPICIDAD
The crowd is like "huuh?"
Cool as fuck......big respect for this. Killer tune.
Fucking awesome!!! Really passion!!!
This wasn't a concert, it was a radio show... probably 20 people maximum
great cover :-)
Wow what a brilliant version. It’s like JD live with decent sound quality
@littlecreepyboy there could have been also Siouxie and Eldritch from The Sisters of Mercy, singing altoghether
feels like there are two kinds of NIN audiences-one who know what time it is and acknowledge that NIN come from a lineage including Cure, Bauhaus, Joy Division, Bowie etc (and of course including Ministry, industrial et all) and the other that seems to just be there to be Trents cult. its a shame, you get more out of NINs music when you can see how its connected to a rich past.
One does not simply cover Joy Division.
Simply perfect... Peter is the best vocals of all time.
Mike Patton is top ,but Peter is cool too...
So true. But I love Peter Murphy.. His voice is still mesmerizing, and he DOES sound good on this track...I have not listened to NIN in twenty years, he just doesn't do anything for me anymore. Most of the kids there probably never even heard of Joy Division (gasp! ) and just thought it was an original NIN song. What a tragedy.
How's that a tragedy? You made no sense
where is the bass guitar????
Destiny unfolded...
TV on the radio did the music I believe
nice
How do you know that? I like Joy Division as much as NIN and Bauhaus. I have listened to JD and Bauhaus and lot of bands, I could swear you had notice ever,since I was 5 years old because my sister. Then with time I discovered NIN. F.Y. and all the people who thinks they are experts on music..
By the way, Im not a teen, Im 31 yo.
A moco tendido!
listening to this one understands that Joy Division can't really be covered successfully...
it was a radio show- small audience.
Ohhhhhhhh
nice try even nicer to hear it being done 10/10 Bravo!
Its very odd I now , at 61 years old , work with Epileptic/ Autism ... I found myself ...
i think i was dead during this tour ,sigh
@Dalgren969 because it doesnt sound exactly like the original?
7!!!
Well as I se it, talent is TALENT and it't just quite right if it gets through different generations of musicians, so wtf should be wrong with Trent Reznor covering Joy Division??? :-) have a nice time, man...
Just perfish!! 😈
Since Bauhaus was as innovative as Joy Division, I think it's alright if Peter Murphy joins in on a cover.
JD is so much better. RIP Ian.
Can i Cry?
Luciano Secundino Si
Why do you doubt them???/ I have don't underestimate kids ever
:o
it's probably a private recording session...
BAH!!.....
Well seeing as how one of Ian's biggest musical being Jim Morrison, and how Ian was strongly influenced off of him: the answer would be not at all. Joy Division would sound no where near as good if they had a raspy singer. Ian's influences didn't have raspy voices. There is only a couple good bands that are okay to good with raspy voices, like Nirvana, because it was it's own thing. It was mimicking anything else.
Ian was influenced by Morrison, Bowie, Iggy and Reed. He listened to Sinatra before recording Love Will Tear Us Apart.
i cant hear in this version the bass lines is a good version but for shure are better ones just my opinion
The karma to burn cover is way better.
Family.....dead or delayed by daughters?